The NXR Podcast - September 16, 2024


THE INTERVIEW - Boomers & The Fifth Commandment

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE SERMON - Jesus Chooses Blue-Collar Men THE LIVESTREAM - Righteous Deception and Am I A Racist Movie Review

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 5 minutes

Words per minute

176.63

Word count

11,608

Sentence count

348

Harmful content

Misogyny

34

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

40

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Pastor Joel Webbin sits down with author Zachary Garris to discuss his new book, Honor Thy Fathers. They discuss the importance of the 5th commandment in light of the challenges faced by our generation and the mistakes our predecessors have made, and the need to honor our immediate fathers.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 All right, welcome to another episode of Theology Applied. I am your host, Pastor Joel Webin with
00:00:03 Right Response Ministries. In this episode, I'm privileged to welcome back to the show,
00:00:07 it's been a while, but Zachary Garris. The last time we had him, I think it was
00:00:12 somewhat shortly after he'd written his first book, which was Masculine Christianity.
00:00:17 This is now his second book that he's written. It's called Honor Thy Fathers. Honor Thy Fathers.
00:00:24 And so we're discussing the importance of the fifth commandment in light of some of the challenges
00:00:29 with our generation and some of the older generation preceding us and some of the mistakes
00:00:35 that they've made, and yet still the importance of trying to honor our immediate fathers. In my
00:00:40 case, that would be boomers, but not at the expense of honoring ancient fathers, all those
00:00:45 who came before them. So we're talking about the fifth commandment, honoring fathers, and
00:00:49 particularly honoring our ancient fathers, centuries of Christodom, and what they believed
00:00:56 about the biblical view of men and women, because that is one of the big theological 0.55
00:01:04 topics where recent generations, our immediate fathers, such as the boomers, have gotten off
00:01:12 the rails into not just first and second wave and third wave, but just absolute head-over-heels
00:01:21 rank feminism, of which the last 2,000 years of church history and our ancient fathers would not 1.00
00:01:28 even begin to be capable of recognizing. So that's the discussion that we're talking about today.
00:01:34 Roles of men and women, the nature of men and women, the Reformed tradition, and what has been
00:01:42 taught historically about men and women, and how to honor ancient fathers when your immediate
00:01:49 fathers are telling you, you should disagree. Applying God's word to every aspect of life.
00:01:56 This is Theology Applied.
00:02:03 All right, welcome to another episode of Theology Applied. I am your host, Pastor Joel Webbin with
00:02:07 Right Response Ministries. And in this episode, I am privileged to welcome to the show Zachary
00:02:11 Garris. He's published a couple books that have both been very helpful. One was Masculine
00:02:17 Christianity, and his most recent book, Honor Thy Fathers, which he published with New Christendom
00:02:23 Press, has just recently come out, and it's been a hit, I think, for a lot of people, because
00:02:29 a lot of the problem that we're experiencing today is that we are spurning our fathers,
00:02:34 especially as Thomas Watson, I believe it was, would say our ancient fathers, and just adopting
00:02:41 so many things that are modern, progressive, and not going back to the biblical roots and the rich
00:02:46 heritage that we had before us. So, Zachary, welcome to the show. Thanks for coming on.
00:02:51 Yeah, thanks for having me.
00:02:53 All right, so let's start with this. Just give us real quick a synopsis, and I know it's a little
00:02:58 bit cliche, it's always the question you get asked, but why did you write the book? What's
00:03:02 your purpose? What are you trying to accomplish with it? And why do you think a book like this
00:03:06 is necessary today? Yeah, Honored Eye Fathers is essentially a historical look at
00:03:14 reform teaching on male headship, but it discusses male rule in the home, in the church,
00:03:22 and in the commonwealth. And my other book, Massacent Christianity, was more exegetical,
00:03:27 got into scripture, though it had some history, of course. But this is more of a historical angle,
00:03:32 but it's also polemical. Honor thy fathers is comparing. The first section is looking at the
00:03:37 older reformed theologians of the 16th and 17th centuries. And then the second part of the book
00:03:43 is kind of contrasting them with modern theologians, especially those who would call themselves
00:03:49 reform. And yeah, I think that's needed because I mean, part of the book is showing that we've
00:03:56 departed from the earlier tradition on these matters. Right. Yeah. So on that note, you know,
00:04:05 we talked about this a little bit offline, the two of us, but I got in a little bit of trouble
00:04:09 recently, a couple of days ago, and I think that it, I don't, I'm sure it's not exactly
00:04:14 what you would say. And so feel free to disagree with me wherever, you know, you and I would
00:04:19 differ, but I tweeted something out the other day and got a little bit of pushback, but I think it's
00:04:23 in the vein, the overarching vein of what you're communicating with your book, Honor Thy Fathers.
00:04:29 And just, I was talking about the fifth commandment. I wrote this, the fifth commandment,
00:04:33 honoring, which is honoring our fathers is vital to all those who desire to live a long
00:04:38 life in the land and be blessed by God. However, it is wise to hold as a respectful suspicion,
00:04:45 a respectful suspicion toward all those who advocate for honoring our immediate fathers
00:04:50 at the expense of honoring all the centuries of godly fathers who preceded them.
00:04:55 Careful obedience to the fifth commandment is similar to the thinking that we had to apply
00:05:00 during COVID. If a lesser civil official is demanding that we submit to that which God
00:05:04 calls wicked, it becomes necessary to appeal to a more righteous civil magistrate above them.
00:05:10 Likewise, while it is important to still exercise respect for our immediate fathers,
00:05:16 it is good and proper to appeal to generations of fathers who preceded them if our immediate
00:05:21 fathers have spent their lives spitting on their legacy. In short, beware of those who demand that
00:05:28 you only honor one generation of fathers, especially if it happens to be the very
00:05:34 generation of fathers that has been marked by rebellion towards their own fathers since the 0.56
00:05:39 beginning of their lives, aka the boomers. Now, obviously, part of the pushback that I got was, 0.92
00:05:45 well, it's a generation that's still alive and could see the tweet and respond. I wasn't saying
00:05:51 everybody, but I am saying that in a general sense, I really think, and it's not like all
00:05:55 our problems start with the boomers. That's an oversimplification. I get that. But I think of
00:06:00 the 1960s, I think of the civil rights movement. I think of, you know, protesting on the White
00:06:05 House, you know, front lawn and those, you know, stick it to the man and all these, the boomers, 0.84
00:06:12 I think it's a fact, not every single one of them, but to say that they, from their teen and early 0.88
00:06:17 adulthood years, were kind of the rebellious generation, long hair, hippies, smoking weed,
00:06:23 those kinds of things. And they had the benefit of getting to be rebellious, go against the system,
00:06:30 uh live in a van you know and and and do drugs and in their 30s when they they wanted to have
00:06:36 normal lives everything was waiting for them they could still get a house with a great mortgage and
00:06:40 they could get a good job and they could have retirement and vacation time and all you know
00:06:44 all those kinds of things and that's i mean i think that that's fair to say i'm not talking
00:06:47 about every individual obviously um there are older members of the older generation who have
00:06:53 been godly and faithful and xyz but i'm saying in general speaking of group dynamics i have noticed
00:06:59 I want to see if it's your experience as well.
00:07:02 But I think that particular generation, the reason I tweeted this out is I regularly see
00:07:07 them disparaging, in my opinion, disparaging young men and saying that they're misogynistic
00:07:14 or they're this or they're that because of their theological views, a biblical patriarch
