00:00:00Expedia. Hey you. What you doing? Scrolling? Doom scrolling? Looking at other people's vacations? Miami? San Diego? Cancun? Okay, what about you? What places will you go? Expedia is the one place you go to go places. Your trip can earn rewards which you can use towards your next eligible stay. Soon people will be doom scrolling you. You'll be that friend's friend, but with rewards. What are you waiting for? Expedia. The one place you go to go places. Terms apply.
00:00:30bet MGM home of the two up early payout presents footy prime the stage is set the sides are poised
00:00:36now is the time your favorite sports book and your favorite podcast together at last
00:00:41footy prime and bet MGM welcome the world come join the party for the best insights analysis
00:00:47and share in the global celebration right here at home listen to footy prime daily on your favorite
00:00:52podcast platform download bet MGM app make it legendary must be 19 plus Ontario only please
00:00:58play responsibly. Six o'clock in the morning, Sunday, October 20th, 2002, Ashland, Virginia,
00:01:06about a block and a half off Interstate 95. The Ponderosa Steakhouse is closed and dark.
00:01:12It has been closed since the night before when a man was shot in its parking lot. The lot is
00:01:18still taped off as a crime scene. Inside, in the hall by the front doors, there is a public
00:01:23telephone. At exactly 6 a.m., it rings. One of the men standing outside is an FBI agent. He hears the
00:01:32phone ringing inside the locked building and says somebody should get in there and answer it. No one
00:01:38does. It is not his crime scene. His hands are tied. The phone continues ringing, then stops.
00:01:46six hours earlier around midnight in the woods behind that restaurant investigators find a
00:01:54plastic sandwich bag tacked to a tree with two white thumbtacks it looks like a halloween bag
00:02:01the kind of child takes trick-or-treating folded inside it is a letter written on pink paper
00:02:07with stars stuck to it investigators bag it unopened it goes to a lab in the morning
00:11:47The first page or so was the guy basically had it wrong. In tarot world, death means transition of some sort. Could be a job promotion, a move, something like that. Did not mean the cessation of life. So that was the first page. And then it was trifurcated. For you, Mr. Police, it's some sort of a respectful deferential term, maybe an older person.
00:12:08I actually did some search on the internet, and there's some hip-hop rap song references to that Mr. Police, and I was a police officer prior to the FBI, and nobody ever called me that.
00:12:18Then the next line is, call me God in quotation marks, and what the heck did they mean by that?
00:12:26There was a movie called Navy Seal starring Charlie Sheen back in the 80s, and the sniper on that team, his nickname was God because he had the power of life and death.
00:12:37But I focused on the word press as opposed to media, and I summed up the end of it.
00:12:42It seems like using Mr. Police, someone deferential, hip-hop related, maybe younger, using press, the older word, which is now media was more common.
00:13:38Why did he use quotation marks over call me God, then separate do not release to the press?
00:13:44If anything, they could have been underlined or exclamation mark.
00:13:48It was this person's way of emphasizing something important to them.
00:13:52And again, what I did in the Unabom case, I compared the Unabom writings to the eventual writings of Ted Kaczynski, many people in between.
00:14:00But finally, with Ted Kaczynski, we could line up these unusual punctuation marks and other, you know, verb and noun phrases.
00:14:08And that's what I was hoping to do in this case.
00:14:10While Fitz worked on the language, Jim Clemente worked on the scenes.
00:14:15The choice of targets, the distances of the shots, the timing.
00:14:18When the first six one-shots, one-kill happened, we immediately felt that this is somebody who is a little older, they're not in their 20s, they're probably, they're most likely police or military trained because these are very efficient kills.
00:14:40And I know that sounds cold, but this is the way we analyze them.
00:14:45This is somebody who's sticking and running, sticking and running, sticking and running,
00:14:49and being incredibly efficient all through that day.
00:14:55In other words, they didn't decompensate at all.
00:14:57They didn't have, you know, their nerves get up,
00:15:01and it didn't interfere with the later killings in that same day.
00:15:06Clemente read the sniper as a disciplined adult,
00:15:09a man who was trained to shoot and has killed before.
00:15:36And I'm seeing some younger kind of influences in these notes.
00:15:42And I also remember, Fitz, you saying that Mr. Police is a line from some Jamaican reggae songs.
00:15:54And so that was the first time you mentioned that this person could have connections to Jamaica.
00:16:00Jamaica, off a phrase on the back of a tarot card.
00:16:03and as we were arguing this out everybody said well well certainly this guy is in his late 30s
00:16:12or early 40s because he must be police and military trained but Fitz was saying well I
00:16:18don't know based on these writings he's either well if he's a he's an adult he's just barely an
00:16:25adult but Fitz said I think he's more like 15 16 years old and everybody said that's impossible
00:16:31There was one answer, though, that made both takes true.
00:16:35So I jumped in to back Fitz up and say, well, then either for the first time we have a guy who is perfectly calm, cool and collected while he is planning and executing the shootings, but decompensates and communicates like a child or for the first time in U.S. history, we have a sniper team, one old and one younger.
00:16:56But the profilers took issue with the idea of a team.
00:17:00In their experience, criminal snipers did not share control.
00:17:04But every single sniper case, criminal sniper case prior to this was a lone actor and a white male.
00:17:12So that's where you get the statistics pushing in one direction.
00:17:16But Fitz stuck to his guns. I supported him.
00:17:20And we eventually convinced the rest of the crew that this could be possible.
00:17:25They said, snipers don't work well together because they have a God complex.
