The Michael Knowles Show - May 23, 2026


Islam Is Superior & Supernatural Is Fake? Catholic & Protestant Debunk | Michael Knowles ft. Billy Hallowell

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Ep. 1980 - Spencer Pratt's Path To Become Mayor Of Los Angeles "Digital Abortion Nightmare" Michael Discusses Pro-Life Crisis | Dan Steiner

Episode Stats


Length

58 minutes

Words per minute

205.79

Word count

12,139

Sentence count

826

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

18

sentences flagged

Hate speech

121

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Billy Hallowell is a filmmaker who investigates the paranormal and demonic possession. In this episode, we talk to Billy about his new film, "Demonic Foes," and how he s debunking the idea that demons and angels are real.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 It's the family and friends event at Shoppers Drug Mart.
00:00:04 Get 20% off almost all regular priced merchandise.
00:00:07 Two days only.
00:00:08 Tuesday, May 26th and Wednesday, May 27th.
00:00:11 Open your PC Optimum app to get your coupons.
00:00:17 Astral projection.
00:00:18 She's in his office.
00:00:19 She tells him, I know where the priest is.
00:00:20 I know what he's doing right now.
00:00:22 She describes the priest walking near the river.
00:00:24 He's wearing a blue jacket.
00:00:25 She's saying all these things, very specific details.
00:00:28 He calls the priest.
00:00:29 He says to the priest, what are you doing right now?
00:00:31 Where are you?
00:00:31 He then proceeds to tell him, I'm walking near the river.
00:00:34 I'm wearing a blue jacket.
00:00:35 All the details she was able to tell him.
00:00:37 You know, my position on, you know, are Muslims and Christians worshiping the same God? 0.96
00:00:42 No, they're not. 0.75
00:00:43 But then you'd say the Jews don't worship the same God. 1.00
00:00:45 Well, I think this is an interesting argument. 1.00
00:00:47 So hold on.
00:00:48 You're saying the biggest challenge to atheism is the nation state of Israel?
00:00:51 I do. 0.88
00:00:51 I think it is.
00:00:52 Now that we've juiced the algorithm with talk about the state of Israel.
00:00:55 I've ruined your show.
00:00:56 No, no, no.
00:00:57 That's much better, because now we got all the views up
00:00:59 so we can talk about angels and demons.
00:01:01 Keep going.
00:01:01 Aliens are angels and demons for materialists.
00:01:04 That's my view, which is why I think it's so important
00:01:06 that we investigate the supernatural 0.96
00:01:09 in our desiccated, degraded age
00:01:13 that doesn't recognize spiritual reality.
00:01:15 Well, I'm very pleased to be here with the filmmaker
00:01:18 of investigating the supernatural angels and demons.
00:01:21 That would be Billy Hallowell.
00:01:23 Billy, thank you for being here.
00:01:25 Thank you for having me.
00:01:27 I think there is more interest now in the supernatural
00:01:31 than there has been basically at any other point in my life.
00:01:34 Oh, 100%. 100%.
00:01:37 And I think even before this whole disclosure thing, right,
00:01:40 what happens every October?
00:01:42 15 movies come out about demons, right?
00:01:44 Yeah.
00:01:44 It's The Conjuring.
00:01:45 This goes back 10 years.
00:01:46 It goes back even further to The Exorcist.
00:01:47 But really, the last 10 years, we've seen a big uptick in this.
00:01:51 I think the reason is because people have a common experience, right?
00:01:55 Ghosts or claims of ghosts.
00:01:56 and I don't really believe in ghosts personally.
00:01:58 I think you're dealing with angels and demons always.
00:02:00 But all of those subjects have really bubbled up
00:02:03 in the last 10 years.
00:02:04 People are very interested.
00:02:05 Now you have aliens, you have UFOs, disclosures,
00:02:07 things we would have laughed at 10 years ago,
00:02:09 we're now talking about very openly.
00:02:11 But then even the way they talk about aliens,
00:02:13 because, you know, to my mind,
00:02:16 the aliens are either a hallucination
00:02:19 or an occult phenomenon.
00:02:20 But the reason it had to be Little Green Men
00:02:22 is because people were trapped in this materialist idea
00:02:26 that everything has to be physical.
00:02:27 Nothing can be immaterial.
00:02:29 But now, even when they talk about the aliens,
00:02:31 you'll hear people start to say,
00:02:32 well, I don't think they're intergalactic.
00:02:34 I think they're interdimensional.
00:02:37 Even the notion that there is more of a spiritual reality to them,
00:02:41 even that is becoming mainstream.
00:02:43 So for those who have not been convinced,
00:02:45 we have the producers compiling the very finest collection
00:02:49 of lib reddit tier materialist atheists
00:02:53 debunking the supernatural.
00:02:56 There's no evidence of anything supernatural.
00:02:58 Well, that's just not accurate.
00:03:00 There are medically documented cases of people with demonic possession
00:03:03 speaking in languages they don't know, for example.
00:03:05 Okay, medically documented cases of people with demonic possession
00:03:10 sounds awesome.
00:03:12 I would love to take a look at that, you know, medical documentation.
00:03:16 I get the feeling you're not going to provide any, are you?
00:03:18 We do have one source that was flashed on screen,
00:03:21 a book by Richard Gallagher called Demonic Foes.
00:03:24 Okay, I bought the book.
00:03:25 I only skimmed through a couple of chapters, but I did also watch a few of Dr. Gallagher's interviews.
00:03:30 In the book, he talks about some of his experiences with people he believes were demonically possessed,
00:03:35 including a woman he calls Julia.
00:03:37 Evidence for demonic possession consists principally in people like Julia having special powers.
00:03:42 But we don't have to take Dr. Gallagher's word for this.
00:03:45 Oh no, actually we can't, because he didn't see this himself.
00:03:48 That's not to say that I can prove she wasn't possessed, or that Dr. Gallagher's priests were mistaken or lying,
00:03:53 but this book, which is the only citation Redeemed Zuma provided, hardly fulfills my evidential
00:04:00 expectations. First of all, he's mistaken because Dr. Gallagher's in our film, first of all. So
00:04:05 Dr. Gallagher did see these things directly, did interact with Julia directly, and I'll tell you
00:04:11 one of the things he did see, okay? So I would love for them to be able to explain this. Julia
00:04:15 could astral project. Now, astral projection sounds ridiculous, it sounds sci-fi, but the ability to 0.99
00:04:20 see what is happening 50 miles away, 100 miles away when you're not physically there.
00:04:25 Now, Dr. Gallagher was a skeptic, and that's an important part that's obviously left out of this
00:04:28 when he came into this. Catholic Church came to him and said, look, you're a psychiatrist.
00:04:34 You're, you know, Ivy League educated. You teach at Columbia University. We want you to come in
00:04:38 and tell us whether this person is crazy or possessed. So he says, okay, I don't want to do
00:04:43 that because I'm a skeptic. They say you're the perfect person to do it. So he gets into it. He
00:04:47 meets Julia. Astral projection. She's in his office. She tells him, I know where the priest is.
00:04:52 I know what he's doing right now. She describes the priest walking near the river. He's wearing
00:04:56 a blue jacket. She's saying all these things, very specific details. Gallagher thinks it's
00:05:00 ridiculous. He calls the priest. He says to the priest, what are you doing right now? Where are 0.72
00:05:05 you? The priest says, you're with Julia, aren't you? He already knows the priest what's going on.
00:05:09 He then proceeds to tell him, I'm walking near the river. I'm wearing a blue jacket. All the
00:05:14 details, she was able to tell him. Now, she had no way to know that. She was sitting in his office,
00:05:18 so he specifically and directly heard this. That's just one of the examples. Another one,
00:05:23 and this one's kind of funny, the night before he met Julia, the priest brings Julia to his house.
00:05:28 The night before that, he wakes up Dr. Gallagher, and his cats are losing their minds, okay? He has
00:05:32 these two cats. They're fighting him and his wife. They get up. They separate the cats out, and they're
00:05:36 like, what in the world is going on? The next morning, Julia's at his door with the priest. One
00:05:40 of the first things she says to him. They've never met. She knows nothing about him. How did you like
00:05:44 what happened with your cats last night? So that's his first interaction with this woman. Now, there 0.89
00:05:49 are plenty of other details that are more convincing than that, but the fact he didn't know and didn't
00:05:53 interact is not accurate. Yeah. What is astral projection in your mind? Because I've heard about
00:05:59 this. It's like a new agey thing, but you see claims of it that go much further back. How does
00:06:06 it work? Because I think I have a theory. Here's my theory. I mean, how it works is essentially
00:06:10 demons, which will transmit information to you, just like automatic writing. They're basically
00:06:14 telling you, here's what's going on. The priest is walking near the river. Here's what he's doing.
00:06:18 You believe you're able to have this special ability because you're so special. You're so
00:06:22 awesome. You can see it's not you. It's the demons delivering that information to you.
00:06:26 Yeah, because there's a parallel within the Christian life with the claims of mystics
