The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - March 03, 2026


Pierre CORNERS Carney! Makes Carney a "unity" offer he cannot accept


Episode Stats

Length

21 minutes

Words per Minute

188.61247

Word Count

4,122

Sentence Count

233


Summary


Transcript

00:00:00.000 Hey guys, Wyatt Claypool here, and welcome back to the National Telegraph YouTube channel.
00:00:06.020 I'm happy to see Pierre Polyev and the Conservative Party regain their footing that they had lost over the past couple of months
00:00:12.420 and are refining their messaging against Mark Carney's liberals
00:00:15.800 and being far more focused on the failures of the Carney government and what they should be doing instead.
00:00:22.700 I think the secret sauce that Polyev had been missing for a while
00:00:25.980 was he wasn't giving his own suggestions for what Carney should be doing.
00:00:31.080 It's not enough just to say the current government is failing,
00:00:34.220 because that doesn't mean people should then trust you to solve the problems.
00:00:37.780 You actually have to suggest what you would do differently,
00:00:41.360 and I know a lot of parties never want to give the other side advice.
00:00:45.420 I sometimes give the liberals advice on my show, and I'll have tons of comments saying,
00:00:49.500 don't tell them what to do, that would be a smart thing to do, never say that.
00:00:52.820 They'll never take the advice from a Conservative.
00:00:54.880 So it's actually smart for the Conservatives to give Carney as much advice as humanly possible,
00:01:00.880 because they are far too insecure to take it.
00:01:03.400 And then it allows the Canadian public to imagine how much better things would be
00:01:07.960 if the Conservatives were in charge than the Liberals,
00:01:11.080 and they'll actually be quite mad at the Liberals for not taking the good ideas,
00:01:16.100 and they will be forced to unelect the Liberals and put the Conservatives in.
00:01:19.740 But in just a second here, I want to take you guys in to a podcast appearance
00:01:24.580 that Polyev did on Peter Mansbridge's podcast.
00:01:28.060 Peter Mansbridge, of course, used to be the host of CBC The National.
00:01:32.460 He is very liberal, and I think Polyev's performance on this podcast was quite good.
00:01:37.640 But before we get into it, I just want to mention to you guys,
00:01:40.740 first, if you like the channel, make sure to leave a like on this video,
00:01:44.980 subscribe if you're not yet a subscriber,
00:01:47.080 leave a comment on what you think about all this,
00:01:49.440 and hit the join button below the video if you want to become a channel member
00:01:53.020 and help support the channel, make it more sustainable for me,
00:01:55.980 and allow me to be less reliant on the YouTube algorithm for monthly income.
00:02:00.960 And then I also just quickly want to mention
00:02:02.880 that I will be going to a 1BC event in Nanaimo tonight.
00:02:07.040 This is kind of a short notice, little last reminder if you guys want to show up.
00:02:11.720 It's going to be probably already quite a packed house,
00:02:14.600 but I'll be going to Nanaimo with Dallas Brody and the 1BC team around,
00:02:19.400 I think it's 6 or 7.
00:02:20.480 I'll link the event in the description below if you guys still want to show up
00:02:23.780 and say hi and all that stuff.
00:02:25.960 Hopefully we don't hit fire code,
00:02:27.440 and I'm not baiting you guys out to showing up to an event
00:02:29.920 that you're not allowed to even be in.
00:02:31.980 We'll figure it out.
00:02:32.580 Don't drive from far away.
00:02:33.640 Do not drive farther than from Parksville, I guess I would say.
00:02:36.320 Either if you're in Nanaimo or Parksville, show up.
00:02:39.220 Don't drive from Comox.
00:02:40.900 Anyways, so here we have the Bridge podcast with Pierre Polyev and Peter Mansbridge.
00:02:47.000 This clip is on specifically the failure of Mark Carney
00:02:50.700 to get a deal signed with Donald Trump and the Americans,
00:02:53.800 and I think Polyev does a very good job pushing back
00:02:56.540 on the excuse-making here from Peter Mansbridge.
00:02:59.980 Now, maybe Peter's just being a neutral host.
00:03:02.640 I tend to not think so.
00:03:04.080 I don't think he would be defending or throwing out excuses for a conservative
00:03:08.260 if a liberal had come on and attacked the conservatives.
00:03:11.600 There seems to be a fundamental difference between the way you look at the path forward
