The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - November 17, 2026


Liberals DROP 5% in New Polls - Carney Approval Falls 7%

Media Finally Admits the Carney Liberals are Sinking Themselves!

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

165.58

Word count

4,201

Sentence count

189

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
00:00:00 Ahoy everyone, Wyatt Claypool here, back for some more polling time on the whiteboard.
00:00:05 It looks like reality is finally catching up with the Mark Carney Liberals,
00:00:10 with multiple polls showing the Liberals' lead over the pure poly of Conservatives
00:00:14 falling significantly. And it is likely to get worse, since most of the surveys we're going to
00:00:21 be talking about today were conducted before the budget came out, before the Stellantis scandal,
00:00:27 and before their new immigration plan that is extremely unpopular.
00:00:32 So when we're going to be looking at 5% drops in their lead,
00:00:36 know that this is only the beginning.
00:00:39 The liberals got extremely arrogant, never thought they were going to be unpopular again,
00:00:43 and decided to do whatever they wanted,
00:00:46 despite the fact that the public was obviously going to hate it.
00:00:50 Anyways, before we get into some of the numbers out from Angus Reid,
00:00:54 I do just want to remind you guys, if you like the show,
00:00:56 make sure to leave a like on the video, subscribe if you are not yet a subscriber. We are almost to
00:01:02 100,000 subscribers on the channel, and if you want to support my work, you can always hit the
00:01:06 join button below and contribute a few dollars a month. It really does help make the channel
00:01:11 more sustainable and allows me to do very niche videos like these polling videos that usually a
00:01:17 lot of people don't like. Anyways, without further ado, let's get into the new numbers out from
00:01:23 Angus Reid. Angus Reid, just a few weeks ago, had the Liberals leading the Conservatives by about
00:01:30 15-16 points, and their lead has come down significantly since then, but I will show you
00:01:37 what they were at back in, I believe, September or October, and then we'll jump ahead to what
00:01:43 their November numbers are saying. So back in late September, early October, Angus Reid had
00:01:50 the Liberals sitting at 46% in the national polls. That is a significant gain from their 2025
00:02:01 election results that would be doing about 3% better. And it's hard to do much better when
00:02:07 both the Conservatives and Liberals were already in the low to mid-40s. And 46% would obviously
00:02:14 have them gaining more seats than they won in 25, and they would easily win a majority government.
00:02:19 Back then, back in late September, early October, the federal conservatives were only sitting at 32% in the Angus Reid survey. That is a massive drop off.
00:02:33 Now, I am going to explain a bit later the problems with response bias and how that was probably suppressing the conservative numbers and boosting the liberal numbers over the last couple of months among many pollsters.
00:02:46 But in general, momentum was not on the side of the Conservatives as a couple of months ago, especially after the by-election losses, even if the by-elections were obviously going to be won by the Liberals, because most of them were safe Liberal seats.
00:03:00 The NDP were at 12% of the vote in late September, and I will just fill in November now because they haven't budged since then. They were at 12% back then, and they are still at 12% now.
00:03:16 Avi Lewis as the new NDP leader, I'm not sure if he really adds anything to the party that Jagmeet Singh wasn't already giving it.
00:03:24 He's kind of lackluster. I think really the NDP's growth is going to be mostly reliant on the Liberals messing up more than Avi Lewis and the NDP doing anything significantly well.
00:03:38 It really, I think, if the Liberals fail to deliver on a lot of their big affordability promises, more left-leaning voters will exit us over to the NDP, where more right-leaning voters will jump over back to the Conservatives.
00:03:54 Last poll also had the Bloc Quebecois at the same place they are in now, so I'll also fill those two in.
00:04:00 They are at 5% in both Angus Reid surveys, and I will also explain why I think that's probably a bit off here,
00:04:09 and they may still be overestimating the Liberals right now.
00:04:13 The NDP, or the Greens, in the last survey were at 2%, and we'll start with them in filling up the new numbers.
00:04:21 So they were at 2% back in September, and now in November, they are at 3%.
00:04:27 It really probably has nothing to do with Mike Morrison or whatever his name is being the new Green leader.
00:04:33 Most people don't pay attention that much.
00:04:36 I think that they're mostly just going to be gaining as the Liberals fall due to affordability issues the same way as the NDP,
00:04:43 but to a lesser extent because it is the Green Party.
