The NXR Podcast - April 16, 2024


THE CONFERENCE - Presuppositional Apologetics - Session 6 - Dr. Joseph Boot | Blueprints for Christendom 2.0 2024

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW | The 3 Basic Beliefs Of All Christian Nationalists with AD Robles THE LIVESTREAM - Baptists, Your Children Are Holy (Whether You Agree Or Not)

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 5 minutes

Words per minute

129.06

Word count

8,398

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Hate speech

18

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Fr. Dr. Carl Sagan talks about the role of apologetics in the defense of the Christian faith, and why it is so important to understand the role apologetics plays in the Christian life.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I do recognize some of you from last year, and it's been great talking with you also at our table, so thank you.
00:00:10 My task for this first session this morning is to talk about presuppositionalism and apologetics.
00:00:18 So before we begin, why don't we just say a word of prayer together?
00:00:21 our lord and our god may the words of my mouth and the meditation of our hearts
00:00:33 be pleasing and acceptable in your sight o lord our rock and our redeemer open my lips
00:00:43 and my mouth shall show forth thy praise forgive us our sins lord we pray
00:00:50 For Christ's sake, amen.
00:00:58 So one of the critical issues, one of the critical subjects as we think about Christendom 2.0
00:01:09 is, of course, the presentation and defense of the faith.
00:01:17 Giving a defense.
00:01:20 Now, the requirement to get fit, which is literally what 1 Peter 3.15 is all about, to get fit, to be ready to prepare ourselves to give an apologia, an apologia, a defense of the faith is memorably set out by the Apostle Peter to the church as a whole.
00:01:43 but honor the Messiah as Lord in your hearts always be ready to give a defense to anyone who
00:01:51 asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you however do this with gentleness and respect
00:01:58 keeping your conscience clear so that when you are accused those who denounce your Christian life
00:02:04 will be put to shame so we know that's our task it's task for all of us but the
00:02:12 way we go about that task has been a matter of discussion of debate and of dispute
00:02:18 and I want to say to start with what's most important to keep in mind
00:02:23 taking seriously seriously this calling as an act of obedience is that this is ultimately about
00:02:31 the glory of God and the extension of his kingdom so notwithstanding the importance of a trustworthy
00:02:40 methodology in apologetics, our primary concern is a faithful witness to the gospel. It's not
00:02:51 about winning arguments with other Christians over apologetic strategy. We can have those
00:02:58 discussions, but the primary concern is the extension of the kingdom. We're surrounded
00:03:03 by people in a culture that do not know the lord the clamor and the noise of our diseased culture
00:03:13 seeks to distract people from confronting themselves in the silence there's a lack of
00:03:22 silence in contemporary culture people need to face their hopeless condition before god
00:03:31 and so with gentleness with respect we have to offer a reason even in the face of opposition
00:03:37 so that the quiet convicting presence of the holy spirit will still hearts before him and his word
00:03:45 can be heard now regrettably having said that amongst many christian people the apologetic
00:03:54 mandate is often misunderstood it's misapplied and that leads often to ambivalence to reticence
00:04:03 even hostility to the task of defending the faith
00:04:07 I'm slightly distracted by the bright light and you may be distracted by the bright light on this
00:04:14 salmon jacket it's not a mark of low testosterone
00:04:20 is actually a mark of very high testosterone because you need great security in your
00:04:27 masculinity to wear a coat like this one so thank you
00:04:33 now the the misunderstandings tend to arise principally because people think that apologetics
00:04:44 is concerned with establishing the truth of christianity by human reason
00:04:49 by direct rational proofs for god various forms of theoretical and scientific demonstration which
00:05:01 allegedly verify christian belief beyond a reasonable doubt before the bar of human reason
00:05:09 now i think the difficulty there is that that perspective attempts too much and accomplishes
00:05:16 too little it places an impossible and unsustainable burden on human theoretical
00:05:23 reasoning and at the same time actually fails to challenge unbelievers at the religious root
00:05:30 of their rebellion against god in the tradition of augustine and anselm i think the first
00:05:38 modern christian thinker to specifically identify this problem was the danish christian philosopher
00:05:46 soren kierkegaard a great critic of rationalism and romanticism in the 19th century and he said
00:05:54 this if one were to describe the whole orthodox apologetic apologetic effort in one single
00:06:00 sentence but also with categorical precision one might say that it has the intent to make
00:06:06 christianity plausible to this one might add that if it were to succeed then it would then
00:06:13 then would this effort have the ironical fate that precisely upon the day of its triumph
00:06:19 it would have lost everything and entirely quashed Christianity.
00:06:23 To make Christianity plausible is the same as to misrepresent it.
00:06:31 What did he mean by that?
00:06:33 Well, because biblical Christianity cannot be made plausible to human beings within any other paradigm
00:06:44 than the one which begins with faith in the Lord Jesus Christ, 0.93
00:06:48 christianity to the unbeliever always looks implausible 0.53
00:06:53 until you've got the lens of the word of god on your nose
00:06:58 a starting point rooted in the lord jesus christ the faith appears implausible from the biblical
00:07:08 standpoint the unbeliever doesn't merely have some erroneous beliefs here and there
00:07:12 they exist in untruth 0.87
00:07:16 they're unregenerate they exist in untruth orthodox rationalistic and evidential apologetics
00:07:27 neglect to take proper account of what scripture says about the condition of fallen human beings
00:07:34 the nature of the creation order under a curse and the character of god's self-revelation in christ
00:07:42 who shatters all the assumptions and expectations of human reason.
