The NXR Podcast - November 11, 2024


THE INTERVIEW - No Such Thing As Female Angels!? with Tim Chaffey - ICYMI

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
THE SERMON - Christ: The Stability of Our Times - Isaiah 33_1-6 THE LIVESTREAM - "Sinful Ethnic Partiality?" - The Statement on CN & The Reveal Of Baby Mabel

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 18 minutes

Words per minute

186.02

Word count

14,599

Sentence count

560

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

26

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Dr. Tim Chafee returns to the show to finish up our mini-series on the Nephilim, Fallen Angels, and the Giants. In this episode, we cover the most frequently asked questions about the fallen angels and giants.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it.
00:00:04 It's annoying.
00:00:05 Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm so that
00:00:12 our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries
00:00:20 aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 You're doing a great job.
00:00:28 We've got several hundred reviews so far, but we'd like to reach a thousand reviews
00:00:32 by the end of this year, the year of our Lord, 2024.
00:00:36 If you haven't left a review yet, take a moment and help us achieve our goal.
00:00:41 All right, welcome back to another episode of Theology Applied.
00:00:44 I'm your host, Pastor Joel Webbin, here with Right Response Ministries.
00:00:47 This is our fourth and final episode with Dr. Tim Chafee coming back onto the show
00:00:53 to finish our four-part series on the Nephilim, the Watchers. Well, I guess I should start in
00:00:59 order. The Watchers, Fallen Angels, the Nephilim, and the Giants. And today is kind of like a free
00:01:04 safety catch-all where we're kind of just dotting I's and crossing T's and finishing up all the
00:01:11 looming hangover questions that you guys have had, the most commonly asked questions from the
00:01:16 previous three episodes that we've already done. And just to give you a little bit of a sample of
00:01:20 tasting, we're going to talk about is there really such a thing as female angels? We kind of have a 1.00
00:01:26 sneaking suspicion they might all be men. I know that sounds crazy. Hear us out. We've got some
00:01:30 arguments. So are there female angels or are they all male angels? And then male angels, are they
00:01:36 physical, body and spirit, or just spirit? How could they procreate with human female women? 0.97
00:01:43 How does that work? And then we talk about, in addition to all that, how big were giants 0.99
00:01:50 actually? What kind of size did they get to? I think it's fascinating. It's some of the most
00:01:55 fascinating, but also really practical questions, handling some of the most frequent, not only
00:02:01 questions, but objections to this idea that fallen angels that rebelled against God could actually
00:02:06 procreate with human women. A lot of people just think that that's fantastical. I think that's
00:02:10 what the Word of God teaches. So does Dr. Tim Chafee. And I think that between the two of us,
00:02:14 we make a very compelling argument. So tune in now.
00:02:18 Applying God's word to every aspect of life. This is Theology Applied.
00:02:29 All right, welcome back to another episode of Theology Applied. I'm your host, Pastor Joel
00:02:33 Webin with Right Response Ministries. Today, I am joined for the fourth and final time with Dr.
00:02:38 Tim Chafee. We've been doing a mini series, a four-part series. And so if you haven't seen
00:02:43 the first three parts, I encourage you to feel free to watch this video. But if you have any
00:02:47 looming questions, you know, well, they didn't really make a thorough argument because they
00:02:50 didn't answer this objection and they didn't handle this, you know, nuance or whatever.
