The Crime Scene： Idaho College Murders and Bryan Kohberger, Megyn Kelly Show Special - Part One ｜ Ep. 688
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
152.87141
Summary
In November of 2014, the bodies of four University of Idaho students were found in their beds in the early morning hours of the morning. The police have never been able to identify the identity of the killer, and the case has never been solved. In this special edition of The Megynkel show, we take you on a journey with just Meghan and me as we dive into the case.
Transcript
00:00:00.500
Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, live on Sirius XM Channel 111 every weekday at New East.
00:00:13.140
Suppose you wanted to kill someone. That would be easy. There are lots of ways.
00:00:19.700
But suppose you wanted to kill four people, all in the same house, all within moments of one another,
00:00:25.800
and you chose to use a knife. That could help eliminate the noise, but it would require skill,
00:00:32.720
strength, and endurance. Murder is hard work, especially if people fight back.
00:00:39.820
Then there's the really big obstacle. You want to get away with it. You're determined to stab four
00:00:45.900
people living in a single home in the still of the night and then disappear without leaving a clue
00:00:52.200
to your identity. Now that's a more difficult challenge. But you did it. You have everybody
00:00:59.680
stumped. It's the perfect crime. Welcome to a special edition of The Megyn Kelly Show, everyone.
00:01:07.580
I'm Megyn Kelly. And for the first time ever, I'm going to spend the episode today and all five
00:01:13.600
episodes this week taking you on a journey with just you and me as we dive into a true crime case
00:01:21.880
that has captivated the nation since it happened a little more than a year ago.
00:01:28.960
Ever since four young students in Idaho were found dead last November, I have consumed every podcast,
00:01:36.400
every article I could find about this case. I've watched all the true crime shows. I've read all
00:01:42.920
the magazine pieces, everything on the internet, and I've done my own reporting on the case,
00:01:47.620
interviewing experts and lawyers to try to make sense of what happened in Idaho. As we will explore
00:01:55.560
in each episode this week, there is something haunting and fascinating about the details of this
00:02:03.800
crime. It is a mystery, but it's really several mysteries all in one. In this series, I will bring
00:02:10.660
you some of our reporting, as well as the reporting and incredibly eloquent writing of Howard Bloom.
00:02:17.600
That was his writing at the top there. He is second to none when it comes to covering the Idaho murders.
00:02:23.380
This is the guy. That's the way this episode started with his words that he used to open his first
00:02:29.500
dispatch on this case for the media outlet, Air Mail News. It's relatively new and it's very good.
00:02:35.200
Bloom is a veteran and award-winning true crime writer and reporter who has written more than a
00:02:41.660
dozen books and countless articles in his decades-long career. He's done some of the best
00:02:46.300
and most unique reporting on this story. And his forthcoming book on this case will be published in
00:02:52.100
the spring by HarperCollins. That's going to be a must read. And it is Bloom's storytelling that we'll
00:02:58.900
begin with today. We asked Howard if we could strike a deal where we could use some of his,
00:03:04.600
not just his reporting, but his actual writing and intersperse it with our own so we could bring
00:03:09.060
you some of the interviews and soundbites and so on that we've amassed for you to tell this story.
00:03:15.240
And he agreed. It had been a football Saturday in mid-November, the last home game of the 2022 season
00:03:21.900
for the University of Idaho Vandals. The Kibbe Dome packed with more than 7,600 fans.
00:03:28.180
And despite the disappointing loss, Saturday night was still party night for a college
00:03:33.860
celebrated in knowledgeable polls as the best party school in the state. The stately row of
00:03:40.720
wet frats, as they're known on the U of Idaho campus, twisting along Nez Perce Drive, was crowded
00:03:48.180
with the brothers and their dates. High-spirited assemblies fueled by blaring music, prospects of
00:03:54.540
mischief and rivers of alcohol. Downtown Main Street was hopping too. The pool tables at Mingles
00:04:01.220
and the metal-sheathed bar at the Corner Club were shoulder-to-shoulder with students and townies
00:04:07.360
filling the brisk autumn night with the keen of cheery, rowdy, late-night fun.
00:04:12.140
And then in the heavy quiet of the new Sunday morning, four young corpses, all students,
00:04:20.440
all friends, were found hacked to death in their beds in a pale, clappered house, little
00:04:27.580
more than a stone's throw away from the heart of the university campus. There was so much
00:04:33.220
blood, it had seeped through the wooden floors and run down the building's gray concrete foundation
00:04:39.100
in jagged red rivulets. But before we get to that Sunday morning, we need to look back.
00:04:46.600
We need to talk about the six young students who were in the house that night and what brought
00:04:50.720
them there. Two of the six went way back. Maddie Mogan and Kaylee Gonsalves met in 2013 in the
00:04:58.340
sixth grade and became inseparable. They grew up in the tourist town of Coeur d'Alene, Idaho,
00:05:05.260
best friends for years. Listen to their parents talk about each of them.
00:05:10.100
Kaylee was one that was going to shake the world. I've yet to come across somebody who
00:05:14.400
has had anything negative to say, which people think, oh, no one would tell you that. But
00:05:19.320
I mean, I got siblings and they'll tell stories about their brother or their sister. They're not
00:05:27.260
going to hold back. So I think she found a way to live in a big family and learned the right ways
00:05:35.580
to get along with people. And that showed later on in her life when she was able to go to college and
00:05:42.680
meet all these people. Maddie Mogan, yes. She's just, she was the sweetest, smart, loving. She was the best.
