The NXR Podcast - August 23, 2024


THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Scientology | EP 8 with @TheCultishShow

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Does Christian Nationalism Have A Racism Problem? - Live with Eric Conn THE INTERVIEW - The Fifth Commandment with Eric Conn

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 13 minutes

Words per minute

180.21

Word count

13,291

Sentence count

722

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

16

sentences flagged

Hate speech

55

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Scientology is a religious movement founded by science fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard in the early 1950s. It is based on Hubbard s teachings and a set of doctrines outlined in his writing, particularly in Dianetics, the modern science of mental health, published in 1950. Through auditing, as well as other Scientology practices, followers seek to free themselves from spiritual limitations and achieve higher levels of awareness and ability. The Church of Scientology, founded in 1953, continues to serve as a central organization for the dissemination and practice of Scientology beliefs.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Scientology is a religious movement founded by science fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard in the early 1950s.
00:00:07 It is based on Hubbard's teachings and a set of doctrines outlined in his writing, particularly in his book
00:00:13 Dianetics, the Modern Science of Mental Health, published in 1950.
00:00:18 Central to Scientology is the concept of auditing, a form of spiritual counseling
00:00:23 aimed at helping individuals overcome past traumas, known as engrams,
00:00:28 and achieve spiritual enlightenment. Auditing often involves the use of an electronic device
00:00:33 known as an e-meter, which is believed to measure a person's mental state and can help identify
00:00:40 areas of spiritual distress. Scientology teaches that humans are immortal beings called thetans
00:00:46 who have forgotten their true and spiritual potential. Through auditing, as well as other
00:00:52 Scientology practices, followers seek to free themselves from spiritual limitations and achieve
00:00:57 higher levels of awareness and ability. The Church of Scientology, founded in 1953,
00:01:04 continues to serve as a central organization for the dissemination and practice of Scientology
00:01:10 beliefs. Scientology, that's our episode for today. Go ahead and kick us off. I mean, Scientology,
00:01:23 did you guys ever watch uh in the clear going clear going clear yes yeah i thought it was that
00:01:29 was my first sort of introduction to uh the the that world and man what a crazy world right that
00:01:36 it is it really what what that kind of the history of exposés on scientology it kind of shows
00:01:43 you know people had limited information in the 1950s as far as how information could be
00:01:49 disseminated. You had the major news networks, things like that. And as time progressed, you had
00:01:56 in the 1970s, you had, you know, cult awareness groups really starting to spawn out where it's
00:02:01 kind of really grassroots movements of people communicating because you had at a time a lot
00:02:07 of young people in the wake of the sexual revolution and kind of the hippie movement of
00:02:13 just the rebelliousness of that time period of just getting sucked into all sorts of different
00:02:18 movements specifically in California and so that's where you had a lot of you know the cult
00:02:22 awareness network you had a lot of the people who are doing um like almost like kidnappings you call
00:02:29 like cult interventions or cult deprogrammings and so there was this huge sort of grassroots
00:02:34 movement and then the internet came along and that's where a lot of Scientology began to truly
00:02:40 be exposed and now people who are leaving Scientology now had a place to go uh to hear
00:02:46 their voice. And now you've seen it with documentaries like Going Clear. You've seen
00:02:52 there was a recent series that came out several years ago with Leah Remini from the King of
00:02:57 Queens, who was a former Scientologist called Scientology the Aftermath, where it was a really
00:03:01 opportunity to where, while it wasn't a Christian show, they did a really good job really documenting
00:03:08 the abuses of Scientology. It was co-hosted by Leah Remini and Mike Rinder, who's a former
00:03:14 spokesperson for Scientology. So really, in many ways, Scientology is a case study
00:03:20 for a historical cult, a very recent cult in contrast to Mormonism or Jehovah's Witnesses
00:03:27 that started very recent here in the 1950s. And it's very much a case study of what once
00:03:35 was done in secret will now be shattered from the rooftops, i.e. now Twitter, Facebook, X. And so
00:03:42 So what you really have now, which once was a very surging organization that really had a grassroots move and interest in its growth, was growing quite heavily.
00:03:51 It's now very much dwindling.
00:03:54 And the only really thing that's happening right now as far as Scientology growth is really them having to do stuff with their funds.
00:04:04 So it's really just a lot of them continuing to build buildings, facilities, things like that, that are empty.
00:04:12 So it's sort of becoming an empty shell of itself in a sense.
00:04:15 So, yeah, it's a very, there are many layers to the story of Scientology,
00:04:19 but they're definitely, when people think of a cult,
00:04:23 Scientology is one of the definitive ones coming to mind
00:04:25 because, of course, you have major celebrities like John Travolta and Tom Cruise,
00:04:30 who had, they have a notable history with Scientology.
00:04:34 So I'm really excited to unpack this.
00:04:36 Yeah, people, when they think about Scientology, they also think about South Park.
00:04:39 Yes.
00:04:39 You know what I mean?
00:04:40 South Park did wonderful episodes on Mormonism, but they also did some pretty funny ones on Scientology.
00:04:45 You may be like, oh, man, Andrew, you're a Christian.
00:04:47 You're referencing South Park.
00:04:48 Hey, at your discretion, if you want to watch the Scientology episode on South Park, go ahead.
00:04:52 They do actually have a really good explanation of Scientology.
00:04:56 But L. Ron Hubbard is the founder of Scientology. 0.96
00:05:00 And L. Ron Hubbard, when I think about him, I think of a pathological liar.
00:05:04 And who better to create, quote-unquote, a religion than somebody who writes many science fiction books prior to even—
00:05:11 Isn't that funny that he started his own religion, but he was formerly a fiction novelist?
00:05:17 Yeah, and I think he was very pragmatic, right?
00:05:19 So when he wrote Dianetics, what he was trying to do was combat Freudian psychology or psychology that was very prominent during that time.
00:05:29 He noticed that there was a need for people to talk to someone and tell them their problems.
00:05:33 So he goes and writes, Dianetics, you don't need to go to your psychologist.
00:05:39 Here it is.
00:05:39 We have the book, Dianetics, and Dianetics literally means it means through thought or
00:05:43 through the soul.
00:05:44 Let me give you an explanation of what Dianetics is about.
00:05:47 So mankind, according to Hubbard, is basically good and that the basic instinct for all people
00:05:53 is survival.
00:05:54 Man's environmental conditions and painful experiences result in failure.
00:05:58 So in Dianetics, L. Ron Hubbard breaks up the mind into three parts, the analytical mind, the reactive mind and the somatic mind.
00:06:06 So the analytical mind, it works as like a perfect computer and never makes a mistake.
00:06:11 So when we're talking about this, you'll notice how within Dianetics or in Scientology, the body is more of like a vessel for something called a thetan.
00:06:21 OK, so within this mind is also the reactive mind, and that holds mental images of pictures from the past, which are called engrams, right?
00:06:31 They're the source of aberrations or any type of psychosomatic illness.
00:06:35 Any mental illness that there could be is coming from some type of memory from the past or trauma, right? 0.97
00:06:41 So there's also reincarnation for these thetans here. 0.89
00:06:44 The somatic mind as well is the mind that keeps the body regulated and functioning by the analytical and reactive minds placing solutions to the effect on the physical level. 0.67
00:06:55 So we have the somatic mind, which is really just governing our body's functions, right?
00:07:01 So the issue within Scientology is that we have these engrams that are creating psychological problems and we must get rid of engrams.
00:07:10 And you mentioned it in that that open there that through the process of auditing through somebody who, you know, of course, you're paying for sessions.
00:07:20 Your type of psychiatrist, remember, he's trying to combat modern psychology, will help you find these engrams and rid yourself of these engrams.
00:07:30 And that is not done for free, right?
00:07:34 That's done for a price. 0.70
00:07:35 So before coming what they would call an operating thetan, which is someone who is rid of all of their engrams, you must become clear of your engrams, right? 0.94
00:07:48 So in Christian terms, we can almost think of engrams as of like sin, but it's his own redefinition of sin, right? 0.96
00:07:55 And so let me just look at the glasses here.
00:07:57 so before you can go clear there's about 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 almost 13 different classes
00:08:08 that you must take 13 different things you must pay for in order to become clear of all of your
00:08:16 n grams interesting stuff right yeah and all those all those classes you have to pay for them
00:08:23 yeah they all cost yeah and guess what if you can't pay for it what do you do what do you think
00:08:27 i don't know well you join the sea org so we actually have a solution for you our solution
00:08:33 is this uh you can sign something called the billion year contract and you will devote all
00:08:38 of your life all of your finances everything to scientology and what do you do in the sea org well
00:08:44 you can become an auditor how do you become an auditor well we got classes for that right well