00:02:54 It's very likely that we actually did address it in one of the previous parts. So I encourage you
00:02:59 to go back and check out the first three episodes. But you don't have to do that preemptively. You're
00:03:04 welcome to stay and just watch this and work your way backwards or forwards, whatever you want to
00:03:08 do. But this is the fourth and final episode dealing with the Nephilim. We're dealing with
00:03:12 fallen angels. We're dealing with the Nephilim. And we're also dealing with their, you know, 1.00
00:03:18 down generations giants. And so that's what we've been dealing with. And today we really want to
00:03:22 focus in on some of the questions that you guys have left for us in the comments and the things
00:03:28 that seem to be the most inquisitive questions, but also the most popular common questions,
00:03:34 right working with you know faqs you know trying to deal with the most frequently asked questions
00:03:39 how can we address all those so this is kind of a final summary video where we dot some i's cross
00:03:45 some t's and without further ado let's go ahead and get started tim chafee thank you for coming
00:03:50 on the show again hey joel it's great to be with you again thanks for having me it's been a lot of
00:03:54 fun so far and i'm looking forward to this one as well all right well let's go ahead and do this you
00:03:58 said that it might be helpful to give obviously we don't want to i mean people can go back and
00:04:03 watch the video. So we want to keep it brief, but it might be helpful for people just to get a
00:04:06 little bit of a refresher. So why don't you take care of that job and recap a little bit of what
00:04:12 we've covered thus far? Yeah. Okay. So some of the objections we get, let me, let me just give
00:04:16 you like a rapid fire type of thing. We, a lot of times I hear people say, well, Jesus said angels
00:04:22 can't do that. And they'll point to Matthew 22, 30. Just very quickly, we've covered that in two
00:04:26 other episodes. So no, Jesus didn't say they cannot do that. He said the ones in who are still
00:04:30 in heaven don't do that so he never said about what the ones who left heaven and are rebelling
00:04:36 what they can or can't do um some people say well this whole issue that you're talking about the
00:04:40 fallen angel view that's all based on the book of enoch uh it's not true uh there's much in this
00:04:45 much about in the bible in the book of enoch is just representing a an interpretation that was
00:04:50 had that people had during the intertestamental period so it aligns with this but it's not based
00:04:54 on the book of enoch uh some people think that the spies were lying in numbers 13 and saying that
00:05:00 the Nephilim were in the land. But we have to remember that the narrator, Moses himself,
00:05:05 tells us earlier in the chapter that the spies actually saw the Anakim there and the Anakim
00:05:10 are of the Nephilim. So there were giants in the land. Some people wonder how it's possible that
00:05:15 people like you and me could think that God would ever allow something so wretched, so perverse.
00:05:21 And all we have to do is look around our culture, our world today. God permits or allows abortion.
00:05:25 He allows murder. He allows rape. He allows all sorts of evil things. Just because that stuff exists, it doesn't mean we get to deny the reality of it. We don't have to be comfortable. We don't have to like it, but it occurs. 0.99
00:05:38 So those are just some of the objections that I hear, or the Bible would never call this marriage between the fallen angels and human women because that's not what biblical marriage is.
00:05:49 Well, Solomon had a thousand wives, princes, and concubines, and that's not ideal either.
00:05:55 If you think about worship in the Bible, you have true worship, and you also have false worship. 0.56
00:06:00 You have the worship of pagan gods, of idols and everything, and you have the true worship of the one true God.
00:06:07 So the same word is used in both cases.
00:06:09 It's just one is what is ideal and what is right versus what is a distortion of that.
00:06:16 Great. Okay, so then let's start there.
00:06:19 with the angels, you know, specifically what you were talking about, you said, Jesus didn't say
00:06:24 they can't do that to, you know, just to explicitly spell out the, that he says, you know, that angels
00:06:29 do not marry in heaven. You know, that when we go to heaven, you know, cause it's, it's one of
00:06:36 those gotcha moments with the religious rulers of the day within, within Judaism, they're, you know, 0.97
00:06:40 trying to, to, you know, to trick Jesus. And so they say, you know, Jesus, if there was this 0.92
00:06:46 hypothetical situation with a woman who had seven husbands, right? And, you know, the first husband
00:06:50 dies, she marries again. The second, you know, not simultaneously, but one's in sequence after
00:06:55 another. The husbands keep dying. She keeps remarrying. And then, you know, eventually has
00:06:59 a total of seven husbands. Which husband will she be married to in the resurrection? And Jesus 0.91
00:07:03 responds and says, you know, in the resurrection, you know, in heaven, we will be as the angels are
00:07:08 who don't marry. And so to use that and say, well, there you have it. Case closed. Out of the mouth
00:07:14 of Christ himself, angels cannot procreate. Well, wait a second, you just eisegeted, you just read
00:07:19 into the text by that word cannot, speaking of ability, rather than what Jesus says they do not
00:07:24 do, speaking of, that's not a prescriptive, that's a descriptive language of this is how it is,
00:07:32 but that's not speaking in terms of possibility, ability. And so angels in heaven don't marry.
