The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - September 24, 2025


Liberals in BIG trouble in new polls - Canadians regret not voting Conservative!

Hosted by
Mentioned
Pierre Poilievre demolishes Liberal Minister after secret tape comes out! Liberals trying to undermine Danielle Smith in Alberta! (Poll analysis)

Episode Stats


Length

19 minutes

Words per minute

165.09

Word count

3,242

Sentence count

156

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we look at how things have shifted in the polls over the past week and a half, and how the momentum has shifted from the Liberals to the Tories. We also look at the most recent numbers from Nanos and Angus Reid.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Ahoy everyone, Wyatt Claypool here, back yet again to talk about the current state of national polls in Canada.
00:00:08 We have just had Parliament reconvene, and like I had been predicting, by the time that Parliament was back into session,
00:00:16 Mark Carney and the Liberals were going to be past their honeymoon period.
00:00:20 It ended probably two or three months sooner than it would normally do for another government,
00:00:26 but the Liberal government has been making so many mistakes over the summer
00:00:31 that inevitably Canadians were going to stop having this artificial feeling of positivity
00:00:38 because, hey, it's a new government, let's give them a chance.
00:00:43 People are kind of past that, it doesn't mean that they are suffering in the polls and down 20 points like Justin Trudeau was,
00:00:50 but people are more realistically grading how they're doing these days,
00:00:54 and that's why we're seeing pollsters who lean heavily Liberal showing it get pretty close with the Conservatives,
00:01:02 as well as other pollsters showing the Conservatives taking the lead.
00:01:06 That's not just Abacus Data anymore, that is also the Angus Reid Institute
00:01:11 who has had now two polls in a row where the Conservatives are leading the Liberals.
00:01:17 But before I get into the Angus Reid numbers that I want to discuss,
00:01:21 I also want to talk about the Nanos numbers.
00:01:24 Now, I don't even like Nanos as a pollster.
00:01:27 I find their between-election methodology tends to be quite lazy,
00:01:32 which means their polls tend to lean quite heavily Liberal.
00:01:36 But even in a poll like that, you can still see a massive momentum shift
00:01:41 from the Liberals towards the Conservatives.
00:01:44 But before we get deeper into the numbers, guys, I just want to remind you,
00:01:49 hey, if you like this show, make sure to leave a like on this video,
00:01:53 subscribe to the channel if you want to see more videos like this,
00:01:57 and also leave a comment on what you think.
00:01:59 It helps us on the algorithm, and I do like scrolling through on my off time
00:02:03 and seeing what people say about what's going on.
00:02:06 But I want to go back to a few of the older Nanos polls
00:02:11 to show you guys how things have shifted.
00:02:14 So they actually tend to pull the most out of all the pollsters these days.
00:02:19 They will release new numbers every week or so,
00:02:22 or even sometimes, like twice a week, they will have new numbers out.
00:02:26 But I want to go back, not very far, but to August 5th.
00:02:32 August, actually not August, August 29th,
00:02:36 and then we're going to go to September 5th next.
00:02:38 But back on August 29th, what we ended up seeing in the polls back then
00:02:47 was we had Nanos showing the Liberals at 43% of the vote,
00:02:55 and we had the Conservatives all the way down at just 32%.
00:03:02 And then after that, once we get to September 5th,
00:03:07 saying it right this time,
00:03:09 we then had a little bit of a shift
00:03:12 to the Liberals still having 43% of the vote,
00:03:18 but the Conservatives went up to 33%.
00:03:24 Now, this is shortly after, or this is in the aftermath of the Air Canada fiasco.
