The NXR Podcast - November 04, 2024


THE INTERVIEW - Natural Law & Theonomy with David Reece

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE SERMON - What Does The Bible Say About Divorce? Part 2 THE LIVESTREAM - Return of the King | 2024 Presidential Election Livestream

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 44 minutes

Words per minute

172.45

Word count

18,013

Sentence count

799

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

20

sentences flagged

Hate speech

46

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Pastor Andrew Isker and Pastor David Reeser begin their nine-part series "Israel: The History, the Bible, the Scripture, the Big Shebang." In this episode, the guys discuss the role of the Bible in shaping our understanding of the world, and how it relates to the modern world.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it.
00:00:04 It's annoying.
00:00:05 Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm so that
00:00:12 our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries
00:00:20 aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 You're doing a great job.
00:00:28 We've got several hundred reviews so far, but we'd like to reach a thousand reviews by the end of this year, the year of our Lord, 2024.
00:00:36 If you haven't left a review yet, take a moment and help us achieve our goal.
00:00:42 All right, I'm going to be honest with you.
00:00:44 This one, it's going behind the paywall.
00:00:47 It's not something we typically do.
00:00:48 In fact, thus far, every single piece of content that we've produced here at Right Response Ministries
00:00:54 has eventually been made available to you for free publicly.
00:00:59 This is an exception, though.
00:01:00 First two episodes will launch publicly.
00:01:03 The next seven episodes will exclusively be available for our members at patreon.com forward slash Right Response Ministries.
00:01:12 Why?
00:01:13 Well, I'll give you the reason.
00:01:14 because right now the vast majority of evangelical Christians
00:01:18 are not ready for the conversation that we have in these episodes.
00:01:23 And frankly, you and I both know that many of those individuals
00:01:27 are actually bad faith actors who will seek to slice it up,
00:01:32 take us out of context, put it out there for the world wide web
00:01:36 in order to discredit this ministry and see to it that we're canceled.
00:01:41 And honestly, I'm not willing to let that happen.
00:01:43 What conversation am I even talking about?
00:01:46 I'm talking about a nine-part series between myself and Pastor Andrew Isker on Israel.
00:01:54 The history, the scripture, the whole big shebang.
00:01:58 Check it out at patreon.com forward slash right response ministries.
00:02:03 You can get every single episode available now, all of it ad-free.
00:02:07 And here's a couple clips just to whet your appetite.
00:02:11 And so our entire moral framework is based around 1930 and 1940. 0.89
00:02:15 And every bad thing is Hitler.
00:02:18 Every failure to confront the bad thing is Neville Chamberlain. 0.85
00:02:23 And Saddam Hussein, Hitler.
00:02:25 Vladimir Putin, Hitler.
00:02:27 Donald Trump, Hitler.
00:02:28 That's the only moral framework that we have that is operable.
00:02:32 So the moment that a young man crosses the aisle and the don't believe your lying eyes rhetoric doesn't work any longer,
00:02:40 And he's just noticed too much because it really is that blatantly obvious.
00:02:44 And he has nowhere else to go.
00:02:45 And he crosses the aisle.
00:02:46 Well, the moment he crosses the aisle, there's no reasonable, wise, mature leader over there.
00:02:50 You would just have the guys on the TV telling them, this is what the Bible says.
00:02:54 You have to believe this.
00:02:56 On the radio, the Christian radio stations, you'd only hear those guys preaching that particular thing.
00:03:03 When that is actually, when you look at all of church history, that's the minority view.
00:03:08 a tiny minority view the rest of theological history in the church is that you know is
00:03:16 the the kind of stuff that we're saying yeah this one's a banger again go to patreon.com
00:03:23 forward slash right response ministries to get all nine parts ad free right now available today
00:03:30 All right, welcome to another episode of Theology Applied. I'm your host,
00:03:46 Pastor Joel Webin with Right Response Ministries. And in this episode, I welcome back my friend,
00:03:51 Mr. David Reese. He is the CEO of Armored Republic. He's the pastor of Puritan Reformed
00:03:55 church in Arizona, outside of Phoenix, I believe, right? You're in the Phoenix larger area.
00:04:01 Yes, sir. Absolutely.
00:04:03 All right. So today we are going to talk. So one of the things I love about David is
00:04:08 when other Christians are tempted to throw you under the bus for cheap points with suburban
00:04:14 moms with perhaps softer sensibilities, David has proven time and time again to be,
00:04:20 um, he's, he's a real friend and he's loyal. And it's not because, um, we perfectly agree on
00:04:27 everything. We have like 95% agreement. So we agree on a lot. Um, but we disagree. And a lot
00:04:33 of you guys have, I've, you know, you've reached out and emailed or left, left comments on YouTube
00:04:37 and said that you've been particularly blessed by our conversations at the points where we actually
00:04:42 disagree and trying to model, um, how within the reformed world, we can, um, love our brothers in
00:04:47 Christ and yet disagree. And so I think the last episode that Mr. Reese and I had together was on
00:04:54 Trump. I'm going to vote for Trump. He is not. And we hashed it out and we did so in a way that
00:05:00 we hope is honoring to Christ and beneficial for all of you who are still probably trying to make
00:05:07 that decision. What is the Christian position? What's the righteous thing to do? And so today
00:05:11 we want to talk about, so both of us are on the theonomic side of the aisle. I always like to add
00:05:18 the qualifier of general equity theonomy because there's some things within the reconstruction camp
00:05:23 that I would disagree with, but I'm a massive fan of, I love Greg Bonson, but I especially love
00:05:29 Rush Dooney. I think that Rush Dooney, in my assessment, Rush Dooney is one of the old school
00:05:35 theonomist that didn't carry with it. The theonomy of Rushduni was not colored by what I would
00:05:46 consider to be the post-war consensus lens. So all that being said, both of us, Mr. Reese and myself,
00:05:52 are theonomists, and yet we would have different conceptions and nuances and particulars. And so
00:05:58 we want to talk about immigration today, and we want to talk about what is the theonomic mitigating
00:06:05 mechanism in order to stop unhealthy nation crippling levels of immigration. But we want to
00:06:14 first set the stage, and I'm going to give it to Mr. Reese to help us define terms with the larger
00:06:19 conversation before we get into the particulars of immigration, the larger conversation of theonomy,
00:06:26 God's law, and natural law, because there is a danger on the natural law side. Both David and I
00:06:33 affirm natural law. We're both Reformed, and we understand that that is absolutely a part of
00:06:37 the Reformed tradition. But there is something to be said for if it's only natural law, or if
00:06:43 natural law supersedes special revelation and God's law, then the word that you often hear
00:06:49 thrown around is prudence, prudence, prudence. But prudence is really, and I think you'll agree
00:06:53 with this, Mr. Reese, is it can easily become a euphemism for man's reason. Prudence, aka man's
00:07:01 reason, and if it's just man's reason with no bumpers, no buffers, then man's reason, I'm
00:07:12 persuaded, is why we're in the current situation that we are. Man's reason gets us right back to
00:07:17 the Enlightenment and all these things that have ruined the West. And so we want to frame that
00:07:23 first. Natural law, what's a biblical conception of natural law? How did the Reformers understand
00:07:27 it? How does that work within a theonomic conception? When does natural law bow the knee
00:07:33 to special revelation and these kinds of things? And then we're going to play it out with a case
00:07:38 study and say, okay, so now with this theonomic conception over and against a pure natural law
00:07:44 conception, how does this play out with immigration? And at that point, that's where you'll see David
00:07:50 and I agreeing on 95%, disagreeing on 5%. And the nice thing about both of us is in real time,
00:07:56 this is a real conversation. It's not staged in real time. One of us might be persuaded. And so
00:08:00 you might see one of us tipping the hat and actually coming across the aisle and agreeing
00:08:05 with the other. And so in that sense, it makes for a very interesting conversation. So without
00:08:09 further ado, welcome to the show. Give us our terms, line it all out for us. Mr. Reese, it's
00:08:14 good to see you. Thank you, brother. Pastor Webb, I appreciate you having me on. You know, the other
00:08:18 thing is, by the way, the main reason that I can afford to offend suburban women is because I 0.82
00:08:22 already have such widespread popularity amongst suburban women my support of base right base
00:08:29 support uh and and especially for armored republic uh that those are the principal customers that i
00:08:34 have nice so i assume you're being sarcastic yeah yeah basically i'm sure this would be surprising
00:08:41 to you but the purchasers of body armor are like 98 men so you know the other two percent are
00:08:46 for their husband principally. So anyway, all right. So, um, okay. So when we talk about,
00:08:52 uh, about political philosophy, um, there are Gordon Clark did a really magnificent job of
00:08:59 kind of addressing the different possible ways that somebody can try to claim to know what the
00:09:03 government should do. And when we think about any sort of question like this, the main thing we're
00:09:07 dealing with is the question of how do I know what the government should do? Right? So, so the
00:09:13 The question of how do you know is something that has to be addressed, but we don't have time to go all the way back there.
00:09:18 But he did this fantastic job of kind of listing out the main ways of organizing political theory.
00:09:24 So the first one is this political idea that you really, when you look around and you look at justifications for force,
00:09:33 the main thing is to say, okay, what should the government do or what is it the government is authorized to do?
00:09:39 And the answer is that they shouldn't do anything, and they're not authorized to do anything, and that philosophy is called anarchy.
00:09:46 And I think that we don't deal seriously enough with the issue of anarchy as Christians a lot of the time, because that question, when you look around and you go, okay, God made human beings, what authorizes human beings to command other human beings to do stuff?
00:10:02 and if you don't have a warrant from god to be able to order people to do stuff then you're just
00:10:11 tyrannizing it right and and so i think that we all kind of just like blow off anarchism as a 0.78
00:10:18 problem that's intellectual by kind of being like well that's stupid i was like well i mean but but
00:10:25 seriously why can one guy go and order another guy to do a thing is it just because he has a 0.93
00:10:32 badge and a gun like what about the badge is magical and and i mean i get why the gun is
00:10:38 effective at getting somebody to do something right so so that leads us into sort of the next
00:10:42 one which is this idea of well there isn't a moral justification for being able to exercise authority
00:10:47 in fact the exercise of authority is sort of a misnomer is really just the exercise of power
00:10:54 and so we could take you know mal's justification the badge is just a luxury the gun is the thing
00:11:00 right and and so if that's the case then you know power comes from the barrel of a gun and it's just 0.86
00:11:04 telling people what to do and having enough force to intimidate them to do it and killing the guys 1.00
00:11:09 that aren't scared enough right so those those are those are things that an anarchy is is stupid 0.97
00:11:16 ultimately because it's unavoidable that there's going to be people who try to use coercive power 0.52
00:11:21 right so the there's there's actually a period in history that was anarchic in the sense of the
00:11:27 civil state. And that was the period from the creation of the world until the Noahic covenant.
00:11:33 So we have like 1,500 years where the civil magistracy did not exist, where God had not
00:11:39 authorized somebody to wield the sword for the purpose of vengeance. There was the right of the
00:11:45 use of the sword before then to be able to defend yourself. And we have an angelic fire sword
00:11:53 carrying guy defending the tree of life and the garden, God's private property against Adam and
00:12:00 Eve potentially trespassing in there. But that idea of there's this age of anarchy and real
00:12:07 politic where people were just ordering people around and building empires without any sort of
00:12:13 actual authorization from God. And again, that's the... Absence. For 1,500 years, you got the
00:12:18 absence of the civil magistrate and the presence of Nephilim. That always helps. I know that you're 1.00