00:06:32 throughout the centuries to be able to bilocate.
00:06:34 And it almost sounds like it's the same thing.
00:06:36 Now, bilocation or astral projection
00:06:39 would not necessarily contradict
00:06:40 any laws of physics or metaphysics
00:06:44 in the sense that you can't be in two places
00:06:47 at the same time in the same respect,
00:06:50 but you could, in principle,
00:06:52 be in two places at the same time in different respects.
00:06:55 And so some of the claims of Christian mystics
00:06:57 throughout the ages or about Christian mystics
00:06:59 is that they could bilocate,
00:07:00 which which superficially seems similar to astral projection but the difference
00:07:04 of course would be one is you have a sort of special grace or power thanks to
00:07:11 God and the other is that you're dealing with the occult and demons are telling
00:07:15 you see they're giving you the information yes you just you hit on
00:07:17 something that I've discovered you know I wrote a book in 2020 called playing
00:07:20 with fire I looked at this from a journalist perspective what do what do 0.77
00:07:23 Christians believe about evil and I started encountering this pattern all
00:07:26 the things that God does you know prophecy right let's talk about prophecy 0.98
00:07:30 We see that throughout scripture, right?
00:07:31 The ability, God is giving a message to people.
00:07:33 It's coming from God and they're giving us prophecy.
00:07:36 I think Israel and, you know, not to bring up a debated topic,
00:07:39 a lot of people believe the book of Ezekiel and other Old Testament books
00:07:42 are prophesying things that even haven't happened yet,
00:07:44 but 1948 would be one big thing that has happened.
00:07:47 Okay, that's prophecy.
00:07:48 Is that controversial now?
00:07:49 I don't think it is, but apparently there are some podcasters and hosts that think it is.
00:07:54 Okay, so you've got that.
00:07:56 Then you have psychics.
00:07:58 So Satan perverts every single thing God does with a counterfeit of it.
00:08:02 So psychics are saying, well, we can predict the future, too.
00:08:04 We're able to do that.
00:08:05 But they're not getting those messages from God.
00:08:07 They're getting those messages from demons.
00:08:09 People would dismiss psychics.
00:08:11 They would say it's not true.
00:08:12 I know plenty of ex-psychics. 0.95
00:08:13 In fact, some of them you've had on your show, Jen Nees, it would be one of them.
00:08:16 Yeah, who would tell you what that was like, what that experience was like.
00:08:19 And they thought they were interacting with these spirit guides that were actually demons.
00:08:23 So this goes down the line.
00:08:25 And even in possession cases, people will say there's oil dripping down the wall sometimes, right? 0.99
00:08:29 Well, what do Christians do? 1.00
00:08:31 They anoint the sick with oil. 1.00
00:08:32 So you see this again and again, this pattern.
00:08:34 And I think astral projection and what you were just, the bilocating, that's sort of another example of that.
00:08:39 Yeah, yeah.
00:08:39 You know, the thing is, though, the audience right now didn't hear a single thing
00:08:43 because now they're all fighting in the comments over whether or not the nation state of Israel is prophetic.
00:08:47 Well, it is.
00:08:48 So there we go.
00:08:49 It's solved.
00:08:51 That, should we get it?
00:08:53 Because we could do like two hours on this. 0.94
00:08:54 No, we won't get sidetracked by the nation state of Israel. 0.97
00:08:59 I wrote a book on that. 0.99
00:09:00 It's called Armageddon Code.
00:09:01 Yeah, check it out.
00:09:02 All right.
00:09:02 Well, before Armageddon strikes, what's the next one?
00:09:05 There is no such thing as demon, witches, juju, ghosts, or spirits.
00:09:11 Not on it, not anywhere in our universe.
00:09:14 If something can be observed, measured, or tested, how can it interact with atoms?
00:09:20 How can it move energy?
00:09:21 How can it affect the physical world at all?
00:09:24 For thousands of years, every single claim of magic or spirit collapsed the moment real evidence was demanded.
00:09:33 Not one survived.
00:09:34 Why?
00:09:35 Because you can't move an object without a force.
00:09:38 You can't create fear without a brain.
00:09:41 Nothing can affect reality without physical laws.
00:09:45 And if you claim otherwise, provide your evidence for one.
00:09:49 I'm waiting.
00:09:50 Was that an Aramaic?
00:09:52 I don't...
00:09:53 what did he say it was a lot of yelling and kind of english okay did you get anything out of that
00:09:59 i think what he's saying is there's no proof whatsoever of of witchcraft or demons or or any
00:10:05 sort of non-physical force impacting anything physically which i don't know how much proof
00:10:10 people need i will tell you this i'm actually skeptical like naturally skeptical so when i got
00:10:14 sent out to do all these investigations and look at these stories i'm like okay you say you were
00:10:18 impacted by a demon you say you interacted with an angel prove it to me and i have a high bar for
00:10:22 what I want to be proven to me. But when you interact with people and they provide details
00:10:27 that can no other way could they be possible, you have to start to say to yourself, well,
00:10:31 what's going on here? Like for instance, a miracle, can you prove a miracle? Well, not a hundred
00:10:35 percent, but I think you can get 99% of the way there where I could say, well, I have no other
00:10:40 explanation for how that brain tumor disappeared. I have no other explanation for how this person
00:10:44 was healed of paralysis, right? The same goes for the demonic realm. And I would also pose this
00:10:49 question it's interesting to me we're sitting here having this conversation it's 2026 people
00:10:53 have been having this conversation since the beginning of humanity why why do people continue
00:10:58 to have this conversation because there's a common experience and we see this in anthropology we see
00:11:02 it in sociology that people are experiencing things they can't explain they'll attribute it
00:11:07 to ghosts they'll attribute it to all sorts of things right they may not have a good theological
00:11:10 framework but it's happening and if you ask americans at a high rate they will say i either
00:11:15 have experienced this or i've seen somebody else who has yeah yeah so again are all these people
00:11:20 lying is everybody lying or is something going on my friend drew clavin makes this point he says
00:11:25 you walk into a party you ask people have you ever seen a ghost he said just about everybody in the
00:11:30 party is going to tell you they have maybe not literally everyone but you at the very least you
00:11:35 walk into a room of 10 people guaranteed at least one of them probably many more are going to tell
00:11:39 you, they've seen a ghost. And yet, in our modern life, we say that's totally crazy.
00:11:45 Right.
00:11:46 Virtually everyone everywhere for all of history has said that something has happened.
00:11:49 Then something's happening.
00:11:50 Yes. And even beyond that, we're talking about the supernatural here versus the merely natural.
00:11:55 It seems to me that we can deduce, infer the existence of the supernatural from the mere
00:12:01 fact that the natural world is contingent, caused, subject to change, temporal. So if
00:12:09 there is if there is this thing called the natural which you know is contingent and caused and all
00:12:16 the rest mustn't there be a supernatural on which it rests I mean I would even argue and obviously
00:12:21 this isn't proof but it's interesting we're sitting here we're cognizant we're having a
00:12:25 conversation where did we come from how did we get here how is this even happening why are our
00:12:29 words intelligible there you go well but his were not intelligent they were but ours are they were
00:12:33 not there was a lot of I heard yelling and anger over witchcraft that's all I heard but I do think
00:12:37 it is, it is interesting because, you know, all of this is miraculous and yet we've become so
00:12:42 material that we walk outside, we see flowers growing, these amazing things that God created
00:12:47 and we assume, Oh, Oh, like whatever, no big deal. It's all miraculous. Our earth would either
00:12:52 freeze or burn if we were off our axis at all. I mean, all of these things scientifically do not
00:12:58 make sense. And yet here we are. And so the idea that we have a creator, all of that, but I think
00:13:02 specifically on these issues, when you start to get into the cases, which is what we did in the
00:13:06 film, you know, and you start to look at them. I mean, Richard Gallagher, he had many other
00:13:10 cases that were incredibly compelling. And these are cases that have been verified, yes,
00:13:14 scientifically, yes, medically, and he's not alone. What is, what is tough about this is a lot of
00:13:19 people, they have these experiences, a lot of doctors, right? They see miracles, they see
00:13:23 healing, healings. They can't talk about it. They're afraid to talk about it because of that
00:13:27 reaction. And yet we're pretending this isn't mainstream when most Americans actually have
00:13:32 experienced it and agree with it, which I think is super interesting. All right, next one.
00:13:35 The chance of you being you, existing now, the chance of that sperm hitting that egg, is 400 trillion to one.
00:13:41 And I think life is like a holiday. We don't exist for 13 and a half billion years.