00:05:53.540
She never caused me one day of stress in my life. You know, just she was the best child I could have
00:06:08.720
The night of November 12th, Maddie and Kaylee went out together in Moscow to the Corner Club bar.
00:06:16.020
More on that in a minute. Ethan Chapin was in the house that night. He was a triplet.
00:06:20.860
He and his brother Hunter and sister Maisie all attended the University of Idaho. His girlfriend
00:06:27.300
was Zanna Kernodal. She had a tough upbringing, but she was thriving. Ethan and Zanna's parents.
00:06:35.160
He literally lit up every room. Every, everybody. He was friend to all.
00:06:45.760
He just, he was an incredible human. Zanna was, she was tough. She was, she was strong. She was funny.
00:07:01.220
She just, she just couldn't make you smile no matter what. And she just had a quirkiness about her that
00:07:10.400
that, uh, not a lot of people possess that kind of talent to be able to light up a room like she did.
00:07:19.780
On the night of November 12th, 2022, Ethan and Zanna went to a party at Ethan's fraternity,
00:07:26.020
Theta Chi. One of Zanna's roommates, Bethany Funk, was at Theta Chi that night as well. But by 1.45 a.m.
00:07:33.820
on the morning of November 13th, all five roommates, including the fifth,
00:07:38.660
a young woman named Dylan Mortensen, were home in the house on 1122 King Road, along with Zanna's
00:07:46.780
boyfriend, Ethan Chapin. Zanna received a DoorDash delivery order at approximately 4 a.m.
00:07:54.580
And shortly after 4 a.m., reports are that all of the roommates were either asleep or at least
00:08:01.540
in their respective rooms. The roommates were close, active on social media, Pinterest, Instagram,
00:08:07.840
TikTok. We see how close they were in the social media posts they made, like this one.
00:08:12.640
Guys, it smells like dirty dick in here. Murphy, you've been a bad boy.
00:08:21.760
Oh my god, it's 9-10. Guys, can anybody drop me to class? I'm fucking late for my video.
00:08:29.340
Did anybody do their chores today? Fuck, I'm just gonna do it.
00:08:37.160
Oh, shit, you guys. It's 8. Gotta go. Jake's calling.
00:08:47.960
Get out of here. You seriously gotta get out of here. You're fucking freaking the shit out.
00:08:52.840
Okay, guys, I know I talk about myself a lot, but like, what would you guys do in my situation?
00:09:07.460
Yo, is it okay to have a party? Like, just three or four people, at most.
00:09:11.880
Hmm, so fun. So full of life. So funny. And so unaware of the fate that would soon befall them.
00:09:22.620
At precisely 8.57 p.m. on the last full day of her life, in the midst of a busy Saturday,
00:09:28.160
bustling with the flurry of convivial activities generated by a football game in a college town,
00:09:33.420
Kaylee Gonsalves paused before going out for a night at the Corner Club bar with her best friend,
00:09:39.560
Maddie. She posted a series of photos on her Instagram account, which she captioned,
00:09:45.780
one lucky girl to be surrounded by these people every day.
00:09:49.160
Oh, the photos are a cheery collection of six college kids, the youngest 19, the oldest 21,
00:09:56.580
bursting with bright-eyed good looks and future promise. They were meant to be, it appears,
00:10:03.520
visual testimony to the fun the students were having, to the blessings a munificent life had
00:10:09.140
generously bestowed on them. We know the girl's house on King Road was one that was full of joy
00:10:15.560
in the way a college house often is. It was the frequent location of parties or informal gatherings.
00:10:22.960
Many said the door was always open, that the roommates gave the door code out to friends who
00:10:27.560
gave the code to friends, and they would find themselves in the role of host quite often.
00:10:33.360
On several occasions, the parties brought out the police. And it is actually, strangely enough,
00:10:39.680
through police body camera footage that we get to know the personalities of these young women.
00:10:45.560
You can see how respectful they were of law enforcement in these interactions,
00:10:49.860
poised, friendly, outgoing. There was Zana one night apologizing for a noise complaint made by a
00:10:56.740
neighbor. What's your name? Zana. Zana, do you live here? Yes. This is the second noise complaint
00:11:03.180
we've had here tonight, within two hours. I'm sorry about that. So this time it was the blonde gal
00:11:07.740
and the guy on the back porch playing music. Okay. So I sincerely apologize about that. I'm just going to bed.
00:11:16.380
Okay. So just so you understand, you could be getting a misdemeanor citation for this, which means you have to go in front of a judge
00:11:24.140
and explain why you couldn't keep the people in your house quiet. Okay. We've already talked to Maddie once
00:11:30.120
and told her the same thing. Okay. The only reason she's not getting a ticket is because she's not standing
00:11:34.320
here in front of me. But I'm telling you right now, if we have to come back, you're getting a ticket.
00:11:38.600
Okay. So you will have to go see a judge. I'm fine right now.
00:11:42.120
You're not going to take it right now. I'm just trying to go to bed right now.
00:11:45.880
Kaylee, too, takes the lead in engaging with the police when they showed up to a party,
00:11:50.220
talking her way out of a potential $300 fine or a noise violation.