00:04:46 But now, let's look at the Conservative Party of Canada and Liberal Party of Canada's movements here, because this is where it's most significant.
00:04:56 So, the Conservatives have gone from 32% and have jumped up to 34%.
00:05:03 I know this doesn't seem like a big gain, it's only 2%, but really what you're looking at is the swing between the Liberals and the Conservatives.
00:05:13 Their combined change, where is that putting the polls at?
00:05:15 So we've gone from 32% to 34, a two-point gain, and the Liberals have fallen by 3% and are down now at 43 in the polls as of early November.
00:05:34 So that is a three-point fall, meaning that the combined change that we are seeing between the Liberal Party and the Conservative Party is 5%.
00:05:45 Their lead going from 14% down to 9%.
00:05:50 They are now sub-10% lead, which is actually new for the Liberals over the past couple of months across every pollster.
00:05:59 The liberals were enjoying double-digit leads, usually in the mid-teens, which wasn't shocking because every time Mark Carney fights with Donald Trump, he gets a massive approval boost, the liberals get a polling lead boost because he's fighting for Team Canada, and isn't that Trump guy so bad?
00:06:17 And there's this sort of political spell, I think, that gets cast on voters whenever Carney fights with Trump, that basically because he's fighting with Trump, any opposition to Mark Carney is seen as either being pro-Trump or undermining Team Canada.
00:06:35 I'm not kidding you.
00:06:36 Look at Avi Lewis's approval ratings over time.
00:06:39 He started out significantly negative when typically outside of Jagmeet Singh in his last year in office,
00:06:48 usually NDP leaders have very positive approval ratings because the Liberals don't mind the NDP guy.
00:06:54 They know he's not really much of a threat to Liberal power.
00:06:58 You know, even Conservatives typically don't hate the NDP leader because, hey, they're challenging the Liberals from the left.
00:07:04 I don't agree with him on any policy, but he's probably a good guy.
00:07:08 Avi Lewis has been like negative 10, negative like 13 in many approval ratings for leader polls,
00:07:15 simply because he opposes Mark Carney and Mark Carney opposes Trump.
00:07:20 So it's like Avi Lewis doesn't want Carney to oppose Trump.
00:07:23 He's not on Team Canada.
00:07:25 That's how a lot of voters end up thinking about this stuff.
00:07:28 Same thing obviously goes for Pierre Polyev because he criticizes Mark Carney.
00:07:33 It's like he's taking Trump's side in the trade war. It's really annoying, but we are starting to see those issues that kind of diminish over time because of just how much the liberals are messing up on the jobs market, the economy, public finance, immigration.
00:07:49 And to show you this, I need to lay this out for you, and then I'll get back to the BQ and the conservative thing I wanted to talk about.
00:07:57 This poll was conducted, if I can get this, I do need to find that this is significant.
00:08:04 Um, I believe this one was, yes, conducted between November 3rd. So we have November 3rd to November 6th. So this poll, guys, is not taking into account a lot of bad news that hit the Liberals.
00:08:26 Do you know when the budget was dropped? Late on November 5th.
00:08:31 That, like, well past the time where pollsters are even probably doing surveying that day.
00:08:36 And so we have this poll only taking into account a single day when the budget was out on November 6th.
00:08:45 Every other day, voters were flying blind.
00:08:48 They were simply judging Carney and the liberals based on the general vibes of the economy.
00:08:52 General vibes of affordability and many other issues like immigration and, you know, crime and foreign policy and whatnot.
00:09:03 So that is significant.
00:09:05 Another thing is, do you know when the Stellantis scandal really got fired up?
00:09:09 I believe it was between the 7th and the 8th of November.
00:09:15 Yes, the Stellantis issue existed before that, but the announcement that the plant was closing, that was back on the 7th and the 8th.
00:09:26 So, in this poll, where the liberals fell a collective, the swing between the conservatives and the liberals was 5%.
00:09:33 That had nothing to do with the new immigration plan that everybody hates.
00:09:39 It had nothing to do with the massive deficit budget.
00:09:42 It had nothing to do with the Stellantis plant closure in Brampton.
00:09:46 That's hitting them now.
00:09:48 And when we get to the next Abacus data poll that also had a 5% swing between the Liberals
00:09:53 and the Conservatives, I bet you we are probably going to see Abacus, which fell from a plus
00:09:58 16 lead for the Liberals down to 11, they're probably going to be going significantly sub
00:10:03 10, where now you're going to see the Liberals and the Conservatives in what I would consider
00:10:08 a very competitive race between, you know, a 5 to 6 point lead.
00:10:11 And even these numbers right now, I think, are still a little bit overheated for the Liberals, and it's down to this concept, response bias.
