The Michael Knowles Show - June 30, 2026


Ep. 2005 - "I've Never Said This In An Interview Before" | JD Vance On Faith, Iran & AI

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Ep. 2004 - "Temporary" Haitians Own More U.S. Homes Than Zoomers Ep. 2006 - WORST Ruling Ever: The Supreme Court Betrays America

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 6 minutes

Words per minute

182.68

Word count

12,202

Sentence count

822

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

53

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

With war brewing around the world, political breakdown at home, and AI advancements that threaten to upend all of society and even our view of ourselves, I think we re all feeling a little apocalyptic. So joining me to weigh in on all these matters and more is Vice President J.D. Vance.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey there, it's Wayfair here, where delivery and setup are as easy as a few taps on your phone.
00:00:05 You're relaxing in an old hammock, scrolling Wayfair's app, when you spot it, a brand new patio set.
00:00:10 Next thing you know, Wayfair delivers it right to your patio and sets it up.
00:00:14 Oh, you need a new grill too? Alright, Wayfair's got you covered.
00:00:18 With Wayfair's room of choice delivery and fast experts set up on qualifying orders,
00:00:22 life gets a little easier. Visit Wayfair.com or the Wayfair app.
00:00:26 Wayfair, every style, every home.
00:00:28 July is National Grilling Month, and there's no better time to stock up on America's best meat from Good Ranchers.
00:00:34 They source 100% of their meat from American farms and ranches and deliver it straight to your door, making summer grilling easier than ever.
00:00:39 Good Ranchers makes it simple to stock the kitchen with quality American-raised meat, while also supporting the farmers and ranchers keeping American agriculture alive.
00:00:46 Visit GoodRanchers.com to get $50 off your order when you use the code DAILYWIRE.
00:00:51 That's code DAILYWIRE for $50 off, but you can also get free meat with every order on top of the $50 off if you decide to start a plan today.
00:00:58 goodranchers.com. American meat delivered. I love a good conversion story. I don't usually
00:01:04 do interviews on my daily show. I rarely plug politicians' books. But when I heard there was
00:01:11 a new book out on a religious conversion, specifically a conversion to Catholicism,
00:01:17 I could not resist sitting down with the author, who just happens to be the vice president of the
00:01:22 United States, with war brewing around the world, political breakdown at home, especially on the
00:01:27 right, and AI advancements that threaten to upend all of society and even our view of ourselves,
00:01:34 I think we're all feeling a little apocalyptic. So joining me to weigh in on all these matters
00:01:40 and more is Vice President J.D. Vance. I'm Michael Knowles. This is The Michael Knowles Show.
00:01:57 Mr. Vice President, thank you for being here.
00:02:06 It's good to see you. Thanks for having me.
00:02:07 I'm really sorry that we're not in my usual studio.
00:02:10 We're in your town.
00:02:12 That's right.
00:02:12 If we were in my studio, we would be in nice, big, comfortable chairs, maybe with a cigar.
00:02:17 This is a little bit more formal, but I really appreciate the opportunity.
00:02:21 Of course.
00:02:21 Because I've read a lot of political books.
00:02:24 I have a lot of friends who are politicians.
00:02:26 and most of the books are horrible
00:02:28 and I don't even actually read them.
00:02:32 This book, I really, really enjoyed.
00:02:34 It's not flattery at all.
00:02:35 Everyone needs to go out and get Communion by J.D. Vance.
00:02:37 Thank you.
00:02:38 Because this touches on something that I care about
00:02:40 more than Iran and AI and 2028.
00:02:45 We'll get to all of it, which I have to ask about.
00:02:47 But this touches on something I care about a lot more,
00:02:49 which is a religious conversion,
00:02:51 specifically to Catholicism.
00:02:53 And the way that I know that your conversion is sincere is that no American politician in his right mind would ever convert to Catholicism for self-interested reasons.
00:03:05 Yes, yeah.
00:03:05 So I have to ask, one, why did you do it?
00:03:09 And two, you're not the only one.
00:03:12 You are in many ways the kind of voice of the millennials and the Zoomer, older Zoomer generation here.
00:03:18 There's been a big surge in religious reversion and especially to Catholicism.
00:03:23 Why?
00:03:24 We will get to much more with our vice president friend,
00:03:27 but first, you need to go to puretalk.com slash Knowles,
00:03:31 K-N-O-W-L-E-S.
00:03:33 Our spending habits say something about our values.
00:03:36 I want a company that is not just the smart financial choice,
00:03:39 but also aligns with what I believe.
00:03:41 Now, I know you're like me,
00:03:42 and that is why you should switch to veteran-led Pure Talk.
00:03:46 This is a wireless company that champions American work ethic
00:03:49 and favors community over corporations.
00:03:51 Pure Talk has great values and is a notch above the big wireless corporations. From customer
00:03:58 support, reception, data, value, Pure Talk has five stars in every category. You're going to
00:04:02 get the best service available to you, top-notch 5G network on the very best towers, not just
00:04:07 similar, the very best towers for the best price, $34.99 per month from a wonderful company that
00:04:13 supports our veterans, supports our country. You even get great customer service because the people
00:04:19 on the other line speak English. The average family of four is saving $1,000 a year. That
00:04:23 could be a lot of extra money for your 4th of July summer vacation. Head on over right now
00:04:27 to puretalk.com slash Knowles. No service contract, no cancellation fees. puretalk.com
00:04:34 slash Knowles. Make the switch and start championing your values in every area of your life.
00:04:38 puretalk.com slash Knowles to make the switch to Pure Talk, a wireless network that values
00:04:43 what you value. Okay, back to the vice president. Okay. So before, first of all, thank you for
00:04:51 doing this. It's good to see you. Pleasure. I know we had planned to schedule this last week,
00:04:57 I believe, and I had to go to Switzerland. So thank you for being here. I will never forgive
00:05:00 the Iranians for doing that to me, but we're here now. We're the Swiss. But okay, before you get 1.00
00:05:06 into the why Catholicism, I think you have to get into the why Christianity, then not Christianity,
00:05:12 then back to Christianity and then get there.
00:05:14 So let me give like the 90 second summary
00:05:16 of my faith journey from when I was a kid
00:05:19 until I was, you know, 24, 25.
00:05:21 So basically raised in an evangelical household,
00:05:24 raised by my grandmother,
00:05:26 but with like a lot of Pentecostal flavor
00:05:28 from my biological father.
00:05:32 Basically unchurched.
00:05:33 I would go to church with my dad,
00:05:35 my stepmom sometimes,
00:05:36 but mainly it was with my grandma.
00:05:38 We would watch TBN,
00:05:39 we'd watch Paul and Jane Crouch,
00:05:40 we'd watch Billy Graham revivals.
00:05:42 And I realized after my grandmother died, this is when I was 21 years old, maybe 20,
00:05:47 but right before I left for Iraq in 2005, Mamaw died.
00:05:52 And I realized that was my connection to Christianity.
00:05:56 So there was no institutional connection.
00:05:58 That's sort of one of the subtexts of the book is trying to raise my own kids in a more
00:06:02 institutional faith and the hope that it takes in a way that I didn't.
00:06:06 Because two years after my grandmother was dead, I called myself an atheist.
00:06:10 Yeah.
00:06:11 Yeah.
00:06:11 Okay. So I'm an atheist. I become, and maybe I always was a striver. I'm obsessed with
00:06:17 achievement for achievement's sake. Really, Mr. Vice President? Shocked to hear it.
00:06:23 Yeah. And I get to law school and I'm at Yale. And I realized that I've like won all these
00:06:29 competitions, the meritocratic competitions that life had told me to win, but I found them deeply
00:06:34 unfulfilling. And frankly, I found that I was becoming a shitty person in the process or a
00:06:38 bad person, excuse me, if you have to edit that out. I don't know. What are the rules?
00:06:40 We never go blue on this show. We make exceptions for top government officials.
00:06:44 Okay. I have terrible language as I talk about in the book. It's one of my many non-Christian
00:06:49 or one of my many traits I have to work on as a Christian. Okay. So I am at law school.
00:06:58 I'm doing very well in sort of all the worldly things. I'm doing not so well in the non-worldly
00:07:03 things. I fall in love. That woman is now the second lady and soon to be mother of four
00:07:09 Vance children, currently the mother of three Vance children. And I sort of realized like
00:07:13 everything I've geared my life towards over the last few years is hollow. But this person that
00:07:18 I'm in love with, she really wants me to be a good husband, eventually a good father. She wants
00:07:23 me to care about virtue, being a good human being and like the deepest sense of the word.
00:07:28 And I kept on returning to this idea that the elites who fashion themselves hyper-rational,
00:07:34 They didn't believe in superstitious things
00:07:36 like Jesus Christ is the son of God.
