What Happened to Missing Plane MH370: A Megyn Kelly Show True Crime Special | Ep. 574
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 28 minutes
Words per Minute
155.54947
Summary
In addition to being a writer and journalist, William Longavisha is also an aviation expert. He was a professional pilot for many years before turning to journalism, and he has researched and investigated the MH370 findings more than pretty much any other journalist, including those involved in that recent Netflix special.
Transcript
00:00:00.480
Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show, your home for open, honest, and provocative conversations.
00:00:12.140
Hey everyone, I'm Megyn Kelly. Welcome to The Megyn Kelly Show and the final day of our hot
00:00:16.760
crime summer week. Today we investigate the mystery of MH370, a missing plane. You may
00:00:23.820
think you know this story, but you do not know it like this. Oh my gosh. We're going
00:00:30.420
to take you from takeoff to the controversial search and investigation with famed writer,
00:00:36.420
author, and journalist, William Longavisha. In addition to his journalism, he's also an
00:00:42.040
aviation expert. He was a professional pilot for many years before turning to journalism,
00:00:46.900
and he has researched and investigated the MH370 findings more than pretty much any other
00:00:52.800
journalist, including those involved with that recent Netflix special, and we're going to get
00:00:58.480
to that too. We will try to get to the bottom once and for all about what happened, where that plane
00:01:04.260
is, and we will get into the head of that pilot. Set the stage, because I watched this whole special
00:01:12.040
on Netflix about what happened to the plane. I was excited. I was like, okay, I want my answers.
00:01:17.400
I walked away frustrated and kind of angry that I had been led down a bunch of
00:01:22.640
paths that seemed equally unreasonable and led to trust people who turned out to be, to me,
00:01:29.740
kind of quacky and didn't get any answers. There wasn't an answer. So is there an answer? I mean,
00:01:37.660
is there a better place to go for what not definitively, but most likely happened to MH370?
00:01:45.320
Yes, there is completely an answer. It's indisputable. In fact, the answer is indisputable.
00:01:50.760
The motive is a different question. The why is the question. The what is indisputable.
00:02:05.180
Well, this airplane took off. It was in 2014, March, at night, just after midnight,
00:02:13.360
out of Kuala Lumpur in Malaysia, so Air Malaysia. They were going to Beijing, about a six-hour flight,
00:02:18.860
straight on up the coast of Asia, basically, to Beijing. And after leveling off, a few minutes
00:02:27.660
after leveling off, it got over the South China Sea, disappeared from radar. This does occasionally
00:02:34.340
happen. It usually means that there's a crash, which happens immediately. In this case, there was no crash.
00:02:40.300
It disappeared from radar. And for reasons we can discuss, we know that it kept flying not toward
00:02:48.700
Beijing, but essentially 90 degrees to that path, and then in the roughly opposite direction toward
00:02:56.540
the South Pole out over the Indian Ocean for about seven hours. And that doesn't fit any profile that
00:03:04.720
any of us have ever seen before with an airplane accident, whether it's a terrorist act or explosion
00:03:11.280
or a system failure. It just disappeared after a very, very strange flight, an enigmatic flight
00:03:20.160
that we were able to piece together, however, conclusively. And at the end of that flight,
00:03:27.920
it ran out of gas and went into the deep ocean in a remote part of the Indian Ocean and has not yet
00:03:34.160
been found, period. It basically was on its way northeast toward Beijing. It turned around,
00:03:42.080
it crossed back over, and then it went south over the Indian Ocean. This is what you say happened.
00:03:48.240
And there are data points that support that theory. The most important being the
00:03:53.440
MRSAT data, right? Can you explain what that is?
00:03:57.840
Yes, I would say that the most important initial data points is primary radar, right? So that
00:04:04.000
either military radar or just raw radar. And that showed, within a few days, it clearly showed that
00:04:11.920
the airplane turned west across the Malay Peninsula and then went northwest up the Straits of Malacca,
00:04:20.480
around the top of Indonesia, and then south from there into the depths of the Indian Ocean.
00:04:27.840
It was on radar for a long time after making the first turn. So that's the first thing.
00:04:39.760
It was on primary radar. It was not on normal air traffic control, computer-enhanced,
00:04:48.720
transponder-based secondary radar, which is the normal air traffic control radar. It carries a lot
00:04:54.480
of data with it. It was on the kind of radar that the military uses for air defense reasons,
00:04:59.440
and also that it lies underneath normal air traffic control radar. So it was an unenhanced,
00:05:07.520
raw target. And that was the first thing. No matter what, it stayed, I think I'm going to say it was in
00:05:15.920
the air, being seen by some form of radar for about an hour after making the first crazy,
00:05:25.920
silent turn off course from Beijing. As it proceeded then around the top of Indonesia,
00:05:34.880
it then disappeared from radar range, normal radar range, both Thai and Indonesian, let alone Malaysian
00:05:42.320
military. And then the, but at about the same time that that occurred, that it was being lost from
00:05:49.280
normal radar. It, it's complicated to explain this, but a series of electronic handshakes
00:06:00.400
began. And these handshakes are related to an obscure communication device in the ceiling of the
00:06:08.160
cabin of the 777. This was a 777 Boeing that is responsible for some forms of communication, largely
00:06:16.240
entertainment stuff. And other things reports to maintenance. Um, so satellite based and those
00:06:22.960
handshakes where either the airplane or the ground-based satellite, the ground base of the satellite
00:06:30.160
system was, was trying to establish communications always unsuccessfully, but the attempt to establish
00:06:37.760
communications carried with it whispers of content with hints of location and of direction. And in the end of
00:06:50.720
a final violent dive, um, that the use of that information, which was basically interpreted in London,
00:07:01.040
in Marsat as the company, um, was, was revolutionary. That information never been used before. There were
00:07:09.920
two forms of it, these handshakes, and they were able to, in Marsat in London, they specifically were
00:07:16.080
able to derive distance from the satellite. And there were, I think, seven handshakes, uh, and me being a
00:07:23.360
little wrong on that, but roughly seven handshakes, each of which gave it, gave a distance from the
00:07:28.000
satellite and an arc. And then also, uh, a, through a Doppler effect, if you know what I mean, distortion
00:07:35.520
of frequencies. Um, and I'm simplifying it a little bit related to the speed of the airplane and problems
00:07:41.920
with the wobbling satellite. They were able to, in Marsat was able in London to derive a directional
00:07:49.360
information or at least turn information. So the turns were seen because it, it warped sort of like a
00:07:57.840
train going by, you know, a Doppler effect. Um, it warped the signals and, um, uh, a train going by,
00:08:05.280
I'm talking audio, uh, a train whistle, anything like that. That's of course the famous Doppler
00:08:10.720
effect. We all learned about it in high school. Um, but it was happening electronically out over the
00:08:15.760
Indian ocean. This was never, this is revolutionary stuff. And it was, it was, um, out of desperation
00:08:23.280
that these brilliant people in London realized they had real information. They could go back into the
00:08:30.080
records during those hours and derive from that satellite, uh, a lot of information of where the
00:08:36.360
airplane was at any given time or at each given handshake and where it was turning. So that's what
00:08:42.880
I'm talking about. Hmm. That's fascinating. So let's start back at the first kind of radar that you said
00:08:49.740
picked up the plane. You said it wasn't the normal air traffic control radar. Now, why do we know why
00:08:56.660
that was that? It wasn't being picked up on the normal air traffic control radar?
00:09:03.780
Well, because the airplane's transponder was turned off, uh, whether if, if, if we're talking about a
00:09:10.440
simple, simple, uh, single failure, this is not uncommon. It's why airplanes typically have two
00:09:17.560
transponders. I mean, transponder failures are not uncommon. Uh, and you know, it's not very exotic
00:09:23.980
technology, that kind of transponder. It's similar, similar to the traffic, uh, the total transponders
00:09:30.380
you have in your car, easy pass or something like that. So, um, the, the transponder transmits all kinds
00:09:36.560
of information, uh, about the airplane, uh, the flight number, uh, where it's going, et cetera, et cetera,
00:09:42.520
uh, altitude, um, it piggybacks on the, um, the data coming in with, with raw primary radar. Um, so
00:09:53.500
we know that the transponder turned off. Did it turn itself off or did someone turn it off? Well,
00:10:03.440
given that it's totally unrelated to communications, it happened at seconds after communications stopped
00:10:09.380
and given that it is totally unrelated to which way the airplane's flying, it happened at the same
00:10:15.680
time that the airplane made its first radical, crazy turn. We know it was turned off. It didn't
00:10:21.400
turn itself off. These are independent. These would be independent issues. So yeah, that's what happens.
00:10:28.460
It's a logical deduction. What about the second transponder? I mean, were they, were they both,
00:10:32.520
were they both turned off? Cause you say there's a backup. They both would have been turned off.
