The NXR Podcast - May 10, 2024


THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Faeries | The “Elemental Spirits” (Colossians 2_8)

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Are Christian Women “Birthing Machines”? THE INTERVIEW - How To Identify An Abusive Church

Episode Stats


Length

53 minutes

Words per minute

182.24

Word count

9,722

Sentence count

762

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

28

sentences flagged

Hate speech

69

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Mythology and Mythology, we take a look at the preternatural beings that have been described as fairies, ghosts, spirits, spirits of the dead, and spirits of purgatory. Are they real? And if so, who are they really?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 King James VI, yes, that King James, the namesake for the King James Bible, wrote a small pamphlet
00:00:10 in 1597 titled, Daemonology, wherein he tries to classify and systematize our understanding
00:00:17 of all the fallen and unclean spirits that are creeping about in our world.
00:00:21 But he includes something that might surprise you, a whole section dedicated to things called
00:00:27 fairies.
00:00:28 Up to his day, and for long after him, everyone had a category in their minds
00:00:33 for a preternatural being that doesn't quite seem to fit with all of our other neat categories.
00:00:39 A trickster, a helper, a malicious enemy, a benefactor, and noble spirit who lives in fairyland.
00:00:46 Depending on when it was and where it was, everyone has figured fairies to be these things.
00:00:52 But what are they really? Or are they really at all? 1.00
00:00:56 And if so, how do we know?
00:01:00 I mean, what's the biblical, let's just start there.
00:01:02 What are a couple of things that if you were saying,
00:01:04 I'm building a biblical premise to allow for this category of fairies? 1.00
00:01:09 The first thing I would say, no, I do think this is important. 1.00
00:01:13 King James, believe me.
00:01:14 I'm kidding.
00:01:14 I'm going to give an asterisk and an answer.
00:01:17 The asterisk is, well, let me give the answer, then the asterisk.
00:01:20 The answer is that the Bible does not purport to contain an exhaustive knowledge of the
00:01:26 created order.
00:01:27 It doesn't.
00:01:28 And that's true for the spiritually created order and the physically created order.
00:01:31 I'm not saying that God doesn't know, but it does not present to us an exhaustive list.
00:01:34 No, it doesn't.
00:01:35 It's not a zoology textbook.
00:01:36 This is odd.
00:01:37 This is a fast, we know this.
00:01:39 Like there are animals that are real that are not mentioned in scripture.
00:01:42 And it's because scripture isn't trying to do that.
00:01:44 That's not what it's trying to do.
00:01:45 It's not giving us exhaustive knowledge of, you know, the, the math behind atomic fission or an
00:01:52 entire list of every mammal or anything like that. So that's true. We know that, but the asterisk
00:01:58 means that when we leave the pages of scripture and we go out into the world and we start doing
00:02:03 our investigation and our natural theology and things, we are always going to be looking to
00:02:07 avoid drawing conclusions that would be contrary to any known principle of scripture. In this area,
00:02:13 We have to be careful on that front.
00:02:16 This is similar, in my opinion,
00:02:17 to the question that theologians
00:02:19 have genuinely wrestled with,
00:02:21 which is, could there be intelligent life
00:02:23 on another planet?
00:02:24 It's a similar type of question.
00:02:27 Well, sure, I guess there could be.
00:02:28 It would introduce some theological questions.
00:02:32 Lewis solves this in his Heavens Trilogy,
00:02:34 what we call the Space Trilogy in Ogden,
00:02:37 that there are, and some of them aren't fallen.
00:02:40 Because the question immediately comes up,
00:02:42 Like, did Jesus have to go die on that planet too?
00:02:44 Right, exactly.
00:02:45 Or did God have to incarnate?
00:02:47 And part of the problem is like,
00:02:49 the incarnation is already difficult enough
00:02:52 in terms of the divine taking upon itself,
00:02:54 you know, the human nature in addition,
00:02:56 you know, but then to take a third nature
00:02:58 because it wouldn't be another Jesus.
00:03:00 It wouldn't be another Jesus.
00:03:00 It would be God taking on the nature of that thing.
00:03:03 Exactly.
00:03:03 So I've discussed this before.
00:03:05 The only thing that I could even conceive of would be,
00:03:07 you know, if there are,
00:03:09 like we're talking about not just life,
00:03:11 like animals, but sentient, you know,
00:03:13 human-like life on another planet,
00:03:16 they would either have to be unfallen 0.95
00:03:18 or fallen and damned. 0.61
00:03:21 Yeah.
00:03:21 Yeah, morally responsible creatures. 0.92
00:03:24 Right, but damned in the sense 0.90
00:03:26 that like Jesus isn't coming for them. 0.90
00:03:27 He's not coming for them.
00:03:28 And there is another option
00:03:30 and it's that we don't know
00:03:30 because God knows things we don't.
00:03:32 Right.
00:03:32 And God can do whatever he wants.
00:03:34 And maybe there's, not just maybe,
00:03:37 there are things that are far beyond our comprehension.
00:03:40 Yes.
00:03:40 So that's part of the answer, I think, first.
00:03:43 A similar category was the starting point
00:03:45 for the horribly faulty doctrine of purgatory
00:03:49 for the Roman church,
00:03:50 which is that they were noticing something
00:03:52 that seemed to be happening a lot.
00:03:55 And that is that their parishioners
00:03:57 were seeing the spirits of the dead
00:03:58 wandering in the meadows and the fields
00:04:00 after they had passed away.
00:04:03 And they were trying to come up with,
00:04:04 and it's gone by many names,
00:04:07 the processional or even the wild hunt.
00:04:10 in mythology. But it's this idea that they seem to see often around them, that the spirits of
00:04:18 the deceased are still lingering, and they can't explain why. And that was one of the seeds of the
00:04:25 eventual doctrine of purgatory. Okay, that's not a good way to respond. It's not a good way to do
00:04:30 theology. No, that's not how you do natural theology. That's not how you do theology proper.
00:04:36 They did that inappropriately,
00:04:37 but it wasn't inappropriate to notice something that was happening.
00:04:41 And we address at length spirits lingering after death in our ghost episode.
00:04:44 Yes, indeed.
00:04:46 That's not a biblical category.
00:04:47 So the category here is similar in that we don't actually have
00:04:51 a cut and dry chapter and verse where we can say,
00:04:54 look, it mentions fairies or some preternatural thing,
00:04:58 which preternatural is sort of in between. 0.98
00:05:01 It's natural in some sense, but it's also very much supernatural.
00:05:05 Right. But it, it sort of toes the line between both worlds and it's habsies. 0.93
00:05:09 So you, you helped, yeah, you helped me. So we, we began to delve into the fairy category 0.99
00:05:14 in the Bigfoot episode. And you, you mentioned something, Ben, that was really helpful for
00:05:19 me to see it. Just thinking about angelic beings, because we talked about angelic beings in our
00:05:24 angel episode. And so in the, in the angel episode, we talked about not all angels are the same,
00:05:29 you know, and, and the word angel, you know, if we're talking about angels as, as just a big
00:05:33 banner, you know, overarching category to encompass every kind of heavenly host, heavenly
00:05:37 creature of, then it would be, you know, cherubim and seraphim and the four living creatures
00:05:42 covered with eyes and six wings and Ezekiel's, you know, wheel conception with eyes within
00:05:47 and all these different things.
00:05:48 The 24 elders on thrones and the seven, you know, torches that contain the spirits of
00:05:52 God.
