The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - August 19, 2026


Carney Is A Fraud - Trump Trade Deal is Hot Garbage for Canada!

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Carney Completely Freezes When Asked About Trump - Liberals Make Excuses! Carney Getting SMACKED by his Own Trump Trade Deal!

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

193.66

Word count

9,035

Sentence count

343

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

33

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 So, apparently, Mark Carney and the Liberals have a trade deal with Trump and the Americans.
00:00:05 And I want to clarify something I said yesterday on the show.
00:00:09 I said I don't think Mark Carney is going to get a trade deal.
00:00:12 Now, obviously, I don't think he was just going to sit there and let 50% more tariffs hit us and do absolutely nothing.
00:00:19 I always believed that he'd probably sign something last minute at least to deflect those new 50% tariffs.
00:00:25 What I thought is he's never going to sign something that's going to be wide-ranging and deal with the problems that we want dealt with.
00:00:32 And that's exactly what is happening here.
00:00:35 We're not actually dealing with the major problems.
00:00:37 We're, like, slightly lowering tariffs, but the pain is still going to be ongoing, if not permanent now.
00:00:44 The entire thing makes a farce out of Mark Carney pretending, like,
00:00:48 I've dealt with Donald Trump before and I'm going to sign a good deal for Canadians.
00:00:52 The current deal looks like it's locking us in at tariff rates that we had back in May 2025.
00:01:00 That's a victory.
00:01:01 He was literally running against the current tariff rates that we are now agreeing to permanently.
00:01:08 But don't just take my word for it.
00:01:10 We will be jumping into some of the details in just a second here.
00:01:13 But first, just reminding you guys, if you like the show, make sure to leave a like on the video.
00:01:18 Subscribe if you are not yet a subscriber.
00:01:19 We are getting close to having 100,000 subscribers on this channel, less than 5,000 to go.
00:01:25 So if you are not a subscriber and you've watched my show a couple times, hey, why not hit the subscribe button, be a pal.
00:01:32 And, of course, if you guys want to help out more, you can always hit the join button and become a monthly contributing member of the channel.
00:01:38 It really helps make it more sustainable for me.
00:01:40 And, of course, leave a comment on what you think about the current deal that Mark Carney looks like he's negotiating with with President Donald Trump.
00:01:48 So this came out late last night. It was literally 11 p.m. Eastern time, one hour before the new tariffs were going to go into place.
00:01:57 Mackenzie Gray here from the Globe and Mail was reporting. He said,
00:02:00 Breaking, Trump has paused a new 50% tariffs on Canada for three days because he says there's a deal on trade.
00:02:09 Now, Donald Trump here said on Truth Social,
00:02:11 I have paused the 50% tariffs against Canada that were scheduled to kick in tomorrow morning for a three-day period.
00:02:17 based on the fact that Canada and the USA, subject to finalization of the documents, have a deal.
00:02:23 The great Keystone XL pipeline long ago killed by sleepy Joe Biden may be awoken from the grave.
00:02:29 Thank you for your attention in this manner, President Donald J. Trump.
00:02:32 Now, the funny thing about the whole Keystone XL pipeline being mentioned by Donald Trump is,
00:02:37 as we're going to get into it, Mark Carney doesn't actually mention it in his own statement.
00:02:42 For some reason, only Americans have actually mentioned the Keystone XL pipeline so far.
00:02:46 and that kind of proves that Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and to a certain extent also
00:02:52 Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe have the right attitude in dealing with the Americans. The only
00:02:57 silver lining of this deal is that the Keystone XL pipeline might get built and the great thing
00:03:02 is that Alberta and Saskatchewan do not need to rely on other provinces to build this. I'm not
00:03:07 even sure if it goes into Saskatchewan. I'm just saying those are the two reliable provinces
00:03:11 obviously when it comes to building energy infrastructure this thing can just go right
00:03:16 over the Alberta or Saskatchewan border into the United States without the need to negotiate with
00:03:22 British Columbia with a bunch of First Nation bands we can just do it the rest of the deal
00:03:28 is not so good but let's first get into what Mark Carney posted yesterday which was very vague it
00:03:36 didn't really give a lot of details and in fact he doesn't even use the word deal when talking about
00:03:41 the potential trade deal. Maybe a focus group told him, do not say deal because dealing with
00:03:46 Trump is bad for your poll numbers. I don't know. But he said yesterday, my statement on ongoing
00:03:52 Canada-U.S. trade negotiations. Over the last number of weeks, Canada has engaged in intensive
00:03:58 discussions with the United States to address outstanding trade issues and deliver greater
00:04:03 certainty and real benefits for Canadian businesses, workers, farmers, and families.