00:11:54.520
How are you? Good. How are you? Good. Is this your place? Yeah. Perfect. You know,
00:12:00.240
I'm here. Um, I assume noise. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Nothing against having a party. Once neighbors
00:12:06.440
start calling in, they have an issue. Fair. Uh, you go to school? Uh, yeah. Okay. What year? Senior.
00:12:11.720
Senior. Okay. So I'll tell you the same thing I told them. You probably know the girl, right?
00:12:15.380
Actually, no. Oh, okay. So usually, at least for me, I'll give you a verbal warning. Okay. Uh,
00:12:19.840
once I have neighbors calling in, you're too loud. You're serving the peace. Yeah. Nothing against having
00:12:23.620
parties. Nothing against having people over who are over here to drink. But again,
00:12:26.720
once we start disturbing the neighbors, then we've got an issue. Yeah.
00:12:29.280
Most ticket is up to $300. Yeah. Somewhere around $300, $400.
00:12:32.900
It's a pretty expensive ticket. I don't want to give that to you. That being said,
00:12:35.180
this is your place. So I'm going to hold you. I'd much rather you spend that $300 on beer
00:12:39.200
or something fun. Yeah. Most ticket, right? Yeah. Thank you. I appreciate it. Yeah.
00:12:44.120
That being said, warnings. Don't do it again. Yep. I'd hate to come back in a few hours
00:12:49.580
and then have to issue that. So, yeah. Any questions for me? No. All right. Have a good day.
00:12:55.880
Hmm. The girl's natural warmth and respect on these tapes, even in a tense situation,
00:13:01.060
makes their fate that November feel all the more incomprehensible.
00:13:06.540
In March of this year, Howard Bloom was a guest on the Megyn Kelly show. It was episode 515.
00:13:13.000
He talked about the afternoon of Sunday, November 13th, shortly after 1158 AM,
00:13:20.140
the time a 911 call came in from roommate Dylan Mortensen's cell phone.
00:13:27.460
First thing, they knew that something serious was wrong because all they got a report of was an
00:13:32.360
unconscious victim, an unconscious person, rather, at the house. And then they see a group of kids
00:13:38.560
mulling about the house, like goals on a beach, as it was described to me. And these kids are silent.
00:13:47.020
They've been putting it up with the university kids all their professional lives as cops. I don't think
00:13:52.560
they've ever seen silent kids before. They knew that this was something serious.
00:13:59.080
Bloom writes that the call was passed to Sergeant Shane Gunderson. Gunderson, who on that day was midway
00:14:05.840
through a 12-hour shift that had started at 6 AM, was running the operations division at the
00:14:11.040
sparklingly modernistic, it had opened barely 11 months earlier, Southview Avenue Police Headquarters.
00:14:18.020
Prior to that moment, he would tell people his tour had been long and slow, a languid weekend morning
00:14:23.920
punctuated by the chimes of the town's many church bells tolling solemnly in the wind.
00:14:28.500
In fact, he had spent a good deal of that desk-bound Sunday morning mulling something other than police
00:14:35.340
business. Gunderson had been avidly mapping out in his mind a strategy for the eight-hour, or easily
00:14:42.120
more, trek to the summit of Mount Bora he and a friend from the University of Idaho Psych Department
00:14:48.300
had been planning for the spring. It's Idaho's highest point, and the trail up the southwest ridge
00:14:55.040
to the 12,662-foot summit is a steep, hard climb. And, he would admit, after a beer or two,
00:15:03.380
it was just the sort of challenge he'd been missing lately. Now that he had his sergeant stripes,
00:15:07.700
police work was more about distributing memos and filing papers than getting out into the field.
00:15:13.260
That bothered him. Nearly 10 years on the force, he still wanted to be the gung-ho officer who had
00:15:19.680
joined up straight out of Lewis Clark State College in nearby Lewiston and worked his way up from
00:15:24.780
patrolman. In his early days, he had distinguished himself as a hands-on cop, someone out on the
00:15:30.780
streets doing what the Moscow PD calls community policing. Back then, he'd scored a lot of points
00:15:37.860
both in and out of the department, as well as winning the Officer of the Year honor in 2017,
00:15:43.560
when he single-handedly planned and organized a hot dog barbecue, bringing together the cops and
00:15:49.660
local school kids. He was from the area, growing up in small-town potlatch, and still smarting from
00:15:57.560
his own childhood run-ins. He knew only too well how hard-ass cops could sour things, make things
00:16:03.960
confrontational. It was his job, he'd say with determination, looking out for and working with
00:16:10.280
the citizens of Moscow. When the 911 call came in, Gunderson had a corporal and two other officers
00:16:16.160
on duty to assist with patrol. He could have left the response to them. He certainly, he'd tell people
00:16:22.240
with a hint of embarrassment, had no intimation of something out of the ordinary. That morning,
00:16:28.620
he was simply eager to break the monotony. And as always, he felt strongly, it was important for him
00:16:33.960
to get out on the street where people could see him. He swiftly decided he'd go to the scene too,
00:16:40.120
with his officers. It was a quick trip. The roads leading into the university neighborhood that
00:16:45.880
Sunday were as empty as the classrooms. And as soon as Gunderson's black-and-white cruiser pulled
00:16:51.760
up behind the neat row of cars parked in the driveway of the austere, cantilevered house on King Road,
00:16:58.360
he immediately knew something was very wrong. It was the noise. There wasn't any. Just an eerie,
00:17:07.640
unnatural silence. A cluster of young people were wandering about, not merely subdued. They seemed
00:17:16.380
stunned, as if drained by a deep and intense shock. When the three mystified officers approached the
00:17:23.880
front door, someone in the crowd, it would later be shared, muttered a single plaintiff word,
00:17:29.620
dead. Still, Gunderson would confess to others he was unprepared for the strong smell of blood
00:17:36.640
that rose up in his nostrils the moment he walked inside. The coroner, who had once been an emergency
00:17:43.200
room nurse in an earlier stage of her life, would describe the scene in press interviews
00:17:47.880
as chaos, lots of blood. Few others would even attempt to put into words what they saw.
