The NXR Podcast - June 07, 2024


THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Angels | Classifications, Physicality, & Sexes

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Pushing Back the Curse: Neuralink, Epidurals, and TRT THE SERMON - Living in a Time of Judgment | Lamentations 2

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 10 minutes

Words per minute

189.3

Word count

13,325

Sentence count

1,017

Harmful content

Misogyny

19

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

69

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we talk about angels and how we can better understand them. We discuss what angels are, what they do, and what they are not. We also discuss the difference between angels and spirits and how to better understand angels.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 After this I looked, and behold, a door standing open in heaven.
00:00:04 And the first voice, which I had heard speaking to me like a trumpet, said,
00:00:08 Come up here, and I will show you what must take place after this.
00:00:12 At once I was in the Spirit, and behold, a throne stood in heaven, with one seated on the throne.
00:00:18 And he who sat there had the appearance of jasper and carnelian.
00:00:23 And around the throne was a rainbow that had the appearance of an emerald.
00:00:27 Around the throne were twenty-four thrones.
00:00:30 And seated on the thrones were twenty-four elders,
00:00:33 clothed in white garments with golden crowns on their heads.
00:00:37 From the throne came flashes of lightning, and rumblings, and peals of thunder.
00:00:42 And before the throne were burning seven torches of fire,
00:00:45 which are the seven spirits of God.
00:00:48 And before the throne there was, as it were, a sea of glass like crystal.
00:00:52 And around the throne, on each side of the throne, are four living creatures,
00:00:55 full of eyes in front and behind.
00:00:57 The first living creature like a lion
00:01:00 The second living creature like an ox
00:01:02 The third living creature with the face of a man
00:01:05 And the fourth living creature like an eagle in flight
00:01:08 And the four living creatures, each of them with six wings
00:01:11 Are full of eyes all around and within
00:01:13 And day and night they never cease to say
00:01:16 Holy, holy, holy is the Lord God Almighty
00:01:19 Who was and is and is to come
00:01:21 Revelation chapter 4 verses 1 through 8
00:01:27 this is the word of the lord thanks be to god thanks i feel like i should have been standing
00:01:34 for the reading of the word of god indeed amen i know i feel disrespectful sitting down much like
00:01:38 john chrysostom said that no one should be allowed to pray seated for respect of the angel that is
00:01:43 standing next obvious real quote the angel sits next to you obvious and not even because of
00:01:47 reverence for god but the angel the angel is right next to you yeah take it up with him
00:01:53 Does he have a verse?
00:01:55 No.
00:01:55 He's Chrysostom.
00:01:56 Did he make it up?
00:01:57 Yes.
00:01:58 Yeah.
00:02:00 We're excited.
00:02:01 I made it up.
00:02:02 Chrysostom made it up.
00:02:03 Yeah.
00:02:03 There you go.
00:02:04 Well, Ben, for this one,
00:02:06 why don't you just get us started with,
00:02:08 all of us, let's do all three of us,
00:02:10 because Brian, we've all been talking about it.
00:02:12 We've all got a lot of ideas,
00:02:13 but let's line it out in question form.
00:02:16 What are some of the main,
00:02:18 if we could boil it down to like top five questions
00:02:21 that we want to answer about properly understanding angels?
00:02:26 What are those questions?
00:02:27 I would ask questions like,
00:02:29 are there different classes of angel?
00:02:32 Great question.
00:02:32 It's a big one.
00:02:33 Also an easy one.
00:02:34 Are all angels the same or are there different classes?
00:02:36 Right, because people tend to think
00:02:37 when they hear the word angel,
00:02:38 angel means something specific too.
00:02:40 Angel means messenger.
00:02:42 Right.
00:02:42 And we see particular types of angel in the Bible
00:02:45 that appear as humans.
00:02:47 Two of them are named at least,
00:02:48 you know, are debatably another,
00:02:49 but are named and they bring messages from God, Gabriel and Michael.
00:02:54 I would also add, do the saints have guardian angels?
00:02:58 I think that's one that I'm personally fascinated with.
00:03:00 Yep.
00:03:01 Okay, so great question.
00:03:03 So that's two right there.
00:03:04 Are there different classifications of angels?
00:03:06 Do individual saints, Christians, have guardian angels?
00:03:10 Ben?
00:03:11 The two biggest questions for me, and these are kind of related,
00:03:14 is how do we understand John saying
00:03:18 that he was in Revelation 4,
00:03:20 that he was in the spirit
00:03:21 and in the spirit,
00:03:23 he saw in heaven thrones
00:03:25 with being seated upon them
00:03:27 with crowns on their head.
00:03:29 This is a spiritual thing.
00:03:31 And yet these are,
00:03:32 this very physical language.
00:03:34 This is very like brick and mortar space,
00:03:37 something you can see, touch, feel, smell.
00:03:40 So how should we understand the language
00:03:42 that's being used here?
00:03:43 That's sort of the second part of the question.
00:03:45 Is it analogical?
00:03:46 Is it purely metaphorical?
00:03:48 Is it univocal or equivocal?
00:03:50 What kind of conclusions are we actually able to draw
00:03:53 about the angelic dwelling place
00:03:56 and the heavenly dwelling place from texts like this?
00:03:59 What does it mean that an angel is spiritual?
00:04:02 Does it mean that that vision is of something else
00:04:06 or something projected
00:04:07 or something not really truly its essence?
00:04:08 Or does it mean that he was actually seeing
00:04:12 the real thing.
00:04:13 That is what that thing is.
00:04:14 Right.
00:04:15 What it looks like
00:04:16 but in a different plane.
00:04:17 And that it's still spiritual
00:04:18 but not exclusive,
00:04:19 not only,
00:04:20 merely spiritual.
00:04:21 Yeah.
00:04:21 But it's like us.
00:04:23 We are a spirit,
00:04:24 you know,
00:04:25 a soul body composite,
00:04:27 right?
00:04:27 There's both elements there.
00:04:29 And then angels,
00:04:29 perhaps there's an emphasis.
00:04:31 There may be more spiritual
00:04:32 but still a physical component.
00:04:35 Or maybe in a different realm,
00:04:38 in the heavenly realm,
00:04:40 maybe to be spiritual
00:04:42 doesn't mean precisely what we often conceptualize in our mind.
00:04:45 Maybe 1 Corinthians 15,
00:04:47 there are heavenly bodies and there are earthly bodies.
00:04:48 To me, that's like the biggest question
00:04:50 that I'm almost certain we won't actually answer,
00:04:54 but we'll give it our best shot.
00:04:56 Yep, we've got some thoughts.
00:04:57 We'll kick it around.
00:04:57 And then last question, here would be my question.
00:05:00 So that was two questions.
00:05:02 Yeah, it was kind of a two-parter, but...
00:05:04 Yeah, well, like what kind of language,
00:05:05 how much can we draw from that?
00:05:06 Is a language strictly under the banner of analogical,
00:05:10 typological symbolic language or is can we read some of this literally yeah um and then that that
00:05:17 was a question as per the your hermeneutics how to read the angel passages in the bible but then
00:05:22 the question you're deriving from that is how how physical slash how spiritual are angels yeah yeah
00:05:28 your question again are there different classes of angels and then are there guardian angels among
00:05:32 one you know as one of the classes and then my question in a typical chauvinistic uh style
00:05:40 Are there any female angels or are they all male?
00:05:45 Yeah.
00:05:45 I think we should start with,
00:05:47 first let's start with classifications
00:05:48 and then go to how much of this is literal physical.
00:05:52 Yeah.
00:05:53 That makes sense.
00:05:54 Because if you just start with literal physical,
00:05:57 part of the difficulty is there are some,
00:05:59 for lack of a better word,
00:06:00 there are some unhinged angel texts in scripture.
00:06:04 Ezekiel, we're talking about wheels.
00:06:06 Yeah, wheels within wheels with eyes all over.
00:06:08 With eyes all over.
00:06:09 And then, you know, Revelation chapter four,
00:06:11 you've got the four living creatures
00:06:13 covered in eyes with six wings.
00:06:15 They cover their face, they cover their feet
00:06:16 and two wings, they're flying.
00:06:18 24 elders seated on 24 thrones with golden crowns,
00:06:22 cherubim, seraphim.
00:06:22 And the seven spirits of God
00:06:24 that are fire before the throne.
00:06:25 Right, and it says,
00:06:27 and in them are the seven spirits of God,
00:06:30 which I mean, right there, I'm like, okay.
00:06:32 That already is bizarre.
00:06:33 Which is super bizarre.
00:06:34 Honestly, I'm like, is that soul shattering?
00:06:36 Is that like Harry Potter straight up Voldemort style?
00:06:39 I have an idea of that whole passage
00:06:40 that I'm just going to like shamelessly throw in
00:06:43 eventually whenever we get there.
00:06:45 Yeah, wow.
00:06:45 And that I think answers all of it.
00:06:47 We even...
00:06:48 Okay, well, maybe you lead with that.
00:06:50 We even have passages,
00:06:51 this is probably bringing in another category altogether,
00:06:55 but I think it fits in the classes
00:06:56 because you have to answer this,
00:06:57 is the angel of the Lord.
00:06:59 Right, yeah.
00:06:59 And passages like in Exodus,
00:07:01 where in the burning bush,
00:07:03 the angel of the Lord is speaking.
00:07:05 I mean, he's appeared in the midst of the fire.
00:07:07 So real quick, let's define, yeah.
00:07:10 So let's define a couple of terms.
00:07:11 What's a theophany?
00:07:13 A theophany is an appearance of God in bodily form.
00:07:16 Right, but it doesn't mean that God himself
00:07:18 in an ontological sense that God in his essence is flesh,
00:07:22 but it means that God is taking upon himself,
00:07:25 not even flesh, but a physical, visible manifestation form.
00:07:30 So like we would say it was a theophany
00:07:33 or maybe even more particularly in my opinion,
00:07:35 a Christophany of God walking with Adam and Eve
00:07:39 in the garden in the cool of the day.
00:07:41 But Jesus was walking with them.
00:07:42 The reason why we say it a Christophany
00:07:44 is because this was not Jesus, God in the flesh,
00:07:47 because this predates the incarnation.
00:07:50 He had not yet taken on flesh.
00:07:51 It would be to limit or reduce the incarnation,
00:07:54 what happened there.
00:07:55 Right, the incarnation.
00:07:56 Exactly, it would say the incarnation is,
00:07:57 you know, he was already doing this.
00:07:59 He could have just, you know, showed up again.
00:08:01 We can't do that because the incarnation
00:08:02 is the strangest thing that's ever happened
00:08:04 The history of the world.
00:08:05 It's incredible that God became man.
