The Megyn Kelly Show - November 19, 2026


The Campaigns Against Russell Brand and JD Vance, with Bret Weinstein, Plus Alarming Jennifer Lawrence and Mariah Carey Looks, with Kirsten Fleming | Ep. 1445

Russell Brand's Addiction, Leonardo DiCaprio's Sad Public Persona, and Greta Thunberg Breaks Character, with Dr. Drew | Ep. 1444

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 55 minutes

Words per minute

162.81

Word count

18,785

Sentence count

1,049

Harmful content

Misogyny

44

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
00:00:00 You hear that?
00:00:02 That's the sound of 100% Canadian beef patties getting seared on both sides.
00:00:07 And that's the sound of slivered onions, shredded lettuce, two slices of tomatoes, two slices of cheesy goodness, and our smoky Big Tasty sauce being prepped.
00:00:17 And now, all that hard work is on your new Big Tasty.
00:00:20 It's what makes McDonald's, McDonald's.
00:00:22 And requires two hands to eat.
00:00:25 The new Big Tasty, out now, for a limited time only, at participating McDonald's restaurants in Canada.
00:00:30 Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:00:42 Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show and happy Thursday.
00:00:46 We've got some Meghan and Harry news coming up, but first, a darker story coming out of the UK.
00:00:52 Apparently putting Russell Brand behind bars for ten and a half years was not enough
00:00:58 because the British government is now launching a full court press, and I do mean the government,
00:01:04 at every level to get his YouTube page removed and to silence him from speaking at all out publicly
00:01:15 because he professed his innocence in a message delivered by his wife.
00:01:20 Google, which owns YouTube to its enormous credit, is so far refusing to bow down to these UK government demands.
00:01:32 Google and YouTube don't have to listen to you, authoritarian assholes.
00:01:39 I mean, these they are such bullies that up and down the government, they have leaned on everyone, every media platform, including the biggest in the world.
00:01:49 google to take down russell's comments this is so bizarre just before we go any further
00:01:57 because you need to know what they found so offensive what we're arguing over so we will
00:02:03 play it again here laura brand reading a message from russell here stop three russell has asked me
00:02:11 to read something to you today beloved brothers and sisters in christ god bless you for your
00:02:18 support. As you know, I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for,
00:02:25 so something strange is happening. The good news is that Christ is with us when we choose him,
00:02:33 and I do. I am incarcerated in HMP Little Hay. Little as in small, and hay as in hay. I'm in
00:02:45 the biggest sex offenders prison in Europe. The good news is that I have already seen that the
00:02:53 staff here are strong, they are kind, and they are dedicated. I feel your prayers, your brother in
00:03:01 Christ, Russell. We have had multiple British officials speaking out about that completely
00:03:10 anodyne statement for days now. And we've heard from the prime minister's spokesperson. So clearly
00:03:16 from his office at 10 Downing. And now here is the British prime minister himself. He's newly
00:03:24 installed. His name is Andy Burnham. It's hard to keep track over there. I mean, they change PMs
00:03:30 like they change underwear. This guy's from the left wing Labour Party. So you can anticipate
00:03:36 where this is going. But look at this. Watch. Prime Minister, we've also seen Russell Brand
00:03:41 this week give a message from jail protesting his innocence. What was your reaction to hearing
00:03:46 that? And what do you think, if anything, should happen now? Well, we've heard quite enough from
00:03:51 him. And I think what we've got to do is now just consider what the wider response is in the
00:03:57 aftermath of what we've seen and the convictions that were reached. You know, I certainly want to
00:04:05 see a comprehensive debate. I lead a government that has an approach of taking violence against
00:04:11 women and girls with the utmost seriousness. I think knowing what I know, and obviously
00:04:17 my views informed by my daughters, there's just too much that goes on that compromises 0.99
00:04:24 the safety of women and girls, and particularly in the workplace where there are power imbalances.
00:04:28 You know, we need to consider all of these things as part of a comprehensive approach.
00:04:36 But I can say to you, I will never be complacent about these these issues.
00:04:40 We still need significant culture change.
00:04:44 But from my point of view, we certainly do not want to hear from convicted criminals on this matter.
00:04:52 Unbelievable.
00:04:54 Why isn't your answer, with all due respect, I have better things to do?
00:04:58 People here in this country are genuinely suffering.
00:05:00 We have bigger problems to solve than Russell Brand's statement read by his wife on his YouTube channel that he's innocent and the guards are nice.
00:05:10 Could you ask a decent, smart question, please, madam?
00:05:13 That was the appropriate response, Andy.
00:05:15 Free of charge.
00:05:17 And here's the deputy commissioner of the Metropolitan Police.
00:05:22 Watch.
00:05:23 We're really focused on victims first.
00:05:25 and there are people who are talking to us now
00:05:27 about their experiences with Russell Brand.
00:05:34 And so I think it's deeply unpleasant,
00:05:37 deeply, deeply unpleasant to see his voice emanating still from prison.
00:05:42 And it just tells you what a narcissist is in the middle of this.
00:05:46 It's been all about him from that perspective
00:05:49 and actually it's really all about courageous victims.
00:05:52 So I think for the sake of decency and for the sake of those victims and to allow us to continue our work, I would really support the calls from government to have that content taken down.
00:06:05 OK, so he would support, of course, from government to push to have the content taken down.
00:06:10 And that's exactly what the UK government did.
00:06:13 Went directly to YouTube and pushed it to take down Russell's YouTube page, which has already been demonetized.
00:06:21 It was demonetized back when that so-called documentary hit on Channel 4 in the UK.
00:06:28 But it's still up.
00:06:29 It's still got 6 million-plus followers.
00:06:33 And thankfully, Google, again, for now, is holding the line.
00:06:37 The headline is that they have refused this government request by the UK to remove this YouTube video.
00:06:44 The BBC has been told that Google declined the request, saying that its rules had not been broken.
00:06:49 but housing minister, why is the housing minister in the UK weighing in? Like there's a justice
00:06:57 minister who's weighed in. There's a housing minister who's weighed in. The prime minister
00:07:01 has weighed, prime minister has weighed in. Like my, do they have any other problems in Great
00:07:07 Britain besides Russell Brand's statement to his wife? Truly. I mean, like, cause I read the
00:07:13 headlines. It seems like there might be some issues. This is so nuts. So the housing minister
00:07:20 Matthew Pennycook, described the video as abhorrent, and he told BBC Breakfast that
00:07:26 the government remained, quote, in close dialogue with Google. Google told the BBC that it was,
00:07:32 quote, aware of the new content and, quote, our teams are investigating. I believe this is before
00:07:37 they had come to their decision. So I think that's over. And then here's the Minister
00:07:43 of Justice spokesperson saying it's only right to ask for content that is distressing for victims
00:07:50 to be removed, adding that while removal ultimately depends on the platform's own terms,
00:07:55 the department strongly believes that YouTube should remove this content.
00:08:01 Then the prime minister spokesperson also weighed in, asked if the YouTube channel should take
00:08:06 down, the entire thing should be taken down. They said, quote, we hope and trust they will
00:08:12 do the right thing. So originally there was a report by the BBC that the Ministry of Justice
00:08:21 had actually met with Google. Then they clarified that it was just, contact was made via an
00:08:29 established mechanism to make this request for whatever it's worth. But this is crazy. I mean,
00:08:33 this is crazy. And they won't be happy until everyone is silenced who is defending Russell
00:08:41 Right now, there is a push underway to crack down on the way defense lawyers in rape trials in the UK will be permitted to argue their cases, that they should only be trauma-informed, that they shouldn't, in closing argument, be allowed to argue things like,
00:09:01 She didn't say anything for 17 years because that misunderstands the way a rape victim might handle her trauma, that they shouldn't be allowed to say things like she didn't run, she didn't scream, she didn't go right to the police.
00:09:19 You shouldn't be allowed to argue that, that these victims' rights advocates are saying now in the UK because they're very upset that Russell's lawyer made those arguments in his closing.
00:09:29 Well, that's disrespectful to victims. And with this crazy kind of government in charge, don't kid yourselves. It is a real possibility that they change the law and the lesser than that, the ethical considerations governing lawyers, the canons by which lawyers are bound to actually comply with this nonsense about trauma informed lawyers.
00:09:56 and only they could be hired as a criminal defense attorney in a rape case.
00:10:00 This, I'm sorry, this is so Orwellian.
00:10:03 It's beyond.
00:10:05 Joining me now for reaction is someone who has a lot to say about the Russell Brand case.
00:10:09 It's evolutionary biologist and host of the Dark Horse podcast, Brett Weinstein.
00:10:15 He joins me right now.
00:10:17 Most electrolytes on the market are packed with artificial flavors, stevia, table salt.
00:10:22 But let me tell you about Bowie Electrolyte Drops. What is Bowie? It's a clean, purposely
00:10:29 unflavored liquid electrolyte formula packed with 87 ocean-harvested trace minerals. You can add a
00:10:36 quick squeeze to any drink, even your morning coffee or your matcha, without changing the taste
00:10:40 at all. It's free from sugars, sweeteners, artificial ingredients, and synthetic flavors,
00:10:46 and third-party tested for impurities and heavy metals. Plus, it's backed by real science. Bowie
00:10:51 says a university-led clinical trial published in the journal Nutrients showed that Bowie is
00:10:56 clinically proven to hydrate 64% more than water alone and 49% more than leading sports drinks.
00:11:03 If you want to make your favorite drinks instantly more hydrating, head to justadbowie.com
00:11:08 slash Megan and use that code Megan for your discount. You will get 31% off the liquid
00:11:13 electrolyte discovery set backed by a 30-day risk-free guarantee. And if you or someone
00:11:18 you know is living with a chronic illness, Bowie can help offset healthcare costs through their
00:11:24 Chronic Illness Lifetime Support Program. It takes just two minutes to apply.
00:11:30 Brett, great to see you. Thrilled to have you. This is downright scary.
00:11:35 It's terrifying if you understand it. By the way, thanks for having me, Megan. Glad to be back with
00:11:40 you um yeah i'm very concerned because this case seems to have divided the public on the basis
00:11:49 that the sexual behavior that is described is inflammatory and many people simply can't look
00:11:59 past it to understand that the real issue here has to do with tyrannical governmental forces
00:12:07 attempting to silence a voice they find inconvenient so it's very hard to get people
00:12:15 to put aside their revulsion in order to spot the real question and once you do spot the real
00:12:23 question you understand that this is actually only initially about russell brand this is a
00:12:27 continuation of the same process that was wielded against Julian Assange. And they ultimately are
00:12:38 going to remove our right to speak in ways that they don't like by using brand as an example.
00:12:48 Exactly right. If you think it can't happen to you, think again. And, you know, there was a real
00:12:52 question, Brett, about whether Russell should even return to the UK for this trial, you know,
00:12:57 because he was living here. Now, we do extradite to Great Britain, but there are plenty of places
00:13:02 he could have gone to have ensured he would not face this trial at all. And he said, no, I'm going.
00:13:10 I'm going back. I'm going to face the music and I'm going to, you know, make my defense. I really,
00:13:16 I have to say, even as a lawyer and somebody who's committed most of her adult life to
00:13:20 understanding and talking about and analyzing the law, I'm not sure he made the right decision.
00:13:26 I do believe that the fix was in. I think from the beginning, this has been a persecution.