00:10:21 It's something that pollsters have a very difficult time filtering out, because unless you're just going to make a judgment call and say,
00:10:29 I think these guys are just polling too high, then you're just going to have to leave it in.
00:10:34 And it's kind of a little hairy as a pollster to just simply say the numbers are wrong, and I think that we should remove two points from them and add two points to them, because whoever picks up the phone is whoever picks up the phone.
00:10:47 And the thing is that you can even balance your poll for how people voted in the last election.
00:10:53 What pollsters should be doing if they don't suck, if they're not nanos or ecos, is that they should be asking people, how did you vote in the last election?
00:11:02 And you generally want the mix of people to be accurate to how people voted in the last election, and then you want to see how that representative mix of people have changed how they plan to vote next time since the last election, with some people who didn't vote last time also mixed in to the population of the poll, because people who didn't vote last time may vote next time, you never know.
00:11:28 So, what we have been having over the last couple of months is probably liberals polling too high and conservatives polling too low.
00:11:37 I'm not denying the conservatives have been behind. I just don't think they were really behind by 16 points, even if I do think abacus data is a good pollster.
00:11:45 The problem that you fall into is that when liberals are excited because the prime minister, the liberal prime minister, has taken it to Donald Trump and taken swings and he's signing useless pieces of paper and meeting with foreign dignitaries, he's doing a good job.
00:12:01 So I'm excited to pick up the phone and tell you who I'm voting for. Whereas conservatives, when they lost some by-elections in August, and then the Trump thing with Carney happens and he's getting all this good press, you get a little bit depressed and you don't want to pick up the phone and tell the pollster who you're voting for.
00:12:19 Whether it's an online survey, IVR where you hit the buttons, or a live caller thing, you're not going to take the poll. At least a significant portion of conservatives won't take the poll. And what ends up happening is disproportionately the people who are willing to pick up the phone who voted conservative last time are the people who are telling you they're voting liberal next time.
00:12:39 Which means that, yes, the Liberals gained over those last couple of months, but they didn't gain 7-8% like some of the pollsters were showing it. They probably gained 4. 4 or 5 points, it's still a big bump, but it's not this massive bump like some other pollsters were showing, or pretty much all of them were.
00:12:58 And so that's the thing I think is still affecting this poll, and that's where I bring you to the Bloc Québécois. Do you feel like the Bloc Québécois have lost support from the last election?
00:13:12 Now, if you're watching my show, you're probably not a big Bloc Québécois supporter, even if you're in the province of Quebec. You're probably a conservative. They got 6% of the vote nationally in the last election. I think that works out to 27-28% in Quebec.
00:13:28 The Parti Quebecois, PSPP, Paul Saint-Pierre Palimondon, is now the Premier of Quebec, who leads the Parti Quebecois, a separatist party.
00:13:41 The Bloc Quebecois has like a one-to-one overlap, pretty much, with people who vote for the PQ provincially.
00:13:48 Now, they won like 32% of the vote provincially. It was a very cut-up election.
00:13:53 There was like five or six parties getting significant portions of the vote.
00:13:57 The Bloc Québécois can also win votes from the CAQ.
00:14:02 They didn't win any seats this last election.
00:14:04 They were in government, got absolutely demolished.
00:14:06 But they still got around like 11-12% of the vote.
00:14:09 And the Parti Québécois can also take votes from Quebec's Solidaire people,
00:14:14 who kind of swing between NDP and BQ, depending on their mood,
00:14:18 because even though the NDP federally is not a separatist party,
00:14:22 Solidaire, the orange-colored Socialist Party of Quebec,
00:14:25 they're actually Quebec separatists as well so they also might swing over to the BQ even though
00:14:32 their voters are probably a little mixed between the NDP and the BQ but this is my point like
00:14:37 they're not five percent guys it's probably just an overheated response over the last few months
00:14:43 for the liberals that suppressed both conservatives and Le Quebecois a little bit if I was to guess
00:14:49 Probably the Liberals are more at, like, 41% now, and the Conservatives are probably either still at 34%, maybe they're at 35%, maybe the NDP's a little lower.
00:15:00 But I think if we're, in reality, I think my prediction number for where the Bloc Québécois should be right now is at least at 7%.
00:15:08 I think they at least gained a little bit over the last year, since the last election, because, my goodness, most of the job losses in this country have been in Quebec.