00:05:53 So that would be if we're using angel to mean every heavenly creature, but the word angel
00:05:58 actually just means messenger.
00:05:59 And so you could say there's angels and using that in the sense of heavenly creatures, but then there are angel angels and angel angels, meaning angels that are messengers.
00:06:11 And those angels tend to look like us, but all this is still in the heavenly creature category.
00:06:16 But what you introduced towards the end of the Bigfoot episode, as you started to tease the fairy topic, was, but how do we know that God has not also created angelic type beings, but apart from the heavenly location?
00:06:32 That from the beginning, they actually had not just that they would come like messenger angels
00:06:37 with momentary visitations to earth to bring a message, but that their proper abode,
00:06:44 their natural habitat was earthly because God is a compassionate God who cares for his image-bearing
00:06:48 creatures, man, but also as the Psalms say, have compassion on all he has made. And so
00:06:54 an angel of a particular forest or river or this or that.
00:06:58 We have heavenly-facing angels, man-facing angels,
00:07:02 and then what if there's also spiritual beings that are nature-facing?
00:07:07 The Bible doesn't forbid it.
00:07:09 It's not said explicitly.
00:07:10 It goes back to your disclaimer from the beginning.
00:07:12 But the reason that would be so radical,
00:07:14 and essentially this is an elemental spirit.
00:07:16 And it would be.
00:07:17 The reason that would be radical is because until yesterday,
00:07:21 when we had our discussion on angels at the time of recording,
00:07:24 every theologian has virtually just assumed or presupposed
00:07:28 that angels are pure spirit
00:07:30 as it's properly understood.
00:07:32 And so all of the language
00:07:33 regarding them is analogical.
00:07:35 That's been a big assumption.
00:07:36 Until yesterday.
00:07:37 Until yesterday.
00:07:40 That sounds like a...
00:07:42 I'm getting a little uncomfortable.
00:07:43 That's really cool.
00:07:44 I'm getting a little uncomfortable.
00:07:45 Like maybe we should come out
00:07:46 with some kind of reference Bible
00:07:47 for this view.
00:07:50 Maybe like a Scofield.
00:07:53 Boom.
00:07:55 That's what people, 1.00
00:07:55 that's what all of the Reformed Pop 1.00
00:07:57 is doing to us, right? 1.00
00:07:58 Exactly. So the reason that that would be a radical view to take, that an elemental spirit
00:08:04 who serves God by overseeing some geographical area or geographical entity like a river or a
00:08:11 forest on earth is because that would be preternatural. That would be a thing that
00:08:16 directly toes the line. It's not a messenger to man who sometimes intervenes and who sometimes
00:08:22 is visible and who sometimes... No, it would be a thing that is always in between the unseen and
00:08:28 the seen. So that would be a relatively radical thing, especially for moderns to conceive of.
00:08:34 But that's actually one of the four primary views of the fairy, is that all of them are
00:08:39 preternatural somehow. But the first view that's put forth, by the way, by the medievals,
00:08:44 and I'm paraphrasing Lewis in the discarded image when I'm saying all these,
00:08:48 but the first view is that they are somehow a third species of rational being distinct from
00:08:56 angels as we think of them and men assuming men are not pure spirit angels are pure spirit but
00:09:03 there's some other thing in the spectrum between us and them that's a rational being before god
00:09:08 that's responsible and for the record if you haven't listened to the angel episode definitely
00:09:12 I'm not sure if angels aren't pure spirit.
00:09:15 Right, right.
00:09:16 I think a major spiritual component, but yeah.
00:09:19 And then the second view is that they are angels,
00:09:23 purely pure spirit,
00:09:25 but who have been demoted for whatever reason.
00:09:28 And so the common justification for this view,
00:09:31 which I think is very bad,
00:09:33 is that they began to fall with Lucifer,
00:09:37 but then repented during the fall.
00:09:41 We're excited.
00:09:42 I made it up.
00:09:43 Okay, I didn't make it up.
00:09:44 This is the medieval.
00:09:45 The medievals made it up.
00:09:46 You said this about you because-
00:09:47 We're excited, crackpot.
00:09:48 Because it's not a good idea.
00:09:48 Yeah, exactly.
00:09:49 So the idea is that as they were,
00:09:51 and you have to,
00:09:52 if you've never read Paradise Lost,
00:09:54 this is how Milton imagined it.
00:09:57 And it's because the medievals imagined it this way,
00:10:00 is as the angels were being pushed from heaven,
00:10:03 as the stars were falling,
00:10:05 and the gates of heaven closed behind them,
00:10:07 some of the angels repented,
00:10:09 genuine repentance.
00:10:10 and they were in ashes and sackcloth.
00:10:13 And so they were not allowed into hell
00:10:16 because of their repentance,
00:10:17 but they could not go back into heaven
00:10:19 because they were no longer holy.
00:10:21 And so the gates of heaven were close to them.
00:10:22 The gates of hell were close to them
00:10:24 and they were kind of stuck in the middle, 1.00
00:10:26 hence a preternatural fairy.
00:10:27 Stuck in the middle of you. 1.00
00:10:29 And I don't like that.
00:10:31 You know what?
00:10:31 I'm going to be honest, Ben.
00:10:33 I'm going to rule that out of my personal.
00:10:35 But that's just-
00:10:35 But that was a real view.
00:10:37 That was a real view.
00:10:38 And then the third theory,
00:10:40 the third medieval theory
00:10:43 is that they were the dead souls
00:10:45 that were roaming the world.
00:10:47 Like what we talked about before
00:10:48 that eventually led to the purgatory.
00:10:50 No, no, no.
00:10:51 Actual human souls.
00:10:52 Dead saints.
00:10:53 Dead saints or reprobate 0.82
00:10:55 who for whatever reason
00:10:56 had to still roam the world 0.75
00:10:58 as part of their either purgatorial...
00:11:00 Joel's like, no.
00:11:01 Exactly.
00:11:01 Right.
00:11:02 Joel's like, just no.
00:11:03 But that was the third view.
00:11:04 As part of their either purgatorial penance or...
00:11:07 These were the medievals?
00:11:08 Yes.
00:11:09 Have they read a Bible before?
00:11:10 Yes, they have.
00:11:11 Well, some of them haven't.
00:11:12 Some of them haven't, actually.
00:11:14 A lot of them actually haven't to be fair.
00:11:16 Hence the Reformation I was seeing.
00:11:18 You just went full Mark Cuban.
00:11:19 But for that reason, I'm out.
00:11:21 I'm out.
00:11:22 Yeah, that's also a horrible view.
00:11:24 And then the last one is probably the safest,
00:11:26 which is that they are simply a category of angels who fell.
00:11:30 Love it.
00:11:31 That's what we need from you, Ben.
00:11:32 Give me a view. 1.00
00:11:35 Give me fairies or give me death. 1.00
00:11:37 Right. 1.00
00:11:37 Like, give me fairies without giving me heresy. 0.99
00:11:41 Right. 1.00
00:11:41 No, I 100% agree.
00:11:42 And if you can give that.
00:11:43 Ferrisy.
00:11:44 So I actually like it.
00:11:45 Fairy heresy is.
00:11:46 Goal achieved.
00:11:47 The fairy heresy.
00:11:48 Ferrisy.
00:11:49 Ferrisy.
00:11:49 Oh, wow.
00:11:51 That's what a ferris is.
00:11:52 Dude, maybe that's where the trademark. 1.00
00:11:53 That's a radical view of fairies. 1.00
00:11:54 Maybe that's where they got the name. 1.00
00:11:55 TM.
00:11:56 Trademark.
00:11:56 TM.
00:11:57 And by the way, I'm legally obligated to make the joke.
00:12:01 Okay. 0.85
00:12:01 when we say fairies we are not talking about elton john that you saw in concert right that's
00:12:10 a different kind of fairy right that one we're talking about fairies that are useful and is
00:12:15 sinful or is definitely fallen but they're active definitely fallen they're useful or or harmful 0.99
00:12:21 similar category trickster right totally sinful don't trust them stay far away don't seek out
00:12:27 their council yeah but you're describing elton john right now that is elton john i like a