00:12:28 a Sethite guy, right? I assume. Yes, I am. Yeah. So I believe the city of God, city of man.
00:12:34 Even within the Sethite conception, though, if you're a Sethite guy who's read a decent amount
00:12:42 of James Jordan. You can still, I mean, Sethite position still allows for dragons. It still
00:12:49 allows for, I mean, all kinds of lowercase g gods, even like Heiser's conception, which I think
00:12:56 Heiser hated Calvinism. He gets things wrong. But I think he gets a lot right. But even within
00:13:00 Heiser's conception, divine counsel, these kinds of things are fully on the table. You don't have
00:13:05 to believe in hybrid humanoid angels, fallen angels. I personally do, but you don't in order 1.00
00:13:12 to still look at, you know, the antediluvian world and say, wow, crazy time. 1.00
00:13:18 I mean, no, absolutely. 1.00
00:13:20 I mean, like, absolutely, there are these monster beast things.
00:13:24 And you even have, like, Job interacting with that, right?
00:13:27 And I think that there's, even after the flood, you've got this world filled with serious
00:13:33 beasts that have to be taken care of.
00:13:35 And I think people just underestimate the degree to which the strivings of honorable
00:13:40 men to slay these beasts and and make space safe you know it's kind of like when we when we
00:13:46 introduce like you know prime predators like top tier predators back into places it's like
00:13:51 we just we just decursified this place what right why are you bringing back dragons right
00:13:57 right anyway so yeah also there are real giants i mean like you know goliath is a real giant right
00:14:03 so so i'm not i'm not i'm not opposed to any of that there's all i think there's demonic
00:14:08 interaction there and and you you certainly have councils of angels i mean anybody who's read
00:14:11 milton uh you know paradise lost and paradise gained and all that you've got some interesting
00:14:17 stuff about that kind of that that council of the of the gods you know the the angels so anyways
00:14:22 yeah okay anyway so cool stuff um so my point was to say presence of nephilim or however you know
00:14:30 like unique evil unique evil um genesis 6 15 or 14 um i i think you'll agree with me that um yes
00:14:40 it's true when the calvinist you know stands in the pulpit and says you know uh every thought and
00:14:44 inclination of the heart was only evil continually and you know the calvinist is going to look at
00:14:48 that and say uh that's the depiction of all mankind apart from saving grace which is you
00:14:53 know received by faith in christ alone and i would say yes and amen however i believe that genesis
00:14:58 6, 15, and 14, is also uniquely a depiction of that time. It's true inwardly of the people of
00:15:05 that time at the level of the heart, and also true inwardly at the level of the heart of people
00:15:10 today. All unbelievers throughout all time periods, that is an accurate description of total 1.00
00:15:16 depravity, sin at the level of the heart. But I believe it also served as a unique description of 1.00
00:15:21 sin at the level of outward behavior, that during that time, and that brings us back to your point,
00:15:25 um in part because of the absence of the civil magistrate um that there was that evil the heart
00:15:31 was far more outwardly manifest in the antediluvian world before the new covenant than it is today
00:15:37 i think that gets us back on track absolutely so i think you have this the preaching of the law was
00:15:43 so minimized and the power to it was you know from god converting was so minimal in terms of
00:15:50 what he was doing there that you have the the binding power of the law um you know one of the
00:15:56 three uses right mirror chain and and lamp the binding power of the law was was so minimized
00:16:02 that you just had this like horrific wickedness and there's this dramatic engagement of demonic
00:16:08 power that's occurring and you have these beasts that are just the curse is like outrageous on
00:16:15 You look at the fossils of beasts that have been captured because of the flood causing quick covering, and you go, the teeth on those things are rather large.
00:16:29 And you go, I'm not sure that I know of any lizards or dogs or cats that do have teeth that big in our time.
00:16:37 So that's all like manifestation of huge levels of curse on the land.
00:16:43 So, okay, so we have anarchy, we have realpolitik, right?
00:16:48 So this idea that there's no justification for the exercise of power makes it so that you either end up as an anarchist
00:16:55 or you become a person who goes, well, there's not a justification for it, but I'm just going to do it.
00:16:59 And so you have this, like, raw exercise of power.
00:17:02 And that's very popular in the Democrat Party, and it's becoming increasingly popular in Republican circles.
00:17:07 It's just like, whatever, let's just do what we want, right?
00:17:10 So the law of God is very important to restrain evil. 0.75
00:17:14 So we end up with the kind of classical answer that you find that people who call themselves Christians will put forward,
00:17:21 and you end up with this natural law view.
00:17:24 And it's classical to us in America because, in particular, we're affected by kind of Lockean thought about how do we try to take Presbyterian principles.
00:17:34 Locke was raised by Presbyterian, Scotch Presbyterian parents.
00:17:36 And he's like, well, let's take Presbyterian principles and let's try to figure out a way to kind of put them in.
00:17:41 So we have this natural law view of the way government works.
00:17:46 But Locke is not the only person to try to use natural law to justify the civil order.
00:17:51 And so inside of natural law, you have a bunch of different ways of defining that.
00:17:56 And so I think that's one of the things that we should come back to when we're kind of comparing and contrasting a theonomy with natural law.
00:18:04 So the natural law philosophy, the most popular version of it is to look around and go like, well, what is nature like?
00:18:11 And then to try to derive principles from observing.
00:18:14 So there's other views, but that's sort of the Thomistic, Thomas Aquinas view where you're looking around and you're deriving the nature of things by observation and then thinking about it and trying to come up with rules and oughts from what is.
00:18:31 So we can talk more about that later.
00:18:32 But then the other effort is to have a social contract view.
00:18:37 And the social contract view is this effort to say, well, the way that the state gets its power is by agreement, by the forming of a contract.
00:18:46 But that view of social contract, contracts aren't binding across generations in the same way that covenants are.
00:18:54 And so social contract sounds sort of persuasive, especially to Americans, because of the fact that we go, OK, well, yeah, there is a consent of the people in relationship to government.
00:19:06 There is an electing of people. There is an ability to resist higher powers when they do tyrannical things, when they violate the contract.
00:19:13 But here's the deal. We're not allowed to contract anything and everything to the state.
00:19:17 there are there are authorized powers given to the state and it's not just a contract that's
00:19:24 binding forever we go oh no we accidentally gave away our choice of who we get to marry to the
00:19:28 civil magistrate one generation contracted that and we're stuck with that forever oh no
00:19:32 no that's not a legitimate function of the state and and so what we're going to do is retain the
00:19:39 the dual role of of the parents and the children agreeing together about who to marry as opposed
00:19:45 to saying that the civil magistrate is going to get to select your spouse and so any sort of
00:19:51 mistake like that historically doesn't make a contract that you're stuck in that has to go
00:19:56 through a revision there it's it's no illegitimate powers are restrained by the law of god so covenant
00:20:01 versus contract the covenant is a voluntary agreement a con a covenant is defined by god
00:20:06 and so the state is defined by god it's given by god in genesis 9 and so genesis 9 is where it's
00:20:12 formed in terms of the Noahic covenant. And what we find is that we have definitions being laid out
00:20:19 of the powers of the state elsewhere in scripture. Then there is the divine right view. The divine
00:20:24 right view is, you know, Locke has two treatises on government. There's the first treatise,
00:20:32 and there's the second treatise. And we are all very, the second treatise is the famous one in
00:20:37 america because he argues from natural law the first treatise is the treatise that everybody
00:20:43 forgets about and it's kind of like well why are we talking about a second treatise was there a
00:20:46 first one because second normally means that there were the first and nobody ever talks about the
00:20:49 first one and in the first one one of the things he deconstructs is this idea that like kings
00:20:53 have an inheritance from adam that they have this like inherited monarchy that's an absolute monarchy
00:21:01 because their fief symbol of their zone, you know, could be traced back or something.
00:21:07 So like you might have somebody like Charles II being like, I can train my lineage back
00:21:13 to Adam and find how my inheritance would make it so that I have a right to rule England.
00:21:18 You know, some sort of absurdity like that.
00:21:20 Everybody can trace their lineage back to Adam.
00:21:22 Well, I mean, yeah, of course.
00:21:23 I mean, can't you?
00:21:24 Yeah, everybody.
00:21:26 So that, but the idea that I'm the one who gets to inherit this particular chunk of land
00:21:33 would be like a silly manifestation of that.
00:21:35 And so the divine right of kings is sort of like, who has the blue blood?
00:21:39 How do you identify the ones that are royal in their veins?
00:21:45 And maybe you have lesser nobility or whatever that manifests that.
00:21:49 So you end up with these things like, well, the way you show yourself to be worthy of
00:21:53 of having the divine right to rule and your rule is absolute as though you were dealing with your
00:21:59 private property, um, that divine right view, uh, you're kind of like looking for signs of that.
00:22:05 Um, and, and, and that, that looking for signs of that can be like, well, were you brave enough
00:22:09 in battle or whatever else? And so you, you end up with these after the fact justifications to
00:22:13 try to justify an absolute rule. So would that be, would Cromwell kind of be an example of that?
00:22:18 So I don't think Cromwell was.
00:22:22 I think that the monarchy that he resisted was.
00:22:25 I think Cromwell would have made a divine law argument.
00:22:30 I think he would be an example of the sixth category, which is the one I believe in, basically theonomy, that there's a divine law or a covenant theory for government.
00:22:42 and that that that covenant theory involves you know just means to form the government but also
00:22:48 um you know what are what is the government's power what are the crimes and the penalties all
00:22:53 that kind of stuff the only reason i thought of cromwell is like i mean he certainly had the
00:22:56 consent of the people um and and there was a covenant uh of sorts that was present there
00:23:02 i was just thinking but he but he was ironically like it breaks the you know the divine rule
00:23:08 metric in terms of like, you know, he's not of noble blood. He's not within this lineage.
00:23:14 But you just, you mentioned what made me think of Cromwell was you mentioned in passing,
00:23:19 like somebody who fought really well. And Cromwell would be like an example of somebody,
00:23:23 it was like, that would be an example of instead of, you know, monarchy, it was like meritocracy.
00:23:28 It was like one of the first, you know, notable times that England was like, okay, you know,
00:23:34 um you know just the the son of the king and his son and his son and his son by you know default
00:23:41 being king uh hasn't been working out for us at least recently um maybe we should just have have
00:23:48 it as merit you know may the best man win and this is a virtuous man you know who's fought well
00:23:52 and so he kind of ascends that's you know he was in some sense a populist figure you know but then
00:23:58 the problem was succession, you know, um, that like Cromwell's son did not pan out to be the
00:24:05 man that Cromwell was. No, he did not. And then they went back to Kings. So, yeah. Yeah. And I,
00:24:11 I think, um, we should absolutely do an episode on Cromwell. Like I was just like tracing. I was
00:24:20 like going through my head. I was like, how can I talk about Cromwell? And I was like, I need like
00:24:23 90 minutes for cromwell like let's but so anyways there's also sorts of awesome to talk about
00:24:30 with that and the english civil war and everything so uh maybe you'll tolerate me doing that with
00:24:35 you sometimes sure okay okay so so that we got through this we have anarchy realpolitik natural
00:24:41 law uh social contract uh divine right and we have divine law or covenant theory covenant view
00:24:48 So those are sort of the things that we're stuck with there.
00:24:52 So as we think about those, the Bible is plainly not anarchic.
00:24:57 It plainly teaches that there are civil authorities.
00:25:00 We see it in Genesis 9.
00:25:01 We see it all throughout the Torah, the laying out of legitimate authority.