00:04:07 substantial progress has been made although there is some important work still to be done
00:04:11 as the work is ongoing the united states has agreed to postpone the implementation
00:04:16 of its 50 percent tariff on a range of canadian goods under section 338 of the u.s tariff act of
00:04:22 1930 until the end of day august 21st while we continue this work canada remains focused on
00:04:28 building a stronger more independent and more competitive economy at home now what you will
00:04:33 notice between the statements that the Carney liberals make and the Trump administration makes
00:04:39 is that the Trump administration is far more detailed. Even though it's early going,
00:04:46 they do kind of give you little nuggets of what they thought they got out of this. Trump, in his
00:04:50 just very short statement, shorter than Mark Carney's, immediately mentioned the Keystone XL
00:04:55 pipeline. And probably the Keystone XL pipeline was always going to be built. It wasn't really
00:05:00 like a project that i think anyone in canada has a problem with anymore especially since it really
00:05:06 only has to do with alberta and america and so you know maybe carney threw that in as like a little
00:05:11 bit of like a sweetener to the deal if he did that's smart that's not a bad thing to do uh but
00:05:17 overall it's kind of a little bit you know like when you see the rest of the deal it's like okay
00:05:22 maybe you got a little bit extra from throwing in the keystone xl pipeline and if you did something
00:05:27 that was really easy to do you know good on you but the rest of the deal i wish he was doing that
00:05:33 more so uh you know like throwing in little goodies that canadians either want to do anyways
00:05:38 or would like to get rid of in the case of supply management in order to reduce the tariff rates
00:05:43 because like spoiler alert we're not really building any uh we're not really doing much
00:05:48 when it comes to reducing tariff rates so this was posted by a canadian news correspondent in
00:05:54 washington and he says josh wingrove here trump's official declaration says canada has quote
00:06:02 expressed a commitment to remove the discriminated discriminations or unreasonable and unequal
00:06:07 impositions on dairy alcohol and vehicles the basis of the on of the potential new tariffs
00:06:13 now one thing to be a little wary of in terms of if this deal actually goes through or not is he
00:06:19 mentions on dairy and as of today the liberals are heavily walking back the idea that they're
00:06:25 going to touch dairy at all that they're going to touch supply management at all maybe they still
00:06:29 are and they're really trying to massage it in front of canadians but what it sounds like we've
00:06:34 done is we've just gone back to may 2025 june 2025 tariff rates because remember later on in 2025
00:06:42 or early 26, that's when tariffs on aluminum, steel, lumber, they all jumped up to 50%.
00:06:49 Now, look what has happened. Because, you know, this ain't really great. It looks like we basically
00:06:57 settled for what were the tariff rates that we considered intolerable in early 2025 as like a
00:07:03 big win. Check this out. From Table Salt here, good account for following little breaking news
00:07:10 things on social media. He says, Bloomberg reporting that the Canada-US deal locks in
00:07:16 a 25% US tariff on Canadian steel and aluminum in a blow to Kearney. It means that in order to get
00:07:23 rid of the new August 19th 50% tariff, we had to lock in the previous bad deal we had. And we're
00:07:29 not even touching softwood lumber yet. And I haven't heard anything on autos. Maybe if we
00:07:34 reduce the autos to nothing, that wouldn't be actually too bad. In fact, maybe the private
00:07:38 sector unions and the auto plants in Canada would be happy with that because it might mean if
00:07:43 there's still aluminum and steel tariffs why not build the car with the aluminum and steel in
00:07:47 Canada and then take the tariff-free car once it goes to the U.S. or a very low tariff that would
00:07:53 be a silver lining it's still not great for the entire economy if that's true and I'm just
00:07:57 speculating I have no clue at the what it's going to look like on autos even if that was true you
00:08:02 know round of applause for the auto sector fair enough take what you can get but the overall
00:08:08 economy would still not be doing so hot because we effectively would have to funnel all of our
00:08:12 steel and aluminum through the auto sector to actually have its finished products bought by
00:08:17 the Americans. Because a 25% steel and aluminum tariff basically makes it that you're really
00:08:23 never going to source Canadian steel and aluminum as an American firm first. You're always going to
00:08:28 go for steel and aluminum producers in America. It doesn't matter if the Canadians can do it 1.00
00:08:33 cheaper, the tariff makes it more expensive automatically. And now this would be a great
00:08:38 time for Carney and the Liberals to cut taxes substantially, especially for corporations.
00:08:43 But no, we're Liberals, so we're never actually going to do that. And apparently we also have to
00:08:47 be getting rid of the booze ban right now. So of course, you know, Laura Babcock, Charlie Angus,
00:08:54 and Klaus Kellerman most affected here. I want to jump over to actually Laura Babcock's,
00:09:01 um her reaction to all this i'm just going to highlight first the thing that she ends up
00:09:05 commenting on uh jeffrey lescombe here says if as part of the canada u.s deal canada opens the door
00:09:12 to more american dairy let me assure you no canadian i know would touch american dairy with
00:09:17 a 10-foot pole even if it were free thanks for your attention to this matter no have you have
00:09:25 have these people ever met a struggling family if the dairy products were cheaper or free they will
00:09:33 take them because in fact most people are not so economically comfortable that they can base their
00:09:39 lives around hating america now what glora babcock says in response is truly unhinged but of course
00:09:46 we're going to go over to her praising carny anyways laura here says no u.s booze and in
00:09:52 brackets after all these things she says like uh she says something like watery so no u.s booze
00:09:58 watery no u.s dairy gross no u.s produce explosive diarrhea no u.s travel ice gestapo well you know
00:10:07 laura i hope that you're not going to just sneak over the border because you know the ice doesn't
00:10:11 need to arrest you if you you know go the legal way but oh i know she says here canadians will
00:10:17 boycott American goods and travel until the scourge of Trump and Meg is long gone,
00:10:23 regardless of any new trade deals. We have freedom of choice. And so notice how she puts
00:10:28 deals in scare quotes. So she doesn't actually believe this is a deal. This is bad. But let's
00:10:34 just go back to this. No U.S. booze, watery. No U.S. dairy, gross. No U.S. produce, explosive
00:10:40 diarrhea. You should talk to your doctor, Laura. I don't want to deal with that one. But if you're
00:10:45 having explosive diarrhea because of u.s produce i don't think that's a u.s thing i think that might
00:10:49 be a you know what you how you're consuming things how you're washing it and all that
00:10:54 and then again no u.s travel ice gestapo i don't know how that affects you unless you're
00:11:00 illegally jumping the border to enter the united states maybe that's a common practice for laura 0.96
00:11:04 babcock but all these people they always list booze first because that's the biggest thing 1.00
00:11:09 oh my goodness guys laura babcock's not gonna drink bourbon good honor i don't know maybe her 1.00
00:11:14 liver will be happier with her if she doesn't do that. But, like, these people would drink the 1.00
00:11:20 bottle tears of Uyghur Muslim slaves in China before they would drink bourbon because they're 0.94
00:11:27 irrational anti-Americans. You don't have to like the tariffs from America. In fact, I hate them so 1.00
00:11:33 much that I don't like the deal that Carney is cutting because it's leaving so many of them in
00:11:38 place. But it doesn't matter if we got a zero tariff deal. Laura Babcock would have not been
00:11:43 buying American products anyways. She probably never bought American products to begin with. 0.97
00:11:48 He is just an America hater like Charlie Angus. In just a second now, I want to take you guys,
00:11:54 I actually do want to play an excerpt from her show yesterday just to show you the
00:11:57 unhinged kind of rhetoric her and Charlie Angus were engaging in 24 hours before.
