The Michael Knowles Show - July 02, 2026


Friendly Fire: The JD Vance Debate, Midterm Madness & Return of the Firing Squad

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Ep. 2006 - WORST Ruling Ever: The Supreme Court Betrays America Ep. 2008 - GOP Launches A Secret Weapon On Libs: Goth "Baddies"

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 9 minutes

Words per minute

195.64

Word count

13,534

Sentence count

812

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

37

sentences flagged

Hate speech

43

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, the guys discuss the FIFA World Cup, the current state of the sport of soccer in the United States, and whether or not the World Cup is a good or bad thing for the country. Plus, the boys debate the best way to make money off of soccer.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 visit betmgm casino and check out the newest exclusive the price is right fortune pick
00:00:06 betmgm and game sense remind you to play responsibly 19 plus to wager ontario only
00:00:12 please play responsibly if you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to
00:00:16 you please contact connects ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge
00:00:23 betmgm operates pursuant to an operating agreement with i-gaming ontario
00:00:27 Before you knew what a stock was, you traded snacks, cards, turns.
00:00:34 That instinct to trade didn't disappear.
00:00:37 It just grew up.
00:00:38 With no minimums, no monthly fees, and 100 free trades, TD Easy Trade taps into that instinct.
00:00:44 Because you are made to trade.
00:00:46 And TD Easy Trade is made to help.
00:00:48 So what was your reaction when FIFA tried to steal that World Cup game away from us?
00:00:54 Yeah, no, I mean, I've been obviously watching the coverage for, you know, I can't even sleep. I'm so, because Pele, right, was kicking it with his head. I'll tell you, man, I am so black-pilled that Americans are taking soccer seriously.
00:01:12 Well, we're taking it seriously because we're finally good at it.
00:01:15 Yeah, I hate that. I don't want us to be good at it. I don't want us to play it.
00:01:18 No, this is a good rule.
00:01:19 No, this is a good rule.
00:01:20 Look, here, this is not being anti-American already. I want us to be great at everything.
00:01:24 a poverty ball. I hate this freaking sport. It sucks. It's third world. It's gay. And I don't 0.99
00:01:29 like it. I mean, but if we get good at it, then it's the most important sport. That's the way I
00:01:36 see it. I feel the same way. I feel the same way about like the Olympics. I just want America to
00:01:43 be the best at everything. I want us to kick everyone's ass. Do you want us to be the best 1.00
00:01:47 at transgender ballet? USAID was funding that in the Philippines. Should we, let's say they start
00:01:53 a transgender ballet league and america joins do we want to be the best or the worst i want to be 0.99
00:01:58 the worst in that um yeah i i mean now we get to the question whether soccer is inherently immoral
00:02:04 michael yeah it's inherently immoral i'm not going that i'm not quite there though i'm close
00:02:09 it's that i find it inherently well it is the most corrupt sport i mean by far is it that i actually
00:02:15 yeah well i mean i mean they're literally trying to get us out of the tournament right now i mean
00:02:19 that's that's what's happening is 100 the most corrupt sport our best our best score was just
00:02:23 red carded for legitimately no reason because fifa decided that it's impossible for the united
00:02:29 states to essentially make the quarter so that's that's the right am i getting this right ben this
00:02:33 is the other thing is it's like it does seem anti-american i'm not even just intrinsically
00:02:38 in the sport i mean like the people who play it and fifa and whatever they don't seem to be super
00:02:44 pro america and also if we're gonna have a world championship i want it to be like baseball where
00:02:49 where we just declare what the world is.
00:02:52 Like we do the World Series,
00:02:53 there's us in Canada.
00:02:54 But see, this is someone
00:02:56 who should be a big fan of soft power.
00:03:00 The World Cup here in America
00:03:01 has been the biggest soft power export
00:03:05 of American values that I've seen
00:03:07 in years, in decades.
00:03:09 All these people are going to go back home
00:03:11 and demand of their politicians, 0.93
00:03:12 why don't we have air conditioning? 1.00
00:03:14 Why don't we have showers at work?
00:03:16 Why don't we have all these things?
00:03:17 This World Cup has gone so well, and all of these foreign fans who came over have been so impressed by all the different aspects of it, that they're going to go back home and export American values and capitalism and say, what are we doing living the way that we currently live when we've seen the way that people live in America? 0.80
00:03:34 We've seen Buckees.
00:03:34 That's something that's great. 0.99
00:03:36 Yeah.
00:03:36 And it doesn't require any more money for the Pentagon.
00:03:38 Yeah.
00:03:39 No, look.
00:03:39 Actually, that's the best argument to watch soccer that I've ever heard in my entire life and ever will hear. 0.99
00:03:44 The fear, of course, with all of this cross-cultural pollination is that, you know, is it us exporting our soft power or are we just importing third worldism and, you know, this kind of lame sport? 0.98
00:03:55 But to your point, yes, people are talking about Buc-ee's, they're talking about Waffle House, they're talking about ranch dressing. 0.99
00:04:00 And did you see the guy Freddy is apparently going to the White House?
00:04:06 Well, so he was invited.
00:04:09 Here's the thing with Freddy, and I don't know if you've followed this.
00:04:12 We've been paying attention to it on the opinion side.
00:04:13 The backlash against him on the internet has been insane because basically people dug up some vaguely right of center things that he might have tweeted out in the past and things that, you know, they've gone after him basically as being someone who clearly wants to stay sort of, you know, he hasn't shown his face.
00:04:36 He wants to stay, have some degree of anonymity and like be normal when he gets back from this.
00:04:40 Probably never had any expectation of going viral.
00:04:42 But I also think it's phenomenal in the sense that all these different people, he is one of many, and there are so many people who are going to go back and, I think, import the values that we still have here in this country that are good and are valuable back.
00:04:57 I think that this has been one of the best things that we could possibly do in America's 250th, and I did not expect that.
00:05:03 I honestly thought it could be a complete crap show, but it turns out to be great.
00:05:07 Yeah. Okay. Look, you, you have done more to convince me to like soccer than anyone has ever 0.98
00:05:14 done. You don't have to watch it. I'm not saying you have to watch it.
00:05:18 I, you know what I wanted? Oh, first of all, I guess I should say it's friendly fire.
00:05:28 The 4th of July is coming up. So we're all getting ready to celebrate Somali independence 0.98
00:05:33 day in columbus ohio i don't know if anyone's going to make the trek out there but do you guys
00:05:37 do you have any big fourth of july plans uh might have my uh yes that's like that's an actual thing
00:05:47 we are right on the verge yeah no we are right on the verge of of baby time uh i thought like
00:05:54 one of the reasons that i can't stick around for the entire broadcast as you can hear my voice is
00:05:58 totally gone the reason my voice is totally gone is because like two nights ago my wife started
00:06:03 having contractions about 20 minutes apart and we thought for sure it was time to go to the hospital
00:06:06 and uh that lasted until about two o'clock in the morning at which point it abated so i was so short
00:06:12 on sleep that it totally wrecked my voice but yeah i mean any any moment and and i've had a deal
00:06:16 for 20 years with my wife uh which is that if the baby is born between july 2nd and july 4th
00:06:23 any year but particularly into 50 year then i get to use a founding father name so this is like uh
00:06:29 So this is exciting.
00:06:32 So governor, I assume, or are you going to flow what the options are?
00:06:36 Gouverneur Morris, yeah.
00:06:37 Gouverneur Morris is going to be, yeah, exactly.
00:06:41 But there are some good ones to choose from.
00:06:44 Jefferson Shapiro sounds kind of wild, but there are some possibilities.
00:06:49 Charles Carroll Shapiro, that could be a good.
00:06:52 Dude, if your kid is born on the 4th of July, in the 250th, that would be,
00:06:57 it's like Providence, you know, Providence has its ways. God has its way in history,
00:07:03 has his way rather. Okay. Now, well then if I only have you for like five seconds,
00:07:07 what I am told on this schedule that we have to talk about, and I actually do want to talk to you
00:07:11 about is I was just in DC. I'm not totally on baby watch yet, but the reason I look terrible
00:07:19 and sound only slightly better is because I've been traveling all over. We were in DC.
00:07:24 I was already going for the unveiling of this statue of my great, great, great, great, great
00:07:28 grandpa, Simon Knowles, part of the American Revolution displays. And then I was stopping by
00:07:32 the great American state fair, play the yes or no game. But then at the last minute, the vice
00:07:36 president was able to make some time. He actually gave us a whole hour to interview him about his
00:07:41 book and Iran and 2028 and the Democrats and all this stuff. And so did you, Ben, I don't want to
00:07:48 presume. Did you catch any of the interview? Yeah, I did. I caught much of the interview,
00:07:53 actually. I thought you did a good job. It was a really interesting interview.
00:07:57 Obviously, I have significant disagreements with the vice president on a wide variety of issues,
00:08:00 as we've discussed on the program. I thought that, to me, the kind of bizarre fixation that
00:08:08 the vice president has on criticizing people who are mad at the MOU is, I think, unbecoming for him.
00:08:14 He's far more critical of the people who are critical of the MOU than he is the people who have been legitimately undermining the war and siding with Iran the entire time, which I find bizarre.
