Is your 4-year-old gender fluid? Well, now you can send him or her to a transgender summer camp for kids in the San Francisco Bay Area. Plus, we ll have roaming millennial Amanda Prestigiacomo and Jacob Airey join the panel of deplorables to discuss social media depression among kids, President Trump's tough talk on North Korea, and the urgent need for the government to regulate sex robots.
00:00:00.000Is your four-year-old gender fluid? Well, now you can send him or her or Zim or Zer to transgender summer camp for kids in, where else? The San Francisco Bay Area. Plus, we'll have roaming millennial Amanda Prestigiacomo and Jacob Airey join the panel of deplorables to discuss, speaking of the youths, social media depression among kids, President Trump's tough talk on North Korea, and the urgent need for the government to regulate sex robots. I'm Michael Knowles. This is The Michael Knowles Show.
00:01:00.000The kids are toddlers. The ages of the people who go are 4 to 12. The parents of the people who go are obviously abusive and very confused. So this camp is not new. This camp's been around for three years.
00:01:11.940It just made big headlines recently because the enrollment has increased by three times just this year. So obviously, transgenderism is in the air. We're talking about it all the time in the culture.
00:01:23.880And apparently, this has been good business for transgender youth camp. One of the directors said, it has been a sea change. Maybe we can even call it a tsunami in the number of little kids showing up with their families.
00:01:36.720And so when the kids show up, even when they're four years old, they are asked when they register which pronoun they would prefer to be called by. And it's either she or he or Z or whatever.
00:01:48.080And for the record, Marshall, I would only like to be referred to with the pronoun sir, sir or master in the accusative. Sir in the – well, make a note and we'll talk about it later.
00:01:58.540Luckily, we have obtained a letter from one of the attendees of this camp. We get access to great stuff at this show. We have obtained a letter. Can we play it?
00:02:07.540Take me home. Oh, not a father. Take me home. I hate Granada. Don't leave me out in the forest where I might get eaten by a bear.
00:02:24.180Take me home. I promise I will not make noise.
00:02:32.180So trans camp is apparently like a band camp. It's much more socially isolating, obviously, and confusing. But it's just like any other camp. You go to basketball camp. You go to baseball camp, whatever.
00:02:44.700It is a little interesting in that most summer camps that we think of are camps to do something. So I had to go to basketball camp when I was a kid one time. It turned out about as you would expect, I think.
00:02:57.440But this is a camp about who you are imagining yourself to be, who you deeply think yourself to be. And obviously, adolescence is a very confusing time. We take on a lot of different identities that we try out.
00:03:10.080No joke. When I was four years old, I did identify as Batman for about a month. I had people call me Batman. Seriously. And that's just a very imaginative time.
00:03:20.260These parents are obviously taking it to be some deep, profound, immutable fact of their child's existence and sending this to their camp. It can't possibly be good.
00:03:30.060But, you know, even the founder of this camp, Sandra Collins, admits, quote, a decade ago, the camp wouldn't have existed. Eventually, I do believe it won't be so innovative.
00:03:39.820She's probably right. She said, I didn't know you could be transgender at a very young age, but my daughter knew for sure at two.
00:03:47.760I don't know if that's exactly right. What could go wrong with allowing your two-year-old to deny the facts of their biology and to deny reality to their parents?
00:03:57.000Well, there are a lot of scientific data on this that I think the mainstream media are ignoring.
00:04:02.080And I'm sorry if I know these scientific data. That is called hate speech if you're at Google or you work for the mainstream journalist outlets.
00:04:09.400But we know there are high rates of post-op regret. People who transition from one gender to another, they undergo surgery to look more like the other sex, and they regret it later.
00:04:21.080Some of these studies put the number at 20%. So one in five people who undergo this process and these surgeries, according to some studies, regret it, ultimately go back, or they are just upset that they made that decision.
00:04:34.060Most children who identify as transsexual or as the other sex, the vast majority of those kids will change their mind by the time they become adults.
00:04:44.320They go on to lead perfectly normal lives. One study puts that number as high as 80%.
00:04:49.00080% of kids who identify they're a boy but they think they're a girl will change their mind by the time they pass through puberty and enter into adulthood.
00:04:57.760Now, there was a review of more than 100 international medical studies, so this is a meta-analysis of all these studies, that found, quote,
00:05:05.800no robust scientific evidence that gender reassignment surgery is clinically effective.
00:05:10.920And this is why Paul McHugh, who was a pioneer of this surgery at Johns Hopkins, he was chair of psychology at Johns Hopkins,
00:05:18.220he stopped doing the surgery because, quote,
00:05:20.880there's little scientific evidence for the therapeutic value of interventions that delay puberty or modify the secondary sex characteristics of adolescence.
00:05:30.400There is no evidence that all children who express gender, atypical thoughts, or behavior should be encouraged to become transgender.
00:05:38.600And that's what, you know, trans is in the news all the time.
