The NXR Podcast - July 05, 2025


THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Christian Nationalism, Aristotle, & The Plague Of Multiculturalism - S05E01

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - The Abolition of Reality - Interview with the Author John Waters THE LIVESTREAM - Elon Musk Forms New Political Party | Will It Succeed? (w ⧸ J. Burden)

Episode Stats


Length

56 minutes

Words per minute

178.19

Word count

10,012

Sentence count

440

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

40

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Dr. Stephen W. Wolfe joins us to discuss his new book, Christian Nationalism. Dr. Wolfe is a professor of political philosophy at the University of Wisconsin-Madison and the author of the book, "Christian Nationalism: How to Build a Political System Out of the Bible."

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:30 All right, here we are with Dr. Stephen Wolfe. Thanks for coming on the show.
00:00:50 Yeah, thanks for having me.
00:00:51 You're welcome. So we are going to be doing a 10-part series all on the topic of Christian
00:00:57 nationalism. And what we want to do from the very outset is actually have Stephen define Christian
00:01:03 nationalism and answer, really, I would argue, and I think you would make the same argument,
00:01:08 90% of your opponent's objections to your book come from the introduction. And I think it's
00:01:14 because, not because the introduction is uniquely flawed, but because I think a lot of your 0.76
00:01:20 opponents didn't get past the introduction and are really silly in a lot of their objections. 0.97
00:01:26 So like, you know, biblicism is a rampant plague 0.96
00:01:30 on evangelicals, especially in the Baptist world, 1.00
00:01:33 which I'm a part of.
00:01:34 And so for a lot of guys,
00:01:36 they read the one line where you said,
00:01:38 I'm not a theologian.
00:01:39 And I've had to correct so many guys and say,
00:01:41 when Stephen Wolf says he's not a theologian,
00:01:43 you need to understand that those of you who are objecting,
00:01:46 Stephen Wolf would also say that you are not a theologian.
00:01:49 He means I do not have a PhD in theology.
00:01:52 He doesn't mean I haven't read the Bible
00:01:54 and I don't have theological ideas
00:01:55 or that I don't know basic theology
00:01:57 or the Westminster Confession of Faith.
00:02:00 Everybody, and part of this is Sproul's fault,
00:02:02 who I love, but everyone's a theologian.
00:02:05 I know what he means, but let's just be honest
00:02:07 and say 99% of these theologians
00:02:09 that everyone is one of are bad theologians.
00:02:12 And so, you know, all you're saying is that
00:02:15 I'm going to assume the theology of the reformers
00:02:19 and then work from that to political philosophy.
00:02:22 Is that right?
00:02:23 Yeah, when I said I'm not a theologian,
00:02:25 I mean, I don't work out of the discipline of theology, and there's a classic distinction
00:02:32 that the Reformers made and the post-Reformation Reformers made, and that distinction would be
00:02:39 between theology and politics and ethics. And a lot of them wrote about in those different
00:02:44 disciplines, but some did not. And a lot of the guys who wrote political works like Bartholomew
00:02:49 Keckerman and guys I'm working on now and on Alstead, um, they, they, they wrote not as
00:02:55 theologians, but in kind of the, the realm or discipline of politics. So that's what I was
00:03:00 focusing on. Um, but, but also I, I've never been trained in going from scripture to theological
00:03:06 statements. And, uh, so I wanted to, I wanted a robust theological system from, from which I could
00:03:14 build a political theory. And that's what I've studied. That's what I know. That's what I could
00:03:20 call myself as a political theorist. I have a PhD in political science. And so I wanted to assume
00:03:26 certain doctrines that I considered and still consider the majority opinions of the Reformed
00:03:31 tradition and work from those. And I wanted really solid statements because I wanted to work
00:03:37 analytically, syllogistically, systematically to build a systematic or a system of political
00:03:43 doctrine. And to do that, I needed good, robust theology. And I'd rather just, instead of doing
00:03:50 the work, which has already been done for us, you can pick up Turretin's three-volume Institutes
00:03:54 of Olympic Theology, it's already been done for us, and the statements he makes are repeated
00:04:00 throughout our tradition, so why not just take those and work from them?
00:04:05 Right. Stand on the shoulders of the people who came before us. I completely agree. But I do think that, you know, if I could be frank, I think that you, sometimes your modesty betrays you. I think you're being too modest. Like, so I know that some, again, of the boomer brain Baptist, and for the record, I'm not picking on older people. Boomer is a state of mind. It's not merely an age. You can be a 30-year-old boomer.
00:04:31 The spirit of boomerism is strong with many young individuals.
00:04:35 And so what I'm saying is that a lot of like kind of boomer type biblicist Baptist, when
00:04:42 you made that one little statement just a moment ago, where you said, you know, I've
00:04:46 never been trained in the work of going from scripture to theological statements or positions.
00:04:52 A lot of guys are going to hear that.
00:04:54 And in their presumption and arrogance, they're going to say, well, then what business does
00:04:57 he have, you know, right?
00:04:59 And they're just going to write you off.
00:05:00 Yeah. I mean, what they'll say is that how can you have a Christian, how can it be Christian
00:05:05 nationalism when you didn't do exegesis? And the simple answer is that if I'm using theological
00:05:13 statements like, you know, Christ is Lord, and I'm speaking to a Christian audience,
00:05:18 do I need to demonstrate that truth from scripture or can I assume that? And if I'm
00:05:23 using Christ as Lord in an argument with an audience that affirms that, then I can work
00:05:31 from there and have a Christian conclusion from that. So if you have Christian doctrine that we
00:05:35 all agree on, and that's my audience, then you can make a Christian statement and conclusion
00:05:41 from that. And that's precisely what I did. And so I would just say if people have a problem,
00:05:46 um i mean the problem should be with the soundness of my of my arguments right and so if you agree
00:05:53 with the premises and it's a valid argument then you're compelled yourself to agree with the
00:05:58 conclusion agreed and so if you're going to attack me instead of saying i didn't ground these
00:06:03 statements in scripture you should ask is are those statements true or false that's what you
00:06:07 should be asking and i think if you actually approach it from that uh perspective what you'll
00:06:13 find is that you actually agree with those statements. And so that should be the area of
00:06:20 attack. But yeah, I think there is, within the 20th century, this, like you said, this
00:06:24 biblicist, it's really kind of rooted in a type of reactionary fundamentalism. So I don't like
00:06:30 tossing out fundamentalists all the time. It's usually overused. But there is this fear of
00:06:35 believing anything or stating anything without having a sort of scriptural proof next to it.
00:06:41 but sometimes, and just in an argument, you can assume what your audience already assumes and
00:06:48 you can work from it. I mean, that's the nature of argument itself. Especially if we want to
