The NXR Podcast - June 07, 2025


THE CONFERENCE - Natural Law & Theonomy w David Reece and Stephen Wolfe

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Trump Vs. Elon Musk: BILLIONAIRE SHOWDOWN | Epstein Island? Impeachment? Ketamine Addict? THE LIVESTREAM - California Is Shielding the Lawless—Legally

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 19 minutes

Words per minute

164.59

Word count

13,129

Sentence count

513

Harmful content

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Pastor Wolfe and Pastor Reese discuss the role of military power in our society and why it is not the same as God's power in the Bible. They also discuss the difference between theonomy and natural law and why God gives us all equal power.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 So Wolf is going to come and give us 10 to 15 minutes opening statement.
00:00:31 Then immediately after that, we'll give 10 to 15 minutes for Pastor Reese.
00:00:35 Then they're going to come and sit in the chairs and begin to, in an informal sense, they're going to discuss.
00:00:41 But what that'll be, obviously, is cross-examination.
00:00:44 And then what I'll do, guys, is I'll just come back up when it's about, when it's probably about, you know, 10, 15 till.
00:00:51 and kind of, you know, politely say, you know, cut you off
00:00:57 and then have each of you come back to the podium for some final remarks.
00:01:01 Is that good? You feel good?
00:01:02 All right, this is Dr. Wolfe. Welcome them.
00:01:15 This thing needs to turn on, so give me a moment here.
00:01:18 But let's do some philosophy.
00:01:21 Does that sound okay?
00:01:23 I'm not going to get like tomatoes thrown.
00:01:25 No, I'm just kidding.
00:01:25 You guys are great.
00:01:27 So it's actually, it's great that we can talk about this.
00:01:31 It's been, between theonomy and natural law and other issues, it's been kind of a big
00:01:37 topic for a few years, and there is a resurgence of natural law people.
00:01:43 And obviously the theonomists who thought they had the, I don't know, they controlled
00:01:48 the Christian nation idea.
00:01:49 now that the natural law people are coming back. 0.55
00:01:55 Yeah, so let me just get started.
00:01:58 So again, thanks.
00:01:59 All right, so the first principle is
00:02:00 that all power is a means to an end.
00:02:05 All right, so all power is a means to an end.
00:02:07 And there's all sorts of different powers.
00:02:09 You guys have a power in your family as parents.
00:02:13 You have a power as, of course, the civil state has power.
00:02:17 There's power in the church.
00:02:19 So there's various types of power, but what they all share is they're all a means to an end.
00:02:26 Okay, they're all for something.
00:02:28 They're all for some end.
00:02:29 You exercise power for something.
00:02:32 So, and the other thing is that all means are sufficient for their end.
00:02:39 Okay, so when you have an end in mind or a purpose or something, some institution or something,
00:02:45 the power that's associated with that, is going to be sufficient to accomplish the end of that
00:02:52 thing. So, Adam's created. Adam is commanded to multiply, exercise dominion over the earth.
00:02:59 He is given sufficient means to do that. That means God grants him the faculties such that he
00:03:05 can accomplish that ought. So, in other words, if you ought to do something, you also can do
00:03:12 something. So first think about military power. I was in the military for a while as an active duty
00:03:18 guy. And the military officer has power. He has power to command a soldier to do this or that,
00:03:24 to take the hill. And that power, being qualified as military power, means that it's designed to
00:03:31 be sufficient to complete that end of military, to win the nation's wars. Okay. But that power is
00:03:40 also at times limited because there's some things that soldiers want to do that might be very unwise
00:03:47 and yet the military officer does not have the power to tell him no. So if anyone's been in the
00:03:52 military before you know that soldiers sometimes just show up from a night of partying and they
00:03:59 tell you I just met a girl and we're going to get married tomorrow. If you've ever heard that story
00:04:04 please raise your hand. Come on, there's got to be guys. A lot of times it's in boot camp. They get
00:04:11 their first weekend, and then they want to get married. Anyway, he comes to you and says that,
00:04:17 and you as a military officer, you can't say no to him. You don't have the power. It's not within
00:04:22 the bounds of your power. You can tell him, hey, that's very unwise. You should not do that.
00:04:30 But you don't have, it's not within that scope of military power.
00:04:34 But that is, the forbidding marriage in that way is actually a matter of circumstances.
00:04:40 Because if you're on the front lines in a battle, and you had just established a front line,
00:04:45 and you have foxholes, and this soldier's in a foxhole, and he comes to you and says,
00:04:50 hey, sir, yesterday I was at a farmhouse, and I met a girl, and we're going to get married.
00:04:55 Well, if you're in that situation, guess what?
00:04:57 that military officer is going to be like soldier get back in the foxhole you're not getting married
00:05:02 right now so it is circumstantial the same action the same thing as in getting married or whatever
00:05:08 it is the power applied to that can change based upon the circumstances all right so the same thing
00:05:17 can be you can forbid it or you can permit it at or you have don't have a power over it same thing
00:05:25 in a family. So you guys have, you have a family, and there's certain duties associated with the
00:05:31 family. And one of those, let's say it is the power to do, to bring your children in to do
00:05:38 family worship. Now that you have that duty, but you also have to determine things such as when
00:05:44 you're going to do it, what sort of order you're going to do it, how you're going to do it, who's
00:05:48 going to participate, perhaps children do prayer, whatever you do. Maybe they choose, like in my
00:05:53 home they typically choose the songs and so you have to make decisions and determinations in order
00:05:59 to fulfill that duty you have a principle and then for your family you have to decide what time
00:06:05 perhaps you work late perhaps you uh or you do it before dinner whatever it is you have to make that
00:06:10 decision you have that power and that becomes a sort of law in a way we usually don't call those
00:06:16 rules of the home laws but they are by definition they actually meet a law that is a legitimate
00:06:22 authority issues a command of action accompanied with sanction. That is, if the children don't show
00:06:28 up, they get a correction. So it is a sort of law that means, in a way, you as the person having
00:06:36 law over the family, or having the power over that family, are establishing sorts of laws to
00:06:42 fulfill prior duties. Okay. Now, to get to civil power, so we've talked about various forms of
00:06:51 power. Civil power is, in its genus, it's still a power. It's a means to an end. But the species of
00:06:57 power that is civil power, what is it for? It is for a rightfully ordered civil society. It is that
00:07:05 it uses, that power is to rightfully order that civil society. For what end? The end is to,
00:07:12 such that the people would procure earthly and heavenly good. That is, you'd have good vocations,
00:07:18 you'd have good social life and but at the same time it would encourage you indirectly to eternal
00:07:23 life all right so that's that that is the definition that's what civil power does rightfully
00:07:29 ordered civil society the the issue though is if that is the means to that end power is that means
00:07:35 to that end it has to do that for all sorts of different civil societies that is it's a it's a
00:07:41 it has to operate for different peoples people have different traditions ways of life people
00:07:47 who have different characteristics, different perhaps economic situation, just the varieties
00:07:53 that you encounter in the world today, even in historic Christian societies, you see wide
00:07:59 differences between Italy, France, Germany, UK, Scotland, and the United States. So what this
00:08:05 means then is the power ordained of God to rightfully order civil society to the end of
00:08:11 earthly and heavenly good must be extensive enough, expansive enough, such that it can order
00:08:18 all those varieties of peoples. Just like your power as a member of a family or as in a family
00:08:25 has the power to arrange your family according to prior duties in various ways given the
00:08:32 circumstances of that familiar, given the circumstances in your particular family.
00:08:38 right so that means your familial power is extensive and things can be different in different
00:08:44 places different families that it also applies just as much to human society and so that means
00:08:52 that the power civil power is extensive and that means that it has to be determined by some lawful
00:08:58 authority for given the particular search situation and i'd argue that is just a deduction of the
00:09:06 facts. So I, so far, all I've given you is premises, and I think the conclusion follows, which means
00:09:12 that civil power itself, the power to make law, can be different in different places. It's extensive
00:09:19 such that it can meet the end of earthly life in all different sorts of places, all right?
00:09:26 And why is that? And that's because whenever God establishes an end for something,
00:09:31 he's going to give it sufficient means to accomplish that all right now let's talk a
00:09:37 little bit i don't know how long i've gone but the limits so there are limits to power
00:09:41 limits to civil power and that's limited by the nature of civil life just like the military
00:09:47 leader himself is limited by the end of military success civil power is limited by the end of
00:09:54 civil life and that includes things like natural rights so sorry cj i do like natural rights
00:10:00 But this means the right to life
00:10:03 The right to the conscience
00:10:05 That is to not be imposed on your beliefs
00:10:07 In the inward sense
00:10:08 The right to liberty
00:10:10 And the right to even property
00:10:12 From pro-property
00:10:13 And why are these natural rights?