00:07:49 How can human reason account for the eternal God
00:07:54 manifesting himself fully in the temporal historical form of the man, Jesus Christ?
00:08:03 this also leads this assumption about apologetics where it's misunderstood leads to i think
00:08:16 unwarranted beliefs that before anyone can seek to defend their faith their intellectual
00:08:22 development and their relevant knowledge base must be highly advanced
00:08:26 their capacity to follow and retain lengthy chains of reasoning tightly honed
00:08:34 so i hope that in the course of this lecture we may get past some of those misunderstandings that
00:08:41 you don't have to be a brilliant philosopher to defend your faith so let's think about the
00:08:47 governing assumptions for a minute of a presuppositional method so i've said the
00:08:52 important thing about apologetics is winning the lost there are debates about how to do it
00:08:57 and obviously being asked to talk about presuppositionalism means that there's a
00:09:01 distinction between that view and other views what are the governing assumptions of the
00:09:06 presuppositional method well before summarizing the particular apologetic challenge we're facing
00:09:13 let's mention a few of those the first is to notice that there is no such thing as a view
00:09:21 from nowhere the autonomy of human reason is an illusion
00:09:28 there is no such thing as a neutral view from nowhere human understanding human reasoning is a
00:09:37 tool that can cut in various directions that's why by the way there are so many schools of thought
00:09:45 competing in the various academic disciplines and they all claim to be logical and reasonable
00:09:52 they all claim to be rational but there are multiple different perspectives laws of thought
00:10:01 even though laws of thought are god-given do not ensure that our beliefs and assumptions are true
00:10:09 laws of thought work on our beliefs logic may help us reach valid conclusions
00:10:15 and show the implications of our assumptions but it doesn't supply us with the premises
00:10:21 with the beliefs with which to begin
00:10:23 this means that reason is far from being neutral or independent or absolute it's
00:10:31 not a framework it's not a paradigm it is always constrained by the world and life view or what we
00:10:39 might say the plausibility structure within which a given individual is operating. So even on its
00:10:47 own terms, reason can never function as an independent final arbiter, as a final court
00:10:55 of appeal to settle disputes between completing claims. Because the justification of any worldview
00:11:02 is happening within that paradigm, it's happening within that framework. So a presuppositional
00:11:11 apologetic actually focuses on an internal critique of an unbeliever's worldview on
00:11:18 its own terms. When we engage unbelieving worldviews, we're internally criticizing
00:11:26 and showing how it collapses under its own weight. If what it says were true about the
00:11:30 world, it collapses. And then we're inviting people to put on the lens of the Word of God
00:11:37 and to see the explanatory power of biblical faith and how it accounts for the failure
00:11:45 of these competing views, as well as providing the truths that make the rich diversity of human
00:11:53 experience intelligible. But it does so within the structure of the Christian faith. Over the years,
00:11:58 i've done lots of debates on the existence of god i never pretend that i'm starting as
00:12:03 a neutral objective observer seeing where the neutral facts might lead because that would be a
00:12:12 lie all the facts are created facts governed by god secondly this leads us to the importance of
00:12:25 the concept of world and life view in christian apologetics something that again classical forms
00:12:32 of apologetics have typically ignored sometimes even denied simply put a worldview is a framework
00:12:39 it's a structure of understanding some people say a paradigm that rests on certain foundational
00:12:47 beliefs certain basic faith commitments and no human being is without one they may not have
00:12:53 analyzed it but no human being is without a set of assumptions through which they are looking at
00:12:59 the world now non-christian perspectives would all regard the basic claim of christianity
00:13:06 that the eternal god is manifest in the temporal manifestation of a man
00:13:13 the lord jesus christ dying for sin raised to life in power and glory as implausible
00:13:19 as implausible for it to become plausible one's worldview and thinking has to be transformed by
00:13:29 the reality of christ a person's and this is a more technical term but a person's epistemic
00:13:36 position has to be changed epistemic epistemology where we stand in relationship to knowledge
00:13:44 has to be altered a new faith commitment for understanding our life and world is required
00:13:51 and where that change is not taking place people simply take offense at christ
00:13:58 you know there is no way even in apologetics around the offense you know that don't you
00:14:05 people have to go through the offense
00:14:09 Jesus had to say to his disciples blessed is he who is not offended in me do you want to go away
00:14:19 as well we have to go through the offense we live in a culture that doesn't want to be offended
00:14:29 but we have to go through the offense
00:14:32 people will take offense because they are constrained by prior life reviews from which
00:14:40 they have to be liberated greg barnson put it this way each worldview has its presuppositions
00:14:46 about reality knowledge and ethics these mutually influence and support each other
00:14:52 there are no facts or uses of reason which are available outside of the interpretative system
00:14:58 of basic commitments or assumptions which appeals to them the presuppositions used by the christian
00:15:06 and non-christian determine what they will accept as factual and reasonable
00:15:11 that's a fairly paradigmatic statement actually of the presuppositional view of human knowledge
00:15:19 this makes clear that the choice is either or barnes talked about pushing the antithesis
00:15:28 either a personal god or the empty void or what kierkegaard called the vortex
00:15:36 lies behind everything as the central principle
00:15:41 now this doesn't mean that a world and life view is a hypothesis that we're simply testing rather
00:15:50 it's where our thinking rests it's a kind of faith-based certitude by which ideas are tested
00:15:58 so we put the lens of the word of god on and the claims of christ and we test everything in terms of
00:16:04 that again according to the great critic of rationalism kirkegaard he said a life view
00:16:16 listen to this closely it's a little bit involved because it's in translation from the danish
00:16:20 but a life view he says is certainty in oneself whether this has oriented itself only in all
00:16:29 worldly relationships a purely human standpoint by which means it keeps itself from contact
