The NXR Podcast - July 12, 2024


THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Transhumanism & Artificial Intelligence | Ep 2 with @TheCultishShow

Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Owen Strachan, Immigration, & The Great Commission THE SERMON - In His Kindness, God Will Destroy Dispensationalism - Galatians 3_15-29 | Pastor Andrew Isker

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 8 minutes

Words per minute

180.41

Word count

12,314

Sentence count

622

Harmful content

Misogyny

13

sentences flagged

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

56

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we discuss artificial intelligence, transhumanism, and artificial intelligence's relationship with Christianity. We talk about the difference between open artificial intelligence and narrow AI, and the role of artificial intelligence in the Christian worldview.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transhumanism is a philosophical, intellectual, and profoundly spiritual movement that advocates 0.87
00:00:13 for the enchantment of human capacities through the use of science, technology, and witchcraft.
00:00:19 It seeks to overcome the biological limitations and enhance human, intellectual, physical,
00:00:25 and psychological capabilities, ultimately aiming to achieve a post-human condition.
00:00:31 Central to the transhumanist thought is the belief in the potential of emerging technologies
00:00:36 such as artificial intelligence, biotechnology, nanotechnology, and robotics to radically
00:00:41 transform human existence. Its ultimate aim is to achieve human immortality, or perhaps better said,
00:00:48 for man to be as god here we go transhumanism and artificial intelligence guys kick us off
00:00:58 andrew what do you to start with this artificial intelligence there are different kinds
00:01:03 can you can you help us with understanding like you know like that like the christian who
00:01:09 is gonna you know use chat gpt that's in right yeah what kind of artificial intelligence are
00:01:16 we talking about? Yeah, that's a good question. So using chat GPT is sin. I am a sinner. I'm a
00:01:22 sinner regardless needing of repentance. But yeah, so I use artificial intelligence, right? I think
00:01:27 artificial intelligence can be used to the glory of God. Artificial intelligence also like mid
00:01:32 journey. I use that to create art. It's actually art that I can use even in YouTube thumbnails.
00:01:37 It's not art that I have to pay for because it's not essentially being made by humans. It's being
00:01:41 made by some form of artificial intelligence. So when we're thinking about artificial
00:01:47 intelligence, transhumanism, we have to think about these things correctly in forms of
00:01:53 biblically, right? So we don't actually get to the point of people like Elon Musk and other people
00:02:00 who are transhumanists thinking that they can avoid the ramifications of death by transferring
00:02:04 their consciousness into some type of computer. So the conversation can go in many different
00:02:10 routes, but when I like to think of artificial intelligence, I think of systems developed by
00:02:15 individuals to try to make the lives of humans easier, right? But these systems are not neutral,
00:02:22 okay? These systems are made by humans. So when we're thinking about ChatGPT, for example,
00:02:28 you can ask it certain questions, but it is biased. It'll respond and say, well, I don't think that
00:02:35 you're being politically correct. And I need to be soft with the way I explain things. Uh, and you
00:02:41 go, well, chat GPT, I don't agree with you. You can have an argument with this artificial
00:02:44 intelligence. It shows you that it's not neutral. So that's, I think the basic starting point and
00:02:50 premise, at least for the conversation on transhumanism and artificial intelligence is,
00:02:55 well, how should we look at it as Christians? What are your thoughts on that, Joel?
00:03:00 Yeah. Well, yeah, I, I, I think that's helpful. Uh, first thing to understand is it's not
00:03:05 neutral it's it's the collective it's been it's being taught you know and like as more and more
00:03:11 people use chat gpt and other you know narrow ai that's that's a part of it too is like understanding
00:03:18 the difference between narrow ai versus open ai you know and then and then all that you know
00:03:23 versus transhumanism and those kinds of things you know so it's this we're talking about narrow ai
00:03:29 it's um it's it's basically it's a it's we've been using ai for a long time i think that's what i
00:03:37 want people to realize like narrow ai we've been using for a long time that's what google is any
00:03:42 search engine that's what uh maps your your apple maps or google like if you've ever uh you know
00:03:49 used gps even before cell phones you know like if you had a gps thing in your car that like with a
00:03:54 voice that says go this direction or siri or what like um you've been using ai and so so to say one
00:04:02 i draw the line at uh you know mid-journey or i draw the line at gpt um that's that's cute you
00:04:10 know that's but uh that's baseless inconsistent not principled so just don't call it christian
00:04:16 just say i arbitrarily and randomly for no reason at all have decided this so you know if that's
00:04:23 Everyone's welcome to be inconsistent and arbitrary.
00:04:25 That's fine. You can do that.
00:04:27 But just don't pretend that it's a principle.
00:04:29 But there is a line, though,
00:04:31 between narrow AI and open AI.
00:04:34 I would be curious to hear both of you guys,
00:04:37 and we can start with you, Jeremiah,
00:04:38 but I'm pretty confident
00:04:43 that true open artificial intelligence
00:04:47 and transhumanism, I don't think that it's possible.
00:04:51 I really don't think that it's something that man will ever be able to achieve.
00:04:56 Right. When we kind of talk about this, what I think is most important, you know, you have a lot of times Christians, especially in the apologetic realm, people are asking about, you know, evidentialism versus presuppositionalism.
00:05:09 I think specifically within the category of transhumanism and artificial intelligence, I don't see evidentialism as really useful and hardly practically really any way.
00:05:19 I see really the only way this can really be approached is understanding truly the presuppositional apologetics, specifically having a true understanding, as Bonson referred to, the preconditions of intelligibility, and really understanding not only that, but even like who ontologically, like who are we truly as human beings?
00:05:40 Like, are we truly made in the image of God? Do we have justifiable, can we give accounting for us having distinctions? Are you, am I truly distinct from you, or am I truly distinct from you with my own personality, personhood, or are we truly part of some sort of mind hive that are part of a higher collective consciousness?
00:05:59 Are we part of some sort of higher transcendent impersonal force?
00:06:03 Or are we literally biological bags of protoplasm just moving about being blind and pitiless indifference, even though Richard Dawkins might be having second thoughts about that quote as of right now?
00:06:15 But that's really a big part of it.
00:06:19 So I think when it comes down to how you view AI, a Christian should view AI through a very different—should and will view it from a very different perspective than someone like Sam Harris or somebody like Elon Musk. 0.71
00:06:34 So when you look at Elon Musk, he would argue—because we're talking about AI and we're also talking about transhumanism. 0.62
00:06:42 So, what I believe about AI is that I believe that at its core, AI on the very premise level would be inherently neutral. However, it always artificially emulates its user, specifically even one who is regenerate or unregenerate.
00:06:58 And so, going back to Romans 1, when it talks about how mankind suppresses the truth and unrighteousness, if the utilizers at the heads of Silicon Valley who have a worldview that's radically antithetical to the Christian worldview, they are going to adhere and adopt AI, they're going to mold it in their own image.
00:07:18 One way where you'd see this practically, where Apologia Studios, which we are under the umbrella of, if there is a video that is uploaded without even putting any sort of titles or descriptions or tags, the AI will go through and automatically decipher what's being discussed within the one video.
00:07:37 So if it's a message where Jeff, for example, will be talking about abortion and the murder of babies, they will pick that up and they'll automatically demonetize you.
00:07:49 And Jeff's had to work on a couple different ways to get around that.
00:07:53 But that would be a definitive example where you see AI would be arguably suppressing the truth and unrighteousness.
00:08:00 That doesn't mean that somehow the AI is sinning, but it's artificially emulating those who believe that it's okay to murder your babies. Therefore, I'm going to make AI in my own image to be an extension of my suppression of the truth in unrighteousness.
00:08:17 Now, also, it has to do with when you believe, like, what is the ultimate purpose of us?
00:08:24 Like, when you talk about being part of, are we dealing with a history that's truly linear, that's going from, like, Genesis all the way to Revelation, definitive beginning, a fall into sin, and ultimately a redemption through Christ, both individually and collectively as far as Christ, and then redeeming the world, having a post-millennial hope.
