The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - May 18, 2026


Carney's Mouth got Canada in Trouble! Trump removes Canada from Defence Board!

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Liberal MPs turning on Carney over Fake Pipeline Agreement! Carney In DENIAL - Says Trump Cutting Him Off Is No Big Deal!

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

163.44

Word count

2,870

Sentence count

144

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Wyatt Claypool explains why Canada has been kicked off the NATO defense board and why the Americans don t like it. He also points out that Canada spends far less than the U.S. on its own defense.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, Wyatt Claypool here, and welcome back to the National Telegraph YouTube channel.
00:00:06 So it looks like Prime Minister Mark Carney's snide remarks against the Americans
00:00:10 cozying up with China and lack of action on defense has finally caught up with them
00:00:16 because U.S. President Donald Trump and the Americans are cutting Canada out of a mutual
00:00:22 defense board that we've been together on for 86 years. In fact, before the Americans even got
00:00:29 involved in World War II. Now, liberal politicians and liberals in the media, but I repeat myself,
00:00:37 are just going to say that this is just nasty American behavior because they like to pretend
00:00:43 that Canada exists in a vacuum and nothing we say or do should affect anyone else, but whatever the
00:00:49 Americans say and do deeply affects us. Carney has been alienating the Americans. That matters.
00:00:58 We were all offended by the 51st state jokes that Donald Trump was making, but every time Carney goes out and slags Trump and the Americans, they're just supposed to get over it, despite the fact that they've been flipping our defense bills for many decades at this point.
00:01:15 This is exactly like the whole tariff issue. I don't like the American tariffs, obviously,
00:01:23 but they also don't like our supply management tariffs. Are their current tariffs in terms of
00:01:28 raw dollar cost higher than ours? Sure, but you could say that ours have been going on for 40
00:01:34 plus years, so they probably balance out in terms of general costs on each other's economies at
00:01:40 this point. But the current scuffle is over Canada's defense spending, and it probably is
00:01:46 about a lot of other things, but at least on the surface, it's about Canada's failure to actually
00:01:51 meet its defense commitments. The Undersecretary of War in the United States, Elbridge Colby,
00:01:59 put out this tweet this morning, which read,
00:02:02 A strong Canada that prioritizes hard power over rhetoric benefits us all. Unfortunately,
00:02:08 Canada has failed to make credible progress on its defense commitments,
00:02:13 DOW is positing the Permanent Joint Board on Defense to reassess how this forum benefits
00:02:19 shared North American defense. We can no longer avoid the gaps between rhetoric and reality.
00:02:26 Real powers must sustain our rhetoric with shared defense and security responsibilities.
00:02:31 Delivering on shared continental defense begins by recognizing our shared geography.
00:02:36 Only by investing in our own defense capabilities will Americans and Canadians be safe, secure, and prosperous.
00:02:43 And of course, he shares a map of the United States and Canada here,
00:02:47 pointing out, you know, that we're right next to each other.
00:02:50 And this is all about the fact that Canada really puts up pretty much no money to its own defense
00:02:56 relative to how much money the United States puts up for the defense of Canada.
00:03:01 And the touch I really like here of what Elbridge Colby did was he linked the WEF website with the link going to Davos 2026, special addressed by Mark Carney.
00:03:15 His extremely snide speech where he talked about Canada and the rest of the middle powers in the world are going to pop out of the great power rivalry and we're going to hold up each other.
00:03:29 We're going to take our own defense seriously. We're going to trade more with each other and leave the implied great power rivalry between America and China.
00:03:39 Just we're just going to ignore it all. We're going to leave that aside.
00:03:43 Despite the fact that when Carney gave that speech, he was just about to sign a new trade deal with China, who he had previously called in the April 2025 election our greatest national security threat. 0.97
