The NXR Podcast - June 08, 2023


BONUS EPISODE - “Shiny Happy People” | Duggars, Pearls, & Bill Gothard Vs. Biblical Patriarchy

Hosted by
Mentioned
DAILY TRUTH - A Generational Epidemic Of Bad Parenting DAILY TRUTH - Types & Shadows | Circumcision & The Gospel

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 46 minutes

Words per minute

161.29

Word count

17,139

Sentence count

383

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

35

sentences flagged

Hate speech

36

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Pastor Joel Webin discusses a new documentary that focuses on Bill and Debby Pearl and their relationship with their 19 children. What are the similarities and differences between the patriarchy of the 80s and 90s and the patriarchy that we find in biblical patriarchy?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 All right, listen, guys, I get it.
00:00:01 Many of you are unable to financially support this ministry because you're spending your
00:00:05 cash and your lives on raising young children in the fear and admonition of the Lord.
00:00:10 Praise God for you and that endeavor.
00:00:13 However, algorithms are a thing.
00:00:16 Shadow banning, sadly, is a thing.
00:00:19 And one major way that you can help to expand the reach and effectiveness of this ministry
00:00:24 that doesn't cost you a dime is by spending just a few moments leaving us a five-star review. Also,
00:00:31 perhaps even more effective than that, you can share our podcast with a friend. We hope you'll
00:00:37 take the time to do so. Thank you so much. God bless.
00:00:43 Shiny Happy People. It's a new documentary. It's available on Amazon Prime and it's getting a lot
00:00:48 of momentum. A lot of people are watching this documentary. Again, shiny happy people that
00:00:53 focuses on Bill Gothard, focuses on Michael and Debbie Pearl, and of course it highlights most of
00:01:01 all the Duggars, which was a popular sitcom reality TV on TLC for several years. They ended
00:01:09 up having 19 children. They were professing Christians. I can't speak to whether or not
00:01:14 they're truly regenerate, but professing Christians, conservative in many regards, and yet there were
00:01:20 a few scandals that came out. So, all that being said, this is a popular documentary that is
00:01:26 making the rounds. A lot of people are talking about it, and so I want to address it today.
00:01:30 If I were to focus, you know, just giving you a snapshot of what I'm going to do, I'm going to
00:01:35 try to distinguish between the 1980s patriarchy and biblical patriarchy. The patriarchy that we
00:01:44 find with the Duggars, the Pearls, and Bill Gothard, the patriarchy that we found in the 1970s,
00:01:51 80s, and 90s versus biblical patriarchy. That's what I'm going to be discussing today. What are
00:01:57 the similarities? What are the distinctions? Are there serious abuses? How serious are these abuses?
00:02:04 Those are the kinds of things that we'll discuss in this video. Quickly, I want to make an
00:02:08 announcement and also have a very brief word from our first sponsor for the day. The announcement
00:02:13 is this if you have not already please go to right response conference.com right response
00:02:20 conference.com and register for our upcoming spring conference many of you came out to our
00:02:25 theonomy and post-millennialism conference this past may but we have our next spring conference
00:02:30 coming up march 1st 2nd and 3rd of 2024 march 1st 2nd and 3rd that's a friday saturday and sunday
00:02:38 the additional announcement we've announced this conference before but the additional announcement
00:02:42 is in addition to Douglas Wilson and Brian Sauve and Joe Boot and myself,
00:02:48 we now also have Michael Foster from It's Good to Be a Man joining our speaker lineup.
00:02:53 We're going to be discussing seven vital doctrines that Christians need to understand,
00:03:00 be able to articulate, and certainly believe and live out if we are to steward the world in a righteous manner.
00:03:07 If we're to exercise godly leadership, godly influence in every single sphere of life,
00:03:13 all of Christ for all of life, not just marriage and parenting in the home, not just as Christians
00:03:17 for an hour and a half on Sunday morning at church, but in the arts and medicine and politics
00:03:22 and culture, all of Christ for all of life.
00:03:25 So we have Douglas Wilson, Brian Sauve, Dr. Joe Boot.
00:03:28 We also have Michael Foster now joining the lineup and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webin.
00:03:34 And one last important thing with this conference that's a new announcement to make is that
00:03:39 we're going to be doing a live Theology Applied episode at the conference, and for that episode
00:03:45 I'm going to have Doug Wilson, I'm going to have Michael Foster, and I'm also going to
00:03:51 have Eric Kahn from its, not It's Good to Be a Man, but Hard Man Podcast is the name
00:03:56 of his podcast.
00:03:57 So Eric Kahn and Michael Foster and Doug Wilson and myself, the four of us, will be doing
00:04:02 a 90-minute panel, a live theology applied episode at the conference on the topic of
00:04:09 biblical patriarchy.
00:04:11 What is it? 0.60
00:04:12 What is it not?
00:04:13 And really, it's a lot of the topics and themes that I'll be discussing in this episode today
00:04:18 we'll discuss at greater length, the four of us together, live at this conference.
00:04:23 So again, go to rightresponseconference.com to register for our spring conference.
00:04:28 The title is Blueprints for Christendom 2.0.
00:04:31 blueprints for chrysidom 2.0 march 1st 2nd and 3rd of next year all right now a brief word from
00:04:38 our first sponsor of the day there are very few things as important as fellowship taking the time
00:04:44 to spread the gospel is our duty as christians but sharing the word over a warm cup of squirrely
00:04:50 joe's coffee now that is our passion like the caffeine coursing through their veins squirrely 0.99
00:04:56 Joes is energized by their calling and emboldened to model their relentless faith. Based in Olney, 0.99
00:05:04 Illinois, their association with the endangered white squirrel isn't just a novelty. It's a
00:05:10 reminder that His Majesty can appear in the most unexpected places, in a humble squirrel,
00:05:17 through a chance conversation, and even in a simple cup of Joe. Share coffee, serve humbly,
00:05:25 live faithfully. Squirrely Joes is owned and operated by Joe Morris, his wife Rachel,
00:05:33 and their seven children. They believe in being a truly Christian business where Christ is in the
00:05:39 DNA of the business. Joe also believes in living Coram Deo, that means before the face of God,
00:05:47 in every aspect of life. Joe is also a pastor of a small reformed church, and both Joe and Rachel
00:05:56 are veterans of the U.S. Marine Corps and U.S. Army, respectively. They believe that Christians
00:06:02 should be building a thoroughly Christian economy by doing business with other like-minded Christians.
00:06:09 The coffee is also fantastic. So, don't delay. Visit squirrelyjoes.com to order your coffee
00:06:17 today again that's squirrelyjoes.com to order your coffee today all right so what are the
00:06:26 distinctions between the 1970s and 80s and 90s patriarchal movement that was tied with the
00:06:33 homeschool movement and all those kinds of things trying to take america back for god
00:06:37 what are the distinctions between those groups of christians many of them professed they all
00:06:44 professed Christ and many of them I think probably really were regenerate godly people who love the
00:06:49 Lord but some of them were wolves some of them I think were I think they were just talking the
00:06:55 talk but what is the distinction between again the group you know that would follow the teachings
00:07:01 of you know Bill Gothard groups that would be lumped in largely you know with the Duggars and
00:07:07 the Pearls what's the distinction between their version of patriarchy and the biblical patriarchy
00:07:14 that I and individuals today would prescribe to.
00:07:18 If you're wondering, well, who are the people today?
00:07:20 Well, you know who they are.
00:07:22 They're the individuals that have been in a demeaning fashion
00:07:26 labeled as Theobros and Tradwives on Twitter and social media, right?
00:07:32 People who, well, I mean, we're all sinners.
00:07:35 We all make mistakes.
00:07:36 But in large part, it would be individuals who believe
00:07:39 that head coverings might actually be biblical
00:07:42 and that it certainly has the lion's share of church history in its corner,
00:07:47 that it's really a novelty, that we don't have head coverings today in the church.
00:07:52 It would be individuals who say, yeah, complementarianism had a lot of biblical roots,
00:07:57 but we think that at some level it was a halfway house between biblical patriarchy and egalitarianism
00:08:03 simply to appease feminists.
00:08:06 And John Piper, him and Wayne Grudem, who coined the phrase back, I believe it was 1988,
00:08:11 John Piper actually said as much he said that it was a way of trying with language to appease
00:08:17 those who were anti-patriarchal so yeah so the Theobros and Tradwives the biblical patriarchy
00:08:25 guys today were saying there are some problems with complementarianism it roots the distinction
00:08:30 and roles between men and women in design but only in the physical capacity only in the fact
00:08:36 that males and females differ they they have distinctions in design um at a physical level 0.92
00:08:42 but uh but nothing more than that um there's only the physical distinction women have hips 0.98
00:08:47 right so so they should nurture children you know men have biceps so they should go to war 1.00
00:08:52 uh literal physical war but beyond that uh the cry of the complementarian uh if she's a woman
00:08:59 is anything you can do i can do better i can do anything better than you but i won't because i'm
00:09:03 not called to but i could right so yeah the biblical patriarchy guys today are saying maybe
00:09:09 that's not the strongest biblical you know position that's not the witness of church history
00:09:14 and so it's basically you know the biblical patriarchy guys today are saying hey maybe we
00:09:19 shouldn't just have boomer theology right and what i mean by that is theology that has really
00:09:24 only been believed in the west by christians for the last 60 years for well over 1900 years
00:09:32 nobody believed these things so it's a novelty so we're getting back to um well we're getting
00:09:39 back to church history we're getting back to the scripture we're getting back to what virtually
00:09:43 all of humanity certainly all of christian influenced humanity in the west believed for
00:09:48 over 19 centuries um so anyways you can call you can call us theobros you can call us trad wives
00:09:54 and certainly you'll be able to find a crazy crackpot here or there who will um who will make 0.99
00:10:01 all your dreams come true by saying something stupid that I and others would not actually agree 1.00
00:10:06 with. But that's who I'm basically going to be comparing and contrasting in this video. The 0.99
00:10:10 1980s kind of guys, people like the Duggars, the Pearls, Bill Gothard versus the Theobro Tradwives 0.95
00:10:18 today. Myself, I would be one of them. Dale Partridge would be one of them. Eric Kahn, 1.00
00:10:24 Brian Sauve, Michael Foster. There are some distinctions, but for the most part, we're on
00:10:28 the same page. We have different strategies, but we're reasoned. We're reasoned, and we're trying
00:10:33 to be careful, and we're trying to say, hey, this is what patriarchy is. This is what it's not.
00:10:37 There is such a thing as abusive patriarchy, and that's kind of what I'm going to be addressing
00:10:41 in this video, because I think there were some legitimate abuses underneath the patriarchal
00:10:47 banner in the past decades, and I think that this new documentary, Shiny Happy People, reveals
00:10:53 some real abuses. However, the problem is that it does what most godless documentaries do. So you
00:10:59 might remember another documentary that was made by unbelievers, namely Christianity Today,
00:11:04 The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill. And I mean that. I'm not just trying to be snarky. I believe that 0.86
00:11:09 there were probably the same percentage of regenerate, truly regenerate people involved
00:11:14 in making shiny, happy people as there were in The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill. Christianity Today
00:11:20 is not Krishna it's just not and I believe that there are several individuals if not the vast
00:11:27 majority of those individuals who at least publicly are not displaying any significant
00:11:33 fruit of the spirit and so I don't you know I don't see the heart I don't have election goggles 0.95
00:11:37 but I have no reason with confidence to say that these people are actually Christians 0.95
00:11:40 now there's a similarity in the difference between these two things right so the the rise and fall