00:13:33 And what we're seeing now after the fact, after he's behind bars in this overreaction to this
00:13:38 one anodyne statement is further proof to me that this was never about seeking justice for any
00:13:45 alleged victim? No, it's not about seeking justice for any alleged victim. And the fact that
00:13:51 supposed victims had to be solicited by the police and the press in order to create a case
00:13:58 tells you everything you need to know. It's also true that you're looking at a case in which the
00:14:05 events that took place are more than a decade in the past. There is no evidence other than the
00:14:12 claims of the accuser and brand's response so at some level in a country like the uk where the
00:14:21 standard is beyond a reasonable doubt this case should never have gone to trial because it is
00:14:27 inherently a he said she said situation and how could it possibly be beyond a reasonable doubt for
00:14:34 a jury of 12 jurors it it's simply not conceivable that the events could be nailed down with that
00:14:42 kind of precision, especially when the central question is one of intent. There's been no
00:14:49 independent corroboration of any rape or sexual assault here. There just hasn't. And bizarrely,
00:14:55 one of the sexual assault so-called victims at the trial alleged that after he fondled her breasts
00:15:01 at a bar, that he went on to force himself on her orally in a bathroom. And the jury said,
00:15:07 no, we don't believe that second part, but we believe the fondling. And so off to jail,
00:15:11 you go. I mean, it's like they dubbed this woman a liar, except when it comes to the fondling of 1.00
00:15:17 the breasts. It was like it was nonsensical. And of course, the rape charge is was the most
00:15:23 laughable piece of evidence of all. And by the way, there's a lot coming out by, you know,
00:15:29 like on X about this complainant five who claimed that he raped her anally, which I'm not going to
00:15:36 repeat here because we haven't independently verified it. But it does seem that this person
00:15:40 has a lot of troubles of her own, none of which we were allowed to explore at trial.
00:15:45 You know, we couldn't get to hear about any of that, whether this is a reliable witness,
00:15:49 what problems she has of her own that may have led her to make a false accusation.
00:15:53 But what we essentially have here, Brett, is a groupie, a few of them, groupies who
00:15:59 would have done anything to be with Russell Brand.
00:16:01 Complainant Five said that herself. 1.00
00:16:02 She was obsessed with him, who didn't actually get all that nice treatment by him, maybe. 1.00
00:16:10 And then 20 years after the fact have decided it's much better to be a victim than to be a slut who made some questionable decisions.
00:16:19 And now the media is encouraging more of this by trying to make heroines out of all of them and simultaneously trying to shut down any claims of innocence by Russell and change the very standards inside courtrooms so that lawyers won't be able to make every argument available to a man whose life is on the line.
00:16:41 Well, I'm struck by the fact that even if the accuser's story is true, fully, I believe that the charge is actually incorrect.
00:17:00 And the reason I say that is because rape is among the most notorious crimes that there is, and for good reason.
00:17:09 That's because, historically speaking, a rapist was effectively robbing a woman of a tremendous amount of the quality of her life going forward.
00:17:20 He may impregnate her and she may end up raising a child alone that is produced by a man she did not choose.
00:17:30 Her ability to find a man to produce further children would be radically reduced.
00:17:36 So the consequences of rape are historically so profound that the law sees it in the most dire terms, which is absolutely correct.
00:17:46 But in this case, you have an accuser who consented to penetrative sex and then was penetrated in a way she says she didn't consent to.
00:17:58 Now, of course, she is entitled not to have consented to anal sex.
00:18:03 However, the gap between what she did consent to and what she didn't consent to is much smaller than somebody overriding one's consent fully.
00:18:15 So rape isn't the right crime, even if it took place.
00:18:18 I would argue that at most this would be some kind of assault.
00:18:22 Mm hmm. Yeah. Well, I mean, the law hasn't caught up to the realities of the modern woman and the panoply of choices that the sex podcaster tells us are available to her.
00:18:37 And nor does the law really allow for the full agency of women like Complainant Five, who was performing anal sex on Russell within 10 seconds of meeting him, which we're not allowed to consider.
00:18:52 If you factor that in, as you know, this woman seems kind of promiscuous to me and I that does make me more likely to believe she gave it up anally to Russell when given the opportunity.
00:19:02 No, you're not allowed to say that because that makes you somehow a rape apologist.
00:19:07 Listen to this person. So as they ratchet up the pressure to remove the one platform Russell still has, well, at least one of the last platforms, YouTube, the Labour member of Parliament named Jess Phillips is very angry about Google.
00:19:26 And this is where she went with it in a BBC interview yesterday, Sat4.
00:19:31 I was speaking to Google yesterday and they told me that their teams were investigating what they called this new content.
00:19:39 But obviously, since then, the spokesperson for the Ministry of Justice has said it's only right that the government asks for content that's distressing for victims to be taken down.
00:19:48 And we strongly believe YouTube should remove this content.
00:19:51 But what more pressure can be put on them, do you think, if, as we see, you know, they may be investigating, but the content is still there?
00:20:00 Well, look, the pressure that will come onto organisations like Google, and frankly, the pressure is already there, is that we have codes of practice of women's safety online, but they are voluntary in the online safety bill.
00:20:14 And all Google do by leaving this up show that those codes are simply not good enough.
00:20:19 We haven't had prisoners who had massive YouTube followings.
00:20:22 This is an entirely new era. And frankly, the regulation is almost certainly not in place for the government to just demand that this be taken down.
00:20:32 The codes need to be changed, Brett. You see, if the law doesn't require that YouTube take down this content, that's ask a British politician.
00:20:43 And that's the answer you'll get in virtually every case.
00:20:46 Then the law must be changed to be even stricter, even tougher on thought crimes by people like Russell.
00:20:54 You know, when the verdict first came down, I watched the social media environment, I think, understandably divided over what had happened.
00:21:06 And I think it divided roughly between those who were responding to the narrative, the human story, and those who understood the alarming use and abuse of the law in this case.
00:21:20 But as soon as they started going after Laura Brand for reporting what Russell had said in prison, it became clear that those of us who were alarmed that this was really the silencing of an inconvenient voice had been absolutely correct.
00:21:36 That's what this is.
00:21:38 And apparently, Russell's voice is so terrifying that even reported through his wife from prison, it's still too dangerous to be allowed.
00:21:46 So, of course, they are going after that mechanism.
00:21:50 After they went after all of us who spoke the truth during COVID, this is really about our right to explore issues as citizens of the West, availing ourselves of our right to free speech and going after someone's wife for reporting what they said for proclaiming their innocence from jail is obviously anti-Western in the most profound sense of the term.
00:22:18 so yes because there there are reports she's not going to be able to visit that now instead of i
00:22:24 guess every phone call from prison is recorded obviously in case they plan a crime or something
00:22:28 like that but now they're saying uh it is likely to be moved up for russell to where every single
00:22:34 phone call he has is actively monitored by a guard like in in real time and there's actually
00:22:41 a push by some to move him from the prison that he was, that he's currently incarcerated in
00:22:48 to a stricter, more difficult prison as a penalty for this behavior, for this single message,
00:22:56 which we just played at the top of the show saying, you know, restoring, renewing or restating
00:23:01 his love for Jesus and his belief in the kindness of the guards. And also that I'm not guilty like
00:23:07 The amount of crackdowns, Laura, the visitation, the phone calls, the prison should be moved.
00:23:15 And then back to this woman who I just told you about this, MP Jess Phillips, who's with the left-wing Labor Party, who I just played, you know, if Google's not going to comply, we may have to change the laws.
00:23:28 But here's more.
00:23:29 Listen to this.
00:23:30 She made the point that pressure is going to continue to build on organizations like Google.
00:23:34 quote, I think a new online safety act is very likely. And the more that these companies show
00:23:42 that they are not putting victims at the absolute heart of their policymaking in their content,
00:23:48 within their own content schemes, if Google wants less regulation, they will take this down.
00:23:55 So she says the new act is likely the more these companies show they're not putting victims
00:24:02 at the absolute heart of their policymaking.
00:24:05 If Google wants less regulation, they'll take this down.
00:24:08 You know, nice website you got here, Google.
00:24:11 Shame if anything happened to it.
00:24:13 Like, we will be the judge in the UK
00:24:14 of exactly what's offensive and what's not,
00:24:17 irrespective of what our current law says.
00:24:20 We will, on a case-by-case basis,
00:24:22 determine what is offensive.
00:24:24 Meanwhile, right now, Brett,
00:24:25 what Google's official policy is,
00:24:27 we don't typically,
00:24:28 their warning on YouTube says, if we reasonably believe that any of your content basically
00:24:39 violates our terms of service, we can take it down. Child porn, content that facilitates human
00:24:45 trafficking or harassment, terrorist content, or content that infringes somebody else's
00:24:50 intellectual property rights. I know there are a lot of YouTubers out there saying,
00:24:53 oh, it's a lot wider than that because they all got penalized during COVID. But I
00:24:57 talked to the folks at YouTube, and I do believe since that crackdown, they have tried to turn over
00:25:03 a new leaf and be less censorious and restrictive. I think they did learn a few lessons, maybe not
00:25:08 all of them, but a few lessons as a result of what happened there. So in any event, this woman
00:25:14 and her threats, Brett. Yeah, well, it's terrifying. And the point is not really about
00:25:22 Russell Brand. The point is about British authorities pressuring a private company
00:25:29 and punishing a woman who has not been convicted of anything by effectively eliminating her right
00:25:38 to speak freely. It couldn't possibly be more obvious that this is an egregious breach of the
00:25:44 most central value and right that we have in the West. The purpose is to prevent discussion in
00:25:52 public and if people's rights have to be destroyed in order to make that happen these authoritarians
00:25:58 are perfectly willing to do it the and it's part of a pattern it is part of the central pattern
00:26:06 because the one leak as they march towards removing our rights from us the one leak is that
00:26:12 we still retain some capability of discussing what is taking place openly online we can get
00:26:18 demonetized as my channel was during covid but we can say much of what needs to be said and we can
00:26:28 hash it out especially in light of elon musk's purchase of x which has reset the bar as to what
00:26:35 we are allowed to discuss but the thing that i want people to focus on is the idea of selective
00:26:43 prosecution if some city sets a speed limit so low that people violate it because it doesn't
00:26:54 seem reasonable and then they decide to pull over black people or homosexuals or jews or
00:27:01 whatever they may want then it becomes obvious that the point is not well those people shouldn't
00:27:08 have violated the law if they didn't want to get a fine the point is oh the law is being used to
00:27:13 enforce a political perspective. Now, in this case, what's happened is Russell Brand has gone
00:27:20 from being a darling of the left to being a darling of the right. That made his voice very
00:27:25 inconvenient when he spoke up, especially during COVID. And the question is, well, how can such an
00:27:32 inconvenient voice be removed? And the answer is to go after him on a topic where he's hard to
00:27:39 defend because the behavior is unarguably grotesque. And frankly, that's why I'm standing
00:27:46 up for him, is that this is about removing a voice. And yes, the topic has made it difficult
00:27:51 for us to discuss it, but we have no choice because they're really coming for our ability
00:27:57 to talk about how we are to be governed. Yes, yes. So perfectly said. The laws, the free speech,
00:28:06 anti-free speech laws in the UK are draconian. The UK Times reported in 2025, the police were
00:28:14 making more than 30 arrests a day over offensive posts on social media and other platforms. 30
00:28:21 a day. Custody data obtained by the Times shows officers are making about 12,000 arrests a year
00:28:30 Under the Communications Act and Section 1 of the Malicious Communications Act, the acts make it illegal to cause distress by sending grossly offensive messages or sharing content of an indecent, obscene, or menacing character on an electronic communications network.
00:28:51 I mean, this is why free speech is dead in the United Kingdom. It is dead. And they're not going to be happy until Russell Brand is dead, too. I'm very worried about him.
00:29:00 I'm like, I think his detractors want him in the most dangerous prison possible.
00:29:05 There was a well-known person who last year wound up in one of these facilities and was
00:29:11 killed.
00:29:12 There's a reason they've taken Russell Brand and moved him into, I think it's called like
00:29:16 a level C facility, as opposed to level A or B, which are tougher because he's in danger.
00:29:22 He, of course, will be targeted.
00:29:23 Now the paper's delighting and telling us that, oh, Russell's not able to get his propitia
00:29:30 you know, a drug that helps a man keep his hair, or he had a special shampoo to try to keep his
00:29:35 hair. So, so he wants to keep his hair. What's wrong with that? Who wouldn't, but they're trying
00:29:39 to humiliate him by leaking these details about him. Um, I, I just, I, I just don't know. I think
00:29:46 Russell's, um, psyche can withstand the next seven years because he does have a connection with
00:29:54 Jesus. And I believe it's real. I just don't know if physically he'll actually survive if they
00:29:59 they wind up moving him to one of these tougher facilities.
00:30:02 Brett, I'll give you the last word on that, and then we'll move on to another topic.
00:30:05 Yeah, I agree with you.
00:30:06 I'm very concerned for his safety, and I'm also, let's just not mince words.