00:25:06 We see the teaching of the legitimate extent of government in lots of places in Scripture,
00:25:12 limits on taxation and all that kind of stuff.
00:25:15 We find that in 1 Samuel 8, where it says that 10% is a tyrannically high tax rate.
00:25:20 We go to the classic text in Romans 13, verses 1 through 7, where we find the authority of the state.
00:25:27 And verses 1 through 7 is not like a general command to submit to anybody who has a badge and a gun.
00:25:31 It's a laying out of the job qualifications for you to find who's authorized to rule and who's not in the extent of their power.
00:25:38 And so you find all that.
00:25:40 That anarchy just doesn't line up with Scripture.
00:25:43 Realpolitik, that just whoever happens to have the power,
00:25:46 is also not what lines up with Scripture because we have tests for tyranny,
00:25:49 and we have all sorts of examples of resistance against tyranny,
00:25:53 the doctrine of the lesser magistrate.
00:25:55 We have this idea of appealing to heaven and calling upon his power,
00:25:58 God's power to save us from tyrants.
00:26:01 And you have this idea that not that might makes right,
00:26:06 except in the sense that God, who is the ultimate might,
00:26:08 does actually determine what's right.
00:26:10 But amongst men and amongst creatures, it is not might that makes right or not might that justifies the exercise of power.
00:26:17 And so we have limits on power, and we find all sorts of things in the Scripture that show the rebuke of power,
00:26:23 and prophets often going to rebuke kings, for example.
00:26:27 So it is not the case that simply that authority flows from power.
00:26:33 That is not the Scripture doctrine.
00:26:36 With natural law, and again, we'll spend more time on that, social contract, government is not just by the consent of men.
00:26:43 Men are born under governments, and they have a duty to submit to legitimate governments whether or not they signed the contract.
00:26:48 And furthermore, you do not have the right to contract away powers that God has not given to the state.
00:26:54 And we find the example of Uriah trying to go in and participate in the sacrifices in the temple and God giving him leprosy in response to that.
00:27:04 Like, it's not just the powers that are taken or the powers that are agreed to representatively or whatever.
00:27:10 It is powers that God defines.
00:27:12 He defines the jurisdictions and the spheres.
00:27:14 And then as far as the divine right goes, we find the idea that people can be removed from office.
00:27:20 We find the idea that there's legitimate ways to enter office as opposed to usurping.
00:27:26 And it's not just some bloodline.
00:27:28 It's not just an inheritance line there.
00:27:31 you have the example of Saul being elected by the people, and then him losing his right to rule
00:27:37 because of his actions, and then him being removed, and you have the idea of David. And even with
00:27:43 David, there's a process, even though God chose him, there's a process of Judah electing him,
00:27:48 and then there's a process of the other tribes electing him. And so there's the process of law,
00:27:54 as well as the fact that there is limits on authority. So I want to say that there's process
00:28:00 of law, there's divine law, there's theonomy, there's covenant institution that is binding
00:28:05 across generations that has limits of process for selection of officers and all that kind of stuff.
00:28:10 So that's sort of my effort to give us the limits. So that's why I think we need to zero in on
00:28:14 natural law and we need to zero in on theonomy and contrast those two views to really be able to
00:28:19 figure out what is it that the scriptures teach. You have heard it said that cash is king. Well,
00:28:25 our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants you to know that cash flow is the key to building
00:28:30 wealth. The partners at Private Family Banking are experts at teaching you how to implement a
00:28:36 new way of thinking about money. This powerful and innovative approach provides a fail-safe
00:28:42 method for redirecting the cash flow you already have into a privatized banking system that you
00:28:48 now own and control. This new system places you and your family on the wealth curve for
00:28:54 continuously compounding tax protected gains now and unto future generations. You may also be
00:29:02 familiar with the age old wisdom that the best time to plant a tree for shade was 10 years ago,
00:29:08 but the second best time is today. So start your journey of building your financial legacy right
00:29:15 now. The sooner you start, the better. Let a private family banking partner help you put
00:29:21 post-mill talk into post-mill action. Contact them today by emailing banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:29:29 Again, that's banking at privatefamilybanking.com and request a free step-by-step wealth building
00:29:37 plan that will be the game changer that you have been looking for. Lastly, a complimentary
00:29:42 discovery call can be scheduled by using the link in this episode's show notes.
00:29:48 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God,
00:29:52 not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:29:56 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
00:30:00 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
00:30:03 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:30:07 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:30:12 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
00:30:18 Reese Fund, Christian capital, boldly deployed.
00:30:23 Are you a Christian who struggles to find companies who align with your convictions?
00:30:27 Do you wish that you could work with Christian brothers rather than pagans who hate everything
00:30:32 you love?
00:30:32 You shouldn't have to dedicate your hard work to men or women who support evil.
00:30:38 At Top Knot Alpaca Care, we're looking for mature men who desire hard work and long days
00:30:44 building the kingdom.
00:30:45 your vocation is more important than just the income you bring in for your family your work
00:30:52 should equip you with better life skills and deeper relationships than you could ever get
00:30:57 from college now if you can't handle overwhelming smells of things like urine feces and ammonia
00:31:03 wrestling 500 pound llamas and traveling for months at a time or being pushed to grow physically
00:31:10 emotionally, and spiritually, then you need not apply. We're a growing company with a variety
00:31:16 of open positions. So contact us today before our interview window closes in January. Call Elijah
00:31:22 at Top Knot with the phone number that's listed in the description for this show.
00:31:27 Go to the description. The phone number for Elijah with Top Knot will be right there.
00:31:32 Give him a call today. So then, is there, where would you like me to go? Would you like me to
00:31:37 lay out the different types of well maybe maybe starting with just trying to if if maybe the two
00:31:43 of us can try to flesh out and define natural law and maybe some of the different conceptions
00:31:49 because i i don't know about you but i've found that um their natural law is it's kind of similar
00:31:56 to the larger like christian nationalism discussion you know it's like i'm a christian
00:32:00 nationalist what kind like i i'm i'm down i i like christian nationalism but i have you know
00:32:07 a particular type of, you know, Christian nationalism that I would adhere to. And,
00:32:11 and not everybody who, you know, wears the moniker necessarily means the same thing. So
00:32:18 in terms of natural law, I think that, you know, there is a, you know, there's a conception of
00:32:24 natural law that I think is perfectly biblical, you know, thinking of Romans one, thinking of
00:32:29 Romans two, especially Romans two. So if we could flesh that out starting there, I think that would
00:32:35 be helpful. So if somebody put forward this view of natural law that says natural law is this idea
00:32:43 that my conscience, my feelings, what's beautiful, what's pleasant is what's right. If somebody puts
00:32:53 forward that what's natural is what feels good, how would you respond to that if somebody said
00:33:00 that's what natural law is? That's the Disney version of natural law, follow your heart.
00:33:04 we would say, well, yeah, those things may come naturally, but the problem is that nature
00:33:09 is under a curse. And so even like, I remember people making arguments, liberals, progressive,
00:33:17 Christians, Christian in name only, but making arguments 10 years ago, 15 years ago with 0.62
00:33:23 homosexuality and leading up to Bergerfell in 2015. And just like we have evangelicals for 0.91
00:33:29 Harris, there were evangelicals for sodomy and gay marriage and things like that.
00:33:33 And one of the arguments that they would make was a natural law argument. Now, I don't think it actually suffices as a genuine natural law argument, but they were arguing, well, we're reasoning from nature.
00:33:45 And so one of the examples that they would give from nature is they would say, well, we found certain species, thanks to Alex Jones and his observations, the frogs really are turning gay.
00:33:56 And so we found this species of mudfish or frog or whatever that engages sexually with its partner of the same sex and blah, blah, blah. 0.87
00:34:07 And so therefore, sodomy is on the table and people can be gay and they can have the rights of marriage. 0.77
00:34:13 And my point is that in their minds, now I don't think they were right, obviously, but in their minds, they would have called that a natural law argument.
00:34:21 And I remember all the way back then thinking, you know, one problem with nature.
00:34:26 So we know from Romans 1 that, like, God reveals himself by what he has made.
00:34:31 So the creation, the cosmos, actually does speak of God.
00:34:33 And it doesn't just speak of, like, Romans 2 in terms of love for neighbor, the obligation,
00:34:38 the moral obligation of man as it, you know, horizontally affects his neighbor.
00:34:43 You know, don't steal from your neighbor.
00:34:44 Don't murder your neighbor.
00:34:46 Certainly the conscience speaks of that. 1.00
00:34:48 And that's natural to the Imago Dei. 0.75
00:34:51 And even for fallen men, unregenerate men, still have a conscience.
00:34:55 And they don't even, it's not just that they haven't lived up to God's standard.
00:34:58 They're without an apologia, an excuse, because they can't even meet their own standard.
00:35:02 All men are compromised.
00:35:03 All men have fallen short of the glory of God.
00:35:05 And so that's the horizontal aspect, Romans 2.
00:35:07 But you also have the vertical aspect.
00:35:09 You have, you know, Romans 1 is arguing that natural law, nature, natural revelation, I
00:35:16 should say, but I think it, you know, Romans 1 is kind of like natural revelation.
00:35:19 Romans 2 is like natural law, but nature itself testifies to the glory of God, his divine power
00:35:25 and his eternal power and divine nature, or divine nature and eternal power. One of those,
00:35:31 I can't remember. So, but that's all in scripture. The problem though, I remember thinking this like
00:35:36 eight years ago, here's the problem. If nature itself is under a curse and nature, if we decide
00:35:42 that nature will be the ultimate standard apart from special revelation or over and above and
00:35:49 against special revelation. Well, nature, Romans 1 is true, of course, that nature does reveal to
00:35:57 us that there's a God in heaven. And I think you can argue from nature, the triune God, and not
00:36:01 just a deistic deism, but actual Christian God, the triune God. And I think that we actually can
00:36:09 see that in nature. However, all that being said, nature also lies. And what I mean by that is that
00:36:17 because nature has fallen and under a curse, if all we do is observe nature, we will come away
00:36:23 with some really bad ideas. Like, there really are certain species that do things that are
00:36:29 immoral, right? Like praying mantis, you know, like after they mate, you know, the female praying
00:36:34 mantis, you know, eats the head off of the male praying mantis. And so if nature's all you have,
00:36:39 and you look at, you know, praying mantis, and all of a sudden you start making an argument like,
00:36:42 Like, you know, after your, you know, spouse conceives, then, you know, the wife can murder
00:36:49 her husband, you know, and carry on his line without him. Like, no, that would be a bad
00:36:53 argument. That's a bad argument. So my point is to say, I think natural law is real. I think it's
00:36:58 inevitable and inescapable, and I am Reformed, and it's part of the Reformed tradition. But you
00:37:02 got to be real clear about what you mean by natural law. And when you look at natural revelation,
00:37:07 I think it's important to say natural revelation reveals true things about God, but it's not
00:37:11 exhaustive truth. That's why we need special revelation because nature, I think, and this
00:37:17 gets back to, you know, Jim Jordan, some of his conceptions, I think nature, there's a sense in
00:37:21 which the curse has been pushed back as time goes on. And so, you know, nature was particularly
00:37:26 cursed in the antediluvian world. However, at the same time, I think you can make an argument in 0.94