00:08:48 if you don't want to be an auditor and you just want to pay for sessions guess what you can sign
00:08:51 people up go talk to your friends get them to hold two tin cans and talk about your problems and when
00:08:56 that meter blurs or moves
00:08:58 one direction, we can see that's an engram, and let's
00:09:00 help them get rid of their engrams. Yeah.
00:09:02 I want to backtrack just for a second.
00:09:04 When you talk about L. Ron Hubbard, we only briefly
00:09:06 mentioned about him being a science fiction author.
00:09:09 He, L. Ron Hubbard
00:09:10 actually holds the record
00:09:12 for the most amount of published works.
00:09:14 In fact, the Guinness World Record, public record,
00:09:16 the most amount of published works by
00:09:18 one author is
00:09:19 1084 by L. Ron Hubbard,
00:09:22 who first work was published in
00:09:24 February 1934 and last in March of 2006 which that was published after his passing but he holds
00:09:30 the Guinness World Record so really he wrote the most amount of science fiction of any science
00:09:35 fiction anybody who's a writer of science fiction he's published the most amount ever and then when
00:09:42 it comes to Dianetics the one thing that I think would be important to understand is that he
00:09:47 he truly believed like what he was writing now he did have motivation I think financially he
00:09:54 had many different motivations but what he wrote down he truly believed and he submitted it to a
00:09:59 lot of different boards of psychological boards with confidence saying this is going to be really
00:10:04 accepted and it was basically became a laughing stock and his you know he definitely his ego was
00:10:10 definitely hurt by that but really what ended up happening is that Dianetics sort of it became kind
00:10:15 of like a viral post right you may know a thing or two about viral posts right so he uh it really
00:10:21 there became all these like groups that people just got a hold of this book and was really no
00:10:28 help of his own besides from publishing it it became a new york times bestseller you had people
00:10:33 who are doing their own on their own accord um their own uh dianetics classes it just it took
00:10:39 a life of its own so once old one hubbard got wake of this that's where it's like how do i central
00:10:46 how do I capture this momentum? And then there was the motivation, let me see if I can turn this
00:10:52 into a religion. So it wasn't the religion at first, then I'll publish Dianetics. It came about
00:10:57 of it really going viral by just people at that time when it was published, just getting a hold
00:11:04 of it on their own accord. And that's where you see that. And again, one of the motivations for
00:11:10 Alon Hubbard was money. And the one appeal of creating it into a religion was that he could
00:11:17 get tax exempt status. He would fall into the category of a religion. So that's, uh, that's a
00:11:24 definitely a very interesting component that really became a catalyst to him to kind of build
00:11:29 all these other, um, you know, moving integral parts when it came to the E meters, the bridge
00:11:35 to total freedom uh whether you are in ot3 uh you know all the way up to i believe the highest rank
00:11:41 is ot9 uh and that count and ot means operating thetan which is some of the descriptions uh that
00:11:50 was described in our opening sequence so and you want to do it go ahead yeah let me jump back to
00:11:54 you so in definitions of scientology a thetan is a timeless energy that reincarnates in interplanetary
00:12:01 life forms so the thetan would be what inhabits the analytical somatic and reactive mind right
00:12:09 to get rid of engrams to become an operating thetan one has the ability to manipulate matter
00:12:15 energy space in time so we can find that there's even occultic beliefs within uh scientology to
00:12:21 where once you have this supernatural uh ability you can manipulate the world around you because
00:12:29 the spirit supersedes matter, right? Scientology.org describes an operating thetan as someone like
00:12:35 this in quote, operating thetan is a state of spiritual awareness in which an individual is
00:12:40 able to control themselves and their environment. An OT is someone who knows that they know and can
00:12:45 create positive and pro survival effects on all their dynamics. They have been fully familiarized
00:12:51 with their capabilities as a thetan and can willingly and knowingly be at cause over life, 0.98
00:12:55 thought, matter, energy, space, and time. That's what an operating thetan is. But what you'll 0.75
00:13:01 notice is within this framework of these classes, we can find a similarity to NXIVM, right?
00:13:10 NXIVM, what was his name? Renier? John Renier? Something Renier. David Renier?
00:13:16 David Renier. Yeah, I think it was David Renier. What we can find is almost like an MLM structure
00:13:21 in terms of people being your product
00:13:26 and you must do this class or that class
00:13:29 and then you can actually have this control over your life.
00:13:31 You can make your life better in this way
00:13:33 or better in that way.
00:13:34 We know with NXIVM, 0.99
00:13:35 it became a really bad, horrible sex cult. 0.92
00:13:38 But within Scientology, it just took a different form. 0.86
00:13:42 But I think that David Rainier took lessons
00:13:44 from L. Ron Hubbard when creating NXIVM
00:13:46 in terms of being this self-help, self-achievement class.
00:13:50 But yeah, the goal is essentially to become an operating thetan, but that's not where it stops. Right. They had to keep making more and more and more. And even David Miscavige, who's the current leader of Scientology today, states that there's still some more classes that they're waiting for. Right. The bridge to total freedom is never completed. It's still being constructed. Point in being. Right. Well, I think it's actually Miscavige. Miscavige. There you go. Yeah. But it's, yeah, Miscavige. There's probably some people out there who would like call him that. 0.62
00:14:18 Oh, no, me for sure.
00:14:20 I remember I used to say instead of Aleister Crowley,
00:14:21 I kept going Aliester Crowley.
00:14:23 Oh, yeah.
00:14:23 Get corrected on that as well.
00:14:24 Well, I think we always have the YouTube comment section
00:14:26 to make sure we're always fully corrected.
00:14:28 That's where all the actuallys go.
00:14:30 Get rid of our engrams.
00:14:31 Yeah, anyways, there might be a YouTube comment section for that,
00:14:34 which I'll make sure not to read.
00:14:37 But feel free to fully express yourself there.
00:14:39 But, yeah, what you really end up seeing
00:14:42 is this very much a personal self-improvement type of cult.
00:14:48 structure. And what's very interesting, too, is that you kind of see at that time this sort of
00:14:54 attempt at re-enchantment, this idea of sort of blending in science, but also sort of giving a
00:15:04 supernatural, you know, spiritual element to it. So, that's where you think of, like, theology.
00:15:09 So, Scientology, you see, like, the blending of the material and the immaterial together.
00:15:14 and and so yeah and then you have um you know this continued progression um and you you will
00:15:22 what you'll end up seeing is that you know L. Ron Hubbard his gain what his motivation was uh
00:15:28 in many ways just financial and seeing the opportunity to be tax exempt he really spent
00:15:33 a majority of his life on the run uh just because of a lot of a lot of different shady dealings
00:15:39 a lot of it I think did have to deal with him believing he didn't have to pay the government
00:15:45 so when any of the reputation that L. Ron Hubbard has was always him on the boat you'll see when
00:15:51 you kind of look up L. Ron Hubbard you always see pictures of him sort of being the sea captain
00:15:55 one of the main reasons why is because he wanted to be in neutral territory where he could always
00:16:01 be evasive and evading the government so that's that's a big that's a big big part of it and what
00:16:07 you'll see consistently throughout the story of L. Ron Hubbard, and you think about, you know,
00:16:13 one thing leads to what goes around, comes around, is that there's always this continual,
00:16:20 like, physical abuse, that particularly there's something indicative within the nature and the
00:16:25 culture and the zeitgeist behind spirituality are those who physically, you know, abuse,
00:16:33 and also mentally and spiritually abuse their assailants.
00:16:38 And there's many ways in which that happened.
00:16:39 I think a great resource is not only the documentary
00:16:43 done by Lawrence Wright,
00:16:45 who's done a lot of really great works.
00:16:47 He's one of my favorite journalists.
00:16:50 It's both the documentary Going Clear,
00:16:52 but more particularly the book Going Clear.
00:16:55 And again, it's been a while since I've read the book,
00:16:58 but I believe he gathered a lot of just independent lines
00:17:01 of testimony and witness of even those who are on his ship uh do you remember the name of his ship
00:17:07 oh man i'll have to look it up look it up look it up but it's like there's times in which he would
00:17:13 not be happy with a particular performance with someone on his ship and would you know just throw
00:17:19 them overboard like just for kicks um and would do all sorts of ways and they would hold up and
00:17:24 they would swim back or he would straight up kill them i wouldn't kill them it was done in such a
00:17:30 way to just terrify and very much create a Stockholm syndrome. And who did this? L. Ron
00:17:36 Hubbard. Wow. L. Ron Hubbard. And so you'll see that. And then what ends up happening is that as
00:17:42 Scientology progressed, one of the persons who is up and coming who leads Scientology to this day
00:17:49 is David Miscavige. Now, David Miscavige's testimony is that he, I believe, grew up in
00:17:56 Scientology, or his parents were attracted to it, and that he had a lot of issues with asthma. His
00:18:01 claim is that the process of auditing actually helped cure him of his asthma, so he became a
00:18:09 true believer. What is fascinating, though, you think about somebody, you know, someone of a young
00:18:15 stature in their 20s acquiring great powers, happened all throughout history. There is a
00:18:21 moment in which L. Ron Hubbard passed away, where David Miscavige was in the right place