00:08:06 Yes.
00:08:07 Yeah, incredible.
00:08:08 But God appeared as man.
00:08:10 So another one, Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego.
00:08:12 Yeah, in the midst of the fire.
00:08:13 There was a fourth one who looked
00:08:15 as though he was one of the gods.
00:08:17 Yeah.
00:08:17 You know, a son of the gods.
00:08:20 Sounds like, you know, 0.96
00:08:21 Abraham hosted Yahweh for dinner
00:08:23 with two other angels with him.
00:08:25 So there are two angels.
00:08:27 And in that case, in terms of classifications,
00:08:28 we would say these are messenger angels.
00:08:30 And angel just means messenger.
00:08:31 So these are like Gabriel type angels, right?
00:08:33 but there's two of them are that is what I'm saying.
00:08:37 But there's a third that is the angel of the Lord.
00:08:40 So accompanied by two messenger type angels,
00:08:42 but one is the angel of the Lord
00:08:44 that we would say again is a Christophany.
00:08:46 Jacob wrestles with the angel of the Lord.
00:08:48 And that's a Christophany.
00:08:50 I have wrestled with God.
00:08:52 Right, it's not Gabriel, it's not Michael.
00:08:53 Right, and then Joshua dressed for battle,
00:08:58 but it says the angel of the Lord.
00:08:59 Are you for us or against us?
00:09:01 No.
00:09:01 You know, no.
00:09:02 Well, you know what?
00:09:04 Man, I preached through Joshua recently
00:09:06 and digging into the text,
00:09:08 there's a really good case to be made
00:09:10 where instead of no meaning neither,
00:09:14 he says, are you for us or for our enemies?
00:09:17 And it's like two separate questions.
00:09:19 Are you for us?
00:09:20 And there's not an answer.
00:09:21 Are you for our enemies?
00:09:23 No.
00:09:24 Because he doesn't actually say neither.
00:09:25 He's clearly for them.
00:09:26 He's for them.
00:09:26 Yeah, by the end of it.
00:09:27 No.
00:09:28 Like, how dare you even ask? 1.00
00:09:30 Yeah, of course I'm not for your godless pagan. 1.00
00:09:32 enemies. I'm about to wipe those people up. In the angel discussion, though the angel of the 1.00
00:09:39 Lord is a messenger in the sense that it is bringing the revelation of God somehow, the
00:09:44 message of God, we clearly make a distinction that we're not saying that God himself is in
00:09:51 the same category of being as other beings that are called angels. This is a word you can use
00:09:57 generally, to refer as well to human messengers, pastors and other human messengers. In fact,
00:10:02 a lot of people think that in Revelation 1, when Christ is holding the seven stars for the seven
00:10:08 churches that are the seven angels, that he's actually referring to the pastors of those
00:10:12 churches. Because the angels are the pastors. The lampstands are the churches. Yes, exactly.
00:10:18 The seven ministers is another translation. And he's holding them in his hand. And I see it as
00:10:23 it's also, you know, because John is caught up
00:10:25 in the same chapter, in the very beginning,
00:10:27 he's caught up on the Lord's day.
00:10:28 So it's the day that Christ rose from the dead.
00:10:30 Christ, who is Lord of the Sabbath, 0.68
00:10:32 he never uses his authority,
00:10:35 his lordship of the Sabbath to remove the Sabbath,
00:10:37 but he strictly reminds those who'd abused the Sabbath,
00:10:41 namely the religious rulers of the day,
00:10:43 that God didn't make man to observe his Sabbath,
00:10:46 but he made Sabbath to serve man,
00:10:48 that man needed a rest.
00:10:50 God didn't need to rest on the seventh day,
00:10:52 but he rested to set an example
00:10:53 for his finite creatures who would need to rest.
00:10:56 And then Jesus doesn't eradicate the Sabbath,
00:10:58 but simply reminds us as Lord of the Sabbath
00:11:00 that the Sabbath is a gift to us.
00:11:03 And then he renews, not removes,
00:11:05 but renews the Sabbath from the last day of the week
00:11:06 to the first by virtue of his resurrection,
00:11:09 then twice more by appearing to the disciples
00:11:11 in both instances on the Lord's day.
00:11:14 So multiple cases to be said for that
00:11:16 and not just, oh, it was the Catholic church.
00:11:18 I mean, you know, like the Christian Sabbath
00:11:20 is very much the first day of the week.
00:11:22 And then the apostle John, back to Revelation,
00:11:24 is caught up in the spirit on the Lord's day,
00:11:27 which is the Christian Sabbath
00:11:29 that the New Testament church already
00:11:30 with the first century church was meeting.
00:11:33 They were meeting, sure, every single day,
00:11:35 daily, devoting themselves to the apostles' teaching,
00:11:38 the breaking of bread,
00:11:39 which I don't think is the Lord's supper.
00:11:40 I think it's a daily potluck meal and theology and prayer.
00:11:44 But then on the first day of the week,
00:11:47 that is, I think, the whole church,
00:11:49 not just small groups and organic discipleship
00:11:51 and fellowship and communion,
00:11:53 but that's the church actually gathering
00:11:56 in an ecclesia, formal sense
00:11:58 for the ordinary means of worship church.
00:12:01 That's the Lord's day.
00:12:02 That's already been being done in the first century.
00:12:05 It's unique to the other daily meetings
00:12:07 throughout the week.
00:12:08 That one's unique.
00:12:09 And on that day, John's caught up.
00:12:11 And so I think he's seen church.
00:12:13 He's seen heaven,
00:12:14 but he's also seen church from heaven's perspective.
00:12:18 What church, we see church on earth,
00:12:20 but he gets to see church in heaven.
00:12:22 So the lampstand is the church, but it's lit.
00:12:24 And I think it's because the church is gathered
00:12:26 and it's the Lord's day,
00:12:28 the day that they're supposed to be gathered.
00:12:30 And when the lampstand that is the church is lit,
00:12:32 AKA gathered on the Lord's day, the Christian Sabbath, 0.84
00:12:35 Christ isn't walking in their midst
00:12:38 and holding the minister, the pastor,
00:12:40 and the sword, the minister speaks the word of God,
00:12:43 but the sword actually begins to protrude
00:12:46 not from the minister's mouth,
00:12:47 but from Christ's mouth and cuts the hearts of man.
00:12:50 And so we come, we gather
00:12:51 because man shall not live by bread alone,
00:12:53 but every word that proceeds from the mouth of God,
00:12:55 Christ is God.
00:12:56 And a word proceeds not only from the minister's mouth,
00:12:58 but from his.
00:12:59 And apart from that, you can't do anything.
00:13:01 So if you're listening to this, you like YouTube,
00:13:03 you claim to be a Christian,
00:13:04 but you don't go to church, stop it. 1.00
00:13:06 Stop.
00:13:07 Stop it, guys. 0.99
00:13:07 Go to church. 0.69
00:13:08 The devil will get you.
00:13:09 So I'm gonna take a stab at answering the first question.
00:13:11 Yeah, let's talk about,
00:13:12 we've made a distinction now.
00:13:13 The angel of the Lord is a Christophany or theophany,
00:13:17 different category.
00:13:17 We have angelic messengers,
00:13:19 but what kind of classification
00:13:20 are we seeing in scripture for angels?
00:13:22 So the first thing that we have to understand
00:13:24 is that when we use the term angel,
00:13:26 we're using a catch-all term
00:13:28 to describe many different beings.
00:13:30 Yes.
00:13:30 So an angel is a rank of the angels.
00:13:34 An angel is actually the lowest rank.
00:13:37 That doesn't take away from their nobility,
00:13:39 that just in the rank of order,
00:13:41 they are the lowest ones
00:13:42 because they are the most concerned
00:13:44 with the affairs of man directly.
00:13:45 They are most like unto man.
00:13:47 They're most concerned with what's happening to man.
00:13:50 They are the messengers.
00:13:51 They herald God's decree to man.
00:13:54 Gabriel does this to Mary, et cetera.
00:13:56 The angel Gabriel also goes to Daniel, et cetera.
00:14:00 And they're ministering spirits.
00:14:01 And they're ministering spirits, yes.
00:14:02 But when it says all angels,
00:14:03 that doesn't necessarily mean the wheel guys.
00:14:05 Right.
00:14:05 And it doesn't necessarily mean the four living creature guys.
00:14:07 It could, maybe, but we don't know.
00:14:09 It could, and some other,
00:14:11 But certainly the angels, as it pertains to messengers, man-facing angels, are not all
00:14:17 them ministering spirits to serve the children of Abraham who are to inherit salvation.
00:14:22 But then we would say the larger context of the word angel is the spiritual servants of
00:14:28 God that are serving him in different ways, but in the spiritual plane.
00:14:34 And so these would include things like the seraphim, which are the highest of the order
00:14:37 of angels.
00:14:38 and I believe they are the spirits of fire before God
00:14:43 that contain the seven spirits of God.
00:14:44 But we know that they are fiery spirits
00:14:47 that guard God's holiness.
00:14:50 They are guardians of God's holiness.
00:14:51 And we have the cherubim.
00:14:53 The cherubim are guardians of God's throne.
00:14:55 They're also just guardians in general.
00:14:57 They guard everything.
00:14:58 They guarded the garden of Eden
00:14:59 before the flood wiped it away. 0.99
00:15:01 And so the cherubim are the living creatures.
00:15:03 They're the ones who in Ezekiel,
00:15:05 all of them have four faces,
00:15:07 the lion, the ox, the man, and the eagle.
00:15:10 In Revelation 4, each one has a different face.
00:15:14 One of them is the lion, one is the ox,
00:15:16 one is the man, one is the eagle in flight.
00:15:17 They're all covered with wings.
00:15:19 Also, it's interesting, in Ezekiel,
00:15:21 they only have four wings,
00:15:23 but in Revelation 4, they have six wings.
00:15:26 So that's fascinating in itself.
00:15:27 And they're covered with eyes, which is terrifying.
00:15:29 It's like you get a two-door sedan
00:15:30 and you get a four-door sedan.
00:15:31 Double it and give it to the next.
00:15:32 There's multiple different types of these beings.
00:15:36 But that's the cherubim. 0.96
00:15:36 But that would be like subclasses
00:15:38 within overarching class being cherubim. 0.75
00:15:40 Right, so they're guarding the throne of God. 0.97
00:15:42 And then you have the ophanim,
00:15:44 which are a little bit more of a subtextual category,
00:15:48 but they would be the wheels within wheels
00:15:49 that are next to the cherubim
00:15:52 and together are the living creatures with the cherubim.
00:15:55 And they are the throne of God.
00:15:57 They bring that, they proceed from the throne of God.
00:16:00 Some people believe that this is what Moses
00:16:02 was encountering in the burning bush,
00:16:04 but that's kind of iffy.
00:16:05 And then you have powers and principalities and dominions and authorities, which are more concerned
00:16:12 with the realm of men, but really concerned with ensuring God's decree is carried out in the realm
00:16:17 of men. And then you have angels and archangels. Angels are the messengers that we've already