00:17:54.140
There are moments, cops will tell you, that are too profound, too unnerving to be experienced in
00:18:01.740
the present. All you can do is move forward. There will be time later to try to make sense of it all.
00:18:08.360
Procedure takes precedence. It allows a protective membrane to be stretched between the real
00:18:13.540
and the two real. All other thoughts, all other feelings become extraneous. The trio of officers
00:18:21.660
meanwhile proceeded with haste to the second floor. They opened the bedroom door to find two dead bodies,
00:18:29.360
a male and a female. The pair was gruesomely drenched in blood, yet both had their good-looking faces
00:18:36.440
oddly preserved, like masks. Even at that probing moment, it was difficult, one of the young officers
00:18:44.400
would later wail, to look at the 20-year-old pair. They were Ethan and Zanna. On the third floor,
00:18:53.260
things got, if possible, worse. In one bedroom, lying in a single bed, were two inert women. It was Maddie
00:19:01.520
and Kaylee. They might have been sisters, so similar were the 21-year-old's pretty Barbie doll-like
00:19:08.020
sculpted features, their long cascades of thick, streaked blonde hair falling down to their narrow
00:19:13.380
shoulders. Yet in death, there was one gruesome difference. Kaylee, it would be reported, had been
00:19:20.660
hacked with a particular ferocity. It was as if her wild assailant, or was it assailants, had been intent
00:19:28.820
on gouging out chunks of her flesh. Large punctures was how the lacerations had been described. Maddie's
00:19:37.780
wounds, while no less fatal, appeared less feral, more measured, at least in comparison. Across the
00:19:45.700
narrow hallway was one final door. The officers pulled it open, and at last, they discovered a sign
00:19:51.960
of life. A fluffy, caramel-colored dog. It was Murphy, Kaylee's frisky labradoodle. He was unharmed,
00:20:00.920
not marred by even a speck of blood. A small consolation, and barely one at that for all they
00:20:07.260
had seen and were only beginning to process. Later that day, around 4 p.m., a police officer named
00:20:14.400
Brett Payne arrived at the scene, he would go on to interview the two surviving roommates, Dylan and
00:20:22.580
Bethany, who in the affidavit he would file were only identified as DM and BF. Here is, directly from
00:20:31.580
the affidavit, what he learned from his interviews with both Dylan and Bethany, although it appeared
00:20:37.280
Bethany had slept through the commotion on floors above her first-floor bedroom. DM and BF, quoting
00:20:44.940
here from the affidavit, both made statements during interviews that indicated the occupants
00:20:49.660
of the King Road residence were at home by 2 a.m. and asleep, or at least in their rooms, by
00:20:54.700
approximately 4 a.m., he wrote. This is with the exception of Zanna Kurnodal, who received a DoorDash
00:21:00.620
order at the residence at approximately 4 a.m. Law enforcement identified the DoorDash delivery
00:21:05.600
driver who reported this information. DM stated she originally went to sleep in her bedroom
00:21:11.280
on the southeast side of the second floor. DM stated she was awoken at approximately 4 a.m.
00:21:18.080
by what she stated sounded like Gonsalves playing with her dog in one of the upstairs bedrooms,
00:21:23.820
which were located on the third floor. A short time later, DM said she heard who she thought
00:21:30.900
was Gonsalves say something to the effect of, there's someone here. A review of records obtained
00:21:38.660
from a forensic download of Kurnodal's phone showed this could also have been Kurnodal,
00:21:44.580
as her cellular phone indicated she was likely awake and using the TikTok app at approximately 4.12 a.m.
00:21:53.580
DM stated she looked out of her bedroom but did not see anything when she heard the comment
00:21:58.360
about someone being in the house. DM stated she opened her door a second time when she heard
00:22:03.980
what she thought was crying coming from Kurnodal's room. DM then said she heard a male voice say
00:22:10.340
something to the effect of, it's okay, I'm going to help you. At approximately 4.17 a.m.,
00:22:18.680
a security camera located at 1112 King Road, a residence immediately to the northwest
00:22:24.040
of 1122 King picked up distorted audio of what sounded like voices or a whimper followed by a loud
00:22:32.760
thud. A dog can also be heard barking numerous times starting at 4.17 a.m. The security camera
00:22:40.320
is less than 50 feet from the west wall of Zanna Kurnodal's bedroom. DM stated she opened her door for
00:22:48.260
the third time after she heard the crying and saw a figure clad in black clothing and a mask that
00:22:55.180
covered the person's mouth and nose walking towards her. DM described the figure as 5'10 or taller,
00:23:02.020
male, not very muscular, but athletically built, with bushy eyebrows. The male walked past DM as she
00:23:10.160
stood in a, quote, frozen shock phase. The male walked toward the back sliding glass door. DM locked herself
00:23:17.940
in her room after seeing the male. DM did not state that she recognized the male. This leads
00:23:24.120
investigators to believe that the murderer left the scene. We'll get back to the affidavit in a bit.