00:11:46 of Mars Hill that got a lot of momentum for a while and it was saying you know Driscoll's the
00:11:50 worst person who's ever lived he's terrible here's the difference though I you know I've watched
00:11:55 four episodes so far now I think that's all that's available right now with this new documentary you
00:12:00 know the shiny happy people and what it chronicles are legitimate abuses and that's not to say that
00:12:07 the rise and fall of Mars Hill with you know that Mark Driscoll didn't actually have real failures
00:12:12 but I want to first draw out that there's a massive difference between the failures of Mark
00:12:18 Driscoll, right? Well, he was mean, or he was quarrelsome, or, you know, he was emotionally
00:12:25 abusive behind the scenes, which I can neither confirm nor deny, right? That behind the scenes
00:12:31 in some of his staff meetings and pastoral meetings and some of these things, or maybe
00:12:35 even counseling with some members in the church, he, you know, he cursed at someone. If those
00:12:41 things are all true, there are significant problems with that. And an argument can certainly be made
00:12:48 if those things are true especially a repetitive pattern that he actually was disqualified from
00:12:52 ministry but the distinction between the rise and fall of Mars Hill with Driscoll versus this new
00:12:59 documentary dealing with Bill Gothard and the pearls and things like that is that what's being
00:13:05 chronicled in this documentary shiny happy people is not he raised his voice or he yelled or he was 0.86
00:13:13 quarrelsome it's uh he raped me he molested children and in the case of josh duggar he 0.76
00:13:22 molested children and confessed to it and admitted it and has been found guilty right so i just want 0.93
00:13:29 to draw those are some pretty big distinctions uh the similarity though between these two
00:13:34 hit pieces is that they're hit pieces the rise and fall of mars hill by one group of non-christians
00:13:40 called Christianity Today, and the documentary, Shiny Happy People, another group of non-Christians,
00:13:46 both of them are lumping in conservative Christians with individuals who actually were
00:13:54 abusive, right? So the rise and fall of Mars Hill was not just trying to say, hey, Mark Driscoll
00:13:59 took it too far. No, they have a whole episode where they basically say, you know, the root of
00:14:05 a lot of these problems isn't actually Driscoll and his personal decisions or his individual
00:14:10 personality. But the real root of the problem is any biblical theology that says that men
00:14:17 are called to lead and love like Christ. Male headship, as just a sweeping doctrine,
00:14:25 that's the problem. So what Christianity today did was it didn't just attack Driscoll and Mars 0.88
00:14:31 Hill, one individual pastor and one individual church. It attacked traditional conservative
00:14:37 christianity across the board and in that sense that's very similar to shiny happy people which
00:14:45 does the same thing um saying that you know it very much um explicitly even not just implicitly
00:14:51 but even explicitly making the statements that um homeschooling children christians choosing to
00:14:56 homeschool children is cultish um certainly they address homeschooling children with the purpose
00:15:02 that these children would grow up in the fear and admonition of the lord with conservative
00:15:06 traditional biblical virtues and values, and then seek positions of influence in the civil sphere,
00:15:13 run for local office, or these kinds of things in government and politics, that that's a terrible,
00:15:17 terrible thing. No, it's not. And, you know, my pushback to that would be by, you know, by what
00:15:25 standard, right? I mean, that's what progressives and leftists and godless people have been doing
00:15:30 for decades. They send their kids to public schools that are right now, you know, if anybody's
00:15:35 taking summer classes it's painted you know with rainbow vomit everywhere and you've got the homo 1.00
00:15:40 jihad convincing every single child as young as you've got pornography in the school libraries 0.99
00:15:46 at middle schools and even in some cases elementary schools you've got all this indoctrination from
00:15:52 the left and certainly there's a push to you know you can be anything you want to be and you can be
00:15:57 influential and you can be in politics you could be the next president of the united states so
00:16:01 the same thing is happening right it's not whether but which everybody's doing that everybody is
00:16:07 teaching children what they believe is true and then telling children to reach for the stars and
00:16:12 to make a difference in the world so so that that as just a raw basic premise of teaching children
00:16:21 your convictions and then telling those children to live out those convictions in meaningful
00:16:26 influential ways in the real world that is not inherently good or bad the question is what are
00:16:33 you teaching them is what you're teaching them actually true right so in that sense i think that
00:16:39 these two things i'm comparing them because i think there's a lot of similarities between the
00:16:43 rise and fall of mars hill and the shiny happy people both are are not just you know a hit piece
00:16:49 on individual churches or individual pastors or ministers or men, but as they draw out real 0.67
00:16:58 failures, they sweep up every conservative Bible-believing Christian into the orbit and
00:17:05 paint them all as nefarious and bad. And I think that that's a serious problem. That said, I think
00:17:12 whatever abuses allegedly Driscoll may have committed, they pale in comparison to the legitimate
00:17:19 abuses that took place that the shiny happy people documentary is showcasing i think that
00:17:25 there are some serious failures all right so all that being established now i want to get to some
00:17:29 distinctions between the shiny happy people version 1980s you know 70s 80s and 90s version
00:17:36 of patriarchy versus the biblical patriarchy that there seems to be a resurgence of today that's why
00:17:41 this is relevant why it matters one because it's dealing with something that is inherently true
00:17:48 in god's word patriarchy simply means father rule it is a biblical doctrine it's what the church of
00:17:53 jesus christ has held to all the way up until about 15 minutes ago so this is something that's
00:18:00 true and it's something that right now mainstream media is trying to dismantle single-handedly
00:18:06 dismantle with this documentary and so it's something that's worth talking about but it's
00:18:11 extra relevant because i think that right now within certain reformed circles there are individual
00:18:18 pastors and leaders such as myself who are gaining influence and there seems to be a very recent
00:18:25 present right now it's happening resurgence of patriarchal views father rule male headship
00:18:32 patriarchal views rising and then you have the release of this documentary that says patriarchy
00:18:38 is really, really bad, but all the examples, all the evidence of bad patriarchy is not bad
00:18:43 patriarchy from today. It's bad patriarchy from, again, the 70s, 80s, and 90s. It's not the bad
00:18:49 patriarchy of, you know, Douglas Wilson or Michael Foster or Joel Webin. It's the bad patriarchy of
00:18:57 Bill Gothard and the Pearls and the Duggars, all right? And there is some very big distinctions
00:19:04 between those guys of the 1970s and 80s and 90s
00:19:08 versus the guys who are trying, by God's grace,
00:19:13 to dust off this doctrine of patriarchy and say,
00:19:15 it's biblical.
00:19:16 Yes, it's been abused.
00:19:18 Yes, it's been abused.
00:19:19 We acknowledge that. 0.96
00:19:20 But it's biblical, and it's true, and it's right.
00:19:22 It's biblical, it's true, and it's right.
00:19:24 We are not on the same team.
00:19:26 Big distinctions between the two of us.
00:19:28 So, here's the first.
00:19:29 There is a distinction between fear and faith.
00:19:32 a distinction between fear and faith if you look at the Duggars you look at the Pearls you look at
00:19:40 Bill Gothard you look at the movement that the shiny happy people is is emphasizing what they're
00:19:48 what they're showcasing that movement of Christians by and large well over 90 percent of them were
00:19:56 dispensational premillennial they were premillennial dispensationalists um in a nutshell
00:20:04 there's a lot and i've talked about dispensationalism plenty in the past so you can
00:20:08 watch some of my old videos if you want to know what dispensationalism is and the problems that
00:20:12 i find with it or if you want to know you know premillennialism as an eschatology what that
00:20:16 means so let me just give you a nutshell definition the dispensational premillennials
00:20:22 believe that Jesus is going to return
00:20:25 and that he's going to return relatively soon.
00:20:28 That he could come back any moment now,
00:20:31 which is true, even from a post-millennial
00:20:33 or all-millennial perspective,
00:20:34 Jesus, no man knows the day or the hour.
00:20:36 But the pre-mill dispensationalist
00:20:39 believes Jesus is very likely
00:20:41 going to come back next Thursday.
00:20:42 I mean, really soon, really soon.
00:20:45 And more than just that,
00:20:46 not just the soonness of Christ's return,
00:20:49 but also that everything is going
00:20:51 to get progressively worse until he does return so jesus is coming back soon and until he does
00:20:58 everything is going to get progressively worse it's going to spiral into greater and greater
00:21:03 immorality okay so that was one of the dominant theological viewpoints and eschological viewpoints
00:21:11 of the patriarchal homeschool movement with the duggars and the pearls and bill gothard from the
00:21:18 1970s 80s and 90s um that is a massive distinction between the patriarchal guys today
00:21:25 the trad wives and theo bros who are being made of fun of you know because that's what you do
00:21:31 right you you just you you coddle left and you punch right right that's what conservatives do
00:21:37 today you know even christian conservatives sadly you coddle left and you punch right and so as some
00:21:44 conservative people that i really would consider us to be on the same team as they're punching us
00:21:49 because you know we're a couple inches to the right of them um you know calling you know saying 0.98
00:21:55 that oh well this is ridiculous and you know this is you know this patriarchy is it's hyper 0.55
00:22:00 patriarchy whatever one thing that i would hope that they would realize um is that pretty much 0.93
00:22:06 everyone on my team within this patriarchal space biblical patriarchy we're not dispensational and
00:22:14 we're not pre-millennialist we're not we are post-millennial and we adhere to covenant theology
00:22:21 post-millennial and we adhere to covenant theology now you might be saying well why does it matter
00:22:26 here are just some practical implications that come from those two massive christian worldviews
00:22:32 right? Whether if you're a pre-mill dispensationalist versus a covenant
00:22:36 post-millennial guy, here are some of the distinctions. It's the distinction,
00:22:40 the difference between immediate and patient. Immediate
00:22:44 and patient. The dispensational pre-mill person, 0.91
00:22:48 a lot of times what they're going to do is they're just going to opt out
00:22:52 of any kind of culture war. And I'm grateful
00:22:56 for guys, older guys in the 1970s and 80s and 90s
00:23:00 who said, we're not going to do that.
00:23:02 We're not just going to opt out.
00:23:04 Jesus, yeah, we think he might come back next Thursday,
00:23:06 but he also might come back in 50 years.
00:23:08 And if he's going to come back in 50 years,
00:23:10 then my children are going to have to live,
00:23:12 you know, the vast majority of their lives in this world,
00:23:15 and I'd like it to not be a hellhole.
00:23:17 And so we're not going to opt out of culture,
00:23:20 but we're actually going to engage.
00:23:22 And so praise God for that standpoint.
00:23:24 But with that standpoint, if you're, you know,
00:23:27 a lot of dispensational guys just opt out.
00:23:29 They don't really engage, right?
00:23:30 Everything's spiritual, and it's not necessarily cultural.
00:23:34 It's not tangible, right?
00:23:36 So they're not really going to engage in some of these things.
00:23:38 But there are plenty of dispensational guys who do, to be fair.
00:23:42 Plenty of dispensational guys who do engage.
00:23:45 However, if you are a dispi pre-mill person, and you're not on the opting out side of things,
00:23:50 but you're on the, let's press in and engage and make a different side of things,
00:23:54 by virtue of your eschatology and the way that you read the scripture you're going to say let's
00:24:02 make a difference and it needs to happen today so you're going to be pushing for the whole enchilada
00:24:08 up front right away right it's been said you know that the church lives in the light of eternity
00:24:15 therefore we can afford to be patient but that is very much a post-millennial perspective if your