00:03:16.920 with the negotiations with the U.S.
00:03:19.520 and the way Carney looks at the path forward.
00:03:21.940 Should there be a new election in the country to determine whose vision is the one that Canadians
00:03:30.900 agree with?
00:03:32.820 That, you know, you should or he should have a new mandate to go into these negotiations?
00:03:40.020 Well, Mr. Carney was elected on exactly that mandate last time.
00:03:45.940 He said that the reason he was calling the election 10 months ago was to get a mandate
00:03:50.500 to negotiate a deal with the Americans.
00:03:52.800 But certain things have changed.
00:03:55.320 I hate this line.
00:03:57.380 Certain things have changed.
00:03:59.160 Well, Trump's very difficult to deal with.
00:04:01.920 Well, Trump did this or that, and ergo there's no longer a path to a deal.
00:04:05.920 Well, isn't it so convenient for the liberals that you can always just say,
00:04:10.740 Trump's erratic.
00:04:12.380 Then don't make a promise that you can get a deal signed with him then.
00:04:15.760 Don't say anything.
00:04:17.040 Admit that you failed.
00:04:18.220 Admit that you should have never promised that.
00:04:20.100 Well, they don't want to do that because that would be admitting to a failure.
00:04:22.760 So instead, the liberals in the media will just keep making endless excuses.
00:04:27.540 Well, he wants to get a deal.
00:04:29.320 He wants more than ever to get a deal.
00:04:31.740 That's what Carney wants most in this life.
00:04:35.020 But you see, he can't do it because Donald Trump, the stock market, everything's on computers now.
00:04:42.740 We can't do it anymore.
00:04:44.140 And you're actually mean for blaming him.
00:04:46.880 I'll let this keep going here.
00:04:48.320 It has been a year.
00:04:50.700 You're much stronger as of today on your position on this and the way you're detailing it.
00:04:55.920 And I'm just wondering whether you think an election is necessary at this point before the heavy lifting goes on in these negotiations.
00:05:06.240 I don't.
00:05:07.300 I do think that we should work together as parties.
00:05:10.020 And that's why I've made the offer to Mr. Carney that we would set up an all party committee that would create a united effort on behalf of the whole country to fight for Canada in the United States and in any other market.
00:05:25.680 I think that being united will be a real force going forward.
00:05:32.220 We have disagreements.
00:05:33.560 But I think all parties agree that we want tariff-free access to the United States.
00:05:37.360 There might be disagreements about how likely it is to achieve them or how to go about it.
00:05:42.720 But on that core fact, there is an agreement.
00:05:45.780 We also agree on the sacrosanct nature of the Canadian sovereignty, that we need to protect our country and its distinctiveness.
00:05:53.840 The disagreement right now is on getting it done.
00:05:57.140 And my criticism, my main criticism of Mr. Carney is that in 10 months, he hasn't really done very much.
00:06:02.400 There's been lots of announcements and papers signed and ceremonies held, but not actual results.
00:06:07.980 And I think it would be better for us to see some results for him than to spend a half a billion dollars on an election less than a year after the last one.
00:06:16.240 Now, and so I think this is good positioning from Pierre Polyev.
00:06:20.140 You cannot be the guy demanding an election because some people will then see you as the disruptive one and Mark Carney as the stability.
00:06:29.020 He is the unifier.
00:06:30.420 And we need more liberals in parliament to have more stability.
00:06:33.580 So what Polyev is doing is baiting out Carney.
00:06:36.340 Carney can't accept his help because Carney and the liberals have painted Pierre Polyev as one of many devils that they do not like.
00:06:44.940 So they cannot work with him.
00:06:46.420 But Polyev is making very good suggestions on what they should be doing, saying, hey, let's have an all parties committee on how we could actually negotiate a good deal with the United States.
00:06:55.100 We'll even include the NDP, the bloc and the greens.
00:06:57.060 Let's do it.
00:06:58.080 And Carney can't say yes.
00:06:59.680 And Polyev's idea, it's something I had been advocating for for months, but it doesn't take away from the fact that it's a good idea to propose at any time.
00:07:07.420 Polyev said, how about we strike some sort of a Kanzuk deal along with the United States where we band together and we basically have zero tariff relationships among each other.