00:12:32 concept flamboyantly dressed yeah well no so here's the interesting within those four they
00:12:37 like to dance in rivers well yeah within those four views of fairies you then have three you
00:12:42 then have three classes okay of fairies okay all right and this comes from nature
00:12:47 because people were witnessing these things so they claim and the three classes are the there's
00:12:53 the really low tier fairies that are almost purely malicious. 1.00
00:12:57 Right. 1.00
00:12:58 And they're the trickster, they're, you know, 1.00
00:13:00 the Pukwudgie type figures, all these things. 1.00
00:13:02 And we'll get into that later.
00:13:04 We'll just drop that word.
00:13:05 We'll just drop Pukwudgie and move on. 1.00
00:13:06 But so, and so they're not good. 1.00
00:13:10 Okay.
00:13:10 They're antithetical to the goals of men.
00:13:13 Then you have this middle class that's sort of like apathy.
00:13:17 But it bends towards malice.
00:13:20 So this would be, the example that I've heard 0.96
00:13:23 is this would be the seductress in the woods,
00:13:27 the Lamia figure from Greek mythology, 0.98
00:13:29 who is sort of a serpent, but also is genuinely a woman 0.93
00:13:33 and who wants to seduce men to steal their purity.
00:13:36 That seems not that neutral to me.
00:13:38 Well, but, yeah, well, nothing's neutral,
00:13:41 but the neutrality comes in, it's apathy, not neutrality.
00:13:46 So if a woman, if a member of this class is attracted to a human, 0.97
00:13:51 well, then they become malicious.
00:13:53 But otherwise, they don't concern themselves.
00:13:55 They're just like, ah, people could take them or leave them.
00:13:57 Unless you cross their radar.
00:13:59 Which is why a lot of the folklore contains the warning.
00:14:02 Don't talk about them.
00:14:03 Don't do anything.
00:14:04 You don't want to catch their interest.
00:14:06 Right, exactly.
00:14:07 And then the final class is the high fairy.
00:14:10 And this is what I like to imagine Tolkien had in mind.
00:14:12 And that's Elton John.
00:14:13 Yeah.
00:14:14 actually couldn't be further yes so the high the high fairy is uh what i like to think tolkien had
00:14:22 in mind when he was conceiving of the the high elves the eldar in middle earth because they
00:14:28 are apathetic towards men but if they ever do concern themselves with men it's overwhelmingly
00:14:33 positive are you a beef jerky enthusiast well then stop it seriously stop it because
00:14:40 Biltong is superior to beef jerky in every single way. It's a traditional South African meat snack,
00:14:48 but it's free from all the preservatives, the sugar, and the soy. It's like the Wagyu of jerky.
00:14:54 Now, here's the exciting news from Farmer Bills Provisions. Farmer Bills is introducing their
00:14:59 brand new product line for your enjoyment. We've got right here the traditional beef slab. You've
00:15:06 also got, if you want a smaller portion, you've got the slices. It's just as much meat, but you're
00:15:11 able to eat it in increments. This is for yourself as an individual, or maybe for you and your family,
00:15:16 your kids. Then you've got the meat sticks. This is what, if you're a working man, you want a snack
00:15:21 to keep in your pocket to eat, you know, before lunch or something like that, grab one of their
00:15:26 beef sticks and take it on the go. Lastly, you got to check out the tallow. For all the moms out
00:15:32 there. My wife, she swears by this. Many women in our church say that it's a fantastic product.
00:15:38 So don't waste any more time. Go to farmabillsprovisions.com today to support a Christian
00:15:45 owned small business. And while you're at it, go ahead and subscribe so that you can save on
00:15:50 multiple options and ensure that you and your family will never be without your favorites.
00:15:56 And the last thing is this, if you want to get 15% off your purchase, all you got to do is type
00:16:01 in the promo code WRITERESPONSE. Again, the promo code, type in WRITERESPONSE. So visit
00:16:08 pharmabillsprovisions.com today and get 15% off your purchase. 0.96
00:16:15 The word soap makes Christian soap. What makes our soap Christian? First and foremost,
00:16:21 it is because our soap is good soap, made exclusively from natural and organic ingredients.
00:16:27 In addition to making a good product, we also promote a good message.
00:16:32 Our bottles of soap aren't wrapped in heretical garbage.
00:16:36 They're wrapped in sound doctrine and the infallible truth of Scripture.
00:16:40 Lastly, we have a good mission.
00:16:42 At the Word Soap, 10% of all our profits go directly to the godly men and women at Abolitionist Rising
00:16:49 who are fighting to protect the lives of unborn children.
00:16:53 Our product is pure.
00:16:54 Our message is true.
00:16:57 and our mission is pleasing to Christ.
00:16:59 So join us.
00:17:01 Visit thewordsoap.com today.
00:17:03 Again, that's thewordsoap.com.
00:17:06 Everyone needs soap, so wash yourself in the word.
00:17:12 Who has provided these categories?
00:17:14 Medievals?
00:17:15 The medievals.
00:17:15 Are they?
00:17:16 Yes.
00:17:17 And C.S. Lewis has transcribed them.
00:17:18 Yeah, yeah.
00:17:19 There's just a problem with this view in general
00:17:21 is that it gives you a similar issue
00:17:24 in that if they are not holy and righteous,
00:17:27 right if they if they can sin and do occasionally sin which like the high elves do yeah in tolkien's
00:17:34 world or this neutral then they're either never they're not redeemable including that positive
00:17:41 category right not redeemable unless god takes on their nature too right and you have an incarnate
00:17:46 which we're of course that's just didn't no no no so that's one of my problems with this category
00:17:51 of saying that it's this kind of thing instead of that it's actually either just a fallen this is
00:17:56 why I like this. So I think that there's a way to have this category as a real category in nature
00:18:03 and in the unseen nature as well. That's, that doesn't break any rules that we know are there,
00:18:10 like what you're saying. And I think that the way to do that is to say, no, they were noticing
00:18:15 something. I think that there is something there that doesn't seem to fit as nicely with,
00:18:21 oh, it's just a demon. Right. Oh, it's clearly an angel. And I think that that category is a
00:18:25 combination of view number one and view number four, which is it's not really a third species,
00:18:34 a third intelligent species. I don't think that. But I do think that it's so different from our
00:18:41 normal conception of an angel that we would think like, wow, that seems like a third species.
00:18:46 So would you say that? And when I say, well, just real quick. So I think that it's a
00:18:50 preternatural, supernatural entity
00:18:52 that is placed over a geographic area.
00:18:56 That's what I think.
00:18:56 So categorically, hang on.
00:18:57 I have some questions, but go ahead.
00:18:58 Categorically, you would put it in the category
00:19:00 of angelic beings generally, as is colloquially common.
00:19:04 Fallen angel.
00:19:04 Fallen, and yet you're-
00:19:05 Well, some not.
00:19:06 But hang on, hang on.
00:19:07 Let me finish my question.
00:19:08 Because I think this is an important question.
00:19:11 We finished the question.
00:19:11 You've got, under the banner,
00:19:14 we colloquially call angels, angelic beings.
00:19:17 And yet, even if they're all fallen,
00:19:19 some of them would be,
00:19:21 you're recognizing gradations
00:19:23 within angelic ranks of fallenness.
00:19:26 Yes.
00:19:26 So that some of them are, 0.95
00:19:27 they're still fallen and damned,
00:19:28 but they're less malevolent.
00:19:29 Is that what you're saying?
00:19:31 No, if they're all fallen,
00:19:33 I think that we would have worse rivers in the world.
00:19:36 Well, what I'm saying is people are all fallen,
00:19:38 but they're not all equally sinful.