00:07:20 or whatever it is.
00:07:21 And then whenever they get pushback from the younger generation saying, no, I think this
00:07:25 is what the Bible teaches.
00:07:26 there's usually some kind of quip of honor your elders or you're not keeping the fifth commandment
00:07:32 or it's like listen um i we want to be as respectful as possible but you're not honoring
00:07:39 your fathers you you would excommunicate john calvin you would excommunicate john knox you
00:07:45 would ex all these guys gouge all these guys you you have to edit their books you can't even
00:07:51 publish them without censoring them because it says superiors. Like, you dishonor your fathers
00:07:56 every day. Your generation is marked. It is marked in American history as dishonoring fathers. 1.00
00:08:04 And I don't know. I don't think it's fair to say to a younger generation that wants to,
00:08:10 we're not wanting to progress forward. We're wanting to actually go back and to get to
00:08:15 biblical masculinity, biblical femininity, biblical views on all these theological subjects
00:08:21 And it's the older generation that's telling us that we're rebelling when in reality, if you look at a chain in each individual link, our generation is actually matching up with all these prior links except for one.
00:08:36 That's the rebellious generation, in my opinion.
00:08:39 What do you think?
00:08:41 Yeah, I think the first thing I'd say is there are a lot of great boomers, you know, that generation, obviously.
00:08:48 um yeah i think even in my church uh people in that age range lots of great men and women and
00:08:55 so we we should honor them i mean that's part of the the fifth commandment um you know understood
00:09:01 in its in its broader scope which which something like the westminster larger catechism does this
00:09:06 uh and and so i mean i take this up in the book which is they even ask the the scope of the
00:09:13 fifth commandment right which is to honor your father and mother and they they include not only
00:09:19 natural parents but superiors and age gifts uh and then those in authority family church and
00:09:25 commonwealth but yeah when you read the reformers on these kind of things they would of course
00:09:31 include uh spiritual forefathers and and prior generations it's not it's not limited to those
00:09:37 fathers is what thomas watson says yeah it's not limited to those who are living so so we need to
00:09:43 honor both right and um i mean there's also a sense in which um those who are older are still to um
00:09:54 honor and and treat respectfully the those who would be considered their inferiors in in age um
00:10:01 um and in the the larger catechism gets into that kind of thing as well so yeah there's a lot of
00:10:08 great boomers but i think just when you look at the history of like at least we can say the west
00:10:12 of the united states is our our country's been in decline for some time and i'm i surely wouldn't say
00:10:19 it started with the boomers i mean there were problems with prior generations right um but
00:10:24 there definitely has been a big shift in the last, say, 50 or so years where, I mean, feminism has 0.72
00:10:33 really become a massive problem. I mean, I argue feminism was around with like the first wave 0.85
00:10:37 women's rights movement, but that didn't really come to full fruition until I think like the 1960s
00:10:43 and 70s, you started to see this dramatic shift. I mean, you can even see it in the birth rates and
00:10:47 all of those kinds of things. And so we have to recognize that America has been in decline
00:10:54 and it didn't start with you know people under 50 uh so that that i think just needs to be 0.51
00:11:01 recognized and when you when you look at things in like the church i mean there's just been a lot of
00:11:08 a lot of compromise in in this period um you know i you could bring up like the the complementarian
00:11:14 movement which really took off in like the 80s and 90s especially and and that's had its fracturing
00:11:21 to the point where people speak of narrow and broad complementarianism.
00:11:25 And, you know, as I argue, even in this book, Honor Thy Fathers,
00:11:29 there's been a lot of deviation, even amongst some of the broader complementarians.
00:11:34 They've deviated from our forefathers.
00:11:36 So I just think it needs to be understood that we're to honor not only those who are living,
00:11:42 but also the dead.
00:11:43 And so there's going to sometimes be conflicts and views there.
00:11:47 And so in our manners and how we speak with older Christians with whom we disagree, we should be respectful, but they shouldn't talk down to us because we disagree or we think that actually the older guys got it right, the old dead guys. 0.98
00:12:03 I mean, that's a lot of times the way I think it is. 0.99
00:12:07 Well, that's what it is.
00:12:08 It's a debate between the young whippersnappers who are not making up novel doctrines.
00:12:13 we're simply like we just we went back and and we read we did the reading that that's all that's
00:12:20 all it is so it's the young whippersnappers who read you know william gouge instead of
00:12:25 john piper you know what i mean on on on domestical duties you know like biblical manhood and biblical
00:12:32 womanhood and then we're just repeating those arguments old arguments that were common that
00:12:38 is what people believe is what the church believed for centuries and centuries and centuries
00:12:42 and then we're being chastised, but being chastised from a standpoint of I'm older
00:12:48 and wiser and more experienced. And the irony is what I'm trying to communicate is the irony is
00:12:54 the younger guys are actually the ones who are holding to the older position.
00:12:59 And so we're saying, well, no, no, your view is the novel view. Your view is the misnomer.
00:13:06 I understand that I'm half your age. I get that. But the views that I'm espousing are not on the
00:13:15 basis of my own personal credibility and life experience. That's not the foundation for my
00:13:21 view. The foundation for my view is the Word of God as articulated and interpreted throughout the
00:13:28 witness of church history for centuries instead of just since 1988 with the origin of complementarianism.
00:13:36 right i is that fair yeah yeah i i think so and uh they shouldn't look down on us
00:13:45 uh who who want to go further back i think that's that's not a a bad thing i mean i i think part of
00:13:52 this is there's the assumption that there's been progress right progress in ideology progress in
00:13:57 the united states culturally politically uh theologically and i would challenge that in
00:14:05 most ways. I think there's been a lot of regress. And so, you know, theology doesn't really change
00:14:14 much. I mean, sometimes there's like new insights, but for the most part, we should be, I think,
00:14:18 fairly traditional and continuing what was passed down from our spiritual fathers. And so when there
00:14:25 are new things or deviations, most of the time those are wrong, and it's good to criticize those.
00:14:32 It just happens to be that many of the guys who made up some of those deviations are still alive and leaders in the church and whatnot.
00:14:41 And so like even with my book here, I don't want to disrespectfully engage them, but I do want to engage them and I want to tell them I think they're wrong.
00:14:49 And here's why. And I give my reasons. And I would I mean, the best thing I think would be they say, yeah, those are really good points.
00:14:55 And let me think about it. And and they can change their views. And honestly, I think it's kind of arrogant to go against the entire reform tradition.
00:15:05 I mean, that's that's kind of thing with this book is it's showing it wasn't just one guy.
00:15:09 I mean, I'm not just going to like John Calvin or something. I'm going to the entirety of the tradition and showing that actually they all were, you know, very patriarchal, held to a very strong view of male rule.
00:15:22 um you know this idea of a tie-breaking vote in marriage none of them fought like that that's
00:15:28 that's totally modern and and and unbiblical i would say it doesn't use that kind of
00:15:34 qualification in the scripture so yeah i think um i mean i mean some of this is you know there's
00:15:40 ties even with politics in the sense that if we include culture and the like i mean you get into
00:15:47 kind of this older conservatism and so this this ties in with some of these even historical debates
00:15:53 and whatnot and there's there's kind of like a a lot of neoconservatism politically but also in
