The NXR Podcast - September 30, 2024


THE INTERVIEW - No, Diversity Is Not Our Strength with Stephen Wolfe - ICYMI

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Steven Lawson and Why Men Fall THE LIVESTREAM - When A Member In Our Church Shared A Holocaust Meme

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 33 minutes

Words per minute

181.73

Word count

16,917

Sentence count

321

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

16

sentences flagged

Hate speech

42

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Dr. Stephen Wolfe is the author of The Case for Christian Nationalism, a book that argues that multiculturalism is not only bad, but actually detrimental to our society. In this episode, Pastor Joel Webbin and Dr. Wolfe discuss how we can be welcoming and hospitable to people of all backgrounds.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 All right, welcome to another episode of Theology Applied.
00:00:02 I am your host, Pastor Joel Webbin
00:00:03 with Right Response Ministries.
00:00:05 And in this episode, I was privileged to welcome
00:00:07 to the show's Dr. Stephen Wolfe.
00:00:09 He is the author of The Case for Christian Nationalism.
00:00:12 And we're talking about multiculturalism 1.00
00:00:15 and that it is bad. 1.00
00:00:18 Diversity in terms of culture is not our strength.
00:00:23 And so we're talking about multiculturalism, 0.61
00:00:25 particularly here in America, 1.00
00:00:27 the negative effects that we have suffered as a nation because of it, especially over the last
00:00:32 60 years, and what to do about it, and then answering some of the big questions of, okay,
00:00:38 well, if we're going to have a monoculture, then doesn't that mean that you are racist? And the
00:00:43 answer is no. And we'll flesh that out and show you how we can have unity. Diversity is not our
00:00:49 strength. Unity is our strength. And yet how we can be welcoming and hospitable to different
00:00:55 ethnicities and all these things that we find in scripture. That's the episode. And Dr. Stephen
00:01:00 Wolfe, you've probably heard all the scary, you know, he's the boogeyman hiding under your bed.
00:01:07 Try to lower your shields for a moment. Use discernment. You may disagree, but give him a
00:01:12 chance. He's got some really good things to say, and I'd like you to hear it for yourself. So tune
00:01:16 in now. Applying God's word to every aspect of life. This is Theology Applied.
00:01:25 All right, welcome back to another episode of Theology Applied. I am your host, Pastor Joel
00:01:31 Webin with Right Response Ministries, and in this episode, I'm privileged to welcome to the show
00:01:35 Stephen Wolfe, Dr. Stephen Wolfe. He's not a pastor. Praise God, we need pastors, but we don't
00:01:42 need everyone to be a pastor, so he's doing what God's called him to do. He is also the author,
00:01:47 you probably recognize his name, he's the author of The Case for Christian Nationalism, and Stephen
00:01:52 and I just recently were able to have the privilege of speaking at the new Christendom
00:01:57 conference with the Ogden boys. That's Brian Sauve and Eric Kahn, Dan Burkholder, and Ben Garrett.
00:02:03 That was a blessing. And one of the talks at the conference that Stephen presented for us was on
00:02:09 multiculturalism, arguing that, well, that diversity is not our strength, but the type of diversity in
00:02:16 view might surprise you. And I think it's worth fleshing out. So Stephen, can you give us maybe
00:02:20 you a recap of that talk that you presented. Yeah, yeah. So yeah, thanks for having me on.
00:02:29 Yeah, so what I was trying to address was several things. One was whether or not multiculturalism
00:02:35 is actually a good thing, not only theoretically, but actually in effect. So like in the world, 0.90
00:02:42 is there any indicator through social science and research that multiculturalism is actually good 0.73
00:02:47 for society um and in every society it's actually bad uh this it's one of the funny things that
00:02:54 actually liberals uh liberal and leftist researchers who have really tried to prove
00:02:59 that multiculturalism is good um have actually demonstrated and been honest about it that it's
00:03:05 actually bad there's been there's been actually researchers who've done research on social trust
00:03:09 around the country around the world and they sat on the on the research because they they got the
00:03:15 data they're expecting to show this great you know result of multiculturalism is great and
00:03:20 britches and it's it's magical and all that um but then in the end it actually shows that it's 0.85
00:03:25 not good and so they sit on it for like five six years until they just found well we got to get it
00:03:31 out there so they publish it and it shows that essentially um a diverse ethically and culturally
00:03:40 diverse countries actually have very low social trust, even down to the local level. And there's
00:03:47 all sorts of research on this. I mean, even in like businesses, it's basically people admit
00:03:52 deep down in the academic journals that diversity in the workplace actually doesn't add any benefit
00:03:58 despite the propaganda in that area from businesses to the military. It's just not
00:04:05 shown to actually increase effectiveness so i i wanted i talked about that i mentioned i i uh
00:04:12 discussed some of the research on that which is pretty conclusive um and then i also uh talk about
00:04:18 the united states so we tend to think that the united states from its very beginning was intended
00:04:23 to be a sort of multi-ethnic um state or multi-ethnic uh people meaning basically meaning
00:04:31 that there is no ethnicity or cultural group that is more american than anyone else that's the idea
00:04:39 that we've all been taught for our entire lives most people actually i'd say everyone's lives at
00:04:45 this point uh and um that that's that's kind of our ideology but one of the things i wanted to
00:04:51 show is that actually from the beginning that was not the case um and that uh the founders
00:04:56 were self-consciously they understood themselves to be british or at least stem from the british
00:05:04 and even this sort of american self-consciousness there was early on both in the founding i'd say
00:05:10 in the early american republic a sense of um a peoplehood that was around a ethnic core that
00:05:18 that you can call uniquely american some people have called it like a sort of britishness on
00:05:24 steroids or like a uh so there is something kind of distinct but also rooted ancestrally in a
00:05:29 british a british um uh ethnos and so that was the core and so they they considered that particularity
00:05:37 uh to be um necessary to uphold the universal so when we think of the american like political uh
00:05:47 political thought we think of these very universal ideas of all men are created equal
00:05:52 you know they have natural rights so these things are universal if natural rights are natural that
00:05:57 means that each human being has these rights and so we've taken that recently in the last i'd say
00:06:04 50 years to say essentially that's all it means to american is to affirm the propositions but the
00:06:09 founders and i would say well in the 19th century even in the early 20th century even past world
00:06:15 war too i'd say the predominant thinking was that the there's a cultural particularity a people
00:06:22 that undergird those the affirming those propositions so to believe in natural rights
00:06:28 to believe in sort of american liberty to believe in religious liberty as the uh kind of anglo
00:06:33 tradition affirms it um to believe in equality the those sorts of ideas uh stem and are supported by
00:06:43 a cultural uh particularity that people have identified as anglo-protestant so it's both
00:06:49 rooted in english and uh but also it's a it's the product of a protestant tradition
00:06:55 that i'm sure we can get to but that's what i was trying to get at is actually okay multiculturalism
00:07:00 is bad and oh by the way we as americans are not committed to multiculturalism in principle we are
00:07:07 actually committed to the idea that we have a people uh and we have a place and we have ideas
00:07:15 that are associated with those people and um we cannot expect everyone around the world who are
00:07:21 not part of that uh political um that that's that essentially western civilization but um but even
00:07:29 kind of people who are not western european to affirm those ideas at least not readily so they
00:07:36 they can't just show up to america and all of a sudden they affirm the propositions and then
00:07:41 they're they're exactly one of us as historically understood so we're not actually historically
00:07:46 committed to that as good americans um and i i mean yeah and so that that's kind of the over the
00:07:53 that's what i'm saying is that we actually should as americans say there is a core ethnicity or
00:07:58 there is a core culture that is an open culture meaning that people can assimilate into it so
00:08:05 it's not bound by perfect genetic markers as if you're the this sort of you know if you're too
00:08:10 if you're too german you're out that's not that's not the um the principle nevertheless it is uh
00:08:17 there is a core way of life um a core heritage to which newcomers should conform and that is
00:08:27 necessary to maintain our old american principles so all those principles that the old people the
00:08:33 elder folks love that they heard from reagan um and and uh all those core conservative principles
00:08:40 we talk about of liberty and freedom and justice for all and all that those are actually undergirded
00:08:45 by an old american conception of people um that is not as universal as we are taught and that it's
00:08:52 actually that teaching is very new right the the post-war sentiment is uh what you and others have
00:08:58 refer to it as um so basically your talk in a nutshell was uh multiculturalism is not our
00:09:05 strength uh that america from its founding uh that was not the intent um but it was meant to
00:09:12 be a monoculture and then you went on to say okay so which one is it which culture and you describe
00:09:18 that as anglo-protestant so could you take just a moment and maybe taking those two words and
00:09:24 breaking each of them down what do you mean by protestant and what do you mean by anglo do
00:09:29 catholics have a place and do people who aren't white have a place what does it mean anglo
00:09:34 protestant culture yeah so it has a it's it's rooted in a british uh intellectual uh political
00:09:43 tradition so uh this is explicitly affirmed by the founders so if you look at the continental
00:09:49 congress in 1774 uh 75 76 you'll you'll see them regularly appeal to their britishness and they are
00:09:57 actually asserting their rights as englishmen so they they're they're self-consciously knew they
00:10:03 were part of a tradition extending to the magna carta all the way back to the the saxon kings
00:10:08 of the ninth century and eighth century um so there was a self-conscious britishness to the
00:10:15 founders uh and it's from a legal tradition or not just well not just legal but also a political
00:10:21 tradition that you can see reflected uh everything from uh from from fortescue fortescue on law
00:10:29 getting back to the magna carta which is regular appeal regularly appealed to by people like samuel
00:10:33 adams um you can see this through uh some expressions through john locke and also religious
00:10:39 liberty as well so uh and this this ties to the protestantism uh the reason why we as protestants
00:10:47 can affirm religious liberty is not this sort of okay i guess we'll tolerate you guys you baptists
00:10:53 we're we're congregationalists and presbyterians i guess we can tolerate you guys even though we
00:10:58 think you're heathen um that was actually not the the protestant tradition but within the anglo world
00:11:04 there was a steady uh recognition that we as fellow protestants can get along without wanting
00:11:13 to uh suppress each other and this is even you can see this even in new england in the 17th century
00:11:19 where they did actually say baptists look you can be part of our churches you can be in our churches