00:12:03 But she says this in response to Mark Carney's statement I showed earlier. She says,
00:12:08 thank you for your efforts prime minister no one wants your job to have to deal with the
00:12:13 mercurial mercurial madman in the white house what are you happy with the efforts i thought 1.00
00:12:19 you'd put in the deals and scare croats like it's all nonsense anyways i hated the stupid lie 1.00
00:12:26 you can't deal with donald trump you can deal with them carney just sucks at it you know exhibit 1.00
00:12:32 proof is that we have a deal that's only reducing tariffs and not eliminating them. It's almost like 0.97
00:12:38 we should have made a deal back when the tariffs were only 25% because then we're making a deal
00:12:43 to take it from that position lower. The problem is when you burn all your leverage, everything has
00:12:49 value. When you give concessions for free and you aren't chipping away at the current tariffs by
00:12:53 giving things, then when they go up and you have less leverage, then all you can do is slightly go
00:13:00 down from there. The thing is that our hand has only become weaker since then. We've only become
00:13:06 jumpier when we actually have the opportunity to negotiate, which results in us doing things
00:13:12 mostly just to prevent even more tariffs from hitting us, and the amount of actual damage
00:13:17 we're doing to the current tariffs is minimal. When the 25% tariffs were around, we should have
00:13:22 gone to the table, played hardball. I'm never saying let's beg and let's get on our knees and
00:13:27 say oh we'll give you whatever you want to take the tariffs away there's a certain way negotiations
00:13:32 are done oftentimes and this is something trump is famous for you ask for more than you actually
00:13:37 want you act more aggressive than you're actually willing to be and at the end of the day you have
00:13:41 to make the other person feel like they won it's just how negotiations work do you think you'd ever
00:13:46 sell a house if at the like right before the signing you start making fun of the person like
00:13:51 oh my goodness you're paying probably a hundred thousand dollars more than you really should
00:13:54 No, you don't. You act like it's the greatest deal that's ever been signed and the person's actually ripping you off. That's what Carney should have been doing. But he is scared of Trump because Trump, in his mind, is a stupid non-sophisticate and Carney is the sophisticated. He is the most sophisticated on earth.
00:14:10 So he was always scared of engaging with Trump directly, not wanting to look like he got fleeced. And I guess his fear has been proven true because he got fleeced here. He has burned a lot of ammo for very, very little in return.
00:14:25 I want to jump over to Dominic LeBlanc speaking here to reporters next to Jameson Greer. I think actually Jameson Greer walked away right before the clip of him plays, but I watched the whole CPAC clip, skipping the French parts, of course, of Jameson Greer and Dominic LeBlanc speaking.
00:14:43 When it got to Dominic LeBlanc, the thing I found very telling, and this goes back to the supposed claim that we are giving up something regarding dairy, that the one thing Dominic LeBlanc talks about is supply management.
00:14:56 That is the thing he thinks is most important to portray to Canadians.
00:15:01 And ongoing U.S. concerns about how the Canadian government allocates quotas for carefree imports of dairy products.
00:15:08 Minister LeBlanc had this to say about the supply management system.
00:15:11 I am very confident in these discussions. And as we finalize the final text, as Ambassador Greer said, the prime minister was very clear. We needed to protect supply management. We needed to ensure that the supply management regime remained entirely intact.
00:15:28 and i'm entirely intact this is apparently the god of canadian politics we cannot touch supply
00:15:37 management notice how i did not say the liberal party because i am about going to get to a clip
00:15:42 where i have to admonish here polio who said that we shouldn't have touched it's good we don't touch
00:15:47 supply management i'm going to explain why he thinks that and why people should stop thinking
00:15:53 because none of these people actually believe in supply management they just don't understand how
00:15:57 interest groups work. I'm confident that that's the case. So, you know, we're waiting to see
00:16:02 clarification between those comments. What, if anything, has been tweaked? You know, Greer also
00:16:08 spoke about economic security and digital alignment. We are short on details about what
00:16:12 that looks like. She is not blinking, by the way. I just have to comment on that. You know, and I
00:16:17 know no shot at her. She's probably been up all night drinking coffee, following this whole thing 1.00
00:16:22 completely wired but that's just something i had to say on paper and you know trump in a social
00:16:27 media post last night suggested keystone xl could be you know quote awoken from the grave as part
00:16:33 of an agreement you know that of course is that pipeline project the biden administration canceled
00:16:38 which would have moved oil from alberta to us refineries again not hearing from the canada side
00:16:43 about what exactly has been negotiation negotiated um and we don't know more about what this means
00:16:49 for other hard-hit Canadian industry.
00:16:52 I think she was on screen for like 40 seconds.
00:16:54 I think I counted three blinks, but whatever. 0.95
00:16:56 Good for her. 1.00
00:16:57 And she's right.
00:16:58 You know, she's not making the point herself,
00:17:00 but she's just kind of, you know, implying the point.
00:17:03 Why are we always learning the details of these things
00:17:05 from the Americans?
00:17:06 The 50% to 25% steel and aluminum tariffs news
00:17:09 came from Bloomberg, an American company
00:17:11 or American news outlet.
00:17:13 We have not learned anything from the Canadian side
00:17:16 other than we are definitely not touching supply management.
00:17:19 Why not touch it? Because again, things have value. If you put it on the table, it's not like Trump's like, I'm going to give you nothing for it. You know, this isn't Pawn Stars or whatever, where you're going to, you know, put something on the table. He says, actually, it's worth $0 because it's a fake or something like that. You will get something from it.