00:13:46 Then we have these 80, 90 years if we're lucky. Then we die, never to exist again.
00:13:50 And some people are even offended by that. They go, you can't say that.
00:13:53 It can't be chance. It's too good. Someone must have made it all.
00:13:57 And I'm too special. I can't just not exist. I'll live again. I'll go to heaven.
00:14:02 i'll be with my friends and family or i'll come back as a spirit and i'll walk amongst you
00:14:06 or i'll be reincarnated i'll come back as someone else that would just be someone else
00:14:11 that's all that's happened you're not involved that is just that's actually a good point someone
00:14:18 else right many people believe in reincarnation of course some people even claim they remember
00:14:23 who they were in a previous life um there's a society in america of course um in california
00:14:30 of course, right?
00:14:33 And they remember who they were in a previous life.
00:14:35 And they're always someone pretty special
00:14:36 in their previous life.
00:14:38 Not so much in the life they've got now.
00:14:41 But I saw a documentary about it,
00:14:43 and every year they have a come-as-you-were party
00:14:45 where they go dressed as the person they were in history.
00:14:49 Two Napoleons.
00:14:54 I kind of agree with him on that. 0.87
00:14:55 I mean, the first part where he's mocking people
00:14:57 for recognizing that there's a spiritual aspect
00:15:00 to human nature and to life. 0.92
00:15:02 That part's kind of silly, read it to your atheism.
00:15:04 But the part where he's making fun 0.52
00:15:06 of the neo-gnostic, new age, woo-woo,
00:15:08 reincarnation stuff, that's spot on. 0.98
00:15:10 It is, it's silly.
00:15:12 I mean, look, at the end of the day, 0.60
00:15:13 I go where the evidence is, right?
00:15:15 So my thing is, when you look at scripture,
00:15:17 and I know the minute you say that,
00:15:18 people are like, well, you can't look
00:15:19 at scripture as evidence.
00:15:20 I start to look at what does the archeology say, right?
00:15:23 What do the facts say on prophecy?
00:15:25 I think 1948 is super interesting.
00:15:26 I actually think Ezekiel 36 to 37
00:15:29 is the biggest challenge to atheism that exists in the Bible.
00:15:32 So hold on, you're saying the biggest challenge to atheism
00:15:34 is the nation state of Israel? 0.78
00:15:35 I do, I think it is.
00:15:37 What would you say, though, to the vast majority of Christians on earth
00:15:40 who say that the nation state of Israel
00:15:43 has nothing to do with biblical prophecy?
00:15:45 I would say I think they're wrong.
00:15:48 Now, here's what I would say, though.
00:15:49 I would say that it's more complicated than both sides probably want to admit.
00:15:54 I think you have a situation, like let's talk about the odds.
00:15:56 What are the odds that a nation, no other nation in the history of the world, has been absent from a map for 1,900 years, let's say, 2,400 years, reemerges on the map, and people are going to say, okay, well, human beings made that happen.
00:16:07 That's going to be the argument.
00:16:08 Human beings, and God works through human beings, so we see that in Scripture, so there's no conflict there.
00:16:13 But the reality is looking at the details of what preceded that. 0.76
00:16:18 It was the Holocaust. 0.75
00:16:19 You have these horrific events, and you have a pattern throughout history, and we can't do this justice in the amount of time we have.
00:16:24 But we have a pattern throughout history of the Jewish people being targeted and attempted to 0.77
00:16:29 wipe them out. You go back to Queen Esther, you go back to what happened with Haman there. 0.60
00:16:33 I mean, from the beginning of time, you go back to 400 years in slavery again and again and again.
00:16:38 And I think you see the same demonic spirit appearing on October 7th, right? You see this
00:16:42 same quest, this irrational quest to wipe the Jewish people out. So the idea that you would 1.00
00:16:48 have a portion of scripture, even let's say that, okay, let's say Israel was forced back onto the 0.81
00:16:53 at by people only.
00:16:54 I think that...
00:16:55 Like the British Empire, for instance?
00:16:56 Right, okay.
00:16:57 Now, I'm not, and I'm not disagreeing that there were, you know, human factions that
00:17:00 did usher this in, but the conditions around it, if you were to put, you know, like, what 0.79
00:17:06 are the odds that it was the Holocaust that really sparked that, the quest that really
00:17:09 sparked that... 1.00
00:17:10 Well, no, the odds would be good. 1.00
00:17:11 If you're saying that the people have tried to kill the Jews for all of history, which 1.00
00:17:15 is true, then you say, all right, and then the latest sort of most ghastly modern industrial 1.00
00:17:21 attempt was the Holocaust. And that after the Holocaust, people, especially being that the 0.96
00:17:27 good guys won, people would have sympathy for the stateless. I mean, there are plenty of stateless
00:17:32 peoples, right? The Tibetans, the Uyghurs, the Gypsies, the Kurds. But this one stateless group
00:17:38 was targeted and nearly exterminated. And there had coincidentally been a nationalist movement
00:17:45 that rose up in the middle of the 19th century, really more toward the end of the 19th century.
00:17:48 And they said, hey, we want this land that we've been longing for for 2,000 years.
00:17:52 And, hey, global superpower, can we please have it?
00:17:56 And they say, yeah, that seems nice.
00:17:57 To me that, as someone who is not like a Christian Zionist or a Christian nationalist for that matter,
00:18:04 though I like nationalism and Christianity, but as someone who doesn't take that,
00:18:08 like I kind of justify the state of Israel on international law.
00:18:12 Sure, political grounds.
00:18:13 Political grounds.
00:18:13 But I could see, I can give a lot of natural explanations for how the state of Israel comes
00:18:21 about, especially because what it really gets down to and what everyone's fighting about in
00:18:25 the comments right now is the church for all of history, just about, has understood herself to
00:18:30 be the new Israel, the spiritual Israel, a view that is in some quarters in recent decades really
00:18:35 opposed. But I guess my view on it is, if the vast majority of Christians for all of history
00:18:43 have believed this thing, and you believe this other thing, how would that be your greatest
00:18:50 evidence against atheism? So I think one of the reasons why people believed that thing for so
00:18:55 long was because nobody could imagine a world in which Israel could ever be back on the map again
00:19:00 after 80, 70, right? Like, I think there was this real struggle that people had to imagine,
00:19:04 well, how would that even be possible? And so a lot of people gave up on the idea of a physical
00:19:08 Israel, and it became sort of this ingrained thing. Well, God must have meant something
00:19:12 different there, or maybe it was talking about the Assyrian or the Babylonian captivity.
00:19:16 The church was trying to claim the state of the Holy Land for itself.
00:19:19 That was the Crusades. Again, that self-understanding of Israel. So it wasn't 0.98
00:19:24 like the Christians were saying, if only we could get the Jews back to Tel Aviv, we'd be so happy.
00:19:29 They didn't even care about it. Right. And my point is, what we 1.00
00:19:32 see now, though, is exactly what you see in Ezekiel 36-37, which is a country comprised of
00:19:38 Jewish people, okay? And people will argue they're not really the Jewish people. Well, they are. Most
00:19:42 of them are. I think they're the Jews. Well, they're the Jews, right? I met the black Hebrew 1.00
00:19:46 Israelites one time, and they told me they were the Jews, but I'm more convinced by... You weren't
00:19:49 convinced they were not, but... Yeah, I think... But it's the conditions in 36-37 that I think are 1.00
00:19:54 really interesting. The conditions that the country would be more prosperous than it would ever be,
00:19:58 that you would have them come from every nation, right?
00:20:00 I mean, those are things that are very specific.
00:20:03 And I think when you start to pull it all together,
00:20:05 it becomes something at the very least
00:20:08 that I think causes you to say,
00:20:10 huh, we've never seen that happen before anywhere.
00:20:13 Now, I understand the opposition to it, 0.99
00:20:15 but I also think Christians have to be careful. 1.00
00:20:17 I know this is not what we were even here to talk, 1.00
00:20:18 but here we are. 1.00
00:20:19 Christians have to be super careful. 1.00
00:20:21 Like Jewish people are not Christian people, right? 1.00
00:20:23 Some are. 1.00
00:20:24 Some are. 1.00
00:20:25 They're Messianic.
00:20:25 No, not just Messianic.
00:20:27 all the first Christians were Jews, plenty of Jewish converts throughout history, many of Jewish
00:20:31 converts today. Yes, a hundred percent. I mean, I'm referring to currently practicing Jewish people
00:20:36 or, and look, it's a secular state, essentially, you know, Israel. So, you know, so there's some
00:20:40 other factors there, but I think sometimes people treat it as though it has been merged,
00:20:45 like Christians are merged together with them theologically. We're obviously not. There's a
00:20:48 separation and you've got to be careful with that. And I think you can believe, and I'll just say
00:20:52 this and then we can put it throughout. You can believe that there is a prophetic significance to
