The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - February 27, 2025


Mark Carney got caught in HUGE LIE about his Brookfield company!

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Liberal debate was AWFUL and proves Conservatives will win in 2025! Polls, Liberal leadership, and Ontario Election

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

165.93

Word count

2,836

Sentence count

172

Harmful content

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Brookfield Asset Management has moved their HQ out of Canada to Trump's hometown of New York City. Mark Carney claimed that the decision was made after he resigned from the board, knowing that he was running for the Liberal Party Leadership. Now, Conservative MP Michael Barrett has called that out as a complete lie.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 It's a day ending in Y, so Mark Carney's liberal leadership campaign has another scandal on its hands, this time regarding the company that Mark Carney sat on the board of for many years, Brookfield Asset Management.
00:00:14 This is a company that recently had moved its headquarters from Toronto to New York City, but it totally didn't have anything to do with Mark Carney. He claimed that this all happened after he resigned from the board, knowing that he may run for the Liberal Party leadership and become the next Prime Minister of Canada.
00:00:36 Well, Michael Barrett, the Conservative MP, has basically showed that this is complete nonsense. He says,
00:00:44 Breaking, Carney lied. Carney was chair of Brookfield board when they unanimously voted to move their headquarters out of Canada to New York City, Trump's hometown.
00:00:55 Here's a letter he wrote to shareholders urging them to approve the move on December 1st, 2024. Mark Carney can't be trusted. If Carney wins, Canada loses.
00:01:04 What's so funny about the December 1st date as well is I guarantee you by this point he knows that Justin Trudeau has a very good chance of being replaced as the leader and he is going to run for it.
00:01:18 If he had advised this back in 2019, 2020, 2021, maybe I would get it. He didn't have many close associations with Trudeau government at this point. He had just started advising them.
00:01:31 He doesn't look bad because he's identifying that the Canadian economy is bad and he's going to move his company's board to a different jurisdiction.
00:01:42 This is four years, more than four years, into him advising Justin Trudeau on Canada's economy.
00:01:48 He realizes that he's made things worse and now he's going to take Brookfield Asset Management from Toronto to New York City.
00:01:56 I'm going to read the parts of this letter that have been highlighted in just a second.
00:02:00 Then I want to cut to what Mr. Poliev has said as well as Michael Barrett in a press conference this morning.
00:02:07 But before I get into it, guys, remember to like this video, subscribe to the channel, leave a comment.
00:02:13 Do you think Mark Carney is actually going to be able to win the Liberal Party leadership race at this rate?
00:02:18 And how do you think this is going to actually play with the average Canadian?
00:02:23 I think there is a chance that maybe this is a very complicated issue and a lot of Canadians don't really want to hear about it.
00:02:28 But I think most people are going to look at this and say, this guy's like Michael Ignatieff on steroids.
00:02:35 He lived in London for a long time and then he moved his company to the US. 0.98
00:02:40 Complete hypocrite and moved his company recently.
00:02:42 Anyways, reading the highlighted sections here for you guys. 0.96
00:02:48 First, it reads,
00:02:49 We believe, however, remember, this is Mark Carney writing this.
00:02:53 It's signed Mark Carney.
00:02:55 We believe, however, that there is more we can do to broaden our shareholder base and gain access to the deepest pool of capital.
00:03:02 The most common feedback that we hear from investors encourage us to position Brookfield Asset Management for inclusion in some of the most widely followed global large cap stock indices, including the US.
00:03:18 And then it goes on to say later.
00:03:20 The board, based on, among the other things, the recommendations of the GNCC unanimously determined that the arrangement is in the best interest of BAM and unanimously approve the arrangement.
00:03:36 Accordingly, the board unanimously recommends that shareholders vote for the arrangement resolution at the meeting.
00:03:43 So, Mark Carney isn't just the man penning this letter.
00:03:49 I've been messing up a few words.