00:16:21 discussed. They're ministering spirits. And then the archangels seem to be some special category.
00:16:26 We only see the word appear in reference to the cry of an archangel in scripture.
00:16:31 And specifically Michael.
00:16:33 At least that's what we think.
00:16:34 Yeah, yeah.
00:16:35 Even that is a supposition.
00:16:37 Right, but they seem to be a special category of angel
00:16:41 that is a warrior, the head of God's armies.
00:16:45 It's not Christ.
00:16:46 Michael is not Christ.
00:16:47 No way.
00:16:48 But he is the head of Christ's armies,
00:16:50 which is very fascinating,
00:16:52 assuming it's Michael, but the archangel.
00:16:53 Right, yeah.
00:16:54 And so those are kind of all the different categories.
00:16:56 So in my mind,
00:16:57 well, then we also have the watchers thrown in there.
00:16:59 Yeah.
00:16:59 From Daniel 4, we know that there's a category of heavenly being
00:17:03 that's a servant of God called the Watcher.
00:17:05 And we don't know if they might be another name
00:17:07 for one of these other existing types of angels.
00:17:10 It could be another name for, my guess is another name for messengers,
00:17:15 just angels, angels.
00:17:16 Or it could be, probably I lean stronger towards this,
00:17:20 if messenger, angel, angel, angel, angel, messengers,
00:17:24 so there's your, you know, Gabriel.
00:17:26 If that's a very large class and the Watchers was like,
00:17:29 like, uh, the, the highest, it's a rank, you know, like a rank with, but within that class
00:17:34 within an army, everybody is a person, right. But a general is not a captain. It's not a
00:17:39 lieutenant. It's not an intelligence officer. It's not a combat engineer. And so within the
00:17:43 thrones, dominions, rulers, authorities, overseeing thrones, bringing messages to men
00:17:47 for all we know, that might be the same type of thing that actually has a different role
00:17:54 or a different rank. Yeah. It could be like, they're all generals. So they're all in that
00:17:58 class, but there's two-star generals. Yeah, there's lots of variations. Are you a beef jerky
00:18:02 enthusiast? Well, then stop it. Seriously, stop it. Because biltong is superior to beef jerky in
00:18:11 every single way. It's a traditional South African meat snack, but it's free from all the preservatives,
00:18:17 the sugar, and the soy. It's like the Wagyu of jerky. Now, here's the exciting news from
00:18:23 Farmer Bill's Provisions. Farmer Bill's is introducing their brand new product line for
00:18:28 your enjoyment. We've got right here the traditional beef slab. You've also got, if you want a smaller
00:18:35 portion, you've got the slices. It's just as much meat, but you're able to eat it in increments.
00:18:40 This is for yourself as an individual or maybe for you and your family, your kids. Then you've
00:18:44 got the meat sticks. This is what, if you're a working man, you want a snack to keep in your
00:18:49 pocket to eat before lunch or something like that, grab one of their beef sticks and take it on the
00:18:55 go. Lastly, you got to check out the tallow. For all the moms out there, my wife, she swears by
00:19:01 this. Many women in our church say that it's a fantastic product. So don't waste any more time.
00:19:07 Go to FarmerBillsProvisions.com today to support a Christian-owned small business. And while you're
00:19:14 at it, go ahead and subscribe so that you can save on multiple options and ensure that you and your
00:19:20 family will never be without your favorites. And the last thing is this, if you want to get 15%
00:19:25 off your purchase, all you got to do is type in the promo code, right response. Again, the promo
00:19:32 code type in right response. So visit farmer bills, provisions.com today and get 15% off your
00:19:40 purchase. So I'd like to say two more things just real quick. So in Revelation 4, I think that one
00:19:46 compelling argument would be that the 24 elders are watchers. I think that the fiery spirits are
00:19:51 the seraphim and the cherubim are named. They are the living creatures. The seven spirits? Spirits
00:19:56 of God. Are what? The seraphim. The seraphim. Because they're fire guarding the holiness of God.
00:20:02 Four living creatures are cherubim. The living creatures are the cherubim because they're
00:20:05 guarding the throne. The Ophanim is the throne. And the 24 elders are the watchers. So I don't 1.00
00:20:12 think that's all of the angelic categories. I also think that there could be more. God is not
00:20:19 obligated to tell us. The Bible doesn't tell us this is the exhaustive place. He's not obligated
00:20:24 to tell us that these are all the heavenly beings. We get peeks behind the curtain into the heavenly
00:20:29 realm. We don't get full access. And we know this because Paul says, I was caught up to the
00:20:35 third heaven, whether in body or in vision, I don't know. And I'm not allowed to tell you.
00:20:39 And you're like, thanks, Paul. Yeah. He was supposed to obviously supposed to divinely
00:20:44 inspired. I'm not criticizing the Holy Spirit, but we know for a fact that there are things about
00:20:50 this topic that are a outside of our knowledge and be intentionally. So God didn't, he did not
00:20:59 intend for us to know this all the way to the bottom thing. So that would be my attempt at
00:21:03 answering. Yeah. So the 24 elders, that's interesting. I think you could say that,
00:21:08 but you're saying that more probabilistically than certainty. Oh, I'm not having any certainty
00:21:13 behind it. I'm saying that would help, that would help me personally conceptualize the scene that's
00:21:19 going on. Because we know that the watchers are some category that decrees something that's then
00:21:26 carried out. It would even work, I think, with your idea that, and I do think that's right,
00:21:31 that it's the heavenly church.
00:21:33 I've heard that before.
00:21:34 I think it's really compelling.
00:21:35 It's the liturgy from heaven's perspective.
00:21:36 And so you're actually seeing the watchers
00:21:38 that are overseeing the heavenly liturgy,
00:21:41 ensuring that it's-
00:21:42 I thought you were gonna,
00:21:42 I smiled because I thought
00:21:43 you were gonna make fun of me,
00:21:44 but go ahead.
00:21:44 No, no, no.
00:21:45 I've heard that before
00:21:46 and I think that it's-
00:21:47 Right, and I've heard it before too.
00:21:48 I think it's really compelling.
00:21:49 It's the thing that I'm saying.
00:21:51 I agree with that one.
00:21:52 It's not my original.
00:21:53 Sure, and none of this is like stuff
00:21:54 that we for the first time came up with.
00:21:56 Well, in a few of the episodes
00:21:58 that we've recorded,
00:21:59 there have been a couple-
00:21:59 There have been some firsts.
00:22:00 Originals, yeah.
00:22:01 This is not one of them.
00:22:02 This is not one.
00:22:02 That's true. 0.92
00:22:02 Except for what I'm saying about the Watchers and the 24 elders.
00:22:05 That's Ben's theory.
00:22:06 So the only thing that I would push back on that, Ben,
00:22:08 is just because it just seems like a very God-facing role.
00:22:12 They're taking off their crowns and throwing them down
00:22:14 and singing along with...
00:22:16 This is the throne room.
00:22:18 Whereas I kind of imagine the Watchers
00:22:20 being more higher concern of the affairs of men.
00:22:24 And not because they don't...
00:22:26 Talking about Watchers that didn't fall,
00:22:28 But the good watchers that never rebelled, not because they're not, that they don't, that their allegiance isn't to God above men, because it is to God, but it's actually their role.
00:22:39 They're more turned towards man.
00:22:41 Yeah, their role, they're designed to be.
00:22:43 But the elders, everything in the Revelation 4 description seems like, none of it seems, like messengers don't get listed.
00:22:50 You know what I mean?
00:22:50 Like they don't make the list.
00:22:51 I see watchers, to me, makes more of a sense of relating more to the messengers than cherubim.
00:22:59 I think that's a really good point.
00:23:01 My understanding of the watchers would be more like the messenger is the manager.
00:23:06 Exactly, a messenger manager.
00:23:08 And the watcher is like the COO, CEO type person.
00:23:12 And I think that it would condemn them yet more to look down and condescend to that far.
00:23:19 but also the number 24 like it's very clearly intentional so the idea that like i don't like
00:23:27 the idea that by happenstance when none of it's happened to god's sovereign over all things
00:23:30 including even you know a fall of angels but but i but then it's like that seems like a number like
00:23:36 god's it was very precise he started with it he still has 24 of these guys eight of them fall
00:23:41 right no yeah it's not like well we had once upon a time we had 36 i don't even necessarily think
00:23:46 that that's all the watchers.
00:23:47 Oh, okay.
00:23:48 I think that that's 24 elders of the watchers.
00:23:51 Oh, I see, I see, I see, I see.
00:23:53 Okay.
00:23:53 Now, I would have to reconsult my notes,
00:23:56 but I'm trying to remember
00:23:57 what some of the traditional views
00:23:59 of that passage would be.
00:24:00 Apostles and tribes?
00:24:02 Yeah.
00:24:02 Leaders, patriarchs and apostles?
00:24:04 Yeah, patriarchs and apostles are what I've heard.
00:24:06 Uh-huh.
00:24:07 Because it's 12 and 12.
00:24:08 But who are the apostles?
00:24:10 Would Paul be in there
00:24:10 or would Matthias be in there?
00:24:12 Oh, yeah.
00:24:13 um uh the the classic traditional joke that everyone always says is that they're half
00:24:20 cheeking it yeah paul and uh yeah yeah sure they're sharing a seat who's in whose lap but
00:24:26 then i've also heard others you know say that like that the the 12th seat is um well never mind
00:24:33 never mind i'm not even going to share that one guys basically long story short i'm presenting
00:24:37 that as a brand new idea like brand spanking new yeah that would help me understand the
00:24:43 passage for what I believe it to be, which is a purely heavenly scene. A big point I think to
00:24:48 make, we've already made it, but just a big point to remember is that in a lot of these things,
00:24:52 I think in particularly here with the angels, there are things we know, and then there are
00:24:56 things that we can composite and compile together based on the data. But because the scripture's
00:25:01 main focus isn't here, there's going to be, you have like two different instincts that are always
00:25:07 kind of warring in the church.
00:25:08 You have the hyper-biblicist minimalism. 1.00
00:25:12 Right.
00:25:12 It's like, if it's not directly said
00:25:14 about them in scripture.
00:25:15 Chapter and verse.
00:25:16 Do not say it.
00:25:16 And then you give them one,
00:25:17 they're like, New Testament, please.
00:25:18 Yeah, yeah.
00:25:19 They don't like half the Bible.
00:25:20 And then even then on that view.
00:25:22 I won't take a shower