00:19:40 I see what you're saying.
00:19:41 So you might have an angelic being that's fallen 0.69
00:19:45 that is just absolutely like the equivalent of Pol Pot.
00:19:49 No, well, why are they all fallen?
00:19:52 I'm saying if amongst those that are fallen,
00:19:54 I'm asking you,
00:19:56 do you believe that there are those kinds of gradations
00:19:58 or are all fallen angels equally bad?
00:20:01 No, I think that the ones that are fallen,
00:20:04 and I don't think they're all fallen.
00:20:06 I don't think that.
00:20:07 But I think the ones that are all fallen
00:20:09 are serving the role that they've been given.
00:20:10 And so from our perspective,
00:20:13 We might perceive that as different gradations of malice,
00:20:17 but it actually, the ones that are fallen
00:20:19 all hate the image of God.
00:20:21 Right, they're all fallen.
00:20:22 They all share that just like all men who are fallen
00:20:25 are haters of God, haters of one another.
00:20:28 And yet there's Mother Teresa and there's Pol Pot.
00:20:30 All men are fallen, but you said,
00:20:33 but not all equally sinful.
00:20:34 But at the level of the heart,
00:20:35 we say that totally depravity,
00:20:36 they are all equally sinful.
00:20:38 But what we're saying is in terms of outward manifestations,
00:20:40 they don't do the most evil.
00:20:42 possible thing all the time. Yeah, one guy murders and another guy steals a candy bar.
00:20:46 Right. Level the heart in terms of rebellion, hostility towards God apart from salvation. Yes,
00:20:50 equal. And frankly, some of that is just a grace of God in not giving them the tools
00:20:54 that they would need to exercise the completeness of their depravity.
00:20:59 And I'm like a man, so a man in a, like what we were talking about yesterday. If you have a guy
00:21:04 who lives a mile away from his nearest neighbor and he has a wife and kids and he has a good job,
00:21:09 He's not going to be as evil as the guy who's desperate.
00:21:12 And both of them are non-believers.
00:21:15 Now they may, they are just as evil. 0.99
00:21:17 In the eyes of God, they both deserve damnation. 0.95
00:21:19 I don't think they're just as evil. 0.98
00:21:20 Well, no, no, no, no.
00:21:22 I think that-
00:21:23 In the eyes of God.
00:21:24 No, I don't.
00:21:24 I still think. 0.97
00:21:25 I think that Pol Pot is worse than the, 0.94
00:21:29 but the distinction is that the bar graph,
00:21:32 there is a genuine difference
00:21:34 and there will be in judgment and reward,
00:21:36 but that the gap between the least evil person
00:21:39 and God is still so great
00:21:40 as it's like the golf ball world thing.
00:21:42 Like the highest mountain to the lowest depth,
00:21:44 you won't even feel it.
00:21:45 Literally, that's all I mean. 0.99
00:21:47 What I'm saying is they both deserve damnation equally. 0.89
00:21:51 But their punishment will be different. 0.99
00:21:54 Yeah, like beating, severe beating.
00:21:57 Exactly, not all sin is equal.
00:21:59 It's all equal in its ability to eternally separate you
00:22:01 from the benevolent presence of God.
00:22:04 But it's, there will be,
00:22:06 there's a hierarchy of heaven, I believe,
00:22:07 hierarchy on earth, there's a hierarchy in hell.
00:22:10 But it is, they are equally,
00:22:12 the problem I think is the word evil.
00:22:14 They're equally, you know, the mass murderer
00:22:17 and the dude who helps old ladies cross the street,
00:22:21 but he's not regenerate.
00:22:23 Maybe evil is not the right word,
00:22:24 but they're equally, in their heart of hearts,
00:22:27 they both equally hate God.
00:22:29 The mind of, you know, Romans 8,
00:22:31 the mind of the sinful man,
00:22:32 It's not just indifferent or neutral or apathetic, hostile.
00:22:35 So they both are completely hostile towards God.
00:22:38 Meaning that if you could sit them down
00:22:40 and accurately describe to them,
00:22:42 not just some general notion of Jesus,
00:22:44 but the God of the Bible,
00:22:46 they would both, if they were being truthful,
00:22:48 they may not both say it.
00:22:49 One might have more self-control than it.
00:22:50 But if you could give them both a true serum,
00:22:53 give them an actual accurate depiction of Jesus,
00:22:56 they would both respond and say, I hate that guy.
00:22:59 Yeah.
00:23:00 Yeah.
00:23:00 But then the manifestations of that
00:23:02 will be very different in the world.
00:23:04 Yeah, yeah, 100%. 1.00
00:23:05 Yeah, one guy, I hate Jesus and I'll help old ladies. 1.00
00:23:08 The other, I hate Jesus and I'll kill people. 1.00
00:23:09 And so, you know, if you're a preternatural 1.00
00:23:12 being bound to a creek,
00:23:14 you're not gonna have that much opportunity
00:23:16 to wreak malice.
00:23:18 Gotcha. 0.99
00:23:18 Because you just got a creek.
00:23:19 You're literally, you're a creek, you know?
00:23:21 If you're a preternatural being 0.88
00:23:23 who lives in a forest in Mongolia
00:23:26 where no one ever goes,
00:23:27 well, you don't have that much opportunity
00:23:28 to wreak a bunch of havoc on people.
00:23:30 Gotcha.
00:23:30 Now, I also believe that not all of them are fallen, though.
00:23:33 Yeah, let's go.
00:23:33 So there might be a class of what we colloquially call angelic being
00:23:37 that is earth-focused, not fallen.
00:23:40 It's just doing its job.
00:23:41 Yeah.
00:23:41 It's just out there doing its job.
00:23:43 It's like, and this would be like, wow, this forest is quite pleasant.
00:23:47 Right.
00:23:47 You know, and then some places are like, suicide forest in Japan.
00:23:49 I'm never going there. 0.83
00:23:50 Yeah, suicide forest in Japan.
00:23:52 The Mountain of the Dead, Lord of the Rings.
00:23:56 And even in the pass.
00:23:59 Mount Shasta.
00:23:59 The Dyatlov Pass.
00:24:00 They've got that mountain of the dead, basically.
00:24:03 We've all been in situations, I think.
00:24:06 Places.
00:24:06 And I certainly have,
00:24:08 where we've been in geographic places,
00:24:10 maybe even where man cannot be seen.
00:24:13 There's not a structure.
00:24:14 It's just nature.
00:24:15 Where we have felt either good or bad.
00:24:18 And you're like, there's something.
00:24:18 And you have no reason other than the place that you're in
00:24:22 to explain it away.
00:24:23 Like, it's even beautiful.
00:24:24 It's not just because, oh, this is bad because it's a swamp.
00:24:27 This is good because it's a meadow.
00:24:29 but like there have been like where it's like this is visibly pleasant uh and i don't want to
00:24:35 be here inexplicable right this feels i feel like i'm in danger like existential dread something
00:24:41 here wants to harm me right right and that see this is really interesting to me because you were
00:24:47 saying you were saying that you want to and i think the reason you might want to do this is
00:24:53 because there's so much evidence of eyewitness and people seeing this kind of thing interacting
00:24:58 commonality of belief in it,
00:24:59 that you want to have a category
00:25:01 where you're not coming up with a third state of being,
00:25:04 a third species that's rational,
00:25:06 that ends up with all sorts of theological problems.
00:25:09 So you don't want that.
00:25:10 You don't want to just say it's nothing at all.
00:25:12 But this view would let you say,
00:25:14 it's just a class of spiritual being
00:25:16 under this genus of heavenly being
00:25:19 that not heavenly even in this case,
00:25:21 but it's just bound to earth on purpose.
00:25:23 It's angelic, but it's-
00:25:24 God created it for this.
00:25:25 And there's probably ones on Jupiter
00:25:27 and there's probably ones in stars distant
00:25:29 and God has them all over the...
00:25:31 Well, that's the thing is I would say
00:25:32 every star and planet would have one.
00:25:35 Like this is straight from Aquinas.
00:25:37 This is his moment.
00:25:38 This is the stars.
00:25:39 We've been preparing for this for years.
00:25:41 For years.
00:25:42 And right now I'm proud of him