00:07:38 They were the ones who seemed to be
00:07:40 the less focused on what mattered,
00:07:42 the least focused on what mattered. 1.00
00:07:43 And meanwhile, it was all these sort of bumpkins 0.98
00:07:45 that I dismissed as sub-rational, as superstitious, 0.92
00:07:49 who seemed to have things figured out in a much deeper way. 0.51
00:07:51 So that leads me down the pathway back to Christianity. 0.64
00:07:55 And I think that was almost 90 seconds, 0.85
00:07:56 maybe a little bit longer.
00:07:58 But okay, then it's like,
00:08:00 how do you become a Christian in this world?
00:08:04 And there were all of these things that attracted me to Catholicism.
00:08:09 So, number one, I really liked the sense that it was institutionally stable, okay?
00:08:15 And again, going back to my unchurched upbringing, when things were going well in my religious life,
00:08:25 it was very much attached to, like, a single individual, whether it was my grandmother or a pastor,
00:08:30 and sometimes the pastors would come and go.
00:08:32 I was really attracted to the idea that like in this church, the mass was more or less the same,
00:08:38 whether you were on vacation in some faraway country or whether you were in suburban Cincinnati.
00:08:42 But I also like doctrinally that, you know, like things didn't change based on who the person
00:08:49 giving the homily was. And that sense of stability, the idea that Christian doctrine
00:08:55 was fundamentally founded on Jesus Christ
00:08:58 and the church beyond that,
00:09:01 that if it really is founded on Jesus Christ,
00:09:04 it shouldn't change.
00:09:06 Now, of course, it's going to have to apply itself
00:09:07 to new circumstances.
00:09:08 When Jesus Christ died and rose from the dead,
00:09:11 we didn't have automobiles.
00:09:12 We didn't have modern narcotics.
00:09:15 We didn't have a lot of the things
00:09:16 that they were dealing with at the time.
00:09:18 But the principle is fundamentally immovable.
00:09:22 And then there's an open question
00:09:24 about how you apply the principle to new things.
00:09:26 And then the final thing I'd say is,
00:09:28 and then we can, I'm sure, go into the details.
00:09:31 I'm trying to summarize this very quickly
00:09:32 because I know we only have an hour.
00:09:34 But there is something about the connection
00:09:39 between the past, the present, and the future
00:09:43 that I really liked about the Catholic Church.
00:09:47 This idea that you had your role to play,
00:09:50 whether it was a big role or a small role
00:09:52 in the life of the church,
00:09:53 you were inheriting that from thousands of years of history and you would eventually die and
00:09:59 hopefully be rejoined with the Lord and you would pass on that legacy to some other person who would
00:10:05 then carry it on after you. That continuity across the generations I found very very attractive and
00:10:10 one of the things I write about in the book is that sort of one of these existential fears that
00:10:14 animate me I've never been particularly afraid of dying you know it's funny when we had this sort
00:10:20 of situation at the, what, the Willard Hotel, or no, we're in the Willard Hotel right now.
00:10:25 Currently.
00:10:25 Where was the White House Correspondents Association dinner? Anyway, there was the
00:10:29 assassination.
00:10:29 It was at the Hilton, maybe?
00:10:31 Yeah, wherever it was. And it was obviously focused on the president, but, you know,
00:10:34 you hear loud noises, and then the guys with the machine guns run in, and you're kind of like,
00:10:37 oh, something kind of crazy is going on. I just, I don't, the idea of dying doesn't really scare
00:10:44 me. It's never scared me, whether as an atheist or as a Christian. And I talk about that a little
00:10:48 bit in the book, communion, you should buy it, that I've always been somewhat troubled by that
00:10:55 because if you think potentially hell is waiting you on the other end, shouldn't you be really
00:10:59 afraid of it? But I've just never been afraid of dying. What I have been afraid of, and there's
00:11:05 this existential dread that kind of animates me, we haven't gotten into this in any of the
00:11:08 interviews that I've done, but I guess we can get into it here, is this idea that the continuity
00:11:16 across generations is going to stop with us.
00:11:19 That we inherited something
00:11:20 and instead of building upon it and passing it on,
00:11:23 it's just going to die with us.
00:11:25 You see it decay.
00:11:25 That feeling of decay and of stasis
00:11:29 rather than dynamism and growth. 0.98
00:11:32 And that, I felt like the Catholicism's continuity
00:11:37 was in some ways an antidote to that 0.98
00:11:40 because it's, you know, yeah,
00:11:42 there are certainly things you can look at our world.
00:11:44 I think there are things you can look at
00:11:46 be very hopeful about. There are things you can look at in our modern world and be very despairing
00:11:49 about. But if you look at the long history of the Christian faith, it's very hard not to say
00:11:56 that many, many other people in many, many generations past had it far worse than we did. 1.00
00:12:01 Yes.
00:12:01 And that gives me a certain sense of, okay, like maybe we should stop whining and try to build
00:12:07 something rather than just complain about how bad things are for us right now.
00:12:10 Right. It is, the church is the only institution from antiquity that has survived in the West
00:12:16 all the time. So I totally get it. And I feel that anxiety. It bothers me whether we're talking
00:12:22 about a restaurant or we're talking about a monument in Washington, D.C. It bothers me to
00:12:26 see it get dirtier and fall apart and be neglected even in the minds of people. Absolutely. Yeah, I
00:12:31 feel that same anxiety. And even your story of you come from modest means, you end up at Yale,
00:12:39 You become much more conservative and Christian, I guess, as a result of that.
00:12:43 Lose a maternal figure and come to the faith in a large way through intellectual figures.
00:12:50 It resonates.
00:12:52 Sure.
00:12:52 I get what you're talking about.
00:12:53 Yeah.
00:12:53 In the book, you talk about a few of those figures in particular.
00:12:57 Augustine, Aquinas, Rene Girard.
00:13:00 Yeah.
00:13:00 The 20th century Catholic writer.
00:13:02 Sure. 0.80
00:13:03 About mimetic desire.
00:13:05 Yes, preach.
00:13:07 I love it.
00:13:08 this then leads me to wonder after you were brought back to the faith in no small part
00:13:15 through the intellect thinking of the decline of civilization thinking about these great writers
00:13:19 thinking about the doctrines and parsing just differences between them yep did you have any
00:13:24 religious experience what c.s lewis would call the numinous experience did you ever see a ghost
00:13:29 kind of thing um you know never never quite saw a ghost but definitely and you know one of the
00:13:33 things I talk about in the book, and this is something I'm still very much working on,
00:13:38 is when I returned to the faith, one of the things that had just degraded during my
00:13:44 many years of not being religious at all was my ability to pray. And so, I remember distinctively,
00:13:50 you know, 14, 15, 16, like talking to God and being able to talk to God in this very natural
00:13:56 way. And then I start returning to the faith and I go to pray and I'm not exactly sure what to say.
00:14:02 And there's this interesting way in which just that prayer muscle had kind of atrophied.
00:14:07 It's come back.
00:14:08 I don't know that it's come back all the way.
00:14:10 But one of the things, again, I really liked about the sort of the ancient Christian canon
00:14:14 was all of these prayers that were just, you say the prayer, right?
00:14:19 Of course, the most important is the Lord's Prayer.
00:14:21 There's the glory be, glory be to the Father, to the Son, and to the Holy Spirit.
00:14:25 And you sort of go through these prayers.
00:14:28 And I found that that inner conversation with God was a very good part of just getting me back into the ritual practice of prayer again.
00:14:38 And so, yeah, Augustine was fascinating.
00:14:42 Aquinas was fascinating.
00:14:43 Gerard was particularly fascinating to me.
00:14:45 But the faith can't just be something that you think about.
00:14:49 It has to be something that you practice, and it has to be something that you feel.
00:14:52 And that was very much, again, something that was part of my own faith journey I write about in the book.
00:14:58 um but the the interesting thing so there's this quote from pulp fiction i keep returning to
00:15:06 which is i'm going to butcher a little bit but it's right after you know samuel jackson and
00:15:11 john travolta these gangsters just murder a few people and then but they they miss one guy and
00:15:17 that guy's like hiding in the bathroom so he pops out and he shoots at point blank range samuel
00:15:22 jackson is totally fine right despite the fact that multiple bullets should have hit him and he
00:15:27 kind of looks around. He kills the guy who tried to shoot him. And then he has this religious 0.98
00:15:31 sort of epiphany. And that's really the entire movie from his perspective is this
00:15:35 ongoing religious journey. Now, what's fascinating about it is he talks about miracles. And there's
00:15:42 this debate between him and John Travolta about whether this counts as a miracle. And he says,
00:15:45 look, what matters is not whether this is an according to Hoyle miracle. What matters is
00:15:50 that I felt the touch of God. And just two things sitting here right now, when I think about like
00:15:57 feeling the touch of God. Okay. One of which I didn't even write about in the book. It just
00:16:01 occurred to me now, but I'm going to tell it to you. The first one, and I guess he's out of himself
00:16:06 now. This is Ross Douthat and I. We're having a conversation. This is in 2019, probably. And,
00:16:13 you know, he at the time was one of the foremost conservative critics of Pope Francis.