00:10:17 Why are these rights at all?
00:10:19 Well because
00:10:19 Exercising these rights
00:10:22 Exercising your right to property
00:10:24 To life, to conscience, to liberty
00:10:26 And all those other things you want to say are natural rights
00:10:28 is necessary for you as human beings to achieve your end as as human beings in the way god has
00:10:35 created you and so civil society in promoting the good of that society ought to recognize
00:10:41 those rights because that's what it's what it's there to do promote the good
00:10:46 and so the limits then would be limited by those natural rights uh and uh and and other things as
00:10:53 well. Now, so I said before that power is extensive. I think in the abstract, power is
00:10:59 actually extremely extensive. That means it can do all sorts of things. The difference, though,
00:11:04 is that the people establish constitutions. So I'm pro-constitutionalism. And what is
00:11:11 constitution? Constitution establishes the fundamental laws of a land, and it actually
00:11:16 primarily directs and limits power. So in our constitution, we have three branches of government
00:11:22 that recognizes three functions of government,
00:11:25 executive, legislative, and judicial,
00:11:27 we decided to separate them to three branches.
00:11:29 Didn't have to do that, but we did,
00:11:31 and there's checks and balances, and it's limited.
00:11:33 So we took the concept, the abstract concept of civil power,
00:11:37 and channeled it through a constitution
00:11:41 into what we have today.
00:11:43 And you can go to other places
00:11:44 that have different political systems
00:11:45 from people who decided to do it differently.
00:11:50 All right, and this is how,
00:11:51 you can actually read the debates of our that produced our our constitution it's called the
00:11:57 federal convention debates you can buy it's a thick book um james madison and a scribe you know
00:12:02 furiously writing stuff down and what you find in there is not actually abstract philosophy or
00:12:07 theology you find them the men using experience from the ages uh citing everyone from plutarch
00:12:15 to Swiss Confederation, to other, just experience among the states, and they applied experience
00:12:23 to say what is suitable given the experience of humankind over the known history that would
00:12:29 then produce a constitution that would be stable and secure the rights of the people
00:12:35 and at the same time have sufficient power to achieve its end.
00:12:38 So they relied upon experience, and our constitution, as you read it, is a product of reflection
00:12:44 upon human experience particularly western experience all right and uh and so that and
00:12:50 but again that could be different in different places some places it seemed to require dictators
00:12:56 uh sorry but iraq seemed to need saddam hussein as much i don't like that um and perhaps even
00:13:03 syria required uh assad to be in power to maintain the peace so different places have different
00:13:09 needs given on a given up their situation and that is a determination of the people for uh for their
00:13:17 good um so uh yeah and i will say i mean i i guess to pre to uh to i guess preemptively go after what
00:13:27 he might say um i i think the mosaic polity the the mosaic polity is a perfect example of
00:13:36 the application of natural law, but it's not the sole alone universal example of the application
00:13:43 of natural law. And it was fundamentally connected to a body politic, namely the Israelites.
00:13:51 And whenever a body politic is dissolved, so too do the laws and its fundamental laws,
00:13:58 namely the constitution. And so those laws as such, as a body of law, are not universal but
00:14:04 particular, and yet at the same time, they can be used for our own thinking on what law would be
00:14:11 suitable and what law would not be. So, I do think that we can use the Old Testament or just
00:14:17 scripture to form civil laws, but at the same time, I don't think that the polity itself
00:14:27 is the sole standard given the variety of institutions or of human experience and societies
00:14:33 and given the, as the argument I said earlier.
00:14:37 So I'll just leave it at that.
00:14:38 Thank you.
00:14:55 Okay, so I have up here,
00:14:59 we had the, basically an attempt
00:15:02 to try to express both of our positions side by side
00:15:06 in a way of trying to help to positively put forward positions
00:15:11 as opposed to merely some sort of like negative tearing down.
00:15:15 I think one of the things that's helpful when you're trying to charitably debate
00:15:18 and to come to unity if possible
00:15:20 is to try to have both sides of sort of a duty to positively construct.
00:15:26 And so I think the question here is not merely whether I could attack
00:15:30 what Dr. Wolfe has said, but rather I'm trying to put side by side two views for you to compare
00:15:37 and contrast and for you to be able to consider those. And so the position that Dr. Wolfe just
00:15:43 explained, we had this idea that God has given broad authority to the civil power,
00:15:48 which is to be prudently limited by particular peoples in constitutions. And so that you
00:15:54 obviously heard him just express that and sort of an outline of that view. So then for me,
00:15:58 this idea that the bible teaches the regulative principle of the civil power which teaches that
00:16:06 the civil power only possesses the authority to do what god commands it to do in the bible
00:16:12 so i'm saying essentially that there's not a broad power but instead the explicit commandments
00:16:18 plus the necessary inferences that you could derive from scripture and necessary inference
00:16:24 being strict or rigorous drawing of conclusions.
00:16:28 So that's the idea of what I'm positing
00:16:30 as my understanding of the biblical
00:16:32 or God-ordained order for government,
00:16:35 for civil power.
00:16:37 So I have a summary here
00:16:39 for some of the basic reasoning.
00:16:43 And Dr. Wolf, my main thing is going to be this idea
00:16:46 that I'm still not fully sure
00:16:48 what is meant by natural law.
00:16:50 I heard in the speech a reference
00:16:52 to the idea of the experience of the ages
00:16:54 And so I'm going to posit some definitions of natural law, because one of my big goals is to really truly understand what's intended by natural law, and to then be able to discuss in that.
00:17:04 So I have here four propositions that are if we should glorify God in all that we do, and if the only rule to direct us how we may glorify and enjoy God is the scripture, three,
00:17:19 And if the natural law is anything other than what is revealed in Scripture, then it is no rule to direct us.
00:17:29 Ultimately, if natural law, if it is the same as the law in Scripture, then Scripture is more clear and it's infallible.
00:17:39 And so it is not something to direct us.
00:17:42 So these are the two things here is, is it something outside of and in addition to Scripture and therefore no rule?
00:17:48 or is it something that is the same as the content of scripture and I've heard Dr. Wolf express the
00:17:53 idea of the natural law is the moral law in the past and so I think he's saying number four that
00:18:00 the idea that it's the same and not something just different and so I think what we're going to end
00:18:05 up doing is to a larger part in the conversation trying to come to understand what's really being
00:18:10 said that that is different so then when we talk about the origin and nature of civil power
00:18:17 I mentioned before that I believe that Dr. Wolf and I disagree about the origin of civil power
00:18:23 so I believe he would assert that it is in the garden that there is a civil power that's inherent
00:18:28 in Adam's rule and then whereas I'm saying the civil power comes from Genesis 9 and this key
00:18:35 verse is Genesis 9 verse 5 whoever sheds man's blood by man his blood shall be shed for in the
00:18:43 image of God, he made man. Okay, so this idea of man punishing. Now, in past conversations with
00:18:49 Dr. Wolfe, he's expressed that he agrees that civil power, he thinks civil power is distinct
00:18:54 from the idea of this coercive power with the sword. And if I'm wrong, you can correct me
00:19:01 down the line here. But my understanding is that there's agreement that this is where kind of the
00:19:04 coercive power with the sword seems to come in. So there's some sort of a distinction between the
00:19:09 civil power versus the coercive avenging power. Now, again, the Westminster Confession of Faith,
00:19:17 which I believe we're both committed to, says that good works are only such as God has commanded in
00:19:22 his holy word and not such as without the warrant thereof or devised by men out of a blind zeal
00:19:28 or upon a pretense of good intention. So mere intention or in terms of the pursuit of a goal
00:19:33 is insufficient it requires the means to be prescribed and that prescription is in the law
00:19:40 of god so if it's a good work to exercise civil power which we both agree then the law of god
00:19:47 the commandments of god provide that and so that's my my assertion and understanding
00:19:53 i already read to you in my speech second timothy three verses 16 and 17 but again
00:20:00 the idea that the purpose of the giving of the scriptures was to teach such that the man of God
00:20:05 could be complete, thoroughly equipped for every good work, not incomplete, not partially equipped
00:20:11 for some good works. So then, if there's a question about the extensiveness of state power,
00:20:19 how broad is it? I think in order to defend a broad view, one would have to take the assertion
00:20:24 that there's a grant of power that's sort of normative.