00:20:57 Israel while, and also believe that the church is the fulfillment of that promise. You can believe
00:21:01 those two things together. Yeah, you know, that's getting closer to my view, which is the church is
00:21:07 the new Israel, the spiritual Israel. I think that the prophecies that pertain to Israel as such
00:21:13 really are figures of the church and all of that. I have hold very traditional views on that.
00:21:19 However, I do kind of wonder if the nation state of 1948 is not a little bit of a wink of providence.
00:21:27 Is there not at least like a little bit of significance to it?
00:21:30 I know that's...
00:21:31 Maybe we're more aligned.
00:21:32 Yeah, yeah.
00:21:33 I don't, again, like they're certainly not synonymous in any way.
00:21:36 I don't really, certainly wouldn't justify the state on exegetical grounds.
00:21:40 But, you know, the thing is, if you believe in providence, everything has some significance.
00:21:46 Like, if you believe in providence,
00:21:47 that this is a deeply semiotic world
00:21:50 in which God is expressing, you know,
00:21:52 abundant meaning to us
00:21:53 that we could never fully comprehend,
00:21:55 you do wonder, when there are major global events,
00:21:58 you know, if...
00:21:58 Why does it always center around Israel?
00:22:00 Right, yeah, well, or even...
00:22:01 No, I was going to go even further than that.
00:22:02 Like, Constantine at the Milvian Bridge,
00:22:04 when he has this vision of Christ
00:22:06 and raises the Christian standard
00:22:07 and it converts the entire Roman Empire,
00:22:09 like, that's a pretty significant event, you know?
00:22:13 and it doesn't necessarily have to be prophesied in Scripture.
00:22:17 But that is my kind of like one, it's my dipping my toe
00:22:20 into that specifically sort of Protestant thing.
00:22:23 What about, okay, Revelation?
00:22:25 I think when you read Revelation, and I know another powder keg.
00:22:29 That's always what a priest told me.
00:22:31 He said, Michael, anyone who tells you he understands the book of Revelation is a madman.
00:22:35 It's complicated, okay?
00:22:36 I've read it a million times, and every time I read it, I'm like,
00:22:38 oh, I wonder what's going on there.
00:22:39 But it does feel like Israel's a physical location again in Revelation.
00:22:44 It does, right?
00:22:45 And I believe a good chunk of Revelation is unfulfilled.
00:22:48 Okay, that's my belief.
00:22:49 So that's interesting to me.
00:22:51 And again, it brings me back to what is going on prophetically.
00:22:53 So I think you can believe both of those things.
00:22:54 I think we've chosen that you have to be one or the other.
00:22:57 It's like, well, no, I think there's significance prophetically to Israel still.
00:23:01 And I do believe that there is a promise to Israel that does not just end at the church.
00:23:05 I do believe that.
00:23:06 You're talking about the Jews.
00:23:07 I do.
00:23:08 now now that they'll convert at the end well some may i mean that's that that is one idea of what
00:23:14 could be going on in revelation the 144 000 there's lots of different theories about that you
00:23:17 know so um i think it'll be interesting to see what happens i don't know but what i do know is
00:23:22 i i do believe there's a prophetic significance and i do think that ezekiel 36 to 37 is a challenge
00:23:28 to atheism is a is a one of the bible's premier challenges to atheism but it's not more than like
00:23:34 the resurrection well no the resurrection is the best let me rephrase the the old testament in the
00:23:39 old testament i think it is the biggest yes yeah that's and that's pretty interesting the other
00:23:42 crucial part here speak pun intended now that we've juiced the algorithm with talk about the
00:23:49 state of israel i've ruined your shows no no no that's much better because now we got all the
00:23:52 views up so we can talk about angels and demons keep going hey people a supernatural explanation
00:23:58 should only be accepted when the supernatural has been proven to exist. Theists claim the
00:24:04 supernatural as an explanation for things, yet to date have not proven the supernatural to exist.
00:24:09 So, until they can, any explanation that invokes the supernatural should be dismissed.
00:24:16 Now the rebuttals. What is supernatural? The supernatural is anything that is not natural
00:24:21 nor bound to natural laws such as physics. An example of this would be ghosts, specters, demons,
00:24:28 The supernatural cannot be tested empirically.
00:24:31 This is a false statement.
00:24:34 If people claim to speak to the dead or an all-knowing deity, that can be empirically investigated and verified.
00:24:41 An example are the self-proclaimed prophets that said God told them personally that Trump would have won the last U.S. elections, which was false.
00:24:50 It's metaphysical.
00:24:51 This is irrelevant.
00:24:53 As if the supernatural can interact with the physical world, it can be detected.
00:24:56 An example are psychics who claim they can move objects with their minds or people who channel slash control spirits.
00:25:05 Personal experiences.
00:25:07 Hearsay is hearsay.
00:25:09 And not only I really don't care about it, it's totally irrelevant and useless to prove anything if not accompanied by an empirical evidence.
00:25:18 So, no.
00:25:21 This is quite the Karen session.
00:25:23 I mean, so what is natural?
00:25:26 It always makes me laugh because these people decide, like, oh, no, we've decided what is natural and what is not, right?
00:25:31 Because all the things we talked about before, yeah, it's natural, it's material, I get it.
00:25:35 But I actually think it's all supernatural still, like the flowers growing outside, the trees, you and I being able to talk.
00:25:39 So they've made a decision on what they believe is natural.
00:25:41 Everything else is supernatural.
00:25:43 What these people do, I mean, look, I have sat, and I'm not proud of this, before I really understood the danger of this,
00:25:49 where I listened to a psychic talk to somebody in my family.
00:25:53 And this psychic picked up a pair of glasses
00:25:55 from my dead grandfather
00:25:57 and picked those glasses up
00:25:59 and started telling people in our family
00:26:02 details that this person could have never known
00:26:04 down to the detail of the man who manned,
00:26:09 one of my family members worked in a prison.
00:26:10 The man who worked the front of that prison,
00:26:13 his name was Bud,
00:26:14 and not a name you would traditionally know.
00:26:16 She could name him, talk about what he looked like.
00:26:18 she knew everything by touching these glasses. How else do you explain that? So people have
00:26:22 plenty of examples that would defy everything he just cared about, that would very much prove.
00:26:28 So individual experiences do matter because in the collective, again, they point to evidence.
00:26:33 He also, he says you can't prove anything without hard, tangible, empirical evidence.
00:26:39 But he doesn't really believe that because I can know something about justice. Justice is giving
00:26:44 to each what he deserves. I can know that definitively. And I have to know that. We
00:26:49 have to make conclusions about that. That's the only way we can have a society. I can't touch
00:26:54 justice. Or freedom or liberty. Or freedom or liberty or grace or virtue or anything. So we all
00:27:00 do that. In fact, we can come to conclusions about mathematics without empirical evidence. I guess
00:27:05 one plus one equals two. I guess we have empirical evidence for that. But there's a lot of
00:27:10 mathematics that we don't have empirical evidence for. So even that, that very reductive empiricist
00:27:15 view is kind of silly by any standard, a standard by which we all live our lives.
00:27:20 No, absolutely. I mean, you create a standard, again, what is natural? You create the standard
00:27:24 that's ridiculous to begin with, and then you have a measurement that everything else that does have
00:27:27 evidence, you're just dismissing it all when these people, I mean, look, I've spent now years looking
00:27:32 at this stuff, and I want it to not be true half the time because I want to poke the hole in it.
00:27:37 I want to be like, oh, I caught you.
00:27:38 You lied.
00:27:39 Too often, I'm in a position where I'm finding myself saying these details.
00:27:44 Like, do you want me to give you an example?
00:27:45 Because this one's kind of wild.
00:27:46 Okay, so in our most recent film, there's a man who, Bruce Venata, who died, crushed
00:27:51 underneath a semi-truck.
00:27:53 He was a mechanic.
00:27:53 He's under the semi-truck doing work on it, falls off the jack.
00:27:56 Semi-truck lands on him, crushes his torso, his abdomen rather, dies under this truck.
00:28:03 Now, the EMTs come.
00:28:04 This man claims he, now it sounds crazy.
00:28:06 He rose above his body 15 feet.
00:28:08 We've heard these stories.
00:28:09 He's looking at these two angels, putting their hands on his abdomen.
00:28:12 And he also has a miracle, which we could talk about after.
00:28:15 He's talking about all these things that happened.
00:28:17 Now, this man, they could not do any CPR on him because of the injuries.
00:28:20 He comes to on his own in the middle of he's severed five arteries, which nobody's ever survived severing five arteries.
00:28:26 Now, we could say he's lying.
00:28:29 But this man was able to describe the EMTs who came through the back door of that building, what they were wearing, what they looked like.