00:08:42 That's something that's linear.
00:08:44 However, if you're embracing an Eastern worldview, there's not truly a beginning, there's not truly an end, and so you're going to view that.
00:08:52 Or if you're an evolutionist, you're going to say that ultimately it's just an involvement of the species, a survival of the fittest.
00:08:59 So somebody like Elon Musk, his worldview, if he's holding on to evolutionary perspective, he would see us as being really just tangibly body and flesh and just us and not really having a soul or spirit.
00:09:16 Now, if you're going to create AI and create technology to those presuppositions, that's where you look at Neuralink, and then you bring into question, this is technology that's being created, that we're being conditioned into, that is based off of presuppositions of who we are ontologically, they're not biblical.
00:09:35 whole. And so, I think when you're looking at this, and again, talking about one versus two,
00:09:41 is that we're in a society right now where we're going from a belief and a distinction between two,
00:09:47 where you're worshiping the Creator, and in that perspective, you're using AI. If you're building
00:09:52 AI and utilizing that to the glory of God, we're building it through the lens of two. Like, this
00:09:56 t-shirt was actually, Andrew created this. Yeah, that's AI. Yeah, it's AI. I did make that. I
00:10:01 Yeah, it's one of our t-shirts available in the store,
00:10:03 and it's shopcoldish.com.
00:10:05 And so you would see it, of that aspect,
00:10:08 like used for good.
00:10:09 There's ways you can love your neighbor
00:10:11 and be environmentally responsible.
00:10:13 There's actually a really interesting documentary
00:10:14 that came out that was hosted by Robert Downey Jr.,
00:10:16 a.k.a. Tony Stark,
00:10:18 and he was talking about how they can use AI.
00:10:21 There's pizza companies who use AI
00:10:23 where they do an algorithm
00:10:26 based off of the purchasing decisions
00:10:28 in different counties and districts,
00:10:30 whether or not they like pepperoni whether like whether or not they like sausage whether or not
00:10:35 they like um you know just a vegetarian pizza they want just bell peppers or whatever on it
00:10:40 and then they'll distribute those products accordingly to those stores so that way they
00:10:45 help they lay weights a lot less resources uh and they're being that's a way to be environmentally
00:10:51 responsible just to be a better stewards of what god's given you that that could save you
00:10:55 your restaurant a lot of money if you're a christian business person you want to say you
00:10:58 want to pay your employees more. And having worked briefly a couple of times in the food industry,
00:11:03 you realize the small little micro decisions equal to a lot, a lot of money. So you could
00:11:07 utilize that as a way to love your neighbor, pay your employees more, which would help towards 1.00
00:11:12 helping people in their households, provide for their families so the woman can stay home. So you 1.00
00:11:16 have, that would be viewing AI through a lens of two-ism, doing it to the glory of God. But if
00:11:23 you're viewing it through one-ism, and that's the majority of technology that's happening right now,
00:11:28 that's where it can become dangerous because then you see not only is this idea of a rejection of
00:11:33 personhood that we have as a as a preconditions of intelligibility through a christian worldview
00:11:38 um you're you're dealing it through a lens of assumptions of paganism but ultimately
00:11:43 the ascension the attempt to try and be white god to not try thinking you're doing something new
00:11:50 through modernity but in reality you're trying to really emulate what happened at the tower of
00:11:56 through technology and technocracy.
00:11:58 Yeah, that's good. I think thinking about it in the two forms
00:12:00 of narrow AI and open AI is very helpful,
00:12:03 because the goal for many people like Elon Musk
00:12:07 would be to avoid being overthrown by AI
00:12:11 as being the main producers of new things,
00:12:15 making humans essentially become irrelevant.
00:12:17 And that point would be called singularity.
00:12:19 So in order to avoid that, the goal would be
00:12:23 be to blend humanity with AI, right? I think the Bible is very clear that God uses the foolishness
00:12:32 of the gospel to shame the wisdom of the wise. So when I'm thinking about open AI, I'm thinking
00:12:36 about all of mankind's transcendental wisdom, right? Let's say it's loaded on some cloud
00:12:42 neural network, everything, everything on Google that you can think of. The goal would be to somehow
00:12:50 create a relationship between humanity and this cloud network in which you are constantly connected
00:12:57 with it and there's no bandwidth issues, right? So I already have a symbiotic relationship with
00:13:04 AI through my phone, this narrow AI with Google, but how long does it take me to get the information?
00:13:08 Well, how fast I touch it, right? Well, how fast the internet is. Imagine connecting your brain
00:13:15 to a cloud network in which you get all of that information like that and you're connected to
00:13:21 everybody. So I agree with Joel in the main sense. I think it's impossible because I think it's a
00:13:27 fundamentally a materialistic worldview that assumes that we're nothing but neurons firing
00:13:32 and impulses in the brain once you can control it. I don't believe that because I'm Christian.
00:13:36 I don't think it's something that can essentially happen, but that's the goal for the people with
00:13:40 that worldview right so avoid singularity by uh joining with this board collective consciousness
00:13:46 for example but then there's there's scary things with that like if you listen to joe rogan and elon
00:13:52 musk talking joe rogan asked him a great question he's like well how do we censor this type of free
00:13:57 speech on this cloud neural network really he says there's going to be some types of thoughts
00:14:02 that are not good that we want people to avoid uh and he says well what are you thinking he goes
00:14:08 I'm thinking like more like fundamentalism. And when we think of the words fundamentalism in a
00:14:12 secular society, we're thinking about Christian thought. And then what we think about even with
00:14:17 the Borg and Star Trek is how does the Borg essentially get disrupted and ended by self
00:14:23 government, right? That they're no longer connected to this neural network. But the goal really with
00:14:29 the wisdom of men is to create an omnipresent, omniscient, an omnipotent wisdom that we can
00:14:37 all connect to in order to be essentially gods of ourselves. It's transhumanism. That's the goal
00:14:42 of it, right? And eventually never die. It's just man's gospel. And it's just, there's nothing new
00:14:49 under the sun, right? It's the same lie that was given to man in the garden. Number one, I don't
00:14:53 think it's possible because I don't believe we're just material byproducts of neurons firing,
00:14:58 just matter in motion. I believe I have a soul. And I think that's something you can't emulate
00:15:02 or put into a computer system.
00:15:05 But it is a conversation that needs to take place
00:15:07 because philosophically,
00:15:08 this is like one of the biggest realms of thought
00:15:11 that's going within our nation right now.
00:15:13 How can we symbiotically connect to this system
00:15:17 to become gods?
00:15:18 And who can have access to this technology?
00:15:21 Real quick, before we continue with the show,
00:15:23 I wanted to let you know
00:15:24 that this is actually just one episode
00:15:26 of a 10-part series
00:15:28 that we will be slowly releasing to the public
00:15:31 on places like YouTube and your favorite podcast platform over the coming months.
00:15:37 However, if you want to get all 10 of these episodes right now, early access and ad-free,
00:15:44 we are making them available exclusively for our Patreon members over at patreon.com
00:15:51 forward slash right response ministries.
00:15:54 Here are the titles for just a few of those episodes.
00:15:57 We've got transhumanism and artificial intelligence.
00:16:01 We also have DMT and the astral realm.
00:16:05 We also have neo-paganism.
00:16:08 And another of my favorite episodes is an entire episode devoted to the Greys.
00:16:15 So again, head on over to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries and sign up
00:16:21 for our silver tier, which is just $5 a month.
00:16:25 And you'll be able to get all 10 of these episodes ad free right now.
00:16:30 And if you join us at the Gold Tier for just $10 a month, you'll get early access, ad-free
00:16:36 for the full 10 episodes, plus an additional live stream that I and the guys who join me
00:16:43 for this series, that's Jeremiah Roberts and Andrew Sunkrant, the three of us will be doing
00:16:48 live streams where we'll be taking questions from you, our Gold Tier Patreon members, and
00:16:54 providing for you the best answers that we possibly can from the Word of God.
00:16:58 So don't delay. Go to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries and become a supporter today.
00:17:05 Right. And yeah, to become God's and to escape death, the, you know, God's judgment for our sin and live forever, achieve immortality.
00:17:17 I do think we've talked about this offline a little bit, but I don't think it's achievable. I really don't.
00:17:24 I don't think God will allow it. And I think for the precise reasons that you said, Andrew,