00:16:35 with a deeper experience or whether in its heavenward direction the religious it is found
00:16:43 there in the center as much for its heavenly as its earthly existence has won the true conviction
00:16:49 that neither death nor life nor angels nor principalities nor powers nor the present nor
00:16:54 the future nor height nor depth nor any other creation will be able to separate us from the
00:17:00 love of god in christ jesus our lord it's either the imminent or the transcendent and here is the
00:17:10 transcendent referent that later men like cornelius van till and herman doiver called the
00:17:17 archimedean point for the christian remember archimedes he's trying to find a lever and a
00:17:23 position with which to raise the world a position with which to truly understand things here it is
00:17:30 this is the transcendent referring in christ that lies outside space and time in the eternal god
00:17:36 even though it's manifest in history so that's something of the christian mind but the problem
00:17:42 we're dealing with today is the collapse of the christian mind the immediate difficulty
00:17:49 is that the Christian life view has collapsed in our time and not just in the culture quite
00:17:58 frequently in the world some years ago I was speaking in California in the Santa Cruz area
00:18:03 on apologetics and after my lecture I was taken out to lunch by a very nice young couple one of
00:18:10 the questions they asked me with a smile was how long I'd been an Apollo Jedi
00:18:14 i which was a humorous question but it it highlighted a misperception of the real
00:18:23 challenge that we're confronted with today we're confronted with the near total collapse of a
00:18:31 christian world and life view in the culture and often amongst believers and so it is not simply
00:18:37 better techniques in evangelism that we need, or smarter apologists, a kind of elite bunch of
00:18:44 Apollo Jedi who will do the heavy lifting for us, what we need is a recovery, and in many respects
00:18:51 a discovery, a fresh discovery of what it means to think Christianly and to be Christian before
00:19:00 a watching world. The current reality is that the questions confronting believers in the West
00:19:07 are qualitatively, not just quantitatively, different from the questions we faced even
00:19:14 25 years ago when I began in the work of Christian apologetics, because there is no longer a shared
00:19:21 understanding of reality that can undergird a common discourse. The common discourse is hard
00:19:28 to have now isn't it you've got all these disparate groups screaming at each other
00:19:33 because the basis for that common discourse has eroded beneath us the plausibility structure
00:19:41 based on christian foundations has been eroding and so for the first time in centuries we can
00:19:47 actually be talking with people our own neighbors whose basic religious presuppositions are
00:19:54 antithetical to our own if you'd have told my grandparents that by the time their grandson
00:20:02 or grandsons were having children of their own that there would be 72 genders
00:20:08 they'd have thought you'd need committing to an insane asylum but this is where we are now
00:20:17 these differing worldview starting points have we've said determine the kind of questions
00:20:24 people would deem relevant to addressing the existential socio-cultural and theoretical
00:20:32 problems of life it's quite unusual these days to be confronted with a question for example 0.93
00:20:37 unless you're talking to a muslim about the trinity or to be asked for five good reasons 0.84
00:20:42 to believe in the historicity of the resurrection 0.87
00:20:44 the pervasiveness of these unbelieving worldviews within the culture have had an impact on the
00:20:53 contemporary church now there were cultural prophets who saw it coming i think that's enough
00:20:58 for that slide um and uh there was a man named harry an english thinker called harry blamire
00:21:05 back in the 60s he wrote a book called the christian mind had a deep impact on me and he
00:21:10 opens this classic with a fairly commonplace observation that the thinking of modern people
00:21:15 has been secularized but he says that's not the primary challenge for believers this is what he
00:21:20 said tragic as this is it would not be so desperately tragic had the christian mind held
00:21:27 out against the secular drift but unfortunately the christian mind has succumbed to the secular
00:21:33 drift with a degree of weakness and nervelessness unmatched in christian history there is no longer
00:21:39 a christian mind there is still of course a christian ethic a christian practice and a
00:21:44 christian spirituality as a spiritual being in prayer and meditation the christian strives to
00:21:49 cultivate a dimension of life unexplored by the non-christian but as a thinking being the modern
00:21:55 christian has succumbed to secularization he accepts religion its morality its worship its
00:22:02 spiritual culture but he rejects the religious view of life the view which relates all problems
00:22:08 social political cultural to the doctrinal foundations of the christian faith the view
00:22:14 which sees all things here below in terms of god's supremacy he said that in the 60s
00:22:21 and it's interesting even when you read that you think well actually you know because of the
00:22:26 paganization of our culture people are exploring things like meditation and actually many christians
00:22:31 don't give a great deal of thought to an objective moral framework that we're all agreed we're all
00:22:36 agreed on we'll deal with that this afternoon when we talk about god's law as a consequence
00:22:42 it's not enough anymore to simply speak of equipping Christians to answer a few disconnected
00:22:48 questions about their personal faith or respond to an isolated question about a Christian doctrine
00:22:56 as all we need is a couple of seminars on the five most popular objections to the faith and
00:23:01 all will be well for the church and Christian apologetics let's just have a youth day and have
00:23:05 the three top questions and all will be well it's not enough we need renewal and reformation in
00:23:13 terms of a comprehensive scriptural view of reality we need to be able to reformulate the
00:23:21 questions of our time explaining their religious roots and their meaning
00:23:27 and that helps us deal then with the unbelievers own queries and difficulties whether they are real
00:23:35 or imagined and that can only be done within the context within the framework of a robust
00:23:41 biblical world and life view blamire understood this he says there is something before the
00:23:47 christian dialogue and that is the christian mind a mind trained informed equipped to handle
00:23:55 the data of secular controversy within a framework of reference which is constructed
00:24:01 of christian presuppositions the christian mind is the prerequisite of christian thinking and