00:23:35.240
Dylan then locked her bedroom door until the morning in a decision that would just befuddle so many
00:23:41.120
people. Why? Why? Why didn't she do more? We don't know the answers, but surely we will by the time
00:23:49.360
this case is tried. Sometime after 11 a.m., the roommates attempted to wake their friends. They were
00:23:57.120
unable to, and they would call others to the house for help. There, at least one of those friends finally
00:24:03.340
dialed 911. Howard Bloom, again with us, back in March. One can, you know, raise all sorts of
00:24:11.560
questions, as I do. At the same time, I think one has to cut this poor girl a little slack. In many ways,
00:24:19.340
she's a victim, too. She will live with this for her entire life. She saw something incredible,
00:24:29.520
astonishing, and she just perhaps couldn't deal with it.
00:24:37.140
Back to Sergeant Gunderson. He quickly called his boss, Captain Roger Lanier, the head of the 24
00:24:43.720
Officer Operations Division. He found him, not unexpectedly for a Sunday, sitting down to lunch
00:24:49.460
with his family. Lanier was a veteran cop. He had spent more than 20 years on the force in nearby
00:24:55.060
Lewiston before having been lured six years earlier to Moscow with a captain's rank. After all his years
00:25:01.600
on the job, he'd become a steady, avuncular presence, a bald-headed, genial cop who never got
00:25:07.280
flustered because, as he would tell people, he had seen it all in his day. But Gunderson's report
00:25:13.460
left him unnerved. It took me a second, he recalled, a sharp edge even weeks later to the memory.
00:25:19.880
I really had to think about what I'd just heard. Four murders in Moscow, Idaho, was so out of
00:25:27.760
character. At the time, they were fairly certain it was college students and it was near the campus,
00:25:33.620
and that area is kind of a campus community. So once I got over the initial shock, I knew that I was
00:25:40.100
coming to the station. So I drove in, and everybody just kind of fell into a roll. That was an all-hands-on-deck
00:25:46.680
moment Sunday afternoon. It became fairly apparent when I got to the scene that we were going to need
00:25:54.060
resources outside of just what the Moscow Police Department could provide.
00:26:00.000
But quickly, Lanier's professionalism took control. He had a thousand questions, and yet he knew the only
00:26:06.180
hope of finding answers would be to follow the previously established protocols. Dutifully, he gave
00:26:12.240
the orders to set up the perimeters of the crime scene to bring in the forensic team and to summon
00:26:17.600
the coroner. It was standard in a major case, and if four homicides was not a major case, what was?
00:26:25.680
To alert the Idaho State Police, and he did that too. Moscow was the responsibility of the state's
00:26:32.960
District 2 Detective Office in Lewiston, the county seat and where he'd been on the job for two decades,
00:26:39.000
and he knew many of the state detectives. There was a companionship. Still, it was a difficult
00:26:44.640
conversation. But his next call was harder. The university had to be informed. It was not just
00:26:51.780
that four students had been brutally murdered in an off-campus home, but there was no way of knowing
00:26:56.700
whether the killer or killers planned to strike again. The students needed to be warned. At 2.07 p.m.,
00:27:04.860
a little over two hours after the three cops had entered the blood-soaked house, the University
00:27:10.080
Office of Public Safety and Security sent a vandal alert email to the students and faculty,
00:27:16.800
quote, Moscow PD investigating a homicide on King Road near campus. Suspect is not known at this time.
00:27:23.000
Stay away from the area and shelter in place, end quote. A shelter in place order requires people
00:27:28.220
to take refuge in a room with no or few windows. At this point, busy hours had already quickly flown
00:27:34.980
by. But despite his marathon of activities, Lanier still had not succeeded in completing one task that
00:27:41.080
was at the top of his mental list. He had not been able to speak with his boss, James Fry, the chief of
00:27:47.320
police. By the time Lanier had finally reached him, it was hours after the discovery of the bodies.
00:27:53.220
And by the time Fry finally entered the home on King Road, it was dark outside, according to several
00:27:59.220
accounts, close to 6 p.m. For some abstruse reason, he had thought it was important to go home first and
00:28:06.140
change into his chief's uniform. Perhaps he hadn't fully grasped the magnitude of the disaster.
00:28:13.740
Or maybe, after nearly 28 years as a Moscow cop, he had felt his uniform was integral to his ability
00:28:21.260
to command. But what he saw that evening left him, he would confide to a friend later,
00:28:26.740
physically and emotionally drained. He was a father of two daughters who had attended the
00:28:31.820
University of Idaho. And he had also graduated from the university nearly three decades earlier.
