On June 24, 2022, the Supreme Court overruled Roe v. Wade, making abortion illegal in all but the most remote areas of the United States. In the wake of this landmark decision, the pro-life movement had been waiting for decades for a moment where they could lay claim to a constitutional right to abortion. On this episode of The Choosing Life Podcast, we are joined by Ian Reid, the filmmaker behind the documentary, "Choosing Death," and founder of Outer Limits, a film studio dedicated to stories that heal, move, and inspire.
00:00:03.440For Colson Aviation, it's when your business from Port Alberni, B.C. takes off globally.
00:00:09.480It's fighting forest fires from the air while protecting yourself from financial risks on the ground.
00:00:15.800Turn uncertainty into your next business opportunity with Export Development Canada's market insights, connections, and financial solutions.
00:00:24.900Discover the export impact today at edc.ca slash export.
00:00:30.000The Constitution does not confer a right to abortion.
00:00:39.480Roe and Casey are overruled, and the authority to regulate abortion is returned to the people and their elected representatives.
00:00:47.480That's what the Supreme Court ruled in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization on June 24, 2022.
00:00:54.520It's the decision that the pro-life movement had been waiting to read since 1973, when the Supreme Court invented, out of whole cloth, a supposed constitutional right to abortion.
00:01:07.700Since that time, defenders of abortion tried to paper over Roe's weak, frankly non-existent, legal reasoning with euphemisms and slogans.
00:01:24.840At The Daily Wire, we're committed to cutting through these sorts of cheap slogans and getting to the heart of what matters in our politics and culture.
00:01:34.820On this podcast, we'll be getting to the heart of the abortion debate.
00:01:41.300We recently released an investigative documentary called Choosing Death, which shined a light on the four foundational lies of the pro-abortion movement.
00:01:49.920Conversations with abortionists, Planned Parenthood workers, pro-life advocates, even abortion survivors.
00:01:59.020They are the first-hand accounts of the people who know abortion best.
00:02:04.040Now more than ever, we must show people the gruesome reality that lies beneath the euphemisms, beneath the lies of the abortion lobby.
00:02:15.100Then, and only then, will we grow a culture of life.
00:02:19.920I'm Michael Knowles, and this is the Choosing Life Podcast.
00:02:34.020Right now, I would strongly recommend you go to hallo.com slash choose life, because today's world is a scary one.
00:02:43.340Too many people don't seem to care about the truth.
00:02:45.760And I would suggest that that's all rooted in people becoming less, or really, just anti-religious.
00:02:53.420That's why it's more important than ever to keep our relationship with God strong.
00:02:58.640Hallow is the number one Christian prayer app in the United States.
00:03:01.860It's like Calm or Headspace, but rooted in Catholic faith.
00:03:05.640It is the perfect resource to deepen your relationship with God and find peace through audio-guided prayer and meditation.
00:03:12.220Several of Hallow's meditations encourage you to choose life, and to pray for others to choose life, such as their Litany for Life with Lila Rose.
00:03:35.560The last few weeks have been an absolute whirlwind.
00:03:41.920This documentary comes out, Choosing Death, the Legacy of Roe.
00:03:46.400And then just a couple of weeks later, the Supreme Court overrules Roe v. Wade in the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization decision.
00:03:56.920This is the most important Supreme Court decision probably of the last 50 years, if not longer.
00:04:06.720And we are joined now by Ian Reid, the filmmaker, the documentarian behind Choosing Death, and the founder of Outer Limits, a film studio dedicated to stories that heal, move, and inspire.
00:04:18.880Ian, thank you so much for coming on the show.
00:04:38.200And now people will hear your side of the conversation in these very, very long-form interviews and in this podcast.
00:04:45.400So I guess my first question would just be a little bit about you and how you found yourself in the pro-life movement.
00:04:51.940Yeah, well, you know, it's really been a topic that I've just found to be incredibly important through the majority of my adult life.
00:04:59.440You know, as I arrived at voting age, I started analyzing the issues and what was important to me as a voter and as a citizen.
00:05:05.360And really one issue rose to the fore above everything else for me, and that was this issue of life.
00:05:12.360I can't think of a topic that deserves our attention more.
00:05:15.280I mean, if you look at the political landscape, what other topic in our country today has so much controversy surrounding it that it has become a single issue that dictates entire elections?
00:05:26.280And that's why the Dobbs decision is so ground shaking in the impact that it's going to have on our country moving forward and why we have to have a response to those who disagree with us for why the pro-life movement is the right movement going forward.