00:07:37 rebellious angels who leave heaven, Jesus says nothing about what they can do. And so that's
00:07:45 what's in reference there. But I think that it's interesting. We've explored a little bit of this
00:07:49 in our previous episode, the most recent episode, I think part three, but I think it's worth
00:07:54 exploring again. I am of the persuasion. I think you are, neither of us are definitive, but I think
00:07:59 we both lean in this direction. I'm of the persuasion that one of the reasons angels don't
00:08:04 Mary in heaven is that it's not God's design. It's not his will, but also it is an impossibility
00:08:11 because I truly am, again, not a hundred percent sure, but leaning heavily towards
00:08:18 the possibility that angels are exclusively male. You want to talk about that? What do you think
00:08:23 about that? Yeah, we did cover that a bit in one of the other episodes as well. There's no
00:08:30 indication anywhere in scripture at least no clear indication anywhere in scripture that
00:08:34 um angels could be described as feminine um we there is the one verse that you you and i talked
00:08:40 about in zechariah 5 where it's a vision of these two storks and they're in the feminine but whether
00:08:45 or not that and some people think that they're demons or at least evil spirits uh you know
00:08:50 fallen angels but again it's a vision how much do we read into that and um are they really
00:08:57 representing two individuals um spirits or are they also are they representing maybe nations or
00:09:04 some other corporate entities groups like like the two witnesses in revelation that could be two
00:09:09 individual people but it also could those two you know lots of faithful biblical scholars have
00:09:14 have defined that as a representative of two churches corporate groups of of people and so
00:09:20 to use a vision uh that's just not the strong but when we have a narrative historical narrative like
00:09:26 gabriel you know speaking to mary or uh three angels one of them being the angel of the lord
00:09:31 uh himself but then accompanied with two other angels meeting with abraham and in all these
00:09:36 instances not visions but actual um physical um appearances of angels as as uh historical
00:09:42 narrative in the script they're exclusively man yeah that's right you do have the one
00:09:46 verse in hebrews 13 that talks about how we're supposed to be hospitable to strangers because
00:09:51 some people have entertained angels unaware again it doesn't say therefore someday there's
00:09:55 going to be a female who shows up at your door and you should, you know, welcome her because
00:09:58 it's really a female angel. It doesn't say that it would be within the realm of possibility just
00:10:03 from the textual standpoint, but it is not proof at all that there are female angels. Um, I would
00:10:09 agree with you whenever we do see angels in scripture, whenever they are, whenever their
00:10:13 gender is referenced at all, it's always male, um, masculine. So my, yeah, so thank you. So,
00:10:20 so further fleshing that out, my position, um, and I think you and I are, are pretty linked up
00:10:24 on this. I'm sure there'd be some differences, but, um, my, my position is that, um, so now
00:10:29 taking that, so we we've established that I know is, I know it's not a, you know, hands down
00:10:33 definitive case, but we've, we've made a plausible argument for angels being male. Um, and so it's,
00:10:38 it's a two part, two prong argument. Angels don't marry in heaven one, because there's only dude
00:10:43 angels in heaven, you know, and not chick angels in heaven. Uh, but then two, because it's also 0.99
00:10:47 not God's design and will. So it's, uh, these aren't the angels that are in heaven are not
00:10:51 rebellious angels. They're submitted to the lordship and authority of God as the supreme
00:10:56 being, but also they're male, who would they marry? But on earth, one, you have females, 0.93
00:11:02 not female angels, but you do have female human beings. And then two, these are rebellious angels 0.68
00:11:08 who are no longer submitted to God's will. Now the question is, okay, so if angels are male,
00:11:14 Um, the next thing is though, like, but, but how does, how does one male species, um, mate with a
00:11:21 another female species? And, and so what I would add, uh, now dealing with, with that objection
00:11:27 is, um, I think of David in the Psalms, which is, uh, finds its ultimate highest fulfillment,
00:11:32 um, as the author of Hebrews spells out for us, uh, it has a messianic, uh, fulfillment in Christ.
00:11:38 So that the ultimate interpretation with David's, what I'm about to quote of David in the Psalms
00:11:42 is that Christ ultimately fulfills it.
00:11:45 But David is also,
00:11:47 I think it also is a faithful interpretation
00:11:48 of David means it as it pertains to not just Christ,
00:11:53 but as it pertains to humanity in general as a whole.
00:11:56 And what David says is,
00:11:57 who is man that you are mindful of him
00:12:00 or the son of man that you should care for him?
00:12:03 He's talking about the compassion of God
00:12:05 towards all things considered a puny,
00:12:08 tiny little creature, namely you and I.
00:12:11 But this infinite God who created all things is so compassionate and kind that he loves man, even man, us.