00:37:31 terms of like Psalm 19, the skies pour forth speech, the stars, right? So beasts, you know,
00:37:37 that are particularly malevolent. But the stars, I think that the skies actually perhaps,
00:37:45 I think you could argue, spoke more clearly in earlier years than they do now. And part of that
00:37:53 is because in these last days, Hebrews 1, God spoke to us in many, many ways by the prophets,
00:37:58 our fathers, the prophets, many times and in many ways, dreams, visions. And I think even,
00:38:03 I think you can include in Hebrews 1, 1 through 3, even saying that God spoke with more clarity
00:38:09 and maybe even a wider scope of breadth through natural revelation. But now he's given his final
00:38:16 word, who is his son, and his son has been inscripturated by the apostles and all the
00:38:21 prophets who pointed to him and the apostles who pointed back to him, the Bible, the canon,
00:38:26 and this is God's final word and it's the clearest word. And I even think there's an argument to be
00:38:30 made for, you know, the Magi following the star, that it was kind of like the last of the skies.
00:38:37 They still, fourth speech, Psalm 19 is still true today, but I think it might have been even more
00:38:42 acutely true, and that, like, the stars may have been more active in older times and brighter
00:38:49 and clearer as they testify to God. And then one star in particular, under God's divine providence,
00:38:55 as God is about to give his final word in his son, the birth of his son, one star, you know,
00:39:00 it's like the last of the skies moving in a very particular divine kind of supernatural way leading
00:39:05 up to, and now the stars are more quiet. The stars used to scream. Now they whisper because the sun
00:39:12 is now arrived. The brightest star has come. You know, like, I don't know. I feel like,
00:39:16 feel like that'll preach. So anyways, all that being said, the point is natural revelation
00:39:19 is true. It is biblical, but nature, we should remember, is under a curse. And because nature's
00:39:26 under a curse, there are certain things that nature tells us that aren't the overarching
00:39:32 truth. Like nature tells us that death has the final word, but scripture tells us that death
00:39:36 will be swallowed up in life. And like, we need scripture. So anyways.
00:39:41 I'm like such a wet blanket. I'm going to, I'm going to, I'm looking, I know you and I are
00:39:48 planning to have a conversation in the near future about how do we know stuff. And so I'm
00:39:55 going to I'm going to I'm going to put a pin in it that's fine talking about some of those things
00:39:59 but I want to give you a brief a brief reply which I would say if I think about natural law
00:40:05 right like okay I think there's four ways that people have tried to give natural law historically
00:40:11 one is the feeling based one which you so eloquently called Disney natural law right which
00:40:16 I love it's exactly right it's exactly what it is it's like my perverted affections tell me what
00:40:21 is right. And so therefore, what is right is whatever I want. Therefore, I'm God. That's
00:40:26 that first natural law. And then you actually addressed other versions of it as well. I think
00:40:31 what you laid out, one of the ones you mentioned is the observation of stuff where you're like, 0.98
00:40:35 well, the frogs are totally gay. So the world is gay. And so like, gay frogs, gay world, man, 0.99
00:40:41 like you got to just deal with it. So this, I think the idea that you look around at nature 1.00
00:40:47 and you can find what's right based upon what you can observe in nature.
00:40:52 That's sort of the, like, Marquis de Sade version of natural law.
00:40:56 And I think that we try, like, you can read, like, apologists like Thomas Aquinas
00:41:03 or, like, Pele or something like that where you try to, like, do some, like,
00:41:07 arguments from the observation of nature about God and about ethics.
00:41:11 And I think that when you do that, and it's based upon what you see, right, you end up with this problem of, first, you can't derive an ought from what it is.
00:41:24 Like, you don't see oughts anywhere.
00:41:27 Oughts are not observable.
00:41:30 And so when we're looking around and seeing descriptions of, making descriptions of what we see, we already have to have a definition of good coming in on those observations.
00:41:41 So we're like, we're engaged looking at the world and looking at creatures and saying, well, this is happening and it's good, right?
00:41:49 So we already have a judgment of good that we're imposing in.
00:41:51 So we smuggle it in and we don't really get the aughts from our observation.
00:41:56 We are just, we're just imposing them.
00:41:57 And I think so when we then talk about observing the world, when I read Romans chapter 1,
00:42:09 and I look at verses, I think, 19 and 20 are sort of the key there to the main thing that
00:42:16 was being talked about. So you have this, like, being able to see from the things that are made.
00:42:21 and that's that language that the text says if the wrath of god is revealed from heaven against
00:42:28 all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who suppress the truth and unrighteousness because
00:42:33 what may be known of god is manifest in them for god has shown it to them for since the creation
00:42:38 of the world this is verse 20 romans 120 but since the creation of the world his invisible attributes
00:42:44 are clearly seen being understood by the things that are made even his eternal power and godhead
00:42:51 so that they are without excuse.
00:42:54 So like you're paraphrasing from memory, super impressive.
00:42:56 And so the thing there that people read as like we look at creation
00:43:04 and understand by looking at creation is being understood by the things that are made.
00:43:11 The being understood by the things that are made is in Greek,
00:43:14 it is like being understood by the creature.
00:43:18 and we think of it as like being understood by looking at the stuff that was made and i i would
00:43:25 posit to you um that that the text there is saying being understood by the creature not by means of
00:43:34 looking at stuff but by man and the word that's used there is the same word that's used in ephesians
00:43:39 where it says uh you know that we are his workmanship that word like workmanship is the
00:43:44 same word that's here that's the by the the things that are made the things that are made is one greek
00:43:48 word, and it's the same one in Ephesians, that's workmanship. So I would put forward that it's
00:43:53 being understood by men, not being understood by looking at the universe. So real quick, I need
00:43:59 you to flesh out that distinction a little bit better. So workmanship is a word that describes
00:44:04 mankind, but also is being used to describe the cosmos, all created things, is his handiwork,
00:44:12 his workmanship. And so this workmanship, speaking of the cosmos, created things apart
00:44:18 from man, man being the pinnacle of the earthly cosmos. But everything else is also God's
00:44:27 workmanship. And you're saying that there's a distinction between man's observation of God's
00:44:34 workmanship, leading him into certain conclusions and truth, versus what? You're saying it's not
00:44:43 that, that it's not just man's mere observation of the created cosmos, but it's, because
00:44:50 it almost sounds like what you're saying would almost be kind of like a similar concept to the
00:44:59 hermeneutic of um carl bart uh you know what he did in his hermeneutic in terms of reading special
00:45:06 revelation the scripture that it's um that is not really infallible in and of itself but it becomes
00:45:11 infallible in man's in the reading of scripture you know like the the words on the page itself
00:45:17 are actually not god's work um it becomes god's word when it's being read by a human being created
00:45:23 in the image of god and especially a regenerate human being that has a spirit at work within him
00:45:27 And so it's like, really, it's the words on the page, plus the person, plus the spirit,
00:45:31 you know, our powers combined, those three things make it the word of God.
00:45:35 And I'm like, no, no, thanks.
00:45:37 You know, and it almost sounds like you were saying that, and I'm not even disagreeing
00:45:41 with you, but I just need some more clarity.
00:45:44 It sounds like you're applying like a Bardian hermeneutic of special revelation to interpreting
00:45:49 natural revelation.
00:45:51 So yeah, so I don't mean that.
00:45:53 I don't mean that natural revelation requires the the agreement of of the person for it to exist
00:46:01 So let me let me let me round out and this might help to make it a little bit more clear if I if I explain
00:46:05 So the four categories that there that are natural others there's natural law of feelings, which is bogus Disney
00:46:10 There's natural law of observation, which is sort of the Thomist, you know view where you're looking at stuff and drawing out
00:46:15 And then there's this natural law where you can just kind of reason it out, right?
00:46:19 Like R.C. Sproul's, you know, kind of description of rationalism is, you know, you're sitting in a Dutch oven,
00:46:25 reasoning it out by yourself in the dark, you know.
00:46:28 And so it's not that.
00:46:29 It's not reason alone either.
00:46:31 It's not like I'm going to posit a definition of man, and if I view man as, you know, like, you know, it's not that.
00:46:38 So what is it, right?
00:46:40 And I'm going to argue natural law is thought content that's planted in man.
00:46:46 So if you think about the heart of man, the heart of man is his mind.
00:46:54 And there are certain content pieces that are unavoidably present at the moment of conception by the very nature of man.
00:47:05 So the image of God, whatever that is, is present in man at conception.
00:47:10 The image of God is reason plus innate concepts.
00:47:17 Innate ideas, innate categories, whatever label you want to use for that.
00:47:21 And I think those categories are defined for us as the attributes of God
00:47:25 and also the categories for the moral law.
00:47:29 And so what we do is we end up taking, like, eternality,
00:47:33 which is an attribute of God, and we, like, apply it to the universe,
00:47:37 and now we have a false god, right?
00:47:39 So we construct false gods by taking the attributes of God
00:47:44 that are unavoidable to thought, and we make these false gods.
00:47:48 And then the way we corrupt the moral law is we'll have, like, okay,
00:47:52 there's people I'm supposed to honor, Fifth Commandment,
00:47:54 and, like, you give honor illegitimately, or you give honor without any constraints,
00:47:58 or, like, you worship your ancestors, or you throw off honor
00:48:02 and you honor the inappropriate people or whatever, right?
00:48:04 Same with the Sixth Commandment. 1.00
00:48:05 Oh, I shouldn't kill anybody unless they're Jews or unborn children, right? 1.00
00:48:09 Like, those are—so you end up with, like, explaining away, you know, 1.00
00:48:13 categories of the human race as human and trying to say they're not really human and so therefore 0.91
00:48:17 i can kill them and and so we have this sort of like or maybe the bourgeoisie the bourgeoisie 1.00
00:48:23 are not people um you know and so the idea that you have a right to to kill them and take their 0.99
00:48:27 stuff um and so the these these things are corruptions there so so my point would be
00:48:34 you don't have to imagine for a second a mind that is disconnected from sensory experience
00:48:39 You're paralyzed at such a point where there's a breaking of a connection to any of your
00:48:46 sense experience.
00:48:46 You're blind, you're deaf, you can't feel stuff, there's no tactile experience, you're 0.94
00:48:52 not smelling stuff, and you're not tasting things. 0.91
00:48:54 That's tragic.
00:48:56 And so all of that, that person is still inexcusable if they reject God.
00:49:02 And that's because there's a natural law and there's natural revelation.
00:49:07 it's inherent to their nature as a man and so the the it's not natural in the sense of feeling it's
00:49:16 not natural in the sense of observing nature it's not natural in the sense of like logic alone it's
00:49:20 natural in the sense that it's a part of the very nature of man and so we unavoidably have categories
00:49:26 of thought that we that we make moral judgments with and we accuse or excuse ourselves based upon
00:49:31 those judgments and those are those are contradictory so we're condemned under even our
00:49:35 own judgment all right that's it guys i tried to warn you the time has finally arrived our early
00:49:40 bird pricing is gone but don't despair we've gone above and beyond to make this conference affordable
00:49:46 to all so even now it's only 170 bucks for an adult it's cheap for teenagers and free for kids
00:49:54 what am i talking about well i'm talking about the christ is king conference how to defeat trash
00:49:59 world it's happening april 3rd 4th and 5th the year of our lord 2025 that's a thursday friday
00:50:06 saturday three full days jam-packed with eight main sessions three panels and an extraordinarily
00:50:12 based lineup of speakers we've got steve dace orrin mcintyre andrew isker david reese steven
00:50:20 wolf eric khan john harris ady robles dan burkholder ben garrett dusty deevers the christian
00:50:27 friends himself and yours truly, Joel Webber. Sign up today. Don't miss this conference. And