00:18:28 at the right time, where he essentially did a big power grab. He did an immediate audit of those who
00:18:35 were unequivocally loyal to him. Anybody who was nobly questionable about his decision making,
00:18:41 he went and just drove them out. And he did that with an iron fist. In fact, the comparison I
00:18:47 could think of. If anyone's followed, you know, the Iraq war or Saddam Hussein and his rights to
00:18:53 power, there's this very notable moment where he gathers all his military officials in. And you
00:18:58 can see the footage where all of a sudden, you know, he's there and all of a sudden you see
00:19:02 people who are grabbed and they're let out of the room and, uh, they are done with, they are just,
00:19:08 they are disposed of. It wasn't quite to that extent, but what you did see is that those who
00:19:14 were in any way questioning on any level, and again, David Miscavige would be the judge, jury,
00:19:20 and executioner of this, at least as far as excommunicating them from the Church of Scientology
00:19:26 would be just, you're done with. So, there is a part where he did a full, like, just cleansing
00:19:33 of anybody who was opposed to him, and so then, and that was, so after L. Ron Hubbard passed,
00:19:39 that's where dave miscavige took over and that's where scientology sort of took a different it
00:19:45 became sort of a different animal and a different uh beast per se as far as its involvement not only
00:19:51 with um the u.s government but also in relation to celebrities there's a lot of different aspects
00:19:57 do you have any commentary you want to give on that real quick before we continue with the show
00:20:00 i wanted to let you know that this is actually just one episode of a 10 part series that we will
00:20:06 be slowly releasing to the public on places like YouTube and your favorite podcast platform
00:20:13 over the coming months. However, if you want to get all 10 of these episodes right now early
00:20:20 access and ad-free, we are making them available exclusively for our Patreon members over at
00:20:27 patreon.com forward slash right response ministries. Here are the titles for just a few of those
00:20:34 episodes. We've got transhumanism and artificial intelligence. We also have DMT and the astral
00:20:42 realm. We also have neo-paganism. And another of my favorite episodes is an entire episode devoted
00:20:50 to the greys. So again, head on over to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries and sign
00:20:59 up for our silver tier which is just five dollars a month and you'll be able to get all 10 of these
00:21:04 episodes ad free right now and if you join us at the gold tier for just ten dollars a month you'll
00:21:12 get early access ad free for the full 10 episodes plus an additional live stream that i and the guys
00:21:20 who join me for this series that's jeremiah roberts and andrew suncrant the three of us will be doing
00:21:26 live streams where we'll be taking questions from you our gold tier patreon members and providing
00:21:32 for you the best answers that we possibly can from the word of god so don't delay go to patreon.com
00:21:39 forward slash right response ministries and become a supporter today in terms of thinking about
00:21:45 scientology i think what's really helpful for the christian is you can go read kingdom of the cults
00:21:50 Dr. Walter Martin does an excellent explanation of what L. Ron Hubbard taught about Jesus,
00:21:57 nature of God, and salvation. So one thing I do want to talk about quickly is what did
00:22:04 L. Ron Hubbard teach about Jesus Christ, right? So there's kind of like an evolution in thought
00:22:10 at first. L. Ron Hubbard was saying that Jesus Christ was just like a master, like a teacher,
00:22:15 great one, that he was just a level above clear, wasn't even God in the flesh, right?
00:22:20 So later it came to that Jesus Christ wasn't even actually a person.
00:22:25 He was just an engram that was implanted in thetans millions of years ago.
00:22:28 So you don't get...
00:22:30 He was bad.
00:22:32 Yeah, essentially, right?
00:22:33 Like he stops your bridge...
00:22:34 Engrams are bad, right?
00:22:35 Yeah, he's just a memory.
00:22:36 He's not even real.
00:22:38 He is a memory planted in thetans for millions of years ago. 0.98
00:22:42 But that's not even information you get until I think you're operating Thetan level three. 0.92
00:22:46 I could be wrong there, but it costs a lot of money to get that information. 0.75
00:22:50 That's very important information for them.
00:22:53 But to say this, we've talked about this before with Scientology is when we talk about this, it almost is like, wow, this is crazy.
00:23:00 How can anyone believe it?
00:23:01 But the truth is, is it's like a frog in boiling water.
00:23:04 Right. So they get you in and they're just slowly turning up the temperature.
00:23:08 And by the time that it's so hot, you can't move from the water.
00:23:12 You know, they've got all of your life in their hands.
00:23:16 So when we think about Christ and we're confessing our sin to Christ, it says he remembers our sins as far as the East is from the West.
00:23:23 We have forgiveness for our sins.
00:23:25 We don't stand condemned.
00:23:26 But within Scientology, which was Jerry was starting to explain here, we find that all of your sins and engrams are recorded and put inside shelves to be used against you at any time of need that they want.
00:23:39 Right?
00:23:40 Because you're going to an auditor.
00:23:41 you're telling this auditor of course all of your secrets typically it starts with memories from your
00:23:46 your past actually things that happened with you and then they'll try to help you go clear of those
00:23:51 events uh so well not just past past lives well that's what i was going to get to so first it 0.53
00:23:57 starts with your past and then it gets into your past lives remember you're you're a thetan so 0.77
00:24:02 you've been reincarnated or rebirthed multiple multiple times so within scientology your sins 0.85
00:24:09 or your engrams aren't um forgiven as far as the east is from the west no they're stored in a box
00:24:14 to be able to be used against you if you ever need to leave i mean we did an interview with
00:24:18 mike rinder uh who left scientology and what was his book called again um oh man i can't remember
00:24:26 why am i blanking on his book anyways awesome interview with him and he can give you a he gives
00:24:31 you a brief description of what it was like living within scientology and then when you're trying to
00:24:35 leave, they've got everything against you, right? Not only that, they have a policy. It's called
00:24:40 the fair game doctrine. And the fair game doctrine means that if you're trying to leave and you're
00:24:45 going to tarnish the works of Scientology, it's fair game. We can follow you. We can go to your
00:24:50 house. We can terrorize you. They won't kill you, right? But they'll go pretty far as to try to make 0.99
00:24:57 your life a living hell so that you don't tarnish the works and names of L. Ron Hubbard.
00:25:03 His book's called A Billion Years.
00:25:05 A Billion Years.
00:25:06 My Lifetime Inside Scientology.
00:25:08 Right.
00:25:09 Amazing book.
00:25:09 And think about how crazy it must be, okay, to, for Mike Rinder, for example, his parents
00:25:16 became Scientologists.
00:25:18 Well, what do you do with your children, right?
00:25:20 What do you do with your children if you were to join the Sea Org?
00:25:22 Jerry, give a brief explanation of what happens to the children of parents who are in the
00:25:26 Sea Org.
00:25:27 There, so this is an example, you know, we have a slogan, you know, that's, that we've,
00:25:32 it's been kind of our popular uh t-shirt that we've had called bad theology hurts people
00:25:36 how the underlying presuppositions of scientology that children are no different than adults they
00:25:45 are adults trapped in humans bodies so when so basically children are just taught are viewed no
00:25:54 different than adults so there are many times because of the fact that the parents are committed
00:25:59 to being in the Sea Org and to give their unequivocal life at that time to Scientology,
00:26:06 there are many times, and this was really depicted on many different cases
00:26:09 with people who grew up in Scientology, in Scientology of the Aftermath,
00:26:14 and Lee Roney and Mike Render's show,
00:26:16 is that you would have just a lot of these sort of camps,
00:26:20 camps in which, you know, you really would just be like child labor,
00:26:23 where you were, the only education that you really got were Scientology classes.
00:26:28 you would be spent a lot of time like away from your parents because there's not really true
00:26:35 ownership of like they're your mother and father i mean they're the ones who birthed you into the
00:26:40 world but there's not there's no real difference no one is truly taught as a children so anyone who
00:26:46 grows up in scientology they're ultimately robbed of their childhood and usually those who escape
00:26:53 those who escaped Scientology the only time they've been able to connect with is kind of like
00:26:59 the sort of like being like a lost boy like in Peter Pan like the only equivalent I can give to
00:27:04 it would be Warren Jeffs who is the leader of the FLDS who's now in federal prison and he was no
00:27:11 no I think it was in the early 2000s when it got exposed of all the different you know underage
00:27:15 you know polygamous cults the polygamous wives and even underage wives that he had married
00:27:20 there was a point in which uh and there's a there's a parallel here and i forget their note
00:27:26 they're kind of known as the lost boys i forget the actual name and title of it but as these boys
00:27:32 were growing up jeff saw them as competition because eventually they're going to hit puberty
00:27:38 they're going to be start being attracted towards women and but i need to bring more women i need
00:27:42 i need to be sealed to more women so he would find these boys uh who are around 12 and 13 years old
00:27:48 would find some way to excommunicate them
00:27:51 and isolate them from their whole upbringing,
00:27:55 their whole tribe of what they grew up in.
00:27:57 So you actually have these areas in Utah
