The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - April 01, 2026


Carney getting ROASTED for supporting Michael Ma's CCP lies!

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
INSANE: Carney joins Michael Ma in denying forced labour in China! Caroline Elliott EXPOSED as Liberal in BC Conservative leadership race!

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

184.26

Word count

4,532

Sentence count

158

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Mark Carney continues to defend Michael Ma, despite the fact that he was the first person to question his views on forced labor in China. He also praises him for crossing the floor of his own party and joining the centre-left.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Wyatt Claypool here, and welcome back to the National Telegraph YouTube channel.
00:00:06 I need to deliver you guys some extremely not-shocking news, and that is Prime Minister
00:00:13 Mark Carney refuses to learn a lesson. Last week, just last Thursday, Liberal MP and CCP puppet
00:00:23 Michael Ma tried to deny in a committee meeting that there is any forced labor in China,
00:00:29 even when the media followed up with him and asked if he believes there's forced labor in China
00:00:33 directly asking him the question he could not say he would just say that there are you know
00:00:39 bad labor practices all over the planet and then Carney proceeded to do the same thing yesterday
00:00:45 at a press conference where people asked him whether or not he agrees with Michael Ma and
00:00:52 he made an excuse for what Michael Ma said say that he had apologized even though he had not
00:00:56 apologized. But when Carney was asked about the forced labor, he also wouldn't say if China has
00:01:03 forced labor. And now Carney has done a fundraiser event with Michael Ma. It was co-hosted by Ma,
00:01:11 and he'd proceeded to praise Ma from the podium. Now, the funny thing is it seemed like the Liberal
00:01:18 Party originally planned to distance themselves, at least temporarily, from Ma while keeping him
00:01:23 Caucus. The original invite for the fundraiser listed Ma as a co-host, and then another one
00:01:31 that came out later had removed Ma, and then maybe the liberals got some pressure from somewhere,
00:01:36 maybe Beijing, and so Michael was re-added, and now Carney again is praising him. We are about
00:01:43 to go to that video in just a second here, but before I do that, I just want to remind you guys,
00:01:48 if you like the video, make sure to leave a like. If you're on mobile, make sure to hype the video
00:01:53 below in the comment section. Leave a comment on what you think about this situation. And if you
00:01:58 like the channel a lot, consider making a monthly contribution. It's just a small financial
00:02:03 contribution per month to help make the channel more sustainable for me. And as always, if you
00:02:08 are a senior living on a fixed income, do not feel like you should be contributing. I am going to 1.00
00:02:14 keep all the content free forever. Anyways, so let's get to this tape that Shavloy Majumdar,
00:02:20 a conservative mp put out uh just an hour ago showing carney giving this or praising speech
00:02:28 to about michael ma and a closed door fundraiser so this was not meant to be seen by anyone
00:02:36 so we're going to go slowly through it because there is captions but they go by
00:02:39 fast. So
00:03:09 He's immediately going back to what Michael said when he crossed the floor, basically signaling that he's a decent man.
00:03:15 He believes in all these great shared values, and that's why we should keep embracing him.
00:03:20 Let's go back to some of the things that he said about him.
00:03:23 So look, he said he was guided by the values of building up others, which, let's be clear, that means precisely diddly squat.
00:03:35 That doesn't mean anything.
00:03:37 Apparently, he likes building up others with forced labor if he can get away with it.
00:03:41 Let's move on to the second comment that Carney makes.
00:03:44 Delivering results.
00:03:46 Results-oriented individuals and choosing a path that creates opportunities.
00:03:51 He's a results-oriented individual and likes creating opportunities.
00:03:57 That means nothing.
00:03:59 This has been the problem with all of the liberal floor crossers. 1.00
00:04:02 every single time someone crosses the floor and joins the liberals the only thing they can really
00:04:08 say are the most generic sort of truisms oh that carney is a unifier why well because i'm crossing
00:04:17 basically the only evidence that he's a unifier is that this person is crossing and joining them
00:04:21 or he's stable because he has a bigger party and he's in government that like really these people's
00:04:28 crossing is only justified by them wanting to be part of the government. And even Carney is trying
00:04:33 to cite these completely empty reasons as like some sort of signifier of this person's principle.
