The NXR Podcast - April 02, 2024


THE CONFERENCE - Biblical Patriarchy - Session 4 - Eric Conn | Blueprints for Christendom 2.0 2024

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW - The Real Truth About The Crusades & Why It Matters with The Kings Hall THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - The Lost City of Atlantis Was Just Found!

Episode Stats


Length

53 minutes

Words per minute

157.28

Word count

8,470

Sentence count

562

Harmful content

Misogyny

65

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

73

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Pastor Dusty Devers is a man of courage. He was brave enough to stand up for biblical patriarchy and speak against it in a speech at the Evangelical Theological Society of America in 2000. In this episode, Pastor Devers shares the story of a woman who sent her husband to work as a promise keeper so that her husband could reconnect with other men his age.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you, Pastor Joel. I appreciate the height of this podium.
00:00:05 We have some pastors at our church who are about 6'5", and normally I'm reaching and leaning in so that I can get to the microphone.
00:00:13 But they made this one short. Joel actually has to lean down, which is also quite interesting.
00:00:20 As we look at everything that's going on in our culture, it's an encouragement to me.
00:00:24 You know, we've heard Dusty speak, we've heard Joel, we've heard Pastor Brian.
00:00:29 And what an encouragement that God has not left his church in the dark without teachers or alone.
00:00:35 Amen?
00:00:37 At this point, let's pray.
00:00:39 I want to pray for us and then we'll get started on today's talk,
00:00:41 which will be recovering a vision for biblical patriarchy.
00:00:46 Let's pray.
00:00:48 Father, we thank you so much for the souls gathered here.
00:00:51 We thank you that you are faithful to your bride, to the church.
00:00:56 God, we ask that you would continue to build her up in faithfulness.
00:01:00 Lord, we thank you, especially for the men gathered here, that you have made them bold.
00:01:06 We thank you for Dusty Devers, for his faith that he's willing to put into action.
00:01:10 We pray for his family as well.
00:01:12 God, would you give them courage as they are fighting literally demonic powers?
00:01:17 Would you put your arms and your angels around them?
00:01:20 Would you protect them?
00:01:22 Father, would you also inspire other men to be raised up, that they too may be courageous,
00:01:27 that they may fight the good fight of the faith.
00:01:30 Lord, and help us to see that our generations are brought to you.
00:01:35 God, we ask all these things in the high name of Jesus Christ, our King.
00:01:39 Amen.
00:01:41 Amen.
00:01:41 Well, I want to begin this talk again on biblical patriarchy, everybody's favorite doctrine.
00:01:46 particularly if you're a feminist on Twitter you you probably hate me you might know who I am
00:01:52 maybe you blocked me that's okay but I want to start this talk with actually a talk that comes
00:01:59 from the year 2000 or rather in the 2000s this talk is what I think is fantastically good one
00:02:08 theologian stood at the Evangelical Theological Society to deliver a scathing indictment of the
00:02:14 American church. And a feminist followed him, so you know how brave he was actually being in this 0.77
00:02:21 situation. And he specifically addressed the failure of complementarianism to make much of a
00:02:26 dent in the orthodoxy or the orthopraxy of the church, right? The complementarian doctrines,
00:02:33 which had been around since the early 90s, 1989 and following, had made little impact, both on
00:02:38 the teaching of the church, but worse, on the practice of the church. Complementarianism had
00:02:44 become, he said, a weak compromise with feminist teachings. As such, it had resulted in a church 0.73
00:02:50 that was softly patriarchal, he said on paper, but fundamentally egalitarian in practice.
00:02:57 Wasn't that what we find in the church so much today? We use words like headship,
00:03:02 but they mean nothing, right? For all intents and purposes, he said, the conservative
00:03:07 and the complementarian wing of the church was pragmatically egalitarian. 0.79
00:03:13 Now, among other signs of demise, the speaker noted how many wives are encouraged to work outside the home
00:03:19 and how child care is relegated to daycares and public schools. 0.72
00:03:25 You know how excited people get when you talk about women working outside the home,
00:03:29 particularly in our secular spaces on Twitter.
00:03:33 Now, this brave speaker told the story of one complementarian wife who sent her husband to promise keepers.
00:03:40 She sent him to promise keepers. 0.94
00:03:42 Thank you for laughing because that is ridiculous. 0.72
00:03:45 She said she did it. 0.93
00:03:47 She told this to a sociologist so that her husband could, quote, reconnect with other men his age.
00:03:54 Of this incident, the speaker said this, and I find this fitting.
00:03:58 He said, this complementarian woman does not seem to recognize that she is sending her husband off to be with one his own age as though she were a mother sending her grade school son off to summer youth camp. 0.85
00:04:11 How often does this sort of thing happen in the church today?
00:04:15 Well, quite frequently.
00:04:17 Likewise, our speaker said, because the church had blindly adopted psychotherapeutic practices, which he said, and he's right,
00:04:26 They're inherently Marxist and anti-hierarchical.
00:04:30 Think of Freud.
00:04:32 Because of this, evangelicals had neutered headship of any meaningful authority.
00:04:37 Instead, the church had foolishly adopted a servant-leader model.
00:04:41 This comes largely out of the Promise Keeper's movement.
00:04:46 Servant leadership is what we got.
00:04:48 And what it did was empty the concept of virtually all its authoritative character of actual biblical headship.
00:04:56 So the speaker, also being brave, he said, what should we do about this?
00:05:00 And this is actually when I think it gets really good.
00:05:03 We had a simple and clear solution for the church moving forward.
00:05:07 It was not appeasement, as you see from so many people today.
00:05:12 No, but he said that the church needed to recover biblical patriarchy.
00:05:16 And I want to quote from him.
00:05:18 He said, quote, unless evangelical churches are willing to be countercultural
00:05:23 against not just the secular culture, and here's the thing I want to underline, not just against
00:05:30 the secular culture, but also against the evangelical establishment itself. That's what