00:06:34.200I was a pediatric transitioner, so I started medical transition when I was underage.
00:06:39.500And I stopped transitioning nearly a year ago.
00:06:43.160And for me, detransition involves, you know, a lot of thought and a lot of unlearning of what I understood about myself.
00:06:49.760When I was transitioning, I felt a lot of intense, very intense body dysphoria that felt very innate and very integral at the time to the way I perceived myself in the world.
00:07:00.620And what I came to realize eventually was that this was not the case, that there were all these factors that played into my dysphoria,
00:07:08.500dissociation and feelings of inferiority for being female and depression, body dysmorphia.
00:07:15.820You know, all of these things contributing to this kind of general sense of alienation, sense of otherness from the people around me and specifically from other women.
00:07:24.880And there are these conditions that go along with gender dysphoria.
00:07:31.320There is a two to three times increase in likelihood, if you have gender dysphoria, that you'll suffer from some other mental affliction, including anxiety or depression or so on and so forth.
00:07:42.520Obviously, we know that the suicide rates, according to most studies, are identical pre and post-op.
00:07:49.960And the left and people who support the transgenderism movement would say, well, that's social stress.
00:08:02.660There's that might be a factor, but there's no reason to believe that that's the main factor or or the, you know, the sole factor when it comes to all of these other conditions that accompany gender dysphoria.
00:09:48.560There's another example of not just people who went through this as kids, but also people who went through the transition and changed their gender when they were adults, regretting it not long after.
00:10:20.580Now, first of all, not only have you done extensive research on sex change surgery, you've been through the process yourself, but you say it fixed nothing.
00:10:29.520What can you share with us about that?
00:10:30.940Yeah, you know, when people go through this gender change, there's very high expectations that, you know, their life is just going to be wonderful and everything's going to be great.
00:10:42.200And I can tell you the way it starts, that was true for me.
00:10:46.020But then there's a time, what I call, when you kind of begin to sober up and realize that gender reassignment surgery really doesn't make you a female.
00:10:56.800It's much more to being a woman than just having some cosmetic surgery and hormones.
00:11:02.380So it didn't fix the problem for Walt.
00:11:05.080And he lived for eight years as a woman, appearing to be a woman and wearing women's clothing.
00:12:03.140But the psychological problems and therefore the philosophical problems that come up with it are a little clearer when you look at other forms of body dysmorphia and delusion.
00:12:12.600There is an extreme example, a guy whose name is Stalking Cat, Dennis Abner.
00:12:34.820He is a man who, I think he was in the Navy, and then he decided to get $200,000 worth of surgery to tattoo his face, pull up his cheeks, have whiskers sticking out, cut off parts of his ears.
00:12:47.740All so that he could appear more like a cat, because he was under the impression that he really, deep down inside somewhere, is a cat.
00:12:55.780He has cat-like abilities and what have you.
00:13:04.560But it's really sad because this is a real human being.
00:13:07.200And we can see much more clearly what happens when we indulge delusion, when it's not just a boy becoming like a girl, when boys and girls can look like each other, but when it's a boy trying to look like an animal or something to that effect.
00:13:21.500This is ultimately, I think, what brings up the central flaw in the left's embrace of transgenderism, the central contradiction, which is that the left on the one hand says men and women are exactly the same.
00:13:33.580They're indiscernible, that just talk to Google, fired a guy for contradicting this yesterday.
00:13:39.160Men can do everything that women can do and vice versa.
00:13:42.880On the other hand, they're saying that the sexes are so totally different that if you feel that you are a certain way metaphysically or you really want to be a different way metaphysically, you should undergo costly, painful, and extensive surgery just to have the cosmetic appearance of looking like that other sex.
00:13:59.280They've never been able to resolve this conflict, and I think that's why, I think it has shown one of the major paradoxes at the heart of leftist intersectional hierarchies.
00:14:10.880But, now that we've talked about the transgender camp, now that we've talked about leftist hierarchies, we have to get to the exciting part of the show, our panel of deplorables.
00:14:19.980We have with us, again, Roaming Millennial, you know her from all the YouTubes, The Daily Wire's favorite, Amanda Presta Giacomo, and for some reason, Jacob Berry is back.
00:16:09.440But there doesn't appear to be a cure.
00:16:11.240So, Amanda, if there isn't a cure for this at the moment, if there's really, doesn't seem to be an effective way to reduce suicide rates or depression surgically,
00:16:20.000then why shouldn't we just tell these people to call themselves whatever name they want and pretend to be whatever sex they want?
00:16:45.280We should not be encouraging this, especially, I mean, particularly with children who, as you said, grow out of this confusion.
00:16:51.560I mean, we're just basically indoctrinating, you know, Tommy, the two-year-old, who says he's a dinosaur on Wednesday and then on Thursday he's a girl.
00:17:04.040And, you know, I think, I mean, 80% of these kids, that's the lone number grow out, you know, for these studies, grow out of this confusion.
00:17:12.800We should not be pushing this on them.