00:25:43 because he's saying stars have angels
00:25:45 instead of stars.
00:25:46 Well, yeah.
00:25:47 I mean, I think that the symbolism of scripture
00:25:50 would clearly demand that we see stars
00:25:55 and think, look, the angels.
00:25:56 Look, Korya Kinn is real.
00:25:58 But I also think that within each star,
00:26:02 within each planet,
00:26:04 I think that,
00:26:04 and this is straight from Thomas Aquinas
00:26:06 and Albertus Magnus, by the way,
00:26:08 that there is some kind of spiritual
00:26:10 or preternatural intelligence placed there by God
00:26:13 to ensure that it's carried out properly.
00:26:16 We've got Ramendu.
00:26:17 Everything has a job.
00:26:18 Ramendu, Korya Kinn.
00:26:20 Exactly, yeah.
00:26:21 It's all in Lewis.
00:26:23 What do they teach these kids these things?
00:26:24 Every single thing. 0.62
00:26:24 The L deal. 0.95
00:26:25 This is the medieval point. 0.92
00:26:27 Every single thing that you see has a job.
00:26:30 And its job is to join in the symphony of creation
00:26:33 to sing proper notes to God
00:26:35 that over time will manifest itself
00:26:38 as this symphony that's beautiful.
00:26:41 Okay, it may seem discordial
00:26:43 when you're right there in it,
00:26:44 but if you zoom back.
00:26:45 Like a good composer,
00:26:46 God is using the jarring notes to do something.
00:26:49 Right.
00:26:50 They're not meaningless.
00:26:51 This is Tolkien.
00:26:52 Yeah, again, in Tolkien,
00:26:54 it's important to see Tolkien and Lewis and everybody else who has riffed on this idea,
00:27:00 they are riffing in on something that is biblical. They're riffing on something God actually did in
00:27:05 the world, hence why they're good stories. It's because they're echoing the story God is actually
00:27:09 telling in history. Judges 5.19 says that the stars fought against Cicera. Many, many examples.
00:27:16 But it's also a song. And so you're supposed to think, wow, the stars fought against us. Job 38,
00:27:21 God is asking Job, where were you
00:27:23 when I laid the foundations of the earth?
00:27:24 When the sons of God sang with the stars of the dawn.
00:27:29 That was before the stars were even made.
00:27:31 Real quick question.
00:27:32 So James B. Jordan talks about this,
00:27:34 but the sky was more active,
00:27:37 not just more visible because of not,
00:27:39 you know, big cities and lights and pollution
00:27:41 or this or that.
00:27:42 So certainly more visible. 0.83
00:27:43 Abraham goes out.
00:27:43 I mean, it's just like, bam, that's a lot of stars.
00:27:46 More visible, but actually more active.
00:27:48 So like Psalm 19, the, you know, the sky pours forth speech and there's the setting of the sun
00:27:54 and clouds and things like that. But when you think of like the Greeks, for instance, I mean,
00:28:00 they're surrounded, everybody's a barbarian except for them, you know, and whether or not they had
00:28:04 Moses, right? But, but another hypothesis is, you know, so maybe they actually had special revelation
00:28:11 and not just natural revelation. God has two books, you know, like special and natural. But
00:28:16 one argument is that God like actually was speaking more actively through the skies,
00:28:22 especially astronomy and the stars leading up to the birth of Christ, where we have another
00:28:28 star moving significant. And that it's not just like, we read that and it's like, but it's like,
00:28:34 no, stars actually moved more than they do now. Like that was actually a thing. And then big
00:28:40 movement, people knew. The Magi were paying attention. They were paying attention. They 0.77
00:28:46 Exactly. And that they weren't necessarily regenerate. Maybe they were, maybe they weren't,
00:28:50 but they knew how to read the book of natural revelation. And the book of natural revelation
00:28:56 until, here's the whole point, until the completion of the book of special revelation
00:29:00 in God's grace and kindness, the book of natural revelation spoke more clearly than it does now,
00:29:05 because there's an expectation of God to believe his prophets, to believe the final word, which is
00:29:11 his son in these last days. But long ago, he spoke to our fathers, you know, in many ways,
00:29:16 many ways. But now he's spoken to us through his son. And so the same kind of argument that you
00:29:21 would make for cessationism and saying like, well, I don't know if the gift of prophecy is,
00:29:25 you know, continuing in the way that, you know, blah, blah, blah. Same thing like, and also
00:29:30 stars used to dance and now they're a little bit more still. What do you think about that?
00:29:36 I think that it makes sense. And I think that there's a really good reason for it.
00:29:39 And I think that Jesus, well, yes, but also since the enlightenment, we've been in a 300 year
00:29:46 decline where we have sought to muzzle the song of creation. You're right. Yeah. So our ears have
00:29:51 grown hard like our hearts. You're right. Yes. But we've also tried to silence the sky. You're
00:29:57 right. And so we've made a bunch of pollution that makes it harder to see. Yeah. Spiritual,
00:30:02 moral pollution. And that fogged ourselves. And the point is that matters. Yeah. And that matters.
00:30:07 that actually has more to do spiritually
00:30:10 than a lot of people give me credit for.
00:30:11 I don't know if I'd be comfortable
00:30:12 saying that the book of nature speaks less clearly.
00:30:15 I think there might be ways that,
00:30:17 like for example,
00:30:18 I don't know if I'd be comfortable,
00:30:20 and maybe I'd have to read the whole argument,
00:30:21 to say that one could not learn
00:30:26 to read those things just as clearly.
00:30:30 Well, yes, sir.
00:30:31 I guess the distinction would be that-
00:30:33 You see it today with animals and marriage.
00:30:35 It's not to say that nature doesn't still speak.
00:30:36 I would just say that the distinction is that the greatest event in history, like you said,
00:30:41 I do agree with that, was taking place.
00:30:43 It reminds me of Caspian and Prince Caspian when they're talking about,
00:30:48 or actually, I'm sorry, the last battle,
00:30:49 when the centaurs are talking about the portents and things in the skies.
00:30:54 And this is a very Disby view, kind of default Disby view that Lewis is putting forward.
00:30:59 Feel free to leave it out.
00:31:00 At the end.
00:31:00 But he's saying that all of the worst portents have been in the sky
00:31:06 for years now,
00:31:07 and they've been developing towards this.
00:31:09 They were reading it.
00:31:11 So was it more active
00:31:12 or was it just that the message was so great
00:31:15 that all of the biggest announcements were happening?
00:31:20 The biggest event in history is taking place.
00:31:21 So everything's coming together and saying,
00:31:23 but I think part of it like Jordan is trying to get at
00:31:26 is saying that not even just towards the event
00:31:29 and the importance of the event,
00:31:30 but just saying that because we have this conception
00:31:33 that a lot of times we think God is only doing something
00:31:36 under the old covenant, before the coming of Christ,
00:31:39 he was only doing something with his covenant people, Israel. 0.72
00:31:42 And the rest of the world was just damned. 0.96
00:31:44 They were just SOL.
00:31:48 It's like, okay, but I mean, Nineveh, an entire city,
00:31:51 arguably 120 to 500,000 people coming in one foul swoop.
00:31:55 The men of Nineveh will rise up on the day of judgment.
00:31:57 It seems like that's regeneration.
00:31:59 They're saved and all of them might want to hold onto that.
00:32:02 That's not just a Rahab or a Ruth.
00:32:04 That's like 500,000. 0.55
00:32:05 And the horse they came in on.
00:32:07 Yeah, so that's like 500,000 people coming to faith.
00:32:10 And then beyond that, and that's through special revelation
00:32:12 because that was a prophet speaking,
00:32:13 that's Jonah, going, word of the Lord.
