The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - October 21, 2025


Carney Liberals are "worried" budget won't pass! New Election?

Hosted by
Mentioned
Pathetic: Media attacks Poilievre because Carney is flopping! Poilievre confronts lying media about RCMP corruption!

Episode Stats


Length

16 minutes

Words per minute

184.37

Word count

3,080

Sentence count

173

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Wyatt Claypool talks about the possibility that the budget will not pass in the next couple of weeks, and what that means for the future of Canadian politics as we know it. He also talks about why the Liberals should not want another election right now.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Wyatt Claypool here.
00:00:02 It seems like the Liberals are genuinely concerned as to whether or not their budget is going to pass in the next couple of weeks here,
00:00:10 and it could make Canadian politics much more interesting than it already is.
00:00:15 Now, I'm not sure if the Liberals actually want a new election or not,
00:00:21 because some people are speculating as to whether or not the Liberals are intentionally trying to tank negotiations
00:00:27 around trying to pass their budget in order to try and go for a majority government.
00:00:32 But from my perspective, it actually does genuinely sound like they are concerned that this thing is not going to pass,
00:00:38 and they are trying to batter either the Bloc Québécois or the NDP on board to do it.
00:00:44 I think the saving grace for the Liberals here is going to be that the NDP is currently in a leadership race,
00:00:50 and so they may just pass it in order to buy themselves some more time.
00:00:54 Although, frankly, they probably do better an election with Don Davies as their leader
00:01:00 than any of the other people currently running for the NDP leadership,
00:01:04 but that's just my opinion about a party I would never vote for, so take it with a grain of salt.
00:01:10 But I want to take you through the statement that Dominic LeBlanc made in Parliament today,
00:01:15 where he does not sound super, super confident in anything that is going on right now.
00:01:21 Actually, before we get to that, I do just want to show you guys the charts.
00:01:24 Because this is also why they should not want an election right now.
00:01:29 So the last federal election was super, super tight.
00:01:33 The Liberals ended up winning the popular vote by 2.3%,
00:01:37 but the Conservatives actually got disproportionately more seats than they usually do
00:01:41 because their vote has become more efficient.
00:01:44 So despite the Liberals winning the popular vote by 2.3%,
00:01:48 which normally would actually have the Liberals winning a majority,
00:01:51 they still only got a minority government,
00:01:54 they're only a few seats away from a majority, but it's still not a majority.
00:01:59 And after they won, you see this big lead that opens up for the Liberals as they enter their honeymoon phase,
00:02:06 which after several policy fumbles and rhetorical foot-in-their-mouth moments,
00:02:11 has whittled back down to basically where we were at the election.
00:02:16 In fact, the margin between the Liberals and Conservatives is closer than the election was.
00:02:22 Right now, with all the polls averaged, you have the Liberals at 40.9% and the Conservatives at 38.4%.
00:02:28 So that is the flavor that we, that is kind of, that is what is flavoring the situation
00:02:35 as we are getting in to the issue about the budget.
00:02:39 So let's jump over to that now.
00:02:42 Look at this.
00:02:44 We have the, we have not finance, is he the finance minister?
00:02:48 It's Dominic LeBlanc.
00:02:49 He's not the finance minister, but I think he's our trade representative with the Americans.
00:02:54 But he is talking about the Bloc Québécois not being supportive of the budget
00:02:58 or at least hedging on whether or not they will actually vote for it.
00:03:01 So I just want to say, because I haven't said this in English yet,
00:03:04 that we're, we're two weeks from the budget.
00:03:06 I, I think that, um, uh, what I'm seeing in Parliament worries me.
00:03:11 Um, we have, uh, two opposition parties principally that aren't taking this matter very seriously.
00:03:18 Canadians are looking for certainty.