00:16:00 the church where i think a lot of people have just shifted left on a lot of issues and so then they
00:16:06 hear something that's like more right wing and like it's more it's more on the right it's like
00:16:13 a paleo conservative take or something and they they freak out it's like they've never heard it
00:16:19 before and maybe they haven't but uh that's that's not because people didn't used to hold a lot of
00:16:24 these views before it's just i don't know between the media and the education system i don't know
00:16:32 they have this like very narrow window of what's acceptable and i think i think that's what's going
00:16:37 on right now for a whole host of things and i mean i'm doing it somewhat on the theological front
00:16:41 is trying to take us back to the older Reformed theologians
00:16:46 and not just do theology in the 20th century.
00:16:50 I mean, that doesn't make sense.
00:16:53 You shouldn't do that really in any field,
00:16:55 but especially not theology.
00:16:58 Right.
00:16:59 So for our listeners, could you just articulate briefly?
00:17:03 I've done this probably a number of times,
00:17:05 and I think I may have even done it with you once upon a time
00:17:08 shortly after you published your first book, Masculine Christianity. But
00:17:12 for those who maybe haven't heard it or are unaware, could you articulate just some of
00:17:19 the distinctions between complementarianism and patriarchy? Because I think a lot of people are
00:17:23 underneath the impression that, well, you know, complementarianism is patriarchy. It's just that
00:17:28 patriarchy has become, you know, it has negative connotations and viewed as derogatory. And so,
00:17:37 you know we just are replacing you know just a new placeholder a new term um but it's the same
00:17:42 doctrine whereas i i would say no it's it's not and and the guys who coined the term were very
00:17:47 clear about um you know by their own admission uh flat out said that this is a halfway house in
00:17:54 between egalitarianism and patriarchy and that it was based you know i mean the intention it has
00:18:01 been said by by the framers of complementarianism that it was meant to um kind of um be a you know
00:18:09 um to to uh to hold back the floodgate uh of um of feminism that maybe this will be enough to
00:18:17 appease the egalitarians and the feminists um so that we don't lose everything um so could you
00:18:23 do do your you know your best to just articulate you know what what are you arguing for when you
00:18:29 say patriarchy why is complementarianism not sufficient yeah well first let me say you know
00:18:34 i obviously some people don't like the term patriarchy i mean it's just referring to father
00:18:38 rule right and so uh if we're talking about godly biblical patriarchy i don't see how you could have
00:18:43 a problem with that though though i will say in this book i use more of the language of just like
00:18:46 the traditional reform position so you know there's various terms we can use for these things
00:18:52 um so complementarianism really was a reaction to egalitarianism in the uh
00:19:00 1980s really is responding i think to these things and if we were to summarize
00:19:09 complementarianism there's really two points that were essential they affirm male headship in the
00:19:14 home and then in the church they would say only men can be uh well hold the office of elder or
00:19:20 pastor. And those are fairly like minimal affirmations because what that allowed is
00:19:28 people to hold maybe some other more egalitarian views. So like some, what we call narrow
00:19:34 complementarians would say, well, I think, you know, only a man can be a pastor, but I think a
00:19:42 woman could preach. I mean, I've heard people articulate that position because she does it 0.95
00:19:45 under the authority of the session well uh that's really out of line of with the tradition and i
00:19:51 think also makes an arbitrary distinction uh between office and tasks right um sprawl but
00:19:58 said that just real quick i gotta gotta say it rc sprawl he allowed for women to preach there is a
00:20:05 video and audio recording that you can find on renewing your mind it was a q a that he did
00:20:12 in a small group, probably in the Ligonier studio
00:20:15 where he had finished lecturing
00:20:17 and was allowing people to ask.
00:20:19 And it was funny because there was a woman,
00:20:20 I forget her name, because he names her.
00:20:23 And she says, are you implying that a woman could preach?
00:20:30 And he said, so-and-so, I didn't imply it.
00:20:34 I said it.
00:20:35 And he laughs.
00:20:36 But basically he said he doesn't believe
00:20:38 that a woman could be a ruling elder,
00:20:40 but that she could teach R.C. Sproul towards the end of his life. 0.92
00:20:45 And I love R.C. Sproul, but I'm just saying, yeah,
00:20:49 the boomer generation really started folding. 0.70
00:20:52 The best of them started folding on this.
00:20:55 Yeah, I obviously like R.C. Sproul.
00:20:57 I'd be curious to see the details and what the context there was.
00:21:02 Because, I mean, some of these guys do make distinctions.
00:21:05 Like, you know, sometimes we might be talking about,
00:21:07 well, it's a woman teaching in a women's setting or something.
00:21:11 That might be different.
00:21:13 Unfortunately, no, it was not that.
00:21:16 I wish it was.
00:21:17 It was not.
00:21:18 That is concerning if he said something like that.
00:21:20 But let me just say, I think, so you have like the narrow complementarian strand,
00:21:26 but then you have the broader complementarians who would,
00:21:29 they would say, no, a woman can't preach.
00:21:32 And, you know, I mean, in general, they would say that the worship service should be led by men.
00:21:40 But that's the thing is some of this starts to break down, you know, where some complementarians even think women can read scripture or in public worship or lead certain prayers in public worship.
00:21:52 And, yeah, the worst of them think that, you know, women could even preach.
00:21:55 um and then and then you get outside the worship service and then there's the question of women
00:22:00 teaching in sunday school uh to like mixed groups with men and and you know some of these narrow
00:22:05 complementarians especially would say that they can so you've got that but then um you also have
00:22:12 kind of the softening of male headship where you know this is this whole tie-breaking vote
00:22:18 where scripture just speaks of um the husband is the head of his wife and and you know ephesians
00:22:24 5 even says the wife should submit to her husband in everything you know it says in everything not
00:22:28 in not in an occasional tie-breaking vote it's it's the idea that the man is to actually lead
00:22:34 like they use that language but he's actually a leader and that means he leads in everything by
00:22:40 example and decision making his wife is you know his counselor he consults her on things but he's
00:22:48 still the leader. He doesn't let her lead most of the time, and then he only leads if there's
00:22:54 a disagreement. I mean, that's not what the scripture says. It's not what the Reformed
00:22:59 tradition ever said about male headship and marriage. So you've got that, and then most
00:23:04 complementarians probably wouldn't go to the issue of civil leadership, where they might allow
00:23:13 women to, or more likely it's probably they just don't say anything about women in political
00:23:20 office, where you go read, obviously Knox had the strongest statements against this,
00:23:24 but even Calvin said, yeah, that shouldn't be normative. It's not ordinary for women to 1.00
00:23:27 hold political office. That should mostly be men. And so, you know, that's pretty much the, 1.00
00:23:33 I would say probably the most standard view would be Calvin's, but complementarians probably
00:23:39 aren't going to say much about that and obviously we have it now where we have a woman running for
00:23:44 uh president of the united states and so so that that has just that issues kind of exploded where 1.00
00:23:51 they you know we don't just have occasional women running for office they like push for
00:23:55 half candidate the candidates being women and then it goes beyond that where it's i don't know
00:24:02 the men are just getting drowned out in a lot of these things so um but but there's other issues
00:24:07 where you know complementarianism many of them were not all but many of them were getting into
00:24:13 the whole ess thing um eternal subordination of the son right rather than just saying that the son
00:24:19 you know post-incarnation submits to the will of the father because they were they were saying