00:24:07 christian thinking is the prerequisite of christian action you know we have a lot of young christians
00:24:13 today especially the younger generation they want to get straight into action they're out there
00:24:17 talking about social justice and engagement and everything else but they don't have a christian
00:24:21 mind they can't have a christian dialogue because they don't have a worldview constructed of
00:24:26 christian presuppositions and so their christian action often ends up being carl marx baptized
00:24:32 we have to have a christian mind before we're capable of serious christian dialogue and then
00:24:40 careful christian action effective christian apologetics today then requires a total christian
00:24:46 view of reality as rooted in scripture systematic unbelief being confronted by systematic belief
00:24:54 in every sphere of life now what i'm not appealing for is a new kind of evangelical
00:25:00 scholasticism a kind of elitist intellectualizing of the faith i'm talking rather about relearning
00:25:09 to think and live by the simple profundity of the word revelation of god in every aspect of life
00:25:16 human identity sexuality marriage family law politics economics philosophy the art science
00:25:25 business media education and all things besides how do we give an answer in those contexts
00:25:31 i began to ask myself that question about 15 years ago where is the defense as i was looking
00:25:38 for it as an apologist where is the defense of the christian view of law of education
00:25:44 of economic life of political life of the family of identity i'd spend a lot of time talking about
00:25:51 who is jesus why did he die what about the resurrection and is that what about evil and
00:25:55 suffering well those are important they're not unimportant but where was the defense of the
00:26:01 issues where the attack was actually taking place most uh younger people today in the universities
00:26:06 aren't biblically literate enough to make objections that were made 30 or 40 years ago
00:26:13 we need to then think christianly now what i've said this kind of programmatic
00:26:21 agenda a programmatic defense of a christian philosophy of life might seem a bit radical
00:26:27 a bit unnecessary a bit over the top even for this conference um roy closer framed the question
00:26:36 of the christian skeptical of this kind of thinking in this way he said an excellent
00:26:40 christian philosophy he said this while one can articulate a christian view of god a christian
00:26:45 view of how to stand in right relation to god and a christian view of ethics why is it necessary to
00:26:50 articulate a distinctly christian view of everything that seems like a fair question
00:26:55 doesn't it after all isn't the faith we defend centered on the hope of heaven and afterlife and
00:27:00 deliverance from an evil world why must we defend a distinctly christian view of everything since
00:27:09 on that basis everything is not really very important is there really a christian way to
00:27:16 boil an egg besides isn't it only areas of morality and spirituality that christians
00:27:23 and non-christians disagree isn't the vast majority of daily life essentially neutral
00:27:27 many christians of course will agree that we should think about christian things
00:27:34 and themes we should be spiritual people but surely there isn't a distinctly christian view
00:27:41 of everything and those questions themselves actually belie the collapse of the christian
00:27:48 mind they reveal the need for developing a presuppositional apologetic the fundamental
00:27:55 confusion in those objections is equating thinking christianly with thinking about christianity
00:28:01 this is how blamire puts it to think christianly is to accept all things with the mind as related
00:28:13 directly or indirectly to man's eternal destiny as the redeemed and chosen child of god
00:28:19 you can think christianly or you can think secularly about the most sacred things the
00:28:24 sacrament of the altar for example likewise you can think christianly or you can think
00:28:29 secularly about the most mundane things there is nothing in our experience however trivial
00:28:33 worldly or even evil which cannot be thought about christianly the fact that many people
00:28:39 are writing about things christian is in itself irrelevant to the question whether there is still
00:28:43 a christian mind you see what he's saying we've got christian bookshops today we've got christian
00:28:49 authors we can we can stack shelves with endless christian books plenty of people are talking about
00:28:54 things christian and yet very often these books do not contain a christian mind
00:28:59 they look at all of this content but not from the world view of the word of god
00:29:04 now to establish this point biblically is important otherwise you might think well
00:29:11 this is the gospel according to joe how do we know there is a christian world and life view
00:29:18 a truly christian mind well here's a good place to start the fear of the lord is the foundation
00:29:24 of true knowledge or the fear of the lord is the beginning of wisdom the word translated
00:29:34 foundation there or beginning literally means principal part principal part jesus makes the
00:29:43 same point when he's rebuking the pharisees you'll remember with their misleading interpretations of 0.75
00:29:48 the law he says woe to you experts in the law you have taken away the key of knowledge 0.96
00:29:54 what is the key of knowledge well it's the knowledge of God especially through the
00:30:01 son as revealed in the word of God this is the heart knowledge that Paul calls having the mind
00:30:07 of Christ and so the apostle Paul directs us actually to Christ Christ himself as the one
00:30:16 who alone gives true understanding he says by him you were enriched in a few spiritual churchy
00:30:22 things sorry i missed did i misquote that by him you were enriched in everything in all speech
00:30:30 and all knowledge in all speech and all knowledge clearly what paul is saying is that knowing god
00:30:44 through christ affects everything including all knowledge not some artificially restricted
00:30:49 ecclesiastical or churchy knowledge so a little later on he says the lord knows that the reasonings
00:30:57 of the wise are meaningless everything is yours you belong to christ and christ belongs to god
00:31:09 don't spiritualize that text away too quickly into pious sentiment it means that every area
00:31:16 of knowledge every area of life in all creation belongs to those who belong to christ
00:31:20 truth and life are not captive to the meaningless reasonings of unbelievers to the emptiness the
00:31:29 speculations of the philosophers paul says elsewhere in fact they know neither truth nor
00:31:34 life as they should the implication of this is that though unbelievers know many things partially
00:31:42 as creatures made in God's image, their knowledge of all things suffers from a critical lack.