00:04:39 Again, this is such a lame way of trying to make people stay by Ma and not throw him under the bus
00:04:45 like they should be. Fundamental liberal values are creating opportunities, valuing results,
00:04:58 like I'm pretty sure that's just a functional person thing to value that's not ideological
00:05:03 and then the liberals in the comments will be like oh well it's because those are liberal values and
00:05:08 they're universal like no liberals are a big government wealth redistributionist very corporate
00:05:15 welfare based party these are the actual values what do they spend your money on is what the
00:05:21 liberals value in fact they're not creating opportunities they're losing tens of thousands
00:05:24 of jobs every single month they're raising taxes they are doing a lot of things that end up creating
00:05:31 less value and creating fewer opportunities but they can cite that they like creating
00:05:36 opportunities so i guess that means they're great but let's finish off this tape
00:05:39 He's so glad to welcome and work with Michael Ma. Not a word about what he had said. He's not saying that you might have heard in the media that Michael had said this and Michael would like to apologize for his words being taken out of context.
00:06:06 The problem is his words weren't taken out of context. He said what he said. And as we said in yesterday's video, Northern Perspectives pointed out that the excuse that Carney used for Ma was the same excuse he used for Paul Chang, who he later had to get rid of when Paul Chang had made a really disgusting comment about arresting Joe Tay and taking him to the Chinese consulate for the bounty on his head.
00:06:28 Joe Tay being a conservative candidate in the 25 election who was a freedom fighter in Hong Kong
00:06:33 Paul Chang who was a liberal candidate at the time and a liberal MP was mocking the idea of
00:06:39 having him arrested he later had to get rid of him even though Carney had pretended like it was all
00:06:44 okay because he quote-unquote apologized which he didn't do same thing's happening again with
00:06:48 Michael Ma and I think this will end up damaging him quite severely with a lot of voters in Canada
00:06:54 because he's eating the scandal. He's just going to eat the scandal and hope it goes away
00:07:00 because he really wants his majority. This is indicative of the fact that the liberals don't
00:07:05 actually think they can win all three by-elections. The Terrebonne by-election could go to the Bloc
00:07:11 Quebecois, and that would mean if he only wins two out of three, replacing Freeland and Bill Blair
00:07:17 in Scarborough and University Rosedale, that he will need Michael Ma's seat in Markham Unionville
00:07:23 in order to pass stuff. So he's basically just okay with ideological corruption, with a Chinese 1.00
00:07:30 CCP puppet being in the caucus, because he wants that majority government. He's going to actually
00:07:36 take such a blow from Canadians who already thought the floor crossings felt sleazy,
00:07:41 now knowing how much Mark Carney values the votes more than he values the actual principles of the
00:07:47 matter. But now I want to get to another video. This was from CTV News, where they were discussing
00:07:54 how this had gone down, and the reviews from the commentators are terrible. There's not really
00:08:02 anyone defending what Michael Ma did. They'll maybe make excuses that, well, at least he
00:08:07 apologized, but he didn't really apologize. When the liberals, obviously the conservatives on the
00:08:12 panel attack michael ma but even the liberals are very apologetic about this because they can't
00:08:18 pretend this is a non-issue uh check out this segment with uh bashi cavallis on ctv news
00:08:23 uh has apologized for his comments as he should have uh he's recognized the seriousness of the
00:08:30 issue uh in that in that apology so the first is to recognize up front the seriousness of the issue
00:08:37 he does. He's apologized. He apologized directly to Ms. McQuaid Johnson as well, but then more
00:08:44 broadly about the issue. He continues to be a member of our caucus, and I'll continue to work
00:08:50 with him. That was Prime Minister Mark Carney facing questions for the first time on the
00:08:57 controversy surrounding an exchange at a parliamentary committee last week involving
00:09:01 Liberal MP Michael Ma. Ma, who crossed the floor from the Conservatives to the Liberals in December,
00:09:05 faced backlash for appearing to question the practice of forced labor in China,
00:09:09 interrogating an expert and demanding to know if she's seen it with her own eyes.