00:05:37 we're facing. He said, unless we do that, the future of complementarian Christianity is in fact
00:05:43 bleak. He went on to say, more patriarchal complementarianism will resonate among a
00:05:49 generation seeking stability in a family-fractured Western culture in ways that soft-bellied, big-tent
00:05:56 complementarianism never can. So he's advocating we need to be bold. We need to oppose all the
00:06:03 sexual craziness that's going on in our culture and specifically in our churches. Well, he rightly
00:06:09 pointed out that patriarchy is not a secondary issue within Christian theology. It's a matter
00:06:15 of vital importance. Many of you, rightly so, would ask the question, as you come to a conference
00:06:21 like this, okay, covenant succession, I get that one, that's important. Post-millennialism, I get
00:06:26 that, that's important, but really patriarchy. Why is that in this series of talks for building
00:06:33 Christendom 2.0? Well, C.S. Lewis was wise to this, and our speaker pointed it out. In fact, C.S. Lewis
00:06:41 included male headship as part of his book, Mere Christianity. Well, why did he do that?
00:06:48 The speaker says this, male headship has been asserted and assumed by the Christian church
00:06:54 with virtual unanimity from the first century until the rise of contemporary feminism.
00:07:01 That's a bold statement in the church today. Patriarchy has been the baseline for 2,000 years,
00:07:07 and only recently have we abandoned it. He went on to say this, if we are to reclaim the debate,
00:07:14 we must not fear making a claim that is disturbingly counter-cultural, and yet,
00:07:20 he said, strikingly biblical, patriarchy. Patriarchy is a claim that the less than
00:07:27 evangelical feminists understand increasingly. Indeed, he said Christianity is undergirded by 0.98
00:07:33 a vision of patriarchy. Now, finally, our speaker concluded by saying this, patriarchy for the
00:07:41 Christian is essential. Egalitarians are winning the evangelical gender debate, not because their
00:07:47 arguments are stronger, but because in some sense, we are all egalitarian now. That's the reality we
00:07:55 have to face in the church. Practically speaking, most people are egalitarian or feminist. He went 0.98
00:08:02 on to say this, our response must be more than simply a reaction. It must instead present an
00:08:09 alternative vision, a vision that sums up the burden of male headship under the cosmic rubric
00:08:15 of the gospel of Christ and the restoration of all things in him. It must produce churches that
00:08:20 are not embarrassed. We cannot be embarrassed that when we say our father, we mean that we
00:08:27 are patriarchs of the oldest kind. Amen indeed. What a great speech, right? It's phenomenally
00:08:35 accurate. The majority of Christians today really are functionally egalitarian. Headship has been
00:08:42 robbed of its authority. Why? Because we have ignored scripture for too long. We have ignored
00:08:48 the faith of our fathers on this issue of biblical sexuality, and we've let the woke sociologists do
00:08:55 are theologizing for us. Now, despite having greater power and influence than ever, think
00:09:00 about this. How many churches are on every street corner in the South? How much money does the
00:09:07 gospel coalition have in these major conference circuits? How much money is represented? And yet
00:09:13 for all that, the church is being more shaped by the world than it is shaping the world. Why is this?
00:09:20 why is it that evangelical leadership has in mass betrayed us on the issue of biblical sexuality
00:09:28 well this failure of church leadership is i think typified most by the speaker himself
00:09:35 well who was this brave speaker oh it was none other than dr russell moore
00:09:41 right russell moore the now leftist editor-in-chief at christianity yesterday
00:09:47 right his speech if you try to find this has been scrubbed from almost every major publication
00:09:54 in which it was linked denny burke cbmw ets it's all gone you can't find it
00:10:01 and in 2023 russell moore said this in an article for christianity today he said i put more trust
00:10:10 in Beth Moore today, that is the Anglican lady priestrics, right? I put more trust in Beth Moore
00:10:19 today than Russell Moore when I delivered that speech. This is where we are as evangelical
00:10:25 leadership has left us, right? The patriarchy he once defended was, he said in the article,
00:10:32 more John Wayne than Jesus, right? An obvious nod to the evangelical left and Kristen Kobaz Dumas.
00:10:40 Now, why do I bring this up in this talk? I want to illustrate by this example just how far the
00:10:48 church has fallen in just 20 years. I mean, think about this today. If you talk about patriarchy
00:10:54 at all, who gets mad on Twitter? It's the conservative Christians. A dark cloud, so it
00:11:02 seems, looms over the church, which seems to have all but abandoned these historic doctrines
00:11:07 of patriarchy. And so I think we are in a desperate lurch. Again, I think as you look at
00:11:15 leaders like Russell Moore, what you see is something like in The Lord of Rings, Saruman.
00:11:20 You exchange the truth for a lie, and what do you get in return? Money, power, power among the
00:11:27 leftist elites especially. But I think as Moore said 20 years ago, our task remains the same.
00:11:34 It's not simply to fight a feminist culture, but to oppose the evangelical establishment itself.
00:11:42 Now, this is a daunting task, no doubt.
00:11:45 It's encouraging to see everybody here, but I wonder if you've ever thought about the fact that maybe there's 800 of us here.
00:11:51 How many Christians are in America?
00:11:54 We really seem to be up against it. 1.00
00:11:58 It's a desperate situation.
00:12:00 and a lot of times people ask me, Eric, do you actually think, do you actually believe
00:12:05 that patriarchy could be recovered? Absolutely. That's my answer as well. Yes, absolutely it can
00:12:13 be recovered. But the more important question is, what is true? As we look at the scriptures,
00:12:19 are we convicted about the clarity of God's word on this issue? So many people have not even looked
00:12:25 at the historic commentaries, the confessions, or the church fathers on these issues.
00:12:32 We listen more to sociologists and psychologists. But there's encouragement for us as well, and I
00:12:38 want to give that to you today. This is not the first time the church has been badly on the ropes.
00:12:47 I love this quote from G.K. Chesterton. Someone asked him about the church, and again, in his time,
00:12:54 there's been lots of times where the church seems to be doing poorly. He said this,