00:03:19 We had an election six months ago.
00:03:21 Canadians are looking for predictability, stability, and especially a plan.
00:03:27 We intend to present a plan to Canadians to deal with this very critical moment in our history.
00:03:33 Isn't that kind of telling?
00:03:35 It's six months in and we're only tabling the plan on how to deal with this critical moment right now.
00:03:40 Like, I thought you guys were, you know, Mark Carney was the man with a plan
00:03:44 and you guys were going to lead us through a crisis.
00:03:45 But six months in, we're only tabling the plan.
00:03:48 And what we're seeing is our, our opposition parties, the Bloc Québécois,
00:03:52 who without having even read the budget, uh, eliminate the possibility that they will support it.
00:03:57 And the Conservatives making, uh, just ludicrous demands with respect to the budget.
00:04:02 It sounds like you're worried about maybe Canada going to another election.
00:04:04 Is that a realistic possibility that Canadians can expect?
00:04:06 We have, we have, um, uh, minority government, but we believe we have a mandate.
00:04:12 Um, and when I see opposition parties, uh, not, uh, uh, ruling out the possibility of voting for the budget,
00:04:19 uh, that's starting to worry me.
00:04:20 But I think it's them that are misreading the mood of Canadians.
00:04:23 If an election is necessary.
00:04:25 They're misreading the mood of Canadians.
00:04:28 We had a poll we just looked at.
00:04:29 The mood of Canadians is actually very undecided on whether or not they like this government or not.
00:04:35 Like, does Mark Carney personally have a positive approval rating, like a net positive approval rating?
00:04:41 Yes.
00:04:42 But he's also a new prime minister.
00:04:44 And it usually takes a while for people to sour on the personality of the prime minister.
00:04:49 You know, Mark Carney is also a fairly boring guy.
00:04:52 He's not going to rub people the wrong way for quite a while.
00:04:54 Now, I don't like him, but the average person who doesn't follow politics very closely
00:04:59 is probably not going to be bothered by Mark Carney until much, much later.
00:05:04 Trudeau was a far more polarizing personality, but Carney is not.
00:05:07 But that doesn't mean that people actually vote for his party.
00:05:10 He's also not the super charismatic leader that people will, you know, fight to the hilt for.
00:05:15 He's just kind of, like, you know, a somewhat nice guy to most people.
00:05:18 But, you know, his policies haven't been great so far,
00:05:21 and his elbows-up thing kind of faded away quite quickly.
00:05:25 And the budget is not exactly what they expected from a guy who was pushing himself
00:05:30 as, like, the fiscally conservative liberal leader.
00:05:34 It's just not a good look for them right now to also basically be saying,
00:05:38 well, you know, we should stay in government because, you know,
00:05:40 there was an election six months ago and we're still in.
00:05:42 Like, yeah, I guess you had a mandate,
00:05:44 but you guys quickly shredded the mandate by doing none of what you really said.
00:05:49 But they're not really saving money and they're not investing more and spending less.
00:05:53 They're just spending more.
00:05:55 They're not doing the elbows-up thing anymore.
00:05:57 I don't really know what else they were really elected into government to do
00:06:00 that was at the forefront of people's minds,
00:06:02 because it was pretty much just the anti-Trump stuff for most of their voters,
00:06:05 and that was it.
00:06:06 We would obviously, reluctantly, because we don't think Canadians want an election,
00:06:12 but election there will be.
00:06:14 It's the opposition parties who have that decision in their hands.
00:06:18 Why don't you accept the NDP's demands?
00:06:19 Well, which ones?
00:06:21 The one that said it's inimaginable that they vote for the budget,
00:06:24 the negotiable demands, or the non-negotiable demands?
00:06:28 It's pretty hard to follow.
00:06:29 What about the NDP?
00:06:31 You'll have to ask the NDP about the NDP.
00:06:34 Have you been having those conversations?
00:06:35 Minister.
00:06:36 What I just said is that the Prime Minister has had conversations,
00:06:40 Mr. Chopin has had conversations,