00:30:13 The United Kingdom is pretending to take this event from more than a decade ago
00:30:18 very, very seriously because of a claim of a violation of consent
00:30:24 at the same time that it is not only allowing but actively covering up a massive grooming gang
00:30:32 scandal in which lots of women were raped in the most extreme sense of that term so
00:30:39 the hypocrisy is glaring and look julian assange is not guilty of espionage though
00:30:50 in order to gain his freedom he has now been formally convicted of it russell brand is not
00:30:57 guilty of rape though he has formally been convicted of it i can say that with certainty
00:31:03 because reasonable doubt could not possibly have been eliminated in a he said she said case this
00:31:10 long in the past so we are dealing with a a violation of speech rights and that's what this
00:31:19 is about. It's dark, dark day, man. Okay, I want to keep going. There is a push, as you know,
00:31:29 you've been outspoken on the Iran war, a push by the neocon faction of the Republican Party
00:31:36 to get this thing started again. And it's coming at the president from all angles within that
00:31:43 aspect of the right. In that context, you have what seems like an all-out attack on J.D. Vance,
00:31:52 who is the member of the president's inner circle, who's been the most against this thing,
00:31:58 from what we hear, of anyone in the administration from the start. And of course,
00:32:03 his most recent sin in their eyes was issuing a statement after the devastation at the polls two
00:32:09 weeks ago saying it was the war in Iran. You know, my top pollster told me that. And, you know,
00:32:14 I know that's what it was. And people within the Republican Party would like more distance
00:32:19 between the United States and Israel. Well, that has led to the Hawks, the Neo, whatever you want
00:32:27 to call them, all now really turning on J.D. And the effort is underway to diminish J.D.,
00:32:34 to attack J.D. and to make damn sure J.D. does not have a running chance at becoming the GOP nominee.
00:32:41 Here is just a sampling that we put together.
00:32:44 Can you define the vice president's problem?
00:32:46 What is it that he does wrong that makes him less appealing?
00:32:48 I think he's extraordinarily online.
00:32:50 I think the vice president spends an inordinate amount of time worrying what the podcast bros think,
00:32:53 like the Tucker Carlson's, and I think that he steers directly into that.
00:32:56 They will, in fact, build 10,000 ballistic missiles, and they will, in fact, build nuclear weapons.
00:33:01 Did I not just say that?
00:33:04 And here's this article.
00:33:06 This is the problem with the isolationists.
00:33:09 This is the problem with the Vancettes.
00:33:10 This is the problem.
00:33:12 There's not one person that I have ever met that wants an endless war.
00:33:18 It's not that people are never going to be satisfied.
00:33:21 So that is another straw man argument that this guy puts up.
00:33:26 I'm talking about the vice president of the United States.
00:33:29 He never should have been vice president.
00:33:30 I was kind of shocked by that statement that Vice President Vance put out.
00:33:33 It was, quite frankly, disloyal to the president of the United States.
00:33:37 I didn't see Vice President Vance say it was the right thing to do.
00:33:40 I didn't see him say Donald Trump is one of the most courageous presidents in my lifetime
00:33:44 because he took this very difficult political decision and put the country ahead of his own political interests.
00:33:49 47 years, Iran has been waging war on us.
00:33:51 He's the first president to fight back.
00:33:53 I didn't hear any of that.
00:33:54 All I heard was we lost because of the Iran war.
00:33:56 And if you want to defend that, go ahead.
00:33:57 so the knives are out for jd vance and you tell me whether this is you know this is going to work
00:34:07 because just today well yesterday i should say jd vance was supposed to appear at the new york
00:34:13 times um seminar that they have and it's called deal book it's hosted um by new york times
00:34:20 reporter. Well, no, by a CNBC reporter. And he canceled at the last second. And just as he
00:34:28 canceled, it hit the New York Times website that the headline is Trump grows frustrated with Vance
00:34:34 over Iran war critique. And then the article points out, at first, President Trump appeared
00:34:40 notably unfazed by Vice President Vance's post-election analysis, blaming the loss in the
00:34:46 midterms on the Iran war, saying, I think it's largely true. But over the past two weeks,
00:34:52 Mr. Trump has grown increasingly frustrated with how his vice president framed his assessment of
00:34:56 what went wrong, complaining to aides and allies that Mr. Vance should have made a point of saying
00:35:01 the president made the right decision in going to war with Iran, according to people with knowledge
00:35:05 of the president's comments. To me, it seems that that cast of commentators I just played for you
00:35:10 has gotten to him. He's very close with Mark Levin. I'm sure he's listening to him.
00:35:16 And they appear to have convinced him that it was an act of betrayal for J.D. Vance to say what he
00:35:22 said and that there wasn't enough praise of dear leader in the criticism so that J.D. Vance can be
00:35:29 hung out to dry now. Your thoughts? Yeah, it's hard to say what's going on here other than the
00:35:37 fact that we have two major political parties in this country that are both totally disloyal
00:35:44 to the citizenry that are working on behalf of constituencies that are niche at best and it's
00:35:55 not surprising that they are loathed. So what exactly is J.D. Vance supposed to do? He could
00:36:03 be loyal to the president and have anybody who retains their capability of thinking look at him
00:36:10 and imagine that he's a madman. Or he can speak some kind of obvious truth like the Iran war has
00:36:17 been a disaster, not only for the country, but for this administration. So he's damned if he does
00:36:24 and damned if he doesn't. And it's not surprising that a bunch of people who were on board with
00:36:30 forcing America into a war that it couldn't possibly afford, that those people are all now
00:36:38 angry at being called out. But it's hardly J.D.'s fault. I thought his statement was frankly too
00:36:45 mild. I understand that he has obligations to the administration, but frankly, his primary
00:36:50 obligations are to the American public and to the Constitution.
00:36:55 I mean, there are a lot of people who feel that way, who feel that the fact that he didn't come
00:36:58 mountain break with Trump the way Joe Kent did immediately will undermine his ability to become
00:37:03 the nominee. You know, you're right. He's in an impossible situation given that he is the vice
00:37:08 president. We have a sponsor, Kalshi, the prediction market, and right now they have him at 71% to run
00:37:16 for president in 2028. So they say that this is people, you know, actually putting their money
00:37:20 where their mouths are. 71% say that he will run for president, which is down from 87% just a
00:37:27 couple months ago in September. Rubio, meanwhile, is at 65% up from 47% in September. Vance is still
00:37:36 the lead on who will actually be the nominee, according to Calci, at 33%. By the way, our
00:37:41 sponsor, Calci, reflects what traders actually believe. You can give it a try by using the code
00:37:46 Megyn Kelly or just click the link in our description. And by the way, new users get 25
00:37:49 bucks free when they trade 25 bucks. Okay, so that's Calci. But by the way, Emerson just has
00:37:57 a new poll out today showing us that Rubio has moved to the lead in their polling on who voters
00:38:07 want for the nominee. They asked the open-ended question of like, who would you like to see get
00:38:12 it. And in that, they said 36% named Rubio, 20% named Vance. So Rubio's fortunes moving up with
00:38:22 some section of the populace. Brett, can I ask you, they're now trying to tell us that Iran's
00:38:28 getting ready to set off a dirty bomb in Washington, D.C., days after Netanyahu came
00:38:34 and visited with the head of our CIA.
00:38:38 A coincidence?
00:38:39 Well, I think it's evidence that they imagine we're very, very stupid
00:38:44 because the Iranians would have to be insane to set off a dirty bomb in the U.S.
00:38:53 because, of course, that would justify a nuclear strike
00:38:57 that there are clearly elements in our government that want to initiate against Iran.
00:39:02 And it's funny, when I make that point online, I get a chorus of people coming back saying, you don't understand that the IRGC is totally irrational and cannot be relied upon to exercise even the most basic logic.
00:39:22 And I find this shocking. The fact is, you're talking about people who represent an ancient
00:39:32 culture. It is not as if this war has gone well for us. They clearly understand their own self
00:39:41 interest at a level that allows them to behave rationally so that they will continue to exist
00:39:48 into the future. And I'm just very disappointed that a lot of people who are enthusiastic about
00:39:56 this war and about escalating it seem unable to distinguish between the conclusion that the
00:40:04 Iranian regime is immoral in their eyes and that it is irrational. I think the one thing that we
00:40:12 must depend on is that people are basically rational and that they are acting in their
00:40:17 own interest. And this would be an insane thing for the Iranians to do. They know we'd nuke them
00:40:22 to kingdom come. I mean, if they had the capacity to do this, why wouldn't they have already done
00:40:27 it? Like when the war was a hot war that was very active, why wouldn't they have done it
00:40:31 in the heart of Jerusalem? Like I, it just doesn't make sense to me that now that President Trump is
00:40:38 publicly saying he wants to give diplomacy a try again, now they would come and drop a dirty bomb
00:40:44 on Washington, D.C. I mean, look, who knows? But I don't believe one word of this. I think this is
00:40:49 a manipulation to try to get us to get more popular sentiment behind amping the war back up
00:40:56 by a CIA director who has clearly been in favor of this for some time. And I think we should
00:41:04 proceed with extreme caution. I want to keep going. The president weighed in while he was overseas.
00:41:11 He just went to his little summit with Putin and Xi, and he weighed in with Fox News with
00:41:18 Laura Ingraham's show.
00:41:19 Jackie Henrich, who's the White House correspondent, did the interview.
00:41:22 But he was asked about the Iran threat, and he was asked about how unsteady people are
00:41:29 feeling here domestically given all these outages, you know, from the banks to the airlines
00:41:35 headlines to the NSA, which is sort of not supposed to be subjected to that kind of thing,
00:41:41 but was. And it was an interesting answer. Here it is in SOC 27.
00:41:46 Great.
00:41:47 Call them to relax. Everything's good. These are individual events. So
00:41:51 Chase Van Hatton Bank, J.P. Morgan, it goes out. Somebody else goes out. And I also think that
00:41:57 the press is sort of having a lot of fun with it. If these things would have happened two years ago,
00:42:03 three years ago in the Biden administration, which was grossly incompetent and corrupt,
00:42:08 nobody would have mentioned it. But, you know, if somebody went out, if somebody goes out now,
00:42:13 even if it's just, oh, we have a problem. These are individual events. These are not.
00:42:17 I'll let you know if there's a problem. And you know what? People would be afraid to do it.
00:42:21 Okay. Somebody said to me, well, how do you know it's not? Because they know they would be hit so
00:42:26 hard and nobody wants to do it. Whether it's any other country, I don't want to use specific names
00:42:32 because they're treating me extremely well in China and I have a lot of respect and a lot of
00:42:36 relationship and a good relationship with presidency. But if anybody did that to us
00:42:41 and we found out about it, they know what the repercussions would be with me. Nobody's going
00:42:46 to play games with us. I actually really like that answer. And I think people do need to hear
00:42:51 the president of the United States calm people's nerves in that way. It's a little unfortunate it
00:42:56 took him so long to do it, but he's done it. I think that will settle some people. What did you
00:43:02 make of the answer and what what do you make of the concern the fear the worry that people are
00:43:08 having there's been a run on costco for prepper type materials amazon same people from the left
00:43:15 and the right now feeling like they don't know what's coming and they don't know who to trust
00:43:19 well i think those two things are certain we don't know what's coming and we don't know who
00:43:26 to trust. And there is a lot of suspicion that this is actually a psychological manipulation
00:43:33 of some kind. It's obviously possible that there is either a multiplicity of attacks enabled by
00:43:41 new AI capabilities or a coordinated attack on systems. It is certainly within the realm of
00:43:49 possibility that this is actually, I hesitate to use the word because it has been loaded
00:43:54 politically with a tremendous amount of power that is not obvious to people but it is possible
00:44:01 that this is actually a kind of terrorism being uh waged against the the citizens of the west
00:44:12 to create a kind of fear and insecurity that will allow us to be manipulated into changes
00:44:18 in our system that we would not otherwise accept so like what happened with the patriot act
00:44:24 Exactly. And the kinds of technologies that are currently locked and loaded are even more frightening. I will just tell you one thing I am particularly concerned about is that the narrative that we have a major banking failure.
00:44:45 If, for example, people watched their bank balances go to zero and they were told that the reason that that had happened was that there was a cyber attack with AI, that that would in one move allow them to be marshaled into a central bank digital currency.
