The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - May 16, 2026


3rd Liberal MP Resigning - Carney to LOSE his Liberal Majority (Chaos Ensues)

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
NDP Radicals Launch Recall against OneBC leader Dallas Brodie! Liberal MPs turning on Carney over Fake Pipeline Agreement!

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

169.44

Word count

3,194

Sentence count

129

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

PM Mark Carney is losing his majority in the House of Commons, and now another Liberal MP is leaving the party. Stephen Gilbeau, a former environment minister under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, is now the third Liberal to announce he is stepping down.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Wyatt Claypool here, and welcome back to the National Telegraph YouTube channel.
00:00:06 Well, it looks like Prime Minister Mark Carney's Liberal government is going to be losing its
00:00:11 majority status this summer. They arbitrarily got a majority through five floor crossers, 1.00
00:00:17 and now it looks like they are going to arbitrarily lose their majority status
00:00:21 from a bunch of resignations. You guys probably already know about the first two because I've
00:00:27 talked about them on the show multiple times. The first being Jonathan Wilkinson, the MP from North
00:00:33 Vancouver Capilano. If the Conservatives fight really hard for that one, they actually could
00:00:37 at least come close to winning it, if not win it in a by-election because it used to be a
00:00:42 Conservative riding. The other one I've been talking about is Nate Erskine-Smith, who has
00:00:47 confirmed that he is leaving in June despite the fact he did not win the Provincial Ontario
00:00:53 Liberal's nomination in Scarborough Southwest. That was objectively rigged against him because
00:00:59 Ontario provincial politics is very, very corrupt. But now the third Liberal who is going to be going
00:01:06 out the door looks like it is going to be former environment minister under Trudeau, Stephen
00:01:12 Gilbeau. This article from the National Post reads, with such a slim majority, can Carney
00:01:19 afford to lose Gilbeau. Caucus management needs to be as vigorous right now as the negotiations
00:01:24 with Alberta, said Marcy Serks, former Trudeau staffer. Down here, the National Post reports,
00:01:32 a well-connected liberal source told National Post that Gilbeau has not yet made up his mind
00:01:36 on his political future and is giving himself time to see how things play out with the negotiations
00:01:41 in Alberta for an oil pipeline and the proposed reform of major projects. For now, Gilbeau sees
00:01:47 himself as a watchdog on the environment, the source says. But as National Post previously
00:01:53 reported, Ottawa is expected to desire a pipeline to the West Coast as being in the national interest
00:01:58 this fall as part of the memorandum of understanding Carney's government is negotiating
00:02:03 with Alberta Premier Danielle Smith. Now, the funny thing with all of this is that we could
00:02:09 have Stephen Gilboa end up leaving the Liberal caucus, resigning his seat or maybe crossing the
00:02:15 floor over a pipeline that's probably not even going to get built. What Carney and Daniel Smith
00:02:23 signed yesterday was basically Alberta committing to raising its industrial carbon tax to $130 a ton
00:02:31 by 2040 in exchange for the maybe sort of promise that we might build a pipeline, which at best
00:02:40 looks like it's just going to be an expansion to the pipeline that goes to Burnaby. And at worst,
00:02:47 there's no pipeline and we're just kicking the can down the road so that Carney can find another
00:02:52 reason to say no to a pipeline project that he had been previously saying yes to. I want to get
00:02:58 into some posts on social media here that might indicate that right now Stephen Gilbeau is quite
00:03:05 mad because again, even though Carney's probably not even going to build a pipeline, Stephen
00:03:10 Gilbeau is such a hard left true believer. I could see him just being mad that the idea of a pipeline
00:03:17 is being normalized by Carney speaking with Danielle Smith, who Stephen Gilbeau absolutely
00:03:23 hates. Those two have been nemesises for a very long time. Anyways, but before I get into some
00:03:29 additional information. I just want to remind you guys, if you like the show, make sure to leave a
00:03:35 like on this video. Subscribe if you're not yet a subscriber. Leave a comment with what you think
00:03:40 about this mess. And if you want to join the other members of the channel in helping make the channel
00:03:45 more sustainable for me, please consider hitting the join button below the video. It really helps
00:03:51 me out. And of course, I thank everyone who is already helping me be less reliant on the YouTube
00:03:56 algorithm by making a small contribution each month. But now let's get into Stephen Gilbeau's
00:04:02 Twitter timeline, because I think that it tends to reveal what his current mindset is. This is a post