00:17:35 And so we, of course, even if I don't like supply management, if they weren't going to give us anything substantial in return, maybe I'm going to say, well, I'm not going to offer you it because you're not giving me enough.
00:17:45 This is what I mean with hardball.
00:17:46 You have to be willing to give something up to get more back.
00:17:50 That doesn't mean that if they say, I'm only going to give you this for it.
00:17:52 You're just like, I don't, what are we talking about here?
00:17:55 You're giving me nothing. 1.00
00:17:56 You're treating me like crap. 1.00
00:17:57 Bye. 1.00
00:17:57 And then you have to be able to walk away.
00:17:59 You have to be able to do a lot of things.
00:18:01 I know people are going to say, well, why are you being so naive?
00:18:03 You're just creating a scenario in which your ideas would work.
00:18:06 I'm not.
00:18:08 I'm actually basically saying that a lot of things can happen, and you just need to have a strategy that's dynamic. 0.99
00:18:15 Carney's strategy has only been dynamic in its stupidity. 0.96
00:18:18 Like, he takes a shot at Trump, acts really tough, talks about a middle powers alliance at Davos, and then gives him a bunch of concessions. 0.99
00:18:25 Gordie Howe Bridge, DST, Streaming Act.
00:18:27 And he didn't put those on the negotiating table and saw, what can I get for the DST?
00:18:32 Maybe putting the DST on the table to only lower the tariffs on another two points.
00:18:37 I don't like the DST either.
00:18:38 Maybe that's all you can get for it.
00:18:39 Maybe you can say, hey, I'm taking a 5% streaming tax off the table.
00:18:43 I want the steel tax and the aluminum tax also lowered by another 5%.
00:18:46 On the Netflix streaming tax, that was going to be 15%.
00:18:52 I want another 15% off.
00:18:54 And then maybe you can have a 6.5% tariff on steel and aluminum.
00:18:57 you know just enough that maybe american firms will be usually the place that people go first
00:19:02 but once you know if you're right along the border they're going to use a lot of steel and aluminum
00:19:06 from canada figure something out like that but it's like carney hasn't even thought of the fact
00:19:11 that things have value and they can be traded for value like who could have guessed a liberal doesn't
00:19:16 understand the economic value of things since they just blow money constantly and overpay for major
00:19:22 projects and all that stuff you know who could have guessed but now i need to get to the clip
00:19:26 up here, Polly, of talking about supply management. They got to figure it out. They have to realize
00:19:31 supply management is not popular. And even in the supply management writings, you are not going to
00:19:37 lose the election. Would you support changes to supply managed dairy to try to strike a deal with
00:19:43 the Trump administration? Well, what we we don't we do not believe that there should be unilateral
00:19:49 concessions to the United States of America getting nothing in return. We believe that
00:19:55 And the United States spends tens, if not hundreds of billions of dollars in subsidies to its farmers, which put our producers at a competitive disadvantage.
00:20:07 And we believe in standing up for our farmers on this side of the border, including supply managed farmers.
00:20:12 The thing is that if you're doing this, you're only standing up for supply management farmers.
00:20:17 Alberta, perfect example.
00:20:18 12% of the population of the country in terms of farmland really good quality farmland it's
00:20:24 probably even more than 12% of the country we only get 9% of the quota now I've heard it's 1.00
00:20:29 gone up a little bit like by 12% recently the chump change we're going from like 9 to like 9.5 0.98
00:20:35 in that case doesn't matter the thing is that you're not standing up for farmers you're standing 0.88
00:20:40 up for a government bureaucracy that incentivizes inefficiency and it rewards people for not being
00:20:46 very productive. And it's a cartel that keeps other dairy farmers out. Basically, it makes it 0.97
00:20:52 so that unless you're part of the special club of about 4,000 supply management farmers, you're out
00:20:59 of it. You just don't have it. And the thing is that even some of the supply management farmers,
00:21:03 if you offered them, how about dairy industry, your corporate taxes, or even your personal income
00:21:08 taxes are halved. It's going to be halved, but the whole market's going to be opened up.
00:21:12 they probably not complain all that much. We believe that they produce an excellent product
00:21:19 and we don't accept the view that our farmers are getting unfair advantages over the United States.
00:21:30 If you look south of the border, they're the ones that are doing massive subsidies that create
00:21:35 enormous one-sided advantages in their favor. What do you call what we do? By the way,
00:21:41 pound for pound per capita yes they spend more on subsidies pound for pound per capita our direct
00:21:48 and indirect subsidies are more than the american subsidies are even if they had higher subsidies
00:21:54 just see how much higher their subsidies are than us even if it's not true and just say okay how about
00:22:00 it's an open market but if you have subsidized dairy in your country we will be putting on a
00:22:05 reciprocal tariff to deal with the fact that is unfair competition. Here's what a former MP told
00:22:12 me. Really, really smart guy, and I thought it was a great point. All the MPs, liberal, conservative,
00:22:20 Black Quebecois, who are freaked out about supply management ever going away because they live in
00:22:25 these rural ridings or ridings with big rural areas in them, and they have dairy farmers in
00:22:30 their ridings. There's only 4,000 supply management dairy farms in the area. Now, not in a riding. If
00:22:38 it was in a single riding, you had 4,000 families involved in supply management dairy. Yeah, you'd
00:22:42 be kind of screwed if you ever voted against it. A lot of these farms, a lot of these ridings have 0.79
00:22:47 more farmers who do different types of agricultural work than supply management. And then they have
00:22:53 suburban and urban areas attached to them. I was told the most supply management riding,
00:22:59 The riding with the highest degree of supply management voters in terms of the farms is the Beauce.
00:23:06 If you know anything about the Beauce, that used to be the riding of Monsieur Maxime Bernier, who was always against supply management.
