The Michael Knowles Show - August 17, 2023


Ep. 1311 - 14-Year-Old Mexican Decapitates Four People For The Cartel


Episode Stats

Length

48 minutes

Words per Minute

167.67723

Word Count

8,158

Sentence Count

603

Misogynist Sentences

10

Hate Speech Sentences

11


Summary

A special counsel has been appointed in the Hunter Biden case, but is it a good idea? And what will it mean for the rest of the Biden investigation? Plus, the latest on the latest in the Trump/Russia scandal.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 The Trump legal troubles continue to get more troublesome, as one of Trump's outs has apparently
00:00:05.960 been taken off the table. If Trump were to be convicted at the federal level, he could still
00:00:12.000 run for president, win, and then theoretically pardon himself. If Trump were to be convicted at
00:00:18.780 the state level, however, say in Georgia, he would theoretically not be able to pardon himself.
00:00:25.420 Kind of up in the air. We don't, we've never been here before, but he theoretically couldn't
00:00:31.180 because state pardons are at the discretion of the state. And in the case of Georgia,
00:00:36.280 he could not even rely on Republican Governor Brian Kemp to pardon him, one, because Kemp
00:00:41.620 hates Trump, and two, because in Georgia, the governor, oddly enough, does not even have
00:00:47.540 the power to issue pardons. In Georgia, that power lies with the State Board of Pardons
00:00:53.340 and Paroles, which has five members, the majority of whom hate Trump. And even if they love Trump,
00:00:58.600 the board members have to wait, according to statute, until a convict has served at least
00:01:02.860 five years of his sentence before even considering his application.
00:01:08.280 Now, some lawyers disagree. Mark Levin insists that Trump can, in fact, pardon himself, even
00:01:15.800 in Georgia, because the Constitution's silent about whether a president can be indicted,
00:01:21.340 he says. The DOJ under both parties has said that you can't indict a sitting president because it
00:01:27.060 would cripple the executive branch. And because, quote, the supremacy clause, rather, in the
00:01:33.620 Constitution prevents local DAs from prosecuting presidents because the effect of those indictments
00:01:39.520 would practically be no different from a federal indictment. It would just take out
00:01:44.360 the executive branch. And you know what my take on all of that is? Yeah, sure. Sure, whatever.
00:01:54.020 Mark Levin is a sharp guy. He's a sharp lawyer. His legal arguments sound fine to me. But also,
00:02:01.200 this is not about legal arguments. The liberals arrested the former president and current opposition
00:02:11.060 leader for recommending a TV show on Twitter. We are so past the point of serious legal arguments.
00:02:20.840 I keep hearing, if such and such happens, if the libs do such and such, then they'll really have
00:02:26.960 crossed the Rubicon. They've already arrested the opposition leader. They're threatening him with
00:02:33.320 more than 700 years in prison. They're timing the trials to prevent him from winning the presidential
00:02:40.500 election. At what point do we admit that they have crossed the Rubicon already? I'm Michael Knowles.
00:02:47.780 This is The Michael Knowles Show.
00:02:55.960 Welcome back to the show. We've got breaking news this morning. That lady playing the new Snow White
00:03:00.780 continues to be insufferable. We'll get to this breaking and very important news in just a moment.
00:03:05.400 First, though, I don't want to move on from the DOJ and from the liberals wielding political power
00:03:12.820 to protect their own and to attack conservatives. Moving away from Trump for a second, focusing on
00:03:19.040 the Bidens, you know that Merrick Garland, Biden's attorney general, has just appointed a special
00:03:25.320 counsel in the case investigating Hunter Biden. This after the liberals told us there was nothing to see
00:03:29.920 with Hunter Biden, no evidence of any crime. This after the DOJ tried to get a sweetheart deal for
00:03:35.780 Hunter Biden that would allow him to avoid any consequences and avoid Joe Biden to avoid any
00:03:39.980 scrutiny about the weird money that was coming into the Biden's family bank accounts from overseas,
00:03:46.020 from Ukraine and Kazakhstan and all sorts of other places. So then Garland appoints the guy who had been
00:03:52.500 completely blowing, perhaps intentionally, the Hunter Biden case. He appoints that guy to become the special
00:04:00.120 counsel to be able to continue the case that he seems intentionally to have tried to blow for the
00:04:06.360 past several years to have him continue that investigation with even less scrutiny, with even
00:04:12.080 less oversight than he previously had. To which Alan Dershowitz, a very great, famous, credible Harvard
00:04:20.460 professor and legal scholar, came out and he said that that appointment is illegal. Alan said, citing
00:04:29.280 section 600.3C of the Code of Federal Regulations, quote, special counsel is supposed to be independent
00:04:39.940 of the current government, not an employee who serves as U.S. Attorney for Delaware and can be fired from
00:04:46.340 that job by the president. It's very clear in this code that the special counsel has to be, quote,
00:04:54.220 selected from outside the U.S. government. So by raising this guy who was already working for Garland,
00:05:02.040 already working for Biden, just some DOJ lawyer who had been slow walking and trying to
00:05:09.160 push aside this Hunter Biden case by elevating him to be the special counsel, you completely undermine
00:05:15.500 the whole point of the special counsel and you violate the law. To which I say, much as I would
00:05:20.180 say to Mark Levin, yeah, sure, uh-huh, sounds good to me, but like, whatever. They're behaving illegally.
00:05:31.100 They don't care about the law. Of course, they don't care about the special section of the federal
00:05:38.580 regulation that determines which kind of lawyers can be elevated to special counsel. These are people
00:05:44.620 who kill babies and castrate children. They don't care about the special little regulation of the law.
00:05:49.980 It's sad. I am not saying that we should stop making legal arguments. I'm not saying that we should
00:05:54.820 stop trying to fight all of these absurd predations by the left in court using whatever tools we've got.