00:16:18 And my view of the papacy is, you know, it's, you don't treat it like you're a congressional
00:16:24 representative. It's not a political office. Obviously, you can have pragmatic disagreements,
00:16:30 but you should have a little respect for it as a practicing Catholic.
00:16:34 Yes.
00:16:34 Okay. And so, Ross and I were going back and forth about whether he was properly differential,
00:16:39 even to this person who was clearly not aligned with American conservatives on a whole host of
00:16:45 issues.
00:16:45 A very diplomatic way to put it.
00:16:46 Yeah, yeah. So, we're at a conference. We're having this argument. We're in the basement
00:16:51 of this hotel. There's a kind of an open bar that's been set out for us. And we're drinking
00:16:57 too much and talking about Catholicism and talking about the Pope. And I make this kind of really
00:17:02 strident argument about the papacy. And even talking about it, it sounds insane, but there's
00:17:10 like a wine glass back behind the bar. And it's not like we're in southeastern Ohio. It's not
00:17:15 like there was an earthquake. Just kind of one glass kind of jumps off and shatters on the ground
00:17:21 in the middle of this conversation,
00:17:23 and both Ross and I had this sort of moment
00:17:25 where like, oh, that was really weird.
00:17:27 Yeah.
00:17:27 And again, is it an according to Hoyle miracle?
00:17:31 Maybe, maybe not, but I felt the touch of God.
00:17:33 Maybe.
00:17:33 If a guy can rise from the dead,
00:17:36 a glass can fall off a shelf.
00:17:37 Absolutely, absolutely.
00:17:38 So that felt like a very powerful moment. 0.99
00:17:42 I'll give you another just very stupid moment, 1.00
00:17:45 but not stupid. 1.00
00:17:46 It's disrespectful to God. 1.00
00:17:48 Providential.
00:17:49 Providential.
00:17:49 but okay i i so there's a church in cincinnati that uh does really early confessions on either
00:17:59 saturday or sunday okay it's um it's it's it's in the oakley neighborhood of cincinnati saint
00:18:05 cecilia's church okay and they would always do really early confessions i think on sunday
00:18:10 so like you know if i hadn't gone to confession a couple months i always wake up really early but
00:18:15 you had to be there by like 7 a.m. or something, okay?
00:18:17 So I'd get in my minivan and I'd go to confession
00:18:20 before the kids were even awake on a Sunday morning.
00:18:23 Okay, I remember one time distinctively being like,
00:18:26 you know, if you weren't in line by 7.15
00:18:28 or sort of you kind of missed your window,
00:18:30 I remember distinctively like I woke up at 7.02
00:18:33 later than I normally wake up.
00:18:35 And I'm like, there's no way I can make it
00:18:37 to St. Cecilia's Church.
00:18:38 But I just felt this little voice like,
00:18:40 go and try to make it.
00:18:41 Maybe the line will be extra long.
00:18:42 Maybe you'll get it at the very end.
00:18:44 and the ride from my house to St. Cecilia's
00:18:47 is probably a 15-minute drive.
00:18:49 I got there in like eight minutes
00:18:51 because every single red light was green.
00:18:56 And like, again, maybe every red light was green.
00:19:00 Maybe it was just a coincidence of the universe,
00:19:02 but I felt the touch of God.
00:19:04 I got in line in time and just little things like that.
00:19:08 You know, my attitude on this is,
00:19:10 I've talked to buddies about this,
00:19:12 some of whom are still very, very atheist and very non-religious is like, I really do think
00:19:17 that there are these moments where God speaks to all of us. You just have to be trying to listen
00:19:22 a little bit. And yeah, you know, every few months I'll have a little moment like that where it's
00:19:28 like, huh, that was kind of weird. Like what are the odds that the 25 traffic lights from my house
00:19:35 to St. Cecilia's, maybe it's only a dozen, but there are a lot of them that all of them would
00:19:40 be green in such a way that made it possible for me to get there very quickly. Right. Right. Anyway.
00:19:46 We will get to much, much more with the vice president. First though, you need to get to
00:19:51 angel.com slash Knowles. The story of George Washington did not begin at Valley Forge or
00:19:56 Yorktown. It began decades earlier with a 20 year old facing failure, surviving near death and being
00:20:02 shaped by providence into the man who had found the greatest nation in human history. Young
00:20:07 Washington tells that story, directed by John Irwin, starring Andy Serkis, Ben Kingsley, and
00:20:12 the great, the greatest Kelsey Grammer. No revisionism, no rewriting, just the truth of
00:20:19 who Washington was and what God had planned for him. March into theaters July 4th. Help make it
00:20:25 the number one movie in America. Here is the smart move. Do not pay 30 bucks at the box office.
00:20:31 A premium Angel Guild membership costs just 15 bucks a month, 25% off, locked in for 12 months,
00:20:36 two free tickets to Young Washington, every future Angel release. This is really, really
00:20:40 good stuff. Join the Angel Guild today. Go to angel.com slash Knowles. Take advantage of our
00:20:45 special offer and become a premium member for the lowest price of the season. Two free tickets to
00:20:50 see Young Washington in theaters this Independence Day. Be part of making this film the number one
00:20:54 movie in America for our nation's 250th birthday. I've noticed this, you mentioned confession about
00:20:59 the state of grace. Yeah. And something about the state of grace that's really nice is the priest
00:21:04 cuts all the demons off you, and so your life is better. But the other thing, just about your
00:21:08 perception, it seems to me that all those little signs, you know, the Christian view of the world 0.75
00:21:13 is a deeply semiotic view. Nothing is merely what it seems, you know, everything means something.
00:21:19 St. Thomas Aquinas begins the Summa Theologiae with that observation. And in the state of grace,
00:21:24 you kind of see it a little bit more, I think. But on the flip side, when you're in a real state
00:21:30 of sin, you know, Dante trying to walk up the mountain, sometimes then God, he doesn't just
00:21:35 whisper at you. Sometimes he shakes you and says, hey, idiot, you know, pay attention. Why aren't you? 1.00
00:21:40 And so I think, yes, if you go into a room, even of these liberal elites that you assail in the
00:21:45 book, that rightly assail, you go into a room and you say, do you believe in God? No. Do you
00:21:50 believe in miracles? No. Do you believe in this, that? No. But if you ask them something as silly
00:21:55 is, have you ever seen a ghost? A lot of them will say yes. We all kind of know that there's
00:22:00 meaning in the world. So then on this point, of all, you go to these very liberal institutions.
00:22:05 Can I make an observation just about that? Okay. One of the really interesting things about
00:22:10 just the secular, hyper-progressive, hyper-liberal age that we live in
00:22:16 is you realize how many of the rituals and institutions and practices of Catholicism
00:22:24 show up in the modern world completely divorced from the God part and the grace part of it.
00:22:31 Okay. So we're thankfully, thanks to Donald Trump, I would say, we're past the point where most
00:22:39 people, at least that I see, hang out those hideous signs in their yard that say, in this
00:22:45 house, we believe, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. You know, love is love. Water is people, whatever.
00:22:50 No person is illegal.
00:22:52 Okay.
00:22:52 So that sign is like such a disgusting butchering of the Nicene Creed.
00:23:01 And when you realize, you're like, oh my God,
00:23:03 people still have this desire to profess, to do it very publicly.
00:23:09 And even to do it in this kind of cadence that you see in the Nicene Creed.
00:23:14 And of course, they do it in this very politically motivated way.
00:23:19 Confession.
00:23:20 is another thing, it's, like, I find, as a, you know, Protestant, I find confession deeply
00:23:27 uncomfortable. I still do. Ditto, and I'm a cradle cat, you know? But it's just, like,
00:23:34 the craziest ritual. You're going to go in this, you know, tiny booth and sit there with a total
00:23:38 stranger and tell them about every terrible thing you've done over the last couple of months. It's
00:23:41 nuts. But what, if you think about it, it is so similar to the ritual of modern therapy.
00:23:50 Of course.
00:23:51 And, but minus the guilt and forgiveness. Like the thing that's, that's, that's, you know,
00:23:57 I talk about the liberation of guilt.
00:23:59 Ah, guilt too. Yes.
00:24:00 Because there's, there's actually, you know, I've always heard this phrase,
00:24:03 Christian guilt or Catholic guilt, as if it's terrible to feel guilty when you do something
00:24:06 bad, but sometimes if I'm impatient with my kid, for example, it's kind of a good thing to feel
00:24:12 guilty, to feel like there's an inner voice telling you to be a better human being, a better father,
00:24:17 a better husband. So then you go and talk to somebody about it, but not in this like, oh,
00:24:22 you know, maybe I yelled at my kid because, you know, my mom yelled at me when I was nine years
00:24:27 old and I never dealt with the unresolved trauma of it. No, maybe that there's certainly an element.
00:24:33 And I do believe that everybody's,
00:24:35 the demons of everyone's past
00:24:36 continue to follow them around.
