Canadians are finally starting to sour on Prime Minister Mark Carney and the Liberal Party of Canada. Poll numbers have been going down for the Liberals since mid-August. In this episode, I discuss why this is happening and how it could affect upcoming by-elections like North Vancouver-Capilano.
00:04:57.580they're at 23 points, which is great for them, considering I believe they only had like 12% of
00:05:02.700the vote in British Columbia last election. And the Greens are still sitting around 3%. And I
00:05:07.480believe the Conservatives probably gained one of their extra points from the PPC and the NDP
00:05:12.340probably gained their extra point from undecided voters or so, or one point from the Liberals and
00:05:18.080the Conservatives gained one from the PPC. It doesn't really matter, though. Although this is
00:05:23.700still a wider margin for the liberals than the last election had. It's still bad for the liberals
00:05:30.380because naturally the liberals are losing a lot of votes in interior ridings back towards the
00:05:35.900conservatives, making ridings like Kelowna far more winnable. At the same time, they're now going
00:05:40.940to have to fend off the NDP in downtown area Vancouver ridings, as well as in places like
00:05:48.200Victoria. This also helps people like Don Davies and Jenny Kwan have more stable ridings where they
00:05:54.700are in Vancouver. And so this will actually have quite a significant impact on the North Vancouver
00:06:01.880Capilano riding. Jonathan Wilkinson, the incumbent liberal, the liberal who has now resigned his seat
00:06:08.340causing a by-election to probably happen sometime in August or September, made that riding safe.
00:06:15.180It was previously held by the conservative, who actually held it for two terms, Andrew Saxton, who had won it from a liberal who held it for two terms, Don Bell.
00:06:25.200But Don Bell had won that riding from a conservative who had held it since 1993 for the Reform Party.
00:06:32.380That is a traditionally conservative riding before Jonathan Wilkinson had actually won it back in 2015.
00:07:04.100The NDP absolutely crashed in North Vancouver Capilano.
00:07:08.680The good thing for the NDP, though, is that they now have a BC-based leader,
00:07:13.440I know that Jagmeet Singh was technically BC-based, but he's not actually. He was from Brampton. He just simply moved out to BC looking for a riding. But the federal NDP leader is now Avi Lewis from Vancouver. They're going to invest a lot of money in this by-election.
00:07:30.640Jonathan Wilkinson left basically declaring, like Stephen Gilboa, a partial betrayal by Mark Carney
00:07:36.920against the green left climate zealots. And so there are a lot of votes for the NDP to pick back
00:07:44.000up, especially public sector unions don't like Mark Carney because they will cry bloody murder
00:07:49.260if you cut any public employees and you don't increase their pay enough. And although Mark
00:07:54.040Carney is still definitely a liberal because he has slightly reduced the public service in some
00:07:59.700areas, you are going to have a lot of the unions try and punish Mark Carney by flooding people
00:08:05.100back towards the NDP in that riding. And then you get a lot of what I would call disconnected,
00:08:10.820rich, greeny voters who are also now going to vote either Green Party or NDP because
00:08:15.860Mark Carney is insufficiently climate zealous enough, even though he's never going to build
00:08:20.980a pipeline, but because he talks too favorably about pipelines, they are now going to leave.
00:08:25.940And pair this up with the Conservatives running the same candidate that they did last time, who has a generally pretty good reputation in the riding and still scored 36% in the last election, despite it being a very liberal-dominated riding, you actually have a very competitive race heating up here.
00:08:45.700Overall, just to talk a little bit more about the polls, we are now seeing four pollsters showing the Liberals having fallen from 13% leads from pretty much all of them down to 5% and 8%.
00:08:59.460And I really don't think that this next news cycle is going to be particularly favorable towards the Liberals.
00:09:06.400They are only being hit with more conflict of interest scandals, more bad economic news.
00:09:11.400yes, they got a bunch of jobs created during the summer. But the thing is that job numbers only
00:09:16.460actually help a government's approval rating and polling if it's real, in the sense that you can
00:09:22.040kind of fudge some good summer job numbers because it's the summer and there's a bunch of seasonal
00:09:27.360work that always comes through. You can fudge some numbers by hiring people to do the census
00:09:31.940and because FIFA is in town. But at the end of the day, when the average person in other parts
00:09:37.160of Canada who aren't either doing the census or working at FIFA are still not getting jobs,
00:09:42.700they're not going to start voting for the Liberal Party. This is the big problem that the Liberals
00:09:48.040have. Yes, the media went out there for like a few weeks saying, well, we're not really in a
00:09:53.020recession when you think about it. It's only a technical recession. Or is it even a technical
00:09:58.020recession? Or is it just a sluggish economy? Well, you look at the polling from places like
00:10:03.540abacus data, 57% of people say, yes, we are in a recession. Only 23% said no or not, leaving a
00:10:11.420bunch of other people undecided. Undecideds tend to break the way that the vast majority of people
00:10:15.840are already going. So you'd probably have most of those people say, yes, we are in a recession.