00:24:24 well it's in eternity because they're trying to say look uh you know in the trinity you have
00:24:31 equality between the persons but still submission and they're wanting to say look so the husband
00:24:36 and wife are equal, but the wife submits to the husband. And the thing is, the scriptures, 0.67
00:24:42 well, one, I don't think they teach eternal subordination to the son, but two, they don't,
00:24:47 you know, compare husband and wife to father and son in the Trinity. That's just not a comparison
00:24:53 the scripture makes. So, and in one sense, I mean, so we have to qualify these things. I mean,
00:25:01 in one sense, a man and a woman are equal, right? They're made in God's image. They're equal worth
00:25:05 and value, but in another sense, they're unequal. And that's, that's even like the, you know,
00:25:09 tied with, um, male headship is, is the husband actually, uh, husband and wife don't have equal
00:25:16 authority in the marriage relationship. They don't, they're unequal. I, we, for some reason,
00:25:20 a lot of these guys just are uncomfortable saying that, um, even though that's the obvious
00:25:24 implication of, of submission. So, uh, anyway, uh, I'm trying to think if there's some other
00:25:31 issues, but I think that kind of shows like, even if somebody holds a broader complementarian
00:25:35 position and some people would maybe call me that you know say that's my view but um and there's
00:25:40 going to be overlap there are going to be some of these things where uh you know the patriarchal or
00:25:45 just traditional reform position is going to just be more robust more consistent and uh and certainly
00:25:53 more rooted in in the history of uh of christian thought and theology you have heard it said that
00:26:01 cash is king. Well, our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants you to know that cash flow
00:26:06 is the key to building wealth. The partners at Private Family Banking are experts at teaching
00:26:12 you how to implement a new way of thinking about money. This powerful and innovative approach
00:26:18 provides a fail-safe method for redirecting the cash flow you already have into a privatized
00:26:24 banking system that you now own and control. This new system places you and your family
00:26:30 on the wealth curve for continuously compounding
00:26:34 tax-protected gains now and unto future generations.
00:26:38 You may also be familiar with the age-old wisdom
00:26:42 that the best time to plant a tree for shade
00:26:44 was 10 years ago, but the second best time is today.
00:26:48 So start your journey of building
00:26:51 your financial legacy right now.
00:26:53 The sooner you start, the better.
00:26:55 Let a private family banking partner
00:26:57 help you put post-mill talk into post-mill action.
00:27:02 Contact them today by emailing
00:27:03 banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:27:07 Again, that's banking at privatefamilybanking.com
00:27:11 and request a free step-by-step wealth building plan
00:27:15 that will be the game changer
00:27:17 that you have been looking for.
00:27:19 Lastly, a complimentary discovery call
00:27:22 can be scheduled by using the link
00:27:24 in this episode's show notes.
00:27:26 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God
00:27:30 and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:27:34 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
00:27:37 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
00:27:41 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:27:45 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:27:49 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
00:27:56 reese fund christian capital boldly deployed
00:28:01 right yep agreed um yeah it seems like uh part what another distinction with complementarianism
00:28:09 between that and uh biblical patriarchy or whatever you want to call it gendered piety or the
00:28:14 like the reform tradition contains a lot more than just its views of men and women so like
00:28:19 even if you call it that then it's like the reform tradition on patriarchy you know like
00:28:25 That's what I would want to, so I don't know, however you slice it, but I think just one more distinction between complementarianism and patriarchy is the emphasis, the Bible's emphasis in the patriarchal view on nature, and that's part of what keeps God and his character from being capricious and arbitrary, and so I think a lot of the complementarian ethos is the woman, whether it be in the house or in the church,
00:28:55 or society at large um the woman is you know basically looking to the man and saying anything
00:29:00 you can do i can do better i can do anything better than you but i won't um you know so like
00:29:06 i you know i remember a pretty well-known woman who uh is considered to be conservative
00:29:13 i i don't think so but you know people consider her to be conservative the bar for being conservative
00:29:18 is pretty low these days you know you can you know you can do uh swimsuit modeling you know 0.89
00:29:24 and stuff like that. And, you know, conservatives are a joke. So anyways, you know that. But she
00:29:29 said that, you know, that she could preach better than most men, but she won't. And she won't
00:29:37 because, you know, she recognizes that the Bible does not permit that, her preaching to mixed 0.97
00:29:43 groups, men being present on the Lord's Day. And I appreciate, you know, her holding the line in
00:29:48 that sense. But I remember hearing that and thinking, well, that's, I think that's the root
00:29:53 the problem. I know what she meant. She meant that women are capable of theological competence.
00:30:05 If that's the statement, then I agree. I think women are capable of theological competence. I 0.97
00:30:10 think women can learn. In fact, I mean, that's one of the things that we see in 1 Timothy chapter
00:30:14 2. Not only is it permissible, but you could even argue that there's an insistent with apostolic
00:30:19 command a woman must learn. And then he begins to outline in what manner and what heart posture
00:30:25 she should learn, learn with submissiveness and quietness, but she should learn. And the chief
00:30:30 context for learning, I would argue is not sending all of our daughters to seminary, but
00:30:33 the chief context for learning that was in the mind of the apostle Paul, you know, as he's writing
00:30:38 this is the church. You know, on the Lord's day, women are learning right there with their husbands
00:30:43 sitting on the pew next to them from those who are biblically qualified to preach and teach who
00:30:46 are men. But the point is, women should learn, and women can be competent, but I don't think 0.99
00:30:53 it's merely that a woman is not allowed to preach. I honestly believe, because of what I know about
00:30:59 the Scripture on this matter, and because of what I know about the character and nature of God,
00:31:04 it's not that fish can fly just as good as birds, but God has designated and determined that fish
00:31:10 should swim, just because. And birds can swim just as good as fish, but God has determined
00:31:15 and designated that birds should fly. No, the role of creatures, it extends from their design
00:31:26 and their nature. And so I would say that there's something about preaching that is not mere
00:31:31 theological competence or mere oration and the ability to articulate and compel. But there's
00:31:39 something in the very nature of preaching. I think it's a misunderstanding of the nature of men and
00:31:43 women and a misunderstanding of the nature of preaching. I think there's something in nature,
00:31:47 not just role, but role stems from nature, and there's something in the design of preaching
00:31:52 and the design of men and women where it's not just that a woman can preach, and as it was said
00:31:58 by this particular woman, can preach better than most men, but won't because I'm conservative.
00:32:03 No, the reason you are not permitted in Scripture to preach is not merely because you're not allowed 0.83
00:32:09 to but because you are unable to you can't preach it's not just that sally shouldn't preach
00:32:16 sally can't preach she can't um because the preaching of the nature of preaching and the
00:32:22 nature of sally are incompatible um and i think i can argue that i'm curious what you would say
00:32:29 so i this is a good point you raise about nature and it's actually the one i forgot
00:32:35 to raise as far as problems with complementarianism. So I do think this is one of the big
00:32:42 problems with complementarianism, is they detached the command, which would be, or prohibition,