00:07:19.920 And we align against communist China, we align against Russia, we align against Iran, we align against other brutal dictatorships and just crazy Islamic theocracies around the world.
00:07:31.740 How about let's do that?
00:07:33.680 It's an idea too good for Carney to outright reject, but he also won't take it.
00:07:40.060 One, because the liberals are in bed with the CCP and they can't accept it for that reason, and also because they're too arrogant to actually accept help from a conservative.
00:07:48.700 Very, very petty stuff.
00:07:50.500 And so I think what Polyev is doing is setting himself up very well in this position, on this issue.
00:07:57.280 I want to get to this other interview where the interviewer, Peter Mansbridge, then comes back at him and starts asking him about the floor crossings.
00:08:05.220 And this is the one thing the media is currently trying to use to insinuate that Polyev's not a strong leader, that things are not stable inside the party.
00:08:14.880 And I think Polyev taking this head on is quite good.
00:08:17.780 In fact, we've already seen polling coming out.
00:08:20.080 I don't have the numbers for you, but one of the pollsters came back from a survey and they said around two thirds of Canadians really don't like the floor crossings.
00:08:27.820 It kind of makes them, I guess, a good way of putting this is politically queasy, the idea that no matter what party you favor, people just arbitrarily getting up and leaving is bad form.
00:08:38.640 And it reflects badly on the party that accepts in the people crossing the floor for no reason.
00:08:44.300 And before some liberal says, well, Wyatt, are you cool with it when liberals cross the floor and join the conservatives, but not when conservatives cross the floor and join the liberals?
00:08:53.080 No, I don't like it when conservatives gain liberals because I don't want liberals in our parties.
00:09:00.920 This is the problem in British Columbia with the B.C. conservatives.
00:09:04.040 It is a party mostly full of B.C. liberals or people who are basically B.C. liberals, even if they had never run for the party or sat as a B.C. liberal MLA.
00:09:13.000 The thing is that when a party doesn't have a core philosophy because there's just too many random people in the party with just differing ideologies, it makes it dysfunctional.
00:09:22.960 I did not like it when then conservative leader Andrew Scheer brought in Leona Alislev into the party.
00:09:29.480 It gained nothing for the party.
00:09:31.240 It ideologically watered down the conservatives for no reason.
00:09:34.580 And unlike what some people think, it doesn't help your party to grow the potent bigger.
00:09:39.800 However, the electoral coalition you run with is not about the people that vote for you.
00:09:45.680 Your electoral coalition are kind of the people that are, you know, at arm or that are kind of near the party.
00:09:52.020 It turns into your advocates, the people running for you, the sort of, I guess, advocacy organizations that are on your side.
00:09:59.300 That makes up your coalition.
00:10:00.920 It's like serving a soup.
00:10:02.420 You basically make a soup and then you see how much of the public wants it.
00:10:05.680 Just because you add more ingredients to said soup does not actually mean people are more likely to want it.
00:10:12.120 If you are selling the conservative soup, generally you should keep it pretty conservative because 90%, 80%, you know, 80% to 90% of the people who are going to vote for you want the pure conservative soup.
00:10:23.800 You can sell some people more in the center on it, but you don't need to become a centrist soup to sell them it.
00:10:30.600 You can get people bandwagoning on.
00:10:33.180 In fact, really, every time parties water themselves down, what ends up happening, or at least on the right, what always ends up happening, when you move left as a party, you grab up.
00:10:43.500 Let's say in Canada, you expand your voter coalition and you gain 200,000 voters for the conservative party, but you lost 300,000 on your right because they said, well, they're not going to do the things I wanted them to do.
00:10:55.780 What's the point of me showing up and voting when they're only going to be kind of making changes?
00:11:00.500 People want to show up for full fat reform.
00:11:03.100 They don't want minor changes, and I think that with the floor crossings from the conservatives to the liberals, it makes liberals queasy.