00:27:59 where these boys would just show up,
00:28:01 a bunch of 12- and 13-year-old boys who were just orphans.
00:28:04 Typically Salt Lake City.
00:28:05 Yeah, typically Salt Lake City.
00:28:07 So you would really see the same thing happen.
00:28:09 And their parents would still be a part of Scientology?
00:28:12 Oh, he's talking about Warren Jeffs here.
00:28:14 Warren Jeffs. Give me a comparison.
00:28:15 So Warren says, so you'd have the same thing
00:28:18 where just because they're, the only education
00:28:20 that they really get are Scientology classes.
00:28:22 There's not, they don't have practical real life world skills
00:28:25 and they come to a point where they just say,
00:28:28 I have to leave, I have to get out.
00:28:29 So many of them, they're held against their will
00:28:31 and sometimes it's really like a Stockholm syndrome,
00:28:34 like mental buying, like you're told if you,
00:28:36 and this is similar with any cult,
00:28:38 that usually if you leave the group,
00:28:40 there's no salvation outside of it,
00:28:41 terrible things will happen to you and to your parents.
00:28:45 And so there's all these sort of like a mental binding and breaking, a systematic breaking down.
00:28:52 So usually it's like there's a mental prison.
00:28:56 And this is something we articulate in our interview with Mike Rinder.
00:28:59 There is a literal that theology and worldview behind Scientology and those who become believers, like you think that you're climbing this bridge to total freedom.
00:29:09 But when in reality, you're building this mind prison.
00:29:13 Um, so to try and describe it, like Mike Rinder, in our interview with him, he did, he was talking with, um, somebody who was in the FBI and was talking about, well, couldn't you just go and like bring them out or like have, have a conversation, just talk with them?
00:29:28 It's like, it's not just that simple. Like they're so ingrained that this is their life. And if they
00:29:35 leave, then everything that is possibly terrible that could happen to them and the people that
00:29:41 they care for, like there is this mental prison that is created through the inklings of Scientology.
00:29:49 And that's, and then the children, they're taught that, that they're basically taught that. And,
00:29:53 And yeah, the way that children are treated is terrible.
00:29:58 And you can see that depicted in the show, Scientology, the Aftermath.
00:30:01 And again, this is having, and again, this comes from an underlying worldview
00:30:06 that children are adults, are just adults trapped in these little bodies.
00:30:11 And therefore, we should treat them no different than adults.
00:30:14 And how they treat adults is awful as well, too.
00:30:17 Well, in reality, too, having children was kind of frowned upon within Scientology
00:30:22 because it takes away the aspect of work, work, work, work, work in the Sea Org.
00:30:26 So they work people 80 hours, 90 hours a week, small amounts of sleep,
00:30:31 pay them very little bits of amount of money, right?
00:30:33 Because everything that they're working towards is trying to get more classes
00:30:36 so they can level up on their journey to the bridge to total freedom.
00:30:39 I mean, there's stories of even forced abortions
00:30:42 for individuals who got pregnant within Scientology.
00:30:45 It was frowned upon, but we find that within many different cults,
00:30:48 Like the leaders always want to control the sexual appetites of their followers, right?
00:30:53 Like even with Jim Jones, it's noted that he would separate families. 0.55
00:30:56 He would have sexual relations with different people that were once family units.
00:31:02 You know, he wanted that control over the minds.
00:31:04 The same thing happens within Scientology.
00:31:07 But within Scientology as well, there is a ruling cosmology.
00:31:11 And I want to talk about their story, essentially, of the Phaeton, of the earth, of who we are, what they believe.
00:31:20 And this is something, again, when I talk about this, it's going to sound extremely funny to you.
00:31:25 But remember, the people who hold to this have paid, man, I forgot what the amount was last time I looked up.
00:31:31 I think it's somewhere around $500,000 to $750,000 already to receive this information.
00:31:37 So once this stuff became public, it was a big deal for Scientology.
00:31:41 But let me give you some of their cosmology.
00:31:45 So there's an existence of a cosmic ruler named Lord Xenu, who was believed to have lived approximately 75 million years ago.
00:31:56 And this was the narrative.
00:31:57 There was massive overpopulation.
00:31:59 So Xenu was the ruler of a galactic confederacy, an ancient intergalactic civilization that was facing severe overpopulation.
00:32:07 So in order to make their less overpopulation, what did Xenu do?
00:32:13 Well, he took these people, these Thetans, and he brought them to another area, right? 0.56
00:32:20 He brought billions of beings to Earth, which was known as T-Giak or T-Gi. 0.87
00:32:26 That was what Xenu called the Earth.
00:32:29 And these beings were frozen and transported in spacecraft to various volcanoes on Earth. 0.79
00:32:35 And then Xenu dropped hydrogen bombs into the volcanoes and triggered a massive explosion, killing the Thetans, their bodies.
00:32:42 But the spirits of these Thetans, known as body Thetans, were released from their physical forms. 0.78
00:32:47 Then these beings were brought to implant stations.
00:32:50 So Xenu then subjected these disembodied Thetans to a complex implantation process. 0.95
00:32:55 and this involved implanting false narratives engrams into the thetans minds which were indeed
00:33:01 intended to control and manipulate them so there's implant stations which also implanted false
00:33:07 religious narratives and beliefs there we go for the idea of jesus christ throughout history the
00:33:12 idea of buddhism hinduism none of those are enough those are all false implantation narratives
00:33:17 although you know he creates his own religion from these religions but that is the effects
00:33:24 right? It creates traumatic experiences and false beliefs as engrams in individuals. So we're
00:33:30 trying to overcome what Lord Zinu once did through Dianetics in the process of Scientology in order 0.92
00:33:36 to go clear, become operating Thetans, and then preach this gospel to the rest of the world. 0.66
00:33:41 So the hope of the Scientologist is to spread Dianetics to everybody, right? The only way you
00:33:47 can get rid of drug addiction, trauma, to control yourself, to control any demi-urge that you may 0.94
00:33:53 have uh is through the process of dianetics and auditing and becoming an operating thetan that's
00:34:00 their post-millennial hope in a sense yeah it's uh it's it's pretty wild but really that is what
00:34:07 they teach so yeah here's some of my questions i've been listening the whole time it's been
00:34:12 super helpful fascinating what i guess my i have two main questions one how how did scientology
00:34:20 take off because at one point like you were talking about a little bit jeremiah like um
00:34:25 that they read this people just organically read this essay would be the equivalent of something
00:34:30 on social media today going viral like he submitted it to certain you know journals and
00:34:35 peer review and everybody mocked you know mocked him but then you know but then the what is it
00:34:40 called the dialectics uh dianetics dianetics like it just kind of took off and so so my question is
00:34:47 like, is there anything beyond that? Like, what made Scientology successful? Because there was
00:34:53 a time where it was growing quickly. And then my second question is, and how come that doesn't
00:35:00 work anymore? I wonder, like, just practically, not just the power of Christ, you know, revealing
00:35:05 and exposing falsehoods and lies. Praise God for that. But I feel like there's probably also
00:35:11 some practical dynamics. I'm thinking about, like, could something like Scientology exist
00:35:16 in because it seems like it requires secrecy like uh like like it it can only be something
00:35:24 like that type of cult cults still exist and some of them are growing but that particular type of
00:35:30 cult seems like it thrives on you know like you have to take these classes and there's certain
00:35:37 information that you don't get to access like but we live in the information age where everything
00:35:42 is publicly available you can't really you can't really keep something under tabs anymore i wonder
00:35:49 if i guess what i'm saying is i wonder if the internet and social media more particularly
00:35:54 kills scientology yes uh yeah i'll give a couple of reasons why i think and again it's multi-layered
00:36:00 but i think one of the areas in which it really grew in popularity was when that they established
00:36:05 the celebrity center uh in la and because of the nature of la and hollywood and people who are
00:36:12 aspiring actors and is a lot of, you know, confidence in trying to get, you know, your
00:36:17 audition, your audition after audition after audition for your first big break. You think of
00:36:21 any notable celebrity, you know, you look at some of their earlier videos, it's them showing up in
00:36:25 some Coca-Cola commercial from the 1980s. Those are always like fun videos to see. Well, someone
00:36:31 like John Travolta would have been attracted to Scientology because he, there's a lot that,
00:36:37 there's some general classes that deal with, you know, confidence, controlling your emotions,
00:36:42 you know, knowing that certain things are with your reactive mind and giving.
00:36:45 And he, John Travolta, attributed a lot of the first roles that he got,
00:36:49 including, I believe, his role in Grease,
00:36:52 which was, you know, a move that really kind of put him to the forefront.
00:36:55 And also Saturday Night Fever.
00:36:57 Like those, those are two of the really big breaks that Travolta got.
00:37:01 And then he gave and created Scientology to that.
00:37:05 And then, of course, you've had Tom Cruise, who was very notable.
00:37:08 So you kind of had different people.
00:37:10 but Leah Remini at that time, I mean, she got her big break
00:37:13 when she did the sitcom The King of Queens
00:37:15 along with Kevin James, and at that time,