00:06:42 other ministers have had conversations,
00:06:44 and we will continue to listen to what they have to say.
00:06:48 So they know the Conservatives are going to vote against it.
00:06:51 They don't think the bloc's going to vote for it,
00:06:54 and so that's not great for them.
00:06:56 And then with the NDP,
00:06:57 he genuinely doesn't know what the NDP are going to do.
00:07:00 Now, again, I think 80% chance the NDP just votes for it
00:07:04 because they're in a leadership election,
00:07:05 and they need to buy themselves time,
00:07:06 and they're kind of broke.
00:07:08 At the same time, with only seven current MPs,
00:07:11 they could slap together a very cheap and dirty campaign
00:07:15 in order to try and increase their siege count,
00:07:17 because the polls have showed them bounce back
00:07:20 from just 6% in the last election up to 12%,
00:07:24 and 12% would probably have them scoring around 15 seats or so,
00:07:28 which would make them an official party again.
00:07:30 That was actually one of the things that ended up falling through
00:07:33 with the NDP previously,
00:07:34 is that they said they would enter an official liberal coalition,
00:07:38 or at least they would support them on confidence measures,
00:07:40 as long as they lowered the official party threshold
00:07:43 so that they would get extra funding in Parliament,
00:07:45 even though they don't actually have the seats
00:07:48 that they need in order to be an official party.
00:07:51 So maybe that also ends up coming out
00:07:53 in order to pass the budget that the NDP
00:07:56 get to be an official party with seven seats.
00:07:58 Again, if I was the NDP, I would just call an election now,
00:08:01 because guess what?
00:08:02 You're not going to be Prime Minister.
00:08:04 Whoever is the NDP leader is almost immaterial.
00:08:06 And frankly, Don Davies is probably a better leader
00:08:10 than Heather McPherson or Avi Lewis.
00:08:13 There's that other guy who's more of a trade unionist,
00:08:16 but that's pretty much like Don Davies.
00:08:18 He's an old Teamsters lawyer,
00:08:20 which is frankly not a bad guy to be running
00:08:22 as the leader of your party right now
00:08:24 when the NDP needs to recover from the perception
00:08:27 that they are a pretentious party
00:08:30 of downtown metropolitan elites like Jagmeet Singh.
00:08:33 And, you know, why not throw the Teamsters lawyer in
00:08:36 as the leader for now, get some more seats,
00:08:38 and then have your leadership race afterwards.
00:08:41 Again, it's not like he's going to be Prime Minister.
00:08:43 It's not like it's a position
00:08:45 where the person's going to be able to do anything
00:08:47 post-election in terms of the Prime Minister's office.
00:08:50 They are just the leader of the NDP,
00:08:52 and that is all they will ever be.
00:08:54 But now let's jump over to some other clips here.
00:08:57 We had Mark Carney here.
00:09:00 This was kind of funny.
00:09:01 talking about how we need to, like, you know,
00:09:04 he's going to go off now to Asia
00:09:06 to sign more trade agreements,
00:09:08 i.e. a bunch of hollow nothing
00:09:10 because he has to basically travel around
00:09:13 talking with world leaders to pretend he's doing stuff
00:09:15 because he actually hasn't gotten anything done yet.
00:09:18 Our strategy is diversifying trade.
00:09:20 That's why we're going to Asia.
00:09:22 You saw the Indonesian trade deal.
00:09:24 We're in talks with ASEAN,
00:09:25 which is the group of countries
00:09:26 that I'm meeting with in Kuala Lumpur,
00:09:29 and then more broadly at APEC,
00:09:32 including with China.
00:09:33 You might have not been able to hear that.
00:09:35 Some of the clips I end up playing are a bit quieter.
00:09:37 But he was talking about how,
00:09:39 well, we signed an agreement with Indonesia
00:09:40 in Kuala Lumpur,
00:09:42 so I'm going to go out to Asia
00:09:44 to try and sign more of those deals.
00:09:46 And then someone asked him,
00:09:47 well, are you going to sign a deal with India?
00:09:48 And then he just refused to answer it
00:09:50 because the liberals these days
00:09:52 are supposed to dislike India
00:09:54 for petty internal community reasons
00:09:57 from a lot of Kalistanis.
00:10:00 And so, yeah,
00:10:01 he's not actually serious about signing agreements