00:06:51 progress like that. The only way we're going to progress is we're going to like, we have to assume
00:06:56 certain things have already been established. Otherwise we're just reinventing the wheel
00:07:00 again and again. Like, I mean, the stereotypical guy who, you know, um, and, and some of this is
00:07:07 because of higher criticism and all these kinds of things, which fundamentalism tried to stand
00:07:10 against. But because there's been, you know, all these liberal attacks on basic, you know,
00:07:17 fundamental doctrines of the Christian faith, a lot of, you know, the most recent generation of
00:07:23 Christians, instead of being able to stand on shoulders of giants who preceded them and carry 0.57
00:07:28 the ball further and forward, they've had to simply redo the work that's already been done 0.97
00:07:34 because people are like, well, how do we know that the Bible is really the word of God? And so then
00:07:37 you spend 60 years with guys going back to original manuscripts and learning the Hebrew
00:07:42 and learning the Greek and this and that. And the final conclusion is, yeah, the ESV would have done
00:07:47 just fine. That was good. King James is probably a little bit better, but it turns out there's a
00:07:57 difference in building a house versus inspecting a house. The most previous generation, I feel like
00:08:01 we've devoted 95% of our time to inspecting the house built by our fathers, uh, instead of
00:08:07 building new wings and new and new developments and new structures. And I appreciated that about
00:08:13 your book, um, that you didn't go and, uh, and indict your fathers. And when I say spiritual
00:08:21 fathers, I mean, guys like Calvin, you know, and the reformers, but instead, uh, you said,
00:08:26 I'm going to trust my fathers. They built a house. It's sound. And I would like to build an addition
00:08:31 to the house. We're going to add a
00:08:33 grandma suite in the backyard, you know,
00:08:35 whatever. So... Yeah, I mean
00:08:37 in my audience, like the people
00:08:39 I was criticizing in the book,
00:08:41 I'm going after people
00:08:43 for the most part who assume 0.79
00:08:45 or argue within the Reformed
00:08:47 tradition itself.
00:08:50 And so if I'm going to take
00:08:51 from that tradition, then they should be okay with
00:08:53 that. And for the most part, I
00:08:54 assumed what I thought I could assume
00:08:57 and then I argued for things I thought I
00:08:59 really couldn't just assume. So
00:09:01 I think it is a majority, and we'll get to this in a later episode, I think it is a majority
00:09:05 position in the Reformed tradition that in the state of integrity, had Adam not fallen, that
00:09:10 there would have been some type of civil government, civil magistracy. That, I think, is the majority
00:09:16 position. But I did not assume that, because I knew it would be very controversial to just assume
00:09:20 that, because I think most people don't know that, largely because it's kind of buried in Latin.
00:09:26 There's still, as things are coming out, we're seeing more and more, it's easier to demonstrate
00:09:30 that that is the majority position. But I didn't assume that, so I argued for it.
00:09:35 And so people can make whatever they want with those arguments. But the things that I assumed
00:09:40 the most were in the realm of anthropology, assumptions of the ends of man, assumptions
00:09:46 about the constitution of man, the role of reason in man in his original state. And so I assumed all
00:09:52 those things. And then because that's like the foundation of a political theory. So if you read
00:09:58 the foundational text of political theory even if the ones you don't like so like the leviathan by
00:10:02 thomas hobbes um or or lox trees on government he he starts with the question of what is man
00:10:09 and so i wanted to get those theological groundies in place so then i could do what i consider myself
00:10:16 good at which would be political theory um and uh so anyway i i would just say again like if people
00:10:22 again, if you're going to criticize, instead of criticizing that method, which is really kind of
00:10:28 a superficial criticism, you've got to go at, is what I'm saying true, or is it false? And does
00:10:35 the conclusion validly follow from the premises? Right. I completely agree. And that's it. So I
00:10:41 really think like, yeah, so I think the argument that I don't use scripture, for example,
00:10:47 I really think that is one of the worst criticisms. It's the most understandable, 0.72
00:10:51 but also the worst criticism because what it reflects is this, I think, a very 20th century
00:10:57 mentality that we're afraid of reasoning. Like we're afraid of the traditional notion
00:11:03 of an argument with premises. And it has to then be built around exegesis. And I think what people
00:11:10 will find out more and more as they read these works that are being translated, which I'm very
00:11:14 excited about in the next year, they'll see that a lot of our Reformed forefathers,
00:11:20 they did not actually do exegesis in their—I mean, some of them did, but a lot of these works
00:11:25 are not full of what we would consider exegesis. In some places, they cite Aristotle more than
00:11:32 they cite Scripture. And again, you can disagree with that all day long, but as they understood
00:11:36 the political discipline, it was a practical—it's practical philosophy, and it deals with our
00:11:43 our experience in the world, our understanding of ourselves and our nature, and then applying those
00:11:49 practically in real life. And so that being said, there is the philosophy side. And even in the
00:11:56 book, I say, I hope there is a guy who does theology, who's trained in theology, who will
00:12:02 then provide a theological argument for what I'm saying. So in other words, or I should say a
00:12:07 biblical argument. So it'd be, and I know there are actually maybe two or three people doing that
00:12:11 as we speak. And so, which is very exciting because like we could, like philosophy will
00:12:18 not contradict, like true sound philosophy will not contradict scripture. Yeah. So like scripture
00:12:24 is revealed truth. And a lot of that is kind of above nature. So it's things that mainly concern
00:12:30 salvation. Like the Trinity itself is above nature. You can't reason to that. But there are a lot of
00:12:37 things like God is one, like that's a sort of statement that is a natural truth that you could
00:12:42 actually demonstrate at least in principle through philosophy. It's also stated in scripture. And so
00:12:48 you can go at that question of the oneness of God from these two different lights, as they say,
00:12:53 from the light of revealed truth and the light of reason as well. So I did it from the side of
00:13:00 politics or political theory or practical philosophy, and others are now doing it from
00:13:05 the side of revealed truth trying to demonstrate the same conclusion that's great and you know
00:13:10 light's not god's not going to contradict himself right um natural revelation will not contradict
00:13:15 special revelation um and so again you come to the same conclusion on natural truth from the twin
00:13:22 lights um scripture and and reason amen um so we want to you know in this episode in the second
00:13:29 half, we want to give a definition for Christian nationalism. But before we do, I would be remiss
00:13:36 if we don't talk about that infamous racist Aristotle. So a while back, by the time this
00:13:44 airs, this will be some time we'll have passed in between. But I think a lot of our listeners