00:24:38 I write about this concept in the book.
00:24:40 But maybe the reason that, you know,
00:24:43 you weren't super patient with your kid
00:24:44 is just that you're a flawed human being 1.00
00:24:46 and you screwed up. 1.00
00:24:48 And there's nothing wrong with saying,
00:24:49 I screwed up, I should feel bad about it,
00:24:51 and I should make amends.
00:24:53 And I think that sort of,
00:24:55 that seems to me is a much healthier,
00:24:57 but also much truer to human nature way
00:25:00 to think about misconduct and right and wrong.
00:25:02 Yeah, of course. I have a buddy, actually, who put a sign in his yard with the same font
00:25:07 and says, in this house, we believe in God, the Father Almighty.
00:25:10 That's great.
00:25:11 That's brilliant.
00:25:12 Yeah, you see all of it. I mean, the transgender transition, which is, you know,
00:25:16 they refer to the past as a dead name. I mean, that is a kind of a secular baptism.
00:25:20 That's right.
00:25:20 You see all of these echoes. So, look, I guess that gets to the first point, which is,
00:25:24 why are these young people converting, especially to more liturgical, traditional,
00:25:27 especially Catholic religion? Well, because it has the real version of the things that
00:25:32 they're seeking in the world. Okay, I get that. In harder politics and policy, you're at all of
00:25:38 these liberal institutions, Yale Law School especially, but elsewhere, traipsing around
00:25:44 rich businesses and all the rest. And the one thing that everyone agrees on is meritocracy.
00:25:54 Now, you have two, probably my two favorite chapters of the book. One is pulling from
00:25:58 Pope Leo XIII's encyclical, Rerum Novarum, you call it of new things. The other one is
00:26:03 borrowing from Thomas Carlyle's mockery of economics as the dismal science. And these
00:26:08 are my two favorite chapters of the book. I was arguing with a colleague of mine. He's a friend
00:26:13 and a colleague. I won't say his name. He speaks very quickly, doesn't eat shellfish. I'm not going
00:26:18 to say a very famous podcaster, but we were arguing about this because I love this perspective
00:26:23 of the Catholic social teaching, the critique of meritocracy, the mockery of economics,
00:26:29 which Edmund Burke starts modern conservatism with, mocking the economists,
00:26:33 sophisters, and calculators who have destroyed Western civilization.
00:26:36 But what you write is total heresy and blasphemy compared to the last 30 to 60 years of American
00:26:45 conservatism.
00:26:45 The one thing, no matter what we all disagree on, everyone agreed meritocracy is good,
00:26:50 and that's what the left gets wrong
00:26:53 and that we need to double down on meritocracy.
00:26:54 You say it stinks.
00:26:56 Why?
00:26:57 Well, I think a couple of things.
00:26:58 I mean, first of all,
00:26:59 I think that,
00:27:01 yeah, I think Aristotle once said
00:27:03 that virtue lies in the mean.
00:27:05 And like any sort of,
00:27:07 there's like the vice
00:27:08 and the virtue version of anything.
00:27:10 I don't think ambition is bad.
00:27:12 In fact, I think that if you're ambitious
00:27:14 because you want to build,
00:27:16 you know, a rocket that goes to the moon,
00:27:19 right?
00:27:19 we couldn't have gotten the moon were it not for that kind of ambition. Or if your ambition is to
00:27:24 build a building that a lot of people live in, that provides comfort and so forth, I think that's
00:27:28 good. But I think what we've allowed in our modern society, what meritocracy has done is warped it
00:27:34 into ambition for ambition's sake. Ambition not to build something beautiful, but to get ahead of
00:27:38 other people. Ambition not to make an amazing product, but ambition to make a lot of money
00:27:43 for money's sake. And I think that we've allowed that basic human desire to achieve great and
00:27:49 beautiful things to be warped into a vice of just being better than other people. And I think that
00:27:55 is sort of what Christian teaching is counseling us against. It's okay that God makes us all
00:28:02 creatures big and small. Some of us he makes to be ambitious. I'm certainly an ambitious person.
00:28:07 I'm the vice president of the United States. I think he makes some people who just want more
00:28:11 normal things out of life. They want a nice job and they want to provide their kids with nice
00:28:15 things. And that's good too. I think that when it becomes warping and disorienting is when it
00:28:22 becomes ambition for ambition's sake. And what the meritocracy, I think the modern meritocracy
00:28:27 in 21st century America has done is taught people to want to be better than everyone else.
00:28:33 And I think it has two really, really big problems. First of all, if you're orienting 1.00
00:28:37 yourself not to some objective truth, but to how other people are performing and behaving,
00:28:43 you're not your own person and you're certainly not God's person. You're fundamentally following
00:28:48 the crowd. This is like an insight from Rene Girard. So at some level, meritocracy is
00:28:52 fundamentally derivative of other people. That's a bad thing. The second thing is that I actually
00:29:00 think that it, I don't know how to put this, but I think that meritocracy can steal from us
00:29:08 a sense of what really, really matters. And you saw this at Yale Law School. You see it in any
00:29:14 elite institution. You don't see people bragging about their kids in the same way they brag about
00:29:20 their jobs. You don't see people bragging about their relationships as you do the same way they
00:29:25 brag about their credentials. And so one of the core lessons of my life is that the most valuable
00:29:31 thing I got out of law school was friendships, particularly the relationship with the woman
00:29:35 who's now my wife. Those things matter fundamentally way more. Nobody is on their deathbed and looks
00:29:42 back and says, this is like the most trite cliche in the world because it's true. Nobody looks back 1.00
00:29:48 and says, I wish that I had spent less time with my son so that my net worth was a thousand dollars
00:29:53 higher. No one thinks that. And yet meritocracy trains people to think exactly that when they're
00:29:59 in the point of their life when those decisions are made. It's also like the definition of cynicism,
00:30:04 which knows the price of everything and the value of nothing. And your telling of these
00:30:09 conversations at Yale Law School is, you know, you don't just hear it at Yale Law School. You
00:30:14 hear it throughout our culture. And they just tell you that all that matters is slaving away,
00:30:18 doing spreadsheets for Mr. McGillicuddy at the widget factory to drive up GDP. And so then,
00:30:23 And there's a liberation in it.
00:30:25 I mean, the craziest conversation that I had, conversations that I had at Yale Law School
00:30:31 was people who counted themselves as feminists, which, you know, to take like the positive
00:30:39 spin on feminism, it would be that women should have the same rights as men. 1.00
00:30:43 And yet they define success and achievement as spending as much time in a cubicle at Goldman
00:30:50 Sachs, I mean, it's enough to make somebody a Marxist and say, you have like totally internalized
00:30:56 a set of ideas that is completely opposed to your well-being as a human being. Like if you think
00:31:04 that it is liberating for you to sit in a cubicle at Goldman Sachs, you have been had.
00:31:10 Yes.
00:31:10 And we all got to just admit that before we can make any progress as a civilization.
00:31:14 No, I mean, this is really, on the point about Catholic social teaching, this is the point of Rerum Novarum and Pope Leo XIII.
00:31:22 He said, hold on, communism, totally awful, terrible, you can't be Catholic and communist.
00:31:27 Every pope since has basically said that.
00:31:29 But also, we're not ideological laissez-faire capitalists who think we need to send our kids to the coal mines.
00:31:35 You know, we have to put these things in their proper order.
00:31:37 So then my question for you is, there's been a massive restructuring of what conservatism means.
00:31:45 President Trump led a lot of that.
00:31:47 So looking ahead, you are the heir apparent now.
00:31:50 Whether you like it or not, you are.
00:31:52 So looking ahead to 2028 and beyond, if there's this thing going on even beyond you,
00:31:57 this restructuring of what it means to be a conservative,
00:32:00 then if it's not creative destruction, tax cuts for wealthy people exclusively,
00:32:06 and, I don't know, just like GDP ticking up.
00:32:11 Yeah.
00:32:13 What is it?
00:32:14 Well, first of all, I think that people need to appreciate
00:32:17 how fully they lost the argument,
00:32:20 so to the point that they've really moved the goalposts.
00:32:23 I mean, if you remember when Donald Trump ran for president the first time,
00:32:26 the idea of tariffs on imported goods was a heresy in the GOP.
00:32:32 It is now the baseline position
00:32:34 that virtually every Republican politician adopts 1.00
00:32:37 is like, of course, we shouldn't let foreign countries 1.00
00:32:40 like prey on American workers 0.94
00:32:42 and prey on American industries. 0.77
00:32:43 Immigration restriction? 0.69
00:32:44 Immigration restriction.
00:32:45 Again, there is, obviously, 1.00
00:32:47 there's a cultural and crime and law and order element to it,
00:32:49 but there's also a very powerful economic argument 1.00
00:32:51 that we don't want to let the wages of immigrants
00:32:53 undercut the wages of Native American workers.
00:32:55 Again, that is just boilerplate at this point in the GOP.