00:50:33 I'll give you a little bit of a secret here. There's a couple more potential speakers in the
00:50:39 wings. Haven't completely confirmed yet, so I cannot disclose, but I'll say this. If it happens,
00:50:44 it's going to blow your mind. So register at rightresponseconference.com. Again, that's
00:50:49 rightresponseconference.com. Register today. Are you a Christian struggling to find companies that
00:50:55 align with your values and beliefs? Well, then Squirrely Joe's has you covered for all your 0.97
00:51:00 coffee needs. All of their coffee is hand-selected and roasted fresh every day by a family of fellow
00:51:06 believers. Try them out, and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your
00:51:11 investment supports a company committed to following God's teachings and upholding truth
00:51:17 and righteousness, ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the growth of God's kingdom.
00:51:23 Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil.
00:51:27 Right Response listeners have access to an exclusive deal.
00:51:31 Your first bag of coffee is free.
00:51:34 All you have to do is cover the shipping.
00:51:36 So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash Right Response.
00:51:41 Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com forward slash Right Response
00:51:45 to claim your first free bag of coffee today. 0.97
00:51:50 Visit thewordsoap.com today.
00:51:52 again that's the word soap.com everyone needs soap so wash yourself in the word
00:51:58 no that's that's good that that's that i appreciate that that's helpful because
00:52:05 you're right that's a really good point that you bring up like you know uh helen keller like uh
00:52:11 is you know is she excused like you know does romans one not apply to her all all men are
00:52:17 without an excuse, unless you can't, you know, you can't hear or see, you know, like the, well,
00:52:23 then, well, then you actually do have an excuse because you, you know, the sky's poor for speech,
00:52:29 you know, Psalm 19 or Romans 1, you know, like what God has made his handiwork. Well, you know,
00:52:34 she can't see it. She can't hear it. And so she doesn't need Jesus to get to heaven. She's actually,
00:52:42 you know she's uh she's uh she's excused um you know i and of course we would say no um so that
00:52:49 that is helpful to say that uh it's not just um it's not just god's handiwork and seeing these
00:52:56 things that renders man without an apologia but but that it's uh it's something that god it's
00:53:03 not just what god has made outside of man that he can observe but it's also god's making of man
00:53:08 himself, something that's inside of man and the way that God constructed him that makes him morally
00:53:14 culpable. And that right there, if you think about experience, experience as a whole is
00:53:26 interpreted. You don't learn from experience, you interpret experience. And your interpretations
00:53:33 of experience are based upon your worldview.
00:53:36 And so when I look at the stars, I can say that's cosmic dust caused by chaos.
00:53:44 Or I can say those are lights in heaven created by God.
00:53:50 And when I think about Psalm 19, it talks about the heavens declaring the glory of God,
00:53:57 and there's no place where their speech is not heard.
00:54:00 um uh you know it's talking it's not that the stars are literally pouring out propositional
00:54:05 thought content right the the issue is is you know if there's nobody to look at the stars are
00:54:12 they speaking to them you know it's it's the it's the it's the observer that that the stars remind
00:54:20 them of the of the stuff that's written on their heart so you look at the stars and the stars have
00:54:25 been frequent objects of worship so is the the sun but their changeableness the fact that they
00:54:31 are changeable means they're not eternal right yeah they're not immutable and so that that that
00:54:36 eternality um is necessary to divinity and and without eternality you know they're not divine
00:54:43 so as you look at them and recognize the changeableness of them it's it that thinking
00:54:49 about the changeableness of them is what reminds you that they're not god and and so the there's
00:54:56 there's a there's the unchangeable one who is god and and so i think the your your own the the stuff
00:55:04 written on your heart your mind is is the stuff that as you observe it that that's the speech and
00:55:11 so it's where they're where they're where their speech in other words where there's rational
00:55:14 minds is where that's observed. And so that idea, so natural law, it's not, the reformed
00:55:23 or biblical view of natural law is not feeling, it's not observation of the sense of experience,
00:55:28 it's not sitting in a Dutch oven and reasoning with nothing else, it's not rationalism. It's
00:55:33 the innate categories. And so there are two main things we have to deal with with this idea of
00:55:38 natural law. It's the inexcusability of man for rejecting God, which is, again, you've got these
00:55:43 categories, the attributes of God. He's infinite, eternal, and unchangeable in his being, wisdom,
00:55:47 power, holiness, justice, goodness, and truth. That's sort of catechism question four. What is
00:55:51 God? That definition, I think that does a great job of cataloging the attributes of divinity
00:55:57 that distinguish God from creatures. And so what you have is the infinitude of God. God is infinite,
00:56:06 other things are not. God is eternal, other things are not. God is unchangeable, other things are
00:56:11 not. So the creator-creature distinction there is carefully guarded. Creatures are finite,
00:56:19 temporal, and changeable. And so the finitude of things and the temporality being inside of time
00:56:30 and the changeableness, which is what time is. Time is change, right? So if you're changeable,
00:56:36 you're in time and so that that whole idea that that those attributes of divinity are are are
00:56:43 things that are that are written in our heart and we we are interpreting things through this lens
00:56:49 of what's changeable what's not what's what's what's temporal what's eternal what's what's uh
00:56:53 infinite what's what's finite those are categories that are unavoidable um and so and then with them
00:56:59 And so as a result, we make idols conceptually,
00:57:03 and we have these false gods, and these false gods are incoherent messes.
00:57:11 They're self-contradictory in their nature because we've made up
00:57:17 this incoherent definition of a false god.
00:57:20 And so only the biblical God has a coherent definition that is not contradictory.
00:57:27 And then when we go to moral choice, we have the objective spoken word of God
00:57:34 from the oracles of God, and that law condemns people who are in the church.
00:57:39 They hear that, and they go, okay, I'm without excuse from this written law.
00:57:42 But also the law in the heart, those moral categories,
00:57:45 make it so that our own choices, we accuse or excuse ourselves.
00:57:49 And so one day I go, you know, it's bad to judge people.
00:57:51 And then I all of a sudden realize I've just judged people by judging their judging.
00:57:56 And so you go, I have an incoherent ethical system, and I have just done the thing I am condemning, right?
00:58:03 So you realize your own internal self-contradiction and realize that by your own standard, you're condemned.
00:58:09 So that's how I understand the inexcusability to work, both in terms of our conceptual idolatry
00:58:14 and in terms of ethical judgments and the use of the law to judge us.
00:58:20 And the two keys to being held responsible are there has to be a judge to judge us, and there has to be a law by which we're judged.
00:58:27 And our false view of the judge is bogus, and it's obvious that we are lying to ourselves.
00:58:33 And our own standards we break.
00:58:35 And then God's the actual judge, and his standard is the actual standard, and we're guilty under those as well.
00:58:41 And so, woe is me.
00:58:43 I am a man of unclean lips, and I live amongst a people of unclean lips.
00:58:46 It should be the only appropriate response from anybody.
00:58:48 Right.
00:58:48 Right. No, that's all really good. The only thing that I would say in response is, at this point,
00:58:54 I think I'm, because I'm with you, because I've, you know, as I've taught Romans 1 on multiple
00:59:01 occasions, I've always, I've always, you know, tried to emphasize that Romans 1 doesn't merely
00:59:08 say, and this goes to your point, because I think you're exactly right, Romans 1 doesn't merely
00:59:14 communicate that the attributes of God, his existence, his holiness, his divine nature,
00:59:20 his deity, Godhead, and also his power, his eternal power, omnipotence, and infinitude,
00:59:29 and eternality, and all these things. Romans 1 doesn't merely say that the created cosmos,
00:59:35 God's handiwork outside of man himself, by means of everything else that God has made,
00:59:40 that God's creation testifies and speaks, communicates these truths, the truth of God's
00:59:51 existence and the truth of many, not all in an exhaustive sense, but many of his attributes.
00:59:56 Romans 1 doesn't merely say that, that creation testifies or speaks about God,
01:00:01 but Romans 1 goes further and says that these things have been clearly perceived. So it's not
01:00:08 just creation has sent a message, that God has sent a message through creation. It's also man
01:00:16 has to be included in this equation because it's also God has made creation in such a way
01:00:23 that creation is speaking about God, about its maker. Also, God has made man in such a way that
01:00:32 man is receiving the message. So it's not just that the message goes out from creation,
01:00:37 But the message is received by the pinnacle of earthly creation, God's image-bearing creatures,
01:00:43 man. And that's precisely why man is, at the end of the day, without an excuse that is morally
01:00:50 culpable, because it's not just that God was faithful. And this, I mean, you could argue that
01:00:55 this would be enough, but God and his generosity and his kindness and his mercy and everything
01:01:00 about him, he goes much further. God is not merely faithful to make sure that his creation
01:01:09 sends the message, but he's also been faithful to make sure that mankind receives the message.
01:01:16 It's been clearly perceived, not just clearly communicated by creation, but clearly perceived
01:01:22 as the word that Romans 1, if I'm remembering correctly, uses. So not just message has been
01:01:28 sent out, but message received. So the culpability of man, I think, is twofold. It's not just that
01:01:36 man is morally responsible because the message is there, written in the sky and in the trees and
01:01:40 the forests and rivers and everywhere he looks and everything he hears. It's not just the message
01:01:46 is there, but also God has constructed not just the creation to speak the message, but man in such
01:01:51 a way that the message is within him. The message is not just outside of him to be observed, but
01:01:59 inside of him in such a way that it is perceived. And so I guess, I don't know how to think about it
01:02:06 because you've raised some good points. As of now, I think I would want to say that both are true
01:02:13 instead of just that I want to say that, no, there really is an observational factor of creation
01:02:20 outside of man really is speaking something true about God that can be observed. And also,
01:02:28 there really is something in man, in that image, you know, the image of God has been tarnished,
01:02:36 but a vestige still remains. And in the remaining image of God that all people have,
01:02:41 there's something in man that testifies to the reality of God, the truth of God, the glory of
01:02:46 God, holiness of God, and the law of God and man's moral obligation to submit to that law,
01:02:53 that it's both outside of man and inside of man, I guess is where currently, I think that's where
01:03:00 I would hang my coat. Is that different than what you're saying? Am I saying the same thing?
01:03:05 Because it sounds like you're really going to give the full emphasis or at least the lion's
01:03:10 share to what is in man, the Imago Dei, whereas I'm kind of, I don't know, maybe I'm splitting it
01:03:18 like a 50-50. Sure, I think, so what I would want to say is, you know, Augustine uses this analogy
01:03:25 that natural theology or natural law is sort of like invisible ink written on a page,
01:03:34 and experience is like the heat of a flame that causes the invisible ink to become visible.
01:03:43 And so it's like the other thing.
01:03:46 So this idea that you have these categories, you have these attributes that are in the mind
01:03:57 that are unavoidable to human thought and you're structuring them
01:04:00 And you start to, as you engage with experience, you're starting to think about things.
01:04:05 You go, well, is this like this?
01:04:06 And how is that?
01:04:07 And is man this?
01:04:09 And so you start to posit stuff about the things you're experiencing.
01:04:14 It's sort of the process.
01:04:17 And so the experience is a kind of opportunity to think and to analyze and to start imposing the thought categories on.
01:04:26 The other thing that Augustine talks about,
01:04:28 there's this book called De Magistra, or Of the Teacher.
01:04:31 And it's this fantastic little, it's almost like a platonic dialogue.