00:25:22 unless you can show me in the red letters.
00:25:24 What's funny is that people
00:25:25 that tend towards that
00:25:26 also tend to think of the angels
00:25:28 as a monolith generally.
00:25:30 It's just like, there's the angels, right?
00:25:31 And some of them are fallen and whatnot.
00:25:33 Don't tell me there's Nephilim spirits, whatever. 0.99
00:25:35 On the other side,
00:25:36 you have like the medieval and these conceptions with multiple ranks and nine ranks and there's
00:25:41 and they went all the way out not only with angels but with their demonology right yeah and they had
00:25:46 developed an elaborate and some of it was almost a bit of a reach empiric where they were in they
00:25:52 were they were like trying to in their fight against the demons they're like well there's
00:25:56 this demon and so i'm not even right now saying which one i think is right i'm just saying those
00:26:00 Those are kind of the polar ends.
00:26:02 The polar ends of the spectrum.
00:26:03 And both in there.
00:26:04 Yeah, Pseudo-Dionysus.
00:26:05 In his celestial hierarchy, he makes up.
00:26:08 He just makes it up.
00:26:09 Two angelic ranks to make it the number nine.
00:26:11 Yeah.
00:26:11 And he makes up the virtues in the potestas,
00:26:15 which are the ones that exercise power
00:26:18 over the other angels underneath them.
00:26:20 Yeah.
00:26:21 And then the virtues,
00:26:22 which counteract the vice of the demons.
00:26:24 That's the right.
00:26:25 And we're excited.
00:26:26 He made it up.
00:26:27 Some like apocryphal sources,
00:26:29 but pretty much he just...
00:26:30 But a lot of it had to do with...
00:26:32 To his credit, the rest of it's really good.
00:26:33 With things like balance and the beauty of numbers
00:26:37 and things like that.
00:26:38 They were, they had...
00:26:40 The triad of triads.
00:26:40 You certainly can't say that they didn't ask the why behind things.
00:26:44 Like why would there be this number of angels and this type?
00:26:47 In fact, they would be accused of not being content
00:26:49 with not knowing the why.
00:26:50 Yeah.
00:26:51 However, we do...
00:26:52 That said, we know a lot about this class of spiritual beings.
00:26:57 One thing we haven't talked about though, guys,
00:26:59 is a divine council.
00:27:01 Yeah.
00:27:01 Right.
00:27:02 Because that is a conversation that it's controversial.
00:27:05 Sure.
00:27:06 But it also, it definitely has implication.
00:27:09 It does.
00:27:09 For how you view a lot of scripture.
00:27:11 So I don't know if you guys want to jump in on that at all.
00:27:14 Well, I feel like that might have to be its own thing.
00:27:17 But in terms of like...
00:27:18 Maybe we just reference it and say this is also...
00:27:20 Whether it's Trinitarian language,
00:27:22 we're aware of the divine council.
00:27:23 Whether it's Trinitarian language or in our image
00:27:26 is a divine council of lower G, you know.
00:27:28 The basic idea of the divine council is that
00:27:30 there is a group of spiritual beings
00:27:35 that are the divine council,
00:27:37 that it is not improper to call them Elohim
00:27:39 because the Bible does.
00:27:40 God's.
00:27:40 Which is God's.
00:27:42 But none of them are God's in this sense.
00:27:46 Yahweh alone can create ex nihilo. 0.98
00:27:50 But it is perfectly permissible to call them God's. 0.98
00:27:53 It's a word that has range that can be used of, 0.98
00:27:56 even kind of, I'll give a crass example,
00:27:58 but this is how language works.
00:28:00 People will look at another person and say,
00:28:01 bro, you're a God.
00:28:03 Yeah.
00:28:03 And they mean that you are elite at this thing.
00:28:06 Right.
00:28:06 And in this sense,
00:28:07 the divine counsel idea is also that part of what is happening
00:28:11 in the ancient Near East,
00:28:14 and then also in scripture,
00:28:15 you know,
00:28:16 controverting it is that again,
00:28:18 from the one people go out all these demonic religions,
00:28:20 the nations are given over Deuteronomy 32 to be governed by
00:28:25 table of nations,
00:28:25 fallen spiritual beings of some sort,
00:28:28 that there are spiritual powers behind thrones
00:28:32 that are misleading the nations
00:28:34 that are actually have held the nations captive to deceit.
00:28:37 And that one of the things that the scriptures are doing
00:28:40 is actually contradicting the idea of the false,
00:28:46 of the pagan religions,
00:28:48 like you see in Mesopotamia and Canaanite religion, 0.68
00:28:50 that these are the real gods 0.52
00:28:52 and that Yahweh is just another one of these.
00:28:54 And it's to show, well, no, there is a divine council of angelic beings
00:28:59 or of spiritual beings that God has set as in Job that he speaks to.
00:29:04 He assembles this council of spiritual beings and he speaks with them. 0.85
00:29:09 And then, but that those false ones are actually liars and deceivers.
00:29:13 And that one thing Christ is doing is he's binding the strong man
00:29:18 so that the nations will no longer be held captive to these beings.
00:29:22 He's supplanting them. 0.90
00:29:24 The Prince of Persia.
00:29:25 Yeah.
00:29:26 So this is a lot of like the Michael Heiser stuff.
00:29:29 And honestly, there's a lot of good stuff.
00:29:31 Michael Heiser is, I mean, he's controversial for some,
00:29:34 but I think there's a lot of-
00:29:36 When he's in his lane, he's pretty good.
00:29:38 It's when he has some really,
00:29:39 what I think is tremendously sloppy theology
00:29:41 when it comes to other areas like sovereignty
00:29:43 and other areas as well.
00:29:46 But there's compelling biblical arguments that he makes
00:29:49 that this, and not just like from ancient Near Eastern texts,
00:29:53 which is an area of his expertise.
00:29:55 There's actually compelling biblical evidence
00:29:57 in Psalm 82, Deuteronomy 32, that there is such thing.
00:30:01 Now, whether or not God,
00:30:03 like you're referencing in Genesis is saying,
00:30:05 let us make man in our image.
00:30:08 That's yet to be.
00:30:09 Classical interpretation of that verse
00:30:10 that God is Trinitarian.
00:30:12 Divine counsel view is that God is speaking
00:30:14 to the divine counsel and that the spiritual beings
00:30:17 that he made are imagers in the heavenly realm
00:30:20 and that men are imagers on the earthly realm
00:30:23 to oversimplify.
00:30:24 So there's also a category then there
00:30:26 that mixes up with how you,
00:30:28 whether you accept that or not as biblically sound
00:30:31 and then where you'd fit the divine counsel in
00:30:34 would be some subset of angelic or spiritual being as well.
00:30:39 Right.
00:30:40 Okay.
00:30:40 So that's classifications.
00:30:41 I feel like we've got,
00:30:42 we're, you know,
00:30:43 so that we don't make this a two hour episode,
00:30:45 So we've got to now talk about, okay, physical-spiritual dichotomy.
00:30:50 A lot of people think of angels.
00:30:51 This is what I'm saying.
00:30:52 They think of angels, messenger angels, like Gabriel, appearing to Mary.
00:30:57 They think of them in the same way that you would think about a theophany, right?
00:31:03 Because God really is, if we're talking about ontologically in terms of God's essence,
00:31:07 he really is a most pure spirit.
00:31:09 This is the confessional position.
00:31:11 A most pure spirit without body, parts, or passions.
00:31:14 meaning the parts, meaning that God is not divisible.
00:31:16 There's not one piece of God
00:31:18 that could be subtracted from the rest of God
00:31:20 and he'd still be God.
00:31:21 And philosophical, if we're doing, you know,
00:31:24 philosophical theology,
00:31:25 God is what we would call a simple being.
00:31:27 And we're not being demeaning in that sense.
00:31:29 God is the most complex, you know,
00:31:31 being in all the universe.
00:31:33 But a simple being, we're complex beings if,
00:31:36 you know, pardon the crude analogy,
00:31:38 but if we amputated your left arm, Ben,
00:31:41 you would still be bent.
00:31:42 You wouldn't lose your core identity.
00:31:44 You'd be bent, missing an arm, but you're still bent.
00:31:46 There's nothing, all that is in God is God.
00:31:49 There's nothing that can be removed from God.
00:31:51 And God is not the sum total of all his parts.
00:31:54 So it's not that, well, God has justice and has peace
00:31:57 and has this and has that.
00:31:58 He's not a composite.
00:31:59 And then, you know, these powers combined,
00:32:01 I'm captain planet.
00:32:02 That's not how God works.
00:32:03 So God is not without parts.
00:32:05 God without passions, impassibility, divine impassibility.
00:32:08 What we're saying is that first and foremost,
00:32:11 in the simplest sense, the divine cannot suffer.
00:32:14 The divine cannot die.
00:32:15 He is immortal.
00:32:17 And partly because the divine cannot change.
00:32:19 Right, right.
00:32:19 Because impassibility is really a subset of immutability.
00:32:23 Yes.
00:32:23 Because change, even change in feelings or emotive states,
00:32:29 God does not emote.
00:32:30 He's not a teenage girl.
00:32:31 And so what we have in biblical language
00:32:34 when speaking of God, and we'll come back to angels,
00:32:36 but when speaking of God is we have,
00:32:38 we should understand biblical language
00:32:40 underneath the banner of the doctrine of analogy
00:32:43 in two primary categories,
00:32:45 one being anthropomorphic.
00:32:47 So his eyes are roaming to and fro.
00:32:49 Well, he doesn't have a body.
00:32:50 He doesn't have eyes.
00:32:51 He doesn't have eyes, right?
00:32:52 His right arm is not short,
00:32:54 is mighty to save.
00:32:55 He doesn't have an arm.
00:32:56 So that's anthropomorphic language,
00:32:59 speaking of God in a physical way,
00:33:01 but with analogy, not literally.
00:33:05 Anthropopathic is speaking of God in an emotional way.
00:33:08 So like the Lord's anger flared up
00:33:10 And it flared up in a moment because he just came into new information
00:33:14 that previously he was unaware.
00:33:15 No, of course not.
00:33:17 He's the omniscient one.
00:33:18 He doesn't flare up.
00:33:19 He's not a petty God.
00:33:21 He's not the Greek gods who just get mad all of a sudden
00:33:24 and demand blood or wrath won't go away.
00:33:28 No, no, no.
00:33:28 God, before the foundation of the world, he did demand blood,
00:33:31 but he put that blood forward himself,
00:33:33 and he knew that he would require it
00:33:35 since before the foundation of the world were even laid.
00:33:38 Propitiation is actually a pagan term
00:33:40 to satiate the wrath of the gods,
00:33:42 but it finds its place in Christian theology
00:33:45 and even in the New Testament scripture.
00:33:47 But the one difference is that in Christian terms,
00:33:50 a propitiation is the sacrifice that God requires,
00:33:53 but that God also supplies.
00:33:55 It's the sacrifice that is God,
00:33:57 the son of God is the sacrifice put forward by God
00:34:00 to satisfy God.