00:10:36.680
Yeah. Well, no, they weren't. You can't turn off the primary. I mean, the, the primary is what the
00:10:41.860
military uses to see pieces of metal in the sky, right? They don't rely on transponders to say when
00:10:48.160
the enemy is invading their airspace. So primary transponder, you can't turn it off. It's just going
00:10:53.560
to pick you up. And in fact, the Malaysian air traffic control has a baseline, a primary radar,
00:11:02.260
but they didn't look at it. I mean, we're talking levels of incompetence here, right? Which is part
00:11:07.320
of the story of what, what happened here in terms of the disappearance, the military very quickly said,
00:11:14.900
admitted basically out of Penang on the peninsula there where they have a F, a fighter base
00:11:22.400
that they, they were watching it that, or at least they said they were watching it. They should have
00:11:28.220
been watching it. Uh, and they said, well, we knew it was, uh, uh, we knew what the airplane was. Uh,
00:11:35.860
so we didn't bother to, to make anything out of it. We didn't send any, um, interceptors up to find
00:11:44.060
out what's going on because we knew it was MH370. So who cares? Well, that, that falls apart in a hurry
00:11:49.560
because the search, the initial search took place in the South China Sea, totally the wrong place,
00:11:56.700
as if the airplane had gone down on course for Beijing and the military. So that is just
00:12:03.300
completely not believable. It very quickly was obviously a coverup, which is completely believable
00:12:10.900
in Malaysia, uh, political embarrassment, corruption, brutality, whatever, dysfunctional government,
00:12:17.220
um, dysfunctional military. They were either asleep and there's some indication they may actually
00:12:23.200
have been asleep, uh, or they were just incompetent. The military was in one way or another was tracking
00:12:31.420
this thing right along and didn't do anything about it. Why ask them? I've tried. You don't get very far
00:12:40.460
with that kind of question in Malaysia. So the primary radar was showing it. And, and it was,
00:12:49.580
let's say it was both the military radar and the civilian primary radar. The military fessed up a lot
00:12:56.420
sooner than the civilian did to having had primary radar on this machine, on this airplane, but, um,
00:13:04.600
they came up with all kinds of crazy excuses why they didn't do anything about it. So it,
00:13:10.460
we don't know, I mean, truly they could have been asleep. Is there a record of it? So we know it
00:13:18.300
did in fact appear on the radar. And the real question is just, why didn't they do anything
00:13:22.300
about it? They were asleep. They didn't care. They were incompetent, but do we know it did in fact
00:13:26.640
appear on their radar? Yeah, we do. I mean, the images exist and, uh, not the full radar record,
00:13:33.840
but they, they, they certainly exist. Uh, and they, they were pretty widely disseminated. Um,
00:13:39.740
yes, we do. There it is. They, they, they provided images that showed it, but then provided
00:13:45.120
false explanations for their inaction. Hmm. Got it. And this is all relevant to what I think is your
00:13:53.900
belief as to why this plane did what it did. And that relates to the pilot. And that explains,
00:14:00.560
if it relates to an intentional decision by the pilot, why there might've been a coverup,
00:14:05.480
why the Malaysian government might've misled us. I mean, it really does explain a lot
00:14:10.180
if this was an intentional downing of an aircraft by the pilot. But to this day,
00:14:15.920
the Malaysians are saying, that's not what this was. That's that wasn't it. So let's talk about,
00:14:22.040
before we get into the pilot, let's just talk about the end of the flight. So we can,
00:14:25.460
you know, take the viewers and the listeners there. Then it turns South over the Indian ocean,
00:14:31.960
which is a bear of an ocean. My God, the, the videotapes I've seen of the retrieval efforts,
00:14:39.740
they did make the Australians did the Chinese did. There was, there were a few efforts to actually
00:14:45.840
see if they could find debris someplace in the ocean. And three, three, three, more than three years
00:14:51.660
of efforts by the, primarily by the Australians. Yeah. And the $120 million on that.
00:14:58.100
And we've got some videotape of those boats out there trying to do it. And it was just,
00:15:02.480
it was chilling to me because the waves they dealt with, like that is a scary ocean and they were on
00:15:10.000
it for a long time. And that's where we believe this aircraft wound up. But one of the mysteries is
00:15:16.400
in this post nine 11 world in which this plane may have been taken down, why wouldn't the passengers
00:15:22.840
have fought? Why, why would they have allowed, somebody might've realized at some point it was
00:15:28.000
making weird turns. They were well past the number of hours that would have taken them to get to Beijing
00:15:33.120
by the time we believe the plane went down. So what, what happened to the passengers? What do you
00:15:39.040
think? It's no one really knows, but it's because of the amount of time that transpired. It's likely
00:15:47.700
that they were incapacitated in one way or another, very early in the events, right? So after, right
00:15:54.040
after the first left turn, the turning away from Beijing, we know the airplane climbed to 40,000 feet,
00:16:02.520
had been at 35,000 feet, 40,000 feet was the, pretty much the ceiling of the airplane performance
00:16:08.700
ceiling at that time, that weight that night. So they climbed as high as they could go. And it's,
00:16:15.920
I think there would be general agreement. Well, there's a lot of disagreement here because people
00:16:21.740
have all kinds of crazy theories, but reasonable people think that the, the passengers were incapacitated
00:16:28.160
and actually probably killed by depressurizing the airplane. Very easy to do. You depress,
00:16:36.140
you throw a switch, you depressurize the cabin. The people basically go to sleep and you, you know,
00:16:44.500
masks fall, but they put them on, but they're no good at that altitude. I mean, those are masks are good
00:16:51.000
only for riding a short descent down to higher pressures in the lower altitudes. At 40,000 feet,
00:16:57.720
the mask is really not going to do you a normal mask, but in the cockpit, there are four pressure
00:17:04.800
masks, which are different, right? They pressurize the oxygen flow to the lungs. So you have a sort
00:17:10.140
of a mini pressurized airplane. If you can put that mask on, they're quick donning masks. So slap those
00:17:16.120
on, depressurize the airplane. Everybody in the back dies within minutes at peaceful death,
00:17:23.740
not screaming. How, how would it be a peaceful death?
00:17:27.720
Well, because the people go to extreme hypoxia. People go to sleep. They don't, they don't,
00:17:34.220
they're not gasping for breath. They don't feel that they're suffocating. Yeah. Hypoxia. So it seems,
00:17:43.740
I think many people would agree that the airplane was depressurized at roughly the same time that
00:17:51.400
the entire electrical system was shut down, which is another matter that, um, and this is all very
00:17:58.980
closely associated with the first left to turn away from Beijing and a short, a tight turn,
00:18:05.120
high G load turn and a climb to 40,000 feet. So if you were going to depressurize the aircraft with a
00:18:11.200
switch, why would you need to go up to 40,000 feet? You don't. So, you know, that's like overkill,
00:18:17.520
but it makes it happen faster. So yeah. And you'd also don't need to make a tight turn. We know that
00:18:24.460
that, that initial turn away from Beijing was not flown on autopilot. It was too tight for an autopilot.
00:18:30.880
It was flown by hand and it was, somebody was flying that airplane that made that turn.
00:18:36.040
It was a tight turn, steep, steep bank angle, high bank angle, high G load.
00:18:44.940
I don't know. I don't know. I mean, whoever was doing it, not entirely rational, obviously.
00:18:53.300
So then we go out over the Indian ocean and we go South for how many hours was it over the Indian
00:18:58.220
ocean? Well, the whole flight lasted what, seven hours, six hours, I think probably five hours over
00:19:07.320
the Indian ocean, something like that. Yeah. I'm going to guess about, I'd have to go back and look
00:19:13.380
at my notes and all that. That's been a long time for me, but I'd say five hours actually over the
00:19:18.220
Indian ocean. That's a long time by the way. Right. So is there anything to be gleaned from that?
00:19:25.700
No. I mean, why would, if, if a guy is suicidal and intent on killing himself and all his passengers,
00:19:38.100
why would he wait so long to do it? That's totally unknown. I have a theory, which is nothing,
00:19:47.220
nothing at all solid is, is, is that the, if indeed the captain did this, and I think he did. Okay.
00:19:54.540
Why waltz around this, his name is Zahari. He may have, having committed to this flight path that he
00:20:05.700
presumably actually had thought through in advance and practice on a flight simulator, that he,
00:20:12.100
that he found himself in a quandary, that he actually knew he couldn't turn back. For one thing,
00:20:21.360
he probably killed the entire plane load of passengers. And also he had just deviated,
00:20:25.960
you know, from the course to Beijing, that he couldn't go back home ever again, that he knew
00:20:32.020
that he had to die that, but, but, um, he didn't want to die maybe, or he was savoring the last moments
00:20:42.080
of his life. I don't know. It's, it's, it's always struck me is that that long flight, the length of
00:20:49.260
that flight, after he made that last turn out over the Indian ocean and then flew pretty much straight
00:20:54.620
for five hours, let's say, um, that he was in a, some kind of a, an emotional or philosophical,
00:21:02.020
um, quandary. I, I want to, I don't want to, I want to, I don't want to. And it just went on until
00:21:07.760
they ran out of gas. He couldn't quite bring himself to do it. And finally he let it do it to
00:21:13.600
him. But I, I don't know that. And I think, I know that nobody knows that, that that's why would
00:21:20.740
he take five hours when I just do what every other suicidal pilot does. And there are quite a few have
00:21:25.580
been around, you know, this is a fairly stand, not standard, but an occasional occurrence. Um,
00:21:31.020
you push the airplane into the ground right away within minutes, you don't wait around.
00:21:35.960
So he waited around for five hours. So I cannot explain that.
00:21:40.640
It's incredibly eerie to think about that man up there, potentially flying that aircraft
00:21:45.600
with dead bodies, filling up the cabin, dead at his hand.
00:21:50.120
Just shut the door. He said the door shut. He doesn't need to worry about that.
00:21:54.180
But he knew is my point. He knew it was on his soul. It was on his moral conscience.