00:32:15 But basically I think what's trying to be communicated
00:32:18 with this view is just emphasizing the mercy of God.
00:32:22 That even before the completion of special revelation,
00:32:24 the scripture, and even before the covenantal change 0.52
00:32:28 and grafting in of Gentiles and those kinds of things,
00:32:31 that God still was saving Old Testament saints
00:32:35 even outside of Israel
00:32:37 and even some that weren't included
00:32:41 in the biblical record.
00:32:42 There could be an entire nation
00:32:43 that was saved in 1500 BC
00:32:46 that we don't even know about.
00:32:47 The Bible doesn't contain everything that happened.
00:32:50 Right.
00:32:50 God left some of the story.
00:32:52 Like there are parts of it that we'll learn eventually.
00:32:55 I mean, I hope that Noah's we're fully known
00:32:57 means that we'll get to see
00:32:59 that we'll get to do what Gandalf did
00:33:00 and going into the vaults in Gondor
00:33:03 and looking through all the scrolls.
00:33:05 Like we'll get to read the story of this tribe
00:33:07 in ancient South America that no one knew about but God.
00:33:11 And he did some miraculous.
00:33:15 But to think that God's doing that through nature,
00:33:17 but to think also that this preterate natural fairy
00:33:21 is maybe that that's part of his role.
00:33:25 That's just a really compelling.
00:33:26 Emphasis on his.
00:33:27 Yeah. 0.97
00:33:28 All male.
00:33:29 but river daughters. No, it's a really compelling view to me. I think that when you look at nature
00:33:38 with an honest eye, it's difficult not to see how even the most material of things like a rock on
00:33:45 the side of the road is in the tapestry with spiritual things. Like a whole framework for me
00:33:52 is what Bob Vink says. I mentioned it in one of the other episodes in his book, Christianity and
00:33:57 science, that every single thing we see is pointing us towards something unseen. He's not just
00:34:03 blowing smoke when he says that. He's being a Christian because every single thing that we
00:34:08 engage in is engaged in the midst of an unseen realm and an eternity that matters. And so the
00:34:17 stakes are high. And if the stakes are that high, then it would make sense that God, you know, in
00:34:22 he loves to use servants to accomplish his will. I mean, we exist, for example. Angels exist. We
00:34:29 know that. And so why would there not be some kind of preternatural category that is over
00:34:35 geographic areas to ensure that God's decree is carried out and they're there because God just
00:34:40 likes them? He likes to see people obeying him. He likes to see people delighting in how he delights
00:34:45 in himself. We know that this is true. And so you can go, I think, too far with that. You can say
00:34:51 like, well, the river started speaking to me and told me about Christ. I doubt it. No, but I doubt
00:34:57 it. But, but there could, but there could very well be a sense in which when you're in a place
00:35:02 and you feel an existential dread, or on the flip side, you feel some amount of peace that
00:35:08 seems to be really nice and something that you really need. Maybe you should just pause and pay
00:35:12 attention. All of creation. And there's a temptation for us to reduce this to purely
00:35:17 anthropomorphic analogy. All of creation praises God. Read Psalm 148. The clouds, the fire, the
00:35:24 hail, the snow, the cedar trees, the dragons, everything in creation is commanded to praise
00:35:29 God. Wild winds that do his word. They not only praise God, but they accomplish his will.
00:35:35 And again, many times it's attributing to them the ability to do that. And kind of the modern
00:35:43 in me wants to reduce that down to just saying, well, it's, it's praising God by doing what it
00:35:48 was supposed to do. Like it's when the wind is blowing and that's what it's supposed to do.
00:35:51 There's no like knowledge in it or there's no nothing, you know, nothing like that.
00:35:54 It's the glory of fulfilling your purpose.
00:35:56 Doing the thing that you were created to be and do. And I think that's certainly true regardless,
00:36:00 but this, what you're saying also allows for the possibility that here we have servants of God
00:36:06 who are going and mediating his will and ensuring in the winds that the things actually do what
00:36:12 a fairy that's like the trees really are
00:36:14 worshiping God on a windy day
00:36:16 but then there's a conductor 0.76
00:36:18 that's a fairy
00:36:20 he's over that group
00:36:22 he's the first chair in the string section
00:36:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson by the way right now
00:36:26 is about to pop like Kool-Aid
00:36:28 and just be like
00:36:30 oh yeah you think that
00:36:32 winds are just
00:36:34 high pressure areas moving through the fluid
00:36:36 of the atmosphere
00:36:37 but hell is
00:36:40 Common Neil deGrasse Tyson.
00:36:42 Hell's hot.
00:36:43 I'll say this.
00:36:44 It's easier to conceive of something like this
00:36:47 in the realm of the celestial, I think.
00:36:49 Because it's so far, we think it's out there.
00:36:51 We think it's so far removed from us.
00:36:53 We know that the stars are meant to praise the Lord
00:36:58 and that the sky pours out praise.
00:37:00 But we also know that some stars are fallen
00:37:03 in the sense that they're worshiped.
00:37:06 We read this in Amos where it says 0.82
00:37:08 that you gave up your God for Molech and his star, Rephin. And then Stephen repeats that in his 0.54
00:37:15 sermon to the Sanhedrin in the book of Acts, chapter seven. There's a multiple. Yeah, there's
00:37:20 but they all, they're referencing the same thing. And that's that Molech, this fallen God has a 0.94
00:37:25 servant and one of his servants is a star. And so they're worshiping the celestial host. So some of 0.63
00:37:32 them maybe are fallen, but certainly not most of them, or certainly not all of them, it would be
00:37:37 of remnant. And so I think, yeah, a third. So I think that you can have the same thing here on
00:37:42 earth where some of them maybe fell, some of them didn't. But it's really easy to draw that
00:37:48 conclusion about the stars, at least conceptually, where you are meant to think that way.
00:37:52 So system-wise, I can't help it, but like, so you have heavenly creatures and they're all
00:37:58 creatures. God alone is the creator, heavenly creatures. And some of them are, you could call
00:38:02 angels in a loose term, but there are angel angels, messenger angels, and anytime they're
00:38:08 sighted, they look a lot like us. Gabriel, you know, they interact with us. Anytime they're
00:38:13 sighted, you know, earthly visitations, but their abode is still heaven. Man facing God in terms of
00:38:18 allegiance, but man facing in terms of duty and role and those kinds of things, ministering spirits
00:38:24 to aid men, those who are to inherit salvation. So that's angel angels under this heavenly
00:38:30 classification or a heavenly type of, of heavenly creature. And then there's also in, in that
00:38:37 category, cherubim, seraphim, four living creatures, and this would be higher classes, higher, but not
00:38:43 necessarily man facing, but very much God facing, holy, holy, holy, guarding the holiness of God,
00:38:49 guarding, you know, all these different things. But then we're saying some of those that were
00:38:55 heaven was their abode fell watchers and arguably others, but watchers fell. And then, so then you
00:39:02 have that category of fallen heavenly angels. Then you have the category of their offspring
00:39:07 with the daughters of men, Nephilim, who died, but now disembodied spirits. And often that's 0.81
00:39:12 what we think of when we think of a demon. They can be sent into the pit, but are bound to the
00:39:17 earth. Right. Bound to the earth for now. And so you have Nephilim disembodied spirits,
00:39:22 the disembodied spirits of the Nephilim
