The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - May 31, 2025


Carney Liberals spending $486 billion with NO PLAN!

Hosted by
Mentioned
Smith holds massive lead over NDP in Alberta - Low Popularity for Independence Carney's BIG LIE on Immigration! Worse than Justin Trudeau

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

194.71

Word count

2,716

Sentence count

161

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Mark Carney is the new finance minister of Canada, but what does this mean for the country's finances? Is he going to be as bad as Justin Trudeau was when he was Prime Minister, or will he be as good as his replacement, Finance Minister Bill Morneau?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Wyatt Claypool here. I know I'm going to end up repeating this ad nauseum over the next couple of years,
00:00:08 but Mark Carney has not budged an inch from the agenda of Justin Trudeau.
00:00:13 Because in reality, was it Justin Trudeau's agenda, or was it Mark Carney's agenda,
00:00:19 or is it just how a lot of Canadian leftists think, and so swapping one guy out for the other is really not going to change much.
00:00:26 Plus, again, as is always repeated, Mark Carney was the financial advisor for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
00:00:36 So the guy who for five years advised on Canada's finances cannot then be expected to be a complete 180 from Justin Trudeau when he himself takes power.
00:00:47 Check this out. It's a great example.
00:00:49 So you know how we're not going to be releasing a budget until the fall?
00:00:53 Well, previously they didn't even want to release a budget in the year 2025 at all.
00:00:57 Well, at least they're putting out a spending plan right now.
00:01:01 Well, that spending plan is basically just a dollar sign and nothing else.
00:01:06 Right here, Global News is reporting Carney government tables $186 billion spending plan with few details.
00:01:14 And that is on top of the $33 billion they already spent through an order in council that they, at least in the order in council,
00:01:22 they actually allocated which departments the money is going towards.
00:01:26 This is basically just $486 billion.
00:01:29 You know, this department gets this money.
00:01:31 This general area gets this much money.
00:01:34 And the thing is, a lot of promises are already broken in the spending plan.
00:01:38 As was pointed out in the Global News article that I will be linking in the description below and pinning at the top of the comments,
00:01:45 there is not the $3.5 billion that he promised he was going to use in order to create a new economic corridor in Canada
00:01:52 to make sure, you know, as he keeps saying that we have an east to west economy
00:01:57 and that we are one Canadian economy rather than 13 separate economies.
00:02:01 He isn't putting any money towards that.
00:02:03 It's almost like they've just copy and pasted what Trudeau did in 2024 into 2025
00:02:11 because this money is basically the exact same amount that Justin Trudeau spent in the year 2024.
00:02:18 And the funny thing is, as you read on in the article, there are things like,
00:02:23 you know how we got rid of the consumer carbon tax and ergo the rebates go away?
00:02:29 We're still spending like $3.5 billion on the rebate program every year despite nobody getting rebates.
00:02:37 Like some people might be getting rebates, but somehow we are still finding ways of spending money
00:02:42 despite the fact that we have dedicated ourselves to not doing something.
00:02:46 Maybe the $3.5 billion was because we did send out some checks this year, but it looks like that money will stay,
00:02:53 like we'll keep going because the money was already spent to send all that stuff out in,
00:02:58 I would assume, the $33 billion order in council spending that was already done.
00:03:02 But you can't make any sense of this stuff.
00:03:04 I want to scroll down here a little longer.
00:03:06 And so you can see some of these little anecdotes in the article.
00:03:12 So right here it says,
00:03:14 And indeed, the spending plan table Tuesday is almost certain to change when it is updated in the fall,
00:03:19 when it will likely include nearly $24 billion in spending commitments for this year
00:03:24 that the liberals promised during the election campaign.
00:03:27 So we already have $33 billion that was spent.
00:03:30 Now we have, what is it, $486 billion.
00:03:34 And then at the very least, they are going to bring in another $24 billion.
00:03:40 And the problem is, is that their platform they ran on assumed that they were going to get a lot of revenues from counter tariffs.
00:03:48 Well, Mark Carney already abandoned the counter tariffs during the election.
00:03:53 I didn't think the tariffs were a good idea in the first place.
00:03:55 I think you just lower taxes in your own economy, make it easier to function in Canada's economy.
00:04:00 And it doesn't matter if the U.S. puts tariffs on your imports.
00:04:03 You'll just be doing better in general because it's easier to operate.
00:04:06 But if you're going to, but he was running on it and then he drops it.
00:04:10 And now there is, I think it was like $28 billion hole in his spending plan where he was going to spend like $128 billion more or whatever it was.
00:04:19 It was nuts.
00:04:19 And he was thinking or saying to people, don't worry, guys, I'm going to be spending that much more money over the next four years, but we will find at least $28 billion in savings from the tariff revenues as well as finding duplicate programs we're going to eliminate.
00:04:35 What programs is this man going to eliminate?