00:11:24 um our congregationalist church you just can't have your own so you see this in 30 in the 1630s
00:11:29 40s 50s 60s uh but baptists of course one of their own churches uh but so eventually you see 0.94
00:11:35 this in the 17 teens that cotton mather is now ordaining a baptist uh in there in a baptist
00:11:42 church so there is a development where they see okay look we've always affirmed that that that
00:11:50 a baptist can have the same faith as us in themselves they can be true christians and
00:11:55 that's why we let him in our churches but now we've realized hey we can actually form a civil
00:12:01 polity a civil society where we tolerate one another and we affirm each other's mutual
00:12:06 protestantism and each other's mutual faith that we disagree on things and that's all again i mean
00:12:11 this is new england was a few decades later where england recognized this earlier in the 1600s
00:12:18 but this is all just like our angle protestant tradition and so when you get to the founding
00:12:23 and we talk about religious liberty that this is not like the enlightenment showing up that's not
00:12:28 like all of a sudden they read john locke and like oh my dogmatic slumber i finally woke out of that
00:12:34 no it was a progress into it and the first amendment actually is an expression of a long
00:12:40 anglo-protestant tradition of experience or it was the experience with each other that then developed
00:12:46 into the first amendment saying we can form a civil union despite theological differences and
00:12:52 that's what is expressed in the first amendment um and that so that's the angle protestant
00:12:56 tradition is rooted in protestantism which says so like roman catholicism you have a ecclesiastical
00:13:03 earthly head of the church namely the pope and to be in to be in you have to be aligned
00:13:08 institutionally right that's not true in protestantism this is this is why you could
00:13:14 you could have the calvinist at least appealing to the lutherans and saying lutherans we think
00:13:18 your brothers and lutherans just like scoff at us but but you know but the same thing with like
00:13:23 presbyterians and baptists and congregationalists and baptists and anglicans anglicans and
00:13:28 presbyterians we could all affirm each other's mutual faith because we do not believe that you
00:13:33 have to be aligned with an institution uh a a singular institution um to be in um and so for
00:13:42 that reason you can have principled religious liberty that as i said affirms each other's
00:13:47 mutual faith and that was developed within the anglo's the anglo world right which comes to
00:13:52 expression and comes to i think uh it's its ultimate expression is 19th century in america
00:13:59 where eventually you have disestablishment like i think the the last the last uh quasi
00:14:05 establishment is goes disestablished in the 1830s in one of the states but then you still have
00:14:10 flourishing and high religiosity um and this is what toqueville shows up the united states and
00:14:16 looks around and says wow you guys don't have establishment and you have all this high
00:14:19 religiosity everyone cares intensely about religion and people are attending church and
00:14:23 and uh anyone who's an atheist has to remain silent about it because it would have it would
00:14:29 there's a high social cost uh and they get and so it's it it so it came to this expression with
00:14:36 the 19th century that we've lost of course but uh anyway i mean there's a lot to say about
00:14:40 angled Protestantism with the work ethic and a sense of ordered liberty that comes without
00:14:47 a heavy-handed order. Again, that's one of the unique things about the American tradition is we
00:14:53 can have high liberty with also high order without a kind of magistrate constantly threatening to
00:15:03 put us into order. Are you a Christian struggling to find companies that align with your values and
00:15:08 beliefs? Well, then Squirrely Joe's has you covered for all your coffee needs. All of their
00:15:13 coffee is hand-selected and roasted fresh every day by a family of fellow believers. Try them out
00:15:20 and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your investment supports a company committed
00:15:25 to following God's teachings and upholding truth and righteousness, ensuring that your hard-earned
00:15:32 money contributes to the growth of God's kingdom. Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans
00:15:37 who support evil.
00:15:39 Right Response listeners have access
00:15:41 to an exclusive deal.
00:15:43 Your first bag of coffee is free.
00:15:45 All you have to do is cover the shipping.
00:15:47 So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com
00:15:50 forward slash right response.
00:15:53 Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com
00:15:55 forward slash right response 0.96
00:15:57 to claim your first free bag of coffee today.
00:16:01 Visit thewordsoap.com today.
00:16:04 Again, that's thewordsoap.com.
00:16:06 Everyone needs soap, so wash yourself in the Word.
00:16:36 our founding and you know the american project um but sadly our population has slipped i have
00:16:42 two questions so one well on that if i can comment on that yeah go ahead i think that's really
00:16:46 important to point out so again we have this it's overly universalistic conception of of our our way
00:16:53 of life uh and so whenever whenever when someone like mentions like protestant franco or they
00:16:59 mentioned right uh the old the old the old you know classical conception of a dictator all that
00:17:05 people freak out um but they don't realize that again our american principles were designed for
00:17:12 people who could self who could govern themselves um who could have ordered liberty without a heavy
00:17:19 handed with heavy-handed law we don't have those people and anymore and and we don't yeah and we
00:17:24 no longer have that uh and it's it is undergirded by an angle protestant culture and so a lot of
00:17:31 people on the right are saying well look you'll get our look at the the country now and it's it's
00:17:37 foolish to try to continue these like these this idea of ordered liberty with self-government if
00:17:43 you don't have the people for that right like we would all love to go back to times where we could 0.99
00:17:48 have ordered liberty but we can't we can't have that anymore because it's that was undergirded
00:17:53 by a particular core people right um and once those people are gone once that particularity
00:17:59 and that culture is gone then well guess what you now men must be governed meaning that like now you
00:18:05 need the heavy hand of law and this is like this like burke has a great line which i wish i could
00:18:09 quote right now but it's essentially that people people who can't self-govern are have to be
00:18:15 controlled by a heavy hand of government you talk about the french revolution which back then a lot
00:18:21 of people thought that the french could not actually govern that they didn't they uh a lot
00:18:26 even french themselves recognized that they didn't have a tradition of liberty like the anglos did
00:18:31 and so you get the french revolution people are predicting that it's just going to be a disaster
00:18:36 which is exactly what happened because they didn't have they had a tradition of of uh royal
00:18:41 absolutism right whereas the this is what monescue is praising in the mid 18 1700s he's saying look
00:18:48 i'm french but the model is england um and then you get to the late 1780s and you have the french
00:18:54 revolution and you have like i said my talk like gouverneur morris who was a founding father is
00:18:59 saying look like these people these frenchmen don't know liberty it's going to take time right
00:19:04 um so again the point is like you can have a you can list the universal abstract rights all day
00:19:09 long and people could say yay cheer on them on but if you don't have if you're not part of a
00:19:13 a people whose whose experience and tradition and culture can can govern themselves can actually
00:19:22 bring about order to liberty then it's not going to work and that's that's the state we're in now
00:19:26 right yeah systems i'm i'm with you systems of government i think have to fit the people
00:19:31 and so you know this we've talked a little bit like i i am happy and unashamed to wear the
00:19:37 moniker of a general equity theonomist uh meaning that i don't have you know i would remain
00:19:43 reserve some distinctions from um some of the og reconstructionist although i appreciate rush
00:19:49 Duny and a lot of what he said in Bonson, but I would be distinct from them and I would kind of
00:19:53 give that disclaimer of general equity, lowercase t, theonomist. But what I'm saying is that
00:19:59 sometimes the OG, you know, hardcore capital T, theonomist, reconstructionist, not only do they
00:20:05 say, well, you know, the general equity of the civil codes given to Israel, these things need to
00:20:10 be, you know, they need to be legislated in governments and in all places and all times,
00:20:16 but sometimes they'll go even further than that and say that the Bible actually prescribes
00:20:20 not just laws, but a particular form of government. And I would reserve that. I do think there are
00:20:27 some basic principles in terms of not just laws, but forms of government, representative government.
00:20:32 I think of Deuteronomy 18, you know, and there's, you know, guys over, you know, Jethro, the father
00:20:37 in law of Moses over tens and fifties and hundreds and thousands. One thing that I will point out
00:20:43 with that is a lot of guys will say, you know, we shouldn't vote for Trump because he doesn't,
00:20:48 you know, it's a low bar. We're not saying he has to be a perfect Christian or a Calvinist or this,
00:20:52 that, and the other, but he's got to meet at least this, you know, this gracious standard
00:20:55 that God put forth through Jethro, you know, to Moses and Deuteronomy 18. But I would, I would say,
00:21:00 which is you, you, you love justice. You don't take a bribe, those kinds of things. You could
00:21:04 not even be regenerate and still meet the standard. And so that should be the standard for our
00:21:08 elected, elected officials, you know, and the president would be one of those. And I would
00:21:12 push back on that and just say, number one, that's the standard given to Moses to appoint
00:21:17 these men. That's different than in our two-party system. Once we've gone through the primaries and
00:21:23 all these things, and we have two candidates before us, politics is the realm of the possible.
00:21:27 There's two candidates that can actually win, and neither of them meet this Deuteronomy 18 standard,
00:21:35 and it's not Moses. It's not a prophet, monarch-type figure from on high who gets to pick
00:21:42 down. It's all the people at the bottom picking up, choosing up, and one of them will be chosen.
00:21:50 It's not going to be, hey, well, I guess we just don't have a president this year because nobody
00:21:53 meets the standard. No, you're going to have one, and so that's why I think the lesser of two evils
00:21:58 comes into play in Deuteronomy 18, which I think is a great ideal standard. I think it's very
00:22:04 different in that being a standard for Moses as a monarch type figure to choose and select down
00:22:10 than for us, you know, in a representative democracy type thing, the people to choose
00:22:16 up. So all that being said, my point is, yes, there are some principles you can glean, I think,
00:22:21 from the scripture in the Old Testament, some major principles of, you know, forms, not just
00:22:26 laws, but forms of government like representative government. That said, I like republics. I think
00:22:33 republics are ideal. Um, but as Benjamin Franklin allegedly said, you know, what, you know, what
00:22:38 did you give us a republic? If there's a condition you can keep it. And I think the, you know, the
00:22:44 jury has come back in the verdict is here. Uh, we did not keep it. And, um, and I don't think that
00:22:49 we currently have, and this is unfortunate. I'm not happy about it, but I don't think we currently
00:22:53 have, uh, the quality of people required in order to sustain a republic. So, so this whole, you