00:23:13 He was a very flamboyantly libertarian MP, and then he became crazy when he became the PPC leader.
00:23:19 I don't even exactly mean the ideas were crazy. I just mean, like, just became a very, you know, wishy-washy, erratic populist who cared more about attacking conservatives than actually building a movement. I literally never go after anyone. I never shame anyone for starting their own party, for pushing their movement forward as best they can. I just thought he mismanaged it terribly.
00:23:41 This is the 2015 election, where the Liberals won their majority under Justin Trudeau.
00:23:47 Maxime Bernier increased his vote count by 8.17%.
00:23:51 He got 58.89% of the vote in an election where the Liberals won a majority of the seats.
00:23:58 Yes, he spent way more than the Liberal, but if the Liberal thought they could win,
00:24:01 they would have dumped money into the riding.
00:24:03 They can't beat him because guess what?
00:24:05 Because guess what?
00:24:06 Supply management doesn't matter.
00:24:07 It is the heaviest per capita riding for dairy farmers, and they still, there's no way that they could beat Maxime Bernier until he voluntarily became a PPC guy, and then he didn't try to win re-election, and the person who beat him was not a liberal, it was a conservative.
00:24:23 Was it a pro-supply management conservative? Sure, but the anti-supply management libertarian
00:24:28 conservative had been winning every election since 2004. This is not an issue, but conservatives
00:24:34 convince themselves that if they get a phone call, that if they talk about supply management,
00:24:39 all 15 farmers showed up to my office and they complained, that's probably half the supply
00:24:43 management farmers that exist. There are not many votes. There are less than probably a thousand
00:24:48 of them and their workers combined. I'm not saying throw people aside if they're not a big part of
00:24:53 the population. I'm saying supply management isn't good for the average person. It's not good
00:24:57 for the general public. And we can find a way to make it work for those farmers in the future
00:25:01 without subsidies, without trade restrictions, without market quotas and having a cartel system
00:25:07 where only certain people are involved. We can do that. But for some reason, we have a political
00:25:13 system where everyone is terrified of a very small number of voters who make life more expensive for
00:25:20 the average canadian the average canadian whose household makes less than 70 000 a year pays one
00:25:25 to one and a half percent of their household income every year just paying for the increased
00:25:30 costs on eggs dairy cheese poultry all that stuff like just not a very wide range of products products
00:25:38 that people buy a lot of course that the the increased cost on top of the base price of the
00:25:44 product is one to one and a half percent of those families yearly incomes that's insane simply to
00:25:51 keep this bloated system going these farmers could probably be making more money if we just had a
00:25:56 more free market and their taxes were a lot far lower i'm fine give a special tax rate to farmers
00:26:02 that's like a quarter of what the current one is if that matters so much to everybody else
00:26:07 But anyways, so we've got to move on to some other stuff.
00:26:11 Hopefully you like that little political lesson in what's going on here.
00:26:15 I do want to jump over, though, to Pierre Polly's press conference again, because he did make some good points about the ongoing trade negotiations, how Carney up to this point had basically completely kept him out of the loop of what's happening.
00:26:27 And if it's true, like we're hearing, that we're only getting slight reductions back to the original levels on these tariffs, that's pathetic that you were stiff-arming away the Conservatives.
00:26:38 Has the Prime Minister briefed you at all during these negotiations since the threat of Section 338 tariffs?
00:26:44 No. No, in fact, we're here, and I reiterate my offer. Conservatives have offered to help the Prime Minister since the very beginning.
00:26:54 I've done it numerous times in our phone calls. When I went to the United States of America,
00:26:59 I very clearly refused to criticize him on foreign soil. I briefed him on my visit and
00:27:06 my meetings with governors and other American leaders. But our MPs have reached out again and
00:27:15 again to the government to offer any help we can. Richard Bragdon here is the chair of the
00:27:20 Canada-U.S. Parliamentary Friendship Group. He's been continually offering his help, but Mr. Carney
00:27:27 has refused to have any help from anybody. But we still want to make sure that he keeps his word
00:27:34 and gets the great deal, the even better deal that he promised Canadians. Remember when
00:27:40 commentator hacked, including supposed conservatives, were saying that, you know,
00:27:45 here, Polyev should really be trying to be cooperative with the Liberal government rather 0.95
00:27:49 than being so oppositional where is the cooperation fred delori you said that it's that it's loser
00:27:55 talk to be constantly chipping away at the uh the prime minister and attacking him well where is the
00:28:01 cooperation from the other side you'll never have this be criticized despite the fact the deal looks
00:28:06 like it sucks you're never going to have any criticism that they should have been working with
00:28:09 pure polyev and jamil javani and shavloy majumdar who had far better ideas on how to get a good deal 0.56
00:28:16 you're just going to have them ignore it. You're going to have tons and tons of spin about how
00:28:19 this is really the best we could have all hoped for. Really, when you think about it,
00:28:23 he did as good of a job anyone could have expected. Kate Harrison on CTV News, I thought,
00:28:27 had a really good way of summing up how pathetic this whole thing is, because we should have made 0.53
00:28:31 probably a deal in June 2025. Okay, we didn't do it. We should have made it by Carney's two due 0.50
00:28:37 dates in mid-July and at the end of July 2025. Okay, we didn't do that. But in October, when
00:28:44 the 50% tariffs were coming in on steel, aluminum, and softwood, not just the 25% ones. By the way,
00:28:51 I do have to comment on the haircut and glasses of the woman in the middle. No shot, just, you 1.00
00:28:55 know, I think the camera angle is making her look weird. But we should have been making a deal back 0.99
00:29:01 in October, as Kate Harrison points out, because what has the waiting and the extra pain of
00:29:06 sitting under these tariffs actually gotten us? Kate, what do you think? I wish the Prime Minister
00:29:12 made himself more available to Canadians than the leader of the opposition, because we may
00:29:16 actually know a bit more about what's going on. I would expect Mr. Polyak to focus on transparency
00:29:22 and on wasted time. A lot of what we are discussing today, Marcia, was discussed back in October.