00:03:30 But let's go a little bit further.
00:03:33 So now we're on September 12th,
00:03:37 and on September 12th, we have the Liberals falling 1.242%,
00:03:43 and the Conservatives jumping up to 35%.
00:03:48 So they've gained two, the Liberals have lost one.
00:03:52 And now, in the final day we will look at,
00:03:55 we will look at the most recent numbers,
00:03:57 which are on September 19th.
00:04:01 This is basically after a week of Parliament being back in session,
00:04:06 and now we have the Liberals falling an extra point down to 41%,
00:04:10 and the Conservatives now being at 36%.
00:04:16 Now, we're actually getting into more realistic numbers here from Nanos,
00:04:21 because previously they had been showing the Liberals leading by 15 points post-election,
00:04:28 13 points, 14 points.
00:04:30 Now, even here, they're still at 11.
00:04:32 So they went from plus 11 back here,
00:04:37 which is a very good lead for the Liberals, nationally speaking, of course,
00:04:42 and then we go to September 19th,
00:04:45 where now the Conservatives are only behind,
00:04:49 the Liberals are leading, by 5 points.
00:04:52 So since then, we have had more than half of the Liberal lead diminish,
00:04:58 and it's gone down by negative 6.
00:05:00 So naturally, the Conservatives are very happy with the big momentum shift that has happened,
00:05:06 and this is a result of the death of 1,000 cuts
00:05:10 that the Mark Carney Liberals are currently going through.
00:05:12 They can pull out of it.
00:05:14 Obviously, if they just start passing popular legislation,
00:05:18 if they actually start, you know, getting their act together,
00:05:20 as if that will ever happen, it could reverse.
00:05:23 Now, I don't think it's going to happen,
00:05:25 but they could kick out of this thing.
00:05:28 And, but, this is just Nanos.
00:05:31 Nanos, again, has a very liberal methodology between elections.
00:05:36 It's kind of a strange concept.
00:05:39 Nanos is actually a very good pollster during elections,
00:05:42 but between elections, they go to a cheaper form of polling
00:05:46 that means that they're more likely to get people living in urban areas.
00:05:50 If it's a live phone poll,
00:05:52 naturally, a farmer is not going to pick up the phone
00:05:54 and then sit through a five-minute survey.
00:05:57 They're just going to pick up the phone,
00:05:59 hear someone talking,
00:06:00 hey, would you like to take it,
00:06:01 and then they're just going to click.
00:06:02 It actually tends to be easier to get working-class people,
00:06:06 farmers, or more conservative types to take a poll
00:06:09 when it's one of those IVR polls where it's a robotic voice
00:06:12 and it lets you just hit your button and go within 30 seconds.
00:06:15 When it's a live phone poll,
00:06:17 they have to give you a lot more stipulations and whatnot,
00:06:19 so people click off.
00:06:21 And even with that methodology,
00:06:23 conservatives are not doing too bad,
00:06:25 at least compared to how they were doing
00:06:27 just less than a month ago from the 29th to the 19th.
00:06:33 Just 20 days ago, just 22 days ago or so,
00:06:36 the conservatives were getting murdered,
00:06:38 and now it's actually kind of competitive.
00:06:40 But now I want to jump over to the Angus Reid poll,
00:06:44 and I want to show you some of the regionals.
00:06:46 We haven't actually really done regionals on the show yet,
00:06:49 and I want to go over the bright spots currently
00:06:52 for the conservatives in the major regions
00:06:54 that they need to secure in order to win the next election.
00:06:58 Anyways, I'm going to clear the board,
00:06:59 and then we will be back in just a second.
00:07:04 And we're back.
00:07:06 Forgive me for the chart kind of angling up.
00:07:08 It's just the way that I positioned the board.
00:07:10 You'll get over it.
00:07:12 So this is the current national numbers for Angus Reid.