00:28:38.320
It was impossible, he said, not to feel a visceral tie to the victims and to their parents. The cruelty of
00:28:45.080
the crime was deep and affecting, and yet he knew there was police work to be done. His mind was
00:28:51.920
racing, but, quixotically perhaps, within moments of buried memory, pushed itself forward. What if,
00:29:00.140
Fry asked himself with a sudden alarm, a serial killer had attacked the four students?
00:29:05.900
Pausing here to bring you some of Chief Fry's initial comments to the Moscow, Idaho community
00:29:13.260
from his very first press conference several days after the murders.
00:29:18.800
My name is Chief James Fry with the Moscow Police Department. I'm going to be reading from my notes
00:29:23.380
today because I want the information you received to be extremely accurate. This was a horrible crime
00:29:28.920
that took the lives of Ethan Chapin, Zanna Kurnodl, Madison Mogan, and Kaylee Goncalves.
00:29:39.640
This horrible crime has affected all of us, the families, the University of Idaho, our community,
00:29:48.260
our country, and our officers. Based on details of the scene, we believe this was an isolated,
00:29:55.880
targeted attack on our victims. We do not have a suspect at this time, and that individual is still
00:30:03.120
out there. We cannot say that there's no threat to the community, and as we have stated, please stay
00:30:09.320
vigilant, report any suspicious activity, and be aware of your surroundings at all times.
00:30:16.720
Here's what was challenging for the police from Bloom's reporting.
00:30:19.840
Fact. The four students were killed in their sleep, or at least while in their rooms,
00:30:25.380
sometime between 3 and 5 a.m. In the weeks ahead, they would develop a more precise timeline.
00:30:31.120
The murders the authorities deduced occurred between 4 and 4.25 a.m. Think about that. At 4.12 a.m.,
00:30:39.960
they had Zanna on TikTok, and the murders took place between 4 and 4.25 a.m.
00:30:46.200
Fact. There was no sign of forced entry or of robbery. Fact. A single weapon had been used.
00:30:53.940
A long-bladed knife. Critically, a tan leather knife sheath, stamped with a U.S. Marine Corps insignia,
00:31:02.140
was found lying next to Maddie Mogan's bed. Fact. There was no trail of blood outside the house.
00:31:10.020
Fact. The house was a repository for a large collection of forensic evidence.
00:31:14.880
Blood. Saliva. Hair. Prints. DNA. But whether any of those belonged to the killer.
00:31:22.420
After the autopsies, the general consensus held that it was a single assailant.
00:31:27.200
Still was undetermined. These were all, the investigators agreed, important pieces in the puzzle.
00:31:33.840
Yet they were not enough. For more than three weeks, the early morning conferences ended in a grim litany
00:31:39.880
of what remained unknown. They couldn't figure out how the killer had gotten away, seemingly without
00:31:46.500
leaving a clue. And they had no idea why he had chosen these victims. And now, as the investigation
00:31:54.920
in Moscow plotted on, and frustratingly on, an exasperated Chief Frye appealed to locals to become,
00:32:01.660
in effect, consulting detectives. We appreciate everybody's help that has been sending in those
00:32:09.180
tips. And investigators are vetting those, and they're following up on those. And the response
00:32:15.020
has been very great. We appreciate all the help from across the nation and our community.
00:32:20.040
He wanted help to put his men on the right scent. Detectives are looking for context to the events and
00:32:26.620
people involved in these murders, a Moscow PD press release announced, to assist with the ongoing
00:32:32.760
investigation. Any odd or out-of-the-ordinary events that took place should be reported. And nearly
00:32:39.580
begging, the release urged, your information, whether you believe it is significant or not,
00:32:44.220
might be the piece of the puzzle that helps investigators solve these murders. The tips poured
00:32:50.140
in. A new generation of consulting detectives, armed with cell phones and laptops, with access
00:32:56.260
to a vast repository of information from selfies to Facebook pages, and further stoked by the
00:33:01.540
barrage of the raw theories and hearsay, disseminated on Reddit and 4chan, embraced the opportunity.
00:33:09.280
It was a real-life mystery that had the compelling allure of a particularly thorny CSI episode.
00:33:15.740
And not least, the police were pleading for help.
00:33:18.880
More than 9,025 email tips were received, in addition to the 4,575 phone calls and 6,050 digital
00:33:29.640
media submissions. An army of law enforcement analysts was assigned to the long, daunting task
00:33:35.640
to see if in all the oysters there was a single pearl. Much of it led down rabbit holes of fatuous
00:33:43.340
speculation. Some of it was not just wrongheaded, but cruel. Innocent ex-boyfriends, a hoodie-wearing
00:33:50.880
bystander lurking at a food truck where Maddie and Kaylee had ordered early morning bowls of
00:33:55.560
carbonara to soak up the alcohol ingested during the last carefree pub crawl of their lives.
00:34:02.260
A bro neighbor who insisted on sharing rambling anecdotes with every reporter who knocked on his
00:34:07.140
door. And frat brothers who were rumored to be stoked up on steroids and driven by long,
00:34:12.960
gestating grievances. All were callously and persistently slandered with a malicious authority.
00:34:20.320
It got so madcap that a history prof at the university decided she had to sue to put an
00:34:25.980
end to one internet sleuth's bizarre speculation that a failed romance with one of the women
00:34:31.500
had driven the teacher to kill. And then the analysts hit a gold seam.