00:37:19 she's a true believer in Scientology and gave that credit.
00:37:21 Wait, hold up. The actress who was the wife of Kevin James
00:37:24 in King of Queens, she was Scientologist?
00:37:25 Yes, she was Scientologist.
00:37:26 Oh, I didn't know that.
00:37:26 Yeah, so the show Scientology, The Aftermath
00:37:29 is co-hosted by Leah Remini and Mike Quintero.
00:37:31 My eyes are getting weary.
00:37:32 Back is getting tight.
00:37:34 Yeah.
00:37:34 Go ahead, sorry.
00:37:35 That show was funny. I enjoyed it.
00:37:37 But yeah, so that would be an example of just,
00:37:39 I mean, cults always, they're seeking out a particular group of people,
00:37:44 and I think they were trying to show prejudice towards those who were aspiring up-and-comers
00:37:50 to show the glamour of that. And so, a lot of the growth happened really like pre-internet,
00:37:56 and I think just with, because cults do operate in secrecy.
00:38:00 Right.
00:38:01 So, there's always not a lot of transparency. I mean, if you look at, for example, Mormonism,
00:38:05 When Mormon missionaries come over to your door, they're giving you, they're cloaking everything in very basic, generic Christian terminology.
00:38:12 They're not going to go on day one and start talking about what happens inside the temple,
00:38:16 that you're going to put on this white chef's hat and along with this green apron and start, you know,
00:38:22 talking about, you know, the Garden of Eden and Ascent to Godhead and everything that takes place inside of the Mormon temple.
00:38:28 They're not going to do that on day one.
00:38:30 That's not until later.
00:38:31 Uh, in the, in the same way, you know, Scientology just starts off, hey, take a personality test,
00:38:36 come in here for a free personality test.
00:38:38 And they do that to this day.
00:38:39 Then, then it's like, oh, well, buy this course and buy that course and start scaling the bridge.
00:38:44 And so people, there's a lot of those who are attracted, I think, to Scientology were those
00:38:49 who were trying to, were very heavily in the personal development space.
00:38:53 Uh, and so I think a lot of, a lot of what people who want to become an actor, a notable star,
00:38:58 you know and I get that sometimes being in front of a camera and going into those roles you know
00:39:03 you deal with your own internal monologue you know like you see a YouTube when you're first
00:39:07 brand new I remember seeing like a YouTube comment of somebody saying something about me about my
00:39:13 what I look like or how I sound or how I'm talking or I'm using too many ums and ahs and just seeing
00:39:19 that criticism and just being racked like oh I can't I'll never amount to anything because
00:39:24 Somebody on YouTube said something.
00:39:26 And so there's levels in which you would want to embrace
00:39:29 how to deal with the emotion of somebody criticizing you.
00:39:33 And that's exemplified, too, in Hollywood.
00:39:36 You know, you're going before an audition against, like, three people,
00:39:40 and, you know, you're going to do this one quick addition,
00:39:42 and you'll get it, you'll do tons of them,
00:39:44 and, you know, dealing with the ups and downs
00:39:46 of trying to get your big break, you know?
00:39:48 So I think that area created a lot of that.
00:39:51 And honestly, what ended up...
00:39:52 This is so foreign to me,
00:39:53 Like what you're talking about, that experience of receiving criticism on YouTube.
00:39:59 I've never, never, never, never experienced that.
00:40:03 I know nothing, barely anything about that.
00:40:05 I don't even know what you're talking about.
00:40:06 Right, maybe once or twice.
00:40:08 And honestly, I think just the, again, as I mentioned at the beginning of the podcast,
00:40:12 they would just be a pinnacle example of information being readily available on the internet.
00:40:18 One of the most notable, fascinating stories, he passed away, but it's David Miscavige's father,
00:40:24 Ron Miscavige. He was in a position to where he was highly questioning Scientology.
00:40:29 They are starting to view him as an SP, which stands for Suppressive Person.
00:40:33 And he was being questioned, he was, in some sense, I believe he was actually being 0.72
00:40:39 held against his will, or he was in a place, he was still inside that mine prison.
00:40:46 and he had the audacity he had an ipad which he snuck into his room and somehow he got outside
00:40:55 of the ip address of servers where it can be detected and found a way to access the internet
00:41:01 about the truth about scientology and then he saw something he could never look back seeing all the
00:41:08 different cover-ups and scandals and and things of that nature that would not be complete that
00:41:12 would be completely cut off from, severed off from anybody loyal to Scientology. They would say,
00:41:18 do not look at that. That is the only things that suppresses people information happen. Most,
00:41:23 most of the time, cults are conditioned, are mentally conditioned to what's called a siege
00:41:28 mentality. Well, they'll interpret any sort of level criticism of their group as unwarranted
00:41:34 persecution. That's usually how a cult member is, that mind prison is built to have that siege
00:41:40 mentality, but Ron Miscavige would be an ideal case of having the internet allow him to, you
00:41:47 know, to all of a sudden really question the church and ultimately allowed him to escape.
00:41:53 And that's happened with multiple different people within Scientology. And I think that that's one
00:41:58 of the reasons why it has dwindled. And so now with it being readily available, now you have those
00:42:03 who sort of have a network where people can connect with. That's why you had the show that
00:42:10 which the A&E show, Scientology, the Aftermath, which won multiple Emmy awards, where you would
00:42:15 have people who would connect with them. Now there's a place where people can come to the
00:42:18 internet, on social media, on different Reddit groups where people can talk. And it's not just
00:42:23 Scientology. We did an episode on this cult, this Korean cult called Shincheonji. And it's the same
00:42:29 thing. They sneak people into, hey, let's go do this Bible study. And they ask the question, 0.61
00:42:34 oh, we'll get to that later. We'll get to that later. We'll get down to the road. And they keep
00:42:37 on feeding them breadcrumbs and start getting them conditioned into accepting and believing
00:42:43 what they say and to ultimately give adherence and reverence to whoever is the messianic figure
00:42:50 that they're trying to adhere them to. So really, there is a mind prison that surely was slowly
00:42:55 built about. And I think the difficult challenge is when it comes to Scientology, as it has,
00:43:01 it is, I do believe it's dwindling down. I don't know what the history will be like
00:43:05 or what Scientology, if he even has any future outside of David Miscavige, I think at this point
00:43:11 he's in his early 60s. He's probably sometime in his, yeah, late 50s, early 60s, I would guess.
00:43:17 So there's, I don't know how much, you're looking at maybe a couple more decades at the absolute max
00:43:23 because he ruled with an iron fist, so I don't know what that vacuum is going to be filled.
00:43:27 But I think the challenge, I'll let you jump in, Andrew, as we kind of wrap up here and give a
00:43:31 basic overview is the challenge with the import why this meant why we've done what we've done
00:43:37 why we even launched cultish is because when you look at a show like leo remny and scientology
00:43:43 the aftermath you look at all this abuse that has taken place and you see the people who have just
00:43:49 been chewed up and spit out of this machine being promised a bag of goods and being thrown to the
00:43:54 wasted like an empty pack of cigarettes. They're not really given something truly tangible to
00:44:03 leave. Okay, well, now I can think freely for myself. Well, how do you know you won't be
00:44:07 deceived again? One of my favorite quotes is by G.K. Chesterton, who said that an open mind
00:44:12 is no different than an open mouth. Eventually, you have to bite down on something. And our hope
00:44:18 within cultish is that the majority of those who experience spiritual abuse, who experience
00:44:23 an abusive cult like Scientology, the majority of them become atheists and agnostic. And you
00:44:30 ended up really seeing that in the show. And that was the heartbreaking, I'm thankful.
00:44:34 And I give thanks to God that Lee and Mike were able to expose the abuse, but there's no place
00:44:40 to put them. There's no true hope. And that's where, you know, thankfully, Andrew, you got to
00:44:45 give Mike the gospel and he was on Cultish, which was awesome. But yeah, I think that the challenge
00:44:50 is, is that, is giving people who, it's not just people who are in the cults and evangelizing them
00:44:56 and giving them the hope of the gospel, it's that those who have been spit out of the machine
00:45:00 of not just Scientology, but really any destructive cult in giving them true hope in Christ.
00:45:06 Yeah. Amen, man. So when thinking about the deterioration of Scientology, we also got to
00:45:11 think about the death of L. Ron Hubbard, right? He was their revelator. He was the one creating all
00:45:15 of these new classes. I mean, they're still waiting for the resurrection of L. Ron Hubbard.
00:45:19 There's a whole floor in a Scientology building dedicated to his house that he will inhabit when he comes back from the dead.
00:45:26 He's still dead, right?
00:45:28 He won't come back from the dead.
00:45:30 So there's this idea of ongoing revelation from L. Ron Hubbard.
00:45:34 So when he was still alive, he was saying, oh, well, there's going to be another class that comes out, another class that comes out.
00:45:40 So all of the revelation wasn't out yet, which gave them something to look forward to.
00:45:44 Well, now it's out.
00:45:45 And not only is it out for them, but the cat's out of the bag
00:45:48 and everyone can read it because of the internet.
00:45:50 Right.
00:45:51 But in terms of not going into Scientology,
00:45:55 we have the internet to protect ourselves from there,
00:45:56 but what about the people who are already in it?
00:45:58 That's the question. So since they have that mind prison,
