The NXR Podcast - April 09, 2024


THE CONFERENCE - Live Panel on Biblical Patriarchy & Christian Nationalism - Deevers, Wilson, Sauve, Conn, and Webbon

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW - A Simple Primer For Family Worship with David Reece THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Hollow Earth | The Last Living Dragons & Primary Water w Haunted Cosmos

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 23 minutes

Words per minute

166.37

Word count

13,947

Sentence count

586

Harmful content

Misogyny

39

sentences flagged

Toxicity

12

sentences flagged

Hate speech

85

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we have a panel where we discuss the concept of biblical patriarchy and how it relates to the modern manosphere. We discuss the differences between the Red Pill movement and the Tradeweek movement, and how they are related to each other.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 So the idea for this panel is to talk about biblical patriarchy.
00:00:04 Eric just did a great job on the topic,
00:00:06 and now putting a little bit more into practice and discussion format.
00:00:12 And let's begin by just praying.
00:00:14 Father, we pray that you would bless our time together,
00:00:16 help us to be wise, help us to be clear in our discourse.
00:00:20 And we just pray that all that we say would be ultimately for your glory
00:00:24 and the good of your people.
00:00:25 We pray this for Jesus' sake. Amen.
00:00:28 Okay, I'm just going to dive right in so that we don't like build up to exciting discourse. We can
00:00:34 just have it right away. So this is my first question for all of you. It's a agree or disagree
00:00:39 question with the follow-up being why? And we'll go individually. Everybody gets the answer. Take
00:00:45 as long as you want. And it could be just the only question for 90 minutes and it might get us all
00:00:49 the... I have a feeling. I have a feeling. So it has been said recently on Twitter
00:00:55 that the word was mirror, and I did not like it,
00:01:01 but that tradwives is the mirror kind of exact opposite,
00:01:07 like two sides but of the same coin,
00:01:09 the mirror movement of red pill.
00:01:13 Agree, disagree, and why?
00:01:17 Eric, I'd love to hear from you first.
00:01:19 Yeah, so I would disagree.
00:01:21 And the basic reason why is I think
00:01:23 when you look at the the red pill movement uh i think the guy that most people will think of is
00:01:29 andrew tate so if you follow the red pill moment down through like andrew tate what are you going
00:01:36 to get you're going to get like bugattis and a harem right and i think then when you look at
00:01:42 something like trad wives for the most part it's like if if what i get out of that is like pretty
00:01:46 dresses and sourdough I'm I feel like that's a different thing than Andrew Tate so that's that's
00:01:54 my basic disagree and I know Brian we were actually talking about this he's got a long
00:01:58 beautiful let's hear Brian that's great I mean there's more to be said but everything you said
00:02:04 I personally agree with but right um nuance and it depends as it stated if I have to say yes or
00:02:12 know, I'd say no. I can see how you would get there from a certain line of reasoning. And it
00:02:18 would go like this. The red pill manosphere is responding to real, actual problems in the world
00:02:24 where people are disobeying God and the nature that he gave them. And so there are all sorts
00:02:30 of problems when that happens. There are problems in marriages where men are getting married and
00:02:37 maybe committing no covenant breaking sin. And then one day find their wife of 10, 20 years 0.51
00:02:44 gone with the kids, go into court, get a no fault divorce and take his kids and half his income for
00:02:50 18 years. Right? So one of the things that happens when, when that becomes the legal background of
00:02:56 our culture, which it very much is, uh, is that you're going to have a reaction that's just based
00:03:02 on people having eyes in their head. And some men are going to say, well, our culture has been very
00:03:06 anti-men in lots of ways, so let's be pro-men. But then one of the dangers of that is that you can
00:03:13 have a pro-men message, which is severely lacking in our culture, that is then but not governed by
00:03:20 Christ. So then they say, what should a man be and do? And then they're just going to answer that
00:03:25 question, most often in the manosphere world, through an evolutionary perspective and worldview
00:03:29 and go back to Greek and Roman philosophy and Stoicism. And you do, you end up with working
00:03:36 out, high tea, eat steak, and have a harem, which is just a different way of ruining the world
00:03:42 than the way that they were reacting to. The same thing happens in our world on the side of 0.96
00:03:49 femininity, where femininity can be corrupted in multiple directions, just like masculinity can. 0.99
00:03:57 And so you're going to have counter movements reacting to that. One thing you can have that is 0.50
00:04:02 certainly a part of the trad wife movement, which, by the way, I'm not an expert in and don't follow
00:04:08 trad wife accounts because I'm married. I have a wife who makes sourdough and wears dresses, you
00:04:17 know, a good fair bit of time. But you can have sort of a pinup pornified version of traditionalism
00:04:25 that's actually, at its root, ultra not traditional, 0.94
00:04:29 and it's just women who are wearing low-cut shirts
00:04:32 on Instagram or TikTok and monetized, 1.00
00:04:34 they're getting a lot of airplay out of a trend, 0.98
00:04:38 which is a reaction to feminism
00:04:41 and the flattening of all sexual distinctions. 0.97
00:04:44 So then we have androgyny.
00:04:45 Well, what are we gonna do?
00:04:46 We're gonna have hyper-femininity 1.00
00:04:47 that actually ends up not being feminine at all. 0.51
00:04:51 Same thing with the red pill, in a sense.
00:04:53 So I see that, but the difference that I would say is that I don't think that that's the dominant note of the vast majority of the content that I see around the traditional femininity kind of world.
00:05:06 a lot of it genuinely is i think women reclaiming roles in the home as being a helper
00:05:13 cooking caring for your people clothing them well undoing some of the ill effects of the
00:05:20 industrial revolution that's atomizing the home and tearing everybody in a million directions
00:05:25 so on the surface i would say they are different because the heart of the manosphere movement
00:05:30 really the dominant notes and and i've spoken at manosphere conference conferences and it's like
00:05:36 at the heart of it, the dominant note is evolutionary harem building, pickup artistry,
00:05:43 absolute filth, about 98% of it in my experience. And then in the trad wife movement, I think it's 0.89
00:05:52 a very different ratio that's actually, a lot of it is genuinely Christian. I think quite a bit of 0.63
00:05:59 it is genuinely Christian. So I want both to return to nature. Really the answer to me is like, 1.00
00:06:05 I want men to return to faithful, monogamous,
00:06:10 covenant marriage in Christ's name. 1.00
00:06:12 I want women to return to older women, 0.99
00:06:15 teach the younger women to be workers at home, 1.00
00:06:16 love your children, love your husband, 0.95
00:06:18 lest the word of God be reviled.
00:06:19 That's what I wanna see.
00:06:21 So I think there's some missing on both sides,
00:06:23 but some of it does have to do with your perspective.
00:06:25 What are you looking at on Instagram?
00:06:26 What's the algorithm feeding you?
00:06:28 Because there certainly is pinup version 1.00
00:06:29 of trad wife culture out there. 0.98
00:06:31 So that was a typical, Eric says no,
00:06:34 and then I talk for five times longer and say nuanced,
00:06:37 welcome to the King's Hall podcast.
00:06:39 That's basically.
00:06:40 He really just means no.
00:06:42 All right, Pastor Doug.
00:06:44 So I agree with everything that's just been said thus far.
00:06:47 I would maybe set the cat among the pigeons.
00:06:51 I would also say there was nothing in what was just said
00:06:54 that was inconsistent with what Allie Beth said
00:06:57 in that first clip.
00:06:59 She was saying, okay, this is great.
00:07:02 Nothing against sourdough, nothing against,
00:07:03 But there's a way of pretending, which you just said.
00:07:08 And I've certainly seen before.
00:07:10 We went through this back in the 80s and 90s.
00:07:13 There was another version of the same sort of thing with the homeschool mom.
00:07:17 And there was the same sort of thing. 0.90
00:07:20 And I came, as a pastor, I came to the conclusion that there's sometimes an inverse ratio between the size of the head covering and the submissiveness of the woman. 0.99
00:07:31 Right. 1.00
00:07:31 Yeah. 1.00
00:07:31 Why does your wife wear her head covering to church? 1.00
00:07:39 She insisted. 0.95
00:07:44 So, okay.
00:07:46 But to echo what you just said and to amen it,
00:07:51 domesticity is discipleship.
00:07:56 Domesticity is the calling that God has called women to. 0.99
00:07:59 and this is the apostolic instruction is that women are to be busy at home there be keepers
00:08:05 at home they're to give themselves over to it so that the word of god may not be blasphemed
00:08:10 but discipleship is hard you know it's challenging being a godly husband and a godly father
00:08:17 is challenging and it's the same with being a godly woman it and it's easy to be godly on
00:08:24 Instagram, basically.
00:08:27 I can take a photo
00:08:28 of my quiet time and not have to go through
00:08:30 it.
00:08:33 So,
00:08:34 agree,
00:08:36 and I think I would, I'm
00:08:38 certain that I would have disagreements
00:08:40 with Allie Beth at various junctures,
00:08:43 but I think that what she was saying
00:08:44 in that initial clip was something
00:08:46 that the conservative Christians
00:08:48 ought to hear. Okay, no role-playing. 0.80
00:08:50 Let's not do role-playing. Let's
00:08:52 do it for real, because we mean it.
00:08:54 And it's a sacrifice to the Father.
00:08:58 And I think that we should reclaim, be working to reclaim patriarchy.
00:09:03 I'll just finish with the word patriarchy.
00:09:07 I've never been comfortable with the word complementarian.
00:09:11 And I think it's because left-wing complementarians are basically egalitarians.
00:09:18 And right-wing complementarians are patriarchal.
00:09:21 So let's just call it what it is.
00:09:23 and then um not pastor but senator deavers your turn why not both oh yeah you're right all right