00:24:23 dispensational pre-mill, and you want to engage the culture, which I thank God for, right? You're
00:24:28 not just being a pietist. You're engaging. You're getting in. You're still going to have a sense of
00:24:35 urgency and immediacy that can be good. There are strengths that come from that, but it also,
00:24:41 at the same time, I think can be bad. There are certain pitfalls that come with that. So that's
00:24:45 one distinction. Pre-mill dispensationalists versus post-mill covenant theologians, right?
00:24:51 the resurgence of patriarchy that we're seeing today among some younger ministers and some older
00:24:58 ministers that across the board, they're post-mill and they're covenantal. None of them are
00:25:04 dispensational and none of them are pre-mill. They're covenantal, they're post-mill. There's
00:25:11 a patience instead of the immediacy. And then also there's an optimism instead of pessimism.
00:25:17 so instead of a pessimistic eschatology
00:25:20 that everything is destined by God
00:25:21 to get worse and worse until Christ returns
00:25:23 we believe that slowly
00:25:25 the leaven will work through the whole batch of dough
00:25:28 that slowly the mustard seed will grow
00:25:29 into a great tree
00:25:30 that slowly the stone cut by no human hands
00:25:33 will grow into an entire earth
00:25:35 filling mountain
00:25:36 but we believe that God's plan for the end of the world
00:25:40 is not cataclysmic
00:25:42 and sudden but gradual
00:25:43 and progressive
00:25:44 and that shapes your your strategy instead of having a five-year plan for how to take over
00:25:51 the world post-millennial christians have 500 year plans and that's not to you know to foster
00:25:58 apathy but that's to say no we want to make a significant change and we want it to be rooted
00:26:05 deeply in the scripture and in the world we want it to last we want to build to last so that's one
00:26:14 big difference of these you know the the people that are being portrayed in the shiny happy people
00:26:19 documentary they are patriarchal i think there's some hyper patriarchy and there are some legitimate
00:26:25 examples of abuse and i'll get to some of that here in a moment but the first distinction is
00:26:30 that they are the vast majority are dispensational instead of covenantal and they are pre-millennial
00:26:37 instead of post-millennial that would be one major difference the next difference that i want us to
00:26:42 look at is this the difference between in terms of parenting style the difference between threat
00:26:47 and promise threat and promise or the difference between you could say again fear versus security
00:26:55 fear versus security and this one is vital and it gets not just into dispensationalism and
00:27:01 eschatology but it gets into the gospel and it gets into reformed theology so i'll hit this in
00:27:07 just a moment but one final word from our last sponsor of the day with the banking industry and
00:27:13 another tailspin and the fed ready to raise interest rates once again many of you are
00:27:18 probably asking when does this madness stop if you're interested in learning how to establish
00:27:24 a family banking system outside of today's mainstream banking insanity then schedule a
00:27:30 call with our sponsors at private family banking there's a way for individuals families and
00:27:36 businesses to put their hard-earned money to work continuously accruing compounding interest
00:27:42 and then have those resources available as collateral for cash or for financing investments,
00:27:49 businesses, college, and other major life expenditures without having to go to the big
00:27:55 banks for loans. Income tax protected, safety from stock market losses, guaranteed rates of
00:28:02 compounding interest and the ability to store up an inheritance for your children's children
00:28:08 and avoid the death tax on your estate. If this interests you, then email our friends at
00:28:15 banking at privatefamilybanking.com. Again, that's banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:28:22 or you can give them a call at 830-339-9472. Again, that's 830-339-9472. Schedule your appointment
00:28:38 today. All right. So the difference between threat and promise. Again, this is a distinction
00:28:45 drawing out some of the major distinctions between the patriarchal, and I would argue not
00:28:50 in every case but in some cases hyper patriarchal guys from the 1970s 80s and 90s versus the
00:28:56 resurgence of biblical patriarchy that we find our ourselves witnessing today okay i think that
00:29:02 some of the 1970s 80s and 90s guys guys who are being displayed in this documentary happy you know
00:29:08 shiny happy people um i think some of them were hyper patriarchal that it was extra biblical
00:29:15 that it was legalistic and that in terms of parenting also in their marriage and the way
00:29:20 that they would correspond with their wives but especially in their parenting with their children
00:29:24 that relied heavily on threat threatening rather than promise it relied more on what could be lost
00:29:33 by the child than the security the security and so that being said what doctrine does this get
00:29:41 into? Well, it gets into Reformed theology. Again, there's just simply no denying the fact that the
00:29:47 vast majority of these individuals who were part of this movement, again, many of them regenerate,
00:29:53 many of them Christians, and many of them, I would argue the vast majority, not abusive. Okay.
00:29:59 But nonetheless, they do have some theological dispositions that I would strongly disagree with,
00:30:05 and I think that doctrine matters. So, most of them were Arminian, and I think that we just need 1.00
00:30:11 to recognize that theology matters there are implications direct implications for what we
00:30:16 believe and so in terms of their view of soteriology that word soteriology just means you know your
00:30:21 doctrine of salvation how does god save people what is salvation how does god save um they were
00:30:27 arminian um not reformed they were not calvinist um and so they relied very heavily on decisionism
00:30:35 revivalism
00:30:37 very heavily on
00:30:39 the individual
00:30:41 and the choices that that individual
00:30:44 makes that at the end
00:30:46 of the day
00:30:46 election is not really a thing
00:30:50 for the Arminian it's not
00:30:52 you know some of them try to get
00:30:54 cute with biblical text and say well you know
00:30:56 God does elect people
00:30:57 but then when you press and say well what does that
00:31:00 election look like well because God is outside
00:31:02 of time before the foundations of the world were
00:31:04 laid, God looked into the future and saw all those who would choose him. And then based off of that
00:31:09 foreknowledge, which is not the biblical definite foreknowledge that's talked about in Ephesians
00:31:14 and in Peter's epistles, it's not talking about just knowing the future. It's to foreknow in an
00:31:20 intimate sense. God knows everyone in the future, but God doesn't save everyone. We're not
00:31:26 universalists. So God knew every person who would exist and every choice that they would make and
00:31:31 the very number of hairs on their heads. God knew, he foreknew everyone, but he didn't save
00:31:37 everyone. Foreknowledge in Ephesians and in Peter's epistles, what it's getting at is not
00:31:42 just the mere intellectual knowledge of someone's existence that's going to come about in the
00:31:48 future, but it's a relational knowing. It's an intimate knowing. God pre-loved. He foreknew and
00:31:54 pre-loved, salvificantly loved this individual and determined that he would elect them, choose
00:31:59 them for salvation. But again, the Arminian, if he has any doctrine of election whatsoever,
00:32:03 it's the idea that, you know, that God, you know, uses kind of a time warp because he's outside of
00:32:08 time. And so, you know, God, you know, before the foundations of the world were laid, he looked
00:32:12 into the future, he looked into all the people that he would create, and he looked at those
00:32:15 people and the decisions and choices they would make. And those people who God knew in eternity
00:32:21 past, looking forward, he knew that they would choose him, the people that God knew would choose
00:32:25 him god then went back into the past and chose them but that's not election that's i mean it is
00:32:32 election but it's man's election because essentially all that's saying is that uh that man chooses god
00:32:37 the contingent factor right the determining factor is that uh certain men choose god
00:32:43 and then god responds he reacts to man's choice of god by choosing the men and women and children
00:32:52 but the people, mankind, he chooses individuals who first choose him. And the only sense in which
00:32:59 God chooses them first is chronologically, but it's based off of his knowledge of what man would
00:33:04 do. So in chronological time, because God's outside of time and eternity past, technically
00:33:08 God makes the first choice in a chronological timeline, but in a logical sense, in a logical
00:33:14 timeline, not chronological, but logical, it is man's choice that ultimately has the final say
00:33:20 of whether or not God will choose man.
00:33:21 Man has to first choose God,
00:33:23 and then God warps back into eternity past
00:33:25 and chooses man.
00:33:27 If there's any doctrine of election
00:33:29 within the Arminian soteriology whatsoever,
00:33:33 the Arminian view of salvation,
00:33:36 that would be it.
00:33:37 So my point is,
00:33:39 it relies heavily on man, 0.80
00:33:41 man's decisions, right?
00:33:43 It's decisionism, revivalism,
00:33:47 make a choice, make a choice,
00:33:49 make a choice have have an experience uh have some kind of emotional you know eliciting experience
00:33:58 at this youth camp you know or this billy graham revival or you know and and then choose choose
00:34:05 um that's that's their soteriology and the 1970s and 80s and 90s you know patriarchal
00:34:13 homeschool movement kind of again a lot of really really great stuff um but also at the same time a
00:34:20 lot of bad doctrine and when it comes to their view of salvation again i'm not talking about
00:34:26 well some of them no the vast majority of them were arminian they were they were dispensational
00:34:32 pre-millennial arminians and that matters that affects everything including your home life
00:34:41 the way you view family the way you view marriage and the way you view parenting the way you view
00:34:46 parenting is going to be shaped by the way you think god as a heavenly father adopts children
00:34:53 how does god save children how does god turn enemies into adopted sons how does god save
00:35:03 is going to affect how you parent it is so arminian versus calvinist threat versus promise
00:35:12 within that framework are arminians not only is it relying you know heavily on man's initial
00:35:19 choice of god and then god simply reacts to man's choice and chooses him back not only is it there
00:35:25 this contrast between arminian and calvinist views of salvation soteriology but within that framework
00:35:32 there's the difference the distinction between losing salvation versus eternal security of the
00:35:38 believer right once saved always saved perhaps better articulated if saved always saved sure
00:35:46 Matthew 7 is true many will say on that day Lord Lord we did this in your name did that in your
00:35:50 name but notice the Lord's response he doesn't say I used to know you when you chose me and were
00:35:55 following me but I don't know you anymore because you stopped choosing me and you chose sin and you
00:36:01 walked away and so i knew you for a while but know you no longer that's not what matthew 7 says it
00:36:09 says many will claim christ on that final day lord lord we did this in your name that in your name
00:36:14 but the lord jesus will respond not by saying i used to know you for a time but i don't know you
00:36:19 any longer but rather he'll say depart from me you evil workers of iniquity i never knew you
00:36:25 so these aren't people who lost their salvation they are people who never had salvation they
00:36:32 professed belief in christ they walk the walk and talk the talk but they never these are not people
00:36:37 who who actually were saved for a while and then walked out of that umbrella to use gothard's
00:36:43 you know big teaching illustration that you know they were under the umbrella and they were safe
00:36:49 and then they walked out of the no they were never under the umbrella they were under god's wrath
00:36:53 the whole time. Children of God's wrath, according to Ephesians 1 and Ephesians 2 and Romans.
00:36:59 They were never saved. They professed faith, but they did not possess faith. And again,
00:37:07 doctrine matters. Arminian versus Calvinist makes a difference. And not just in your view of
00:37:12 salvation, but that view of salvation and how you read the scripture and all of scripture in light
00:37:17 of these doctrines is going to affect the way that you live, including the way you live at home
00:37:21 as a husband and a father can we lose our salvation or not so Arminian versus Calvinist