00:34:02 And that's, I mean, this is the pastor moment,
00:34:06 preaching the gospel.
00:34:07 That's the gospel.
00:34:09 The substitutionary atonement 0.94
00:34:11 and that God puts forward the perfect lamb.
00:34:12 Behold, the lamb of God
00:34:13 that takes away the sins of the world.
00:34:15 All that being said,
00:34:16 anthropomorphic, emotional,
00:34:18 I'm sorry, physical, but analogy.
00:34:22 And then anthropopathic, emotional, but analogy.
00:34:25 All that is true of God.
00:34:27 And when we see appearances of God,
00:34:31 it is not him taking on flesh
00:34:34 unless, until we're talking about
00:34:36 the second member of the Trinity,
00:34:37 the God, man, Christ Jesus in the incarnation 2,000 years ago. But everything preceding that,
00:34:42 it's a theophany or Christophany. But I don't think when the Bible talks about angels that
00:34:48 we should apply our classical theism lens in a one-to-one ratio to angels in the way that we do
00:34:55 God. For me, the framework texts that confuse me in this regard are the passages describing
00:35:05 Christ's current state, that he is glorified man and he is at the right hand of God the Father.
00:35:12 In the phrases like that, we have a mixture of literal language and anthropomorphic analogical
00:35:18 language, because we know that Christ literally is seated because he is a glorified man. He has
00:35:25 flesh forever. And yet he's not seated literally at the right hand of God the Father, because God
00:35:31 the father does not have a right hand. Right. So we have a mixture of language and the same thing.
00:35:36 Half of it is purely literal. It's, it's, it's univocal language. The other half is analogical.
00:35:42 Right. When we talk about the angels, it seems to do the same thing. And so I am confused by it.
00:35:50 It called, yeah, they're, they're called spirits and they're also described as
00:35:53 very straightforwardly having these attributes that you can look at. Right. And it seems like
00:35:57 we were talking about this last night when you describe the the the living creatures
00:36:02 or the cherubim is it describing what it actually is right or is it describing some
00:36:09 analogy of what it is that's sensible to us or an analogy that really comes as a physical
00:36:15 description in the plain words of the text but is actually describing uh less of what they are
00:36:20 and more of why they are their role and their function yes so boving does this in in volume
00:36:25 two of his reform dogmatics, he discusses the angels. And he says that the rule of analogical
00:36:33 language also applies to them because they're pure spirit. And it's my understanding that they
00:36:38 take that from when he calls them ministering spirits. But that's the only thing. Pure spirit.
00:36:44 And they're saying angels are pure spirit. And so now- And pure male.
00:36:48 Yeah. But if you go, yes, angels are pure spirit, well, then you have to then say that all of the
00:36:57 language regarding any physicality of them would be analogical with no exceptions. And so he says
00:37:04 that the cherubim being, it's the majesty of the lion. It's the strength of the ox. It's the
00:37:10 swiftness of the eagle to carry out God's decree. And it's the dignity of the man that it matters
00:37:15 that it's doing this.
00:37:16 But all of that is analogical.
00:37:18 It's all true knowledge.
00:37:19 It's genuine takeaways about their nature,
00:37:22 but not about their appearance.
00:37:24 And so on the flip side of that-
00:37:26 Right, what you just said, true knowledge,
00:37:28 people need to understand that analogical language
00:37:30 in the Bible is not lying.
00:37:32 No, it's true.
00:37:33 It's all saying something true.
00:37:34 It's just in what sense is it true?
00:37:36 We're not agnostics.
00:37:37 It's true, genuine knowledge of God.
00:37:39 And so then on the flip side of that,
00:37:40 you have to reckon with,
00:37:43 We've already brought it up in another episode,
00:37:45 but texts like when Samuel's ghost appears
00:37:49 to Saul and the witch of Endor,
00:37:51 they can A, it's pure spirit. 0.52
00:37:53 It's not his body.
00:37:54 Right.
00:37:55 It's not his body coming out
00:37:56 of whatever grave Samuel's body is in.
00:37:58 At that time, it is pure spirit.
00:37:59 Right.
00:37:59 And yet they can A, recognize it as Samuel
00:38:01 and it is not omnipresent.
00:38:03 It's bound to a geography.
00:38:05 So pure spirit without a body.
00:38:06 It can also speak.
00:38:07 It's still a physical locale.
00:38:08 Right.
00:38:09 A spirit that's bound.
00:38:10 And it can speak.
00:38:10 I think that one, I told you guys this last night, I think that the answer is that there
00:38:15 is such thing as a spiritual body or a type that is real. And it would be improper for us to call
00:38:22 it physical, even though we, some of the things that we mean by physical, I think are true of it,
00:38:27 that it's real. And it's not just like a hologram, but that there's genuinely a different category
00:38:33 that we're actually making a category error when we try to reason our physicality into
00:38:38 this type of being. And 1 Corinthians 15 is an interesting passage to me on this, where Paul's
00:38:43 talking about the resurrection. And there are two ways I think you could think about this. One of
00:38:48 them makes sense for what I'm saying, and the other interpretation wouldn't. But he says,
00:38:51 how are the dead raised? 1 Corinthians 15, 35. With what kind of body do they come? You foolish
00:38:57 person. What you sow does not come to life unless it dies. And what you sow is not the body that is 1.00
00:39:02 to be, but a bare kernel, perhaps of weed or of some other grain. But God gives it a body as he
00:39:06 has chosen and to each kind of seed, its own body for not all flesh is the same. So he's saying in
00:39:12 the resurrection, there'll be different types of bodies. Your body will be to your resurrected body
00:39:17 as a tree is to the seed that grew it. So it's related, but it's not identical. He says for not
00:39:23 all flesh is the same. Now he's making a more basic point about the nature of flesh in general
00:39:27 or of bodies in general for not all flesh is the same, but there is one kind for humans and other
00:39:32 for animals, another for birds, and another for fish. There are heavenly bodies and earthly bodies,
00:39:37 but the glory of the heavenly is of one kind, and the glory of the earthly is of another.
00:39:41 Then he's, you know, the glory of the sun. So two ways you can think about that. Either Paul,
00:39:46 when he says heavenly bodies and earthly bodies, is talking about celestial bodies,
00:39:49 like the stars. That's one way you could think about that, that he's just talking, he's now
00:39:55 explaining it further when he says the glory of the sun, the moon, and the stars. Another one would
00:39:58 be to say that Paul is talking about the particular type of state of being that God gives to things
00:40:05 like heavenly beings, like angelic beings, which I think is at least possible. Which are, of course,
00:40:11 just stars. Yeah. And then if you go one step further and you understand that even in your
00:40:17 world, that is not what stars are, only what they're made of. But in that sense, then I think
00:40:23 that we're talking about a class of being that is not, it is spiritual, but that doesn't mean
00:40:30 that it's everything we often think of when we think of spiritual in this sense.
00:40:37 Right Response Ministries 2025 conference is a go. This is three days, full jam-packed conference
00:40:45 with eight main sessions, three to four hour and a half long panels, and an all-star super-based
00:40:52 lineup of speakers, 15 speakers in all. Who are they? Steve Dace, Jeff Durbin, Orne McIntyre,
00:40:59 Stephen Wolf, Brian Sauve, Andrew Isker, John Harris, Eric Kahn, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder,
00:41:06 the Christian Prince himself, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, Zachary Garris, David Reese, and yours
00:41:13 truly, Pastor Joel Webin. Again, this is April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, 2025, and the early registration
00:41:20 is open right now this is the longest conference with the most speakers we've ever offered and yet
00:41:27 it is our all-time lowest price the early registration available today is only 140 bucks
00:41:34 for an adult so go to right response conference.com again that is right response conference.com
00:41:42 to register right now because the early registration will not last long
00:41:47 Yeah, because we think of spiritual as living outside of any physical plane
00:41:52 in an ethereal, strictly, you know, 17th dimension type thing
00:41:55 that has no visible kind of, but that's...
00:42:00 It's like a thought.
00:42:01 Right, it's like a thought.
00:42:02 We think of spirit as like this thing that is totally intangible.
00:42:07 And what I'm saying is that I don't think the biblical evidence backs up
00:42:10 that that is what, when we're talking about created spiritual beings,
00:42:14 Again, to make the distinction,
00:42:16 there is this absolute gulf of being
00:42:18 between the creator and the creature.
00:42:21 You cannot reason from one to the other.
00:42:23 There is no analogy.
00:42:24 And those who worship him must worship in spirit and in truth.
00:42:27 And in terms of God in his essence, which is spirit,
00:42:31 we're not really going there.
00:42:33 We're not touching that.
00:42:34 We're talking about angels.
00:42:36 And what does it mean for them to be spirit?
00:42:37 He alone has a seity.
00:42:39 He's self-existent.
00:42:39 He's not created.
00:42:40 But God did create heavenly bodies.
00:42:43 Okay.
00:42:43 So, and I'm not, just to be clear right now,
00:42:46 because it's kind of in the zeitgeist,
00:42:47 I'm also not talking about like a spiritual resurrection,
00:42:50 full preterism type of stuff.
00:42:51 You get resurrected and you get a physical glorified body.
00:42:55 But I'm saying that I think we can argue.
00:42:59 Right now we're still awaiting the resurrection.
00:43:01 And so both for the damned and for those who are righteous,
00:43:05 there's a spiritual existence,
00:43:07 but still has some kind of substance to it.
00:43:11 In a sense that Samuel, like you said,
00:43:13 He could talk.
00:43:13 He could be recognized, which is huge.
00:43:17 And even the woman, I mean, the witch of Endor,
00:43:19 you can tell she's shocked.
00:43:20 It's like, you know, she had this familiar spirit
00:43:23 that she was using that would take on the form
00:43:25 and pretend to be whoever the dead, you know, 0.99
00:43:28 and she's ripping people off.
00:43:29 Like, oh, you want to talk to your mom?
00:43:30 You miss her so much.
00:43:31 Let me go.
00:43:32 Congratulations, it's the devil.
00:43:33 But at least back then, you know, the witches of Endor, 1.00
00:43:37 the mediums, at least they put forth an effort.
00:43:39 At least they had a spirit that, you know,