00:17:30 because it doesn't take into account what man really is. They don't understand. It's not just
00:17:36 their theology is lacking. They don't have a proper, because their theology is lacking,
00:17:40 they don't have a proper anthropology. They don't know what man is. They think the world is just
00:17:44 stuff. And they think that you're just a meat bag, and that's neurons and all these things.
00:17:50 And so they don't take into account the fullness of man, spirit, and body.
00:17:56 So I don't think they can do it, but I do think they can make it look like they did it.
00:18:00 And so I think it's highly probable that as more and more people, as we become more and
00:18:08 more social media driven, where our lives are on the internet, there's so much that
00:18:15 you can find out about a person that you've never met without ever having a conversation
00:18:20 in real life with them simply by just scouring you know the the interweb you know and you can
00:18:27 find a lot you can find about you know the names of their parents and their children and this and
00:18:32 that the other their address you know that all these things are at least most of these things
00:18:37 much of these things are public information you know and then if the person's you know active on
00:18:42 social media then you can get a lot of their opinions and their tastes and their preferences
00:18:46 and memories, experiences.
00:18:49 And so I think that as time goes on
00:18:53 and people become even more public and less private
00:18:56 and more and more of their experiences
00:18:59 and characteristics and even memories
00:19:03 are being uploaded, uploaded, and uploaded
00:19:06 for all to see,
00:19:07 then I think there will be an opportunity
00:19:11 for the Elon Musk of the world
00:19:14 to say um you know for the the low low fee of you know initial fee for the uploading process
00:19:22 for this procedure where they take you know the body like you know the person or like right before
00:19:27 death before they die they come in with this machine you know and they hook it up and blah
00:19:31 blah blah and then there's of course going to be a hosting fee you know for all that bandwidth you
00:19:36 know so to keep you know uh sally you know your grandma sally you know uh comfortable and uh and
00:19:43 you know her vitality her virtual vitality up you know on the cloud uh every month you know
00:19:50 it's like paying rent you know you're gonna pay three thousand dollars a month you know
00:19:53 so that she gets to live forever you don't want her to die you know and it's gonna be the same
00:19:57 concept here's a funny thing it'll be the secular humanist um equivalent to the roman catholic 0.73
00:20:03 church with purgatory you know um so they you know if you pay enough money tetzel you know
00:20:09 every time a coin in the coffer clings the soul from purgatory springs so you can get them out 0.91
00:20:14 you know whereas with transhumanism it'll be so you can keep them in you know you have a monthly 0.96
00:20:19 you know fee and and that'll be worse uh because you know with tetzel it was you know pay this 0.98
00:20:25 and they're out but this will be you have to keep paying to keep them in you know and so anyways
00:20:30 now all that being said here's my here's my point i don't think that it'll be real i think they'll
00:20:35 be able to collect enough data to where you'll be able to talk to grandma sally you know allegedly
00:20:42 and grandma sally what are you doing today oh well you know in the virtual cloud i'm doing this
00:20:47 and and grandma sally will will say the things they'll be able to mimic her voice they'll be
00:20:53 able to mimic a hologram of her physical image they'll be able to mimic you know um and and she
00:20:59 she'll be able to say she'll say the types that it'll seem like grandma sally because they'll
00:21:04 have so much intel that we've that we've shared publicly through social media and all these kind
00:21:09 of things that grandma sally remember you know in 1999 when we did this and of course i remember
00:21:15 that and then and they'll be able to just spit right back yeah and then we did this and we did
00:21:19 that and it's accurate because that was shared at one point online and it has records of it so
00:21:24 here's the deal grandma sally if she wasn't a christian where is she actually she's in she's
00:21:29 in hell, but, but you think grandma Sally. And so even that, what are the implications with
00:21:35 evangelism and the urgency, you know, like, oh, we don't need to share the gospel anymore. Like
00:21:40 anyways, I'm rambling, but that's my side. You're tripping me out. You want to know why? It's
00:21:44 possible. Yeah. You you're tripping me out. You want to know why? Yeah. Because it reminds me of
00:21:48 a form of crystal ball gazing. Right. And that used to take different forms throughout the
00:21:52 centuries as staring in a mirror or the ancient Egyptians would stare at water until they see
00:21:56 something. And what would spirits do, right? Especially demons, they would mimic and they
00:22:01 would be counterfeits in order to give information. Maybe they would appear as your dead loved ones.
00:22:05 Right. I've heard stories of LDS. Familiar spirits. Right. I'd see your stories of LDS individuals 0.98
00:22:09 doing baptisms for the dead. And they're like, I saw my dead relative wave at me when I was
00:22:14 baptized for them. And then they disappeared. Right. You know what I mean? Those things happen
00:22:17 inside the temple. They say it does at least. What's interesting about what you're explaining,
00:22:22 it's almost like a man-made familiar spirit, right?
00:22:25 We're uploading it.
00:22:25 We're creating it.
00:22:26 These spirits, they're around us.
00:22:27 They watch.
00:22:28 They know everything about us.
00:22:29 And then you can get this form of entity contact
00:22:31 through crystal ball gazing, staring in a mirror,
00:22:33 staring in a river, right?
00:22:34 But now we're doing it for ourselves.
00:22:36 We're making counterfeit, counterfeit familiar spirits.
00:22:39 You're right.
00:22:39 It's a man-made familiar spirit,
00:22:41 which to be honest, if, I mean, that's like,
00:22:44 if you're going to tee it up that nicely for,
00:22:46 you know, the dark realm,
00:22:48 then it'll probably be both.
00:22:50 It'll be a man-made familiar spirit.
00:22:52 and then the familiar spirits, the ones that are real,
00:22:54 will say, that's too tempting.
00:22:56 I think we'll dabble a little bit too.
00:22:58 And then you'll have, you know,
00:22:59 so you have the man-made AI kind of thing going on
00:23:02 that's mimicking a familiar spirit.
00:23:04 And then are familiar spirits capable of attaching themselves
00:23:09 in that artificial realm and start kind of speaking
00:23:14 and guiding that, you know,
00:23:16 because if nobody's doing it, right?
00:23:17 Oh, well, that's the whole idea of AIs.
00:23:19 It's just, it's a hands-off kind of thing.
00:23:21 So, but man's hands, once we build it, and then our hands are off, can the demon's hands get on?
00:23:28 No, yeah.
00:23:28 And can they start?
00:23:29 I think so, man.
00:23:30 There's actually, and I don't recommend this for a friend, but there's AI threads going around where there's specific art with prompts that are given that create this very familiar looking demonic woman.
00:23:42 It's the same thing.
00:23:43 It has a name, and it actually has innovated multiple different forms of AI in art generation.
00:23:48 But it reminds me of what we talked about with Colin Samuul a long time ago when we were talking about aliens. Back when the nuclear threat was really wide going around during the Cold War, there's accounts of people who harness these codes to, you know, if they push a button, it's going to be a nuclear holocaust.
00:24:09 There's accounts of these systems being infiltrated by forces that were trying to launch codes when no one was.
00:24:18 And a lot of people think that it could have been demonic entities invading these systems in order to try to create a nuclear holocaust.
00:24:25 So the same thing would be with these familiar spirits using these types of modes of human wisdom in order to trick us and deceive us.
00:24:34 I see that being 110% a possibility.
00:24:37 Right.
00:24:37 Yeah, and what's very interesting, too,
00:24:39 in this conversation is that
00:24:40 it's just how much our thoughts on AI
00:24:44 have been influenced by
00:24:45 through the realm of Hollywood.
00:24:46 Yes.
00:24:47 So even a lot of times,
00:24:48 you'll do posts about something weird
00:24:49 going on with AI,
00:24:50 and people will say,
00:24:51 oh, Skynet is here.
00:24:53 What is that a reference to?
00:24:54 Obviously, the Terminator franchise.
00:24:56 Terminator 1 and 2 are the only ones that count.
00:24:58 That's the only ones I accept as canon.
00:25:00 Amen, dude.
00:25:01 But honestly,
00:25:03 what is tapped into is this fear.
00:25:05 What they represent in Terminator 1, and specifically Terminator 2,
00:25:10 there's this day, Judgment Day, which ultimately is articulated,
00:25:14 where everyone understands this, is a concept called singularity,
00:25:18 which eventually, there is going to be a moment
00:25:20 where the capacity of AI is going to take over.
00:25:24 We're not going to be able to turn it off.
00:25:26 And how you view singularity ultimately comes through
00:25:30 your presuppositions about who we are ontologically as people,
00:25:34 people, but also what is the purpose of ultimately existence and the meaning of the world. If we have