00:31:48 Klauser puts it this way, there is some kind of mistake with respect to every kind of truth
00:31:53 and knowledge that can't be avoided if one does not know God, but can be avoided if one does know
00:32:00 God. Now, what's not being said here is that if you want a distinctly Christian view of quantum
00:32:07 mechanics or the mating habits of the common cockroach or the functions the physiology of
00:32:14 the human heart that all you need to do is look up the relevant verse in the bible if you were to go
00:32:21 in for heart surgery next week and when you got in and the surgeon's putting his gloves on and
00:32:26 and putting his robes on and they're just about to put the mask over your face and you see him
00:32:30 with a bible in his hand flicking through and saying to one of the nurses where's that passage
00:32:35 about the heart again because i'm now what are we doing you'd be pretty concerned
00:32:40 the bible does not give us exhaustive or encyclopedic knowledge of all things and
00:32:47 disciplines it doesn't intend to part of the task that was given to human beings at the beginning
00:32:54 of creation according to scripture is to observe discover name created entities and their functions
00:33:03 to bring out the potentiality of creation by learning about God's laws for all aspects of
00:33:09 created reality in light of his spoken word there was no point in the history of human beings where
00:33:15 they were simply left to look at creation and learn and understand there was always verbal
00:33:22 revelation from God those two things together is what are important a distinctly Christian
00:33:30 worldview and apologetic then rests not on finding a proof text for thermodynamics or heart disease
00:33:36 in the bible but recognizing jesus christ as the religious foundation for all knowledge and that
00:33:44 means taking full account of what scripture says about god and his creation about his lord and
00:33:49 redemptive work in history in all of our observations in all of our thinking and all of our theorizing
00:33:57 and living that's the starting point for a faithful apologetic and then of course we aim 0.81
00:34:03 to show the unbeliever that if they reject that biblical starting point the biblical paradigm of
00:34:12 creation of a fall into sin of redemption through christ of a consummation of all things
00:34:19 that paradigm of the scriptures if we reject that we make a perilous religious mistake that
00:34:27 sets aside the principal part the key of knowledge
00:34:31 and that mistake will then misdirect one's total understanding and it will eventually reduce all
00:34:42 of life to meaninglessness and unintelligibility so let me conclude this section with don't get
00:34:49 excited i'm nowhere near finished but just this section um with a definition then of apologetics
00:34:54 by the best-looking apologist in North America today.
00:34:58 Christian apologetics is the work of articulating,
00:35:03 defending, and translating the Christian mind,
00:35:07 conscience, hope, and imagination into all aspects of life
00:35:11 so that the embodied Christian world and life view
00:35:14 is set forth as true, satisfying, and full of meaning.
00:35:19 it's an art as well as a science christian persuasion is an art under the guidance of
00:35:29 the holy spirit as well as a science and that that vision for apologetics integrated into normal
00:35:34 christian life that is part of your priestly service and my priestly service to god paul
00:35:40 said that his ministry was for the defense and confirmation of the gospel we are to bring each
00:35:48 area of life into relation to the gospel procedurally then from a procedural point of view
00:35:56 the believer armed with a christian mind with christian presuppositions ready to defend and
00:36:05 translate the faith into all of life has set apart christ as lord not reason as lord
00:36:12 has set apart Christ as Lord in their hearts,
00:36:17 and that includes a surrender to the authority of his word.
00:36:22 As such, God's word in Scripture becomes our ultimate criterion for truth.
00:36:30 Think about this.
00:36:31 If the reach of our reasons or of our grasp of various external evidences
00:36:39 are more reliable and more authoritative
00:36:43 to stand as proofs of that word
00:36:46 than it's actually our thinking
00:36:48 and our logical procedures
00:36:49 that are the ultimate criterion for truth
00:36:52 displacing God's word, isn't it?
00:36:57 The reality is nobody proves
00:37:00 their most basic assumptions,
00:37:02 their most ultimate criterion,
00:37:05 their Archimedian point directly.
00:37:09 Otherwise, they wouldn't be their most basic assumptions, would they?
00:37:13 What you proved them with would be your most basic assumption.
00:37:21 Here's a tongue twister for you.
00:37:23 All arguments must begin with assumptions.
00:37:27 Therefore, it is impossible that all assumptions be based on arguments.
00:37:31 I'll give you 30 seconds to think about that.
00:37:32 all arguments must begin with assumptions and therefore it's impossible that all assumptions
00:37:41 be based on arguments the ultimate questions of life always come down to religious authority
00:37:47 to a given faith where does ultimate authority lie with the author of all things
00:37:55 or with me or you or Oprah or Jimmy Fallon or whatever it is these days
00:38:04 where does ultimate authority lie it's therefore important that we seek to defend the faith in a
00:38:12 manner that's consistent with our fundamental beliefs about God and his word the very notion
00:38:17 actually that god the god about which i've been speaking needs my feeble efforts to prop up
00:38:26 his sovereignty and lordship to prop him up on the face of it is absurd isn't it
00:38:34 i do not establish the reality of the one who establishes me
00:38:42 when moses asked for god's name he asked for a definition effectively
00:38:51 god says i am who i am i am that i am i will be who i will be you can't define me moses
00:39:02 because i am the source of all definition
00:39:06 human beings reason from existence not to existence you analyze all of your thought
00:39:20 you will discover that you are reasoning from not to existence the holy spirit through the
00:39:27 scriptures reveals to us the god of all truth whose word is law whose creation is meaning
00:39:36 and who knows the end from the beginning the only kind of word that such a god can speak
00:39:45 is an authoritative and totally infallible word there's nothing new that can be brought
00:39:52 to god's attention that will change his mind about something oh i didn't notice that one
00:39:58 Oh, I let one slip my mind.