00:32:49 women being pastor or preaching, they detached that from God's design and the nature of man and
00:32:56 woman. And so I do think this is essential, is you have to understand those things go together. 0.66
00:33:01 the very nature of the thing or person and the telos, right? The goal, the end for which it's
00:33:11 made. And so God's commands are not arbitrary. And the reason he places restrictions on women
00:33:19 that he doesn't on men is because of his design for men to lead. And so this gets into like
00:33:27 natural law. And I realize people like to argue about that when it comes to like the political
00:33:30 realm and everything. But when we're talking about male and female relationships, duties,
00:33:39 gender roles, as some people like to say, we have to understand that God designed men to lead,
00:33:46 and he formed man this way. So even when we get into the very biology of man, testosterone,
00:33:53 all of these things that make a man different from a woman, that has ties with God's commands 0.79
00:34:02 for leadership. So both to be the head of the household, right? The very constituency of a man 0.95
00:34:08 is different from a woman, personality to some extent, right? And how they think and function. 1.00
00:34:13 And this stuff goes down deep. And so when Paul says, I do not permit a woman to teach or exercise 1.00
00:34:22 authority over man, that's 1 Timothy 2.12, he's not just making that up. Oh, God told me this, 0.99
00:34:29 so I'm going to repeat this command. No, he knows that this flows from and is tied from
00:34:34 the different constituencies of man and woman. And in fact, what did we see? What's his reasoning
00:34:39 in 1 Timothy 2? He actually goes to creation. He's actually making a sort of natural law argument.
00:34:44 because he says he says um for um um ad was formed first and and so he's going to the very
00:34:54 fact that he he was created first there's something about creational priority uh i think
00:34:59 it's tied with headship and though and then we could even go elsewhere like first corinthians
00:35:02 11 he says that a man was not made for a woman but the woman for man she's the helper to her
00:35:09 husband doesn't mean she's lesser uh worth or value of course we always have to tell egalitarians
00:35:16 that's not what we're saying um but um but it does mean as far as her work and uh god's design
00:35:24 for woman she is there to help her husband she's a life-giving being so it's you know she's a mother
00:35:30 i mean that's so important right it's speaking of hierarchy my my kids are not of less innate
00:35:36 value. If we're talking about the innate dignity and value of a human being made in the image of
00:35:40 God, I have four kids and a fifth on the way. They are not of less value than I am, but God has a
00:35:46 created order and a hierarchy. They are not my equals or my peers in terms of authority. We're
00:35:52 talking about authority. Yeah, absolutely. Right. And I mean, obviously with children, right, they
00:35:57 grow and mature, but that, you know, with a woman, that's not, that's not the case. She's an adult 0.99
00:36:02 woman she'll never become a man and regardless what people say uh and and uh she she can't hold 0.99
00:36:09 that authority she's she's not designed to do so um i mean there's exceptional cases where like a 1.00
00:36:16 widow right is the head of her household but that's that's not that's not ideal obviously 0.75
00:36:21 um so even then according to paul if she's younger he would say the ideal is for her to find a new
00:36:30 head and to remarry her first timothy 5 5 5 5 14 yeah and yeah and that so even there we have that
00:36:38 passage we have uh titus 2 and paul is is directing women's work towards the home i mean it's kind of
00:36:44 another issue but he he's directing women towards work in the home and child rearing and he's
00:36:50 directing men towards well leadership in the home but also their work is outside the home so this
00:36:54 even ties in with like the leadership and church thing is men's man's work is directed outside the
00:37:01 home uh whether it's leadership in the church or civil leadership or business or whatever they're
00:37:06 they're doing um so so i mean i think that's kind of an underlying principle there but yeah so real
00:37:13 quick getting back to what you were saying i was just going to get you back on track but you were
00:37:16 saying you know paul appeals to the it's a natural law argument at some level it's also special
00:37:21 revelation got it got to throw that in there but he gets to you know the order of creation but he
00:37:26 also he's kind of a two-pronged argument he he references the order of creation but also the
00:37:30 order of the fall so in creation man is formed first and man is formed from the dust of the
00:37:35 ground but it's the woman who's formed second and she's formed from man and for man so that's
00:37:40 the order of creation and its purposes but then he makes a second argument in terms of
00:37:45 the order of the fall so adam is formed first but eve falls first
00:37:50 yeah and so well what what did most of the complementarians do with this
00:37:56 is they've come up with this view that they say well it's just role reversal um but i'm not really
00:38:03 sure entirely what they mean i mean i've read their stuff on this it doesn't really explain
00:38:07 paul's uh reasoning i think uh it makes a lot more sense which is what i think most older writers
00:38:14 held is he's saying there's something about eve and her deception she was the one deceived adam
00:38:20 was not deceived adam sinned willingly and um which is not to absolve him of guilt if anything
00:38:27 it only you know indicts him further right it's not like saying this is a good thing about adam
00:38:33 it's just when compared to the man uh the woman and her i guess we could say uh just constituency
00:38:41 the way she's designed and i actually i like this explanation is that woman is made to follow right
00:38:47 so eve was made to follow and the problem is she didn't follow adam and she didn't follow god she
00:38:53 followed the serpent right so that that was tied with her deception she was deceived i mean that
00:38:59 was her own word she says the serpent deceived me in genesis 3 and i ate so paul's just picking that
00:39:05 up adam doesn't say you know eve deceived me that's not what adam says he you know now he does
00:39:11 Adam has plenty of sin. And again, if anything, he's more responsible, not less. But notice,
00:39:19 it's not deception. So it's not, you say, well, the serpent deceived me. And then Adam says,
00:39:24 well, the woman deceived me. No, it's the woman you gave me. She then gave me the fruit and I
00:39:30 ate of it. And if anything, the implication there, and I ate of it is I knew exactly what I was doing
00:39:36 and i sinned with my eyes wide open but i did it you know there's a lot of different commentaries
00:39:41 from older writers on this but you know some of them not all but some of them even say that you
00:39:45 know adam did it because um his his main sin in that moment was idolatry and loving his wife more
00:39:53 than god um he he knew exactly what happened when he saw that his wife had eaten of the fruit and
00:39:59 would surely die as god had threatened and promised um he said i'd rather die with her
00:40:04 than live with god and and ate of the fruit with her whereas what he should have done is he should
00:40:09 have run to god and said god um oh help us what what do we do my wife has eaten of this fruit
00:40:16 and then he could have even been you know like the second adam um by saying i i offer myself
00:40:22 his tribute take me instead of her would you please you know like and you know but so he but
00:40:28 But he wasn't deceived is the point.
00:40:32 Right.
00:40:32 He should have killed the serpent and guarded his wife, Genesis 2.15.
00:40:37 He should have done what God said, which is to guard, but he didn't.
00:40:41 And so there is a role reversal in a sense.
00:40:43 He follows his wife when he's supposed to lead, and he follows her into sin.
00:40:49 But yes, Paul is very clear in 1 Timothy 2.14.
00:40:53 He says the woman was deceived and the man was not deceived.
00:40:58 right? And that's just very clear in the text. So there's something about man's not deceived
00:41:04 and woman is. And so, I mean, I don't know, people come back and say, well, if a woman's
00:41:11 more deceived than man, then she can't teach children either. And I'm like, no, that's not
00:41:15 what it says, because it's just a comparison. If it's going to be between a man and a woman, 0.60