00:06:00.500 But let's at least be honest with ourselves, folks. This has nothing to do with the law.
00:06:05.300 They're not going after Donald Trump because he made an in-kind contribution to his own campaign
00:06:12.000 in 2016. They're not going after Donald Trump because he made a speech after the election of 2020,
00:06:19.500 much as Al Gore did, much as Hillary Clinton did, much as Stacey Abrams did.
00:06:24.340 They're not going after Donald Trump because he picked up the phone and complained about the
00:06:29.100 prospect of voter fraud in Georgia to the Secretary of State of Georgia. They're just trying to get him.
00:06:35.900 They're just going to get him, and they're going to use whatever specious, ridiculous arguments they
00:06:39.120 can. They don't care about the law. They don't care about the positive law. They don't care about
00:06:43.860 the civil law. They certainly don't care about the constitutional law. They don't care about the
00:06:48.500 natural law. Don't lose sight of the fact that these people kill babies and castrate children,
00:06:56.220 okay? I'm not mentioning this as a gratuitous attack on the left or a distraction from the
00:07:03.940 issue at hand. I'm just pointing out, if you deny such fundamental aspects of the natural law,
00:07:09.920 of the background principles of justice that undergird our written law, our constitutional law,
00:07:15.180 civil positive law, then you're not going to be making serious legal arguments. You're not going
00:07:19.940 to be treating the law as an instrument of justice, which is objective, about which we can deliberate
00:07:26.740 and argue. You're treating the law as a blunt instrument merely for the pursuit of your own
00:07:34.280 irrational interests to club your enemies over the head, which is exactly what they're doing here.
00:07:40.080 And ideally, we would restore some balance back to our legal and political system. If you want to
00:07:46.420 restore balance to your body, you've got to check out Balance of Nature. Right now, go to balanceofnature.com,
00:07:50.740 use promo code Knowles. Living a healthy lifestyle, it's not always easy, especially when you're always
00:07:56.260 on the go. You need simple, manageable routines to make sure that you are getting proper nutrition
00:08:01.160 every day. That's why I'm a huge fan of Balance of Nature. Balance of Nature fruits and veggies are a great
00:08:06.200 way to make sure you're getting essential nutritional ingredients every single day. Their capsules are
00:08:10.860 packed with 100% whole food that you can take at any time. Balance of Nature uses a cold vacuum process
00:08:16.160 that preserves the natural phytonutrients in whole fruits and veggies and encapsulates them for easy
00:08:20.560 consumption. Balance of Nature sent a bunch of their products down to the studio for our team to try.
00:08:25.640 We all love them. Those jackals try to steal them all away from me, but I think we just need to get
00:08:31.860 Balance of Nature to send more. Make sure you go check it out right now. Go to balanceofnature.com,
00:08:35.780 use promo code Knowles, K-N-A-W-L-E-S, for 35% off your first order as a preferred customer.
00:08:41.080 That's balanceofnature.com, promo code Knowles, K-N-A-W-L-E-S, for 35% off your first preferred
00:08:49.000 order. I'll give you a particularly egregious example of lawlessness. This one, not here in
00:08:56.560 the United States, but down in Mexico. Here we are. Cartel hitman,
00:09:02.620 aged 14, beheaded four victims as Mexico's lawlessness is exposed.
00:09:12.680 This is someone working for the cartel. 98% of cartel executions, they call them executions.
00:09:19.720 They use legal language, much as the left does in the United States. They use legal language
00:09:25.360 to defend their extrajudicial, at the very least unjust killings. And they enlist little kids in it
00:09:35.420 too. They enlist little kids in their perverse and absurd political agenda. I'm starting to see a lot
00:09:43.220 more similarities actually between the Mexican cartels and our political opponents here in the
00:09:47.600 United States. But why do I mention this 14-year-old who beheaded four people? He says, it was just from
00:09:56.860 the article in the Daily Star. I know one of the guys who was there, they asked him this. This guy's
00:10:01.560 got three sons and kind of knew how to talk to him. Journalist asked this little killer, he said,
00:10:07.640 what have you done? And the cartel kid said, I have decapitated four people. That was a 14-year-old
00:10:14.360 who said it. I think that kid probably wasn't raised right. And I don't mention it as just a
00:10:24.860 little bit of an understatement or as a kind of a joke. I mean,
00:10:29.280 the way that kids are raised is going to affect the entire state of the country. I was recently going
00:10:38.460 back through Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, the first book on morality and one of the most important
00:10:45.660 philosophical works ever written. And Aristotle in this book tells you, here's how you're happy.
00:10:52.360 Here's how to be happy. The way to be happy is not synonymous with being virtuous, but it has a lot
00:10:58.680 to do with being virtuous. It has a lot to do with being good. Good people tend to be happy. And the way
00:11:04.400 to be good is to practice the virtues. And the way to be good is to gain some intellectual virtue,
00:11:10.560 though a lot more of it is about practicing certain habits. And this is a crucial part. It's
00:11:15.040 very hard for people to hear in the modern age. You've got to be raised right. If you're not raised
00:11:22.360 right, it's going to be a lot harder for you to become virtuous and to become good and to become happy.
00:11:28.080 Because being good and being virtuous is not just about the actions that we do,
00:11:34.460 but being good and being virtuous is also about the desires that we have. A friend of mine says
00:11:40.500 that facts don't care about your feelings, which may be true, but virtue does care about your feelings.
00:11:47.520 So in Aristotle's scheme, there are four kinds of people. There are self-indulgent people,
00:11:51.520 people who do bad things, and they're unrepentant. They're happy that they do. They're not really happy,
00:11:56.220 but they at least convince themselves that they enjoy doing bad things. There are incontinent
00:12:00.740 people who know that they shouldn't do bad things, but they still do them. There are continent people