00:11:11.940 Are we just a conservative party now?
00:11:14.340 And a lot of people who are even liberals just find this kind of gross and gunky.
00:11:19.640 Conservatives who voted for these people are definitely never going to vote for them as liberals, and so if anything, it's strengthening the conservative side because they get to replace these weak conservatives with real conservatives.
00:11:29.780 And for the liberal side, it makes them look hacky and like they don't really believe in their own message.
00:11:35.080 But anyways, now without further ado, here is that clip.
00:11:38.060 I rant too much, guys.
00:11:39.940 Let's move it to the other situation in caucus and for caucus management, and that's the issue of the floor crossers.
00:11:47.840 There have been three in the past year, and out of your caucus of 140 or so, I mean, three doesn't sound like much, but it is a minority government,
00:11:56.520 and we all know how that number can be looked at.
00:12:01.600 You've called it dirty backroom deals that were made by the prime minister, who you respect.
00:12:09.320 You really believe that?
00:12:10.580 It was a dirty backroom deal?
00:12:11.880 I mean, it's not like it was the first time this happened in the country.
00:12:14.940 In fact, your party did the same thing in, what, 2011 with David Emerson.
00:12:19.820 And there have been countless examples of this going on in the past.
00:12:26.360 Were those really dirty backroom deals?
00:12:29.800 I think I don't take back my words on that.
00:12:32.500 These members were elected on a conservative platform with me as their conservative leader,
00:12:37.520 and nothing has changed about our agenda since that time.
00:12:41.700 So I think that, but I'm not going to spend a lot of time talking about them.
00:12:46.540 I think there's been too much time, frankly, and I think this is one of the problems I have with Ottawa
00:12:50.720 and the entire political discourse in Ottawa is that it is absolutely fixated on the inside baseball machinations in the halls of power
00:13:03.640 and not at all focused on the real lives of people.
00:13:07.180 Like, you know, we've got people out there who are living 200 bucks away from losing their homes.
00:13:14.400 You've got well over 2 million lined up at food banks.
00:13:18.860 We've got a problem with malnutrition because people can't pay their bill.
00:13:22.100 The first time in a generation, of any generation, that our young people cannot afford homes at all,
00:13:28.480 our Brampton and Surrey are being torn apart by extortion.
00:13:31.800 And we've talked more in Ottawa about three MPs than all of those issues combined.
00:13:38.640 So that's where my focus is on.
00:13:40.380 My focus is on the lives of people here at home in Canada.
00:13:43.820 Well, I can understand that, but I can also understand that the discussion does come up to that.
00:13:49.900 I mean, there were three MPs who were elected just in the last year who chose to leave,
00:13:55.020 and it wasn't just leaving your party, it was leaving you.
00:13:57.660 Well, but the thing, this is what I find annoying about this,
00:14:02.460 how does he know that they left him?
00:14:05.240 They left.
00:14:06.260 But for some reason, the media always makes it about him, Paulieff.
00:14:10.700 When Mark Carney loses Chrystia Freeland and Bill Blair,
00:14:14.960 and who was the other person?
00:14:16.080 There was some other person there who gives a crap, though.
00:14:18.560 Nate Erskine-Smith is leaving.
00:14:20.360 Probably Jonathan Wilkinson, Stephen Gilboa, all these other people.
00:14:22.880 It never has anything to do about them.
00:14:24.620 The media always promote it as, oh, this person's moving on to a new stage in their career.
00:14:29.860 Oh, this person's going to be the high commissioner of the United Kingdom.
00:14:32.760 Oh, Chrystia Freeland's going to be an economic advisor to Ukraine
00:14:36.420 and then be the new president or CEO of the Rhodes Society.
00:14:41.380 Is no one going to investigate why she doesn't want to stick around
00:14:43.800 and be a member of a government, a high-ranking member of the government?
00:14:47.060 No, because we don't investigate what happens with the liberals.
00:14:50.040 You think it would be more of a big deal when government officials are leaving
00:14:53.400 rather than flaky people in the opposition?
00:14:57.300 Well, they knew who I was when they ran and won under my leadership.
00:15:02.100 So that is the reality.