00:05:42.180And so when The Daily Wire started talking to me and my team about what might a film, a documentary about the issue of abortion and its history look like, as we started diving into the lies behind the abortion movement and the facts surrounding the Roe v. Wade verdict back in 1973,
00:06:02.080the rationale for the majority opinion in that case. What we discovered as a team was that the lies really haven't changed since 1973.
00:06:13.900The same lies that the justices used to make their decision in Roe v. Wade are the same lies that are used today, albeit the language is slightly changed.
00:06:23.760The way that the lies are presented are, you know, more catchy and almost weirdly lighthearted in the way that they're talked about by the pro-choice movement now.
00:06:35.080But the lies are at their core the exact same lies that were used to get Roe v. Wade passed into the social and moral mainstream.
00:06:43.480I love that you're using that verb passed because that's not the common language that you would hear about a court decision.
00:06:50.860That is the kind of language you would hear about a piece of legislation.
00:06:55.000And frankly, the court's decision in Roe was much closer to a piece of legislation, albeit from the bench, than it was a court decision.
00:07:13.900Even defenders of Roe v. Wade, even Ruth Bader Ginsburg, for goodness sakes, would mock the legal reasoning or lack thereof.
00:07:24.140And then when Roe was upheld, partially upheld in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, the Casey decision overruled parts of Roe because it just – from a legal perspective, it didn't make a lot of sense.
00:07:35.460And I think that we get a sense of Roe v. Wade being something that was passed rather than something that was decided upon, even in conversations in this series.
00:07:46.640You know, we'll hear from the law professor at the University of Notre Dame, Carter Sneed.
00:07:50.180And he talks about how the arguments used by the court in the majority opinion aren't the typical types of legal argumentation that you would expect from the highest court in the United States.
00:08:01.720What you get is you get arguments that are pulled from obscure legal briefs that weren't even heard in the argumentation before the court.
00:08:09.800Many of those facts were pulled from shoddy research that was done by pro-choice advocates and pro-choice organizations who wanted to prove a point rather than get to the actual truth of the facts that the court should be considering.
00:08:23.620And something I love about your documentary is it's not merely about the legal nitty-gritty.
00:08:28.920Frankly, that's only a very small part of it.
00:08:32.280I've always been fascinated with the abstract legal arguments around – especially around a case as preposterous as Roe.
00:08:38.640But the more damaging lies would seem to me or the more shocking lies or the lies that really pull at your heartstrings are the lies that the pro-abortion movement has told about the babies themselves.
00:08:52.800And I think you do a marvelous job in your interviews of exposing those.
00:08:57.460We're not just talking about how to misread some statutes.
00:09:00.440We're talking about living little human beings.
00:09:04.280I think one of the most painful truths through this entire film, and it's something that we've seen a lot of response from audiences as well,
00:09:13.140is that the pro-choice advocates, the pro-abortion movement, have successfully convinced the culture to talk about the unborn and human beings in the womb as if the science somehow wasn't conclusive that these are actual human beings who should have the rights of personhood.
00:09:34.480And they somehow code over the entire fact that all scientists and doctors – in fact, if you look at recent studies, something like 95% or 90% of doctors and scientists who study life in the womb agree that it's conclusive that it's a human being in the womb from the moment of conception.
00:10:10.740Frankly, I'm shocked the number is so low as 95%.
00:10:13.020Well, and you have to ask, you know, is the answer that they gave somehow dictated not by the science but by some sort of other core beliefs that are, in their opinion, more foundational to the way they live their lives and do their research than the science itself?
00:10:31.860Of course. It's just a way to paper over reality.
00:10:37.220I mean this is a recurring theme in your film is these euphemisms, these slogans, the up is down and left is right and black is white kind of illogic that you see suffusing the pro-abortion movement.
00:10:52.140Yeah, and what's really painful is – and what has become really clear to me as we've been working on this film is just how widespread the groupthink has become.
00:11:01.860You see on social media, you know, look, I'm a filmmaker, I have a lot of friends who are not conservative, you know, the majority of the film industry leans pretty far left.
00:11:12.000And seeing just the talking points and the total lack of research that's spread in fun little memes and catchy one-liners that actually have no basis in either the science or in good legal decision-making from the court, you know, is shocking and a little bit frightening when you think about how these catchy one-liners from the pro-abortion movement have taken hold of people who haven't put any thought into the issue themselves.
00:11:39.820You'll sometimes hear people refer to an unwanted child or, you know, a product of conception.
00:11:47.940That's another euphemism and it's this very dehumanizing kind of language.