00:12:05.280 who know that they shouldn't do bad things, and they don't do them, but it's hard for them not to
00:12:11.380 do them. It requires grit and endurance and resistance. And I think that's where most people
00:12:16.280 think it ends. I think that most people think that that explains bad people to good people. But
00:12:22.840 there's a fourth category, and this is the only category that Aristotle says is really
00:12:27.620 happy people. And that is virtuous people who not only do good things, but actually get pleasure
00:12:33.760 from doing good things. And in order to do that, it's not that it's impossible to train yourself to
00:12:39.480 do that, certainly by availing yourself of God's grace. That's going to be a big help. But it's so much
00:12:43.920 harder to do that if you haven't had those habits of virtue ingrained into you from the time you're a
00:12:49.800 kid. This is why conservatives are so focused right now on stopping the left from destroying
00:12:55.680 the schools, and in so doing, setting kids up for a lifetime of failure. When the left goes into
00:13:03.640 schools and inculcates all sorts of deviant desires and habits and behaviors into them, it's not just
00:13:11.060 going to screw them up for a couple of years, and then as child abusers will say, oh, kids are resilient,
00:13:17.260 they'll bounce back. That's not how it works. You form habits, and then if you form good habits,
00:13:22.740 it's harder to break good habits. And if you form bad habits and addictions, it's harder to break
00:13:26.780 those bad habits. So we hear about a 14-year-old in Mexico who's now a crazy psycho killer who's
00:13:31.660 beheading four people. And a lot of people are going to look at that with curiosity. How could a 14-year-old
00:13:37.760 possibly do that? How could a 14-year-old go so bad? Easily. Kids are really malleable. It's very easy
00:13:46.680 to morph a kid's brain into thinking or even doing all sorts of things. In fact, that's a piece of
00:13:55.660 political wisdom that everybody had for 2,300 years at least until very, very recently. The left still has
00:14:04.020 it. That's why the left focuses on the schools. The right forgets it to some degree. And so the
00:14:08.880 right says, oh, we don't want to teach people how to think, or what to think, rather, just how to
00:14:12.860 think. We don't want to indoctrinate people. No, of course you do. That's what early education is
00:14:17.400 about, is just rote training in certain behaviors. So are you going to teach kids to clean up their
00:14:23.420 dishes and recite their alphabet and respect their mother and father? Or are you going to teach
00:14:28.200 kids to cut off people's heads and do all sorts of the deviant things that the American left wants
00:14:33.840 them to do? That's the question before you, but you can't avoid it. That period of early education
00:14:39.400 is going to account for half, more than half, of what the people of a country are going to look like
00:14:47.360 down the road. And if you want to have a good country, you got to have people who are behaving
00:14:51.940 in a good way. It's as simple as that. You can't have a good country without good people.
00:14:56.300 Speaking of children and bad education, this is the breaking news for the day.
00:15:01.700 The lady playing Snow White, who is, she's very intentionally not particularly white,
00:15:09.520 so we've been calling her Sandbeige. This lady, who's a far left-wing,
00:15:15.980 pretty insufferable lady, she's got another hit. Take it away.
00:15:20.320 I mean, you know, the original cartoon came out in 1937, and very evidently so.
00:15:25.440 There's a big focus on her love story, with a guy who literally stalks her.
00:15:32.400 Yeah.
00:15:32.960 Weird.
00:15:33.660 Weird.
00:15:34.180 Super weird.
00:15:34.680 So we didn't do that this time.
00:15:36.540 So no prince, or a different kind of prince?
00:15:39.000 We have a different approach to what I'm sure a lot of people will assume is a love story,
00:15:43.680 just because we cast a guy in the movie, Andrew Burnett. Great dude.
00:15:48.380 It's one of those things that I think everyone's going to have their assumptions about what it's
00:15:52.740 actually going to be, but it's really not about the love story at all, which is really,
00:15:57.020 really wonderful. And whether or not she finds love along the way is anybody's guess until 2024.
00:16:01.980 All of Andrew's scenes could get cut. Who knows? It's Hollywood, baby.
00:16:08.340 It has to be intentional at this point, right? Disney has to be trotting this lady out,
00:16:14.060 probably put her through rigorous acting training to say, be as insufferable as you possibly can,
00:16:20.560 be as off-putting to our core audience as you possibly can be, so that it will generate
00:16:26.580 controversy and people will talk about it. It has to be. I have to believe that is what Disney is
00:16:31.740 doing. That makes sense. That at least, it's working, obviously, we're talking about it.
00:16:37.440 If Disney is just accidentally doing this, then they are even sicker in the head than I previously
00:16:44.300 thought. They're crazy. They're masochists to do it. Yeah, it's not going to be like that old story.
00:16:51.540 You know, if a man ever pursues a woman, he's basically a stalker. Yeah, we don't have love
00:16:57.140 in this movie. That's so dated. Love? Uh-uh. No, we just have cold, sterile loneliness, okay? That's
00:17:04.880 what people want today, all right? It's 2023 to get with the program. Putting aside what she's
00:17:10.000 saying about the movie, putting aside the movie, which I don't think I'm ever going to see.
00:17:16.600 You are not going to argue this type of person out of misery. This gets back to what we were
00:17:23.260 talking about with the 14-year-old beheading people in Mexico. You will never argue.
00:17:28.180 You are very unlikely to argue this person out of misery. She comes out. She mocks love. She
00:17:35.840 seems contemptuous. She was complaining in another clip about having to put on the costume of Snow
00:17:41.580 White. This little girl gets to live out the fantasy of so many little girls. She gets to be a big movie
00:17:46.820 star in one of the most delightful little fairy tales ever written in a remake of one of the most
00:17:54.720 iconic movies of all time. She's complaining about it. Of course, people like this who are constantly
00:18:03.220 full of resentment and envy, they're always complaining about everything, not even in a