00:12:59 on five occasions in church history, the church has gone to the dogs, but on every occasion it
00:13:05 was the dog that died. This is the church of the Lord Jesus Christ. He conquered the grave. He is
00:13:12 the risen Lord. And so for us, as we seek out his word, and we want to do that today and ask the
00:13:18 question, what is biblical patriarchy? We do so fundamentally from a position of hope.
00:13:25 So if we look at this question, how is patriarchy to be recovered?
00:13:30 Where do we begin with this project?
00:13:33 Well, I love what Dr. Joe Boot, who's here with Ezra Institute,
00:13:37 what he says in his book, The Mission of God.
00:13:39 Every revival, every reformation is fundamentally looking back to the law of God
00:13:44 and to our fathers and doing the deep work of repentance.
00:13:49 I also love what Dr. Martin Lloyd-Jones said about this
00:13:53 when preaching a sermon on Genesis 26.
00:13:57 You'll remember in that passage, Isaac had departed to Gerar,
00:14:01 and the land was without water.
00:14:04 Why was the land without water, I wonder?
00:14:07 Well, the Philistines had stopped the wells of Abraham, Isaac's father.
00:14:11 And so he realized Isaac did his desperate situation.
00:14:16 He realized that his people's survival depended upon him,
00:14:19 and so Isaac re-dug the wells of his father.
00:14:23 Isaac re-dug these ancient wells.
00:14:26 He didn't send for the diviners.
00:14:28 He didn't send for the technocratic experts of his day.
00:14:32 He didn't take a straw poll.
00:14:34 No, he went back to his father's wisdom and he said,
00:14:36 if I know anything about my father, it's that he knows where the water is.
00:14:42 Right?
00:14:42 Abraham knew where to find the living water.
00:14:45 This is what Lloyd-Jones says about that passage in his sermon.
00:14:51 He says, 1.00
00:14:51 the man who experiments in the midst of a crisis is a fool. There is great value in the readings 0.99
00:14:58 of church history and the study of the past, and nothing surely is more important for us
00:15:03 at this present time than to read the history of the past and to discover its message afresh.
00:15:11 The issue today, he said, is that we think that our problems are new and that we think that they
00:15:17 are unique. And the church and the world have never been confronted by such problems before.
00:15:23 But Lloyd-Jones said, and I find this quite helpful, every time you get one of these great
00:15:28 and glorious and mighty periods of true revival, you will find that in every instance it seems to
00:15:34 be a returning to something that had been obtained before. Every time the church is thus revived,
00:15:40 she seems to be doing what Isaac did. She is going back to something that had happened before,
00:15:45 rediscovering it and finding that ancient supply and so there is nothing that I know of Lloyd
00:15:50 Jones writes that is more striking in the history of the church than just this principle
00:15:56 all right so as we discuss patriarchy we'll lay out some points general principles and points for
00:16:02 what is biblical patriarchy we have to face the fact that our need is not something novel or new
00:16:08 or faddish, right? How many times do we have to read a new sociological study or read from a
00:16:15 professor at the University of Oklahoma or wherever else? Sorry, Oklahoma, right? We have to read from
00:16:22 these professors that we now know that the word effeminacy doesn't mean effeminacy because
00:16:28 somebody in 2024 found out that the church fathers and everybody else for 2,000 years was
00:16:33 quite simply wrong, right? That is, of course, nonsense. We don't need a new definition from
00:16:40 Rachel Hollis about motherhood or womanhood. We don't need a new defense of lady pastors 0.99
00:16:46 from an up-and-coming lady pastorics in training at a reform denomination. And we're all going to
00:16:54 pretend, by the way, along the way that she won't ever become a preacher, even though that's what
00:16:59 keeps happening, right? Our starting point, most of all, cannot be appeasement of our culture.
00:17:07 I appreciate so much what Dusty Devers had to say because I think that is the heart of the issue. 0.58
00:17:12 When you look at biblical sexuality in the church today, I think what you should notice
00:17:16 is that our theology is developed more from cowardice than from the Word of God.
00:17:22 We are simply embarrassed about what Scripture teaches. It was interesting to me that when
00:17:28 Russell Moore in 2023 completely flip-flopped on his position, it wasn't because he came up with a
00:17:33 new interpretation of the text. And so what do we need to do in this moment and in this time is to
00:17:40 go back to our fathers, to Genesis and Abraham, to the patriarchs, to the Puritans, to the reformers.
00:17:49 All right, these are the men who built the first Christendom. And what we need to do is re-dig
00:17:54 their wells and go back and study what our fathers said, right? I think it's fitting that as we go
00:18:01 back and we study them, that we should truly learn what it means to rule well as a king and as a
00:18:08 father. Fundamentally, what we have to do is we have to put the ancient landmark back where it
00:18:14 was moved. And this means that we have to go back and we have to read the old dead guys. Because the
00:18:21 one thing about it is they had problems, but they're not our problems. They weren't enmeshed
00:18:26 in 1960s liberation sexual theology. They had problems, but not those. So what I want to do
00:18:34 now is give just a brief defense of biblical patriarchy. And as we jump into this, I want to
00:18:41 make a couple baseline recommendations. A talk like this is bound to bring many questions.
00:18:47 and so as you have questions it's good to talk to your husbands it's good to talk to pastors
00:18:53 but it's also good to read so i want to recommend to you a book that has been most helpful to me on
00:18:59 this issue which is masculine christianity by mr zach garris he's actually a pca pastor
00:19:05 and he's done a phenomenal job outlining the biblical historical doctrine of patriarchy
00:19:12 This book, by the way, you can get it in hard copy, also Canon, the Canon app.
00:19:17 They have this in audio book.
00:19:18 If you already have the app, you can listen to it there.
00:19:20 But this is a phenomenal book.
00:19:22 The other book I want to recommend is also by Zach Garris.
00:19:26 And this is titled Honor Thy Fathers, Recovering the Anti-Feminist Theology of the Reformers.
00:19:33 And this will be released this summer, Lord willing, from New Christendom Press.
00:19:38 He essentially goes through Calvin, Vermigley, Luther.