00:11:54.140You never think about these people as people.
00:11:56.840You say, oh, it's just someone who's unwanted, okay.
00:11:59.400In your movie, you sit down with a woman who survived an abortion.
00:12:05.240So this is a woman who not only was once spoken of as a clump of cells, a product of conception, an unwanted child, but she was – there was an attempt to assassinate her.
00:12:17.040There was an attempt to kill her when she was in the womb and she managed to survive, albeit with some injury.
00:12:22.440And I just wonder now that we're decades on, this is a fully grown woman now, if the same sort of pro-abortion advocate who uses that kind of language could look that woman in the eyes and say, oh, you, you're unwanted.
00:12:39.780The world would be better off if you had died.
00:12:43.080Yeah, I think there are really two types of people in the pro-choice movement.
00:12:48.060I think one group of people in the pro-choice movement are people who just don't know, the people who don't know the reality of what's happening in abortion, don't know the reality of how developed children are in the womb when the majority of abortions are committed on them, and people who have seen the catchy phrases and talking points and are like, oh, yeah, I want what's best for women.
00:13:09.880And those people in their, I hate to say naivete or ignorance, but they're well-meaning people, a lot of them, I think, they just don't know how gruesome and what a violation of basic fundamental human rights abortion actually is.
00:13:25.700And we really hoped, I hope that a lot of people in that group get a chance to see this film because we do present a lot of facts and presented in hopefully a winsome, interesting way through the stories that are told.
00:13:38.540But facts that counterbalance the false narrative on a lot of those talking points.
00:13:44.880But then I think there's a second side of the pro-abortion movement.
00:13:48.520And unfortunately, those people are people who know the facts, know what's actually going on in abortion, and don't care.
00:13:57.180They want what they want, regardless of what it does to the human beings that are affected.
00:14:03.520And unfortunately, as we'll hear in Claire Colwell's interview, which is the first episode of this series, there are people in the pro-choice movement, the pro-abortion movement, who have said straight to her face, it would have been better if you had been killed.
00:14:16.980It would be better if you weren't speaking publicly about this issue, and we would rather that you had been killed alongside your twin in your mother's womb.
00:14:26.040And when you hear that, it just, it's shocking, but it also gives you a little insight into what at least a segment of the pro-abortion movement really is all about.
00:14:38.160They don't really care about the value of the woman's life if that woman is on the, quote, wrong side of the issue from their perspective.
00:14:48.380Of course. Of course. I like that distinction because that's true.
00:14:51.460There are plenty of people who support abortion out of ignorance.
00:14:54.500I supported abortion out of ignorance for my teenage years.
00:14:58.280I lived in a liberal place. Almost all my friends were liberals.
00:15:02.440The idea that one even could be pro-life was outlandish to me.
00:15:06.780I assumed all the pro-lifers hated women.
00:15:08.600I just bought everything that they said on CNN and NBC.
00:15:13.180And I was convinced by a female bioethicist, actually, that all the arguments I was making were either stupid or extremely evil.
00:16:21.680And he started doing them moonlighting on the side because he could make extra money doing them more efficiently than other doctors could.
00:16:31.300And the moment that he realized that he could no longer do abortions was when a baby who was much further into term than he thought it was ended up kicking his instrument that was in the womb of the mother.
00:16:47.120And he tells the story better than anyone else could because he lived it.
00:16:50.340And you can feel the emotion as he tells his own story.
00:16:55.060But I think you have to hear stories like that from actual former abortionists, people who are in the room doing those procedures to actually get a sense of what goes on in real abortions, apart from the partisanship, apart from the talking points, to get a sense of what's actually happening at the hands of these abortionists.
00:17:14.700And his story is a difficult one, but I think it's important for people to hear.
00:17:21.440We'll hear more from our conversation with Ian in a moment.
00:17:24.340First, though, text PRO-LIFE to 47581.
00:17:29.240Because as the country grapples with the aftermath of overturning Roe v. Wade, the pro-life movement has come under fire from far-left pro-abortion extremists.
00:17:39.120Not only have leftists firebombed and vandalized pro-life clinics in multiple states,
00:17:43.700but online pro-life groups have experienced mass censorship by Google, Facebook, TikTok, you name it.
00:17:52.000That's why Live Action has been working tirelessly to find ways to spread the truth about abortion and share resources with those who need it most without relying on biased big tech.
00:18:02.040If you want to join Live Action's Fight for Life, text PRO-LIFE to 47581 and opt in to receive updates from Live Action about their ongoing work to end abortion.