00:28:36 He could pick them out of a lineup six weeks later.
00:28:37 The only way that man could have known
00:28:39 who those people were,
00:28:40 he was dead under a truck,
00:28:41 is if he were 15 feet above his body
00:28:43 staring at that door.
00:28:45 There are lots of examples like this.
00:28:46 Are we just going to dismiss them all?
00:28:48 Go to hallow.com slash Knowles. 0.99
00:28:50 May is Mental Health Awareness Month
00:28:51 and it is probably arriving 1.00
00:28:53 at just the right time for a lot of people.
00:28:55 Maybe a little too late, actually.
00:28:58 Because even when life is objectively good,
00:29:00 modern life can feel exhausting.
00:29:02 Constant notifications, constant pressure,
00:29:04 constant responsibility,
00:29:04 work, family schedules, finances, headlines, obligations. It can feel like your attention
00:29:09 is being pulled in 10 different directions all the time. This time of year often makes it even
00:29:12 more intense. School years ending, summer schedules starting, vacations to plan, events to attend,
00:29:17 even more commitments stacked onto an already busy life. A lot of people are carrying stress
00:29:21 they barely even notice anymore because they've gotten so used to operating at that level
00:29:25 constantly. That is one reason prayer really matters. Studies have shown that prayer can
00:29:30 help reduce stress, improve mental health, and lower cortisol levels. Beyond the science of it,
00:29:34 prayer creates space to step outside the noise for a moment and remember that not everything
00:29:38 depends entirely on you that is the idea behind hallow's new detachment challenge detachment
00:29:43 doesn't mean indifference or withdrawing from your responsibilities it means loosening your
00:29:47 grip on things that ultimately you cannot control placing them in god's hands instead right now go
00:29:52 to hallow.com slash knolls download the hallow app get three months for free hallow.com h-a-l-l-o-w
00:29:59 dot com slash knolls canada v-l-e-s for three months free well and just even at a really basic
00:30:03 level. Because I don't know, I'm not a philosopher. I'm not a theologian. I'm certainly not a
00:30:07 biologist. And so I just try to get basic about it. I know that part of me is intellect and will.
00:30:16 Maybe not the most abundant intellect, but enough that I can speak. You're pretty smart. Thank you.
00:30:20 I appreciate it. It's intellect and will. I desire things. I pursue those desires. And I
00:30:26 think about things universally in a different way than lower animals have, which is instinct and
00:30:32 appetite, so much so that my intellect sometimes can override my appetites, hopefully, and
00:30:37 through the force of my higher will. And then I would say to the doctor, the biologist,
00:30:42 I'd say, hey, cut me open, find the intellect. In that case, they would say the brain. But
00:30:46 the brain is not synonymous with the intellect. I know this because the brain, like all physical
00:30:51 organs, can receive physical things, electrical impulses. My eyes can receive color. My hands
00:30:58 can receive texture, but my intellect deals in universals, things that can't be touched.
00:31:04 And so a merely physical object could not receive immaterial forms. Therefore, it doesn't
00:31:10 take Plato or Aristotle for me to come to the conclusion that part of me is immaterial.
00:31:16 My will, what is my will? Why is it that when I want to eat the cookie, my disciplined will
00:31:21 will say, no, I want to be healthy, I want to be thin and sexy more than I want to eat
00:31:26 the cookie. Where's that part of me? Find that. You can't actually identify it. And so isn't the
00:31:34 simpler explanation that we are what we have always thought ourselves to be, which is in part
00:31:40 physical, but in part spiritual? Absolutely. I mean, I think one of the most dangerous things
00:31:44 that's happened, particularly on the secular side and the left, is this idea that we're almost
00:31:49 animals. I mean, it's like the way that they treat human beings is, you know, we just, we have all
00:31:53 these base instincts that we have to satisfy and that's where we are and that's all that matters
00:31:58 and whatever feels good whatever you think is good this crazy relativism that doesn't work which is
00:32:02 one reason why so many young people are coming to faith because guess what they're realizing this is
00:32:06 all a lie and it's all hitting them they're the first generation gen z the first generation to
00:32:11 grow up on smartphones and tablets and all this chaos really i mean i'm an elderly millennial i'm
00:32:15 42 so like we kind of had it but they really have it and they've hit this wall and they're like wow
00:32:20 none of this was true. None of this works. And we need a real answer. Now, the danger is that
00:32:25 they're looking for all different answers. So you see the rise of the occult among young women in 0.95
00:32:28 particular, but you see the rise of Christianity in particular among young men. And so the goal 0.69
00:32:33 is get the truth out to as many people as you can, because these young people, they're hungry
00:32:39 for it. But I think in some ways, what the left has done and what the secular side has done
00:32:43 has actually led to that. Unfortunately, there's a lot of bodies laying out there and a lot of
00:32:48 tragedy that's happened on the gender front and all these other issues because of that but it is
00:32:52 interesting to watch the realization of what you just said come to fruition in these young people
00:32:56 yeah no i because people recognize that the materialist explanation is just insufficient
00:33:02 and that there are phenomena that they experience and desires that they deeply feel
00:33:06 that that are not satisfied by it and then the problem to your point especially the young women
00:33:11 is they say and that's why i'm gonna put crystals in my front yard it's like well hold on it's like
00:33:18 okay i'm gonna sage my house and put yeah i'm like in a way the crystals are kind of an improvement 0.99
00:33:25 over atheist materialism but you know what's even cooler than sage around your stupid like 0.99
00:33:31 whitewashed millennial living room or crystals in your yard you know it's more even more um how 1.00
00:33:36 about a beautiful altar of sacrifice uh in the christian faith which is predicated on the fact
00:33:42 that a man died and rose from the dead yeah like that's more interesting to me than sage well
00:33:47 because it all goes back to where do you see the power do you see the power in yourself because
00:33:51 that's what the left has sold the left has sold this idea that we have the power in ourselves
00:33:55 that we can make all the best decisions it's all about us that does not work that has let us down
00:34:01 complete chaos and a lot of us for a long time we were just willing to let it happen like oh yeah 0.99
00:34:05 don't worry about those kids over there that they're transing it's like what in the world 0.99
00:34:08 is going on and i think we've had a little bit of a semblance of a wake up now where everyone's like 0.67
00:34:13 oh, no, we can actually talk about the truth right now.
00:34:16 And so we're in this unique window where I actually think
00:34:18 this supernatural conversation is especially important
00:34:21 because I actually believe that the supernatural,
00:34:23 and this is kind of wild because all these people are wrong.
00:34:26 The supernatural is an apologetics tool,
00:34:28 and I never thought of it this way.
00:34:30 If you can prove that miracles are real,
00:34:31 if you can prove that angels and demons are real,
00:34:33 that there's a spiritual realm and that these stories are happening,
00:34:36 a lot of young people are going to find that to be the one key
00:34:39 that actually puts them over the edge into faith.
00:34:42 And that's something that if you had asked me that two years ago, I probably would have said no.
00:34:45 Oh, no, I've seen that.
00:34:46 I think I had a greater appreciation of that long before I had any clearer view of religion
00:34:54 or a return to clear view of religion in that if you can convince someone that sin exists,
00:34:59 you can convince them that evil exists.
00:35:01 And if you convince them that evil exists, you can convince them that it has a personality,
00:35:06 that it has a kind of force to it.
00:35:08 And if you can convince them that evil has a personality,
00:35:10 You've convinced them the devil exists.
00:35:12 But what's crazy to come all the way back is if the devil exists, certainly God exists.
00:35:20 Say, oh, yikes.
00:35:21 I just, I guess I just sinned myself out of atheist materialism, which is not the right
00:35:25 I recommend.
00:35:26 I recommend going the other way.
00:35:27 Don't do that.
00:35:27 All right, next one.
00:35:28 C'è una luna, mezzo mare, mamma mia, me mare dare, figlia mia chiuda dare, mamma mia,
00:35:42 Okay, I love you.
00:36:12 Love that song.
00:36:12 So I was mostly focused on the song.
00:36:14 Made me like the video.
00:36:15 But I couldn't read on the screen.
00:36:16 The text was too small.
00:36:17 What is she doing?
00:36:18 I saw a job at the end. 0.91
00:36:19 I think she's basically pulling out all these different things that, you know,
00:36:23 looked like it was her communion, and then it was the evil eye, which, I mean,
00:36:26 the evil eye is more of an occultic thing than anything else.
00:36:28 Yeah, it's folk folklore occult.
00:36:30 It's not protecting you.