00:20:28 When you talk about worship,
00:20:30 there's this language of the normative principle
00:20:32 and the regulative principle.
00:20:34 So that's where this language normally comes in.
00:20:36 And the idea that the normative principle
00:20:38 is such that you are authorized,
00:20:42 the normative principle of worship would be
00:20:44 that you're authorized to worship God
00:20:46 in any way that he has not forbidden.
00:20:49 The regulative principle of worship would be
00:20:52 that you are only authorized to worship God in the way that he's instituted or commanded.
00:20:58 And so I would take that regulative principle and apply it to authority in general. And I would say
00:21:04 there's a regulative principle of civil government. So I'm making the assertion that the state and
00:21:11 civil power can only do what God commands. And if we have a normative principle, my concern would be
00:21:19 that it turns us into slaves where there's an ability for the state to
00:21:23 command us to do all sorts of things and then for freedom to be maintained there
00:21:29 has to be a regulative principle of the state the danger of anarchy is to say
00:21:34 that the state has no power or to limit its powers beyond what God has given to
00:21:39 it and so for example I would one thing that people who call themselves
00:21:44 libertarians would disagree with I think the first table of the law in other
00:21:48 words the first second third and fourth commandments should be enforced by the state
00:21:52 that there should be a punishing of idolatry of suppressing us blasphemies and a protecting of
00:21:58 the Sabbath so that puts me typically in the outer rim of the cocktail parties at the libertarian
00:22:04 party I've never gotten an invitation don't worry so so that being the case when I think about the
00:22:14 types of natural law I'm trying to understand is this idea of the way that natural law gets
00:22:20 talked about. There's a number of different ways it gets discussed. The romanticists would talk
00:22:25 about natural law as feeling. So the book Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen is about one sister
00:22:32 who has good sense and the other sister who has sensibility, right feeling. And so this idea that
00:22:39 right feeling is what determines the good uh what's the right course of action that's kind of
00:22:44 the philosophy of disney you know follow your heart and i do not believe that that's what dr
00:22:48 wolf is saying at all so charitable interpretation not trying to pretend that in any way i don't mean
00:22:52 that's his position but then there's this question okay what about empiricism is it observation
00:22:57 and i i hear some of that the idea of looking at the experience of the ages are you determining
00:23:02 you know what ought to be done or whatever from from empiricism or rationalism where you're using
00:23:08 reason apart from experience you're trying to have like a definition of the nature of man or
00:23:11 of the state and reason out from that apart from scripture well then there's the scripture using
00:23:17 it as a thing to define that and you could say natural law is the moral law of scripture and
00:23:24 there's also this idea that there's natural law written on the heart the work of the law written
00:23:28 on the heart which is the basis for inexcusability so if those definitions that's what i'm trying to
00:23:34 figure out if or if there's another definition for natural law that's being talked about trying to
00:23:38 figure out which what's the definition that we're working with so the biblical uses of natural law
00:23:45 are the moral law in scripture is a natural law the work of the law in the heart makes men
00:23:51 inexcusable that moral law in scripture is infallibly known from scripture alone
00:23:56 it's corrupted in the hearts of fallen men since the fall sorry for the repetition fallen men
00:24:03 And we are incapable since the fall
00:24:06 of rightly directing ourselves by this law
00:24:10 apart from scripture.
00:24:11 So the natural law, if it's the moral law,
00:24:13 the way we get it is by going to the law
00:24:15 in the scriptures as opposed to something,
00:24:18 some other means.
00:24:20 So then, that's it,
00:24:22 and you should go to all my websites.
00:24:23 Thanks.
00:24:23 Thanks.
00:24:32 I guess I've been challenged to define natural law, so I'll do that a bit.
00:24:39 I'll talk about natural law a bit.
00:24:45 Natural law is a moral law that directs man to his end, his natural end.
00:24:54 and it is the sole means to that end and that that end you can define it as happiness
00:25:00 um and uh or human flourishing is that okay uh so that that it's it's a it's a measure
00:25:08 a standard where it's a means for man the sole means by which man would achieve his end and this
00:25:15 is the what is was established in the garden it was the standard it was it's uh for adam
00:25:21 and his his progeny and it's immutable meaning it doesn't change precisely because it is the
00:25:29 only fitting law given the nature of man himself so god created man in a certain way
00:25:36 and in creating him a certain way for a certain end god ordained a law and that would be the the
00:25:45 natural law and it's called natural for that reason it's natural in the sense that it's natural
00:25:49 to man as man. It's fitting, suitable for his nature, for the end God ordained for man.
00:25:58 So that's why it's called natural law. It's also called the moral law. It's called a moral law
00:26:03 oftentimes to distinguish that law from non-rational animals or animals. And that's
00:26:12 because dogs and cats and lizards don't have rationality. That is, they cannot fulfill a moral
00:26:18 law that that is they don't have a moral choice and so man the natural law is a moral law because
00:26:24 man is a moral being capable of exercising moral choice and that's that's why we are the highest
00:26:32 being on earth precisely for that that we can choose we can do have a moral choice and because
00:26:38 there's a moral choice that means we can also where we are the beings that can recognize and
00:26:43 worship God, which is itself part, the principal part of the natural law. So that's what I mean by
00:26:50 natural law. And I think the important point is that it's immutable, and that's because there's
00:26:56 no other law by which man would achieve his end as a human being, which means post-fall that endures
00:27:05 as the standard of righteousness for man. That is, you are all under still that same moral law
00:27:11 because you are still human beings, though corrupted, and it still applies. 0.96
00:27:16 It has not changed, and according to the Reformed tradition,
00:27:19 the substance of that law has not changed or abrogated
00:27:23 or not even there's been an addition to it.
00:27:28 And so that endures.
00:27:31 Now when I say talk about experience,
00:27:33 what I'm saying is that according to the second table of the law,
00:27:38 that is more discernible by fallen man than the first table.
00:27:43 This is why you can read stuff in, you know, Plato and Aristotle
00:27:47 and others like Cicero and Seneca
00:27:50 and you can read their ethical works and their political works
00:27:53 and find a lot of truth there
00:27:56 because they're speaking of second table things
00:27:59 which are more immediate in their experience 0.74
00:28:03 so that they can see that if you're in a society of liars
00:28:08 that doesn't tend to go well if you're in a society where children disobey their parents 0.54
00:28:13 that tends not to go well if you're in a society of murderers that tends not to go well and so
00:28:18 they can observe those that those these things end well for societies and individuals and so
00:28:24 they can discern those second table duties but that's different than first table and the first
00:28:31 table concern our duties to God, those were largely rendered obliterated, say that. So this is why
00:28:42 they created idols. This is why they worship, they become polytheistic. This is why you eventually
00:28:48 see human sacrifice, not among the Greeks and Romans, but among others. And so that was
00:28:56 corrupted, and Calvin says this explicitly in his Institutes, that the virtues that made your
00:29:04 recognition and proper worship of God were obliterated. But he says that the duties with
00:29:11 regard to fellow man were weakened such that there still is sin, there still is injustice,
00:29:17 there still is corruption in individuals and in society. But nevertheless, because it wasn't
00:29:23 utterly obliterated, you can still read and learn from experience with profit, especially if you're
00:29:31 going to try to order society and individuals. So there's a lot to learn from Plutarch, who was a
00:29:37 pagan, who wrote on people's lives in parallel. And you can learn from the actions of these men
00:29:45 and his analysis, various principles of leadership and civil leadership.
00:29:53 So I'll leave it at that, but I think, I hope that explains my position on natural law.
00:29:57 Oh, one more thing.
00:30:00 And you mentioned this, that the Ten Commandments is an inscripturated form of natural law.
00:30:07 So when you obey the Ten Commandments, you're actually obeying the natural law,
00:30:13 and you're being fully human.
00:30:15 So it's not a purely divine law.
00:30:20 It's not that you're simply just obeying God.
00:30:23 You're obeying God and in so doing,
00:30:26 you are fulfilling your human nature.
00:30:30 You're fulfilling what you ought to be as a creature.
00:30:36 And so in other words,
00:30:38 the scriptural law and the natural law
00:30:41 are the same in substance.
00:30:43 By scriptural law, I mean moral law.
00:30:45 The moral law in scripture is the same in substance,
00:30:48 but it's delivered through two different means.
00:30:51 One would be, natural law would be ordinarily delivered
00:30:53 through reason or right thinking.