00:43:41 and whereas a lot of people today,
00:43:42 is like, well, just, there's not even,
00:43:45 they haven't even taken the time
00:43:46 to get a familiar spirit.
00:43:47 But that does happen today.
00:43:49 It reminds me of what we were talking about with Egypt
00:43:52 in that the gods of Egypt,
00:43:55 their witchcraft stopped working at some point.
00:43:57 That there is times in places
00:44:00 that are yet under darkness 0.87
00:44:02 or I think can return to darkness through apostasy
00:44:04 and corruption and grievous sin.
00:44:06 Actually, the judgment's more severe.
00:44:08 Where the magic starts working again.
00:44:09 This is what I'm concerned about.
00:44:11 We're going to talk about this in another episode.
00:44:12 with DMT and some of these spiritual pathways
00:44:15 opening through pharmakeia and degeneracy,
00:44:18 where some of those old doors
00:44:20 that are genuinely closed when a people turn to Christ,
00:44:23 you find genuine protection
00:44:24 because Paul says that we have power
00:44:27 to tear down every stronghold
00:44:29 and lofty opinion raised against the knowledge of God.
00:44:31 Second Corinthians 10, three to five.
00:44:34 So-
00:44:34 And I think there's a corporate national application.
00:44:36 I believe that 100% that this is true of peoples.
00:44:40 I think it's true of individuals.
00:44:41 I think it's true of families.
00:44:42 I think it's true of schools.
00:44:44 I think it can be true of business entities.
00:44:45 I think it can be true of nations.
00:44:47 And even empires of nations.
00:44:50 But the problem is that when Jesus comes
00:44:53 and casts the demons out and it's filled,
00:44:57 the house is swept clean and put in order
00:44:59 and then filled with devotion to Christ
00:45:01 and the altar is erected to the true and living triune God.
00:45:04 But then the people become unfaithful and turn from God
00:45:08 and the house is now empty of the spirit.
00:45:10 then what happens is those demons, they don't disappear.
00:45:14 They went somewhere.
00:45:15 They're still around.
00:45:16 And then they come back with seven other demons worse than themselves.
00:45:20 And what Jesus talks about at an individual level,
00:45:23 I think that there is a corporate application for nations.
00:45:27 The West, because honestly, you know, G.K. Chesterton talks about this. 0.51
00:45:31 Like paganism is a hop and a skip away from Christianity.
00:45:34 Yeah, right.
00:45:34 And understand what I'm saying there in the sense that like paganism understands,
00:45:38 paganism gets supernatural.
00:45:40 they get spiritual, they get sacrifice, they get blood,
00:45:43 they get all these kinds of things.
00:45:45 It's only secular humanists.
00:45:46 It's only materialists that are all so sophisticated. 0.99
00:45:50 I feel like Jesus would look at Mr. Pagan Man and say, 1.00
00:45:54 I tell you the truth, you are not far from the kingdom. 1.00
00:45:57 Whereas he would look at your Western modern and say,
00:46:02 goodness gracious, you're the bottom of this arrow.
00:46:04 This is why you can read a book like Till We Have Faces by C.S. Lewis,
00:46:07 set in a pre-Christian pagan society,
00:46:10 And walk away from the book thinking,
00:46:12 wow, what a great book expositing Christian virtue.
00:46:15 And then you can read the Ransom Trilogy
00:46:18 and That Hideous Strength, also written by C.S. Lewis,
00:46:21 about a pagan society, post-Christian, 0.98
00:46:23 and think those people are damned to hell. 0.97
00:46:26 And there is no virtue in them whatsoever. 0.99
00:46:28 It's like what happened in Canaan. 0.59
00:46:30 Canaan, Joshua, who is Yeshua,
00:46:32 I mean, he's like a Christ figure.
00:46:34 And the people of God drive out the giants
00:46:36 and they drive out the pagans
00:46:37 and they don't do it perfectly,
00:46:39 but they do genuinely drive out Baal. 0.84
00:46:41 He's put to flight and Molech 1.00
00:46:44 and these human sacrificial cults. 1.00
00:46:46 Well, then what happens?
00:46:47 By the time Christ comes, 0.97
00:46:49 Israel has become like Egypt and Babylon. 1.00
00:46:52 It's full of unclean spirits. 0.99
00:46:54 The people are all oppressed by unclean spirits.
00:46:56 They're just drenched in demons.
00:46:57 And full of the most base,
00:47:00 like Herod slaughtering children, 0.68
00:47:01 just like Pharaoh. 0.87
00:47:02 Right.
00:47:03 You see the exact principle play out 1.00
00:47:06 that the Baals were cast out, 1.00
00:47:08 But then emptiness came, it became a desert waste, 0.99
00:47:13 a haunt of jackals and out.
00:47:14 And then it, of course, what happens when you have a vacuum,
00:47:18 it's a job description to the demons.
00:47:20 And so they flood back in and we're in danger,
00:47:23 that is happening.
00:47:24 We're also in danger of that further happening in our nation
00:47:27 with all of these trifling with demonic
00:47:30 and we could get a UAPs and a bunch of other stuff.
00:47:34 And we will.
00:47:34 And overall, we believe that the trajectory is likely long.
00:47:38 It could be thousands of years, and it's also up.
00:47:41 But we leave room for, when we say, oh, a little dip,
00:47:45 we're not talking about a bad week.
00:47:47 We're talking, like I say, we've been in a dip
00:47:49 since the Enlightenment, arguably, earlier.
00:47:52 And so big dip.
00:47:53 Could fully fall.
00:47:53 Oh, yeah.
00:47:54 America could absolutely, in fact,
00:47:56 in terms of tipping point, we're very far gone.
00:48:00 Yeah, it's likely that it will fall.
00:48:01 And you look back over the history of nations,
00:48:04 and we see many of the Eastern Christian realms
00:48:08 that were conquered by Muslims
00:48:10 are still Muslim today. 1.00
00:48:12 Muslim ruled today. 1.00
00:48:14 God sends chastening enemies in. 1.00
00:48:17 He doesn't withhold judgment ultimately
00:48:19 from those chastening instruments in his hand,
00:48:21 the demons or the pagans or whoever,
00:48:24 but he really does chasten his people.
00:48:26 Right.
00:48:27 And we really can be given over to these things.
00:48:29 So classes of angels,
00:48:30 and we've already done some of that
00:48:31 in terms of the how much should we understand
00:48:34 literally versus analogically.
00:48:36 And okay, so angels are spirit,
00:48:38 but there is a physical sense, a physical component,
00:48:41 which back to the Samuel, he comes up.
00:48:44 He doesn't just appear, but he's called up.
00:48:47 He's ascending from Sheol in the belly of the earth. 0.90
00:48:50 And we've talked about like the belly of the earth
00:48:52 that it seems as though, even though there's spirit,
00:48:56 this is before the resurrection, still waiting,
00:48:58 they're held in a physical space.
00:49:01 Right, I just wouldn't call it.
00:49:02 Whether it's in the belly of the earth.
00:49:04 Physical, yeah.
00:49:05 I would call it a heavenly body.
00:49:07 Okay, but I'm saying the space under the earth,
00:49:10 they're held in a physical space.
00:49:13 It's not just on another plane.
00:49:14 It's in this world.
00:49:16 It's in this world in a physical space,
00:49:18 like deep under the earth.
00:49:19 Same thing with the angels locked in gloomy dungeons.
00:49:23 Yeah.
00:49:24 Right?
00:49:24 They're not locked in a spiritual prison.
00:49:27 In an imaginary gloomy.
00:49:29 There probably are spiritual components to it,
00:49:31 But it's also a prison, very arguably, down in a physical place.
00:49:38 Let me ask you this.
00:49:38 Yeah.
00:49:39 So I'm thinking about Enoch and Elijah
00:49:41 and how they could maybe help conceptualize what we're talking about
00:49:46 because they were still in their physical bodies
00:49:47 when they were taken up to be with the Lord.
00:49:51 And there's debate as to what happened to them after that.
00:49:54 But they were in a heavenly place with a physical body.
00:49:58 We know that.
00:49:59 Just like Christ is now.
00:50:00 Possibly, yeah.
00:50:01 it's most likely. What do you think, because you just said you don't like the word physical.
00:50:07 So man is made from the dust of the earth. That's the earthly body is made from the dust.
00:50:14 Augustine in book eight or 11, I can't remember which, of City of God says that the angels were
00:50:19 created when God said, let there be light. Are you comfortable with saying that a heavenly body
00:50:23 could be, emphasis on could be, made of whatever light is that's not produced by a star or a source,
00:50:31 but just whatever God's, whenever God says, let there be light, and it just is.
00:50:34 Well, the thing is, what we see is always light with our eyes. It's always some kind of light.
00:50:40 I think I'm just most comfortable saying that I think that there is such thing as a heavenly body.
00:50:45 Yeah.
00:50:46 That is, if you want to call it physical with all the asterisks, that you don't necessarily mean
00:50:51 that it is made of kneecaps and the same components that a physical i would be i would
00:50:57 not want to say that in fact i would be much more comfortable saying even if it came to this that
00:51:04 this angels ministering spirits are able for a time to put on a physical body that is truly a
00:51:12 physical body but that's not their normative state at all times or in every situation i'm not
00:51:17 necessarily saying i actually believe that but i think i'd be more comfortable with that than
00:51:22 calling them physical i think they have a different type of i think it's a category error i think i
00:51:29 would be most comfortable saying that they have a body that's not an earthly body yes it's a
00:51:35 heavenly body but it is a body but it's a real body right and that the category doesn't mean
00:51:40 that you couldn't touch it yeah it doesn't mean couldn't see it doesn't mean you couldn't see it
00:51:45 couldn't hear it and it doesn't mean that they're even that's pure analog you know analogy that they
00:51:50 have eyes and wings and faces that i actually think that probably is what they are when you
00:51:55 see that and i think that the angels that appear as men i think that that actually is what they are
00:52:00 sure i just think it's a heavenly body it's just a it's not exactly the same type and that there's
00:52:06 some element there of mystery that is not explicated fully right to us okay yeah i i agree
00:52:12 with that. At least I think it's plausible. Last question. Angels being male. Yeah. Oh,
00:52:19 wait, guardian angels. Take it away, Joe. Yeah, I know, but we only have so much time. The answer
00:52:22 is yes, there are guardian angels. They take care of you. The answer is that every angel is a
00:52:27 guardian. Yeah, just like, okay. All angels are ministering spirits. Whether or not each individual
00:52:32 Christian has their own individual guardian angel. We don't know. We don't know. I've actually
00:52:36 strongly grown in opposition to that idea. Of to what? That we each have our own. Everyone has an
00:52:40 individual guardian angel right and the point is that we don't know because we're not supposed to