00:46:01 and they're not able to get to the internet,
00:46:03 we still see them in there, but it is slowly dwindling out.
00:46:06 But one of the main reasons would be,
00:46:08 number one, there's no more revelation.
00:46:10 Number two, we can see all the revelation that has been given,
00:46:14 been given and it is demonstrably false, right? False Christ, false gospel, false salvation
00:46:19 doesn't lead to freedom. When the sun sets you free, you are free. Indeed, it leads you to
00:46:23 a mind prison where you're literally just supporting a business.
00:46:31 Right Response Ministries 2025 conference is a go. This is three days, full jam-packed conference
00:46:40 with eight main sessions, three to four hour and a half long panels, and an all-star super-based
00:46:46 lineup of speakers, 15 speakers in all. Who are they? Steve Dace, Jeff Durbin, Orrin McIntyre,
00:46:53 Stephen Wolf, Brian Sauve, Andrew Isker, John Harris, Eric Kahn, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder,
00:47:00 the Christian Prince himself, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, David Reese, and yours truly,
00:47:06 Pastor Joel Webben. Again, this is April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, 2025, and the early registration is open
00:47:14 right now. This is the longest conference with the most speakers we've ever offered, and yet
00:47:20 it is our all-time lowest price. The early registration available today is only 140 bucks
00:47:27 for an adult. So go to rightresponseconference.com. Again, that is rightresponseconference.com
00:47:35 to register right now because the early registration will not last long.
00:47:41 The last thing that I want to end with is I'm just thinking to play the contrarian for a moment
00:47:48 and just preemptively maybe answer some of their questions or provide an explanation for some of
00:47:56 their criticisms. You know that somebody has been listening, and if they actually made it this far,
00:48:02 you know which maybe they didn't but maybe there's a couple and they're probably thinking
00:48:07 you know if some unbelievers are listening and they made it this far they're thinking
00:48:11 um you guys are sitting here talking about this cult but you're a cult you know like you guys are
00:48:19 part of apologia church and i heard that apology you know apologia and jeff durbin and this and
00:48:26 that are like their views on abortion, you know, and equal protections for the unborn. And, you
00:48:34 know, Joel, like you're a part of a church I've heard about, you know, you hold to biblical
00:48:37 patriarchy, your views on, you know, men and women, like you guys are, are cult leaders. You're a part
00:48:44 of a cult. And I would just want to end, and I'm, you know, I'm curious to hear, you know, if you
00:48:49 guys have a quick answer. If not, we could save it for another episode. But my answer is fairly
00:48:53 simple. There's more that could be said, but here's three distinctions. Number one, I have one
00:49:00 wife. How many wives do you have? One. How many wives do you have? One. Right. So we don't each 0.96
00:49:05 have 10 wives. One wife. And that is a distinction. Cult leaders typically, it's like, well, what's 0.98
00:49:14 the common denominator? They're wanting to get laid by multiple women. That's just, to put it
00:49:19 frankly, that's what it is. So we all have one wife. That's one distinction. Here's a second
00:49:23 distinction. People leave my church all the time, all the time. They move away geographically,
00:49:30 or they just decide that they disagree on a secondary doctrine or something like that.
00:49:34 They're not reformed, and they're, you know, or they disagree on, you know, whatever, whatever it
00:49:40 may be. You know, they're continuationists. I'm more of a cessationist. That has to do, those are
00:49:44 two different doctrines dealing with gifts of the Spirit all the time. You know, we planted the
00:49:49 church here in Texas, Covenant Bible Church, that I pastor in Central Texas about three years ago.
00:49:55 We're right at the three-year mark, and we went from, you know, 20 people in my living room,
00:50:00 including kids, to well over 200 people. And yet, so we've gained at least 200 people,
00:50:08 but we've also, it's not the same people we've cycled through, a few people. We've had at least,
00:50:14 probably at least 50, 60, 70 adults leave
00:50:19 just in the last three years.
00:50:21 And a lot of them I still talk to, still friends with, you know,
00:50:26 and still share a lot of things in common.
00:50:29 My wife is friends with some of the women who came and went,
00:50:33 and still friends.
00:50:34 We didn't cut them off.
00:50:36 We didn't shun them.
00:50:38 And they were allowed to leave.
00:50:40 And people were actually even surprised
00:50:42 surprise, because I do have strong convictions. And when I preach, I don't preach, I don't pace
00:50:46 back and forth with, you know, skinny jeans and a deep v-neck, you know, and with a, you know,
00:50:53 plexiglass pulpit, you know, and an Instagram coffee mug and say, well, you know, I just think
00:50:58 and I feel. No, when I preach, I declare, let the one who speaks speak as though he is speaking the
00:51:03 very oracles of God. So, I preach with confidence, not in the flesh, but confidence in the risen Lord
00:51:08 and that God wrote a book. So, I say these things confidently, not because I'm great,
00:51:13 but because God is great, and He wrote it down. We do know the answers. So, when I preach, it's
00:51:18 not just the opinions and preferences of men. It's, thus saith the Lord. So, my style of preaching
00:51:24 is confident, and there's theological reasons for that. I think that's right. But outside of the
00:51:30 pulpit, when someone comes and says, hey, I think we're going to move on. We're going to go to this
00:51:35 other church, as long as it's somewhere in the realm of orthodoxy, it's Presbyterian, had people 0.84
00:51:39 leave the church because they developed Presbyterian convictions of paedo-baptism, baptizing their
00:51:43 babies. Well, I think we're going to go to this Presbyterian church, or I think we're going to go 0.98
00:51:47 to this Anglican church, or I think we're going to... That has happened dozens, dozens of times
00:51:54 just in the last three years. And sometimes people in the church who stay in the church,
00:52:00 who are faithful members, and these get frustrated with me because I let people go too easily.
00:52:04 I can't believe you.
00:52:05 And I'm like, they're allowed to leave.
00:52:07 Like church membership means something.
00:52:08 I don't want to make it mean nothing.
00:52:10 It's not trivial or trite.
00:52:11 It means something.
00:52:13 But the church membership covenant, it is a covenant,
00:52:17 but it is not on par or the same degree of covenant as a marriage covenant.
00:52:22 Right.
00:52:22 You're allowed to leave. 0.80
00:52:23 So one, we all have one wife.
00:52:26 Two, people leave.
00:52:28 That's a huge difference.
00:52:30 Yeah.
00:52:30 Right?
00:52:30 They leave, and with relative ease, frequently and easily, people leave our churches.
00:52:38 That would be another big difference.
00:52:40 And then the third thing that I would just throw in there is I'm not a millionaire.
00:52:46 Are you a millionaire?
00:52:47 Nope.
00:52:47 Are you a millionaire?
00:52:49 How many jets do you guys have?
00:52:50 Zero.
00:52:51 None.
00:52:52 Yeah, so for the troll, who probably didn't make it this far, but if there's a troll 0.99
00:52:56 or two that made it this far, and they're like, well, you guys, well, you're hypocrites. 0.98
00:53:00 You're talking about this cult Scientology, 0.99
00:53:01 but you're a part of the patriarchy cult,
00:53:03 or you're a part of the post-mill cult.
00:53:05 Grow up, get a life,
00:53:08 and you don't know what the heck you're talking about, respectfully.
00:53:12 These, just for the record, these jeans,
00:53:14 if someone does an audit of my clothing audit,
00:53:16 this is a $10 shirt from Ross.
00:53:19 This is a $15 pair of jeans I bought from Costco.
00:53:22 It's actually the first pair of jeans I bought in the year.
00:53:23 Hey, Costco actually has great clothes.
00:53:25 They're durable.
00:53:25 They do.
00:53:26 I saw a meme that talks about it.
00:53:28 is uh like when you finally realize you're old enough to buy a costco clothes without shame and
00:53:32 it's like it is time yeah so i i'm very proud to be sporting the new uh 15 costco jeans so uh good
00:53:39 job there dude they're um flannels yeah like two of my favorite flannels which you know yeah i'm a
00:53:45 30 you know mid 30s you know white male with a beard so naturally half of my wardrobe is flannels
00:53:51 um yeah but my two best ones are from costco they like they just they're like the flannel that will
00:53:57 never die. They're thick and they last. Yeah, well, I will say this in regards to, you know,
00:54:03 those, I mean, cult a lot of times now just tends to be a pejorative. It's like anything that I
00:54:07 don't like. Exactly. That's why I wanted to bring it up here at the end. Even a secondary issue of,
00:54:11 you know, a staunch disagreement. So, people have said, oh, are you going to talk about the
00:54:15 charismatic cult? Right. You know, and it's like, no, okay, there are elements of hyper-charismania
00:54:19 that can be cultish. We can talk about the prosperity gospel as a heresy. Right. But not
00:54:24 every charismatic falls under the banner of the prosperity gospel.
00:54:27 Right, right.
00:54:28 And so a lot of times they'll use cult as just sort of this emotional impact pejorative.
00:54:32 And that has to do that we're dealing, it's the nature of language in general in a postmodern
00:54:37 culture where words aren't based in the inherent meaning of what they, in the etymology of
00:54:42 what they actually are.
00:54:44 Words are basically conformed to how it makes you feel.
00:54:47 And so when that's the root etymology is the here and there of your emotions.
00:54:51 and so many ways like I said the word cult is the pejorative just something I don't like right
00:54:57 because I had people even as I was I was announcing this we're going to do this series you know I had
00:55:02 people on YouTube you know saying uh as we did some preview videos and saying like are you going