00:09:13 He's since apologized. As you heard there, the prime minister isn't saying, though,
00:09:17 whether Ma will face consequences for his comments or whether he will still co-host
00:09:21 a liberal fundraising event with him tonight in Markham.
00:09:24 So this was before the event, obviously. We do know he hosted the event, and we do know that
00:09:30 he was not basically lessened in his prominence at that event. He, in fact,
00:09:34 appeared on stage, I believe, at one point with Carney. And then Carney made those glowing
00:09:38 comments about him pretending like he's this like standard bearer of liberal values. But here is now
00:09:45 the commentators coming in just a second. Let's bring back our front bench, Louie Hammond, Lisa
00:09:49 Raitt, Tom Mulcair, and Rob Benzie to talk about that. Lisa, I'll start with you. What did you
00:09:53 think of the prime minister's response? He's walking a tightrope here, and it has a little
00:09:58 bit to do with what's going on in the United States right now. But most of all, Vashi, I would
00:10:03 love to know what was going through doug ford's head that time because he had the strangest smile
00:10:07 on his face as he's watching it all go down i'm sure he's saying i'm glad it's not me this time
00:10:12 in the united states there is an inquiry going on under section 301 and it has to do with whether
00:10:20 or not there's forced labor in supply chains and it's against canada we're one of the countries
00:10:25 named if the u.s finds that there is forced labor in a supply chain then unfortunately they can put
00:10:32 tariffs on. They can choose what they can do with respect to our economy. So the prime minister has
00:10:37 a very fine line to walk. He can't admit that there is forced labor because it plays into the
00:10:41 hands of the United States. But equally, he can't say that there isn't because we all know that
00:10:45 there is. And here, and Lisa Raid's the conservative on the panel, and she's making a good 0.76
00:10:49 point. I just temper that with the fact that it's not shocking that Lisa Raid is saying this.
00:10:53 She makes a good point because if the one thing I would disagree with her on is that it's not
00:10:59 really that Carney's walking a tightrope, he's already caught. The United States isn't going to
00:11:04 be stupid and pretend like Canada isn't obviously using supply chains that involve forced labor. 0.96
00:11:10 They know that based on Carney's integration with China, his excitement in wanting to integrate as 1.00
00:11:16 much as possible with China, that Carney is throwing better judgment to the wind, and a U.S.
00:11:21 investigator is very easily going to be able to find that production that is coming to Canada,
00:11:26 are a lot of the goods that are coming into our country or that we have a trade partnership for
00:11:31 our own manufacturing. It's going to involve parts and pieces that have forced labor or indentured
00:11:36 servitude attached to them in China. It's giving the Trump administration a great excuse to keep 0.97
00:11:42 tariffs on. And in this case, Carney's not really going to be able to have some sort of moral
00:11:47 grandstanding moment when Trump comes out and says, well, I'm going to have to keep tariffs
00:11:51 on them because they keep using child slaves in a lot of the production of goods that they're 0.96
00:11:56 taking into their own country. We'll get back to the tape here and hear a bit more from the
00:12:00 commentators. It's a tough situation that Mr. Ma has put the prime minister in.
00:12:06 We lost Lisa's picture there. That's why everybody at home was stuck on a shot of me for as long as
00:12:11 uncomfortably possible. We are hearing Lisa perfectly, though, so I'll pick up on her point,
00:12:16 Louis, and ask you, I think part of the tightrope, as she rightly points out, is what's going on with
00:12:21 the United States in their investigation. Part of it is also the pursuit of a different relationship,
00:12:26 a new and expanded relationship with China. I imagine that's factoring in as well,
00:12:31 rightly or as many would contend wrongly. So to give you a little bit of a dynamic of the
00:12:36 panel here. So Lisa Wright, who was on screen and now is not on screen, was the conservative.
