The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - November 17, 2026


Liberals Collapse in QP - Conservatives Demand Minister Joly RESIGN!

Media Finally Admits the Carney Liberals are Sinking Themselves!

Episode Stats


Length

26 minutes

Words per minute

165.96

Word count

4,328

Sentence count

205

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

16

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 The Carney Liberals' performance today in Question Period is nothing short of embarrassing.
00:00:06 They're not even just dodging questions anymore, they're now having tantrums in response to questions.
00:00:11 In fact, the Liberal House leader, Steve McKinnon, had a tantrum in response to a Conservative MP
00:00:18 demanding that Melanie Jolie, the industry minister, resign for her incompetence
00:00:23 and lying about the Stellantis plant closure in Brampton.
00:00:27 Check this out.
00:00:28 I'm a member for Barry South, Innisfil.
00:00:32 Systematically dismantling the auto industry in this country.
00:00:36 There are reports of more than a dozen meetings between the company and Liberals on selling the plant to Rochelle.
00:00:43 There are also reports that four Liberal MPs toured the plant with Rochelle discussing the sale.
00:00:49 The bottom line is that privately, the Prime Minister knew the sale was happening.
00:00:53 The minister also knew, but in public, they acted shocked, indignant, and outraged.
00:00:59 Turns out it was all an act of deceit because the sale was in the works months ago and the liberals knew it all along.
00:01:07 After this massive betrayal of these workers, will the minister resign?
00:01:12 I just want to say, great question from MP Broussard there.
00:01:17 Absolutely no notes.
00:01:18 I didn't even know that the Liberals had apparently done a tour of the closing Stellantis plants with Rochelle, so they cannot pretend that they didn't know about the deal or were not lending their approval to the deal.
00:01:32 If you're literally touring around with Rochelle looking at the plant space, you can't pretend that you don't support Rochelle buying it from Stellantis.
00:01:41 And by the way, there's nothing wrong with that. Stellantis wants to move on while handing back a bunch of the subsidy money. Let them. Lower taxes and regulations if you want businesses to stay in Canada. You cannot strong arm them or bribe them into growing the economy. They are leaving because the economy, their business, is not growing.
00:02:00 But now, check out the Liberal House leader here, Steve McKinnon, freaking out and gesticulating in response to Broussard demanding that an incompetent minister maybe quit her job.
00:02:11 Where was that member and where was that leader when illegal and unjustified tariff specifically targeted our steel, our forest, our automobile, and our aluminum industries?
00:02:30 Where was that member? Where was that party? Where was that leader?
00:02:34 How dare they ask my colleague to resign? They should all resign!
00:02:38 what was that like any liberal standing up and applauding that just needs to give their head
00:02:45 a shake that was embarrassing it started off it already started off bad before he got to the big
00:02:52 flourish at the end they should all resign mr speaker before that he's just like where were
00:02:58 they when trump imposed steel and aluminum and forest and auto tariffs on our economy
00:03:05 what are they the super friends what are they the justice league is john brassard secretly
00:03:11 superman and pure poly of the hulk what are they gonna do about it i know those are from different
00:03:16 franchises don't get on my backs comic book nerds but what were they gonna do about them
00:03:22 in fact when conservative politicians went down to the united states to meet with the trump
00:03:27 administration like danielle smith and like jamil giovanni they get attacked by the liberals and the
00:03:34 media for doing that it's such a lame response to a very good question and I know last video I said
00:03:41 I'm going to stop using the word lame but this righteous indignation this fake righteous indignation
00:03:49 from Steve McKinnon is lame answer the question at least justify the at least justify the record
00:03:58 of Melanie Jolie by explaining why it's good oh if they're going to demand my colleague resign
00:04:04 they're crazy and they should resign instead get out of here in just a second we're going to jump
00:04:10 over to some other questions asked by the conservatives and dissect the extremely awful 0.89