00:37:27 salvation being something that could be lost versus the eternal security of the believer
00:37:33 and then another thing that comes out of this is works versus unconditional election grace
00:37:39 works versus grace you might say well no no no these guys the 70s and 80s they didn't believe
00:37:44 that we were saved by works you can hear their gospel proclamation you know that we're saved 0.99
00:37:48 by faith alone that we're all sinners we've all fallen short and that's true the Duggars would 0.90
00:37:52 affirm that that we've fallen short of the glory of God we're all sinners we all deserve hell
00:37:58 and that ultimately we're not saved by works there's no way that we can earn the love of God
00:38:03 by our good behavior we've already missed the mark too far and therefore we are solely reliant
00:38:10 on the grace of god amen that's true um but again here's the thing um is a choice a work
00:38:19 is a choice of work or maybe i could put it in the opposite sense is making the wrong choice
00:38:27 is that is that a bad work is that a sinful work is that a sin like the way that you know when i
00:38:35 used to argue with armenians all the time which i you know by god's grace i you know don't do that
00:38:41 very often these days uh but you know there was a time uh where you know a lot of armenians were 0.99
00:38:47 you know picking fights and i was picking some fights myself and you know and having these kind
00:38:52 of conversations and you know people would say you know i would always say well okay did jesus
00:38:57 die for all the sins of every single person or did he die for the sins of the elect you know and
00:39:04 I'd say, well, no, Jesus died for everyone.
00:39:06 Of course, Jesus didn't just die for some people.
00:39:08 He died for everyone.
00:39:09 Universal atonement.
00:39:11 He died for every single person and all their sins.
00:39:13 And then I would say, okay, well, why do people go to hell?
00:39:18 Because we're not just talking about God's mercy.
00:39:20 In this instance, we're actually talking about God's justice.
00:39:23 It is not just for God, who claims to be a just judge,
00:39:27 to exact double payment for the same crime.
00:39:30 So a person defies him and lives a life of sin against him.
00:39:33 but if Jesus died for that person
00:39:35 because he died for each and every individual person
00:39:38 a universal atonement
00:39:39 Jesus didn't just die for God's people
00:39:41 but he died for all people
00:39:42 if this is the case
00:39:43 and Jesus died for everyone
00:39:45 each and every individual
00:39:46 and Jesus, you know, the wages of sin is death
00:39:49 and Jesus is, you know, he who knew no sin became sin
00:39:53 so that we might inherit the righteousness of God
00:39:55 so the sins not just of the elect
00:39:57 but the sins of every individual person
00:40:00 who has ever lived and ever will
00:40:01 were imputed to Christ
00:40:02 they were laid upon his shoulder and then jesus he merited the wages of sin what sin earns what
00:40:09 sin deserves namely death and he died under the wrath of god on the cross at calvary
00:40:14 and paid the full penalty for sin and he did that for everyone then the question is why do people go
00:40:21 to hell right and to which you know the arminian and you know fundamental fundamentalist you know
00:40:26 independent baptist is going to respond and say well you know jesus died for everyone's sin but
00:40:30 but you have to choose to receive that gift so jesus it's like his atonement is wrapped in a
00:40:38 in a present you know and it's and it's offered to every single individual person you know but
00:40:42 some people just they never open the gift they refuse it in their arrogance and pride you know
00:40:45 and and uh and so yeah jesus did die for all their sins but you have to receive his death
00:40:52 for your sins to which my counter would simply be is choosing to reject jesus death for sin
00:40:57 a sin? And if Jesus died for all of your sins, did he die for the sin of rejecting his death
00:41:03 for sin? It's so silly. I mean, this is why I don't argue with Arminians anymore, because 0.99
00:41:09 I don't argue with Arminians for the same reason I don't argue with my two-year-old, 0.97
00:41:14 right? Because it's not productive. I'm sorry, I'm not trying to be overly 1.00
00:41:20 demeaning, but it's just, it's not the witness of church history. It's not the teachings of
00:41:25 scripture. And it's just not, I just don't think it's helpful to entertain it. I think, you know,
00:41:30 by engaging too much, you're giving credence to the view. Like this is, this is a really
00:41:34 legitimate view. No, it's not. It's just not. So I think let's just, let's hold to biblical theology
00:41:39 and move on. Hold to biblical theology and move on. So all that being said, everybody limits the
00:41:45 atonement, right? The Arminian would say, you know, well, we, we hold to, you know, universal
00:41:49 atonement that Jesus died for everyone. Okay, fine. But you're still limiting the atonement.
00:41:54 See, because what you're saying is that the atonement is not limited in its scope of individuals who Jesus died for.
00:42:01 He died universally for each and every individual.
00:42:03 But that atonement doesn't cover all of their sin.
00:42:07 See, the Calvinist limits the atonement in terms of the number of people that Christ died for.
00:42:12 The Arminian limits the atonement in terms of how many sins of all people Christ died for.
00:42:17 Because they believe there's at least one sin that Jesus did not atone for.
00:42:21 and that's the sin of rejecting jesus atonement which of course is a sin now here's the further
00:42:28 problem right let's just play it out just a little bit more and then we'll move on the further
00:42:31 problem is if you you know if the arminian you say okay so jesus died for everyone's sin each and
00:42:36 every individual person all their sins except for the sin of not choosing to accept his death for
00:42:43 their sins great well then based off of your view you would have to say that that the people in hell
00:42:48 right now today that the only sin that they are suffering in hell for that they're being punished
00:42:55 by God for is the sin of rejecting Jesus and his substitutionary death his atonement his salvation
00:43:03 that's the only sin they're being punished for because Jesus died for all their other sins so
00:43:08 there's no one in hell today being punished for the sin of murder or the sin of lust or perversion
00:43:14 or theft or lying bearing false witness well how do you square that with volumes of biblical texts
00:43:22 that talk about how this individual will not inherit the the you know the kingdom of god and
00:43:28 it's not just the individual who rejects jesus will not inherit uh the kingdom of god or the
00:43:32 individual who has unbelief in the gospel will not inherit the kingdom of god but no liars and 0.99
00:43:38 perjurers those who are disobedient to their parents the homosexual uh the the perverts 0.99
00:43:43 the cowardly right the coward will go to the lake of fire and he'll go to the lake of fire 1.00
00:43:48 not just because he rejected jesus he'll go to the lake of fire the coward will go to the lake of 0.97
00:43:53 fire for his cowardice and his rejection of jesus and he will be punished eternally under the white
00:44:01 hot wrath of god for not only the sin of rejecting jesus which is a very great sin if not the
00:44:07 greatest sin, but he will also be punished for other sins, lesser sins, like his sin of cowardice
00:44:16 or theft or lying or perversion or adultery or murder or anything else. And that's, again, that
00:44:24 is an indisputable testimony from not just one isolated passage, but the overarching theme of
00:44:34 scripture is that people go to hell for rejecting jesus yes and a litany of all the other sins
00:44:40 they've committed those sins were not atoned for so the arminian wants to limit the atonement
00:44:45 not in terms of the scope of the number of people who jesus has died for but in the number of sins
00:44:51 that jesus is atoned for and there's one sin that he didn't atone for and that's the sin of rejecting
00:44:56 his atonement but again that would logically conclude that the only sin that people therefore
00:45:01 are being punished for in hell is the one sin that jesus didn't atone for which is the sin of
00:45:05 rejecting his atonement but then what do you do with all the biblical texts that say that people
00:45:10 are being punished by god for other sins like lying like theft like you know so you get the
00:45:15 point again it's i've just at this point in my christian life and pastoral ministry i just you
00:45:23 know it's been a while i feel a little bit rusty but you know i just i don't have these arguments
00:45:27 anymore. Um, all that being said, if you're Arminian, you're going to parent like an Arminian.
00:45:36 If you're reformed, you're going to parent like you're reformed. If you're covenantal, 0.53
00:45:40 you're going to have covenantal parenting. If you're dispensational, you're going to have
00:45:42 dispensational parenting. If you're pre-millennial, you're going to be a pre-millennial parent.
00:45:47 And if you're post-millennial, you're going to be a post-millennial parent, right? So threat versus
00:45:52 promise. That's one of the distinctions that I'm raising out and in the marriage realm and especially
00:45:57 the parenting realm the difference between threat threatening parenting versus promised parenting
00:46:02 well that's arminianism versus calvinism it's can you lose your salvation right can you lose the
00:46:08 love of god versus are you eternally secure in god's unconditional love right in the same way
00:46:15 you know the arminian would say why you know nobody does anything to earn god's salvation
00:46:19 and so you can't do anything to lose it but if you press them you say but but do people make a
00:46:24 choice to receive god's salvation okay great and they'll say yes well you got to at least make the
00:46:31 right choice you know uh well okay so you don't do anything to earn it so you can't do anything
00:46:36 to lose it right well but you choose something to earn it and so you can make another choice to lose
00:46:41 it logically right and they'll say oh yeah i guess so yeah so you can you can walk out of the love of
00:46:50 god you can walk out of salvation you can walk out of fatherly affection you're not secure
00:46:58 not truly not truly it's the difference between works if you think of a choice
00:47:07 being a work which i would argue it is right john talks about is not by the the will of man
00:47:13 nor the work of man right it's not the flesh it's not the work it's not the will
00:47:18 so we don't earn salvation by doing good deeds but we also don't earn salvation by
00:47:24 making some great choice right that the difference between christians and everybody else is that you
00:47:31 know at the end of the day christians are just a little wiser just a little better you know not
00:47:35 really better in terms of their deeds but they're a little better in the terms of you know well they
00:47:40 just they were able to open their eyes and survey the land and see well this is sin this is satan
00:47:45 this is god this is his love and they just made the better choice the calvinist doesn't believe
00:47:50 that but at some level the arminian does they do so the 1970s and 80s and 90s when i would argue
00:48:00 not all of them but some of them hyper patriarchal guys they were dispensational they were not
00:48:06 covenantal they were pre-mill they were not post-mill they were arminian they were not
00:48:11 calvinist they believe that you could walk out of god's love walk out of salvation by decisionism
00:48:16 same thing that got you in can get you out decisionism revivalism man's choice man's choice
00:48:23 and that does affect the way that you parent whether there's security and promise versus
00:48:31 threatening and judgment all right here's another one independent fundamental baptist
00:48:37 versus confessional reformed theology. 0.85
00:48:44 The tradwives and theobros of today's resurgence of patriarchy,
00:48:50 again, there's always going to be somebody who hops on the train,
00:48:55 who starts drinking the Kool-Aid, who says,
00:48:57 hey, this is the cool new thing, and who's wacky and weird
00:49:00 and doesn't really understand the arguments and takes it too far.
00:49:04 But in terms of the leaders, I'm talking about today's pre-war,
00:49:07 present-day leaders within the patriarchal position, within Christianity, they are all
00:49:15 reformed. They're not Arminian. They're all post-Milman, as far as I know. They're not
00:49:20 pre-Milman. They're all covenantal. They're not dispensational. And they're all confessional.
00:49:27 That's the next distinction I'm drawing out. They're not independent fundamental Baptists.
00:49:33 And you guys have heard me talk about independent fundamental Baptists before.
00:49:37 probably, if you follow this show at all. So, I won't go into a, you know, ridiculously thorough
00:49:44 diatribe, but suffice it to say, again, there are some legitimate good brothers within that camp,