00:13:51 will probably remember the notorious showdown between Eric Kahn and Dr. James White. And I love
00:14:03 them both. But I think that, you know, Dr. White was unfair in some of his criticisms. So I came
00:14:09 out and publicly defended Eric Kahn and saying, you know, he posted on X, not even Aristotle
00:14:17 directly, but it was somebody commentating on something that Aristotle had said.
00:14:21 And it was about nations and their ability to not be chaotic and not be having factions and
00:14:28 divisions and these kinds of things. And he just simply said that one of the things that helps with
00:14:32 that is if there is an ethnocentric or monoethnic polis, body of people, citizens. But it wasn't
00:14:43 just that. There were a few statements, some explicit, some implicit, baked into the pie.
00:14:49 And I took it as at least three. One, Aristotle is saying, yeah, if everybody are from the same
00:14:57 tribe, the same lineage, then that's going to help. But then it wasn't just that statement.
00:15:04 He went beyond that. He said, that becomes exceedingly necessary. You need that help
00:15:09 in not all nations indiscriminately, but in a nation with a particular form of government,
00:15:15 namely democracy. And then he, you know, again, this guy commentating on Aristotle said that what
00:15:21 Aristotle was getting at is that in a, especially a raw democracy, which none of our founders were
00:15:27 fond of and wasn't their desire or vision for our nation, but something that devolves and becomes
00:15:33 less and less of a republic and more and more of a just, you know, the voice of the people,
00:15:37 the voice of God, very democratic by nature, um, that kind of form of government, uh, usually is
00:15:43 not, if we're honest, it's not truly a democracy, but democracy gives way for an oligarchy. Um,
00:15:51 like, you know, uh, leading up to the 2024 election, you know, there was a, a poll that
00:15:55 was done that said, uh, 20% of people who took this poll and it was thousands of people said
00:16:01 that they would vote, uh, for whoever Taylor Swift told them to that the more you move away
00:16:05 from a republic, an aristocracy, which is, you know, is different than a republic, but those
00:16:10 who are qualified, what inevitably happens is it's not that each and every individual in a
00:16:15 democratic sense has equal weight and say, but naturally those who are influencers, whether
00:16:21 they be, you know, celebrities or actors or, you know, somebody in the NFL, you know, athletes
00:16:26 or leaders of corporations or Elon Musk or whatever, they rise to the top inevitably.
00:16:32 and um and so then your democracy is actually not really a democracy it becomes an oligarchy and
00:16:38 these people can sway and get the masses to do whatever they want you know the the npcs the
00:16:42 non-player characters you just you know elon switches out the chip and says uh we're doing
00:16:46 the trump dance now you know whereas just a couple years ago we were kneeling you know
00:16:50 in solidarity to the suffrage of black americans you know with colin uh kaepernick you know and
00:16:55 and it's so quick that the masses can just on a dime shift and and that's because we've moved
00:17:01 away from a republic, more to democracy, and out of that democracy emerges an oligarchy. Some people
00:17:06 are nefarious, others maybe not, but just about across the board, none of them are really qualified
00:17:11 to be political leaders. So I took it as Aristotle saying that in that form of government, not
00:17:17 necessarily a monarchy, not in every form of government, but in a raw democracy that gives
00:17:22 way to an oligarchy, those leaders, for their own ends, for their own benefit, can pit different
00:17:32 tribes and factions against one another within a nation. And so if you have a clear natural divide
00:17:37 by having multiple different lineages and tribes, then that becomes just a breeding ground for
00:17:45 resentment for nefarious political leaders, oligarchs to play off of. And so Eric Kahn
00:17:50 retweeted that and said, basic, I can't even remember what he said, but he basically said,
00:17:54 yep. And James White, of course, said, you know, yeah, Aristotle was right. Exactly. And James
00:17:59 White responded by like, no, you know, and clutched his pearls. And so then I came out to defend,
00:18:04 you know, Eric, because he's my friend and because I think he was right and said, Eric's not being a
00:18:10 racist, you know, and, but notice, here's the thing, two things explicitly said in this and
00:18:15 one implicitly, and I'll say this final thing and give it to you. One, Aristotle didn't technically
00:18:23 say, at least in this quote, in this commentary on Aristotle, it did not say that no nation ever,
00:18:29 in all places, in all times, couldn't have more than one ethnicity and get along. Number two,
00:18:37 instead, he said, different ethnicities with a particular form of government, namely a democracy
00:18:43 with oligarchs who are playing off of it with nefarious means. And then number three, I think
00:18:48 we can assume implicitly Aristotle is also talking about a nation that's not Christian. So this is
00:18:54 also what naturally might happen aside from Christian nationalism. So when Eric retweeted
00:19:01 that, said Aristotle was right, Eric was not saying that a Christian nation with a different
00:19:06 form of government, not a democracy, but rather perhaps a monarchy or perhaps a republic or an
00:19:11 aristocracy. Eric was simply saying, when he says Aristotle was right, you have to take what
00:19:17 Aristotle said. A non-Christian nation with this exact form of government, democracy devolving 0.93
00:19:25 into oligarchy, with multiple different ethnicities, probably isn't a good idea. 0.76
00:19:31 What Eric did not say is that in a Christian nation with a republic, you know, that you can't
00:19:40 have some different ethnicities. And so I came out and defended him with that. But all that being 0.83
00:19:44 said, at face value, when I looked at it, I had to stop and pause and think for a second, but I was
00:19:50 like, yeah, Aristotle is right. And none of that means that the gospel is impotent. But what he's
00:19:59 saying is just naturally, he's observing that apart from saving grace and apart from a Christian
00:20:05 nation, just a, you know, pagan nation with an oligarchy and raw democracy and multiple different,
00:20:12 you know, Somalians and Haitians and this and that. And it's like, of course it's true. How do 0.99
00:20:19 I know? Because I wasn't born 15 minutes ago. It's happened here. That's the whole thing that's
00:20:24 been happening for the last few decades is one group of leaders, Democrats, playing off of the
00:20:31 plight of, of one minority group against another majority group and, and transferring guilt and
00:20:37 this and that so that they can get elected. And like, of course it's true. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I 0.94
00:20:43 mean, yeah, I have a lot to say on this. I think I'm crazy though, real quick. No, I mean, you're
00:20:47 absolutely right. Um, I mean, there's Aristotle and Joel are right. That's what they're both
00:20:52 right. Yeah. You guys are both right. Um, yeah. I mean, first of all, in the Aristotle thing,
00:20:56 this has been really frustrating because I, I, I, again, like this doesn't mean that James
00:21:00 why it's wrong with his criticism of the use of Aristotle. I understand that critique. But it's
00:21:07 when people lose their minds over it, you have to—if you know the Christian political tradition,