00:08:22 But obviously, listen, he's really well-spoken.
00:08:25 He's very smooth.
00:08:26 Yeah, and I thought you did a good job of the interview.
00:08:28 No, thank you.
00:08:29 I appreciate it.
00:08:29 You know, it's funny that you mentioned that, the criticism of criticizing the people who are criticizing the MOU.
00:08:34 Because I did, even when he was talking about that, I wanted to clarify.
00:08:37 I said, hold on, you're talking about the people who are upset about the war not continuing versus, you know, it's unclear which critics he was talking about.
00:08:44 And, uh, but you made that clear. I, my take on it is that the media, at least, I don't know if
00:08:50 it's really the admin as much, but the media at least had made him kind of the face of the MOU.
00:08:55 And so criticism of the MOU is often seen as criticism of him, even though obviously look,
00:09:00 it's, Oh, I mean, listen, I've criticized him directly for the MOU. I mean, I'm not gonna put
00:09:04 it on the media. I've criticized the president for signing it, but JD Vance made himself the
00:09:07 face of this. He personally negotiated it. He continues to personally do press on behalf of
00:09:12 an MOU that is currently falling apart, not just in the Strait of Hormuz, but also because
00:09:16 an actual good peace plan has been put forward in Lebanon, which runs directly against the
00:09:21 MOU, you know, Vance's approach, which has been to essentially take sort of an Obama-esque
00:09:26 tack with regard to opponents of the MOU.
00:09:29 All they want is endless war.
00:09:30 They just want endless bombing.
00:09:31 That's what they're promoting.
00:09:32 And we've discussed this on the show multiple times on Friendly Fire.
00:09:35 Like, what would alternatives be?
00:09:36 I mean, one alternative would be just to walk away from the strait and not hand them things. 0.85
00:09:39 Another alternative would be to bomb Harga Island and provide as much aerial defense for the Saudis, Bahrain, and UAE as possible and basically destroy the Iranian economic capacity from this point forward. 0.81
00:09:50 Another possibility would be to essentially arm up all of our allies and then attempt to actually project into the Strait of Hormuz. 0.80
00:09:58 And if the Saudis don't like it, tell the Saudis to stick it. 0.57
00:10:00 Project Freedom is something that the president wanted to do. And the Saudis apparently said, no, I have never and will never understand the idea that if we are funding and paying for a base in Saudi Arabia, Saudi Arabia gets to tell us what to do with that base. That's insane to me. I think that we should tell the Saudis, listen, we're paying for your defense. All your F-35s belong to us.
00:10:20 Right. But now we're trying to protect you from your moral nemesis in Iran. 0.99
00:10:24 If we feel like opening the strait using bases that we are supplying, staffing and running, then we're just going to do that. 0.98
00:10:30 But in any case, those are all, I think, fair critiques of the MOU without reference to eternal war, forever war.
00:10:38 And I don't like the dumbed down version of this politics that sounds very much like Barack Obama's defense of the JCPOA, where Obama would say, if you oppose the JCPOA, it's because you want a forever war with Iran or you want a nuclear war with Iran or you want to obliterate.
00:10:49 Iranian civilization or anything like that. I get the criticism, but isn't it in the context
00:10:54 of not just the GOP, but in the context of Trump, a criticism of endless war is not just
00:10:59 Obama-ian, it's also Trump-ian. Trump in 2016, one of his big breaks with the rest of the GOP
00:11:07 is he criticized George Bush for endless wars and specifically Iraq. So when the vice president
00:11:12 comes out and uses that language, that seems to me to be very much in line with Trump.
00:11:17 Well, the problem is that Trump's version of the endless war.
00:11:20 Hold on.
00:11:21 Ben, talk.
00:11:22 I actually, I've not had the time to watch the interview yet.
00:11:27 I have to ask you, did you ask the vice president about his criticism?
00:11:30 Me, personally.
00:11:31 Did he criticize you?
00:11:33 When he went on Megyn Kelly, Megyn Kelly read him a list of things that had been said about the MOU by some people, by Mark Levin, by others.
00:11:42 But then one of them was from me.
00:11:44 and that was what led into him saying all these people just want to keep the war going on forever
00:11:48 they want to keep bombing until all the iranians really oh as someone to get the ratings someone
00:11:54 who opposed the iraq war the iraq war that by the way tons of people supported including his old
00:12:00 boss david from who was calling people like me unpatriotic conservatives at the time that we
00:12:04 opposed the iraq war i i think it's really i think it's unfortunate and i think it's beneath him
00:12:11 to suggest that people like me who do not,
00:12:15 in fact, I've been, you know,
00:12:17 really do want to just walk away from this thing.
00:12:20 I think this deal is bad. 1.00
00:12:21 Don't want to hand the Iranians any money. 1.00
00:12:23 Want to keep bombing until all the Iranians are dead. 0.99
00:12:27 That, I didn't realize, 0.98
00:12:28 I think, Ben, you might have frozen up a little bit.
00:12:30 I don't think that the, you know,
00:12:34 it wouldn't have been great to bring up that question
00:12:36 had I known about it.
00:12:37 In fact, I think to get the real ratings up,
00:12:40 I should have had you walk out from the back,
00:12:41 like, well, we have him here. Ben Dominic, you are the father. That's, wow, that's amazing.
00:12:47 Could you have the glass shattering sound before I walk out? I just think that I have to agree
00:12:56 with Ben. I think that he's, it's unfortunate that he's using that argument because there's
00:13:02 a lot of us who back the president, who think that he did something that was bold here,
00:13:08 who just don't like the nature of this deal
00:13:10 and who certainly don't want to keep 0.58
00:13:12 bombing the Iranians forever. 0.86
00:13:14 Are you kidding? 0.97
00:13:15 Hold on, didn't Ben, our other pal Ben on here
00:13:17 just said he did want to keep bombing the Iranians, didn't you?
00:13:19 No, I actually didn't.
00:13:21 Nothing that I just implied actually said.
00:13:23 You said to bomb Karg Island.
00:13:24 None of which, none of which.
00:13:25 But bombing Karg Island is not bombing 0.99
00:13:28 until every Iranian is dead, Mike. 0.95
00:13:29 I'm confused. 0.97
00:13:30 No, I'm not saying every Iranian is dead. 0.98
00:13:32 Well, hold on.
00:13:33 Karg Island is a small island off the coast of Iran
00:13:36 with a completely military population,
00:13:39 it would take presumably about three B-2 sorties
00:13:42 to finish Harga Island,
00:13:44 and then you would never have to go there again.
00:13:45 That does not sound like an endless bombing of Iran
00:13:47 resulting in the death of 90 million citizens to me.
00:13:50 I might be getting that wrong,
00:13:51 but I'm not sure that's how bombs work.
00:13:53 No, no, I'm not saying, look, I don't know.
00:13:56 I actually didn't even hear the vice president's comments
00:13:58 about, you know, destroying all this.
00:14:00 I guess President Trump did say
00:14:01 he was going to destroy the whole civilization,
00:14:03 but I didn't hear that.
00:14:04 He's the only one who's threatened to do it.
00:14:05 I didn't threaten it, neither did Ben Domenich.
00:14:07 But yeah, there you go.
00:14:08 No, I just mean the issue here with the MOU, I think everybody can agree, and I predicted
00:14:13 this from the beginning, that if we did end this with a deal, the deal would be deeply
00:14:17 dissatisfying.
00:14:18 So I don't think anybody disagrees on that.
00:14:19 But it just seems like right now we have a couple of options, which is either, maybe
00:14:23 there's a third, but you get some version of the MOU, or you get some version of continuing
00:14:29 to bomb them and fire missiles at them.
00:14:31 Or, you know, you could walk away, but now you're walking away with Iran in control of the Strait of Hormuz, so now you're in a much worse position. 0.91
00:14:38 And they're effectively in control of the Strait anyway. 0.96
00:14:40 Honestly, I'm of the opinion that we'd be better off walking away from the Strait of Hormuz completely, retaining the sanctions, making them float their ghost ship.
00:14:48 Yeah, that's right.
00:14:49 Like replace the MOU with a ham and cheese sandwich.
00:14:51 Yeah, exactly.
00:14:53 I agree with this.
00:14:54 So that was one issue that I had with what the vice president was saying.
00:14:57 The other one was, of course, the vice president's bizarre attack on Milton Friedman's economics, as though Milton Friedman's economics stopped applying in the 1980s for some unspecified reason, because the vice president in 2019 read Rerum Novarum, which means that now Milton Friedman is irrelevant, which is a strange timeline, since it turns out that he wrote that after Rerum Novarum.
00:15:17 Hold on, here's the clip for those who didn't see it.
00:15:19 part of why Milton Friedman's ideas made more sense in the 1980s is because they were being
00:15:28 advocated in a country that still had a very rich and powerful institutional Christianity.
00:15:35 And so like being laissez-faire in a world where there are Christian guardrails on everything
00:15:42 is a much different proposition than being laissez-faire in a world where
00:15:47 globalized liberalism has become the sort of status quo of american elites
00:15:52 okay so i'm not sure i disagree with that yeah there we go all right i i i thought i don't i
00:16:00 don't think he's wrong there i think i think that one of the problems that we've known about when
00:16:05 it comes to the american capitalism is that we didn't just import cheap televisions for people
00:16:11 to watch we didn't just import you know these different goods uh from around the world that
00:16:16 people enjoy here in America. We also imported a lot of their values with it unintentionally.
00:16:21 We thought that this was going to change China, but it changed us. And it's one of these things 0.92
00:16:25 that I think is sort of an underestimated aspect of it. You need kind of both of these things