00:04:08 he made back on May 1st. He hasn't really posted that much since then, and I think it's more so
00:04:15 just an indication that the man is smoldering below the surface and, you know, I guess doesn't
00:04:20 really want to interact with the public right now because he doesn't like what Carney's doing.
00:04:24 and here he says it's never the right time for oil companies to do their fair share in fighting
00:04:31 pollution even when they make 60 billion in profits but as hard as it is i am now recommending
00:04:38 that canada postpone the pathways cc us project martha finley former vp for suncor uh and so yeah
00:04:46 he's basically mad that we're seeing all these like i guess green energy type projects being put
00:04:54 on the back burner throughout the economy. And in this other article from La Presse that he wrote,
00:05:00 he talks about, again, that effectively his stance is still very much anti-oil and he's not moving.
00:05:08 He says here in this translated article, there is no more time to hesitate.
00:05:13 When it comes to fighting climate change, now is not the time to beat around the bush,
00:05:18 writes former environment minister, Stephen Gilbeau,
00:05:21 urges his leader, Premier Mark Carney,
00:05:24 Prime Minister, but it's French, of course,
00:05:26 to take the necessary steps to fulfill his commitments
00:05:28 to achieving carbon neutrality by 2050.
00:05:33 And he does this whole Canada's at a crossroads thing
00:05:36 and we need to be careful about, you know,
00:05:38 signing a deal with the Alberta government.
00:05:40 Understand, carbon neutrality means
00:05:44 the oil and gas industry is shuttered.
00:05:46 There is no way of getting to the mythical goal of carbon neutrality without completely gutting Alberta's oil and gas industry.
00:05:54 So this man is not happy right now with what Mark Carney did.
00:05:59 Again, I'm going to keep reiterating, even though it's not even going to result in a pipeline.
00:06:04 Right now, the plan just says by September of 2027, we will potentially issue a construction permit or we might basically start the construction approval process.
00:06:15 But that's a process that could take a very long time to actually finish. Remember, we've had multiple pipelines proposed over the years that made it through multiple hurdles and then were either shut down or overregulated to the point the companies pulled out and the liberal government blamed them for the failure when they were obviously the perpetrators of the failure in reality.
00:06:38 And so to give you some perspective of just like what the current state of parliament looks like, Mark Carney has 174 liberal seats. You need 172 for a bare majority where the speaker can break ties.
00:06:57 Now, if Stephen Gilboa, Nate Erskine-Smith, and Jonathan Wilkinson all end up resigning at the same time,
00:07:05 do you know what could actually happen?
00:07:07 The rest of Parliament, which is not happy with the Liberals, not Elizabeth May, the NDP, the Bloc, or the Conservatives,
00:07:13 they could then basically hold the Liberals hostage for a bit and make them redo the committee appointments all across government.
00:07:22 they could force everyone they could basically force a vote requiring there to be a reshuffling
00:07:30 of the committees because what you may have heard uh from previous reports if steve mckinnon and
00:07:36 the liberals their house leader had shuffled all the committees or really packed the committees
00:07:40 with extra liberals so they could have more in-camera meetings so they could prevent people
00:07:45 like finance minister francois philippe champaign testifying about his conflict of interest on the
00:07:50 Alto train. They did that, and if we have three liberals leave, that could all be undone overnight,
00:07:56 and you could actually start having, you know, testimony forced again, and the only way that
00:08:01 maybe Mark Carney could save the situation is by proroguing Parliament and just waiting out until
00:08:07 he can get his by-elections. Now, he could call them right away and basically just try and go on
00:08:13 summer break and have his government survive through that time when we're not in session,
00:08:17 But I believe the rest of Parliament, with a majority, is allowed to force Parliament to come back into session over the summer.
00:08:28 And that is a tactic that I absolutely endorse Pierre Polyev and the Conservatives engaging in with other parties' help.
00:08:37 Now I just want to move on to just a clip of Mark Carney speaking in Parliament.
00:08:41 And I'm just doing this because this one particularly annoys me.
00:08:44 I just despise this kind of, like, low IQ ballyhooing of non-successes.
00:08:53 We keep hearing that we're doing fantastic under Mark Carney.
00:08:57 Yes, we keep losing jobs every month, but there's always a silver lining to any piece of information.
00:09:03 And he is going to tell you that we're actually doing better than ever right now.
00:09:07 Asking rents have declined for 18 consecutive months.