00:29:28 It is very, very hard to believe that we enter this new potential deal or negotiation in a better
00:29:36 position than we were last October. So again, what have Canadians given up in order to get a
00:29:42 temporary stay of execution? And what does it mean for the long term? The Prime Minister should make
00:29:47 himself available to answer that. Kate Harrison, Sabrina Grover, really appreciate it. Yeah, and
00:29:52 she's right, because the thing is not much seemingly has changed about what we were talking
00:29:56 about in October. If anything, it's far worse, because we're only getting slight reductions,
00:30:01 again because we blew a bunch of the leverage to just simply prevent the new 50 percent tariffs
00:30:06 were coming in and then the little we had left we could get back to the original you know early
00:30:11 2025 tariff rate that was so bad at the time it was the election issue so we are in such a we are
00:30:19 in such a this is such a great deal we are back into the position where Carney was pitching
00:30:24 himself as the guy you need to fix the problem it's like he was claiming that he's the world's
00:30:30 best plumber and he's going to be able to fix the leak and the leak gets worse. And then he makes
00:30:34 the leak. He basically fixes the problem to the point where the leak is as bad as when he
00:30:39 volunteered to fix the problem. And now he's claiming that he's, you know, he's doing very
00:30:42 good work. And I found it very curious that you don't see a lot of liberals out there right now
00:30:46 celebrating the deal. No gloating from Mark Gerritsen, to my knowledge, there's like one
00:30:53 MLA, sorry, one MP from the London area last night who had like quote tweeted Mark Carney
00:30:59 statements and said like you know success we've avoided the new 50 percent tariffs if that's what
00:31:05 you're gloating about that's what you're trying to market to canadians i don't think it's going
00:31:08 to work because the elbows up propaganda as you all know was very very strong you can't simply
00:31:14 tell people well you know this is good enough you should give mark carney a big slap on the back
00:31:19 that's not how it works but liberals like this guy are going to try and do it we were listening in
00:31:23 to some of that reaction why don't we start with what we heard from donald trump and minister
00:31:29 Dominic LeBlanc because there was as we've been discussing a little bit more alignment there
00:31:33 about finalization of a deal what did you make of those remarks well I mean first of all let's
00:31:41 take a step back here and to call this negotiate a negotiation is I think a total misnomer the
00:31:46 Americans have a gun to our head with these 50 tariffs on top of the other stuff they've been
00:31:50 throwing at us and uh this so-called negotiation is what we will do to have them remove the gun
00:31:58 from our head so right right at the beginning we're at a disadvantage uh they're not putting
00:32:03 anything on the table by the way the reason and that's a that's a very weird freeze frame right
00:32:08 there i might have to take a photo of that for my personal files i always find stuff like this funny
00:32:13 but like i'm sorry you can't say uh gun to our head it's so unfair i can't believe he's doing
00:32:19 this to us okay it's unfair the reason he can threaten us this way and we can't threaten him
00:32:25 back the same way is because we have become economically weak underneath the liberals they
00:32:30 can keep saying how great everything is under carny and look how look how many jobs we created
00:32:35 in july it's like guys we still have like the lowest or second lowest employment rate that
00:32:41 were the second highest unemployment rate in the g7 and i think we're competing with france for
00:32:46 the bottom slot and we're almost right there with them and it's france guys come on like sorry our
00:32:52 economy is not healthy. That is why these threats are so devastating to us. If we had a good economy,
00:32:58 if we were cutting taxes and our productivity was increasing domestically, we could maybe wait
00:33:03 Trump out until the midterms and then he might want to make a better deal. Or we would just have
00:33:07 more leverage to be able to use against them, that they really need us because they know that
00:33:10 they really can't kind of diminish us that quickly over time because our economy is doing pretty well
00:33:16 domestically, and yet hurts us, but it's going to hurt them more. Trump knows his tariffs hurt us
00:33:23 more than they hurt him, even though they do hurt himself, but that's the whole point of a tariff
00:33:27 fight. You're basically willing to shoot yourself in the foot knowing you're doing more damage to
00:33:31 your opponent, but if we had a healthy economy, that wouldn't be true. So them acting like, oh my
00:33:36 goodness, he was threatening us, so we had to do it. We only had to do it because we have a bad
00:33:39 liberal economy. And by the way, too, Carney signed up for this. We keep acting as if he was
00:33:44 like forced into it in like a shotgun wedding type scenario where we forced him to like go and
00:33:50 negotiate the deal he volunteered claiming he was the guy who could do it and it turns out
00:33:56 well shockingly he's not the guy other than perhaps removing this gun from our head so i think it's
00:34:02 important to keep that in mind and i think it's also important to um to to to realize how that
00:34:07 that's kind of sets the parameters of the difficult job that uh prime minister carney has here it's
00:34:14 not that difficult is it so difficult that you are unable to give him concessions for nothing
00:34:21 that's just something he had to do because that's something that I'll always point back to DST
00:34:26 streaming tax our other reciprocal tariff some of the things that we're doing on autos
00:34:30 as well as the Gordie Howe bridge there's probably other stuff too under the table that we don't know
00:34:34 about yet what did this all did this all have to be given to him for free because we were complaining
00:34:39 oh my goodness Jameson Greer's not giving us any credit for that stuff yes because you gave it to
00:34:43 them for free if you give someone something for free and then you come back next week say actually
00:34:48 i want a hundred dollars for that they they are in their rights to say pack sand and i'm sorry
00:34:53 they're not our friend at the negotiating tables on the world stage they are a close ally and friend
00:34:59 at the negotiating table where they from their own perspective even if i think the tariff thing
00:35:04 is misguided and silly they are negotiating for their people and so once you're at the negotiating
00:35:10 cable. It's only Canada and the U.S. It's not Canada and the U.S. versus the world. They are 0.98
00:35:14 being going to be a bit aggressive. They're going to be a bit hostile trying to get everything that
00:35:18 they want. Of course, they're going to take everything. Would Trump, would Carney, if Trump
00:35:22 offered him things for free, would he have just taken it and then given him, but then also giving
00:35:27 him the world in return? Obviously not. Carney was the one who did that. So I hate this difficult
00:35:32 job rhetoric. He pretended like, yeah, it's a tough job, but he's the man to do it. Well, he's not
00:35:38 doing it and how there's no job so difficult that you just give things away for free for no reason 0.93
00:35:44 that was his own choice for simply buying time one of the dumbest things you could do because
00:35:49 time doesn't get us anything uh this is not about a win-win deal uh this might be kind of less pain
00:35:55 deal for canada but a lot will depend on the details and well you know what are we giving up
00:36:00 in the process and i think uh you know there's a vacuum certainly on the canadian side in terms of
00:36:06 discussion of this and that's i guess understandable given the the um state of these talks but with
00:36:12 donald trump there's never a vacuum on the other side uh there might be vacuous but there's no
00:36:17 vacuum there's blah blah bloviating and he kind of lets everything out and he defines the debate
00:36:24 that we then have to react to so it's not a clean situation that the prime minister is going to be
00:36:29 dealing i hate i hate this helpless rhetoric that we're just helpless in the face of trump and
00:36:34 Whatever he says, that's just kind of how the terms are going to go.