00:15:22 It's been an absolute bloodbath for Quebec manufacturing and construction.
00:15:26 And you think the BQ are going down and the Liberals are going up?
00:15:31 Nah.
00:15:32 In this Angus Reid poll, in fact, the Conservatives and the Bloc are tied in Quebec.
00:15:38 No.
00:15:38 The Conservatives will always be third place in Quebec.
00:15:41 Unless, like, a big breakthrough happens and the Conservatives are about to sweep the entire country
00:15:46 and Quebec voters come along for the ride because they want their MP to be a Conservative,
00:15:52 they're always going to be third place.
00:15:54 The Bloc Quebecois fight the Liberals for second place.
00:15:57 23% in Quebec is way too low for the Bloc Quebecois,
00:16:01 especially in this very Quebec nationalistic environment where the Liberals have been screwing up on the Quebec economy massively.
00:16:11 So, where does this leave us?
00:16:14 I think what we're probably going to see across all pollsters, because Ipsos also shows a two-point swing between the Liberals and the Conservatives.
00:16:23 I think Research Co. also tightened up.
00:16:26 Nanos is showing the Conservatives going down again or only up slightly and the Liberals shooting up.
00:16:31 nanos's polling numbers never make any sense when when a pollster when it's objectively a bad news
00:16:38 cycle for the liberals it's so objectively bad liberals in the liberal media are admitting it's
00:16:42 been a bad couple of weeks and it's really been a bad couple of months they are saying it's been
00:16:47 bad and yet nanos shows the liberals at 49 of the vote right now and increasing no they're not
00:16:54 nick nanos just needs to go back to school and learn how to poll again the funny thing is nick
00:17:00 is a good pollster sometimes. Between elections, they go to a much cheaper rolling poll sort of
00:17:06 way of doing things where they poll 1,000 people, and that really means they poll a new 250 people
00:17:12 every few days, and they remove the oldest 250 sample and add in a new 250 sample. But those
00:17:18 samples are so tiny that oftentimes they're not even polling anyone from rural Saskatchewan.
00:17:23 There's nobody from rural New Brunswick. Nobody from rural Manitoba. And so you get these absurd
00:17:29 samples where the liberals are technically leading in the prairies that they have like a 15 point
00:17:35 lead in ontario it doesn't make any sense when a pollster is just defying the reality that we see
00:17:43 in terms of the national mood it's wrong i'm not saying the liberals aren't leading i am saying
00:17:48 they're still leading i'm saying their lead is dropping and when a pollster is just zigzagging
00:17:53 completely away from the national trend it's just bad ignore them turn the lights out you're done
00:18:01 you suck at your job at least they're usually good during the actual elections where they do
00:18:07 a rolling poll but it's a new thousand people every day or 500 people every day you cannot do 0.99
00:18:14 a rolling poll where you're pulling a school gymnasium of people every day and that's it
00:18:19 200 people every few days is so tiny, the margin of error in these polls is incredibly, incredibly high.
00:18:29 Anyways, but also what we ended up finding in this Angus Reid poll, same thing, actually wasn't the same thing with Abacus data,
00:18:37 but in the Angus Reid poll, we're seeing that both Carney and the Liberal government's overall approval rating has actually swung 6%,
00:18:45 with Carney's approval rating dipping 3% and disapproval jumping 3%, which usually tends to
00:18:52 happen one-to-one. If someone doesn't approve of you, they disapprove of you. Some people kind of
00:18:57 sit in neutral territory, but most people swing from one side to the other. And again, November
00:19:02 3rd to 6th, before much of the bad news actually started hitting. And when you look at the big
00:19:09 issues that people are naming, like in the Abacus data poll, we're seeing immigration in some polls
00:19:15 that would have only hit single digits jumping in to double digits. In the Angus Reid, I think
00:19:20 14% of people chose it as their top issue, which is pretty big. Usually people are only picking it
00:19:27 around 6% or 8%. And in the Abacus data poll, you can choose your top three issues. And usually
00:19:34 immigration sat in the mid-teens, 12%, 14%. It's now at 24% in their poll. And the issue of Donald
00:19:43 Trump administration is starting to fade. And that's a bad sign for the liberals because that
00:19:48 is their big issue. Even in Abagas Data's poll, where they still showed the liberals leading
00:19:53 nationally by 11%. So it's a pool of voters they're serving that are saying they will vote
00:19:59 liberal by 11% margin. Even that pool of voters, when you ask them who would be better at handling
00:20:06 the cost of living crisis in Canada, they actually choose the conservatives by a margin of 4%.
00:20:13 Of the people who pick cost of living as their top issue, which was 64% of the survey, within those two-thirds of Canadians, by a margin of four points, they actually trust the Conservatives more.