00:03:59 Mark Carney is a massive hypocrite and the Americans don't like him. Now, in reaction to this, we have liberal hacks, of course, saying that this just demonstrates the Americans are not reliable partners and they're so mean and they're so terrible, to which I ask, is it ever Canada's fault? Do we ever say and do anything that strains the relationship? 0.92
00:04:21 Do we ever fail to do something like adequately spend on our own defense that ticks off the Americans?
00:04:28 That's a big aspect of the whole trade fiasco going on right now.
00:04:32 I think we should have free trade between the countries.
00:04:34 I think we should have zero tariffs.
00:04:37 The Americans do have a point when they point out that they spend billions every year on defense that benefits Canada while we barely spend on our own defense.
00:04:46 We claim that we are now at 2% GDP on defense, but when you actually look into the details, it's complete nonsense.
00:04:55 Do you think that Canada's military is more robust than just a year ago?
00:05:01 Not really, but we're somehow spending more, and I'll be getting into that a little bit of just how we're fudging the numbers to make it look like we're actually hitting our NATO commitments.
00:05:09 But in response to what Elbridge Colby said, of course, we have the failed, hacky, liberal, former leader of the Conservative Party, Aaron O'Toole, sounding off, saying,
00:05:20 This is profoundly misguided and quite strange coming right after the president visits to China.
00:05:25 Canada has been and will be an ally that shares values of liberty.
00:05:30 As a Canadian whose grandfather deployed to Alaska for joint defense in World War II, I hope we don't lose sight of that. 0.98
00:05:36 oh my goodness Aaron O'Toole is the most pedantic fool who's ever been in Canadian politics you 0.95
00:05:44 could say no that's Justin Trudeau at least Justin Trudeau wins at least Justin Trudeau 1.00
00:05:49 had some people that like him nobody likes Aaron O'Toole because he says stupid things like this 0.98
00:05:55 Okanda has been and always will be an ally that shares values of liberty 0.94
00:05:59 i'm sorry we're just we don't we have bill 22 on the order paper right now where we're trying to
00:06:06 force internet like it's not internet providers but like vpn services to disclose personal
00:06:13 information of all their users we're not exactly a great lover of liberty these days as a country
00:06:19 ruled by the liberals but also on the defense side i don't care if canada loves liberty i'm
00:06:27 a Canadian. I'm a patriotic Canadian that wants our country to be better. But our country passively
00:06:33 loving the value of liberty does not actually make us a good ally. A war is going to break out
00:06:39 between the Americans and China, and Canada's going to walk into the room with a box of donuts
00:06:44 and an essay on liberty. Like, come on, how about we spend on our defense so we don't look pathetic 0.96
00:06:50 next to the Americans, so we actually look like we can carry our own weight? Because it's not just 0.76
00:06:55 that the Americans spend more on defense because they're bigger than us? They spend more on defense
00:07:01 per capita than we do. We basically have the enjoyment of the giant umbrella that America
00:07:08 builds around us, and we'll have people making snide remarks of like, well, America would be
00:07:12 spending it anyway, so who cares? Okay, you can try and test that theory if you want. I'm unwilling
00:07:20 to test that theory because it's really stupid to, especially at a time when we have our own 0.98
00:07:26 foreign affairs minister, Anita Anand, admitting that Russia is a threat to us, that also China 0.96
00:07:31 is a threat to us, but she won't vocalize that country because we're pretending it's no longer
00:07:35 a national security threat. But she knows Canada has threats and America is paying to defend
00:07:40 ourselves, to defend us. And now the liberals are trying to ballyhoo, no, no, no, no, we spend more
00:07:45 money on defense than we did a year ago. We're actually hitting our 2% NATO commitment now.
00:07:50 Not really. And technically, are we hitting it? Yes, but we're being massive weasels by thinking that we are like by claiming that we are based on the circumstances.
00:08:00 This is a article from the BBC, and I want to get to the headline of it after I read the body, some of the text, the body text here, just because it's very ironic when I show you what it says first and then we cut to the headline.
00:08:14 Right here it says,