00:16:30 to have a really strong nation. That doesn't make Milton Friedman's approach wrong. It means that
00:16:36 we need a religious revival in America, which is what I have argued consistently with my
00:16:42 atheist libertarian friends, you guys should be the biggest fans of like Rick Santorum or,
00:16:47 you know, pick your, pick your, Mike Huckabee, what have you, religious revivalism, because you
00:16:52 need that strength of society and family and everything else that goes with it in order to
00:16:57 have the type of laissez-faire free nation that we've enjoyed for centuries. Ben, other Ben,
00:17:02 you totally disagree. Well, so I agree, obviously, that church is very, very important. I mean,
00:17:08 I've spent my entire life preaching in favor of the idea that people need to go to church.
00:17:11 And obviously, church membership was higher in the 1980s than it is now.
00:17:15 I mean, if we're going to get factual about this, the reality is the church attendance in America really started to decline around the year 2000.
00:17:20 That's really when things started to drop fairly precipitously.
00:17:23 As late as 1999, 70 percent of people, adults, were members of a church synagogue, a church or a synagogue in the United States.
00:17:32 But the idea that the fundamental basis of economics changes because of church attendance, and therefore what you need is government to somehow come in as the centralizing force that's going to re-inculcate a common good.
00:17:45 So welfare programs or redistributionism or government regulation are going to re-inculcate virtue in the American population.
00:17:53 It seems to me that if we are going to look at a correlation, the growth of government since the 1960s has been exponential.
00:18:00 the attendance in church has dropped radically in that same exact period in fact i think it can make
00:18:05 the very strong case that actually one of the reasons for attendance declining in church and
00:18:10 church membership declining is government actually replacing the functionality of church in everyday
00:18:15 life for people uh like this is certainly true to say social security is that you know if the
00:18:20 government pays for social security you don't take care of grandma and she doesn't live in your house
00:18:23 if you don't i don't have to give as much charity through my church or be a member of my church
00:18:27 or engage in the values of my church
00:18:30 in order to gain access
00:18:31 to all of the institutional support of the church
00:18:34 in order to just go pick up a check from the government.
00:18:36 And so this bizarre attempt
00:18:37 to sort of reverse engineer virtue
00:18:40 via government fiat, government redistributionism
00:18:42 and centralization of economic resources,
00:18:44 it's completely backward to me.
00:18:46 I think when you have that dollar sign
00:18:49 as like the primary motivation in your life too,
00:18:51 that also allows for the type of lies to emerge
00:18:55 that build off of that social security experience
00:18:58 that all of these socialists,
00:18:59 who I know we're going to talk about later,
00:19:01 you know, can exploit
00:19:03 because everything becomes just a monetary issue.
00:19:06 It's all about, you know, who gets the money,
00:19:08 who's scrabbling over this piece of the pie.
00:19:11 And there is no kind of shared communitarian value
00:19:14 that brings people together.
00:19:16 And that says, I mean,
00:19:17 just think about something as simple
00:19:18 as the cost of childcare in America
00:19:20 when we have gone from an era
00:19:22 in which, you know, relatives and friends,
00:19:24 and you could have trust teenagers that you could trust to watch your kids and not just
00:19:28 have their nose in their phones. Like that's something that definitely we have lost here
00:19:33 in the recent decades. And it's a major problem. And I think that it's one of the reasons why all
00:19:39 these people are able to exploit a message of anti-capitalism to a bunch of dumb people who 0.97
00:19:44 don't understand that it's what made the country as powerful as it was in the first place. 0.94
00:19:48 But also when we talk about the growth of government, I agree with a lot of those
00:19:52 observations. But we can't only think about it from a quantitative perspective. There is also
00:19:56 a qualitative perspective. In some ways, in the earlier parts of our country, we had a much bigger
00:20:02 government role than we do today when we were prosecuting blasphemy. At the very least, when 0.99
00:20:06 we had blue laws that said you couldn't sell goods on Sundays or restricted the sale of liquor or
00:20:13 what have you. So in some ways, we had a much bigger government then. Since the 60s, obviously,
00:20:18 You've had this massive growth in the welfare state, but you've also had court rulings that have said the government has to pull back on certain moral matters.
00:20:27 So I think there's a qualitative aspect there, too.
00:20:28 So, Michael, I agree with a lot of that, actually, but that's not what the vice president is suggesting.
00:20:32 He's not suggesting a return of blue laws and blasphemy laws.
00:20:35 He's suggesting massive governmental intervention in the economy, and that reverses the arrow of causality.
00:20:41 So I think that you can make a very solid historical case that church arrow capitalism because that's actually true.
00:20:48 I mean, the reality is that market capitalism in the West was actually an outgrowth originally of property rights rooted in sort of Catholic perceptions of property and then later adamrated by Protestant perceptions of the value of free markets, capitalism, innovation, and work ethic.
00:21:04 I mean, that's Max Faber.
00:21:05 And so you can say these institutions precede capitalism, which clearly is true, but I don't think that you can then say the Marxist thing, and it actually is a Marxist idea, that economics precedes social institutions.
00:21:16 And so what if we just change our economic system and then people go back to church?
00:21:20 That's actually not.
00:21:21 There are, I think we can say that political communities precede some social institutions or are coincidental with them.
00:21:29 And so, you know, in the way, and you can't really firmly separate politics from economics, though maybe the Marxists would like to focus much more on the material and the economic.
00:21:38 But the juxtaposition that the vice president is making here is not between Milton Friedman and Karl Marx.
00:21:44 it's between Milton Friedman and the economics of Alexander Hamilton. Last I checked,
00:21:49 Hamilton precedes Milton Friedman. I don't mean to diss Friedman. I like a lot about Friedman.
00:21:54 But there are some things that seem to be important for the government to take on. Namely,
00:21:59 under a totally laissez-faire system, which developed under the name of neoliberalism in
00:22:05 the last 40, 50 years, we've outsourced a lot of our manufacturing or supply change to a degree
00:22:11 that means that we are now very, very vulnerable to China.
00:22:15 If we ever were to go to a serious war with China, 0.92
00:22:17 we would be really up the creek without a paddle. 0.63
00:22:19 We saw a preview of that during COVID.
00:22:21 So that might suggest that maybe the government
00:22:23 could focus in a Hamiltonian way
00:22:25 on the development of industry in the United States
00:22:27 so that we're not in a dangerous situation.
00:22:28 The Hamiltonian argument on a national security level
00:22:30 is something that I've actually agreed with
00:22:33 and it makes sense to me.
00:22:34 I think that he's using what we would call in law school
00:22:36 an argument that proves too much.
00:22:38 He's basically saying that because
00:22:39 you're taking key industries and outsourcing them. Therefore, the government should be in control
00:22:44 of an enormous swath of American industry that has nothing to do with national security or just
00:22:48 call it national security and stuff it under that rubric. And I think that that's totally wrong.
00:22:53 And when he talks about Alexander Hamilton, I can guarantee you this, the idea that Alexander
00:22:57 Hamilton would have been in favor of the kinds of nationalization schemes, full scale, that are
00:23:01 being contemplated, or the gigantic welfare state that has been built, or the gigantic administrative
00:23:06 and regulatory state is totally insane. What Alexander Hamilton was stumping for in a national
00:23:09 bank was the idea that America ought to be able to pay its collective debt. That is the thing
00:23:14 that he was attempting to craft an institution to do. The entire purpose of the national bank
00:23:19 was basically to uphold the solvency of the United States because the United States kept
00:23:23 blowing out a bunch of meaningless paper notes. Now, if you're talking about consolidation under
00:23:29 a single institution, you may notice that the main concern of Alexander Hamilton, which was that
00:23:33 our good faith and credit be good is being undermined by the very institutions that J.D.
00:23:38 Vance is calling to expand because the full faith and credit of the United States is not being put
00:23:42 at risk by paper speculators in South Carolina. The full faith and credit of the United States
00:23:46 being put at risk by, yes, by Congress and by the Federal Reserve and by the Secretary of the
00:23:52 Treasury and by blowing out money at an exorbitant rate, unsupportable and unprecedented in all of
00:23:58 human history. Yeah, listen, I'm all for reigning back Congress. I think that long precedes the
00:24:03 Trump administration, certainly. But even to that, one last point of Friedman, and then right before,
00:24:07 I know I have to let you go, but I do want to talk about Tucker's new political party.
00:24:11 But one last point of Friedman, let's not forget, during the very height of Milton Friedman's
00:24:16 influence, which is a relatively recent innovation in American history, you also had no less a free
00:24:21 trader than Ronald Reagan protecting U.S. steel. Was he really doing that for national security
00:24:26 purposes? Harley Davidson's, agriculture. You had George W. Bush, for example, protecting
00:24:31 industries. So you can trace protectionism back to Alexander Hamilton, to George Washington.
00:24:36 It's precedented. It's just dumb. It's precedented. It's just dumb. It was not a good idea in the 1.00