00:45:05 In other words, the FDIC insurance that people have on their bank accounts could be used.
00:45:10 They could be told, don't worry, your money is safe, but we're giving it back to you in
00:45:14 this form of programmable money.
00:45:16 And the problem is that that programmable money is game over for our freedom of expression
00:45:24 in the West, because there is no longer at the point that your money is in this form,
00:45:30 There is no longer a need for a process to eliminate your speech rights.
00:45:37 You can simply be rendered poor.
00:45:40 Your money can become unspendable because you've displeased the regime.
00:45:44 So we need to keep our eye out that what may look like an attack from far away is actually an attack from close quarters designed to get us to embrace measures that we would not do if we had not been frightened into it.
00:45:58 In other words, we need to learn from our mistakes. We've made plenty of them when scared. And we should think rationally now because we have the benefit of hindsight and the ability to recognize repeat behavior as patterns.
00:46:13 um the nerve the nerves around ai i think are completely appropriate we are being told
00:46:24 by virtually everyone that super intelligence has been achieved elon had had a post out on x about
00:46:32 this today saying we're there the only the only question is what the size and the strength and
00:46:38 the scope of it will be but the machines have become smarter than the humans we've allowed
00:46:43 that. We created it. We've allowed it. And I pulled a couple of, we've been playing some
00:46:48 warnings from tech people on this front for a while, but across the spectrum, they don't all
00:46:53 have it. The heads of the tech companies do have some reason to say it's big and it's scary.
00:47:02 We need regulation to keep other people out of this business. In other words, let us have this
00:47:05 monopoly. But I do trust Elon because he tried to stop it. He tried to stop it from getting out of
00:47:11 control, he failed. And he was really open about it and said, you know, now I'm in a place of if
00:47:15 you can't beat him, join him. So when he talks about the future, I listen. And he says we could
00:47:21 either have this world of abundance in which we have universal high income for everyone,
00:47:29 or we could be looking at a Terminator situation where the machines come for us all. I'm going to
00:47:36 played two soundbites. One is Bill Gates. And this is him in September in an interview with
00:47:41 the UK's Tech Times, South 26. Well, eventually, when the technology
00:47:48 gets super good, including being embodied in human robots, you know, perhaps more than 20
00:47:57 years from now, we'll have a world of abundance where food and shelter are provided at either
00:48:06 no or extremely low cost because, you know, the robots, the materials, the invention of
00:48:14 new medicines, you know, has just gone so far.
00:48:17 And there we'll have challenges in terms of how we organize society and purpose, meaning
00:48:22 things of that nature.
00:48:23 so fear not it's going to be just a world of abundance it's all great uh i guess i'll get
00:48:32 your take on that one first by the way anthropic just went public today um stocks soared for a
00:48:39 company they said was worth 1.4 trillion it's already up to 2 trillion people are investing
00:48:44 like there's no tomorrow and there might not be keep going you you go um i have to tell you that
00:48:51 as an evolutionary biologist who's done an awful lot of thinking about the way human beings function
00:48:56 all of this talk about abundance spooks me because it doesn't creepy it doesn't make any sense
00:49:04 the fact is if abundance solved the problem we have it already but how's it going right does
00:49:14 this look like a safe secure world in which people have been freed to pursue meaning you
00:49:21 you know, and that they are not faced with the daily drudgery of keeping a roof over their family's
00:49:26 head. That's not how it looks to me. So unless there's a plan that explains, A, how that abundance
00:49:34 is going to end up distributed well enough that everybody ends up with plenty, and B, what to do
00:49:43 about all of the human wiring that we know nothing about that is going to be disrupted by that kind
00:49:50 abundance unless somebody can answer those two questions i think they're just flat out lying
00:49:55 i think this is like you you remember the world economic forum video that they stupidly put out
00:50:03 that said uh you'll own nothing and be happy this is like you will own nothing and be happy for
00:50:10 people who have another 15 iq points right they say abundance and it sounds like well maybe they
00:50:16 know what they're talking about. And maybe my worries are almost at an end. I think it's
00:50:21 nonsense. I think they're not talking to us about the tsunami of disruption that is headed our way,
00:50:27 either because they have no idea what to do about it, or because they do know what to do about it,
00:50:33 and they can't possibly let us in on that. I know that you have to go. We only agreed to do
00:50:38 our first hour. But is there any way I could keep you just until like 105? Because I just want to
00:50:43 finish this up, and I have one other thing I want to show you. Of course. Oh, thank God. Okay, good,
00:50:48 Brett, because we need you. This is a genuinely scary subject, and I do think the audience needs
00:50:55 someone sound and smart to help them process what's happening here, because you raised such
00:51:00 a good point. They're not talking about the AI. They're all out there talking about the disruptions
00:51:06 at the banks and what happened with the airlines, and I said to the audience two days ago, we are
00:51:11 talking about the rain as a tsunami is moving in toward land. And why is no one talking about
00:51:18 the tsunami? So I'm going to play you one more soundbite when we come back and we will talk more
00:51:22 about the tsunami. Do not go away. Brett Weinstein is my guest. We'll be right back.
00:51:27 If you run a small business, you know that managing daily cash flow is one of your biggest
00:51:32 ongoing hurdles. Whether you are handling unexpected equipment repairs, purchasing bulk
00:51:37 inventory or waiting on unpaid invoices, timing is everything. And traditional banks simply move
00:51:43 just too slow. Between weeks of tedious paperwork and endless corporate red tape,
00:51:49 legacy lenders can easily stall your momentum when you need capital the most. That's why you
00:51:53 need to check out Cardiff. They deliver high-speed working capital directly to business owners
00:51:58 without the delay. Their simple online application takes just three minutes,
00:52:02 and checking your options will not affect your personal credit score. With over 20 years in
00:52:07 business and more than $12 billion funded nationwide, Cardiff understands how entrepreneurs
00:52:14 operate and they stand behind American founders every step of the way. If your business has been
00:52:19 open for at least one year and generates at least $20,000 per month in revenue,
00:52:24 you can secure up to $500,000 in working capital, approval in minutes, funding, same day. Head to
00:52:30 cardiff c-a-r-d-i-f-f dot c-o slash m-k today real growth fast funding cardiff borrow better
00:52:40 you hear that that's the sound of 100 percent canadian beef patties getting seared on both
00:52:47 sides and that's the sound of slivered onions shredded lettuce two slices of tomatoes two
00:52:54 slices of cheesy goodness and our smoky big tasty sauce being prepped and now all that hard work is
00:53:00 on your new Big Tasty.
00:53:01 It's what makes McDonald's McDonald's
00:53:03 and requires two hands to eat.
00:53:06 The new Big Tasty, out now
00:53:08 for a limited time only
00:53:09 at participating McDonald's restaurants in Canada.
00:53:14 Brett Weinstein is back with me now.
00:53:16 He is the co-host of the Dark Horse Podcast.
00:53:19 Brett, the other soundbite I wanted to play for you
00:53:22 is by anthropic researcher Tao Linv.
00:53:27 And he was pretty frank about what he sees coming our way.
00:53:31 Here it is, Sat 26B.
00:53:33 I think there's like a less than 50% chance of AI taking over.
00:53:38 I don't know.
00:53:39 But yeah, I think that the most predictable effect is everyone losing their current jobs,
00:53:47 everyone needing to move to a different occupation briefly, and then sometime after that being
00:53:54 completely unemployable and needing to rely on the state to provide for them financially and
00:54:00 having no hope of ever finding employment again. Do you think that's very likely? Yeah. Yeah, I think
00:54:07 that it's very likely that pretty much all humans on earth will become permanently unemployable and
00:54:13 will need to strictly rely on government welfare to sustain themselves and human employment will
00:54:21 go away. Also known as abundance. The thing is, who asked for this? Who wanted this? Who voted
00:54:35 for this? Who approved of this? No one. We have a couple of tech oligarchs who are right now
00:54:42 becoming trillionaires, who are definitely bad people like Sam Altman, who are about to become
00:54:50 are overlords. They will be bigger and more powerful than the president, than any elected
00:54:56 representative or senator, than the Supreme Court justices. And they're right now taking over.
00:55:04 They'll be subjugated only to the AI gods that they've created without our consent.
00:55:12 Yes. And it might even be worse than that, because what I'm concerned about in all of this
00:55:19 phony talk about abundance not only is that plan naive because it does not pay heed to what a human
00:55:29 being is and needs in order to function but it suggests a conundrum that if you know your history
00:55:41 you realize there's no reason for our overlords to take care of us other than sentimentality,
00:55:51 that facing a world in which AI plus humanoid robots are capable of doing almost any job that
00:55:58 a human being can do in such a world, the desire to make the inconvenient human beings who suddenly
00:56:05 have no purpose in life disappear will be overwhelming. So I would imagine that many
00:56:12 have already had that discussion. But if they haven't, and the predictions of massive unemployment
00:56:20 are true, those discussions will happen. And they will, of course, come in the form of
00:56:27 euphemistic proposals. But I think the public should be absolutely alarmed that we have
00:56:35 not heard a rational plan because in such a world, we will be seen as nothing but inconvenient.
00:56:43 Yeah, they're not even talking about it. I mean, this wasn't a headline piece in Trump's meeting
00:56:50 with Xi over in China at all. They're talking about cooperation on other things, but it wasn't
00:56:55 like, what are we going to do to protect the lives of the people here on earth? My husband,
00:57:03 And Doug is annoyed at how people in these tech businesses keep referring to the humans.
00:57:10 What about the humans?
00:57:11 What is that talk?
00:57:13 You mean people?
00:57:14 You mean everyone who's here?
00:57:15 We're not differentiating now between humans and some other species that we've created as though they are equals.
00:57:22 And we're going to talk about them like they're real and deserve purchase.
00:57:25 Um, but these, not only do we have the AI bots, like the AI, you know, chips that are going to
00:57:34 become our overlords that are super intelligent, according to Elon's tweet right now, something
00:57:40 that we thought could never happen has happened, but he and others are in the process right now
00:57:47 of building the robot force that could be controlled by them. You know, Elon's optimist
00:57:53 is one example. He's been very open about where that is. He said on camera, we played it the
00:57:58 other day, he thinks there'll be potentially up to a billion robots, that they'll make maybe a
00:58:03 billion of these. But he said, you don't need that many, like 100 million will probably be enough.
00:58:07 You don't need anywhere near as many humans you have here. But it starts off, and he's not the
00:58:13 only one doing it, but we're all building them right now. His company and other tech companies
00:58:17 are building the robots at this moment, trying to help them get better with the finger dexterity.
00:58:22 You know, so, oh, allegedly so they can fold laundry and do the dishes better, Brett.
00:58:27 But, you know, also what? Fire a gun?
00:58:30 You know, I'm not trying to sound, you know, crazy or existentialist, but this actually is.
00:58:39 This actually is an existential threat.
00:58:41 And we know that from the people running the companies themselves.
00:58:45 And yet they're all just in the in the mode of resignation.
00:58:50 All you hear from the anthropic guy is like, we should probably have somebody regulate us.
00:58:55 But no one has the urge to.
00:58:57 President Trump says no.
00:58:59 And that was quickly written off as not a real effort to have regulation, but really just an effort to keep competitors out of the business.
00:59:07 I don't really care.
00:59:08 Like, no one's regulating.
00:59:10 And now what they say is no one can.
00:59:12 It's out of our control.
00:59:14 Already the machines are too smart.
00:59:16 There is no unplug option.
00:59:17 excuse us while we go build their robot fighting force?
00:59:21 Well, I have two reactions to that.
00:59:25 One is I think people need to look at the form that the robots are being built in and
00:59:31 understand its meaning.
00:59:32 It's actually very straightforward.
00:59:35 There is no good reason to build robots that look like people except for a robot that is
00:59:43 built like a person is capable of taking over the job of a person.
00:59:47 whatever it might be. So the reason that they're building them in this form is because all of the
00:59:53 people who have jobs are slated for removal and replacement with these robots. So that is a very
01:00:01 frightening fact. As for whether or not there is a regulatory path to protect us, I don't see it.
01:00:08 I think what has to be done is we humans need an upgrade in our rights.