00:04:16 answers from the liberals but before we do that i just want to remind you guys if you like the
00:04:21 channel make sure to leave a like on the video type the video if you are using the youtube mobile
00:04:25 app and of course if you are not yet a subscriber to the national telegraph youtube channel make
00:04:30 sure you hit the subscribe button. We are almost at 100,000 subscribers, and if you do, my videos
00:04:36 will pop up in your feed more regularly. But now let's move on to Melissa Lansman's question
00:04:42 along the same lines. The Honorable Member for Thornhill. Speaker, just because you say the same 0.53
00:04:53 answer over and over again, it doesn't make it true. It neither makes it true when you scream
00:04:57 that answer, but not a single answer for the thousands of Stellantis workers who lost their
00:05:03 job. Here's another question. The Prime Minister goes to China and floats letting in even more
00:05:08 EVs. That means more Chinese electric cars flooding our market and more layoffs like
00:05:13 Stellantis. Europe proves it. Chinese imports cost them 104,000 auto jobs in 2024 and 2025 1.00
00:05:19 alone. That's 142 jobs lost a day. So before he signs on the dotted line, will the Prime Minister
00:05:26 think of the Canadian autoworkers that he's selling out.
00:05:30 The Honourable Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of International Trade.
00:05:34 Thank you very much, Speaker.
00:05:35 Speaker, the Prime Minister and this government is absolutely clear
00:05:38 that our autoworkers are one of the best in the world.
00:05:41 And our number one job is to make sure that they are fully deployed,
00:05:44 that they remain very much part of a North American integrated market.
00:05:48 Okay, so already this is a horrible response.
00:05:53 He starts out with, hey, Prime Minister Mark Carney thinks Canadian auto workers are super cool. Carney thinks Canadian auto workers are the cutest auto workers. And he is focused on, this government is focused on making sure they remain fully deployed, which is why we're losing thousands of manufacturing jobs, both in the auto sector and outside of the auto sector.
00:06:18 Like, what are you talking about? I don't care what you guys think you're focused on. I care how you're actually performing, and you suck. That's all I can really say. You suck at your jobs. This is why Melanie Jolie should resign.
00:06:33 In fact, Carney would be smart to get her to resign because it would look like he's taking charge.
00:06:38 Okay, she's not doing a good job, so I'm going to replace her.
00:06:42 Now, that would be giving lie to the idea that Carney is not micromanaging all these ministers because he absolutely is. 0.98
00:06:50 And Melanie Jolie really sucks more so because Mark Carney himself sucks. 0.96
00:06:54 But that would be a great way of Carney at least rhetorically distancing himself from all these layoffs. 0.99
00:06:59 Oh, I'm going to do a shuffle.
00:07:01 we're going to get rid of Melanie Jolie and we're going to stick in who's his face into that role.
00:07:05 And now everything's going to turn around and would at least buy him several months
00:07:09 pretending like they're kind of revamping their industrial strategy.
00:07:14 And speaker, that is why we are really focused on making sure that we end an arrangement with the United States
00:07:21 so that we can continue without those important jobs.
00:07:23 But we also will ensure that we continue to diversify our economy to ensure that we...
00:07:28 Someone should bring out the shepherd hook and just pull him off screen. 0.79
00:07:32 He's bombing here.
00:07:33 We are opening new opportunities for our workers as well,
00:07:36 but we will stand by our auto workers every single day.
00:07:42 The Honorable Member for Sudbury.
00:07:44 Mr. Speaker, Canadians who work hard should keep more of what they earn.
00:07:49 We're going to get into one of these annoying things
00:07:51 where a liberal MP is going to ask their own government a question.
00:07:54 I hate that.
00:07:55 It doesn't matter if it's a conservative government or a liberal government
00:07:58 in federally or provincially. I hate the tradition of MPs of your own governing party asking you
00:08:05 questions. If you were in a coalition government and your smaller coalition partner asked you
00:08:10 questions, I get that. I hate stuff like this. But now I want to jump back to the beginning
00:08:14 where Pierre Polyev was going after the insanely incompetent finance minister,
00:08:20 Francois-Philippe Champagne. It has been just a bloodbath for the liberals over the past couple