00:32:59 And I mean, even things like
00:33:00 when the president said a few weeks ago
00:33:03 that, you know, yeah, he absolutely wanted to, like,
00:33:06 seize the equity of the AI companies.
00:33:10 And, you know, it's like, shh, you're not supposed to say that.
00:33:14 And it's like, guys, he's the president, and he sets the agenda,
00:33:17 and he just said it.
00:33:18 And by the way, nobody really even protested.
00:33:20 So, like, the president has already,
00:33:23 and obviously I'm biased, I'm his vice president,
00:33:25 but the president has already, like, completely reoriented the conversation
00:33:29 towards what you might call an American developmentalist,
00:33:33 approach. Like American economic policy on the right is now much more Alexander Hamilton than
00:33:40 it is Milton Friedman. I think that's obviously a good thing. You might disagree, but that's just
00:33:45 a normative statement. Notice though what you've just said, because for the people who say that
00:33:49 betraying some nostalgic retconning of a caricature of the 1980s, that to change that in
00:33:58 any way would be abandoning American history and the tradition. You say, well, hold on. I just went
00:34:02 from Milton Friedman to Hamilton.
00:34:04 And to some degree, George Washington.
00:34:05 Right, 200 years backwards in history, actually.
00:34:07 That's very much a foundation
00:34:08 of American developmental economics and economic policy.
00:34:13 And I do think, you know,
00:34:16 I don't want to say you can go back to the future
00:34:19 or, you know, forward to the past,
00:34:22 but I do think fundamentally
00:34:24 that Hamiltonian tradition
00:34:27 is going to be what we see on the American right
00:34:29 and will dominate American conservative economic thinking
00:34:32 for the future, which is not laissez-faire. It's actually much more about, you know, building
00:34:38 the kind of tools, building the kind of infrastructure that allow human beings to
00:34:43 flourish, that allow national and native industries to flourish at the expense of a
00:34:49 hyper-globalized economy. And I think those are the basic principles that are going to carry us
00:34:53 into the future. But to me, it's fundamentally about the dignity of the human person. The
00:34:59 economy is a tool to service the dignity of the human person. If a set of economic policies make
00:35:05 it easier for a person to raise a family, to earn a living wage, to give back to their community,
00:35:12 to maybe go to church on Sunday, or to actually spend some leisure time building the kind of life
00:35:18 that matters, like that is the sort of thing that we want to be supportive of. Now, obviously,
00:35:22 to do those things, you do need economic development. But if you turn economic development
00:35:28 into a sort of idol,
00:35:30 then you end up sacrificing
00:35:31 a lot of the things that matter most.
00:35:33 And I do think that, you know,
00:35:34 for our friends who are sort of
00:35:35 on the more laissez-faire side
00:35:37 of the American right,
00:35:39 in hindsight,
00:35:40 part of why Milton Friedman's ideas
00:35:43 made more sense in the 1980s
00:35:46 is because they were being advocated
00:35:48 in a country that still had
00:35:50 a very rich and powerful
00:35:53 institutional Christianity. 0.88
00:35:55 And so, like, being laissez-faire 0.95
00:35:58 in a world where there are Christian guardrails on everything 0.97
00:36:02 is a much different proposition 0.99
00:36:04 than being laissez-faire in a world
00:36:06 where globalized liberalism has become
00:36:09 the sort of status quo of American elites.
00:36:12 Of course, because so much of that liberalism,
00:36:15 classical variety or more modern variety,
00:36:18 it is resting upon a foundation that it did not create,
00:36:22 and a foundation that it in many ways weakens.
00:36:25 So obviously we're-
00:36:26 I think that's exactly right.
00:36:27 I think you could say that about, you know, I have a British friend who has been in British conservative politics for longer than I have, maybe longer than I've been alive.
00:36:37 He's, you know, on the older side of things.
00:36:39 And he was making this observation about Margaret Thatcher to another British conservative who was just scandalized by it, but couldn't push back against it in anything besides an emotional way.
00:36:50 said, you know, Margaret Thatcher, an amazing human being, like a true giant in the history
00:36:56 of Western politics. But like fundamentally, Margaret Thatcher was trying to preserve
00:37:02 the shop and the community around the shop that her father had when she was a little girl.
00:37:08 And yet, if you look at modern Britain and the result of Margaret Thatcher's policies,
00:37:13 you would say that her policies actually got Britain further away from that ideal and not
00:37:18 closer to that ideal. That's not, by the way, criticizing her. I think she was trying out
00:37:22 something in a very new era, in a situation where things were quite broken. But we have to be honest,
00:37:29 like what worked and what didn't work. And I think, unfortunately, I would say
00:37:33 Thatcher's politics and a lot of 20th century conservative politics was, it sort of bought
00:37:41 the premises of modern liberalism and was not infused enough with the basic Christian underpinning
00:37:47 of the West. Yeah, Ayn Rand is not going to save your culture. It's not going to happen. So then
00:37:51 we're throwing around all these names, all of our good dead friends. Five figures off the top of
00:37:57 your head. Thinkers, intellectuals, or statesmen, perhaps. Okay. On that cliffhanger, we will get
00:38:05 back to the vice president. But first, you need to go to leafilter.com slash Knowles, K-N-O-W-L-E-S.
00:38:12 One of the most expensive habits people have is trying to save money. Not all the time,
00:38:16 but when it comes to buying cheap versions of things that actually matter, everyone does it.
00:38:20 You buy the knockoff phone charger. Sweet little Lisa was talking about this the other day.
00:38:24 You buy whatever it is, the bargain power tool, the very suspiciously affordable version of the
00:38:29 thing you actually wanted. Then for weeks, you convince yourself you're a financial genius.
00:38:33 Then it breaks. Then you buy the big one, the real one, and then you've paid twice. Don't do that.
00:38:37 I've learned over the years, some things are worth doing right the first time. That is especially
00:38:40 true when it comes to protecting your home. Do not cheap out on your gutter guard, okay? Leaf
00:38:46 Filter is not just another gutter guard. It is a trusted name built on more than 20 years of
00:38:52 engineering and over 50 patents. There are a lot of companies that want to claim that they're just
00:38:57 as good as Leaf Filter. You've heard of Leaf Filter. This is just as good. You can save a
00:39:01 little money though. No, you ain't going to save any money. You want to get what is already a
00:39:05 terrific deal for the real thing. Start protecting your home today with Leaf Filter, America's number
00:39:10 one gutter protection system. Schedule your free inspection at leaffilter.com slash Knowles up to
00:39:15 35% off at leaffilter.com slash Knowles. Minimum purchase required restrictions apply. See
00:39:19 representative for warranty and promotion details. The grill is shot. The chairs are held together by
00:39:25 optimism. And what happened to the rug? Sounds like your outdoor setup is not ready for patio
00:39:30 season. Fix it all with Wayfair. Shop Wayfair for grills, rugs, furniture, and more. With 20 million
00:39:37 five-star reviews, room of choice delivery, and expert setup on qualifying orders, it's never
00:39:43 been easier to do more for less. Get 10% off your first eligible purchase. Hurry to Wayfair.com or
00:39:49 download the app now. I'm not going to say Jesus because that's too easy, but that's obviously
00:39:56 the one and done. I think that's a gimme. That's the center box on bingo. But so the three who I
00:40:03 think have got to be part of this conversation for me are Aquinas, Augustine, and René Girard.
00:40:10 I talk about the three of them. And all of them in different ways, but very, very influential
00:40:16 to my own thinking on these topics. So I probably honestly would put Alexander Hamilton in there,
00:40:28 Or maybe the French economist, I always forget his name, who basically provided a lot of like
00:40:34 the developmental influences to Alexander Hamilton. In some ways, Hamilton was just
00:40:38 applying this guy's ideas. I will get you the name and you can tell your audience later.
00:40:44 And then if I had to pick a fifth name, it's...
00:40:49 see this is what's
00:40:56 this is what's very hard
00:40:57 about this question
00:40:58 but
00:40:59 I
00:41:00 I might actually say
00:41:03 again
00:41:06 not Frank Meyer
00:41:10 but the Catholic 0.71
00:41:11 who was pushing back
00:41:13 against Frank Meyer
00:41:13 well Meyer converted
00:41:14 in the end
00:41:15 he did convert
00:41:16 in the end
00:41:16 I'm talking about his
00:41:17 his interlocutor
00:41:18 I can't remember
00:41:19 his name but he had such uh brent bozell brent bozell brent bozell yeah great answer but like
00:41:25 who ghost wrote conscience of a conservative exactly which is why that book was so good
00:41:28 yeah that's exactly that is a great answer that's a guy yeah i to it one of the unsung heroes of
00:41:34 20th century conservatism he's moderately sung i should say moderately sung hero yeah but i also
00:41:39 think was way ahead of his time yeah was very thoughtful about what was actually going on in
00:41:45 conservative movement at the time. And if you were to look at somebody, you know, one of my mentors
00:41:51 in the investment business once told me like the most valuable thing you can do as an investor,
00:41:57 as a thinker, is to try to identify people who have made discrete predictions about the future
00:42:02 and like lean on the people who have been more right than wrong. Predicting the future is
00:42:08 inherently, as you know, a very, very difficult business. But if you get somebody who's willing
00:42:14 to actually say what they think is going to happen and it's more right than wrong, that's
00:42:19 like a very, very important thinker. And I don't think there's a single person in 1950s
00:42:25 America who was more correct about the future of either the American right or the country
00:42:30 than Bozell.