00:39:24 who are physically now dead. 0.97
00:39:26 God wiped them out, but whatever, and still roaming.
00:39:31 And then the watchers who fell,
00:39:33 some of them locked in gloomy dungeons who did the deed.
00:39:36 Arguably some fallen watchers, angels, heavenly angels
00:39:38 who did not do the deed of taking the daughters of men 0.74
00:39:42 and created the Nephilim. 0.61
00:39:43 And so you have Nephilim disembodied spirits on earth,
00:39:46 maybe some watchers that have not been locked
00:39:48 in gloomy dungeons wandering on earth.
00:39:50 And then this last category of still angelic in the sense of it's not human beings.
00:39:57 It's an angelic creature, but earthly abode.
00:40:01 That's where the fairy thing comes in.
00:40:02 And with them, same as the heaven ones.
00:40:04 Some fell, some didn't.
00:40:05 And with these, some fell, some didn't.
00:40:07 And we're saying, if anything, probably a minority fell, right?
00:40:11 And if we're counting the stars, that a lot of these stars are not fallen.
00:40:16 And they were created to specifically govern over the physical processes of God's creation.
00:40:23 Yeah, create a cosmos to orchestrate it in its duty, its glory, to worship.
00:40:29 Real quick, before we continue with the show,
00:40:31 you need to be aware that you're merely watching one episode
00:40:34 of what's actually a 10-part series covering all things under the banner of high strangeness.
00:40:41 The 10 episodes include the following.
00:40:43 Number one, the lost city of Atlantis has just recently been discovered.
00:40:48 Episode number two, Hollow Earth, the last living dragons and primary water.
00:40:54 Episode number three, biblical giants, their clans, sizes, and supernatural abilities.
00:41:01 Episode number four, mythological giants.
00:41:04 Hercules was actually a Nephilim.
00:41:07 Episode number five, everyone has been wrong about Bigfoot.
00:41:11 episode number six fairies the elemental spirits episode number seven the biblical case for the
00:41:18 existence of mermaids episode number eight ghost that's not your grandma that's a demon episode
00:41:26 number nine witches necromancy and familiar spirits and lastly episode 10 angels their
00:41:34 classifications physicality and sexes now all 10 of these episodes are available ad free right now
00:41:44 exclusively on patreon these episodes are only dropping one at a time over a series of multiple
00:41:51 weeks but you can get them all available today ad free plus the addition of two exclusive bonus
00:42:00 episodes at patreon.com forward slash right response ministries again it's exclusively found
00:42:08 at patreon.com forward slash right response ministries go and check them out today and now
00:42:16 back to our program a key distinction would be i do think 100 true i think that they are
00:42:23 they've got it i mean confirmed full sense i think that they're heavenly beings thanks for tuning in
00:42:27 No, you're good.
00:42:29 I think they're just like the rest of the angelic hosts,
00:42:33 heavenly beings.
00:42:35 But I think because of the role they've been given,
00:42:37 we perceive them as preternatural.
00:42:39 And we're not wrong to do that.
00:42:41 Perception is reality for us.
00:42:42 We don't have the mind of God or the eyes of God.
00:42:44 We have the mind and eyes of men.
00:42:46 So I think that we're right to view them as preternatural,
00:42:49 towing the line.
00:42:51 But I think that in their actual nature,
00:42:52 they are heavenly beings.
00:42:53 They're supernatural.
00:42:54 That are taking on this.
00:42:55 Yeah, they're supernatural,
00:42:56 role, but they're taking on this role. Much like, I mean, much like the Ainu in Middle Earth. 0.98
00:43:01 Yeah. Like that is, you know. It's a similar. It's fictional, but it's a good way to conceive 0.99
00:43:06 of it where they have been given this role. And so they take on this role by also assuming some
00:43:12 of the raiment of the world. Like the Maiar. Yeah. So I think that view, going back to your 1.00
00:43:19 very first question, Joel, of this, okay, what can we say? What are the categories? Again,
00:43:24 the biblical data doesn't tell us everything, doesn't purport to, and we're never going to
00:43:29 say something contrary to, which is why we would rule out several of these beliefs that have
00:43:33 existed. You saw me shaking my head. There's this one. I was like, oh, no to that. You can't do it
00:43:39 because the scriptures close the door. This is one where work needs to be done. At least someone
00:43:45 could make a biblical argument that this is ruled out and we would hear it. But to my knowledge now,
00:43:51 it's not ruled out. Like this is something that's possible. It explains a lot of these
00:43:55 sightings that people have or a lot of the folklore and tradition, just like we're saying
00:44:00 the Nephilim and the Watchers in Genesis 6 explains a lot of history and mythology in the
00:44:06 world, even with ancient through to modern. Demigods. Yeah. So this is another category like
00:44:14 that where we're saying here's a way of understanding the history of mythology of
00:44:19 the world through a category that is biblically possible. And we're not going to come down and
00:44:25 say, you know, bind someone's conscience and say like, we're going to add this. This is now going
00:44:30 to be a chapter in the systematic theology on the level of theology proper. It's like, absolutely
00:44:34 not. This is glory of kings to search things out. What we're trying to do is we're making exactly
00:44:38 what you said, making sense of the world, making sense of narratives that you found in cultures
00:44:43 all over the planet before they even had supposedly interaction with one another.
00:44:47 and instead of doing the typical materialistic,
00:44:50 secular, humanistic, Darwinian, arrogant thing 1.00
00:44:54 and saying, that's all stupid 1.00
00:44:55 and we're the first generation of human beings 1.00
00:44:57 to ever been born that are intelligent.
00:45:00 We're not gonna do that.
00:45:01 And then saying, it's nothing. 1.00
00:45:03 It's nothing and you're dumb. 1.00
00:45:04 And then also not saying 1.00
00:45:05 everything the ancients ever said, full send.
00:45:08 Although if I had to choose hard press between the two,
00:45:11 probably everything the ancients said.
00:45:14 Hard press.
00:45:14 But what we're trying to do is say no to modernism
00:45:20 and then materialism,
00:45:22 but then also no to untethered spirit,
00:45:25 Gnosticism, spiritualism.
00:45:27 We're not mystics.
00:45:27 We don't wanna fall in any ditch.
00:45:29 And so we're trying to say,
00:45:31 there's probably something true there in Greek mythology, 1.00
00:45:34 but probably shouldn't trust the Greeks 100%. 0.99
00:45:36 It's garbled. 1.00
00:45:37 And so take, but let's see.
00:45:39 And then what does the Bible actually,
00:45:41 where do we, what portions of this
00:45:43 we also find in scripture, oh, we found, okay, this is legit. This is probably true.
00:45:48 This categorical thinking is-
00:45:51 And they're not binding the conscience.
00:45:52 No, no.
00:45:52 But you can believe in this and it could be right.
00:45:54 It's a way to attempt to walk along, walk in the pasture that orthodoxy fences in.
00:46:02 Yeah.
00:46:03 You know, walk in the pasture of your confession is what I like to tell people. So the confession
00:46:07 is a fence.
00:46:08 Don't hop the fence.
00:46:09 You love the fence.
00:46:10 Right.
00:46:10 You don't try to ruin the fence. You don't try to go beyond it.
00:46:12 you love the fence when you reach it. But within the fence, there's a rich, fertile field that you
00:46:16 can walk around and explore in. And I think that because we've, for hundreds of years now, let this
00:46:22 whole category go, that it's actually really rich. And so I'm just saying, let's just go graze over
00:46:27 there and see what there is. And you find that there's many ways to reconcile this idea that