00:08:27 of months. They can't point to anything that works, and everything that they want to do
00:08:32 is incredibly unpopular. Again, like I said in a video a couple days ago, their new immigration
00:08:38 targets are as popular as mandatory tetanus shots. Nobody thinks that we need to be vastly
00:08:45 increasing the amount of TFWs and permanent residents that we're bringing into the country, 1.00
00:08:50 let alone taking people that we did not deem worthy of being permanent residents and just
00:08:55 making 200,000 temporary residents permanent. That is insane. Irresponsible. I don't even know
00:09:03 what other things that we need to describe it as. It's the worst. And now the Liberals are,
00:09:08 I don't even know what they do these days to justify their existence, but
00:09:11 we'll watch them attempt to do it right now. Society, thank you.
00:09:17 While the Prime Minister sends billions of our money abroad, Canadians are paying the price
00:09:22 and losing their jobs here at home.
00:09:24 Stats Canada reported today that inflation is 50% above target.
00:09:29 Now the first three quarters of this year have been the worst for insolvency
00:09:33 since the Great Global Recession.
00:09:35 The dollar has fallen beneath 70 cents American.
00:09:40 And finally, what is the Prime Minister's solution?
00:09:43 Send half a billion dollars to Brazil for forests.
00:09:47 Why is the Prime Minister wasting our money abroad
00:09:50 when Canadians can't afford to feed themselves here at home.
00:09:53 If you don't know the details on that story,
00:09:55 we actually talked about this story a few months ago.
00:09:58 It might have been more like five or six months ago.
00:10:01 The Liberals had given $120 million to Brazil
00:10:05 to fight climate change and, like, I guess,
00:10:09 deforestation in the rainforest. 1.00
00:10:11 Stupid. 1.00
00:10:12 Why are we doing that? 1.00
00:10:14 Especially with Lula in charge of Brazil,
00:10:16 effectively a dictator by quote-unquote democratic means the idea that he's actually a legitimate
00:10:23 president considering he keeps trying to jail all his political opponents is laughable at best 0.97
00:10:28 but then we decided hey that didn't look stupid enough for us to do let's give them another 350 0.98
00:10:36 380 million dollars to fight climate change and force beetles or whatever we're doing 0.78
00:10:42 At the time when food bank usage is at record highs, the people are being laid off left and right. 0.99
00:10:50 Let's give money to the Brazilians. 0.95
00:10:53 Okay, let's see Francois-Philippe Chambayne try and justify this one.
00:11:00 The Honorable Minister of Finance.
00:11:04 It is that the leader of the opposition was missing in action last week, because you know we presented a great budget, budget 2026, Mr. Speaker, which will bring growth in this country, back on affordability, build on our sovereignty, Mr. Speaker.
00:11:19 Mr. Speaker, in this morning, I introduced a motion to put in action the 2027 supplement that's going to help 12 million people, put 120,000 people out of poverty, Mr. Speaker. That's the kind of things that Canadians expect. That's what we're delivering for Canadians, Mr. Speaker.
00:11:37 a bloated program guys don't worry who cares that we're literally sending like 13 billion
00:11:44 dollars in foreign aid every year while we can't pay for anything at home we just approved more
00:11:50 program spending instead of cutting people's taxes substantially like also it's kind of a
00:11:56 self-defeating thing for him to say because okay if these programs are so great why are we spending
00:12:02 money on brazilian forests and teaching gender theory in pakistan when we could just add more
00:12:07 money to those programs budgets now i don't like the programs in general but again if they're so
00:12:12 great how about we cut foreign aid spending and put more money into the programs and they never
00:12:18 really think of that which i think pure poly was going to smack them over the honorable leader of
00:12:23 the opposition mr speaker last week i was actually you know where i was i was talking to kim over at
00:12:30 Tim Hortons, who told me that her husband had committed suicide because of financial pressures
00:12:35 and that she's hanging on by her fingernails. She said to me, and I quote, I just need some
00:12:42 light at the end of the tunnel and I hope it's not an oncoming train. Meanwhile, this government
00:12:47 is sending a half billion Canadian tax dollars to Brazil for forests. Why the hell are they