00:25:40 blind, pitiless, indifference where it's an evolutionary worldview, then you're looking at
00:25:44 survival of the fittest. Then if singularity means that this could be the ending of homeo sapiens
00:25:48 because we're just the next person on the chopping block. And so that's where Sam Harris has spoken
00:25:54 about his concerns about singularity. There's a reason why we talked about when we first launched
00:25:59 that Elon Musk is concerned that when we, if we don't shut off AI, we're opening up the demon that
00:26:03 we won't be able to turn it off.
00:26:06 And even, and again, it's presuppositions
00:26:08 that have to do with how we view the world
00:26:11 and even understanding the seen and the unseen realm.
00:26:14 So, another movie that was articulated
00:26:17 a couple years ago,
00:26:18 it wasn't really that great of a movie,
00:26:20 but it was with Johnny Depp called Transcendence.
00:26:23 And in that, his consciousness was uploaded to hard,
00:26:26 was uploaded onto this computer, a neural network system.
00:26:30 And so, that's a question where you start to have to ask,
00:26:33 Who are we truly? Is consciousness part of this individual collective? You've talked about one
00:26:40 versus two. If we live in a world of one-ism, then consciousness, there's no true distinctions
00:26:48 as far as me as a human being. I am just part of this hive. I'm part of the hive mind hive.
00:26:56 And so, through that presupposition, yes, I could, my consciousness, we could create technologies
00:27:02 to where I could be immortal, that might be a catalyst to achieve transcendence, which is
00:27:08 everyone within one-ism are always trying to do. And we'll get into the reason, but why that
00:27:13 ultimately is a bankrupt worldview. There's no way out. But what ends up happening where if you
00:27:21 look through a distinctly Christian worldview, what's the primary thing, what's the primary
00:27:25 scripture I think is the biggest counterpoint to the idea of the transcendence through uploading
00:27:30 your consciousness through a hard drive and to achieve immortality is that what does the scripture
00:27:34 say? To be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord. You're a pastor. You've hosted
00:27:41 funerals. And so, that's something that I've seen. I've been at funerals of specifically
00:27:47 Christians. That is the hope that one day, like the hope of the resurrection is based off of that
00:27:53 historical resurrection of Jesus Christ. The holding on to a view where you could achieve
00:27:59 immortality through technology. That is the most antichrist, antithetical disposition against
00:28:06 what the gospel is. And while we should love technology and utilize it, we're doing it right
00:28:12 now. We could, I could do a post right now about any topic that's even this discussion that would
00:28:19 be put in front of thousands of people all over the world. The last five to six years, I, for the
00:28:25 most part, besides when I'm at the studio, I've operated a cultist from my phone. Praise God for
00:28:30 that. This is a phone made by pagans. This is papyrus that was made by the pagans back in ancient,
00:28:35 you know, back in ancient times, like in the first century that was utilized for, you know,
00:28:39 thousands of years. And we use technology for that. Like, we have our scriptures here because
00:28:44 the pagans invented papyrus. And the same way we can use that. But then you have presuppositions
00:28:50 that go completely antithetical to everything that we should know about that.
00:28:56 And then you also have those right now in high power.
00:28:59 You have people like at the World Economic Forum
00:29:02 who are talking about how they want to create the fourth industrial revolution
00:29:07 where we are a full merger between technology.
00:29:11 We're part flesh and ontological flesh and human,
00:29:13 but we're completely integrated with technology
00:29:17 and believing that we're part of this mind hive.
00:29:20 And so that's where it's extremely dangerous because then you start making distinctions between the perfect human race and ones who just aren't as good.
00:29:30 Haves and the have-nots.
00:29:31 And you start creating have and have-nots.
00:29:33 So when you're part of a mind hive, you really, you could look at a genocide as just like an iOS update.
00:29:39 You're just updating to hire a phone.
00:29:40 You know, the perfect race is the iPhone, you know, 15 plus, where we were not too long ago, like, oh, we can just get rid of the iPhone, you know, the iPhone 4s.
00:29:52 We don't need those.
00:29:53 Those are less persons, you know, and so you would all of a sudden. 1.00
00:29:57 I don't think they'd get rid of a race. 1.00
00:29:58 I think they'd get rid of a sex. 1.00
00:30:00 I think they'd get rid of men. 0.99
00:30:02 White men, for starters, were first in the chopping block. 0.99
00:30:04 But seriously, I think they would get rid of men. 1.00
00:30:06 Like, at this point, you know, we've probably got enough.
00:30:09 Yeah. 0.89
00:30:09 semen on file? Do you really need men to continue the human race? 1.00
00:30:17 Wow. That's interesting. I'm thinking of this crazy dystopian universe right now. But what's
00:30:23 interesting is being a Christian, it's like, I don't want the wisdom of the world. I want the
00:30:27 wisdom of God to flow in me through his word. There's this weird Gnostic heresy that still 1.00
00:30:33 permeates throughout our culture today, that there's this weird transcendent form of wisdom
00:30:38 that we must tap into in order to create the perfect human, you know, the spark of divine
00:30:45 within humanity, the, the, the one ism, right? The flesh is evil. There's wisdom that I must get.
00:30:50 So we're creating this cloud conscious network of all of human wisdom. Uh, and then if we just
00:30:57 tap into that, we'll have salvation, right? Uh, through maybe a material item used a neural link,
00:31:03 for example. But the point I'm trying to make is, is that won't save you. And it won't save you
00:31:09 from the judgment of God, right? It says it's appointed for all men to die once and then comes 0.91
00:31:12 the judgment. Salvation comes through Christ's sacrifice on the cross for us and the wisdom
00:31:18 that we inherit of God through the Holy Spirit, because nobody knows the mind of God. AI doesn't
00:31:24 know the mind of God, except for the Holy Spirit, who is God. And when he dwells in you through his
00:31:28 word, you can have a relationship with him. Like I will have immortality because of what Jesus did
00:31:33 in God with me. It's really just a counterfeit gospel. It's a counterfeit gospel. It's counterfeit
00:31:41 wisdom. It won't save anybody. Instead, it makes individuals think that in order to avoid this
00:31:46 judgment of singularity, which you were talking about, instead of placing their faith in Christ,
00:31:51 you're placing it in the wisdom of men and material objects. Yeah, that's good. Yeah.
00:31:57 It's kind of a part of the eternal life that we always forget. It's not just immortality and
00:32:02 living forever. But it's, you know, Jesus says, and this is eternal life, that they know me,
00:32:08 you know, they know the father, you know, and me who you have sent. And, and so part of eternal
00:32:15 life, a significant part of eternal life is relationship with God and knowing God. Whereas
00:32:20 it seems like, you know, this, this counterfeit gospel is the immortality piece there. So to
00:32:26 escape judgment, to not die. And then, you know, I feel like the transhumanist would say, and this
00:32:32 eternal life knowing self you know like you know instead of knowing me knowing god it's you know 0.98
00:32:37 deeper and deeper and deeper knowledge of self which again i don't think they'll be able to
00:32:42 achieve i think they'll be able to fake and pretend to get you to pay that monthly fee for
00:32:46 you know grandma sally um but here's the thing i don't think they'll uh achieve it and i have some
00:32:51 like and not just because i'm guessing on a whim i have some serious theological convictions for
00:32:55 why objectively i don't think they'll be able to uh achieve it but uh even if they were it would
00:33:01 it would become quickly devolve into hell it would just be it would be you know because eternal life
00:33:07 of loving knowing self apart from christ um and devolving further and further spiraling into
00:33:13 self um and then this hive mind of of other selves of humanity as a whole and and its depravity and
00:33:22 like we were saying from the very beginning even with you know narrow ai which is what we have now
00:33:27 And we've had for a very long time, you know, things like chat GPT are just a further evolved, but it's still firmly in the category of narrow AI.
00:33:35 And these are just tools, right?
00:33:37 A hammer, you can build a house, you can bash in a man's skull. 0.87
00:33:40 You know, it's just a tool.
00:33:42 And to be fair, it's a very, very, very powerful tool.
00:33:45 It's a much, you know, further developed and upgraded tool, but it's still just a tool.
00:33:50 um and so anyway but my point is just to say that i i don't think um if we somehow could
00:33:58 achieve transhumanism i think it would uh it would not be neutral that's that's my point
00:34:04 it's just a tool and it's always going to have the imprint of man on it um and because man is
00:34:12 inherently evil apart from salvation which comes through christ alone um you would be devolving
