Ep. 823 - The “Friendly,” “Peaceful” Taliban Takeover
Summary
The Taliban have seized control of Afghanistan's capital city of Kabul, but it's a relatively peaceful takeover. Is it a catastrophe or a nightmare? And is it a mostly peaceful takeover? Plus, a look at Joe Biden's response to the situation.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
The scenes out of Afghanistan have been heartbreaking. Desperate people doing whatever
00:00:04.680
they can to flee the country as the Taliban reestablishes control over the capital city
00:00:09.500
and the rest of the country. Some people are calling it a catastrophe. Other people
00:00:15.020
are calling it a nightmare. And MSNBC reporters are calling it a relatively peaceful takeover.
00:00:23.940
The country is essentially now in the hands of the Taliban for all intents and purposes.
00:00:30.000
They've taken over Kabul. The president, or should I now say the former president of Afghanistan,
00:00:36.700
Ashraf Ghani, has fled the country. The Taliban have taken over the presidential palace. They've
00:00:42.880
renamed the country the Islamic Emirate, taken down the Afghan flag and hoisted up their own colors.
00:00:50.460
And it's been a relatively peaceful, if you like, process. They haven't had to fire a lot of shots.
00:00:57.700
There hasn't been a lot of bloodshed in Kabul. It was a pretty straightforward takeover for them.
00:01:03.780
They've also taken over the airport. There have been reports of shots fired at the airport and
00:01:09.040
Taliban fighters are all over the place. But they're not in any sort of clashes with U.S.
00:01:15.720
personnel, although commercial flights have so far been suspended.
00:01:20.020
That's a lot of whiplash. It's a mostly peaceful takeover of the country. And it's peaceful. And
00:01:26.860
there are definitely shots being fired by the militants who are everywhere. But it's mostly
00:01:30.280
peaceful. Turns out that relatively peaceful takeovers, much like mostly peaceful protests,
00:01:36.160
seem to involve a fair bit of violence. But Joe Biden has doubled down on the strategy
00:01:40.980
in his first comments since everything that he said wouldn't happen, happened in Afghanistan.
00:01:46.400
With the president this week, is it any wonder that Democrats want to ban Donald Trump from
00:01:51.840
ever appearing on a ballot? Again, I'm Michael Knowles. This is The Michael Knowles Show.
00:02:02.780
Welcome back to the show. My favorite comment yesterday from There's a Verse for That, who says,
00:02:07.540
all the Afghan terrorists are going free. Meanwhile, domestic terrorists who took pictures in the
00:02:12.200
Capitol are rotting away in solitary confinement. Good job, O Biden. Yes, this is what the liberal
00:02:18.360
order wants. They want to go easy on terrorists who want to destroy America. And they want to define
00:02:26.860
you to define half the country as terrorists, lock you up, and throw away the key. At least that is the
00:02:33.980
way our political order works. It's enough to probably disturb your sleep at night. Well, if you want to
00:02:39.620
sleep easy, I recommend you check out Helix. Helix Sleep has a quiz that takes just two minutes to
00:02:44.460
complete and matches your body type and sleep preferences to the perfect mattress for you.