00:12:53 wasting our money abroad when people here at home can't afford to feed themselves?
00:13:00 Let's just be careful about certain terms.
00:13:06 The Honourable Minister of Jobs and Families.
00:13:09 Let me guess. Take care.
00:13:10 Mr. Speaker, first of all, my heart goes out to Kim.
00:13:13 Yeah, yeah, it got a little more awkward trying to be arrogant all of a sudden.
00:13:17 Yeah, maybe consequences of your bad policies should be taken a little bit more seriously, 1.00
00:13:23 but let's let Patty Hayes, you finish here. 0.76
00:13:25 The family member who has just recently lost a loved one to suicide, I can tell you that there's nothing more horrific for a family to have to go through that.
00:13:35 Having said that, Mr. Speaker, I hope that the member opposite is telling Kim about the budget, about the different measures in place to support Canadian workers, to make sure that people have the supports that they need, to make sure that provinces and territories have what they need as well.
00:13:52 Okay, it's another shepherd's hook moment. Please get her off the stage. The leader of the opposition just mentioned somebody whose husband killed himself because of financial stresses. And Patty Hayes, you is here saying, have you have you ever heard of the the grocery room? Have you ever did you do you know about the summer jobs program that we have? Have you ever heard of school lunches? We're paying for school lunches now.
00:14:19 It's like people don't want to live lives of relying on the governments for scraps to barely scrape by.
00:14:28 People would rather the economy be chugging along properly through lower taxation and deregulation than having this big, bloated, sluggish economy being supplemented through cash injections by the government. 0.96
00:14:43 That's pathetic and sad. 0.93
00:14:46 and bringing this up in response to what 0.99
00:14:48 Polly have said is horrible I would have
00:14:50 just punted I would have been our heart goes out
00:14:52 to them we will always be trying to find solutions
00:14:54 for people like Kim and her
00:14:56 family we feel really bad for her
00:14:58 blah blah blah and I would have moved on
00:14:59 like again I'm not trying to give them advice they'll never
00:15:02 take my advice but
00:15:03 take a knee on that one 0.99
00:15:05 shut up stop 1.00
00:15:07 talking about liberal 0.99
00:15:10 programs nobody
00:15:12 cares be quiet
00:15:14 to help people who are struggling with mental health.
00:15:17 Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
00:15:18 Leader of the Opposition.
00:15:23 Last week I was also wondering where I was last week, Mr. Speaker,
00:15:26 speaking to autoworkers at Stellantis who are out in the cold.
00:15:30 The Prime Minister claimed he felt betrayed by the sale of their plant to Rochelle.
00:15:36 We now find out that his government was intimately involved in brokering the sale.
00:15:40 And now the Prime Minister is saying that he wants to pivot to Chinese automakers.
00:15:45 According to Brian Kingston of the Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers,
00:15:49 ask about the Europeans how their China auto strategy is working out.
00:15:54 104,000 lost jobs since they started.
00:15:58 Why is the Prime Minister selling out our odd workers to Beijing?
00:16:04 The Honourable Minister of Finance.
00:16:05 Mr. Speaker, let me set the record straight. Our priority number one has always been to restore operation and the tenant has fled, Mr. Speaker. It's always been to make sure that the companies would respect the undertaking and their obligations to the workers, to the industry and to Canadians, Mr. Speaker.
00:16:22 that's obviously not true like as john brassard got uh to later in this question period but it
00:16:28 was already pretty well known even before he just added some more meat on the bones to the fact that
00:16:33 they literally had toured the plants with rochelle you were involved in the talks about the sales
00:16:40 how is it that you you can't come back and say well we've always been focused on on trying to
00:16:45 make sure that stalantis is always keeping these people employed well clearly they're not going to
00:16:51 keep them employed if you know they're going to sell what they're not of course they have they're
00:16:55 not going to make sure everyone still has a job if they're leaving and selling it to another company
00:17:01 who you were on the tour of all the of the plant space with obviously not this is this is just so