00:08:44 percent of GDP on defense by 2035. Now, usually when I read, I like to scroll down to show you
00:08:52 the next paragraph as I go. I have deliberately obscured the next paragraph because it's quite
00:08:58 funny. Canada reached that two percent milestone by increasing salaries as well as pledging to
00:09:04 buy new equipment, upgrade existing bases, and build new infrastructure in the Arctic.
00:09:08 We also ended up just redefining a bunch of our regular infrastructure money spending that we never actually considered defense spending in the first place. It's now defense spending. Fantastic. So we're just spending more on salaries and defense commitments.
00:09:26 you know we might buy something someday so that is money spent now on defense you know we're
00:09:34 gonna get invaded by russia and we're just gonna post on some big billboards that in five years 0.91
00:09:39 we might buy jets and they're gonna run scared they're gonna be like oh my goodness the canadians 0.56
00:09:44 might do something which feels like the entire carny liberal government watch out he might do
00:09:51 something guys he's really thinking about it and he'll sign an mou about how he might do something
00:09:56 So don't you try and mess with Canada, because he's going to show up with a long essay about how much he likes liberty and how much the great power rivalry doesn't interest him.
00:10:07 Okay, okay, thanks, Mark. Thanks, Mark. That's really great.
00:10:10 But yeah, so no, we fraudulently got to 2% of our GDP spent on defense. And then we're all shocked, we're all surprised Pikachu at the fact that the Americans are calling our bluff and saying that, well, it doesn't look like we actually need to have this mutual defense board anymore, because you guys aren't even involved in actually defending the continent.
00:10:33 it. What does having Canada involved in the board achieve? I think like you'll every once in a while
00:10:39 get some Canadians saying, well, we spend more on icebreakers than the Americans do. It's like,
00:10:44 well, it turns out they don't have as much Arctic waters in their territory. And good for us.
00:10:50 That should be a default. I assume we also spend more on icebreakers than the Congo. 0.90
00:10:56 We probably spend more on winter coats than people in South Sudan. 1.00
00:11:01 It turns out that, yes, if you pick a stupid test, you might beat the Americans on that stupid test. 0.99
00:11:08 We should be spending 2% of our GDP on arms, on personnel, on actual equipment that can be used to defend us. 1.00
00:11:18 You know, radar, stuff like that.
00:11:21 This is the actual headline to that BBC article.
00:11:26 Why Canada is seeing its biggest military recruitment surge in 30 years?
00:11:30 No.
00:11:32 In fact, the vast majority of the money was spent on salaries and commitments to maybe buy something.
00:11:39 Yes, our recruitment might be up.
00:11:41 Those are not all military personnel.
00:11:43 And by the way, we've never had good military recruitment.
00:11:46 You didn't have to try that hard to boost it above levels that we haven't seen in 30 years.
00:11:52 We had a more professional, effective military in, let's say, 2010 when Stephen Harper was still prime minister than we do now because our military was focused on the ability to defend our country and strike at enemies.
00:12:08 And we no longer have that.
00:12:11 And what do we think this is setting us up for when it comes to renegotiations on, like, the USMCA in Kuzma?
00:12:18 We look really stupid right now considering that they just pulled us off of this board because we aren't really hitting our defense commitments. And then Carney's going to swagger up and say, I demand zero tariffs and a fantastic deal for Canada. And Trump is going to say, okay, I'll give you that. You just need to start spending another $10 billion every single year on defense because you're not properly paying for your own defense. I'm paying for it. And you're looking at me like I'm doing something wrong to tariff you?
00:12:48 Now, again, I don't like the tariffs, but we've seeded a big argument to Trump here.
00:12:52 I just want to get to this clip here of Anita Anand on Al Jazeera talking about military spending,
00:12:57 because, of course, she was here spreading the misinformation that Canada's military is being beefed up.
00:13:03 And, of course, she went on to a Qatari propaganda channel like Al Jazeera to talk about this.
00:13:08 Canada is now spending 2% of GDP on defense as per the NATO suggestions or requirements, depending on how you put it.