00:09:11 every single month that this government has been in office, Canadian average salaries have increased.
00:09:18 Now, two things here. The thing about rents is actually true. In most cities, rents have gone
00:09:25 down. And that is because actually of something Trudeau started doing that Mark Carney just let
00:09:29 keep happening. Trudeau spiked immigration rates massively. TFWs, students, permanent residents,
00:09:38 all of that thing. And it ended up heavily overheating the rental market. And after when
00:09:44 Trudeau was kind of in the last couple of months in government before he stepped down, he had Mark
00:09:49 Miller, the then immigration minister, start winding down the TFW student visa rates. When
00:09:55 Mark Carney got in, he basically just held steady the decreases that Trudeau was already putting in
00:10:01 place, which lowered rents a bit. Now, this isn't really anything to brag about, considering the
00:10:06 fact that rents are still massively elevated compared to what they were just five years ago
00:10:12 and even five years ago canada was far more expensive to live in than anywhere in the united
00:10:17 states pretty much outside like new york city and san francisco but the second part there is he says
00:10:24 that wages have gone up every single canadian average salaries have gone up every month
00:10:29 canadian average salaries have increased and now the imf says that canada will be the second
00:10:35 strongest economy in the g7 this year and next we are growing canada strong no we're not the second
00:10:44 strongest economy according to the imf according to specific imf growth stats we might have the
00:10:51 second best growth in certain areas but that's considering we literally had a retracting economy
00:10:58 last year. I'm not sure if you know this, but it's like saying that, like, how do I even put
00:11:06 this? Basically, the liberals dug us into a hole and they want you to give them credit for climbing
00:11:11 out of the hole. That is what the growth is. That is what the IMF is saying is the second best
00:11:18 growth. Us simply getting back to par and pushing a little bit further when every country has been
00:11:24 growing every single year, not retracting like we have. Wages have not gone up. Average Canadian
00:11:31 wages have not gone up. This is just a consequence of the change Trudeau and Carney finally made to
00:11:37 immigration. We have less TFWs, which means that the amount of people in the economy making minimum
00:11:44 wage has gone down because we don't just have all these extra cheap laborers around for service
00:11:51 jobs, which means that if you take a couple hundred thousand TFWs out of the equation
00:11:55 on average, now the average Canadian makes more. Now, no one's actually gotten an increase in
00:12:02 their salary. It's just simply that we've lowered the amount of people working and we've mostly
00:12:08 taken them from the low end of the labor pool, meaning that we now have, I guess, technically
00:12:15 the median wage is higher, which means the average wage is higher. We can literally have not one
00:12:20 person being given a dollar more on their salary, and technically average wages have gone up. And
00:12:26 Maher Carney knows this. He's not a stupid man. He's an economist. He worked at Goldman Sachs. 1.00
00:12:33 He was at Brookfield, for goodness sake. Obviously, they know that this is like,
00:12:40 he knows that he's just fiddling with the numbers. But the last thing I want to do here is just get
00:12:45 over to the um do i want to do this yeah i guess we'll talk a little bit about cbc's coverage
00:12:51 on the pipeline issue again rosemary barton in like the worst crossover i've ever seen in my life
00:12:57 was on cbc power and politics with david cochran who are always in a competition to see who can be
00:13:03 like the worst host at the cbc every week but uh here's her talking to david cochran about the east
00:13:09 First is West fight going on.
00:13:11 Now, you know, as well as those conditions, the things that have to happen for the pipeline to get built,
00:13:16 I think there's all sorts of challenges, other political challenges that have opened up here.
00:13:21 And I presume the Prime Minister has thought of them, but I'm not sure how they are going to be resolved.
00:13:26 David Eby did not mince words in that statement.
00:13:30 And I would say that that statement might be shared by people in Quebec, too,
00:13:34 who believe that, which is where the Prime Minister has most of his power base, his political power base,
00:13:39 who believe that the prime minister is kind of bending over backwards
00:13:42 for a premier who has asked for a lot of things and is getting them in a very short timeline
00:13:49 no in fact danielle smith has not gotten a lot of anything and i'm not slagging danielle smith i
00:13:56 think she's being a little bit naive in signing this because in certain sense you're kind of
00:14:00 giving your tacit endorsement to the plan of mark carney when it's not being implemented for