00:17:09 i don't even know like it's so self-defeating every time they try and defend themselves or act
00:17:15 like they're actually the good guys and all this because it ends up just explode exposing another
00:17:19 lie they're telling or making them just seem impotent to do anything to positively affect
00:17:25 the situation so either they are lying or too incompetent to breathe
00:17:33 instead of complaining they should join them and fight for canadians mr speaker
00:17:36 at the time like that workers at stalantes are explaining every member of the side to fight for
00:17:41 them on this side of the house we know that every day is a good thing to fight for canadians by the
00:17:46 By the way, they actually will not go in and out and meet the Unifor workers.
00:17:49 And again, I am not a fan of Unifor.
00:17:51 I'm just not a big union guy in general.
00:17:53 I find unions tend to be pretty out of touch with how the economy works in general.
00:17:57 Not the actual workers themselves.
00:17:59 They actually tend to be very conservative voters these days.
00:18:01 But the leadership, Lana Payne and people like that.
00:18:04 But the liberals, aside from the fact that I maybe don't agree on the exact takes from the union on how you actually grow the economy and secure jobs.
00:18:12 The Liberal ministers, the Liberal MPs, they will never go and meet directly with the Unifor workers. They'll get absolutely reamed out by them in public about all the times that they've been lying about the situation and how they're nauseated by the Liberals pretending to be on their side and always in their corner.
00:18:31 And so when Francois-Philippe Champagne out here is acting like, when are the Conservatives going to come out and defend workers with us?
00:18:39 You're not out there. You refuse to meet with them.
00:18:43 Unifor had to twist Melanie Jolie's arm to come and meet with them.
00:18:47 That's actually how that went.
00:18:48 The Honourable Leader of the Opposition.
00:18:50 While Canadians are lacking housing, jobs, and health care, the Prime Minister intends to massively increase immigration here next year.
00:19:04 He's looking at more than 600 new permanent residents.
00:19:08 It's by far a record, 200,000 more than the highest year under Justin Trudeau.
00:19:12 the national post believes that it'll take another 500 000 jobs just to fill this when we're losing
00:19:20 115 000 jobs why is the prime minister depriving canadians of jobs housing and health care and when
00:19:28 will he regain control of immigration now there's a really good reason why we're watching him ask
00:19:35 this question in french this is a massive hot button issue right now in quebec obviously mass
00:19:42 immigration all across Canada has always been unpopular if you actually follow the polling
00:19:47 results. But it's been particularly unpopular in Quebec, especially now, because since the
00:19:53 beginning of the year, the Quebec economy has lost a combined more than 200,000 full and part-time
00:19:59 jobs. And now you're going to impose more immigration on the entire country, which includes 0.96
00:20:06 Quebec, even if they disproportionately aren't going to take as many people as other parts of
00:20:10 canada so now watch the liberals try and get out of this one again it's open season it's a shooting
00:20:16 gallery it's a turkey hunt at the moment for both the conservatives and the bloc quebecois this is
00:20:22 why when some polls come out and i see the bloc only at five or six percent i'm just thinking
00:20:27 the pq just won the provincial election yes it's a minority government but the party quebecois
00:20:35 won the provincial election and they're very likely uh in like they're very likely to be more
00:20:43 at like seven or eight percent nationally right now they would not be at five or six like some
00:20:48 polls are showing the issues right now for the liberals that have to do with quebec are going
00:20:54 to be sinking their approval rating very quickly the honorable minister of immigration refugees
00:21:00 and citizenship mr speaker we have regained control and figures show this a person already
00:21:10 established in canada who has a home a job and a doctor does not put additional pressure on
00:21:18 services on the contrary they support these services that we depend on if the conservatives
00:21:27 want well they need to tell canadians what uh spots they want to eliminate our plan is working
00:21:35 it's transparent and we are here for canadians okay let's be very clear they never regained
00:21:42 control over immigration the liberals were kind of getting it under a little bit more under control
