The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - July 04, 2026


Carney's $44 Billion Pipeline SCAM Exposed: Albertans Get Screwed Again!

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Carney SHUTS DOWN his own Fake Pipeline - Tanker Ban Remains! Liberal MP makes FOOL of Himself Attack Jamil Jivani's Canada Day Message!

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

170.14

Word count

3,705

Sentence count

169

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

It's time to prematurely celebrate! Canada could, maybe, possibly, build a potential oil and gas pipeline to the West Coast. If you take the word of Prime Minister Mark Carney and Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, a pipeline is coming under construction.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Wyatt Claypool here and welcome back to the National Telegraph YouTube channel.
00:00:06 It's time to prematurely celebrate everyone. Canada could, maybe, possibly build a potential
00:00:14 oil and gas pipeline to the West Coast if you take the word of Prime Minister Mark Carney and
00:00:20 the Liberals. I'm not trying to be deliberately pessimistic just to naysay the Liberals,
00:00:26 I just know the history. Energy East, Keystone XL, Northern Gateway, all got shut down under this
00:00:35 liberal government. The only major pipeline project to be complete under them was Trans Mountain
00:00:42 that went massively over budget and over schedule. The announcement yesterday between Prime Minister
00:00:49 Mark Carney and Alberta Premier Danielle Smith wasn't even an announcement about a pipeline
00:00:55 coming under construction. They are announcing that we plan to make a plan sometime in October.
00:01:04 It's really annoying seeing all the people wanting to be optimistic simply because, well,
00:01:09 we should be optimistic. Should we be optimistic in life? Sure. But if you know the history of how
00:01:16 the liberals have acted with pipeline projects, you should be somewhat pessimistic. Trust but
00:01:21 verify, at the very least. I don't even think we should trust this plan at all, and I'm going to
00:01:26 explain it to you in just a second here. But first, I will jump over to some clips from the press
00:01:32 conference between Carney and Danielle Smith. Check it out. This is a new approach that helps
00:01:39 us reach our full potential, one that builds in partnership, partnership, the federal government,
00:01:45 alberta british columbia partnership with territories partnership with indigenous
00:01:50 people's partnership with the private sector indigenous people's full partnership partners
00:01:56 in development operating and equity ownership we've agreed at least i think that's what's in
00:02:02 the submission that i may get momentarily uh that the best route for a new pipeline is one
00:02:09 that goes through one that already exists out through the trans mountain corridor
00:02:13 to our pacific coast the gateway to the world's fastest growing markets
00:02:18 we've already agreed to reform carbon markets so they promote real emissions
00:02:22 we've already agreed to substantial methane reductions and to new measures new incentives
00:02:29 and reforms so that power markets can grow sustainably and affordably and this being alberta
00:02:36 significantly we will maintain the federal government will maintain the tanker band to
00:02:41 to protect Canada's coastlines and precious habitats,
00:02:44 and consistent with the MOU as a prerequisite for the pipeline,
00:02:49 the government of Canada, the government of Alberta,
00:02:51 and the Oil Science Alliance, the five companies
00:02:54 in the Oil Science Alliance, have now agreed on the terms
00:02:57 to launch the Pathways Project, the world's largest carbon
00:03:01 capture and utilization and storage project, which,
00:03:04 together with other emission reduction commitments
00:03:06 in the agreement, will achieve 16 million tons
00:03:08 emissions reductions per year or the equivalent of taking 90 percent of the cars in Alberta off
00:03:14 the road. Now, this is what I think is the real prize for Prime Minister Mark Carney in this
00:03:21 entire thing. Now, could the potential pipeline actually get built? Sure, there's a possibility
00:03:28 of everything. I don't put it down at only like a five percent chance at happening, but between
00:03:33 betting on it happening or not happening. I would bet on it not happening with the modifier that
00:03:40 yes, one day a pipeline will be built. I just think that the next few years are going to be
00:03:45 a complete waste of time. And if a pipeline does get built, it's going to be because someone else
00:03:50 comes in and says, let's just stop all this stupid hoop jumping and just start building the thing. 0.98