00:12:42 The two guys on the diagonal here are, I believe, more liberal. The guy who's about to speak,
00:12:47 I think, is the commentator from CTV News, but generally going to be a bit more liberal leaning,
00:12:52 trying to be more neutral. And then you have Tom Mulcair there in the right corner,
00:12:55 the former NDP leader, who I would actually say is kind of more liberal himself these days. Like,
00:13:00 he's definitely no Avi Lewis NDP guy. He is a very much and like sort of like a halfway between
00:13:06 liberal and NDP kind of a personality, more of a Trudeau or a Carney than he is Avi Lewis,
00:13:14 who is a complete radical right there's no there's no question about it i mean and obviously the
00:13:20 prime minister is in a bit of a pickle tonight because he doesn't want to antagonize the chinese
00:13:25 just as his finance minister mr champagne is heading to beijing this week on a mission as
00:13:32 a follow-up to the state visit that mark carney paid to beijing early year and so it's a very
00:13:37 tight line for him to walk he has to be careful there's no question about it and you know what
00:13:43 the chinese are looking at this and they're probably asking okay where do we send the box 0.86
00:13:47 of chocolates in ottawa i mean they're already weaponizing this this this informationist propaganda
00:13:54 against professor mcway johnson who testified before committee as you mentioned it and as i
00:13:59 said they're probably asking where do we send the bouquet of flowers um but i think actually if you
00:14:04 take us and he's absolutely right about that we ended up covering it on the show the other day
00:14:09 A viewer of the show, Nehan Azam, had brought it to my attention that pro-CCP publications, both in Canada and in Beijing, were praising Michael Ma's own performance in that committee, meaning denying the forced labor, basically saying, look at this hero, this principled man standing up into Margaret McQuaid Johnson, saying that she has no evidence of forced labor because she has not seen it with her own eyes, which is just insane.
00:14:37 We know tons of things we have not seen with our own eyes are real, but Michael Ma was just making the most backhanded, dumb excuse for basically pretending like something doesn't exist because this particular person hasn't snuck in that province herself and monitored it from the hills with her own binoculars. 0.78
00:14:55 It's so ridiculous. 0.74
00:14:57 And so Mark Carney and the liberals know what the Chinese government's position on that was. 0.95
00:15:03 They were happy with it.
00:15:04 So it would be hard for Carney to now, unless he actually grew a spine, to say that, no, there is forced labor in China.
00:15:11 Michael Ma is out of my caucus for saying those disgusting comments, and we are going to reevaluate how we trade with China.
00:15:18 No, no, he's full speed ahead.
00:15:19 He is the same position as Michael Ma.
00:15:22 Step back and you look at this.
00:15:24 I think this illustrates two things for Mark Carney.
00:15:27 Number one, a short majority is a very tricky thing to deal with.
00:15:32 I think that in normal circumstances, there is a world in which Mr. Ma would have been excluded from caucus after these comments.
00:15:41 That's not going to happen because Mark Carney cannot afford to lose a single MP.
00:15:46 And the other thing that I think it illustrates is that it's all fine and good for Mark Carney.
00:15:50 And I think he's on the right track with wanting to sort of, you know, lift our dependence, economic dependence on the United States,
00:15:56 strike new strategic economic partnerships with countries like China and India.
00:16:02 but you know what if you're going to deal with countries like china and india you're going to
00:16:05 have to be very transactional and by virtue of being transactional that's that means oftentimes
00:16:10 you're going to need to overlook maybe some of the things on which you used to put on a premium
00:16:16 i'm not trying to suggest that mark carney doesn't care about human rights and slave labor
00:16:20 i'm sure he does but it isn't the first okay but how much do you really care about it this
00:16:25 is where the little bit of the liberalism comes in how much do you really care about it if you're
00:16:31 willing to just ignore it in this case it's demonstrating that your hierarchy of values puts
00:16:36 concern over child labor and forced labor kind of lower down on the scale that you're willing to
00:16:41 defend your own mp's disgusting comments denying that it even exists first thing top of mind that's
00:16:48 going to be mentioned when canadian when champagne or mr carney back in january sits down with the
00:16:54 the authorities in Beijing. Are we going to hear them say it that bluntly, Benzie?