00:07:16 We have the conservatives leading by three points right now,
00:07:20 which is only up by one since the last time that they did a poll.
00:07:25 But still, generally speaking,
00:07:27 I think the conservatives will be happy with any lead right now,
00:07:31 considering how bad the polls were to them
00:07:33 just a couple of months ago.
00:07:36 Two months ago, we were maybe sitting with Abacus data,
00:07:39 showing you reasonably competitive numbers
00:07:42 where they were within two points.
00:07:43 And then the rest of the polls,
00:07:45 the conservatives were down five, down seven, down 14.
00:07:49 And now, again, like we just showed with Nanos,
00:07:52 they are only five behind a pollster
00:07:54 that used to say 14 or 15 behind,
00:07:57 which indeed is a big improvement.
00:08:00 But we will just go party to party here.
00:08:03 The liberals are currently sitting at 38%,
00:08:06 conservatives 41%, NDP 10%.
00:08:09 We have two for the Green Party,
00:08:12 and we have eight right now for the Bloc Quebecois.
00:08:17 And I do just want to quickly bring up
00:08:19 where this will put us for the seat count.
00:08:22 I'm specifically using Shrey Attiste,
00:08:24 who I will show on screen in just a second here.
00:08:27 I think he does a fantastic job
00:08:29 when it comes to polling analysis.
00:08:31 He does a lot of the seat projections.
00:08:33 And even though the guy is literally
00:08:35 just out of grade 11,
00:08:37 or I think he's just starting grade 11,
00:08:39 or he's just finished it,
00:08:41 now he's going into grade 12,
00:08:42 easily one of the most accurate people is him,
00:08:45 as well as the great Canadian bagel,
00:08:47 who are quite good.
00:08:49 So I'm using his analysis
00:08:50 because he was quite close
00:08:52 on the actual federal election.
00:08:54 As you can see him right there,
00:08:56 I will be plugging his account
00:08:57 in the description below.
00:08:59 So right now, we have the Conservatives
00:09:02 with 157 seats with this result.
00:09:07 The Liberals, let's just use Black 1.00
00:09:09 to make it easier not having to switch.
00:09:11 We have them with 137.
00:09:14 NDP would gain seats and be at 11.
00:09:17 The Green Party would have two seats,
00:09:19 which is a gain of one.
00:09:21 And the Bloc Quebecois would be at 36 seats,
00:09:25 which actually would be a gain of 14 for them.
00:09:28 This would be a loss.
00:09:30 Let's make sure I'm still writing this on screen.
00:09:32 Oh, it wouldn't be.
00:09:33 That would be, for the Liberals,
00:09:36 a loss of actually 32 seats there.
00:09:42 Now, the big area that the Liberals
00:09:45 are losing support in the fastest,
00:09:47 not that hard to guess,
00:09:49 it is the province of Ontario.
00:09:52 Now, if you actually remember back
00:09:54 during the federal election,
00:09:55 it wasn't like this was a big victory
00:09:58 for the Liberals,
00:09:59 where they blew out the Conservatives,
00:10:01 but they were just a vote or two short
00:10:03 of a majority.
00:10:04 They were close to a majority,
00:10:06 no doubt about that,
00:10:07 but they were actually very close
00:10:09 in all the ridings that they won
00:10:11 in order to secure a minority government.
00:10:14 In fact, the Conservatives
00:10:15 were only 82 votes behind
00:10:17 getting a minority government themselves,
00:10:21 82 votes within the closest ridings.
00:10:23 You took the margin of difference
00:10:25 between the Liberals and Conservatives,
00:10:27 where the Conservatives would need
00:10:29 to win for a minority government.
00:10:30 It was only 8,200 votes collectively,
00:10:33 which is at least super, super tight.
00:10:36 And even then,
00:10:37 they only ended up winning
00:10:38 an extra seat from the bloc
00:10:40 because terrible,
00:10:41 they just decided,
00:10:42 who cares about election integrity?
00:10:44 Yeah, the Liberal won by one vote
00:10:46 because elections can't have messed up
00:10:47 massively with mail-in ballots,