00:23:01 Protestant Franco or monarchy or whatever. None of these things, I don't know anybody on the right
00:23:07 or dissident right or whatever you want to call it, New Christodom, whatever. I don't know anybody
00:23:12 who's giddy about it and saying, yes, this is what we've always wanted. We never wanted a republic.
00:23:17 We've always wanted a king. I don't hear that. I hear people saying, you know what, it's just time
00:23:23 not to make something happen. It's time to simply recognize what already has happened. We need to
00:23:29 know where we currently are and not just deal. We can't afford to have this, you know, five-year-old
00:23:36 idealism. We need to put our big boy pants on, grow up, be an adult, recognize the times,
00:23:41 where we currently are and what our people are currently suited for so that we can get back
00:23:48 to the ideal. So I think a representative constitutional republic is still the ideal.
00:23:53 I'd love to see us have it, but we don't have it now. We have it in pretense, but not in practice.
00:23:58 and i don't think that we're qualified for what do you think yeah i don't think that's a crazy
00:24:04 thing right wing watch will pick me up saying these kinds of things you know and like oh my
00:24:09 goodness this right wing extremist and i'm like what world do you live in like we don't have a
00:24:14 high trust society i can't put um uh fruit in in a cart on the on the street and a little sign that
00:24:21 says take one banana and leave 50 cents and like you you what america do people think we're living 1.00
00:24:27 it joel the hysterical women at right wing watch are losing their minds right now they need to pop
00:24:35 some more pills yeah um but yeah no i mean it's just a it's a it's a one of the most basic i mean
00:24:43 you pick up any pretty much any text in the western political canon going all the way back to
00:24:48 plato's republic and it's uh you'll see different regime types and uh and the regime some of the
00:24:57 the regime types take on their own character and they shape the way that people think but also
00:25:01 they just the reason why these regime types work so regime types usually like you know king or
00:25:07 aristocracy um or sort of democracy and there's others but that's a basic idea like why do you
00:25:14 have these different regime types and it's because well this one this particular type
00:25:19 is actually more suited to the people than another type and this is this is not just some pagan
00:25:25 saying this i even i found this once in uh pagans or pagan uh calvin's in uh calvin's commentaries
00:25:32 and of course it's among the founders and everyone affirmed this uh and it's it's the idea that you
00:25:39 the form that that uh that not every form fits with every sort of person or people and that some
00:25:47 people can be at one point uh a king would best suit them and then a few generations later an
00:25:54 aristocracy or democracy or whatever um would best suit them or you know a republic is probably
00:26:00 better to say than a democracy right and this is just basic stuff uh it's really just as as time
00:26:05 and kind would say it's just basic stuff um in the tradition uh and and we should recognize that
00:26:12 so if we move away if as a people we move away such that the form of government is not actually
00:26:18 producing good i mean that's the purpose right so this is when people think people have to realize
00:26:23 is that the form of government this also includes laws um customs everything if if if none of that
00:26:30 if that together is not actually producing good then something's wrong and and it needs to be
00:26:35 changed like it's it's it's a the form of government is good only in so far that actually
00:26:41 produces good if there's something unsuitable about it or ill-suited for the people and it
00:26:47 produces their bad well then something needs to change but the purpose of the system is what it
00:26:52 does not not what particular label is assigned to it well this is public education okay but what 0.98
00:26:57 does it actually accomplish oh well it trains kids and indoctrinates them to be gay and communist
00:27:02 the purpose of the system is what it actually does yeah and also it's not it's not just good
00:27:09 in itself absolutely so if you take like just take our constitution our constitution is is good
00:27:16 as a sort of wise document for the people that it governed initially but the question is is it
00:27:22 is it absolutely good such that um even if it ends up not working for people you have to retain it
00:27:29 same thing with republic or like just just saying everything has to be a republican form of government
00:27:34 or has to be a democracy um is really treating the form as the end in itself right but no one in no
00:27:41 one in history i mean this this is like again why we're weird no one in history has affirmed that
00:27:47 the form of government is an absolute absolute necessity even if it doesn't suit the people
00:27:53 right so again this is just that the founders thought that the our system of government
00:27:59 was well suited for a people of self-government and an order of liberty right they and if it was
00:28:08 a different group of people they would have produced a different document uh right so we
00:28:13 can't have this absolutist view of of the form of government now i'm not like saying right now
00:28:19 we have to change the form of government to be clear but but we just have to get away from that
00:28:23 thinking that there is a sort of perfect that there's a there's the perfect is the only thing
00:28:29 we can have right um whereas oftentimes as again the tradition and basic stuff the the perfect is
00:28:36 the enemy of the good in the sense that the perfect can actually produce bad because because
00:28:40 the people aren't perfect or it's not suited for them they're not ready for it it's just so much
00:28:45 of it reminds me of parenting it's like um the ideal the ideal as a father is that um that my
00:28:52 children would be self-governed and i would be able to have a high degree of trust with them
00:28:57 and be more lax in in regards to uh rules for the household and uh expectations and that they
00:29:04 would just get it done. The problem is that my children are currently six, four, three, and one
00:29:10 years old. So that's not, so the ideal, you know, I mean, that's what I'm working towards. We'll get
00:29:16 there by God's grace one day. That's what we're working towards. But here's the irony. Putting
00:29:24 the ideal into play today, ironically, often ensures that the ideal is never accomplished
00:29:33 tomorrow. If you put the ideal, the ideal is not always the means to the ideal. There's usually
00:29:41 another means that shapes and forms and prepares a people, whether it be children or whether it
00:29:49 be a populace, you know, of a nation. It's usually some other regiment that serves as the training
00:29:55 ground that prepares people for the ideal. It's not just ideal from A to Z, it's Z is the ideal 0.51
00:30:02 And there's other steps along the way.
00:30:05 And I think of even the American project, you know, guys is, well, this is the best
00:30:08 form of government.
00:30:08 And I'm even willing to concede that point and say, I could be wrong, I'm fallible, but
00:30:14 yeah, I like it.
00:30:15 I like a constitutional republic.
00:30:17 I think that's great if the people, you know, are conducive for that.
00:30:21 But people say, you know, and that's been our thing from the beginning.
00:30:24 It's like, okay, but these people didn't just grow on trees.
00:30:27 They weren't hanging in midair.
00:30:28 They didn't just appear.
00:30:29 Americans didn't just, the founders and the covenanters and the pilgrims and the Puritans,
00:30:34 they didn't just appear. And that's your point that I find so refreshing and helpful.
00:30:39 These aren't people that just grew out of American soil one day and popped into existence. These are
00:30:44 people who transitioned from another place and another heritage and a thousand years of history,
00:30:52 namely this Anglo-Protestant heritage from Great Britain. And the funny thing is,
00:30:59 what's the thing that prepared for generations these people and their posterity to one day
00:31:05 be in America and have this constitutional republic? What's the thing that prepared
00:31:09 them for centuries in England? A monarchy. Isn't that interesting?
00:31:15 Yeah, well, I mean, more than that, too. It was the people's interaction with the monarchy.
00:31:22 I mean, some of the major events in the history of England, going back to the Magna Carta,
00:31:27 was the the people or the you know the the various powers um having a conflict resolution
00:31:34 conflict and then resolution so that's essentially what the magna carta was same thing with the the
00:31:39 glorious restoration um in in 1680s um and so i mean even the english civil war was essentially
00:31:46 a war of course against the king so there there was this tradition of resistance which again is
00:31:52 what the uh the founders appealed to so it was monarchy but it was also this interaction with
00:31:59 monarchy and so and then and then add to that the the nature of the new world was explicitly from
00:32:04 the very beginning you see this reflected in early massachusetts bay colony this like rejection of
00:32:10 aristocracy that was rooted in a kind of puritan um puritan religion essentially and uh and so
00:32:19 self-government uh minus uh without aristocracy and then you get into the founding where you have
00:32:25 a george washington who could have if he wanted to just become the king of america
00:32:30 uh and he denied that and they called him mr president um not king or some royal title
00:32:37 uh and so there there that uh and with that there was again a development of ordered liberty that
00:32:45 didn't need this sort of aristocracy i mean people have said like what why why was there why was there
00:32:50 so much trouble in france and there was so much trouble in um in germany and in the in the 19th
00:32:58 century and a lot of people think it's because of the stability of the monarchy uh and that people
00:33:02 could look up this is like a an old what's his name bad badget or bad shot i forget how to say
00:33:08 his name but it's an old claim of of of england that the modern people could look to the aristocracy
00:33:14 and kind of have a sort of stability and that's what's held england together for so long uh but
00:33:20 in america we didn't have the aristocracy but still kind of held together i mean you have the
00:33:24 civil war and other things but but generally speaking the idea of ordered liberty existed
00:33:28 apart from these uh these these kind of um aristocratic figures i mean you have you have
00:33:33 andrew jackson's and lincoln's and that sort but but still that that's the that's our tradition
00:33:38 um and you you wonder now if we could still have that without a figure this is one reason why i
00:33:45 brought up the idea of a christian prince in my book and that was that we need some guy to be a
00:33:51 unifier um and but within the tradition the american tradition people think when i say
00:33:56 christian prince they a dictator i'm thinking some sort of like some sort of modern form of
00:34:02 dictator right i really in our tradition means someone like george washington right so someone
00:34:07 whose own presence he was a tall man he sat in and um in the federal convention debates that
00:34:13 produced our constitution as presiding and he didn't say much but his presence there it added
00:34:20 to legitimacy added to the gravity of the event his support for it of course helped he did two
00:34:26 terms and then humbly said i'm done and even decades afterwards people would have a little
00:34:31 on their mantle they'd have a little image of george washington as if he was the guy who held
00:34:37 the country together he knew it he knew that he was a type of cincinnatus who um he was a sort of
00:34:44 as my envision a christian prince who is the embodiment of the people but he also had this
00:34:49 again this anglo protestant um humility to say i'm not going to become king or dominate you guys
00:34:58 even though i could probably do that i'm going to retire and go go back to the farm uh and he did