00:03:55 Mark Carney is always slowly moving towards building something while never actually getting 0.99
00:04:01 there. But because he is promising Danielle Smith that something could be built in like 10 plus
00:04:07 years, he's going to get her to invest billions of dollars into the carbon capture pathways project
00:04:14 where massively increasing our industrial carbon tax, committing to methane reductions and all 0.96
00:04:20 these other sorts of things. And we might get a potential pipeline at some point. That is also
00:04:26 requiring it to basically be mostly government and First Nations owned. The only private sector
00:04:33 stake in this entire thing right now is Pembina Pipelines, who's going to be constructing it and
00:04:39 getting a 10% stake in the project, meaning that the rest of the stake right now is Alberta,
00:04:46 the federal government, the BC government, and First Nation groups. And by the way,
00:04:51 The First Nations thing is such a bag of cats that people seem to have not really noticed how bad it could potentially get. 0.91
00:05:00 Because although people have been playing this thing up as, well, it's going to be easy to build. 0.99
00:05:04 Because we've already built the Trans Mountain Pipeline.
00:05:09 It's like the KMX or whatever.
00:05:11 But we already have that corridor with a pipeline in it.
00:05:15 So we can just add another pipeline.
00:05:16 Easy peasy.
00:05:17 That was before Mark Carney, earlier this year, gave the land title of the entire Lower Mainland to the Musqueam First Nations Band, which is anti-oil and gas, and they're already extremely rich and really don't need any royalties from a potential pipeline.
00:05:38 They already own casinos, they already take a cut of revenues from the Vancouver airport,
00:05:44 and other direct money given to them by both the BC government and the Canadian federal government.
00:05:51 They also have land disputes with the Cowichan and the Tawasin. 0.61
00:05:55 And what better way of demonstrating this is your property by blocking a major project just for the heck of it? 0.98
00:06:02 Especially if the Tawasin want it, I guarantee the Musqueam will say they don't want it, 1.00
00:06:07 and vice versa. If the Musqueam want it, the Tawasi can flex their arms and say, hey, actually, 1.00
00:06:13 yes, you may have gotten Mark Carney to sign you over land title to this area, but this comes 0.99
00:06:19 through our territory as well. And we're saying no to the potential pipeline just to demonstrate
00:06:24 who really owns the land over here. This is going to be a bag of cats. And even the optimistic
00:06:33 plan for getting this thing built requires $44 billion of taxpayer money. Now, some of that
00:06:41 might be kicked in by Pembina pipelines, but they're being paid to construct the thing and
00:06:45 getting a stake. I actually don't think they're kicking in any money really themselves. If anything,
00:06:50 it's going to be a very small minority of the money, but at least $36 billion is going to be
00:06:56 coming directly from Canadian taxpayers, whether Canadian federal or Alberta and BC provincial.
00:07:03 And that is just the start of it. That's if it goes well. They only think this pipeline is going to get started either in October 2027, which is the hyperoptimistic schedule, or it could get started in, like, October of 2029.
00:07:21 And whenever the government gives you a date range for when they think they are going to start or complete something, the later date is probably the earliest they are ever going to complete it.
00:07:31 If not, they're going to need a few more years. So right now, based on that, earliest this thing's
00:07:37 going to get built is 2036. So I don't know why everyone's getting so hot and bothered over this
00:07:43 thing when we are literally multiple governments away from actually seeing it come to fruition.
00:07:51 Even the port that this thing is going to cannot currently handle the pipeline, and it needs
00:07:56 another 10 billion dollars of upgrades in order to take it in. I just want to jump to now a clip
00:08:03 of Danielle Spith being asked why now does the government have to step in to make sure this 1.00
00:08:09 project can even get underway because that is a big problem. The private sector is barely involved
00:08:15 in it in any way and Pemna Pipeline is only involved in it because their business is
00:08:19 of constructing pipelines.
00:08:21 After seven months, this project
00:08:25 will now require government support in terms of equity.
00:08:31 Why do you think that it remains too risky for the private sector
00:08:36 to run with it by itself?
00:08:40 I would say that we did have a number of projects,
00:08:43 and I can elaborate on them.
00:08:45 I mean, we did have Northern Gateway that had all of its approvals