00:15:05.000 And the reality is also that their constituents voted for our plan on affordability,
00:15:10.220 on crime, on housing, on fiscal responsibility.
00:15:16.520 And now they're part of a government that has doubled the deficit,
00:15:21.140 that's overseeing a drop in home building,
00:15:24.340 that hasn't changed a single word of the criminal code to stop crime.
00:15:28.400 So basically the opposite of all the things they were elected on.
00:15:31.280 Has there been any self-reflection on your part?
00:15:35.860 There is.
00:15:37.240 Peter, can you actually substantiate the idea that they've left on their own?
00:15:41.400 There's just this insinuation that Polyev has to look inwardly.
00:15:46.120 You know, there are things I would change about the federal conservatives under Peter Polyev,
00:15:50.220 and I think that they are at least slowly moving in the direction of it.
00:15:53.160 I wish it would be far faster.
00:15:54.600 Like, cleaning up the way nominations are done.
00:15:56.840 If you guys don't know, I actually ran for a federal nomination for this last election
00:16:00.440 in Calgary-Signal Hill, and the party at the time kicked me out
00:16:03.600 because they didn't want me to win,
00:16:05.060 and I looked like I was going to beat who was the favorite in the race.
00:16:07.820 I still actually made sure that person lost anyways,
00:16:09.800 and they really ticked at me for a while.
00:16:11.660 Stuff like that needs to not happen,
00:16:13.080 because in fact you want people who your own base likes,
00:16:15.720 not people they have to accept.
00:16:17.540 Because how many people volunteer and donate for someone who's,
00:16:20.740 eh, eh, well, I guess we'll put them in office because Polyev wants us to.
00:16:25.020 That's something they need to clean up.
00:16:26.400 I think there's certain things around messaging and policy
00:16:29.000 that they need to get better at, especially policy,
00:16:31.780 run on an across-the-board big tax cut.
00:16:35.100 None of these small 15% tax cuts under $50,000.
00:16:38.420 20% cut for every single bracket, including taking a point out the GST.
00:16:43.080 Super easy. Do it, including corporate.
00:16:45.720 But overall, when Peter Mansbridge is like,
00:16:47.940 oh, there's no inward reflection,
00:16:49.920 what is he supposed to reflect on, Peter?
00:16:51.660 You're not naming anything,
00:16:52.820 but they're just trying to throw darts,
00:16:54.080 insinuations that Polyev's not that good,
00:16:57.240 never with any real substance behind the accusations
00:17:00.460 or the calls for him to look inwardly.
00:17:03.640 There is every day in every way,
00:17:06.220 no matter what the circumstances are.
00:17:07.960 But at the end of the day, I have to focus on the people who voted for us
00:17:13.020 and the ones we need next time.
00:17:14.680 We had 8.3 million, a record number for our party.
00:17:19.260 And those people, like when I bump into them on the streets,
00:17:22.560 they're not talking to me about party membership on Parliament Hill.
00:17:26.240 They're talking to me where their next meal is going to come from
00:17:28.620 or whether they're going to be safe when they walk out the front door
00:17:32.200 under their streets or whether their job is secured.
00:17:34.900 And I think Ottawa, I think the political scene in Ottawa
00:17:39.440 would be much better, much more served
00:17:43.600 if it would focus on the daily lives of people
00:17:45.980 rather than on the political machinations of Parliament Hill.
00:17:50.400 Yeah.
00:17:51.220 But yeah, the thing is, the media needs the drama
00:17:53.540 because they don't have anything to really promote from Mark Carney.
00:17:57.540 I remember I showed that clip a while ago from CPAC.
00:18:01.160 It's like Canada's public broadcaster of all the things that happened on Parliament Hill
00:18:05.280 and some of the legislatures as well.
00:18:07.280 Basically, if a press conference happens, they kind of covered it,
00:18:10.380 cover it as a duty of theirs to make sure that things that happen
00:18:13.340 in Canadian politics around the legislature and parliament buildings are recorded.
00:18:18.200 And I remember they do some of their own programming as well, like panel shows.
00:18:21.700 I find their panel shows are so much better than CBCs.
00:18:24.120 They have actual interesting people on.
00:18:26.240 And one of the liberal strategists, one of the people who works for the liberals
00:18:30.740 who came on the panel, like when they were trying to defend the Carney record,