00:02:49.700
Why would you buy a mattress made for somebody else? Doesn't make any sense. With Helix, you're
00:02:53.100
getting a mattress that you know will be perfect for the way that you sleep. They got soft, they got
00:02:57.680
medium, they got firm mattresses. They've got mattresses that are great for cooling you down if you sleep
00:03:01.640
hot. They even have a Helix Plus mattress for plus size sleepers. And the mattress comes right to
00:03:06.760
your door shipped for free. You don't ever need to go to a mattress store again. You don't need to
00:03:11.880
take my word for it. Helix was awarded the number one best overall mattress pick of 2020 by GQ and
00:03:17.220
Wired Magazine. Just go to helixsleep.com slash Knowles. Take their two-minute sleep quiz. They
00:03:22.480
will match you to a customized mattress that will give you the best sleep of your life. They've got
00:03:26.940
a 10-year warranty. You get to try it out for 100 nights risk-free. Won't matter because you're not
00:03:31.780
going to want to send it back. If you did, they would pick it up for you even if you don't love it,
00:03:35.360
but you're going to love it. Helix is offering up to $200 off all mattress orders and two free
00:03:38.860
pillows for our listeners at helixsleep.com slash Knowles. That's helixsleep.com slash Knowles for
00:03:44.380
up to $200 off and two free pillows. MSNBC sees the glass half full. That's the same network,
00:03:52.060
by the way, that called the George Floyd riots mostly peaceful protests with the buildings burning
00:03:57.520
down behind them. Now they're saying this is a relatively peaceful takeover. I suppose as far as
00:04:01.660
takeovers go, it actually is relatively peaceful, meaning, yeah, they're executing lots of people
00:04:07.220
and beheading lots of people, but there's no major battle taking place in Kabul because the Afghan
00:04:11.460
military didn't even fight back and the American forces were leaving. The political leadership said
00:04:16.800
pull out of the country. The State Department taking a similarly optimistic view. So the State
00:04:23.440
Department spokesman Ned Price is confident in the ability of the United States to impel the Taliban
00:04:33.100
to have an inclusive government. Additionally, the UN Security Council issued a joint press statement
00:04:39.900
earlier today calling for a new government that is united, inclusive, and representative,
00:04:45.740
including with the full and meaningful participation of women. The Council spoke with one voice to
00:04:54.300
underscore that Afghanistan must abide by its international obligations, including to international
00:05:00.100
humanitarian law and ensure the safety and security of all Afghans and international citizens.
00:05:06.360
I'm sure that'll do it. It's done. It's over. I don't know why we spent 20 years in a military
00:05:11.980
occupation in Afghanistan when Ned Price could have just gotten on TV or, and frankly, he might still
00:05:18.620
do this, written a strongly worded letter to the Taliban and said, hey, dear Taliban, to whom it may
00:05:27.900
concern at the Taliban, we want you to elect women to your government. And if you don't, well, we're,
00:05:35.940
we in the international community will be very disappointed in you, Taliban. Okay. So maybe
00:05:42.820
think about that. Taliban, as far as I can tell, completely ignoring the demands of the United
00:05:50.600
States State Department. One CNN reporter observing on the ground, a CNN reporter who is now wearing a
00:05:57.520
hijab because otherwise she'll be killed. She is now wearing the hijab, but she's looking on the bright
00:06:02.380
side. She's saying, sure. You know, these guys seem pretty, they're saying mean things there.
00:06:08.100
They don't sound like they're going along with this, but they seem friendly enough.
00:06:14.040
They're just chanting death to America, but they seem friendly at the same time. It's utterly bizarre.
00:06:20.740
Look, they're mostly friendly terrorists who want to destroy our country. Mostly friendly though.
00:06:27.780
And actually, I hate to give credit to CNN too, but in a way they do seem kind of friendly. In a way,
00:06:34.300
that's the scariest part. Because if you look at the clip, they're chanting, it's like, oh,
00:06:38.580
death to America. We took over the country. Oh, hey, buddy, buddy, habibi, death to America.
00:06:46.380
Gosh, it's bad. It's bad. It's not looking good. Seems like a contradiction, but there it is.
00:06:53.560
It's chanting death to America, but mostly friendly. A takeover of a country, but mostly
00:06:59.560
peaceful. If you like contradictions, by the way, you'll love Joe Biden's speech. Joe Biden
00:07:02.880
spoke yesterday. He finally left Camp David. He was ignoring the takeover of Afghanistan for several
00:07:08.540
days. The takeover of Afghanistan happened in exactly the way that he and his administration
00:07:12.880
said it would not happen. And so he finally addressed it. It was a very, very interesting speech.
00:07:19.180
It tells you a lot about Joe Biden and the state of the crumbling American empire.
00:07:23.380
The highlights. It did not begin in the strongest way.
00:07:30.080
My national security team and I have been closely monitoring the situation on the ground in Afghanistan
00:07:34.500
and moving quickly to execute the plans we had put in place to respond to every constituency,
00:07:41.540
including in contingency, including the rapid collapse we're seeing now.
00:07:47.000
So that's, I think within the first 10 seconds of the speech, of his slurred speech,
00:07:52.740
he confuses constituency with contingency. They're very, very different things, obviously.
00:07:59.220
And the ruling class in this country doesn't seem to have much of either of an actual constituency
00:08:05.220
that supports them or contingency plans because everything went wrong in Afghanistan.
00:08:09.260
The speech did get a little bit better from there. He made a point that I think is pretty
00:08:13.540
popular. He said, we now, as the official policy of the United States, will not nation build in every
00:08:25.260
Our mission in Afghanistan was never supposed to have been nation building.