00:10:49 but, you know,
00:10:50 what's a bit of incompetence
00:10:52 between friends that happens
00:10:53 to get the Liberals the seat.
00:10:55 So in just a second here,
00:10:56 I'm going to clear the board again,
00:10:57 and then we will be back
00:10:58 talking about how the Conservatives
00:11:01 and Liberals are faring right now
00:11:03 in the province of Ontario.
00:11:04 Obviously, I will also be adding
00:11:06 in the NDP as well,
00:11:08 but I will see you guys back
00:11:09 in just a second.
00:11:12 Okay, so we're back once again,
00:11:14 and now I want to break down
00:11:16 the current Angus Reid numbers
00:11:18 for the province of Ontario
00:11:19 compared to the percentages of the vote
00:11:22 that we saw in the April general election.
00:11:26 So right now,
00:11:27 in the Angus Reid poll,
00:11:29 we'll start off with that one.
00:11:31 We had the Conservatives running with,
00:11:34 we now have the Conservatives behind,
00:11:37 but catching up,
00:11:38 with the Liberals having 44% of the vote
00:11:42 and the Conservatives having 42%.
00:11:47 Now, naturally,
00:11:49 one would maybe assume
00:11:50 a plus two Liberal victory
00:11:52 in the province of Ontario
00:11:54 would generally mean like,
00:11:56 okay, well,
00:11:57 can the Conservatives even win
00:11:58 the biggest province
00:11:59 the Liberals are leading?
00:12:01 The problem, though,
00:12:02 is obviously,
00:12:03 for a Liberal party to win,
00:12:05 it really needs to run up the score
00:12:07 in large, populous urban areas
00:12:10 like Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver.
00:12:13 You get the picture.
00:12:15 And the thing is,
00:12:15 when it's that tight,
00:12:16 this is basically saying
00:12:17 the only thing the Liberals
00:12:19 are really winning is Toronto.
00:12:20 This would be the Conservatives
00:12:22 getting into other areas of the GTA.
00:12:25 And to benchmark this thing a little bit,
00:12:27 we currently have also the NDP
00:12:30 with 10% in Ontario
00:12:33 in this Angus Reid poll.
00:12:36 And so with all that,
00:12:37 I want to now show you
00:12:39 the 2025 results
00:12:41 on the other side here
00:12:43 because the Liberal win in 2025
00:12:46 was far bigger than this.
00:12:48 In the election in April,
00:12:51 we had the Liberals getting 49% of the vote
00:12:55 and we had the Conservatives
00:12:57 getting 43.8%.
00:13:02 Now, the Conservatives
00:13:04 are still doing better
00:13:05 in the last election
00:13:06 than they are doing in this poll,
00:13:08 but all the numbers
00:13:09 are always relative.
00:13:11 Are you beating the other parties
00:13:12 is really the thing
00:13:13 that you want to see.
00:13:15 And in the election,
00:13:16 back in April,
00:13:17 we effectively saw,
00:13:19 we actually literally saw,
00:13:21 the Liberals win
00:13:22 by, what is this,
00:13:24 5.2%.
00:13:26 They have a 5.2% win
00:13:28 and now it's down
00:13:29 to a 2% victory.
00:13:31 And a big problem as well
00:13:33 is in Ontario,
00:13:35 the NDP in the general election
00:13:38 had only gotten 4.9%.
00:13:42 So them doubling their vote
00:13:44 immediately puts the NDP
00:13:45 back into play
00:13:47 in many of the ridings
00:13:48 that they had lost
00:13:49 to the Liberals.
00:13:51 Not to the Conservatives.
00:13:52 I believe with this,
00:13:54 the Liberals would,
00:13:55 or the Conservatives
00:13:55 would still be holding
00:13:57 onto ridings
00:13:57 like Hamilton East,
00:13:59 like the Windsor ridings
00:14:00 because their vote
00:14:01 is pretty much stable.
00:14:03 The one that is falling here
00:14:04 is the Liberals.
00:14:06 They effectively fall
00:14:07 by five points
00:14:08 and surprise, surprise,
00:14:09 we see the NDP
00:14:10 gain five points.
00:14:12 So what we,
00:14:13 and this is probably
00:14:14 a direct result
00:14:15 of what we've seen
00:14:16 with the Air Canada fiasco.
00:14:19 The Liberals
00:14:19 with their newly required