00:09:32 it's just everybody gets to be a pastor the reverend none of us are cool enough to be
00:09:36 senators you're the only one so you've got it you've got to own that title but pastor senator
00:09:40 reverend the great dusty deavers please keep going the most reverend pastor
00:09:48 now we're getting somewhere
00:09:51 so I didn't catch 0.80
00:09:54 any of the Allie Beth Stuckey
00:09:56 trad wife conversation
00:09:58 because I was out 0.61
00:09:59 legislating morality
00:10:00 and about time
00:10:10 speaking of no fault divorce
00:10:15 I'm not going to make
00:10:18 any further comment on that issue
00:10:19 I'd rather talk about
00:10:22 abolishing pornography or 0.83
00:10:23 abolishing abortion, not smashing it 0.69
00:10:26 or no fault divorce 0.76
00:10:30 oh Dusty 0.98
00:10:31 come on 1.00
00:10:32 we'll have to have a sidebar
00:10:34 he gets a chance to respond 0.99
00:10:36 I'd have to smash it in the mouth 1.00
00:10:38 oh 1.00
00:10:40 yeah
00:10:41 go ahead
00:10:43 You guys get to take that topic. 0.93
00:10:45 Dusty said, look at me.
00:10:46 This is my panel now.
00:10:48 Look at me.
00:10:48 I'm the captain now.
00:10:50 I'm the senator now.
00:10:51 The next topic is going to Indy this summer to disrupt the SBC.
00:10:56 Amen?
00:10:57 Who's coming with me?
00:11:00 All right.
00:11:01 So these are my thoughts.
00:11:03 So everything that was said thus far, I agree with.
00:11:06 These are my thoughts specifically on since that clip is in view,
00:11:11 and it should be.
00:11:12 Like, we don't have to dance around and be coy.
00:11:15 I didn't have any problem either with what was said in the clip, so I agree with you, Doug.
00:11:19 For me, as I thought about it, it was the context of the hour-long panel that happened with Founders.
00:11:29 And Tom Askell is incredible and deserves all our respect and all our honor and the benefit of the doubt.
00:11:35 But the hour-long panel, that context didn't quite fit it for me.
00:11:40 It didn't fix it for me because that's part of the context.
00:11:45 But then the larger context is not the hour.
00:11:47 But for me, it's the last nine months.
00:11:50 And so I'll just, you know, I'll be frank, but also careful and charitable.
00:11:54 There are other statements that, you know, I'm going to hear that portion, that clip,
00:11:59 but I'm going to hear it in light of other things that have been said.
00:12:02 And I think part of the challenge, it's kind of gets to my talk earlier this afternoon,
00:12:08 is obedience in theory.
00:12:10 I think that's one of my big concerns. 1.00
00:12:12 I'm concerned about pietism. 0.95
00:12:13 I'm concerned about theoretical obedience.
00:12:16 So, you know, one of the statements that has been made
00:12:19 is that, you know, godly motherhood, for instance,
00:12:23 is not the highest calling of a Christian woman,
00:12:26 but rather the highest calling of a Christian woman.
00:12:29 The woman portion is irrelevant,
00:12:31 whether it be Christian woman or Christian man
00:12:34 or child or adult.
00:12:35 The highest calling of all Christians
00:12:37 is to glorify God and enjoy him forever.
00:12:40 And my immediate response is, how?
00:12:44 I just, I feel like we have to, yes, of course, a million times,
00:12:47 a million amens, glorify God and enjoy him forever.
00:12:51 But if it's only, if it's merely theory,
00:12:54 then obedience becomes androgynous, becomes generic,
00:12:57 it becomes theoretical.
00:13:01 The favorite egalitarian verse that's always used
00:13:05 is, you know, Ephesians 5, when you look at the headline, and then you get into Paul's case
00:13:10 studies. But the headline principle is mutual submission to one another out of reverence for
00:13:15 Christ. But then Paul doesn't just leave it in the abstract. He then begins to say, and this is
00:13:21 what that mutual submission for one another as the body of Christ out of reverence for Christ
00:13:24 looks like based off of God's sovereignly appointed station for that individual in their life.
00:13:30 because the egalitarian wants to have
00:13:33 the verse about mutual submission in Ephesians 5
00:13:37 override what Paul later says
00:13:40 about husbands and wives particularly
00:13:43 that the husband is called to love his wife 0.91
00:13:46 and lead his wife and the wife is called to submit
00:13:48 but if you use that hermeneutic and you were consistent with it
00:13:51 you'd have to also apply that to parents and children
00:13:53 so you'd have to say to the parents
00:13:55 they go and tell their 3 year old
00:13:58 hey you need to do this and the three-year-old says no and the parent of course needs to mutually
00:14:03 submit to that three-year-old and right like let's be consistent right if it's it's so it's
00:14:08 mutual submission as the principle but there's a practical visible expression and that varies
00:14:15 with particularity based off of station of life and gender comes into the picture man or woman or
00:14:23 single or married, parent or child. And so what I'm concerned about is biblical womanhood is not
00:14:33 synonymous or somehow exhaustively described by sourdough and sundresses. Sure. But then I would
00:14:43 love to have a follow-up of, if not, then what? And I want the what not just to describe matters
00:14:51 of the heart. I want the what at some point to also embrace matters of practice. Like there's a
00:14:58 guy, you might have heard of him, but he once said, theology comes out of our fingertips. I thought it
00:15:03 was really good, you know. And that's for all of us, whether you're a man or whether you're a woman,
00:15:09 theology in practice, theology applied. And so, and I do believe that the practical obedience of
00:15:16 a woman particularly a married woman who is a mother is a um a she's a lady of the hearth
00:15:22 as brian said i think that's a great way she is um home oriented she is uh it's it's a domestic 0.76
00:15:27 feminine beauty um she's not she's not a slay queen she's not a boss babe she's not uh she's
00:15:34 not fierce like you got to do something with first peter three and a quiet and gentle spirit
00:15:39 is the way that this inner beauty uh that's imperishable the heart is defined and and as
00:15:44 quiet and gentle mean you must make sourdough of course not but if not good sourdough good sourdough 0.99
00:15:52 right so i just want to hear okay so because every woman's going to look different some women are 1.00
00:15:55 going to be incredibly domestic and feminine um but they're gonna be like sourdough's gross we 0.89
00:16:00 just don't like it and they make something else that's really awesome but what what is it that
00:16:05 that's my thoughts let me say something towards that uh jared moore uh who is running for sbc
00:16:12 president i'm dropping this this guy is shameless this is a politician i'm hoping that uh somebody's
00:16:18 recording these things to send to william wolf um but jared moore who's running for sbc president 0.59
00:16:25 in his book uh lust of the flesh he talks about that holiness so if you tell a man who's who's
00:16:31 been uh you know same sex attracted uh the point for him to overcome is not just holiness pursue
00:16:40 holiness. It's pursue holiness that particularly looks like heterosexual marriage, true marriage.
00:16:49 That's what you're to pursue. That's what it is to glorify God in your sexuality, in your life.
00:16:55 Not just to stop doing something, but to put on Christ in these areas. So I think that's what
00:17:02 you're getting at. On the ground, it's don't just put off certain sins. Don't just mortify certain
00:17:09 things, but vivify, come to life and put on Christ in these ways. And whenever you think about
00:17:17 men's and women's roles, be zealous for these good works that were prepared for you before
00:17:23 the foundation of the world. Pretty straightforward. And one of the things I think that comes into the
00:17:29 context of a lot of these conversations is we're trying to land principles that are timeless
00:17:35 in actual practical situations in a world
00:17:39 that is wildly disobedient to these principles.
00:17:43 So there's going to be some sparks,
00:17:45 but one of the things that I think conservatives
00:17:48 in particular have done just profoundly poorly
00:17:50 is that often one of the things we do
00:17:54 is to put our message forward,
00:17:57 we say, well, how's the world marketing things? 0.99
00:18:00 Well, they're getting a pretty lady 0.99
00:18:02 to be their spokesman for their thing, 0.91
00:18:04 getting a a news lady or they're getting a politics lady or they're getting a and then
00:18:09 they're going to send that lady out to do cultural battle and it smacks of marketing to me quite
00:18:16 often and the way that we're going to do it is by basically giving away a lot of our principles
00:18:22 right at the beginning because Paul really does say in Titus that if this doesn't happen
00:18:28 and he's talking about older women discipling younger women to be workers at home that the
00:18:35 word of god will be reviled that's a really big deal that we should take very seriously so there's
00:18:41 going to be a lot of um there's going to be a lot of sparks when that that principle heads into a
00:18:47 culture like ours i think but but i think we we are right to be skeptical when we see that
00:18:54 nature is is commonly counter-signaled or anytime you make an argument from nature and say the
00:19:00 nature of the woman is this and it lends itself it was it's not arbitrary god made the woman this
00:19:05 way for this vocation and god made the man this way for this vocation um often the instinct i
00:19:11 think you're pointing to joel is that we want to immediately soften that back to a spiritual thing
00:19:16 that has no teeth in the real world and say well don't you know that it's about godliness not
00:19:21 strength men and you'd say well no just because the manosphere uses strength to pick up 20 women
00:19:28 per month at a bar strength isn't the problem their weakness is the problem that they have
00:19:34 no strength and self-control over their flesh um so i i do think that that's part of this
00:19:39 conversation is a lot of people miss we want to boil it down to propositions in abstract
00:19:43 but we really are looking at a situation in the world
00:19:48 where conservatism for too long
00:19:52 has just been leftism with a different flavor,
00:19:55 like cherry leftism, grape leftism.
00:19:59 Slow leftism.
00:20:01 Slow leftism.
00:20:02 And so when you say something like,
00:20:05 man, I really don't want to make a state of affairs
00:20:08 where we just, conservatives begin to prop up
00:20:12 And we say, well, for political commentary, we're going to have our lady guy and our lady and we're going to have our guy.