00:03:50 I'm deeply sorry, people.
00:03:52 He's not just the one penning this letter telling shareholders that the board voted in favor.
00:03:57 He is saying that the board voted unanimously in favor of it, which means he voted in favor of this.
00:04:03 You cannot run away from this at all.
00:04:06 This is legitimately less than a couple of months ago.
00:04:11 This is December 1st.
00:04:12 You really can't pretend like this isn't really what you believe.
00:04:17 Oh, well, of course I believe in Canada's economy, but, you know, I had done this four or five years ago.
00:04:22 This happened, like, last week.
00:04:24 And right when he knows he's probably going to be running for leader, he's been running a shadow campaign to become leader for about a year now.
00:04:32 Just bringing up this post by Mr.
00:04:36 Pierre Pauly of the leader of the Federal Conservatives.
00:04:39 He, in response to Michael Barrett, had said, Mark Carney said he had nothing to do with Brookfield moving their HQ out of Canada to Trump's hometown of New York City.
00:04:48 Documents show he chaired the board meeting that unanimously determined the move, taking jobs away from Canadians.
00:04:54 His name is on the letter urging shareholders to approve the move.
00:04:58 Why did Mark Carney lie about this decision to sell out Canadian jobs?
00:05:02 And the thing is, normally I would say, hey, if the Canadian economy isn't good for your company or you have better opportunities elsewhere, I can't tell you not to stay.
00:05:12 I can't tell you to stay.
00:05:12 But you can't be Mark Carney and be this kind of raw, raw Canadian guy who is demonizing Donald Trump in the United States and then move to the United States where the economy is far better.
00:05:26 Anyways, here is Michael Barrett today presenting this evidence in Parliament.
00:05:30 Not in Parliament, obviously.
00:05:32 It's still an obsession.
00:05:33 But, you know, in the parliamentary halls.
00:05:35 Last night, Mark Carney lied to Canadians.
00:05:38 He lied to Canadians, saying that his company, Brookfield Asset Management, only moved their headquarters from Canada to Donald Trump's hometown of New York City after he had resigned from the board.
00:05:55 We all know that Brookfield made that announcement on October the 31st, proving that Mr. Carney was lying to Canadians.
00:06:06 But this morning, we can share with you a letter signed by Mark Carney on December the 1st.
00:06:17 Now, this is days after, just days after Donald Trump had threatened Canada for the first time with unjustified tariffs.
00:06:25 Now, this letter says that the decision by the board, of which Mark Carney at that time was chair, was unanimous to move the headquarters and Canadian jobs to Donald Trump's hometown of New York City.
00:06:43 And the letter implores shareholders, urges them to support the move.
00:06:49 And I think this is going to be one of the biggest hits on Mark Carney going into a federal election if he does become the leader of the Liberal Party.
00:06:58 And again, that's not even a done deal.
00:07:00 I'll show you the poll result here if you haven't seen it yet for the latest Main Street poll that they did only of Liberal members.
00:07:07 Because he's leading, definitely, but this is before the debates where he kind of looked really lackluster.
00:07:14 And in this poll, he's not doing so hot.
00:07:17 And I guarantee Karina Gould and Bayless are going to be getting a bump out of this.
00:07:20 And they can maybe horse trade with Freeland to make her the leader instead.
00:07:24 But I think a lot of Canadians are going to get the impression of Carney that the man's kind of a weasel.
00:07:30 He's the guy who will say whatever he needs to in the meeting he's currently in to get through it.
00:07:36 But he doesn't really have the integrity, to be honest, today and tomorrow.
00:07:41 It depends on what's beneficial today.
00:07:43 Here is the current polling right now.
00:07:46 We have Mark Carney at 43%.
00:07:48 It's a substantial lead.
00:07:51 Nobody's saying he's not leading.
00:07:52 But he has Freeland at 31% behind him, 12% behind.
00:07:57 Karina Gould's at 16%.
00:07:58 Bayless is at 3% and undecideds are at 7%.
00:08:01 Naturally, there's much fewer undecideds in leadership races compared to other elections
00:08:07 because the members tended to have signed up through one of the candidates.
00:08:10 And they're more likely to stay loyal to them than switch.
00:08:14 But I think after the very weak French performance of Carney and just a boring who cares performance in English from Carney,