00:30:56 And that same law through scripture is delivered by faith.
00:31:02 And you receive it by faith.
00:31:04 So you can know that you ought not to murder
00:31:06 simply by faith because God told you not to murder.
00:31:10 You don't need anything else than that.
00:31:11 You already know not to murder.
00:31:13 But in principle, you could reach that same conclusion by reflecting upon human nature itself.
00:31:18 And yeah, so reason and faith can lead to the same ethical duties.
00:31:26 So thank you.
00:31:27 So I think you communicated that you're saying natural law is that which is pointed at the goal of human flourishing.
00:31:33 Is that distinct from the goal of glorifying God?
00:31:37 no
00:31:39 well
00:31:39 glorifying
00:31:40 like acting
00:31:41 to the glory
00:31:42 to the glory
00:31:43 of God
00:31:43 would be a condition
00:31:44 of it being a good work
00:31:45 yeah
00:31:45 okay so
00:31:46 so is human flourishing
00:31:48 like a
00:31:49 proximate objective
00:31:50 on the way
00:31:51 to glorifying God
00:31:52 or is glorifying God
00:31:53 as the goal
00:31:54 something that
00:31:55 inherently
00:31:56 brings about
00:31:57 human flourishing
00:31:58 what's the relationship
00:32:00 of those
00:32:00 yeah
00:32:01 um
00:32:04 I think I know
00:32:04 what you're going
00:32:05 with that
00:32:05 uh
00:32:06 Yeah, the idea is that, well, let me, I guess, back up a bit to explain it, that I think
00:32:14 in political society, you're glorifying God when you are choosing the best policy given
00:32:21 the circumstances to maximize the good of that society.
00:32:25 And if you were to choose something to the detriment of society, that would actually
00:32:30 produce bad and evil in society, like abortion, that is not to the glory of God. 0.50
00:32:35 So when you're crafting policy, civil policy, you're seeking, it's a good policy if it's
00:32:41 actually bringing about good in society.
00:32:44 It's maximizing the possibility of good, and that would be to the glory of God.
00:32:49 So it's not, I think the difference between you and me is I think you have more of an
00:32:55 idea of that there are these laws, they're given to us, and they ought to be enacted
00:33:00 regardless of considering
00:33:02 the ways in which they would affect society.
00:33:06 That it's to the glory of God
00:33:08 simply to enact the laws.
00:33:10 Whereas my argument is that
00:33:11 you glorify God by enacting the best policy
00:33:14 such that it actually produces good in that society.
00:33:17 And if it doesn't, then it's a bad law.
00:33:19 If it actually results in evil,
00:33:22 then it's a bad law.
00:33:24 Yeah.
00:33:25 So I would say that I believe that
00:33:27 the way we know a law is good
00:33:29 or law is bad, is based upon God's law, that it is the judge of all human law. And I would say that
00:33:35 there are, as far as circumstances go, you have conditions of order and disorder, a more or less
00:33:42 settled civil order or state. And you can go from chaos and sort of a rule of man where you have
00:33:51 wicked human law, and you can have reforms that are on the way to the mature polity and the mature
00:33:59 system. But so, for example, you look at like Nehemiah, who is, when he's reforming things,
00:34:04 there are people breaking the Sabbath. They're coming, they're like, you know, we'd like to sell
00:34:09 grain on the Sabbath. We find that that's a good day to sell grain. And Nehemiah's response is
00:34:15 to close the gates of the city. And then he threatens them when they show up again.
00:34:20 And he says, if you show up again, I'll lay hands on you. And so he's increasing his exercise of
00:34:26 coercive power, but he could have executed them. And so the idea that you can use, as you enact
00:34:35 power, Christian power, you can use lesser penalties as you're rising to the condition. 0.99
00:34:42 So the perverse persons of the land, I think Hezekiah, as opposed to immediately trying to 0.97
00:34:47 execute all of them, what he did with the perverse persons of the land was he made it illegal and
00:34:51 drove them out. And basically if they came back, then they would be executed, right? So there's 0.85
00:34:57 this idea that you can use lesser force in the process of bringing about reform in getting to
00:35:04 the place where you apply the law of God, the force of it in full. And so, but the reason I know that
00:35:10 is not by experience outside of the Bible. The reason I know that is because all the circumstances
00:35:14 and the conditions and the exceptions are laid out in the scripture. The scripture is sufficient
00:35:20 to know the exceptions. When can I break the Sabbath for works of necessity and mercy? How
00:35:26 do I know that? The Lord Jesus Christ exemplified that. So I think all of the circumstances to be
00:35:32 taken into account are given to us in categorical or principial form in the law of God. And I think
00:35:39 that one thing, Stephen, I agree about is the idea that the law of God, or what's calling the
00:35:45 natural law, lines up with the nature of man such that man flourishes in the application of it.
00:35:51 Totally agree with that. I think that the law order lines up with the ontology of man so that
00:35:57 the enactment of the law of God and the performance of it, whether it's an individual household,
00:36:02 church, or state, brings about that flourishing. But I would say that the law of God in more
00:36:08 detail probably than what you're saying. So you're saying the moral law and its principles,
00:36:12 And I'm saying the civil order of Moses provides us with principles of justice that are moral law, that they are showing to us the case laws show us applications and that the principles of due process show us applications.
00:36:29 And so the details of the Mosaic civil order are providing for us the perfect, divinely inspired consideration of categories that we need to interpret experience.
00:36:43 And if we try to interpret experience on our own to draw up principles, we'll do it wrong.
00:36:49 That we have to interpret experience through the systematic arrangement of doctrine of the scriptures.
00:36:56 And so it's the, I don't like the language of worldview or lens or whatever, but the sorting mechanism of propositional content.
00:37:08 So that in your mind, you can sort out the Excel spreadsheet.
00:37:13 That is the presuppositional structure that I would put forward.
00:37:18 And I would say that when you read Plutarch or whatever, you can evaluate and judge the reasoning of Plutarch on the basis of whether it's according to Scripture.
00:37:29 But that you can't know that Plutarch got it right or Xenophon got it right or whatever unless you already have Scripture to judge it.
00:37:38 And so it becomes useful as a thought exercise to go read the Federalist Papers or the record of the debate of the Continental Congress or the Constitutional Convention or whatever when you're applying Scripture to evaluate it.
00:37:54 But it will not by itself give you the knowledge of what is good for a state.
00:37:59 So, do you have any response or anything you want to chase?
00:38:03 Yeah, I mean, like, I think, like, knowledge is doing a lot of work for you in, like, in a sort of certainty or infallibility.
00:38:10 I think in political life, there's a lot of uncertainty, and there's so many dynamics.
00:38:16 Like, if you're involved in an institution or a business, and you make a decision, there's uncertainty built into that decision.
00:38:24 You try to mitigate risk as you go through it.
00:38:26 But you don't have an infallible, like you don't know precisely what that decision is going to result in.
00:38:34 And I think that's the same thing with politics and leadership, and it's the same thing throughout all of life.
00:38:39 I mean, just your own individual life, you make a decision, there's risk involved.
00:38:43 And the very fact of risk means that there's uncertainty in the result.
00:38:47 um and so uh yeah on the experience side i see one of the reasons i emphasize
00:38:53 experience is i think what made america great um was that it was a product of protestant experience
00:39:00 and uh a lot of the founders reflected upon the wars of religion that occurred in the 17th century
00:39:07 16th 70th century and they determined that you know what at the federal level there there will
00:39:12 be a uh will be freedom of religion such that the states this is where we go wrong in 20th century
00:39:17 The states will then have the right to regulate religion according to their own fundamental laws and their own laws.
00:39:24 And I think that was a product of wisdom.
00:39:27 It was also a product of the circumstances at the time because you have Anglicans in Virginia, you have Congregationalists in New England, Quakers in Pennsylvania, and everything in between.
00:39:36 So it was a product of experience.
00:39:40 But it's also not only the American experience, it was a product of experience going first century.
00:39:47 It was the realization that Presbyterians and all the Baptists,
00:39:51 Baptists, please raise your hand.
00:39:54 So it means that it was a product, meaning that we Presbyterians and Baptists
00:39:58 could sit in the same room, call each other brothers,
00:40:00 and we could be a part of the same society.
00:40:03 Whereas that was not the case in the 16th and 17th centuries,
00:40:07 but we learned from experience that actually, you know what,
00:40:09 we can have stable commonwealths, stable governments,
00:40:13 if we acknowledge each other as mutual religion, call each other brothers, and grant freedom to each other.