00:41:21 God says men are to be the leaders in the church. They're to be the preachers and teachers, 0.94
00:41:26 not all men, but some men. And so anyway, I, yeah, I think he's, he's, like you said,
00:41:32 Paul's appealing to creation. It's special revelation, but it's also, he's looking to
00:41:36 nature, the very differences between men and women. And, and he's saying God's prohibition
00:41:41 lines up perfectly with his design, differing design of man and woman. And it's good. And I 0.99
00:41:47 think, yeah, it's good. It's good. And for some reason, the complementarians aren't willing to
00:41:51 go there many of them some of them are um but this also ties in with other issues maybe uh you know
00:41:59 probably the best uh one to bring up would be women in combat because we don't we don't have
00:42:04 as explicit of prohibitions on women in combat as like first timothy two i mean we can go back
00:42:08 to deuteronomy i do think the uh that one verse is a 21 5 is referring to women not wearing its
00:42:15 armor it's gear for war yeah yeah i mean regardless the principle is she's not to dress like a man
00:42:21 and men are the ones who were warriors in the old testament so so either way it's uh it's it's role
00:42:26 reversal and and transgenderism um transvestism sorry uh so so that's a problem but but we should
00:42:34 be able to reason our way there from scripture and natural law to say that women shouldn't serve
00:42:39 in combat and yet you go look at like some of the debates we've had in the church and i can go back
00:42:44 i have a footnote on this i think it's the end of chapter three the orthodox presbyterian church
00:42:48 the OPC, which is kind of the old northern conservative Presbyterian church, they had a
00:42:55 debate in 2001. And thankfully, the majority took, I think, what's the right side is they condemned
00:43:00 women in combat as unnatural. But there was like a substantial minority report and a protest that 0.74
00:43:06 signed this thing. And they said, and this is the view they took, they didn't say, oh, well,
00:43:11 it's good for women to be in combat. They said, well, scripture doesn't speak to this sufficiently.
00:43:16 and so we as a church can't speak to it. But the problem is scripture does speak to this
00:43:22 in a number of instances, and we can also reason our way there. I mean, the Westminster
00:43:29 Confession speaks of making deductions, right, good and necessary consequences. So scripture
00:43:39 is either explicit on a subject or we deduce good and necessary consequences, and that would be,
00:43:45 I think one of these cases is we can, we can easily reason our way to the conclusion that 1.00
00:43:51 women should not serve in combat and it's unnatural. And yet many people today don't
00:43:56 want to say that. Many reform theologians don't want to, don't want to say that. And
00:44:01 I think that's just, well, there's two things going on. One, they're, they're caving to cultural
00:44:07 pressure. They're feeling the cultural pressure and they don't, I mean, in one sense, they don't
00:44:12 want to go beyond scripture okay but we have to go beyond just like the narrow words of scripture
00:44:18 like so this would get into the the fact that i'm i'm not a narrow biblicist um i think the
00:44:24 reformed tradition um you know went beyond the words of scripture they applied the whole of
00:44:29 scripture and so i give an example of like vermigli and some others doing that just that
00:44:33 is they they they said yeah women shouldn't normally you know fighting combat i mean maybe 1.00
00:44:38 there's an exceptional case where a woman's dropping a stone on you know a male soldier's 1.00
00:44:43 head uh uh you know he's a threat to them that that's that's exceptional but she shouldn't dress 0.99
00:44:49 up as a soldier and go fight in in the army that's that's contrary to god's design it's unnatural
00:44:56 and um and yeah and so i think we need to be able to go there we need to be able to reason
00:45:00 and and theologize the way that the older reform theologians did are you a christian struggling
00:45:08 to find companies that align with your values and beliefs well then squirrely joe's has you covered
00:45:13 for all your coffee needs all of their coffee is hand selected and roasted fresh every day by a
00:45:19 family of fellow believers try them out and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your
00:45:25 investment supports a company committed to following god's teachings and upholding truth
00:45:31 and righteousness ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the growth of god's kingdom
00:45:37 stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil right response listeners have
00:45:42 access to an exclusive deal your first bag of coffee is free all you have to do is cover the
00:45:49 shipping so head on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response again that's
00:45:56 squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response to claim your first free bag of coffee today
00:46:03 I agree yeah I think part of the problem with you know you said like there's a lot of reform
00:46:07 guys who aren't willing to go there because they're afraid of cultural pressure and um and
00:46:11 I think you're right and I think there's some underlying reasons for that and I don't think
00:46:15 it's just because of wanting acceptance by the culture um because I think they know that you
00:46:21 know like the New York Times is probably not going to be on their side um but uh there still
00:46:27 are some incentives baked into the reformed camp as small as it is and it is a very small camp um
00:46:34 you know i mean there's at the end of the day you know you're talking about a market size of you
00:46:39 know like maybe a hundred to two hundred thousand people like we forget what us you know we're just
00:46:43 a sliver of the evangelical population and that is even account for you know outside of you know
00:46:48 mainline denominations and then you know roman catholicism and eastern orthodox and you know so
00:46:53 I mean, it's tiny. It's tiny. But because it's tiny, I guess my point is a lot of your
00:47:00 reformed writers, the guys who are going to be putting out the journals, the guys who are going
00:47:05 to be putting out the books, the guys who are going to be speaking at the conferences, these
00:47:08 guys are usually attached to the seminaries. They're adjunct professors and pastoring on the
00:47:14 side, or they're tenured and professors full-time. And you're talking about a very small market,
00:47:20 again 100 to 200,000 people you need enrollment for these seminaries to be able to fund continue
00:47:26 funding the work and one way to double your enrollment is to uh encourage women to sign up
00:47:32 um to say well you know who's to say seminary is just you know all about training ministers you
00:47:38 know like men for for the ministry and you know the preaching of the gospel and you know everybody
00:47:43 needs to know theology right right and you know so what better thing to do when you're young you
00:47:49 As a woman, if you're not a mom yet, knowing that nobody is, because we've completely built
00:47:56 a culture within evangelical Christianity that despises getting married young, despises
00:48:00 having children young, so they know that all these women are going to be single in the
00:48:03 Reformed churches, even when they're 20, 21, 22, 23, then why not go to seminary and learn
00:48:08 more about God, knowing that they're going to rack up $80,000 in debt, and the very thing
00:48:13 that they're called to do, they'll be that much less likely financially to be able to
00:48:18 do it because they've racked up debt and you know but my my point is just um you can follow the
00:48:24 money um not just in politics not just in the corporate world but very much in the reformed
00:48:29 church you can follow the money and uh and get some real clear ideas real fast about why guys
00:48:35 believe and what they believe and write what they write yeah i i i think this is an unfortunate
00:48:44 the thing with seminary is there has been a confusion um between like failure to distinguish
00:48:52 between theological education for women which we all affirm right that's part of church where
00:48:56 we're teaching women preaching to women amen uh confusing that with the training of ministers
00:49:01 and kids i'm family integrated over here i'm not just teaching men and women i'm teaching kids too
00:49:06 yeah amen so i mean seminaries are what were created i mean to get a little bit of history
00:49:14 in the united states the the first seminaries were uh really in the early 1800s i mean princeton