00:52:44 know because we're great at making things that ought not to be accessories accessories like an
00:52:48 angel's an accessory like well it's my angel no it's not it's actually not your no it's not right
00:52:52 so but but to your question about male right so okay so what are some of the passages in scripture
00:52:59 that talk about angels being female what yeah what is what is the passage what is what is it
00:53:03 is zachariah three i'm gonna look is that the one that everyone uh yeah zachariah i think it's four
00:53:09 Zechariah 4, probably.
00:53:11 Yeah, let me, you guys keep going
00:53:13 because that is literally the only time.
00:53:15 But I don't know of any of them, arguably.
00:53:17 Brian, you find it, but it talks about storks.
00:53:23 And it seems like, I mean,
00:53:24 there's a strong argument to be made
00:53:27 for like, these aren't even,
00:53:28 this is not even positive, this is negative.
00:53:30 These are like demonic spirits.
00:53:34 Or there's also an argument to be made
00:53:36 for these being using corporate language
00:53:40 and not individual angelic beings,
00:53:43 but like the two witnesses in Revelation, right?
00:53:46 You could interpret that as two individual people
00:53:48 bearing witness,
00:53:48 but you could also interpret it as two churches,
00:53:51 those kinds of things.
00:53:53 So Ben, take it away for a second.
00:53:55 Well, I was going to say,
00:53:56 the thing that I am curious about is,
00:54:00 and I think it's a really compelling point, by the way,
00:54:03 that your loaded question is getting to,
00:54:04 which is that there's no female quote unquote female angels but then how do we get female 0.94
00:54:11 demons zachariah five nine then i lifted my eyes and saw and behold two women coming forward 0.82
00:54:20 by the way this whole section is full of angels like the whole the whole thing in zachariah so
00:54:24 it's like this is totally normal in the context two women coming forward the wind was in their
00:54:29 wings they had wings like the wings of a stork and they lifted up the basket between earth and 0.84
00:54:33 heaven. And then I said to the angel who talked with me, what are they taking? Where are they
00:54:37 taking the basket? And he said to me, to the land of Shinar to build a house for it. And when this
00:54:42 is prepared, they will set the basket down there on its face. So that's the one passage in the
00:54:47 whole Bible. It says two women. That some people say, well, they had wings and they were women and
00:54:51 they were doing this thing that seems. In the context of other. Of a lot of other angels doing
00:54:56 stuff. That's the only even
00:54:58 plausible 1.00
00:54:59 female manifestation 0.99
00:55:02 of spiritual beings. 1.00
00:55:04 Right. I'm not convinced
00:55:06 that they're, I don't know that we can
00:55:08 be, but I'm not convinced that those
00:55:11 are the same
00:55:13 thing as an angel.
00:55:14 Right. But I'm also not
00:55:16 sure what to do with them if they're not.
00:55:18 Right. You know? Yeah.
00:55:20 It's kind of a tough one. Well, in the same way that
00:55:22 like the church, you know, like
00:55:24 Mother Kirk
00:55:26 might like you can use or a ship you know like uh the wind threatened to to break her apart 0.55
00:55:32 well god says he's like a mother hen yeah to us god god does use feminine language sparingly but
00:55:38 he does right one point that i've made this is exceedingly sparing a minute ago considering it's
00:55:42 the only text yeah i was a minute ago before we were recording had and i did i never thought i'd
00:55:49 never thought of before which is the idea that maybe because in the heavenly realm the heavenly
00:55:54 beings, that this is a, a place where in the heavenly realm, there isn't the feminine in this
00:56:00 sense that we're used to on earth because God himself is not, he does not have a feminine
00:56:06 component. Even what we just said about analogy, he's not, there is no God, the mother, there is
00:56:11 no sister God, there is father, son, and spirit all referred to by male pronouns revealed as
00:56:19 men, which makes sense then in how we are created in God's image hierarchically and
00:56:24 in our relationship as sexed beings, it makes sense to me that there wouldn't be
00:56:29 if that passage isn't a spiritual angelic being that exists in this class and we're just wrong,
00:56:35 but it would make sense to me that there wouldn't be female angels in this heavenly realm,
00:56:41 but that it would be a male, like it's weird to call it a male space because we're all,
00:56:45 ladies are going to be saved
00:56:48 and you know 1.00
00:56:48 obviously 0.98
00:56:49 women are Christians 1.00
00:56:50 women are going to be glorified 1.00
00:56:51 they're not going to be 0.66
00:56:51 they're not going to become men
00:56:53 like some of the
00:56:53 some of the false gospels
00:56:56 right
00:56:56 fake
00:56:56 what are they called
00:56:57 they're just like
00:56:58 Gnostic gospels
00:56:59 like Thomas
00:57:00 yeah
00:57:00 well now you can become a man
00:57:02 because you're a true
00:57:03 you've earned
00:57:04 didn't marry 0.72
00:57:04 become a man 0.72
00:57:05 you've earned it
00:57:05 in the gospel of Thomas
00:57:06 yeah like at the end
00:57:07 of the gospel of Thomas
00:57:08 I'm pretty sure
00:57:08 like that's the whole thing
00:57:10 she becomes a man now
00:57:11 and she's like
00:57:11 you're saved
00:57:12 you're a man
00:57:12 congratulations
00:57:13 but it's like
00:57:15 It's pretty funny.
00:57:16 I almost said based, but I really don't mean it.
00:57:18 I really don't mean it.
00:57:19 It would have been a joke.
00:57:20 No, no. 1.00
00:57:22 Woman is the glory of man. 0.84
00:57:23 She's an image bearer of God.
00:57:24 And in our class of being,
00:57:26 it is good and fitting that there is male and female.
00:57:28 Both male and female.
00:57:30 So God created man.
00:57:31 But angels aren't married or given in marriage.
00:57:32 God created man in his image,
00:57:34 but then mankind, both male and female, he made them.
00:57:37 So both male and female are bearing the image of God. 0.63
00:57:40 But in terms of glories, woman is the glory of man.
00:57:46 Man is the glory of God.
00:57:47 But glory and image, that's two different concepts being spoken of.
00:57:52 So both male and female made in the image of God,
00:57:54 but man bearing the glory of God, woman bearing the glory of man.
00:57:58 As it pertains to the heavenly realm,
00:58:01 I think what I struggle with is that competing glories.
00:58:06 This gets into head coverings.
00:58:07 This gets into a bunch of stuff, 1 Corinthians 11.
00:58:09 I mean, there's a lot here that we don't have time for at all.
00:58:13 Not even a little bit.
00:58:14 But one of the ideas of 1 Corinthians 11 of covering the head
00:58:16 is not just because even the angels that haven't fallen,
00:58:20 that remained in an upright, you know,
00:58:22 stayed in their proper abode, 0.92
00:58:24 that they're just, those angels are just such horned dogs.
00:58:27 You know, if they look down and see, you know,
00:58:30 the Christian church gathering on the Lord's day and worshiping,
00:58:33 they're like, yeah, the guy behind the tree, you know,
00:58:36 with that insanely cool yellow coat.
00:58:38 And so you got to, you know, cover the head, you know, hide your wife, hide your kids.
00:58:43 I don't think that's, you know, I don't think that's what's happening.
00:58:46 I don't think angels or rapists just waste effort opportunities.
00:58:48 And the other thing is, I agree with you that there was a fall of angels.
00:58:52 I don't believe that the angels are just willy nilly.
00:58:56 It's like, how many did we lose today?
00:58:57 Right.
00:58:58 You know, Michael's not reporting the numbers.
00:59:00 So the reformed view is that much like with Adam and Eve,
00:59:03 there was a period after which they would not have been tested anymore.
00:59:08 Yeah.
00:59:09 So had Adam not succumbed-
00:59:11 I agree with that one.
00:59:11 An angel gets its wings.
00:59:13 Right.
00:59:13 So yeah, so had Adam not succumbed,
00:59:15 all of Adam and Eve's progeny
00:59:17 would not have had the same test
00:59:18 because the covenantal head wouldn't have succumbed.
00:59:20 Right, it was a probationary period.
00:59:22 Eventually Adam would have achieved it
00:59:24 and all his posterity would have achieved it with him.
00:59:25 Angels-
00:59:26 The difference is,
00:59:27 the fundamental difference is that angels
00:59:29 are not covenantal as far as we know.
00:59:31 There's no federal headship.
00:59:32 Right, because they don't marry
00:59:34 nor are given in marriage. 0.95
00:59:35 They don't reproduce. 0.96
00:59:36 Not in heaven they don't.
00:59:36 Right, so they're all unique creations
00:59:38 that are uniquely created,
00:59:39 not generated from previous generations.
00:59:43 And so there's no,
00:59:44 the concept that we have of the covenant doesn't apply.
00:59:48 They may have a covenantal structure,
00:59:50 but it would be completely foreign to us.
00:59:52 So because of that,
00:59:53 it seems like the Reformed view
00:59:55 is that all of the angels were created at a single time,
00:59:58 that they're not still being made.
01:00:00 And they all had some period of testing.
01:00:05 Probation.
01:00:05 And then that was it.
01:00:07 And now they all have positively endowed holiness
01:00:10 such that they cannot fall.
01:00:11 They've all been created in a state of integrity,
01:00:13 but not immutable, right?
01:00:15 So without sin, without being fallen, but able to fall.
01:00:20 So state of integrity, but not immutable integrity.
01:00:23 But then angels, humanity would have achieved
01:00:26 that collectively.
01:00:27 Angels made at the same time,
01:00:29 but would achieve that individually.
01:00:31 And probably, I think it's safe to assume,
01:00:33 we don't say it definitively,
01:00:35 but it's plausible that they would achieve that individually
01:00:38 in a task-based scenario, like an angel gets his wings.
01:00:42 Almost like, it's a wonderful life.
01:00:44 Yeah, seriously, that's what I'm saying.
01:00:45 It is canon.
01:00:46 Basically, that's what I'm saying.
01:00:48 It's much like how Christ is Christ,
01:00:50 and the pastor represents Christ,
01:00:53 and then how the angelic ministers represent the deacons
01:00:56 who are tested for a time until their worth is proven.
01:00:58 Well, it could have been getting to Daniel
01:01:00 and beating the Prince of Persia, immutable now.
01:01:03 Like you were already in a state of integrity.
01:01:04 integrity even though there's no like positive this is exactly this i like this enough that i
01:01:09 now it's pretty awesome believe it whole i believe that i will fight to the death there's no it's
01:01:14 like primary water level well here's the thing there's no it's like there's gospel jesus christ