00:08:22 there's a lot of people who could subtly shift away. 0.54
00:08:25 I think that guy needs to win or become extremely close to winning on first ballot or he's so screwed.
00:08:32 Even if he wins, if it's a third ballot win, if he has to go to the end or he only barely scrapes it out after two ballots,
00:08:41 that's going to be a big indicator that the man doesn't have any staying power.
00:08:45 And I've said it before, when polls are showing the liberals suddenly leaping ahead of the conservatives off of the back of this very low energy liberal leadership race,
00:08:53 I think pollsters just need to check their methodologies again.
00:08:57 I'm going to have a video on polling out tomorrow because Abacus Data is releasing a poll tomorrow.
00:09:02 And I think they tend to be one of the more accurate ones.
00:09:05 So I'd like to see what they're going to say.
00:09:06 But a lot of these pollsters, they're saying that, well, if we say Mark Carney is the leader, the liberals are ahead by three points.
00:09:14 Really? You're going to be ahead if Mark Carney is the leader?
00:09:19 Carney doesn't even have 50% name recognition in Canada.
00:09:22 There are actors who do CBC shows who have higher name recognition than Mark Carney.
00:09:30 I think this is just a massive response bias.
00:09:32 I can even bring it up now and I'll probably do it tomorrow as well.
00:09:36 I thought Innovation Research's poll of Canada was great.
00:09:41 And I'm not just saying this because they had the conservatives ahead.
00:09:43 That doesn't benefit me at all to lie about where the conservatives are at.
00:09:48 Because like the numbers are going to be the numbers on election day.
00:09:50 And, you know, I don't want to destroy my reputation by saying, oh, no, the conservatives are like 70 points ahead.
00:09:56 And then they lose by five. 1.00
00:09:57 And I look like an idiot. 0.99
00:09:59 I'm only going to say what I actually think is going on in the polling. 0.99
00:10:03 And Innovation Research does a really good job of balancing the type of voter.
00:10:08 So their latest poll had the liberals at 27 percent and the conservatives at 40, a 13 percent lead for the conservatives,
00:10:15 which I think maybe their lead could be a little smaller than that.
00:10:19 But I think that you're not going to push the conservatives below 40 percent in this election cycle.
00:10:23 I also don't think the People's Party is going to be getting 3 percent.
00:10:27 I think they're going to shrink back to what they were at in 2019, 1.7, 1.9 percent.
00:10:32 And the conservatives are probably going to eat up more of that percentage.
00:10:36 So but this 13 percent lead makes sense when you look at the types of voters that they poll.
00:10:44 I love that Innovation Research does this because when they do personality tests on voters and ask them some fundamental political value questions,
00:10:55 it makes it so that they know that they haven't overpolled a type of person because people may change how they vote,
00:11:02 but their political personalities tend to change far slower over time.
00:11:07 So as you see here, we have like six different categories.
00:11:11 Hey, as you go, moderates, which are moderates, very subject to changing based on the performance of the current government.
00:11:17 We have populist conservatives, more right wing voters, deferential conservatives, a little bit more of like a red Tory.
00:11:26 That's more of I guess a business liberal is a red Tory, but deferential conservatives, generally pretty orthodox.
00:11:32 But, you know, I think I believe if I've looked up the definition, less populist, more like neoconservative type conservatives,
00:11:42 business liberals, more red Tory-ish people who can go between the liberals and conservatives, election to election, left liberals and core left.
00:11:51 The difference between business liberals and pay-as-you-go moderates is moderates could go to NDP, they could go liberal, they could go conservative, they could go green.
00:11:59 I mean, business liberals are going to mostly flip-flop between conservatives and liberals.
00:12:04 And so look at this.
00:12:06 And I think that this is a great way of making sure that you're not over-polling people,
00:12:10 because suddenly if your core left or your left liberal population in your poll suddenly spikes to 27%,
00:12:17 you know you probably over-polled a specific type of voter.
00:12:22 You probably pulled a Starbucks lineup too much.
00:12:24 And so this is what is leading me to think, that the conservatives' lead is going to be more steady than people think.