00:40:19 So that's what I mean in part by experience, that it informs the possibilities of political life
00:40:26 that were not considered or not known, or not considered possible prior to the experience.
00:40:34 And again, I think our society, what we actually love, I say we, I just assume there's the majority,
00:40:39 is part of what we love about the United States
00:40:42 in its traditional understanding
00:40:44 is so much that it was
00:40:46 a product of western
00:40:47 political experience and good principles
00:40:50 so I think like again
00:40:53 I go back I think the knowledge is doing a lot of work
00:40:56 I don't think another thing
00:40:58 perhaps unless you want to respond to that I think there's
00:41:00 like
00:41:00 scripture is infallible but that doesn't mean
00:41:04 that we can derive from it infallible
00:41:06 truth statements
00:41:07 and so even when it comes to law
00:41:09 you can say I'm reading an infallible
00:41:11 text but that doesn't mean an application
00:41:14 of a text you're
00:41:15 applying that infallibly
00:41:17 there's a distinction between
00:41:20 infallible
00:41:22 source and infallible application
00:41:24 so
00:41:25 if you could talk about that
00:41:27 I don't know how you'd respond to that but it seems to me
00:41:29 again like that is an element of
00:41:32 fallibility
00:41:33 so first of all 0.96
00:41:35 arrest the Baptists. I'm kidding. I wouldn't drown any of you. 0.99
00:41:47 You, however, would have to punish me for baptizing babies because of the idolatry. So,
00:41:52 you know, you can work through that internal turmoil. But so as regards this issue of the
00:41:59 infallibility. So there are principles of law. We get them from the scripture. There's necessary
00:42:06 inferences. I can infer invalidly. I can reason wrongly, right? But if I reason rightly, right
00:42:12 reasoning from true premises is infallible. Now that doesn't mean I'm going to infallibly reason,
00:42:20 but good and necessary inference is infallible. If you properly follow the argumentation. So for
00:42:27 example, the Lord Jesus Christ argued against the Sadducees showing to them that by good and
00:42:34 necessary inference, just from the Torah, they had to accept the resurrection. You find the
00:42:40 apostle Paul using good and necessary inference in multiple steps so as to not only have a premise
00:42:47 and a conclusion or two premises as a syllogism to a conclusion, but he has what's called the
00:42:52 sorites in 1 Corinthians 15, where he has premise, secondary premise, conclusion, take the conclusion,
00:43:00 use it as a premise in the next syllogism, do it again, do it again. And so there's this good and
00:43:06 necessary inference. We're shown right reason in the Bible. The Bible shows us how to reason
00:43:10 rightly. And so that which is from the Bible and then drawn by good and necessary inference from it
00:43:16 is certainly true. Now, where we don't have certainty is in our observations of things.
00:43:23 So I can go, it's certainly true that murder is evil. It's certainly true that murder is a
00:43:28 capital crime. It's certainly true that abortion is murder. Okay, I can derive those things from 0.98
00:43:33 the Bible. And then I might go, here's a particular person, did they commit murder?
00:43:40 One's a determination of law, which I can have certainty about from the scriptures.
00:43:46 The other is fallible, requires two or more witnesses for the due process to occur,
00:43:52 and requires due process of law with the right to defend yourself,
00:43:55 the right to present your own evidence, to call your own witnesses,
00:43:59 to this due process of law to prevent tyranny, to help to slow down bad application of law.
00:44:05 So application of law can certainly be fallibly done by human beings,
00:44:09 but the law itself is infallibly given by the hand of God.
00:44:15 and right reason from it is certainly true. And so I'm trying to defend the certainty
00:44:21 of the premises, the certainty of the reasoning structure, and then we leave the fallibility to
00:44:27 our observations and our attempts to apply in life. And so that's the distinction of the fallible
00:44:35 and the infallible parts. And so this idea of knowledge, I would say I can know with certainty
00:44:40 what is right. I cannot know
00:44:43 with certainty whether you did
00:44:44 the right thing.
00:44:47 And so that's what I would posit
00:44:48 for that structure of the issues of knowledge.
00:44:50 And I don't need to infallibly know, but I do have
00:44:53 about whether you did the right thing
00:44:54 or whether you did the right thing
00:44:56 or whether somebody who's being charged with criminal
00:44:58 charges with infallible certainty
00:45:01 whether they're right. But there are standards of
00:45:02 evidence that we have a duty to follow.
00:45:05 So that's how I would deal with that
00:45:06 epistemological issue.
00:45:08 I appreciate you mentioned sorieties
00:45:11 and that's
00:45:12 you can find that in Aristotle by the way
00:45:15 but
00:45:18 but
00:45:20 actually that's great
00:45:22 I would disagree on
00:45:24 well okay yeah I mean so a valid
00:45:26 argument means that you
00:45:28 it's a yeah but
00:45:29 of course it depends upon like any
00:45:32 sound argument depends on
00:45:34 the truth of the conclusion of the
00:45:36 premises. So there is that issue.
00:45:39 You can have a sound argument, of course
00:45:40 that's infallible because of the nature of the definition
00:45:42 of a sound argument. You can have a valid
00:45:44 argument, but that doesn't mean it's
00:45:46 actually true or sound because you could have
00:45:48 so in other words
00:45:50 the validity, the soundness of an argument
00:45:52 depends upon your
00:45:54 certainty with regard to the premises.
00:45:58 So I
00:45:58 actually don't totally, I don't disagree
00:46:00 with what you said
00:46:02 there, I don't think.
00:46:04 Is there something
00:46:05 I think the difference, though, is that...
00:46:07 Start the music.
00:46:09 Yeah, yeah.
00:46:10 I think the difference is probably the extent to which you can...
00:46:18 This goes back to the original question, I think,
00:46:19 is the extent to which we can apply law in different circumstances.
00:46:24 Because, again, I agree that you can use Scripture to craft law.
00:46:29 I think that, again, one difference is that I think you can craft law
00:46:34 for a specific problem in society,
00:46:37 applying moral principles to solve that problem
00:46:39 because you're trying to bring about the good of that society.
00:46:42 And you can actually think through it,
00:46:44 you can reason through it,
00:46:45 and if it doesn't work, you can observe that
00:46:47 and then you can change the law.
00:46:50 So I wonder about the extent of it.
00:46:52 So there's a difference between laws that are bad in themselves
00:46:59 or violations of moral law that are bad in themselves.
00:47:02 So, like, murder is bad in itself, theft is bad in itself.
00:47:05 But there's another category of law called, I'm blanking on it, but anyway, it's the sort
00:47:12 of law in which the action itself is not in itself wrong, so like speeding on a street.
00:47:18 You go in 100 miles an hour down a malum prohibitum, that's what it is, malum prohibitum. 0.83
00:47:23 Malumans say malum prohibitum.
00:47:25 Anyway, that doesn't matter.
00:47:26 But this would be the sort of law that a civil magistrate regulates to promote the good of society.
00:47:34 So if you drive 100 miles an hour down a residential road, you got lucky somehow.
00:47:39 You didn't hit a kid, dog, or old lady or a parked car.
00:47:44 And so, therefore, you didn't do anything unjust.
00:47:46 And so you can't be punished for that because you can only be punished once you commit an act of injustice.
00:47:52 and therefore there comes the correction of that.
00:47:58 I would say that one function of government
00:48:01 is to promote the good by preventing,
00:48:05 by seeking to prevent certain bad behaviors
00:48:07 that diminish the good of society.
00:48:09 So I think speed limits are okay.
00:48:11 I think regulation's okay in certain respects.
00:48:15 So that is you punish things
00:48:17 that are not in themselves wrong,
00:48:20 but in prohibiting them,
00:48:22 you are promoting the good of society, broadly speaking.
00:48:25 So I will often mention traffic laws.
00:48:28 We don't realize it because we've been driving long enough,
00:48:31 but we have embodied these rules of the road,
00:48:35 and we know that the other people hopefully have as well,
00:48:38 unless you're in Los Angeles, which good luck.