00:34:17 not knowing Christ and Him crucified, but knowing further and further self and other selves
00:34:23 in this virtual world that is not neutral, but very much reflective of man who is totally
00:34:34 depraved apart from Christ. My point is, it would be a virtual hell. All we would have done is we
00:34:40 wouldn't have achieved eternal life. We would have just made hell 2.0. There's God's hell,
00:34:45 and then there's Mansell.
00:34:47 They're both bad and you can go to either one.
00:34:50 And again, I don't think we'll achieve it, but.
00:34:55 Right Response Ministries 2025 conference is a go.
00:35:00 This is three days, full jam-packed conference
00:35:03 with eight main sessions,
00:35:05 three to four hour and a half long panels
00:35:07 and an all-star super-based lineup of speakers,
00:35:11 15 speakers in all.
00:35:13 Who are they?
00:35:13 Steve Dace, Jeff Durbin, Orne McIntyre, Stephen Wolfe, Brian Sauve, Andrew Isker, John Harris,
00:35:21 Eric Kahn, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, the Christian Prince himself, Dusty Devers,
00:35:27 Ben Garrett, David Reese, and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webin. Again, this is April 3rd,
00:35:33 4th, and 5th, 2025, and the early registration is open right now. This is the longest conference
00:35:41 with the most speakers we've ever offered, and yet it is our all-time lowest price.
00:35:46 The early registration available today is only $140 for an adult.
00:35:52 So go to rightresponseconference.com.
00:35:55 Again, that is rightresponseconference.com to register right now
00:36:00 because the early registration will not last long.
00:36:05 Yeah, it's really weird.
00:36:06 like when i think about ai and if there was a possibility let's say to to up to put this
00:36:12 consciousness inside of you let's just say there's a possibility uh again upload your consciousness
00:36:17 to the cloud or put to put all of it into you okay like a neural link kind of yeah yeah so
00:36:22 what i'm thinking about i know what terrified me when i was a child and that was demon possession
00:36:26 right i think i first saw the exorcist when i was 10 i don't recommend it for anybody you were 10
00:36:31 I was 10. It terrified me. But that scared me. Possession scared me. But when I'm thinking about
00:36:38 a symbiotic relationship with no bandwidth between this transcendental wisdom of all men,
00:36:43 I'm thinking about demonic possession in a weird sense. It's not a demon. It's a counterfeit. But
00:36:48 you're literally paying for someone to possess you and take away all of your self-government.
00:36:52 If you're connected to all of these people, it's essentially possession. And that terrifies me.
00:36:57 it's a weird form of a counterfeit Holy spirit, right?
00:37:02 Like I want the Holy spirit to dwell in me,
00:37:04 to have the mind of Christ, Philippians chapter two,
00:37:07 to consider others higher than myself.
00:37:09 Instead of the mind of collective man,
00:37:11 the mind of mankind.
00:37:12 So instead of being like Christ,
00:37:15 the Holy spirit possessing me and dwelling within me,
00:37:18 I have mankind dwelling within me,
00:37:20 collective mankind and the mind of man
00:37:22 instead of the mind of Christ.
00:37:23 Yeah.
00:37:24 Yeah. 0.89
00:37:24 It's straight up putting Babel inside of you. 0.97
00:37:25 Yeah. 0.99
00:37:26 Yeah.
00:37:26 Weird.
00:37:27 Yeah.
00:37:27 Another example would be the merging of technology and it really is indicative on what worldview that you have because a lot of even what's being articulated, it has been readily available for thousands of years, way before the technology was ever invented.
00:37:42 So, when you look at, like, what is occultism primarily?
00:37:46 What's really interesting is that, you know, the main thing, like, throughout the Old Testament, there's not really that much mention of demons.
00:37:54 There's only a couple of examples that are given.
00:37:57 Like you have the instance with Samuel and the woman of Endor.
00:38:01 But as a whole, the dangers of the occult is not because it's going to open up the demons.
00:38:07 It's because it's an abomination to God.
00:38:10 So really what's emphasized throughout the Old Testament when it comes to that is to fear Yahweh.
00:38:15 That's what's really emphasized.
00:38:16 There's not too much focus on demons.
00:38:18 And all of a sudden, you have in the New Testament that they're everywhere.
00:38:22 Like you look in the Gospel of Mark and it's like Omaha Beach with just the invisible principalities and powers going on.
00:38:29 So what you end up seeing, though, is that when it comes to AI, technology is inherently neutral.
00:38:36 But what you're seeing is that it can be a catalyst for good and a catalyst for evil.
00:38:41 Like one way that we'll get into is like here's a pinnacle example of where people think it's modernity and it's new to evolved technology, but there's nothing new under the sun is Dr. Stephen Greer.
00:38:51 We'll talk more about that in our episode on the Greys, but he's someone who's a, I believe he's a physicist. He knows quite a bit about the whole UFO conversation, but what he ends up advocating for is that the government has, you know, because of their, you know, they're trying to hide UFOs and aliens as a way to cover up for, you know, they're trying to not make it accessible to us.
00:39:15 So therefore, we need to start having CE5 disclosures, which are close encounters of the fifth kind. And that's by getting into seances and occultic practices to get in contact with entities. Therefore, you can over surpass the middleman, which is the government trying to hide everything away.
00:39:32 But where I'm going with this in connection technology and AI, he utilizes this by telling people to download this app that's available through his website in the Apple Store where you can conduct a CE5 disclosure through an app on your phone.
00:39:46 Now, while an app is an app, it has probably the same technology, the same encoding that will be utilized for like a Bible app, or if you have an app, or there's other Christian companies that have a good app that can be used for the glory of God.
00:39:58 The same coding might be used for his website that might be used for the same principles will be for like ApologyStudios.com or for our website.
00:40:07 But that technology is being used as a catalyst where there's nothing new under the sun.
00:40:13 that technology is being utilized to do something that god and his law warns about and says don't
00:40:18 do that don't cross over don't try and transcend through these occultic practices through these
00:40:26 sorcerers and magicians so at once was the divining rods you think about the comparison with moses
00:40:31 when he is putting the gods on trial uh when he's putting the plagues in egypt's one of the first
00:40:36 thing he does when he goes before pharaoh both of them cast down their rods right both of the rods
00:40:42 turn into snakes. Aaron did it through the power of God. Like feral sorcerers, they did the same
00:40:50 thing. However, it is done through their practice of the dark arts, being involved with that.
00:40:56 So then the question is, in the same way how those two rods are together, like they both got used,
00:41:01 but had different powers tapped into it, you have technology that can, if you're not careful,
00:41:06 it'll be tapped into really the nothing new into the sun, which is just ancient neo-paganism.
00:41:12 You have a predisposition of oneness, and it's not just technology. Now we're trying to bend
00:41:17 the universe to our will. That's the technology going on behind CERN, you know, and that's a
00:41:22 whole rabbit hole in it. But even like the presuppositions is that I'm God, I have control
00:41:29 over the universe, I am one with the universe, and I can bend the universe to my will. And I can,
00:41:34 In the same way how you could build a temple goddess and to be able to tap into unknown powers and information, I want to utilize, instead of using bricks and stone, I want to use technology to try and get in contact with entities that bend the universe to my will so I can practice alchemy through technology.
00:41:53 I mean, yeah, this has been going on for ages, man. Like there's books, which we'll talk about later as well. When we talk about Mormonism, like the Magus that gives sacred geometry and rituals and rites, if they're done in certain ways, or if you pray a certain way on a certain day, you're able to contact God essentially to get divine revelation.
00:42:15 uh there is nothing new under the sun as long as you do x y or z you're able to gain this type of
00:42:22 knowledge which will eventually lead to some type of awakening in your soul or in your mind it just
00:42:27 went from sacred daggers and circles on the ground to material objects placed inside the brain right
00:42:33 you know but i mean there's a benefit though to neural link because it's basically created in its
00:42:38 most basic form to help people medically right like it has been implanted there's a youtube video
00:42:43 of a man talking about it.
00:42:44 Mind you, he's still in a wheelchair
00:42:45 when he's talking.
00:42:46 But the benefits of Neuralink
00:42:48 neurologically could eventually lead
00:42:50 to someone who's paralyzed
00:42:51 actually be able to walk one day
00:42:53 because that does actually have nerve,
00:42:56 you know, that does work biologically
00:42:57 in that sense.
00:42:58 But that's separating it from
00:43:00 connecting to your soul to consciousness.
00:43:02 You know what I mean?