00:22:02.580
Well, now you're bringing that up. So yes, it's inconceivable that the co-pilot was involved
00:22:10.400
in this. He was a young man and he was getting married. He, he was 24 years old, uh, 27 years
00:22:19.040
old, Farik Hamid. Uh, he, he, he was riding high because to be a co-pilot, a first officer
00:22:26.900
on a Boeing triple seven in Malaysia, in Malaysia is a really big deal in society. So he was just
00:22:34.740
riding as high as you can ride almost in Malaysia. And he was about to get married and all this.
00:22:42.440
He was not political. He was not religious. He, there was no motive conceivable for this guy.
00:22:50.720
We know he was not involved in this. So we know that, that he had to be eliminated, um,
00:22:57.920
one way or another. Now the obvious one is to lock, that the captain locked him out.
00:23:03.080
We've seen this before in the, uh, German wings accident in, uh, in Europe. Um, the co-pilot
00:23:10.120
locked the captain out when he went to the toilet. Uh, when we've seen variations of the lockout
00:23:17.240
theme, where you get yourself alone in the cabin and then you crash the airplane. Uh, if that's your,
00:23:24.960
your, you know, desire, I, I don't know how long we can go on this, but after I wrote this piece,
00:23:34.580
a man approached me, a man I've known for a long time, I guess I should not name him,
00:23:38.560
but he's one of the preeminent human factors, accident investigators in the world. Uh, and
00:23:46.740
very well known and very respected and had a private conversation with me. And he said that he
00:23:57.440
was doing studies on, um, he was doing studies on voice analysis of the radio transmissions. Now
00:24:07.120
remember the cockpit voice recorder was never found. So all they had to go on for human factors with voice
00:24:15.220
were the radio transmissions. I had noticed, and I wrote about the fact that the captain,
00:24:21.640
he was handling the radios and the co-pilot was handling the flying of the airplane or managing
00:24:26.880
the co-pilot, the, uh, the autopilot, um, and totally normal on departure from Kuala Lumpur that the
00:24:35.140
captain's Zahari, his radio transmissions were weird. He was making unnecessary, unusual radio transmissions.
00:24:45.220
Uh, I, I, I noticed it. I, from the transcripts, I never heard them, but from the transcripts,
00:24:52.880
you could tell that why do you do that? This is reporting level when he shouldn't have reported
00:24:58.200
level reporting level again, when he, there was no reason he hadn't changed his altitude.
00:25:02.640
He was just, and then, and blowing some, the final response where he should have read back a
00:25:07.360
frequency and didn't do it. Why? I made a note of that and didn't have an answer when I wrote the
00:25:15.900
piece. This highly respected man approached me a little bit later, and he had been on the, associated
00:25:25.520
with the investigation in Kuala Lumpur. And he said that, um, he and a partner would have been doing
00:25:33.300
studies for years about, um, measuring stress in people's voices and largely with, uh, either cockpit
00:25:41.620
voice recorders or with, um, radio transmissions. And I'm going to get this wrong. So don't quote me
00:25:52.100
on this, but he, what he said to me, and I have every reason to believe him, a very, very sober guy
00:25:58.120
is that they know they have found that as people, people stress goes up in airplane accidents and
00:26:07.720
also in shipping, certain shipping accidents that you can measure changes in the, the timber, I think
00:26:14.860
is the word, the tone of the voice, it gets higher. Okay. As the stress goes up.
00:26:21.040
And also that the, the language becomes more and more confused. So the first level is normal,
00:26:29.680
say baseline, normal radio transmission. The second level of you, it's, it's getting a little bit
00:26:36.140
higher. The level, let's call that level two. The third level is, it's getting higher and also
00:26:43.920
confused, grammatically confused. Like they're not really talking in normal sentences. And the fourth
00:26:50.880
level is something. And the fifth level is just howling screams as people are dying. This guy's
00:26:56.620
listened to more people dying on tape than probably anybody in the world. Um, and he, he also told me
00:27:03.140
that it was, that it's 90% of pilots who die in a cockpit are screaming when they die. 10% aren't.
00:27:12.620
So, uh, and they, he doesn't know why, but 10% stay cool. And I know certain situations, uh, certain
00:27:20.360
Brazilian flight, for instance, where the Brazilian pilots just stayed cool, cool, cool, but most of
00:27:27.780
them scream. Um, and in the very end, in this flight, he measured and he had a graphed and showed me the
00:27:37.140
graphs, the changes in Sahari's voice and radio transmissions from the ground where he was talking
00:27:45.040
to ground control at the airport through the takeoff to the point of leveling off to the first
00:27:52.720
unnecessary transmissions that I had noticed were strange, but okay. I don't know why he, maybe he was
00:27:59.960
getting sloppy and it went up the scale. It got to a level, you know, three or something. He, he was,
00:28:08.260
he was mixing his language. His voice was really high. Um, Sahari and it peaked right after soon after
00:28:17.720
the initial level off at 37,000 feet. And then as the minutes went by, there were another say seven or
00:28:25.000
10 minutes before the airplane turned and disappeared. Um, his subsequent radio transmissions
00:28:31.480
began to descend that began to normalize, never gotten normal on the basis of that, though, you
00:28:38.500
know, you can't prove it at all. He believes that what happened to the co-pilot was that the captain
00:28:44.580
attacked the co-pilot right after leveling off. Now there are various ways that you can kill a guy
00:28:50.140
in the cockpit with you, including, you know, crash axes and whatever it is. Um, so he believes
00:28:58.320
that he had, has, um, audible evidence of an attack that occurred in the cockpit. I don't know if that's
00:29:08.100
true. He doesn't know if that's true. He's a sober guy. I'm a sober guy. So it's interesting. It does
00:29:15.820
make sense. We don't know exactly what happened to the first officer of the co-pilot. We, but we do
00:29:23.500
know he wasn't up there sucking his thumb when the other guy was flying for seven hours like that. I
00:29:29.440
mean, he was incapacitated too. Did the captain send him back to the bathroom? Did he go back by
00:29:36.380
himself? That would be unusual because they had just taken off from Kuala Lumpur and they hadn't been
00:29:41.100
in the air very long, um, and get locked out by the captain. Was it a lockout? We don't know,
00:29:48.340
but if he was away from the cockpit, he wouldn't have had pressure, pressure, oxygen. He would have
00:29:54.520
been just like the passengers and the flight attendants susceptible to depressurization.
00:29:59.620
We don't know. All he needed to do was come up with some excuse to get him out of the cockpit.
00:30:03.760
And then he would have been just like the other passengers. Can I just clarify something,
00:30:07.300
William? You, did you say that this gentleman picked up on radio transmissions that happened
00:30:14.540
after they signed off, you know, Malaysia flight three 70 good night. They happened after that?
00:30:21.880
No, before, before, before that good night. Um, that, that was the last radio transmission.
00:30:28.460
It, these are radio transmissions that started on the ground, call that baseline normal and ended
00:30:35.340
with the final sign off. And they peaked in their strangeness and the stress level that could be
00:30:40.420
measured in the voice and the changes in the voice right after the airplane leveled off at 37,000.
00:30:48.540
Wow. So he could have, it's possible under this theory that he could have killed the co-pilot
00:30:53.080
before he even signed off with air traffic control.
00:30:56.420
Well, yeah, I'm not tabloid. I don't think you are either. Um, and so, you know, we veer too easily
00:31:02.180
into the tabloid territory here, but it's, it is a possible explanation. And I, I, I mentioned it
00:31:08.460
because I have such deep respect for the guy who brought it up to me, who made it a special trip
00:31:14.500
to see me, um, to explain this to me with evidence. Um, and I, I've long, long known and respected
00:31:22.420
him and you can't get more sober than this guy is. He's not a crazy in any way. He's very serious.
00:31:33.340
Let's talk about possible motive and what they found at, um, Zahari's home because the flight
00:31:41.300
simulator made a lot of news. The picture of him sitting in front of his home flight simulator,
00:31:46.300
and they did find a route on there that looks like this one I'm told, but they also found routes,
00:31:54.920
you know, hundreds of routes on there. And, you know, there's a, been a debate about how much we
00:32:00.120
can really tell from the fact that that one route may have been on his flight simulator and also what
00:32:07.560
was going on in his life. You know, the Malaysians would tell us this is a happy man, well-adjusted man.
00:32:11.420
This is not a depressed guy. There's no reason to think he had it in him to kill 239 passengers
00:32:18.400
just on a whim. So can you speak a little bit about what we know of him outside of the aircraft?
00:32:25.120
Well, let's take the simulator first. We know that he had the simulator. He was a simulator buff.
00:32:29.360
He was an airplane buff. He was also an internet buff and he was in chat groups and social media and
00:32:34.800
blah, blah, blah. But he, he was running hundreds of flights. It was the Microsoft simulator, but a
00:32:41.740
fancy setup. It wasn't a full motion simulator, but it was a pretty fancy setup. Invested thousands
00:32:47.600
of dollars into this thing. He played with it a lot. So there were hundreds of flights, as you say,
00:32:54.860
that were recorded by that simulator and then rather clumsily erased. But they were kind of all over
00:33:01.620
the map. And then there was this one flight, which was also erased with the other flights.
00:33:07.060
And this flight eerily duplicated the turns, the irrational turns, the flight path with no reason
00:33:16.480
and no destination, no landing airport that actually did occur. That's number one.
00:33:22.440
Number two, and I eventually, I mean, initially put no weight in this. I thought this is,
00:33:28.140
but there are other aspects of it, which amount to that of all those flights, this was the,
00:33:39.840
I think I'm right about this. I could be wrong, but of all those flights, this was the only one
00:33:46.160
that was flown in a very particular way. Whereas the other flights, he would essentially turn on the
00:33:52.480
autopilot and let the simulator fly for hours and run the entire flight smoothly, start to finish.