00:36:31 Don't play with it.
00:36:32 No.
00:36:33 You know, I don't know.
00:36:34 People are so strange.
00:36:35 I don't really know what she was doing.
00:36:36 I'm not really sure what her point was.
00:36:38 But almost equating all these things, maybe.
00:36:41 Like all these things are just silly, maybe.
00:36:43 I don't know.
00:36:44 Now, she didn't say that.
00:36:44 I want to put words in her mouth. 1.00
00:36:45 But, you know, the hijab, the evil eye, the communion photo, you know, all of that stuff. 0.99
00:36:50 Again, I would challenge people, and people will laugh at this oftentimes, where's the evidence? 0.98
00:36:55 Like which faith system?
00:36:57 And it's funny.
00:36:58 If you go on ChatGPT and you start playing around, you start asking questions about which faith system has the most evidence.
00:37:04 It is very interesting what you'll find because the reality is archaeology.
00:37:08 Again, we got a little Gerald when I brought this up last time,
00:37:10 but Israel and prophecy, right?
00:37:11 There's a lot in Scripture that is verifiable and true.
00:37:14 Yeah, right.
00:37:15 And as time goes on, there'll be more.
00:37:16 And, well, that actually does relate to what you're talking about,
00:37:20 which is the relative evidence for the religions.
00:37:22 Because on the one hand, you see this syncretic stuff, 0.96
00:37:24 the malocchio, the evil eye with Christianity. 0.98
00:37:27 And you always see degrees of syncretism crop up 0.90
00:37:30 because the devil works overtime.
00:37:32 So in Latin America, there's the Santeria,
00:37:34 which is the mixing of the occult with Christianity. 0.60
00:37:37 There's, I guess you get a little bit of that in the Mediterranean too.
00:37:40 Sometimes in more modern styles of religion,
00:37:43 you'll get a little New Age weird woo-woo stuff in addition to Christianity.
00:37:49 So that always creeps in. 0.99
00:37:51 But the one that really threw me for a loop there was she married a Muslim. 1.00
00:37:55 And she says that there's no, I mean, if she converts him, that's all good.
00:37:59 But you're saying there's no conflict between Islam and Christianity? 0.94
00:38:02 Well, there's a major conflict between Islam and Christianity. 0.91
00:38:05 The denial of Jesus as God, the denial of the crucifixion, the denial of all of that. 0.62
00:38:12 I mean, one thing that people don't know, and I think it's helpful to know, is that, yes, Islam looks at Jesus as the second most important prophet, but it's not the same Jesus, right? 0.57
00:38:21 This is not the Jesus that we have of Christianity.
00:38:23 So there's a lot of conflation, right?
00:38:25 We're worshiping the same God.
00:38:27 You know, my position on, you know, are Muslims and Christians worshiping the same God?
00:38:31 No, they're not, because now I understand the view of Allah and God as the Father being the same. 0.61
00:38:37 I understand the argument.
00:38:38 But the Christian belief is that you have Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
00:38:41 You have a trinity in one.
00:38:42 If you're not acknowledging that, then no, it is not the same God. 0.76
00:38:45 But then you'd say the Jews don't worship the same God. 0.98
00:38:47 Well, I think this is an interesting argument, right?
00:38:50 Because I think it is the same Father, God.
00:38:52 I think it's actually different.
00:38:54 It's different in that the Old Testament, both religious systems.
00:38:58 Yeah.
00:38:58 So, yes, in a sense, it's not the same in terms of Christianity looking at Father, Son, Holy Spirit.
00:39:04 But the Father God is the same. 0.75
00:39:05 The Father God in Islam is not the same because it's not the same holy book. 0.94
00:39:09 It's not the same tradition, right? 0.99
00:39:10 It's a completely...
00:39:11 They would say it's the same tradition. 0.56
00:39:12 Well, it's a rewritten version of the Bible, right? 0.97
00:39:15 Whereas Christians acknowledge the Old Testament, right? 0.96
00:39:19 So you're looking at the same scriptures, whereas I would say it's the same Father. 0.95
00:39:22 but they would but the jews wouldn't say that they wouldn't even refer to god as the father 0.64
00:39:27 because they deny the son right so from the jewish so from the jewish perspective no it's
00:39:32 not the same but i think what i would say the father from the christian perspective is the
00:39:35 same father it's the same but not the same for islam but not the same for islam totally different
00:39:39 holy book what but it's different book but you might be talking about the you could in principle
00:39:44 be talking about the same god couldn't you or no i would have to be the same book this i know this
00:39:50 is a big debate. I would say, I would say, no, I don't believe it's the same God. I know that
00:39:54 people would say, well, the three Abrahamic faiths, they're worshiping the same father.
00:39:57 I think the argument for Jews and Christians would be you're working from the same text,
00:40:02 right? At least in the old Testament. So Christians, obviously from the Jewish perspective,
00:40:06 but the Jews are working from other texts too, like the Talmud. That's true. Although it differs 0.59
00:40:11 and look, even in the Christian world, we can get complicated with this because there's certain
00:40:14 holy books that not like Catholics have some books that Protestants don't. So, but I think
00:40:19 it's much closer. I think the argument, there's a big difference between the way that Muslims are
00:40:23 looking at the father based on the Quran and the way that Jews and Christians are. What about the
00:40:28 God of Plato, the one? Is it the same God? Boy, no, it's not. It goes, to me, it goes back to the
00:40:37 text, right? So I would say the closest you're going to get between the two out of the three
00:40:42 would be Jews and Christians, Old Testament. Now you're dealing with totally different stories.
00:40:48 rewritten stories, I mean, in the Quran. But we're not talking about the books or the specific
00:40:53 stories. We're talking about God, the, you know, being himself, I am that I am. And so it seems
00:40:59 the way that I work out of this problem, which, you know, is very much the Catholic answer, but
00:41:04 it's that, no, these, when Plato is describing the one, he is describing, albeit through a veil
00:41:14 and somewhat vaguely. He is talking about God. And St. Augustine would see it that way. You see
00:41:21 the Neoplatonic tradition through all of Christianity. And so when the Jews are talking 1.00
00:41:28 about God, even though they deny the Son, they are talking about the same God. And even the 0.92
00:41:35 Muslims, you know, who have wrong conceptions of God, but they are talking about the same God. 0.99
00:41:39 So one of the problems with the Muslim conception is that, at least since the 9th century, 0.98
00:41:43 It's a voluntarist conception. Pope Benedict talks about this at Regensburg. He says that the Muslim conception of Allah is as one who is totally transcendent, pure will. 0.94
00:41:55 In other words, if Allah, and he's quoting this medieval Muslim historian, Ibn Hazm, if Allah willed his followers to worship idols, they would be bound to do so. 0.91
00:42:05 Whereas the Christian conception of God certainly does not permit of that, because the Christian
00:42:10 conception of God is a God that is identifiable with the Logos, the divine reason, which also
00:42:16 you see an early sense of in Plato and Aristotle, so that these are all the same God, albeit
00:42:24 with some misperceptions in Christianity, you have the fullness of truth. 0.93
00:42:28 But what it also means is we look at the Jews and we say, well, the Jews are missing out 0.90
00:42:32 because they deny the resurrection. 1.00
00:42:34 Right.
00:42:34 Right. But think about for the Muslims, the Muslims deny the crucifixion. The Muslims in 0.94
00:42:41 the Quran, they say they crucified him not. They think that it was either an illusion or he was
00:42:46 rescued from the cross, but they cannot bear that Jesus was crucified. And they deny that he's God
00:42:52 as well. They deny the incarnation. But then it reminds me of St. Paul. I think Philippians 318,
00:42:57 I might be getting the verse wrong because I'm Catholic. We don't, you know, we don't say it as
00:43:01 Well, but I think it's Philippians 3.18 where he says,
00:43:05 there are many walking now, and I tell you, even weeping,
00:43:07 who are enemies of the cross of Christ.
00:43:10 And I find that to be a really interesting phrase,
00:43:12 and it has all sorts of meaning and resonance. 0.93
00:43:15 But one of the little winks that I see from that is in this rise of Islam, 0.57
00:43:19 which is a religion that very explicitly denies the crucifixion, 0.98
00:43:22 the cross on which Christ conquered death.
00:43:25 I think this is a really interesting conversation because, you know,
00:43:30 we're actually talking about two different things, I think. You're talking about the concept of God,
00:43:34 which I actually think of the Father, let's say, right? Which I think, as we're talking about it,
00:43:39 I'm thinking about, in practice, the nature of how God would play his nature out in human affairs.
00:43:46 And I think when I'm talking about the Jews in the Old Testament and the Christians,
00:43:50 they would have a more similar ideology of how God the Father in the Old Testament would apply
00:43:57 himself to specific circumstances. I think juxtaposing that to the Quran, there'd be some