00:13:17 This is after years of previous governments in Canada sort of dragging their feet, I think we can agree, on that target.
00:13:24 I wonder, was this because you could no longer count on the United States to guarantee Canada's security?
00:13:33 Now, in this interview, she should immediately say no.
00:13:37 No, America's a reliable partner.
00:13:40 We're very good allies.
00:13:41 She should say that.
00:13:42 Now, because Al Jazeera is a Qatari propaganda outlet that, although it technically is an ally of the United States, isn't really an ally of the United States.
00:13:51 It's more of just an ally out of convenience at the same time that they are one of the biggest private facilitators of financing between terrorists and different sketchy organizations.
00:14:05 Of course they asked it in such a way where they want to blame America.
00:14:08 She should be pushing back on that.
00:14:10 But because she is a terrible foreign affairs minister, she's going to screw this whole thing up and immediately start playing in to the narrative that Albrecht Colby put out in his tweet.
00:14:20 We committed to reaching 2% of GDP as one of the founding members of the NATO alliance.
00:14:27 And so that's exactly what we did this year.
00:14:29 We're also on track to meeting 5% of GDP by 2035.
00:14:35 And I'm asking you why it didn't happen sooner.
00:14:36 There is a commitment to security and defense, specifically given the changing geopolitical environment.
00:14:46 We are seeing the Russian threat move further and further north towards the Arctic Circle.
00:14:53 This has become more and more palpable since the illegal further invasion of Ukraine by Russia in 2022.
00:15:00 I was the minister of national defense at the time.
00:15:03 so no no credit to the americans but she does vaguely point to oh yes changing geopolitical
00:15:11 environments have caused us to spend more just say that the americans are forcing you to spend
00:15:15 more just blame them for this even though this is an obligation you should have been taking care of
00:15:20 for a long time and even harper wasn't taking care of it you know shame on him too although he
00:15:26 actually spent what he did spend on real military like you know equipment real defense but you can't
00:15:33 even actually throw a bone to the americans who have been paying for our defense for a very long
00:15:37 time yeah we partially cover our own but it's so partial if the americans didn't exist we'd have 1.00
00:15:43 to be spending so much more than we currently do and she can't do it because left-wing orthodoxy 0.98
00:15:49 won't allow her to even pretend to be an ally of the united states again we are now working closely 0.93
00:15:57 with China. And Aaron O'Toole, in his tweet that I read earlier, tried to make like a snide
00:16:04 insinuation of like, basically undercutting Canada right after he went to China, as if he's up to
00:16:10 something with China. No. In fact, America is the country that is best at holding China accountable.
00:16:17 People say, well, America trades with China. Well, they talk about trade deals with China.
00:16:22 Yeah, but they're also paying for our national defense. 0.59
00:16:26 They also don't let Chinese spies into their country or they prosecute them when they find 0.85
00:16:30 them. 0.98
00:16:31 We don't.
00:16:32 So we don't really have the privilege to say, well, they trade with China. 1.00
00:16:36 What a bunch of hypocrites. 0.99
00:16:37 I'm like, yeah, you got them. 1.00
00:16:39 I guess you got them.
00:16:40 You got the country that's paying for your defense and doesn't want you deepening your
00:16:44 ties with China.
00:16:45 Not as just because we can.
00:16:48 As an oppositional move against the United States. 0.70
00:16:51 Maybe that ticks off the United States a little bit, that we're growing closer to China, not because we have the wherewithal to, you know, benefit ourselves through trade while being able to stiff arm them on on their national security threats, on their ability to affect our country.
00:17:07 No, we're just doing it as a U.S. replacement, which is absolutely pathetic and was always going to lead to the United States taking retaliatory actions like cutting us out of this defense board.
00:17:17 and I can't disagree we probably don't add very much to the board at this point anyways with all
00:17:24 that being said thank you guys for watching make sure to like share subscribe do all that fantastic
00:17:30 stuff and I'll see you guys next time