00:35:04 that and he established that tradition ever since so that's the sort of people person i'm talking
00:35:09 about this like the classical notion of someone like cincinnatus leaving his farm to solve the
00:35:16 the issues of the day to for the people to then rally around and solve it and then go back and
00:35:22 that's the genius of our system or the genius of our tradition the anglo the american anglo-pros
00:35:28 tradition is that you have a sense of duty mixed with the type of humility to then exit when you
00:35:34 must. And someone like FDR violated that and all that. But you have the George Washingtons,
00:35:42 and that's my notion of an American Christian prince. 0.95
00:35:46 Right. No, that's good. And we still have those systems, but the problem is that that's not just 0.99
00:35:50 like, that's not just a form or a system of a guy who comes in and has a humble presence presiding
00:35:55 over these things and, you know, courage and, you know, all these. And then when he's done,
00:36:01 He doesn't try to hold on to power, but he lets it go and is content to go back to the
00:36:05 farm.
00:36:06 That's not just a system.
00:36:07 That's a, that's a certain type.
00:36:09 That's a high caliber man.
00:36:10 It's not just the system.
00:36:11 It's the person.
00:36:12 We don't have those people we have. 0.94
00:36:15 Instead, we have, you know, boomers who want to, you know, like take organ donors and AI 0.73
00:36:23 and live forever, you know, never let go of power. 0.78
00:36:28 meanwhile they you know they can't control their bowel movements you know in a public speech like
00:36:32 that i mean that we're nowhere near is the the exact opposite of george washington you know
00:36:37 again so at the leader level and then at the people level at the populace in in both regards
00:36:42 it seems like one of the major problems is we just don't have the people we don't have that
00:36:46 caliber of of man of person um for the current form of government that we have
00:36:53 yeah and uh and yeah and unfortunately the the sort of people we have in mind 0.96
00:37:03 to rise up in the younger generations are being in a way held back by by the boomers and and
00:37:09 others i mean you just see in the church when i when i talk about having you know young men
00:37:14 fulfilling their potential in all aspects of their life not only spiritual not only mental
00:37:19 but also physical you see these guys lose their minds as if like oh it's nichian uh you know like 0.81
00:37:25 us encouraging people who are 20 to maximize the potential of their youth right violates the boomer
00:37:31 mentality of you know it's it's as if they they prefer everyone to be fat and weak and like just
00:37:38 obey like whatever the the church ladies say um instead of being strong and assertive and physically
00:37:45 you know mentally and physically fit uh for for that um to to serve their country and people
00:37:51 it's it's like anathema and so it's very unfortunate it's as if they're trying to hold
00:37:57 back then prevent the rise of of of of a greatness that does tremendous good in the world right it's
00:38:06 a i don't like the word gnostic toss but there is a sort of gnosticism there that there's like
00:38:10 there's a spiritualism side so it doesn't matter if you're fat or get trampled on by the church
00:38:15 ladies it that's all kind of good in a sense because you're denying yourself or something
00:38:20 it's a perversion and subversion of christian truth um and so what we well you know what i'm
00:38:27 trying to do what i know you're trying to do and other people is encourage younger people guys who
00:38:30 are like i don't know how old you are but i'm 40 41 trying to say hey look like if you're 20
00:38:36 you don't need to be fat and lazy and weak right you don't need to do that like you should you
00:38:42 should seek to do within the limit within the limits of your capacities and capabilities try
00:38:47 to maximize yourself in the i i wish that i did that when i was 20 and you get older and you're
00:38:52 like well yeah i should have done that so i'm saying look like youth is good like and take
00:38:57 advantage of it um to develop yourself and be the best person you can be and i think if we have that
00:39:03 kind of environmentally of that sort of ethos within the christian world we would have men
00:39:09 that are just outstanding and great and and uh not not think that i mean i know you're a pastor
00:39:15 but there is there's this thing this is i beat on this like i'm always saying like you gotta stop
00:39:21 thinking that like the the pinnacle of greatness is being a being a pastor being a pastor is
00:39:26 wonderful it's great it's essential it's like crucial for people's like um uh for the good
00:39:31 life to submit to a pastor but at the same time it's not there's other forms of greatness there's
00:39:38 greatness in politics there's greatness in athletics and there's there's all sorts of
00:39:43 things that you can achieve in a christian life and you can do these other things and most people
00:39:48 are best suited for those other things and not being pastor uh and but in the evangelical world
00:39:52 it's like you get a job and your job is so that you uh have enough money so you can do your like
00:39:59 your international missions trip twice a year yeah anything else you talked about this in your talk
00:40:04 it's like people think that everything is purely instrumental for some spiritual end when actually
00:40:09 no there's earthly goods here of inheritance of self-development that actually can produce
00:40:14 tremendous amounts of good right and those things do serve a spiritual end but the spiritual end is
00:40:20 not always global missions it's not always um simply eternal salvation of individual souls
00:40:27 There are, it's not just that there are spiritual ends and then there are temporal earthly goods.
00:40:33 It's no, there are actually, there's a multitude of different spiritual ends beyond just eternal
00:40:40 individual conversion and justification.
00:40:44 Even with the gospel, you know, Owen, John Owen talked about how, you know, justification
00:40:49 is the heart of the gospel, but it's not the end of the gospel.
00:40:52 The end of the gospel is not just being reminded again and again, uh, of justification by faith
00:40:57 alone. Uh, but the end purpose aim of the gospel is not justification, but rather communion with
00:41:04 the triune God, uh, that, that all of this is serving, uh, the purpose of being able to eternally
00:41:10 belly up to the table, uh, the wedding supper of the lamb and commune and dying and feast and
00:41:16 fellowship uh with uh with the triune god enjoying fellowship with him forever and so even in terms
00:41:23 of spiritual lens it's not just conversion it's never less not saying it's something other than
00:41:28 or less than but it's more than merely conversion so these temporal goods whether it be physical
00:41:34 training which is of some value and that's part of the the problem is that we um yeah we we just
00:41:41 we're, uh, we have this because it's easy. It's easy to just say, Oh, everything else is of no
00:41:48 value. This one thing is of ultimate value. Uh, that's actually really easy. Like there's the,
00:41:53 um, the old moniker, uh, I had a friend who had the tattoo and he deeply regrets it, you know, 0.96
00:41:57 but it said that moderate moderation is for cowards, which is a really foolish saying, 0.95
00:42:03 you know? So it's basically like, just, you know, pick, pick one or two or three things 0.97
00:42:07 and go all in and then everything else don't do it at all, which is not, it's not a Christian
00:42:11 idea. The Christian idea is, no, there's actually like a thousand things, and they're not necessarily
00:42:19 of ultimate value. And there's a triage, and some things are more valuable, and spiritual things
00:42:24 are of eternal value. But it's not as simple as just saying, hey, everything's a distraction,
00:42:29 leave it entirely alone, pick these two or three things, give it everything you got.
00:42:34 That's actually easier. That appeals, I think, to apathy, a lazy person, a lazy man. 0.81
00:42:40 But in reality, the actuality is that, no, there's like at any given point in my life,
00:42:48 there's probably a thousand things that have varied degrees of value. And I'm expected to
00:42:54 weigh through these things with discernment and wisdom and give 30 minutes here and three hours
00:42:59 there and 20 minutes. So physical training is not of ultimate value. It's also not of no value.
00:43:05 it's of some value, which means I need to give it some time. And that's just one example that
00:43:12 the Apostle Paul cites, but I think there are a million different temporal goods that could fall
00:43:17 into the some value bucket, that category. And to figure that out and then to give the things of
00:43:24 some value, some energy, and some time is a lot of work, which is, I think, why pietism appeals
00:43:32 and Gnosticism appeals, because it's easy.
00:43:36 It's actually easier.
00:43:37 It sounds really good, but it's actually way easier.
00:43:40 You have heard it said that cash is king.
00:43:43 Well, our sponsor, Private Family Banking,
00:43:45 wants you to know that cash flow
00:43:46 is the key to building wealth.
00:43:49 The partners at Private Family Banking
00:43:51 are experts at teaching you how to implement
00:43:53 a new way of thinking about money.
00:43:56 This powerful and innovative approach
00:43:58 provides a fail-safe method
00:44:00 for redirecting the cash flow you already have
00:44:03 into a privatized banking system
00:44:06 that you now own and control.
00:44:08 This new system places you and your family
00:44:11 on the wealth curve
00:44:12 for continuously compounding tax-protected gains
00:44:16 now and unto future generations.
00:44:19 You may also be familiar with the age-old wisdom
00:44:22 that the best time to plant a tree for shade
00:44:25 was 10 years ago,
00:44:26 but the second best time is today.
00:44:28 So start your journey of building your financial legacy right now.
00:44:34 The sooner you start, the better.
00:44:36 Let a private family banking partner help you put post-mill talk into post-mill action.
00:44:42 Contact them today by emailing banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:44:47 Again, that's banking at privatefamilybanking.com
00:44:51 and request a free step-by-step wealth building plan
00:44:55 that will be the game changer that you have been looking for.
00:44:59 Lastly, a complimentary discovery call can be scheduled
00:45:03 by using the link in this episode's show notes.
00:45:06 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians
00:45:09 to do their duty before God and not to have their consciences ruled
00:45:12 by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:45:14 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
00:45:18 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
00:45:21 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:45:24 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:45:30 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
00:45:36 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:45:42 Yeah, I mean, one thing is that we tend to treat these goods as kind of like zero sum in the sense that if you're devoting your attention to politics or some issue that you care for,
00:45:54 Well, then you must then not be devoting your attention to something that's higher in value.
00:45:59 And so we kind of have this zero sum mentality.
00:46:02 And this is where the, like, what we call the Jesus juke comes in.
00:46:05 It's like, you really care about this one issue.
00:46:07 That's kind of more of a temporal thing, I guess, or earthly thing.
00:46:10 And then, but, oh, you care, like you, like you caring about that means you're not caring
00:46:15 about these other things, like these more spiritual things.
00:46:17 So it's like a zero sum mentality.
00:46:19 And there is a, there is a legitimate like concern, a pastoral concern.
00:46:23 If someone's intense about an issue, a good pastor would be like, okay, look, I affirm that you care about this.
00:46:28 I think it's good that you care about this, but let's make sure that it's not a distraction from something that's more important.