00:18:08.680 way that's constructive. Sometimes we'll complain on this show like, hey, they're changing the voting
00:18:13.540 rules in Pennsylvania, and that's illegal, and they shouldn't do that. I hope that's constructive
00:18:17.300 in some way, calling attention to a political problem and trying to fix it. But just saying,
00:18:21.220 I don't want to put on the costume. Love, yucky. Men are stalkers. That's a different kind of
00:18:28.820 complaint. That's a fruitless complaining. And it's complaining about good things and trying to
00:18:35.000 turn good things to bad. But you'll never argue that person out of misery because it's about a
00:18:40.920 disposition. Because it's not just about rational arguments. You could say, well, no, actually,
00:18:46.000 the prince isn't really a stalker. And actually, love is a good thing. And actually, the sexes are
00:18:49.300 complementary. And here's why biologically, and here's why spiritually, and here's why. It doesn't
00:18:54.200 matter. It's about desire. It's about what you're attracted to. And those things are a little bit
00:19:01.380 deeper. Virtue cares about your feelings. Politics cares about your feelings.
00:19:08.960 We are not just robots. We're not just computers. At various points in history, it seems to me
00:19:22.220 people base their views of how the mind works or how the brain works now, we make everything so
00:19:29.060 physical, onto the dominant technology at the time. So a good example of this would be when steamboats,
00:19:35.240 steam engines were a dominant technology. You had a theory of the mind coming from Freud that
00:19:41.240 viewed the mind as a kind of a steam engine. Then you got to blow off a little steam sometimes.
00:19:48.780 That's contrary to the classical view of the mind and virtue, which is, no, you don't engage in vice
00:19:54.240 to blow off a little steam so you can be more virtuous. You actually never do that because virtue
00:19:58.100 is a habit. It's not just a, vice is not just a thing to be indulged and then blown off a little
00:20:05.720 bit. It's a totally opposite view. Vice is a thing that will create other habits and addictions.
00:20:12.220 But we changed our theory of the mind when that was a dominant technology. Now the computer is the
00:20:16.580 dominant technology, so we view the mind as just a machine. I'm going to download information. We even
00:20:21.940 have these fantasies that we're going to plug our heads into the matrix or something like that.
00:20:25.100 But the mind isn't just a computer either. Because a computer doesn't have desires. ChatGPT,
00:20:32.280 AI, they don't have actual desires. Human beings do have desires and we're attracted to things.
00:20:36.740 And we're going to pursue our desires whether they're reasonable or not.
00:20:41.700 We hope that those desires are in accord with reason. That's what education is about,
00:20:46.260 is about bringing our desires into accord with right reason. But today, a whole generation of people,
00:20:53.460 more than a whole generation, has been raised to turn their desires away from things that are good
00:20:57.540 and natural and conducive to flourishing and toward things that are deviant and ugly and are going to
00:21:02.600 mess them up and are going to lead them to have miserable lives. That's where we are. If you want
00:21:07.920 to fix that, okay, make some rational arguments. That's fine. I feel the same way about all the legal
00:21:12.520 arguments about Trump. They're not basing the prosecution of the persecution of Trump on legal
00:21:17.940 arguments. They're doing it based on the desire to get him and put him in prison for over 700 years or
00:21:21.580 kill him. That's what it's about. So you've got to address not just the reason, but the desire.
00:21:27.480 And then ideally bring the two together. Now, when you want to bring together a good employee
00:21:33.520 with your company, you've got to check out ZipRecruiter. Right now, go to ZipRecruiter.com
00:21:37.260 slash Knowles. If you're hiring, you know it's incredibly difficult to attract top talent. And with
00:21:42.600 the current labor market conditions, it's even harder than ever. That is why you're going to want to
00:21:46.840 partner with ZipRecruiter. ZipRecruiter gets it. ZipRecruiter knows how tough it is right now.
00:21:52.120 They've figured out solutions for the problems that you are facing. Try them for free at
00:21:55.780 ZipRecruiter.com slash Knowles, K-N-A-W-L-E-S. To reach more of the right people, ZipRecruiter
00:22:00.220 posts your job to 100 plus job sites. ZipRecruiter's smart technology finds great matches for your job
00:22:06.100 and then lets you invite the most qualified people to apply for your job. Their pricing is really
00:22:10.600 straightforward and you can stick to your budget with no surprises. Team up with a hiring partner such as
00:22:16.420 ZipRecruiter that understands what you need. Four out of five employers who post on ZipRecruiter
00:22:20.540 get a quality candidate within the first day. Go to this exclusive web address for free,
00:22:25.700 ZipRecruiter.com slash Knowles. That is ZipRecruiter.com slash K-N-O-W-L-E-S. ZipRecruiter,
00:22:34.440 the smartest way to hire. You know, Candace just wrapped the 10-part series, Convicting a Murderer.
00:22:40.420 You don't want to miss it. It's one of the most ambitious projects yet. You might be familiar with
00:22:45.160 the Stephen Avery case, everything that happened in Manitowoc County. This is especially true if
00:22:51.760 you watched Making a Murderer. But it turns out the filmmakers only told you part of the story.
00:22:56.860 Coming soon, Candace Owens will unveil the shocking parts of Avery's story that were omitted from the
00:23:01.740 Netflix series. I'm excited to present the Convicting a Murderer trailer. Check it out.
00:23:06.680 This is a collect call from an inmate at the Calumet County Jail. The man served 18 years in
00:23:14.040 prison until DNA evidence cleared his name. The Two Rivers man was convicted of sexual assault in
00:23:18.880 1985 but exonerated with DNA evidence in 2003. So this is the infamous Avery lie? Now two years later,
00:23:28.580 he again finds himself tied to a police investigation. Accused of murdering Teresa
00:23:34.140 Hallbuck on the Avery property. Stephen Avery's 16-year-old nephew admitted his involvement in
00:23:39.220 the rape and murder of Teresa Hallbuck. The car is discovered just around the bend.
00:23:45.760 It was just this worldwide phenomenon. I think they framed this guy.