00:33:58.500
Or maybe he'd stop it and didn't go get a cup of coffee and forget it. But this is a flight in which
00:34:04.520
he advanced the aircraft along that path manually. So, and it's the only one. So there was a different
00:34:12.900
approach to this flight. So he was as if he was impatient. So he's pushing it forward, pushing it
00:34:18.320
forward, pushing it forward by hand, basically manually. And then also, I think subtracting
00:34:24.900
the fuel. My impression is that the fuel subtraction was not happening automatically. So he had to
00:34:29.740
punch a few keys and take out some fuel to establish the actual fuel exhaustion point.
00:34:37.300
So there is that, which is odd. And the other thing about the simulator is that he,
00:34:46.500
there was really no reason to do this. In other words, why would you need a simulator? And that's
00:34:56.080
the other side. Like maybe this hit, maybe that's totally by chance. Because if I wanted to figure
00:35:01.800
out how I want to crash an airplane, I know how much fuel I've got on board. I know where I want
00:35:06.840
to go down if I want to run it out of gas. And I just go to Google Earth. I mean, you can do the same
00:35:12.460
thing on Google Earth. So, you know, you don't need a simulator for this. And Google Earth is free.
00:35:17.620
So why would you use a simulator? What's the answer to that, do you think?
00:35:31.360
People say that, and that he was leaving a message, a goodbye. If so, it's a really bizarre
00:35:37.620
goodbye, because he erased it, along with the other stuff. And he would then assume that the FBI
00:35:42.720
and others would come in and find it, and pull it out of the memory. And that's a really, really
00:35:50.580
obscure way to say goodbye. Was he trying to sow confusion? Well, it didn't sow much confusion.
00:35:57.480
I have no idea. And you see, unlike many observers of this accident, amateur observers,
00:36:04.780
and I'm an amateur observer, I don't claim to know everything. There are things about this accident
00:36:11.000
that are unknown, and will probably always be unknown.
00:36:17.000
What about his mental state? Was there evidence that this was a depressed guy, or his life wasn't
00:36:26.040
Yes. When I was in Kuala Lumpur on this assignment for the Atlantic Monthly,
00:36:33.280
I spent a lot of time on that, because it was so obvious to me, it became obvious really
00:36:42.400
quickly, that the airplane didn't fail, that the pilot failed, that this was an intentional act,
00:36:49.620
and it fit a pattern of other intentional acts, suicide murders, that I have written about
00:36:55.620
in the Atlantic over the years. So it wasn't...
00:37:03.280
Extremely surprising to me that a guy, a pilot, would do this. It does very rarely, but it does
00:37:12.400
I can name them. It takes probably two hands to name them. So I was immediately, well, not
00:37:21.580
immediately, but the farther I got into this, in Kuala Lumpur, wondering about what was the deal
00:37:26.480
with this guy. Well, the Malaysians were putting out a story that everything was hunky-dory. He was
00:37:33.560
sort of in a way like the co-pilot who was indeed hunky-dory, right? He was this young guy getting
00:37:39.760
married. But the more I talked to people, the more I looked around, the more obvious it became
00:37:48.160
to me that he was... Despite what the Malaysians were saying, despite what their god-awful police
00:37:55.620
report, this completely corrupted police report said, and they painted him as a model citizen,
00:38:03.380
he was deeply, deeply disturbed. He was going through, you could say, an intense midlife crisis.
00:38:11.680
You know, I think that's a polite way of putting it. He was 53. His wife had left him. His children
00:38:19.080
were grown and had left also out of the house, normally, normally. But he was alone in this
00:38:26.860
house, big house. He had two houses. His wife had moved into another house. And the first sign of
00:38:33.540
trouble I noticed was that his wife was saying, as I think one of his daughters was saying, that
00:38:40.720
everything was normal. Daddy, he's such a nice guy. Everything was fine. He was happy. He wasn't
00:38:46.640
fine. His wife had just left him. And I don't know how soon before the accident. That's some
00:38:53.620
time before. And then other things began to appear about his mental condition. He was
00:39:02.420
obsessing about some cute little internet models. They were twins, you know, far beneath his age,
00:39:11.060
you know, like professional virgins, right? He was just writing the messages. And they were,
00:39:18.980
you know, whatever the word is for that. But they were making a splash in Malaysian society
00:39:25.400
by being cute little, clean cut girls. And it was like, really inappropriate for this guy. What is
00:39:32.300
he doing? He's, he's, he's, he's 53. And they were, I think, in their 20s. That's weird,
00:39:39.400
a sign of mental distress. And then there were other things that began to add up to point to a
00:39:46.880
very unhappy man. And I really don't even talk about them. I think it's appropriate to talk about
00:39:55.740
them. But it became apparent to me that the wife and daughter were covering up for him and the
00:40:01.620
reputation of their husband, father, and also that the Malaysian government was covering up for him
00:40:08.980
because they didn't want to be embarrassed. And that's really typical for a country like Malaysia,
00:40:13.600
or let's say for Malaysia, it's very typical. It's all about face saving, covering up dishonesty,
00:40:19.880
corruption. It's a very dishonest place on some level.
00:40:25.580
When you say, when you say there's something more that you don't want to talk about,
00:40:28.700
can you give us like a category, like sexual or?
00:40:34.020
Yeah, sexual. But again, I, you know, I know quite a bit about that now, and I never wrote about it.
00:40:41.400
And I, I don't know, but it does explain. To me, when I was in Malaysia, I really wasn't so
00:40:48.340
interested in his motivations, his motives, because I, it became apparent to me that he had
00:40:55.440
done this. And if he had done this, uh, well, what gain would there be in finding out exactly
00:41:02.820
why he'd done it? Why are you going to get into the airline population globally and try to weed
00:41:07.880
out people who might do this for those psychological reasons? He can't do it.
00:41:10.980
We like to tell ourselves that, you know, we, we like to tell ourselves that because we want,
00:41:15.620
like to think we have some control over stopping the next guy. You know, that, that one, you
00:41:20.980
mentioned the German pilot who flew that plane into the side of the mountain was just unforgettable
00:41:25.520
and such a mystery to the rest of us civilians. Like how, what, how, you know, why didn't they see
00:41:31.320
the signs? And you think if you can figure out what are the signs, then you can prevent the next
00:41:35.860
one. Well, in that case, there was a fairly long track record of psychological problems,
00:41:42.920
the German guy, and they, you know, Lufthansa should have known, um, he, he had a real, a real
00:41:48.300
psychological problem going on with depression. And, and, uh, but in Zahari's case, no. And it's a,
00:41:55.460
it's a famous problem in aviation is you as globally, as an airline, or as a, as a, a, an aviation
00:42:03.960
regulatory agency, or as passengers, you really cannot predict who is going to crash your
00:42:10.940
airplane. It's been a problem since the beginning of aviation. It remains a problem today. It's
00:42:16.440
very, very difficult to do. If I would say it's impossible, you really can't do it on the basis
00:42:21.680
of flight hours of licenses of, you know, exams. Um, it's, it's, it's very stubborn problem. Now it's
00:42:28.900
very rare that airplane, the airline pilots crash airplanes, very, very rare, but when they do,
00:42:35.880
it's almost always a big surprise. And that's not because people are asleep at the wheel. It's the,
00:42:41.880
it's the, it's the reason is that, uh, it's just about impossible to predict. So who, so to go into
00:42:48.800
the quality of the poor and really go to ground on what his motivations were, uh, I thought at the
00:42:55.680
time was not worth my time. I mean, I, I was more interested in what was the evidence that existed
00:43:05.240
and still exists to what went wrong. And it was any possibility of a technical failure. And there is no
00:43:12.560
possibility of a technical failure, no conceivable possibility of combinations of technical failures
00:43:18.840
could have caused the airplane to do what it did before it crashed. There's nothing on earth
00:43:24.200
that could explain that it has to be human intervention. And it's pretty inconceivable that it would be
00:43:35.180
Let's talk about some of the other theories that are out there. Um, one that was explored by the Netflix
00:43:41.500
documentary was they, they had a woman. I'm going to go through a few of them. So they get more,
00:43:47.700
they get progressively outlandish. We'll start with the one that's perhaps the least outlandish.
00:43:51.800
They had a woman who said she was an expert. Not really. She was like a home amateur who had become
00:43:59.420
what she felt was somewhat of an expert in detecting debris in the ocean via satellite images. And she
00:44:05.640
felt very strongly that she did find said debris, um, over in, what was the other ocean? Um, on the South
00:44:15.280
China Sea, which would have been, no, not in the Indian Ocean. She said she found debris floating.
00:44:20.380
Oh, I know what you're talking about. The French, she's French.