00:48:40 But in most places, they've embodied those rules,
00:48:44 and we have common expectations of behavior on the roads,
00:48:48 given the rules, because society has imposed those,
00:48:51 and now there's commonality and and because we have that commonality it it facilitates your
00:48:58 movement so when you're on the road most people are going somewhere else they don't have the same
00:49:03 interest that you do or the same end as you do and yet the rules of the road coordinate that
00:49:09 activity such that you can go from point a to point b some other person can go from d to e or
00:49:15 whatever. And so it promotes the good. And I would say that is a legitimate power of the civil
00:49:22 government. And this is true, I would say, on all sorts of regulations as well. So I wonder if that
00:49:28 category of law, you would affirm that category of law. So as far as regulations go, typically
00:49:34 you're talking about things like, can an inspector come into your house or business without there
00:49:39 having been probable cause or a warrant on the basis of some sort of crime or harm that's
00:49:43 occurred. So I would say, no, I think that's a tyrannical power that the state does not have
00:49:47 the right to just come into my house and see if my smoke detectors work. I think that the idea of
00:49:53 going into a place, into private property, without having some event occurring where there's emergency
00:49:59 need to stop an ongoing crime, which is what probable cause is, right, where you're seeing
00:50:04 something happen and you need to intervene, or there's a warrant, which is our mechanism,
00:50:10 that's our our form for dealing with this where we have okay we're going to intrude upon your
00:50:14 private property right which includes the right to exclude people with badges and guns and so your
00:50:21 ability to say i don't want you on my property is going to be infringed upon by public power
00:50:25 because of the idea that there's some basis from the testimony of sworn witnesses and so i think
00:50:32 that the property right is actually something that that there shouldn't be regulatory infringement
00:50:37 of entering on. But there should be punishments for people who commit harms, people who are
00:50:43 negligent, who leave a hole open and somebody falls in. You don't have a hole inspector who
00:50:48 walks around writing tickets for people leaving the hole in the ground. You have punishments for
00:50:54 people when somebody is harmed. And that's what you find in terms of the justice order of the
00:50:59 Old Testament law. But I would say as far as like speed limits or rules of the road go, that's
00:51:05 actually a question of the property holder's right to regulate the use of the property.
00:51:09 So if there's a private road, you can set rules for speed. You can set rules for how it goes.
00:51:14 If the government owns the road, they are now the property holder. So the problem we face in
00:51:19 America is there's way too much public land. That's a part of the problem, which makes it so
00:51:23 the government has huge domains where they're trying to control the detail. Now, if you own
00:51:31 property, you have to have rules for how it's used in terms of the way people behave on it.
00:51:36 And so the property owned by the civil order, by the state, is something where it can act as the
00:51:42 property owner and therefore set rules as a property owner. And that's not so much a function
00:51:47 as the state as it is a property holder. And the state is a legal person that has the ability to
00:51:54 own property. Okay, so you have this idea of holding of a road and you say, here's the rule
00:52:00 of the road. And you know what kind of crime it is when you violate the rules of the road?
00:52:03 It's trespassing. Because you're using the property that's owned by the state in a manner
00:52:09 that's not according to the conditions for the use by the property owner. And so you start to go,
00:52:14 wait, what if the government owns tons and tons of land? Can they set the conditions for all that?
00:52:18 And now you see why I would love for that to be private land. In Arizona, the majority of the
00:52:22 land is owned by the federal government and the state government and by tribes. And so there's
00:52:28 all these people stuck in the middle of the desert in a gigantic six million person city
00:52:31 in this huge area the size of Britain. And we're all there because you can't get the land away from
00:52:38 the government, as opposed to the ability to develop the land. So you have these desert
00:52:42 wastelands. I mean, deserts are literally curses in the Bible. It's like, you're going to be so
00:52:47 bad, your land's going to be a desert. Ha, I'm already there. And so this idea of taking the
00:52:55 desert and turning it into garden city. I mean, I live in the middle of a desert that was turned
00:53:00 into an orange grove. I have flood irrigation in Phoenix. My yard has grass. A desert has been
00:53:09 turned into a garden city. But the parts that the government owns do not have grass. They are not
00:53:16 places where people want to live. And so the idea of government ownership of the land, I think, is a
00:53:20 big problem. And the idea of the right of
00:53:22 trespass control, that solves
00:53:24 all the problems of road laws.
00:53:27 And so that's, I don't
00:53:28 think that there's an issue here where there's
00:53:30 an incapability of dealing with it.
00:53:33 So,
00:53:34 if you want to, where do you want to go?
00:53:36 Do you want to keep going on traffic law?
00:53:39 Should we?
00:53:41 Yeah, well, that's
00:53:42 an instant response. I think it opens up
00:53:44 a perhaps different disagreement.
00:53:46 So, you know, I guess
00:53:48 I'll use the stock line that
00:53:50 The government is, you know, by four of the people.
00:53:54 So I do think that the government is a different sort of entity than simply a sort of private entity or separate entity such that.
00:54:06 Because it is something that you elect members.
00:54:10 There is a, the difference is government is by its design, its end is for the people themselves.
00:54:18 whereas in a private industry it is designed for principally for the people
00:54:24 who own it so government is something that serves the people it should arise
00:54:28 from the people by their by their consent and there should be some
00:54:32 mechanism by which they express their their public interest so I would say
00:54:37 it's a different entity and it involves when it owns these this land or roads
00:54:43 it's not a private it's actually a shared space it's something that is in a way theirs but also
00:54:51 ours and it's something that then we would petition the government or through various means
00:54:57 come to regulate and so i i guess i'm more on the side of that there is a that there is a a
00:55:05 communal shared aspect to this that and there's a function of government to for the good of what
00:55:13 you might say the commons so there is a some there are i mean there are some things by the
00:55:18 very nature that don't admit of ownership very well unless it's actually granted by the state
00:55:24 so you have like a large lake like in what sense can can you walk upon a lake up upon a lake that's
00:55:32 no no one's seen before and say i declare this you know wolf lake and it's my lake now and the
00:55:37 moment someone shows up to it they uh they're trespassing or they're they're they're you know
00:55:42 they're all the way the other side another bank and they're fishing and you're like hey you're
00:55:45 taking my fish there are certain things that are by the very nature common and so at least you know
00:55:52 i know roads aren't they are common in a sense they're created go through land on but there are
00:55:56 i'm saying that there are aspects to our our environment our world that are common and then
00:56:03 the collective interest of the people would be we want a lake for fishing and so it's actually they
00:56:10 might then have an interest a collective interest as a public and regulate the way in which that lake
00:56:16 is fished because there's a come there's a common interest and so government one government function
00:56:21 would be precisely for that and that's just one example i think it extends farther out
00:56:28 but i just don't think that we can neatly distinguish all these private ownerships and
00:56:33 everything's private i don't think even in principle you can do that really well because we
00:56:38 we don't just like share like when i when i think of someone who drives down the road
00:56:43 and we talked about this the other night and throw out like a mcdonald's you know ever seen
00:56:48 those people that like they throw this about there and it falls on someone's property you
00:56:52 know on the side of the road and like we could think of that as an injustice to the property
00:56:57 owner um because now they have to clean up the mess perhaps but i see that as an injustice to
00:57:03 our shared world because i have to see it right i like when you share a visible space you share
00:57:10 more than just a line between land between land or whatever you share a visible space and you all
00:57:17 have a common collective interest in in the order and beauty of that space and so that's where i
00:57:23 think it would arise from that all sorts of regulations as well um uh yeah anyway go ahead
00:57:30 I think the creation of a large administrative state to manage all sorts of common areas is one of the great problems of tyranny.
00:57:39 You want to avoid administrative states.
00:57:42 The Declaration of Independence talks about the king sending forth his ministers to eat out our substance as a swarm of locusts.
00:57:49 And I think that you couldn't even name all of the three-letter agencies that exist.
00:57:54 If anybody here can send me a text message, you don't have my number.
00:57:57 But if you can send an email to my email list back there with, like, all of the three-letter agencies within the next 15 minutes, if you could find them all, I'd give you $100.
00:58:06 Like, I don't think you could do it in 15 minutes.
00:58:09 You couldn't get a comprehensive list of the three-letter agencies to get the $100 and email it to me.
00:58:16 The amount of administrative state burden that exists from an effort to manage the commons as opposed to making the commons private.
00:58:24 it. If you sell something off to people to use, there's private stewardship. When you have the
00:58:32 state own it and it's a public good, you end up with this administrative state to manage it for
00:58:39 the people. And I would suggest that the good of the people is advanced by private property
00:58:46 ownership and the wealth being owned by households and individuals and the state focusing on its
00:58:52 work of administering justice, waging just warfare, and seeking to maintain borders and to stop
00:59:00 ongoing disruption of the peace. And going beyond that makes it so that the state is this actor
00:59:06 that is pretending to be omnicompetent, but is really just the DMV.