00:24:40 80s. It wasn't a good idea when George W. Bushed it. It's a dumb idea now, unless you're doing it
00:24:43 for national security reasons. Okay. Now, before I let you go, big news, maybe. I actually don't 0.96
00:24:49 think it's that big news. But Tucker left the GOP. He's starting a new political party. It's
00:24:55 going to be a non-interventionist, America first, reformed political party. Where have I heard of
00:25:01 that before uh it's not easy can i just ask which which version of tucker is this party like like i
00:25:08 mean he he contains multitudes you know he is legion you know but it does i mean you look back
00:25:14 it's a funny question but there's a real answer to it i think the real answer is pap you can
00:25:18 right am i am i misreading that yes i know that's right that's right it's like the pap
00:25:22 you can version of the reform party in 2000 where pap you can in 1.4 percent of the vote but just
00:25:27 enough in uh in florida to cast the presidency to george w bush uh that's that his only role in
00:25:34 history pat buchanan um but the the the idea first of all it's not true okay tucker's saying he's 0.92
00:25:40 launching a third party he's not doing any of this shit but let's explain exactly what tucker is 0.75
00:25:43 doing here what tucker is doing here is he's blackmailing the republican party into embracing 0.96
00:25:47 his positions by claiming that he's going to posit a threat to the republican party from the outside
00:25:52 So what you actually have right now is Tucker trying to run a quasi-DSA play.
00:25:56 Essentially, he's looking at 2026.
00:25:58 2026 is going to be a disaster area for Republicans.
00:26:01 Right now, Republicans are running dead even or behind in all six of the various states in which they have races up to and including Iowa, Texas, and Alaska.
00:26:09 Tucker is looking at that. 0.97
00:26:10 He is hoping he wants the Republicans to get their asses kicked because then what he's going to say is the reason that they got destroyed is because they didn't cater to people like me. 0.99
00:26:18 and me sitting outside here with my non-existent third party, if only they'd engaged with me, 0.99
00:26:24 if only they'd come back to me, then they would have won. And so it's basically a blackmail play.
00:26:28 And it's smart. It's smart. But the idea that Tucker Carlson, who, again, says in that same
00:26:33 interview that he has no attention span and is widely known in the media as one of the lazier
00:26:37 members of the media, that Tucker is going to sit there with the actual nuts and bolts of building a
00:26:43 ground up political party based on the pretensions of thomas massey marjorie taylor green and joe
00:26:48 kent yeah uh good luck i mean listen my dream is that he starts a third party i would love for
00:26:53 tucker carlson to start a third party because then we could have a clear referendum on the 0.98
00:26:56 stupidity of his ideas but instead what he's going to do is not that what he's going to do 0.98
00:27:00 is he's going to falsely claim that 2026 happened because not because it was an off-air election 0.99
00:27:04 not because trump was unpopular on a wide variety of issues but because tucker carlson personally
00:27:09 was displeased with Donald Trump's policy on Iran and Epstein and all the rest. And therefore,
00:27:14 the only way to assure Republican victory going forward is to put Tucker Carlson in the driver's
00:27:21 seat of the party. And obviously, Tucker is very much aligned with J.D. Vann. So I think that's
00:27:24 the political move he's making here. You know, I could sense that this was just a replay of the
00:27:29 Reform Party, especially the 2000 Pat Buchanan version. Tucker himself. Can I disagree for a
00:27:35 second, I've met Pat Buchanan. I know Pat Buchanan. Tucker's no Pat Buchanan. Pat Buchanan
00:27:41 is smarter than Tucker. He's more consistent than Tucker. He is a more disciplined speaker than
00:27:48 Tucker. I still think that his 1992 convention speech was something that presaged. It is
00:27:54 essential viewing for anyone to understand American politics. And by the way, while being
00:27:59 referred to as a culture war speech it is mostly about economics it is not it is about it is about
00:28:05 crime economics and and working class issues and then they did this whole revisionist history
00:28:11 where it was like oh no he came in and destroyed hw's chances for re-election uh by turning it
00:28:16 into this uh you know election that was going to be about abortion and gays and stuff like that
00:28:20 the truth is that i think that you have to understand you need to understand pat buchanan
00:28:25 in order to understand politics.
00:28:27 I'm not sure you need to understand Tucker.
00:28:29 And I'm not sure it's possible to understand him
00:28:32 just given how crazy he's been in the last couple of years.
00:28:35 No, it's an interesting point.
00:28:36 And I guess, I mean, if the roadmap
00:28:38 for the new Tucker party or in Ben's view,
00:28:41 not like kind of fake out party is just,
00:28:44 okay, I'm gonna do what Pat Buchanan tried to do in 2000,
00:28:48 then you could, I mean, even to your point, Ben,
00:28:50 where you say, I don't compare Tucker to Pat Buchanan.
00:28:53 You say, well, if you're just gonna replay
00:28:54 the same script, then, you know, one, it can only happen first one time. And, and to your point,
00:29:00 other Ben, I really, this is very annoying, you know, having the only other two guys in the show.
00:29:03 Anyway, it, to your point, it like, it didn't work out. He got point. We'll figure this out
00:29:09 eventually. Yes. But, but it, it actually had not occurred to me. I can't read Tucker in when he
00:29:15 does these things that are really out there and I can't, some people in politics, I can read them
00:29:20 like an open book. Tucker, I couldn't figure out exactly what he was getting at here.
00:29:24 But sociopathy is very, very difficult to understand.
00:29:28 I think your read on that is probably right. I don't, I don't, Tucker's too smart to want to
00:29:33 start another political party. And he doesn't. And just by the way, there is a, there is our
00:29:38 sponsors at Calci have a market on Tucker running for president in 2028 himself. And I guess it's
00:29:45 currently at around 25%, something like that. Yeah. And I would short that. No way. I would
00:29:50 short that. Absolutely. He does not have the discipline. He does not have the discipline
00:29:55 to start a political party. He does not, definitely doesn't have the discipline to run for president.
00:29:59 All right. That's not going to. On that, I guess no one here is joining the Tucker party. No one,
00:30:03 you're not, neither of you are signing up. Okay. That's fine. But Ben, you are signing out. You
00:30:07 got, you're on baby watch. That's awesome. Everybody keep Ben and more in your prayers.
00:30:11 If your kid is born on 4th of July, I'm going to have severe birthday envy, but it would be very cool.
00:30:18 And I look forward to Governor Shapiro coming out.
00:30:22 Good to see you, sir.
00:30:23 Thanks so much, guys.
00:30:24 Now, all of you folks, the Declaration of Independence names three rights, life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
00:30:30 Notice that order.
00:30:31 Life comes first because without it, the other two mean nothing.
00:30:34 The founders understood this, and yet every day in America, unborn babies are denied that first and most basic right.
00:30:39 Pre-Born exists to change that.
00:30:42 I love Pre-Born.
00:30:43 It is a wonderful ministry.
00:30:45 It is one of my very favorite nonprofit organizations.
00:30:47 I personally support it.
00:30:48 I encourage you to give whatever you can.
00:30:51 And they're so good, they even fundraise for their administrative costs elsewhere.
00:30:54 So every dollar you give is going towards saving babies.
00:30:57 You give $28, that buys an ultrasound.
00:31:00 A mother who sees her baby on ultrasound for the first time is 80% more likely to choose life.
00:31:07 It is one of the best RIs you're going to get.
00:31:09 In honor of America's 250th birthday, we're asking our friends to prayerfully consider
00:31:14 a special gift of $250 to multiply your impact and help save even more lives.
00:31:19 Right now, donate.
00:31:20 About pound 250, say keyword baby.
00:31:22 That's pound 250, keyword baby.
00:31:24 Or go to preborn.com slash Knowles.
00:31:26 Preborn.com slash Knowles.
00:31:27 Every gift is tax-deductible.
00:31:28 Preborn.com slash Knowles.
00:31:31 Do we have Cabot?
00:31:33 Oh, we do.
00:31:34 We do.
00:31:35 Hey, Cabot, what's up?
00:31:37 And now it's less confusing because there's only one better.
00:31:38 Thank goodness.
00:31:39 It was driving me nuts, man. I've only worked in media for like 10 or 15 years. I couldn't figure out how to do it.
00:31:46 We got to be thing one and thing two or something like that.
00:31:50 So, all right, Cabot, we already covered my interview with the vice president and Iran and Tucker's new political party, which I heard you just joined.
00:31:59 But now I want to talk about the Dems. Where do the midterms stand?
00:32:04 Yeah, it's been really interesting.
00:32:06 I think given the last three or four months,
00:32:09 you would have expected Republicans
00:32:10 to have lost a ton of ground on the generic ballot
00:32:13 with regard to the midterms.
00:32:15 But if you actually look back,
00:32:16 the week before the war in Iran started,
00:32:18 Democrats were at like 47.5%,
00:32:20 Republicans in the high 43s.
00:32:23 Despite the last three or four months
00:32:25 of inflation going back up
00:32:27 and the war getting worse
00:32:28 and people not being happy with the war once it ended,
00:32:31 Democrats have only gained about half a percent
00:32:33 in the generic ballot.
00:32:34 And so I'm still maybe delusionally optimistic
00:32:38 that given the lack of momentum for the Democrats,
00:32:42 given the apparent ceiling that we're seeing,
00:32:44 given these new socialist candidates
00:32:46 that are going to give the Republicans people to point to
00:32:48 and make this race about,
00:32:51 that things maybe won't be as bad
00:32:53 as a lot of Republicans are bracing for.
00:32:55 I'm always the delusional optimist though.
00:32:57 But yeah, the big thing is just