00:21:15 especially after the 12th century or the 13th century, the use of Aristotle is ubiquitous. And
00:21:21 it's not just Thomas Aquinas. It's not just, you know, Marsilius of Padua. It's Calvin's using the
00:21:27 the four causes of Aristotle and his Ephesians commentary.
00:21:31 Yeah, you had like two weeks where like every day, multiple times a day,
00:21:35 you're posting Calvin quoting Aristotle.
00:21:39 Yeah, and everyone quoted him like the New England Puritans
00:21:42 would call Aristotle the philosopher.
00:21:44 Like calling him the philosopher following from Aquinas
00:21:47 is again ubiquitous in the Reformed tradition.
00:21:50 Now that doesn't mean they were right to do that, 0.93
00:21:52 but it does mean that you should probably chill out.
00:21:54 Like you should probably not lose your mind over the fact that
00:21:57 in your own tradition you claim to be a part of, these guys all quoted him, often as authorities
00:22:04 in various things. They wouldn't cite these guys in theological matters because the anthropology
00:22:10 of the Reformed tradition is that when it comes to theological matters, man basically lost the
00:22:15 ability to reason properly when it came to theology. So that's why they're polytheistic
00:22:19 and sacrifices, all these things that they kind of devised to try to fill this gap in theology.
00:22:24 but that doesn't mean that they're worthless when it comes to politics i mean we'll get to
00:22:28 that a little later but um the point is just like you should just chill out a bit because
00:22:34 you're criticizing not just eric khan but calvin vermily junius uh zanke um kecker just go down
00:22:43 the line turretin all these greats of our tradition appealed to aristotle particularly
00:22:50 in ethics and politics as an authority on those matters.
00:22:54 So I just, you know, just like, again, chill out.
00:22:57 Yeah.
00:22:58 Not you.
00:22:59 No, I know.
00:23:00 But, and yeah, so I, yeah, and the reason, yeah,
00:23:05 so I think that in political matters,
00:23:08 like this is the problem I think with like people
00:23:10 like James White and others in that orbit,
00:23:13 because they're, sorry,
00:23:15 but they have a sort of post-millennial fantasy going on.
00:23:18 um and and that is that they can't conceive of a christian nation apart from some sort of broad
00:23:25 revival revivalism which to be fair none of that is innate to uh eschatology and being
00:23:32 i'm post-millennial and one of the big revelations for me about a year ago was just just looking
00:23:38 through history for one um but then also especially you know looking at biblical history
00:23:44 I was like, yeah, Josiah, so much of what God has done, we can ask the question in terms of
00:23:51 theoretically, what can God do? But even as a cessationist, the continuationist is always
00:23:58 going to, well, you're saying God can't do it. Yeah, but of course God can do certain things,
00:24:04 but the better question is, what does God do? What will God do? And one of the best ways to
00:24:09 answer to that, I think, is simply to say, what has God already done? Is there any patterns? Can
00:24:15 we notice a little bit? Can we notice any patterns on the part of God and what seems to be his MO
00:24:20 in biblical history and then providentially as it's played out in the gospel age over the last
00:24:24 2,000 years? And so whether it's Josiah or King David, what I've noticed is that God really can
00:24:31 sin revival in a grassroots way where it's bottom-up. Preachers throughout the land,
00:24:39 George Whitefield, these kinds of things, and you get enough critical mass of the everyman,
00:24:45 you know, the power to the people, regenerate hearts, and even then, they still have to be
00:24:51 trained on how does my Christian faith play out politically, so there still needs to be training
00:24:56 on application and this, but you can actually have a bottom-up grassroots revival where you
00:25:04 get 50% plus one of the population of a nation with regenerate hearts and enough training of how
00:25:10 to apply these regenerate hearts, regenerate minds in the political sphere to where they can
00:25:17 eventually vote their way into righteousness. That can happen. Historically, and certainly in
00:25:23 terms of biblical history, that's not typically what God does. If we're asking the question not
00:25:27 what can God do, but what has God done, the lion's share, the majority report, would fall on what I
00:25:35 would consider to be a top-down revival, where God, in his providence, uses one or just a handful
00:25:43 of individuals, works them into seats of real power, which is not inherently evil. Power can
00:25:49 be used good or bad. And then he gets a hold of those guys' hearts, puts them into the seats of
00:25:55 power, and then they say, under Christian nationalism, revoice for Nazis. If you use that 0.75
00:26:01 unironically, you will be immediately deported. But my point is, under Christian nationalism, 0.78
00:26:07 there will be no more avocado toast. And they literally just come in, and they lay down the 0.90
00:26:13 law without the majority support of the people. They just say, this is the way it's going to be.
00:26:17 And then the law, this is basic Reformed doctrine in its second use, has this pedological function
00:26:25 and serves as a tutor. And the people maybe don't like it at first, but eventually the law is used
00:26:32 to shape the people in their hearts and minds and actually sets the better backdrop for pastors in
00:26:37 churches to preach the gospel to people who now actually view themselves as sinners, because
00:26:42 in the state, there's a just law that is functioning as a clear mirror to show them
00:26:46 their own need for Christ, it's—obviously, that's what God has done, and to think that—so
00:26:55 anyways, my point is, I'm postmillennial, and for me, all that means—it means a lot of things—but
00:27:00 for this purpose, all that means is, you think it could happen, I think it will happen, right?
00:27:05 But when I say, I think it will happen, I don't see anything in postmillennial eschatology that
00:27:11 says that it will happen and it must happen bottom up. That you can't argue from eschatology.
00:27:18 Yeah, so I agree with everything you just said. My criticism, when I say post-mobile fantasy,
00:27:25 what I mean is that they see, they have a sort of progressive outlook so that the experiences
00:27:33 of human history with like what Aristotle's talking about, how ethnic distinctions or
00:27:39 differences create political conflict, that stuff will just all go away. Because in the progress
00:27:46 of the millennium, those issues will just go away. So when a sort of fantastical post-millennial
00:27:53 political theory is devised, it's with the assumption of some future state that they just
00:27:58 kind of posit these principles. And so they can reject all what they consider bad in the past
00:28:03 because that's eliminated by grace. And so that's one of my criticisms.
00:28:09 But we haven't gotten there yet.
00:28:10 You're arguing A to Z, but skipping B, C, D, E.
00:28:14 I mean, my argument was that those problems will never go away.
00:28:17 I think even, and I would hope that post-mobile people would see that.
00:28:21 But I guess as an on-millennial guy, I see that these problems of what Aristotle describes are going to be perpetual.
00:28:30 They're always going to be issues.
00:28:32 There's always going to be political disputes.
00:28:34 Politics is always going to be agonistic.
00:28:36 there's always going to be differences and you have to struggle through that like grace is not