00:40:03 The Bible does not contain hypotheses.
00:40:10 It doesn't contain scientific argumentation.
00:40:15 It doesn't contain, as far as I can tell, any classical apologetic arguments.
00:40:21 it is the infallible word of god christ is the final word as god incarnate he is god
00:40:35 incarnate by definition then without such revelation from the all conditioning god
00:40:41 there can be no ultimate objective truth no absolute eternal reality there's only an endless
00:40:49 series of human hypotheses and rationalizations applied to brute facts that's uncreated facts in
00:40:57 a chaotic cosmos that is impervious to true interpretation
00:41:02 the facts of experience become as van till said like beads without a chain to give them unity
00:41:13 it's like trying to gain knowledge gaining knowledge is like an attempt to sew without
00:41:21 fastening the ends and without tying a knot in the thread Greg Barnson puts it this way he says
00:41:27 for the Christian every fact is created pre-interpreted and divinely revelatory 0.60
00:41:33 the unbeliever holds just the opposite one begins with the creator and approaches the world thinking 0.97
00:41:42 god's thoughts after him while the other attempts to interpret experience by imposing abstract 0.94
00:41:49 formal unifying principles on concrete contingent diverse facts that sounds like a bit of a mouthful
00:41:57 just get some greg barnson and read his introduction to presuppositional apologetics
00:42:05 but he's basically saying look for the non-believer without the creator god who
00:42:12 governs and rules all things the world is just a chaos of brute fact of uncreated fact
00:42:17 from that's emerged from the womb of chance and the human mind must somehow rationalize
00:42:23 for the first time the chaos that's out there 0.99
00:42:26 but the unbeliever is unable to establish a relationship between the human mind and the 0.99
00:42:34 chaotic facts out there in our experience this is all to say that the bible's truth
00:42:40 and explanatory power carries self-attesting authority the lord jesus never appeals to
00:42:49 greek systems of logic he doesn't footnote any philosophers he doesn't quote any human
00:42:56 authorities to support his claim it would be absurd for him to do so as both god and king
00:43:03 the word made flesh through whom all things were made to whom all things belong who says before 0.51
00:43:08 Abraham was I am let me just consult Socrates to make sure that's correct
00:43:15 his word is totally self-attesting and this is what caused and still causes such offense 0.83
00:43:27 now in our apologetic efforts we can legitimately speak about the text of the bible seen through
00:43:36 historical investigation we can point to ancient and plentiful manuscripts which show the accuracy
00:43:43 of its transmission we can answer the questions of those who ask about textual variants we can
00:43:48 point to discoveries and archaeology to grab people's attention that's fine we can use
00:43:56 evidence is to grab people's attention but none of this proves or demonstrates the bible to be
00:44:02 the word of god historical inquiry can only ever produce varying degrees of confidence in any
00:44:11 specific event and sinful people are no more likely to accept god's revelation of himself
00:44:19 in history as they are to accept god's revelation of himself in the bible if they don't like it
00:44:24 in a few weeks time i'll be doing a debate on the resurrection around easter time in a
00:44:31 college setting in the uk but i won't be offering
00:44:34 10 historical reasons for to believe the resurrection as my fundamental argument
00:44:39 jesus was raised from the dead but i cannot prove that unequivocally by human reason i believe it
00:44:51 on faith i believe it and it's only by believing it that i can understand anything else
00:45:01 faith in the word of god is our starting point then in apologetics as in the rest of the christian
00:45:13 life why would we move out of the normal christian life and then suddenly when we get
00:45:17 into christian apologetics say well now we need to use a different form of authority
00:45:21 this is the result of course of placing our trust in jesus christ rather than the epistemic
00:45:31 confusion confusion of human beings and their empty reasoning we boldly and unapologetically
00:45:38 stand on the word of god and presuppose the christian worldview we submit a priori
00:45:45 to the dependability of god's word i do not hold that the bible is true
00:45:50 after i've analyzed it and decided i think it's logical by my judgment
00:45:55 or ethical by my estimation
00:46:01 or sufficiently supported by the most recent historical research the lord jesus says in
00:46:10 john 17 17 when he prayed to his father thy word is truth psalm 119 declares thy law is truth that's
00:46:21 our sure foundation let me say something radical to you prayerful reflection upon the word of god
00:46:28 by the holy spirit is our archimedian point of departure and apologetics it's the word of god
00:46:35 the work of the Holy Spirit and our prayerful dependence upon both the word and the spirit
00:46:41 that is the point of departure for us and that contrasts with traditional views of apologetics
00:46:47 that must first seek to prove God and the validity of his word first usually they try and prove some
00:46:53 kind of abstract conception of theism then move to try and establish that maybe Jesus was raised
00:47:01 from the dead probably and now might you please consider the bible as the word of god and jesus's
00:47:06 claims van till says
00:47:11 traditional apologetics built into it the right and ability of the natural man apart from the
00:47:19 work of the spirit of god to be the judge of the claim of the authoritative word of god
00:47:23 it is man who by means of his self-established intellectual tools puts his stamp of approval
00:47:29 on the word of god and then only after that grand act does he listen to it god's word must first
00:47:36 pass man's test of good and evil truth and falsity but once you tell a non-christian this why should
00:47:43 he be worried by anything else that you say you have already told him he is quite all right just
00:47:48 the way he is the scripture is not correct then the scripture is not correct when it talks of
00:47:53 darkened minds willful ignorance dead men and blind people with this method the correctness
00:48:00 of the natural man's problematics is endorsed that is all he needs to reject the christian faith
00:48:08 it's because of this so when the apostles are engaged in evangelism in the book of acts and
00:48:15 giving an account of the faith to the skeptic we're told they reasoned with them from the
00:48:20 scriptures act 17 17 they didn't reason to the scriptures as though they were establishing their
00:48:27 authority but from the worldview of the scriptures now that doesn't set aside careful thinking or
00:48:37 reasoned arguments as witnessed paul in the areopagus on mars hill but it is reasoning
00:48:45 with the scriptures and in light of the scriptures not pretending to neutrality to see if god's claims
00:48:54 in scripture are valid it's important that actually we remember in our evangelistic and
00:49:01 apologetic efforts that it is god the holy spirit who reveals christ to people and not us our task
00:49:10 is to be faithful to be obedient to glorify god it is the holy spirit who reveals christ to people
00:49:15 When Jesus asked Peter, who do you say that I am?