00:33:00 what these socialist races are going to do
00:33:02 to the midterms more broadly.
00:33:05 And we talk about that a lot
00:33:06 on my new show, Wired In,
00:33:08 which we filmed right on the set.
00:33:09 Which Ben Dominic has been on
00:33:10 about half a dozen times.
00:33:12 And Michael Knowles,
00:33:13 what do we got to do to get you back?
00:33:14 Yeah, I did it.
00:33:15 No, I did it once.
00:33:17 And I got, I don't know,
00:33:18 I felt too intimidated.
00:33:19 You on that nice big set.
00:33:20 I kind of felt like you were
00:33:21 set and suit mogging me.
00:33:23 So I don't know, maybe I'd like to come back
00:33:25 now that we're in the heat of midterm season.
00:33:28 And you point out you got all these socialists,
00:33:30 but you're too rosy about it.
00:33:32 Ben, can you please bring us down to earth?
00:33:35 Yeah, so I actually think that this midterm is going to be terrible for Republicans.
00:33:40 And I think that they are likely to still hold the Senate.
00:33:45 But that's still, I think, something that is a lot closer than anyone expected it to be, just given the map.
00:33:51 Some of the decisions that they've made have made this a lot riskier.
00:33:56 We saw that New York Times poll, for instance, that has Ken Paxton tied with James Tallarico.
00:34:00 uh something uh along the lines of these supreme court cases that just came down uh they they
00:34:07 benefit tallarico because uh paxton is going to have to lean hard on the birthright citizenship
00:34:12 uh question uh he's going to have to support whatever the republicans coalesce around in
00:34:16 response to that tallarico gets to punt on uh the transgender sports question because he can
00:34:22 basically say texas decided not to have men and girls sports and i agree with them and that's
00:34:27 going to be fine. And I have nothing to do with that as a senator. And the problem that really
00:34:31 shows in that poll is, and it's been apparent across multiple polls actually, is that Paxton
00:34:36 is losing Hispanics to Tallarico dramatically. So you don't have the same type of situation that
00:34:43 you had with Ted Cruz, for instance, just two years ago. Now that doesn't mean that I don't
00:34:47 think Paxton's going to win. I actually do think he's going to win, but the amount of time that's
00:34:51 going to be spent backing someone like him, the amount of money that's going to have to go into
00:34:54 a state that should have been safe. That's stuff that comes away from other states that are much
00:34:59 riskier. Democrats are also trying to play fast and loose in a bunch of these situations. We've
00:35:04 seen them do it before, backing independent candidates in certain sentences. In Alaska,
00:35:09 they actually put a guy with the same name as Dan Sullivan on the ballot, which is pretty 0.87
00:35:14 ridiculous. The one thing that I do think, though, that we should keep in mind is the Democrats lost
00:35:19 this redistricting war. And so in a lot of these situations, these people are running in completely
00:35:25 new districts. And the candidates, therefore, you can't rely on a one-to-one comparison
00:35:30 compared to how they performed before because they have a different electorate that may not
00:35:35 know them, that has a new response to them. I think the real question here is if the Democratic
00:35:41 Party is able to basically pull the wool over the eyes of the independent voter, say that these
00:35:47 socialists that are confined to just these little spots in the country. Don't care about that.
00:35:51 Don't look at that. You know, there is no man behind the curtain who believes in Marx and
00:35:56 Engels. You know, we are instead going to, you know, try to, you know, turn this into a situation
00:36:02 where we are the party that's about affordability, that's about anti-corruption, that is anti-war,
00:36:08 that is, you know, going to make your gas prices come down, et cetera, et cetera. They're going to
00:36:12 try to run in that direction. And I think Republicans are going to run on crime and
00:36:18 calling Democrats crazy. That doesn't tend to be the kind of message that gets people out who
00:36:23 aren't already going to vote. Wow. Yeah. And so it makes me even more upset about the Supreme
00:36:28 Court decisions because the birthright citizenship one ultimately is much, much more important,
00:36:33 I think, than the Title IX decision, which seemed actually in contradiction to Gorsuch's view from
00:36:39 the Title VII decision. And I don't know, it seemed a little bit like they were kind of just
00:36:43 following the headlines and the opinion polls. But regardless, birthright citizenship, that is a
00:36:48 nation-shaping, like Demos-shaping event. And so that's obviously terrible for Republicans. But at
00:36:53 least we got the trans win, right? No, to your point, Ben, that takes the killer issue for the 1.00
00:36:59 Dems, especially in places like Texas. I mean, Ted Cruz really wrecked Colin Allred. When that race
00:37:06 looked like it might be a little tight. He destroyed him on the trans sports issue.
00:37:10 Now it's totally off the table. Yeah. It bails them out. And the last thing I would just say 0.97
00:37:16 about this is I think Republicans always miscalculate how much voters are actually
00:37:22 paying attention to the craziest things that congressmen and, in some cases, Senate candidates
00:37:28 in Michigan and in Maine, Senate candidates, or I'm assuming the craziest guy is going to win in
00:37:33 michigan uh that they always kind of count on that to help them across the country and i don't think
00:37:41 that that's actually the way it works in midterms it can help you when you're doing a national
00:37:45 election in a presidential year but it helps you less when it comes to these midterm elections
00:37:50 because it's it is more localized and it's more about people's immediate concerns i think
00:37:55 unfortunately republicans have been you know they've been throwing rocks at each other here
00:37:59 here in Washington. They can't get on the same page. White House and the Senate are split,
00:38:04 you know, and all these different, you know, House things or shenanigans are going on.
00:38:08 I just do not see a lot of signs that, you know, this is going to be a good situation,
00:38:14 you know, for Republicans. I know that there's a there's a Calci market on this, of course,
00:38:19 which party will win the U.S. Senate that you can check out. They're one of our sponsors,
00:38:24 of course. And I think that this is a situation where everything has tightened. People are a lot
00:38:30 more concerned about this than they were six months ago when Republicans were confident they
00:38:36 were going to hold that body. It could end up being 50-50, in which case, J.D. Vance, clear your
00:38:43 schedule. You're going to be voting a lot. Ben, I agree with you that I think the average primary
00:38:48 or the average midterm voter
00:38:50 maybe isn't super aware
00:38:52 of what Chevalier is doing
00:38:54 or what Kiros in Colorado is doing.
00:38:58 But I do think that Democrat leadership
00:39:00 is very aware of those people
00:39:02 and they're very scared of them.
00:39:04 And we've started to see Democratic leadership
00:39:05 be forced to embrace them.
00:39:07 We saw Kamala Harris this week come out
00:39:09 and call Momdani personally.
00:39:11 She called a number of pro-Palestinian groups.
00:39:14 Please, please, please do it.
00:39:16 Yeah. And we saw J.B. Pritzker try to run as a socialist. But we saw J.B. Pritzker. I beg you for America. Do it. Pritzker went on CNN and he said, yeah, the strategy of these socialist candidates, he didn't fully endorse them. He said their strategy is one that's going to win in 2026 and beyond.
00:39:32 Well, yeah, as a billionaire, he has to say that so they don't kill him.
00:39:35 Yeah, but my point is that I think that these candidates, while they might not have a huge
00:39:40 impact on Senate voters in Texas, they will have an impact on the broader perception of
00:39:46 Democrats in that they're going to force Democratic leadership to go further left for fear of
00:39:51 being eaten, as you point out.
00:39:52 Usually Pritzker's the one doing the eating, but in this case, he's the one getting eaten.
00:39:55 I wasn't going to say it.
00:39:55 A lot for people to feed on there.
00:39:57 But I think that's going to have an impact.
00:39:59 I'm sure he lost all that weight naturally.
00:40:00 Yeah.
00:40:01 Yeah. What I want to know about the DSA stuff, there was that poll that just came out that
00:40:06 showed that rank-and-file Dems have a higher opinion of the Democratic Socialists than they
00:40:12 do of Democrats in Congress. And you think, well, all right, that's a low bar. Democrats in Congress
00:40:17 aren't polling that well. But it's pretty scary that the Democrat voter would today prefer the
00:40:23 Socialists, who used to be this kind of fringe, weird, young element of the party, even six,
00:40:28 eight years ago, to now they're polling higher than the Democrats in Congress. What does that
00:40:33 tell you about the state of the party? To me, when I got that news, it reminded me of what we
00:40:40 saw after Charlie was killed, which is, you know, that itself was obviously a major personal trauma
00:40:45 for a lot of people and a political trauma. And then there was this additional political trauma,
00:40:49 which is that you found out 28% of young leftists agreed that it was okay and, you know,
00:40:55 it could be justified. And huge swaths throughout the mainstream left on television, in office,
00:41:02 they would all minimize or dismiss that killing. You say, okay, well, that's now a major political
00:41:06 scandal. You're seeing, I don't know, you're just seeing a lot of evidence coming out that the
00:41:13 Democrat party, you look at the California state senators, they just voted to allow child molesters
00:41:20 to run for office. They voted down a measure that would keep them out of office. That wasn't just-
00:41:24 more representation. They do. No, they do. I mean, the headlines, the headlines weren't even
00:41:29 as bad as the reality. I mean, who will speak for Epstein's Island? No, the original thing that
00:41:36 we were seeing in the headlines is Scott Wiener was the one who did this. And Scott Wiener is a