00:12:22 And he says, who is man that you are mindful of him or the son of man that you should show compassion to him?
00:12:27 You made him just a little lower than the angels.
00:12:32 And I understand that this is a fairly literal hermeneutic that I'm about to apply here, but a lot of text should be interpreted literally.
00:12:39 And I take that to mean that a male angel and a female human being would not be likened to a male elephant and a female frog trying to mate.
00:12:56 I take it much more like a little lower.
00:12:58 If man is made just a little lower, and I know that you hold the view that angels like man have likewise been created in the image of God.
00:13:05 So both are image-bearing creatures, and one is only a little lower than the other.
00:13:09 I take it as like two different species separate, but within the canine larger family, like
00:13:16 a Great Dane and a German Shepherd, angel, male, female, human being, and that they
00:13:25 very absolutely could procreate.
00:13:28 And that brings up another thing, just briefly, that I think a lot of times Christians have
00:13:33 a, we over-spiritualize, I think a lot of times, especially modern evangelicals. I think some of
00:13:40 it's Gnostic. I'm not saying this interpretation is hard Gnosticism, you know, that it's heretical
00:13:44 or anything like that. But in general, I think that we have modern Christians having Gnostic 0.65
00:13:49 bent, Gnostic bent and over-spiritualizing bad habit. Angels, as far as we know, they're not
00:13:57 omnipresent like God. God is the most pure spirit without body parts and passions. He's not confined
00:14:01 to a physical location, a physical body.
00:14:05 Christ, the second member of the Godhead,
00:14:07 second member of the Trinity,
00:14:08 he is the God-man, divine, fully God and fully man.
00:14:11 And so he does have a body
00:14:12 and he's seated on a throne physically in heaven
00:14:15 at the right hand of the Father.
00:14:17 But the Father and Christ before the incarnation
00:14:20 and the Spirit are most pure spirits
00:14:23 without body parts and passions and infinite.
00:14:25 But every creature that God made,
00:14:27 both heavenly and earthly creatures,
00:14:29 angels, I don't think there's any reason to think that angels are pure spirit in heaven. And then
00:14:36 whenever there's an angelic appearance on earth, it's actually just a purely spiritual entity
00:14:43 without a body projecting a hologram or an apparition that looks physical. I don't think
00:14:49 that's it. I think it's a physical being, just like human beings. We have both spirit and body,
00:14:54 spirit and body i think angels likewise are spirit and body a spirit with a physical locale
00:14:59 of of the body and when they come to earth they're coming in in in both spirit and body they
00:15:05 actually are appearing in flesh um in their body and and you know uh golly gee what does that body
00:15:12 look like um a lot like ours to the point where even you know the inhabitants of sodom you know
00:15:18 could notice hey there's something different about them like so in their lust and perversion
00:15:22 they were desirable, these angels, but they also weren't sitting there and saying, what's this
00:15:27 crazy monster in town that looks nothing like a human being at all? It was like, no, they stand
00:15:33 out, but also they look like people, enough to where we desire them lustfully and in a perverse
00:15:41 way. And same with the three angels, one being the angel of the Lord, eat with Abraham. So I see
00:15:49 angels is one, I think male, and then two, physical beings, not that unlike human beings
00:15:58 to where they're physical, they're male, they don't mate in heaven because it's not God's will. 0.97
00:16:05 And there's not female angels, but there are female women. And the gap between human beings
00:16:10 and angels is not that big. And these are also angels who, if they come to earth, the ones that
00:16:15 were fallen. They're rebellious, so they're not submitted to God's will. It's not a crazy
00:16:19 position. Anything you think on that? Yeah, I would largely agree with that.
00:16:26 I have a friend who, he argues that Jesus spoke against the fallen angel view in this way. In
00:16:33 fact, he went so far as saying, if the fallen angel's view is true, we can't be saved because
00:16:39 Jesus would have lied, and then Jesus can't be our Savior. Well, where does he say that,
00:16:43 anything like this well uh once jesus rises from the dead and he appears to the disciples
00:16:47 and uh this he says handle me and see for a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see
00:16:52 that i have and so they look at that and they say see jesus said spirits don't have flesh and bones
00:16:57 so how can you how can you argue this well first of all that word spirit is just the greek word
00:17:02 pneuma which means lots of different things translated as our breath or as the wind or as
00:17:07 The Holy Spirit is also used that term.
00:17:13 So spirits, it could be referring to angelic beings.