00:17:00 I don't think we will. I think I think Louie's right. I think it's a difficult situation for
00:17:06 the prime minister politically because he doesn't have he doesn't yet have a majority. He'll have
00:17:11 one probably two weeks from tonight. But even then, it'll be so slim. He can't afford to lose
00:17:16 an errant MP. What Mr. Ma said was idiotic and problematic for the government and offensive 1.00
00:17:23 to a professor who's very well regarded um and i think i was at the event today with the prime 0.99
00:17:30 minister and premier ford and mayor chow uh and you could tell mr carney was getting that his
00:17:36 body language was such that this was something that bugged him clearly he wasn't just bothered
00:17:40 by the indigenous protesters who were screaming that's what you could hear on the clip uh it was
00:17:44 it was clearly uh that this was a concern for him but it's not that much of a concern because right
00:17:49 about now in about an hour or so he's going to be at a golf course in markham uh with mr ma at a
00:17:56 liberal fundraiser so i think politics is is is a dirty business and this is a a tricky a tricky
00:18:03 situation for a for a rookie prime minister who has you know so far been very very lucky and
00:18:09 fortunate and had incredible uh incredibly uh he's sort of the rookie of the year so far in politics
00:18:15 but who knows the things could get messy this is i kind of love this because that guy is very
00:18:23 clearly a liberal on the panel even he's not defending it he's doing what the media did back
00:18:29 in snc lavalin the snc lavalin scandal with justin trudeau they don't necessarily defend
00:18:35 justin trudeau but they talk about how tricky of a situation this is and let's see how mark carney
00:18:40 uses his skill, wit, and charm to get out of it. Like, no, he messed up. It's your responsibility
00:18:48 as an observer who supposedly cares about principle and ethics to hold him to account
00:18:54 to say that what he should be doing is getting rid of Michael Ma. But we just kind of act like
00:18:58 there's this big confusing mess that's going on. And maybe the rookie of the year, Mark Carney,
00:19:03 might be able to figure out a way out of this paper bag that he's in. It's like, no, there's
00:19:08 no way out of this other than doing the right thing. Either he doesn't do the right thing and
00:19:14 deserves criticism forever for doing it, or he does do the right thing and maybe we can give him
00:19:18 a small golf clap if he actually gets rid of Michael Ma. I will come on the show and give him
00:19:22 a golf clap if he gets rid of him. He's not going to, but the way a lot of liberals like to frame
00:19:27 this thing is, oh, this is a mess that Mark Carney's going to have to deal with. And there's
00:19:33 just a presupposition that, well, you know, if he can kind of bury it by the next week, he's dealt
00:19:39 with it, even though he's really just trying to make people ignore the thing that happened,
00:19:43 happened, and allow Michael Ma to continue being a CCP puppet in his own caucus. Let's get to the
00:19:50 last comments made by Tom Mulcair here, and then we'll probably be done. I've got just one minute
00:19:55 left. We've got a camera at that fundraiser, I'll say, so we'll see what happens there. It all goes
00:19:59 to you, Tom. Last word to you. Well, without in any way trying to defend what Mr. Ma did, I do
00:20:04 think it's fair to remember that when you're in a parliamentary committee, you're not in a court
00:20:08 of law. Expert testimony is open to a simple question like, can you cite your sources? Can
00:20:13 you tell us which human rights group who's able to back this up? That's a fair question.
00:20:19 Okay, that's fair. But Tom Mulcair is being way too fair to Michael Ma.