00:08:49 and they were then canceled.
00:08:50 We did have Keystone XL who had all of its approvals
00:08:53 and we're starting to build pipelines across the border
00:08:56 and a presidential permit was canceled.
00:08:58 We had Energy East that was a billion dollars
00:09:00 into a regulatory approval process
00:09:01 and couldn't see the way to a finish line.
00:09:03 So it was canceled.
00:09:04 So we have pipeline companies
00:09:05 that have literally spent billions of dollars
00:09:08 in recent years on failed regulatory approval processes.
00:09:11 That's the environment we're finding ourselves in.
00:09:13 And so it does take some work, I think,
00:09:16 to make sure that the private sector proponents
00:09:20 understand that this is a real process,
00:09:21 there's a real commitment on the part of all three parties,
00:09:25 myself, as well as the Premier of British Columbia,
00:09:28 as well as the Prime Minister,
00:09:30 to get this project to the finish line.
00:09:32 So what the share of the private sector stake will be,
00:09:36 that remains to be seen.
00:09:38 Maybe over time, as more and more certainty comes in,
00:09:41 maybe we'll be talking with Scott
00:09:42 about him wanting to take on a larger and larger share.
00:09:45 This is not exactly inspiring, considering that right now the only private sector stake is 10% at the moment.
00:09:54 And also, isn't it kind of awkward to be saying all this when you're standing right next to the guy who's making the private sector not want to put in more money?
00:10:04 The only reason Pevinda Pipeline is putting 10% in is because the provincial and federal governments are going to be putting in billions of taxpayer dollars to get it constructed.
00:10:16 And they could still only get 10% into the pot from the private sector.
00:10:21 Now, they're saying, well, First Nations are going to have a stake in it.
00:10:25 I really doubt First Nations are going to be putting any money into it.
00:10:28 So that's just going to be more taxpayer money.
00:10:29 And even if they were putting any money into it, that's still just taxpayer money, because where do you think the ban councils are getting their cash from?
00:10:38 But Mark Carney could clear out all the regulations.
00:10:40 We could have been building a pipeline to the North Coast to either Prince Rupert or Kinemat, but he didn't want to actually sign an approval for a pipeline to be built there and go through all of the consultations and environmental reviews as fast as humanly possible,
00:10:57 if not just leapfrog over it. He could have done that. And I find it not annoying. And I respect
00:11:03 Danielle Smith. But she's having to sit there and just act like this just has to be done. 1.00
00:11:10 No, it doesn't. It only has to be done because the man to your direct left has made it that way.
00:11:18 And so I want to now jump over to another clip of Danielle Smith on CBC the next day,
00:11:24 basically tacitly admitting that, yeah, Pembina Pipeline could even end up pulling out of this
00:11:29 project. Check it out. I want to focus in still on the private company here, Pembina. When you
00:11:35 read the news release that they've put out going along with this, they are interested in this 10%
00:11:39 stake, but they make it clear there is a lot of caution around this. They're still evaluating the
00:11:44 plan. Is it possible they could choose to walk away, that this could become entirely a public
00:11:48 project? Well, I hope not. I mean, I think that what we've been looking for and what the private
00:11:55 industry has been looking for is some indication that governments can work together to clear
00:11:59 regulatory hurdles so projects can get built. So you have to remember the environment we're
00:12:03 walking into. We have an environment where the Northern Gateway Project got all of its
00:12:07 approvals and was canceled. And then we had the Keystone XL Project that was approved and in
00:12:11 construction and then a presidential permit from the U.S. was canceled. And then we had a billion
00:12:15 dollars spent on an Energy East regulatory process. They pulled the plug on because they
00:12:19 couldn't see the way through to the finish line. So you can well imagine why it is that pipeline
00:12:23 proponents are a little bit nervous based on the past 10 years of history. Now it may seem like I
00:12:30 just basically played her saying the same thing twice. The difference though is in that CBC clip
00:12:36 she said that she'd like to see the regulatory hurdles taken down so that private companies
00:12:42 would be interested in actually footing the bill themselves. And by the way, I want private
00:12:48 companies to foot the bill themselves, not because I'm like, oh, you hands off taxpayer money.