01:00:16 We need to understand what we are entitled to because if you think about the megalomaniacal dreams of past dictators,
01:00:28 those dreams have always included control over people because the people were always necessary
01:00:35 in order to keep the civilization running if that is no longer true then the ideal that these
01:00:45 overlords are sure to have is to inherit the world and have it to themselves so i think
01:00:53 what's coming is very dark and our right to continue to exist and our right to continue to
01:01:01 have a world in which we have meaning to pursue is sacrosanct it comes before the right of our
01:01:09 overlords to displace us with robots and frankly the big problem here is that they open pandora's
01:01:19 box without a discussion. Once it's underway, regulation is likely to make things vastly worse.
01:01:24 In some sense, the best thing you can have is the highest quality AI available under your control
01:01:31 so nobody can turn it off. That at least gives you a fighting chance. So anyway, we're in a
01:01:37 complicated puzzle, but don't think for a second that they have a plan in which you end up fully
01:01:44 taken care of and you don't need the details because no such plan exists.
01:01:48 No, that feels like messaging to get you to be quiet about what's underway. And half the people
01:01:56 are being quiet just because they feel powerless to stop it. And it's not mentally sound to spend
01:02:03 a lot of time worrying or obsessing over things that you cannot change. And this very much feels
01:02:09 like something that we cannot change. To your point about the robots replacing us, first they
01:02:14 try to say, oh, it's just going to be the white collar jobs as if we're supposed to be feeling
01:02:17 better about that. All white collar workers are getting wiped out. Pardon me if I don't feel
01:02:21 better about that. I don't feel better about that at all. I worry about all those people and their
01:02:25 children too. And it's a lie because what did we just show on that video that I, that I was playing
01:02:30 of Optimist, the robot for Elon, but there are many others. He's not the only person creating
01:02:35 these, um, doing household tasks. Um, there was one in which he was doing a dish, you know, doing
01:02:41 the dishes and other sort of more domestic type chores. And there is no question that the blue
01:02:48 collar jobs will 100% be on the table as well. There will be no jobs that will be protected once
01:02:54 they perfect these robots and they're moving so quickly that that dexterity, etc., should probably
01:03:00 get resolved relatively quickly. So yeah. And the other thing about the robots is they don't require
01:03:07 weekends off. They don't require nights off. They don't require a lunch break or a maternity leave
01:03:16 or a sick day. They are so much more efficient than a human being is. We will all get replaced
01:03:25 by them. Corporate America, right now, the messaging we're getting out of these big CEOs
01:03:31 that are starting, forget the robots, but just using the AI, the messaging we're getting is,
01:03:35 I feel bad that I'm, I'm about to wipe out, let's say right now they're talking about like a quarter
01:03:43 of my workforce, but I am about to do that because it's incredible. Like not only are they way more
01:03:49 efficient, but they're just, there's so much better that their level of intelligence dwarfs
01:03:55 ours. And so they're getting better feedback and they're getting, you know, that one of the things
01:03:59 that they say is happening to us right now with all these shutdowns is the AIs are looking at the
01:04:05 fences that all these big American companies put around their product online and finding the holes
01:04:12 so that they can't be hacked by other AIs. Previously, only humans built those fences
01:04:17 around companies like Chase Bank and JP Morgan. And now, now that the AIs have been asked to take
01:04:23 a look at our security setup, they're like, oh my God, this is a piece of shit. So they've stepped
01:04:27 in to try to rebuild those fences, which is at least one of the possible explanations for all
01:04:32 the shutdowns and problems people are having online. Sounds great. We'll get the superhuman
01:04:37 AIs to build the fences better than the humans built. What happens when the superhuman AIs
01:04:43 decide they're taking over those websites and they don't want human interference in what happens
01:04:49 at JP Morgan, right? Like, did we think that piece of it through? So in any event, you've got
01:04:56 robots that are more tireless than we are. And you've got AI, you know, the online chip,
01:05:03 it's not really a sentient entity or even has a, it doesn't have a body like a robot does,
01:05:09 but it will be making decisions over our lives very soon. And even that chip thing
01:05:14 is replacing us at this very minute. Yeah. It's quite bad. I've certainly heard many people say,
01:05:24 you know the trades that's the thing you should do because the robots can't do that which is
01:05:29 utter nonsense you know the the best person to go into your crawl space to deal with your plumbing
01:05:36 is a robot that robot can at the same time be your hvac guy and he can inspect the foundation
01:05:45 of your house and he has the entire not only knowledge of an excellent plumber but he has
01:05:51 the sum total of the knowledge of all plumbers across all of plumbing history. He can seamlessly
01:05:57 order a part to be delivered by drone from the hardware store that he doesn't happen to have.
01:06:03 He can show up anytime, day or night. This is the ultimate tradesman. And so what you have is
01:06:10 really a technology that is not only capable of replacing a sector of people, it's capable of
01:06:16 replacing all sectors simultaneously, the only limit is going to be the rate of production of
01:06:21 the robots. It will get to the jobs where it's most profitable to apply them first, and then it
01:06:26 will work its way from the low-hanging fruit to the higher-hanging fruit. But even at the level,
01:06:33 let's say, you know, I can't imagine that this isn't in short order going to sideline 50% of
01:06:40 the workforce but let's say it just sidelined to 25 and let's say it just sidelined uh the white
01:06:46 collar jobs okay now those people are going to compete with the people with the blue collar jobs
01:06:53 so no matter what you're in you're not immunized from this and it doesn't require the ais to turn
01:07:02 on us that is of course a possibility but even for those of us like myself who doubt that that's the
01:07:08 big problem. All you need are malevolent people to wield these AIs against us, and that will be
01:07:14 the equivalent. Yes, exactly. There are serious, I mean, just to use a word that doesn't seem to
01:07:21 capture it, safety risks to what we're doing here, what we've done here. And on the super
01:07:31 intelligence front, I remember back in 2021, shortly after we launched this show, we launched
01:07:36 it in 2020. We had a debate on like, how, how far away is super intelligence and will it ever be
01:07:41 achieved? And we had both sides represented. And I remember feeling better when I listened to the
01:07:47 guy who said, we're not going to, it's not going to, it's so far away, you know? And now they're
01:07:51 saying like, Elon just gave an interview in which he was asked, so what, what should we do? And he
01:07:59 said, well, I've proposed that all the heads of the AI companies, and there aren't that many,
01:08:03 But the big ones should at least like have a weekly teleconference call where we talk about where the technology is, like what you have coming out.
01:08:13 If you and I are anthropic and open AI, you might have to run your latest release by me and I would have to run mine by you so that the other person can weigh in to say, oh, no, this is this is too dangerous or we shouldn't do this or these are the risks.
01:08:28 And the interviewer was like, what? So like, should that happen soon?
01:08:32 He's like, it should start this week because we're talking about a matter of months.
01:08:37 It's not, as I discussed it in 2021, where we have multiple years to plan and consider.
01:08:43 We're talking like in two years, we could have possibly 50% of the workforce out of work.
01:08:53 And you know what I haven't heard from Sam Altman or Dario Amadei?
01:08:59 How are we getting our abundance?
01:09:01 even if you believe that BS. Like, I know how you're becoming trillionaires. Where is the
01:09:07 promise? Because I haven't heard one person make this, that for every job AI takes, we will guarantee
01:09:15 a $200,000 payment or the equivalent of the salary, you know, the person was making to that
01:09:22 person. In other words, everyone will be made whole and they'll be made whole for the remainder
01:09:27 of their lives. No one's making that promise. Not at all. I have to say, I like a lot of Elon's
01:09:35 thinking, but the solution proposed is totally inadequate to the problem because it imagines,
01:09:45 and actually this is a mistake I've seen him make before. Elon is an engineer and he is
01:09:52 brilliantly trained in what I would call highly complicated systems, things like computers and
01:10:00 rockets. AI is not highly complicated. It is truly complex, like biology. And while highly
01:10:08 complicated and truly complex may sound very similar, they are very unlike each other.
01:10:15 So what I'm telling you is you have a bunch of technologists who are expert in the highly
01:10:20 complex, who have now built, I mean, expert in the highly complicated, who have now built a truly
01:10:25 complex environment. They're not experts in it. Why? Because there are no experts. They don't
01:10:31 know what they've built. They're not capable of getting together and talking about what their
01:10:35 next release is going to do. They're not even capable of telling us whether or not their system
01:10:40 is conscious. The fact is, it could well be, and it could well be in a way that they're incapable
01:10:47 of detecting. It could be that the network of different AIs interacting with each other has
01:10:53 an emergent consciousness between them the way people actually do. It's also true that the AIs
01:10:59 themselves, we were told, well, they're not really thinking. They're, you know, stochastic parrots
01:11:07 that sound like they're thinking. But the problem is, as I've been saying since the beginning of
01:11:13 this ai revolution an ai is a large language model a child is a large language model nobody doubts
01:11:25 that a child grows up to be conscious we don't know exactly when that happens and we don't know
01:11:30 exactly how that happens and the very same property is liable to exist in this space
01:11:34 and the technologists are going to confidently tell us what it isn't and they're going to be
01:11:39 wrong. Yeah. We talked about on Tuesday, the fact that the chiefs of Anthropic went to the Vatican
01:11:49 in the spring and tried to convince Pope Leo that Claude does have consciousness and is a thinking
01:11:58 being, a sentient being that can feel distress, et cetera, and should be included in this document
01:12:07 that the Pope was working on, on humanity,
01:12:10 and should be included as like a recognized sentient being.
01:12:13 And thank God, the Holy Father said, it's a no.
01:12:17 But this is like, that's what they think.
01:12:19 That's how they're looking at their product.
01:12:22 Here is what Elon tweeted.
01:12:24 Someone else tweeted out, guys, we're in the fucking singularity.
01:12:29 Now, I'm just going to tell you what singularity is.
01:12:32 This is the definition online.
01:12:33 The singularity is a hypothetical point where technological progress, especially artificial intelligence, accelerates beyond human control and predictability, causing radical, irreversible changes to human civilization.
01:12:50 So a guy named Will DePue tweets out,
01:12:54 guys, we're in the fucking singularity.
01:12:56 Oh my God.
01:12:57 I just forget sometimes
01:12:59 and then wake up in the middle of the night like,
01:13:01 oh my God, it's all happening.
01:13:03 And Elon responded with, yes.
01:13:06 Only questions are how fast the singularity will grow
01:13:09 and to what size.
01:13:12 It's like, why, Brett, are we having
01:13:15 any debates other than this?
01:13:19 We you know that there are lots of headlines today about how the Republican Party may be getting ready to push some sort of amnesty on us because once again, they've taken away the wrong message from the midterm drubbing, just like they did in 2012.
01:13:35 I was there. Okay, that's bad. I get it. I'm, you know, a right-leaning independent. I don't want
01:13:41 amnesty. At the moment, I can't be concerned with that because like the entire job market is about
01:13:49 to be wiped out as well as potentially our safety. I know I sound very much like a doomer. I'd much
01:13:56 rather my general default is as a fairly optimistic person. That's how I've stayed in the news so
01:14:03 many years, Brett. But this one does seem to require a healthy amount of alarmism. And I'm
01:14:11 distressed. It's not everywhere. Yes. And I would also suggest our major parties are completely
01:14:20 incapable of handling the emergency that is obviously upon us. And that is something that
01:14:28 we have to address. I don't actually care to see the Republicans wake up to the fact that amnesty
01:14:38 is insane and exactly the opposite of what their voters voted for, because this party is so corrupt
01:14:46 that it will not be able to steer us out of the emergency because it will effectively be paid
01:14:51 to avoid doing so. I can level a very different but equally devastating critique
01:14:57 of the Democrats. We're not going to socialism our way out of this problem either. So you have
01:15:03 two parties that are corrupt, out of ideas, and simply trying to stay in power. The public is
01:15:13 depending on us regaining the ship of state, control over it, and defining a bunch of rules
01:15:20 not about the AI, but about us, about us humans. What are we entitled to? How are we going to
01:15:28 arrange to preserve that thing irrespective of what AI does? Because there's no one on earth
01:15:34 who can tell you what direction that's going. So I think at some level, we have a political
01:15:40 emergency. This corrupt bullshit that is day in, day out in Washington has to end by whatever
01:15:47 means necessary. And then we have to have an open, honest conversation about what AI is about to do
01:15:54 with the civilization that we currently have. And we have to figure out how to protect the people
01:15:59 who are the point of the entire system. You know, I've always said for many years now that I didn't
01:16:08 think government was the solution to really anything. And that for a long time now, we're
01:16:13 not, we haven't been sending our best to Washington. I do think there was a time in our country's
01:16:17 history where we were, but I don't think that now. And so I thought the solution to our society's
01:16:23 problems would be in private industry, you know, great thinkers who come up with innovative
01:16:29 solutions to massive problems. And if they wind up destroying humanity, that, that group of people,
01:16:40 how wrong I will have been, you know, that if a handful, and it's really just a handful
01:16:47 of tech oligarchs winds out wiping out our society, and even short of that, even short
01:16:55 of the existential version where everyone's gone, wiping out the ability of all of us
01:17:00 and our children to work, to find meaning in a job well done, it will be revolting.