00:34:37.320
The Mysterious Case of Rudolf Diesel by Doug Brunt. It's officially a New York Times bestseller as well
00:34:46.080
as an Apple Book of the Year, an Audible Book of the Year. It's even been optioned for a movie.
00:34:51.480
Rave reviews from The Times, The Journal, Publishers Weekly, and more calling Diesel a wildly enjoyable
00:34:57.560
ride. It is a page turning thriller about the greatest caper of the 20th century, all involving
00:35:04.020
a man whose name you likely see at the gas station every day, but probably had no idea, was at the
00:35:10.420
center of one of the greatest mysteries of all time. Don't miss out on the book everyone's talking
00:35:16.040
about. It will make the perfect gift, The Mysterious Case of Rudolf Diesel.
00:35:21.280
The overnight assistant manager, her name at her request remains secret, for a gas station on Troy
00:35:34.320
Road, not far from the house on King Road, had decided she might as well see what she could do.
00:35:39.980
She had not been working the night of the murders, but nevertheless, she spent the downtime on her
00:35:44.760
graveyard shift, reviewing the videos recorded by the station's surveillance cameras on November 13th.
00:35:53.100
I had a weird feeling, she later said. For two nights, she intermittently kept at it, but found
00:36:00.000
nothing. Then on the third night, she spotted a white car speeding down Highway 8 before turning
00:36:06.780
pell-mell down a side street. She took a screenshot of the car and emailed it to the tip line address.
00:36:13.240
Two days later, Moscow police arrived at the gas station to confiscate hours of surveillance footage,
00:36:20.000
and after just a quick view, they began to feel the hunt was on. Encouraged, they reached out on a
00:36:26.480
hunch to Kane Franzich. Recently retired and now investing in real estate, was a freewheeling guy who
00:36:32.480
shares on his website that he listens to classic vinyl while drinking single malt scotch. He also owned
00:36:39.520
a six-unit rental complex on Linda Lane, about three-tenths of a mile from where the bodies had
00:36:45.180
been found with a surveillance camera fixed to the roof. I downloaded it and gave them access to
00:36:51.540
everything from 2 a.m. through noon on Sunday the 13th, he said. Once those tapes were reviewed,
00:36:57.460
the same telltale white car was spotted. And again, it appeared to be making a breakneck getaway
00:37:04.840
through the dark a.m. streets. With this confirming sighting, a different pace, a different mood took
00:37:11.920
over the investigation. The team felt they could now march forward with a purpose. The FBI laboratory
00:37:17.640
enhancement had succeeded in deciphering the blurred image of the car. They believed it was a white 2011
00:37:25.120
to 2013 Hyundai Elantra. Now, there were 22,000 Hyundais in the region that matched the search criteria,
00:37:34.580
and one of them, the police were starting to suspect, had been driven by a killer.
00:37:40.060
From the affidavit released in January, quote, a review of footage from multiple videos obtained from
00:37:47.040
the King Road neighborhood showed multiple sightings of suspect vehicle one, starting at 3.29 a.m.,
00:37:53.540
ending at 4.20 a.m. These sightings show suspect vehicle one makes an initial three passes by the
00:38:01.380
1122 King Road residence and then leaves V.O. Willen to drive. Based off my experience as a patrol
00:38:08.400
officer, this is a residential neighborhood with a very limited number of vehicles that travel in the
00:38:13.100
area during the early morning hours. Upon review of the video, there are only a few cars that enter and
00:38:18.920
exit this area during this time frame. Suspect vehicle one can be seen entering the area a
00:38:24.320
fourth time at approximately 4.04 a.m. It can be seen driving eastbound on King Road, stopping and
00:38:33.240
turning around in front of 500 Queen Road, number 52, and then driving back westbound on King Road.
00:38:39.980
When suspect vehicle one is in front of the King Road residence, it appeared to unsuccessfully
00:38:45.740
attempt to park or turn around in the road. The vehicle then continued to the intersection of
00:38:51.380
Queen Road and King Road, where it can be seen completing a three-point turn and then driving
00:38:56.120
eastbound again down Queen Road. Suspect vehicle one is seen, next, departing the area of the King Road
00:39:05.080
residence at approximately 4.20 a.m. at a high rate of speed. Back now to Bloom's reporting.
00:39:12.800
Finding the one Elantra that would lead to an arrest loomed as a needle-in-a-haystack sort of
00:39:19.680
challenge. The search, even with a small army of burrowers, was a nearly impossible task.
00:39:26.420
Then, as the holiday season approached, a hint of a Christmas miracle. Chief Fry, for once upbeat,
00:39:35.180
met late in the morning of December 20th with Rand Walker, the department psychologist, and Rod
00:39:40.620
Olps, one of the police chaplains in the courthouse law library. It was one of the few places they could
00:39:46.060
huddle where the chief felt no one would be listening. I'm going to need you two to get ready,
00:39:50.500
he said, with a deliberate coyness. I'm going to need you before too long. The two men eagerly asked
00:39:57.660
whether there had been a break in the case. Fry did his best to rein in a pregnant smile.
00:40:01.940
All I'm saying, he reiterated, is I need you both to stand by. I might be calling you very soon.