00:41:42 total freak and a pervert and a deviant, but it wasn't just him. It's like, I wish it were just 0.99
00:41:46 him. It's the mainstream dem, most of the dems on this panel. So what does that say about the party?
00:41:51 So can I just, I'm going to vote a random guy on X who I think had a great explanation for this. 0.97
00:41:58 Shout out to Roman Helmet guy. 1.00
00:42:00 America is a Latin American country now. 1.00
00:42:02 So let me explain politics. 0.99
00:42:04 We elect communists to kill the rich. 1.00
00:42:06 Communism brings poverty and crime. 1.00
00:42:07 So we elect fascists to kill the communists. 0.99
00:42:09 And then the fascists hand the economy to oligarchs. 1.00
00:42:11 So we elect communists to kill the rich. 0.74
00:42:14 And unfortunately, as someone who has been saying for a long time that I thought that American politics was starting to look more and more like Latin America, including, by the way, with Donald Trump, you know, you must, you know, elect the strong man, elect the man who's going to solve the problems, you know, kind of thing. 0.56
00:42:33 I think that that is unfortunately, dangerously what we are setting up in this situation, which is a takeover of a decrepit, octogenarian Democratic Party that is out of touch with its most engaged activist voters.
00:42:50 And it's going to, I think, completely reorient them.
00:42:53 We saw this happen to a degree with the Tea Party, but the Tea Party, basically what happened was their ideas were subsumed into the Republican Party and the fundamental Republican kind of framework that that, you know, three legged stool that we have talked about, you know, for to the nth degree that remained intact.
00:43:12 It just was sort of a change in priorities.
00:43:16 But I don't think this is just a change in priorities.
00:43:18 I think this is a change in one of the American parties.
00:43:21 And I think that, unfortunately, capitalism may end up being a monopartisan affair faster than we could even imagine.
00:43:29 We've had this huge movement of rehabbing Richard Nixon's image, and we've been Nixon-maxing this summer.
00:43:36 I think we might have to start Pinochet-maxing.
00:43:38 Y'all, don't threaten me with a good time.
00:43:40 We might have to start.
00:43:41 Pinochet did nothing wrong.
00:43:42 Exactly. But on the topic of socialism, that poll of the number of Democrats that view socialism favorably, I just can't help but think that that's more a reflection of their despair over the situation in America, their feeling that neither party is speaking for them.
00:43:57 And to that point, I do think that a lot of people who are embracing socialism, while the ideas obviously are abhorrent, they're not all wrong in saying that they have reason to be angry with the way that they've been treated in the country.
00:44:08 But I don't think that actually means what they necessarily think it means.
00:44:13 Like, I don't think most of them would actually support the Democratic Socialists of America
00:44:17 agenda.
00:44:17 And to that point, if you actually look at the agenda, we know that the DSA supports
00:44:22 universal health care, universal child care, and student loan forgiveness, and amnesty.
00:44:27 That's child's play compared to where the DSA platform actually is.
00:44:31 So this month, they published their new, what they call it, the Workers Deserve More plan.
00:44:36 The official plan from the DSA includes abolishing the Senate, defunding the entire War Department, quote, replacing the president and Supreme Court with an executive and judiciary chosen by and subordinate to Congress.
00:44:52 The official DSA platform is do away with the White House, do away with the presidency, do away with the War Department, do away with the Senate.
00:44:58 Establish the third international.
00:45:00 Yeah, do away with the cops, do away with the border.
00:45:02 I don't think that the average Democrat who says, yeah, socialism, I'd do it favorably.
00:45:06 I don't think they're supporting that.
00:45:08 But that is what the USA members are supporting.
00:45:10 But Kavit, can I ask you, I assume you probably saw that viral clip of AOC responding to the
00:45:15 question about, you know, J.D. Vance says you would be a really competitive candidate,
00:45:20 you know, if you ran for president.
00:45:22 And one of the things she says in that clip is about how people in her generation feel
00:45:30 like they've been handed you know a bad situation by the people who came before to me that argument
00:45:38 is the most powerful one that they have because it's true because the simple fact is that the 0.94
00:45:44 boomers are the greatest generation in terms of distribution to themselves and they there's a 1.00
00:45:50 reason why we have the kind of resentment for a situation where they are still by far even though 1.00
00:45:56 they have continually shrunk, obviously, as a generation. They own the most houses in America.
00:46:02 They own the most property in America. They don't want to sell it. They don't want to give it up.
00:46:07 And so you have people who are trying to form families who have to live in apartments. And
00:46:10 that's the kind of thing where that resentment, there's a core truth to it that I think Republicans
00:46:16 have unfortunately failed to address. You know what I find unfortunate? The Cabot's still on
00:46:21 this show. So get out of here, you. No, listen, I know you all want more, Cabot. So whatever you
00:46:27 do, make sure right now to go and subscribe to Cabot's new show, Wired In, on Spotify or Apple
00:46:32 Podcasts. That is the only way you will be sure to see Cabot's return to this program. Cabot,
00:46:39 any parting words? Yes, please go watch Wired In, if nothing else, just so that you can stick it to
00:46:46 Michael Knowles. Yeah, he just had his big 2000th episode. We're on episode 50, and that's something
00:46:51 worth celebrating. So come join us live on Daily Wire, 4 p.m. Eastern, every Monday through Thursday.
00:46:55 It's a lot of fun. And we'll get Michael Knowles back on for the people. I'll do it, especially
00:46:59 if you guys go over there en masse, then I'm going to have to go over there and say, hey,
00:47:03 I'm still here. Go, come on. Hey, watch me. That's wonderful. Cabot, thank you as always.
00:47:07 Good to see you. Now that we've just returned, it's just me and Mr. Dominic, I feel like I can
00:47:14 rest easy. And if you want to rest easy, you need to go check out Helix. America turns 250 this week.
00:47:21 which means it's been 250 years since anyone in this country got a good night's sleep.
00:47:25 The founders ran a revolution on no rest at all. George Washington crossed the Delaware in the
00:47:29 middle of the night. Those men had no choice. You do. Between the kids, the show, and everything
00:47:33 happening in the country, a good night's rest is about the most patriotic thing I can think of.
00:47:39 And for that, I thank our sponsor, Helix. I'm such a good dad. I'm such a good father. I'm not
00:47:46 a founding father, but I'm a father, that I got both of my kids who are out of the crib,
00:47:50 Helix mattresses. And you know what? I just, for anyone who's going to be a house guest of mine,
00:47:55 I just ordered another Helix mattress for our guest room. Ben, have you gotten a beautiful
00:48:01 Helix yet? I do. I actually already had one before I joined the Daily Wire. I like it very much. In
00:48:07 fact, it's my favorite mattress to sleep on, especially when my kid is trying to wake me up
00:48:13 at about 3.30 in the morning and I'm trying to get my wife unsuccessfully to change his diaper
00:48:18 instead of me. That's very fair. When you said it's my favorite mattress to sleep on, I think, 0.56
00:48:24 how many, maybe I need to start mattress maxing. Maybe I need to get another one. Well, with Helix,
00:48:28 the prices are so good, you could get many. They have over 20 mattress models, whether you run hot,
00:48:32 sleep on your side, or need extra support. There's one built for you. They even offer cooling
00:48:35 upgrades, which in July is not a luxury. It's a necessity, especially if you live in Mom Donnie's,
00:48:41 New York. It is the most wanted mattress brand. It is so great. 78 degrees. You saw that? 78
00:48:45 degrees. 78 degrees. Cool. A nice, a nice balmy night in New York. Uh, go there right now.
00:48:51 HelixSleep.com. Do it. You're going to love it. HelixSleep.com slash Daily Wire. 20% off site
00:48:56 wide. 25% off Luxe mattresses. 30% off Elite mattresses. HelixSleep.com slash Daily Wire.
00:49:01 20% off the regular ones. 25% off the Luxe. 30% off the Elite. Make sure you enter Daily Wire
00:49:09 at checkout so they know we sent you at HelixSleep.com slash Daily Wire. There's one more thing
00:49:14 I got to sell. You got to sell it, Ben. Sell it for me. Yeah. So you mentioned Washington crossing
00:49:19 the Delaware. When Washington was crossing the Delaware, he understood the power of truth and
00:49:23 the power of stories. And so he had literally being read to the troops in their boats when
00:49:29 they were crossing the Delaware River in the middle of the night to do their famous raid
00:49:34 that changed the course of history 250 years ago. He had them reading the opening passage
00:49:41 to Thomas Paine's American crisis,
00:49:43 which decries the summer soldier
00:49:46 and the sunshine patriot.
00:49:48 We need more people than summer soldiers
00:49:50 and sunshine patriots.
00:49:52 We need people who are engaged
00:49:54 at this moment in our country
00:49:55 and understand the crisis that we're in.
00:49:57 And the way to understand that crisis
00:49:59 is to subscribe to the Daily Wire Plus.
00:50:02 We are so proud to bring you a new deal
00:50:05 on the 250th anniversary of this country
00:50:08 that is going to be a three-month deal for $17.76, sorry,
00:50:16 that is going to offer you everything that The Daily Wire has to offer.
00:50:21 It is everything.
00:50:22 It's all of the documentaries.
00:50:23 It is a, you know, it's all of the different historical truths.
00:50:27 It's all of the different articles and pieces and things,
00:50:29 the content that we're rolling out, the documentaries,
00:50:32 the whole entertainment library.
00:50:33 And we're going to be putting out a bunch of stuff this summer.
00:50:35 So you definitely need to sign up for this.