00:59:14 All right, so who, like, let's take the large lake. Who has the rightful original claim to own that
00:59:21 lake such that they can sell it. Yeah. So I think that the claiming of unused lands, the Puritans
00:59:27 in the common law worked through the idea of best and highest use. And as a way, how do you glorify
00:59:33 God with this? And you go, okay, there's a grant of dominion to the race of man over the earth.
00:59:37 How do you take property out of the earth and set it aside as private property? When it is unused,
00:59:44 the use of it the work the dominion work is the thing that makes it so that you now as doing
00:59:52 stewardship over it there's a grant of authority otherwise you stuck with a native form of
00:59:58 communism where all things are common when adam is made how do you ever move anything from common
01:00:04 possession to private possession well right i i understand like that's that's lock
01:00:08 No, but there's a difference though
01:00:14 It's one thing to come across an open field
01:00:17 Or clear the land and plant your crops
01:00:19 And you, yeah, I agree with that
01:00:21 That is like the most fundamental claim of ownership
01:00:26 Is that you've exerted work upon some space
01:00:29 And therefore you can claim it as your own
01:00:32 There's a sort of identification, phenomenological
01:00:34 It feels like it's yours
01:00:36 the difference though if it's a large lake
01:00:39 something that is not something
01:00:40 that you can
01:00:41 easily claim as your own
01:00:44 that is truly common
01:00:46 that would then be a collective ownership
01:00:49 that would in some ways be
01:00:51 a something that
01:00:53 more than one party would have a claim
01:00:55 in some sense to that space
01:00:56 one guy's on the other side of the bank
01:00:58 one guy's on this one and they're all
01:01:00 so in that sense by it's very nature
01:01:03 it's like you know
01:01:05 you like even a mountain like okay i hiked i got to the top of this mountain does that mean you
01:01:10 have rights to the mountain because you you you travel to the top of it so there's just things
01:01:16 by their very nature like take um take like yosemite anyone yeah so yosemite there's this
01:01:22 great place strip mine it what what's that i said strip mine it i know that's what you do
01:01:28 no like half dome you know like you climb the top of half dome does that mean you have a right to
01:01:33 you know uh spray paint the side of it because you got the top of it you can do your name you
01:01:38 know like reese company or like reese fund like the first guy to get there reese fund or whatever
01:01:45 you know there's just things by the very nature that are common collective that are for the common
01:01:50 good um and and for that reason there's a common interest and so then then the civil government
01:01:56 would be as something of by for the people would then have a role in securing the commonness of
01:02:01 that thing such that there's no exploitation because that is a problem with common like yeah
01:02:06 you're right if you have a private lake you have an interest in well-stocked you know fishery but
01:02:12 if it's by its very nature something that cannot be privatized or made you know under one party
01:02:17 then it's easily exploited because then you could just go up and get all the fish take it out now
01:02:23 it's there's up in there so then you would there's an interest collective interest in the good
01:02:28 afforded by that thing that is not by its nature private same thing with like hiking on a mountain
01:02:34 something like that and and yeah sorry go ahead sorry so i think scripturally when you have
01:02:41 questions like where does somebody's property start and somebody else's end one of the examples
01:02:46 that's given is if there's a dead body found in the countryside uh you what you do is you measure
01:02:51 where that dead body is compared to the town center of the closest towns and the closer one
01:02:58 is the one that has jurisdiction over the investigation.
01:03:01 And that's a really easy, quick way to deal with
01:03:04 where do boundaries butt up against each other.
01:03:06 So with water, if you're like,
01:03:08 well, I made a town on this side of the water
01:03:10 and he built a ranch on that side of the water
01:03:12 and there's one over here,
01:03:13 and you go, okay, have you claimed along the shoreline?
01:03:16 Are you doing the work to deal with this stuff?
01:03:18 So you have these places.
01:03:21 Who has rights over what water?
01:03:23 You can determine by the same sorts of things
01:03:25 of measuring the distance from the most recent,
01:03:28 from the property holders or whatever.
01:03:29 But the problem is, the alternative is
01:03:31 to have, you know, the department of Lake Five.
01:03:35 And when you have departments that are dealing with this,
01:03:39 they just take the rights from everybody.
01:03:42 So now instead of a private property interest
01:03:44 where people are doing stuff, you know, you can just do things.
01:03:48 And if you do have the ability to just do things, you're free.
01:03:51 And when you can't do stuff,
01:03:53 and you've got to go through the bureaucratic process
01:03:55 of getting the approval of Lake Department 5 to tell you whether you can put a boat that's 14 feet
01:04:00 on the water or not, what you end up with is somebody saying, this is mine. And it's no longer
01:04:06 individuals, it's now the state. It's the state's property. And so it's this eminent domain that is
01:04:13 taking of property and concentrates it to the state. And they do not manage it for the public
01:04:19 good well because the state is not good at taking dominion. The state's job was not to take
01:04:26 dominion. The state's job is to punish criminals. And the individual's job is to take dominion in
01:04:32 the household. All right. Well, you clearly assessed the means of persuasion, which is also 0.92
01:04:42 an aristotle um but uh so for yeah i would say this is a very american audience and a very american
01:04:49 form of rhetoric which is you know i'm american too i guess but um so it's good but i i you go
01:04:55 to other countries and this sort of rhetoric does actually does not land on people so i'm not
01:05:01 criticizing you but uh i i just like to point out that that your your argument it i think that of
01:05:08 the American bureaucratic system, as it functions now, I would agree with you. There are all sorts
01:05:15 of problems. But this doesn't land on other places that actually have very efficient government
01:05:21 and actually respected government in other places. If you go to Europe and ask the people
01:05:26 about their government, they're going to have disagreements. But in general, they're actually
01:05:30 going to like their state. In general, they're going to want actually a stronger state or a
01:05:35 strong state. It's a different, I think, given our culture, we have a very antagonistic view of the
01:05:42 civil government, and we tend to think of it as something very separate from us, as something
01:05:47 outside of us, as something distinguished from us that comes to oppress us, and that's part of our
01:05:52 culture to think like that. And frankly, I think it's part of conservatism as well. I think one of
01:05:59 the problems with conservatism is that we want to, instead of engaging in political life, where we
01:06:06 try to shape the regulations and the function of government in a very active way on city councils,
01:06:12 in county commissions, in state government, we want to, in a way, disengage from politics by
01:06:18 establishing these, what I think are very abstract lines of what's allowed and what's disallowed.
01:06:25 And one of the things I've been trying to say is that actually we as conservatives need to engage in the political process to promote the good for our people and society.
01:06:36 And I do think that involves regulation.
01:06:38 But I think part of our problem and one of the reasons why as conservatives we talk about the state, which is a very modern concept.
01:06:44 Usually when you think of state, it's an old idea using the word state.
01:06:49 But when we think of bureaucracy, we're thinking of 20th century managerialism.
01:06:54 managerial bureaucracy, which is very different than civil servants within the 19th century and
01:07:00 18th century. A very different conception of the role of government. There was far more activity
01:07:06 in politics. There was a smaller government, limited government, and I actually fully support
01:07:11 limited small government. But I think in a, I just think in principle that if we engage thoroughly
01:07:17 in politics like uh than than these uh instead of creating like abstract lines of what's permitted
01:07:25 and not permitted but just sought the good through political political activity um i think we'd have
01:07:31 a different perspective on this um yeah but i but i agree like yeah there's in general the the amount
01:07:40 of regulation is too much you talk to someone from california trying to build a house and i
01:07:43 understand. Just too much. And probably in most states as well. Though I do think, again, I just
01:07:50 don't think there's anything wrong in principle with having inspectors come and make sure that
01:07:53 the overpass is not going to collapse on someone or that the parking garage is not going to collapse
01:07:59 under a 7.0 earthquake. And these are all things that can be made sure of through experts in
01:08:07 principle and that is something we can do as political people again political
01:08:13 animals seek to form in society so I think we've been rapidly
01:08:37 I think I have five minutes
01:08:47 so just one second to lay out my watch
01:08:50 so when we think about the difference here
01:08:56 between natural law and theonomy
01:08:57 and the difference between the broad power
01:08:59 of a civil power
01:09:00 versus a narrow regulated principle sense
01:09:04 I think that we've gone into some of the details of things
01:09:09 as regards things like the problem of the commons
01:09:11 and so kind of pushing to the edges
01:09:13 of some of the more difficult problems.
01:09:17 But on a basic level,
01:09:19 the scriptures provide a law that is infallible.
01:09:24 That law teaches us our duties
01:09:26 and therefore our rights.