00:20:18 And then for theology, we're going to have our lady guy.
00:20:22 But that's going to be pretty controversial in the world today because, I mean, now you're talking about something that's about, you know, a couple country miles away from where the culture is.
00:20:33 I agree with all of that, and we shouldn't be, for PR reasons, sending our women out to do the fighting for us.
00:20:44 Oh, you're a woman, you can talk about abortion, and we can't. 1.00
00:20:47 That's ceding the territory to the enemy. 1.00
00:20:52 So we shouldn't send women out to do our fight our battles. 1.00
00:20:56 At the same time, and I think we have to be careful about us not fighting with the women ourselves, right? 0.99
00:21:02 So if that's part of the default in the evangelical world, where there are women out there,
00:21:10 and women like Allie Beth have done a lot of good and are on our side in the main,
00:21:16 and I don't think we should be fighting with them either.
00:21:19 If there's a better way, and there is a better way, then I think we should model it and just send them in.
00:21:26 Where are the men? Send them in into the fray.
00:21:29 and I think a lot of godly women would say 1.00
00:21:31 thanks for the 1.00
00:21:33 reinforcements and I'm going to go home
00:21:35 and make some sourdough
00:21:36 any
00:21:38 more thoughts Eric you didn't talk much
00:21:41 any other thoughts that you want to add or anybody
00:21:43 else and if not I definitely
00:21:45 want to you know this is what we said
00:21:47 to all of you guys who came to the conference that we're going to
00:21:49 talk about biblical patriarchy
00:21:51 and I think there's some more that we can address
00:21:52 but I also
00:21:54 it was an audible you know we just ran
00:21:57 an audible but we we have dusty and we have doug and we have the ogden boys i feel like christian
00:22:03 nationalism is is worth uh right i mean why why do something as controversial as you know
00:22:08 controversial as patriarchy when you could talk about you know christian nationalism so i think
00:22:12 that'd be a worthy endeavor as well but eric is you just didn't talk much so yeah no my only other
00:22:17 thought is really pastoral um one of the things we talk a lot about in ogden is kind of this idea
00:22:23 that women can't be pastored by men.
00:22:25 So sort of to Doug's point, 0.94
00:22:27 like we need a lady for everything. 1.00
00:22:29 So this was sort of the problem, I think,
00:22:30 with Matt Chandler.
00:22:32 What was the? 1.00
00:22:33 Jen Wilkins.
00:22:33 Jen Wilkins, right? 1.00
00:22:34 You need a woman pastor for women.
00:22:36 So I think just practically, 0.97
00:22:38 one of the ways that you solve this long-term 0.88
00:22:40 is actually by men pastoring
00:22:43 all the people in their congregation.
00:22:46 And so then they're used to that.
00:22:48 I think what is challenging to Doug's point 1.00
00:22:50 is you do have women
00:22:51 who have essentially stepped on the agon they've gone out into the arena and stepped on what stepped
00:22:58 into the agon so the arena that they're they're going out in a place where fundamentally they're
00:23:03 they're being like a man but then they're they're also pulling the rug out and they're saying but
00:23:08 you have to treat me like a lady too and so i think that's why it's sort of an unwinnable position
00:23:13 now to doug's point i've actually wrestled with it like what do you do in that in that scenario
00:23:18 because a lot of times you've got like Allie Bath she's teaching on complementarianism and
00:23:23 patriarchy and making quite a mess of it in many points and then we have to pastorally deal with
00:23:30 that because your women are listening to it yeah and so then you have to respond to it and you're 0.99
00:23:35 like well I I don't I generally don't want to get into it with this lady she's in a role she 0.97
00:23:41 shouldn't be in that would be my take in terms of particularly teaching theology in that in that
00:23:46 section but you get into that and then you say what what do i do pastorally because you know
00:23:52 it's it's the old like you don't hit a girl but what happens when she comes in swinging
00:23:56 with with a knife yes good point good point um what that was one other thing i wanted to say
00:24:05 about i can go ahead go ahead yeah filibuster i can summarize christian nationalism
00:24:11 in a way that will cause all Christians everywhere to agree.
00:24:17 Oh, by mimicking the woman, the leftist woman, 0.82
00:24:20 who said they believe that rights come from God?
00:24:23 No.
00:24:23 I think all Christians should be able to agree on this. 1.00
00:24:27 America should stop making God angry.
00:24:30 who's going to rise up and say no it's okay for america to continue to
00:24:42 make god does 60 million unborn children slaughtered not make him angry does a
00:24:49 burger fell not make him angry does the uh the scourge of porn across does that not make him
00:24:55 angry are are we not visiting are we not inviting him to visit judgment upon us so i i suggest why
00:25:03 don't we stop it it's like that clip uh from what i can't even remember this show new heart
00:25:10 stop it yeah i have two two words for you now i find that most people can remember them yeah
00:25:15 um okay this is one thing with christian nationalism just to go so and i'm curious to
00:25:21 hear doug's take i've talked to you guys about it dusty i think i i haven't talked to you but
00:25:25 i can assume but i'd love to hear your take too um you know i i think a lot of guys are like why
00:25:29 do we need the label we already have one you know it's it's theonomy or you know uh it's it's this
00:25:35 or it's that and they didn't like that one either well yeah but but i'm saying that theonomists
00:25:39 like it you know and so you know and so like we already have a label um and one of the things
00:25:44 that i've noticed and i'm not saying this is the definition because nobody gets that's well that's
00:25:48 the trouble with it nobody gets to say this is the definition um but one of the things that i've
00:25:52 noticed just in talking to guys who are you know christian nationalists self-defined you know
00:25:56 self-labeled uh is one thing i've i've noticed as a distinction is they're uh they're very comfortable
00:26:04 with um they're very comfortable with the civil magistrate and the nation as a whole stepping in
00:26:11 coming into obedience to christ with uh one of two ways they're open to both ways the two ways
00:26:17 being this, it could be a mass move of God's spirit and a revival and just sheer number of
00:26:24 regenerate hearts, 50% plus one of the population of these United States that are born again through,
00:26:30 you know, gospel preaching. And then that lends towards Christians who are in public office and
00:26:35 begin to legislate righteous laws. But they also, and I've noticed this as a distinction from some,
00:26:41 I can't speak for all theonomists, but some of the older school theonomists who have been like,
00:26:46 that's cute Christian nationalism. You know, we've been doing this for, you know, 40 years. 0.50
00:26:51 But I've noticed some of the theonomists are less comfortable where the CN, some of the younger guys
00:26:56 are, they're comfortable with bottom up, but also top down. Like they would say something,
00:27:02 and I would say this too, but they would say, you know, but like the Homo Jihad replaced the flag 0.73
00:27:09 of the United States with the rainbow in the course of 40 years with less than 3% of the 0.79
00:27:14 population so why why are christians not allowed to do that again that you know that a lot of
00:27:20 political change and and and when we understand that the law is a tutor so we're not saying that
00:27:25 that's going to save anybody but the law does function as a tutor and in a in a lawful country
00:27:30 there is more of an awareness the first use of the law more of an awareness of oh i'm a sinner i need
00:27:35 a savior and and it sets it works as that black velvet backdrop for the brilliance of the diamond
00:27:41 for those gospel preachers now to preach a gospel that maybe falls on less deaf ears. And so I feel
00:27:47 like, yeah, Lord, I'm going to pray for revival, but I'm also going to work towards, if we don't
00:27:53 have the numbers, that we still, that we could have a few high caliber men called by God that
00:28:01 would work into positions of civil leadership and do what's right, even if we're the minority.
00:28:06 in maybe that. It could be power from a minority that paves the way for gospel preaching and
00:28:13 revival. Or it could be revival. What do you guys think? Yeah, this is very true. If we got a King
00:28:18 Josiah, I would take it. You can do an awful lot of good top down. So I would thank God. I would
00:28:27 rejoice in it. I would pray for him. I would also be aware that after King Josiah died,
00:28:33 the people went back very quickly to the old ways so it's got to be i think it has to be both
00:28:39 you you have to have leadership genuine leadership godly a godly prince godly president godly
00:28:46 legislators are used by god to do good but the people have got to respond in true faith there's
00:28:52 got to be a genuine thing there and so i would i would like to see it meet in the middle we've been
00:28:59 praying for a Josiah. And it looks like in this next election, we might get a Jehu. 0.97
00:29:07 But I'll take the Jehu.
00:29:11 Dusty, any thoughts? Yeah. So if we get a Josiah, the Lord make it so, he's got to focus on 0.99
00:29:21 repentance orienting us back to the God not of this system but the God over all systems
00:29:27 whenever he does that and he's continually calling for repentance which is reorienting
00:29:35 our hearts and minds to our God alongside well he can be a great tool of repentance
00:29:46 not just correcting some laws but aiming at hearts aiming it not just stapling fruit to a dead tree
00:29:55 but changing the roots and we've got to one of the things that that let's just take an example
00:30:05 out of our current day if you run legislation to abolish pornography you might find yourself on
00:30:13 Jimmy Fallon? Any of the Jimmys. You might find yourself on there, not because you intend to,
00:30:23 but because you stick out so radically. And we should all ask ourselves, why would that even
00:30:28 stick out? Why would that make news? It shouldn't make Jimmy Fallon. It shouldn't even make our
00:30:35 local news because it shouldn't be a big deal. But it's such a big deal that it drives Rolling
00:30:42 stone, that it drives Jimmy Fallon, that it drives the Guardian and the UK Independent. It drives all