00:10:20.160And even when you dug deeper into the numbers, only about a third of the people who said that
00:10:24.640we're in a recession will blame Donald Trump. The rest of people blame Mark Carney's government
00:10:29.620or Justin Trudeau's government being continued by Mark Carney.
00:10:34.260The thing is that there is a lot of rot under the floorboards for the Carney liberals,
00:10:39.440and I actually do believe conflict of interest scandals are going to be the death of them.
00:10:44.240The bad economy is going to be what causes the liberals to never hit 50% of the vote.
00:10:49.700They're always going to be at that kind of lower 40s position.
00:10:52.700Not a bad position to be at, but they're never going to go stratospheric
00:10:56.020because although there's a lot of happy talk, there's not actually sort of like the day-to-day
00:11:01.580feeling of everything's loosening up and groceries are cheaper and I'm doing great at work. That's
00:11:06.380not happening. So the happy talk from the media can only pump their numbers up so much. And as
00:11:12.080soon as they have their own Doug Ford scandal with the gravy plane, where Doug Ford invested
00:11:17.600like $50 million trying to get himself his own jet, which we can argue whether or not the
00:11:22.940Premier of Ontario should have that or not. I actually think there's a good case that Premier
00:11:26.540of Ontario should have a private plane. It just makes sense. But that ticked people off in Ontario
00:11:31.820because it was a bad look after having been basically just completely incompetent with
00:11:37.260spending everywhere else. That was the thing that was such a bad look. It finally cracked through
00:11:42.040into Doug Ford's approvals, which were never great before, but he had an approval rating in the high
00:11:47.18030s, low 40s, and it cratered to 21% after that moment. I think Carney not fully is in that
00:11:54.420position right now, but partially in the position that his dealings with the Vancouver developers,
00:12:00.340the Alto train, and some of these other minor scandals or with the Nova Scotia launch pad for
00:12:05.600the space launch, is going to cause different pockets of voters around the country to start
00:12:12.040saying, well, what's the point? That is so gross to them, to their political sensibilities,
00:12:17.180that they're either going to go vote NDP conservative or they're just going to stay home
00:12:21.820and this added on top of the fact the green left and the Hamas left are mad at Carney for being
00:12:27.740insufficiently zealous even though he's not pro-Israel and he's not pro-pipeline he is just
00:12:32.620simply walking a very foolish tightrope where he's pleasing absolutely nobody in doing what he's0.80
00:12:38.140doing still has high approvals but that's simply because well he's not Donald Trump well not being0.80
00:12:43.660Donald Trump didn't exactly make Justin Trudeau popular. It is possible to be deeply unpopular
00:12:49.940with Donald Trump around, and Mark Carney shouldn't get too comfortable in the current
00:12:54.440polling position that he is in because things can change as they currently are. Angus Reid
00:13:00.460has the liberals only leading by five points. In an election cycle, if the conservatives battled
00:13:05.900it back to just being 1% or 2%, they could win the election. The liberals did not win a majority
00:13:12.360government this last time, despite winning the popular vote in the last election, by like 2.7%.
00:13:17.740So if the conservatives can even dial that back to just 2%, they would actually probably win the
00:13:23.140plurality of seats. It would be a minority government, not a very stable one, but that is
00:13:27.700how sensitive the current liberal lead is. They get a lead mostly from doing really well in downtown
00:13:33.980Toronto, in certain parts of Vancouver, in Montreal, and in certain parts of the Maritimes,
00:13:38.900And everywhere else is a battleground. So the liberals slipping from 8%, 5%, 3% could actually end up having them lose the election because elbows up voters are hyper concentrated in certain other places. And people out in other parts of the country, more suburban, rural areas, do not care. It's a very urbanite type of a liberal ideology to be an elbows up liberal.
00:14:05.560But anyways, now I just quickly want to show you guys something else that has nothing to do with this,
00:14:10.340but it's just so annoying I had to bring it up.