00:19:42 He says, what do they have to say about women, biblical sexuality, pertaining to what is now feminism?
00:19:49 The final recommendation I want to give to you, particularly if you're a pastor, 0.73
00:19:54 but anyone studying God's word, is that you rely on the older guys.
00:20:00 So when you're going through commentaries, it was very common, at least for me,
00:20:03 in seminary that we're reading new commentaries.
00:20:05 commentaries. You read R.T. France on the Gospels, and guess what? He has a very egalitarian view
00:20:11 when you get to sexuality. And an older and a wiser pastor told me, he said, really what you
00:20:17 ought to do is your bedrock for sermon preparation should be John Calvin. It should be Matthew Henry.
00:20:24 It should be John Gill. It should be William Gouge. And as I started making that transition in pulpit
00:20:29 ministry, what I started to notice was how backwards we actually are today. I said, wait a
00:20:36 minute, these guys would get canceled on Twitter if they put these things on there. So then I
00:20:40 thought to myself, what if I did it for them? And that's actually one of the most interesting
00:20:47 things. I often get charged with this, but people say, you're just trying to be a shock jock, Eric.
00:20:52 And I say, actually, I was reading William Gouge on the fifth commandment and he's got some burners.
00:20:58 And so here they are for everybody's enjoyment.
00:21:03 So now as we turn to this question of biblical patriarchy, I want to lay this out in nine
00:21:08 basic points.
00:21:09 And again, I want to just emphasize this, the question, so often you'll see this among
00:21:14 reformed pastors even, but people will say things like, well, yeah, that's a cool principle
00:21:18 from Deuteronomy.
00:21:19 And I think it's true, but I just don't think today that's practical, right?
00:21:23 I don't, I just, in my experience, I don't know if that could actually happen.
00:21:26 the fundamental question that you ought to be asking again particularly for pastors
00:21:31 but fathers and husbands the question is not is this popular the question is not is this going
00:21:38 to be practical are the feminists going to like it is taylor swift going to like it that's not
00:21:42 what we're asking right again we're saying is this true and so we begin with clarity
00:21:49 about what the scripture teaches and from clarity we move to courage and then courage means that
00:21:56 somewhere along the lines we're actually going to have to assert these principles we're actually
00:22:01 going to have to live them we're actually going to have to say to a transgender family member 0.56
00:22:06 i'm not going to that wedding and the reason i'm not going is because this is a public
00:22:11 statement and i know that because i've read william gooch
00:22:14 right so in this talk we're tying together confessionalism post-millennial vision and
00:22:22 all the rest hopefully as we go about it the the final thing i'll say as we jump in now and i
00:22:28 promise we're going to jump in right these are general principles and i don't know if you've
00:22:34 ever noticed this pastors probably have definitely when you give general principles in today's
00:22:40 culture, people's minds like short circuit, right? Well, what about the exceptions? I'm going to give
00:22:47 you a general rule that is good for women to be mothers. This is the glory of women, right, is to 1.00
00:22:53 be mothers. And people will say, what about my triple amputee? Well, yeah, that's an exception. 0.75
00:23:02 But we don't make the rules based off the exceptions.
00:23:04 so it's a good practice that as you hear these again if you have questions by all means talk
00:23:11 to your husbands talk to your pastors talk to your friends point number one what is biblical
00:23:19 patriarchy first of all patriarchy simply means father rule right patriarchy means father rule
00:23:26 in our culture patriarchy is obviously a dirty word it's supposedly responsible for every evil
00:23:33 that has ever happened, right? The patriarchy has actually been smashed, so they tell us,
00:23:40 and yet the women who are in charge are killing more babies than ever, if that's in fact what's 0.99
00:23:45 happening, right? Feminists run the day, and yet they tell us it's still the patriarchy's fault, 1.00
00:23:52 right? It's thought that before 1960, pretty much all women were treated like dirt, 1.00
00:23:58 right but again patriarchy means father rule it comes from the greek word patriarches
00:24:04 and is a combination of the words potter for father and arco for rule as zach garris says
00:24:10 in his book it describes the practice of men providing for and protecting women and children
00:24:15 as well as men leading in church and in society right in its simplest form patriarchy means that
00:24:23 father's rule in home church and in society. Now, it's also interesting that Peter and Paul both
00:24:30 use this word, patriarches, and it's always positive. So Acts 2.29, for example, Peter refers
00:24:37 to David the patriarch. They don't seem to be embarrassed about this language. And so if you
00:24:43 ask the question, well, why are we going to use that word? Number one, because it's a lot easier
00:24:47 to say than complementarianism. But number two, I think it is the biblical word that's used to
00:24:54 describe the interplay between the sexes and particularly men leading in these three spheres.
00:25:00 It's a biblical word. We should use the biblical word. I don't really care what the feminists
00:25:04 think about it. So that's number one. Number two, patriarchy is about a multi-generational 1.00
00:25:10 covenantal vision, right? This is what separates Andrew Tate masculinity from what we're talking
00:25:17 about here. Yes, men should be strong, but for what, right? They have to have what Brian just
00:25:23 talked about with a vision for generations and legacy. I don't have strength so that I can spend
00:25:30 it on myself doing the sort of buy a Bugatti and have 30 women in your harem thing that Andrew Tate
00:25:37 does, right? This is a man who has no vision. That's the fundamental problem, among many other
00:25:43 problems. So patriarchy has to be about this multi-generational and covenantal vision that
00:25:51 husbands and fathers have for their families. The Lord is known, by the way, in the Old Testament
00:25:57 as the God of your fathers, right? God meant to impart this vision upon his people and in their
00:26:03 hearts. And when he visited Abraham in Genesis 15, what did he do? Well, he told him to look at the
00:26:10 stars and envision his sons, both numerous and ruling the cosmos, right? This is what Dusty was
00:26:17 talking about. What we want to fill our men with is this hope. Look at your life. Someone did this