00:46:34 the ancients had with scripture in such a way that you don't break any of the rules. But then also in
00:46:40 a way that seems to tie in really nicely with the whole tenor of creation. Yeah. Right. That
00:46:44 everything has its purpose and its place and its part to play. And not only that, but it's governed.
00:46:49 It's governed. It's all governed. It's not, and it's not just governed in a floaty way of, well,
00:46:54 God decreed it. It's not governed directly by God as the direct authority overall. God appoints
00:47:00 governors. Like I, I am doing things that I'm doing because God decreed it, but I'm also doing
00:47:05 things that I'm doing because I'm a man who's governed. I'm governed by my parents. I'm governed
00:47:10 by my boss. I govern my kids, but they're still doing everything God decreed. So this is just
00:47:17 trying to work out a way to fit in everything to the natural tenor of creation while also not
00:47:23 completely discrediting most of human history as nonsense. I think a great way to end this episode,
00:47:29 Joel, if I could be so bold, would be just with a story of one of these type of fairy
00:47:35 incidents that will because we haven't actually talked a lot about these that's true let's end
00:47:38 it like that here's another great way to end this episode uh encouraging the listener to join on
00:47:45 patreon you can watch some of the bonus episodes you can watch the other because everything we're
00:47:49 talking about you got to watch the angel episode as we're talking there's a lot in the angel episode
00:47:53 and the bigfoot episode gives you a precursor to fairies yeah um but you definitely need to because
00:47:59 we covered some of the angel stuff but not in the depth and there's some missing pieces that are
00:48:03 vital uh that we did in the particular angel episode so you got to check out that and one
00:48:07 more that i might i might uh so humbly suggest mermaids oh yes because we're talking about some
00:48:14 of these these missing cat mermaids actually answers some questions and brings up some
00:48:19 fascinating new ones and i know that one sounds weird but within the christian framework and
00:48:24 like there might be something there it's definitely worth checking out yeah i i do i'm fascinated by
00:48:29 mermaids. Joel loves mermaids. Yep. So all that being said, and then lastly, so join us on Patreon.
00:48:34 It's just Patreon, right, you know, slash Patreon.com slash RightResponseMinistries.com,
00:48:41 but then also subscribe to our channel, but then go to Haunted Cosmos on YouTube. Subscribe to them.
00:48:47 Is there something specific that they should go to? Yeah. Haunted, you search Haunted Cosmos on
00:48:50 YouTube. Okay. If you go to The Haunted Cosmos. Smash the subscribe, smash the like button.
00:48:54 Seriously, subscribe to their channel.
00:48:56 Subscribe to us on podcast.
00:48:57 Hit the bell on both.
00:48:58 Hit the bell.
00:48:59 We're releasing it.
00:49:00 This is going to be coming out.
00:49:01 We'll have a full episode on fairies in this season. 1.00
00:49:04 Awesome. 1.00
00:49:04 Along with many other,
00:49:06 we've dealt with ocean mysteries.
00:49:09 We've dealt with ghosts, Bigfoot, demon, you know,
00:49:12 many of these things,
00:49:13 more than 20 episodes, main episodes.
00:49:15 And we also have a Patreon series
00:49:17 where we have more than 70 episodes
00:49:19 called The Dusty Tome
00:49:20 that's just for our patrons there
00:49:22 and make our show possible.
00:49:22 It's a weekly show only for the patrons.
00:49:24 Yeah. And it's, it's really, really tremendously well done. Ben, Ben does the heavy lifting on
00:49:28 the Dusty Tome and I think everybody would enjoy it. If you enjoy this conversation,
00:49:33 you know, you definitely enjoy those. Okay. Fairy time. Fairy story. So, so this is a story that
00:49:39 comes from a region where you get lots of these kinds of stories, which is among the native North
00:49:44 Americans in Delaware, Massachusetts kind of region. I think it's the Wampanoag is the name
00:49:49 of the tribe. And I might be pronouncing that wrong, but they have a conception of like a two
00:49:54 to three foot tall sort of trickster entity called the Pukwudgie. And they believe in this for 0.98
00:50:01 centuries before oral tradition, many stories of this being that would attempt to lure you into
00:50:06 the woods or trick you into coming into their domain and sometimes doing you harm. Okay. So
00:50:13 So there's this story that's in the background. And then there was a gentleman who in modern
00:50:19 times, not that long ago, he was in this area of the United States and got a job where like
00:50:25 many of us in our youth, he was working swing shifts, that three to 11, three to midnight
00:50:30 kind of shift. And so he would get off of his job very late at night. And that was kind of when he
00:50:38 was, he's going to go do all the things we'd normally do at 6 PM or in the morning. He's
00:50:42 walking his dog. He's going on a run, whatever he's doing. So one night he'd taken his dog out
00:50:48 for a walk at close, you know, right around midnight. And he's walking along a path, you know,
00:50:54 just kind of a foresty area around this mixture between urban, suburban, and foresty. And all of
00:51:00 a sudden he, and I can't remember the exact order, but it's something like he feels a sense of dread.
00:51:05 Like there's something wrong. He starts to hear noises and then even voices in the woods.
00:51:11 and his dog is...
00:51:14 That's classic.
00:51:15 Yeah.
00:51:15 The dog can see the goat.
00:51:17 You know, the dog is...
00:51:18 Right.
00:51:18 The dog's like... 0.99
00:51:19 Like Balaam's donkey. 0.99
00:51:21 Hackles her up. 0.99
00:51:22 Balaam's donkey moment
00:51:23 with his golden retriever
00:51:24 or whatever it is.
00:51:25 And the dog is disturbed
00:51:27 when he sees
00:51:29 this little silhouetted creature
00:51:32 come up at the edge of the woods.
00:51:35 He can see it.
00:51:36 And it's about two to three feet tall.
00:51:38 Trollish kind of thing.
00:51:40 And it says...
00:51:41 I want to, I want to, and he's like, no idea what this is.
00:51:47 Of course, freaked out, leaves, you know, and he just can't stop thinking of, of course,
00:51:53 can't stop thinking about this.
00:51:54 Right.
00:51:55 And he finally, he, he's like, what was it saying?
00:51:58 What was it trying to get at?
00:52:00 And he's not certain, but as the story goes, his conclusion that what it was saying is,
00:52:06 we want you, we want you, trying to get him to go into the woods.
00:52:11 Okay, whether or not that's true or whatever,
00:52:15 eyewitness again type of testimony.
00:52:17 But this is exactly the type of thing we're talking about
00:52:19 where you have the trickster.
00:52:20 This is the kind of story.
00:52:21 Yep.
00:52:22 Trickster entity and this, you know, changelings,
00:52:26 the meeling, there's so many of these types of stories
00:52:29 that we could get into, but we're not going to
00:52:31 because we're out of time.
00:52:32 Yep.
00:52:33 But we're about to record another episode for another week,
00:52:36 which you could watch now if you join Patreon,
00:52:38 but the next one's going to be witches. 0.91
00:52:40 And witches get stitches. 1.00
00:52:41 witches get stitches. Thanks for tuning in. Real quick, right here at the end, I just wanted to 1.00
00:52:46 remind you to become a member at patreon.com forward slash right response ministries exclusively
00:52:52 for our Patreon members. We have all 10 episodes, early access, ad free. Some of my favorite
00:52:59 episodes to be looking forward to is episodes that deal with Bigfoot or fairies or ghost or angels
00:53:05 or giants, or particularly our episode on witches. If you want to watch these episodes now,
00:53:11 and you want to watch them without any ads,
00:53:13 then you've got to join us by becoming a member
00:53:16 at patreon.com forward slash Right Response Ministries.