00:44:22.460
No, the French lady blames us, the Americans. No, there was a civilian woman in this documentary who said,
00:44:29.440
I can see via satellite images debris, uh, in the, in the, uh, South China Sea that is very consistent with
00:44:38.200
airplane debris. And the plane went down, uh, on its way to, uh, Malaysia. I mean, to, uh, China,
00:44:45.700
to Beijing, just as it was supposed to, it didn't make a turn. And why don't they just go and search,
00:44:52.300
just go and search because you'll find the debris there. So what do we, is there any chance this thing
00:44:57.180
actually did go down on course? Well, if it did go down, of course, you'd have to explain the fact
00:45:02.860
that a significant amount of debris washed up in Madagascar, right? On the other side. How do you,
00:45:07.660
how do you get, how do you get there from, from the South China Sea? You don't get there. So it's,
00:45:13.340
you'd have to go below, uh, Singapore and come up to the Malaysian. Well, no, their theory would be
00:45:18.180
that wasn't, that wasn't MH370 over on the other side, on the, on the West side, in the West Bank of
00:45:24.860
the South. We know it was MH370. We know it was MH370. Some, some of those things are unmistakably
00:45:31.180
three, MH370 because of serial numbers. Some don't have serial numbers, but we're off of triple
00:45:37.200
sevens unmistakably. Well, take an inventory of the number of triple sevens that have crashed,
00:45:41.840
uh, in the Indian ocean. So, you know, this, the debris that was found was either ambiguous. Okay.
00:45:49.100
Some of it, you really couldn't tell, or it had serial numbers. That's totally unambiguous. That was
00:45:54.440
MH370. Or it was unambiguously as triple seven without a serial number, but it was found in the
00:46:02.460
Indian ocean. So forget it. Okay. But could it, could it have been messed with? There's a suggestion
00:46:06.300
in the movie that debris found that would be consistent with all this happening over in the
00:46:11.980
West and the South Indian sea and the Indian sea, the way you're explaining that might've been dropped
00:46:16.700
there. There could have been the Malaysians interfering, right? That they, they intentionally
00:46:21.820
dropped something there or some other actors, maybe the Russians to make it look like MH370
00:46:27.240
went down in that ocean, but really it didn't. It wound up in Kazakhstan or it went down on its
00:46:33.500
way to Beijing over on the East in a different ocean altogether. What do you make of that theory?
00:46:40.440
And spirit, conspiratorial fantasy. I mean, you know, I, I make it, I, what I make of it is not
00:46:45.380
total and utter nonsense. And it's over overly embroidered, unnecessarily complicated,
00:46:53.380
requiring a level of conspiracy that doesn't exist, can exist in a country like Malaysia or any other
00:47:00.860
country for that matter. Uh, you know, what, what, what can come out will come out. And that's just
00:47:05.800
not, that's not where it's at. It's just this amateur, amateur stuff.
00:47:09.780
I mentioned Kazakhstan because there is a man named Jeff Wise who features prominently in
00:47:19.200
this doc. I don't know. I don't know if we should call it a documentary, but this film
00:47:23.460
and he's featured prominently quite a bit. He's been all over the news since this plane went down
00:47:28.760
offering different theories. And one of his theories is that the plane may have been hijacked
00:47:36.420
potentially by the Russians. Somebody may have gone down into the belly of the aircraft via a hatch
00:47:44.980
that would have been right in front of the first class department and messed with the signaling such
00:47:50.700
that it would have thrown off the Imarsat data that says pretty definitively it went South over the
00:47:58.400
Indian ocean, not North toward Russia, towards Kazakhstan. Here's a little bit of Jeff Wise, um,
00:48:04.120
offering some of, some of his theories from the film.
00:48:08.680
A modern commercial jetliner is in communication multiple ways with the outside world. All of them
00:48:16.260
went dark at the same time. Why? The most obvious answer would be catastrophic failure. Like the plane
00:48:27.980
blew up. It impacted the ocean. Um, it suffered a fire so intense that it just destroyed all the
00:48:34.840
equipment simultaneously before anyone could issue a mayday call. But the plane's debris was still not
00:48:42.700
found underneath the spot where that disruption and communication occurred. If it wasn't catastrophic
00:48:51.740
failure, what's option two? The only really obvious possibility is that somebody on board the plane
00:49:00.140
deliberately turned off its electronic communication signals. And if that's the case, the question is who?
00:49:07.840
So he goes on to say, if you want to find links between the Russians and this plane, he's not taking it to
00:49:14.820
the pilot. He's taking it someplace else. There are, there were three Russians on board this plane and
00:49:21.120
some, one of them could have gotten down into that hatch I mentioned, messed with the comms and the other,
00:49:27.480
the other tech that was down there and thrown everybody off. Perhaps the plane is sitting to this day,
00:49:37.220
Well, I happen to know Jeff Wise. He's a friend of mine. Um, let's just say that I have always
00:49:48.520
respectfully and sort of vehemently disagreed with him. Um, and I've always told him that, you know,
00:49:57.420
he, he, he has presented his arguments to me, um, at length. Uh, and I, you know,
00:50:07.220
I worry about it frankly. So, um, it's, it's not in the realm of reality. So yeah, that's all I can
00:50:23.740
say. I, he's a great guy. Well, the question is it for, for what, you know, who would have had
00:50:33.140
the sophistication to get out, get down there and the ability to get down there right in the middle of
00:50:36.720
the other passengers and then have the sophistication to turn off, you know, communications
00:50:41.260
equipments and throw off the Amarsat data. I mean, that is one, that is next level sophistication
00:50:47.540
by a potential hijacker. And then the hijackers typically when they hijack, they want something
00:50:54.220
as a result of their feet and they usually claim credit. You know, none of that, none of that happened
00:51:00.820
here. Of course, you're absolutely right. I mean, it's, um, that's number one in all of us
00:51:08.840
theorizing that this was a hijack. It's not a high, it was not a hijacking. Also it would,
00:51:14.920
that particular theory required a level of sophistication in terms of understanding the,
00:51:20.480
the handshakes that we were talking about before, um, that even in Marsat didn't have when the airplane
00:51:26.580
went down. So how would the, the, the, the, the functioning of these two forms of audio
00:51:33.500
handshakes, um, and not audio, electronic handshakes, um, was not known to really anybody,
00:51:41.320
uh, for analysis. So if you don't know it in order to analyze it, how does somebody else know
00:51:47.800
it in order to hijack an airplane? It's the hoax theory, right? So it's just inconceivable.
00:51:54.240
And it delivers a level of expertise into the Russian hands when they can't even keep quiet
00:52:02.060
enough on the front in Ukraine to get off their damn cell phones, to keep from getting hit by
00:52:08.880
drones and missiles, right? Spotted. There's not a huge level of sophistication going on in Russian
00:52:16.060
culture, uh, and science. And this would require some huge level of sophistication beyond anything
00:52:22.920
to pull that off. No way. And for what reason, as you say, but also no way, um, it's just
00:52:31.740
inconceivable. Um, but you know, the music there, when you played that clip, um, you know, the drumming,
00:52:39.120
the ominous drumming and all that, that helps, I guess, make the drama. Well, here was the biggest
00:52:45.200
shock and to me, disappointment of the film. They hold in abeyance, this French journalist who pops
00:52:53.480
up every once in a while, and she's built up as a credible source. Who's probably got the answer as
00:52:58.880
we spend time with Jeff Wise's theory and with the satellite woman who's analyzing the debris, uh, over
00:53:05.440
in the South China sea. And they keep sort of teasing the French journalist as somebody who's going
00:53:10.220
to be the straight shooter who might have real answers for us. And then finally, they let her
00:53:15.440
tell us what her theory is. And her theory is we, the Americans did it. We downed the plane intentionally
00:53:22.860
because it had some sort of goods in the cargo, lithium batteries, other things, perhaps something
00:53:29.960
relating to, um, tech at a Singapore. We don't know that we needed to get rid of. And here's a bit
00:53:37.020
of this woman in the big reveal from the one they built up more, more than anybody on, on us in our role
00:53:43.140
in it. It's sought to so at 1 19 AM, any three seven zero is requested to change over to the Vietnamese
00:54:01.700
Captain Zahari signs off. Wave is now infamous. Good night.
00:54:10.060
And this is the perfect moment for an interception to take place. So it's possible. And that moment,
00:54:18.540
the two U.S. AWOCs moved into action and jammed MH370,
00:54:34.780
making it disappear from the radar. Maybe it receives an order from the AWOCs to go and land somewhere nearby.
00:54:46.860
When Captain Zahari receives the order, it's possible that he says no.
00:54:54.620
He does not accept this order. They still need to stop the plane and its precious cargo to arrive in
00:55:02.540
Beijing. So either through a missile strike or a mid-air collision MH370
00:55:15.820
The theory there being, this is how she says it, the cargo, they say inside MH370's cargo
00:55:26.140
were 2.5 tons of electronics, including lithium batteries, walkie-talkies and accessories,
00:55:33.500
that the cargo was loaded without being scanned, which caused this journalist, Florence de Changer,
00:55:42.060
to believe that the cargo contained highly sensitive U.S. technology. And these two U.S. AWOC planes,
00:55:49.180
which are military planes, spotted it. And that she says they were also spotted near MH370 in the air.
00:55:57.500
They asked him to land so they could inspect the cargo. He refused to do so. And then they shot down MH370
00:56:07.740
You know, conspiracy stuff like that demands belief in the perfection of government agencies,
00:56:19.900
also evil intent and desperation. It's just nonsense, right? Nonsense. And also, by the way,
00:56:29.340
how do you explain the debris then in the Indian Ocean?
00:56:32.780
Fake. That's what the movie suggests is fake. It's fake news.
00:56:38.180
Yeah, don't mention that. But it's, yeah, fake news. It's just nonsense, obviously. And, you know,
00:56:48.780
if you look at the history of airplane accidents, airline accidents, rare is the airline accident where
00:56:55.100
somebody doesn't come up with a reason that it was either a bomb or shot down, preferably by the
00:57:03.260
American military. And I know of only one case where the U.S. military has shot down an airliner,
00:57:11.180
and that's the Iranian airbus. And I believe the ship was the Stark, I believe, mistook it for an Iranian
00:57:23.420
war plane coming at it and shot it down and full of passengers. That was a truly horrendous mistake.