00:50:38 If you've been on the fence about joining, there's no better moment than on the nation's 250th birthday.
00:50:45 Dailywireplus.com.
00:50:46 Go sign up.
00:50:47 And happy Independence Day.
00:50:48 Okay.
00:50:49 Can I actually be totally sincere and earnest, which I almost never am, certainly not on this show?
00:50:54 That was an inspiring ad read.
00:50:57 The Summer Soldier and Sunshine Patriot, Washington.
00:51:00 That was a good, man, that was good.
00:51:03 I want to sign up.
00:51:04 That was great.
00:51:05 I really liked it.
00:51:06 Okay.
00:51:06 Before I let you go.
00:51:07 Hey.
00:51:07 Hey, look, I'm not sure Tom Paine would approve of me using his words to sell things, but
00:51:16 I think it's actually true.
00:51:17 I think that what the Daily Wire offers is the truth about history, the truth about who
00:51:20 we are.
00:51:21 That's what Paine was offering those soldiers.
00:51:23 They knew in that night how desperate they were, that they were really down to the end.
00:51:28 And this was the kind of desperate, brave, heroic act.
00:51:32 and they could never have appreciated that they were in the midst of founding the greatest nation
00:51:38 in the history of the world. And I think that that's something that we should appreciate now.
00:51:42 And subscribing to Daily Wire is, you know, the way I think that you can help appreciate it and
00:51:47 understand it now. And you know what else, you know, we now know, thanks to historians,
00:51:52 is that Thomas Paine slept on a Helix mattress. So head on over to, no, no, he didn't. I don't
00:51:56 think he actually did that. Okay. We are now bringing on Theo Wald to talk about, before we
00:52:00 let all of you guys go. The Supreme Court decisions, I want to go through them. We talked
00:52:05 about the political implications a little bit, but I want to know about the decisions themselves,
00:52:09 and then also Idaho becoming the first U.S. state to use firing squad for executions. Is that the
00:52:16 first U.S. state ever, or just we're bringing it back? I don't know. I don't know. I'm not expert
00:52:21 on that. I think that's a question for Theo. Do we have Theo? Theo. There we go. Yeah, it's good
00:52:27 to be with you guys. And I just want to say, Ben, you know, Thomas Payne was a pamphleteer and a
00:52:31 hustler. I think he would actually appreciate the sales pitch there. I was trying to make a buck,
00:52:36 right? He literally was the original, you know, I'm interested in your ideas and I wish to
00:52:41 subscribe to your newsletter. That's right. So on the big case, on the one that really matters
00:52:48 the most, on the birthright citizenship case, I never thought the court was going to go along
00:52:53 with us out of cowardice. I thought there were good legal arguments and good historical arguments
00:52:58 for the courts to go along with us. But I think the court is just institutionally cowardly for
00:53:03 good reason. The Democrats keep threatening to destroy them for almost a century now. But in
00:53:09 terms of the actual legal matters, what happened? Yeah, I think all of that as preparatory comment,
00:53:17 that's correct. I think anyone who listened to oral argument knew that both Justices Kavanaugh
00:53:22 and ACB, Amy Coney Barrett, were skeptical. That's probably the best way of putting it,
00:53:29 skeptical at best of John Sauer, the Solicitor General, his arguments before the court.
00:53:34 I think the Roberts opinion, one way of sort of distilling this down is to say it's essentially
00:53:40 a discursive armchair historian's view of the 14th Amendment, but really rooted in Anglo common
00:53:46 law. What is the notion of citizenship or subjecthood, more likely, that was imported
00:53:52 from Britain into the United States. And that's where he kind of hinges his entire argument. And
00:53:57 I think Alito is right to say in his dissent, and Thomas does the same, that Roberts really misses
00:54:03 everything from the Declaration of Independence forward. And so you've got a very narrow reading
00:54:11 of what citizenship requires. Hadley Arcus, the famous natural rights theorist, he really
00:54:17 pinpoints this line from robert's opinion where robert says really what this is about is citizenship
00:54:22 is the right to have rights which really would have struck the framers obviously as bizarre but
00:54:29 also the framers of the 14th amendment as bizarre so i i think the the majority opinion is trying to
00:54:35 do a lot and what it's really trying to do to your your point michael is to satisfy this question of
00:54:40 what is the meaning of the 14th amendment what is the meaning of citizenship once and for all and
00:54:44 as we've seen over the last 40 years, anytime the court tries to settle definitively what is really
00:54:51 at root, something of a small P political question, the court ends up regretting it.
00:54:56 You know, just think of Planned Parenthood v. Casey or some of these other sort of seminal
00:54:59 cases where the court tried to say, no, this is the definitive answer for all time. And I think
00:55:04 the dissents from Thomas and Alito both get at this, that not only is it a wrong reading of the
00:55:09 14th Amendment, but it's also a political mistake the court's making. So Theo, I have a couple of
00:55:14 questions about this. And I want to preface this by saying that I'm someone who has for a very long
00:55:18 time, along with including hardline immigration people like my friend Mark Kotorian, supported
00:55:24 birthright citizenship. And the reason that we support it is because we don't believe in having 0.98
00:55:28 stateless children, and we believe that it's chaotic, and we believe in border control,
00:55:34 immigration enforcement, the kind of things that prevent this from being exploited. But the
00:55:39 situation that we face today is obviously dramatically different than everything that
00:55:44 we've seen even just a few decades ago when it comes to the level of birth tourism, when it comes
00:55:49 to the level of people who are aligned to come here for a brief amount of time just in order to
00:55:53 have a baby who can claim dual citizenship, who are exploiting generous Medicaid and other
00:55:58 welfare programs in blue states. Like this is a completely different scenario than we were in
00:56:04 even 15, 20 years ago. And obviously that includes the importation of untold millions during the
00:56:11 biden era the decision though to go with an eo that i know that you were you know uh obviously
00:56:18 a key uh component of that you know is is from you i actually don't know how much of it you
00:56:23 you worked on or if you draft the whole thing but that eo was always something that seemed to put in
00:56:29 people's minds this thing is going to get kicked out because it's not congress it's not something
00:56:34 that has the backing of you know a partisan or potentially even a bipartisan i think you might
00:56:40 gotten some democrat randoms in the in the house that might have gone along with some kind of
00:56:45 solution on immigration just based on where they are um that tried to deal with this birthright
00:56:50 question which has loomed over us forever with all of these random decisions and no definitive 0.97
00:56:55 answer i think robert's opinion is crap i think it's just like ridiculous um but i also think 0.90
00:57:03 that this outcome is one that most americans are just kind of going to kind of shrug at 0.89
00:57:08 unfortunately do you think that it was a wrong decision to do this via executive order
00:57:14 yeah i mean i so the the executive order project that i worked on in 45 you could probably say
00:57:22 it was much more about nipping and tucking and really getting at those uh four categorical
00:57:28 exemptions that roberts kind of dismisses out of hand and says that's a closed universe right
00:57:32 Native Americans, envoys or ambassadors. Right. Exactly. So really trying to hone in on is that the is that the defined space here or is there more sort of elasticity in the joints, if you will, because of the new situation we face with the millions of birth tourists in Miami or Southern California, you know, the false asylee claimants, etc. 0.98
00:57:54 So I think the idea of tackling this through executive order and I'll note executive order alone, right, this could have always been dual tracked with a statutory effort in Congress from the word go back in January of 25.
00:58:09 I think the idea of pushing this solely through executive order, it wasn't just Roberts and ACB who were uncomfortable with that.
00:58:14 Obviously, Kavanaugh notes that, in his opinion, with the existing statute from the 1950s.
00:58:18 And I think both Alito and Thomas both are kind of, you know, the idea that you could do this exclusively through unilateral executive power makes them uncomfortable.
00:58:29 So I think that was also a mistake here and especially a mistake in that I don't think it teed up to your point, Ben.
00:58:36 I don't think it teed up in a neat way the larger political discussion we need to have.
00:58:41 What was missing was exactly what Alito said in his dissent, which is, you now have this very weird scenario where legal immigrants coming to the country applying for citizenship have to engage in kind of like this reason-based, Thomas Paine, if you will, based naturalization process.
00:58:57 They've got to prove their loyalty, their understanding, civics, education.
00:59:01 But then a whole host of people who come here as birth tourists or illegal aliens can just have the magic of birth and automatically give birth to an American citizen. 0.93
00:59:09 And that that's a weird as a very weird scenario. And that's open. That would have been very promising ground for Republicans in Congress or elected Republicans in the state houses across the country to make that argument. 0.61
00:59:21 What we require this of naturalization. Why wouldn't we require something more domicile and allegiance for any citizen who's coming here and giving birth and missed opportunity again?
00:59:31 Yeah. And even so beyond the question of executive order versus legislation or even the Supreme Court precedent, which obviously comes from Wong Kim Ark or the public meaning from the framing of the 14th Amendment, you make this very good point, Ben, which is that Roberts is leaning on or sorry, Theo, you might have made this point.