00:26:24 with Jonathan Edwards, by the way, and they looked at like 200 years after his life, and it's like
00:26:30 dozens and dozens of his sons are lawyers and senators, probably back when senators were a
00:26:35 better thing, right? They impacted their society. All these people came from him.
00:26:42 This is actually a similar thing, what we find in Virgil's Aeneid. Aeneas descends into the grave,
00:26:49 and what does he do? He meets his father, and before him is paraded all the future generations
00:26:54 of his sons. That's the sort of vision that gives you hope. And God told Abraham, this is what is
00:27:02 going to happen, ultimately to bring Christ from your loins. This God-given and patriarchal vision 0.81
00:27:10 calls each of us to look down through the generations and by faith start building because
00:27:15 we believe God's promises. Number three, the scriptures themselves are patriarchal.
00:27:22 and somewhere a feminist brain just like short-circuited again she had a meltdown
00:27:28 right but all of us i mean even when i first started looking into this i said i don't know
00:27:33 are the scriptures really patriarchal this is like 10 years ago well let's look at it even
00:27:38 elizabeth caddy stanton you remember her she was the first wave feminist she is the one that said
00:27:45 that christianity i'm quoting christianity is inherently patriarchal and that's why i hate it
00:27:50 when the feminists say it's patriarchal and then you read the scripture and you say 1.00
00:27:55 she's she's right not that she hated it obviously so what did she do she published her woman's bible 0.81
00:28:03 which deleted all references to patriarchal rule right this is what the scripture teaches
00:28:10 biblical patriarchy scripture is actually quite clear on this issue in the scriptures for example
00:28:17 we learn things like this. Adam was created before Eve, and she was made to be his helper on his
00:28:22 mission. Genesis 2.15. God named mankind after the man, not the woman. Genesis 5.1-2. Adam was the
00:28:31 one who, as ruler, named his wife Eve, mother of all living. Even though Eve sinned first, what did
00:28:37 God do? He called Adam to, first and foremost, to be accountable. And this makes sense when you
00:28:43 consider that Adam ruled and had authority over his wife, and thus he was responsible. He was the
00:28:49 responsible agent for Eve's sin. In fact, Adam was responsible covenantally for all humanity.
00:28:57 This is what patriarchy means. Later, we learn that Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob would be referred
00:29:03 to as the patriarchs. Why? Because they ruled their families. Abraham was promised land and
00:29:09 offspring and given the covenant of circumcision, which applied to who? Male offspring. These 0.95
00:29:15 promises were inherited by his descendants, but specifically by his sons. And the Apostle Paul
00:29:21 includes Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob as patriarchs in Romans 15.8 when he says, Christ became a
00:29:28 servant to Jews. Why? To confirm the promises given to the patriarchs. So the New Testament
00:29:35 doesn't seem to have a problem with patriarchy. In the Old Testament, we think about the civil
00:29:41 structures. Well, elders, prophets, judges, priests, kings, all men. We do have the one case of
00:29:47 Athalia being the queen, but she is a usurper. Judgment falls upon her head. The heads of 1.00
00:29:54 families, men, were chosen for civil government, Exodus 4.29. Of the old covenant structure,
00:30:01 Herman Boving says this, quote, the entire organization of the nation was along patriarchal
00:30:07 lines. You see, what's important to read the old guys, right? It's along patriarchal lines in clans, 1.00
00:30:15 families, and households. Each group had a head or representative or prince, a man. All these heads
00:30:21 or princes together formed the members of the assembly. When they gathered, the congregation
00:30:25 of Israel was thus gathered, end quote. Well, what about Jesus? This is one that I get a lot
00:30:33 on Twitter, social media, but also in email. Wasn't Jesus like a modern-day hippie? Didn't
00:30:40 he have like really long hair and flip-flops? Hung out at coffee shops in Boulder, Colorado?
00:30:48 Well, that's not actually what we find from the biblical record. Jesus not only had shorter hair
00:30:53 like the Jewish men of his day, but he exercised manly authority. What did he do? He applauded John 0.57
00:31:00 the Baptist because he wasn't soft. And this is from Matthew 11. The Greek word that's used there
00:31:07 is malikos, which means effeminacy. He's applauding John for not being effeminate.
00:31:13 God sent Christ in the flesh as a man. That seems obvious, but again, as previous speakers have said,
00:31:20 we're not even sure what men are anymore. Christ came as a man. He was resurrected with a male
00:31:26 body. He taught with authority, and he overturned the tables in the temple. God's people, in fact,
00:31:33 expected a male Messiah because the prophecies were about a man, and God's leaders had always
00:31:38 been men. Point number four, gender rules are rooted in creation. Gender rules are rooted 0.97
00:31:46 in creation. Now modern feminists like to claim that gender rules are just cultural, right? These 1.00
00:31:53 are things that we made up because of John Wayne, not Genesis 1 through 3, which is in fact where
00:31:58 they come from, right? The New Testament authors, including Jesus, root these teachings continually
00:32:04 in creation. So for example, when Jesus is asked about marriage in Matthew 19, what does he do?
00:32:11 He makes a beeline for Genesis and for the creation account.
00:32:16 When Paul says in 1 Timothy 2 that he does not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man,
00:32:21 he ties it specifically to the creation account.
00:32:25 Adam was created first, therefore Adam is to rule.
00:32:29 Creation order matters, in other words.
00:32:31 While he was created second, it is Adam's helper.
00:32:34 She was made for the man.
00:32:36 Paul tells us this in Corinthians. 0.94
00:32:39 This was one that I had the most enjoyment over on Twitter
00:32:42 because I quoted Paul without telling people where it was from,
00:32:46 and they said, you're twisting the word of God.
00:32:49 I said, no, this is literally word for word what the text says.
00:32:53 You just don't like it.
00:32:55 Here's the point in talking about our natures being rooted in creation and in God's design. 0.82
00:33:01 If God made a woman a certain way, everywhere she goes, every sphere,
00:33:06 she takes the same nature with her. 0.98