00:28:40 going to eliminate the nature of politics as it's as it's always been um and well that's even jesus
00:28:47 to put a verse on it like the poor you will always have right so like even in a post-millennial hope
00:28:53 like you're going to have to figure out what do we do with the poor what do we do with the homeless 0.97
00:28:56 what do we do with the immigrant what do we like yeah you'll always have to deal with those issues
00:29:00 and um i and so when when these guys when these guys in the past were citing aristotle cicero
00:29:06 seneca um you know even julie caesar all these when they were talking about these guys and
00:29:12 quoting them as authorities they were doing it when they were living in christian states
00:29:17 they had christian magistrates they had christian nations christian states christian governments
00:29:22 and they appealed to them because they were a body of experience of human history
00:29:30 in the arrangement of political society. And so they were in it, like they were in the Christian 0.51
00:29:36 nation, in the Christian state, in these things. And so they were not afraid to appeal to the
00:29:42 common human experience because they were actually, they didn't have to think through
00:29:46 some future state and then say, oh, it'll be like this, and then appeal to grace to eliminate these
00:29:51 various problems. Um, and so, you know, even if those problems, like you said, are going to go
00:29:57 away in, in, in the future, we still live in them now. I don't, and I don't think they're entirely,
00:30:02 like, I don't believe in it. I think that I actually do hold to, um, and I lean towards it,
00:30:08 not definitively, but the, um, the, uh, possibility, I would say more likely than
00:30:13 not of a golden age, but, uh, a golden age, even then, uh, poverty would not be ultimately
00:30:18 eradicated. Certainly distinctions among different ethnicities would not be eradicated. And that's
00:30:24 like God's created order has distinctions. There's distinction between male and female. 0.93
00:30:31 And it's so funny that like the complementarian, which I usually take opportunity to mock,
00:30:37 I would be patriarchal, but the complementarian will recognize, well, Galatians chapter three
00:30:42 can't be used to eradicate distinctions between gender you know like um uh you know male is still
00:30:48 male female still female um but but then they they're inconsistent or even perhaps dishonest
00:30:54 in their hermeneutic that in the very same breath it's like well male and female still exist uh but
00:31:01 um but no more jew and greek it's like well yeah like no more jew and greek in the sense that um
00:31:06 at the lord's table and the waters of baptism you know one spirit one church one one baptism
00:31:11 that we're all equal in the eternal sense of our dignity, our value in the sight of God,
00:31:17 made in the image of God naturally. And then, you know, and then as regenerate people, you know,
00:31:21 children adopted, there's no stepchildren in God's family and equal standing as members in a church.
00:31:27 And, you know, even you got guys like Robert E. Lee, who's taking the Lord's Supper right there
00:31:31 along with his slaves and their brothers in Christ and co-heirs in grace. And the same thing
00:31:36 with a husband and wife, you know, husbands, you're the head of the home, but don't rub it in. 1.00
00:31:41 your wife is a weaker vessel. Don't, don't exploit that, but rather exercise self-control 0.93
00:31:46 and compassion and sympathy because she is the weaker vessel and you are the head. And yet at
00:31:50 the same time, she's a co-heir in grace. And so it's, it's that kind of language. But my point is
00:31:54 if you, if you're consistent, then you look at Galatians three and you say, yeah, equality
00:32:00 when it comes to the things of God for male and female, but distinctions, natural distinctions
00:32:07 of male and female are not eradicated. Okay, great. Now apply that to master and slave and
00:32:13 Jew and Greek. There will always be distinctions. I'm highly offended by this, to be completely 0.81
00:32:20 honest. I have noticed that there's a disproportionate number of African Americans in the 1.00
00:32:28 NFL and the NBA, and I don't think that's fair. It seems as though that there actually might be 1.00
00:32:34 a pattern, that an argument can be made, not for each and every individual, but in a general group
00:32:38 dynamic, that African Americans seem to be better athletes in those particular sports than white
00:32:45 people. And I'm just very offended by, obviously I'm being facetious, I'm not offended, it's okay. 0.79
00:32:51 That's okay. People are different. There are distinctions, and there's a difference between
00:32:55 disparities that are caused by corruption versus distinctions. And I think, so all that being said,
00:33:04 even with being post-millennial, and even when we get to Z, if we get to Z by God's grace,
00:33:09 and even if that Z means a golden age of prosperity and the nations have flocked to
00:33:14 Mount Zion and all these things, which I do believe, I still actually think that nations
00:33:19 will be different. And if you're not careful, I think it's not just post-mill theology,
00:33:23 but I think it's the combination of the post-millennial eschatology combined with
00:33:28 some of the modern theonomic guys in terms of their ethics. When you put those together,
00:33:35 They won't always say it out loud, but as I've probed a little bit and asked some pointed
00:33:38 questions, what it's revealed to me from some of the post-Miltheonomic guys is they basically
00:33:44 believe that the law of God is so specific and such a particular and strict prescription
00:33:55 that essentially once this happens and we are in this golden age, there'll really be
00:34:01 no difference between China and Brazil and Somalia and America. Basically, the law word of
00:34:06 God doesn't just get you righteousness in terms of righteous laws and obedience and these kinds
00:34:12 of things across the board, but it really will, it'll get you the same stir fry recipes across
00:34:18 the board. It'll get you the same kind of art and philosophy and dances and music to where
00:34:25 But it's so funny, it's ironic, because heaven, we all acknowledge that there's a diversity of heaven, every tribe, tongue, and language, but it seems like some of the post-mill theonomic motivation or goals that they're working towards would eradicate the distinctions in heaven, because eventually, when they get to this golden age, there'd be no distinctions left on earth.
00:34:49 Yeah, well, one of the interesting things is because I'm a natural law guy, you often hear criticism of like natural law can, you know, you get whatever you want out of it.
00:34:59 But it's also true of people who emphasize grace at the same time.
00:35:07 So it just so happens that if you reject natural law and you emphasize grace and a Christian nation is this and that, it just so happens to look a lot like Reaganism of 1980.
00:35:18 and then all of a sudden the christian nation looks a lot like reagan's interpretation of
00:35:24 the pilgrims coming over into massachusetts bay colony and and salem anyone from anywhere can
00:35:29 be american and it's it's interesting because it's uh it's it's just it's fascinating to me how
00:35:35 how like the timeless politics of jesus just happens to be exactly fit with the conservative
00:35:41 politics of the 1980s and 1990s it's just what but yeah so this is the fear this is my fear is
00:35:46 that when you eliminate natural, like the idea that there is a natural, that there's something