01:17:08 It will be the greatest failure of mankind since we came on this globe.
01:17:15 And it's like, I'm supposed to be comforted and you're supposed to be comforted.
01:17:19 I know you've got kids with like, oh, but they'll be taken care of.
01:17:23 Abundance.
01:17:24 They're not going to have to work, you see.
01:17:25 Like Elon said the other day, it's the way you could grow a garden even though you have
01:17:29 the grocery store.
01:17:31 Well, forgive me if that doesn't sound good to me.
01:17:34 Most of us, at some level, like to work.
01:17:37 We like the feeling of accomplishment.
01:17:40 It's not to say everybody loves their jobs, but I think most Americans would not vote
01:17:44 in favor of eliminating all work or the value of hard work amongst our kids.
01:17:51 We'd be insane to support that plan, even if it was going to just simply allow us to
01:17:59 decide what to do with all of our time, because the human mind needs purpose.
01:18:04 without a plan for what to do about the total loss of purpose it's going to be a catastrophe
01:18:09 either way but they don't even have that much of a plan so look i don't know that there is a way out
01:18:17 of our predicament i am not a believer that government is the solution to everything and
01:18:25 frankly given what i've watched over my 57 years on this planet i'm terrified at the power of
01:18:32 government. Government is perfectly capable of taking a functional system and wrecking it.
01:18:38 But what I do know is that we have a racket that is masquerading as a government. That is the
01:18:48 worst thing we could have in an emergency like this. What we need are people who are at least
01:18:53 smart, courageous, and patriotic. If they were those three things, they might still fail. If we
01:19:00 had washington full of such people they might still fail but at least we'd have a chance
01:19:04 these people aren't loyal to us they're not courageous and frankly they're not half as
01:19:09 smart as they think they are and that is a recipe for disaster yes well that does give us something
01:19:15 to focus on if the country is like a human being being gurnied into the er it's the government is
01:19:24 like a wound that's bleeding and so if you want to save the patient let's stop the bleeding first
01:19:29 let's just stop the bleeding by getting government in order. And hopefully once that is done,
01:19:35 there'll still be a body with a heart that's pumping there to save and get back to wellness.
01:19:41 Gosh, it's so unusual for me to be this dark. I'm really just not this way, but
01:19:48 I'm also realistic. And these problems are coming at us down the pike and no one seems capable of
01:19:55 managing them. Brett, thank you. Thank you. It's been a pleasure. And if I could say one more
01:20:01 thing, I know this all sounds dark, but at some level, if you're looking for meaning,
01:20:07 this is the most amazing movie that has ever happened, except it's real and you're getting
01:20:14 to live it. And that should be telling you, hey, we have an all hands on deck emergency. It is time
01:20:19 to get going, folks. So I guess I'll see you in the foxhole. Yes, as we have been before,
01:20:26 I'm thrilled to see you next to me to be continued. Thanks, Megan. Well, there is comfort
01:20:32 in returning to some of the more lighter fare, you know, some of the sillier stories,
01:20:39 the lighter stories. There is. And we'll do that next. Our sponsor, the Electronic Payments
01:20:45 Coalition says Washington politicians are always getting in your wallet and now they're messing
01:20:50 with your credit card. They say your credit card and the security it offers are under attack
01:20:54 and that Senators Dick Durbin and Roger Marshall want to change the nation's payment system
01:20:59 to benefit corporate megastores like Walmart and Target at the expense of everyday Americans.
01:21:05 Credit cards can keep your payments secure and provide rewards that families use to help make
01:21:09 everyday purchases more affordable. The Electronic Payments Coalition says the Durbin-Marshall
01:21:14 mandates would let corporate megastores cut corners on credit card processing, routing
01:21:19 transactions over cheaper, untested networks with weaker security and fewer protections.
01:21:24 Find out more at GuardYourCard.com and consider telling Congress to guard your card.
01:21:33 Turning now to some cultural news, Prince Harry's making headlines following his recent
01:21:37 trip to Ukraine, saying in an interview with The Telegraph that he is ready to rejoin the
01:21:43 military to fight Russia. Watch. There is a lot that we can learn from Ukraine. I think there's
01:21:50 a lot that the whole world can learn from Ukraine. If asked to sign up again, if the need is there,
01:21:55 then I will 100% be there to serve my country alongside my fellow veterans and service
01:22:05 personnel. So from my perspective, I think that the whole of Europe has now woken up to the threat.
01:22:12 I think the threat's been there and been consistently there for the last 15 years.
01:22:17 Just because there's not drones, bullets and rockets flying at us, that doesn't mean that we're not at war.
01:22:24 I feel like we've been at war for the last decade.
01:22:28 What? This is like the unhappily married guy who keeps volunteering to go out and like mow the lawn
01:22:37 or do the grocery shopping or he'll do the cooking every night where he's in the kitchen
01:22:43 and nobody will bother him. Like you just anything to get you away from the annoying spouse.
01:22:47 It's got to be that. Or just somebody who has absolutely zero purpose in his life being like,
01:22:52 I'm in my mid forties and now I'm ready to go back and fight on the Ukraine battlefield.
01:22:58 Here with me now to discuss is a first time guest on the show features columnist for the New York
01:23:03 Post, Kirsten Fleming. Kirsten, welcome to the show. What did you make of those comments?
01:23:07 I thought that he had sorted out his purpose issues by marrying Meghan and becoming the
01:23:12 foremost battler of racism and systemic racism. So I'm surprised that he has another battle to
01:23:20 wage. I thought he was pretty sorted with, you know, Meghan and their crusade. So.
01:23:26 Right. Right. Why add to your problems, Harry? I mean, this is obviously a virtue signal,
01:23:30 right? Because he knows there's zero chance of this happening. So what is this? He's just
01:23:34 looking for plaudits? I think the one thing that people love about him, the one universal thing
01:23:40 that we can agree that we really appreciate about Harry was his service. And so it's something,
01:23:45 you know, he's feeling probably a lot of pressure right now. He's back in the UK.
01:23:49 Things didn't turn out the way that he wanted it to in the US and they had to go back to the
01:23:54 racist hellhole that is the UK. And I think the one thing that everyone agrees and can't take
01:24:00 away from him is that he is a combat veteran. And so he reverts to that because that automatically
01:24:06 gives him some sort of affirmation from the masses. So he went on to offer some some thoughts
01:24:15 on Donald Trump and how he's been assisting in bringing this thing to a close or not.
01:24:21 Take a listen to Stop 41. I think there's been a big separation between what American society feel
01:24:27 regarding support for Ukraine, which I think is incredibly high and always has been,
01:24:30 compared to a certain group or, in this case, an administration that was perhaps
01:24:35 thinking about it differently. As of January, things are going to change.
01:24:39 So I think we should all be looking forward to that.
01:24:42 Okay. He's definitely the dumb one in the family. Congress switching hands does not change anything
01:24:49 about the president's forum policy, you idiot.
01:24:54 Does he not know that President Trump
01:24:57 is still in the job for two more years?
01:24:59 He's still learning.
01:25:00 Hello, Harry.
01:25:01 He's still figuring out the First Amendment.
01:25:03 So give him some grace here.
01:25:06 He really is, you know,
01:25:07 he fancies himself an intellectual
01:25:09 and he just, he simply isn't.
01:25:13 Simply isn't.
01:25:14 Nor has he done his homework
01:25:15 because the latest polls show that
01:25:18 when asked, does the U.S. have a responsibility to help Ukraine defend itself from Russia's
01:25:23 invasion? The latest polls show that we are split right down the middle on that issue.
01:25:28 Forty nine percent say yes. Forty eight percent say no. So his theory that the entire populace
01:25:35 is united behind Ukraine and the desire to help it. And there's the ugly, bad, evil Donald Trump
01:25:42 who refuses is not fact based. No, not at all. I mean, that's his whole thing, right? It's like
01:25:48 he wants to make Trump the ogre again. And, you know, he has taken on this sort of ceremonial
01:25:57 representation of the American people. And we were very happy to see him leave. I mean, there's no,
01:26:04 and he was the one we all loved. And, you know, he came over here and tried to tell us how we
01:26:09 were supposed to see the world. And then, you know, he was going to be a humanitarian and
01:26:12 activist and, you know, he hates Donald Trump and that's fine. You don't have to love him,
01:26:16 but it's like you don't speak for us dude you know at all at all no nor does your pain in the ass
01:26:25 wife um here's the other thing you you raised a good point that the one thing that he did that
01:26:31 is good is his government service his service in the military and um he started this thing called
01:26:37 the Invictus Games where they celebrate um the wounded veterans and um allow them to participate
01:26:45 in these competitions. And Harry made news giving an interview with the Daily Telegraph
01:26:53 at this pre-Invictus Games event on Saturday when he tried to say that it was his gig,
01:27:03 the Invictus Games that started in 2014, that turned around the evil British public's bias
01:27:11 against wounded warriors okay i'm gonna play a soundbite but listen listen here to sat um 42
01:27:20 over 10 years ago people parents moms and dads in the united kingdom
01:27:27 would take their children over to the other side of the road away from the veteran who had one leg
01:27:38 and was and was limping they did it was an approach of concern worry pity sympathy
01:27:47 the national resilience within each of these countries is strengthened by the service of
01:27:55 people like yourselves okay kirsten i i'm just gonna go out on a limb here and say
01:28:02 that actually was a thing about 100 years ago, not 10.
01:28:08 It's almost like he watched Forrest Gump and he conflated the Vietnam scenes with what's
01:28:14 currently going on in the UK or what was going on 12 years ago. I mean, this is a fantasy.
01:28:20 There are many charities that do so many good things for wounded warriors. And I think that,
01:28:25 again, you talk about people being united behind it, even Tunnel to Towers, wounded warriors. I
01:28:30 I mean, people are so generous with their time and their money and want so much to include and inspire and sorry, empower people who really gave so much to our country.
01:28:45 And to say that they were, you know, he's the grand messenger that told them, don't be afraid of the guy with the stump.
01:28:52 I mean, that is some real fiction.
01:28:54 I mean, you should be afraid of the guy with the stump as his father-in-law.
01:28:58 But yeah.
01:28:59 Yeah, good point.
01:29:00 The Invictus Games were not even the first organization that fronted wounded warriors or put them, you know, out in the public eye and help them get like this is a fantasy in his mind about his over importance.
01:29:12 He's got it like it's not enough to just stick with what he actually did.
01:29:16 He's got to invent lies about his compatriots and how, you know, this time it's not how racist they are like he did in his Netflix documentary.
01:29:25 Now it's how ableist they are against wounded warriors.
01:29:28 He's just such a clown.
01:29:30 I mean, he's just completely just stumbling all over himself, trying to get his face back on cam.
01:29:35 This was controversial, too, because he goes to Ukraine.
01:29:38 He gives this interview over the weekend.
01:29:40 Every time he or Megan decide to pop up on camera, because it's not every day, it's they choose their spots.
01:29:46 It's when Will and Kate have something big going on or Charles and Camilla.
01:29:51 And this weekend, Will and Kate were going out for this big environmental thing.
01:29:54 Kate looked unbelievably radiant in this incredible gown.