00:33:09 It's not just that she's easily deceived when we're talking about the church, but not the family.
00:33:15 And then the sphere that nobody likes to talk about because it's so controversial is society, the public sphere.
00:33:23 God did not arbitrarily assign tasks to men and women apart from the sexual nature that he gave them.
00:33:30 Zach Garris writes this.
00:33:33 Contrary to modern thought, these physical and biological differences affect a person's entire being.
00:33:39 Men and women have different bodies, different minds, different personalities, and different dispositions.
00:33:44 Men and women have different natures.
00:33:46 I read an article recently in a newspaper, and this is how you know it's a good newspaper.
00:33:51 They said there's a new sociological study, and it proves a fundamental reality. 1.00
00:33:57 They said men and women are different. 0.99
00:33:59 Like, I did not need this article to know that that was true.
00:34:03 right that's how crazy our society is and that's how far even the church has fallen
00:34:09 so this means that when we talk of roles that men and women occupy they're not arbitrary
00:34:17 this is why God gave women certain physical components right they have breasts and womb
00:34:25 men have more muscle mass on average than women right there's a reason for this and it's related
00:34:32 to their purpose. This is also why, if you understand nature rooted in creation, this is 0.96
00:34:39 why it's a problem when a woman says, I could preach a better sermon than most men. No, in fact, 1.00
00:34:45 you could not. That's as equally absurd as if I said, I could give birth better than most women. 0.99
00:34:53 You cannot do the thing. It is not rooted in your nature. No matter how many crazy articles 1.00
00:34:59 that we read about men lactating.
00:35:03 They don't.
00:35:06 But this is where we are.
00:35:07 This is literally where we are.
00:35:08 We talk about it all the time as pastors.
00:35:10 We're in a position now in our culture
00:35:11 where we say, you're a man, you're a woman,
00:35:16 and people get angry.
00:35:17 But this is what you have to do.
00:35:19 You have to be courageous. 0.99
00:35:22 Number five, women are made for motherhood. 1.00
00:35:26 One of the primary aims of the feminist movement, 1.00
00:35:28 they're outspoken about this, is to push women into the workforce. 0.83
00:35:34 Frederick Engels wrote about this before and after the Communist Manifesto. 0.95
00:35:39 They said, what we want to do is destroy the middle class of working people.
00:35:43 If we do that, then we can push our communist aims.
00:35:46 The only way we can do that is by destroying patriarchy. 0.96
00:35:50 There's a reason that Betty Friedan was a Marxist. 0.70
00:35:55 She fabricated her study about how miserable women were in the 1950s.
00:35:59 It was completely not true.
00:36:03 We moderns have a hard time fathoming that it's been atypical across history 0.95
00:36:08 to have women so prominent in the workforce as today.
00:36:13 But you look at 1950 and before, it simply wasn't happening.
00:36:18 Not in American history, but in world history. 1.00
00:36:21 For thousands of years, women were seen as naturally caretakers in the home. 0.98
00:36:28 That's, in fact, what Scripture tells us. 0.87
00:36:31 Creation tells us that women are made to help the man. 0.97
00:36:34 She does this, get this, she makes immortal souls in her womb. 0.95
00:36:40 And you're trying to tell me that spreadsheets are better. 1.00
00:36:44 She makes immortal souls in her womb, and the home is her proper sphere. 0.98
00:36:51 the church fathers said this for thousands of years a woman can put on pantsuits she can occupy 1.00
00:36:58 a corner office she can sterilize her body for decades via the pill but all the while her 0.98
00:37:03 biology screams out she is made to be a mother her menstrual cycle her breasts her womb they sing
00:37:11 the song of her creation her glory is motherhood it was chesterton i think who so aptly put it this
00:37:19 way. He said, feminism is the muddled idea that women are free when they serve their employers, 1.00
00:37:25 but slaves when they help their husbands. You have to understand that's what our women are 0.86
00:37:31 being inundated with. All the feminists and the crypto feminists on Twitter, you know who they 1.00
00:37:38 attack the most? Moms who stay home. And as men, we have to be the protectors to say, no, 1.00
00:37:46 my wife is not going to take that because I'm going to stand in the gap
00:37:52 point number six men are made to be courageous warriors and workers if you ask me why is
00:38:00 patriarchy so important for this project of rebuilding christendom it's for this reason
00:38:05 christendom simply cannot be recovered without recovering biblical masculinity when you look 0.89
00:38:12 at the first Christendom. Men like Charlemagne and Alfred the Great and Jan Sobieski. Well newsflash 0.78
00:38:19 they were not pietistic effeminate versions of men that we have today. They saddled up their horses
00:38:25 and they defeated an enemy that outnumbered them 200 to 1. This is what we need if we're going to
00:38:33 defend the perimeter. Genesis 2 15 says that man was put in the garden to work and to keep. Why?
00:38:40 Because man was designed for vocational work, right? 0.73
00:38:44 Our culture doesn't even know this.
00:38:46 There's a term for this, you know.
00:38:47 It's called a fami.
00:38:48 It's called a father-mommy, right?
00:38:51 A dad who stays at home while his wife works.
00:38:55 This ought not to be. 0.94
00:38:56 Why?
00:38:56 Genesis 2.15, it's very clear.
00:38:58 It's always been clear. 1.00
00:39:00 The man who doesn't provide for his family is worse than an unbeliever. 1.00
00:39:05 Men are made to be warriors for the sake of their people, right? 1.00
00:39:10 Leon Pottles was correct.
00:39:12 He said this,
00:39:13 A man who has not bled, a man who has not suffered, a man without scars, is no man at all. 1.00
00:39:21 Women will bleed in childbirth and menstruation. 0.88
00:39:24 Men will bleed on the battlefield. 1.00
00:39:27 They were made for this.
00:39:29 Among other things, this means that a man must have a capacity for violence, for the good of his people.
00:39:36 He has to be meek in the sense that he knows how to restrain it,
00:39:40 but he has a capacity for danger.
00:39:44 So when Paul says in 1 Corinthians 16, act like men,
00:39:49 it's clear he means that men must be physically courageous.
00:39:53 Men must be bold, even heroic.
00:39:56 They must defend the perimeter.
00:39:58 But what does the church do today?
00:39:59 The church tends to over-spiritualize this element of masculinity
00:40:02 as though Paul were merely calling for spiritual strength.