01:01:19 then primary water and then uh angels individually reaching a state of immutable integrity but i
01:01:25 would almost see task oriented i like the task oriented thing but i don't but i think it would
01:01:31 have all been at one time yeah like i don't think that maybe i'm okay with that but i mean i'm okay
01:01:35 with that too it's just either one makes sense that would be my sensibility yep kicking out
01:01:39 so all that being said angels my point with competing glories going back to that i don't
01:01:45 think so one the reason we got off on that for the listener just so that you're reminded is we
01:01:49 don't think that at this point in time at this juncture um that uh angels are still going to be
01:01:55 able to fall. Even within my theory, it's absolutely plausible that by these 6,000 years in,
01:02:02 2,000 years after Christ, in his incarnation and coming, that even at an individual basis,
01:02:08 that every angel, because so much of the angel's task was oriented to seeing through the Messiah.
01:02:14 And we see a third of the stars fall.
01:02:17 And they've already fallen, exactly.
01:02:19 In a chunk, it seems.
01:02:21 So all the angels that stayed in heaven, exactly, one fall in a chunk,
01:02:26 all the angels that stayed remained in a state of integrity,
01:02:29 but maybe individually hitting immutability, meaning unable to fall.
01:02:34 But by this point, they've all hit it.
01:02:35 They've all maxed out.
01:02:36 You're all good.
01:02:37 Or collectively, that's perfectly plausible.
01:02:40 Either way, they're all good.
01:02:41 So back to the glory kind of thing and female versus male angels.
01:02:45 The point is, I think it's silly to say that now, today, at this period of time, 0.99
01:02:51 that angels in heaven, a woman needs to cover her head
01:02:55 because they'll be tempted to rebel against God out of lust.
01:02:59 That's not it.
01:03:00 But this is what I do think, that when we worship,
01:03:03 there's a sense in which God in his mercy,
01:03:05 there is a sense that we could speak of condescension and not God demeaning us.
01:03:09 It's not despairing, but to say that God, that he tabernacles among us,
01:03:13 that he is willing to step down, as it were,
01:03:16 analogical language from his throne
01:03:18 in order to inhabit the praises of his people
01:03:21 and dwell with us.
01:03:22 But there's another sense,
01:03:24 and maybe the more important biblical sense,
01:03:26 in which when the church gathers for worship,
01:03:29 it's not just God condescending,
01:03:31 if there's any element of that at all,
01:03:33 but it's the church ascending,
01:03:35 that the church is now seated with him in heavenly places,
01:03:38 that we've ascended the delectable hills.
01:03:41 We're getting a glimpse of the celestial, that the church is going to heaven on the Lord's day,
01:03:46 that in the spiritual sense, we are gathering together and we are going to heaven. And if we're
01:03:51 going to heaven, so not about the angels and their lust problem for our women, it's not that. But if
01:03:57 we're going to heaven, in heaven, there is no competing for the glory of God. And man is the
01:04:04 glory of God, woman, the glory of man. So by concealing the woman, a head covering, it conceals 1.00
01:04:11 woman, which is the glory of man, so that man's glory, woman who's the glory of man, 0.88
01:04:14 is not competing with the glory of God. The glory of man is not rivaling the glory of God. The only
01:04:20 visible glory on display in heaven and within church on the Lord's day goes to heaven for
01:04:26 worship, the only visible glory on display is the glory of God. And that that is why the woman would 0.99
01:04:32 cover her head. Including the glory of God demonstrated in man? Yes. Because the idea isn't 0.93
01:04:37 necessarily competing glory is kind of the right term at least but it seems to me like
01:04:42 it's actually about all of the glories falling into their proper order
01:04:48 because the angels are glorious right there's a glory of the heavenly body and a glory of the
01:04:54 earthly body and a glory of the sun and glory of the stars but the the angels i think bear the
01:04:58 glory of god yes so it's all of it is god all of it's subordinate glory the glory of the way that
01:05:06 i describe glory all the time is the glory of a thing is the weighty goodness of that thing
01:05:09 being and doing what it was made to be and do right so it we have the glory of man who is the
01:05:15 glory of god and then he's bearing glory the woman was given to him to be his helper and she is his
01:05:22 glory so that needs to be covered to demonstrate right that's what i'm ordering okay yeah i full
01:05:28 i think that's great that's yeah exactly that's being covered so it's it's the only the only glory
01:05:33 on display is the glory of God.
01:05:35 Man is the glory of God.
01:05:37 Man's glory is not on display,
01:05:39 but man, who is God's glory,
01:05:41 is on, so God's glory,
01:05:42 and angels, I think, fall into,
01:05:44 I think it's the same principle.
01:05:46 Man is the glory of God. 0.85
01:05:47 Woman, the glory of man.
01:05:48 Angels are the glory of God. 0.99
01:05:50 Full stop.
01:05:52 I guess I still don't think
01:05:53 that precludes the possibility
01:05:55 of an angelic feminine 1.00
01:05:57 because the glory would be 1.00
01:05:59 properly ordered anyway.
01:06:02 Could be, at least.
01:06:02 Right, sure, they could be there and covered.
01:06:04 And it could just be one of those things that we don't.
01:06:06 Or whatever the covering would be.
01:06:07 Or even in the way God designed them,
01:06:09 they have a built-in covering or whatever.
01:06:10 Yeah, like I think. 1.00
01:06:11 And if there was a feminine angel,
01:06:13 you say, it would be fitting that we don't see a lot.
01:06:17 Yeah, no, that's what I'm saying.
01:06:18 It would be totally fitting.
01:06:19 It would actually be like they're in the mess hall of heaven
01:06:22 and they're cooking up the man.
01:06:24 Well, here's the thing.
01:06:26 God doesn't say, this is actually interesting.
01:06:28 I've never thought about this.
01:06:30 I'm kind of opening a door a little bit in my mind.
01:06:32 Because Jesus does not say that in heaven,
01:06:36 there aren't lady angels.
01:06:38 He just says they aren't married or given in marriage.
01:06:41 So it would seem like you could just say...
01:06:45 So I think what you're saying is compelling.
01:06:48 But then what I'm also saying is that I can't get...
01:06:51 But it doesn't have to be what I'm saying.
01:06:52 No, no, I understand that too.
01:06:54 I know that you're not like making dogma or anything.
01:06:56 But I'm also saying I'm not unconvinced
01:06:58 that Zechariah 5 is not mentioning feminine angels.
01:07:01 And because I can't actually think of anything,
01:07:05 even with properly ordered glories
01:07:06 and hierarchy of creation,
01:07:08 all of that being a basic presupposition.
01:07:11 I can't think of anything that would preclude
01:07:14 the possibility of a feminine spirit
01:07:17 as an ministering angel.
01:07:20 As a possibility.
01:07:21 Yes, as a possibility.
01:07:22 So conclusively, what we're saying
01:07:24 is that maybe.
01:07:26 Maybe, right?
01:07:28 Yep.
01:07:28 So we're out of time.
01:07:29 Definitely different classifications of angels.
01:07:30 And definitely masculine.
01:07:32 Yep, and definitely masculine, maybe feminine.
01:07:35 Definitely different classes of angels.
01:07:37 Definitely guardian angels.
01:07:38 Definitely guardian angels.
01:07:39 In a sense, not just you and your one individual.
01:07:41 Not like the Padre Pio way, but in the Calvin way.
01:07:44 Right. 0.67
01:07:45 There you go.
01:07:45 And then, yeah, and then definitely the masculine angel,
01:07:48 maybe the feminine angel.
01:07:50 And then in terms of spirit, yeah, spiritual bodies,
01:07:54 but that doesn't mean what you probably think it means.
01:07:57 Heavenly being doesn't mean there's no physicality.
01:08:00 Your body is nothing.
01:08:01 It doesn't mean just floaty.
01:08:03 You could see it with your eyes right now.
01:08:05 You could see it.
01:08:06 You could touch it.
01:08:06 Yes.
01:08:07 It could talk to you.
01:08:10 And they don't all just look alike.
01:08:12 It's bound by space.
01:08:13 You'd be able to pick one out.
01:08:14 That's Samuel.
01:08:15 Oh, that's the rich man.
01:08:17 That's Lazarus.
01:08:19 And then apply that to angels.
01:08:21 Those are people, but same kind of thing.
01:08:23 And that's before the resurrection.
01:08:25 I think we've solved like 80 to 90% of the problems.
01:08:28 You're all welcome, Christendom.
01:08:30 Yep.
01:08:30 Within that framework, male angels could absolutely procreate with the daughters of men. 0.72
01:08:38 Well, I think they did.
01:08:40 Especially those male angels in rebelling to God who left their heavenly abode.
01:08:43 Jesus only says that the angels in heaven.
01:08:46 They don't.
01:08:47 They don't.
01:08:48 It doesn't say they can't, but he says the angels in heaven.
01:08:50 There's two elements.
01:08:52 They don't.
01:08:53 That's meaning they're not willing to rebel against God in that way.
01:08:56 And angels who are in heaven.
01:08:58 We're talking about angels who left heaven.
01:08:59 and what they can do.
01:09:02 He's not talking about marriage.
01:09:03 And you're accused of doing something horribly unnatural.
01:09:05 Well, he's not talking about copulation.
01:09:07 He's talking about marriage.
01:09:09 Those are not the same thing.
01:09:09 Otherwise, fornication is an impossible category
01:09:11 is another objection as well.
01:09:14 So, I mean, to me, for other reasons,
01:09:18 it's clear that this did happen.
01:09:20 And so you have to add that as a data point
01:09:22 into your understanding of the thing.
01:09:25 Your angel.
01:09:25 Someone would call that a circular,
01:09:27 that I'm begging the question.
01:09:28 I get that.
01:09:29 but I'm convinced from the text.
01:09:30 Frankly, using that text as a proof text 0.99
01:09:33 against angels fornicating with women 0.99
01:09:36 and producing offspring is a midwit take. 0.96
01:09:39 See our published works. 0.99
01:09:40 Right.
01:09:40 Like it's been addressed.
01:09:42 Right here.
01:09:43 Dude.
01:09:44 I'm with you.
01:09:45 All right.
01:09:45 Well, thank you guys for tuning in.
01:09:46 Real quick, right here at the end,
01:09:48 I just wanted to remind you to become a member
01:09:49 at patreon.com forward slash right response ministries.
01:09:54 Exclusively for our Patreon members,
01:09:56 we have all 10 episodes, early access, ad-free.
01:10:01 Some of my favorite episodes to be looking forward to
01:10:03 is episodes that deal with Bigfoot or fairies
01:10:06 or ghosts or angels or giants
01:10:09 or particularly our episode on witches.
01:10:12 If you wanna watch these episodes now
01:10:14 and you wanna watch them without any ads,
01:10:16 then you've gotta join us by becoming a member
01:10:19 at patreon.com forward slash right response ministries.