00:08:29.420
It was never supposed to be creating a unified, centralized democracy.
00:08:34.440
Our only vital national interest in Afghanistan remains today what has always been,
00:08:41.420
preventing a terrorist attack on America's homeland.
00:08:44.960
I will not repeat the mistakes we've made in the past.
00:08:49.840
Mistake of staying and fighting indefinitely in a conflict that is not in the national interest of the United States.
00:08:56.040
So this is a direct contradiction of the Bush foreign policy.
00:09:01.580
The George W. Bush foreign policy is here. We played it yesterday on the show.
00:09:05.360
He articulated it in the second inaugural address.
00:09:07.860
He said, it is now in America's vital national interest to turn every country in the world into an America-style democracy.
00:09:19.940
Even that is a little bit Wilsonian to say that every other country in the world has to look exactly like we do,
00:09:28.940
He said the justification, which was never really plausible,
00:09:32.300
is that any country that is not a Madisonian democracy poses an existential threat to the United States.
00:09:39.100
It's in our urgent national security interest to topple every government that does not resemble ours in the entire world.
00:09:46.420
It was a wild, I mean, it was more Wilsonian than Wilson.
00:09:50.720
It was more progressive than the wildest progressives.
00:09:53.100
But that came to define America's foreign policy and certainly the Republican Party's for years.
00:10:00.120
Joe Biden, along with Donald Trump, saying that is no longer our policy.
00:10:04.400
Along with George W. Bush, the first time he ran for president, by the way, who said we're not going to nation build.
00:10:11.260
And then, you know, you know what Biden had to.
00:10:14.720
There was no way he was going to give this speech without doing it.
00:10:16.880
He was not going to take responsibility for his disastrous exit.
00:10:21.480
He was not going to take responsibility for bungling the actual execution of this plan.
00:10:30.620
When I came into office, I inherited a deal that President Trump negotiated with the Taliban.
00:10:35.620
Under his agreement, U.S. forces would be out of Afghanistan by May 1, 2021, just a little over three months after I took office.
00:10:48.600
U.S. forces had already drawn down during the Trump administration from roughly 15,500 American forces to 2,500 troops in country.
00:11:00.280
And the Taliban was at its strongest militarily since 2001.
00:11:07.640
The choice I had to make as your president was either to follow through on that agreement or be prepared to go back to fighting the Taliban in the middle of the spring fighting season.
00:11:23.060
It just looks so weak for the president of the United States to come out and say, it was not my fault.
00:11:35.940
Already our country looks extremely weak because we bungled the withdrawal.
00:11:39.520
And now the president of the United States can't even man up and take responsibility.
00:11:43.080
So it was pathetic and it was a rough start to his speech.
00:11:47.520
But then, incredibly, he then went on to contradict everything he said.
00:11:51.460
And he doubled down on his decision and said he was proud of it.
00:11:55.020
Now, if you want to make the right decision, I would strongly recommend you check out rockauto.com.
00:12:00.680
I'm going to give you two different visions of your Saturday afternoon.
00:12:06.460
So you go to the brick and mortar auto parts store and you show up and then you wait for a little bit and you're waiting in line.
00:12:10.980
And then a guy starts asking you questions, what make is your car, what model, what year, what color, what this, what that.
00:12:17.840
But finally, he figured out, he goes in the back of the store.
00:12:24.060
He probably goes to rockauto.com, by the way, orders the part.
00:12:27.140
He says, okay, it's going to take a week and then come back in a week and he's going to charge you twice as much.
00:12:34.580
They've got all the parts available for your car or truck.
00:12:38.620
They do not charge higher prices for the do-it-yourselfers versus the pros.
00:12:45.440
And they're a family business that's been serving auto parts customers online for 20 years.
00:12:53.100
See all the parts available for your car or truck.
00:12:54.880
Write Knowles, K-N-W-L-E-S, in their How Did You Hear About Us box, so they know that we sent you.
00:13:02.600
Joe Biden opens up his first remarks on Afghanistan by blaming everyone but him
00:13:08.120
and slurring his speech and mispronouncing words and it was really weak stuff.
00:13:11.040
But then at some point, I guess as his speechwriter was writing the speech, he realized, man, this is bad stuff.