00:20:26 Now, if the Liberal lead in the abacus poll this next Sunday falls from 11 to like 7, you're probably going to have the cost of living issue not only rising and the Conservative margin of trust on that issue rising,
00:20:37 You're probably going to see immigration start to pull into the high 20s and Trump and his administration as a top issue falling into the 20s.
00:20:47 That is the liberal backstop. They need people to be scared of Trump to ignore all the crap. 0.99
00:20:52 But the liberals got arrogant, assuming that Trump was going to be their excuse forever. 0.99
00:20:57 They put out a dog's breakfast of a budget, an immigration plan that even the most moderate, scared to be called xenophobic voter hates.
00:21:07 They have the Stellantis scandal.
00:21:09 They are going to lose working class voters.
00:21:11 They are losing a lot of business liberals who think these guys are incompetent.
00:21:15 Mark Carney is cooking himself up an election defeat two years early,
00:21:20 and I don't think he actually has the wherewithal to pull out of it.
00:21:24 Even their housing promises, they've just been dropping them.
00:21:27 They've just been dropping them.
00:21:29 They're having conflict of interest scandals, hitting them left and right.
00:21:32 Where's the good news?
00:21:34 That's what I have to say, because right now, Carney is flying.
00:21:38 His approval rating, which is still positive, is mostly just on good vibes.
00:21:42 People thinking old Uncle Mark Carney is still looking out for you.
00:21:46 And that should scare them.
00:21:48 When you don't know why you're popular, you can't point to something you did,
00:21:52 you should think that you are sitting on a giant bubble that can pop,
00:21:56 and I think we are going to see it pop over the next year and a half.
00:22:00 When I say year and a half, you're thinking, oh my goodness, they're going to stay popular over the next year and a half.
00:22:05 I guess more so the next few months, we're going to see the Liberals go from just flying in the polls to leading the Conservatives maybe by two or three points, like on very uncomfortable lead.
00:22:16 And all the people who are calling for Pierre Polyev to be replaced, oh my goodness, the Liberals are leading.
00:22:22 That means we should put Mark Mulroney, we should put Jason Kenney, we should put, I don't know who Doug Ford in as federal conservative leader. No. Any conservative leader would have been trailing Mark Carney.
00:22:38 I just explained, Avi Lewis gets hit with negative approval ratings, not because of anything he did or said, it's simply because he's not Mark Carney. Because Carney is popular because he's not Donald Trump.
00:22:52 And if you're not Mark Carney, that means that you are somehow associated with Donald Trump or you are hurting Team Canada.
00:22:59 That is why those people, he is popular and other leaders are not.
00:23:04 But if he starts failing on the economy and Trump, after the U.S. midterm, starts fading as an issue in the forefront of people's minds,
00:23:12 you are going to see Carney and the liberals start to flounder because that's no longer a factor anymore for most voters.
00:23:19 I just want to quickly also, maybe I'll show this on the screens just so I don't have to write it down, but it's interesting to see just how significant the jump was in Angus Reid polling by Mark Carney fighting with Trump.
00:23:34 You see, this is his overall approval rating right now. He has an approval rating of 58%, disapproval rating of 34%. He dropped from 62 to 58. This is actually a 7-point swing. His approval rating fell from 62 to 58, losing 4 points, and disapproval went up 3 points. That's a lot.
00:23:56 But look at the national polling here below. Back in July 2026, the Angus Reid margin between
00:24:05 liberals and conservatives was only 4%. But look at their September poll and see how much
00:24:12 Carney walking away from the trade table with Donald Trump bumped liberal support and dropped
00:24:18 conservative support. This is the patriotism bomb that the liberals are always looking to
00:24:24 capitalize on they went from a four point lead over the conservatives to a 14 point lead and as
00:24:31 that fades as the kind of sugar rush comes off and a lot of the bad news sinks in they're now
00:24:37 back to nine so they went from four to 14 now back to nine and probably going to fall back to
00:24:45 around that four percent margin as a lot of these other issues start to cause the liberals to take
00:24:50 on some water again same thing is happening right now in abacus data they went from 16 to 11 even
00:24:57 in ipsos they went from like 13 till to 10 or something like that you are seeing the liberals
00:25:04 softening because there isn't anything below the surface except for the trump issue anyways so with
00:25:12 all that being said thank you guys for watching make sure to like share subscribe consider hitting
00:25:18 the join button, and I'll see you guys all later.