00:18:14.020Texting PRO-LIFE to 47581 means you won't be at the mercy of the big tech censors in the ongoing fight for life.
00:18:21.660So what do you hope to accomplish with the movie and the series?
00:18:33.680If the point of the movie, and I'm not sure that this was the point, but if the point of the movie was to persuade people that we ought to overrule Roe v. Wade,
00:18:41.960when you made the movie, Roe v. Wade was the law of the land.
00:20:38.500And what you find is they just really weren't.
00:20:40.760And so our objective for the film was we want to provide a little bit of a background on the issue of abortion and its history in the United States
00:20:48.880so that audiences can decide for themselves, should this have been the decision back in 1973?
00:20:55.600And what is my stance on abortion today?
00:20:58.380Look, we made this film just as much for a post-Dobbs world, regardless of the decision,
00:21:06.460We knew that there was going to be a decision sometime, you know, summer 2022.
00:21:10.160And so our objective with the film was not to influence or guide the decision of the court on the case of Dobbs.
00:21:19.480But what the objective was, was to provide a primer of the history of abortion in the United States
00:21:25.580so that audiences, regardless of where they fall on the issue, had a tool set to evaluate where do we go from here?
00:21:32.220Whether the Dobbs decision was going to be upholding Roe v. Wade
00:21:36.180and further enshrining that, quote, right to abortion in U.S. law for who knows how many more decades,
00:21:43.460or overturning Roe v. Wade and putting it back to the states and giving the states the authority to decide for themselves,
00:21:49.160we wanted to give people a tool set to analyze the issue of abortion using real facts and real history
00:21:56.960rather than this fabricated set of facts and one-liners used by the pro-abortion movement.
00:22:02.220Right. Because the Dobbs decision is not exactly a pro-life decision.
00:22:08.580The Dobbs decision is really about the structure of government and the proper place for making these kinds of decisions.
00:22:16.460So all that the Dobbs decision does is sends the issue back to the people and their representatives.
00:22:21.660So now it is incumbent on the pro-life movement to win over the hearts and minds of the people throughout the United States
00:22:29.800to, at that point, build a culture of life.
00:22:35.420The Dobbs decision gave us an opportunity, and now it's up to us to know what to do with that opportunity.
00:22:43.380Right. And this is something that has come up in a lot of conversations both on our team and with friends and colleagues of mine,
00:22:49.500which is that the work of the pro-life movement isn't over now with the Dobbs decision.
00:22:54.800The work of the pro-life movement is really just now ramping up.
00:22:58.420It's not time to sit on our laurels and think, oh, well, now the law is on our side or now the law is protecting the unborn.
00:23:06.380It's really just the first step in what should be the beginning of a real groundswell of work by people who are in the pro-life movement.
00:23:15.380And really, even if you're not in the pro-life movement, if you're a pro-life person in the United States,
00:23:19.680now is the time to start acting in a way that brings support to women in need who works in your community and your state
00:23:29.100to push for greater protections of the lives of the unborn.
00:23:34.420And, you know, look, there are a lot of critics out there who say that the pro-life movement just cares about life
00:23:40.180before the child is out of the womb and doesn't care about life once someone is born.
00:23:44.200And while that's factually just destroyed by the data, and that's just not true, I mean, it's objectively not true.
00:23:51.080If you look at who provides the most care for children in need, who provides the most care for women in need,
00:23:58.080who provides the most support to families who are low-income and are struggling,
00:24:03.460you know, whether you're talking about birthing clinics who provide diapers and milk and formula and support for mothers and families,
00:24:13.300or whether you're talking about charities that provide support for low-income communities and low-income families,
00:24:21.660across the board, those are almost always pro-life groups and organizations or people who are on the pro-life side of the debate.
00:24:29.340So, factually, just totally false that the pro-life movement doesn't care about life after birth.
00:24:33.860But this is the time for us to prove it even more so, right?
00:24:36.740It's the time for us to, as a community, not, you know, point fingers and say, ha, we won this time.
00:24:42.620It's now time to say, look, we know that you might be scared.
00:24:46.120We know that as someone who's pro-choice, you don't know what your future holds,
00:24:49.740but we're going to come alongside you, and we're going to provide the support.
00:24:53.620We're going to provide everything that we can do to help you in a post-abortion world.
00:25:00.640And that's really what we're all fighting for, a post-abortion world where everyone in society sees the results of valuing life even from the earliest stage.
00:25:09.400Right. We're not going to just say, we won this time.