00:55:06 to cover you know you're covering 10 different cults are you going to cover one of the most
00:55:10 deadly and dangerous and quickly growing cults the cult of Calvinism you know and uh and it's
00:55:15 funny like so stuff like that you know so like saying exactly what you said it's a pejorative
00:55:19 So saying, well, you're a part of a cult.
00:55:22 No, there are actual criteria to define.
00:55:26 Cults are, there are definitive criteria to define cult versus a major world religion.
00:55:36 Like, for instance, Islam is not a cult.
00:55:38 It's wrong. 0.62
00:55:39 But there is a difference between a cult and a major world religion, even if the major world religion happens to be a false religion.
00:55:48 So yeah, just saying it's a cult, it's the same as, you know, that's just what people do now with language.
00:55:52 So like saying that you're a racist or saying that you're anti-Semitic, you know, or whatever.
00:55:56 Like I saw a meme the other day on Twitter.
00:55:58 I thought it was hilarious.
00:55:59 It was Bane from Batman.
00:56:03 And it was like the line, but the words are changed slightly. 0.99
00:56:06 The guy is looking at Bane and says, you are racist, bigoted, anti-Semite. 0.95
00:56:12 And it shows Bane and he like holds him by the corner and says, you think this gives you power over me? 0.98
00:56:18 do you feel like you're on charge here do you think this gives you power over there
00:56:24 he's like who cares like the donald trump you know like like responses like who cares yeah like
00:56:31 that's the response like honestly if somebody calls you a racist today 99 of the time you can
00:56:36 biblically and appropriately in a god a christ-honoring way respond with uh by saying who
00:56:41 cares because you're not actually a racist right not it's not to say who like in the in the objective
00:56:47 sense that you shouldn't care about racism. It's just to say, no, you're lying. I'm not actually
00:56:52 a racist, not by any objective definable measure. That word has no meaning anymore, not because I
00:56:58 ruined it, but because you emptied it of its meaning. You're literally just using it as a
00:57:03 pejorative to dismiss the truth of Scripture that I'm preaching. And so when you call me a racist,
00:57:08 no, it does not. I don't lose a moment of sleep. I do not feel bad. It does not give you power over
00:57:17 me. I'm going to, according to your definition of racism, I am going to racist even harder
00:57:22 from here on out. So all that being said, no, Christianity, to stop making it just personally
00:57:29 about us, let's broaden it now. Christianity is not a cult. Right. Yeah. And so I'll give like
00:57:35 two examples. And Andrew, I can give you maybe give your thoughts on it too. So one would be
00:57:39 just a small microcosm, look at like Apologia and just, you know, I've known, like I've had a
00:57:44 relationship with Jeff Durbin that goes back 20 plus years, even pre-Apologia. And it's funny
00:57:50 just because I've just known him for who he is. So, I have just this disconnect from the perception
00:57:56 that someone has who's seen him on YouTube. But within our congregation, I think whenever there's
00:58:02 been somebody who comes in who's starstruck, who has that, and again, it's not just our church or
00:58:10 apologia or response ministries, I think just the nature of social media in general is that we tend
00:58:16 to create a perception of somebody through the avatar of themselves that we perceive through
00:58:23 the realm of social media. So someone comes in and they see Jeff is just like, wow, this amazing
00:58:30 superhuman celebrity pastor and all this stuff, these preconceptions that are made, you know,
00:58:35 through social media, there's probably preconceptions that people would have about us
00:58:39 regarding that. But anybody who's ever come in because of that, we've always been there. We've
00:58:45 always had a lot of reservations being kind of like, okay, let's have you just simmer down a
00:58:50 little bit, right? And I think one of the things I've noticed is that those, and this is probably
00:58:56 indicative of churches elsewhere, those who have sort of looked up to Jeff or other pastors in our
00:59:05 church as sort of this sort of notable celebrity-like figure end up having the hardest time
00:59:11 and struggling because once they're viewed without partiality, um, both with men and women,
00:59:18 whether someone is in sin, uh, and showing, uh, and judging a situation without partiality and
00:59:23 they're dealt with and they're confronted on something, they don't know how to handle that
00:59:27 because all of a sudden that celebrity who has made me feel good and nostalgia and on cloud.
00:59:32 Now I feel like I'm part of this grandos thing bigger than myself, and you have a—and then you're also putting a misconception of even what the church is.
00:59:44 This is a body of people in covenant community with very different backgrounds, and sometimes for you, you're going to grind into each other and bump shoulders and hurt each other and sin against one another.
00:59:56 And all of a sudden, when that paradigm shift, the glass is shattered of normalcy, where say you're just confronted on a particular sin, or there's somebody who unbeknownst sins against you, like two different scenarios, all of a sudden their paradigms are shattered and they don't know what to do with that.
01:00:17 And then they leave, and then later they could become embittered, and those are the ones who
01:00:24 give the biggest cry of spiritual abuse and being abused because of the fact that they
01:00:30 had these preconceived expectations that they brought upon themselves because they saw the
01:00:35 passage as something that they are not.
01:00:37 So those—and again, a cult mentality is that you look at the leader as this grand messianic
01:00:44 figure.
01:00:45 you think about, you know, the people in North Korea who would look at Kim Jong-un or Kim Jong-il
01:00:49 just crying and saying he's the devoted messianic leader. Those who do that end up being the most 0.70
01:00:57 incompatible with a biblically-based church. So, there's that. The other thing I'll say as far as
01:01:03 just dealing with Christianity in general, as far as the gospel, and again, we get the stunningly
01:01:08 original the last five years, the one-star review is, oh, you're just a podcast on cults hosted by
01:01:13 cults thinking that they're suddenly original. It's like, oh, wow, you put so much intellectual
01:01:18 thought into that. That's okay. I thought it's time for me to throw in the towel. We had a good
01:01:23 run. We're done. That's basically your ace of spades on us. No, well, here's the distinction
01:01:28 between biblical Christianity and every other false religion, and particularly cult, is that
01:01:35 they're always based in a private esoteric revelation, private experience. You see this 0.77
01:01:41 with L. Ron Hubbard. You're going to see it with Charles Taze Russell, which we're going to talk
01:01:44 about, and also Joseph Smith that we'll continue to talk about. You will see all of these, and
01:01:50 specifically in this example, L. Ron Hubbard was this private, internal, esoteric experience by how
01:01:57 I came to knowledge about everything that's depicted in Dianetics, and about Xenu, and the
01:02:03 fact that we are operating Thetans. This all was internally verified where you are looking, the
01:02:07 paraphrase Vodibachum, you're looking at an external revelation, an external standard,
01:02:12 a reliable collection of historical documents that was written by eyewitnesses during the
01:02:17 lifetime of other eyewitnesses. It was a public accounting and a public record. That's the
01:02:23 account that Paul makes when Jesus rose from the dead. He said, hey, we've got 500 people who saw
01:02:28 him. We have 500 people who saw him. You know, some have passed away, some have fallen asleep,
01:02:32 but hey, there's, there's, there's, there's, you know, this is, you know, I think it'll bring
01:02:37 to the modern day, like, hey, we've got some friends over in Austin. Let's go talk to them.
01:02:42 They'll talk to you about where they saw him last Friday. We've got somebody over here who saw him
01:02:48 over here. And so, that's really what you had, a very openly, publicly verified historical
01:02:54 account of a public record that's independently verified by those who are followers of Christ,
01:03:00 but even independent historians like Josephus, whereas you have other areas where it's private
01:03:07 esoteric revelation. That's one of the reasons why the first battle that Christians came in 0.98
01:03:11 contact with was the Gnostics. They were public enemy number one, because all of their 1.00
01:03:17 spirituality came from secret gnosis, secret power. And again, there's nothing new under the
01:03:25 sun. Scientology sort of had that modernity. We figured out something else that no one else has
01:03:30 done before. No, this is just, they were, first century had probably a lot of different L. Ron
01:03:35 Hubbard's that were doing this, that, and the other. And that's what Christians were doing in 0.99
01:03:39 the first century. And, you know, once, if Scientology dwindled away and crumbled tomorrow, 0.89
01:03:44 you would see it fragment and you would see it syncretized and re-syncretized. There will be
01:03:49 cult leaders who might take, in the same way how L. Ron Hubbard took elements from a lot of
01:03:54 different components, there are those who would incorporate elements of the works of Scientology.
01:04:00 In fact, one of the areas that was depicted in season three of Scientology, the Aftermath was
01:04:04 a blending between Scientology. It was the Luce Farrakhan and the Nation of Islam. They actually
01:04:10 are utilizing the Scientology curriculum now as part of how they're implementing. So, they're
01:04:17 syncretizing. That'll be a real-life case study of those who are doing it. So, yeah, I think that
01:04:22 would be, generally speaking, internally, like those who view pastors as this celebrity in an
01:04:28 improper way. And people could do it with you, too. You know, like I have misconceptions. I
01:04:33 thought your chair was a lot bigger but uh wait what i thought that chair is bigger oh it's that