00:17:17 It could be a ghost that he's talking about.
00:17:19 And that actually seems to be what he's talking about because other translations actually say that.
00:17:26 Like the Net Bible, touch me and see a ghost does not have flesh and bones as you see that I have.
00:17:30 And so he's not saying, I'm not an angel.
00:17:33 They didn't think that he was an angel.
00:17:35 That's not the point.
00:17:36 And so people who make way too much out of that one use of the word, when there's such a broad range, syntactical range of what that word can mean, I think you have to look at the rest of the context of Scripture.
00:17:52 And in this case, when angels appear, they have human form. They can look human enough for the sinful men at Sodom to lust after them.
00:18:06 and want to molest them um they can eat and drink with abraham just before that 0.62
00:18:11 and they can pull a lot by the hand out of the out of the city uh so they can do all sorts of
00:18:16 physical human activity and to me i i think you're right i think they are uh since i believe that
00:18:24 they are also made in god's image then we are in a in a sense that they're they're not so different
00:18:31 than us. And even though they may not have the same exact flesh and blood while they're in
00:18:39 eternity, you know, not in eternity, but while they're in heaven now. But I think if you think
00:18:42 about eternity, this is one area, Joel, you and I, I think would agree on this where maybe our
00:18:48 amillennial brothers would not, but I'm not quite sure where some of them would go on this, but in
00:18:53 the eternal state. So we have new glorified, not new, we have glorified bodies. This body gets
00:19:00 glorified the one that goes into the grave is the one that comes out of the grave but it's glorified
00:19:03 it's transformed paul talks about in first penthouse 15 and we're going to inhabit a new
00:19:08 heavens and a new earth the new jerusalem is described in revelation 21 22 um it's going to
00:19:14 be a physical reality for all eternity it's not floating on the clouds playing harps it's not
00:19:20 a bodiless existence we are meant to have a body and we're going to have a physical body for all
00:19:26 eternity again glorified we're not going to get sore and you know like we do now and achy joints
00:19:31 or anything right um and angels will be there and i don't think that they're just going to be
00:19:37 floating around ethereal spirits i think that they're going to actually have bodies as well
00:19:43 you have heard it said that cash is king well our sponsor private family banking wants you to know
00:19:49 that cash flow is the key to building wealth the partners at private family banking are experts at
00:19:55 teaching you how to implement a new way of thinking about money.
00:19:59 This powerful and innovative approach provides a fail-safe method
00:20:03 for redirecting the cash flow you already have
00:20:07 into a privatized banking system that you now own and control.
00:20:11 This new system places you and your family on the wealth curve
00:20:15 for continuously compounding tax-protected gains
00:20:19 now and unto future generations.
00:20:21 You may also be familiar with the age-old wisdom that the best time to plant a tree for shade was 10 years ago, but the second best time is today.
00:20:32 So, start your journey of building your financial legacy right now.
00:20:37 The sooner you start, the better.
00:20:39 Let a private family banking partner help you put post-mill talk into post-mill action.
00:20:45 Contact them today by emailing banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:20:49 dot com. Again, that's banking at privatefamilybanking.com and request a free step-by-step
00:20:57 wealth-building plan that will be the game changer that you have been looking for. Lastly,
00:21:03 a complimentary discovery call can be scheduled by using the link in this episode's show notes.
00:21:09 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty
00:21:13 before God and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:21:17 The Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied, not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:21:28 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:21:33 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
00:21:39 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, Boldly Deployed.
00:21:42 Are you a Christian who struggles to find companies who align with your convictions?
00:21:49 Do you wish that you could work with Christian brothers rather than pagans who hate everything
00:21:53 you love? You shouldn't have to dedicate your hard work to men or women who support evil.
00:21:59 At Top Knot Alpaca Care, we're looking for mature men who desire hard work and long days
00:22:05 building the kingdom. Your vocation is more important than just the income you bring in
00:22:11 for your family. Your work should equip you with better life skills and deeper relationships than
00:22:17 you could ever get from college. Now, if you can't handle overwhelming smells of things like urine,
00:22:23 feces, and ammonia, wrestling 500-pound llamas, and traveling for months at a time, or being pushed
00:22:30 to grow physically, emotionally, and spiritually, then you need not apply. We're a growing company
00:22:36 with a variety of open positions.
00:22:39 So contact us today
00:22:40 before our interview window closes in January.