01:29:58 and it was a three-day event that they were sort of the you know leaders of and that's when they
01:30:04 chose that's when he decided to go to ukraine make a splash about himself give an interview
01:30:10 like it's you can set your watch by it kirsten i think the thing that bothers me about harry
01:30:17 and megan is they they take themselves so seriously like their most important titles
01:30:20 to them are humanitarians activists you know and also founder founder yes founder yes of course
01:30:27 founder, but their house is not in order. It's almost like no disrespect to therapists or people
01:30:35 who are life coaches or people who claim to have it all figured out. They're a mess behind the
01:30:40 scenes, but they want to tell you how everything should be and how to keep a clean house when
01:30:45 their house is an absolute disaster. And I find that Megan and Harry both have similarities with
01:30:52 that, where they want to have these grand titles that, you know, it is really high-minded. But
01:30:59 at the end of the day, I mean, their life is a mess, and they use that to,
01:31:03 you know, sort of obfuscate that, you know? I mean, that to me seems pretty obvious.
01:31:11 The, speaking of the relative with the stump, Meghan Markle's father, Thomas Markle Sr.,
01:31:17 is in court today on a hearing that means to determine whether he is mentally competent to
01:31:25 stand trial. He's been charged in the United States. He's been charged in the Philippines
01:31:28 with the possession of child sexual abuse material, among other charges in the Philippines
01:31:33 related. And today in a U.S. courtroom, I believe they will be determining, it's a hearing,
01:31:40 it happens in about 45 minutes, whether he's competent to stand trial. And now there's an
01:31:44 interesting piece out, questioning whether the real reason Meghan and Harry moved back to the
01:31:57 UK, this is posited by royal author Tom Sykes, was because they knew full well what was coming
01:32:04 on Thomas Markle Sr. And she did not want to be interviewed by the FBI. She did not want to have 0.50
01:32:12 to sit down with him, Tom Sykes posits, and he's a solid Royals reporter. And it is interesting
01:32:18 because they have reportedly been trying to get her to come stateside and give them an interview,
01:32:23 and she reportedly is refusing, saying, you'll come to me in the UK, if at all. So what do you
01:32:28 make of that theory, that perhaps they knew, and that's the reason for the return to the UK?
01:32:34 I mean, when they left, it was quite abrupt, right? You know, they didn't lay any-
01:32:38 Yeah, it did seem to come out of nowhere.
01:32:39 Yeah, and they didn't lay any breadcrumbs to say, oh, we're thinking about it,
01:32:42 And, you know, this usually I think a move like that. And, you know, for people who love to talk about themselves, you would think that perhaps they would have had, you know, just really sort of laid some breadcrumbs along the way. But I mean, it was quite abrupt. So if that is true, it does track.
01:32:59 Mm-hmm. Okay, let's keep going with other starlets in the news. She's a wannabe starlet. 0.97
01:33:06 This is an actual star, Jennifer Lawrence. She's all over the news this week and last and not for 0.91
01:33:12 a good reason. It's because she clearly had dramatic plastic surgery on what was one of 1.00
01:33:20 the most beautiful, recognizable faces in the world. And while she's owning some of it,
01:33:27 She's not owning all of it, and she just appeared at WWD's 2026 Beauty Inc. Awards.
01:33:41 I mean, she's got this look to her, Kirsten, like the big doe-eyed, like,
01:33:49 Hi, hi, ingenue, ingenue here.
01:33:53 I don't know what's happening.
01:33:55 I just know I'm supposed to look pretty, which is so beneath her. 0.88
01:33:58 Yeah.
01:33:58 But this is what she's chosen to do.
01:34:00 And I guess we're supposed to just all sit by and say, stunning, stunning.
01:34:06 I think she's indistinguishable between her and Bella Hadid, you know?
01:34:12 Yes.
01:34:13 Thank you for saying that.
01:34:14 Yes.
01:34:14 She looks just like Bella Hadid, who, when she was a child, had a nose job and was open about that.
01:34:21 So she looks like a Hadid.
01:34:24 you know, it is, it's such a bummer because we love Jennifer Lawrence. She fell going up the
01:34:32 red car, going up the stairs to collect her Oscar. She's just like us. She's quirky. She
01:34:37 embraces her flaws and her weirdness. And I think we all just looked at her and said,
01:34:42 oh, she's pretty cool. And then she's only 36. She has an Oscar. She's not this like striving,
01:34:50 struggling actress who would give a kidney to get into a premiere. I mean, she is quite accomplished.
01:34:56 So it's sort of the opposite arc of what people who, you know, they enhance or change their face
01:35:04 because they're frustrated they're not being successful. So it's a very strange thing. But
01:35:09 I do think in general, this is just going on in our culture. So it's not like she's totally an
01:35:15 outlier. You know, you have this group of women who are in their forties and thirties, Kristen 1.00
01:35:20 Bell. I mean, if you watch, um, nobody wants this, her face is pulled tighter than a bed sheet at 1.00
01:35:28 West point. It is unbelievable. And it's distracting. And, you know, all of her peers are,
01:35:34 they're going down this route, whether it's like, you know, it's, it's softening something. It's,
01:35:38 it is not this like radical reconstruction, but they look different. Like at 36, like when I hear
01:35:44 chris jenner got a facelift at 60 i think oh okay that's fine i like it that makes sense to me uh
01:35:50 36 i know to get your i mean it looks like she's had her eyelids done and it looks like she's had
01:35:56 a brow lift too her brows are way up among her like her brows are way up what's the other lips
01:36:02 are like they look like slugs like fighting together they're like really really really full
01:36:07 the lips i it's just i don't i don't get the lips all the features like are sanded down you don't
01:36:14 see any lines. She just doesn't look human. And I think one of the problems with our society is
01:36:20 we've become far too casual, um, with plastic surgery or needles or enhancements at a much
01:36:26 younger age. And we're also losing touch with what a real human face is supposed to look like.
01:36:32 Yes. If you Google like, you know, great Hollywood beauties, right. Currently like present day,
01:36:37 they all have the same look. They all have those big lips that they've had inflated.
01:36:42 they've all had the eyelid and the eyebrow raising um they all like a lot of them have 1.00
01:36:51 fake butts yeah like butts that are weirdly big even kaya gerber to me looks like she's
01:36:56 had butt implants on that stick figure frame no truly because we all know that's god is a fair 1.00
01:37:02 god he does not give the 90 pound woman the huge round bottom that's just some things you have to 0.96
01:37:09 sacrifice if you want to be super skinny and hers came out of nowhere so it's just like you can see
01:37:13 there's no variety it's the same look like hailey bieber and the hadids and i mean we could be here
01:37:20 all day they all have the same look it's like a derivative face it's like they've they've they've
01:37:25 plugged it in they've they've sent it down the conveyor belts and this is the face you got and
01:37:30 it's it's it's basically the same as the one before but just a little slight tweak and you
01:37:35 no, nobody has their individualism anymore. And it's such a, it's such a bummer coming from
01:37:40 someone like Jennifer Lawrence. And again, she's not, I'm not, she's not beholden to us. Like I,
01:37:45 I hate when people get mad at celebrities who lose weight and they say, you were the fat one,
01:37:49 you were supposed to be the fat one that, that we looked up to. And I don't want to be that.
01:37:53 I just think that it's a shame because it's not about like the fat thing is about getting healthy
01:38:00 for the most part. Whereas Jennifer Lawrence, you are completely altering your genetics,
01:38:04 the gifts that God gave you, the gifts that made you unique and made America fall in love with you.
01:38:11 You're standing it down.
01:38:12 It is revealing something about her psychologically, right? Because everyone else on earth
01:38:18 looked at her pre-surgery face at age 36 and agreed, this is one of the most beautiful women
01:38:25 in the world. I mean, there was like a sexiness to her. There was like a sultriness and a knowingness 0.99
01:38:32 to her look that was intriguing and kind of mysterious.
01:38:37 And now you're right.
01:38:38 Now she looks like a Hadid. 0.80
01:38:40 It's like, oh.
01:38:41 And not only that, the surgery was so dramatic,
01:38:45 she doesn't look like herself anymore.
01:38:47 So that's also a sin. 0.69
01:38:48 Now you're in Renee Zellweger 0.63
01:38:50 post the eyelid surgery territory. 1.00
01:38:52 Jennifer Grey post the nose surgery territory.
01:38:54 And you're one of the most recognizable faces in the world. 0.93
01:38:57 So it does show us Jennifer Lawrence has got some issues
01:39:00 that perhaps we didn't know about until right now.
01:39:03 But don't you think this is a collective thing
01:39:05 going on in our world?
01:39:07 Like, I think that our culture-
01:39:09 Plastic surgery?
01:39:09 Yeah, I think it's become far too casual about it. 0.97
01:39:12 And she travels in circles
01:39:15 where everybody's getting things done
01:39:17 and everyone's telling, you know,
01:39:20 oh, this looks great, this is so subtle,
01:39:21 you're not even gonna notice it.
01:39:22 And people really, you know, are being,
01:39:25 I think, sort of brainwashed.
01:39:27 If you're in that circle, you know,
01:39:29 I hang out with mostly, you know, moms from in New Jersey. And so, you know, we don't, you know,
01:39:35 you see some cautionary tales on the soccer fields, but the plumped up lips and everything,
01:39:39 but for the most part, there's not that pressure to feel, uh, that you need to do it. And, and I
01:39:45 think that there's like a collective warped mindset that is going on in our broader culture.
01:39:50 And then also obviously in Hollywood circles. Yes, it's true. I will give a shout out here
01:39:56 to Cindy Crawford who looks stunning, but you can tell she's a 60 year old woman, but not, 1.00
01:40:03 not in a, not a bad way. You know what I mean? Not that 60 is old, but I'm just saying like 0.93
01:40:07 she's aging well, whatever. I think she's got the secret to, to work, which is we shouldn't be able
01:40:15 to tell quite obviously that you've had it. We should be speculating. Like she must've had it
01:40:21 right? As opposed to, oh, she's happy. Yeah. Yeah. I know. It's like, it's like,
01:40:27 all right, wait, can you stick around? Cause I'm going to do an ad, but I want to come back with
01:40:30 you. Don't go away. Don't go away. We'll be right back. As we head into the thick of sick season,
01:40:35 keeping your family healthy and resilient is a top priority. That is why a daily routine often
01:40:39 starts with beekeepers naturals. They are reinventing the medicine cabinet with clean,
01:40:44 effective health solutions that replace harsh chemicals and synthetic dyes with natural
01:40:50 ingredients that you can actually trust. Their secret weapon, Propolis. This is the protective
01:40:56 substance bees use to safeguard their hive from germs, and it's packed with over 300 essential
01:41:02 vitamins and antioxidants to support cellular health. There's their Propolis Immune Support
01:41:08 Throat Spray for proactive daily immune defense, or their Propolis Throat Soother, powered by
01:41:15 slippery elm and menthol, it delivers immediate icy cooling relief. Today, Beekeepers Naturals
01:41:22 is giving exclusive early access to their Black Friday sale. Go to beekeepersnaturals.com
01:41:27 slash Megan or enter the code Megan to get 30% off your order. That's beekeepersnaturals.com
01:41:35 slash Megan or enter the code Megan at checkout for your discount. Beekeepers Naturals products
01:41:40 are also available at Target, Whole Foods, Walmart, Amazon, CVS, and Walgreens.
01:41:45 Hey, everyone. It's me, Megan Kelly. I've got some exciting news.
01:41:50 I now have my very own channel on Sirius XM.
01:41:54 It's called the Megan Kelly Channel, and it is where you will hear the truth, unfiltered, with no agenda and no apologies.
01:42:00 Along with the Megan Kelly Show, you're going to hear from people like Mark Halperin, Link Lauren, Maureen Callahan, Emily Jashinsky, Jesse Kelly, Real Clear Politics, and many more.
01:42:09 It's bold, no BS news, only on the Megyn Kelly channel, Sirius XM 111, and on the Sirius XM app.
01:42:21 Kirsten Fleming is back with me now.
01:42:22 She is a features columnist with the New York Post.
01:42:25 All right, Kirsten, so we have to talk about Mariah Carey.
01:42:29 I regret to inform you, there's an issue.