00:44:02 differences of how the father may. Well, I don't know. I mean, the Jews deny, modern rabbinical
00:44:07 Jews consider it blasphemy that one could even think of the incarnation, that God himself is
00:44:13 incarnate as a man. And the Muslims think substantially the same thing. Really, same goes 0.99
00:44:21 for the crucifixion, the notion that God could die, which of course, Christians, we say, well,
00:44:24 Christ dies in his human nature, obviously not in his divine nature.
00:44:27 Well, they're both denying Jesus.
00:44:30 Yes. 0.92
00:44:30 I guess what I'm saying is the Jewish and Muslim view of God the Father, it's different,
00:44:37 of course.
00:44:38 Or I guess we should just say God, because God is one, three distinct persons in one
00:44:42 divine unity.
00:44:43 But I don't know that it's quite as different as we're claiming here.
00:44:48 And so then you get this tough problem, which is if you say that Muslims don't worship the
00:44:51 real God or they don't pray to the real God or they're not at least reaching out for the real
00:44:55 God, then it seems to me you basically have to say the same thing about the Jews, which people 0.67
00:44:59 don't want to do. Well, I would, I mean, would you do, would you say it? No, I think that, I think
00:45:05 that Muslims, when they're calling out to God, they are in fact speaking about God. They just 1.00
00:45:10 misunderstand God and they've missed the incarnation, which is a pity for them. And that's
00:45:14 why they should. Well, I would actually agree with you. I would actually agree with you. I actually
00:45:16 don't think we're as far off on that. I'm thinking in terms of, again, that the nature of God that
00:45:20 we would read, and we would say, okay, but you're correct that the Jews would reject that. I think 1.00
00:45:25 from the Christian perspective, Father, Son, Holy Spirit, I believe there's only one tradition that
00:45:29 has that right, and it's the Christian tradition, right? I think that if somebody held a gun to my
00:45:33 head and said, which one has a better, if I had to pick between Jews and Muslims and the Father God,
00:45:38 one part of our trinity, which one has a clearer concept of his nature, I would say I think the 0.67
00:45:45 Jews do. Yes, but then we'd fall into partialism, which that very funny Lutheran video on St. 0.87
00:45:49 Paddy's Day tells me it's a damnable heresy. 0.97
00:45:51 Now, I do, I often say...
00:45:53 Do you understand what I'm saying there?
00:45:54 Yes.
00:45:54 Okay.
00:45:55 Yeah, though the reason I think it's tricky
00:45:57 is because you can't really divide God.
00:46:00 I agree with you.
00:46:01 You can't fall into partialism.
00:46:03 And so, you know, when people are asking me
00:46:05 to make a decision between the Jews and the Muslims
00:46:07 on any matter of issues,
00:46:09 whether we're talking about geopolitics or anything else,
00:46:11 I say, look, 990 times out of 1,000,
00:46:14 I want to hang out with the pastrami people 1.00
00:46:16 over the shwarma people. 0.97
00:46:18 Not that I look shawarma every once in a while, it's okay.
00:46:20 But the reason I think it's crucial is not to sound like a woo-woo kind of like lib guy.
00:46:26 No, no, go for it.
00:46:28 Look, I believe in dogmatic religion with doctrines and sacraments and a hierarchy and a visible structure and a vicar of Christ on earth.
00:46:35 So I'm quite dogmatic in my religion.
00:46:38 However, God is God, you know, and God is not constrained by the feebleness of our own rational conceptions.
00:46:46 And so if there's a Muslim guy hanging out, or a Jewish guy hanging out, or a Greco-pagan guy hanging out before the incarnation, and they speak of God as Plato did, I think that God could be reaching out to them.
00:47:08 And I think they could have a sense of who God is, even if they weren't totally properly catechized.
00:47:14 Well, I mean, the first step is reaching out to God to begin with, right?
00:47:17 So, yeah.
00:47:18 Okay.
00:47:19 All right.
00:47:20 I'll accept it. 1.00
00:47:20 But still, nice Catholic girls should not marry Muslim guys unless they convert. 1.00
00:47:24 Going back to that, no, 100%. 1.00
00:47:26 I mean, there's no world in which, I mean, you're unequally yoked.
00:47:29 There's no world in which this is something that would be a blessed or good decision to be doing willfully.
00:47:34 Now, you may end up in a marriage where you convert to Christianity and the other person, you know, that may happen.
00:47:40 That's a different story than entering into it. 0.77
00:47:41 You're asking for a lot of trouble and difficulty.
00:47:44 And I think to then justify it, I know that sounds harsh, is an inappropriate way to tackle it. 1.00
00:47:49 Yeah, yeah, especially with the, because the Muslim conception of religion is a little, even culturally, it's not really all that compatible. 0.95
00:48:02 And it's just basically, not to be politically incorrect, but, you know, let's get the conversion first. 0.91
00:48:08 Then you can go about your wedding.
00:48:09 Okay, next one.
00:48:10 why chose islam over christianity well the fact of the matter is the level of commitment and
00:48:15 submission to your creator it just hit different praying five times a day is one not practicing
00:48:22 any of these paganistic holidays is too like christmas and halloween and all this staying
00:48:28 away from intoxicants like drinking this that literally following the ways of all the previous
00:48:35 prophets. A lot of Christians today, with all due respect, y'all slacking on y'all commitment to the
00:48:42 laws and the commandments of God. In the Islamic religion, that is not tolerable. 1.00
00:48:49 Okay, this is interesting to me because it's very, very heavy-handed on the mandates that 0.98
00:48:55 a religion carries, right? If you don't want to drink, don't drink, right? I mean, Christianity,
00:48:59 I believe, doesn't have an issue with getting drunk, yes. If you feel like people need to
00:49:04 be more devout. They need to be more connected to their faith. Well, that's not a bad criticism.
00:49:08 I think a lot of Christians aren't actually living in the way they should, not because they should 0.99
00:49:11 be mandated to do it, which is more what he seems to be talking about. Like he wants the structure 0.93
00:49:16 of a religion saying, you need to do this, this, this, and that. And if you don't do that, then
00:49:19 you're not doing the right thing. Whereas I want more of a relationship, right, with God that
00:49:24 implores me to do those things. And love motivating you. Yes. And love rather than, you know, servile
00:49:28 fear. Yeah, this was always the knock on Islam, is that Islam is just so carnal. It's just 1.00
00:49:36 so carnal. Even the, you know, the Christian conception of heaven, traditional conception
00:49:41 is that, you know, you're before the beatific vision. So it's really ineffable. St. Thomas
00:49:47 says when he has a vision of God, he says, you know, everything I've written is such
00:49:50 straw. This is the common doctor of the church. It's one of the greatest theologians ever
00:49:54 to live or St. Paul describing being lifted up to the seventh heaven or, you know, and whereas 1.00
00:49:59 with the Muslims, the, the idea is you, if you go to heaven and you just get to sleep with a bunch 1.00
00:50:05 of virgins, you know, it's so carnal. And it's funny because there's a kind of a parallel with 0.98
00:50:11 the Jews in that the, the Jews have this very literal exegesis, which is intentional, you know,
00:50:17 like God literally chooses Israel as this, as this figure, you know, of all the nations in whom,
00:50:23 there's neither Jew nor Greek nor slave nor bond or male nor female. But it's like God works
00:50:28 through particular people. I mean, like the son of God is incarnate. His name is Jesus. He has a
00:50:34 mother and a stepfather. And it's like a time and a place in history and he has friends and
00:50:38 disciples and all. So there's this particular, but in Christianity, the particular figures,
00:50:45 the universal and the, you know, there's, there's moral exegesis, anagogical exegesis,
00:50:50 you know, it kind of opens up vertically. And so I think probably the Islamic exegesis is much 0.96
00:50:58 more to be blamed than the Jewish exegesis, because the Jewish exegesis really is coming
00:51:03 from the literal, which is how God expresses himself in history. Whereas Islam comes later,
00:51:08 Islam comes seven centuries later and says, actually, all that spiritual reading, forget 0.95
00:51:12 about that. We're going to go back and you're going to get virgins in heaven. 0.96
00:51:16 So, and I mean, listening to him, I resonate with that critique because I have fallen into
00:51:21 that.
00:51:21 You know, in the last few years, I've gotten much deeper into my faith and, you know, I'm
00:51:24 an evangelical, I guess, you know, who even knows what that term means anymore, but, you
00:51:28 know, I'm a non-denominational Christian.
00:51:30 And, you know, I'm not about, look, I have no problem with tradition and following steps,
00:51:34 but that is not the thing that's going to motivate me.
00:51:36 It's going to be the relationship, as you were saying, through love.
00:51:38 So he was listing these things off and I thought, do you really need to be that, you need to
00:51:42 be that sort of prompted into your faith?
00:51:45 That's what attracts you into it.
00:51:46 That's just so foreign to me.
00:51:47 Again, I don't mind those things
00:51:48 as an expression of your faith,
00:51:50 but where's the rooting of it?