01:04:35 It's like 30 pages.
01:04:37 And it's this little conversation between Augustine and his son,
01:04:40 who tragically died.
01:04:43 But the dialogue is about, does any man really teach any other man?
01:04:49 And he uses this discussion of language and how language is signs.
01:04:55 and you can't really understand symbols or signs without already knowing the language.
01:05:00 If I'm talking to you in Russian, you wouldn't understand it unless you happen to know Russian.
01:05:03 Do you know Russian?
01:05:04 No.
01:05:05 Okay, all right.
01:05:05 So if I spoke to you in Russian, then the result would be that you'd be like,
01:05:09 I don't know what you're saying, right?
01:05:10 But if you know Russian, then you can.
01:05:12 So as I talk to you in English, I'm using words that are symbols for thoughts,
01:05:17 and you interpret those symbols, and you understand what those symbols mean.
01:05:22 and so if you know the language then you can interpret what's being said if you don't know
01:05:28 the language then the signs are just meaningless gobbledygook that makes sense except i don't even
01:05:33 think russians understand the symbols of russians because i every time i try to read like a great
01:05:40 novel and i've done it you know i've done a couple of them but do that do that do that you know or
01:05:46 you know, whatever. I feel like the names of characters, especially in, you know, in fiction
01:05:53 novels is like, it's like Ivan, Ivan Esky, Ivan, and it's like 27 different names that you have
01:06:03 to keep in the back of your mind. And 26 of them are just variations of the same name. And you're
01:06:08 like, this can't, you can't be serious. Like what, like, why, why can't it just be, even,
01:06:14 even if it's russian why can't we have just very different distinct names you know and and where
01:06:19 they don't all sound the same so it's like is it is it this character and you read like four
01:06:23 paragraphs to realize oh this is a whole other guy who's talking right now so russians i feel
01:06:30 like they gotta do that many names russians have i mean that's absolutely maybe that's the problem
01:06:33 maybe there's only like two names you know maybe like like uh like like when you think of uh
01:06:39 everybody being named muhammad it's like there's got to be another name so the russians have solved
01:06:45 that problem they have they have plenty of names they do not run out of names this is absolutely
01:06:50 true and and so yeah the other problem with dostoevsky novels is like every time like every
01:06:54 five minutes somebody is like passing out or going into hysterical crying fit you're like
01:06:57 is this what life is like in russia it's like it's like a russian anime all right go ahead
01:07:04 So that thing right there, this idea that you have to use the symbols,
01:07:09 you interpret symbols, you have to know the meaning of the symbols
01:07:12 to interpret it rightly.
01:07:14 So the world, we only end up interpreting the world rightly 0.92
01:07:18 with a Christian worldview. 0.90
01:07:20 And so we can grab hold of things to point to people,
01:07:24 to use to argue, who can go, well, is the sun?
01:07:26 Is the sun changing?
01:07:27 Like, okay, so it's not eternal, right? 0.99
01:07:29 And then the Egyptians that are worshiping it might go, oh, you're like, wow. 0.97
01:07:32 You know, but we're going backward in. 0.99
01:07:35 We're going in.
01:07:36 We have the Christian worldview.
01:07:37 It's been given to us. 0.99
01:07:38 And as a result, we can go back and we can deconstruct.
01:07:40 Right.
01:07:41 And so we can use their experience to engage with them to deconstruct. 0.70
01:07:45 And then we can posit a coherent worldview, the Christian worldview.
01:07:49 And we can argue for reasons why the denial of it's absurd.
01:07:52 But it is not – our experience of the natural world is not sufficient to get knowledge, to have certainty about things apart from the revelation of God's spoken word, the propositional revelation that comes to us.
01:08:15 And until we understand and believe what he has said, we don't have knowledge.
01:08:19 The fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge.
01:08:22 but we i think we have to so getting into epistemology here but i think there are
01:08:28 degrees of knowledge because we have to say that um because i'm with you in terms of eternal
01:08:33 knowledge true the truest truths uh the deep magic you know as aslan would say um that only
01:08:41 comes by regeneration you have to you have to become a new creature in christ jesus and and
01:08:46 actually have spiritual eyes and spiritual ears in order to discern these things um but we can't
01:08:51 say, on the flip side, we can say less knowledge or a different kind of knowledge, but we can't
01:08:56 say no knowledge. Because the whole argument of Romans chapter 1 is that man is condemned on the
01:09:02 basis of him having knowledge. And so that's why he's guilty, because he can't stand before God
01:09:10 and claim not to know. He does know. And then that's why he has to constantly lie and suppress
01:09:16 the truth. So it's not just he hasn't received the truth. It's not, number one, that the truth
01:09:21 isn't out there. The truth has been clearly displayed. Also, the truth has been perceived
01:09:27 at some level. The message has been clearly sent out. The message has been received all at a
01:09:32 natural level, natural man, apart from regeneration. And on that basis enough, that truth that has gone
01:09:38 out and that truth that has been, the partial truth of natural revelation, apart from special
01:09:43 revelation, and the partial perception, reception of that truth by natural man is, that equals
01:09:52 partial truth, partial truth reception is enough, it's sufficient for the kind of knowledge,
01:10:00 whatever label we want to give it, the kind of knowledge that's sufficient for what?
01:10:04 Sufficient to condemn.
01:10:06 Sufficient for damnation.
01:10:08 Yeah.
01:10:08 Yeah. So we can talk about knowledge and the definition of the term and all that kind of stuff in our time when we talk about epistemology.
01:10:17 But I think that I get what you're saying.
01:10:20 I agree with you that there's a sufficient thought process that's occurring that a person is condemned.
01:10:25 And so I think that your inexcusability is based upon your thoughts.
01:10:31 And every man is inexcusable, has had thoughts that make them inexcusable, except for the God man.
01:10:38 Jesus Christ. And so, yeah, absolutely. Okay, cool. All right, go on.
01:10:43 So when we think about this, we've got this idea of natural law and the moral element of it.
01:10:49 We just spent a bunch of time on the idea of the moral culpability of man based upon natural law.
01:10:54 And if natural law is something that's written on the heart, if it is the stuff that we're
01:11:02 inexcusable because of, then what we're going to have is we go, okay, natural law, what
01:11:08 does it align with?
01:11:09 And the historic reform view has been that the natural law is the moral law, and that
01:11:13 moral law is the Ten Commandments.
01:11:15 And so what you end up with is you basically say, okay, the Ten Commandments are written
01:11:18 on the heart, and they're going to be in a corrupted form.
01:11:21 And so we have the material out of which the Ten Commandments are made, the categories,
01:11:25 the attributes, the definitions that it's made out of, and then we're going to misconstruct.
01:11:30 And so we have the human laws that are sort of like House of Mirrors version of the Ten Commandments.
01:11:36 And that's what humans come up with because of the corruption.
01:11:40 Now, that idea that the moral law is what the natural law is,
01:11:46 if you come from the reformed conception of what natural law is,
01:11:50 you have to end up saying, if you want to take natural law and apply it to the state,
01:11:54 You have to end up saying that the state and its authority and what crimes are versus sins, that those things are a part of the moral law.
01:12:06 And the distinction of the civil law and the idea that civil authority was given at a particular time, you have to abandon.
01:12:17 So what you end up doing when you try to say that what the state ought to do
01:12:21 is a part of the moral law in terms of the natural law
01:12:25 is you have to say that the state is inherent in man.
01:12:31 And so now the state becomes a creation ordinance.
01:12:34 And so that's why you hear all these guys that love to talk about natural law
01:12:39 in terms of a Christian state.
01:12:41 They'll go back to the idea of Adam a lot because it's essential.
01:12:46 to their doctrine that the state be inherent in man.
01:12:52 So do you not think, real quick,
01:12:54 do you not think that in a prelapsarian world,
01:12:57 if there had been no fall, that there would be no state?
01:13:01 There would be no state.
01:13:02 The state is the minister of wrath.
01:13:04 Where there is no sin, there's no need for wrath.
01:13:07 Oh, really?
01:13:07 Okay.
01:13:09 Okay, so that would be another place where we differ.
01:13:13 like i you know even uh you know doug wilson who's you know for the most part he's far more
01:13:18 van tillion than he is um than he is you know um uh to mystic but uh you know even even wilson has
01:13:27 argued you know that there would still be a necessity for determining um which side of the
01:13:32 road are we going to drive on who makes that decision you know those kinds of um regulations
01:13:39 So there wouldn't be sins to punish with a sword, but that there would still be certain judgments that would need to be rendered for civilization.
01:13:52 And I found that compelling.
01:13:54 That's kind of where I'm at.
01:13:55 But go ahead.
01:13:56 I want to hear you out.
01:13:57 I'm curious.
01:13:59 Sure.
01:13:59 I mean, so we can liken that to also, like, what gauge of rail should we build railroads with, right?
01:14:03 Or how should plugs work for electrical power?
01:14:07 like should we use the european standard or should we use the american standard i think that those
01:14:10 are the those are those are entirely uh easily dealt with in terms of a a free exchange through
01:14:17 voluntary contracts and and how trade works um and and so so i think that the the pre-fall
01:14:26 institutions are the individual in the household um and so what we find is the church as distinct
01:14:33 from the world established in Genesis 3 and the first excommunications of Genesis 4.
01:14:38 And then you have the state being established with this power of the sword
01:14:42 for vengeance-taking and just warfare in Genesis 9.
01:14:47 And so if the state exists before Genesis 9, then what, you know,
01:14:54 so God was just reaffirming that we have the power of the sword to avenge
01:14:59 and institute capital punishment there, but it's already actually existed prior to that.
01:15:03 And with Cain, when he put the curse on, don't punish Cain,
01:15:08 and if you do punish Cain, you'll get a worse curse,
01:15:11 that was just a special exception as opposed to highlighting the problem
01:15:15 of not having the state.
01:15:17 So you end up with a pretty dramatically different framework.
01:15:21 And so when you have natural law and you say the state comes from nature
01:15:27 or for man's nature, then you end up saying that what are crimes
01:15:33 and what are sins is also a part of the things that can be determined
01:15:37 through this sort of understanding of human nature
01:15:41 or of the category of natural law, the moral law.
01:15:45 And so if you think about instead, if you say that divine law
01:15:53 that's given in terms of special revelation
01:15:55 is what establishes the state.
01:15:58 And in fact, if the Noahic Covenant is an administration of the Covenant of Grace,
01:16:04 wherein the state is established,
01:16:06 then you have this time of special institutionalization of the state,
01:16:13 and we have a dependency on special revelation for what the state ought to do.
01:16:18 Now, we do have a sense of justice that's a part of the natural law,
01:16:23 And so we're going to have responses, but humans are going to mess that up.
01:16:27 So you're going to have our sense of justice is going to be more or less accurate
01:16:34 based upon the culture and based upon the presuppositions we're operating on.
01:16:38 But the problem, the reality is we have no idea what the state should do
01:16:42 and what things we should coercively use the state to make people do
01:16:46 without God's word telling us the limits and features of the state.
01:16:53 I think we have some idea, but I'm 100% with you in terms of all those ideas will be corrupted.
01:17:02 All those ideas will, I do think that there would be a natural bent because nature is under a curse
01:17:08 and man's flesh, you know, image of God has been tarnished and the sin nature and all these kinds
01:17:16 of things that the bent will be towards tyranny or anarchy, no state at all, or a wicked, overly
01:17:25 domineering state. Like we need special revelation to clearly define moral law and also to help us
01:17:37 discern between sins and crimes. And that is like those categories commonly are, that's one of the
01:17:44 big mistakes that I continually run into. I find that people are like, well, you're saying that
01:17:50 there need to be forced conversions. And I'm saying, no, I'm saying there needs to be forced