00:49:52 that theological camp, that I'm grateful for. But again, I think it's wrong. I think it's wrong,
00:49:57 and that doesn't mean that it's heretical. I'm not, you know, you can have, there are wrong
00:50:03 doctrines that aren't heresy armenianism for that example i think it's unbiblical i think it's wrong
00:50:09 but it's not heresy it's not heresy pelagianism is and sadly a lot of armenians today actually
00:50:17 are pelagians and so in that sense it would be a heresy i don't have time to flesh that out but
00:50:21 the point is not not all doctrine that is unbiblical is is necessarily you know fits the
00:50:29 criteria for heresy right so there are plenty of independent fundamental baptists who they're not
00:50:35 false teachers in the capital f capital t sense they're not heretics many of them are good
00:50:42 regenerate christians who love the lord are seeking to live a biblical traditional conservative
00:50:48 you know life in their home and and in every other aspect but there are some problems
00:50:55 by and large right of course there's always going to be some exceptions to the rule but by and large
00:51:01 the independent fundamental baptist believes that they're right and the first century church
00:51:08 is right and everybody from about 80 100 to up until you know about 150 years ago 0.92
00:51:20 that all of them were wrong from AD 100 all the way until very recently um you know the vast
00:51:27 majority of church history sure there were some good things here or there but for the most part
00:51:31 they're wrong independent fundamental baptist um I would not say I think this is fair I'm trying to
00:51:37 be fair um I think it's fair to say that the independent fundamental baptist is not necessarily
00:51:43 what we would say is a great esteemer of church history.
00:51:50 You know, if we're thinking of different theological camps
00:51:53 and different denominations and different groups of Christians,
00:51:55 we're saying, you know, which denominations,
00:51:58 which, you know, which traditions within, you know,
00:52:01 the larger evangelical tent, you know, which one,
00:52:04 which of them, you know, really esteem
00:52:06 and really value church history? 0.94
00:52:08 I don't think that independent fundamental Baptist
00:52:11 would make the top 50 on that list
00:52:15 or the top few hundred on that list.
00:52:19 They're just not big fans, right?
00:52:22 Let's get back to the book of Acts. 1.00
00:52:26 Let's get back to the early church
00:52:27 because we got off track
00:52:29 and everybody's been wrong
00:52:31 until fairly recently.
00:52:34 Primitive Baptist would be one expression
00:52:35 that got back on track with them
00:52:38 or got back on track with this other group.
00:52:40 you know but but for well over 1500 years we've been you know we've been missing the mark
00:52:46 um so again that would be one difference between the patriarchal guys and some of these guys and
00:52:54 not just followers but leaders within that movement of the 1970s 80s and 90s some of them
00:52:59 being hyper patriarchal another distinction between them doctrinally and kind of the guys
00:53:05 who are brushing off this doctrine of patriarchy saying i think this is good i think this is the
00:53:09 witness of church history we need to get back to this is what the bible teaches another big
00:53:13 distinction is the lion's share of them were independent fundamental baptists yes a lot of
00:53:20 them were southern baptists but even the southern baptists were still of the arminian for the most
00:53:27 part the arminian sort and not the reformed sort they were big on decisionism revivalism
00:53:36 arminianism independent fundamentalist they were not reformed post-millennial covenantal
00:53:47 and they also weren't confessional so when i say that the guys that i know right the
00:53:55 theobros and trad wives today we're saying no biblical patriarchy is biblical it is good
00:54:01 it can be abused we need to be careful but it is good it's good um again i don't know any of
00:54:09 any of the leaders in this movement for lack of a better term who are not postmill who are not
00:54:16 reformed who are not covenantal and who also are not confessional not just reformed in the sense
00:54:23 that they're calvinistic but they are confessionally reformed they all hold either to the
00:54:31 1689 london baptist confession of faith or for the most part the westminster meaning that there's
00:54:38 a long-standing tradition centuries of being able to say we're pointing to these guys we're not
00:54:46 we're not picking a doctrine out of a hat and saying hey you know nobody's really held to this
00:54:51 But, you know, but we think, you know, we think that the first century church did and then everybody dropped it for 1900 years, but we're picking it back up.
00:55:00 No, we're saying no, that this is this goes all the way through, you know, the reformed tradition for the last 500 years.
00:55:07 And then even before that, it tracks all the way back to Athanasius and to Augustine.
00:55:10 And this is what this person said and what that person said.
00:55:13 And sure, we're not saying that church history is an infallible source of authority like the scripture, subservient to the scripture.
00:55:20 but church history is an authority guys confessions are an authority they're not infallible only the
00:55:28 scripture is infallible but even the doctrine of sola scriptura people they just they don't get
00:55:33 this so even reform guys don't understand sola scriptura sola scriptura means that not that
00:55:38 scripture is the only authority sola scriptura means that scripture is the only infallible
00:55:43 authority the only authority that's perfect that never errs it's the only infallible authority and
00:55:49 it's the highest authority but it's not the only authority because scripture itself testifies to
00:55:54 other authorities and church history is one of them and so one of the points that i want to make
00:55:59 on this the difference between confessional christianity versus independent fundamentalist
00:56:05 baptist which again that's another distinction between the 1970s 80s and 90s guys pearls
00:56:12 duggars bill gothard versus some of the guys today who would describe themselves as being
00:56:19 patriarchal one of the big differences is the guys today are confessional and love church history
00:56:25 the guys of yesteryear were independent fundamentalist baptist or arminian revivalism
00:56:33 kind of southern baptist very detached from from the full breadth of history from the apostles all
00:56:42 the way up to present day it's just nope here we are we just we just appeared in a vacuum and we're
00:56:49 doing church and we're doing it right pure unadulterated true and there are problems
00:56:56 there are problems with that mindset the mindset of we just appeared we don't really have a history
00:57:01 and also jesus is going to return next thursday and so we just appeared and we're about to
00:57:06 disappear i'm just i'm just telling you there are problems with with that kind of theology again i'm
00:57:13 not saying it's heresy the ifb guys are not heretics some of them are but you know but not
00:57:19 not inherently it's not inherently heretical and dispensational premillennialism is not heretical
00:57:24 but but what you got to realize in terms of practical implications of that you put those
00:57:30 two things together you combine them together right not every disby you know premill guy is
00:57:34 an independent fundamentalist baptist who disdains church history and not every independent
00:57:38 fundamentalist baptist well actually they are all dispensational and premill so never mind
00:57:43 um but my point is when you get both when you get the combo ifb and you know dispensational
00:57:49 premill you're basically saying that the church is something that that is you know it doesn't
00:57:56 really have much of a history and doesn't have much of a future just kind of you know there was
00:58:00 the book of acts and the early church first century church and we're trying to get back to
00:58:03 that minus speaking in tongues you know god forbid which i would agree i'm a cessationist
00:58:08 in terms of the sign gifts prophecy and tongues i think they've ceased but you know it's just
00:58:12 funny that we get back to the church you know the the book of acts but minus minus the sign gives
00:58:16 minus minus that um but really you know since the first century church and very recently in the last
00:58:23 hundred two hundred you know maybe three hundred years depending how you're counting and what exact
00:58:27 strain of you know independent fundamentalist baptist you might be from um we basically got
00:58:32 it we got a big gap we got a big gap where the church was just on a hiatus and you know we just
00:58:37 missed the mark. And so, you know, we don't have much of a history and we don't have much of a
00:58:42 future. Don't have much of a history because, you know, church history is just filled with a bunch 0.99
00:58:46 of losers who were wrong. And, uh, and we don't have much of a future because Jesus is coming
00:58:51 back in 15 minutes. And that kind of theology has some problems, has some problems. One of the
00:59:00 problems is, and this is ironic, but one of the problems is as it pertains again with like the
00:59:05 pearls for instance or i'll just you know i'll just use um gothard for a moment bill gothard
00:59:10 um bill gothard is all about you know the the husband and the father being an authority and
00:59:17 the fifth commandment for children right honor your father and mother that it may go well with
00:59:22 you that you may live a long life in the earth right it's the first commandment with a promise
00:59:26 and i would say yes and amen but here's the irony you're telling children to honor their father and
00:59:32 mother but you're doing it from a theological position that has no honor for spiritual fathers
00:59:40 and mothers you look at all of your church fathers all of your theological fathers for all the
00:59:49 centuries and the witness of church history that came before you and you spit on them you despise
00:59:57 them you don't think that they really made any legitimate contribution not not anything
01:00:04 significant basically just you know you've got the first century church chronicled in the new
01:00:11 testament particularly the book of acts they were on it and uh and then everybody missed it
01:00:17 all of your fathers missed it for for centuries for 15 16 17 18 100 years they missed it
01:00:25 but now you got it so so you don't honor your fathers but but children need to honor theirs
01:00:33 and i'm just i'm just drawing that out and that's an irony that's a problem who who is bill gother's
01:00:41 father right and and and and not just you know well this guy who you know is you know five years
01:00:48 older than me or ten years older than me like what what about what about other fathers what
01:00:52 about a hundred years before you what about 200 years before you what about 500 years what about
01:00:57 a thousand years what about 1500 years do you honor your church fathers do you honor your 0.99
01:01:04 spiritual fathers or do you think that they're they were just all dumb and if you think that 1.00
01:01:11 they were all dumb then don't you see the irony the irony of of your children eventually growing 1.00
01:01:18 up and thinking that you're dumb? Isn't that, at least in some sense, in a spiritual theological 1.00
01:01:24 sense, the example that you've set? Is it fathers are stupid? Now, a further ironing in the case of 1.00
01:01:34 Bill Gothard is that he doesn't have children. He wasn't married and didn't have kids, and yet
01:01:43 he's going around doing crusades on marriage and parenting which 0.58
01:01:48 yeah i just i think that's silly i think that's silly all right here's another thing
01:01:57 another distinction between the you know the resurgence of biblical patriarchy that we see
01:02:02 happening today which again we've got to be careful because some people will miss the mark
01:02:07 some people will abuse patriarchy some people will go into hyper patriarchy they'll go too far
01:02:12 and all those things so um it's not perfect it's not perfect but it is different and i believe by
01:02:20 god's grace it is distinctly and clearly better than some of the patriarchy from the 70s the 80s
01:02:28 and the 90s one other difference is that i think at least again the leaders i can't speak to every
01:02:36 you know every single person who's you know wearing the biblical patriarchy label you know
01:02:40 who has 12 followers on twitter you know i i i don't know everybody you know but i'm speaking
01:02:46 of leaders in this movement the patriarchal guys that i respect that i love that i think highly of
01:02:53 who are leaders and pastors in this theological position of biblical patriarchy they're they're
01:03:01 churchmen that's another distinction the guys today the patriarchal guys today are churchmen
01:03:07 and not all of them again but there were some significant leaders in the patriarchy of the past