00:57:32.380
And it was, but typically, how long did it take for that to get out? A few hours. You don't keep secrets
00:57:42.220
like that in the U.S. military. The U.S. military leaks like a sieve. So, no, that didn't happen. Yes,
00:57:50.780
every time, and not every time, but many times when airplanes go down, people come out of the woodwork to
00:57:55.660
say it was a missile, it was a bomb, you know, and it sometimes is, but very rarely. I mean,
00:58:02.860
we know the Russians shot down a Korean airlines, I believe 747, that strayed over their territory way
00:58:09.980
back when, in the closing days of the 83 of the Cold War. Well, there was one more reason. It happened.
00:58:17.500
There was, there was, the Russians shot down MH17 not long after. Oh, that too. Was it after?
00:58:26.300
This one. Absolutely. That too. That too. But again, it's, it wasn't any big mystery about what happened there.
00:58:32.700
It's like, you don't keep secrets like that. And the Russians say, well, we didn't do it. They did it.
00:58:37.260
They didn't do it. We did whatever, you know. Yeah. You shot it down and it was a mistake. Almost certainly
00:58:43.260
it was a mistake in this, in this case in Ukraine. So, you know, they didn't intend to shoot it down.
00:58:49.820
So to have an intentional shoot down of this Malaysian flight. No, sorry.
00:58:55.820
I know because it had lithium batteries on it. We didn't want the Chinese to get the lithium batteries.
00:59:00.860
So we killed 239 civilians. Doesn't really sound like us. No, it doesn't. It's completely unrealistic.
00:59:09.180
I think she's, I don't know what motivates her. I think she probably believes what she says.
00:59:14.940
Most of these people do, you know, that's, that's the fever, you know, you get into that,
00:59:19.180
you get that fever, you start believing it. And that's, you say the fever, the rabbit hole.
00:59:24.460
Thank God I'm not in that category. I frankly haven't thought about this flight, you know, for a few years.
00:59:30.620
Well, the article is spectacular. So, so walk us through what, what, what happened with the investigation?
00:59:37.020
Why, you know, you had the one guy, uh, he was featured in the film as well, who was out there
00:59:43.020
finding all the debris. He had asked oceanographers, like if a plane went down in the Indian ocean,
00:59:49.420
tell me about the currents, where would the debris wash up? And the guy then went to those places.
00:59:53.180
And sure enough, he started finding debris, which as you point out, some had serial numbers,
00:59:57.260
some didn't. There were questions about whether he was plopping the stuff on the beach right before
01:00:01.820
he miraculously found it with, with press in tow. That's how the film portrays him.
01:00:07.180
Um, oh, really? Yeah. Gibson. Yeah. Do you know him? Sure. Yeah. Yeah. I think you may have
01:00:13.100
mentioned him in your article. That's really, that's really unfair. You know, it, Blaine is a
01:00:19.180
very, very complicated guy. And, you know, the idea that he would manufacture this stuff in order
01:00:27.260
to gain publicity for himself is ridiculous. I know that from deep experience with him.
01:00:32.940
Um, he's complicated and he is obsessive in life, not just with MH370. He goes from one
01:00:44.620
obsession to the other. He's an adventurer. He's a world traveler. I think he's gone to 180 countries or
01:00:51.420
190 countries. And that's his goal in life. Um, he's complicated, but he's not a, he's not a cynic.
01:01:01.260
In fact, he should be more cynical, more doubting. Um, so if the press is following him, which I didn't
01:01:09.340
know, but, um, I don't doubt that he showed up with some press in tow, but the idea that
01:01:15.980
that would be his motivation is wrong, that dismiss it, it's unfair to him as a person.
01:01:21.820
Now, what he did is that is, I think it is much less. Sorry, go ahead.
01:01:30.460
It's much less significant than what he, than, than he thinks. The finding of those, of that debris,
01:01:36.460
other people, the first debris that was found was not found by him. It was found at Réunion,
01:01:40.300
the island of, the French Isle of Réunion, um, by a beach cleaning crew. And that had a serial
01:01:47.260
number on the flapper on and was off that airplane. Uh, so, and that's the, the, the debris that was
01:01:53.980
then analyzed by the French and the, the American NTSB got involved in, in north of Paris at the
01:02:00.220
library, the French laboratory. And that's a, uh, a serious piece of debris and evidence. And it was
01:02:06.540
not Blaine Gibson who found it. Blaine Gibson did find debris that is either certainly assignable to
01:02:13.900
MH370 or likely to be MH370, along with a lot of other debris that turned out to be a fishing boat
01:02:20.540
caught on fire, that kind of stuff. And he never claimed to know the difference really. So he,
01:02:27.180
he, I, I, I like him a lot, actually. Uh, I, I, I, uh, there's, there's room in this world for
01:02:36.220
all kinds of eccentric people. He's one of them. What happened to the rest of the debris? That's
01:02:44.860
one of the questions so many people are asking and why they spent three years in the Indian Ocean
01:02:49.340
looking for something, luggage, human remains, the rest of the plane, God willing, the, the black box
01:02:58.940
recorder, you know, all of that stuff. It's hard for some people to wrap their arms around the fact that
01:03:05.660
it's all gone. We only have little pieces. Like where's the main debris?
01:03:12.540
Well, you know, the answer to that is it's at the bottom of the ocean,
01:03:15.340
probably in some deep Canyon. It's a very deep ocean there, um, that has been searched at least
01:03:22.060
once, maybe twice and missed because searching in the deep ocean, that ocean there, where it went
01:03:27.980
down, then first of all, it's a vast area, as you said. Um, it's also hadn't even been mapped,
01:03:33.100
essentially, at least in a non-classified way. Um, so, uh, it's lying at the bottom of the ocean in pieces
01:03:43.020
because we also know that it didn't hit. It was, this was not a water landing that occurred,
01:03:47.820
right? This was a high energy, high, high energy impact and the airplane shattered as airplanes
01:03:56.300
do if they hit the water at high speed. So it's little pieces, probably the most intact pieces
01:04:01.660
are parts of the engines, but, you know, try to find a couple of mediums. I mean, big engines,
01:04:08.380
big jet engines, not that big, um, compared to the size of the ocean and the depth of the ocean
01:04:13.020
and the irregularity of the, of the, of the, uh, of the ocean in that part of the, of the world.
01:04:18.300
It's not a flat plain ocean. It's cut by canyons and mountains, and you can drag devices across it
01:04:24.700
and you'll easily miss things down there, the size of skyscrapers. So it's down there somewhere.
01:04:31.660
The question is why, and I came to this very early on, like, why are they doing this? Why
01:04:37.740
it was ongoing when I, the search was ongoing when I was writing the piece basically. And I said to
01:04:42.940
many people, why are you doing this? You're not going to find anything. I mean, if you do find
01:04:46.700
anything, it's not going to matter because, um, the black box is not going to tell you anything you
01:04:52.140
don't already know. The, the, the, the cockpit voice recorder is a two hour loop. And so you hear the,
01:04:58.380
the, the, the cockpit and that's the guys is reciting his apologies to the cockpit voice
01:05:03.740
recorder. It's almost certainly was not. And, um, and the system, uh, recordings of the flight
01:05:10.860
data recorder is not going to tell you really very much of interest. It'll tell you which engine
01:05:15.180
quit first, which end with second, some stuff about the fuel, some stuff about the final speeds.
01:05:21.580
It's, uh, that's a longer loop, but, um, uh, it, it really wouldn't say anything that we don't
01:05:28.140
already know. So why are you spending all this effort, all this money to drag the ocean in the
01:05:35.820
hope of finding this thing? And in my impression at the time was if you find it, so what? And I think
01:05:43.740
that became the overall conclusion. Um, it really didn't matter to find it enough is enough. It was
01:05:50.860
driven as many, in many cases driven by political pressures, um, and the families of the dead. Yeah.
01:05:59.420
Now that's a legitimate thing. I mean, people don't want to just walk away from their dead
01:06:05.580
loved ones and say, oh, well, you know, we'll never find them, you know? So there's a huge amount
01:06:10.300
of political pressure to be compassionate. And I understand that completely, but, um, it, from a
01:06:16.540
logical point of view, strictly logical point of view, it didn't make any sense. And they finally,
01:06:20.700
they said, okay, enough is enough. Who's funding this? Do you think that there's a, there's reason
01:06:28.860
to believe that he downed the plane there knowing that it would be impossible to retrieve the remnants?
01:06:36.780
I think so. I'm no, impossible to retrieve the remnants at least put a big hurt on the search,
01:06:46.220
but I don't know how much he knew about the sub. I mean, nobody knew that much about the subsurface
01:06:52.620
ocean in that place. And he probably didn't know exactly where he was going to down it. The airplane,
01:06:58.860
we know pretty surely it ran, it went down because it ran out of gas. One engine went first, the other
01:07:05.420
engine went second, and then the, the APU little jet engine in the back cut in, cut out.
01:07:11.580
And if that was all sort of, you could tell from the satellite handshakes, what was going on in an
01:07:20.540
approximate way, but he wouldn't have known that in advance. And the simulation wouldn't have told
01:07:26.140
him that it wouldn't simulate that to that degree. So, um, you know, what were the winds?