00:43:03 So that's a good thing.
00:43:05 That's something I should praise God about. 1.00
00:43:07 Eventually, maybe a blind person
00:43:09 getting Neuralink will be able to see.
00:43:11 I don't know.
00:43:11 That could work one day.
00:43:13 that's a good thing. Just like you talked about with the technology with your iPhone.
00:43:17 Now I can stream and give the gospel to thousands of people online, just at a push of a button.
00:43:23 That's a good thing. But we have to be very wary though, of the ability for people to take
00:43:29 something that can be used for good and use it for evil. But I mean, God even used the Egyptian
00:43:36 culture to be plundered by the Jews. They gave them their gold and said, leave after the death 0.99
00:43:41 of the firstborn. But what was the problem, right? The Jews eventually took that gold and
00:43:45 they instructed Aaron to build a golden calf and they worshiped it. So the warning that we have 0.95
00:43:50 in scripture is if we are to plunder these types of things as Christians in the future, 0.53
00:43:55 if God gives us this technology, we don't want to do what the pagans do and worship it instead
00:44:00 of use it to the glory of God. Amen. So practically speaking, what are, for now,
00:44:06 If there's, you know, for the listener who's saying, well, I, you know, I want to use narrow 0.86
00:44:13 AI as a tool because I think that if Christians just collectively wholesale reject it out
00:44:21 of some superstitious, because I wouldn't say that it's theologically rooted, it would
00:44:26 be a superstitious non-Christian win of like, we're not going to do that for the same reason 0.70
00:44:33 that, you know, our grandparents' generation
00:44:36 didn't use playing cards, right?
00:44:39 Not just that they didn't gamble, right?
00:44:40 There could be a reason, you know,
00:44:41 biblical argument made about that.
00:44:44 But like, you know, my grandparents wanted,
00:44:47 they were Baptist, classic Baptist move here. 0.71
00:44:50 But they, you know, they would do Uno or Domino's, right? 0.92
00:44:56 But not playing cards, right?
00:44:59 Because playing cards, it's like,
00:45:00 well, you gamble with those.
00:45:02 like no one's ever, you know, bet on dominoes.
00:45:05 But consistency wasn't the point. 0.83
00:45:09 It was arbitrary, good old-fashioned Baptist superstition. 0.88
00:45:15 Not based in scripture, not with a theological principle, 0.98
00:45:19 but a very, you know, just a Christianese veneer,
00:45:23 but really superstition.
00:45:26 So all that being said, 0.96
00:45:27 And if Christians take that approach to narrow AI, I think it'll be just one more chapter 0.94
00:45:36 and a significant chapter in the saga of Christians abdicating and handing over to the pagans 0.99
00:45:45 another massive W, another big win, you know what I mean? 0.81
00:45:48 And we fall completely behind because of ultimately in the end, not fidelity to Christ and wanting
00:45:55 to remain pure, but actually just bad doctrine. Yeah. No, you guys were, because you were
00:46:00 theologically anemic and dumb, ignorant, because you're ignorant, theologically ignorant. You 1.00
00:46:08 thought that this was the righteous thing to do. I'm not going to use this or whatever. And once
00:46:13 again, you gave just another massive portion of real estate to the pagans. Yeah. What Paul says
00:46:21 whether you eat or drink, whatever you do, do all things to the glory of God. There's that weird
00:46:27 fear of doing something that could be innately evil to create a biblical conviction that's not
00:46:33 based on the truth in terms of trying to glorify the fear of man. And you're not going to glorify
00:46:39 God in that in terms of technology, I'd say. Like we can do AI and use narrow AI to the glory of
00:46:46 God. It's real. I made a shirt right there that could be used to help fund cultish, a ministry
00:46:52 in which the gospel goes out to different types of demographics in the world. And that's all to
00:46:58 the glory of God. We must have that ability to see that and have our biblical convictions grounded
00:47:05 in the truth. Right. So my question is practically like, what would be the product or what would be
00:47:12 the, the type of AI. So narrow AI, it's a tool. It can be utilized. Christians should not be
00:47:18 superstitious and just completely forsake it and fall behind. Okay. And I, I took too long earlier 0.95
00:47:24 to say that, but that's basically what I was saying. But here's, here's the question. Um,
00:47:28 when, when should the Christian, uh, when should there, what, what legitimately would be a red
00:47:34 flag, like in practical terms, what would be the product that comes out on the market where you
00:47:39 guys would say, oh, that one is too far. Like, it's not just a tool that's, you know, neutrality
00:47:46 is a myth. It's a tool and it can be used, you know, positively or negatively for the glory of
00:47:50 God or, you know, or against God. No, no, that one, it's, no, no, that's not just a hammer,
00:47:56 you know, that can be used well or be used poorly. No, that one, to embrace that at all
00:48:02 would be, you know what I mean? Because there are certain things, like in the scripture,
00:48:06 where it's like, okay, hammer can be good, hammer can be bad.
00:48:09 And then there's other things like, 0.69
00:48:10 and you shall not suffer a witch to live. 0.94
00:48:12 Right, right. 0.95
00:48:13 I get it.
00:48:14 Necromancy is not like, now necromancy, you know,
00:48:16 can be wielded in very positive ways.
00:48:18 Right.
00:48:19 No, no necromancy.
00:48:21 I'd like to hear your thought, Jerry, but real quick,
00:48:24 what I think it would be, it would be like the forbidden fruit.
00:48:26 Do not eat of that, right?
00:48:28 The fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil.
00:48:31 And for the unhinged listener,
00:48:32 when Andrew says the forbidden fruit,
00:48:34 He is not saying, I believe it's any Apple product.
00:48:39 Right, right, right, right.
00:48:40 Because I've got some guys who might be, I hear you.
00:48:43 I see that wink, brother.
00:48:44 I hear you loud and clear.
00:48:46 You're going to mash that iPhone?
00:48:47 Yeah, so that fruit.
00:48:48 That's not what you're saying.
00:48:48 No, no, no.
00:48:49 That fruit would be if there's an item that tells me that I can gain all of the wisdom of the world and become just like God.
00:48:57 Right.
00:48:58 Put it in your body.
00:48:59 Become possessed.
00:49:01 No.
00:49:02 Like, that's where I would hardcore draw the line.
00:49:04 No, I want to be indwelt by the Holy Spirit.
00:49:06 I don't need the wisdom of the world.
00:49:08 God chooses the foolish things, the shame, the wise.
00:49:10 And I am going to be indwelt by the Holy Spirit.
00:49:12 And I'll vehemently reject anything that connects me,
00:49:15 if it were even to be possible,
00:49:17 to a collective consciousness of man's sinful nature.
00:49:20 Amen.
00:49:20 Now, what about the thing that goes in your body
00:49:22 that is strictly, like we talked about earlier,
00:49:24 to help the blind guy see or fix your spine
00:49:27 or the paraplegic to walk,
00:49:29 but we don't know,
00:49:31 could have the possibility later on to be hacked yeah and you see what i'm saying right yeah that's
00:49:37 scary that's hard like what do you say like pastorally what do you say to someone in your 0.92
00:49:42 congregation who's in a wheelchair and let's say it's seven years from now and they they elon's
00:49:47 he's finally done it allegedly he's got this thing and yeah you know it'll cost some money but
00:49:52 they'll be able to walk without a cane without crutches without you know they'll be able to walk
00:49:56 and put that retire the chair but that factory down the road we just drove past maybe they're
00:50:00 working on that right now yeah yeah i know yeah but there's the the the chance and we don't know
00:50:05 but there is the chance that it's not wrong it's not morally wrong now but that same technological
00:50:12 framework is now in your body and could be hacked it's kind of like some of the arguments with the
00:50:19 mrna vaccine it's like right right this thing is now in you and then we can activate it remember
00:50:24 when people were worried about the 5g um you know they were going to send this message and
00:50:29 then everybody who had gotten the vaccine it would that message was going to use a certain
00:50:33 frequency that would then activate this portion of the vaccine certain chemical that would boom
00:50:38 you know and like um what about that you know what about like okay it's it it is still technically
00:50:44 narrow ai and it's for a medical purpose and that's all it's for as of now but the technological
00:50:52 like the foundation has now been laid and not just laid in a product outside but laid in your flesh
00:50:58 in your body, attached to you, that could later on if a switch is flipped. And that's tough.
00:51:05 Right. I think the way that I'm navigating this is just through the realm of being a new husband
00:51:10 and a new father is really, I'm thinking through the lens of what's the jurisdiction when it comes
00:51:15 to the God-given spheres of government? You have self-government, family government, church
00:51:20 government. And while this phone right here is a great piece, like I've got a picture of my little
00:51:26 man right here, and that's the example that I have the responsibility to be his father, to be
00:51:30 the best person that I can, that God's called me to be. But there's a lot of technology on this