01:03:17 recent past 70s 80s and 90s that were not churchmen what church did jim bob dugger uh was he
01:03:27 a member at and i i'm sure you know i mean like over the course of his life his marriage and his
01:03:34 you know being a father with his children i i hope i assume that there's at least you know
01:03:39 how did he at least had a couple legs in the race of a few years here or you know a couple
01:03:44 years there where he was a member in a biblically ordered church i hope i'm willing to extend the
01:03:51 benefit of the doubt but i know what i know is that there was at least if not the entire time
01:03:58 at least a very long period of time where church is just kind of something happening in the duggars
01:04:03 living room with maybe one or two other families that they're friends with there's not really
01:04:10 biblical eldership there's not really you know a biblical church membership there's not really
01:04:16 an understanding of the criteria of what makes church church and the ordinary means of grace
01:04:21 there's no sense of church order and liturgy and the means of grace being rightly administered to
01:04:28 the gathered saints on the Lord's Day with the preaching, the proper preaching of God's
01:04:32 Word and praying of God's Word and singing and psalms and hymns and spiritual songs and
01:04:38 singing of God's Word with the rightly administered sacraments of the Lord's Supper and baptism.
01:04:44 It's, I mean, it's hard.
01:04:46 It's really, really hard.
01:04:47 Even trying to be as charitable as possible, it's hard to say that at least for a long
01:04:52 period of time that it's hard to say that the church that the Duggars participated in
01:04:58 meets the biblical criteria for what actually qualifies as a church
01:05:03 you know and like from my knowledge and from what I know which I'm not omniscient you know and some
01:05:13 of you guys you might be listening to this and you're you know you're in your 60s and 70s and
01:05:17 you were blessed by this movement so you feel defensive you feel frustrated with some of the
01:05:21 things that i'm saying you may know some things that i don't i have no doubt but i tried to do
01:05:26 some serious research coming into this and from what i can tell bill gothard i wasn't really a
01:05:32 churchman he wasn't really a churchman this is not he wasn't even a family man for that matter
01:05:39 i find that again i silly is just the nicest way that is the nicest most charitable term
01:05:44 i could you know i can use but you got a guy teaching christians about marriage and family
01:05:53 and he's not a churchman he's not a pastor of a local church where he ministers week in week out
01:06:02 preaching the word expositionally through books of the bible and administering the sacraments to
01:06:08 the people of god rightly on the lord's day he's not a churchman and he's not even a family man
01:06:14 he doesn't have a wife he doesn't have children 0.63
01:06:19 but he's touching the thighs of somebody else's children
01:06:25 yeah that that that is that's a massive distinction so and and again this isn't
01:06:35 again, this isn't Joe Blow. This isn't some random follower of this movement of the 70s and the 80s
01:06:41 and 90s. This is the godfather, Bill Gotham. This is a big dog. This is a leader. I'm not just
01:06:49 a leader of, you know, thousands of leaders. No, this is like the leader.
01:06:57 And I understand. I know what slander is, right? I'm a biblical conservative.
01:07:02 i'm patriarchal and it's 2023 you think i haven't been slandered i know i know that people lie i'm
01:07:10 aware i'm aware um but there's a difference in people lying saying you know again think about
01:07:21 this in the case of driscoll right this is why i'm you know comparing and contrasting there's
01:07:25 some similarities but there's also some real distinctions think of the difference between
01:07:29 the rise and fall of Mars Hill. The rise and fall of Mars Hill, Christianity Today was not
01:07:34 attempting. I'm sure you can tell. If you got just a little bit of discernment, you should be able to
01:07:38 ascertain. Christianity Today was not trying to do Driscoll any favors in that podcast. Not any.
01:07:46 They were throwing their worst at him. They were. And anytime they tried to seem like, oh, but you
01:07:52 know, but we, you know, we want to be fair. We love just, no, no, no. Anytime that they even
01:07:56 appeared to be defending him or saying something positive about him it was only to bolster up their
01:08:02 credibility for the next hit for the next time they whacked him they hate mark driscoll i know
01:08:09 some of those individuals cosper mike cosper i i've met him this is not a driscoll fan these guys
01:08:17 hate driscoll hate him but here's my point they hate driscoll the whole series is a hit piece on
01:08:23 driscoll and yet the worst things that they can throw at him are you know he was arrogant he was
01:08:31 prideful he was quarrelsome he was divisive he was harsh he was crude that would probably be
01:08:39 their worst uh their worst accusation crude in some of his language overly sexualized uh in some
01:08:46 of his language but one thing that the rise and fall of mars hill never does is say that uh that
01:08:51 driscoll cheated on his wife that he molested children that he was an adulterer that he possessed
01:09:01 infidelity that there was sexual immorality in his actions that's never and and here's my point
01:09:09 christianity today never levied those accusations against driscoll and it's not because they like
01:09:15 him if there was even a hint right that's why the scripture says but among you must not even be a
01:09:23 hint of sexual immorality if there was a hint they would have they would have ran with it but they
01:09:28 didn't because as far as we know driscoll has not committed sexual immorality and again i'm not
01:09:37 saying that driscoll's great i'm not saying he's great driscoll threw reform theology under the bus
01:09:42 he had some buddy buddy with brian houston and some of the prosperity preaching guys that that
01:09:51 made me really really uncomfortable um so i'm not sitting here saying yeah mark driscoll i'm just
01:09:58 saying i'm comparing and contrasting shiny happy people with the rise and fall of mars hill saying
01:10:04 in both instances both of these docu series are done by individuals who hate the people that
01:10:10 they're doing the series about but in the shiny happy people instance the accusations that are
01:10:16 being levied sure some of it could be slander i'm sure i'm sure the majority right i'm willing to
01:10:21 take that position the majority is slander but the kind of accusations that that are that are
01:10:26 being levied some of them have been proven in courts of law and that's not to say a court of
01:10:31 law can't ever be wrong but i'm just saying when it's when it's top leaders and these are criminal
01:10:37 charges and it's instance after instance after instance um there's probably something there
01:10:48 there's probably something there and i don't think it's just my point again is not just that
01:10:55 the people who did the shiny happy people docuseries um that they just really hate bill
01:11:01 Gotham well no Mike Cosper really hates Mark Driscoll truly and if there was a chance of him
01:11:14 being able to throw out an accusation of Driscoll being sexually immoral and it even had a chance
01:11:18 of sticking he would have done it but there wasn't a chance there was a chance with Bill
01:11:25 Gotham there was a chance of that accusation being levied and it's sticking there was a chance with
01:11:34 the Duggars with Josh Duggar particularly of that accusation being levied levied and it's sticking
01:11:42 it being true and there was a chance in the case of Jim Bob Duggar his dad of the accusation of
01:11:49 not properly dealing with not just allegations made about your son but your son's own confession
01:11:56 to sexual immorality and molestation not dealing with it seriously sweeping it under the rug
01:12:07 those accusations can be made and they're sticking and i don't think it's just because
01:12:14 the world hates patriarchy
01:12:16 and hates Christianity. 0.82
01:12:18 I think it's because there were some 0.83
01:12:20 serious flaws.
01:12:21 There were some serious flaws and not
01:12:24 just what, there's always going to be
01:12:25 fringe crackpot
01:12:27 followers of any movement, 0.94
01:12:30 any Christian movement, any pagan movement.
01:12:33 But it's different when it's leaders.
01:12:37 Premier
01:12:37 leaders.
01:12:39 It's different.
01:12:42 All right.
01:12:43 but again one difference okay so pre-mill the 1970s 80s and 90s guys patriarchal guys
01:12:51 homeschool movement guys i think there's some hyper patriarchy there i'll get to some of that
01:12:57 and then the patriarchal guys the resurgence of patriarchy the guys today just to recap the
01:13:03 differences, pre-mill, post-mill,
01:13:07 dispensational, covenantal,
01:13:10 Arminian, decisionism, revivalism
01:13:13 versus reformed, security of the believer,
01:13:18 grace and tota.
01:13:21 Independent fundamental Baptist,
01:13:25 confessional, historical,
01:13:28 reformed Christianity.
01:13:33 and baptizing someone in your backyard swimming pool as a dad because at the end of the day
01:13:41 dads are the ultimate authority in all the world and so we're baptizing someone in our swimming
01:13:48 pool and we're giving you know salting crackers and welter's grape juice on the couch and it's
01:13:56 just our family and that's church versus churchmen the biblical patriarchy guys today are churchmen
01:14:03 every single one of us is a local pastor in a confessionally reformed church that rightly
01:14:11 administers the word and sacrament it can trace our views throughout 2 000 years of church history
01:14:18 and then again certainly in the scripture itself i'm just saying these are some big distinctions
01:14:24 these are big distinctions all right michael and debbie pearl
01:14:32 some people love the pearls
01:14:34 I don't know
01:14:38 I'm not going to speak to a bunch of stuff
01:14:44 because
01:14:44 I want to speak to what I know
01:14:47 I want to speak to what I know
01:14:50 so if you ask
01:14:52 Joel were you shaped by the pearls ministry
01:14:54 I did not even know
01:14:56 who they were
01:14:57 not even the names
01:15:00 of these individuals until very recently so no i'm not shaped by their ministry whatsoever
01:15:07 the little bit that i've seen of it are clips which i understand can be taken out of context
01:15:11 but even given the fact that things can be taken out of context i've been taken out of context i
01:15:15 know what that's like still the clips themselves are just i don't know it's it's bad it's weird
01:15:25 it's just weird so i'll speak to a couple things at least one thing that's kind of going around
01:15:34 right now in the twitterverse and you know and it was one of the things in the documentary the
01:15:39 shiny happy people doc blanket time all right let's talk about blanket time this is the idea
01:15:45 where you put a child and not just a child but you put a baby right six months old that's literally
01:15:51 what was said that's a quote six months old the baby you know it's by that time is you know just
01:15:56 learned how to sit up you sit the baby on a blanket and it's not just the baby's on a blanket
01:16:02 you know and has some toys around them to entertain themselves because mama's doing something and she's
01:16:06 trying to go as fast as she can she's she'll come back you know and be with the baby no this is um
01:16:10 the baby's on the blanket the baby's being told to be still to be content i mean the baby can wiggle
01:16:15 a little bit but the baby needs to be on the blanket the baby needs to you know for the most
01:16:20 part be still and we're going to put a toy in front of the baby on the blanket that the baby
01:16:28 wants and again we're not talking about you know 16 year old child we're talking about six months
01:16:32 seven months eight months and uh you're putting it on the blanket you're telling the baby don't
01:16:37 you touch this and it's just just to test the baby train the baby right um and if the baby
01:16:47 touches it you slap their hand now my position is not that the slap on the hand is abusive um so my
01:16:53 position is not that you know that that this group that this movement was saying you know like you
01:16:58 take a crowbar and you hit the baby and like of course that that's slander i don't think that like
01:17:05 this was some horrible violent physically violent action the bible affirms spanking i affirm spanking 0.98
01:17:12 um what i don't like is is this is what i'll say you know in this instance i'm with doug wilson
01:17:19 not with the pearls i'm with doug wilson not with the pearls um doug wilson has talked about this
01:17:26 and said it's important that we remember that adam and eve when they're placed in the garden
01:17:30 there is a tree and this tree is not just in some far off corner of the garden but the bible says
01:17:35 you know this tree that's off limits the day you eat of it you shall surely die is placed in the