00:22:43 Call Elijah at Top Knot
00:22:45 with the phone number that's listed
00:22:46 in the description for this show.
00:22:49 Go to the description.
00:22:50 The phone number for Elijah with Top Knot
00:22:52 will be right there.
00:22:53 Give him a call today.
00:22:55 Right, which is not that crazy to think,
00:22:56 especially when you think of Jesus.
00:23:00 So since the resurrection
00:23:02 and more specifically the ascension,
00:23:06 Notice this, like, so Jesus in his glorified state
00:23:10 after the resurrection, he was able, right?
00:23:13 Because this is important.
00:23:14 So it's like, well, Jesus isn't the only resurrected being.
00:23:17 No, he is actually, currently.
00:23:20 We're all going to be resurrected on the final day.
00:23:22 But Lazarus was not resurrected.
00:23:24 The better word technically would be
00:23:26 he was revitalized, resuscitated.
00:23:30 But when his body came back, and it's sad,
00:23:33 you know, but his body did not come back for good. His body came back to die twice and Lazarus had
00:23:38 to die twice, you know? And so, you know, he did not come back with a glorified body. He came back
00:23:44 with the same body in the same state, but just resuscitated, revived, but not resurrected in
00:23:51 terms of glorified. But Jesus- Which is why Jesus can be called the firstfruits from among the dead.
00:23:57 Exactly. Otherwise Lazarus, you know, or even before him. Exactly. So Jesus, the firstfruits
00:24:03 of being resurrected, glorified body from the dead, same body that he walked on, uh, on earth
00:24:09 in, uh, for, you know, approximately, you know, 33 plus years until, until he was crucified,
00:24:15 same body, but made new, not a new body, meaning another body, same body, but made new in a new
00:24:21 state, a higher state. And, uh, but here's the thing, uh, he wasn't just resurrected. And then,
00:24:25 and then for the last 2000 years, he's hiding out, uh, somewhere alive on earth. Uh, he was
00:24:30 resurrected and then he ascended. And in his glorified state, he was able, we know he was
00:24:36 able to vanish, walk through a door as he, you know, appearing to the disciples, the door was
00:24:42 locked. He walks into the room. So he's able to appear and vanish. And we don't know exactly how
00:24:46 that works in his glorified body state. But in the ascension, he doesn't just disappear after giving
00:24:54 his final words to his disciples. He physically ascends, levitates, goes up into the sky and only
00:25:01 disappears because the text explicitly says he was then hidden behind the clouds. And what I'm
00:25:06 trying to argue to, this is my point, is that Jesus, the God-man in flesh, still in flesh these
00:25:15 past 2,000 years, he went somewhere. And if he is physical, he has a physical body now, he's not
00:25:23 merely physical, but he does have a physical body forevermore, then that physical body can only
00:25:28 exist logically in a physical place. So he didn't go to the 17th dimension that is solely a spiritual
00:25:35 plane. Wherever heaven is, not even just the new heavens on the new earth that is yet to come,
00:25:42 but even heaven now has some, it must have some physical element in the sense that Jesus has a
00:25:49 physical body. He's seated, a physical body can only be seated on a physical throne. And so the
00:25:54 idea that there are physical, other physical creatures, namely angels in this place that is
00:26:00 spiritual, but also has a physical element to encompass, to be the conducive context for
00:26:05 physical beings, none of this is crazy. And I think the fact that what we know, a lot of it
00:26:10 seems like speculation, but if we argue from what's definitive, we know that Jesus right now
00:26:14 has a physical body and he's somewhere and that somewhere is heaven and so we know heaven has to
00:26:20 have even heaven now before the new heavens and the new earth heaven as it currently is has some
00:26:25 physical element to it to where our physical resurrected lord is able to be there and and
00:26:31 and that makes room in my mind for physical angels being there um what do you think about that
00:26:38 argument no i think that's great and i i look at um first corinthians 15 and uh beginning around
00:26:44 42 43 it talks about how there's the the body is so many natural body it's raised a spiritual body
00:26:50 and people look at that and they think oh this is a so you're so it is spiritual no no it's a
00:26:56 body that is dominated by the spirit rather than a body that's dominated by the flesh um it's so
00:27:02 even if you look into the greek on that that is that bears that out and i've got that in the book
00:27:06 But then he goes on. He says the first man is from earth made of dust. The second man is from heaven. And we're going to be like the one from heaven. We're going to be like Jesus was when we are glorified, when we are transformed. And as he just said, he had a physical body that was different than what it was before. He could not die again.