00:14:21 public sector union base
00:14:23 because of Jagmeet Singh's
00:14:24 competence have now
00:14:25 ticked those same people off
00:14:27 who decided to switch
00:14:28 from Singh's NDP
00:14:29 to the Federal Conservatives
00:14:30 under Carney.
00:14:31 And now those people
00:14:33 are going to go
00:14:33 from Carney's Liberals
00:14:35 back to Don Davies' NDP.
00:14:37 And they haven't had
00:14:38 these voters for very long.
00:14:40 It wasn't like
00:14:40 there was a loyalty
00:14:41 being built up
00:14:42 and, you know,
00:14:43 maybe they'll still
00:14:43 go vote Liberal.
00:14:45 They were giving
00:14:45 the Liberals a chance
00:14:47 and then the Liberals
00:14:48 immediately slapped them
00:14:48 on the nose
00:14:49 and they were off
00:14:50 back to their old party.
00:14:51 So yes,
00:14:52 this is a very bad thing
00:14:54 right now
00:14:54 for the Liberals.
00:14:56 And in other provinces,
00:14:58 the story is the same.
00:15:00 I'm just going to bring
00:15:00 this up on screen
00:15:01 so you can get
00:15:02 the context
00:15:03 I'm working with here.
00:15:05 I'm not going to write
00:15:06 anything else
00:15:07 on the board,
00:15:08 but right now
00:15:08 this Angus Reid poll
00:15:09 shows a lead
00:15:11 for the Conservatives
00:15:12 of 8%
00:15:13 or that's very 6%
00:15:15 in British Columbia.
00:15:17 Now,
00:15:18 in the actual election,
00:15:19 the Conservatives
00:15:20 actually lost
00:15:20 by 0.8%
00:15:21 to the Liberals.
00:15:22 It ended 41%
00:15:23 for the Conservatives,
00:15:25 41.8%
00:15:26 for the Liberals,
00:15:27 and the NDP
00:15:28 got 13%.
00:15:29 So now,
00:15:31 again,
00:15:31 we see the Conservatives
00:15:33 effectively maintaining
00:15:34 their support.
00:15:35 They gained one point
00:15:36 since the election
00:15:36 and the NDP
00:15:38 ends up gaining
00:15:39 three points
00:15:40 and the Liberals
00:15:40 end up losing
00:15:41 to both of those parties.
00:15:43 They lost a point
00:15:44 to the Conservatives
00:15:45 and then they lost
00:15:46 three more points
00:15:47 to the NDP
00:15:48 and one as well
00:15:50 to the Greens.
00:15:51 So,
00:15:52 all around,
00:15:53 this is quite good
00:15:53 for the Conservatives.
00:15:55 Let's find another one here.
00:15:58 Out in Atlantic Canada,
00:16:01 we have the Conservatives
00:16:03 here.
00:16:03 This actually may be
00:16:04 a bit of an underpull
00:16:05 for them
00:16:05 just because it's hard to...
00:16:07 Oh yeah,
00:16:07 we can't really do this one
00:16:08 because they don't do
00:16:09 a conglomeration
00:16:10 of Atlantic Canada
00:16:12 within the Wikipedia page
00:16:13 for the results,
00:16:15 but that's what
00:16:15 we have to work with.
00:16:16 In general though,
00:16:18 Conservatives maintaining,
00:16:20 Liberals are losing
00:16:21 and they're losing
00:16:21 to their left's flank.
00:16:23 Now,
00:16:24 it'd be great
00:16:24 if the Conservatives
00:16:25 were taking votes
00:16:26 away from the Liberals
00:16:27 and expanding their lead
00:16:28 that way
00:16:29 because it's a bigger swing,
00:16:31 but if the Liberals
00:16:32 are bleeding out,
00:16:33 I think Pierre Polyev
00:16:33 and the Conservatives
00:16:34 are going to be
00:16:35 completely satisfied
00:16:37 with that.
00:16:38 And again,
00:16:38 we look at the news cycle
00:16:39 and this is why polling
00:16:41 is actually something
00:16:42 good to look into.
00:16:43 I know a lot of people
00:16:44 are saying,
00:16:44 well,
00:16:44 we're three years away
00:16:45 from the election,
00:16:46 who cares?
00:16:46 Some pollsters are off,
00:16:47 like I don't trust
00:16:48 Nanos' numbers
00:16:49 and neither do I.
00:16:51 I don't trust Nanos' numbers,
00:16:52 you shouldn't either,
00:16:53 but I can still look
00:16:54 at their polls
00:16:55 to see that even
00:16:56 a very liberal
00:16:57 leading pollster
00:16:58 is showing a momentum
00:16:59 shift to the other side.