01:09:28 You have a right to do everything God commands you to do.
01:09:31 you are also free from people imposing upon you a commandment to sin
01:09:36 and a christian liberty is the liberty to do what is right and to not do evil and so the law of god
01:09:44 as a basis to judge civil power laid out in the scriptures is an infallible rule that allows us
01:09:52 to judge all the laws of men i think that there are issues as regards the details of law for
01:10:00 administration like where do you go to vote or you know how are you going to determine the
01:10:07 boundaries of jurisdictions or how is the method of execution to be carried out that sort of thing
01:10:14 those things are administrative details that were particular to Israel that are not binding on us
01:10:20 but if it's not particular to Israel and if it's not a technology thing right if we're talking
01:10:27 about the civil law, it provides everything besides the technologies and the administrative
01:10:33 details that are particular to Israel. The rest provides us with principles of justice
01:10:39 that we must apply because we are not free to invent authorities for people. We're not free
01:10:49 to exercise power over people because God made men equal under law, not equal in gifting,
01:10:58 Not equal in age, but equal under law.
01:11:01 And the distinctions of law come from the ordinance of God.
01:11:06 The Westminster Larger Catechism in the Fifth Commandment
01:11:08 talks about the idea that there's honor owed to people
01:11:11 on the basis of age, on the basis of gifting,
01:11:15 and on the basis of God's ordinance.
01:11:17 And the ordinance of God lays out offices
01:11:21 in three institutions, the household, the church,
01:11:24 and the state.
01:11:26 And so the ordinance of God creates officers in the household, the church, and the state
01:11:30 that we owe honor to, including obedience.
01:11:34 And the nature of those institutions, as well as the nature of the individual,
01:11:38 is revealed for us fully in the scriptures of the Old and New Testaments.
01:11:43 And as a result, we can, by looking at the commandments of God,
01:11:49 by looking at the apodictic law, which is the big principles, like the Ten Commandments,
01:11:54 or by looking at the case laws that are if then statements you organize those under the ten
01:12:00 commandments or by looking at approved and disapproved examples with blessing or cursing
01:12:05 and those things are the details that allow us to have all the sorting categories we need
01:12:11 to be able to make determinations about rightness and wrongness in every institution
01:12:15 including the state things that are necessary to human action and human societies
01:12:23 that are not laid out
01:12:25 as elements of power
01:12:26 or authority of the state
01:12:27 or of the civil power
01:12:28 but still they have to be done
01:12:31 by the nature of human action
01:12:32 by the nature of human societies
01:12:34 those things are logically derivable
01:12:37 from the definitions
01:12:38 of men and states in the Bible.
01:12:42 And so we are able
01:12:43 to come to infallible conclusions
01:12:45 by good necessary inference
01:12:47 to be able to know
01:12:49 what states ought to do
01:12:51 and to know the limits
01:12:52 of their just powers.
01:12:53 It is not necessary for men to write constitutions that are made up human laws and precepts to restrain men.
01:13:05 Instead, God has already given chains to bind princes.
01:13:11 And the chains are the law of God.
01:13:13 And princes want to throw off those chains because they want, out of sinful desire, out of their own depraved hearts, to tyrannize men.
01:13:25 At the same time, subjects want to rebel and do criminal things and throw off legitimate power.
01:13:33 As Americans, we have to be careful about the temptation of rejecting legitimate power.
01:13:37 and so i am not advocating anarchy but i am trying to advocate for a ordered liberty
01:13:44 a christian liberty not license a christian liberty and to say that the law of god is the
01:13:50 law of liberty and it protects your rights and it also restrains your excesses it is the royal law
01:13:57 that shows you how you ought to be ruled and so it provides the perfect balance
01:14:02 there is a real danger and it has shown up over and over again in history of tyrant princes
01:14:09 usurping the rights of the people and when the state is centralized and usurping the people
01:14:17 do not have great mechanisms to protect themselves unless the law of god provides all the things
01:14:24 we've seen gloriously laid out in american history in terms of federalism and the division of powers
01:14:30 and all those sorts of things,
01:14:32 their private ownership of arms.
01:14:34 Those things are part of the Protestant tradition.
01:14:36 It comes from Protestants applying the Bible.
01:14:39 It's not something that merely arose out of experience.
01:14:43 It is something that arose
01:14:44 because the Bible had to be applied
01:14:47 in times of difficulty
01:14:49 and men thought hard
01:14:50 and the Holy Spirit enlightened their minds
01:14:52 that they would see the truth in the word of God.
01:14:56 And so I would put forward to you
01:14:58 that the state is strictly limited
01:15:00 to only do what God commands it
01:15:02 and nothing more.
01:15:04 Thank you.
01:15:15 Well, this is fun,
01:15:16 so thank you for listening to us
01:15:18 talk about this.
01:15:20 I'll say that
01:15:21 we are social beings
01:15:23 and we share a world.
01:15:25 we share a space with others there's a certain calm there's a commonness of our of our life
01:15:33 together and even the things that we own that we call our private property they're not just
01:15:39 ordered for our good but for the good of our neighbors and so everything in the ends everything
01:15:44 we possess everything we have our powers our resources our property it's all oriented to the
01:15:51 good of the people we share that place with. And so I'm, in a way, pushing back, I think,
01:16:00 against a type of individualistic conception of ownership. I think there's both private
01:16:09 individual ownership or single-party ownership and also a common ownership that, in a way,
01:16:15 is concurrent with your own private ownership. And so this means that our common life, our shared
01:16:20 life together should be ordered to that end. Now, that doesn't mean communism. That doesn't mean
01:16:27 50% taxation. But it does mean that for that reason, we ought to be political. And it's in
01:16:36 our nature to be political animals. It's in our very nature to seek after the good of our society
01:16:43 by us observing what is occurring in our society and then seeking the good of that society. And I
01:16:49 think one problem is we think as conservatives that we're very political because we watch maybe
01:16:54 Fox News or listen to talks right talk radio or we you know we shout in the car when I don't know
01:17:00 some talk radio guy says something or you hear Joe Biden talk or whatever but that's not politics
01:17:05 that's just us having having fun I guess but I so I think that that as political animals
01:17:12 as political beings who are designed for a collective society in which you determine and
01:17:19 decide upon the particular actions for your good, that we as Christians ought to be more political
01:17:24 and conduct that activity. I don't think we actually do it as much as we think we do.
01:17:30 How many people, it's not a show of hands, but how many people are involved in their local
01:17:35 community with regard to city council, county commission, perhaps state politics? You might
01:17:41 watch national television a lot, great. I know some people already are and they're doing great
01:17:46 things but but that's that's rare like you go you look at I'm in a county that
01:17:51 is largely Republican and yet the Commission is largely is largely filled
01:17:57 with left-wing Democrats from Raleigh and there's a problem with that and it's
01:18:02 the it's that whoever cares more usually wins and you can care a lot by watching
01:18:07 television listen talk radio or coming you know coming here listen to us talk
01:18:11 but I would say we should care more by being involved in the political sphere
01:18:15 itself and I think we should avoid I think for you know David's I think his
01:18:20 tendency which is common in modern times is in is to actually escape
01:18:27 politics is to leave politics to avoid politics by creating these abstract
01:18:32 barriers between what can happen and what cannot happen now I think there are
01:18:36 barriers I just think having a more extensive view of politics means that
01:18:41 that those abstract lines of division are torn down
01:18:45 and actually permits you to engage in political life
01:18:48 and in that sense, fulfill your human nature
01:18:51 in the way God designed you.
01:18:54 And I think this goes back to our nature.
01:18:56 I don't think our political life is rooted
01:18:57 as a result of sin.
01:19:01 I think the reason that we care for our community
01:19:03 and we care for everything from downtown
01:19:07 to your own street
01:19:08 is not a function of simply your sin,
01:19:13 or it's not like medicine.
01:19:14 There wouldn't be medicine if man weren't fallen, right?
01:19:16 It's not akin to medicine.
01:19:18 It's actually more akin to you loving your own children.
01:19:21 That is a natural thing.
01:19:23 It would be true whether we are fallen or unfallen.
01:19:26 And I think politics is that as well.
01:19:28 And so I think the very desire
01:19:30 to see your city council act,
01:19:32 your commissioner act,
01:19:34 for your state to act,
01:19:35 for your federal government to act,
01:19:36 is actually a very natural thing,
01:19:38 but it only happens if we as people together act.
01:19:43 And so, anyway, well, thank you very much for listening.
01:19:45 Thank you.