00:49:20 theological seminary was one of the big ones um which was presbyterian archibald alexander
00:49:24 samuel miller and then charles hodge uh kind of the early professors so um i mean these were
00:49:31 teaching men they were known like you weren't going to seminary you know just to go study
00:49:36 theology you're going to princeton to train to be a minister i mean because before that you would
00:49:42 train with um other pastors and and you know that that's great too but obviously it has some
00:49:48 deficiencies and so seminary was uh you know in many ways was great um and so i mean yeah that
00:49:57 was the practice it was men um and and there's like this modern thing well let's get women in
00:50:02 the seminaries and yes some of it is motivated by money for sure and i i think it has a negative
00:50:07 influence on the classroom i do think it's it's part of part of seminary and i know people a lot
00:50:14 people do it online now but i mean i went to seminary and there was something about living
00:50:18 amongst like other men training for the ministry and that's great i think that's that's part of
00:50:24 the experience yep um but but yeah so and you know what most of our theological classes a lot
00:50:32 of them were just men and that was great uh but we did have some at rts with with women in the
00:50:37 counseling program and the like but um yeah so i think that's a whole big issue that definitely
00:50:44 needs challenge but also what's happened with a lot of these seminaries is they started to hire 0.99
00:50:47 women professors which is just ridiculous um i mean having having women theological professors
00:50:54 to teach biblical studies or Hebrew, or, I mean, you could go down the line. 1.00
00:50:58 I mean, some of these, like... 0.68
00:50:59 Women training men to do something that the Bible says their professor themselves
00:51:03 is not even permitted to do.
00:51:06 Yeah, I mean, so, like, Westminster Theological Seminary.
00:51:09 I mean, East Philadelphia, they had a woman that was teaching their Hebrew courses for a while.
00:51:16 I mean, this is kind of, unfortunately, fairly common. 0.98
00:51:19 RTS has brought some women in as adjuncts and whatnot.
00:51:24 You know, this is one great thing about Greenville Theological Seminary, Greenville Presbyterian Theological Seminary, is they actually require their professors to have five years of pastoral experience.
00:51:33 So that right off the bat is going to limit that to those positions to men.
00:51:38 And I think that's great. That's that's what seminaries should be doing.
00:51:41 But they're kind of unique in that regard.
00:51:44 So and I think it makes it harder. It certainly makes it harder to find professors.
00:51:48 But we just we need to raise the bar in the church today. 1.00
00:51:51 We just have way too low standards overall, and we're caving to feminism way too much, and our institutions have been doing that.
00:52:00 And so I think if we can say one good thing is happening with the younger generations, I do think there is more – I think the younger men are overall more conservative.
00:52:11 yep we can get the reasons for for why but like i i don't know i mean even my writings i'm hoping
00:52:17 and it seems that way that there's a good influence out there that most guys don't want
00:52:22 to call themselves complementarians anymore they want to say they're they hold patriarchy or or
00:52:27 traditional reform position um you know so there are some good traditional reform position on
00:52:34 patriarchy yeah or yeah that's right i i think i say uh every time you see the traditional reform
00:52:40 position i'm like yeah that you can say that but reform position on what like calvin's institutes
00:52:47 on on what like the regular principle of worship on like on baptism yeah yeah yeah i mean i want
00:52:54 to cover the the entirety of the reform tradition but i would say reform reform tradition on male
00:52:58 rule i do say i think i use that kind of language so male so i'm not i'm not opposed to the term
00:53:02 patriarchy i just i recognize like obviously it has some baggage some people you know they they
00:53:08 use that against us all the time yeah they do but at a certain point at some point you just got to
00:53:14 roll with it you know what i mean it's like yeah that's hey i don't have a problem i don't know i
00:53:18 mean after careful consideration after careful consideration i've decided to become worse
00:53:23 you know you just you just hear it every day like you're misogynistic you're this you're that and
00:53:28 It's like, you know what?
00:53:30 Your claims are slanderous.
00:53:33 And so long as me and my Bible,
00:53:35 like we know that it's not true,
00:53:36 then I'm just going to keep on chugging along.
00:53:38 You can call me whatever you want, you know?
00:53:40 And like, I like that, you know,
00:53:41 Doug Wilson said, you know, a few years ago,
00:53:43 I think he wrote like an article or something,
00:53:46 recovering the lost virtue of sexism.
00:53:50 And like, I think that's good.
00:53:52 The tongue in cheek, you know,
00:53:53 saying like, wait a second,
00:53:54 like, you know, some things really are wrong.
00:53:56 um and then some things are not like this idea that we would treat the uh the two sexes 0.93
00:54:03 differently the whore like oh wait but that's what we're supposed to do that's what chivalry is 0.67
00:54:09 it like yeah that's so anyway some some words are worth fighting for and keeping but some sometimes 0.96
00:54:16 there are some words where it's like okay you know what it's just not it's not worth dying on
00:54:19 that hill we'll you know we'll we'll keep the virtue keep the principle and but not be like
00:54:25 actually actually you know every five seconds so you got to pick and choose right like yeah we're
00:54:30 not gonna i i don't think call our uh our views biblical sexism uh though uh i i wouldn't mind it
00:54:37 but yeah i hear you we we don't we don't um i mean we have to just get used to the fact that
00:54:43 they call us sexist i mean it's a silly term sexism i mean obviously there's like things
00:54:47 that we would speak against which would be like you know uh the abuse of women and variety of
00:54:53 but like yeah obviously they call our views sexist and i'm just like okay whatever that's just some
00:54:58 made-up term you you have that has no rooted uh it's not rooted in scripture i mean the subtitle
00:55:04 to this book is uh recovering the anti-feminist theology of the reformer so that's good that's
00:55:09 another term we're anti-feminists right i'm not a feminist i reject it entirely it's and it's not
00:55:15 enough to not just be feminist that you've got to be anti-feminist that's right i love it i'm
00:55:21 anti-feminist amen let's go okay well let's let's land the plane but here's my final question for 0.96
00:55:27 you um so we were getting this in nature right these roles they stem from nature they're not
00:55:30 capricious they're not arbitrary you can make natural arguments you know from good and necessary
00:55:35 reason and um and then you know and then also there's a whole host of special revelation things
00:55:40 that god just flat out says um but getting into again nature i think you know even the best of
00:55:46 the complementarian folk, right? The broad, hard, complementarian, whatever you want to call it.
00:55:52 I think they still, they're going to say, okay, well, sure. Yeah. You know, these differences
00:55:56 in roles, they stem from the distinctions in nature, but they're still going to limit. This
00:56:01 is what I've noticed. They're going to limit the distinctions at the level of nature exclusively
00:56:06 to the physicality of men and women. So the only distinctions within the realm of nature that exist
00:56:12 at all are men have shoulders, women have hips, right? And so then, you know, mothering, you know,
00:56:19 stems from that, like, yeah, sure. There's, you know, there's ovaries that that's, that is a
00:56:22 distinction in nature. And then that plays into the, but what I want to say is I think the difference
00:56:27 goes all the way down, all the way down. And what I mean by that is, um, certainly there is a
00:56:33 distinction from testosterone and all these, but it, but it's not just the physical distinction
00:56:37 that men can bench more
00:56:39 and that women can nurse children.
00:56:42 I don't think it's just the physical distinction, 1.00
00:56:45 but with some of those physical things
00:56:47 that I think they flow into one another,
00:56:49 what I'm about to say,
00:56:50 but like testosterone, for instance,
00:56:52 and the way it affects people, men,