00:30:49 these conversations. Drives them nuts. It drives them. Yeah, absolutely drives them nuts, and it
00:30:57 drives the demons that are behind them all to say, we must defeat this God. There's a God here that
00:31:06 is untamable and unruly and there is someone in the camp claiming him and they do not want it
00:31:14 to be it shouldn't stick out so if you if this sticks out if you think about in your town if you
00:31:22 went to a city council meeting and say it and said we are going to let's pass legislation that would
00:31:29 that would abolish pornography or abolish abortion
00:31:33 and guarantee that no business could ever open in this town 0.98
00:31:39 or no one will ever practice abortion in this town.
00:31:43 And if anyone does, they'll all be treated as murderers
00:31:45 from the top to the bottom.
00:31:47 And if we start a pornography,
00:31:49 any place that allows pornography,
00:31:53 they're going to see steep fines.
00:31:56 If you went to your city council meeting
00:31:57 and said those kinds of things,
00:31:59 would the people care at all would they think well that's we're already doing that it's fine
00:32:06 great or would they say or would they maybe throw things at you would they run newspaper articles
00:32:15 that lambast you and just smear you uh what would be their response and so if you think about what
00:32:23 that response would be in your town if it would be wild and crazy like what has happened uh with
00:32:30 jimmy fallon and rolling stone then you you probably aren't doing much in your town there's 0.84
00:32:36 one additional difference if you said that in your town everybody would write you off as just a crazy
00:32:42 in uh lone nutcase um you're different because you ran on that platform and got elected and that
00:32:51 spooked them so if you had if you weren't an office holder and you just spoke up at a city
00:32:57 council you might be a 30 second clip on somebody's youtube channel but you got elected and you got
00:33:04 elected saying out loud what you wanted to do and there were a whole lot of people that agreed with
00:33:11 that and supported you and there were a lot of establishment christians who quietly tried to
00:33:19 submarine. In other words, I think your position is strategically critical.
00:33:28 You're at the state level. But why is it international news? Well, it's international
00:33:35 news because it's a harbinger of something that's coming. I completely agree. And I think
00:33:41 I've talked about this before. I think in a lot of ways, there are a few of us that are at the
00:33:47 tip of a battering ram of a door that's just made out of paper that's all it is it's no bulwark
00:33:54 i'll tell you that it's and if a bunch of you and if people across our nation come on uh it just
00:34:04 wasn't that great it wasn't that great uh if if a bunch of us would would just start taking action
00:34:15 you you might see god do something uh in our generation that we haven't seen in many generations
00:34:22 i think there's there's a a theological error that progressivism has weaponized against us
00:34:29 and it's it's kept it's made us to see the wielding or the the pursuit of power as an evil
00:34:36 as an unchristian act they've basically confused the spheres and taken if if you you know
00:34:44 if your eye causes you to lust, tear it out, and then said, why are you trying to ban pornography?
00:34:49 Why doesn't everybody just tear their eye out? Well, because there's different spheres. There's
00:34:52 a minister that wields a sword, and then there's you before the Lord, and those are different
00:34:56 things. But what the left has successfully done is they've convinced us that for Christians,
00:35:03 hilariously, in a Christian nation, fundamentally, a Protestant nation, which is what America
00:35:08 fundamentally is historically, they've convinced us that if we try to assert Protestant ethics, 0.67
00:35:15 that we're sinning and that we're actually being un-Christlike and that we need to be,
00:35:22 well, you're not being meek enough. And it's like, well, no, you're confused. I think that's
00:35:26 a huge part of this is that if you didn't run, then we wouldn't know that there were enough
00:35:31 people there that would resonate with to elect you. And then there's a whole cascading series
00:35:36 of events that happens when Christians, because that's an assertion of power. You're submitting 1.00
00:35:40 to the system of election and all that, but you're asserting power. You're saying, no,
00:35:44 Christians actually want, you're saying we want the power to legislate God's law with respect to
00:35:51 sexual mores and marriage and currency and all these different things. And I think that's
00:35:56 something that we're starting to see the tide turn, particularly in the Zoomer generation, 1.00
00:36:01 where they're seeing, I think, this error of pietism and they're reacting in the right direction. 0.97
00:36:06 Eric, anything you want to add?
00:36:08 Yeah, honestly, my question for Dusty and maybe Doug,
00:36:11 Doug, you talked about kind of a coming wave
00:36:14 or something's coming that's changing.
00:36:16 It seems like one of the X factors in all this, though,
00:36:19 is the evangelical establishment.
00:36:21 Because it's not just like when you win,
00:36:24 there's people at the top of the SBC that don't like that.
00:36:27 So you've actually got to overcome more.
00:36:29 And my question is, A, what's that wave coming?
00:36:32 So for Doug.
00:36:33 and how do you break through the elite establishment i would say first i just stole
00:36:40 joel's podcast you're the captain now i'm the captain so i would say the evangelical establishment
00:36:48 by and large discredited itself during covid and parts of that establishment haven't recognized
00:36:58 that they did that but some of them have right they've they've quietly exited retired that sort
00:37:07 of thing i don't think the establishment is any i believe it's a ghost of what it once was
00:37:13 and i believe that a lot of people and i think there's a lot of empty seats up there
00:37:19 i don't think god has raised up people yet to occupy the positions of influence and leadership
00:37:26 we're we're in the changing of the guard we've seen a good portion of the old guard leave
00:37:31 and we don't know who the next generation of leaders will be um but i'm hopeful i i
00:37:38 you know um i'm i'm hopeful i'm i'm looking at um i think god's got good things in store
00:37:46 and then the second part of your question was it sounded more like for dusty like how are you
00:37:51 going to break through the regime within evangelicalism yeah because it's twofold right
00:37:55 it's political but you're also going to deal with the ecclesial last you know that's fear
00:37:59 church and i mean i think that's exactly what's happening since covid i think it was a a shaking
00:38:06 awakening uh you know we've talked i think i said it in my message the things that are shakable
00:38:11 not only will shake but they must shake and i think that god is bringing quite the shaking
00:38:17 since COVID. And he is realigning some things and exposing where the, I mean, the cracks were
00:38:25 that needed to be just burst wide open. When we saw churches closing for long periods, we saw
00:38:33 people, you know, with this love your neighbor propaganda that was really submit to your
00:38:40 neighbor and not submit to God, submit to the powers that be. And a lot of us were saying the
00:38:46 powers that be don't have jurisdiction. They're illegitimate. And why have we been bowing to these
00:38:52 powers that are just pseudo? It's our fault. It's the fault of pastors for not telling us
00:38:58 better. And if you don't have strong pastors that are preaching the authority of God from
00:39:03 the scriptures and teaching their people that the authority lies in the scriptures and not in
00:39:09 the culture or in your leaders, but it's in the scriptures. And we all have to bow to the same
00:39:15 standard, then the pews are going to establish the culture. And the culture then establishes 0.93
00:39:22 your law because, you know, power arises from the people. And what we ended up with was just
00:39:28 a whole bunch of people who were willing to be led by weak leaders. And I think by God's grace,
00:39:34 um and and and i told doug this earlier um i think the role that um that doug wilson played during
00:39:46 covid for so many of us whether we were baptists or presbyterian or anglican or whatever
00:39:52 he called us back to our confessions we've dealt with this before guys are you know many many years
00:40:02 ago, these dead guys had solved some of these problems. And we've gone so far away from them,
00:40:09 trusting in our own wisdom, trusting in our own strength. We've forgotten the wisdom of our
00:40:15 fathers. And with that reawakening, I think that what you're seeing that I'm just a part of,
00:40:24 that all of you guys are a part of, we're seeing God raising up people who will trust his word,
00:40:31 no matter what the culture says, and be able to say, this is the last thing, you know, the sloth
00:40:37 says, or the sluggard says, there's a lion in the streets. We'll all be killed. And instead of saying, 0.94
00:40:41 oh no, there's a lion in the streets. I think God's raising up a bunch of men that say, let's go get
00:40:46 the lion boys. Let's go kill them. And that's the point. If there's a lion, then let's go. If there's 1.00
00:40:55 not then we just proved you wrong but either way we've got to fight i'm a little bit turnt up amen
00:41:04 turnt up you did you guys have no idea dusty was uh just ripping out you know just a cool clean
00:41:10 hundred set push-ups in the green room right before i'm not even it was like several hundred
00:41:16 push-ups seriously this guy um all right so here's here's a question that i have i also have some
00:41:22 answers, but I like to hear your answers. And when I say you're, I mean the plural, all of you guys.
00:41:27 So we're getting at, you know, is it top down? Is it bottom up? That's just one example, but I'm
00:41:32 sure there's other examples that you guys may think of that I don't. What are some of, I'll
00:41:38 first start it with if. Are there any differences, distinctions between the theonomist position
00:41:46 and a Christian nationalist position? Because that's been some of the pushback is just,
00:41:50 why do we need this we already have a label we already have a team we you know go fight win
00:41:55 and and you guys you know like you know again it's cute the christian nationalists showed up 15