00:12:53 Part of that is my reason. The main thing is that I don't think that the pipeline is going to be
00:12:59 managed in its planning, construction, or maintenance better by the government than a
00:13:05 private company. I think a private company would do far better with this entire project, and they
00:13:10 should be the ones fully profiting off of it if this was a free market. But now we're going to
00:13:16 have government stakes in this project that's probably going to be way over time and way over
00:13:21 budget because Carney at the press conference refuses to actually make the regulatory environment
00:13:27 easier. In fact, just a couple weeks ago, started pulling back on loosening regulations around
00:13:34 energy projects because his own caucus started signing letters to him anonymously saying that
00:13:41 they didn't like his own pipeline plan. That's another crimson red flag on the field. We are
00:13:47 going to assume that this project is not going to get derailed over the next decade while there
00:13:53 are actively people in the Liberal caucus who do not want to see this pipeline approved.
00:13:59 Now, many people have been talking about David Moose on the Loose's video, talking about what
00:14:05 Mark Carney's interest in this project may be, and it's sort of surrounding the whole idea that
00:14:09 he has a lot of friends, whether through other ministers or through Brookfield, that are heavily
00:14:15 invested in the carbon credits market. I don't really know about that. My perspective is that
00:14:20 Carney's real interest in all this is basically pretending he's Mr. Pipeline. It's all political
00:14:26 games. He wants to seem like Mr. Pipeline to make the business liberals in his coalition happy,
00:14:32 and then he wants to make sure the pipeline never actually gets built, especially not even started
00:14:38 before the next federal election, so that he can keep the green left vote on board as well.
00:14:44 He's effectively trying to walk a tightrope where he both is in favor of a pipeline while he's never
00:14:50 actually getting the pipeline built. Now, I want to jump over to a post from my friend Kirk Lubomov,
00:14:56 because I think he had a really good way of summing up what this current project is.
00:15:03 Kirk here says, and I'll bring this back up on screen,
00:15:07 the private sector would have built the TMX expansion project for $7 billion.
00:15:12 The government chased them out of Canada and built it themselves for $35 billion.
00:15:16 The private sector now doesn't want to touch another pipeline project.
00:15:19 The government is stepping in to mismanage the construction of another project
00:15:24 that will cost $45 billion of taxpayer dollars. To build the pipeline, the government also has
00:15:29 to spend $20 billion on the Uneconomical Carbon Capture Project, that's the Pathways Project.
00:15:35 And then Kirk says, so taxpayers will pay $90 billion for something the private sector would
00:15:40 have done themselves for $20 billion if the government had just gotten out of the way.
00:15:44 Completely unacceptable waste and mismanagement. And then he says in another post here,
00:15:50 Canada announces to the world that we can't even build projects of national interest which should
00:15:57 be massively profitable and the private sector would be tripping over themselves to buy in
00:16:02 anywhere else in the world without government having to use taxpayer dollars to try and save
00:16:07 it and create confidence because the red tape and uncertainty is so bad. Only Canada would celebrate
00:16:12 this instead of working day and night to remove these hurdles and uncertainties. Politicians
00:16:17 should even be announcing shouldn't even be announcing this pipeline project private industry
00:16:22 should absolutely i agree and this is where i think what danielle smith is doing is short-sighted
00:16:29 although there is always time in the future to basically change her stance and put pressure on
00:16:34 the federal liberals again we shouldn't be accepting this like what the liberals proposed by the way
00:16:41 the MOU that Danielle Smith had signed with Mark Carney promised that there would either be a
00:16:47 southern or northern route. And then Carney broke that promise by just saying that we're not going
00:16:52 to be getting rid of the tanker ban that blocks oil shipments from coming out of Kitimat or Prince
00:16:58 Rupert, and we're just going to be forced to accept the southern route, which requires us 0.67
00:17:02 to work with the Musqueam who have land title over the entire lower mainland that the pipeline is 0.98
00:17:08 going to have to move through. This is not good. The amount and their people are saying, well, 0.92
00:17:13 it's going to bring so many investments. So we should just shut up and be okay with it. We should