00:59:52 Well, one of you did, and probably the other one agrees with it, that Roberts is leaning on the Anglo tradition, which is where we get our law from, you know, the English common law.
01:00:03 And the English common law had birthright citizenship, so we are told, you know, us soli versus us sanguinis, the right of the blood.
01:00:11 But this, I think, misses a really important point, which is that you had a birthright as a subject of the king, not in any modern sense of citizenship.
01:00:23 And so if we're going to make the parallel and we're going to cite the United Kingdom, we should look at what happens after the Second World War when the United Kingdom begins to change its previous sense of the relation of subject to king into a more modern national kind of citizenship.
01:00:40 What does the UK do?
01:00:42 The UK gets rid of birthright citizenship.
01:00:44 And they vote for this in 1981.
01:00:46 It goes into effect in 1983 precisely because of these problems of mass migration.
01:00:50 And so you say, look, Wong Kim Ark does not decide this definitively in 1898.
01:00:54 The Congress hasn't really weighed in on it.
01:00:56 Obviously, the framers of the 14th Amendment didn't think that what they were doing was just giving a free ride to every Chinese spy that wanted to fly to Guam.
01:01:05 You know, it's totally absurd.
01:01:06 And if you're going to look to the English common law, maybe we consider what the Brits did after that.
01:01:11 Because the court ruled on the substance of the matter, because the court came in, 5-4, Kavanaugh would not join them for the substantive point.
01:01:19 And they say, sorry, 14th Amendment gives every Nicaraguan peasant birthright citizenship immediately.
01:01:26 Is there anything that we can do, the executive or the legislature, to fight back?
01:01:31 Or do we need to fight another 49-year Roe v. Wade-like battle to get this case overturned? 0.51
01:01:38 Yeah, I think that's an excellent distillation, Michael.
01:01:41 And, you know, funnily enough, I was just in London a week ago giving a presentation on exactly what you just laid out on both the 48-49 citizenship bill that obviously Enoch Powell essentially made his career on, the early part of his parliamentary career, fighting that.
01:01:56 And then the 1981 and then the subsequent mid-90s Citizenship Act. So the British have changed their notion of citizenship three times in a fundamental, massive way. And yet we have a chief justice who's saying, well, we got to go back to the 15th century to look at the way the British understand subjecthood. It makes no sense at all.
01:02:15 So to answer your question, unfortunately, because of the expansive opinion here that this is resting on a constitutional interpretation, and I'd also add to Ben's point, because of the flaw in presenting this as an executive order assertion of power, I think in large part, most of what Congress can do has been foreclosed by this opinion.
01:02:35 It will require a constitutional amendment. And I think the white pill, as I've shared elsewhere, is to say that might be a good thing to get people thinking again about the form of citizenship, what's required in a small r republic and having a fulsome discussion about what we want in terms of the rights and duties and obligations that citizenship imposes.
01:02:58 part of the problem here is for 50 years we essentially neglected this entire conversation
01:03:03 and left it to abstract legal theory or judges and ropes to determine who is and who is not a
01:03:09 citizen right and this is can i just you know uh can i just make the point that the politics of
01:03:16 immigration also played into this in the sense that for a long time republicans saw immigration
01:03:21 as kind of a second uh you know third rail of politics other than like uh you know kind of
01:03:26 medicare or something like that they didn't want to touch it because they were worried they were
01:03:30 going to piss everybody off by doing it and the truth is that in that window where you could have
01:03:36 probably moved something on something like this i'm thinking the late 90s early 2000s that didn't
01:03:42 happen and because that didn't happen we're we're left with this situation as you said you know uh
01:03:48 left with a legal academic comment and and judges and robes making this decision i think that we
01:03:54 we need to have a real considered moment here
01:03:59 about what it means to be a citizen,
01:04:02 about what kind of citizens we want and want to welcome.
01:04:07 And look, Calvin Coolidge said that the founders
01:04:10 fought the war following 1776
01:04:14 because they wanted to be citizens, not subjects.
01:04:16 And that's what we want.
01:04:18 There are a lot of people I think today politically
01:04:21 who would be perfectly happy to just be subjects
01:04:23 And we should not be those people.
01:04:26 A very, very good point.
01:04:27 Before I let you go, Theo, we have to talk about, speaking of the dignity of the person and living on our own terms,
01:04:35 I've long thought, if God forbid I'm ever convicted of a capital offense, I'm not joking, this is not just a setup.
01:04:41 What I would want to do is go out, standing up, blindfolded, probably a cigarette in my teeth, by the firing squad.
01:04:48 That actually seems to me to be the most dignified way to go.
01:04:51 So Idaho has this. I believe you were rather involved in that.
01:04:57 I actually don't get what the big deal is.
01:05:01 Yeah, great question, Michael.
01:05:03 I mean, you know, The Guardian and a couple of other international publications have lost their mind in the last 24 hours about this.
01:05:10 You know, the archaic, barbaric, gun-obsessed Americans are bringing back firing squads is essentially how the op-ed from The Guardian read yesterday.
01:05:17 Look, I mean, really, at issue here is something, a very basic premise. It's tied to our previous conversation, which was the people of Idaho, reflective in numerous red states and some blue states across the country, elected to have capital punishment for a certain class of offenses.
01:05:34 and not you know abolitionist activists and a number of their sort of institutional backers
01:05:42 have campaigned to restrict the ability of states like idaho to import the drugs that are necessary
01:05:47 to create the three drug compound for lethal injection this is essentially their way of
01:05:51 short-circuiting the preferred choice of the people and the establishment of the law and idaho's
01:05:57 answer wasn't like some other red states well i guess they got us we don't have access to the
01:06:01 drugs. We can't use compounding pharmacies anymore. So I guess we'll have no more capital
01:06:05 punishment. Instead, what Idaho said was, OK, then we will revert back to a form of execution
01:06:11 that is still recognized under the Eighth Amendment. And to your point, Michael, it turns
01:06:15 out actually there are lots of criminal defendants across the country who prefer the firing squad
01:06:20 because it is a far more effective and humane form of execution. The average firing squad
01:06:25 a formalized medical death occurs in seconds as opposed to eight, nine, ten minutes in the few
01:06:31 lethal injections that actually occur correctly. And I think, you know, you're using trained
01:06:36 professionals, marksmen who are former retired military or police officers, and there's no
01:06:40 violation of the Hippocratic Oath that you require with health professionals using the lethal
01:06:45 injection form of execution. So it makes sense for Idaho. And really, again, at root here is just a
01:06:50 way of saying you're not going to use your embargo and your activism to short circuit the legal
01:06:54 choices that the people of our state have made. Yeah, I say kill them all, you know, no, no, 0.99
01:06:59 kill them all. But, but, you know, if you're going to have capital punishment, that seems like the 1.00
01:07:03 humane and right way to do it. Uh, totally, totally agree with you. Gentlemen, I have to run,
01:07:08 but, but not before Ben gives his final thought. Great work, Theo.
01:07:13 Thanks guys. Thanks for having me. Good to see you. Mr. Dominic, I'm leaving. I'm leaving on a
01:07:19 jet plane. I'm getting out of here, man. I want to go hang out for the 4th of July. And if anything
01:07:27 happens to me, I just, God forbid, I want you to make sure that my family cashes in my life
01:07:34 insurance policy. Everyone knows summer is upon us. We are now deep into it. And by some miracle,
01:07:39 we are all still on speaking terms, okay, with all, you know, somehow, I mean, even though most
01:07:45 of the hosts left us for today's show, maybe we're not on speaking terms. Anyway, look, one thing we
01:07:49 all agree on is policy genius. Whatever your, whatever your plans are, I can tell you what
01:07:53 they should not include. Squinting at some labyrinthine insurance website, trying to divine
01:07:58 whether you're getting a good deal or not. That's what policy genius is for. Most people know they
01:08:02 need life insurance. They just keep putting it off. If process feels complicated, you don't want
01:08:07 to think about how you're going to die, even though you're going to die. So policy genius makes it
01:08:10 super easy. It's an online marketplace. And for once, the word means what it says. You compare
01:08:16 quotes from America's top insurers, side-by-side, for free. Free really means free. Coverage,
01:08:22 prices, terms all laid out plainly. Their license team handles the paperwork and advocates for you
01:08:27 the whole way. No upselling, just the best policy at the best price. So right now, go to
01:08:32 policygenius.com, protect your family, see if you can get a 20-year life insurance policy starting
01:08:38 at just $276 a year for $1 million in coverage. Policygenius.com slash fire, F-I-R-E.
01:08:46 which can be the cause of you needing to cash in your life insurance policy.
01:08:50 Fire.
01:08:51 Compare the quotes right now.
01:08:53 Policygenius.com slash fire.
01:08:56 Mr. Dominic, good to see you, sir.
01:08:58 Happy 4th of July.
01:09:00 We may, who knows if we do a friendly fire during the octave of independence,
01:09:03 but if not, I will see you afterward.
01:09:06 Happy 4th of July to you, Michael, and great to be with you today.
01:09:09 All right, see you all later.