00:40:10.180
But at 4.30 that afternoon, the Moscow police public communications team issued a flash update,
00:40:15.800
quote, investigators are aware of a Hyundai Elantra located in Eugene, Oregon, and have spoken with
00:40:22.420
the owner. The vehicle is not believed to have any relation to any property in Moscow, Idaho,
00:40:28.820
or the ongoing murder investigations. And just like that, the psychologist and the chaplain knew
00:40:35.420
that the chief, despite the hopeful conversation earlier that day, would not be calling them anytime
00:40:41.000
soon. Meanwhile, as the hunt for the Elantra proceeded with tedious concentration, the no less
00:40:48.020
discouraging challenge of finding a clue in the forensic evidence of vast muddle of prints, blood,
00:40:54.700
and DNA that had been collected in the house, was brought vividly home. Body cam footage was
00:41:01.840
released of a call at the King Road residence two months before the murders by a trio of Moscow cops
00:41:07.900
in response to yet another noise complaint from an annoyed neighbor. The body camera footage,
00:41:14.940
Bloom would write, was at first seen as deeply poignant. The house seemed to be nearly shaking with
00:41:21.480
festive noise. Tyler Childress's feathered Indians boomed from the speakers. Kids were calling
00:41:28.180
happily to one another, a giddy mix of bouncy, energetic voices. It was a Thursday night and
00:41:34.660
there was a party going on. This is what it's like to be young. To more acerbic minds, the footage was a
00:41:41.740
small, self-contained story about the tensions of policing in a college town. The kids, being kids,
00:41:48.580
were seen given the police a sly run around, and the cops, being cops, retaliated with a display of
00:41:55.060
petty vengeance. A confiscated stash of beers and Trulies was poured onto the driveway. Yet this being
00:42:03.200
Moscow and this house being destined for infamy, this burst of class warfare would have an unexpected
00:42:09.540
coda. One of the smirking cops spilling the booze would in time be part of the team that first
00:42:16.020
discovered the bodies. Another would help load the cardboard cartons holding the murdered students'
00:42:21.800
belongings into a U-Haul for the grim trip to the police parking lot. To the informed and dispassionate
00:42:28.720
view of the FBI's scientific experts, however, the body cam footage was seen solely in operational terms,
00:42:35.500
and it was dispiriting. It made clear that just about anyone and everyone had access to 1122 King Road.
00:42:42.720
The door was always open, and a stream of people were constantly coming and going.
00:42:50.360
The analysts moaned that there would be so much forensic evidence it might be easier to determine
00:42:54.600
who in Moscow had never been inside the house, rather than their having any realistic hope of
00:43:00.320
ever finding a suspect. And yet, perhaps it wasn't a 2011 to 2013 Elantra after all.
00:43:07.700
Investigators were given access to video footage on the Washington State University, or WSU,
00:43:14.520
campus located nearby in Pullman, Washington. A review of that video indicated that at approximately
00:43:21.340
2.44 a.m. on November 13, 2022, a white sedan, which was consistent with a description of the
00:43:29.360
white Elantra, known as Suspect Vehicle 1, was observed on WSU surveillance cameras traveling north
00:43:36.900
on Southeast Nevada Street at Northeast Stadium Way. At approximately 2.53 a.m., a white sedan,
00:43:44.700
which is consistent with a description of the white Elantra, known as Suspect Vehicle 1,
00:43:48.640
was observed traveling southeast on Nevada Street in Pullman, Washington, toward SR-270.
00:43:55.480
This is Howard Bloom here, quoting from the affidavit.
00:43:58.720
SR-270 connects Pullman, Washington, to Moscow, Idaho.
00:44:02.140
This camera footage from Pullman, Washington, was provided to the same FBI forensic examiner.
00:44:08.280
The forensic examiner identified the vehicle observed in Pullman, Washington as being a
00:44:14.720
2014 to 2016 Hyundai Elantra. At approximately 5.25 a.m., a white sedan, which was consistent with
00:44:24.860
the description of Suspect Vehicle 1, was observed on five cameras in Pullman, Washington,
00:44:29.540
and on WSU campus cameras. What was it doing there? Well, shortly after midnight on November 29th,
00:44:36.540
Washington State Police Officer Daniel Tiango reported that he had identified a 2015 white
00:44:43.200
Elantra on campus with a license plate LFZ-8649. It wasn't from Washington, though, or Idaho.
00:44:52.900
It was registered to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. According to the affidavit, just minutes later,
00:44:59.860
a different officer, Curtis Whitman, located that car in the parking lot of an apartment complex
00:45:05.600
that houses WSU students. The vehicle belonged to a graduate student and a teacher's assistant
00:45:12.540
named Brian Christopher Kohlberger. His major was criminology. Kohlberger would be driving that car
00:45:19.820
shortly after the identification, far away from Washington and Idaho and the scene of that
00:45:25.820
gruesome quadruple murder. It was headed for a cross-country drive. He had a passenger in the car
00:45:31.820
too, his father. Little did they or the small-town community of Moscow, Idaho, or the country that had
00:45:38.260
become obsessed with and terrified by this story, have any idea that the police and the FBI were tracking
00:45:46.360
their every move as they made their way back home to Pennsylvania, but not before a few bizarre
00:45:52.240
chance encounters with authorities along the way. We'll be back tomorrow with that.
00:46:02.020
Thanks for listening to The Megyn Kelly Show. No BS, no agenda, and no fear.