00:14:04 potentially years uh but the idea that somehow alberta has been getting too much attention if
00:14:11 you look at the pro the map of major projects that have been approved for fast tracking
00:14:15 now many of them are like projects already you know 90 done or it's a small expansion to an
00:14:21 existing project regardless though yes they haven't really gotten that much done but what
00:14:26 they have gotten done is actually been concentrated outside of alberta alberta up until this pipeline
00:14:32 that is years away from even actually being approved and it probably isn't going to happen
00:14:37 is like the first one alberta has actually gotten but rosemary ignore her face here her face looks
00:14:45 very weird here but she is making kind of good points politically hacky points but points that
00:14:51 at least kind of indicate the attitude of the liberal base that mark carneau is more likely to
00:14:57 bend to at the end of the day than to the needs of Albertans. What does that mean then for the rest
00:15:03 of the premiers? How much does he have to try and placate them, including David Eby and others who
00:15:10 now say, okay, you've shown cooperative federalism works for Alberta because you're worried about
00:15:15 them staying in the country. What about the rest of us? And I'm not sure that I know how that's
00:15:22 going to unfold in the months ahead. Yeah. Now, of course, if you saw yesterday's show, David Eby
00:15:27 is currently trying to use the idea that Daniel Smith is threatening to separate from Canada
00:15:33 if she doesn't get what she wants. I mean, she's never done that. But we already have like the CBC
00:15:37 kind of giving that tacit nod to the idea that like somehow Daniel Smith is twisting the arm
00:15:43 of the prime minister and the prime minister is neglecting everybody else. That's incorrect. But
00:15:48 the part of what Rosemary said that is correct is the idea that, well, Mark Carney laid out
00:15:55 his priorities or his basically requirements for a pipeline. And that required buy-in from the
00:16:03 provinces and First Nations. Now, in a reasonable country, we would just say,
00:16:09 hack sand, we're building a pipeline anyways. I'm the prime minister, I have the power to do it.
00:16:13 But this is the requirements that Mark Carney has saddled himself with. And not only do we already have Mark Carney, sorry, David Eby basically saying no to the project, but as is reported in SICCA media here, we also have coastal First Nations remain absolute in opposition to West Coast pipeline.
00:16:34 Now, I know everyone's going to say that's not a real First Nations.
00:16:38 Yes, fact check, true.
00:16:40 But Mark Carney thinks they're a real First Nations.
00:16:43 He met with them.
00:16:43 He made his proposal to them about a pipeline.
00:16:46 And they do represent not a lot of tribes, but they do represent many bans.
00:16:51 And many bans not part of coastal First Nations are also against the pipeline, frankly, because it makes them money to oppose the pipeline.
00:16:58 And I'm not just talking about money that comes in from American nonprofits to stop pipelines.
00:17:02 I'm also just talking about consultation fees and other sorts of things like that.
00:17:08 The system of consultations makes bands a lot of money.
00:17:12 And a pipeline might actually make them less money because it's, you know, you don't need the money anymore.
00:17:18 You're economically sufficient.
00:17:20 You have a pipeline running through your territory.
00:17:22 You get some royalties from the oil and gas company.
00:17:25 But that doesn't have the big payouts attached to it that people like Stuart Phillip and those associated with the coastal First Nations want.
00:17:33 They want far bigger payouts that they can get on a one-time basis, but they can always gin something up in order to generate more.
00:17:41 So right now, Carney has signed something with Daniel Smith, where Daniel Smith is already agreeing to increase the industrial carbon tax for the chance in like two years that somehow he's going to be able to make a deal with David Eby and the First Nations to get the pipeline through?
00:17:59 I think not, because that is his requirement, and he said that he wants to get it and deal with unreasonable people, and that doesn't seem like a reasonable plan to actually get something done.
00:18:11 Anyways, well, so even Gilboa might be leaving, and it might actually not mean much of anything, which is kind of funny.
00:18:20 Mark Carney may lose his majority government, but he's not even doing it to get a pipeline built.
00:18:25 So that's not exactly a fantastic week for Mark Carney when this was supposed to be fairly triumphant.
00:18:31 But anyways, with that all being said, thank you guys for watching.
00:18:34 Make sure to like, share, subscribe, leave a comment with what you think,
00:18:38 and of course hit the join button if you want to become a member of the channel thank you to all
00:18:43 the members who are currently already there making the channel very sustainable for me
00:18:47 anyways with that being said i'll see you guys all later