00:42:00 minutes ago but we've been here for 40 years slugging it out and so what uh what are is
00:42:06 christian nationalism just a modern phrase for theonomy or are there actually some distinctions
00:42:11 if so what are there i would say the um the work on defining christian nationalism is stephen wolf's
00:42:18 he is very much in the magisterial protestant tradition he's in the natural law tradition
00:42:24 and he's a tomist the theonomists were vantilian um more uh focused on uh god telling us through
00:42:33 revelation does special revelation as opposed to natural law so there's some denominational
00:42:39 differences right so but i regard those as denominational differences because i believe
00:42:45 that if Stephen Wolfe got to be in charge,
00:42:51 I think the theonomists would be very happy
00:42:53 with most of what he does,
00:42:56 way happier than what we have now.
00:43:00 And if the theonomists were in charge,
00:43:03 I think Stephen Wolfe would be way happier
00:43:05 than what we've got now.
00:43:08 And I like to joke if I were president
00:43:10 and what a glorious three days that would be.
00:43:13 i think i think i'd make steven wolf happy and i think it'd make the i think there's a lot of
00:43:21 the venn diagrams there it's not circles that map onto each other perfectly but there's a
00:43:27 there are a lot of things that everybody who loves god loves his word wants to see and uh i think we
00:43:35 would be very pleased with most of it. We might say with whoever wrote Chronicles, he was a good
00:43:43 king, but he didn't remove the high places. There'd be some of that. But compared to what
00:43:49 we're dealing with now, which is just ungodliness and anarchy on stilts, we are tumbling headlong
00:43:59 into the abyss I would I would take a theonomist I would take a Christian nationalist of Stephen's
00:44:07 stripe I'd be delighted with any of them and this goes back to the earlier point of I want us to 0.70
00:44:13 make sure that we keep our eye on the main adversary and not have not break out into intramural
00:44:20 quarrels it's the it's the disciples on the road arguing about who's going to be great in the
00:44:27 kingdom that we don't have yet you know that's good with real quick going back a page with the
00:44:34 top down bottom up thing um would you say the christian nationalists seem very comfortable
00:44:39 with top down um and not to the expense of bottom up we don't want anything less than revival but
00:44:46 in terms of chronological order and what god in his sovereignty he's his prerogative what he chooses
00:44:50 to do the the cn guys that i talked to offline they seem very comfortable with you know a a you
00:44:56 You know, slim minority getting it done, at least initially.
00:45:02 You know this crew much more than I do.
00:45:04 You've been around the block.
00:45:05 The Theonomists, I'm thinking the Theonomists of old.
00:45:09 I'm thinking of Bonson. 0.99
00:45:10 Were they as comfortable as some of the CN Young Bucks
00:45:14 with a minority approach of it's top-down first that leads them to bottom up? 0.91
00:45:18 I believe the old guard Theonomists and their heirs 0.96
00:45:21 would think that a top-down Christian prince would be a good thing 0.89
00:45:27 They would applaud it, but they wouldn't have high hopes for the long run.
00:45:33 Because they would say, this is great, but going back to what you said, we need the hearts of the people.
00:45:40 But there is a bully pulpit aspect to this that Solomon is the king, civil ruler, and he leads the people in worship when he dedicates the temple.
00:45:51 So I think that there's a number of things that the leaders could do if they agree with the theonomists that it's got to be heart change, then they can be part of that, should be part of it.
00:46:06 I think that's such an important point because some of the pushback that you get from people who have violently reacted against both theonomy, honestly, and Christian nationalism,
00:46:17 I think one of the key points they're missing is the didactic value of law.
00:46:24 Laws don't just result from the culture of a people.
00:46:27 Laws then turn around and shape the culture of the people.
00:46:30 So there is a very real sense in which culture is downstream from worship,
00:46:35 but part of our worship produces a legal system that then continues to disciple and radicalize people further and further.
00:46:42 So you can take something like no-fault divorce.
00:46:44 it didn't just capture well we we have this new idea about marriage and divorce it then turned
00:46:51 around and discipled people about what is marriage all about what is the nature of happiness in
00:46:55 marriage what is a successful marriage is marriage a permanent thing at all so like law has a
00:47:02 didactic value a didactic value and that's part of the top-down conversation is that that three
00:47:08 percent gets a dusty deavers elected and then dusty gets signal boosted by all the you know
00:47:14 the leftists that hate him and he ends up they end up accidentally discipling a couple thousand
00:47:19 more people every time they do that to agree with you who didn't previously right wing boost a very
00:47:24 clear gospel presentation of everything they could have cut out of our i mean any number of the
00:47:29 podcasts i've done they cut a three-minute gospel presentation and they sent it out and that's
00:47:34 exactly what we're talking about. That's why I try to be very clear whenever I'm addressing a crowd
00:47:39 or addressing the media. I step up. Like, we had a big event at the Capitol at the beginning of
00:47:50 February. And the first thing that I did, there was media lined up everywhere. And I said, media,
00:47:55 this is for you. You need to come to Christ. And I preached the gospel. If you, you know, if you're
00:48:00 bound, you are bound in your sin. You're in rebellion against our Lord. And I preached just
00:48:06 a very clear, straightforward gospel message, calling them to come to Christ. And I think
00:48:11 that's where, if we're going to talk about a top down, we have to be very clear that we're not just
00:48:16 here to write laws. We're writing laws that are orienting us to the lawgiver, but we can only
00:48:22 rightly orient ourselves to the lawgiver, not by external law, but by the internal submission to
00:48:28 the lawgiver and trust in him and receiving his grace, receiving the Lord Jesus, and then living
00:48:35 our lives in accordance with him. External law should match the internal law of the heart so
00:48:41 that the conscience and the law of the land are in union. They're in unity. We're not warring
00:48:46 against those things. So yeah, right wing, right wing boost. You know, they sent the gospel message
00:48:53 out to however many hundred thousand, and that's, I think, the very nature of what God is doing
00:49:00 right now. I think he's going to raise more people up, and if and when he does, I just want
00:49:06 to encourage you, let the gospel be at the front, and yes, do your job, and write your laws, and go
00:49:12 into the statehouse, and make good, strong biblical arguments, and write good law,
00:49:21 but have conversation
00:49:23 and be in the public sphere
00:49:25 if they stick a mic in your face
00:49:27 tell them about the goodness and the glory of Christ
00:49:29 Amen
00:49:30 Amen
00:49:31 Here's another question
00:49:36 about distinctions
00:49:37 theonomy, seeing
00:49:39 sometimes you have to
00:49:41 plan a conference
00:49:43 and plan a panel
00:49:46 just so that you can get Doug
00:49:48 to answer your personal questions
00:49:50 And so that's, you know, so indulge me.
00:49:53 But, you know, I've waited a long time for this.
00:49:54 No shame, Joel.
00:49:55 No shame.
00:49:56 But it seems like one of the other distinctions,
00:49:59 correct me if I'm wrong on this,
00:50:00 but would be, so top down, bottom up,
00:50:02 another one would be, what about timeline?
00:50:04 Like I think sometimes,
00:50:05 and this is less of a theonomy thing,
00:50:07 although certainly they overlap,
00:50:08 but more of an eschatology thing,
00:50:10 a post-millennial thing.
00:50:11 I think, Dusty, you're post-millennial, right?
00:50:14 Yep.
00:50:14 So all five of us are post-millennial.
00:50:16 know um but it it does sometimes seem like there's there's a crew that's like uh we will have a
00:50:23 christian nation in 5 000 years you know and then and then a lot of the christian nationalists one
00:50:28 of the things that i appreciate i'm not saying i agree i'm post-millennial right so i think if you
00:50:35 have a different eschatology god bless you you're wrong you know as in texas we say god you know
00:50:39 god bless your heart you know but um but what i appreciate though is the immediacy that um you
00:50:45 There's this sense of maybe 50 years and not 5,000.
00:50:48 Stephen Wolfe says, why not now?
00:50:50 If you have power, then why not exercise it now?
00:50:56 And I think that that's great.
00:50:59 And I think that when you enroll in a math class,
00:51:01 the first thing you encounter would be math problems.
00:51:06 If you're a post-millennialist,
00:51:08 the first temptation you're going to encounter is post-mill problems,
00:51:11 which manana you know the kingdom is going to come sometime and we don't have to worry about it
00:51:17 that is the temptation of the post-millennialist the pre-millennialist is tempted to think it
00:51:23 doesn't do any good what no matter what we do it's all going to blazes um so but everybody's
00:51:28 got their temptations and i i think that anybody who has authority and power and wields it for good
00:51:34 immediately should be applauded, supported, prayed for. I happen to think it's not going to take
00:51:42 as deep root as it's going to for hundreds of years, but that's no excuse to avoid doing the
00:51:50 good you can now. As the great theologian Shia LaBeouf says, don't let your dreams be dreams.
00:51:57 yesterday you said tomorrow tomorrow you'll say you know some other time why not today you know
00:52:06 just do it uh and so if if God puts you in that position just do it let your dreams be reality
00:52:14 he's he's causing that so plant your seed water it and let him bring the growth and he might bring
00:52:22 the growth today because it's a very fast rising seed and you don't forget about working on all the
00:52:28 other seeds in the garden too gk gk chesterton said the one taste of paradise on earth is to
00:52:35 fight in a losing cause and then not lose yep yep amen i'll have what dusty's having
00:52:42 it's fantastic i feel like just the vicinity is okay yeah there it is um squirrely joe's
00:52:50 that's christened him's coffee right there um eric or brian either but uh the idea of the