01:17:54 morality. Forced morality. That's what the state does, is it legislates morality, not conversion.
01:18:01 Only the gospel can change people's heart. But the law of God, when legislated and enforced by
01:18:06 the civil magistrate, absolutely can curb sin at the outward behavioral level. And that's precisely
01:18:13 what the state is meant to do. It's going to curb outward behaviors of sin, particularly though when
01:18:19 it falls into the category of crimes. Nobody in the Christian nationalist or theonomic
01:18:25 camps are arguing for the thought police to enforce coveting. The state cracks down on
01:18:34 coveting when coveting crosses the line and moves to the expression of theft or murder or bearing
01:18:41 false witness or one or the other, you know, commandments. And then I would say the same for
01:18:45 the first table of the law. It's not the first commandment. It's actually kind of funny. Have
01:18:51 you thought about this, David, that the 10th, it's like bookends, like the first and the 10th
01:18:57 of the 10 commandments. Because I don't think that the state should crack down on the first either.
01:19:02 The first is a matter of the heart, having other gods before God, idolatry at the level of the
01:19:07 heart. But the first will become a crime when it moves from the private realm to the public realm
01:19:13 in terms of images, especially public images. Like you can't build a 90-foot tall golden statue
01:19:22 of Nebuchadnezzar and command veneration. That's not just a sin, that's a crime.
01:19:29 And a righteous Christian state would tear down that statue or do what Moses did, grind it into 0.99
01:19:34 dust, put it in the water, and make everybody drink it, something like that. But the first 1.00
01:19:39 commandment, you could have idols of the heart, as even Christians often do. But then when it 0.95
01:19:45 becomes an image, a public image, where you're in an obligatory fashion, you're even requiring
01:19:53 others or even tempting others, drawing others towards idolatry in the public square. And then
01:20:00 third one, blasphemy, especially when it's very blatant and brash and public, mocking Jesus,
01:20:08 you know, publicly, like the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence did a few years back, where they had
01:20:13 to mock Jesus on the cross, and nuns that were, you know, gyrating in front of it, like, yep,
01:20:20 straight to jail, you know, like, yep, that's a crime, and then the fourth, with blue laws and
01:20:26 Sabbath breaking. And all those things would have to be fleshed out in godly ways. But I just,
01:20:32 my point is, I find it interesting that the 10th commandment, two tables of the law, how it pertains
01:20:37 our obligation to God or obligation to neighbor. The last commandment, the 10th, is a sin, not a
01:20:42 crime, but it's a sin that if we don't fight it at the level of the heart by grace, well, then the
01:20:49 10th commandment then expresses itself in commandments five through nine, which are crimes.
01:20:54 And then on the first table of the law over here,
01:20:56 the first commandment, sin of the heart, private,
01:20:59 it's not a crime,
01:21:00 but if we don't find it by grace at the level of the heart,
01:21:02 it will express itself outwardly
01:21:04 in commandments two, three, and four,
01:21:06 which would enter, you know,
01:21:08 cross those categorical lines from sin,
01:21:12 not only being a sin, but now being a sin and a crime.
01:21:16 And I think, I think we, you're not going,
01:21:19 I'm saying all that, I find it interesting,
01:21:21 but also I'm agreeing with you in the sense that
01:21:23 you're not going to derive those conceptions by mere reason. You're going to have to
01:21:30 look at Scripture, particularly all the case laws and civil codes that we have given to Israel.
01:21:39 Otherwise, you just look at the Ten Commandments and say, well, I guess the civil magistrate
01:21:43 punishes none of it or all of it. But the only way that you can look at the summary law of moral
01:21:49 law, in the Decalogue, and then begin to categorize what belongs to the state and what's punishable
01:21:56 by the state and what's not, what belongs to the church and these kinds of things is by looking at
01:22:02 all, you can't just look at Exodus 20. You have to then look at all the case laws and all the civil
01:22:07 codes and see what was actually punished. And then that brings up the next question is, you know,
01:22:12 sins versus crimes. And then if it is a crime, what's the punishment? Because otherwise that too
01:22:18 falls to the reason of man. And it's just like, well, we think that murder gets a slap on the
01:22:22 wrist, you know, or we think that if you murder someone, then we murder your whole family. You 0.99
01:22:27 know, like, how do you know to not go too little, not go too far? Like, you need special revelation
01:22:34 for those things. I think what we just communicated about the first and tenth
01:22:38 commandments, I think it's really neat. I had historically kind of thought about blasphemy
01:22:43 as fitting under the first commandment. But I think as you've described it, I actually think 0.93
01:22:46 you're right. It fits into the second commandment in terms of the criminal codes that would fit
01:22:50 into. And so I actually think, I think that conception that you've got is neat there. And
01:22:53 I think it is a neat mirroring structure in the law. So thank you for pointing that out.
01:22:58 The other thing is you and I did a show a while back where we talked about the law,
01:23:04 I think it was kind of like primer and theonomy or something like that. And we talked about the
01:23:08 structure of the law and how you have like the big principial laws, the apodictic law,
01:23:12 You know, the two great commandments, the Ten Commandments, and you've got below that, you've got case laws, the if-then statements, and they fit inside of those.
01:23:20 And then below that, you've got the approved and disapproved examples.
01:23:22 And so you've kind of got this structure for categorizing and organizing the law.
01:23:27 And so I think without that structure, without that glorious revelation from God of aughts, you know, we're going to come up with some messed up conceptions.
01:23:42 of what we ought to do, and when you get it to the state and you go into the sin-crime
01:23:46 distinction and just penalties and where to use coercive power, it becomes a huge tyrannical
01:23:51 mess, and like you mentioned, anarchy or tyranny is the big thing.
01:23:54 I think tyranny is a general tendency, and one of the big problems with tyranny, when
01:23:59 you don't understand the institutions, there's the individual, the household, the church,
01:24:03 and the state, when you blend those institutions, the tendency is for the city of man to have
01:24:12 the state be the god and to usurp the church and to usurp the household and to usurp the individual
01:24:20 and so you've got like the example like nimrod who was a mighty hunter before the lord what was he 0.88
01:24:24 hunting he was hunting men and he was enslaving them to go build his cities and and so and to
01:24:30 build you know ultimately there's you know the tower of babel and all that so you have this idea 0.81
01:24:34 of tyranny and despotism, in particular.
01:24:39 And despotism, despotis in Greek is a manager, right? 0.91
01:24:43 And the woman is supposed to be the despotis of the oikos. 0.93
01:24:47 She's a manager of the household. 1.00
01:24:49 It's one of the things that she's called to do.
01:24:51 And this managing of the home is, when you're the patriarch 0.93
01:24:57 or matriarch of a home, all the children and all the servants,
01:24:59 you can manage in extraordinary detail. 0.68
01:25:01 You have the right to do that.
01:25:02 You know, and that's the prerogative in power there.
01:25:05 If the state, if you have a despotism and the despot thinks of himself like, you know, like Kim Jong-il or Un or whichever one is running around these days, you know, and you start to think, I can just make everybody do whatever I want in extraordinary detail.
01:25:21 You've made the whole state into sort of the property, the personal property of that dictator or that despot.
01:25:31 And so he thinks of the state like his house.
01:25:35 And I think that the word of God gives us the institutions, and the word of God tells us the authority and power of the institutions.
01:25:44 And the state is super complex.
01:25:47 And you have to exercise this power where you are exercising dominating power and force on other people to demand obedience with the thread of the sword.
01:25:58 And so that's the most ham-handed, big-thumbed power of all of the powers that God has given to man.
01:26:06 And so if we don't have the proper limits and we try to go in and go, we're going to manage sin.
01:26:10 And so we're going to be like, you didn't speak with a good enough tone, off with his head.
01:26:14 That obedience was not prompt enough, off with his head.
01:26:18 So the kind of stuff you'd want to discipline children for, you start using the sword to manage that thing,
01:26:25 and you have this horrific tyranny.
01:26:28 yes yep so so this this this thing so if we say natural real quick that's part of the problem that
01:26:38 we have right now and i know you agree is our entire society our entire culture is managerial
01:26:44 so like what you're it's such an irony and it's a tragic irony but uh what people see today what
01:26:51 they would call authoritarian or tyrannical or domineering um categorically is is not and that
01:27:00 what actually is tyrannical and domineering um is what we actually have so like people think like
01:27:06 well if the state if the state said um that you can't um you can't have uh you know calls to
01:27:16 prayer, sirens five times a day, calls to Muslim prayer. Well, that's tyrannical. That's
01:27:24 authoritarian. That's a breach of the First Amendment. You always have to tell, what's the
01:27:30 first word of the First Amendment? People don't understand, not even close to understanding the
01:27:35 First Amendment, but that's tyrannical. When it's like, no, telling people to the centimeter,
01:27:44 what size screw they have to use to construct a porch in their backyard is tyrannical that's
01:27:52 that like that's actual tyranny that that's the tyranny that we're under is this um the fact that
01:27:58 nobody the fact that um the government knows exactly how much i owe them in taxes
01:28:04 but somehow i still have to figure it out every year and nobody can ever uh uh nobody can ever
01:28:11 contested because it's like 9,000 pages of tax law, you know, that nobody could ever figure out.
01:28:19 And then IRS agents, they're like, you know what, we should spend, you know,
01:28:23 $80 million on giving them guns. And it's like, what? What in the world? And, you know, so you
01:28:31 got to figure out how much you owe. And then you go to them and say, okay, I'm going to pay you
01:28:34 this much. And they say, no, that's wrong. It's more than why don't you just give me a bill?
01:28:38 you know and and and so anyways but that's what it and and the sad thing is it's also i think in
01:28:44 the ecclesiastical realm it's the same theme i don't know what it is and how we got here exactly
01:28:49 i have ideas but um that seems to be the overarching theme not just with the state
01:28:54 but all across the board is the managerial class the managerial culture um and the church is the
01:29:00 same way so so it's like we'll say um the state is tyrannical if they ever thought about um if
01:29:06 they ever thought about saying we're distinctly Christian nation or adopting, you know, the
01:29:12 Apostles' Creed as a preamble to the Constitution, that's tyranny. But they can have a million 0.97
01:29:20 different laws and regulations across the board, you know, with everything else. And that's fine.
01:29:26 So they can be managerial. And then the same thing in the church. You preach something that's
01:29:32 clearly God's word. Like women should be beautiful and beauty for a woman is defined not by perishable
01:29:41 beauty outwardly, but the beauty, imperishable beauty of the heart, which is defined chiefly
01:29:46 by a quiet and gentle spirit. And that will be viewed as authoritarian, tyrannical. But on the
01:29:55 flip side, being a pastor and having 47 different midweek programs, you know, on Wednesday nights
01:30:04 and Tuesday nights and this and that and the other, and like, you got to be in a life group.
01:30:07 And if you're not, you know, then you're failing and we're going to give you a guilt trip and
01:30:12 all these different things. We're like, well, that's fine. That's just trying to foster community.
01:30:18 And that's like, well, no, but he actually doesn't have any jurisdiction to do that.
01:30:22 he can he can ask people to show up on the lord's day um and worship in spirit and in truth with
01:30:30 the ordinary means of grace that he can ask that um but there's actually he actually has no
01:30:36 authority for wednesday night he could suggest it maybe as a good thing but like but no there
01:30:42 there is no um mom's prayer meeting that is morally obligatory uh that a pastor like just
01:30:49 like um you know so it's i i just i don't know as you were talking it just got me thinking i find
01:30:53 that interesting that like right now we're suffering under um the tyranny of a thousand
01:30:59 little laws that come from a managerial class and and it's funny that you used the wife in the home