00:10:03 because he won't sign an agreement
00:10:04 with the biggest power in Asia aside from China.
00:10:10 And so I need to now play,
00:10:12 do we have this?
00:10:13 We have Melanie Jolie talking about
00:10:15 the Stellantis failure
00:10:17 where we now have
00:10:19 the Stellantis car manufacturer plant
00:10:21 leaving Brampton
00:10:22 and they're just pretending
00:10:24 like they can pressure them into staying.
00:10:26 Stellantis has been kind of thumbing their nose 0.50
00:10:28 at a contract they signed.
00:10:29 If GM can walk away,
00:10:30 we don't really have that same sort of deal with them.
00:10:32 So what kind of leverage do we have?
00:10:33 So I think it's two completely different situations.
00:10:35 When you look at Stellantis,
00:10:37 Stellantis had an obligation
00:10:38 to bring back the production
00:10:40 to the Brampton plant
00:10:42 and they failed that obligation.
00:10:45 And so that's why
00:10:46 we're putting maximum pressure on the company.
00:10:49 And it comes to GM,
00:10:50 they decided to let go of their bright drop,
00:10:53 which was an EV vehicle
00:10:55 that was not going well commercially.
00:10:58 That's a decision they took.
00:11:00 What does that tell you
00:11:01 about the green energy sector in general
00:11:03 and the EV sector?
00:11:05 The stuff is not wanted by consumers
00:11:08 despite the fact
00:11:09 that much of this is subsidized by the government,
00:11:11 not just the manufacturer,
00:11:13 but the purchasing is subsidized by the government.
00:11:15 And they still couldn't sell that car.
00:11:16 It's almost like we shouldn't base
00:11:18 our industrial policy
00:11:20 on newfangled green energy
00:11:24 and EVs that nobody actually wants.
00:11:27 And as soon as it stops being a trend,
00:11:28 people stop buying it.
00:11:29 Or as soon as the US gets rid of subsidies
00:11:32 for people buying green EVs,
00:11:35 immediately the entire sector dries up.
00:11:38 Like maybe we shouldn't have done this
00:11:40 and we should have actually invested
00:11:41 in things that matter.
00:11:42 Of course, we'll hold them to account
00:11:44 for any support we've given them
00:11:46 to develop that model.
00:11:48 But at the same time,
00:11:50 we are creating a response group
00:11:52 to make sure that we're bringing a new model
00:11:54 because the 1,200 workers
00:11:57 at the Ingersoll plan
00:11:58 need to know that we're fighting for their jobs.
00:12:00 What's the difference?
00:12:01 What about bringing a new model in? 0.97
00:12:03 That is something that's going to take some time.
00:12:05 What kind of time frame are you looking at?
00:12:07 These are people who are out of work now.
00:12:09 Well, urgency is a matter.
00:12:11 So that's why I'm...
00:12:12 Don't worry, guys.
00:12:13 They're going to create another group
00:12:14 or a department or some agency
00:12:16 to look at something
00:12:17 and probably end up doing nothing.
00:12:18 So we're going to pay a bunch of money
00:12:20 to get absolutely nothing done.
00:12:22 Another sign that the liberals
00:12:24 are actually kind of concerned
00:12:25 about their budget not passing
00:12:27 is the fact they've gone so hard
00:12:29 at Pierre Polyev
00:12:30 trying to paint him
00:12:32 as this far-right figure
00:12:33 because they don't have the issue
00:12:35 of Donald Trump anymore.
00:12:37 Yes, Donald Trump is still around
00:12:38 and they can probably motivate people
00:12:39 to vote for them
00:12:40 because, you know,
00:12:40 hey, Donald Trump's bad.
00:12:42 But it went from like a, you know,
00:12:45 number one issue for a lot of Canadians
00:12:47 to being off the map for most Canadians.
00:12:50 Like it was the number two issue
00:12:51 in the election campaign
00:12:52 and now most pollsters find
00:12:54 Donald Trump and his administration
00:12:55 to be number four, number five,
00:12:57 sometimes even number six for people.
00:12:59 They barely won the last election.
00:13:01 When you look at the tightest ridings,
00:13:03 the liberals barely won
00:13:04 even a minority government.
00:13:06 The conservatives were only 8,000 votes away
00:13:08 in the tightest ridings
00:13:09 from being the ones
00:13:10 in the minority government situation.
00:13:13 And now, and that was with Trump
00:13:15 as the second biggest issue