00:46:34 So you will affirm that it's good, that they care about an issue, but the pastoral concern is that make sure it doesn't distract from these other things as well.
00:46:44 um nevertheless it should never be oh you shouldn't care about this issue intensely
00:46:49 because then you can't care about these other things intensely right uh and right and so that
00:46:56 that's like the the jesus juke and pastors can do that sometimes if they're not thinking clearly
00:47:00 but yeah i think you're absolutely right like you have these there's there's there's a bunch
00:47:05 of different goods out in the world and to to be a complete person is not only to be you know
00:47:11 hyper-spiritual but it's also to be a good a good father that provides material support for their
00:47:17 family i mean that means you have to go outside and work usually and bring home money and then
00:47:20 that all that that's there's a good there that and it's a duty um same thing with
00:47:25 duty to your your parents um you know uh and uh and duty to your community to your church to your
00:47:33 church and their their material needs there's all sorts of goods that we have to kind of devote our
00:47:37 attention to um and to devote one like as i that we become a quasi hermit you know like one of those
00:47:43 old those hermits of old where they essentially distance themselves from society to focus on
00:47:48 their own particular spiritual like the desert fathers or something like that yeah yeah or they 0.98
00:47:53 end up neglecting the the completeness of of your duty so you they fulfill the principle but but
00:47:59 miss all the secondaries right which then means you fail you fall short um so and so that's that's
00:48:07 the problem but yeah i mean um and what i say is like yeah when when you are united to christ
00:48:14 you you justify but you're also restored meaning that the things that the things of this life
00:48:19 the faculties have been restored in in him such that you can now actually act um as a as intended
00:48:28 by by god you know meaning that you can't act perfectly you're not never going to be perfect
00:48:32 in this side of life but you still are regenerated you still are in a way definitively sanctified
00:48:39 and so then what does it mean to be human in this world it's not only to uh to do spiritual things
00:48:45 or to go to church and worship god it's also to labor to have a vocation that you do well at and
00:48:52 that you do good to others through that vocation not only directly in the service but also in
00:48:57 acquiring the means that to support those who depend upon you so all those things are just the
00:49:02 so we're restored to do these things and so they're part of a part of our duty and i would say
00:49:09 for the one reason like well why do i need to be physically fit well i mean you don't have to be a
00:49:13 bodybuilder but i mean to be a bodybuilder takes a tremendous amount of time and and so you could
00:49:18 actually be doing other things i'm not saying don't don't be a bodybuilder but i'm saying
00:49:22 we shouldn't think that we should think that that if like if if you're like a builder for example
00:49:28 or a construction worker you can't devote two hours a day to go working out you have to have
00:49:32 your your strength to do construction right so uh the point being that um uh but whatever it is
00:49:39 you should be fit such that you can aid and be of service to your neighbor and have the one thing i
00:49:45 realized uh when i moved to the south when i moved to louisiana for several years um is that one
00:49:51 reason why these guys like have big trucks i mean part of it's a cultural thing but it's also the
00:49:57 people like owning trucks because they can be resourceful to others what i found is that whenever
00:50:02 i needed some help there were just guys open up oh i got my truck you can borrow it i'll come over
00:50:07 and i'll help you with this stuff it's to be useful person to your neighbor for your friends
00:50:12 and others to have this this uh this resource um and so that's what i mean like you you be fit and
00:50:19 you have these things in service to others. That's why I'm scared to get a truck, Stephen,
00:50:25 because if I get a truck, then I think people in the church are going to every Saturday ask me to
00:50:30 help them move. That is true. Yeah. No, that's really helpful. These are my last two questions
00:50:37 and then you can maybe do your best to answer these and then any concluding thoughts and we
00:50:41 can land the plane. But just for the listener, I know what you mean. And so I think, you know,
00:50:46 uh, yeah, I read your book, took me a second to figure it out. I saw, you know, your infamous
00:50:51 tweet, uh, that everybody was, you know, denouncing and like, how could you, you know, the lone
00:50:56 bulwark, uh, tweet. And I, you know, I didn't have, I'll, I'll say it publicly. I, um, I did
00:51:02 not retweet you and say, this is, uh, insightful and, uh, undeniably true. I also, uh, did not
00:51:09 retweet you and say, oh my goodness, let me clutch my pearls. I was like, uh, I'm going to,
00:51:14 I'm going to let that one. We're not ready for that one. In a couple of years, now time in the
00:51:19 province of God has, for the most part, vindicated to you. I mean, you've gotten a lot of people have
00:51:23 come around. It's pretty crazy how the Overton window has moved so quickly to where something
00:51:28 so controversial that never should have been, but was, has now people are like, oh yeah, that's not
00:51:34 crazy at all. That's just the statistics of voting patterns and speaking not of individuals, but
00:51:38 group dynamics. Anyway, so all that being said, I know what you mean. I read your book. I've been
00:51:43 watching you online you know we've had a little bit of conversation in person and um and i think
00:51:49 i'm just kind of on that same trajectory um theologically and politically and those kinds
00:51:54 of things uh but for the listener who may not understand some of these things i you know it
00:52:00 was helpful probably for guys in the audience during your talk when you know towards the end
00:52:05 you said here are some of my you know favorite anglo protestants and you said well you know like
00:52:09 booker t washington or clarence thomas you know and then and then also so one first question two
00:52:16 questions first question uh how is clarence thomas and for the listener if you don't know
00:52:20 he's a black uh supreme court justice married to a white woman how you know and very conservative
00:52:25 and one of the best supreme court justices we have and we're grateful for um but how is he an
00:52:30 anglo-protestant and then secondly when you say ethnicity uh you know even in your book you know
00:52:36 one of the things that i was able to pick up on i guess a year and a half ago now um but i was like
00:52:41 he's using ethnicity the way that dead guys used to use the word um we've boiled we've truncated
00:52:47 the word ethnicity to exclusively referring to color pigment shades of you know skin pigment
00:52:55 pigment um but used to ethnicity it seems as though it had a it was much more encompassing
00:53:02 it baked into ethnicity was culture and customs and nationality. And that's one of the problems
00:53:08 because in the old world, you don't, it was uncommon in mine. Maybe I'm wrong, but in my
00:53:14 perception, you didn't have a lot of countries like America. Japan is Japanese, you know? And
00:53:21 so when you say, you know, Japanese, it's like, well, are you referring to ethnicity or nationality? 0.94
00:53:26 And the answer is yes, because it's just, it's both. And China is the same way. And 0.58
00:53:30 the Sudan is the same way. And, you know, and so it's really not until very recently in terms of
00:53:36 human history and predominantly in the West and, and most, you know, most blatantly in,
00:53:42 in our country, in America, that we've severed nationality from ethnicity. So ethnicity just
00:53:47 means color now and nationality means citizenship and, you know, these kinds of things. So anyways,
00:53:53 all that being said, how is Clarence Thomas an Anglo Protestant, because we're talking about
00:53:57 culture and not just pigment and then on the pigment um topic um what does the word ethnicity
00:54:04 mean how would how would you advocate for guys you know using that word and entailing in it more
00:54:10 than just color do those questions make sense yeah absolutely um yeah when i when i chose to
00:54:16 write the chapter on the nation i did use the word ethnicity uh instead of race and instead of um
00:54:25 um instead of culture and the the reason was is that is that culture strikes me as too much like
00:54:32 uh like oh we all agree in the same culture at that moment so there's a sort of snapshot in time
00:54:38 type mentality like when you think of culture not necessarily um but then race also doesn't work
00:54:45 because there's you could have a bunch of like white folks who are actually very different um
00:54:50 in terms of their culture and their national.
00:54:53 So the difference between French and English
00:54:55 is just really striking,
00:54:56 or just between Hungarian and English
00:54:59 would be very striking and different.
00:55:01 And so it wouldn't make any sense to use race.
00:55:04 But ethnicity, the reason why I used it the way I did,
00:55:06 which refers to culture, but also ancestry.
00:55:10 So I wanted to connect,
00:55:11 because of course it matters that your people,
00:55:15 that you are connected to this place through generations going back so i of course i'm
00:55:23 connected to the united states because my grandfather was in world war ii of course i
00:55:28 mean that i i am i'm connected because he fought a loved one fought in that in that major that
00:55:34 major kind of national struggle or you know my grandparents went through the great depression
00:55:40 as kids like these history thing the history we learn in the books is not simply the these random
00:55:47 things that are these things that happen to these humans i'm now studying on a page it's people who
00:55:52 are my ancestors my loved ones um so of course like and your ancestry matters i mean imagine
00:55:58 if you i mean everyone or a lot of people have had experience with hey this is my grandparents
00:56:04 house or their property and even if they no one even if you don't know who owns it now you'll
00:56:09 drive by that and you'll see it and you'll have a sort of affection for it because it embodies the
00:56:15 the the life and activity of your grandparents so in napa california my my uh the the wolf side
00:56:23 of my family owned the wolf ranch and i remember driving up the driveway uh to go to christmas
00:56:28 parties and seeing aunts and uncles and cousins and having this great time and now it's not owned
00:56:34 by the family unfortunately anymore um but uh i still occasionally when i when i'm going back to
00:56:40 napa to see grandmother from the other side i drive by and they still have this little wolf
00:56:45 up that's called the wolf ranch and the wolf holding a star on it and so there's affection
00:56:49 there's an affection there built into memory so of course like that place my dad my dad and his
00:56:55 and uncle and grandfather built the house that there with their own hands wow so we don't own
00:56:59 it i don't know even know who owns it now um but if that house burned down i would i wouldn't lose
00:57:05 anything materially but of course i'd lose something else and so what i'm trying to describe
00:57:10 in the book is that something else that there is that that thing that is in a way like emplaced or
00:57:17 embodying the place and so of course like your ancestry matters i mean uh people call that like 0.96
00:57:22 blood and soil but are you just are you are you dumb i mean i like like who like who who who can 0.97
00:57:30 be so kind of insensitive and lack the affection of seeing a field or a battlefield or um or some 1.00
00:57:40 house even a shack that your grandparents or great-grandparents lived life in or on or whatever
00:57:48 like who can be so unfeeling that they wouldn't have something some connection to that that is
00:57:54 beyond property rights or something like that right uh and so yeah that's that's what i was