00:35:53 natural about man that's fixed and immutable, you end up having this plaything of grace.
00:35:59 And that means you can create, you can engineer in your mind, in your imagination, anything you
00:36:05 want. And it just happens, like I said, it often will become precisely your political socialization.
00:36:12 So we have the boomer state of mind, as you mentioned before, the boomer state of mind was engineered in the conservatism of the 1980s and 1990s, Fox News. And so it just happens to be free market. It happens to be anyone can come here as long as they agreed to the covenant as they, instead of, instead of the propositions, now it's the covenant. And, and so, yeah, you can create anything you want and just happens to be that. So I, but I would say if you have a.
00:36:39 So you can do anything you want with nature, but that's a fair point. You can do anything you want
00:36:43 with grace. Yeah, and the liberals and the left-wing theologians do that as well. 0.95
00:36:48 You're right. And so this is why I think it's important to have a nature-grace distinction
00:36:53 and understand that the way humans have arranged and ordered themselves into history,
00:37:01 despite the abuse, it actually reflects something about human nature that's good,
00:37:06 that we ought to examine and affirm as good
00:37:10 and not let grace be this way to destroy all of that.
00:37:14 That there actually is like the natural distinctions
00:37:16 between people groups.
00:37:18 Those, even though there are abuses in there,
00:37:21 there's errors in there,
00:37:22 they need to be corrected by grace.
00:37:24 There is something,
00:37:24 there's an animating principle behind human nature
00:37:28 that drives people to group in certain ways
00:37:32 for their good.
00:37:33 and we shouldn't allow grace to destroy that
00:37:37 under some sort of fantastical project
00:37:39 of really homogenization.
00:37:41 Like you said, there wouldn't be a China,
00:37:42 there wouldn't be a Japan,
00:37:43 there wouldn't be this and that 0.75
00:37:44 because everyone's under exactly the same law
00:37:47 and somehow under the same customs.
00:37:49 Everyone's interchangeable.
00:37:51 You know, this person can be here and there
00:37:53 without any sort of disruption in their way of life
00:37:55 because everyone has the Christian way of life
00:37:57 and the Christian culture, which is universal.
00:37:59 It sounds like globalism.
00:38:01 right it sounds like the interchangeability of workers that uh this guy's cheaper labor so bring
00:38:07 him over he's just like anyone else the abstract human it's the same it's it's grace justifying
00:38:13 like that philosophy uh isn't it convenient you know that philosophy uh also um plays really well
00:38:22 to the gdp continuing to go up you know it's like our theology just so happens that uh it also works
00:38:29 really, really well with shipping labor overseas and hedge fund managers doing really well.
00:38:39 And that's where I'm like, all right. I mean, those are some of the things that got me thinking.
00:38:44 Like, okay, so you're a theonomist, but the way you apply theonomy also really works well
00:38:52 for you to be rich. Like, is that part of it? You promised me it's not part of it?
00:38:59 because it looks like it might be part of it.
00:39:01 And yeah, so all that being said, yeah, I'm with you.
00:39:05 It's also the fact that their underlying philosophy,
00:39:08 I was planning on getting this in another episode, I guess,
00:39:10 but their underlying philosophy
00:39:12 is actually deeply Enlightenment-informed,
00:39:15 or at least the socialization that led to the theology.
00:39:19 I mean, the free market stuff, that's Scottish Enlightenment.
00:39:21 That's Adam Smith.
00:39:23 That's Ricardo.
00:39:24 So the French and the British Isles basically contributed to our notions of free market.
00:39:33 So that's enlightenment.
00:39:34 The rejection of natural law is deeply enlightenment.
00:39:37 And that's like David Hume, Immanuel Kant.
00:39:40 Some other things about the human nature being almost like this bundle of sentiment without a good ordering principle,
00:39:47 that we need grace to sort of,
00:39:51 we need pure revelation
00:39:53 just to have some sense of what is good.
00:39:55 That's very much assumed
00:39:57 certain Thomas Hobbesian notions of man
00:40:00 as a bundle of sentiments.
00:40:02 So there is a deeply,
00:40:03 like even within this camp,
00:40:05 as much as they attack Aristotle and Aquinas
00:40:07 and these guys and their metaphysics,
00:40:10 there is a type of like enlightenment anti-metaphysics
00:40:12 that's operating in the background of all these guys.
00:40:15 We can get into more detail at a different place.
00:40:18 Super interesting.
00:40:20 Real quick, let me say this.
00:40:23 Part of it is back to every nation ending up being the same
00:40:27 and there being no distinctions and those kinds of things
00:40:30 if you use grace to completely eradicate or replace nature.
00:40:36 I hopped on, and I think you know this,
00:40:38 we weren't as close a couple of years ago,
00:40:41 but you probably maybe heard it through the grapevine
00:40:44 or I might have even said something like this directly to you. 0.61
00:40:46 So for me, I was just like, I'm just tired of pietism, you know? 0.96
00:40:49 And that was, that was my first thing coming out of COVID and BLM and, you know, these 0.89
00:40:53 kinds of, and I was like, I want to do something.
00:40:55 I, the Christian faith, um, it shouldn't just affect my marriage and my quiet time.
00:41:00 Like, it's like, surely, like surely we should do something, you know?
00:41:04 And so, you know, and, and you and I were talking, you know, offline before recording,
00:41:10 but for, you know, the past few decades, theonomy was the only game in town. 0.73
00:41:13 if you didn't want to be a pietist, you're a theonomist, you know, and, and praise God for
00:41:18 Rush Dooney and Bonson and Rush Dooney, I like, it's still my favorite. And I, I agree with it 0.96
00:41:22 because, because Rush Dooney kind of, if some of this is generational and he kind of preceded that,
00:41:27 you know, being a little bit older. And so Rush Dooney, um, I feel like Rush Dooney has a little
00:41:32 bit more in common with like someone like Pat Buchanan than he does Reagan. You know, he's,
00:41:36 he's a little bit less boomer ish. And, uh, and so anyways, so I, I hopped on the theonomic, um,
00:41:41 train. And I remember one of the arguments, you know, when you think of pietism, you know,
00:41:47 the mothership of pietism here in America, I always think of Escondido and, you know,
00:41:53 they, you know, just the radical two kingdom, you know, theology and those kinds of things.
00:41:58 And so I remember that, you know, somebody was writing, you know, from Escondido, some, you know,
00:42:04 strong rebuke, you know, to Kuyperianism. And I know you're not a fan, but, you know, but they
00:42:13 were, they were saying like, well, there's no such thing as a Christian stir fry. And so then some
00:42:17 Kuyperian guy, I forget the name, but I read it. And, you know, at the time it was influential for
00:42:22 me. He read, like wrote a response where he said, yes, there is, you know, the gospel affects
00:42:26 everything. There is a Christian stir fry. What's a Christian stir fry? Well, if you go into certain
00:42:30 people groups, they actually, when they cook, they cook by frying things in a pan. And one of the
00:42:36 ingredients is the flesh of other tribes that they've conquered, you know, and they're cannibalistic. 1.00
00:42:40 And so what is a Christian stir fry? A Christian stir fry is, one, it's not cannibalistic. 0.66