00:20:26 did we did we we watched we've watched the tape several times Michael Ma I don't need to play it
00:20:30 again Michael Ma was not saying who is the source for that uh can I can I get that can you send that
00:20:36 to my office I'd really like to see what the human rights watch has said what you know all these other
00:20:41 groups have said no no he was asking snarky snide yes or no questions trying to act like oh so you
00:20:48 haven't seen it yourself that was the attitude it wasn't Michael Ma being genuinely curious
00:20:54 and inquisitive about what she had and saying well i i want the citations because i like having
00:20:59 the citations he doesn't care about the citations he blew her off what mr ma did though is what you
00:21:06 described your word vashi which okay there we go i actually actually is right but so he and i'll
00:21:12 assume that he's making a steel man argument and trying to basically give the best interpretation
00:21:16 of what ma could do and then reversing and saying but we know he didn't do that that's a fair
00:21:22 question what mr ma did though is what you described your word vashi which was to interrogate
00:21:27 as if he was cross-examining and going after the witness and i think that that's where the whole
00:21:31 thing fell apart because there you're not looking for information you're looking to score a political
00:21:35 or other point but i think that we have to understand that in a parliament questions get
00:21:39 asked and and it has to move on i do think that the canadian government is going to have to clear
00:21:44 the air on this for the reason that lisa gave we're going to have to stay with the idea of the
00:21:49 courts. We're going to have to build a business case and a legal case to prove that we're dealing
00:21:53 with a government that is not doing the things that the Americans are likely going to be alleging
00:21:57 as they seek to impose new tariffs, especially with regard to the electric vehicles.
00:22:02 Well, the problem is that we can't build a case. The way that we would have to build a case that
00:22:07 could pass the smell test for the Trump administration is somehow prove that China
00:22:12 isn't engaging in massive amounts of forced labor and child labor. That's the only way we can do that. 0.71
00:22:19 I don't think we're going to be able to clear like China, who is like the John Wayne Gacy of forced labor here. 1.00
00:22:27 I'm not sure if we're going to be able to prove they didn't do it because that's effectively what Tom Mulcair is proposing there.
00:22:34 I like Tom Mulcair's take sometimes, but that's just was kind of weak overall.
00:22:39 But then that's proving how much of a kind of a liberal he has become since being the NDP leader.
00:22:43 He's still trying to kind of find a way through this whole thing for Mark Carney.
00:22:48 and it's like there's just not there's really not Mark Carney either eats the scandal which
00:22:53 it looks like he's going to try and do and he's going to take as much pain as it's going to cost
00:22:57 him or he gets rid of Michael Ma and that's a very slim chance at this point although he did
00:23:02 reverse himself previously and get rid of Paul Chang before the last election but I'm not holding
00:23:06 my breath for something like that to happen anyways with that all being said thank you guys
00:23:11 for watching thanks for keeping up with the Michael Ma saga that's currently going on this
00:23:17 story is not going to go away. I'm going to keep covering it as much as Mark Carney keeps allowing
00:23:22 me to cover it by not getting rid of Michael Ma. But I will be switching up the topics in future
00:23:27 videos. I still want to talk a little bit about Mark Carney at the Juno Awards because, man,
00:23:33 that's embarrassing. I don't even necessarily want to talk about Mark Carney other than it's just
00:23:38 embarrassing that he attended the event. I need to talk about that weird throat singing performance
00:23:43 that happened on the stage because if you don't know they were doing some like tribute to Nelly
00:23:48 Furtado who was like being conducted into the Canadian Music Hall of Fame or like whatever
00:23:53 award that she was getting a Lifetime Achievement Award. The woman who's doing the throat singing 1.00
00:23:58 is this insane activist who screamed and did all this weird huffing and puffing when we were at
00:24:06 UVic in the face of Dallas Brody the 1BC leader the leader I work for and why I'm currently in
00:24:12 british columbia right now uh yeah so that person who obviously has some issues uh for some reason
00:24:20 got to do their weird non-singing singing at the juno awards and it was horrifying it sounded like
00:24:26 a backed up garburator but we will be getting that into another getting into that in another
00:24:31 video anyways thank you guys for watching and i'll see you all next time