00:57:59 trying to get like so ethnicity is that a rhetorical question because i have an answer boomers
00:58:03 boomers is the answer yeah yeah um that's a property right and it's worth this much money
00:58:10 and that's all it is no i'm just kidding yeah not all but a lot yeah and to the credit of like
00:58:16 our generation i think millennials started to try to recover something um a different mentality on
00:58:21 that yeah uh even though we recovered all sorts of bad things too but right uh but yeah so of course
00:58:27 it matters and and so um and that means that like it your connection to the american people if you
00:58:33 take that broader your connection to the american people and our history does it does matter that
00:58:39 your ancestry goes back into that uh and this is why if your people were germans back in 1810
00:58:46 i mean you're just as american as anyone else because you have been here interacted and lived
00:58:52 with this and you've participated in the major events since you since you got here there's a
00:58:57 there's you have actual connection to the people in the place and you've probably intermarried and
00:59:01 all that um and so yeah so it matters but at the same time our my way of ethnicity is not entirely
00:59:10 just a ancestral like genetic thing genetics thing and this is why you asked about clarence thomas
00:59:16 i also mentioned santiago pliego who is a actually born in mexico and now he's here and he's american
00:59:23 citizen naturalized citizen and you talk to him and it's like he he desires not only that he can
00:59:30 be sort of grafted into this american heritage but also that his kids will be as well he wants
00:59:35 his kids to be just as american as me or in you and anyone else so so the ethnicity then is like
00:59:44 an open thing in that the people who come here or existed here but are but are self-consciously
00:59:52 kind of bringing themselves into that heritage and want to be part of it not subvert it not
00:59:58 undermine it right not like hold on to the other stuff but like become one of us assimilate um
01:00:04 and they can be and i think i think like even santiago could be like yeah my people is like
01:00:10 george washington yeah like so i and this is again this is like the american i don't think
01:00:14 this is me being sentimental i think that's just the the american tradition has always been very
01:00:19 open also very kind of like exclusivist and and what the left to call xenophobic but also uh when
01:00:27 people come here this openness to conformity but that's the problem is the problem is that where
01:00:33 america was open but it was open to people who wanted to be american they wanted to join now
01:00:40 america is open to people who have like no desire to be i mean on on voting ballots we have you know
01:00:46 there are voting ballots in some places where you have three languages like if if that's not a sign
01:00:51 of of a nation that's just utterly defeated then i don't know what is i mean to like we're gonna
01:00:56 to have this voting ballot in spanish why we're we're english we speak english that's that we're
01:01:04 americans you know and so to be to have some measure of principled openness uh is great but
01:01:12 it's not an openness to come here and still be a somalian no it's to come here because you love
01:01:17 american you want to be american right right it's it's the desire yeah so you can either you can
01:01:24 either yeah you can come here and kind of exist as a as a kind of um as like a second culture
01:01:32 but uh but not the core so you you would essentially be you you'd have a a tolerated
01:01:39 way of life but it wouldn't be the part of the core or you can actually kind of bring and graft
01:01:44 yourself into the the the core and and that's what i mean by i mean even i mean clarence thomas of
01:01:51 course he's he's he's descendant from from slaves so uh in a way like when we talk about heritage
01:01:59 americans it's it's proper to speak of um even the kind of sort of black subcultures that are here
01:02:06 um the reason i i would say that that he that clarence thomas is part of a sort of angle
01:02:13 protestant ethnos is that he has from from what i can tell self-consciously said i'm american i'm
01:02:22 and i'm and this is this is this is who i am uh and so he's kind of brought himself into that
01:02:28 um i mean this is why people call him like you know the oreo and all sorts of horrible names
01:02:33 uncle tom that uncle tom all that and that's what it is it's it's p this is the same thing like
01:02:37 webb du bois would call like booker t washington is yeah people hate him because he yeah and they
01:02:43 because he's an anglo-protestant yeah they call him that because they have identified anglo-protestant
01:02:49 as as only as essentially a white man's uh which broadly speaking in terms of population has been
01:02:56 right um but but then they just say oh you're you're no longer black and now you're white
01:03:01 right um but and there's no i mean there's no truth in that in itself but it is recognizing
01:03:07 like when they accuse people like soul and uh clarence thomas and others of being those things
01:03:14 they are recognizing rightfully that they have actually now that they are they are part of
01:03:21 the the core american ethnos and that's why they want to denounce them and call them all those 0.94
01:03:27 names uh they'd prefer that they're no longer or not in that core and they would be a sort of like
01:03:33 secondary stream of of american ethnos but not the i mean the core the core has always been
01:03:40 angled protestant and uh but again it's an open ethnicity essentially you can have like like a
01:03:45 antonin scalia uh he is a italian roman catholic and he has this great story you can watch as a
01:03:51 minute and a half and he says that he was in it um no he's in italy first right he went to italy
01:03:57 he was in and then he went to england yeah yeah right he was in he was in like uh continental
01:04:03 europe for a while from from switzerland and then italy and then he said he went to england
01:04:07 i had never been there before after all those all that time in in continental europe and he says he
01:04:13 was home like this is home and he was essentially saying we're anglo he said anglo-saxon i would
01:04:19 say anglo-protestant but we're uh an anglo-saxon people even though he's genetically from i don't
01:04:25 know southern italy or something like that right i know i love that story because it's you know
01:04:30 here he is he's american in terms of you know both culture and his citizenship nationality
01:04:35 but then he goes to uh italy and that's what you know that's his his you know his blood his you
01:04:41 know his ancestry um but he feels more at home in great britain than he does in italy why because
01:04:48 uh because his whole life he's been in america in america came america is this british project
01:04:56 it's this anglo you know protestant project and so naturally his his his italianness uh did not
01:05:03 resonate as profoundly in in italy as his americanness resonated in in england um so yeah
01:05:11 exactly and again that that just shows it so it would be again i i don't i don't want us to think
01:05:19 that this is just a cultural thing as we think it does it does matter i think people need to
01:05:26 remind themselves and become conscious of this and this is one reason why i emphasize it
01:05:30 you need to be conscious of the fact that you have ancestry here right like that you need to
01:05:36 restore that you may not even know like i don't i know that i have like some preacher from
01:05:41 connecticut in the late 1600s in my my my ancestral line but i don't know everything
01:05:47 else but you know what you know what does matter though is that literally my great great great
01:05:51 grandparents they've been here since 16 something and that that matters uh and and everyone here
01:05:58 and if it means that you don't have anyone here well you're interacting with people who do and
01:06:05 you're you are in your living life with people who do and you can see yourself as as your sort
01:06:12 of life project as bringing yourself into that to tell i i forget who it was i think ady roble
01:06:17 was uh was it him who said that his father said we're not speaking spanish in this house we're
01:06:22 speaking english and that's because we're we're becoming american so you can deliberately you
01:06:27 can do these things to become uh one of us but again today that the the the the governing
01:06:35 principle now is that actually no you just be exactly what you were before and just affirm
01:06:40 these propositions take an oath and you're in and live in america is just an idea and an economic
01:06:46 zone and reap the benefits without really any commitment um yeah and that is not sustainable
01:06:54 and really send send send a good portion of your income overseas i mean in central and south
01:07:01 america it's amazing how much of their economies are actually sustained by people in the u.s sending
01:07:06 money back and so the incentive structure for so anyway yeah that's for south america but then when
01:07:11 it comes to ukraine we send money through tax dollars you know or israel yeah you're right you
01:07:17 know but no that's that's really helpful i'd like um just as you were you know the the whether it
01:07:21 be uh clarence thomas thomas soul i mean even vody bacham would fall into this category but
01:07:26 that was helpful thinking uh because i watched the documentaries i don't know if you saw them
01:07:30 there was an uncle Tom documentary and then an uncle Tom too. And, and they were helpful. And
01:07:35 especially the second one, I really liked the second one. They had Votie Bacham in it a lot.
01:07:39 And, but it's helpful to think like, okay, what is this accusation, this pejorative, this being
01:07:44 levied against, you know, black men who are, you know, like Clarence Thomas, Anglo, you know,
01:07:52 Protestants that have really adopted and fully committed and assimilated into this American
01:07:57 heritage and love it and identify with it. And, you know, and so they're being, you know, cursed
01:08:02 and demeaned because of that decision and because of that assimilation. And, you know, what, but 0.55
01:08:08 what's contained in this, you know, pejorative of Uncle Tom that's being levied. And I think one of
01:08:13 the things is, you know, two things that's being contained. One is that there really is a hegemony.
01:08:17 There really is a core culture of America, and it must be the dominant culture. If not,
01:08:23 then we're just fractured and splintered and a house divided against itself cannot stand it's
01:08:28 just not sustainable so there one there really is a core culture and that core culture is anglo
01:08:33 protestant and the fact that that's levied against a black man whereas it wouldn't be levied against
01:08:39 necessarily a white man we just say hey i hate whiteness um but there'd be a recognition of like 0.95
01:08:43 but of course you're white because you know you're of course you're acting like an anglo protestant 0.99
01:08:47 because you're white. And I hate it. But with a black man, the levied charge of Uncle Tom is 1.00
01:08:53 basically a charge of betrayal. You're a traitor to your own kind. And what that to me indicates 1.00
01:08:59 is that not only is there a dominant culture in America's history and heritage that's Anglo 0.95
01:09:04 Protestant, but that that dominant culture has been, in terms of skin color, predominantly made
01:09:09 up of white people. And it doesn't mean that non-white people can't be a part of it, but it
01:09:13 has been majority european um in terms of of of color it has been um predominantly white and
01:09:21 that's why someone like vody bacham would be accused by the left you know as being a turncoat
01:09:27 a traitor and that's what uncle tom means and so i think to recognize that is not to be exclusive
01:09:33 and it's certainly not to be racist which is a word that just has virtually no meaning at this
01:09:39 point. It's none of those things, but it is to recognize we are a distinct people, a distinct
01:09:44 country. We have a heritage, a history, a foundation. What is that? What is that culture?