00:42:44 And I saw his point, because the point can be made in a general sense. This was a silly thing 0.95
00:42:51 about stir fry. But in a general sense, yeah, religion does affect diet. Of course it does.
00:42:57 In India, the cow is not eaten, but the cow dung is being used in certain ways. And that like,
00:43:04 so diet can be affected like very directly by religion. I think like I just read to my girls,
00:43:13 I read Treasure Island and Ben Gunn, you know, is marauded on the island for six years by Captain
00:43:19 Flint and left to die. And when, you know, Jim Hawkins finds him, one of the first things that
00:43:25 he says is like, I wasn't raised to be a pagan. I had a good Christian mother, you know, and a good
00:43:29 Christian upbringing. He's like, please, sir, for these last six years, I've been without a Christian
00:43:34 diet, eggs and cheese and, you know, and that's how people thought. And I understand that it's 0.99
00:43:40 a fictional book, but the author still had that wherewithal to include it in his fictional
00:43:45 story, the idea of not just a Christian religion, but a Christian diet. And so I get the sentiment,
00:43:51 But the point is, if the Kuyperian, I think the truth is somewhere in between, because if the
00:43:57 Kuyperian guy who is writing that rebuttal to Escondido and saying, well, there is such a thing
00:44:00 as Christian stir fry, well, then there would also be, you know, Christian burgers and Christian,
00:44:04 you know, French fries and, you know, and everything, you know, there wouldn't be French
00:44:07 fries, it'd be Christian fries. And, you know, and then to music and to art and to philosophy
00:44:12 and to architecture. And then at the end of the day, what you would have is post-millennials
00:44:17 are right in their eschatology and the Kuyperian theonomic sentiment is right over here in its
00:44:21 ethics and how much the bible actually applies to every single sphere of life what you get is just
00:44:26 this this monolithic um monotonous glob of like you don't have nations you don't have distinctions
00:44:34 of culture i would take my my grandkids one day to visit japan and i'd like to see japanese people
00:44:41 in samurais but i wouldn't i just see i just see pictures of john calvin you know mcdonald's and
00:44:47 right you know exactly and so it matters it matters and when you think about it logically
00:44:53 it's like oh well of course there's distinctions because how can you get to revelation chapter 21
00:44:59 and and of every tribe and tongue and nation and like what are different tribes and tongues and
00:45:04 nations and these distinctions that that exist before the throne of god even now if if they
00:45:09 don't persist in some sense here on earth. It can't all be boiled down to a moral issue. There
00:45:17 are certain things. Not everything is moral. It is not morally superior to speak English versus
00:45:23 Mandarin. Language is not moral. It's natural and by necessity. And these are the kinds of things 0.99
00:45:30 where, you know, two years ago, I was very much like Kuyperianism. What I meant by that in the
00:45:36 same way that I would say today. When I say I'm a Calvinist, I've read the Institutes, believe it
00:45:40 or not. It was a tough read, but I did it. And I don't agree with every point. I agree with a lot.
00:45:45 But when I say I'm a Calvinist, and when most people say they're a Calvinist, what they mean
00:45:48 is I agree with John Calvin's soteriology. In the same sense, I would still say I'm a Kyperian,
00:45:54 and what I mean by that is what he's most known for every square inch. What I mean by that is
00:45:58 all of Christ for all of life. And I still think that that's the general sentiment of all of Christ
00:46:03 for all of life is a good instinct. And I'm a Kuyperian in that sense. I don't mean that I agree
00:46:09 with every sentiment of Abraham Kuyper and all the different things that he said, because it really
00:46:14 does begin to blur lines and create certain problems. And it took me a little while coming
00:46:19 out of COVID and stuff. I was like, well, I just don't want to be a pietist. I just want to be on 0.99
00:46:22 the team that does something. And Theonomist seemed to be the only game in town. And as Providence
00:46:27 would have it, you have been used to change that game. There's now another team in town and a lot
00:46:34 of young guys who put on the theonomic jersey, such as myself, and who would still be perfectly
00:46:40 comfortable saying, well, I'm a general equity theonomist of sorts and blah, blah, blah, as far
00:46:44 as meets the confessional position in the Westminster in the 1689. I'm still perfectly
00:46:49 comfortable there. But a lot of guys, you did change the game. Your book changed the game.
00:46:52 and they realize, wait a second, there's actually a position that goes way before. I don't have to
00:46:58 look to Rushduni in the 1970s, but I can look to the 1600s, and there's actually something that
00:47:03 makes sense of the world, makes sense of the scripture, doesn't cause you to invert and
00:47:08 become a pietist. You can tackle politics and tackle the culture all for the glory of God.
00:47:13 Yeah, I mean, what I tried to do is when I saw the game in town, so like you said,
00:47:19 there were the theonomists and then there were the modern two kingdom guys and the
00:47:24 Kuyperians and all that. And it was like,
00:47:26 he framed it a type of nature versus grace mentality.
00:47:30 So the modern two kingdom guys,
00:47:32 they want to say it's all nature in terms of the political and ethical life is,
00:47:37 is all nature. And so they were afraid of attaching Christian to anything.
00:47:43 So like, I think like Carl Truman would say there are no Christian plumber.
00:47:47 Like, you can't be, like, there's no Christian way to be a plumber or stuff like that, which
00:47:53 sets up this separation of nature and grace. 0.97
00:47:56 But then you have, yeah, the Kuyperian theonomic guys who are all on the side of grace.
00:48:01 They wouldn't probably want to make a nature-grace distinction, but that's probably close enough
00:48:05 to how you frame it.
00:48:07 So I didn't want to do the nature side because I actually think you can have Christian schools
00:48:12 and you can have, you can be a Christian plumber and Christian this and that. 0.96
00:48:17 But I also didn't want the homogenizing force of the theonomic side. And I didn't make anything up 0.99
00:48:25 on this. Instead of separating nature and grace, I distinguished them and was able then to
00:48:33 demonstrate a system in which you can have Christian schools, Christian families, Christian
00:48:41 nations, Christian civil government, Christian civil magistrates, um, without losing one or the
00:48:48 other, without eliminating nature and without, um, without, uh, eliminating grace, right? So I've
00:48:55 always used the classic, uh, like a Christian family, like a Christian family is a natural
00:48:59 thing, husband, wife, having or expecting children. Um, that's a thing in nature, but a Christian
00:49:04 family, you don't lose that. Like grace does not destroy that or undermine it. Um, but it corrects
00:49:10 deficiencies and perfects it because now you forgive one another in christ you do family
00:49:15 worship together you go to church together all those various christian things that you do
00:49:20 it not only adds various things that you do in the family it com it in a way completes the entire
00:49:25 thing without eliminating those natural principles and so it's meaningful to say christian family