00:52:56 we could win and maybe we could win soon what do you think any thoughts on that or or if you don't
00:53:03 have something on that other distinctions in this theonomy versus cn slash where do we overlap where
00:53:09 is it different what what do you think i mean personally i think a lot of this stuff we get
00:53:13 into like the timeline questions and how much change could happen i think a lot of that is
00:53:18 actually beyond us, right? Like, so when I think about this, I'm like, well, have I seen change in
00:53:23 Ogden? Can I pastor my people? Can I love my family, right? And can I support Dusty? Can I
00:53:28 support that cause? So a lot of it is like, well, that's up to the Lord, right? But can you put
00:53:34 your shoulder behind the plow? So I think a lot of it, for most people, it's like, you're probably
00:53:38 not going to run for office, right? But I know that like with Dusty, like, but we can pray for
00:53:43 in Sunday worship, like we can do that.
00:53:46 We know the Lord answers prayer.
00:53:48 He answers the prayers of a righteous man, right?
00:53:50 So I think some of it is not to overcomplicate it.
00:53:54 You do whatever you can do today
00:53:55 with all your heart, with all your might,
00:53:58 and you pray and you see what the Lord does.
00:54:01 Yeah, that's right.
00:54:02 We're always trying to keep our eye
00:54:05 on 500 years down the road and five minutes from now.
00:54:10 And those aren't mutually exclusive goals.
00:54:12 You set your compass bearing for a real long way off, and you're going to have to pass through a lot of steps on your way there.
00:54:20 And to God be the result.
00:54:22 Like, amen.
00:54:23 God's going to be the Lord of those results.
00:54:26 And it just is the case that the world is very difficult to predict.
00:54:30 If it was easy to predict, I would have bought Bitcoin like a long, long time.
00:54:37 Obviously, you know, I'd have a whole lot of Bitcoin, and I'd have a yacht.
00:54:41 and Joel Webin would be, you know, invited on
00:54:43 and you could do your podcast on the yacht.
00:54:45 But I think it's, you see how quickly things can turn?
00:54:49 Woulda, coulda, shoulda.
00:54:50 Yeah, woulda, coulda, shoulda.
00:54:51 But I mean, Barack Obama ran on a non-pro gay marriage platform
00:54:58 like in what, 2008?
00:55:01 And here we are today.
00:55:03 Like things can change fast.
00:55:06 And not only fast in the wrong direction.
00:55:09 That's correct.
00:55:10 And that's something that I think Wilson and you guys with Kings Hall and others, Rigney, have been really helpful with was thinking of like Constantine.
00:55:18 It's like, yeah, sometimes the Christians in the province of God all of a sudden find themselves with immense affluence and influence and power, and they weren't quite ready for it.
00:55:27 So maybe it's not just LARPing.
00:55:28 Like, you know, with our congregation, I've preached this sermon like almost back to back twice, but I didn't title this, but essentially the title was, you got to LARP before you can fly.
00:55:37 Like, sure, there is something to be said for cosplaying and LARPing and grifting
00:55:41 where the person has no inward pure motive.
00:55:44 You know, there's no desire for God's glory or his kingdom or his, you know, none of that.
00:55:49 And so, I mean, it's strictly, you know, it's a Judas type thing.
00:55:51 He's helping himself out of the money bag.
00:55:53 That's it.
00:55:54 But any time you've gotten way off the rails and you try to make a change, 0.73
00:55:59 it's going to look silly at first.
00:56:02 You know, if, yeah, any kind of major change.
00:56:05 If a guy's an alcoholic, you know, he's been drinking, you know, a fifth every single day,
00:56:10 and now all of a sudden he's going to try to get in shape.
00:56:12 He's going to try to be healthy.
00:56:13 He's going to try to get a job.
00:56:15 It'd be real easy for anybody who knows him to say, you know, like, you know, cosplay, LARPer, grifter, you know.
00:56:22 It's like, or repenter.
00:56:24 And repentance, initial repentance, when you're already way off the rails for an individual or society,
00:56:30 at least the beginning steps, even, you know, like Paul Washer talked about this.
00:56:34 i remember hearing this clip i was like thank goodness because every paul washer i was like
00:56:38 i'm going to hell for sure and then you know and then i heard this one and you know he was talking
00:56:42 about the kernels of repentance and i mean to hear it from anybody would be encouraging but to hear
00:56:47 from paul washer i was like like that guy would not i mean this guy does not preach soft sermons
00:56:52 like i probably hurt him to preach this sermon and like so like you know it's good and you know
00:56:56 you can take it to the bank but he was just saying that if our repentance is perfect if we could
00:57:00 achieve perfect repentance guess what we wouldn't need repentance because we could achieve perfect
00:57:04 living the only reason you don't live the reason you don't obey perfectly is because you have
00:57:08 imperfect faith and imperfect repentance because your repentance is not perfectly full and your
00:57:13 faith is is not always there but at times wanes that's the whole reason you said and um so then
00:57:19 what what does repentance look like in in vitro you know what is what does repentance look like
00:57:26 in its kernel stages and what does that look like at a corporate level as a society what would it
00:57:31 look like for the beginning of America to repent. Like, it might look like women making sourdough 1.00
00:57:38 and wearing, you know, sundresses. And that's why I want to say, okay, there, now there can be a 0.98
00:57:43 grift side of this. That is true. But I don't want to blanket, I want to be careful not to disparage
00:57:48 this. And then as it pertains to, you know, the Constantine kind of moment where all of a sudden
00:57:51 you're thrust into power, that's why, you know, back to theonomy and God's law and all these kinds
00:57:56 things in Christian nationality. No, it's not 0.99
00:57:58 LARPing to talk about
00:57:59 if the Presbyterians get power, what
00:58:02 will they do with the Baptists?
00:58:04 That's not a silly conversation.
00:58:06 That's to make sure the Baptists don't get drowned. 0.89
00:58:08 Sit them down and talk to them. 0.69
00:58:10 Yeah, exactly.
00:58:12 Next to a lake.
00:58:13 We complain. No, Eric, no.
00:58:16 We'll complain about...
00:58:18 Well, so far, it looks like, if anything, 1.00
00:58:20 the Baptists are going to be... 0.59
00:58:21 You're outnumbered 10 to 1. 1.00
00:58:23 They're going to sit us down.
00:58:24 Yeah, exactly. 0.99
00:58:25 I saw Dusty doing push-ups. 1.00
00:58:27 I'm going to dry off your children.
00:58:31 It's too late.
00:58:32 Too late, Dusty.
00:58:34 In my mind, they're metaphorically wet.
00:58:36 They're still wet, yeah.
00:58:37 The sprinkling has happened, Dusty.
00:58:39 It can't be undone.
00:58:41 Remember the baptism. 0.92
00:58:41 They're going to convert at some point, Lord willing,
00:58:43 and then they can truly be baptized.
00:58:47 All right, that's enough.
00:58:49 But with all that being said, the point is sacralism, right?
00:58:54 Like James White has talked about this.
00:58:55 James White is awesome.
00:58:56 Praise God for him.
00:58:58 And it's, yes, like the little, the hole, you know,
00:59:01 and you're down there and Luther,
00:59:03 I think it was Luther, it was like next to him, right?
00:59:05 The Baptist that was kept in a hole.
00:59:07 Was it Luther that was in the same room?
00:59:09 No, not in the same room.
00:59:11 I think it was the same castle.
00:59:13 But close.
00:59:14 Yeah.
00:59:14 And he knew, and he knew.
00:59:15 And so then how do you,
00:59:18 I think it's advantageous to not figure out Christendom
00:59:23 once it already happened so let's play this out for a minute so if if someone said i'm afraid
00:59:29 that if christian nationalism took you guys would take power and then you'd start persecuting other
00:59:35 christians you know the presbyterians persecuting the baptists and i'd say okay let's say we're not
00:59:41 going to do that but let's say that your nightmare came true and we were doing that we were persecuting
00:59:47 baptists would that make jesus angry or happy angry okay i think we'd all agree that would
00:59:56 make him angry so do you think that we should modify our behavior down here so that we don't
01:00:01 make jesus angry yeah and i said well welcome to christian nationalism
01:00:06 we've come full circle so you think we should do more of what jesus likes
01:00:14 I too am a Christian nationalist
01:00:16 and Stephen Wolf
01:00:18 took 400 pages to write that
01:00:20 do what Jesus likes 1.00
01:00:21 Christian nation gooder than transing kids 1.00
01:00:24 that's it
01:00:24 any thoughts Brian or Eric
01:00:29 any other
01:00:31 last distinctions with the CEN
01:00:34 versus the Reconstructionist
01:00:36 I would say it's not a versus thing
01:00:38 no it shouldn't be but I just
01:00:39 I hear it framed sometimes
01:00:41 I believe that
01:00:43 we're dealing with, if God grants us any measure of success, as I believe he is in the process of
01:00:50 doing, it's going to involve millions of people. Right. Right. And, and among these millions of
01:00:57 people, there will be all sorts of differences, all sorts of different emphases. And you can thank
01:01:04 God for the, man, I wouldn't have done it that way, but I like their way of doing it better than
01:01:10 my way of not doing it and i think we can we can give thanks to god that christian nationalism
01:01:17 is a national conversation or a worldwide conversation in some ways because the current
01:01:25 or the theonomist can look and say well we've been doing this for a long time uh we've had
01:01:31 westminster we've had the 1689 this is we've had various flavors of theonomy you guys are late to
01:01:39 the game, and they should probably be saying, great, what we've wanted for a long time is
01:01:45 actually a mainstream conversation. The guys who are late to the game, who are saying,
01:01:51 well, Christian nationalism, Christian nationalism, and they don't know a whole lot about historic
01:01:57 perspectives on theonomy or the law of God, they can look back and say, thank you. Thank you for
01:02:04 laying the groundwork so that both in, in, in right now we have, we don't have enemies of each
01:02:10 other, but we see the true and proper enemy that is the enemy of our souls, that ancient serpent
01:02:16 and who is devouring people and he need not divide us. So we need to be thankful for each other.