01:09:51 Multiculturalism is not our strength. We want to have a dominant culture. What is it? What has it 0.80
01:09:57 historically been made up of? And then who all can join? But then in joining, what are the
01:10:03 distinctives and what are the commitments and what does this entail? All these are incredibly
01:10:07 important questions. And none of these are, they're not colorblind, but they're also not,
01:10:15 but they're also, it's, it's, it is not a sinful, a sinful racial partiality. It's
01:10:22 acknowledging race, but, but not sinfully. Like I remember even the statement, I think we showed
01:10:28 you or somebody in our, our little crew showed you, this was a year, half, half ago, and we're
01:10:32 going to actually make it the final draft public. It's been forever. A lot of the guys are SBC,
01:10:37 and they're fighting for the life to try to keep out women pastors right now. But eventually when 0.96
01:10:42 all that's done, we're going to publish our statement on Christian nationalism and the
01:10:46 gospel, the final draft. And one of the things that we changed was initially we said, we repudiate
01:10:52 the sin of ethnic partiality. And after getting some feedback from other guys and thinking through
01:10:59 that and thinking biblically about that, we changed it to, we repudiate instead of the sin
01:11:03 of ethnic partiality, we change it to we repudiate sinful ethnic partiality, recognizing that in the
01:11:10 realm of partiality, it can be done sinfully, but not inherently. And, you know, for Japan to
01:11:19 have a preference for Japanese people is not inherently sinful. It could be. There can be
01:11:26 sinful expressions of that, just kind of in the same way that anger, Jesus says, in your anger,
01:11:30 do not sin so it's not just to be angry is inherently sinful but there is a way in anger
01:11:36 to behave sinfully um and that that's just i don't know i i'm thinking through these things
01:11:43 and and that's just a conversation that right now the the typical american just can't handle
01:11:48 they just lose their mind what people don't get like when when we when i say things like
01:11:53 you should prefer your own or you should prefer your own ethnicity as i've as i've defined it
01:11:58 already but when i say that i'm talking i'm saying that it's actually it it's not that it's not that
01:12:06 it's it's good in itself regardless of the effects but that it's good to prefer your own family your
01:12:15 own parents your own children and your own people your own canon group ethnicity because of the way
01:12:22 that we are made by god that is the way to bring about good so a nation should prefer people who
01:12:29 are similar because if you bring people in who are similar they can assimilate into the collective
01:12:35 life of that people just like in j like again japan why would i mean japan's slipping on this
01:12:40 a little bit but one reason why they've preferred have very restrictive immigration is to keep japan
01:12:46 japanese right as a distinct ethnicity and they knew that wisely knew that if you bring in a
01:12:52 mass outsiders it'll change the nature of japan and and what's happened in japan i mean you go 0.85
01:12:59 there it's the safest cleanest country in the entire world um and there's been recent actually
01:13:04 some immigrants my or they've brought in and there's been videos i've seen where well not so
01:13:09 safe and not so clean um and so yeah so like if the point being is that that that um the ability
01:13:18 to interact with people not only via language but also through cultural and and mutual understanding
01:13:23 of manners and customs uh and to be able to like just even feel the accent i remember i was just
01:13:30 just at the airport i was struggling to try to get answers and in dallas because like where do i go
01:13:36 to get the the the um the courtesy van and like i couldn't communicate with anyone uh because it
01:13:42 was just such just like this uh uh you know um it's like it's like being in babble and all so
01:13:48 right uh no texas is crazy man it's great it's like where where am i yeah yeah and um
01:13:56 anyway the point being is that that there's actually good there's a there's good it's good
01:14:02 to be around people where you can communicate as as well as possible so that we can all achieve
01:14:09 not only collective projects but your own individual project or what you're up to at the
01:14:13 moment so i like again americans have to get like everyone christians have to get out of their mind
01:14:18 this idea that like preferring your own ethnic group is some good in itself that we ought to do
01:14:22 no it's like if you if you just look at not only the social science data but your own experience
01:14:28 you'll see that you gravitate towards people who are similar precisely because of the good involved
01:14:33 in that the good in effect and that's what my argument that's my argument from the book 0.92
01:14:38 and but people just i don't know if it's race brain or what it is but they're incapable
01:14:42 of of seeing that even though they experience it nowadays daily right almost daily they
01:14:49 experience the difficulty of being around difference just just language alone you you
01:14:54 call a helpline you know whatever yeah technical support you know because your webcam's not working
01:14:59 and like this like the almost audible sigh of relief that i'll have uh when when the person
01:15:07 who answers on the other side of the line uh speaks coherent english you know and i'm just
01:15:12 oh phew you know because because i know we you know that so much has been outsourced and
01:15:17 especially with technical support and those kinds of things and hotlines and um support staff and
01:15:23 and uh i know that i've got like a 90 chance that the person who's going to pick up the phone
01:15:27 i i can barely understand you know and and and so it's just it's uh if nothing else i mean god
01:15:34 even says that in Genesis 11, that, you know, if they remain united, one people, that there's
01:15:41 nothing they cannot do. And therefore he confuses their languages and not, it is a judgment,
01:15:47 but it's a judgment with mercy baked into the judgment pie. Because really what it does is
01:15:52 it gets mankind, it doesn't throw them off the rails in their sin and arrogance and pride they
01:15:59 were off the rails. God's judgment of confusing their languages actually gets them back on track
01:16:04 with their original design.
01:16:05 They actually say it's not just a sin of arrogance saying, we'll build a tower to the heavens,
01:16:09 but it's also a sin of direct rebellion to the command given in the garden to be fruitful
01:16:15 and multiply and to spread out and fill the earth and subdue it.
01:16:18 They say, if we do this, not only will we make a name for ourselves and ascend to heaven
01:16:21 and be on par with God, but we will let us make a name for ourselves so that we will
01:16:26 not be scattered over the face of the earth, aka so that we will not fulfill the very command
01:16:31 that God has given us, which was to spread out and to fill the earth. And God's mercy,
01:16:35 it is a judgment for their sin of arrogance, but it's also a mercy of them trying to not obey God. 0.91
01:16:42 And the judgment at Babel is God working as a catalyst to really just not to put man 0.88
01:16:51 now on some track that was never the intended good or purpose, but it's actually as a catalyst,
01:16:58 man had gotten off track because of sin and God now in a catalytic way puts him back on track of
01:17:06 spreading out over the face of the earth and then naturally out of that comes certain distinct
01:17:11 distinctions and and cultural distinctions and uh you know and and that's um and that's a good
01:17:18 that that is a natural good and the other thing about that story people i don't think you'll pick
01:17:22 up on it's like they they could they could achieve their their project even though it was like it was
01:17:29 sinful in orientation they could achieve that precisely because they were the same people
01:17:34 like they spoke the same language right like you could achieve great projects i mean they're they
01:17:39 use greatness to evil ends but you can use you can achieve greatness to good ends and how do you do
01:17:45 that well you have to be able to speak each other's language perfectly i know it turns out that like
01:17:48 Once no one speaks the same language, you can't actually fulfill and achieve the same project.
01:17:53 So if you have this, if you essentially recreate the post-judgment babble in America, well, sorry, we're not actually going to achieve any sort of natural greatness for good.
01:18:05 National, yeah.
01:18:06 So the story itself should communicate to us that you need to have similarity in order to achieve anything great.
01:18:13 Amen.
01:18:14 And without it, you actually can't.
01:18:15 One last biblical example for, for the listeners, because I am after all a pastor. And so I, you
01:18:22 know, but one, one other biblical example that I, I'm, I'm sure, you know, you've used a million
01:18:27 times, but just thinking of the apostle Paul, um, there's a, you know, an order of loves,
01:18:33 you know, uh, there, there's a hierarchy and prioritization of commitments and affections.
01:18:38 And, uh, you know, Paul doesn't say, Hey, for the Cretans, I'd be willing to go to hell. Um,
01:18:43 But he says for his own people, Romans 9, you know, for my own kin, my own, you know,
01:18:50 kinsmen according to the flesh, I would be willing to be cut off from the riches and
01:18:54 the mercies of God if it might somehow reconcile them, save them.
01:18:58 And then, you know, back to like benefits, right?
01:19:01 Like, so like physical training is not ultimate value, but it's not no value, it's some value.
01:19:05 Well, then he talks about, you know, the value of heritage and ancestry, you know, and particularly
01:19:10 of the Jewish sort. 0.63
01:19:11 And he says, you know, well, you know, if salvation is for the Gentiles and for the Jews, and it's not, you know, it's according to the promise and not according to the flesh, then of what benefit is there in being a Jew? 0.80
01:19:21 And you would expect him to say, like, it feels like he's building it all up to say, none, you know, boomers for the win, and, you know, race doesn't exist. 0.64
01:19:29 But he doesn't say that. 0.76
01:19:30 He says, well, actually, what benefit is there in being a Jew, even though you can be saved as a Gentile and co-heirs of grace and all that? 0.69
01:19:38 Well, there's still much in every way. 0.80
01:19:40 there's a benefit in being a jew for theirs is the law and theirs is the prophets and and so then i
01:19:44 think of that like in an anglo sense you know like well if if um you know the the white race is you
01:19:52 know not superior and and doesn't have any special promises or you know christianity 2.0 or you know 0.66
01:19:59 we can get salvation you know not just salvation but salvation you know twice we can be saved
01:20:04 three times or you know if there's none of that in the eternal spiritual truest ultimate sense
01:20:09 well then of what advantage is there and being you know of european descent and i feel like i
01:20:14 could answer that much in the way scripture does paul doesn't say well much in every way uh for
01:20:19 theirs are the reformers theirs are the puritans that there is a like paul says here are the
01:20:24 prophets and and here is the law in our history and even though currently we've rejected that
01:20:30 history by you know the jews rejecting the prophets killing the prophets and then you know
01:20:35 killing christ and yet still um that's part of our story and it's a good story it's a great story
01:20:42 that the prophets are in our lineage and i think for the european to say um that you know that
01:20:48 calvin you know and and luther and you know that the the reformers and the puritans are in that
01:20:54 european lineage and to identify with that and to be proud of that um and not a sinful pride but but
01:21:02 a good sense of pride these are my people this is my history um and and i just don't think it's a
01:21:08 coincidence that all that can be defended biblically without being sinfully racist um but the whole
01:21:16 world including much of the church right now wants to demonize that and wants to get particularly