00:13:16.200
Okay, I'm going to have to completely change course, make a 180-degree pivot and say that I stand by this decision and it was the right decision.
00:13:26.480
And Joe Biden actually starts to make a little bit more sense when he does that.
00:13:33.840
After 20 years, I've learned the hard way that there was never a good time to withdraw U.S. forces.
00:13:47.320
This is the point that all the people who say that we should have stayed in Afghanistan,
00:13:51.000
who are many people in the kind of liberal establishment and some people in the neoconservative establishment,
00:13:58.660
But the people who say we should have stayed in Afghanistan beyond this withdrawal and that it was a mistake to pull out.
00:14:06.180
The only logical conclusion of that is that we should stay in Afghanistan forever.
00:14:11.700
I spoke to my friend Charles Kessler yesterday, who was giving his expert analysis of Afghanistan,
00:14:17.500
and he pointed out that to democratize Afghanistan, as was George W. Bush's mission, would take about 800 years probably.
00:14:27.120
It took 700 years from the Magna Carta in England to a full inclusive democracy,
00:14:33.460
the sort of thing that the State Department is talking about.
00:14:36.580
I'm going to say the English were a little better suited for it and their political institutions were better suited for it.
00:14:49.820
Are we going to stay in Afghanistan for 800 years?
00:14:53.820
Maybe some people believe that we should just hold Afghanistan as an imperial territory forever.
00:15:02.980
Notice, though, how the people who think we should have stayed in Afghanistan, they never admit that.
00:15:06.760
They never admit that that's what they're really saying because they know the American people don't want it because 70% of the Americans wanted to get out of Afghanistan because we don't want to have an overseas empire because we still view ourselves as a republic and a nation state that doesn't just govern the entire world.
00:15:19.600
And maybe that's right, and maybe that's wrong, and maybe we have to be a world empire, but that's the way the situation stands.
00:15:25.100
And so Joe Biden's saying, you know, five more years, 10 more years wouldn't have made a difference.
00:15:31.140
But if Afghanistan is unable to mount any real resistance of the Taliban now, there is no chance that one year, one more year, five more years, or 20 more years of U.S. military boots on the ground would have made any difference.
00:15:53.260
I hate to say that Joe Biden got it, you know, like a stop clock twice a day.
00:15:58.220
And I think a lot of conservatives understand that, too.
00:16:07.720
We want to be, we want to run Afghanistan for 800 years.
00:16:11.360
Not, not like we're in Germany, not like we're in South Korea, even.
00:16:15.880
Those, those, if we withdrew, those places wouldn't completely collapse.
00:16:21.240
Even before we got there, those places did have some kind of a political tradition.
00:16:28.220
Afghanistan is a group of warring tribes that have been killing each other and repelling invaders for a very, very long time.
00:16:35.120
With no political tradition of democracy or, or whatever else you want to install there.
00:16:44.500
Wouldn't it, it basically always kind of would have looked like this.
00:16:51.680
But the just a few more years brigade, I think is not being totally honest here.
00:16:57.520
Then Biden goes back to his ridiculous, mealy-mouthed excuse making.
00:17:03.120
You know, there were a lot of excuses in this speech, but I think his excuse for the scenes that are going on right now of people falling off of airplanes,
00:17:12.220
scrambling, of, of helicopters lifting people out of the embassy, of all these sorts of things.
00:17:22.820
We have safely shut down our embassy and transferred our diplomats.
00:17:28.800
Our diplomatic presence is now consolidated at the airport as well.
00:17:35.240
Our diplomatic presence is now consolidated at the airport.
00:17:40.380
That is a really clever way of saying that the Taliban ran you out of your embassy,
00:17:45.140
chased you down to the airport with thousands of Afghans,
00:17:48.260
and they were clinging to your planes as they were taking off.
00:17:53.040
And that, and then of course afterward, after he gave this speech, which was pathetic,
00:17:59.800
I felt frankly, it was just about the best he could do.
00:18:02.720
After he gave the speech, he didn't take a single question.
00:18:12.700
than pass this decision on to another president of the United States,
00:18:56.440
Even still, did you notice the trick of this whole speech?
00:19:12.560
why did the administration bungle the withdrawal from Afghanistan?
00:19:17.320
Why did this go basically as poorly as it possibly could have,
00:19:24.920
the Taliban wasn't going to come take over right away.