00:18:35.680 it was really funny when even they had to admit,
00:18:38.560 yeah, Carney in the next few months needs to focus on getting some wins
00:18:41.640 because he doesn't have any wins right now.
00:18:43.980 And that's why every time there's a little bit of a bump in the boat
00:18:46.500 that is the Conservative Party, the media just like focuses on with like a telescope on that
00:18:51.760 because they don't want to actually talk about the record of Mark Carney
00:18:54.300 because it's not that good.
00:18:56.180 In fact, there's nothing good to mention about it.
00:18:58.320 There are things he hasn't screwed up maybe that Justin Trudeau would have screwed up.
00:19:02.380 But like we saw in the last couple of days,
00:19:05.000 Mark Carney is very much capable of screwing up even harder than Justin Trudeau did,
00:19:10.220 like with that Musqueam deal that's going to absolutely destroy property values
00:19:14.720 and just certainty within the lower mainland of British Columbia
00:19:18.560 because arbitrarily we're going to give all of the property title,
00:19:21.880 we're going to put Aboriginal title over the entire lower mainland
00:19:25.100 and now it's all in the hands of some random like professional useless person
00:19:31.840 wearing crow feathers on their head.
00:19:33.960 Yes, now this guy is now the champion of the lower mainland.
00:19:38.620 He is now the king.
00:19:39.960 In fact, let's give him the sun and the stars too.
00:19:42.520 It's so ridiculous.
00:19:43.960 And that's something that Mark Carney actually did.
00:19:46.300 This is something that the federal conservatives need to start swinging on.
00:19:50.860 Like all the liberal MPs in the lower mainland need to resign.
00:19:54.140 They need to be called on to resign.
00:19:55.880 We need recall legislation badly, especially Wade Grant.
00:20:00.380 He's like Canadian Al Sharpton.
00:20:02.880 He is a race hustler through and through and that is it.
00:20:06.760 And Wade is a member of the Musqueam band.
00:20:10.200 In fact, he was on the Musqueam Council
00:20:12.180 until he ran for federal politics this last election
00:20:15.420 and he's a liberal MP in the riding that the band is in.
00:20:21.060 He is the parliamentary secretary to the Minister of Environment
00:20:24.040 and he didn't let anyone know what?
00:20:28.000 He's now trying to make excuses.
00:20:29.280 Oh, this doesn't take away anyone's homes.
00:20:31.500 Oh, yes, very good, Wade.
00:20:33.340 Yeah, all of us were thinking that the Musqueam
00:20:35.220 were going to start kicking people's doors down
00:20:36.800 and repossessing their beds.
00:20:38.240 Obviously not.
00:20:39.000 The problem is we could be in a scenario
00:20:41.720 where they end up having thumbs up and thumbs down rights
00:20:44.860 over what comes into Vancouver ports.
00:20:47.780 What economic and what new utilities are built around the area?
00:20:53.000 What economic activity is allowed to happen
00:20:54.640 in the massive borders that they now have
00:20:56.620 with Aboriginal title?
00:20:58.440 Can certain products be dropped off
00:21:00.540 at the Vancouver port, harbour?
00:21:02.440 Are they allowed to bring in oil and gas products
00:21:04.060 or is that not green enough for them?
00:21:06.000 Are they allowed to start taking property taxes from people?
00:21:08.560 Taking a portion of what the city's budgets are?
00:21:11.060 This is a band of 1,495 people,
00:21:14.060 but they need it for economic independence.
00:21:16.240 Because nothing screams economic independence
00:21:17.880 like being a welfare queen.
00:21:20.160 Anyways, that's it for this video, guys.
00:21:22.660 Thank you for watching.
00:21:23.640 I will be linking in the description below
00:21:25.160 that Nanaimo event that's going to be happening
00:21:26.960 actually just in a couple hours here.
00:21:28.760 So this is just like a final call.
00:21:30.220 If you live in Nanaimo and you want to show up,
00:21:32.660 there is that link.
00:21:34.040 If you guys want to swing by,
00:21:35.960 sign up for it now so you get the email
00:21:38.240 about where it's taking place at.
00:21:40.200 In fact, I'm not even sure
00:21:41.500 if you'll get the email right away.
00:21:42.740 I think you should.
00:21:44.280 If not, you can reach out.
00:21:45.900 I'll be putting out in just a second here.
00:21:47.500 Anyways, without all being said,
00:21:48.860 thank you guys for watching
00:21:49.680 and I'll see you all next time.