01:04:38 one that's that one over there okay i was trying to make sense that that's the morpheus chair
01:04:41 yeah um yeah those are welcome to the real um but yeah those those are my those are my two
01:04:46 assessments but anyways uh andrew what's the final thoughts yeah yeah let me take a stab at this this
01:04:50 is a fun one so when i'm thinking about the the trope really that well you are a christian you
01:04:57 are in a cult, your cult leader is Jesus. He had esoteric revelations. Typically when we're hearing
01:05:03 this type of argument against us, it's coming from an atheistic materialist, right? So the first
01:05:09 question I have for them is, what does that matter anyways? Right? So, and then my other question
01:05:15 would be, according to your standards, let me put the shoe back on your foot. So let's take Steve
01:05:20 Hassan's bite model, for example, which is behavior control, information control, thought control,
01:05:25 emotion control. Let me apply that standard to post-modern atheistic agnostic experience in the
01:05:30 world today. Behavior control. So how are you supposed to act? Where do you learn to grow up?
01:05:35 What's your epistemology? So how do you have a justification for the knowledge that you have?
01:05:38 What are you learning? So let's think about that. So in regards to a cult, what I believe
01:05:43 is that there is truth. There is objective truth. And the atheist doesn't like that. Because if
01:05:47 there's objective truth, then there's objective judgment for sin, which is transgression against
01:05:51 the law of God. And there's wrath that is coming for wrong actions against that God. But when I'm
01:05:56 thinking in terms of atheism, behavior control. So when you're going to your government schools,
01:06:00 what are you learning, right? Oh, you are part of a random chance explosion that came from
01:06:06 nothing without actually good evidence for it. But you were once a fish, right? That
01:06:11 protoplasm fish to philosopher today. So within that framework, you have your own different
01:06:18 set of presuppositions about what humanity is and who you are, right? So once you get out of that
01:06:25 framework, see me, I'm a biblical creationist. I say, no, the world was created in six days because
01:06:29 that's what God says. Well, I'm not allowed to think that according to you. So you already have
01:06:34 some type of information, thought, and behavior control because you have a different set of
01:06:38 presuppositions than I do. I'd say that the atheistic cult is the cult of Darwin
01:06:43 in a cult of scientism. So I would argue using the same standard that you are also in a cult,
01:06:49 but then let's stack up against each other the wrongs that these cults have done, right? So
01:06:53 within biblical Christianity, I have the standard of God's word that says thou shall not murder,
01:06:59 okay? It is wrong to kill people. Within the cult of atheistic Darwinianism, there is nothing wrong
01:07:05 with killing in general, right? You can't have a justification for it. It's just one person doing
01:07:11 something wrong against another. There's no moral accountability for it. There's no such thing as
01:07:14 morals in the first place because they're transcendental. They're not material. But
01:07:19 in regards to our death count, let's think about the fruit of the atheistic worldview. We've got
01:07:23 Mao, we've got Stalin, and guess what? We have the same people who call Christianity a cult who
01:07:29 are redefining what life is in the womb and killing babies before they're ever even born.
01:07:33 And what's the death count? I think the last time I looked at the world abortion meter,
01:07:38 It's somewhere upwards in between, I think it's like 1.6 to 1.7 billion humans have been 0.99
01:07:43 slaughtered in the womb because there's people who seek to redefine what life is and they kill
01:07:48 them before they even exist. That's called genocide. But Andrew, the crusades, all of them
01:07:52 combined killed almost 50,000 people, right? Like, I mean, you know, like I think it was like maybe
01:08:00 30 something thousand Muslims were killed and all the crusades combined over the course of
01:08:05 multiple centuries. So Christianity is really, really icky. We're talking about tens of thousands 1.00
01:08:10 of people. And over here with the atheistic Darwinian view, it's only a little shade above
01:08:17 a billion. Right. It's insane that this conversation even happens on a regular basis.
01:08:25 It continues. And the irony is it just shows how much more education we need, how little we know
01:08:33 about history, how little, how ignorant, because atheists tend to pride themselves in being 0.99
01:08:37 educated, but they're so uneducated. They just, like, historically, they just, they don't, 1.00
01:08:44 Christianity on its worst day, like Christendom, I mean, like, whatever you, whoever you, your bad,
01:08:50 you know, arch villain of, you know, Christendom was, take Constantine, take whoever it is, 1.00
01:08:55 like, Christianity throughout history, with all the documentation, all the records, 0.57
01:09:00 on its very worst day cannot even come close
01:09:05 to the best day of a secular humanist nation, ruler.
01:09:13 I mean, goodness gracious, if it was a contest 0.58
01:09:16 of who can kill the most people,
01:09:19 we are losing by almost an infinite chasm.
01:09:24 You just don't understand history.
01:09:26 I think that's a big part of it is like, 1.00
01:09:27 okay, atheists, that's great. 0.99
01:09:29 you're studying biology and, you know, poorly, you know, but studying physics, studying, you know, 0.99
01:09:34 quantum physics, whatever it might be, but you certainly don't understand the history of the
01:09:38 human race. Yeah. And going back to like Judaism real quick, if we were to think about someone to
01:09:43 argue, well, Christianity is a cult of Judaism. Well, we have to go back even to Genesis 3. 0.77
01:09:47 There's the promise of the Messiah to come. They're always looking forward to the one individual who
01:09:51 would be that true prophet, Deuteronomy 18. And the argument from Jesus is that he is that
01:09:56 fulfillment of that true prophet, right? He says to the Pharisees, if you believe the words of
01:10:00 Moses, you'd believe in me because Moses wrote about me. John the Baptist echoed, he who comes 0.87
01:10:04 after me is better than me because he came before me. He existed before me. Who is Jesus Christ?
01:10:09 The word made flesh. So in regards to what we believe about the Messiah, he's the fulfillment
01:10:14 of Judaism. He is Jesus Christ and there's an empty tomb and he defeated death. Christianity
01:10:18 is objectively true. And when you actually argue against him, you argue against the very
01:10:24 grounds of logic and justification and uniformity of nature. Like, it's just, that's just the reality
01:10:30 of it. You can't actually have an argument, so. Right. And it really is a consistent thread. When
01:10:34 you look at the Old Testament and you go straight through the New Testament, it's just this one
01:10:38 consistent thread. Because I think a lot of people in terms of, you know, Christianity and Judaism,
01:10:44 they think Christianity is a, it's a cultish offshoot of Judaism. But the reality is, no,
01:10:51 this is just the consistent fulfillment. Um, the offshoot is Talmudic Judaism. Um, Talmudic 0.92
01:10:57 Judaism is not, it's not like, uh, people think, you know, Christianity is old Testament plus new
01:11:01 Testament. And then Judaism is, uh, old Testament only, uh, no, no, no, no, no. Um, Talmudic Judaism
01:11:09 has its new Testament. It has its, you know, it's extra book. Um, it's not just old Testament only 0.70
01:11:15 it's the old Testament plus the Talmud, which, um, interprets the old Testament, but really
01:11:20 The way to think about modern Judaism today is the same way you should, very similar to how you would think about Mormonism.
01:11:29 So, well, but Mormons have the Bible. 0.76
01:11:30 They just have an extra book. 0.98
01:11:32 Yeah, but that extra book un-writes all the Bible.
01:11:35 Yep.
01:11:35 That's what the Talmud does with the Old Testament.
01:11:37 So it's not, well, you know, Judaism, it can't be that bad because it's half of the Christian faith or two-thirds.
01:11:43 You know, they got the Old Testament, we got the Old Testament plus the New.
01:11:45 No, we have the Old Testament, and we read it very much in light of the New. The New helps
01:11:51 provide those lenses that helps us to see all the rich treasures and prophecies and promises
01:11:57 of the Old Testament. And they have their New Testament that works as a lens to read the Old
01:12:03 Testament too, except their lens, our lens is the New Testament, which is the gospel and apostolic
01:12:09 account of Christ. Jesus is our lens for reading the Old Testament, and they have a lens also.
01:12:14 the Talmud, but it is a demonic lens. Our lens is Christ, and their lens is demonic, and it 0.50
01:12:22 causes them, so it's not that they have half of the truth. The half that they have, the Torah, 0.71
01:12:28 the Old Testament, has all been twisted by the Talmud. And so, not only is Christianity not a 0.91
01:12:36 offshoot cult of Judaism, modern Judaism, Talmudic Judaism, is actually an offshoot cult.
01:12:44 of, um, the, the actual Old Testament. Amen. All right. Well, thank you guys for that. That 0.72
01:12:51 was a long one, but thanks for tuning in. And, um, yeah, we will hit you with the next few
01:12:56 episodes. This is a part of a 10 part series. It might become an 11 part series. I don't know.
01:13:00 We'll see. Um, but yeah, tune in. And if you want to catch all of them ad free and not have to wait
01:13:05 each week for them to come out early access ad free, go to, uh, patreon.com forward slash
01:13:11 right response ministries patreon.com forward slash right response ministries god bless real
01:13:17 quick before you go we hope that you enjoyed the episode and we hope that you're eager for more
01:13:21 however as i already said these will be slow dripping out over the course of weeks and even a
01:13:27 few months but not to worry if you want to be able to watch all 10 of these episodes right now ad
01:13:35 free. All you got to do is join us as a silver tier member over on patreon.com forward slash
01:13:42 right response ministries. God bless.