00:19:27.080
The Biden administration said it wasn't going to happen from a Friday to a Monday.
00:19:31.520
we're not going to see helicopters like Saigon.
00:19:48.000
I don't think he's competent when it comes to actual statecraft.
00:19:59.080
I know that some Republicans push back at me on this,
00:20:01.660
but the guy has lasted in national politics for 50 years.
00:20:08.700
the guy managed to get himself picked to be vice president.
00:20:11.660
The guy managed to become president of the United States.
00:20:19.780
And what he is pursuing here is the number one rule of political communications,
00:20:25.740
which is don't answer the question you are asked.
00:20:32.880
You see this, good politicians do this on TV all the time.
00:20:38.160
but good, good politicians do this in their speeches.
00:20:42.660
hey, here's the explanation of why we bungled this withdrawal,
00:20:46.240
he said, hey, I think we should pull out of Afghanistan.
00:20:49.180
Yet, duh, 70% of Americans agree with you on that.
00:20:51.660
There's nothing courageous about offering that point of view.
00:21:15.760
And now we're going to take in tens of thousands,
00:21:18.860
maybe hundreds of thousands of Afghan refugees.
00:21:24.540
from one of the most terrorist-laden countries on planet Earth.
00:21:34.860
She said the strategy is invade the world, invite the world.
00:21:39.520
We invade the world, we disrupt things like in Libya, like in Syria,
00:21:46.460
we bring all of these foreign nationals to America.
00:21:52.860
Actually, even many more liberal left-wing countries in Europe
00:22:01.120
Now, you absolutely should not miss your chance to win a trip for two,
00:22:05.400
you and a guest, to the Daily Wire studios to see Candace live.
00:22:24.900
that unpacks trending political and cultural topics
00:22:36.920
you also get access to the Morning Wire newsletter
00:22:46.440
because right now we're offering a one-month free trial.
00:22:56.640
Well, the Sweet Baby Gang is in need of a sweet baby anthem.
00:23:00.980
All submissions should be in the form of YouTube video links.
00:23:07.900
But you, the viewer, will be voting on which song wins.
00:23:10.240
To enter, go to dailywire.com slash sbgsubmissions.
00:23:14.020
And on August 25th, voting will take place on Labor Day.
00:23:30.520
The United States is preparing to take in tens of thousands,
00:23:44.880
if not hundreds of thousands of people from Afghanistan
00:23:51.220
You know, frankly, I don't think the United States broke Afghanistan.
00:23:54.280
Actually, Afghanistan today is exactly the same as when we found it.
00:23:57.560
Although they got a little slap on the wrist for 20 years
00:24:03.240
But it's not as though the country is in worse shape today
00:24:13.420
because the Taliban had allowed terrorist cells to flourish there.
00:24:23.540
We occupied the country militarily for 20 years
00:24:30.220
So I actually don't want to hear that we've left the country worse off
00:24:37.500
And the argument is going to be now we've got to take in
00:24:39.460
endless numbers of Afghan citizens to come into the United States.
00:24:48.940
if the Afghans are not going to stay and fight for their own country,
00:24:52.080
then should they at least go to countries in the region?
00:24:59.140
and then plan their assault back on the oppressive regime in their own country?
00:25:03.720
Why don't they fight for their countries, is what I'm saying.
00:25:06.200
The argument you hear from the liberal imperialists is,
00:25:08.500
well, these people, they fought for us, they helped us,
00:25:13.240
and now we've got to bring them to the United States.
00:25:15.340
As though the Afghans have no interests of their own,
00:25:20.040
as though their helping the United States was just pure charity.
00:25:25.820
I am glad for the Afghans who helped the government of the United States
00:25:44.380
And now the United States is leaving after 20 long years.
00:25:47.560
And so Afghanistan does need to form its own country.
00:25:51.940
Afghanistan does need to defend itself at a certain point.
00:25:55.240
And the people there need to stay and fight for their country.
00:26:00.520
Why don't they go to Iraq, another country that we invaded?
00:26:05.100
Why don't they go to any of our allies in the region?
00:26:18.540
when the time is right and defend their country?
00:26:27.820
which is why the movement of people into the United States
00:26:31.120
is the largest movement of human beings ever in recorded history.
00:26:49.780
we aren't expected to take in all of the refugees.
00:26:54.920
and there's no reason to put that language on the show.
00:27:25.240
because then we're going to lose our own country