00:49:23 And Peter replied, thou art the Christ, the son of the living God.
00:49:27 Jesus said, blessed are you, Simon Bar-Jonah, because flesh and blood did not reveal this to you, but my Father who is in heaven.
00:49:34 so the scriptures make crystal clear that all people have a duty to acknowledge God's self
00:49:43 revelation in creation in Christ in scripture and conform their thinking to it every word of
00:49:51 God is a law word it's the condition of our existence his word is the condition of all
00:50:00 life and it is this word we take by faith and trust and which we presuppose in our engagement
00:50:10 with the world that's thinking christianly but to wrap up we could also think unchristianly
00:50:17 those who reject christ and his revelation obviously do not have a christian view of things
00:50:24 but that doesn't make them neutral it does not mean they don't have a faith foundation
00:50:29 for their thinking rather something takes the place of the living god for the unbeliever there
00:50:37 is a god surrogate consequently the problem we face the challenge we face in engaging the
00:50:45 unbeliever is what we can call the epistemological sin of the heart 0.68
00:50:50 it's a sin of the heart it's a refusal to acknowledge God's word revelation and respond
00:50:59 with obedience Paul tells us doesn't he what the situation is for God's wrath is revealed from
00:51:05 heaven against all and godlessness and unrighteousness of people who by their
00:51:11 unrighteousness suppress the truth since what can be known about God is evident among them
00:51:17 because God has shown it to them for his invisible attributes that is his eternal power and divine
00:51:21 nature have been clearly seen since the creation of the world being understood through what he has
00:51:26 made as a result people are without excuse for though they knew God they did not glorify him
00:51:34 as God or show gratitude instead their thinking became nonsense and their senseless minds were
00:51:43 darkened they exchanged the truth of god for the lie it should say really a lie and worshipped
00:51:52 and served something created instead of the creator who is blessed forever what is the lie
00:51:59 the lie right back in the garden of god has god really said
00:52:07 you will not surely die but you will be as god
00:52:16 you can define good and evil and truth and falsehood for yourself you can know it for yourself
00:52:23 it is this reality that we confront all worldviews have their own religious starting
00:52:32 point with a presupposed criterion of truth and this is where the truth is exchanged for a lie
00:52:39 the unbelievers explainer for reality will always posit something that just is that's just there
00:52:48 something that doesn't depend on anything else for its being an unconditioned reality a divine per
00:52:56 say everybody either believes in the living god or they will give something created
00:53:05 a god surrogate the status of divinity and the bible calls that idolatry
00:53:13 it's this religious foundation that it impacts then all knowledge and all truth
00:53:22 And over the centuries, the idol factory, as John Calvin called it, of the human heart
00:53:28 has tried to give divine status to everything, from planetary bodies to numbers,
00:53:37 like the Pythagoreans who worship numbers, to ideas, to logic and human reason,
00:53:44 to emperors and states, to energy and matter, and to many other things besides.
00:53:52 Roy Klauser helpfully summarizes it this way it's almost lunch so hang in there
00:53:56 those who don't see the divine as the biblical transcendent creator will make it some part of
00:54:04 the world instead and regarding anything in the world as self-existent will slant
00:54:09 guide and control the deeper content of every concept the name given to this way of explaining
00:54:18 meaning the way that identifies what part of the world all the rest depends on is reduction.
00:54:26 A reductionist explanation is one that claims to have found the part of the world that everything
00:54:32 else depends on. A Christian should say these are all wrong. They are all examples of regarding 1.00
00:54:40 part of creation as the creator. The ultimate explainer is no part of creation at all.