00:12:32 And I've already talked about this in another video, but look at this.
00:12:36 Business liberals in December 2024, before Trudeau stepped down, are at 43% conservative.
00:12:42 They are going to vote 43% conservative, 27% liberal, 15% NDP.
00:12:48 Makes sense.
00:12:49 These people are going to be far more risk-averse on the economy, so they're not going to be voting NDP much.
00:12:55 And now jump forward to the third week of February, when they just released their last poll.
00:12:59 The conservatives have contracted by five points, and the liberals have gained five points.
00:13:04 Now that makes sense with people like Mark Carney writing that a business liberal would probably be more in the know of who Mark Carney is,
00:13:11 and they may be willing to come back, especially if they're more socially progressive.
00:13:15 They tend to be more default liberal business liberals, that they might be coming back.
00:13:21 The thing is, most business liberals are staying.
00:13:23 It's a pretty rigid stat.
00:13:25 The main area that the liberals have increased with is the core left and the left liberals.
00:13:33 They've gone from 29% with the core left to 37%, and they've gone from 24% with left liberals to 29%.
00:13:39 But you know what I mean.
00:13:42 The main group that's going to be rigid, that's going to be really hard to win back, and I don't think they're coming back, are business liberals.
00:13:50 They may consider voting liberal most elections, but after three election cycles with a government that's terrible on finances,
00:13:57 these people are not going to be won back by some scare ads on abortion.
00:14:01 They're not going to be won back by saying that Polyevs like Trump.
00:14:05 Frankly, some of these people like Trump.
00:14:07 Some of these people like Trump just the way, in the same exact way that Mark Carney seems to like Trump,
00:14:13 because he's trying to go to the U.S., because he realizes Trump's economy is more stable.
00:14:17 And so he's leaving the Trudeau economy he's been advising on to go over to the U.S.
00:14:23 Brookfield Asset Management shareholders are going to be voting conservative.
00:14:26 But let's be very clear.
00:14:28 Anyways, so that's it for me today, guys.
00:14:31 Remember to like, share, and subscribe.
00:14:34 Definitely subscribe if you want to see my video tomorrow going over the Abacus data poll.
00:14:39 Maybe I'll even break down this innovation research poll in more detail.
00:14:43 I think I really love the way that they do polling.
00:14:45 Again, because it makes it so that you know that there has been a response bias.
00:14:51 People are not going to go from identifying themselves as business liberals to hardcore leftists overnight.
00:14:58 People tend to be very rigid with what they consider themselves, but they will vote different ways.
00:15:04 I've door-knocked thousands of doors in my life.
00:15:07 I know that there are a lot of people who love to call themselves centrists.
00:15:11 A lot of people call themselves centrists, they consider themselves moderate,
00:15:14 but that doesn't mean they're not going to vote conservative.
00:15:16 That just means that that is their kind of conception of politics.
00:15:19 They like balance, they don't want too much radical change,
00:15:23 but they might vote for somebody who is pursuing heavy reform if things get bad enough.
00:15:29 And that's where the personality thing comes into play.
00:15:31 I can even see why the core left has some people voting conservative.
00:15:35 They may conceptualize themselves as being very concerned about equality or even equity, all that stuff, 0.89
00:15:43 but they think the liberals are corrupt, they hate the liberals,
00:15:46 and so 10%, 14% of them may cast a ballot for the conservatives simply to get rid of the liberals.
00:15:54 That is absolutely a voter that exists.
00:15:56 There are right-wing populists who may even vote NDP because in their riding,
00:16:02 it might be a liberal that is currently in the seat,
00:16:05 and at least they can vote for the maybe more pro-worker type NDP MP,
00:16:11 even if they don't really like them, maybe their local guy isn't too bad,
00:16:15 and he's better than the very corporate, corrupt liberal.
00:16:19 Because populists tend to actually go a little bit back and forth
00:16:22 between being more lefty on economics and more righty,
00:16:25 so that populist desire to somewhat even vote for the NDP sometimes somewhat makes sense.
00:16:32 Anyways, so that's it for me today, guys.
00:16:35 See you later.
00:16:35 See you later.