01:31:05 as example because i think there's a connection there too that the managerial role and correct
01:31:11 me if you disagree with me but i think it's a uniquely in god's design it is predominantly
01:31:16 maybe not exclusively, but predominantly a feminine role. Whereas I feel like the going out
01:31:22 and taking, you know, conquering new hills, you know, and expansion, and that's a uniquely
01:31:30 masculine role. But then giving to, you know, once the next hill has been conquered and once
01:31:37 the next town has been built and handing that over, you know, to the shield maiden in the home
01:31:43 to manage those things as you go back out to fight and to expand, you know, to work and to 0.95
01:31:47 keep. Like Adam, you know, has given this twofold role, working and keeping, providing, but also
01:31:51 protecting. So it's like conquering more and then defending that which has been conquered. It's this
01:31:57 fighting and building, fighting and building, sword and trowel, like Nehemiah, you know, and
01:32:02 Ezra, you know, and that seems uniquely, you know, inherently masculine. But managing
01:32:08 seems inherently feminine. And right now, you look at the church, and it's really feminine,
01:32:17 and you have very managerial church leadership. And then you look at the state, and by golly, 0.82
01:32:24 wouldn't you know it, it's a gynocracy. It's very feminine. We have a woman currently running 1.00
01:32:30 for president, and wouldn't you know it, 10,000 little managerial laws, but no actual, 1.00
01:32:36 you know um but but but on the world stage we're laughing stock where uh iq has gone down for
01:32:42 america um wealth has gone down for america um life expectancy has gone down for america um
01:32:48 on all the metrics education we're dumber than than ever before um the only thing that keeps
01:32:54 going up for america is uh imprisonment you know like uh that's it and so it it's it's funny that
01:33:01 just this transfer from 10 commandments to 10,000. I think GK Chesterton said that, like,
01:33:06 you can have 10 commandments. If you will not, you'll have 10,000. And it's all the meticulous,
01:33:12 incessant, managerial, and all of this has also come at the same time, and I don't think it's
01:33:18 a coincidence, as our embrace of feminism. But it's not just the state. I see it in the church
01:33:24 also, is my point. Right. No, I think the idea that men are supposed to take risks and have
01:33:31 a little bit more of the pioneer type of work and that women doing some of the,
01:33:35 dealing with the administration, the managing of it, the farming, right? 1.00
01:33:40 You pioneer the land and kind of prepare it and you have refume, whatever,
01:33:43 and there's sort of detail.
01:33:44 I think it's not managing of the detail, managing, I don't think by itself is inherently feminine,
01:33:51 but I do think women are designed to tend to be focused in, have strong relational things
01:33:58 and have a really strong focus on that detail there.
01:34:03 And men are designed to generally be more okay with letting more stuff go.
01:34:10 And that makes it so that we can be more effective
01:34:14 at interacting with other powers that are outside of our jurisdiction.
01:34:19 I think that's a part of the way the Fifth Commandment is written on our heart.
01:34:22 And so we do want to be good managers of the stuff that's in our jurisdiction.
01:34:26 but i do think that there is a special gifting generally speaking to women that uh that they
01:34:33 are better at managing those details and the maintenance right so and generally men are better
01:34:37 at the getting the new stuff and and so i agree with that i agree with the general you know point
01:34:44 that you're making there and all that kind of stuff and just i want to i don't want some man
01:34:47 to hear what you just said and use that as an excuse to not be a hard worker managing the stuff
01:34:52 that he's got jurisdiction over that's true and a lot of guys are apathetic when it comes to
01:34:56 organization um and and absolutely would be tempted to take my argument and say hey the reason why my
01:35:03 life is falling apart is because i'm just so masculine right i'm i'm being a lion i'm just
01:35:08 i'm just sleeping in the day you know waiting to fight off another lion right he comes you know
01:35:14 right so so that's all that's all that's my only good that's my only my only concern about that
01:35:19 good point okay so so we when we have this you know natural law theonomy thing coming on you
01:35:27 know one of the big critiques of theonomy is you go well theonomy doesn't allow the government to
01:35:31 do all this stuff i want it to do because there are limits on its power and i want the trains to
01:35:38 run on time so you know and and you know there's other things that i'd like to have fixed and so
01:35:45 i think that the messianic view of the state the managerial view of the state the desire for a
01:35:52 strong man to come along and fix our problems the worship of princes and the putting of trust in
01:35:57 them the state olatry and the fact that we think the state is the solver of all the problems and
01:36:03 our like pretense like like conservatives think that the military is full of hyper-competent
01:36:07 people and liberals think that like the state department is full of like hyper-competent people
01:36:11 and it's like in reality they're both just the post office yeah you know and it's like there
01:36:17 are some magnificent soldiers and marines and airmen and sailors and those magnificent soldiers
01:36:24 sailors airmen and marines and i don't know what do we call space force people now space forcees
01:36:28 uh spacers i don't know starship commanders okay and the stars guys who work for elon
01:36:33 Right? So when we think about all of those, the magnificent ones all hate the bureaucratic managerial nonsense awful that is the system, right?
01:36:49 And so I think of all of the warfighters that I have talked to that deal with stuff, they hate the system and the bureaucracy and the institution.
01:37:01 and they have some of the people that they worked with that they love
01:37:07 because of the fact that they had virtues and desire to do right things
01:37:11 and all that kind of stuff.
01:37:12 So I think liberals look at the peacetime bureaucracy as full of intelligent
01:37:20 and whatever people, and then conservatives tend to look at the wartime system
01:37:23 and view it that way.
01:37:24 And so what we need to realize is that it's all this horrific nightmare
01:37:28 and Elon should fire 95% of the people
01:37:32 in every institution that we currently have
01:37:35 that's a federal one.
01:37:37 I think he will.
01:37:38 I really do.
01:37:40 What? Say it again?
01:37:42 So that's great. 0.99
01:37:45 The government's ridiculous. 0.97
01:37:46 The federal government's absurd. 0.87
01:37:47 All levels of government are bloated.
01:37:50 And so we have an absurd level of government everywhere.
01:37:54 And what we do is we just forcibly extract money
01:37:57 through tyrannically high taxation of confiscatory levels.
01:38:01 And then we also cheat everybody out of stuff by debasing the currency constantly.
01:38:06 And we can talk about wanting to lower taxes,
01:38:10 but when we spend the money, we're really printing the money.
01:38:13 And so the taxes come from the spending.
01:38:16 The spending is the problem.
01:38:18 And so you go, what should the government do?
01:38:21 right what what is the what is the what is the mission of the civil government what has god
01:38:30 commanded to do and it's supposed to be an avenger of of god right it it is is a minister of wrath
01:38:37 and so its purpose is to punish criminals and its purpose is to wage just wars right and if we're
01:38:49 doing other stuff besides that, then it's not serving its purpose. And so what we find is that
01:38:59 governments don't deal with disputes of law efficiently. The court system's horrific.
01:39:08 And so it takes forever to deal with disputes about breaking contracts, and it takes forever
01:39:14 to deal with any sort of criminal process.
01:39:17 I mean, it costs like the equivalent of the wages
01:39:20 a person an average American is going to earn
01:39:22 in their entire life to deal with prosecuting one criminal.
01:39:25 The inefficiency of our system is absurd.
01:39:29 And so we're terrible at the actual purposes of government.
01:39:34 And in the waging of warfare,
01:39:36 as opposed to having a citizenry that is armed
01:39:40 with limited government that makes it
01:39:43 so that we're not an imperial power, right?
01:39:46 As opposed to having a republic of a citizen soldiery,
01:39:50 we have this huge standing army, and we put it all over the place,
01:39:57 and we spend enormous amounts on enormous numbers of things.
01:40:03 And so every element of what the government does in the United States now is bad.
01:40:10 There is this horrific managerial bloat, administrative bloat, bureaucratic bloat, regulatory bloat,
01:40:19 the bloat of laws, the bloat of rulings, the degree to which it's just this horrific thing.
01:40:27 And the law of God puts restraints on it.
01:40:30 And so what I want to say is people don't like it because the government doesn't do all the stuff they want it to do then.
01:40:36 and i want to suggest to anybody who's not satisfied with that the problem is them
01:40:41 and not god's definition of what the government's supposed to do
01:40:46 all right that's good
01:40:49 um okay well i feel like any final thoughts for this episode i feel like we're going to probably
01:40:58 continue the conversation we want to talk about i would like to you know like i said in the
01:41:02 beginning of the episode i kind of maybe over promise and gonna under deliver and you know
01:41:07 since we're talking about the state you know it's only fitting that i promise something and under
01:41:11 deliver but um but maybe um maybe we can make this i'm thinking we can make this you know a part two
01:41:18 if that's something that you're comfortable with where we talk about okay so now let's take this
01:41:22 concept and um let's talk about immigration because that's outside of you know you know
01:41:29 punishing enemies, both domestic and foreign, you know, waging just wars and, you know, agents of
01:41:37 wrath for those who are criminals. Like you said, what about, you know, immigration? Like I say it's
01:41:42 outside, but I mean, you know, if somebody's coming illegally, then they are a criminal. And
01:41:47 you would, you would argue, right, that the state, that it does fall to the state
01:41:51 to be a protector of borders? Yes, absolutely. That's the extent of the jurisdiction. And so
01:41:58 you've got to and so you know somebody crosses the border um and they're they're not authorized
01:42:03 to do so um you know you've got an invasion yep great you've got you've got trespassing there so
01:42:09 so now the question is you know what do you what do you do about that and who's allowed to come
01:42:12 across and the whole legal immigration versus illegal immigration thing and you know obviously
01:42:17 if you let somebody on your land they're not trespassing right okay uh yeah well then let's
01:42:23 if you're okay with it let's go ahead and make that an episode two and talk about um how this
01:42:28 applies to immigration if there's any room for prudence or if it's simply no it's it's this is
01:42:38 what you're allowed this is this is what's clear of how you can mitigate um immigration and there's
01:42:44 no mitigating factors beyond these um that is a conversation that i think would be really fruitful
01:42:50 to have. And I think that'll play into kind of demonstrating as a case study, natural law
01:42:57 versus theonomy. And then in that, maybe we can also have the conversation of how do we know
01:43:03 what we know in epistemology. Great. So it seems like I filibustered myself into getting another
01:43:09 show. Yeah, you did. But to be fair, not just you, I was over here talking about stars, you know,
01:43:14 and, you know, the stars speaking more loudly and then leading up to Bethlehem and the birth of
01:43:19 jesus and i worked in the nephilim somehow some way and did that and michael heiser you had
01:43:24 dragons yeah we had dragons in there so it's i don't i don't think it's it would not be fair
01:43:29 if i said that it was your fault um you should just tell people this is a show about dragons
01:43:33 the title should just be there you go we talked about dragons we'll get yeah we can get 50 000
01:43:37 views like that uh nephilim brings all the boys to the yard that's that's the strategy here it's
01:43:43 like, you know, you've got giants, maybe just a dash of mermaids, and then boom, Christian
01:43:51 nationalism, theonomy, you know, and like people like, I actually did have, you know, I've had a
01:43:56 few people email us, and it's been encouraging. Yeah. What'd you say? Theonomic mermaids. Theonomic
01:44:03 mermaids, yeah. Riding dragons. There you go. But I've had, it has been funny. I've had a number
01:44:07 of emails where people have reached out, and they said, they've said, I'll be honest, I came for
01:44:12 I came for Giants, and I stayed for the base theology. So, I mean, it works. It really does
01:44:20 work. So, all right, we'll land the plane here for today, and we will pick it up next time.
01:44:25 Thanks for coming on the show. Thanks a lot.