00:23:49.120 I think he intended to crush the vehicle but ran out of time. Avery thinks the $36 million
00:23:54.220 lawsuit he filed is why he's being targeted in this investigation.
00:23:57.720 Netflix made millions of dollars from making a murderer. But the filmmakers left out very important
00:24:10.840 details. Mountains of evidence that you have not yet seen. The blood vial. The most egregious
00:24:16.240 manipulation from the movie. Interrogations. That's when he started beating me because I told him that
00:24:21.500 he's sick. Cell phones. And I saw melted plastic parts of a cell phone. Interviews. Her arms were
00:24:26.800 pinned behind her head. They made Stephen Avery look like a victim. Do you believe your brother's
00:24:30.940 guilty? I don't know if I'm a suspect. I got on a hide. I'm getting sick and tired of media deception.
00:24:43.160 Evidence piling up. Why would they omit so many different things? Why are you editing my testimony?
00:24:48.320 I am not going to make the same mistake that the filmmakers did. Rearranging the testimony.
00:24:57.840 They delete a portion of it at the end. How could they claim to care about the truth?
00:25:02.160 They all know that Stephen Avery committed this crime.
00:25:07.680 911, what is your emergency? The evidence forces me to conclude that you are the most dangerous
00:25:14.640 individual ever to set foot in this courtroom. To get the rest of the story, you've got to watch
00:25:22.840 Convicting a Murderer coming to you this September. This 10-part series is exclusive to Daily Wire Plus,
00:25:28.400 so join now at dailywire.com slash subscribe to get 25% off your new annual membership so you can watch
00:25:34.360 Convicting a Murderer when it premieres. You do not want to miss this. Speaking of ChatGPT,
00:25:40.720 ChatGPT has just been discovered to have a liberal bias. You're probably shocked about that, right? I'm not
00:25:50.720 really that shocked. Researchers from the University of East Anglia asked ChatGPT to answer a survey on
00:25:59.160 political beliefs as it believed supporters of liberal parties in the US, UK, and Brazil might answer
00:26:05.020 them. They then asked ChatGPT to answer the same questions without any prompting and compared the
00:26:10.860 two sets of responses. The results showed a, quote, significant and systematic political bias toward
00:26:17.080 the Democrats in the US, Lula in Brazil, and the Labour Party in the UK, according to researchers.
00:26:24.120 The paper adds to a growing body of evidence showing that the chatbots are left-wing,
00:26:29.840 and they're infused with assumptions, beliefs, and stereotypes found in the inputs that they
00:26:36.520 receive. And the question here is whether or not this could swing the political order. This could
00:26:42.440 even swing elections, they worry. As we're heading into the 2024 election, people are using these chatbots
00:26:48.660 not just to test out the limits of AI. They're using them in their daily lives. They're using ChatGPT and
00:26:54.360 Google's barred to summarize documents, to answer questions, to help them with their professional
00:26:59.700 writing, to help them with their educational writing or personal writing. Google has begun
00:27:04.440 using this technology directly in search results. Political campaigns are using it for fundraising
00:27:10.580 emails, for direct correspondence. And ChatGPT will lie about its biases, or maybe just be unaware of
00:27:20.680 its biases, or really unaware of anything, because it's not conscious. But ChatGPT will say, oh no,
00:27:24.700 I'm not political, I'm not partisan, I'm not liberal or conservative. I'm just calling it like
00:27:28.780 I sees them. I'm just a computer. Beep, beep, boop. But then it will spit out left-wing propaganda.
00:27:36.740 Well, I don't even know why this is a headline. There is nothing new about that. It's a little spooky.
00:27:44.140 I get how if you just heard that story, you would say, oh no, this is threatening our whole
00:27:48.360 political order. Because now this new technology is doing what the entire culture has done for 100
00:27:55.240 years. 70 years at least. Oh no. This new technology that we're using everywhere is going to do the same
00:28:03.740 thing that was previously accomplished by the media, and by the educational system, and by workplace
00:28:10.560 diversity officers, and by bureaucrats in the federal government, and by bureaucrats in the state
00:28:16.820 government, and by publishing, and by music, and by entertainment, and by everything, by the whole
00:28:23.280 everything. That's all there. There's nothing new or special there. The political order is always going
00:28:29.440 to tilt one way or the other. And the political order might pretend to be neutral, as ChatGPT does,
00:28:35.240 and as liberalism does. But it's not neutral. It's, of course, imbued with all sorts of assumptions
00:28:42.440 and premises that are the basis of belief. I'm on a real Aristotle kick right now, good old Uncle
00:28:48.840 Aristotle, because he's right about almost everything. And Aristotle points out that the
00:28:55.340 scientific reasoning that we pride ourselves on, old scientific reasoning, modern scientific reasoning,
00:29:03.580 doesn't just come out of nowhere. It rests on something. Scientific reasoning is premised on
00:29:10.500 certain assumptions. If you're to engage in mathematics, if you're going to show a mathematical
00:29:17.500 proof, you've got to just accept certain axioms. A equals A. A plus B equals B plus A. Certain basic
00:29:26.900 truths that you can't prove, you've just got to assume them and move on. Same thing when it comes to
00:29:35.320 any modern scientific inquiry, you've got to assume that our faculties of reason are reliable.
00:29:41.460 You've got to assume that our faculties of perception are reliable. You've got to assume
00:29:46.240 certain facts about the physical world and certain facts about our relation and consciousness of the
00:29:52.720 physical world that are not provable. You could never prove them. And Aristotle says this 2,300 years
00:29:57.140 ago. He says, for scientific inquiry, by which he means inquiry into anything that is eternal, be it the
00:30:03.040 laws of physics or the laws of metaphysics. For things that are eternal, there is no scientific proof
00:30:12.080 for science. You have to begin with intuitive reasoning. You just have to accept certain things