00:54:47 every one of these divinity candidates is real but they all depend on god the christian would
00:54:54 adopt a systematically non-reductionist approach to every sort of theory every sort of knowledge
00:55:00 and every concept of everything now this idolatry can take very then sophisticated and deceptive
00:55:10 forms so that man's creativity in finding god's surrogates can appear very very sophisticated
00:55:19 these idols then shape people's thinking and through people's thinking they start to shape
00:55:25 culture and society for example some people try and make the physical aspect of reality material
00:55:32 reality, sometimes in tandem with the biological, as the only true reality and use it to explain
00:55:43 everything else. The physical is said to be truly real and everything else, all the non-physical
00:55:50 properties like logical thought beauty love number even history are either illusory
00:56:01 or they are simply byproducts of what is physical philosophers call that epiphenomenal
00:56:08 they're just a byproduct of matter everything is made dependent on the physical aspect of reality
00:56:15 so every other facet is diminished in status as less real i was reading uh this past week about a
00:56:22 new um exhibit about the human brain that everybody's raving about these experiments
00:56:29 being done on rats and other animals and this sort of neurological science deep investigation
00:56:35 of the brain look how these electrons are firing and look at this activity over here when someone's
00:56:39 praying and this activity as though you can reduce human existence to the movement of atoms
00:56:44 to the firing of neurons it's actually self-defeating if you if you follow the
00:56:54 logic of that view out there's no such thing as a historical exhibit within science
00:56:59 everything is made dependent on the physical the importance of the physical aspect is then
00:57:05 overestimated relative to everything that is said to depend upon it and this is the nature
00:57:12 of reductionism it performs a grand leveling matter leaps from one aspect one level of
00:57:19 existence to the next as though the law for the movement of atoms can account for the psychical
00:57:25 the moral the cultural and the faith life of man by contrast the christian will regard everything
00:57:32 though is in creation is equally real equally subject to god equally dependent on his word
00:57:39 no part of the cosmos generates or explains the rest the christian mind is non-reductionist
00:57:48 does not reduce the universe in whole or in part to one or more aspect in fact it doesn't even
00:57:54 reduce remember the cosmos to god we're not pantheists we don't identify any aspect of
00:58:04 creation as the source of the universe and we don't reduce the universe to god as though god
00:58:09 and the universe are somehow one there is a creator creature distinction that the bible begins with
00:58:15 that the gospel of john begins with that it asserts meaning the dependency of all creation
00:58:22 on god and every aspect every constituent aspect of creation equally real no part reduced in its
00:58:30 importance relative to the rest and that is the root of the christian mind in him all things
00:58:39 hold together in him all things consist now that might have sounded a bit abstract i know
00:58:47 that's apologetics for you but when this is applied into the real world of political life
00:58:53 and social life you get national socialism nazism communism marxism and millions of people lose
00:59:02 their lives when you have a reductionist worldview and then you apply it historically
00:59:08 people die human lives are destroyed
00:59:13 perhaps the most popular idol of our age the favorite god surrogate of our age is the state
00:59:22 the political where truth morality and law as well as cradle to grave security is found
00:59:31 in the infallible state as the arbiter of life the crowd the mob the democratic will expresses
00:59:40 a mutiny against god so actually today politics it's politics that fights god and his claims
00:59:47 tooth and nail everything is politicized marriage identity life it's all made an aspect of the
00:59:59 political that's why pastors get up into their pulpit and they want to talk about abortion and
01:00:02 then they're accused of being political and bringing politics into the pulpit
01:00:05 which is exactly where it belongs by the way
01:00:11 interestingly uh kierkegaard foresaw that atheistic and neo-pagan movements would make
01:00:20 their appearance as political trends and then manifest their true identity he said this the
01:00:27 future will correspond inversely to the reformation then everything appeared to be a
01:00:33 religious movement and became politics amen now everything appears to be politics but will become
01:00:39 a religious movement let me end with this in this view of apologetics the how
01:00:53 of the christian faith the how of coming to faith is as important as the what
01:01:01 in this view of apologetics the how of the christian faith is as important as the what
01:01:09 because the what cannot be ascertained or established under the illusion of some universal
01:01:16 capacity of autonomous human thinking and the attempt to do so always ends with the accommodation
01:01:23 of the christian faith to the culture the gradual diminution of the gospel human reasoning itself
01:01:33 needs redemption it needs reconciliation to the truth just as every other aspect of life needs
01:01:42 reconciliation to the truth to learn the truth capital t we must recognize that heretofore we
01:01:52 have lived in untruth and so acknowledge our dependency upon god and his spirit and it's only
01:02:01 here that christ who is the truth becomes for us constitutive of a new paradigm he becomes
01:02:14 constitutive of a new paradigm the christian faith no human perspective is higher that might
01:02:24 be invoked to bring christ and his revelation into judgment let me say that again no human
01:02:34 perspective is higher that might be invoked to bring christ or his revelation into judgment
01:02:42 faith in christ is the archimedean point the difficulty in believing for sinners
01:02:51 is not the reach of their reason it's the hardness of their hearts
01:02:57 that's the fundamental challenge it is difficult to believe because it is difficult to obey
01:03:06 it is difficult to believe because it is difficult to obey and so we have to invite
01:03:14 the unbeliever to take a decisive step pascal talked about this a lot to put on the lens of
01:03:24 christ and the gospel and look again at the world by all means internally critique their worldview
01:03:32 put on their lens and show them where it leads then offer them the lenses of the gospel of jesus
01:03:38 christ and the scriptures and invite them to take a decisive step to take his word and pray for
01:03:47 insight to hang out with christians to go to church and listen to preaching
01:03:55 to take up his word and surrender their illusions and grasp the truth
01:04:04 ultimately we must call them to follow and believe in order that they may understand
01:04:12 i close with the words of the danish philosopher if someone wanted to be his follower
01:04:21 his approach as seen in the gospel was different from lecturing
01:04:24 to such a person he said something like this venture a decisive act then we can begin in
01:04:33 other words follow me what does this mean it means the one does not become a christian by hearing
01:04:39 something about christianity by reading something about it by thinking about it no a setting
01:04:46 is required venture a decisive act the proof does not proceed but follows is in and with
01:04:58 the imitation that follows Christ.
01:05:03 Amen.