00:51:36 phone. There's app developers right now that have an agenda that want to get their hands on my
00:51:44 children, on our children. Specifically, that's a violation of that jurisdiction. And now, right now,
00:51:49 you know, we've even talked with my wife about like, okay, well, how do we, what are we even
00:51:54 going to allow screen time like what are we going to allow him to watch it and at some points
00:51:58 inevitable how do we actually introduce him to this stuff and my question is that right now it's
00:52:03 2024 my son will be 10 in the year 2034 like well is it will even will phones even be a thing
00:52:10 right so if we're going to look at this sort of technology they're already physically trying to
00:52:16 get they already have their hands on their children trying to brainwash them into thinking that
00:52:20 well, you should just take these different puberty blockers 0.99
00:52:24 and we should cut off your private parts 0.99
00:52:25 for people who are underage. 0.99
00:52:27 They're already that aggressive.
00:52:29 What's going to happen when we have the technology 1.00
00:52:31 to implement them to try and create even more gender?
00:52:35 I'm just throwing out conjecture, 0.95
00:52:38 but if they're going to try and implement technology
00:52:41 to even do Neuralink for children
00:52:43 so they can do this, that, and the other,
00:52:46 are they going to work behind my back?
00:52:48 They've already demonstrated to go behind children's backs.
00:52:51 You've seen this with the parents who are going and complaining,
00:52:57 and they're super brave for standing up to the school board
00:52:59 because they never should have handed them over in the first place,
00:53:03 and they're doing the gender confusion behind their back. 0.95
00:53:06 Who's to say they're not going to do the same thing 0.99
00:53:08 when there's that technology?
00:53:09 How dare you teach my children pictures of pornography 0.75
00:53:13 in an elementary school?
00:53:15 Would you like to teach your children yourself?
00:53:17 No, I wear a pantsuit.
00:53:19 I'm a boss babe, and I will not quit my career.
00:53:22 Yeah.
00:53:23 Oh, and you're a conservative?
00:53:25 Mm-hmm.
00:53:25 That's cute.
00:53:26 Right.
00:53:27 Now, but if you're going to utilize that new technology
00:53:30 to where you're going to utilize that to go behind my back
00:53:34 to try and influence my son, you know,
00:53:37 to be, you know, just to be, you know,
00:53:39 to explore his gender identity
00:53:41 and that sort of stuff behind my back, 0.96
00:53:42 that's a direct violation of my God-given jurisdiction
00:53:45 as a father, as a head of my household.
00:53:48 So then, in that case,
00:53:50 that's where you have to practice
00:53:51 with wisdom and discernment.
00:53:53 How do you not be paranoid,
00:53:54 but also know that this sort of technology
00:53:57 is going to be an unequivocal violation
00:53:59 of the jurisdiction?
00:54:01 That could happen also, too,
00:54:02 in the sphere of church government.
00:54:04 There's already the question right now
00:54:05 about whether or not pastors should use AI
00:54:07 to help with their sermon transcripts.
00:54:09 Well, what are the presuppositions behind AI?
00:54:11 They've already shown that,
00:54:12 I think it was with the chat GPT,
00:54:14 where there's a distinction
00:54:15 in trying what they'll say about Jesus
00:54:17 versus what they will say about Muhammad. 0.61
00:54:19 Oh, yeah. 0.68
00:54:19 They will not, there's already blasphemy laws
00:54:21 already ingrained within AI.
00:54:22 Into the algorithm.
00:54:23 Right, so then the question is,
00:54:26 how much should you allow AI to be integrated with this?
00:54:29 So if we end up under, you know,
00:54:30 a sort of totalitarian technocracy state,
00:54:34 like, are there going to be thought crimes behind,
00:54:37 you know, if you even think to entertain
00:54:39 the exegesis behind Romans 1
00:54:41 when it comes to the role of transgenderism
00:54:42 and homosexuality?
00:54:43 And again, there's nothing inherently evil, inherently about AI, or AI is inherently neutral. But if the creators behind Silicon Valley, who ultimately have a worldview of one-ism, their antithetically, their worldviews and their predispositions are opposed to the Christian worldview, their presuppositions are going to be read into the text.
00:55:06 So, if you, and ultimately, now you're blurring distinctions.
00:55:10 Into the code.
00:55:10 Right.
00:55:11 And now, this is, you think about this, this is another level to it.
00:55:15 Now you're blurring distinctions between the material and the immaterial,
00:55:18 because what's the role of, what's one of the primary roles of the Holy Spirit?
00:55:24 Now, we all, we ask Christians, we have the predisposition that all Scripture is inspired by God.
00:55:29 But ultimately, one of the roles of the Holy Spirit is to illuminate the text of Scripture.
00:55:35 But if you have an artificially emulated version with predispositions antithetical to the Christian worldview,
00:55:41 you're now relying on this arbitrary, vague technocracy to eisegete the text of Scripture versus the Holy Spirit.
00:55:49 Right, it's another replacement of the Holy Spirit.
00:55:51 Like Andrew, it's just another example of replacing the Holy Spirit.
00:55:56 And it also eradicates obedience to the first and greatest commandment,
00:56:02 to love the Lord your God with all your heart, all your soul, but also all your mind.
00:56:05 that i no longer have to actively you know love god with my mind but that one you know won't be
00:56:12 a big deal to most evangelicals who haven't been loving god with their minds for at least
00:56:16 60 70 years um we you know we we stopped doing obeying that commandment a very long time ago
00:56:22 right but doctrine divides and you know that's no creed but christ and you know like we've been
00:56:28 anti-intellectual right uh you know forsaking loving the lord with our minds as evangelicals
00:56:34 for a very long time.
00:56:36 You're right.
00:56:36 And viewing this,
00:56:38 and viewing artificial intelligence
00:56:39 through the lens of God's sovereignty
00:56:42 and him working all things out
00:56:44 according to the pleasure of his will,
00:56:45 and you truly do believe that,
00:56:47 then you can understand technology
00:56:49 and its purposes,
00:56:50 what AI can and can't do.
00:56:52 So going back to canon,
00:56:54 Terminator 1, Terminator 2,
00:56:55 the idea of a machine going on,
00:56:58 taking embryonic cybernetic organism
00:57:01 because of the human tissue,
00:57:02 like that happening,
00:57:03 could not happen according in a world that is governed by the sovereign eternal God of Scripture.
00:57:11 Because the one thing is that he is sovereign, he ordains the rising and the falling of kings.
00:57:17 So, according to that predisposition, there's no technology possible to create a portal to go
00:57:23 back in time and space to re-alter history. That would mean that there's an aspect of,
00:57:28 There's a realm in which Christ is not sovereign over.
00:57:32 You cannot go back and try to alter it.
00:57:36 It's not possible.
00:57:37 The same reason why you can't upload someone's consciousness into a hard drive,
00:57:42 because to be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord.
00:57:45 The only way there could be appearance through that would be demonic deception.
00:57:49 And that's where, for me, it gets weird,
00:57:51 because now you're dealing with a part where it's not just technology.
00:57:54 right because and then again someone like elon would have the predisposition that you're just
00:57:59 dealing with like flesh and bone and the neural link is that but now the question is okay if you're
00:58:05 uploading grandma to a hard drive her consciousness to a hard drive so you can you can cause you
00:58:09 communicate with her okay what what a fee right what what what is that is that is that something
00:58:17 that's new is that majority is something brand new i think on one hand it's uh well first and
00:58:21 it's not her right so we know that but then you know then that gives a couple alternatives one
00:58:27 it's a highly sophisticated narrow ai program right and then the other option is it's a little
00:58:36 bit of that and also it's a playground a virtual playground for demons yeah that come in and also
00:58:43 manipulate the program so that grandma uh grandma uh it's so funny you know because in life grandma
00:58:49 just wanted to talk about you know the weather and you know and her cat that she loved we would
00:58:54 you know but now grandma always wants to talk to me about theology and about this one world order 0.93
00:59:01 and how we should care more about women and a global you know government and the environment
00:59:07 oh well at that point it's like okay well you should have known it wasn't grandma all along
00:59:13 but secondly this is you know a highly sophisticated technological program
00:59:18 and here's the thing it could also be demons who want that or it also could just be the highly
00:59:25 sophisticated program that's not neutral because it was made by men who are also they were influenced
00:59:30 by demons and so yeah and either but in either case really to in some level it's in some level
00:59:36 it's uh irrelevant like it's either uh the it's the raw program that was made by demonic men
00:59:43 and therefore has a demonic messaging or it's the the it's not completely the program it's part
00:59:50 program but then that becomes facilitates the context for demons to act but in both cases it's