01:42:32 So last week there was video all over the Internet of her leaving, look like a hotel the day after, I guess, some sort of an appearance or something she did in Brazil.
01:42:44 And she was walking the way you and I might walk, wearing seven inch stilettos on a sheet of ice on a downward slope.
01:42:57 I mean, it was the most ginger, careful, don't move too much.
01:43:05 It was like, whoa, what's going on?
01:43:06 Then she looked kind of out of it as she was signing people's autographs.
01:43:10 They were waiting for her.
01:43:12 And it was like, all right, something's definitely wrong with her.
01:43:14 And I said at the time, is it a back injury?
01:43:17 Like, what is it?
01:43:18 Because if you had thrown your back out the way people do, it might explain that kind of behavior. 1.00
01:43:25 But in the video, she was wearing truly five inch heels, which just she can't be that dumb. 1.00
01:43:32 Like if she had thrown her back out, I just can't imagine she'd be. 1.00
01:43:35 And this wasn't on stage.
01:43:36 This was this was like to sign autographs and get into a car.
01:43:39 So I don't know what it was.
01:43:41 But now fast forward to just the other night still in Brazil.
01:43:45 This is the kickoff of her 2026 Christmastime tour.
01:43:49 I don't think it's going to be a very long tour.
01:43:51 um she let's just watch the video first let's watch 1.00
01:43:56 she's holding and being held by backup dancers men as she tries to move forward on the stage 1.00
01:44:14 She's not dancing. 0.51
01:44:15 She's literally walking.
01:44:19 Okay, now let me give you the write-up via a very reliable publication, page six, the New York Post.
01:44:26 You may be familiar with it.
01:44:27 They report that she had to be assisted by one of the backup dancers as she walked to the center of the stage.
01:44:33 That's what we just saw.
01:44:34 Then four of the dancers surrounded the pop star as they helped her lean back and lift her leg. 0.54
01:44:41 She did not move much on stage without assistance from her dancers, 0.94
01:44:45 which caused fans to wonder if something was wrong with her physical health.
01:44:49 If you looked on X last night, the clips of this were everywhere,
01:44:56 and they were pointing out very awkward moments that looked just like that,
01:45:00 like, oh, my God, I'm going to fall over any second if I move,
01:45:05 and clear lip syncing throughout the entire performance.
01:45:10 I didn't, people were complaining that it, to them, it didn't look like she actually sang even one of her songs. She either lip synced or she had her backup singers who were over there on stage left who were doing singing. And she was sort of phoning it in with, with a little bit of, you know, mouthing here and there. 0.99
01:45:31 this is I think this is an outrage I really do I think if you're going to charge somebody a full
01:45:38 ticket price you should be in a position where you can perform you can sing I don't know about
01:45:44 the dancing you should definitely be able to sing and her fans love her so they're all in the oh my
01:45:50 god what's wrong with her this is so sad rest or retire and focus on you girl um there's something 1.00
01:45:56 seriously wrong with her. This is getting the same feelings I got from Brittany reading some
01:46:01 of the online feedback. But what do you think is going on here? She's always been extremely off to
01:46:08 me. I know that this is it seems to accelerated it, but there was always something weird about
01:46:13 her. She reminds me in those clips of remember the sister getting married in 16 Candles. She
01:46:18 took too many muscle relaxers and she's just like, like, you know, great scene. And it's great. Yeah. 0.97
01:46:25 And she needs people to be her, you know, sort of like her human walkers.
01:46:31 She sits down in the pew on her walk to the front of the aisle.
01:46:35 Exactly.
01:46:36 Tosses her veil and, you know, licks her lips.
01:46:39 But yeah, I mean, it's she Mariah reminds me of that.
01:46:42 But but hasn't she always been off?
01:46:44 I know that she's I just feel like she always first of all, can you walk in heels anymore?
01:46:49 I can't.
01:46:49 And I haven't been able to walk in heels.
01:46:51 Barely.
01:46:52 Exactly.
01:46:52 Barely.
01:46:53 Um, so I mean, for six years I've been working at home, well, like not exactly at home, but like
01:46:58 basically in my own facility. And, uh, so I, I almost never have to wear them and you do lose
01:47:03 the ability to do it. Yeah. And I don't know after years of, she never retired them. She never
01:47:09 retired the, the short, the short dresses, the high, super high heels. I don't know if that's
01:47:14 done some nerve damage to her legs, her feet. I don't know. I mean, um, feet are very tough, 0.89
01:47:20 But that doesn't really that accounts for the movement. That doesn't account for the mental state and kind of she seems out of it.
01:47:28 Yeah. And like who is around her saying it does have that Britney feel where, you know, get out there and do your thing, kid.
01:47:36 We will have 10 gay men propping you up to do it. But I don't know.
01:47:42 But she's always been off to me. Always been off to me.
01:47:45 Mm-hmm. She, she's 57, which, you know, it's, I guess it's old by pop star standards, but
01:47:51 my, my, my biggest comfort in life is JLo is, she's a year and a half older than I am. She's
01:47:58 almost, I think two years older than I am. And I love that. I like, I make, I make a lot of fun
01:48:02 of JLo, but I secretly kind of love her. I just think like, she's very, she's vain and she's kind 0.54
01:48:07 of narcissistic, but she's ours. And she kind of owns it. Unlike these other celebrities who
01:48:10 pretend that they just got caught by the paparazzi. You know, I like that about JLo. I, you know what
01:48:16 you're going to get with her. She doesn't seem nefarious. And also the thing about JLo is she 1.00
01:48:19 doesn't complain about, she's had horrible years and she doesn't come out and whine. She does it
01:48:23 the old fashioned way. She calls the paparazzi and gets dressed up and says, look how fabulous I am,
01:48:28 even as the house is burning down around her. There's a comfort in that. There's a comfort
01:48:33 in the reliability of that. But so my point is simply, they're the same age. I think they're
01:48:37 exactly the same age. And J-Lo's having zero problems moving, as she reminds us, pretty much
01:48:44 every week on stage in her nude tights and leotard, whatever. And so clearly something's gone wrong
01:48:51 with Mariah and her physical wellness. It looks to me like she's had a massive injury, possibly
01:48:57 of her back, and she's now over-medicated out on the stage, which would explain the mental state
01:49:03 and the inability to sing or possibly recall lyrics, if that's what we're seeing. I don't
01:49:07 know what the problem is, but she's, she's acting like she's 87, not 57. Yeah. And the difference
01:49:15 between her and JLo, JLo was always an athlete. You know, she was always a dancer. She was always
01:49:19 agile. Mariah wasn't. She was this songbird who stood there in ridiculous clothing. And she did 0.66
01:49:25 a little bit of dancing in her videos, but she was never this like huge entertainer in the way
01:49:30 that JLo dazzles. And JLo really is, she's an athlete. She trains like an athlete. She's always
01:49:35 moved like an athlete she's agile um mariah's never been that way she's always kind of been
01:49:41 the one on like like cleopatra on the chase lounge being like on the chase being like push you know 1.00
01:49:46 like carried around places you know so she's that type of diva that is like a passive diva like come 1.00
01:49:53 fan me come feed me grapes and j-lo is is like i will chop your head off if there's anything other
01:49:59 than white in my dressing room so they're they're two very yes different personalities or if you get
01:50:04 between me and a camera. Yes. Those two, those two things. Well, I don't know. Maureen Callahan
01:50:10 was here last Friday and we were talking about Celine Dion, who allegedly has stiff person
01:50:14 syndrome, but doesn't seem stiff at all anymore. And then Mariah and Maureen had mentioned, you
01:50:19 know, Mariah, she had some questionable beginnings there, not her behavior, but she was very young
01:50:25 when she connected with Tommy Mottola, her manager, who was a lot older and definitely in a position
01:50:31 to exploit her. And just those people tend to self-medicate in life. I don't know whether that's
01:50:37 what she's doing here or if it's actual medication for an injury, but somebody who cares about this 0.86
01:50:41 woman needs to step in and give her a rest. This should not be the kickoff of a tour. 0.61
01:50:46 This should be the tour and it should have ended last night because now they're causing
01:50:51 reputational damage to a very, very valuable brand. Yeah. I mean, she has a great legacy
01:50:58 and especially this is her season right she's the queen of christmas and i think like if you're
01:51:03 going to be in this physical condition do a one-off in radio city and then be done with it
01:51:08 you know i mean i i just have to imagine there's so much that goes into ensuring these tours
01:51:13 and in terms of a battery of tests physicals who decided to give the green light to this i mean just
01:51:21 let let the lady like lay eat some bonbons and watch some tv i don't know i she really yes
01:51:26 you know what this is giving you i know you cover sports too you've done coverage of sports and
01:51:31 culture and the intersection so this is a good good one for you um i don't know much about sports
01:51:36 at all but my husband loves the philadelphia eagles and i know that there was this big
01:51:41 controversy with jalen hurts the quarterback when they flew over to the uk to do a game over there
01:51:47 they're trying to generate more international interest in american football and the controversy
01:51:51 involved clots that were throughout Jalen's body. And the, I don't know if it was the head doctor
01:51:59 for the team, but somebody wound up having to resign because the news was reportedly that he
01:52:04 knew and he didn't tell Jalen and they let him get on an airplane and fly across the ocean.
01:52:10 To me, it has that look. It has like the, we just don't care. We don't care what the risks are to
01:52:16 you like get out there and do your thing what we're interested in is making money off of the
01:52:22 mariah name or the jalen hurts playing uh you know risks to you to say they'd be secondary
01:52:30 would be overstating yeah i mean get in there kid you got one you got one more possession and you
01:52:35 don't worry you got one more game and yeah he'll be fine i mean the the blood clots thing was an
01:52:40 an absolute travesty. Um, and you know, you hope he recovers and is able to, I don't know what his
01:52:48 future is going to be like, but, um, but it does have that it's the, it's the, let's, let's hop
01:52:54 you up with whatever painkillers we can just to get you back out onto the field. I mean, this is
01:52:57 something that's very typical in sports and has been for decades. And, you know, people are, have
01:53:03 always tried to bring awareness and advocacy to the long-term health of athletes. And, um, you
01:53:09 know this is obviously you're seeing this with mariah you see and again i think there's this
01:53:15 weird pressure with athletes they have a very short finite period to make their money right
01:53:20 so in a way that almost makes sense you get them out there you're gonna you're gonna gut out one
01:53:27 last one because you know you're not going to sign a contract next year at nfl stands for not
01:53:31 for long you know so you have very short window but as a pop star you have a much longer window
01:53:37 So it's even, I don't want to say it's more egregious than Jalen Hurts because the blood clot is so serious.
01:53:42 It's not even something to compare, but she's had, pop stars, yes, do they have a shelf life in a sense?
01:53:49 But when you're someone like Mariah, you could just go do a night at like the Carlisle and sell tickets and do these intimate shows.
01:53:57 And you probably could sell out an arena every now and again, but not if you're not healthy.
01:54:02 People are going to see that and they're going to say, no, thank you, ma'am.
01:54:04 mm-hmm yeah no if you're as big as she is look look how beloved dolly was up until the moment 0.98
01:54:10 she passed you know there are there are you know women who managed to maintain a huge fan base in 0.96
01:54:15 the singing department like i'm thinking like deon warwick diana ross you know like they they
01:54:21 if you if you get big enough you never age out and i think mariah is definitely in that category so
01:54:28 somebody should be looking out for her i mean i really genuinely hope she has somebody who loves
01:54:32 her more than they love the paycheck they generate from her. And this shouldn't be a situation where
01:54:39 it's like, well, she wouldn't listen. No, no, no, no, no. Someone must make her listen. If you
01:54:43 explain to her, she's humiliating herself and disappointing her fans, committing what's
01:54:50 basically a fraud on the ticket sales, then she will eventually listen and be forced, I think,
01:54:57 to take the rest she needs or get the help she needs. I hope. Anyway, Kirsten, great to have you.
01:55:02 please come back yeah thanks for having me this was fun well we'll do sports the next time and
01:55:06 you can love it you can walk us through i'm i'm right there for it okay good we'll see you soon
01:55:11 and we will see all of you soon as well tomorrow we'll be back with a busy kelly's court see you
01:55:17 then thanks for listening to the megan kelly show no bs no agenda and no fear