00:42:31 Great observation. It also reminds me, the only credit I can take on one of these recently
00:42:38 is I called the Pope's name, but it was wish casting. I wasn't predicting it. I just really
00:42:43 wanted it to be Leo. I hope that turns out. Speaking of, in the time I have left with you,
00:42:47 speaking of international affairs, I understand there's some conflict going on somewhere in the
00:42:52 Middle East. The reason that we couldn't do this interview a couple of weeks ago.
00:42:57 You're obviously in this 27 hours a day. Correct. By my understanding, tell me if I have this wrong.
00:43:03 By my understanding, the president said on Monday, we might get peace talks Tuesday.
00:43:09 Iran immediately comes out and says,
00:43:10 we have not scheduled Peace Talks Tuesday.
00:43:12 Then we're in a ceasefire, but we keep shooting at each other.
00:43:16 Then the Iranians say, we can't get a deal
00:43:18 because Israel keeps firing on Hezbollah in southern Lebanon.
00:43:22 So then Israel and Lebanon get a deal, a peace deal.
00:43:25 But Hezbollah, which works for Iran,
00:43:26 says we are not going to abide by the deal.
00:43:29 And then the Strait of Hormuz is open,
00:43:30 but some people say it's closed.
00:43:32 And it's not told, but then the Iranians say there are tolls,
00:43:35 along with Oman, which we didn't even bring up Oman yet.
00:43:38 And so I guess it seems to me, in my layman's understanding, the structural issues preventing peace are all the same as they've been for about 10,000 years.
00:43:50 So now, as we're looking at Schrodinger's Strait of Hormuz or the whole conflict generally, what structurally needs to change to bring about peace?
00:43:59 Is there any timeline you foresee on that happening, like a lasting peace?
00:44:04 And crucially, how significant will that be?
00:44:08 for not just the midterms, but 2028?
00:44:11 Well, first of all, I do think that things are much different
00:44:15 than they were even a few months ago.
00:44:17 I'm not saying they're going to, you know,
00:44:19 I can't predict, of course, the future.
00:44:21 But so one, there are talks, there were scheduled talks,
00:44:25 really technical talks building on the negotiation
00:44:29 that we've already had.
00:44:30 Those are definitely happening tomorrow.
00:44:32 One of the things I find just fascinating 1.00
00:44:35 and frustrating about the Iranians is they'll say, 1.00
00:44:37 No, no, no, there aren't peace talks ongoing, but there are technical talks between the United States and Iran about the peace deal. 0.90
00:44:43 It's like, okay, so it's a Persian negotiating tactic and a Persian rhetorical device that I don't understand, but that is the way that the Iranians have done this.
00:44:54 um one of the things that i is underappreciated about the president's approach to this whole
00:44:59 region of the world is he likes to reshuffle the deck and then see where the leverage points are
00:45:07 where the pressure points are and see where we can make progress and that's really where we are
00:45:11 right now things have changed a lot the iranian military is much weaker the iranian economy is
00:45:16 much weaker um you know lebanon and israel are talking to each other directly in a way that
00:45:22 they weren't a few months ago. They both are sort of broadly aligned. And, you know, you can even
00:45:27 make an argument that if you harmonize the Lebanon-Israel peace deal with the MOU signed
00:45:35 between the United States and Iran, what both of those documents fundamentally say is that Lebanon's
00:45:40 territorial integrity will be respected. Okay. So things have definitely changed. I think the
00:45:46 question is whether that change is durable. And I don't know when this will air, probably tomorrow.
00:45:50 Okay. So I think what the president has said is, let's let this play out. There are a few things that we want. We want durable commitments that are verifiable and backed up by inspections that Iran will denuclearize their entire country. Okay. We're going to see how we get there.
00:46:09 Number two, we want to see what kind of an arrangement actually exists in the Middle East
00:46:18 between not just Iran and the United States, but the GCC, Israel, Lebanon. We're going to play that
00:46:24 situation out. And then on the Strait of Hormuz, I mean, I think you actually said it well, which
00:46:29 is that the Strait is open in the sense that to oil traffic, we're seeing more oil come out of
00:46:36 the Strait of Hormuz. And some days, actually, more oil coming out of the Strait than came out
00:46:40 before the war even started. So there's this element of the, you know, where the world oil
00:46:48 economy is kind of getting back into gear. That's going to take a little bit of time, but you've
00:46:52 already seen the prices come way down. Now, what the cynics will say is, well, if you look at the
00:46:56 number of ships that are trafficking, that's actually down from the pre-war start. But they're
00:47:01 mostly talking about cargo ships and other vessels. At least so far, what we've seen is
00:47:06 the oil traffic has reached its pre-war height. So I think what the president has told us to do
00:47:13 is use this MOU to sort of refill the world's oil economy, to refill some stocks, and then to see
00:47:21 where the hand is. And, you know, as I've said this repeatedly, if the Iranians are willing to 0.98
00:47:30 make the commitments that we would like them to make and are willing to back those up with 1.00
00:47:34 verifiable milestones, then we are going to change our relationship with Iran. And if they don't do 0.99
00:47:40 that, then nothing has really changed except for what we've already accomplished from the military
00:47:45 campaign, which is a lot. So we kind of have two options here. We have the option of pursuing a
00:47:51 long-term deal with the Iranians, but that requires a significant change in their behavior. 1.00
00:47:55 we have the option of banking our wins
00:47:59 and then, of course, doing things on top of that
00:48:02 if the president feels that we have to.
00:48:04 And I think both of those options are very much in play
00:48:06 and the president's going to let this play out.
00:48:09 But what's happening right now
00:48:11 is he's letting those options play out
00:48:13 in an environment where there is significantly less pressure
00:48:16 on the world energy economy.
00:48:19 And this is my biggest frustration
00:48:21 with right-wing critics of what we've done
00:48:23 over the last few months in Iran
00:48:25 is that they don't realize
00:48:27 how completely they were losing
00:48:30 the political argument
00:48:32 because of what was happening
00:48:33 to world energy markets.
00:48:35 So what the president
00:48:36 of the United States has done...
00:48:37 You're talking about the critics
00:48:38 who want more bombs dropping on.
00:48:40 Their attitude is just drop bombs 0.91
00:48:43 and drop bombs and drop bombs
00:48:44 and they can't really articulate
00:48:46 to what end.
00:48:47 What the president is saying,
00:48:49 I'm willing to drop bombs
00:48:50 and he's clearly shown
00:48:51 that he's willing to drop bombs
00:48:52 but only if it serves an objective.
00:48:55 And so what he's doing right now
00:48:57 is taking a lot of pressure
00:48:59 off of the world economy,
00:49:01 the world energy economy in particular,
00:49:03 while not giving up a single one of his gains
00:49:06 and while preserving a lot of optionality.
00:49:08 I think that's a very good place for us to be in,
00:49:11 but there's uncertainty
00:49:12 because no one can be certain
00:49:15 what the Iranians are going to do. 0.53
00:49:15 Right, so then the message, 0.81
00:49:17 if you're an Iranian,
00:49:18 the message you're getting from the U.S.
00:49:19 is not, okay, we've settled this,
00:49:21 You get to keep the Strait of Hormuz, and we'll try to play nice now.
00:49:25 The message is, okay, we're going to serve our self-interest by replenishing the oil coffers.
00:49:31 And get back to us in 60 days, you might have some fire and brimstone coming back down.
00:49:35 And if you actually behave, you won't, right?
00:49:38 And that's what the president has fundamentally put out there.
00:49:41 Now, it is interesting to me because the Iranians have said, we control the straits.
00:49:46 And yeah, we're going to let traffic flow for the next 60 days.
00:49:49 but then we're going to negotiate over what happens from there, okay?
00:49:53 And what I find just bizarre about that assertion is that nobody from the Gulf Coast,
00:50:00 the Gulf Coalition countries, the Arab countries in the Gulf,
00:50:04 and the Omanis, who are sort of the main Iranian theoretically partner,
00:50:08 all of them have come out and said, we don't accept this Iranian tolling mechanism.
00:50:14 And so the Iranians keep on asserting something that isn't actually happening right now,
00:50:19 and they don't have a credible pathway to make happen in the future. 0.95
00:50:22 So I do see this as a bit of a sideshow, because fundamentally, like, their arguments,
00:50:28 what I mean is the sideshow is what they're saying.