00:17:02 And what this also teaches you
00:17:03 is when things happen
00:17:05 in Canadian politics,
00:17:06 where are people moving?
00:17:07 Who's reacting?
00:17:09 So if you were ever
00:17:10 running a campaign
00:17:10 or you were trying
00:17:12 to basically figure out
00:17:13 something that happens
00:17:16 and you're trying to figure
00:17:17 out what the effect
00:17:17 is going to be,
00:17:18 we're starting
00:17:18 to notice patterns.
00:17:20 More labor strikes
00:17:21 are going to see
00:17:22 bigger transfers
00:17:22 back towards the NDP.
00:17:24 We have deficit spending,
00:17:26 we have a lot of issues
00:17:28 around the budget
00:17:29 not being put out.
00:17:30 You're probably going
00:17:31 to see a minor move
00:17:32 towards the conservatives
00:17:35 in the national numbers.
00:17:37 And so right now,
00:17:38 Mark Carney,
00:17:39 with frankly no real
00:17:41 big policy wins
00:17:42 on the horizon,
00:17:43 is going to probably
00:17:44 be turtling up
00:17:45 and not wanting
00:17:46 a new election
00:17:46 anytime soon.
00:17:48 And I think the election
00:17:49 at this point
00:17:49 kind of rests on
00:17:50 who ends up becoming
00:17:51 the federal NDP leader.
00:17:53 Because the Bloc Québécois
00:17:55 and the NDP
00:17:56 are greatly incentivized
00:17:58 to want to actually
00:18:00 gain seats like we saw
00:18:01 in that seat projection
00:18:02 from Sheree Attiste.
00:18:04 I think if Heather McPherson
00:18:05 becomes the new NDP leader,
00:18:07 she will call an election
00:18:08 if she smells blood
00:18:09 in the water.
00:18:10 And I think that's
00:18:11 pretty much the same
00:18:12 with Yves-Francois Blanchet
00:18:13 leading the Bloc Québécois.
00:18:15 Both parties,
00:18:16 really any political party's
00:18:18 job is to gain power.
00:18:20 It doesn't matter
00:18:21 if the conservatives
00:18:22 gain government,
00:18:23 it doesn't matter
00:18:23 if the liberals
00:18:24 keep government,
00:18:25 you want an election
00:18:25 whenever it allows you
00:18:27 to take your seven seats
00:18:28 as the NDP
00:18:28 and turn it into 24.
00:18:30 To take your,
00:18:31 I think it's 24 seats
00:18:32 right now as the Bloc 0.65
00:18:33 and turn it into 34.
00:18:35 You are only ever
00:18:37 trying to make
00:18:37 your party
00:18:38 bigger in parliament.
00:18:40 If you try
00:18:41 and do politics
00:18:41 for any other reason,
00:18:43 you will lose.
00:18:44 It doesn't matter
00:18:44 if you're a small party
00:18:45 or a big party,
00:18:46 you do things
00:18:47 to gain seats.
00:18:49 Obviously,
00:18:49 I'd hope
00:18:50 if you're conservative,
00:18:51 you're doing
00:18:51 principled things,
00:18:53 but naturally,
00:18:54 the sort of
00:18:54 tug-of-war
00:18:55 inside parties
00:18:56 is doing the thing
00:18:57 that may get you a seat
00:18:58 or doing the harder thing
00:18:59 that may not get you a seat,
00:19:01 but it's what pleases
00:19:01 your base.
00:19:02 The good thing,
00:19:03 though,
00:19:03 is I find
00:19:04 it tends to be
00:19:04 the things that
00:19:05 please your base
00:19:06 that also gets you
00:19:06 more seats,
00:19:07 but you'll always
00:19:08 have strategists out there
00:19:09 who can convince
00:19:10 themselves of the opposite
00:19:11 as if your party exists
00:19:13 not to actually fulfill
00:19:14 the things the base wants,
00:19:16 but to betray the base
00:19:17 and try and find weird
00:19:18 in-between voters
00:19:19 who don't like the liberals
00:19:20 or conservatives,
00:19:21 but if you water yourself
00:19:22 down enough,
00:19:23 then they may cast
00:19:23 a ballot for you.
00:19:24 Never chase those people.
00:19:26 They are not worth it.
00:19:27 Anyways,
00:19:28 so that should be it
00:19:29 for this video, guys.
00:19:30 Thank you for watching
00:19:31 and tuning back
00:19:32 into me,
00:19:33 Wyatt Claypool,
00:19:34 rambling about the numbers.
00:19:36 I will see you guys
00:19:37 all next time.