00:36:37 Yeah, are they the more powerful country?
00:36:39 Sure, in part economically because they have better domestic economic policy.
00:36:43 But again, Mark Carney is not a helpless bunny.
00:36:46 He can do his own thing.
00:36:48 But again, he's not very good at this.
00:36:51 He lied on his resume in order to get this job.
00:36:54 That is the problem that we all have. 1.00
00:36:57 I want to jump over to another statement that I saw the other day that I thought was so stupid, 0.99
00:37:02 I just needed to highlight it. 0.95
00:37:04 From this guy, Mark Levesque, former chief economist at the Public Sector Penchman Investment Board or whatever, reading his bio on Twitter just to give a little bit of background.
00:37:15 And this was before the deal was announced yesterday. 0.97
00:37:17 I just thought this was so stupid I had to comment on it. 0.95
00:37:20 He said, CPC partisans and influencers blaming Carney instead of Trump and occasionally backing the U.S. against Canada on trade and Kuzma is really twisted and tells you a lot about their version of the party. 0.99
00:37:34 Harper contained the yahoos, Polyev gives them free reign. 0.91
00:37:38 Well, did Harper, like, crack down on, like, people who are writing opinion articles at newspapers? 0.97
00:37:43 Like, the influencers or content creators are obviously not in pure Polyev's control.
00:37:47 They're not part of the party.
00:37:49 And nobody's ever taken Trump's side.
00:37:52 We've always been arguing on how to get a better deal for Canada.
00:37:57 We have argued against the elbows-up stuff, not because we're not patriotic, 0.99
00:38:00 because it's stupid and it doesn't get us anywhere. 0.93
00:38:02 And I thought this interaction with Roman Fischer was quite interesting, because even though I often don't agree with Roman Fischer, I thought he made some good points against Mark Levesque here. 0.99
00:38:13 He says,
00:38:14 Carney promised something which it appears he cannot deliver. For that, he can be blamed.
00:38:20 Mark Levesque says,
00:38:21 If you wish, but that's a rather minor issue in the big picture now, isn't it?
00:38:26 Especially that I highly doubt that anyone could have been able to deliver it if you believe otherwise.
00:38:30 Please explain who and how.
00:38:32 he's contradicting himself if he's saying that it could never have been done he should have never
00:38:36 promised it which was roman fisher's point stop saying you are the trump whisperer and you've
00:38:41 dealt with them before and you're going to get a great deal for canadians if you knew that was
00:38:45 never possible and by the way the way mark levesse or sorry the way that mark carney had been defining
00:38:51 great deal is that there's not going to be tariffs in place that we're not going to accept a large
00:38:55 american tariff still in place once a deal is signed but that looks like what's going to happen
00:39:00 He then says, by the way, just to clarify, I've really had it with the CPC partisan narrative on this.
00:39:06 Trump is trying to destroy us.
00:39:07 We should be standing up for our country and supporting our negotiating team, not trying to score cheap political points.
00:39:13 Sorry, what is it that we can do at home?
00:39:15 The audience watching the television show at home, what can we do?
00:39:19 Are we supposed to clap along with the Care Bears or really believe in Tinkerbell and somehow our trade negotiating team is going to do better?
00:39:26 or is constructive critique actually potentially a good idea in this case telling the liberals
00:39:33 please put supply management on the table please make the deal earlier so the american companies
00:39:39 can't get used to the tariffs and are complaining less at trump because that's what happens when you
00:39:43 wait longer the side who's better able to deal with the pain gets used to the pain faster and
00:39:49 their people are less jumpy to negotiate we should have been doing it earlier we should have been
00:39:53 willing to put certain things on the table with the condition that we are going to get something
00:39:58 substantial back in return the longer we've waited the worse the problems have gotten and less
00:40:02 leverage we've had so the leverage has bought us less off of a problem that is now worse than it 0.90
00:40:07 was a year ago and so but anyways i hate this whole dumb idea that somehow like us critiquing
00:40:14 us criticizing is like hurting the negotiating team as if like jameson greer is in the room with
00:40:20 like Dominic LeBlanc and and uh whatever our Janice Janice Charette or whatever and he just
00:40:26 picks up his phone and like shows them one of my videos I'm like hey this guy doesn't like you
00:40:30 and then they're like oh my goodness I can't believe why Claypool doesn't like us I can't
00:40:35 even negotiate anymore knowing that Mr. Claypool doesn't like the way I'm negotiating it's like
00:40:40 what what kind of isn't Mark Levesque supposed to have been somebody who had like some amount of
00:40:46 like cachet back in the day like this is such lazy thinking but roman fisher in a longer response
00:40:51 here says should carney not be held to his campaign promises if not by the opposition
00:40:57 then who else did the cpc support our national interests of course but that's not done by
00:41:03 abdicating the responsibility of holding our government to account at the same time
00:41:06 the cpc ought to push the government to achieve the best deal for canadians carney used his status
00:41:12 as an influential central bank economist to convince Canadians he was a deal-making expert
00:41:17 who would be able to save the economy. He accused the CPC of wanting to capitulate and allow for an
00:41:22 American annexation. Now the CPC are supposed to be cheerleaders, even when he makes unilateral
00:41:28 concessions and fails to live up to his promises? That's not how our system works. I have my share
00:41:33 of critiques for the CPC leadership, but bandwagoning whatever Carney does on the U.S.