01:17:40 midst of the garden it's in the middle of the garden it's the tree of the knowledge of the good
01:17:43 of uh the knowledge of good and evil and it's in the midst of the garden but here's the deal
01:17:50 everything else in the garden is is a yes is the way that Doug says he says there's only one no
01:17:59 every other in fact that was the lie of the serpent the serpent comes slithers up to Eve and
01:18:05 says, has God said, you know, that you can't eat the fruit of any tree, right? He twists it,
01:18:11 tries to make God to be capricious and cruel. God said you can't eat of any tree in the garden.
01:18:17 Isn't that spiteful and mean? But that's not what God has said. God said you can't eat of
01:18:26 one tree which means you know god defining one no god was consequently defining everything else
01:18:37 as a yes so you can you can eat from a million trees god is saying yes to a million trees
01:18:45 and saying no to to one just one and so um with the baby blanket thing the baby can't walk
01:18:58 you know and if it's a young baby six months seven months which that that is an age six months was
01:19:03 cited um then you're talking about a baby that can't even crawl and and so you're not talking
01:19:09 about a scenario where the baby has a million options available there's a million toys that
01:19:16 the baby can play with but one toy that the baby can't play with no in this scenario there's only
01:19:21 one thing within their reach and it's a no see with adam and eve there's there's everything is
01:19:29 within their reach and it's a yes except for one in the baby blanket time scenario
01:19:35 only one thing is within their reach and it's a no
01:19:39 i i think that's bad parenting
01:19:44 i think it's bad parenting here's another distinction adam and eve
01:19:51 adam and eve are not placed they're not made and placed in the garden
01:19:55 as six month old babies so there is one no if you eat of this tree the day you
01:20:02 eat of it you shall surely die and god is giving his law word about the one tree that's off limits
01:20:08 he's giving this word to adam and adam is not a six-month-old baby adam is not a toddler adam is
01:20:14 a grown man and there is a distinction and this parents need to understand this parents within
01:20:21 the patriarchal conservative reform camp which i'm a part of proudly you need to understand
01:20:26 especially with young children i i believe that there's a place for disciplining young children
01:20:31 there is you need to start young but you need to understand there is a distinction between
01:20:36 finitude and fallenness finitude and fallenness
01:20:42 god knows our frame he knows that we are dust
01:20:48 it's not just that god knows our nature in the sense that we're fallen and that we've rebelled
01:20:58 against God doesn't just know that we're sinful he knows that we're finite finitude versus
01:21:05 fallenness Adam and Eve their fall was was a fall it wasn't mere finitude it wasn't just that they
01:21:15 were creatures it's that they chose to sin it really was sin it's not a lack of understanding
01:21:22 it's not a disconnect in communication
01:21:25 it's not
01:21:27 some kind of
01:21:28 discrepancy
01:21:32 in their rationale and ability
01:21:34 it's not about ability
01:21:37 they just
01:21:38 they willfully chose to sin against God
01:21:40 that's what it is
01:21:43 that's not necessarily the case with a
01:21:46 six month old baby, now that's not to say
01:21:48 again, I think discipline starts early
01:21:50 I think it does. And I think babies can understand a lot more than we give them credit for.
01:21:55 In the case of my children, I'm a father of four, my wife and I, we started discipline,
01:22:02 not for everything, but we would say, okay, there's a couple of things
01:22:05 that we believe at this stage of life are worthy of discipline. And that stage of life
01:22:11 beginning was usually around 10 to 12 months. So right around the one year mark where it's
01:22:17 no longer just the baby's crying because they're hungry, but it's no, the baby's crying because
01:22:22 they're not getting their way. And you can tell the difference between defiance and finitude.
01:22:28 You can tell the difference between hunger and a fit. And about that age, you know, that's when
01:22:34 the baby starts rearing and arching its back and screaming, you know, not because they're hungry
01:22:39 or not because they're hurting, not because they just need to be comforted, but because you told
01:22:45 them no uh you you did not give them what they wanted and you actually had a reason for it you
01:22:51 weren't just testing them trying them and setting them up to fail you you know that you were being
01:22:57 a good parent and the baby's just sinning so i believe in you know in disciplining children
01:23:04 i believe in starting young um another doug wilson ism uh you know he says that uh the vast
01:23:12 majority if not all of the spankings that parents give to their children should occur
01:23:17 before the you know from from ages zero to five years old and you know my oldest right now is
01:23:26 going to be turning six in a few months and i can tell you that um that's what it's been
01:23:31 and that's not to say that oh well now you know my my soon-to-be six-year-old is sinless
01:23:36 no but it's but but she has she's amazing she's amazing she's obedient she honors her father and
01:23:46 mother because we were diligent by god's grace it's not because we're great but by god's grace
01:23:52 we had you know some you know we're turned on to some some good curriculum and good books and
01:23:58 and you know good mentoring when it comes to parenting young children early on and so we
01:24:04 didn't waste time a lot of parents who are grounding their teenagers right so they're they're
01:24:11 they're 15 year old 16 year old you're grounded for a month know this know that um and they're
01:24:16 and their teenagers are just just a terror just a wreck you know and to the point where even
01:24:23 christians it's become this common expression of like well you know kids are great but wait
01:24:27 till the teenage years no i reject that no the teenage years can be can be great i know
01:24:34 plenty of people i'm not there yet i i admit that but i know plenty of christian parents who have
01:24:39 teenagers and and by their own admission they're constantly saying it is such a blessing and joy
01:24:46 to have a 14 year old 15 year old 16 year old our children our teenage children are wonderful
01:24:53 but these are parents who disciplined when the children were young the parents who have teenagers
01:24:58 who are a nightmare are usually the parents who did not discipline right so the parents who and
01:25:03 see this is the irony so the parents who say it would be abusive to spank my three-year-old
01:25:07 but now you're locking your 13 year old in their room
01:25:12 and that's not abusive so i'm going to ground my teenager for a month 0.77
01:25:20 but god forbid i i barely slap the hand of my 18 month old
01:25:27 and and and that's the i mean it's a tragic irony i mean the bible says for a reason right people
01:25:34 say you know spoil the the the child or spare the rod spoil the child that's not a bible verse i
01:25:39 understand um i'll tell you what is a bible verse he who spares the rod hates his child so you're
01:25:45 right spare the rod spoil the child is not a bible verse but sparing the rod being hatred of the
01:25:52 child is a bible verse it is and this is not my definition i'm not trying to this is not a hashtag
01:25:58 based moment where i'm trying to just you know provoke according to god's word god's standard
01:26:04 um a lot of professing christians they they hate their children gentle parenting i'm going to do
01:26:12 gentle parenting you mean hateful parenting do you mean hateful parenting according to god's
01:26:19 standard because god tells us what is loving towards children and what is hating children
01:26:26 and in that instance these guys from the 70s and 80s and 90s they were right they weren't they're
01:26:31 not wrong about everything there were a lot of good christian saints in these movements from what
01:26:36 what i can tell who who rightly understood that discipline is loving so long as it's done biblically
01:26:42 and it's done well and that's true that's absolutely true but then some of them like
01:26:49 the pearls on record in their books in their literature talk about continuing to discipline
01:26:54 the child all the way up until they're 18 and and not just discipline but discipline
01:26:59 specifically in the vein of spanking physical corporal punishment and i would just i disagree
01:27:09 and i don't know anybody again i'm just i'm just letting you know some of the distinctions
01:27:14 between these patriarchal guys and the patriarchal guys today this resurgence of biblical patriarchy
01:27:21 we are reformed we're not arminian we're confessional we're not independent fundamentalist
01:27:28 baptist we are post-male we're not pre-male we're covenantal we're not dispensational
01:27:33 and 99% of our spanking happens from 0 to 5 years old
01:27:38 and not at 16, 17 and 18 years old
01:27:42 and those are some big differences
01:27:47 and the patriarchal guys that I know today
01:27:51 we don't do blanket tie
01:27:52 we don't like that
01:27:55 I'm not a fan
01:27:56 because we don't see that as what God does
01:28:00 that God only makes one available resource for us
01:28:05 and then demonizes it.
01:28:09 No, God makes a million available resources for us
01:28:13 and calls it good and blesses it
01:28:17 and holds it out to us for our enjoyment
01:28:20 and says that one thing is off limits.
01:28:23 And God didn't do that with six-month-olds.
01:28:26 He did it with adults.
01:28:28 those are radical differences so anyways um those are some of my thoughts
01:28:36 uh let me see i might have had one more thing
01:28:39 i wrote down notes this time oh you know what the duggars quiverful or you might be familiar
01:28:48 with the term uh onanism uh this is something that i had to really think about um because i had
01:28:54 some individuals in the church that i pastored in southern california who who hopped on this train
01:29:00 and so you know i was working through that and and you know theologically giving it a fair shake
01:29:05 you know because everyone's like well you know that's ridiculous well we think a lot of things
01:29:09 are ridiculous because we've been steeped in feminism um and so you know looking at you know 0.98
01:29:16 all right do christians in the last 15 minutes think this is ridiculous or you know is this the 0.99
01:29:20 witness of church history? And what does the Bible, most importantly, what does that say?
01:29:25 I think that in general, Christians today, not just people, but even Christians today,
01:29:30 despise children. They want to have, you know, 1.5 children. At the end of the day, 0.78
01:29:36 they don't really think that children are a blessing and that the man whose quiver is full
01:29:42 is exceedingly blessed, right? The children are a heritage from the Lord. Blessed is the man whose
01:29:46 quiver is full that a man is blessed if he has many children so i i think that the headline of
01:29:52 the story the headline report again not just from the pagans but from evangelical christians
01:29:59 in the west today the headline report is uh that they do not view children as a blessing
01:30:06 not in such a way that they would see it as an added blessing to have several children
01:30:11 and there is there's a legitimate argument to be made for what other blessing all right so if
01:30:19 children are a blessing a heritage from the lord and a man is blessed if his quiver is full right
01:30:25 not just you know white picket fence and 1.5 children but but a full quiver many children
01:30:30 that man is exceedingly blessed if that's the case well there are other things in scripture
01:30:34 that are listed as blessings what other blessing in life would we want to mitigate
01:30:39 right so money is not the root of all evil or all kinds of evil rather the scripture says that the
01:30:46 love of money is a root of all kinds of evil so greed the love of money idolatry of money but
01:30:52 money itself is not inherently good or bad money itself if used wisely is actually a blessing
01:30:59 it's a resource it's merely representative money is just like god giving you cattle
01:31:05 or food or clothes or house or land and those aren't bad things these are things that natural
01:31:12 resources that god made he owns the cattle on a thousand hills and if he gives those thousand
01:31:16 thousand cattle to someone that he loves that's that's great that's great so christian
01:31:22 um are we actively seeking consciously seeking intentionally making certain decisions to say
01:31:29 um without you know i i i could make a million dollars a year without without sinning without
01:31:40 sinning without neglecting something that lord's called me to and i can do it ethically and all
01:31:44 these kinds of things still be with my wife and still be with my children and still be involved
01:31:47 in my church and still fear the lord and i can make a million dollars a year or i can make a