00:13:16 after cost of living,
00:13:17 which it's almost impossible
00:13:19 to not have the cost of living
00:13:20 be the primary issue.
00:13:21 It's pretty much always the biggest issue.
00:13:23 It's the most universal issue
00:13:25 for people to care about.
00:13:26 But now they don't have
00:13:27 their main number two issue
00:13:29 in which that was the one issue
00:13:31 the liberals had a massive advantage on.
00:13:33 It's now number four or five.
00:13:34 It's still going to help them,
00:13:36 but they can't really lean on that one
00:13:38 nearly as much anymore,
00:13:39 so that's why they're now
00:13:40 attacking Pierre Polyev.
00:13:42 You have this person here saying,
00:13:44 quote,
00:13:44 I can't believe that this needs to be said,
00:13:47 but it is wrong to call
00:13:48 for the jailing of your political opponents.
00:13:50 Perhaps somebody should tell Pierre Polyev
00:13:52 these remarks are anti-democratic.
00:13:54 It's emblematic of a politician
00:13:56 who has lost his mind.
00:13:58 And this individual was quoting
00:14:00 the Justin Ling article
00:14:03 about Pierre Polyev
00:14:04 and the Toronto Star
00:14:04 that says Pierre Polyev's
00:14:06 conspiracy theorizing
00:14:07 isn't just wrong,
00:14:09 it's dangerous.
00:14:10 And we've seen a lot of this,
00:14:12 a lot of stuff calling
00:14:13 Pierre Polyev mini-Trump,
00:14:15 and he is a mega,
00:14:17 far-right conspiracy theorist,
00:14:19 and it's all cropped up
00:14:20 very suddenly.
00:14:22 And if the liberal government,
00:14:24 I would say,
00:14:24 if they actually had any issues
00:14:26 that they were doing well on,
00:14:28 if they were actually popular right now,
00:14:30 I don't think they would be
00:14:31 wasting time attacking Pierre Polyev.
00:14:33 If anything,
00:14:33 they would ignore him
00:14:34 and let him make noise over there
00:14:36 while we're getting stuff done
00:14:37 that people like.
00:14:38 They're not getting stuff done
00:14:39 that people like,
00:14:40 that's why they're now
00:14:41 opening up on Pierre,
00:14:42 and that's why they're concerned
00:14:43 about the budget not being passed.
00:14:45 Other parties,
00:14:46 no, they're not very popular right now,
00:14:48 and if we roll the dice again
00:14:49 in another election,
00:14:50 they could end up losing
00:14:51 because Polyev could just say,
00:14:52 hey, you're the guy,
00:14:54 it doesn't matter that I've only
00:14:55 given you six months,
00:14:56 you're the guy who said
00:14:57 you could turn this whole thing
00:14:58 around within months.
00:14:59 We've had six of them,
00:15:01 and not only have you
00:15:02 not turned things around,
00:15:04 things are measurably worse.
00:15:06 Inflation's worse.
00:15:07 The deficits are worse.
00:15:09 Everything's worse,
00:15:10 and now you're going to say
00:15:11 that I'm somehow,
00:15:12 you know,
00:15:13 being,
00:15:14 it's uncouth of me
00:15:15 to call an election
00:15:16 to say maybe we need
00:15:17 a recall on this guy
00:15:18 who promised the world
00:15:20 and is delivering less than that.
00:15:22 Anyways,
00:15:23 so,
00:15:24 with that being said,
00:15:25 thank you guys all for watching.
00:15:26 Just a bit of an update
00:15:27 on the chaos in Parliament.
00:15:29 I will be making a video
00:15:30 probably tomorrow
00:15:31 on the Calgary election situation.
00:15:33 Obviously,
00:15:34 it looks like Jeremy Farkas
00:15:35 has very,
00:15:36 very narrowly won
00:15:38 over Sonia Sharp. 0.99
00:15:39 I mean,
00:15:39 literally by
00:15:40 0.16%
00:15:42 of the vote.
00:15:43 He only won by
00:15:44 500 votes
00:15:45 around that.
00:15:46 There will be a recount.
00:15:47 He still likely will win,
00:15:49 but I do want to make a video
00:15:50 kind of talking about the race.
00:15:52 The silver lining is
00:15:53 Jodi Gondek did lose
00:15:54 and came in a distant third,
00:15:56 so I was right to say
00:15:57 that she looked like
00:15:58 she was going to become
00:15:59 the Lori Lightfoot
00:16:00 of this election,
00:16:01 the terrible Chicago mayor
00:16:03 who in her first re-election bid 0.95
00:16:04 came a distant third place.
00:16:07 But anyways,
00:16:08 with that being said,
00:16:09 thank you guys for watching,
00:16:10 and I will see you guys
00:16:11 next time.
00:16:12 Thank you.