01:21:22 young straight white men to hate their ancestors to to absolutely disobey the fifth commandment
01:21:31 to hate their fathers and to hate their mothers and to hate their heritage and when somebody's 0.82
01:21:36 trying to get you to hate something and like oh it's really bad it's so so bad why is it bad i
01:21:41 can't really you know i can't really back up with substance my argument but it's so bad you should
01:21:44 hate it and it's terrible that like that just that makes me pause i'm like i don't think i will hate
01:21:51 this no i don't think i will you know uh so that i don't know and i think a lot of young men right
01:21:56 now are waking up. And my concern, not to be a concern, bro, but my concern is that there's just
01:22:03 not a lot of good older Christian men in that space to say, you're waking up? Good. You're
01:22:12 right. This is evil. You should hate this. You should hate it. And here's how to hate it well.
01:22:18 Instead, you've got all these guys, pastors in the church saying, oh, you shouldn't be angry at all.
01:22:24 and you know like uh why are you so mad and um are you just jealous and and and and and then
01:22:32 we're shocked when they like flock to nick fuentes or somebody you know like because there's no
01:22:37 reasonable right on on this particular issue especially within you know pastors in the
01:22:42 evangelical church so i'm i'm trying by the grace of god to maybe be a reasonable right you know in
01:22:48 the you're doing it you know as an author and politically and these kinds of and i'm i'm trying
01:22:52 to you know maybe i can be one of the few pastors um that's that doesn't have the you know the race
01:22:58 brain and the you know the boomer mentality so yeah i i mean uh what what i've said before is
01:23:05 that we we tend to be like we tend to view the the western world as this very universal human thing
01:23:11 so any and all can be a part of it um and yet we we are we're also cast as the villains of it
01:23:18 so if you take american history um the history we want to say is the march of progress and freedom
01:23:25 but like who's being marched over or who's the loser in that narrative it's it's the white male
01:23:30 and so essentially the church and the left everyone's basically saying that we have this
01:23:36 progressive narrative of history um and uh and and yet of course we have to cast ourselves as a
01:23:42 villain so it's not surprising again that again people would young men who said wait i don't i'm
01:23:47 i don't want to be a villain i don't want to go through my life as this like self-hating white guy
01:23:50 right um they go to the people who are telling them that no you don't have to be a self-hating
01:23:54 white guy which is you and i are one of those people right um and we're attacked relentlessly 0.51
01:23:59 for for for denying that you have to be a self-hating white guy uh but on the thing of
01:24:05 being proud of of your history and to be european the way i i look at it is like you look at the the 0.91
01:24:10 sort of books look at the works that like that are part of your heritage that you've inherited
01:24:15 um as being someone who's not only american but america as rooted in the old world i mean
01:24:22 everything from shakespeare and then political truth political tradition you have uh you know
01:24:27 everyone from from john locke to the scottish uh the scottish enlightenment all these different
01:24:33 works that um are that reflect uh a a discourse and discussion that's gone over for through
01:24:41 centuries that started and apart from reading the ancient greeks and and the romans and how came to
01:24:48 expression in different places in europe all of that is part of your inheritance and they are
01:24:53 good so they are objectively good in themselves but there are they're also yours i think we should
01:25:00 get away from this idea that you have this that that the the great books of the western tradition
01:25:05 they're in and some are out simply for objective universal human merit um of course they all have
01:25:14 merit but we should also say they're in there because they are distinctly ours you know right
01:25:19 they are our our great books our works that we that when we talk about politics as a westerner
01:25:27 we reference adam smith we reference john locke we reference john calvin or thomas aquinas
01:25:33 um you know because they are part of the broad discussion of our tradition and that's why it
01:25:39 would be weird to to cite you typically some kind of sort of chinese author it would be make a lot
01:25:45 of sense for a some like a someone in china to cite uh to cite a chinese author when it comes
01:25:53 to their political tradition um and perhaps at times it would make sense for us as well but for
01:25:58 the most part if we're talking about the art of war maybe we'll cite you know what's that i was
01:26:03 saying if we're talking about uh fighting in the art of war then that's yeah that's the only time
01:26:07 i hear that yeah certainly there's like some crossover no yeah absolutely but but i mean just
01:26:13 in general in general when when someone cites aquinas or they cite monasque um they they
01:26:22 there's a sense in which there's some authority there even if you disagree there's some seriousness
01:26:28 to it um that needs to be contended with right and and that is true because this is our tradition
01:26:36 and these are the great books that have arisen in that tradition and should be taken seriously
01:26:40 but that'll be different in different places um but but unfortunately either like you go to your
01:26:46 class at like your classical christian school or or college and they'll say oh these just have
01:26:51 objective human worth and that's why they're in and that's why there's movements to like include
01:26:55 international works like non-western or in the canon or in the the curricula because now they're
01:27:02 they're following the logic like well why are you excluding these others if it's just objective human
01:27:07 merit and not something about inheritance but we need to get back to saying no art no like this is
01:27:13 this is ours because they're not as good see i would say i you know i this is controversial but
01:27:19 i would say it's both i would say uh the great tradition western tradition is um is of immense
01:27:24 value because one it's ours everything you're saying it's ours um also uh what's ours is also
01:27:30 best and and i believe that and i think part of the reason i believe that is because c.a it's ours
01:27:36 and i i'm a descendant of this tradition so naturally of course i i think it's best um so i
01:27:42 you know so one it's it's my tradition um but two uh i believe that my tradition is the best
01:27:49 tradition probably in part because it's my tradition so yeah i mean exactly and i don't
01:27:54 think there's anything wrong with that um right and even when even when there's there's things
01:27:59 that would be kind of like people say well why why do we focus on uh like uh the works from
01:28:05 ancient greece when they're so far away from england and there's an argument there but the
01:28:10 fact of the matter is everyone read aristotle everyone read plato and so how can you understand
01:28:15 your own even like from scottish to to anglo to english to french to italian spanish how can you
01:28:23 even understand what they're saying if you haven't read aristotle's ethics or his politics or um you
01:28:30 know plato's republic so uh but yeah yeah so so um affirm your tradition love it and don't don't
01:28:39 let someone say that it's don't don't let them villainize you for saying this is we love it
01:28:45 because it's ours and it's an inheritance yeah don't like don't let the uh the bug eating pod
01:28:52 living regime uh yeah convince you to disobey god and the fifth commandment and hate your father 0.91
01:29:01 and mother that's a sin we that that's a sin so steven thanks for your work and uh thank you for
01:29:07 being willing in a lot of ways to kind of uh be a bit of a trailblazer i mean none of it's really
01:29:14 new if in the big picture of going back to dead guys you know um but uh but in our particular
01:29:19 moment in time sadly we've gotten so far off the rails that uh the things that you've been saying
01:29:25 uh to a lot of you know people today uh are heard as though they're completely novel and nobody has
01:29:31 ever had the unmitigated goal to say such a thing you know before and and yet um you seem perfectly
01:29:37 content to say those things stick to your guns not back down and then you know and then in your
01:29:43 free time uh go hang out with your kids on your farm and play with goats and uh it's great i mean
01:29:50 your ministry and the way that the lord's using you is great because it's um you're providing the
01:29:55 cover fire for for guys like me and some of the guys in the pulpit pastors and we need like you
01:30:00 said more than pastors but you as a non-pastor and being in a little bit less of a cancelable
01:30:06 position. Um, you're using, you're, you're utilizing that, um, that position well and
01:30:12 providing some cover fire. And I hope that more pastors will wake up and see, uh, the cover fire
01:30:17 you're providing and the trail that you're blazing and take advantage of it instead of, uh, just
01:30:23 turning on you and lobbing grenades. Um, but I, I, I don't know. I don't know if you feel this way,
01:30:28 but as a bystander looking in, it does feel hopeful that, you know, that the tide is turning
01:30:34 a little bit. Do you feel that way? Yeah, I think absolutely. Especially among the younger
01:30:39 generations. I think there's some dangers among the younger guys, I think, because they're so
01:30:43 unmoored from a lot of things. But there's also a lot of opportunity that they can break out of
01:30:52 some of the ideology that you see in the older generations. But yeah, I mean, I appreciate what
01:30:58 you have to say, and I try my best. I do, in the spirit of the fifth commandment, I do have to
01:31:02 credit my father for, um, make, for leading me on the, the path to, um, become the sort of thinker
01:31:11 I am today. So I give credit, a lot of credit to him for that. Praise God. All right. Uh, last
01:31:17 thing, how, how can people follow you? Uh, any, any projects on the horizon? Boy, I do have an
01:31:22 event in, uh, are you, I don't know. Yeah. In Texas. Yeah. It's like the, the, the blue, the
01:31:27 true texas conference it's in dallas okay um cj angle is going to be there cool else is going to
01:31:33 be there um i like cj yeah that's in uh yeah and paul gottfried so we're speaking of that
01:31:38 already got media inquiries about how you know you know there's there's nefarious people there
01:31:43 wolf are you you sure you want to associate with those people um but uh i didn't reply back of
01:31:49 course but um i usually mess with the journalists a little bit i i try like i demand that they call
01:31:55 me dr wolf and all sorts of things uh it's kind of fun um but dr jill biden if she can demand then
01:32:01 i think yeah right you're good yeah um yeah oh so also twitter you'll see me it's uh i won't try to
01:32:08 give you my twitter handle but you know you'll see me i'm the guy with 20 000 followers um and
01:32:13 that's that's about it but yeah i have articles american reformer the my speech or talk at the
01:32:19 ogden event will be published there right it's on patreon now if you're a club member on on their
01:32:24 patreon new chrysidham uh new chrysidham press.com slash patreon or something um but it will be
01:32:32 available to the public and then lastly though uh you uh you're starting your own youtube channel
01:32:38 right you want to plug that yeah i'm trying to do that more uh trying to improve you know all
01:32:43 around quality and all that but yeah it said yeah you'll find me there um i think it's like sm wolf
01:32:48 i think it's for steven wolf maybe okay um i don't know i don't know youtube as well just google
01:32:53 steven wolf on youtube i'm sure yeah you'll find me um and uh yeah you can see me there as well
01:32:58 yeah i'm trying to i'm trying to do more of those videos great well thanks for your work
01:33:02 and uh thanks for coming on the show today appreciate it