00:50:32 What will actually happen is going to be determined through a combination of negotiation,
00:50:37 diplomatic, economic, and military leverage.
00:50:39 What they're saying right now for the consumption of their domestic audience,
00:50:42 It really doesn't matter.
00:50:44 What matters is what's going to happen.
00:50:46 That's something that we're working on right now. 0.59
00:50:48 And so then if you look ahead, not just to the midterms, but even to 2028, if this drags on in this kind of stasis, the Iranians don't behave, and Hezbollah keeps up to its antics, and we can't get a piece of steel between these three, four, five, six countries, how significant is that for the Republican chances in 2028?
00:51:10 I don't mean to only come back to 2028, but I think it helps clarify what it means for the party.
00:51:15 Is this, as the president has said, you know, just a digression, sort of a side quest that we had to deal with because of the Iranian nuclear threat?
00:51:22 Or maybe it is that today.
00:51:24 Could this become a major moment in the history of the American empire and the Republican Party?
00:51:31 Well, first of all, I just want to be very clear here. 0.57
00:51:34 Like, this is not going to end in a place where the Iranians are collecting tolls on ships going through the Strait of Hormuz. 0.53
00:51:41 There's a lot of uncertainty because we don't know how the Iranians are going to behave. 0.80
00:51:45 But that is just one thing that every country in the region, including Iran's own allies, say is unacceptable. 1.00
00:51:50 That would be intolerable. 1.00
00:51:51 Unpredictability, yes, because the Iranians are inherently unpredictable. 1.00
00:51:54 Their government's very unstable.
00:51:56 But I don't think that is going to be a situation that exists.
00:52:00 In fact, I feel quite confident that we're not going to have a told Strait of War moves in the future.
00:52:05 But, you know, you brought a question about, like, could this be something that affects the chances in 2028?
00:52:11 Could this be a very important historical moment?
00:52:13 The answer is obviously yes.
00:52:16 But again, how exactly this plays out is very much contingent on the way that the Iranians respond to the leverage the president has put on them.
00:52:26 And if they respond well, I think we're going to look back at this and say, we turned over a new leaf. Now, a lot of people are skeptical, including me, that that will ultimately happen. And then if the Iranians perform or behave poorly, then I think that we still have a lot of leverage points to ensure that this ends up in a place that is good for America's objective.
00:52:45 So I think fundamentally, there's a desire here for everyone to say this is over or, you know, the Democrats and even, frankly, some Republicans are saying, well, you know, this shows that Trump blinked. 0.93
00:52:59 And then other people are saying, you know, it's all over and the Iranians are saying this.
00:53:04 And I would be highly skeptical of what everybody says right now.
00:53:08 I think Marcos said this the other day.
00:53:10 He said this is the end of the beginning, okay?
00:53:13 There is a lot more game to play.
00:53:17 And there are a lot more cards that we're going to see to mix metaphors here.
00:53:21 And the good thing about it is that we're served by an administration.
00:53:26 We're served by a president of the United States who is constantly trying to figure out how to gain an edge for the American people.
00:53:32 I ultimately strongly believe we will look back on this moment and say we got to a good place.
00:53:37 It's going to take a lot of work, not just in the negotiation arena, but in the arenas too.
00:53:42 You know, I have a great deal of sympathy for the administration, actually, on this.
00:53:46 I appreciate it.
00:53:46 Because, look, I was very skeptical of this intervention before, during, and after.
00:53:51 Sure.
00:53:52 And I favor or restrain foreign policy.
00:53:55 But I look at these polls, and I saw a poll a year ago of Americans, especially on the right.
00:54:01 How many of you think that we should stop Iran from getting a nuclear weapon?
00:54:06 90%, 80%, 90%.
00:54:07 How many of you want to go to war with Iran?
00:54:09 Like 10%, 20%, none.
00:54:11 And you say, well, those are in conflict.
00:54:13 Yes.
00:54:14 I've seen the same polls.
00:54:14 And then even, look, to bring it into another issue, it's interesting at this moment that foreign policy rarely rises to the top of conservatives' minds.
00:54:22 It really does seem to be dominating.
00:54:24 You look at China.
00:54:25 The Wall Street Journal had this worrisome report out a couple days ago.
00:54:28 It said that after Anthropic came out with the mythos AI, they said, this is so good.
00:54:33 It's so dangerous.
00:54:34 We're not going to release this to the public.
00:54:36 Wall Street Journal reports China just made its own mythos.
00:54:39 It's out. 1.00
00:54:40 It's so much for that.
00:54:41 That we're clearly in some kind of AI arms race.
00:54:45 We appear to be in a Cold War. 0.78
00:54:47 Maybe it gets a little hot even sometimes with China.
00:54:51 And Americans are divided on this, even conservatives. 0.55
00:54:54 On the one hand, we want to win the arms race with China.
00:54:56 On the other hand, we don't want AI to take all of our jobs, build huge data centers in our backyard, raise our energy prices, all the rest.
00:55:03 So you say, well, no, I don't want to lose the AI arms race, and I don't want the data center in my town.
00:55:08 Well, so in the Trump administration and then looking ahead perhaps to the Vance administration, what does the American foreign policy look like?
00:55:17 Because from what I can tell, we want the privileges of empire, but we don't want the obligations of empire.
00:55:22 First of all, I reject the premise of any future Vance administration.
00:55:25 I'm very focused on being vice president.
00:55:27 No, it was very slick, but I refuse to accept it.
00:55:31 This aggression will not stand.
00:55:33 But on the Trump administration's policy, I mean, we have tried and I think we've done a good job of balancing the economic benefits with the downsides of artificial intelligence, okay?
00:55:49 And you're right.
00:55:50 We don't want to lose the AI race to China.
00:55:52 I think there's an interesting question about how much China's own AI policy is fundamentally derivative of us.
00:55:59 And I don't just mean them copying American models.
00:56:02 That is part of it.
00:56:04 I actually mean, I'm not sure,
00:56:07 I don't think many Americans have a good understanding
00:56:09 of how the Chinese actually think about AI.
00:56:11 I think there's a part of the Chinese policy set,
00:56:15 you know, Xi's inner circle,
00:56:16 that probably just wants to dominate the AI arms race.
00:56:20 I actually think there is a part of Xi's inner circle
00:56:23 that says we don't want to lose to the United States,
00:56:26 but we don't want to win either.
00:56:28 That they're, I think they're a little freaked out by it
00:56:31 is what I'm saying. We will get back to the vice president breaking news as it pertains to
00:56:38 politics, the world, the entire international order. But first, I have some news to break
00:56:44 on Mayflower because our country turns 250 years old this week, the semi-quincentennial of a
00:56:50 country built by tobacco. It deserves a cigar worthy of the occasion. I have been teasing this
00:56:54 for some months now. It's finally arrived. It is our special 250th anniversary of America,
00:57:00 Mayflower Blend, and it is called Mayflower Dawn of America, special reserve edition of our
00:57:07 best-selling flagship blend. This is wrapped in a seven-year-aged true USA Connecticut tobacco
00:57:14 wrapper. This is grown in the shade of New England. This is the kind of tobacco, it's a
00:57:19 more aged, delicious version of the kind of tobacco I grew up smoking. You'll get notes of
00:57:24 cream, almond, toasted bread, coffee, presented exclusively in a commemorative box of 10,
00:57:28 Each cigar sealed in its own tube.
00:57:30 The tubes are beautiful.
00:57:31 On the secondary band, you'll find the words from our framers to ourselves and our posterity.
00:57:36 It's just killer.
00:57:37 It's just a killer cigar.
00:57:38 It's in very, very limited quantity.
00:57:40 It was hard to get this tobacco in the first place.
00:57:42 I'm telling you, this is a limited batch.
00:57:43 I don't want to hear it.
00:57:44 When they're gone, they're gone.
00:57:45 You must be 21 years old or older to order.
00:57:47 Voidware prohibited conditions and exclusions apply.
00:57:51 Celebrate Canada Day by getting even more for your points.
00:57:55 It's the Super Redemption event at Shoppers Drug Mart.
00:57:57 Friday, June 26th to Wednesday, July 1st.
00:58:01 Valid in-store and online.
00:58:05 So where I think that lands for me is, you know,
00:58:11 I am very skeptical of AI to the extent that it leads to like porn slop videos
00:58:18 and weird child predation stuff on the internet.
00:58:22 And I'm more optimistic about AI when it comes to things like curing diseases
00:58:26 and solving, like, very, very big technical challenges for the American people.
00:58:32 So, you know, because of that, I think we have to strike a balance.
00:58:36 Like, I'm not super laissez-faire on some of the applications of AI
00:58:39 because I do think that some of the AI CEOs fundamentally want to control
00:58:42 the information economy in the United States.
00:58:44 They want to sell sometimes very damaging things to our children.
00:58:49 They want to get rich in the process, and they want to control the government.
00:58:52 I think that some AI leaders want to build things
00:58:56 that are genuinely transformative in a good way.