00:04:38 What things is he going to privatize?
00:04:39 There's been nothing he actually was able to say that was a duplicate program he was planning on getting rid of because the thing is the Liberal Party functions on getting federal government employees to vote for them.
00:04:50 So what jobs are they going to eliminate in order to, you know, balance this budget out or try and reduce the deficit?
00:04:56 They're not even attempting to reduce the deficit.
00:04:58 They're still running with like $40, $60 billion deficits in mind.
00:05:03 And that's them being ideal.
00:05:06 That's them saying, you know, I think we can keep it to $60 billion.
00:05:08 Well, my goodness, in 2024, Trudeau and Freeland and Carney thought they were going to keep it to $40 billion, and then they ended up going to $63 billion.
00:05:18 So let's assume if they're saying $60 billion this year, at least assume $80 billion because these guys are not very good with numbers.
00:05:25 Oh, but Wyatt, don't worry.
00:05:27 We have a seasoned economist now running the economy.
00:05:31 He's worked in the private sector.
00:05:33 He's been the governor of the Bank of England, the governor of the Bank of Canada.
00:05:37 Okay, so what? 0.90
00:05:39 He sucked as the financial advisor, and that was his more recent role. 0.98
00:05:44 But anyways, oh, my goodness. 1.00
00:05:45 It's so stupid. 0.99
00:05:47 I need to go into some other stuff here. 0.99
00:05:49 Another thing that I find interesting, although at least he seems to be not giving the CBC all the money he was promising, so far he is giving them quite a bit.
00:05:59 But they say during the campaign, the limerals promised to boost CBC's funding by $150 million a year.
00:06:04 But in the spending plan table Tuesday, the CBC budget is up just $42 million to $1.43 billion.
00:06:10 The minister responsible for CBC, Stephen Gilbeau, declined to answer questions Wednesday about this department's spending plan.
00:06:17 And although I would usually be more sanguine about the fact that at least CBC didn't get the increase we thought they were going to,
00:06:24 I think what's happening right now with the $33 billion OIC and with the $486 billion now and with the $24 billion plan to then be tabled in the fall,
00:06:35 I think what you're going to see with Carney, and we're going to have to stay on top of it altogether,
00:06:39 is you're just going to sort of see in between this large chunk of money that they put forward in the spending plan that they want Parliament to pass,
00:06:48 just pass it with no details basically.
00:06:50 They're also going to be kind of nickel and diming their way higher and giving handouts to different departments,
00:06:56 because, you know, government departments do have their own interests and they do have their own agendas.
00:07:03 It's not like, oh, you work in government, that means that your interest is the public interest.
00:07:08 No, departments have their own interests to grow larger and gain more authority and power.
00:07:13 And so what I think we're going to see from Carney is a continuation of this order and council method
00:07:18 where he puts forward another couple billion here, $10 billion there, $15 billion there, $3 billion there,
00:07:24 just, oh, maybe just $250 million this time.
00:07:27 Why even scrutinize it?
00:07:28 It's such a small amount of money when you think about it.
00:07:30 We're going to be running into a massive debt trap at the time when we should be reducing debt.
00:07:36 And this is where I'm going to be telling the Conservatives, like, guys, right now was the time to be running on a very hawkish plan,
00:07:43 not just to reduce the deficit, but to reduce debt.
00:07:48 We actually just need to go full Ralph Klein, full Mike Harris, full Gordon Campbell, full John Chrétien even,
00:07:55 and reduce federal spending, not only passing a lot of it back to taxpayers through tax cuts,
00:08:01 but also using a large portion of the savings to have a yearly fund that just goes back to paying off the debt.
00:08:08 You could easily cut probably around $50 billion.
00:08:12 I could even probably see possibly $70 or $80 billion of the federal budget per year.
00:08:19 We all know programs that exist that are worthless.
00:08:23 Even in your own life, you may encounter government services where we're spending $50,000, $60,000,
00:08:29 not much in the grand scheme of things, but for something that nobody needs.
00:08:32 I always remember the story in Calgary that even in a city where you'd assume it's more conservative,
00:08:38 this was under Nenshi, who, although a leftist, wasn't as insane as Gondek,
00:08:42 even he had two positions in his government at City Hall for enforcing,
00:08:48 like, it was like a diversity coordinator for bike lanes and buses.
00:08:52 And there was two positions.
00:08:53 One was for bike lanes, one was for public transport and buses and trains.
00:08:56 There was diversity coordinators for that. 0.68
00:08:59 Why?
00:08:59 And each of them were being paid like $114,000 a year.
00:09:04 There are always areas you can save.
00:09:06 Every time you find a position like that in government, federally, provincially, or city,
00:09:11 if you eliminate it, you can do two things or three things, actually, depending on the government.
00:09:16 Cities obviously don't really have debt.
00:09:18 But you can either pay off debt, you can lower taxes, or you can allocate it to somewhere more useful.
00:09:23 So in the city budgets, I would say put more police on the streets.
00:09:26 And on the provincial level, I would actually say, well, actually, I don't think they can just reduce spending in general.