00:56:54 chemically and psychologically and mentally.
00:56:58 I think that the differences are more
00:57:00 than just who can throw up more weights
00:57:02 on the bench press and who can nurse children.
00:57:06 But I really do think, like, there's something to be said for the fact that,
00:57:10 like, just look at competitive chess, right?
00:57:15 So it's not just like, well, men are always going to win in the high jump.
00:57:18 Okay, yeah, that's true. 0.93
00:57:21 But a woman can lift a bishop or a rook or a knight and move it three inches on a board. 1.00
00:57:28 There's no disadvantage. 1.00
00:57:29 There's no physical disadvantage for women in the realm of chess.
00:57:33 um but you can you can study it and you can look at the metrics and all that um men are vastly
00:57:40 superior why and you can say well but it's just because it appeals to men and so you know women
00:57:44 aren't as good as men at chess because they don't care about it um okay but even that that begs
00:57:50 another question what is it about this strategic game that was designed for kings to strategize
00:57:56 war plans why does that appeal to men and not to you know so like at every level whether it's the
00:58:01 the unique mental faculty, or even just the raw appeal and attraction towards a game of strategy
00:58:09 and war. The point is, it's not just that men are stronger and women are able to have babies.
00:58:16 It's not just physical. There are distinctions and differences that go all the way down.
00:58:21 And all of them, to sum them up in my assessment, the distinctions for men, they're all geared
00:58:28 towards leadership. And the distinctions for women, they're all geared toward being a deputy,
00:58:36 a right hand, a helper to nurture, to follow, to trust, to create warmth, to turn a house into a 1.00
00:58:44 home. It is to supplement the man, but it is not to lead him. And I think it's inescapable. So I
00:58:53 just want to get your take on that. Is there another way that you would articulate the differences
00:58:57 of nature that stem beyond just broader shoulders and broader hips well there's actually a lot of
00:59:05 literature and i haven't even dived into it that much but um the the testosterone's effect on on
00:59:13 the brain i mean men and women think very differently this is obvious i mean some of
00:59:17 this we don't need to look into all the literature because if you just live you're like okay my my
00:59:21 mom and sisters think differently and wife think differently than i do okay you know uh they're all 0.86
00:59:26 still human but like there's definitely a just difference in in in how women process things and
00:59:31 so you see this in the political realm you see it in the church and i i think it's it's clear 1.00
00:59:39 that women leading in the church is disastrous and we don't want sessions full of women i mean this 0.98
00:59:49 is this is part of the thing i mean sometimes churches will come up with like uh shepherdesses 0.99
00:59:55 Like they're going to, like some women's council, they're advisors to the session.
00:59:58 It's like, hey, every single elder that's a man, male elder has an advisor at home.
01:00:04 He has his wife and we consult our wives on all sorts of things.
01:00:08 You should, but sometimes, you know, your wife doesn't always agree with you and she
01:00:14 might see things a different way.
01:00:15 And so you take that into account, but she's not the one who ultimately makes the decision
01:00:20 in the church.
01:00:20 And so I think God has designed men to lead, and tied with that is he's designed them to provide, and they would be like providing in the home, but providing in the church the word, like teaching, but also protecting.
01:00:36 And so when you get into the church, you have this discipline aspect that is essential, right?
01:00:41 rebuking one another uh i mean we should all be doing that exhorting one another in christ
01:00:46 um but then then you know you have formal discipline in the church for uh sinful behavior
01:00:54 and uh and false teaching and and the church has to carry those things out the church has
01:00:59 to exercise discipline right and when it doesn't those things fester and they become a problem
01:01:06 And then the church declines into theological liberalism or libertinism and debauchery, and those things happen, right?
01:01:15 And so you have to have men, and particularly godly men, leading the church at the local level, and if you have beyond that, right, at the presbytery and general assembly level.
01:01:27 And you could kind of make the same point with politics.
01:01:31 I mean, not to get into this too much, but things have definitely changed where, like, earlier America, voting was limited not just to men, but kind of men who had established themselves.
01:01:42 They had land and the like, and they had an interest in the commonwealth.
01:01:47 And they had a stake in the future.
01:01:49 They had children.
01:01:50 They were married.
01:01:51 Yeah, they had wives and children to look out for.
01:01:53 And now everybody votes, right? 0.97
01:01:56 We have universal suffrage. 0.98
01:01:58 Suffrage. 0.60
01:01:58 Outside of children. 0.99
01:01:59 You have to become 18 first.
01:02:00 and uh which i think is probably too low but um you know you said so you have universal suffrage
01:02:06 everybody gets to vote even if they are on the government dole right they take more than they
01:02:11 they pay in taxes um they don't have to own any land and i i mean this is just and also so this
01:02:19 kind of fed all these these identity politics and and then i mean we're seeing like just the
01:02:25 differences in the way men and women vote i mean you look if right you see those maps on on twitter
01:02:30 or whatever yes we laugh at it but there's something to it right it's like well if only men
01:02:34 voted like the republicans would always win every time but if only women voted the democrats would
01:02:39 win every time so obviously something's going on there um and actually this is a problem for
01:02:45 the younger generations where the young men are getting more conservative and the young women are
01:02:50 getting drastically more liberal yeah and that's very concerning not only for establishing marriages
01:02:55 but also future voting patterns and uh and and so some of this is the way women and men think
01:03:02 differently uh but it's it and it's tied with how they're processing information and um you know
01:03:08 women are more nurturing and so i don't know i think sometimes men are they're just more suited
01:03:13 to make hard decisions politically and ecclesiastically right so i mean yeah without
01:03:18 getting into all the details there's definitely something here as far as god's design for men and
01:03:21 women being different, and female leadership is destructive. That's just a fact, and we need to 0.99
01:03:28 affirm that, that that's a truth, historically, scripturally, theologically, and if you recognize
01:03:35 that, you can at least be more aware of what's going on, and we can say, actually, we shouldn't
01:03:41 allow the kind of these pushes, people pushing for more female leadership in the church and whatnot. 0.95
01:03:48 We actually need to stand on scripture and the tradition and say, no, it's actually really good
01:03:51 that we have just male elders that's fine we don't need anything else right well said well
01:03:57 thanks so much for coming on the show tell people uh the listeners where they can get your book
01:04:00 so uh honor thy fathers it the ebook is on amazon right now and i think they will have the
01:04:11 hardcover or if they do a softcover on amazon at some point but otherwise you have to go to
01:04:17 new christendom press website and they have it uh on there it's a hardback it's kind of a special
01:04:22 edition it looks really good it does people yeah so so you know that they did a great job on the
01:04:27 cover yeah so you you want to pick that up if you can get the hardcover because it will
01:04:32 uh not be there forever and you're saying the hardcover is only available with new christendom
01:04:36 or or it is on amazon no it's not on amazon it's not um it's only on the on the the new christendom
01:04:43 website so okay uh yeah they may do a soft cover at some point new christenem.com i think is that
01:04:49 what it is i think it's new christenempress.com yeah that's it um yeah and they have it on the
01:04:54 front page there so cool we'll keep up the great work thanks uh zach for spending some time with
01:04:59 us today we appreciate it and uh i hope to see you again soon thank you it was great to be here
01:05:13 Thank you.