00:17:17 just be happy that something's getting done. To which I say no. Why are we always accepting
00:17:22 mediocre concession prizes rather than actually getting a solid win? Again, so many people are
00:17:32 talking about it as if it's already generating $20 billion in revenue every single year.
00:17:39 Yeah, in 2036, it might be doing that. First, it even has to have the plan approved so they can
00:17:45 start planning it. This pipeline is at least going to be taking 10 years to get completed.
00:17:52 In Texas, if you were building a pipeline from planning to completion, and by the way,
00:17:58 we've already basically been through an entire year of planning, and then we have another 10
00:18:01 years after this. In Texas, planning to completion takes one to three years, depending on the size
00:18:08 of the pipeline. So let's say a fairly long pipeline like the one from Alberta to the West
00:18:13 Coast would be a longer-ish one. In Texas, they'd get it done in three years. Maybe compensating
00:18:19 for the terrain between Alberta and British Columbia having to go through the mountains,
00:18:24 let's just add another year or two on top of that. At the very least, the Texans are building 1.00
00:18:29 pipelines in half the time that Canada is and with no government money. Maybe there's some loans 0.94
00:18:35 along the way, but that's very different compared to the government literally just spending 44
00:18:40 billion taxpayer dollars building a pipeline on top of the Pathways Project, on top of the
00:18:46 increased carbon tax. The whole thing is just stupid. Maybe it gets built one day. I don't 1.00
00:18:54 exactly trust the thing. And I actually did like the response here from conservative finance
00:18:59 critic Michael Chong, who actually went after the fact that there's just all this money being
00:19:05 promised all over the place for these new projects with no actual idea of how we're going to be
00:19:10 spending it. I'm just going to read a little bit of this and then that should be it for us today.
00:19:14 So he says in the header here, my statement on Mr. Carney's complete lack of fiscal transparency
00:19:20 on his recent spending announcements
00:19:22 totaling about $100 billion.
00:19:25 And that's literally one-tenth
00:19:27 of the entire Canadian economy right now.
00:19:30 It says the Honorable Michael Chong,
00:19:31 Conservative Shadow Minister for Finance,
00:19:33 released the following statement
00:19:34 on Mr. Carney's lack of fiscal transparency.
00:19:37 Quote, Prime Minister Carney
00:19:39 has announced about $100 billion
00:19:41 in new spending in recent weeks,
00:19:43 including at least $30 billion annually
00:19:45 for defence by 2030,
00:19:48 up to $43.7 billion for a new oil pipeline from Alberta to the West Coast,
00:19:53 and up to $20 billion for new infrastructure projects in British Columbia
00:19:57 without telling Canadians where the money to pay for all that will come from.
00:20:02 As Mr. Carney attends the NATO summit this week,
00:20:04 he will no doubt be touting his defense spending increases,
00:20:09 but Canadians have been left in the dark about exactly how the Liberals
00:20:12 will hit their spending targets and how they're going to pay for it.
00:20:15 Now, I'm not going to read the rest of this, but I can already answer that question. The way we're hitting our NATO targets is we're just increasing salaries. Increasing salaries, redefining domestic infrastructure for civilian use as being defense infrastructure, and then also committing to buying jets and boats someday in the future.
00:20:37 Like, apparently you can just make spending commitments, and that counts as raising your defense spending up to 2% of GDP every year.
00:20:46 Michael Chong in that statement later goes on to describe the situation where the parliamentary budget officer has asked three separate times for a breakdown of where the defense spending is actually going, and the government is unable to provide any transparency on where the money is going.
00:21:05 and so these guys are going to try and build this new west coast pipeline on time with all the new
00:21:12 reconciliation industry hurdles with all the environmental reviews and without getting rid
00:21:18 of bill c48 or bill c69 i'm not a pessimist i feel like i'm just a realist here well anyways
00:21:26 thank you guys for watching the show that should be it for me today make sure to like the video
00:21:30 subscribe leave a comment and of course hit the join button if you guys want to consider becoming
00:21:34 a monthly contributing donor to make the channel more sustainable for me and allow me to be less
00:21:39 reliant on the very awful YouTube algorithm. Anyways, with all that being said, thank you
00:21:44 guys for watching. I'll see you all later.