00:41:38 is just not responsible absolutely 10 out of 10 response from roman fisher and it's kind of funny
00:41:44 because i find sometimes he has problems with things that uh that poly of is doing uh that's
00:41:49 kind of contradictory by the way he's talking to mark now but i find some of the anti-poly of
00:41:53 faction of like the new right guys are kind of realizing that those jabs they were taking at
00:41:58 poly of were not productive at all like anthony coach recently wrote an article at the national
00:42:02 post saying why they would be a disaster to remove pure poly of his leader and it's like agreed i
00:42:08 agree uh that's weird because you were chipping away at him for like the last three or four months
00:42:13 with like what i would call fairly unfair attacks uh things that it really wasn't pure poly's fault
00:42:19 or why would a new leader really change that problem would it would anything get better and
00:42:23 that's effectively what anthony kosh argued things will not get better if we swap him out i'm like
00:42:28 thanks for catching up to where i'm at but you know i'm happy to see they're on board now
00:42:33 mark levesque responds to roman fisher and says what if his campaign promises are unachievable
00:42:38 in the form in that form because the demented madman down south has decided he wants to get us 0.80
00:42:43 on our knees you can't keep going back to trump's crazy if you were our carney promised he was going 0.95
00:42:50 to deal with the supposed madman so you can't keep saying well he's mad well then mark carney's 0.71
00:42:54 mad for saying he was going to be able to negotiate with the madman like the logic is not
00:42:59 logicking for mark levesque he then says context matters and context can be changed yes the context
00:43:06 can the context did not change that he's dealing with trump and the context does matter because
00:43:11 this is the promise carney made to deal with trump because he's dealt with him before and as things
00:43:17 are looking right now he did not deal with him in fact he's basically capitulated in the way that
00:43:22 that the carney liberals were pretending the poly of conservatives would and he then sorry i i have 0.88
00:43:28 to keep pausing reading this because it's so stupid last sentence here last couple sentences 0.95
00:43:33 he says i have no issue with the cbc holding carney to account i do have an issue with apparently he 0.94
00:43:39 started listing stuff i don't care to read the rest of it roman fisher just says if that's the
00:43:43 case maybe they shouldn't have lied to canadians about what was to come it's not like we didn't
00:43:47 know last april that trump wanted to do to do to do our economy and what levers he had to achieve
00:43:53 that goal carney told canadians that come hell or high water he would get a good deal for canadians
00:43:58 and diversify our economy so as to mitigate future risk southern ontario is about to go through a
00:44:04 cape breton style de-industrialization if these new tariffs aren't thwarted carney expressly stated
00:44:10 he wouldn't let such things come to pass and then oh my goodness i'm just going to end this thread
00:44:14 because obviously Mark Levesque is just not getting it but Roman Fisher is absolutely right
00:44:19 and even now under the lower aluminum and steel tariffs we're probably going to have a really big
00:44:25 problem with de-industrialization because you can't just say well it went from 50 to 25 shouldn't it
00:44:31 be easier to deal with them the only reason people were dealing with it was because they were holding 0.51
00:44:36 out hope that they were going to go to zero again or go close to zero I believe the the tariff on
00:44:42 Canadian cars before this was like 6.5% or something like that. If we brought it down to
00:44:48 maybe 7% on autos or 10%, maybe we'd be able to deal with that. The problem is we were holding
00:44:54 out hope that it was going to go to zero. 25% is not acceptable to the car industry, to the auto
00:45:01 sector. They were only holding on because of hope it was going to go to zero and subsidies that they
00:45:06 were receiving. And that goes doubly for aluminum and steel and softwood. And it seems like
00:45:12 the softwood and autos may have not been dealt with at all in this particular deal that's been
00:45:20 signed because we will not touch things like supply management. But anyway, so that should
00:45:26 be it for this video, guys. Hopefully this was an informative rant on the current state of trade
00:45:31 policy. Maybe something's going to leak out later and I'm going to reverse myself and say Mark
00:45:36 Carney's a genius. I can't believe he engineered such an amazing deal. But the liberal's not
00:45:41 gloating about it. Not seeing Mark Gerritsen gloating about what's been signed tells me that
00:45:47 it's not great. And now Mark Carney gets to convince provinces that have the booze bans in
00:45:52 place to get rid of them for a deal that's not fantastic. Maybe Quebec will sign on now because
00:45:58 lower, there's, you know, there's low, they're not touching supply management anymore,
00:46:02 but they do a lot in terms of steel and aluminum. And what are they now going to do when it comes to
00:46:08 like are they going to take the booze off and put the booze back on the shelves having just avoided
00:46:13 like having gone back to early 2025 tariff levels that again were deemed so bad it was the election
00:46:20 issue of that federal election i don't think so or at least they shouldn't if they're not
00:46:26 complete hypocrites but whatever with all that being said thank you guys for watching of course
00:46:31 make sure to like share subscribe leave a comment consider hitting the join button and i'll see you
00:46:38 guys all later.