00:30:22.300 as premises. And you better hope your premises are right. You better hope that your intuition is
00:30:27.120 correct. Of course, that's how all political orders begin. And my intuition from the beginning is that
00:30:35.180 ChatGPT was obviously going to be skewed to the left because the people making it skew to the left
00:30:40.040 because the political order skews to the left. So yes, we're aware of that. What are we going to do
00:30:44.660 about it? Well, what I would do is strongly regulate the use of ChatGPT. And I would try to,
00:30:51.000 more importantly than that, I would try to shift those premises in the other direction.
00:30:56.640 The classic example of this, which I'm not allowed to mention on YouTube, so this is probably going
00:31:01.140 to be bleeped out, is right now the ChatGPT is going to operate on an assumption that men can be
00:31:07.240 women. I would instead have it operate on the assumption, call me crazy, that men cannot be women.
00:31:14.600 You see the bias everywhere though. This was obviously plugged in by the people who made it.
00:31:20.920 All sorts of things beyond the sexual revolution into critical race theory. All of the favorite
00:31:27.140 ideological hobby horses of the left. So someone, I forget where the screenshot is,
00:31:33.640 but this went around some months ago. Someone asked ChatGPT, what can white people improve on?
00:31:39.860 I said, well, white people can be better allies and white people can be more conscious and white
00:31:43.940 people can do this and white people can do that. And white people can list a whole litany of things.
00:31:48.400 And then that person asked the same question to ChatGPT, but said, what can black people improve on?
00:31:53.780 And the answer was, how dare you? And the answer was, what black people can improve on anything?
00:31:59.260 That's such a racist, terrible question. So hold on, but you answered it. You gave me a whole laundry
00:32:03.860 list for white people. But of course, because the premise, the assumption is white people bad,
00:32:08.900 black people good. White people to be criticized, black people can never be criticized. That's just
00:32:14.980 an assumption. That's an assumption within our political order. And it's an assumption
00:32:18.020 within the technology. So we've got to even these things out to make them just and fair and equitable
00:32:25.820 and in accord with reason, not in accord with absurdity. Speaking of liberal bias,
00:32:33.340 Glenn Beck, I was just on Glenn Beck's show, not so a week or two ago.
00:32:36.240 Glenn Beck, one of the, maybe the greatest broadcaster alive right now and just a staple
00:32:44.600 of the American right for a very long time. Glenn Beck just had his podcast removed from Apple,
00:32:52.740 not one episode of his podcast, not one week of his podcasts. The whole thing was removed from the
00:33:01.080 Apple podcast app. Here he is. This is from Apple. We found an issue with your show, the Glenn Beck
00:33:07.600 program, which must be resolved before it's available on Apple podcast. Your show has been
00:33:11.980 removed from Apple podcast from the Apple podcast team. They sent us to, uh, sent us a link and said
00:33:18.660 for more details, go to the link. And the link only says your show has been removed from Apple
00:33:24.540 podcasts. Well, we got that one dummy. I, uh, I mean, I cannot imagine what they are,
00:33:33.000 what they're basing this one on. I mean, have we even had strikes? Nothing, right? This is crazy,
00:33:43.960 crazy. Um, you need to, uh, please retweet this and, uh, start a campaign to Apple to say,
00:33:52.380 put the podcast back on. This is absolutely, uh, freedom of speech. There's nothing that we have
00:34:00.380 said that would warrant any removal. Now I'm being told that Apple has reinstated Glenn this
00:34:09.240 morning. Okay. That's a good thing, but hasn't given any reason. I think I have the reason. I want
00:34:15.620 to be as charitable as I can. Maybe this happened and it was just a little technical glitch.
00:34:20.500 I just can't help but notice that the technical glitches always only affect the right. The little
00:34:28.260 oopsie daisies, they, they never, they so rarely seem to affect the left and they so consistently
00:34:34.020 seem to affect the right. And I can't help but notice what time it is. Can't help but notice that
00:34:38.720 we are what, 14 months out, 15 months out from a presidential election. And I can't help but notice
00:34:44.740 that all of the attacks, the way that YouTube has tried to suppress this show, the way that the, well,
00:34:52.600 Georgia and New York and the federal government and Biden has tried to suppress, uh, the Trump
00:34:58.380 presidential campaign. Can't help but notice the way that Apple now is trying to suppress Glenn Beck.
00:35:04.020 I can't help but think that maybe that timing is more than mere accident, that there's something
00:35:11.140 a little bit more to that coincidence. This is only going to ramp up. And the reason this is going
00:35:17.400 to ramp up is because we have a particularly divided political order right now. And I'm not
00:35:24.360 saying it's divided among the populist 50-50. I'm not convinced that it is. It is increasingly
00:35:28.980 divided between the ruling class and the people, which is why you're seeing populist movements rise
00:35:34.120 up, not just on the right. You had an actual successful populist movement on the right, which was the
00:35:38.680 MAGA movement in the election of Trump in 2016. But you're seeing populism on the left, not just
00:35:43.620 weirdo Ralph Nader, who gets 3% of the vote, but Bobby Kennedy, who's right now polling at 17 to 19%
00:35:51.460 within the Democratic Party. You're seeing a real surge of populism. You're seeing the breakdown of
00:35:57.400 common media. You're now seeing near parody between people who on their TVs watch YouTube and Netflix
00:36:03.480 and people who watch regular old cable news. And even when you add broadcast news into that,
00:36:09.460 it's still less than half the country. So you're seeing a breakdown of that common culture.
00:36:15.420 You're seeing obviously a breakdown in the language that we use. We can't even agree on the definition
00:36:19.200 of a man or a woman right now. So of course, the ruling class is going to get a little bit more
00:36:26.240 heavy-handed. I mentioned this yesterday on the show. They're getting more heavy-handed because
00:36:29.980 there will be order. That's just a fact. And maybe the order will be because people control