01:02:25 The, the new guys coming in should be thankful for the magisterial reformers,
01:02:30 the theonomists thank you for all the spade work you did and the old guard should be saying thank
01:02:36 you lord for the fresh blood thank you for this infusion of energy thank you for this opportunity
01:02:42 yeah so much so much of this is um it's being thankful that god is a god who seems to delight
01:02:53 in lots of differentness like he just does it constantly where there's differentness
01:02:58 and a lot of this i think the turmoil really does come down to turf war some of the time like turf
01:03:05 war of this ministry you know what is it their market share of this camp versus this camp donors
01:03:12 yeah donors and and and power and but there's something at the bottom of that that i think
01:03:18 sometimes gets overlooked and it's that turf wars aren't all evil in the sense that turf wars are
01:03:26 fought over convictions and you don't want somebody who you think is wrong to win the hearts
01:03:31 and minds of more people. So when you see somebody who's turf warring with you, it's good to stop and
01:03:38 say, they're really convinced that they're right about this and that I'm wrong about that. And
01:03:43 maybe have a charity to say, I'm actually going to start with the assumption until they prove me
01:03:48 wrong that they love the people and they don't want them to be discipled by what they see as
01:03:53 error. And if we could take some of the heat out of it and start with that kind of understanding,
01:03:59 I think that can help. And then that's not at all inconsistent with then saying,
01:04:03 and I'm going to flat out believe you're wrong. Here's the 17 point reason why. And I think that
01:04:10 your argument should fail and that my argument should win the hearts and minds of more people
01:04:14 than yours because yours happens to be wrong, right? So it's a really tough tightrope walk
01:04:19 because there's compromise for political reasons
01:04:22 that's a temptation there,
01:04:23 but you can't, I think you can't just start
01:04:26 with the presupposition,
01:04:28 well, there are two people in this debate,
01:04:30 me and people who agree with me, 1.00
01:04:32 and then idiots, 1.00
01:04:33 which is what the flesh wants to do 1.00
01:04:36 with literally everything.
01:04:37 Two ministers were having lunch one time,
01:04:40 and one of them said,
01:04:41 well, we both serve God, you in your way,
01:04:44 and I in his.
01:04:47 Exactly.
01:04:49 So it doesn't mean compromise.
01:04:51 I'm not saying compromise.
01:04:52 I'm not saying relativism,
01:04:53 but I'm saying there is such thing as Christian charity
01:04:56 and Christian charity is really, really important
01:04:59 for what Pastor Wilson's talking about.
01:05:01 And when we're all trying to get the right principles
01:05:05 landed the right way,
01:05:06 we do need to be careful not to see the hordes, 1.00
01:05:13 the Viking hordes approaching 1.00
01:05:14 and then turn around and stab everybody around me 1.00
01:05:19 constantly like that really is a temptation yeah the reason why we can have so much banter
01:05:25 on the platform and you guys are presbyterians clearly we're baptists the reason why we can
01:05:32 have the banter is because we know what time it is we're not fighting each other here
01:05:36 there was a time when we would fight over these things and there still are times you know
01:05:42 closed doors or in our churches, in our denominations. And it's still good to have
01:05:50 those things, but know what time it is. There's a great enemy and we need to be together on this
01:05:56 and fight it. Legalist was an elf and Gimli was a dwarf, but we're in the middle of Helm's Deep.
01:06:04 That's the situation we're in. Dr. Boot and I a while back, he was gracious enough to come on
01:06:09 the podcast, and we did an episode on baptism, and we just talked about how the sons of Issachar
01:06:16 know the times, and the debate about baptism, we don't want to make it trivial, because God's
01:06:22 word matters, and somebody's right, and somebody's wrong, and baptism, it's a sacrament, it matters,
01:06:26 but, you know, we were just talking about, you know, in some sense, you can track historically
01:06:34 within the church, when the Baptist, you know, kind of baptismal arguments were the fiercest,
01:06:42 they were, you know, they were, it was a luxury of Christendom. It was a luxury of the Christians 1.00
01:06:47 are winning. Like the, you know, like the Christian talking about turf wars, the Christians have like 1.00
01:06:52 a monopoly on all turf, you know, so like the Christians are in charge here. And so we can 1.00
01:06:57 afford to talk about, you know, baptism and strongly disagree. And there are just a lot of
01:07:01 churches, right? So it's like, you've got this good Baptist church and this good Presbyterian
01:07:05 church, and they're both across the street. And so, of course, naturally, if you're of 0.98
01:07:09 credo-baptist convictions, then you're going to go to the Baptist church. Whereas now,
01:07:14 part of the reason why I still have a position, but part of the reason why I've changed my
01:07:19 philosophy of ministry, not my theology, but my philosophy of ministry, my presentation
01:07:24 on baptism, I'll still tongue-in-cheek make a joke, but for the most part, people know I'm
01:07:28 joking, and I'm charitable with it, is because they don't have the option. There is not a
01:07:32 Presbyterian church across the street from mine. There is, not quite across it, but there are a
01:07:39 few, actually. But they closed for 16 months with COVID. They were woke with BLM. And so I've got
01:07:47 dear Presbyterian brothers and sisters who are like, we'd rather go to the Baptist church with
01:07:51 the spine than the Presbyterian church that folded like a cheap suit, you know? And that's
01:07:56 You just have to recognize that's a unique time.
01:07:59 So my position is not baptismal catholicity, lowercase c.
01:08:05 I would not put that as my position for all of the gospel age.
01:08:09 I wouldn't write that down in a book and recommend that to our spiritual sons 500 years from now
01:08:15 if Christendom is shining, you know, like Pilgrim's Progress, you know,
01:08:19 like if religion is walking in her glass slippers. 0.93
01:08:22 And I would say, well, in that case, yeah, the Baptist, get in your Baptist church,
01:08:26 presbyterian get in your presbyterian church and still you know have a cigar night you know on
01:08:30 monday but but on sunday worship in your respective places but that is not that's just not where we
01:08:36 are if i could throw one historical note in in here because we're sometimes the victims of
01:08:42 anachronistic thinking because we don't realize that one of the features of the older christendom
01:08:48 was that we we are so used to the voluntarist system of denominations where you just choose
01:08:54 where you want to go. And it's sort of baked into our American DNA. And I think it's an upgrade. I
01:09:00 like that. But in the older Christendom, there were all sorts of things that were tied together.
01:09:07 So baptism was tied to things like citizenship. You know, it wasn't just a denominational
01:09:13 distinctive. And I was just a year or so ago in Boston, and they've got statues. There's a statue
01:09:21 I saw it to a Quaker woman who was executed in Massachusetts back in the 17th century.
01:09:27 And you think, oh, man, you know, good grief, why'd they have to do that?
01:09:31 And I'm not saying it was good that they did that, but it's anachronistic thinking. 1.00
01:09:36 These Quaker women would parade through Boston naked, and they would try to exile them, and they'd keep coming back. 1.00
01:09:44 They wouldn't, they were just being pestilent. 1.00
01:09:47 It was a legal, it was not just a theological denominational thing.
01:09:53 It was a legal sort of thing.
01:09:57 The Salem Witch Trials, the charter of Massachusetts expired.
01:10:03 And they didn't have any legal justification for functioning.
01:10:09 They sent someone back to England to get the charter renewed.
01:10:13 And while he was gone, the Salem Witch Trials broke out.
01:10:17 And it was a local trial in Salem, and it was a hysteria and a bad business.
01:10:24 And then when the charter came back, they had a legal government again.
01:10:29 The Puritan ministers of Massachusetts applied to the governor to have the witch trials suppressed.
01:10:36 So the Puritans suppress the witch trials is not the headline you've read.
01:10:41 There was a lot of legal background that we have forgotten.
01:10:47 So when you hear Christians fighting Christians, sometimes it was all jumbled up with national interests and legal issues.
01:10:55 And it was not just what we would have today.
01:11:02 Joe, you said something that I want to see if you can clarify.
01:11:06 It sounded like you were trying to wash over some of the distinctions of denominations at this time.
01:11:17 I'm not for that.
01:11:19 Is that what you were saying?
01:11:21 No, baptismal Catholicity, not washing over the distinctions of denominations,
01:11:25 but saying that I do think that there is a case to be made for something like the CREC
01:11:33 that would accommodate both positions on mode of baptism at this juncture.
01:11:40 I don't know, like if it was the 1700s, it may not be the position.
01:11:47 But John Bunyan's church did it.
01:11:49 John Bunyan was a Baptist, and he would receive into membership people
01:11:56 who were baptized in infancy, provided they were godly Christians.
01:11:59 So this division, this issue is not a new one.
01:12:06 It goes all the way back.
01:12:07 So there's a hardline Baptist position.
01:12:12 There's a more ecumenical position represented by Bunyan.
01:12:15 And on the other side, on the Presbyterian side, you've got the same hardliners.
01:12:19 Nope, you've got to do it this way.
01:12:22 And in our church, we have a baptismal cooperation agreement where the church is Pato-Baptist.
01:12:28 we subscribe to the Westminster Confession
01:12:30 but we receive Baptists
01:12:33 into membership and good standing
01:12:35 and we defer to the parents' understanding
01:12:37 of baptism
01:12:37 so when their child professes faith
01:12:41 then we baptize them
01:12:42 the tough thing with that is that baptism
01:12:44 unfortunately, just logically
01:12:46 the way that it plays out is not
01:12:48 a two-way street as much as it is a one-way
01:12:51 stream, it is much easier for the Presbyterian 1.00
01:12:53 practically to accommodate the Credo Baptist 1.00
01:12:54 that's why we do it 1.00
01:12:56 Go ahead, Dusty. I know you have a point to make.