01:07:30.300
Yeah. So I don't, I think that he wanted to bury himself and bury the memory of what he did or was
01:07:43.660
doing and bury and bury his life. No. And I mean, he did a very, very bad thing and he wasn't a very,
01:07:54.300
very bad person. He went haywire and how soon before the flight, he went haywire. There's evidence
01:08:05.420
that he had, he was going haywire for weeks before. Um, oh, I forgot to mention to you that the,
01:08:15.260
though the wife and the daughter were originally saying he was a happy, happy guy, well adjusted.
01:08:21.180
And that's what they were maintaining when I was in Kuala Lumpur. And I said, no, this is not true.
01:08:28.060
This is, this is, he was not adjusted. Well, they then came out, I don't know how long afterward,
01:08:35.260
and have since said to newspapers, I think an Australian newspaper that no, he was very,
01:08:40.540
very unhappy. Well, no kidding. Of course he was unhappy, you know, that, that, so, um,
01:08:50.860
Hmm. My God. I mean, 239 dead. Think of how we think about Jeffrey Dahmer, Charles Manson, Ted Bundy.
01:09:01.500
They, they don't hold a candle to this guy. Like there's this, this name does not yet live in infamy.
01:09:08.860
Think about the children that were on that airplane. That's what I think about
01:09:13.100
the children, you know, I, I mean, it's inexplicably evil, a terrible, terrible thing.
01:09:24.220
Yeah. Awful. And the thing about an airplane is that more than most modes of killing,
01:09:31.500
it lends itself to mass killing because they're big airplanes that carry a lot of people. Now,
01:09:38.060
why, if you want to kill yourself, you don't just go out and kill yourself. I don't know. Most people do.
01:09:41.580
They don't take others with them. And they, when they do that, of course, they, they, they commit
01:09:48.540
enormous violence on their friends and families. Suicide does. And it's enormously selfish and they
01:09:55.820
should be, you know, ashamed. But, um, in, in this case, and we've seen these cases before,
01:10:02.780
they decide they're going to take other people with them.
01:10:04.860
Can you explain to us the, the Malaysian government's role in this remaining quote unquote,
01:10:14.300
a mystery for so long? Like what was it there? They were just embarrassed that their pilot appeared
01:10:19.660
to be suicidal and committed this terrible act. And so they did everything possible to cover it up.
01:10:25.100
Yes. And, and, and it, it, it, again, it gets into some sexual stuff. Um, it gets into, you know,
01:10:35.180
really, uh, uh, deep, um, political stuff in, in Malaysia. And I frankly have not tracked it because
01:10:42.460
it doesn't interest me. Malaysian politics. That's the one subject that really does not interest me,
01:10:47.100
but it's certainly played a role here. He was, uh, uh, politically active. He was a partisan,
01:10:53.660
political partisan. And, um, there were, you know, his, the man he was in favor of his prime minister
01:11:00.780
was in jail and blah, blah, blah. Uh, and then out of jail. And, uh, you know, uh, the, the Malaysian
01:11:08.540
government, whether on a political level or on a bureaucratic level, right? The staff, the deep state,
01:11:16.060
um, is, is, uh, uh, scared. They're afraid and they're afraid for their careers. They're afraid
01:11:25.420
for their reputations in a small society, like a place that's a big country, but where very few
01:11:29.580
people actually run it, their friends, their careers, their reputations, their ability to make
01:11:38.300
money, uh, steal money. Um, that is, uh, that's Malaysia. It's a rough place. You know, you don't,
01:11:46.940
you can go to Malaysia as I've done a few times in the past for the Atlantic on different subjects,
01:11:53.340
piracy being one. Um, and, uh, you find that it's, uh, you can see why there are tourists there,
01:12:01.180
especially on the, along the coast, there's some beautiful beaches and resort hotels and
01:12:06.780
Kuala Lumpur. It can be, you know, it's a shopping center city and whatever, but you scratch beneath
01:12:12.140
the surface there, you start poking around areas that they don't want you to poke around and you're
01:12:17.500
taking your life in your hands. And there's no question about that. People disappear off the streets.
01:12:22.460
They do now they did then. And this is not something you just approach casually. Uh, and I have said,
01:12:31.660
you know, Blaine, if he, if he wants to really get at this and have a real adventure in life,
01:12:38.220
go back to Kuala Lumpur and start asking questions, but you know, he's, he's, he's rather paranoid and
01:12:45.580
frightened and to some extent for good reason. He, he, he worries about being killed and assassinated
01:12:52.780
or yeah, basically not arrested, but just taken off, taken out. And it's not entirely crazy.
01:12:59.260
Why aren't the Chinese, like the, the plane was filled mostly with Chinese citizens.
01:13:04.620
So why wouldn't China be putting its foot down and saying, we will find out, we will figure this
01:13:11.740
out. We do think it was your pilot. You know, why would they be so hands off on, on getting to the
01:13:19.420
real truth here? It's an, it's a version of Malaysia. I mean, it's, it's, it's kind of a,
01:13:25.180
it's a more advanced, more populated version, more powerful version of Malaysia. I mean,
01:13:29.820
look at how they responded to the COVID thing. I mean, look, they in this scenario don't have
01:13:35.500
anything to cover up that this isn't their sin. We would think they'd want a real answer.
01:13:39.580
No, I'm not sure of that because they don't want their citizens making trouble. So I can't
01:13:45.500
speak for what the Chinese authorities, I do know for sure that the Chinese authorities,
01:13:50.540
after a little bit of sympathy, told them to shut up and expressions of sympathy or demands for
01:13:57.980
further investigations that happened in China were absolutely shut down in no uncertain terms.
01:14:04.620
When that started to happen, I don't know, but it was a few months after the accident.
01:14:09.020
Initially, the Chinese were on the side of right. You know, let's find out what happened. It wasn't
01:14:18.060
one of their airplanes, but their citizens started making too much of a fuss and the Chinese don't
01:14:24.140
like fusses. So I think that's pretty much why, you know, they did that. I don't think they felt in
01:14:29.340
any way responsible for this, but they just don't like, you know, rabble rousing. They need to keep
01:14:34.940
things calm, keep a lid on it. And that's what they did. They put a lid on this.
01:14:39.500
That does sound like them. There's been so many theories. I remember being on the air when this
01:14:46.460
happened at Fox and it was such a mystery. You know, right from the beginning, it was very confusing
01:14:52.540
because nothing made sense to us civilians right off the top. We've covered a lot of airplanes going
01:14:57.740
down as news anchors, but nothing here was familiar or made sense. You may remember at the time Don
01:15:04.220
Lemon over on CNN said maybe it was a black hole that swallowed up the airplane. So there was a lot of
01:15:12.380
non-based questioning going on out there, not well-founded questioning going on out there.
01:15:16.620
What do you, what do you think, you know, has been missed? Like how, how, I guess I'm trying to ask
01:15:23.420
the fact that most news anchors and news journalists have no background in aviation. It seems to me to
01:15:30.620
have been a real handicap in covering this story well, and some being sucked down conspiracy rabbit
01:15:37.020
holes and so on as somebody who's both a journalist and a former pilot. What's been your impression?
01:15:53.580
experience and education. It's a little bit mysterious, not very, but it's a little bit
01:15:58.380
mysterious and, you know, reporters aren't pilots or engineers and all of that. I mean, so it's basically
01:16:04.540
that, I mean, especially in a case where you don't have the NTSB. NTSB was there, but they basically fled
01:16:12.460
the investigation. In Malaysia, they would not say that, but that's what happened.
01:16:22.380
That's, that's why, because the airplane disappeared and it leaves, as I said, I don't really watch
01:16:30.380
television, but I would expect that to be the case in this case. On the other hand, I, who have covered
01:16:39.500
major airplane accidents ever since the value jet thing in the Everglades, and I've been near France
01:16:44.540
and Egypt there and things in Brazil. I've been all over the world covering. That's not what I really
01:16:50.620
primarily do, but it's what I've been assigned to do at the request of my editors for years. So I've been
01:16:58.380
to many of the really big airplane accident investigations. I know that I normally don't
01:17:05.100
even start into them until a year has gone by and let the crowd wander on. And then I come in
01:17:13.660
with a very long article and very knowledgeable because frankly, I grew up with around airplanes
01:17:18.300
and my friends are, I have deep friends among accident investigators who talk to me both in Europe
01:17:23.900
and in the United States. They trust me because I don't write nonsense. On the other hand, on the
01:17:31.900
third hand, I had an early experience with the value jet accident in the Everglades where a DC-9,
01:17:41.100
an airplane you don't see anymore, the little twin jet belonging to value jet went down in the
01:17:45.980
Everglades. And it was, it turned out to be a cargo fire, oxygen canisters, a really interesting story.
01:17:52.140
I went down to Miami for that, for the Atlantic. And this is a long time ago. And I was
01:17:59.900
holding myself to be superior to these reporters who were around. These are, you know, television
01:18:04.380
reporters, national and local reporters, normal reporters. And I was naive and kind of snobby about
01:18:13.020
it within my own mind. I didn't make that clear to them, but I thought you guys, you know, I know what
01:18:17.740
this was. This was an electrical fire. I know that because I, as a cargo pilot, had had a series of
01:18:23.980
electrical fires that looked a lot like the fire that took this airplane down. And so I thought,
01:18:28.620
yeah, you guys, whatever. Well, it turned out they were right and I was wrong. So now it was easy for
01:18:34.140
me because I didn't have to write anything about it for a year. So I ended up not looking like a fool.