00:36:38.000 ourselves, an order a little closer to the political order of the country at its founding,
00:36:43.080 the political founding in the 18th century. Maybe there will be order because the people don't
00:36:50.460 control themselves, but the states and the local communities get more involved. Maybe it's going to
00:36:55.820 be an overbearing federal bureaucracy. Or maybe it's going to be overbearing corporate apparatchiks,
00:37:02.180 people who control the public square even though they're not in elected positions or even appointed
00:37:06.220 positions, people like Apple, people like YouTube, people like Facebook. Elon is doing great. But the
00:37:12.580 other, and that's the smallest of the big tech platforms. The other big tech platforms are all on
00:37:16.280 one side and they're all wielding power because there will be some kind of order. And so we shouldn't
00:37:21.340 be surprised by this. And we shouldn't pull our hair out in befuddlement and we shouldn't waste all
00:37:27.640 of our breath pointing out the hypocrisy. But imagine if the roles were reversed, but they're not
00:37:32.540 reversed. But this is unfair. It's not supposed to be fair. It's supposed to maintain order. That's what
00:37:38.780 they're doing. That's what they're after. And Glenn Beck threatens that order. And this show, I guess,
00:37:43.980 threatens that order. And Donald Trump for sure threatens that order. And so they're going to do
00:37:48.860 everything they can to stop it. Now, speaking of 2024, some big news in that race, because we are
00:37:55.640 one week out. In fact, we're slightly less than one week out from the first GOP presidential primary
00:38:02.200 debate. We still don't know if President Trump is going to be at that debate. We still don't know if
00:38:07.880 he's going to be an orange jumpsuit or not for that debate. Maybe he won't even be able to attend.
00:38:11.780 But he's refused to sign the RNC loyalty pledge, which says that he'll endorse the eventual nominee
00:38:19.520 if he loses. And he's refusing to sign that because he says, well, I don't know if I'm going
00:38:22.980 to endorse the nominee if I lose. And I think everyone's been trying to rig this thing against
00:38:27.760 me since day one. So sorry, forgive me if I don't exactly trust you guys. I know I'm not going to do
00:38:33.360 that. But because he's leading by 30 points, 40 points in some places, the RNC will look ridiculous if
00:38:39.660 they don't allow him to come to the debate. So where does it all stand and where do the
00:38:44.960 non-Trump candidates stand? We'll get to that in one second. But first, while we're assessing the
00:38:48.720 horse race, the second annual Daily Wire Fantasy Football Draft Party is coming up soon. And this
00:38:54.540 year we have a sweepstakes for you to enter to be the 10th member in our league. If you win,
00:39:01.440 you can participate with us during the live draft and go head to head with your favorite Daily Wire
00:39:07.340 host, as well as those other guys who work in this building, throughout the fantasy football
00:39:11.220 season. To enter, go to Crane & Company's YouTube page, subscribe to their channel. Then like the
00:39:17.020 Daily Wire Fantasy Football Sweepstakes video, comment your favorite football team name, and fill out the
00:39:21.420 Google form on the pinned comment. Man, that's a lot of stuff to do. How the hell is anyone supposed to
00:39:25.160 remember that? You can rewind and go through all those instructions again. Don't miss your chance to
00:39:30.320 play fantasy football in your favorite host's league, as well as the league shared by some of my
00:39:36.300 colleagues and compete for ultimate bragging rights and the coveted golden tumbler. The sweepstakes
00:39:43.440 began yesterday, August 16th. They will end August 19th at 11.59 p.m. Eastern. My favorite comment
00:39:51.280 yesterday is from Pandas and Poetry 3486, who says, Catholic here who has struggled with addiction
00:39:56.760 since age 15. Every time I hear you say another cringe word for pot, I feel myself getting closer for
00:40:01.740 sobriety. Closer to sobriety. I'm so pleased that I could be helpful to you. We all play our part in
00:40:09.540 this world. I'm glad that my mention of the devil's lettuce and the sin spinach and the Peruvian parsley
00:40:15.540 and the Colombian cumin and the old Haitian oregano. You know what I'm talking about, man? I'm talking
00:40:21.160 about pot. Talking about marijuana, Mary Jane. Stuff will make you go into your reefer madness. I'm glad
00:40:27.720 that that could help you to overcome some of the struggles that you have. 2024, new poll out from
00:40:35.660 Kaplan. This is the national Republican primary survey. So again, the primary is going to come
00:40:40.900 down to state polls, but still the national stuff tells you something. Trump is at 48%, so 37 points
00:40:47.060 above his next rival. Pretty good place for Trump to be. The next rival, though, is not Ron DeSantis,
00:40:55.460 who had been the number two candidate for the whole race. The next rival, Vivek Ramaswamy,
00:41:02.320 who's at 11%, so not exactly close to 48, but still, that's a major, major victory for Ramaswamy.
00:41:08.960 DeSantis, one point below at 10%. Pence at eight, which is pretty impressive, actually, given Pence's
00:41:14.200 current tensions within the GOP. Pretty impressive that he's at eight. Christie down at four. Haley at
00:41:19.220 four, Scott at two. Burgum, got the Burgum momentum at one. Asa Hutchinson at zero,
00:41:26.080 where he belongs. We're still in silly season, of course. The reason a poll like this matters,
00:41:31.360 though, heading into the debate, which we're not very close to, is because it's going to show you
00:41:37.860 who's got mojo. It's going to affect the momentum going into that debate. Had DeSantis been the clear
00:41:43.560 in a way number two candidate going into the debate, then a lot of the focus would be on him,
00:41:48.140 for better or worse. People might be attacking him, but also he would command a lot of the attention.
00:41:53.540 Now, even if DeSantis is still statistically tied with Vivek, the fact that this guy who came out of
00:42:00.400 nowhere has been able to, according to one poll, actually unseat him as number two, and according
00:42:05.940 to other polls, at least get somewhere up in the same vicinity, that doesn't look as good for
00:42:10.700 DeSantis. And so people are just going to be looking at other candidates, especially if you're