00:09:31 Like in Alberta, guys, you could actually cut the healthcare system's budget and make the healthcare system better.
00:09:37 I would say go into the AHS right now or whatever regional variant we're setting up right now
00:09:43 where each region is going to have its own healthcare authority, slash administration,
00:09:47 pass some of the savings to taxpayers,
00:09:49 and then take the other portion of the savings and increase nurse pay and nurse positions. 0.80
00:09:54 There are so many people who work in the administration of hospitals and the healthcare system,
00:09:59 and they're even in HR, in positions we don't need at all.
00:10:04 Obviously, some HR is needed, but just not a lot of it.
00:10:07 So many of these people have nursing degrees.
00:10:09 They have nursing backgrounds.
00:10:10 They're doctors.
00:10:11 But they now work in paperwork positions.
00:10:13 And the funny thing is some of them are in positions where it's their job to basically compile reports on the backlog of surgeries.
00:10:23 There's people whose job, who are sitting there as nurses, who are trying to figure out how we could get more nurses on the floor. 0.96
00:10:29 How about we just eliminate these positions?
00:10:31 And in every hospital, we could have another 20 to 30 nurses on the floor every single day. 1.00
00:10:37 But what do I know?
00:10:38 I'm just some random crank online.
00:10:41 But yeah, this is not glick and grid for Canada.
00:10:44 It's not like it's like, you know, the apocalypse approaching. 0.92
00:10:48 But the thing with all the spending and with Mark Carney, the way he's doing things, is Mark Carney is not a dumb man.
00:10:54 And I think that he is doing this in such a way where he can spend as much as he wants without it really having that big bomb of a story.
00:11:01 Because if he came out and he tabled a $600 billion budget, which would be like $50 billion more than Trudeau's last budget.
00:11:08 If he came out with like a $600 billion spending plan all at once, that would be a bomb.
00:11:14 And so many of his liberal voters would be like, oh, I thought he was going to be fiscally responsible.
00:11:17 But if he puts one out that's $486 million, which is still like $60, $70 billion less than Trudeau's last budget, and then he spends $33 billion here, silently another $10 over here, he can nickel and dime him his way up to $600 billion.
00:11:32 And his voters who think he's fiscally responsible are none the wiser.
00:11:35 Unless you're going to be reading deep articles from the National Post or Globe and Mail going over all the little bits and pieces of spending that are causing this to be a bloated budget.
00:11:45 The bomb doesn't quite hit as hard when you do it this way than if you just came out and said, our budget's $600 billion and we're running an $80 billion deficit this year.
00:11:54 So yeah, watch out for that.
00:11:56 And I guess it's just good to be back in Calgary.
00:11:59 I've been driving and flying so much.
00:12:02 So it's nice to be back on the set for once.
00:12:04 My goodness.
00:12:06 And it's also good to have good Wi-Fi while I'm filming this stuff.
00:12:10 I got a haircut when I was on Vancouver Island.
00:12:13 I'm going to try and actually get rest for once because I have been going to sleep at 1 a.m.
00:12:18 and waking up at 6 a.m.
00:12:20 And that's not because I'm staying out late partying.
00:12:23 It's like just working and getting a very late dinner.
00:12:26 Get back to your hotel room.
00:12:27 You're not going to go to sleep right away.
00:12:29 And then it's like, oh, goodness.
00:12:30 You go to sleep at 1 a.m. and then you have to wake up at 6 because you've got to get up and get down to the legislature at like 8.
00:12:36 Or I have to film a video before I get down to the legislature.
00:12:39 And usually I'm a bit late anyways.
00:12:40 Oh, my goodness.
00:12:43 That's crazy.
00:12:43 I'm going to have to make another video about BC politics at some point in my time down there.
00:12:47 And the BC Conservative AGM and the press conference that we had to put on as the independents.
00:12:52 Yeah, it's an adventure out there.
00:12:54 But thanks for watching the show, guys.
00:12:56 Hopefully you don't mind these old mini updates at the end of episodes.
00:12:59 Hopefully it's not dragging.
00:13:00 If you don't like this, don't send me an email.
00:13:02 But just click off the video early.
00:13:04 I had someone send me 50 emails yesterday.
00:13:07 And if you're watching this and you're the one who sent me 50 emails, I blocked your email.
00:13:10 Because, sorry, don't send me 50 emails where each email is just a single link that you think I might want to check out.
00:13:16 I do not have the brain capacity for that.
00:13:18 And at some point it just stresses me out.
00:13:20 And I'm pretty, pretty patient.
00:13:22 I already have a big backlog of emails I have to get to.
00:13:24 So if you've sent me an email, I'm not ignoring you.
00:13:27 It's like the stress of the day makes me not get to them right away.
00:13:29 But thank you guys for holding on.
00:13:32 If you like my show, make sure to drop a like on the video.
00:13:35 Leave a subscribe to the channel if you're not a subscriber.
00:13:37 Although if you're not subscribed, you probably haven't waited this long into the video to hear me just ramble about nonsense.
00:13:42 And if you want to, drop a comment, talk about what you think the budget's going to look like by the end of the year.
00:13:49 And what do you predict the deficit is going to be for the year 2025?
00:13:54 Anyways, that should be it for me today, you guys.
00:13:56 Have a good one.