00:40:06 They think when Paul says act like man, they mean have a really good quiet time.
00:40:11 That's not what builds Christendom.
00:40:14 Quiet times are important, but you have to do far more than that if you're going to be competent and capable as a man.
00:40:22 The reality here is clear.
00:40:23 God gave men chests and muscles and deep voices so that they would learn how to command respect and act with gravitas and auctoritas or manly authority.
00:40:34 so we must reject the false effeminate version of manhood that is so often pushed on us by the
00:40:40 church today one of the things that draws the most ire perhaps in the realm of fathers and
00:40:47 sons protecting is the issue of modesty right this is uh if you talk about yoga pants people 1.00
00:40:54 get really mad i don't know if you know this right there's a coveted thing among feminists 1.00
00:41:01 that has been just embedded in the culture that women think they're free when they take all their 1.00
00:41:06 clothes off in public. And brothers and fathers and husbands ought not to allow this. Why? Because 1.00
00:41:13 they love their daughters. And when daughters are intoxicated and drinking during a Mardi Gras parade
00:41:18 and doing all sorts of lewd gyrations, the question we ought to ask is where are the men?
00:41:25 Where are these young women's fathers?
00:41:30 Men are to protect their women and particularly their sexual purity. 0.88
00:41:36 Number seven, women are not made for military or combat.
00:41:41 This is incredibly unpopular, and I would say law enforcement is included.
00:41:45 Deuteronomy 22.5 tells us, this is actually very clear. 0.99
00:41:48 A woman shall not wear a man's garment, nor shall a man put on a woman's cloak. 0.53
00:41:52 for whoever does these things is an abomination to the Lord your God. Read that again. Whoever
00:41:58 does these things is what? An abomination to the Lord your God. That's some pretty weighty
00:42:05 language. Not only does this prohibit cross-dressing, but the text refers specifically
00:42:11 to a woman who puts on military garb, right? Women are not to serve in the military or combat roles 1.00
00:42:18 because it is a violation of their nature, right? 1.00
00:42:22 Women are not designed to give or to take punches. 1.00
00:42:25 They're not made to enter the arena or the agon. 1.00
00:42:28 That's what men do, right?
00:42:30 But what do we do? 1.00
00:42:31 We continue to push them into these areas, right? 1.00
00:42:35 Women in the UFC, I think it's against a woman's nature. 1.00
00:42:39 It's disgusting to see women cave each other's faces in, right? 1.00
00:42:43 This is against nature. 0.97
00:42:46 Paul makes very similar arguments. 0.99
00:42:48 But other sports, women in full-contact sports, you see this with the NFL. 0.96
00:42:53 They're continually trying to push women into playing. 0.96
00:42:56 Australia does this with rugby. 0.99
00:42:59 Women have leagues, and you know what they found out? 1.00
00:43:02 Cutting sports are notoriously destructive of a woman's ACL, her knee joint, right? 1.00
00:43:08 They have such catastrophic rates of knee failure in women that doctors have said, 1.00
00:43:12 we need to stop putting women in full-contact sports. 1.00
00:43:15 Again, to which we could say, yeah, no kidding. 1.00
00:43:20 The other area where we've connected it in Ogden is women and cultural pugilism. 1.00
00:43:26 Part of the problem is we have women in politics as well. 1.00
00:43:30 We have women all over the place doing things that normally men should be doing. 1.00
00:43:35 And while we admit that the world is messed up and there's going to be some imperfect situations, 1.00
00:43:39 we also have to stand by the principle that women do not need to be out front even in the culture
00:43:45 war fighting for us the thing we should ask ourselves if there are no men to do it why is that 1.00
00:43:52 then maybe we should raise some up maybe we should train them but again the woman's role
00:43:59 is primarily the home i think i'm crazy on this john gill who served 100 years i believe before
00:44:06 Spurgeon in the same church, he applies this principle on Deuteronomy 22.5, and he says this, 0.94
00:44:13 it is very unseemly and impudent and contrary to the modesty of her, that is the woman's sex,
00:44:19 or there shall not be upon her any instrument of a man, any utensil of which he makes use of in his 1.00
00:44:25 trade or in his business. So he's not just saying military, he's also saying trade tools.
00:44:31 John Gill says as if she was employed in it that is the trade her business was not to do the work
00:44:37 of men but to take care of her house and her family and the apostle Paul says the exact same
00:44:45 thing we just don't like it number eight men are made to rule in family in church and in society
00:44:54 fathers are called to rule in the family this much is clear of all the controversial things to say
00:45:00 this is probably the least, but yet it still doesn't happen. Paul is clear in Ephesians 5.25,
00:45:07 for example, that the husband is head of the wife. They are not joint heads of the household.
00:45:13 As my friend Pastor Rich Lusk often says, anything with two heads is called a monster.
00:45:20 There is one head, which is the husband. He has both authority and responsibility to rule his
00:45:27 household. Well, this is the failure of servant leader model. Well, he has the responsibility to
00:45:32 serve his wife's every need, but he has no real authority. But that's never leadership. You have
00:45:38 to have both, authority and responsibility. And the man is to love his wife as Christ loves the
00:45:44 church. She, in turn, is to submit, and here's the part that you all love, she is to submit as one
00:45:52 inferior in rank. Let me say that again, as one inferior in rank, right? They're both equally
00:46:01 valuable before God, but they have a different hierarchical ranking. Our society hates this.
00:46:09 I think this is one reason, this is the language, by the way, of the Westminster Confession,
00:46:14 but this is one reason why the complementarians in 1989, when they formulated their statements,
00:46:19 This is why they said we're anti-hierarchalist.
00:46:22 Well, then you're anti-scripture.
00:46:26 This is how God built the system.
00:46:29 Gouge, William Gouge, says this. 0.99
00:46:31 The necessary subjection of the wife is to that degree of subordination where God has placed all subordinates 0.92
00:46:38 and how he has subjected them to their superiors and set them in a lower rank. 1.00
00:46:44 A wife is a lower rank. 0.57
00:46:47 All that means in hierarchy, it's very, very simple. 1.00
00:46:50 She reports to him.
00:46:53 That's actually just crystal clear.