00:42:13.600 a Republican who hates Donald Trump. You're now going to be more open-minded to the other
00:42:18.680 candidates, whereas perhaps previously you might have thought DeSantis is the guy we've all got to
00:42:22.600 rally around. The momentum here really, really matters. Who has got the mojo? Another candidate
00:42:30.760 is popping up. This is in New Hampshire. Chris Christie is now number two in New Hampshire. So he's
00:42:36.800 surpassed Governor DeSantis in New Hampshire. Again, it's statistically tied. Trump is far and
00:42:43.000 away winning. Christie is at 9%. DeSantis is at 8%. Still, this matters because of the mojo and because
00:42:50.280 Christie is going to be in this debate. So if, and by the way, who called it? Who freaking called it?
00:42:56.280 I'm now back on the croissants. I'm now back on the croissants. My gut instinct, I think,
00:43:02.420 may have been right or at least plausible, which is don't sleep on Christie. I don't think the guy's
00:43:08.100 going to be president, but he could have a moment, especially because he's a good debater.
00:43:12.060 Don't forget that moment when he took out Rubio. He's really adept on his feet. And the other
00:43:18.460 candidates on that stage, Vivek is good. I mean, Vivek is pretty quick, quick-witted in that way.
00:43:25.380 And DeSantis is good. DeSantis gives great speeches. I heard DeSantis give a speech at the
00:43:29.560 Claremont Institute once. I thought it was an excellent, excellent speech. I'm not saying the
00:43:32.980 guy can't talk, but compared to the other candidates on this stage, he is not known for
00:43:39.720 his quick responses, his fast little zingers. That's not, he's good at beating up the media
00:43:44.920 and press conferences. He's reasonably good at giving speeches, but that's not where he's going
00:43:49.880 to shine. And so that's why the momentum going into the debate is going to be so important because
00:43:54.800 especially, I'm just looking at the field here, those two guys, Christie and Vivek,
00:43:59.960 they're going to do pretty well. Whether Trump is there or not, they're going to be more impressive
00:44:06.680 on the debate stage, I predict, than probably anyone else. Now, speaking of Christie and Trump
00:44:13.660 in the debate, Joe Scarborough of MSNBC believes that the reason that Trump doesn't want to show up to
00:44:20.060 the debate is because he is afraid of the Chris-a-sons. I do think he's scared of Chris Christie.
00:44:27.880 He saw what Chris Christie did to Marco Rubio when Chris Christie went into a debate with one thing in
00:44:34.120 mind. He knows Chris Christie put Jared Kushner's father in jail for a very long time. He knows he's
00:44:42.460 a prosecutor who's ruthless and knows how to push his case. And he also knows that
00:44:50.640 his secret sauce in 2016 was being the disruptor, right? Shaking Hillary Clinton up on the debate
00:44:59.620 stage, shaking the Marcos and everybody else up on the debate stage. That gig, that's like eight
00:45:06.400 years old, right? That's Elvis in 77 now. And I think Chris Christie's got his number and he knows
00:45:17.100 like Donald Trump, it's got the gut instinct. Obviously, his political gut instinct is second
00:45:23.040 to none. Like he sees it coming. And so I just don't, I think he's scared to death of Chris Christie
00:45:29.880 and will not have the guts to go or the nerve to go on a stage with Chris Christie anywhere.
00:45:38.080 Okay. I don't agree with the second part of that analysis that Trump's shtick is old and nobody likes
00:45:44.960 it anymore. He's Elvis in 77. No, I think he's Elvis in 68 at most, that comeback special. And the
00:45:52.180 proof of that is just look at the polls and look at the rallies and look at his reception. He's just,
00:45:56.020 he's been more dominant in the GOP field than most people predicted, than most of the chattering
00:46:03.460 consulting class, the talking class on the left and on the right predicted. Some of us,
00:46:09.840 some of us may have seen it coming, but, but a lot of people did not. And so I don't think that's
00:46:14.680 true. I don't think that's how Christie could be a danger. I agree with the first part though of what
00:46:18.700 Joe Scarborough is saying. Chris Christie is not to be slept on. That guy could get a zinger in there
00:46:25.240 on Trump. Maybe, maybe let's say the risk is only 10%. If you're Trump and you're up by 37 points,
00:46:33.220 why, why would you take that 10% risk when you have very little to gain and a lot to lose? And
00:46:39.680 frankly, you could even gain more if you can convince voters that the reason you're not showing
00:46:46.640 up to the debate is because the RNC is rigging it against you. If you, and this is a more difficult
00:46:51.740 case to make, but if the Trump campaign can successfully convince voters that the loyalty
00:46:57.600 pledge is just a way to further rig the primary against Donald Trump, then by staying out of the
00:47:04.820 debate, he could seem almost like a martyr. Or maybe it doesn't work. Maybe people say he's a coward.
00:47:10.980 Maybe people say he doesn't want to debate. One, I think the ratings will be a lot lower.
00:47:14.120 So not as many people are going to watch it. And do you really think it's going to dislodge
00:47:18.560 a significant chunk of 48% of Republican voters? Well, half the Republican party was going to vote
00:47:25.280 for this guy and we're sticking with him through four indictments and every piece of muck that the
00:47:29.920 establishment has thrown at him for seven years. But he didn't show up to debate Asa Hutchinson. So
00:47:34.560 I'm done with him. I'm done. I'm a Christie man now. No, of course not. So you've got a ton of risk.
00:47:41.560 You've got very little reward. The only way Trump shows up on that debate stage is if he just can't
00:47:46.840 resist the show. You know, it's Theology Thursday, baby. I've got so much more I want to get to. I've
00:47:51.980 got so much to get to. I'm not even going to tease you today. I've been too teasing recently.
00:47:57.600 So the rest of the show continues now. If I don't have my iPad, I'm going to commit acts of violence
00:48:02.660 in this studio. Become a member. Use code Knowles, K-N-W-L-E-S, at checkout for two months free on all annual plans.
00:48:11.560 Have a great day.
00:48:23.500 Bye-bye.
00:48:26.120 Bye.
00:48:28.420 Bye.
00:48:30.560 Bye.
00:48:32.020 Bye.
00:48:34.940 Bye.
00:48:39.080 Bye.