00:59:56 uh it's it's it leaves room for demonic influence whether it's you know so anyway it's like a tap
01:00:02 into the prince of the power of the air for a fee right like you asked you asked a question like
01:00:06 ethically when do we draw that line so if we put technology technology in our body that could
01:00:12 eventually be hijacked um ought we be able should we put that in our bodies in the first place
01:00:20 so i've never thought about that to be honest um so i'm trying to think through that right now and
01:00:25 the implications to say well since it could happen or living in a what if i will not get that but i
01:00:31 mean the same thing could be used instead about the electric grid and electricity you know what
01:00:35 i mean right uh the electric grid could be tapped and taken away from us and all of the energy
01:00:40 can be used and placed into something else maybe i'm missing categories here in my thinking i do
01:00:45 think those are separate categories just in the sense of like it being in your body able to
01:00:50 influence your mind okay like sure we're reliant on lots of things like i am dude i yeah i am very
01:00:56 reliant on electricity i'm a soft man in that regard you know and and if i lost it man because
01:01:03 of all the dependencies that i have on you know stove and oven and lights and you know all these
01:01:09 kinds of things uh life would be very hard but it wouldn't um my mind would still be free right i
01:01:17 would still be me i'd have some challenges i'd have to figure some things out but you'd have
01:01:21 someone recording us with a little crank camera yeah right yeah yeah yeah he'd be running in the
01:01:26 back right but i'd still i'd still be me yeah you know whereas i so i do think it's a different
01:01:31 category but i hear you i don't know i don't know you know because i would of course i'd be like no
01:01:36 way would i uh get a chip put in me um but here's something you know to consider i'm also not in a
01:01:42 wheelchair yeah right like that's just a whole nother level of decision making right when it's
01:01:48 like chip that could be hacked, but also I can walk. I really like to walk. I don't want to get
01:02:00 hacked. I like to think as well. Yeah, exactly. So for me, it's like, yeah, no chip, no brainer.
01:02:06 Yeah. And I think ultimately it comes down to just walking in wisdom. And I think in the book
01:02:12 of Colossians is one of my favorite books in the entire New Testament. And one other thing that
01:02:16 Paul says, and again, he's talking to an audience that's like, Colossae was as pagan as you could
01:02:22 get. Like, as much as we're sort of talking about, you know, the return of the old gods and kind of
01:02:26 the rise of neo-paganism, everything that we're facing, like, this is a burnt, like, Colossae was
01:02:32 a burning man 24-7 on steroids. Like, that's what you were really dealing with, with that
01:02:38 congregation when he's writing to. But he says, conduct yourself with wisdom towards outsiders,
01:02:43 making the most of every opportunity, but let your speech be with salt, you know, season with salt.
01:02:48 And he even talks about, it may not be the same, but he also in another part of the scripture,
01:02:53 he talks about being wise as serpents and gentle as does.
01:02:55 So it is a matter of just conducting yourself with wisdom, understanding the world and the culture and where it's headed,
01:03:02 where, again, a lot of people will look at the rise of transhumanism,
01:03:06 think they're tapping into something brand new that no one else has done before.
01:03:09 but when you actually look at what the ancient pagans did,
01:03:13 there's really nothing new under the sun.
01:03:15 And that's where, you know, even when we're talking about technology
01:03:18 and we're talking about in other eras,
01:03:19 I mean, we're talking about how Austin is kind of like
01:03:21 the new technocracy is taking over San Francisco.
01:03:24 And a lot of even, like, a lot of people around Amazon,
01:03:29 Google, who've pushed a lot of the modern AI,
01:03:32 and there's been some weird things happening
01:03:34 where they did the race swapping that happened.
01:03:36 And that's connected, you know,
01:03:38 they have predispositions of critical race. 0.99
01:03:39 Oh, Gemini. How do you say it? 0.92
01:03:41 Gemini, you're right.
01:03:42 Gemini, yeah.
01:03:42 And it was like, show me a colonial blah, blah, blah. 1.00
01:03:46 Black, black. 0.99
01:03:47 It just erased white people. 0.99
01:03:49 Right. 0.78
01:03:49 So you see like predispositions.
01:03:51 Like straight up, no apology.
01:03:53 I forgot about that.
01:03:54 But a lot of times the creativity that's utilized for those who are creating technology,
01:03:57 they're doing it by psychedelic usage.
01:03:59 They're trying to normalize that.
01:04:02 And now also you have a lot of the major technocracies.
01:04:05 They're burners.
01:04:06 They're very heavily involved in Burning Man, which we'll get into.
01:04:08 too, but that's just a thing where you don't want to be...
01:04:11 We're doing an episode on Burning Man, too, yeah.
01:04:13 And so you're not going to be...
01:04:14 At the end of the day, I think you need to not be fearful of technology, but I think
01:04:18 this is where you need to really do your work.
01:04:23 This is as much as some of the people would try and argue against, that the Christian
01:04:28 walk is the ultimate work of the intellect, because you have to really...
01:04:33 You're called to love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength.
01:04:38 You love Him with every ontological distinction of who we are, both with our body and also with
01:04:45 our spirit. And I think through that, you need to understand, okay, who am I? How is God sovereign
01:04:52 in this role? What is this technology? Is it made in such a way that's glorifying God? Or is it
01:04:59 being conducted in a way that's going to violate my jurisdiction of whether it's self-government,
01:05:04 family government, church government, you name it. Say that again. Because that last part is so
01:05:11 helpful in answering the question, you know, so where's the line? And you said you have to ask
01:05:16 the question, is this going to violate? How did you word that again? Just violate the jurisdiction
01:05:22 of family government. So I think like a violation where AI was used in a sinful and wicked way was
01:05:28 in 2020 um i remember i was on facebook and i got a notification that said jeremiah you clicked on a
01:05:34 picture you clicked on an image that had wrong information about covet 19 but it never it never
01:05:40 specified what the piece of uh what the piece of content was it didn't specify um what the article
01:05:46 was what i said so i was basically tried and convicted and i was basically a gaslit by
01:05:52 technology now ai is just ai but you have those at that time who were part of the message that
01:06:00 were part of the you know that was the mantra of like you know social distancing wearing masks you
01:06:04 know just trust the science right so any any thought crime that went against it i got convicted
01:06:10 of a thought crime on that that vital that was a violation of my jurisdiction of self-government
01:06:14 to do my critical thinking to analyze the world around me that and use my reasoning that god gave
01:06:20 me to understand, okay, how do I conduct myself? You know, and if I'm thinking now as a husband
01:06:25 and father, if there's another pandemic, I want to utilize, okay, is it safe to go to work? Should
01:06:30 I not go to work? Cause I want to protect my wife. I want to protect my four month old son.
01:06:35 Um, and like a continuation of my lineage, I want to think critically. If in the event that happened,
01:06:40 that would be a direct violation of that. So that would be something that would be,
01:06:44 you know, you can't punish AI, but you would have to confront the creators of that AI and say, no,
01:06:49 what you did here is wicked and you need to repent. You're violating the space of self-government
01:06:55 and family government. Yep. That's good. I like that. Andrew, any final thoughts for this episode?
01:07:00 No, I love that, man. That was awesome, Jerry. Throwing it down. That was theonomic, brother,
01:07:04 man. Get it, dude. All right. Well, thank you guys for tuning in. This is episode two,
01:07:09 and this is a part of a 10-episode series. So tune in for the rest of them. We've got
01:07:15 a whole episode coming up on Burning Man. We've got an episode on DMT in the astral realm.
01:07:23 The first episode, if you didn't watch that already, go back, check it out. That's on
01:07:27 The Divine Feminine and Taylor Swift. And these are episodes that will be airing at 4 p.m. Central
01:07:32 Time on Fridays, every Friday, one per week. But if you want to catch them all ad-free with early
01:07:38 access, they're actually all 10 available right now. If you join us on Patreon, patreon.com forward
01:07:44 slash Right Response Ministries.
01:07:45 Thanks for tuning in.
01:07:47 Real quick before you go,
01:07:48 we hope that you enjoyed the episode
01:07:50 and we hope that you're eager for more.
01:07:52 However, as I already said,
01:07:54 these will be slow dripping out
01:07:55 over the course of weeks and even a few months.
01:07:59 But not to worry,
01:08:00 if you wanna be able to watch
01:08:01 all 10 of these episodes right now, ad-free,
01:08:06 all you gotta do is join us as a Silver Tier member
01:08:09 over on patreon.com forward slash Right Response Ministries.
01:08:14 God bless.