01:12:59 We go the easy route.
01:13:01 So just in case people are thinking, oh, no, they are moving to that fight between Baptists and Presbyterians and making it, they're forgetting what time it is.
01:13:11 We're not. We've moved into it in an internecine fight.
01:13:16 But we're still willing to say we are willing to fight for the Southern Baptist Convention.
01:13:23 We are willing to fight for a conservative Presbyterianism.
01:13:27 We're willing to fight for a CREC.
01:13:29 We're willing to fight for those things, but we're also willing to fight together for much greater fights as well. 0.87
01:13:37 We want to retain the denominations.
01:13:39 We want to retain the infrastructures.
01:13:42 We want to conserve.
01:13:43 We want to criticize.
01:13:44 We want to correct and create where we need to.
01:13:46 but we at the same time need to come together to fight this serpentine theocracy that's been
01:13:54 pouring across our country all right this is maybe my my last question for you guys
01:13:59 um another thing that i've heard people say is well you know the christian nationalist guys are
01:14:04 against uh you guys just don't seem like you just don't love our sacred democracy enough you know
01:14:11 or you're just you know my constitution you're just not constitutioning hard enough you know what
01:14:16 What if we try classical liberalism even harder?
01:14:19 You know, have we thought about that?
01:14:20 And so what do you guys, I have my answer for that.
01:14:24 I like the Constitution.
01:14:25 I would tell them to read a book.
01:14:27 Read a book.
01:14:29 There's just flagrant historical ignorance.
01:14:33 Because what we are talking about is restoring the Constitution,
01:14:37 returning to the way it was.
01:14:39 People think that James Madison,
01:14:42 they've confused
01:14:44 Earl Warren with James Madison
01:14:46 so the changes
01:14:49 that were brought about in the mid
01:14:50 20th century that were ushered
01:14:53 in was a subversion of
01:14:55 the constitution
01:14:56 it was a subversion of our constitutional
01:14:59 way of governing ourselves 1.00
01:15:00 which was explicitly Christian
01:15:03 there was a supreme court decision
01:15:05 in 1892
01:15:06 exquisitely named
01:15:09 Holy Trinity versus the United States of America
01:15:11 that's on the nose man they should have just looked at and i won't go into the setup of the
01:15:19 case but they decided the case rightly it was a church named holy trinity against the united
01:15:24 states they decided the case rightly and then justice brewer the chief justice said and while
01:15:30 we're on the subject let me tell you why america is a christian nation this is the majority opinion
01:15:35 In 1892, and that year was closer to the year of my birth than this year, today, is to my birth.
01:15:44 It wasn't that long ago.
01:15:46 You might say, well, how old are you?
01:15:50 You'd have to do a lot of math to figure that out.
01:15:52 Well, 1892, basically, that was one lifetime.
01:15:57 One lifetime before my birth.
01:16:00 1892, we're a Christian nation.
01:16:02 and we functionally were down until the mid 20th century and and we're talking about getting back
01:16:11 to that i'll take that and let's take take that as a platform and work from there uh and people
01:16:16 say no you're destroying democracy you're destroying the constitution by what returning to it
01:16:22 right so i think it was madison that talked about our constitution if it's not upheld uh and there's
01:16:32 others who said something similar, but it can become just a parchment barrier. It depends on
01:16:38 the will of the people. So if the people are grounded in the Christian tradition, then that
01:16:47 parchment barrier is thick. It's meaningful. It matters because the standard matters in the hearts 0.74
01:16:56 in the minds of the people, but it becomes just a paper, like tissue paper, parchment barrier,
01:17:02 if the morality of the people has slidden far away from Christian morals, and now you just
01:17:09 have whatever, and we don't have a standard. John Adams, our second president, said,
01:17:16 our constitution presupposes a moral and a religious people. He said, it is wholly unfit
01:17:21 for any other.
01:17:23 And that's true.
01:17:24 And I think one of the interesting things
01:17:27 is, shameless plug, Kelly,
01:17:29 that if you look at the spirituality
01:17:33 or the cosmology that's starting to rise
01:17:37 among our, at least in America,
01:17:42 they're looking towards spiritual things
01:17:45 far more than they have been for years.
01:17:48 If you've got Joe Rogan,
01:17:50 who's clearly working on psychedelics and that those psychedelics are bringing him closer to a
01:17:56 spiritual reality than and even him saying we need Jesus and not not saying that really tongue in
01:18:03 cheek he's leading in and saying we need Jesus and you've got like even if he doesn't believe in
01:18:07 him he's like somebody needs Jesus yeah maybe not me but you need Jesus yeah Jordan Peterson
01:18:12 even Graham Hancock talking so much about the spiritual I think what you're seeing with the
01:18:19 popularity of of podcasts and um that are really talking about this um that we're we're we're
01:18:31 horseshoeing you know we're going back to this pharmakeia and and really tapping into the
01:18:36 spiritual nature and i think that's why haunted cosmos has become i was gonna say somebody's
01:18:41 been listening to haunted cosmos yeah cosmos thanks he corrected our pronunciation based on
01:18:46 the greek but i said it's the same reason i don't walk into a restaurant and say i would like
01:18:50 an extra tortilla with my burrito so you actually do say that though at chili's at chili's he says
01:19:01 it at chili's he doesn't even go to the taqueria he goes to chili's and says that so well yeah i
01:19:09 I mean, intelligent guy, great restaurant.
01:19:13 Did all you guys read Age of Entitlement, Christopher Caldwell?
01:19:18 Yeah.
01:19:18 Yeah.
01:19:21 Who's read in the audience?
01:19:23 Who's read Christopher Caldwell, Age of Entitlement?
01:19:26 Raise your hand.
01:19:27 I'm just curious.
01:19:28 I'd highly recommend it.
01:19:29 I think it's really helpful.
01:19:30 His point, and I think it's the point that I would make
01:19:32 and a lot of other guys would make,
01:19:34 is it's not that, oh, the Constitution is terrible.
01:19:38 the constitution's wonderful um it'd be great if we still had it yeah that's that's his argument
01:19:45 is just and and how do you get rid of something like because it's you know it's just too obvious
01:19:49 nobody's gonna it'll never it'll never work to just you know unless you're nicholas cage nobody
01:19:54 can just take you know the constitution and make it disappear but yeah but he had to give it back
01:19:58 joel right yeah right but this is what you can do what if instead of getting rid of the constitution
01:20:02 Or what if you could take a lens, a particular, you know, you know, a way of interpreting and and and you don't get rid of the Constitution, but you put a lens over the Constitution that becomes the de facto Constitution to where for all intents and purposes, functionally, you now have another, you know, another binding document.
01:20:23 When I was reading that book, Age of Entitlement,
01:20:26 he was throwing hand grenades every direction.
01:20:30 And I was reading this, and I looked at the spy, and who published this?
01:20:34 I know, it's pretty bold.
01:20:35 Well, Claremont.
01:20:37 And I thought, what's going on over there?
01:20:40 And this is another harbinger of people are saying out loud
01:20:45 things that they never would have said out loud 40 years ago.
01:20:50 And we're able to talk to this – if we'd been talking like this in the 70s, there would have been 20 of you.
01:21:01 This is a very different time.
01:21:04 I do wonder, to your original question, the people have some discomfort.
01:21:11 I don't even remember what it was.
01:21:12 To worship our sacred democracy.
01:21:15 And I do think there is at least a portion of the Christian nationalist conversation that is willing to say, maybe we're too pluralistic from the foundation, even from the beginning.
01:21:28 Maybe there's a little bit too much enlightenment.
01:21:31 Maybe there's a little bit too much sprinkled in of that, even as much.
01:21:35 And the upgrade from today to the original thing would be, you know, miles and miles better.
01:21:40 but i do think that there is a willingness and maybe that's where some of this pushback comes
01:21:44 with as well for people to say yeah but maybe there was a little bit too much deism and maybe
01:21:50 there was a little bit let's not to gloss over all the disagreements and you know maybe maybe
01:21:56 we do want to say that there is first table of the law type of not that there wasn't a lot of
01:22:05 that going on but is that part of this so um yes there were there were deistic currents
01:22:10 but jefferson and franklin were probably the only um father founding fathers who were toying with
01:22:18 deism and they were both very bad deists um because they believed that god intervened in
01:22:24 human affairs but they were liberals and affected by the enlightenment but at the constitutional
01:22:30 convention there were 55 men there and 50 of the 55 were orthodox trinitarian christians and
01:22:37 jefferson was in france um at the time and basically it was overwhelmingly christian
01:22:44 with currents here and there um i'd recommend um if you want a real bracing reads go back and read
01:22:52 the early rush duty um this independent republic which i i've been going back and reading him again
01:22:58 And I just finished this Independent Republic again.
01:23:01 It's a really bracing read.
01:23:04 And he pinpoints the areas where there was compromise,
01:23:07 where the founders left a few doors unlocked.
01:23:11 You left some doors unlocked in a bad neighborhood.
01:23:15 It's that level of...
01:23:18 Great.
01:23:20 All right.
01:23:20 Thank you, guys, for serving us this evening and all day.
01:23:24 And we look forward to tomorrow.
01:23:26 I know some of you guys, you brought your kids with you.
01:23:27 God bless you.
01:23:28 Thank you for bringing them and making it a family affair.
01:23:31 And so some of you are probably going to have to head out.
01:23:32 But real quick, before some of you dismiss,
01:23:35 and then as many of you who want, stay for the after party.
01:23:38 We do have one more sponsor that I want to make sure to get to.
01:23:41 So this is Nate from the Ezra Institute.
01:23:44 And you guys were free to go ahead and exit stage left or right.
01:23:48 Thank you. Thank you.