00:51:52 But I will say again, 1.00
00:51:53 critiquing that maybe more Christians 0.98
00:51:55 need to take it seriously
00:51:56 and follow the prophets of their faith
00:51:59 and look to that.
00:51:59 Yeah, I think we all can do a better job at that.
00:52:01 Yeah, I do.
00:52:01 It seems like he's being motivated
00:52:03 by what's the most based,
00:52:05 which is not,
00:52:06 I guess it's not the worst motivation in the world,
00:52:08 but it's certainly not sufficient,
00:52:10 you know, religious thinking because...
00:52:14 Or sustainable.
00:52:15 Right.
00:52:16 A real relationship with God and with Christ is what is sustainable.
00:52:19 It is what the ebbs and the flows of life, right?
00:52:22 When you have children, when you have family, when you have crisis, when you have ups and
00:52:25 downs, that relationship is going to be what carries you through.
00:52:29 That is what sustains you, not I followed these 20 steps and they got me there.
00:52:33 Those things might hold you for a little while, but not permanently.
00:52:35 A priest once explained this to me in a homily where he said, you know, we have this view
00:52:40 that sinning is just breaking the rules.
00:52:46 And he was kind of arguing against kids
00:52:48 going to their first confession when they're seven.
00:52:50 He said, a seven-year-old doesn't have any sense
00:52:51 of personal sin.
00:52:53 They should start going to confession
00:52:54 probably around puberty
00:52:54 when they start really thinking of these things.
00:52:56 He said, you know, we have this idea
00:52:58 that then gets ingrained and, you know,
00:53:00 it messes us up that sinning is when you break a rule.
00:53:03 Sinning is not breaking a rule.
00:53:05 Sinning is a violation of a relationship of grace.
00:53:08 and there are rules, like there are guardrails, but it's not, now my own words, I don't think
00:53:16 people go to hell on technicalities. You know, I don't, like, I don't think you fool God ever.
00:53:22 And so when this guy says, look, now my religion is super based. I don't drink booze for whatever
00:53:27 it is. Let's not forget Christ's first miracle is true. Right. Yes. And it was not grape juice.
00:53:31 And it was, yes. Yeah. Yeah. But, but, and it was for people who'd been drinking for a while.
00:53:34 Right. And they actually appreciated it because it was the better wine. So, I mean, I don't like
00:53:38 Like this whole story that we've recreated to pretend you can never drink is wild to me.
00:53:42 But anyway.
00:53:42 But he says that's like really based.
00:53:44 And I pray five times a day.
00:53:45 And to your point, like nothing's stopping you from praying five times a day.
00:53:48 Pray without ceasing.
00:53:49 The Bible tells us that.
00:53:50 I mean, like, yeah, do that.
00:53:51 It doesn't say you have to do it five times a day facing any particular city.
00:53:53 It just says to do it.
00:53:55 Yeah.
00:53:55 And then the question of like true religion to me is, look, I like outward signs.
00:54:01 Obviously, we have bodies.
00:54:03 I like liturgy.
00:54:04 I like sacraments.
00:54:04 like but what are you doing when nobody's looking what are you doing in your car or what are you
00:54:12 doing when you're talking to your wife and you're kind of frustrated what are you doing you know it's
00:54:16 like to me that is going to tell you more about your religion probably than vestments yeah yeah
00:54:23 i mean look that when i started working on these projects these films i started doing prayer walks
00:54:28 for the first time because i i hate silence and i realize this about myself i fill silence with
00:54:33 music. I fill it with other things. We all do. And it's a huge struggle for me because I don't
00:54:38 like silence. And I thought, if I'm never in silence, am I ever hearing God? And so I started
00:54:42 every morning at 545 going out for like a 20 minute walk without anything and just praying.
00:54:48 And that's been something that I've continued and it has transformed everything for me. Not
00:54:52 because I'm doing that every morning at that time or because it's because it's a real time to connect
00:54:56 with God and it has nothing to do with any particular steps I'm taking. Or again, there's
00:55:01 nothing wrong with if you want to do sacraments do them but it's about that connection and i feel
00:55:05 like when i hear this i don't hear and i'm not saying he's not connected i don't know what is
00:55:10 in his heart i just don't hear that being the argument i hear the argument being i chose this
00:55:14 because it gives me a structure that will keep me and i keep hearing this from people and i keep
00:55:17 saying to myself that's not going to be what keeps you you got to have that deeper i mean there's the
00:55:21 it's there's this idea that lex arondi lex credendi the way that we worship certainly informs the way
00:55:27 that we believe certainly but then there's that third part which is lex vivendi which is like the
00:55:31 way you live your whole life and yeah with with him he says man it's awesome like i pray five
00:55:38 times a day and i wonder and to your point in this modern world if you're never silent how can
00:55:44 you possibly hear the voice of god you can't i mean it's so convicting and and when i realized
00:55:49 last september that i was never if you had asked me a year ago what does it mean to hear the voice
00:55:52 of god i would have had an answer that was totally different from what i have now what would you say
00:55:56 Now I would say, you know, look, I don't hear, I don't hear an audible voice of God. I know there
00:56:00 are people who claim they do, but I, when I pray, I feel him speak to me in my mind. Almost I get
00:56:05 responses that are very direct sometimes. And that's new for me. And I'm still trying to
00:56:09 understand it and I'm still navigating it. And there are days where I'm like, if I'm being very
00:56:12 candid, is that me or God? Cause I really want that thing that I'm praying for. And I'll go back
00:56:16 to God and be like, is that me or you, you know, like clarify that for me, show me that has given
00:56:21 me a clarity I've never, I've never really had before. And I've been a Christian for 42 years,
00:56:24 like my whole entire life. Right. But I'm like, well, have I been right? I know that's like,
00:56:28 I like, have I really been, or has it really been like the last five years? And maybe the reality
00:56:32 is it's been the last five years. And I was just on that path, but it has transformed everything
00:56:37 for me. Yeah. So, you know, sanctification is a, that's right. It's a journey. It's a process.
00:56:41 Yes. And I have a lot, in 10 years, hopefully, hopefully I've learned more. Imagine what you'll
00:56:44 say in 10 years. Have me back. We'll find out. Okay. We've run out of really stupid clips.
00:56:49 Now we get a good clip from your movie, investigating the supernatural angels and 0.99
00:56:54 And while we were driving along a highway,
00:56:57 we went from suburban area to a rural area.
00:57:01 And all of a sudden, we hear this guttural-sounding voice
00:57:06 come out of her in the back. 1.00
00:57:08 You stupid multi-priest. 1.00
00:57:11 You think the changing locations will help you? 1.00
00:57:13 She's mine! 0.76
00:57:14 Mine!
00:57:17 Your mumbo-jumbo prayers will fail.
00:57:20 Just like they always do.
00:57:23 that's pretty scary that's dr gallagher yeah that's after that's a reenactment of dr gallagher
00:57:30 with julia well i didn't i didn't think it was like i mean original footage well you never know
00:57:34 they could have had they could have had a camera in the car you don't know it's a modern era um
00:57:38 but yeah no that that was julia i mean this the things that he saw now again a secularist would 0.97
00:57:43 say well she's just you know mentally ill she's just crazy but when you juxtapose that against 0.71
00:57:48 the other stories when you triangulate it all rather you start to see a person who was clearly 0.95
00:57:52 struggling with something well beyond what mental health providers would have been able to help her
00:57:56 with right and so that's just one example of it one other story that i'll share and this one's a
00:58:01 little bit wild with dr gallagher he was on a call with the priest and they heard they heard a voice
00:58:06 come over this phone call now julia's a thousand miles away and they're on a phone call together
00:58:11 and they hear this voice telling them very similar to what you saw there leave her alone you know
00:58:15 telling them off you know cursing them out basically over the phone both of them heard it
00:58:19 verified it Gallagher was like it was bizarre but we heard the voice very clearly on the call
00:58:24 nobody else was on the call so you have again 10 different stories about julia like that and
00:58:29 unfortunately i won't spoil it but her story does not end the way you would have hoped it would
00:58:33 that means you gotta watch a movie you gotta watch a movie cbn.com forward slash supernatural forget
00:58:37 about the exorcist forget about the exorcism of emily rose you can get it at cbn.com forward slash
00:58:43 supernatural slash supernatural head on over there right now billy a an excellent pleasure i hope i
00:58:48 see you sooner than in the next 10 years.
00:58:51 Yeah, yeah, hopefully. Maybe next year
00:58:53 I'll have different thoughts.
00:58:54 That's right. Next time you're in town, I can't
00:58:57 wait for you to come back. Let's do it.
00:58:58 See you next time.