00:46:55 And the church fathers taught it for millennia. 0.97
00:46:58 In the church, men are to rule. 0.92
00:47:00 Only men can be pastors. 1.00
00:47:02 No lady pastors. 1.00
00:47:03 Sorry, not sorry. 1.00
00:47:05 Christ has appointed men to lead in his church.
00:47:08 And again, 1 Timothy 2 and elsewhere, Paul affirms this.
00:47:12 We need to recognize that preaching and pastoral ministry
00:47:15 is a form of spiritual combat and spiritual warfare. 1.00
00:47:20 And this is one reason why a woman's nature 1.00
00:47:22 is not fitted for that task. 1.00
00:47:26 Finally, we'll conclude with this as we wrap things up.
00:47:28 What about society?
00:47:31 Thomas Watson and other Westminster divines
00:47:33 taught frequently on the fifth commandment.
00:47:36 To Joel's point, it's really hard to do better
00:47:38 than these guys, especially in our day.
00:47:41 Go back to the confessions and read them.
00:47:43 right thomas watson on the fifth commandment taught that the civil sphere just as the church
00:47:50 is an extension of the family starts with the family flows outward as such it's clear in this
00:47:57 structure and in westminster that only men may rule we see this principle in exodus 3 where the
00:48:04 fathers are appointed to rule in the civil sphere but again this is controversial today but actually
00:48:09 biblically quite clear. If a woman cannot lawfully rule in her home, which scripture says she cannot, 0.99
00:48:16 and in the church, how then is she going to rule other households and churches? 0.94
00:48:21 This makes no sense. She is not fitted in her nature for this task. And again, if you think
00:48:28 I'm crazy, here's R.L. Dabney. He says this, does not the apostle here assign the home as the proper
00:48:35 sphere of the Christian woman. That is her kingdom, and neither the secular nor the ecclesiastical
00:48:42 commonwealth. Her duties in her home are to detain her away from the public functions. A wise God,
00:48:49 and here's the point, this is in God's wisdom and his goodness and his mercy to us, right? These
00:48:55 structures are good. A wise God designs no clashing between his domestic, his political,
00:49:01 and his ecclesiastical arrangements.
00:49:06 We have to see, it's not just patriarchy,
00:49:09 but it's patriarchy in this order that God has set,
00:49:12 and it is good.
00:49:13 We have to rejoice that God made it this way
00:49:15 because it is a good thing for us and for our families
00:49:19 upon which Christendom will be built.
00:49:23 Finally, I'll close with this.
00:49:25 Number nine, patriarchy must be marked by contagious joy. 0.92
00:49:30 Everybody thinks, especially on the feminist side, that we're in Ogden and we're just really angry.
00:49:38 We're actually a bunch of friends in a really old church basement that probably has mold.
00:49:45 And the week before we got here, all Brian did was sing the same songs.
00:49:49 I'm so tired of hearing them.
00:49:51 All day.
00:49:52 We rib each other.
00:49:53 We have fun.
00:49:54 We love our culture.
00:49:56 As Pastor Doug has led the way on so many of these issues for so many years,
00:50:00 and we're grateful for him, he said it best.
00:50:02 You can't fight a culture war without a culture.
00:50:06 Our main task is not drinking liberal tears.
00:50:10 We are establishing hardy cultures that are worth defending.
00:50:15 We are building cultures that are filled with psalm singing and feasting and robust worship
00:50:20 and the study of God's Word and Christian education.
00:50:23 and, yes, maybe even a little sourdough.
00:50:29 I'm glad you got that.
00:50:30 That was good.
00:50:30 Put that in there.
00:50:32 Only when we have this great culture are we prepared to fight,
00:50:37 and joy should mark us.
00:50:39 So as we embark on the battle to defend God's design for human sexuality,
00:50:45 we must remember what Chesterton said.
00:50:48 The true soldier fights not because he hates what is in front of him,
00:50:51 but because he loves what is behind him.
00:50:55 It is not a hatred for feminism or a sexual perversion,
00:50:59 a hatred for that that marks us.
00:51:01 But it is our love for our people.
00:51:04 It's our love for the purity of Christ's church.
00:51:07 I love what Joe Rigney has said about this,
00:51:10 talking about King Loon from C.S. Lewis and the Horse and His Boy.
00:51:15 It's this principle that we talk about often in Ogden.
00:51:18 First in, last out, laughing loudest.
00:51:21 Right? Quoting from C.S. Lewis, I'll share this with you. He says this,
00:51:26 This is what it means to be a king, to be first in every desperate attack, to be last in every
00:51:31 desperate retreat, and when there's hunger in the land, as must be now and then in bad years,
00:51:37 to wear finer clothes and to laugh louder over a scantier meal than any man in your land.
00:51:44 This is a vision, a joyful vision for patriarchy.
00:51:48 i want to charge you finally as we close particularly the men dusty spoke at length
00:51:54 about this i love what he said i want you to think about your grandsons especially again
00:52:00 especially men think about your grandsons
00:52:01 what will disappoint them is not that you died in the fight and you gave it your all
00:52:10 what will disappoint them in you is that you were a coward and that you didn't fight this fight
00:52:16 evangelicals have said this for the last many years this is not a hill to die on 0.94
00:52:22 brothers and sisters biblical sexuality and patriarchy is a hill to die on we have to be
00:52:30 willing to plant our flag here and we do so because we know what our father's taught
00:52:37 we have the confession behind us it may be depressing as you look about we are badly
00:52:44 outnumbered by the feminist hordes and the culture and yes even our church institutions
00:52:49 to which I say to you what a time to win glory. We have been chosen to stand in the gap as did
00:52:56 the 300 Spartans at Thermopylae and we fight not for ourselves but for our progeny not because it
00:53:03 is easy but because we look with faith to the future generations of our sons and we come full
00:53:10 circle with patriarchy. When we die, let us die spent in the fight for Christendom. Then we may
00:53:17 say, as Théoden did on the Pelennor fields, as he lay dying, I go now to my father's, in whose
00:53:24 mighty company I shall not now be so ashamed. Amen? Let's pray. Father, we thank you so much
00:53:33 for your grace. We thank you for your word. We ask that you would revive and reform and build
00:53:39 up your church in such a manner that we crush the gates of hell. Father, build up your kingdom
00:53:45 for the sake of your son, Jesus, in whose name we pray. Amen. Amen.