00:49:32 and so it's also meaningful in in a very similar way to say christian nation or christian civil
00:49:37 ruler. See, the irony with that, though, I know you'll probably push back on this, but
00:49:42 I think I can actually do that and make the argument even a little bit stronger than you 0.56
00:49:47 as a Baptist. Because the devil's advocate, if I was Presbyterian, because I've heard the 0.62
00:49:53 Presbyterians make this argument, what they'll say to you is, well, you can do that with the family
00:49:57 because the Christian family is a part of the new covenant. And all the children are members of the
00:50:03 new covenant. They may not be regenerate yet, but they're part of the new covenant. So you can do
00:50:07 that with the family because the Bible does that with the family. The new covenant doesn't just
00:50:11 encompass the church, but within the Presbyterian scheme, covenantal federalism, the new covenant
00:50:18 doesn't just encompass the church, like regenerate church membership as the Baptist would hold,
00:50:22 but actually covers the family. But I don't see in the Bible where it covers the nation or where
00:50:25 it covers the state. Whereas for me as a Baptist, I can say, oh yeah, I have a Christian family. I
00:50:30 have five kids and they're very small. Only two of them are currently baptized as a guy who holds
00:50:37 to, you know, credible profession of faith preceding baptism. Forgive me, humor me for a
00:50:41 moment, you know, but, uh, but as that guy with my, you know, covenantal scheme as a reformed
00:50:46 Baptist, um, I'm still actually able and have been making the argument for years now. Uh, but no,
00:50:52 the whole family's Christian, all of them, even my, my newborn child who's three weeks old today.
00:50:57 Uh, she is a part of a Christian family. We are Christians. And when I lead them through family
00:51:02 worship and when I, and you, you probably would just say like, Joel, you're, you're really all
00:51:05 you're all you're confessing right now is that you're a presbyterian you're just inconsistent
00:51:08 you'll come there eventually but my point is even as a baptist and holding to the the particular
00:51:13 covenantal scheme that i currently hold i'm able to look at my young children who are not baptized
00:51:19 and say you are a part uh a member of a christian family and uh i teach them the lord's prayer and i
00:51:24 don't say uh when we you know learn the lord's prayer i don't teach them to say um mom and dad's
00:51:29 father who art in heaven but our father even though technically in the technical sense they
00:51:34 have not yet been adopted. As far as I know, they could be regenerate. Who knows? But the point is,
00:51:39 I've been perfectly comfortable as a Baptist with Baptist theology and covenantal theology
00:51:44 to consider my whole family, not just the regenerate members, Christian. And so when I say
00:51:50 from that standpoint, and so likewise, the same principle can be applied to a nation.
00:51:57 It means something. And I'm not saying it doesn't mean something with you. I just know that the
00:52:02 presbyterians who don't like christian nationalism who would disagree with you that's what a
00:52:06 westminster escondido presbyterian would probably use as pushback to you as you say yeah what you're
00:52:13 doing with the family doesn't work with the nation because the family is the new covenant yeah i
00:52:18 actually i got that pushback a couple weeks ago when i was in escondido um yeah and i would just
00:52:23 say that i'm not talking about covenantal obligations i'm talking about natural obligations
00:52:28 So a father, as the head of a household, is obligated by nature for him to order his family to the true God.
00:52:35 And the true God is a triumne God.
00:52:37 And so I don't proceed from covenantal obligations in that regard.
00:52:42 So I would say the same thing about the nation, is that a nation as such ought to order its people or order itself to the true God, which is a triumne God.
00:52:52 um and uh and so with that then they should also they should uh support the church and all that so
00:52:58 um i yeah so i i understand i've heard that argument before okay and and there's a reason
00:53:04 why in the book i don't actually proceed along the covenantal lines i proceed along natural
00:53:09 law arguments for that so i think that solves it um whether or not there's sound is a different
00:53:14 question but it makes it coherent um and i i think the and this is i'd say what the reformers
00:53:21 argued as well. Like when they would appeal to Cicero, Aristotle, Plato, saying that the civil
00:53:27 government ought to promote religion, what they're saying is that it's a natural duty because these
00:53:32 guys are making arguments apart from grace, apart from the covenant. And so when Calvin and Turretin
00:53:38 and these other guys say, look what Cicero said, and they're actually saying, no, there's actually
00:53:42 a natural obligation for a Christian ruler to order his people to God. So that's how I'd make
00:53:49 the best blasphemies and yeah yeah amen okay so let's uh right here at the end because i want to
00:53:54 keep the audience's attention and give them a little bit of an appetizer just a sample of what's
00:54:01 to come in this series so this is part one and as we said in the beginning of this episode we you
00:54:06 know we immediately came out of the gate lying by saying that we were going to define christian
00:54:10 nationalism we never got to it but so so i would say let's come right out of the gate in our second
00:54:15 episode, and we will define Christian nationalism. But beyond that, in later episodes, we also want
00:54:22 to not only define Christian nationalism, but also seek to define, attempt to define what is a nation.
00:54:29 I think of like Matt Walsh, you know, what is a woman? But right now, it seems like that's one of
00:54:34 the burning questions is, what is a nation? Because so many Americans, maybe that's probably a unique
00:54:38 problem to us. But right now, man, Americans are just insufferable when it comes to attempting to 0.95
00:54:46 answer that question. Is it an economic zone? Is it a set of propositions? And that's literally
00:54:50 what Reagan, God bless him, he did a lot of good things, but he hurt us. He's a product of his time,
00:54:56 but he hurt us as well by saying, you can move to France, but you can't be a Frenchman.
00:55:02 You can move to Scotland, but you can't be a Scotsman. But anyone from anywhere can
00:55:08 move to america and become an american that sucks i like that's not good and and so for americans 0.57
00:55:17 it's like i mean he he redefined what is a nation yeah he made people think that that was 0.99
00:55:24 that that was a belief from the beginning of the american tradition but that was not was not so
00:55:29 it was not for most of our history that was not the case so we're going to define next episode
00:55:34 right out of the gate what is christian nationalism but later we want to define what
00:55:38 as a nation and then tell the listener what are a few other things we're going to try to cover in
00:55:43 this series what is a nation what is a christian nation uh civil law um cultural christianity
00:55:48 the christian prince uh religious liberty and and uh and then some some american anglo-american
00:55:55 protestantism cool near the end yeah all right so stay tuned uh we hope that you've enjoyed this
00:56:00 first debut episode uh this will be again a 10-part series with dr stephen wolf over christian
00:56:07 nationalism, and we hope that you stay tuned. Thanks.