00:21:48 relative to late stage trudeau levels of immigration in 2023 and 2024 trudeau was
00:21:54 actually the first one to drop the rates of tfw's pr's and students and then the liberals had
00:22:00 declared it under control so what are they doing now they're not keeping it quote-unquote under
00:22:07 control it's still it was still too high as of before the budget but now they're going to blow
00:22:11 out the rates harder than ever before because it's so under control that's like saying we have
00:22:16 the fire under control so let's throw a molotov cocktail into the window of the part of the house
00:22:22 that hasn't burnt down yet. No, if you have the fire under control, that doesn't give you license
00:22:28 to restart the fire. And by the way, no, immigrants are not disproportionately helping prop up services.
00:22:36 They are disproportionate users of them, not contributors to them, both in terms of the tax
00:22:41 base as well as professional skills. I am not advocating for no immigration. I would drop 0.97
00:22:48 immigration, new PR number should be under $80,000, should be $50,000 only per year. With 1.00
00:22:55 that limited amount, not $600,000, not $380,000, with $50,000, $70,000, you could be more likely
00:23:04 to guarantee that the vast majority of people coming in are professionals, are doctors, are
00:23:09 engineers, are architects, are people who are business owners with a lot of capital who are
00:23:15 going to start a new business here that's a reasonable amount because it's been way too much 0.91
00:23:21 for way too long especially with populations of people who are just not likely to assimilate
00:23:26 because we were not picky and choosy about who was coming through the doors but now poly is going to
00:23:31 follow up on that one again because again a lot of blood in the water on this one the honorable
00:23:36 leader of the opposition while canadians face shortages for jobs homes and health care the
00:23:41 Oh, okay. He's doing it again in English, so we can skip there. But it was actually important that he started that one off in French because that is a really big issue in Quebec, which might be able to pry a couple more seats loose for the Conservatives in that province.
00:23:54 Although I don't want the Conservatives overly focusing on Quebec because, yes, Quebec has a lot of seats in it, but Quebec is never where a Conservative victory runs through.
00:24:06 You get these consultants who, like, talk about how the Conservatives need to be able to win Quebec if they want to be able to take Parliament.
00:24:14 No, guys, there's been one election in all of Canadian history where the Conservatives needed Quebec to get the majority or the minority government that they won.
00:24:24 You could have eliminated every Quebec seat in every other election except 1988, and the Conservatives would have still had the same result, whether it was a minority government result or a majority government result.
00:24:36 It's just the truth. Quebec comes along for the ride when the Conservatives are obviously winning in the rest of the country.
00:24:44 First, win southwestern Ontario, northern Ontario, pick up one-third of the seats in the Maritimes, win more seats out on Vancouver Island in the interior, and clean up a couple of the seats in Manitoba and grab a territory or two, and then Quebec will probably come along with you because you have momentum.
00:25:05 You do not chase the median Quebec voter because the median Quebec voter is very much to the left of the average voter that the Conservatives should be courting.
00:25:15 There are Quebec voters who are definitely Conservatives, but they're not default Conservatives.
00:25:20 They come along when your party has momentum, not that they're just the only vote for the winner.
00:25:25 That's not really how Quebec works.
00:25:27 It's more so that you first have to be popular elsewhere, then you can do a bit of cleanup work in Quebec if you want.
00:25:33 But you cannot focus on Quebec as the main place you're going to win seats.
00:25:40 You're never going to pick up a bunch of seats around the Montreal Donut,
00:25:44 but then somehow only grab a couple more in the Maritimes.
00:25:48 You're going to win a lot more in the Maritimes before that translates into seats around the Montreal Donut.
00:25:54 So with all that being said, thank you guys for watching.
00:25:57 Make sure to like, share, subscribe, leave a comment, consider hitting the join button,
00:26:02 and I'll see you guys all later.