00:58:59 And I don't think that we can be, you know, completely unbiased.
00:59:04 There is, you have to sort of pick a side.
00:59:06 Yeah.
00:59:07 And I think in the United States, the side that I pick is
00:59:09 pro the people who are building things that are meaningful and valuable
00:59:12 and anti the people who just want to like, you know, produce slot videos
00:59:16 and make it easier for child predators to interact with our kids.
00:59:20 The data center thing is interesting.
00:59:23 Like, just if you look at the polling,
00:59:25 I've talked to some friends of mine
00:59:26 who work in the AI world about this.
00:59:27 I don't know if I've ever seen,
00:59:29 I mean, like AI data centers
00:59:30 are about as popular as herpes.
00:59:33 It's unbelievable how bad the polling is.
00:59:36 And my view on this is that
00:59:38 it's not really about the data centers,
00:59:40 it's about the energy.
00:59:42 And that 99% of the backlash to AI data centers
00:59:45 is because we're allowing these data centers,
00:59:47 especially in blue states
00:59:48 where they make it hard to build power to tap into the grid.
00:59:51 So an AI data center literally means
00:59:53 you're going to be paying more electricity
00:59:55 so that, you know, somebody in Silicon Valley
00:59:58 can make another billion dollars.
01:00:00 Like, going back to the point about the dignity of human beings,
01:00:03 that is not a good trade.
01:00:04 That's not a trade that we accept.
01:00:06 We should accept.
01:00:07 But I think the most important solution there
01:00:09 is just to build more power. 0.96
01:00:12 And where I think the Chinese are way ahead of us in AI, 1.00
01:00:15 it's the only area, 0.97
01:00:16 is the Chinese are not afraid to build power.
01:00:19 We are.
01:00:20 And so this is where I think the environmental movement
01:00:23 in the United States is going to collide with reality.
01:00:26 And it's funny that if the AI people don't figure this out,
01:00:31 they're going to be the casualty of this war.
01:00:33 Between building power and the environmental movement
01:00:36 in the United States,
01:00:37 AI data centers are going to be the first casualty.
01:00:40 And, you know, my advice to the AI CEOs
01:00:43 would be something like, maybe you should support building more power. And maybe, you know, and we've
01:00:50 pursued policies like this in the Trump administration, where you try to force people
01:00:54 that if they're going to build an AI data center, they can only do it if it's going to raise people's
01:00:58 power costs. I can't help but notice that some of the real billionaire obsessives about
01:01:04 environmentalism, they've changed their tune. People like Bill Gates, he said, basically,
01:01:09 that global warming was solved.
01:01:11 This happens to coincide
01:01:13 with this energy crisis for,
01:01:15 who knows?
01:01:16 Maybe it's a coincidence.
01:01:17 Maybe it's Providence.
01:01:17 Who knows?
01:01:18 I know you have to go.
01:01:19 Yeah.
01:01:19 But you have very important things to do,
01:01:20 like help run the whole country.
01:01:22 I have two brief questions
01:01:23 before you go.
01:01:24 And they're sort of like
01:01:25 pick a name kind of questions.
01:01:26 Sure.
01:01:27 The leading Democrat for 28.
01:01:30 Hmm.
01:01:32 I think it's got to be AOC.
01:01:34 I know that's probably
01:01:34 conventional wisdom, but...
01:01:36 Well, no, I think the conventional wisdom
01:01:37 right now is Newsom.
01:01:38 No, no.
01:01:39 I don't buy that.
01:01:41 I think he hurt himself with his comment
01:01:44 to an audience full of black Americans 0.97
01:01:47 that I'm low IQ just like you. 0.99
01:01:50 Sort of bad in a couple of different ways.
01:01:53 How do you do?
01:01:54 At least two major political gaffes
01:01:58 produced in a single sentence.
01:02:00 The major political gaffes I've had,
01:02:01 it's sort of much less efficient than that.
01:02:05 So yeah, look, I think all-
01:02:07 AOC, more than Ossoff,
01:02:08 more than any of these other guys?
01:02:11 Yeah, I mean, it's funny.
01:02:12 It's the AOC versus Ossoff thing.
01:02:14 I guess the question would be,
01:02:17 who do you think really has the power
01:02:18 in the Democratic Party?
01:02:20 And if you think the answer is like Wall Street
01:02:24 and the left of center business community,
01:02:27 then it would be Ossoff.
01:02:28 And if you think it's the universities,
01:02:30 it would be AOC.
01:02:31 So David Brooks made an observation.
01:02:33 I think David Brooks probably hates my guts,
01:02:35 but he like occasionally will say something
01:02:37 that I think is genuinely brilliant,
01:02:39 and this was one of them.
01:02:40 He said that the fundamental problem
01:02:42 with today's Democratic Party
01:02:43 is that the power center has shifted
01:02:44 from unions to universities.
01:02:48 And if that's right, AOC will be the nominee.
01:02:51 And by the way, I think that's one of the reasons
01:02:52 why the Democratic Party of 2026 is so deranged.
01:02:57 Because, you know, you walk into a union hall,
01:03:01 even where 70% of the guys are still voting Dem,
01:03:04 fundamentally like a normal place
01:03:06 with normal social values.
01:03:09 It's not the university, like, you know,
01:03:13 it's not the university break room.
01:03:16 Faculty lounge, yeah.
01:03:17 Faculty lounge, that's the word that I'm looking for.
01:03:18 Right.
01:03:19 So, and this, by the way, is another reason
01:03:22 why I'm just fundamentally pessimistic about the Dems,
01:03:24 because, you know, it's one thing to be
01:03:28 a socially pragmatic left-of-center Democrat
01:03:33 on economic issues, 0.97
01:03:34 but they're just so dominated by the crazy people and they can't it's like they can't figure out the
01:03:41 part where they get the economic populism which actually is very popular and i think republicans
01:03:45 should be more worried about that yeah but every time they get the economic populism it's with 0.68
01:03:52 somebody like aoc who's like oh we you know need to tax the rich and give all the money to transgender
01:03:58 baseball players who prey on your kids and it's like wait a minute yeah could you like a very 0.53
01:04:03 potent political movement would be half of that, whether you agree with it or not.
01:04:08 Half of that equation is very politically popular. The part where you allow those same
01:04:12 billionaires that you're taxing to get rich by selling unlicensed pharmaceutical products
01:04:17 to 12-year-old minors to gender transition them, that's the part that makes most Americans go,
01:04:23 what the hell are you talking about? And oh, by the way, are you actually against the rich
01:04:29 when your social values and your cultural values
01:04:32 happen to align with the CEOs of nearly every major corporation.
01:04:36 Yes, yeah.
01:04:37 I mean, you saw it just the other day,
01:04:39 this Scott Wiener, this guy who's running for Pelosi's seat.
01:04:43 Like a true deviant.
01:04:46 I mean, there's like something wrong with that guy.
01:04:49 His crowning political achievement
01:04:50 was encouraging pederasty in the law. 0.67
01:04:53 That's not an exaggeration.
01:04:54 And he was kicked out of the trans march
01:04:56 for being too right-wing.
01:04:58 You know, so that's basically the state of the party.
01:05:01 I think, Scott, sometimes you eat the bar
01:05:04 and sometimes the bar eats you, my friend.
01:05:06 Best of luck.
01:05:07 Last question I have for you before I let you go.
01:05:10 Last name to name.
01:05:11 Who's your confirmation saint?
01:05:14 Augustine, St. Augustine.
01:05:15 Yep, that's right.
01:05:16 So that was an easy choice for me.
01:05:18 Confessions was such a big part of my own faith journey.
01:05:21 I write about it a little bit in the book,
01:05:23 but you know, the city of God and everything that he wrote.
01:05:25 So that's an easy one.
01:05:27 We have an Augustinian pope, an Augustinian vice president, maybe soon an Augustinian president.
01:05:32 I gave Pope Leo XIV when I visited him for his inaugural mass.
01:05:37 We found a very old copy of Confessions that we gifted him.
01:05:43 That is, now what am I going to get him?
01:05:46 I don't know.
01:05:46 I don't know what I'm going to need him.
01:05:47 Mr. Vice President, such a pleasure.
01:05:49 Thank you for being very, very generous with your time.
01:05:52 Excellent book.
01:05:52 Thank you.
01:05:53 really, I hardly, I'm not even lying, as I would be inclined to do for a friend or someone I admire,
01:05:59 but this book is really good, so go get it. Communion by J.D. Vance. Thank you, sir.
01:06:03 Good to see you, man. Thanks.
01:06:23 payday for life what would you feel free to do maybe take a long weekend every weekend or try
01:06:28 a bunch of new hobbies would you feel free to upgrade and listen ad free don't worry we get it
01:06:34 every twenty dollar ticket could win you three thousand dollars a month for life and supports
01:06:38 life-saving cancer research at the princess margaret feel free to buy your payday for life
01:06:43 ticket today raffle number 155-2194 please play responsibly