00:17:29And I said, well, if one of them's older and actually forcing his will on the younger one,
00:17:35then he is feeling fine because he's controlling the younger one,
00:17:40and the younger one doesn't really have a say in it.
00:17:42And they're saying, ah, that doesn't make much sense.
00:17:44And I said, well, he could control him completely by sexually victimizing him.
00:17:49And lo and behold, I think it was 11 years later that Malvo came out while he was in prison
00:17:57and said that Mohammed had been sexually victimizing him from almost from day one.
00:18:02That was a guess in a room in 2002 about two men no one had yet identified.
00:18:09Mohammed was never charged with abusing Malvo, and he never answered that allegation.
00:18:15Did you know many U.S. homes have toxic chemicals in their tap water?
00:18:18Even though contaminated water looks clear, it could put you at risk for devastating health
00:18:23concerns, including fatigue, hormone disruption, cognitive decline, even cancer. Surprisingly,
00:18:30standard fridge and pitcher filters do little to remove most contaminants,
00:18:34and bottled water contains microplastics. So what's one solution? Introducing AquaTrue,
00:18:41the countertop water purifier, which they say has been tested and certified to remove
00:18:4584 contaminants, including chlorine, lead, forever chemicals, and microplastics. Its patented
00:18:52four-stage reverse osmosis system goes way beyond ordinary filters for pure, healthy water you can
00:18:59trust. No plumbing, no installation. AquaTrue has been featured in Business Insider, Popular Science,
00:19:06and named Best Countertop Water Filter by Good Housekeeping. Go to aquatrue.com. That's true
00:19:12spelled T-R-U. Now for 20% off your purifier using the promo code MKC, as in MK Confidential.
00:19:21AquaTrue even comes with a 30-day best tasting water guarantee. That's AquaTrue.com, A-Q-U-A-T-R-U.com,
00:23:15overnight they could have had, they would have had, you know, eight, six to eight hours to put
00:23:19agents around every phone booth. It wouldn't have been easy and they could have missed it. We're
00:23:24not denying that. They could have made the arrest potentially right then and there and definitely
00:23:29saved a few more lives. When the letter is finally in hand, it runs four pages. It opens with the
00:23:36same three lines as the tarot card. Page two begins, we have tried to contact you to start
00:23:41negotiation. What follows is a numbered list of the calls they say they made and who took each
00:23:48one. An officer named Derek, a female officer at Rockville, the task force hotline, a priest,
00:23:56even CNN. Every one of them by the writer's account told them to call a different number
00:24:02or hung up. These people took the calls for a hoax or a joke, according to the letter.
00:24:08so your failure to respond has cost you five lives, it accuses. Then the demand,
00:24:15$10 million into a Bank of America account. The note promises to call police at 6 a.m. on Sunday
00:24:22at the Ponderosa buffet and includes the phone number they plan to call. The letter closes with
00:24:28an alternative. If catching them matters more than stopping the killing, then, quote, prepare
00:24:35you body bags. And underneath that, a postscript. Your children are not safe anywhere at any time.
00:24:43And a promise, which Fitz has never forgotten. If we give you our word, then that is what takes
00:24:50place. Word is bond. Four pages was enough. Fitz noticed a conspicuous missing letter.
00:24:58So at the time of the D.C. sniper case, I'm in my Georgetown master's program in linguistics,
00:25:03And I happened to be taking a course in sociolinguistics, and we were studying U.S. dialects.
00:25:09And I was learning about, you know, Boston dialects, New York, Philadelphia, which is mine, other parts of the country.
00:25:17And I realized it's not all geographical, it's cultural.
00:25:20And here I notice on this letter, and one of the hallmarks, if you will, one of the features of Black vernacular English, there's a name for it,
00:25:28is a lot of black people spoken in writing drop the s's on either possessive words or plural words
00:25:36and here in this note when the first two pages alone this letter i think there were four pages
00:25:41total uh the person writes the word negotiation should have been plural demand should have been
00:25:48plural with an s and 10 million dollar which of course should have been plural and if it happened
00:25:54just once okay it's a typo i mean it was handwritten but you know a mistake second time
00:25:59maybe third time i said we have dialect features here of a of a black person most likely male and
00:26:07i was the first one and i know i talked to jim clementi about this and i was the first one to
00:26:12say jim i think we got a black dot let's go up to the task force and tell them that reading changed
00:26:17the profile we were very careful in how we worded the profile uh that was to go out to the public
00:26:23And we very purposefully said, historically speaking, snipers are white males acting on their own.
00:26:32However, and here's the caveat, we don't know if this person exactly fits that, you know, that historical matching in this particular case.
00:26:42And years later, I'd be hearing, oh, the FBI had it wrong.
00:26:45They said it was a white guy in the beginning.
00:26:47We technically didn't, but that's, you have to be careful when you put these profiles together.
00:26:52We don't want investigators or the public ruling out someone if they think they have good evidence otherwise, and they don't make the phone call.
00:27:00So the Bureau hedged in writing on purpose, and the country heard white man, white van, and stopped listening.
00:27:08The men doing the shooting had been trying to get somebody on the phone for two weeks.
00:27:13Now they're asking the police to take their call at the Ponderosa so they can ensure the message gets through.
00:27:20Before any of the notes, one of the snipers called a priest.
00:27:23There was an even more detailed conversation where Muhammad apparently earlier had made a phone call to a priest.
00:27:34It was basically claiming the responsibility for the shootings outside of D.C., but also claiming responsibility for shooting down south.
00:27:45Malvo and Mohamed apparently chose the priest
00:27:48specifically because he would not record their conversation,