01:31:52 hundred thousand dollars a year and i have intentionally deliberately opted for making
01:31:56 100 000 not a million because i see this as a blessing but i just want to put a cap on that
01:32:02 blessing i want to mitigate that blessing i want to harness that blessing you know shrink that
01:32:07 blessing you don't want to have too much blessing here right what other blessing is my point what
01:32:13 other blessing would we go to such great lengths to shrink and yet the bible says that children
01:32:23 are a premier blessing of the Lord and again I'm not talking about the pagans I'm not talking about
01:32:30 the progressives I'm talking about evangelical Christians our Bible says Psalm 127 children
01:32:35 are a heritage from the Lord a blessing from the Lord and a man whose quiver is full he is exceedingly
01:32:40 blessed and we go to great lengths to make sure that we mitigate that blessing from the Lord
01:32:48 so that's that's the headline right see one of the problems with all this kind of stuff is
01:32:54 the footnote becomes a headline the headline becomes the footnote all right so the headline
01:33:00 right now is feminism the headline in our culture today and the headline in the church today is
01:33:06 feminism not abusive patriarchy let's get that straight and the headline in the church not just
01:33:11 the world but the church today is despising children not having too many children and that's
01:33:19 the whole problem just for the record that's the whole problem with the rise and fall of mars hill
01:33:23 and shiny happy people that's my biggest problem with these things right so i've spent all this
01:33:29 time distinguishing saying okay you the patriarchal guys today there are some radical differences
01:33:34 significant doctrinal differences and behavioral differences character differences parenting
01:33:40 differences from these patriarchal guys and myself and other you know today's patriarchal guys
01:33:47 but having established that that there are distinctions and the distinctions matter
01:33:54 having established that let me tell you what i hate what i hate about the rise and fall of mars
01:34:00 hill what i hate about shiny happy people what i hate is that they lie and and they may not lie
01:34:09 with each little detail. The lie is not with the individual trees, the individual statements,
01:34:17 this statement being made. The lie is the forest. Not an individual tree, but the whole forest. The
01:34:23 lie is just the headline of the story. Because the headline of the story is, you know, there's
01:34:30 an epidemic of harsh, quarrelsome pastors in the church who are being divisive. No, there's an
01:34:39 epidemic of limp-wristed effeminate cowardly pastors in the church you know that that's the 1.00
01:34:47 epidemic there's an epidemic of abusive patriarchal no there's an epidemic of feminist 1.00
01:34:53 you know that's the epidemic 0.90
01:34:57 and as it pertains to men there's an epidemic of apathy not not men being abusive
01:35:06 but men in their god-ordained role of headship being apathetic abdicating their authority
01:35:15 not abusing that authority but abdicating that authority men can sin in both directions
01:35:22 they can sin as head of their wife and head of their children they can sin by abuse
01:35:28 and they can sin by abdicating
01:35:30 we just got to stand back for a second and look at the forest not just one isolated tree look at
01:35:37 the forest and just be honest in america in the united states of america in 2023 the year of our
01:35:45 lord what's the big failure what's the headline of the story right now with men is it that men
01:35:55 are just too masculine too domineering too aggressive right abusive in their authority
01:36:05 and leadership is that the headline sure we can there there are always some but is that the 0.99
01:36:11 headline or is the headline that men are cowardly weak abdicating responsibility
01:36:18 not living in their authority whatsoever 0.98
01:36:22 and effeminate not overly masculine but effeminate not masculine enough and that's my big problem
01:36:32 that was my problem with you know the christianity today you know joke of a podcast
01:36:41 with mars hill and that's my problem with the happy you know shiny happy people
01:36:47 thing right now on amazon prime um
01:36:51 you make the footnote the headline it's gaslighting it's just it's which shouldn't
01:36:59 shock us it's the same play from the political left it's the same thing that democrats do
01:37:04 right it's the same kind of documentary that jen saki would make right which shouldn't be
01:37:12 shocking at all because christianity today is filled with a bunch of democrats
01:37:16 who vote for abortion pro-abortion candidates all the way to birth
01:37:22 and the shiny happy people are a bunch of god-hating democrats of course they are
01:37:31 and the people who are being interviewed
01:37:34 have purple and pink hair
01:37:35 so yeah
01:37:41 I think that we need to be discerning
01:37:44 as Christians and we need to know
01:37:46 when we're being
01:37:47 gaslighted we need to have
01:37:50 enough discernment to say I know this play
01:37:51 I know this play
01:37:54 this is just
01:37:56 your typical progressive
01:37:57 God hating 1.00
01:37:59 all christians are bad all men are bad male headship across the board is bad patriarchy 1.00
01:38:06 across the board is bad homeschooling is cultish parenting is bad that's what it is that's what 0.99
01:38:14 this documentary is trying to accomplish that's the point that's the goal and it'll prove to be
01:38:20 successful with a lot of people i think as bible believing jesus loving family loving church loving
01:38:28 Christians. We need to be able to say, look, we need to be able to say exactly what I said in
01:38:34 this podcast. Yeah, I disagree with this. I disagree with that. And this is a distinction.
01:38:40 That's a distinction. That's a distinction. That's a distinction. There are real objective
01:38:44 theological distinctions and they matter. And yet two things can be simultaneously true.
01:38:51 I am not the pearls
01:38:54 I am not Bill Gotham
01:38:56 I am not the Duggars
01:38:58 but I also know 0.99
01:39:00 that Amazon hates Jesus
01:39:02 and that they're not trying
01:39:07 to simply carefully
01:39:08 in a fair good faith way
01:39:10 draw out real abuses
01:39:12 from some individuals
01:39:13 while acknowledging
01:39:14 that Christianity as a whole
01:39:16 is a positive
01:39:16 a net positive influence
01:39:19 in the world today
01:39:19 no
01:39:20 they're not trying to take out Bill Gotham they're trying to take out you they're trying to take out
01:39:28 me and some will say yeah they want to take out you Joel that's because you're patriarchal no no
01:39:32 no you're complementarian with your one million nuances yeah they hate you too right that's what's
01:39:40 so funny you know I think of like with G3 and the Christian nationalism thing which you know
01:39:44 by God's grace we're having some conversations offline and I feel hopeful we'll see what happens
01:39:50 but all that being said good brothers good brothers but you know one of the things that
01:39:54 i've said is that josh bice you know if if the left is completely take over the neo-marxist
01:40:00 take over and the you know and we all get shipped off to the gulag the irony is that josh bice will
01:40:06 have spent you know all the time that he spent to nuance and to be clear that i am not a christian
01:40:10 nationalist and yet me and him will be sharing a cell in the gulag together that the pagans don't
01:40:16 care the pagans aren't looking at g3 and saying oh wow what a charitable nuance really appreciate
01:40:21 that that really makes a difference there no they're looking at me who's just saying yeah
01:40:25 i'm just going to wear the label because because you're going to call me a christian nationalist
01:40:28 no matter what i do if you're a bible believing christian guess what you're a christian nationalist
01:40:33 yeah sure you can to blue in the face you can you know not call yourself that but you're going to
01:40:40 be called that by everybody else. And so all that being said, I wanted to draw out the real
01:40:47 theological distinction because I think we can do patriarchy better. I think we can do it more
01:40:51 biblically. And I think there actually are some pitfalls and failures. And so I know,
01:40:56 and it does matter, there's a difference between me and Bill Gothard. There's a difference between
01:40:59 me and Michael Perl. There is a difference between someone who's reformed and someone who's
01:41:04 arminian there's a difference between boomer con theology that's existed for 15 minutes versus
01:41:11 robust historical confessional christianity and that's the resurgence it's coming from that
01:41:18 and it matters and it makes a difference however in terms of the enemy in terms of their perspective
01:41:26 there's no difference at all
01:41:30 Bill Gothard
01:41:31 Doug Wilson
01:41:33 same thing
01:41:34 Michael Pearl
01:41:37 Michael Foster
01:41:39 same thing
01:41:40 right
01:41:42 Jim Bob Duggar
01:41:45 Joel Webin
01:41:47 same thing
01:41:48 and that's the real enemy that we're facing
01:41:52 and for them
01:41:53 the doctoral distinctives
01:41:56 that are real and objective and matter
01:41:58 don't matter.
01:41:59 Not to them.
01:42:02 And that's why we need to be able to
01:42:03 watch a documentary like this, or don't.
01:42:06 Feel free not to.
01:42:07 But if you must, if you do,
01:42:10 we need to be able to watch a documentary like this.
01:42:12 We need to be able to see the real failures,
01:42:15 learn from them,
01:42:17 do better,
01:42:18 hold to better doctrine,
01:42:20 more biblical doctrine,
01:42:22 but also at the end of the day
01:42:24 realize that the real play
01:42:26 the forest not just individual trees but the forest is that the god haters hate all of us 0.61
01:42:33 we're all christian nationalists to them we're all abusive patriarchal guys to them
01:42:39 and if we think that for them for the enemy that our articulation of theological distinctions is
01:42:49 going to matter we're just we're naive we're kidding ourselves so we we better get used to
01:42:56 being hated we better get used to being hated and we better have a plan and we better have some grit
01:43:05 some gravitas a spine some courage but we're not going to make it we're just not going to make it
01:43:14 All right. One last time. Important announcement. Blueprints for Christendom 2.0. This is our
01:43:22 spring conference, March 1st, 2nd, and 3rd. That's a Friday, Saturday, and Sunday of next year,
01:43:27 2024. We've got Douglas Wilson, Brian Sauve, Dr. Joe Boot, myself, and the newest addition that
01:43:34 we're announcing today is that Michael Foster from It's Good to Be a Man has joined our lineup.
01:43:39 He's going to be talking about biblical patriarchy. And at one point during the conference,
01:43:43 it's actually going to be on Friday, that's March 1st, we're going to have a 90-minute panel
01:43:47 with myself and Michael Foster and Doug Wilson and also Eric Kahn from Hard Man Podcast. The
01:43:54 four of us, Eric, Michael, Doug, and myself, are going to do a 90-minute panel all about biblical
01:43:59 patriarchy. And it's going to just be a further fleshing out discussion of some of the things
01:44:05 that I've talked about in today's episode. You're not going to want to miss this conference, so go
01:44:10 and register as soon as possible.
01:44:12 You can go to rightresponseconference.com.
01:44:15 Again, that's rightresponseconference.com
01:44:18 to register today.
01:44:20 Thanks for tuning in and God bless.
01:44:38 Can I be frank with you for just a second?
01:44:40 right here at the end. Look, some of you guys, you're financially supporting this ministry,
01:44:44 and from the bottom of my heart, I say thank you. I cannot thank you enough. However, some of you,
01:44:51 you just, you can't afford it. In fact, some of you, you shouldn't afford it. Let's be honest.
01:44:58 I mean, we're living in Joe Biden's ridiculous economy. Our nation and our totalitarian political 0.94
01:45:06 elites lost their minds over the last three years due to COVID. We have written checks that we
01:45:14 simply cannot cash. It doesn't matter if people change the definition of a recession. We are
01:45:20 living in a recession right now regardless. Some of you are struggling to afford a carton of eggs
01:45:27 at the grocery store. You cannot support financially this ministry at this time, nor should
01:45:34 you, but you could still help us tremendously. I am asking you, please, if you're willing to do so,
01:45:41 take one minute of your time. Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform,
01:45:48 iTunes, Spotify, whatever that might be. This is the way the system works. We want to be
01:45:53 innocent as doves, but shrewd as vipers. We need to be strategic. You leave us a five-star review
01:46:00 and our podcast shows up for more people and the word of God and courageous theology applied in
01:46:09 practical ways to every realm of life gets out there. Help us get it out there. Thanks for tuning in.