01:18:39.500
So I earned an early lesson to respecting the non-technical aspect of normal reporters,
01:18:50.860
the ability of reporters to get to a story that they are not experts in, and actually maybe do
01:18:57.980
better than an expert like me. I am an expert in aviation, much as I sort of regret it.
01:19:03.260
They did a better job than I did. And for me, it was a profound lesson. So I'm the last person who's
01:19:10.940
going to denigrate. I don't know what they're saying about MH370. I don't watch TV. I don't know.
01:19:17.740
But I will never denigrate reporters. Plus, I spent three years in Baghdad where, you know, where I
01:19:25.740
watched my closest proximity to normal reporters, which I'm not. I came away from that. Well,
01:19:33.180
very early on, I developed a deep respect for the reporters, the ordinary reporters, you know,
01:19:38.780
Chicago Tribune, New York Times, blah, blah, blah, TV reporters, CNN. They were around me,
01:19:45.180
that I had never really been around these people before. And I watched them almost as much as I
01:19:50.620
watched the war. And I came away from it with a deep respect for their courage, for their intelligence,
01:19:58.780
for their ability to learn quickly. And I, again, I'm the last person who's going to criticize
01:20:06.540
normal reporters for their lack of expertise. In Iraq, they knew exactly what was going on.
01:20:14.460
Very early, they knew we were losing the war. And they had a problem transmitting that information
01:20:20.060
to the American public, because they had to be filtered by the institutions that sent them
01:20:24.700
there, the editors and the readers and so forth. But the reporters were incredibly smart,
01:20:30.940
dedicated, brave beyond belief. And so, I'm a fan.
01:20:36.060
Oh, well, let me ask you this, as somebody who has had lengthy experience reporting on these many
01:20:43.420
accidents, I mean, to someone like me, it affects me as a journalist, it affects me as a mom,
01:20:47.740
as a human, and as an airline traveler, because I'm not the strongest, most secure person when I'm up
01:20:57.740
there. I definitely have a fear of flying. And things like this are very scary, you know,
01:21:03.820
to the stuff you were saying about how he could just depressurize the airplane, and
01:21:08.380
in a couple of minutes, you'd be dead. Like, I realize how incredibly rare this is. But just a word
01:21:14.620
from you in parting on the safety of air travel, and what people like me should be remembering when we
01:21:22.700
go up there. Well, I mean, it's often said, and usually believed, but that airplanes are very,
01:21:30.460
very, airline travel is very, very safe. And that is correct. I mean, statistically, you just,
01:21:35.420
this cannot be denied. So being afraid of flying on the airlines is sort of like being afraid of
01:21:40.540
crossing the road. And you would, of course, I mean, I would, and do willingly send my small
01:21:46.620
children, I've got small children, and older children, get on the airplane, no problem, whatever.
01:21:52.860
No problem. I don't, I don't think about it. Like, who's flying the airplane when I'm not flying the
01:21:56.860
airplane? You know, who's, who's in front of me? Fine. And that a lot of them are not very smart
01:22:01.900
people. But the system is so monitored and dependent on teamwork and training and this and that that it
01:22:10.700
turns out to be very, very safe. And it's become that way, partly, largely through engineering, which
01:22:16.060
starting, starting with the advent of the jet engine in the 1960s, and the airplane, the job
01:22:21.260
got more and more boring and more and more safe, right? So that's number one. It doesn't take much
01:22:27.980
to fly one of these airplanes. And, and, and you got two guys, or women, a man, a woman, whoever,
01:22:33.740
who can do it in the front. That's number one. Number two, if you look at the, the thing that seems to
01:22:40.940
scare people the most from my casual observation and conversation, you know, around dinner table,
01:22:48.140
it's turbulence, right? And I know that dominates in a terrible way, the lives of airline pilots.
01:22:55.260
They go around, they tiptoe around, uh, uh, the, the, the passengers fear of turbulence. It's
01:23:03.100
terrible because they only have one life and the passengers threshold for turbulence is ridiculous.
01:23:10.140
The airplanes can handle a whole lot more turbulence than the passengers can. There's
01:23:15.180
no problem with turbulence. When I get in severe turbulence and I had a job, my last job is flying
01:23:20.620
and hunting severe weather, right? So going into severe turbulence and other forms of severe weather
01:23:27.420
on purpose for a few years, I did that. And, uh, I was transitioning to journalism, but, um, yeah,
01:23:34.300
you know, we hunted the worst weather nationwide in the U S, uh, nationwide and flew into it for days on
01:23:43.900
end. And, um, um, um, for technical reasons, it was a job, but point is we were flying into conditions
01:23:53.900
that no airliner ever goes into ever, ever, uh, they, they, they, you, they get a few little bumps,
01:24:01.660
which would, which would be not even worth thinking about it for a pilot. And people are writing letters
01:24:08.220
to the Senator and the Congressman. I mean, they think they're dying. That's a big problem. And it's
01:24:13.500
totally unnecessary. The airplanes are extraordinarily strong. And the, the, to give you an example,
01:24:20.940
and we would find a turbulence, um, that would, is so rough that you couldn't see the instrument
01:24:26.700
panels, right. It's shaken so hard. Um, and also that would, depending on the design of the seatbelt
01:24:32.460
and so forth would bruise your thighs. You know, you have a shoulder harness too, but you can, you come
01:24:36.700
away with it from it bruised, physically bruised. The airplane didn't care. It's fine, but tell that to
01:24:43.580
the passengers. So if there's one thing you can say very specific, uh, other than check the statistics,
01:24:50.300
it's safe globally and safe for a reason, and then you can say very specifically,
01:24:57.420
learn about turbulence, you know, don't be afraid of turbulence. That's
01:25:04.940
one more thing. I had a assignment from Vanity Fair. I, after the Atlantic was working Vanity Fair,
01:25:11.820
they came up with the idea of sending me to find the worst airline in the world and fly with it.
01:25:15.820
Oh, and I, the most unsafe airline in the world and fly with them. And they,
01:25:20.940
I found them in Kinshasa. That's a terrible assignment.
01:25:25.660
What are they trying to kill you off? It was great. No, I thought it was great. No,
01:25:29.500
no, it's great. I had a great time and, and up in the cockpit of these old Soviet turboprops flying
01:25:37.100
around Congo and just really a lot. But anyway, these airlines are blacklisted, right? You can't
01:25:44.220
take them anywhere out of Congo and they crash all the time. Okay. They're not like the airlines here.
01:25:49.020
They don't crash. They hardly ever crash. Those guys, they crash them all the time. Sometimes they
01:25:54.380
die. Sometimes they don't usually don't die, but I went, um, and, and, and I truly had a great time
01:26:02.060
doing that for a few weeks with these pilots. Why? How was that a great time? You're a crazy
01:26:08.300
man. Who would say yes to that? Who would say yes? No. How was that fun? No. The point is that's
01:26:16.060
how safe airplanes are. You know, they don't crash. And if they do crash, they're probably not
01:26:21.900
going to kill you and whatever. It's fine. You know, and by the way, everybody dies sometimes.
01:26:28.540
Oh God, that is of no comfort when you're up there and thinking it's this time it's right now. Um,
01:26:35.580
yeah, but everything else you said, that was a soothing bomb. I I'm going to be thinking about
01:26:41.660
that story about going into the bad weather and the plane can take a lot more than we allow it to.
01:26:46.700
You know, I would say that all you need is just like the, just the jolly word from the captain.
01:26:52.300
That's all I would, I would bear out the turbulent ride. If you know, just be nice to have the pilot
01:26:57.180
say like, Oh, no extra charge for the fun ride. Something like that. Keep us going.
01:27:04.540
It's so burned out. If you look at the air traffic control conversations,
01:27:09.740
the percentage of those are right. We're known as ride reports. So they're seeking from air traffic
01:27:16.780
control ride reports from airplanes that are going ahead of them. And it's a lot of rider reports,
01:27:22.780
rider reports, rider reports. It's really awful. It's awful for the lives of the pilots. And so it
01:27:28.860
put, you put you in a bad mood and every time you get in turbulence, you have to excuse it to the
01:27:33.660
passengers. It makes you really surly in a hurry because it's such not a problem and it's messing with
01:27:40.540
the lives of the pilots. Ah, okay. Well that, that also makes me feel better. I mean, we need,
01:27:46.620
we need to be a little tougher because they do. I mean, I appreciate when they tell you it's going
01:27:50.060
to be bumpy. Okay. It's fine. It's gonna be bumpy, but they need to be saying it's going to be bumpy
01:27:53.900
and we're going to be fine. You don't have to worry about the bumps. I mean, like that,
01:27:57.020
that should be the second part of the message, which it isn't. Yeah. Well, people don't believe in.
01:28:01.820
You have been wonderful, William. Gosh, it's so nice to meet you and have such a clear thinker and
01:28:08.460
researcher and talker on the show and something this complex. What a pleasure. Please come back.
01:28:13.420
Thank you very much. Oh, what an incredible story. My gosh,
01:28:18.540
just a sad, strange mystery that may never get fully officially solved, but really gets you
01:28:25.740
thinking right. And a perfect way to end our hot crime summer week. I want to tell you that I am
01:28:30.700
off next week, spending some time traveling with my family for our summer vacay. We will be back with
01:28:36.460
you on June 26th live to talk about all the news. Have a great, great week. And I'll talk to you soon.
01:28:46.140
Thanks for listening to the Megan Kelly show. No BS, no agenda, and no fear.