00:27:26 um it's he seemed to have had super certain abilities that are not normal like he said he
00:27:32 whether he walked through a door or not i'm not sure exactly how he got there but somehow he
00:27:37 appeared in their midst when the door was locked so whether he just walks right through it or
00:27:40 said i'm going to teleport right there i'm not sure right yeah yeah i don't know but um that's
00:27:46 different than what we can do yeah yes he's god but he wasn't doing those things prior to that
00:27:52 Right. Right. Yeah. Great point. So what we've been arguing so far, and we'll move on to another
00:27:58 topic, but there's one more piece on this subject that I'd love to address. But what we're arguing
00:28:03 so far is that we think, this one we probably feel a little bit less strongly about, but fairly
00:28:08 strong that angels were male. And then second point that we feel probably a little bit stronger
00:28:13 about is that angels certainly are spirit and physical. They have bodies. So we think they
00:28:17 they definitely have bodies and probably male bodies and perhaps exclusively male bodies and
00:28:24 that those angels as creatures created in the image of God like man are different but not so
00:28:30 different from us that male physical angels could not mate with female physical humans and they
00:28:38 don't do that in heaven but it doesn't mean that they can't do that especially if they're
00:28:43 rebelling against God's will on earth. So none of that is crazy. And to say that Jesus just
00:28:48 is the TKO knockout punch for the fallen angel view is just bad exegesis. The Sethite view might
00:28:55 be right, but not from that argument. That doesn't get you the Sethite view. You're going to have to
00:28:59 do better than that. And so the last thing that I want to say, though, I'm just thinking of one
00:29:03 more objection that our listeners might have. And I know it's a genuine question for me. Well,
00:29:08 what about other biblical texts that don't just talk about angels visiting? Because when there's
00:29:13 an angelic visitation on earth, they do appear human, like Gabriel with Mary. But what about
00:29:20 other biblical texts, like Revelation talking about four living creatures covered in eyes with
00:29:27 six wings and one the head of an ox and the head of a lion, or Ezekiel, like wheels? What would you
00:29:35 say about that? Yeah, I think what that shows us, other than maybe John and Ezekiel
00:29:42 struggled to describe what they were seeing because when you read ezekiel's interpretation
00:29:47 or explanation it's really hard to wrap my mind around what he is actually describing um but
00:29:54 yeah they're they're um i mean i understand the passage in terms of he's seeing god's throne and
00:30:01 these uh cherubim that are there they seem to be you know guardians of god's throne in some
00:30:07 sense and so i get that but in terms of how he's describing it it's strange but we have to
00:30:13 understand that that's not saying every single angelic being looks just like that uh we know
00:30:18 the ones in isaiah 6 they have six wings they cover their feet with two of them they cover
00:30:22 their eyes with two of them and they uh they fly with two of them and you know all day and night
00:30:28 they're proclaiming holy holy holy and um so they have they seem to have a unique role to play and
00:30:36 there are other angelic spirits that were or angelic beings that were given the task of
00:30:44 governing certain areas after especially at babel we see that in deuteronomy 32 8 and then that's
00:30:51 talked about elsewhere we covered that in one of the other episodes as well when we're talking about
00:30:55 the divine council so angels have different roles or different abilities there are different kinds
00:31:00 whether you're talking about seraphim and cherubim and perhaps the B'nai Elohim,
00:31:06 which is the sons of God that we've been talking about.
00:31:10 So we shouldn't just assume all angelic life is exactly like it,
00:31:15 just one type of thing, that God created diversity of life here on planet Earth.
00:31:22 And I think there's a diversity of life in heaven with him.
00:31:27 Good. Yeah, I agree.
00:31:28 so what one option is is it could be the ezekiel text or the revelation for you know text uh could
00:31:34 could be um one it could be a a you know more of a metaphorical uh metaphorical symbolic uh writing
00:31:44 and then number two even if it is literal that's that's entirely possible uh but even if it is
00:31:50 literal this is not a description of every type of angel in heaven um and and it seems like if
00:31:57 If anything, we don't know exactly, but if I had to guess, it seems like if it is literal, it would be a description of a minority type of angel in heaven.
00:32:07 Like there's four, not four million, but four living creatures covered in ice.
00:32:12 Like it's a unique and even higher in terms of, I believe that there's different types of angels and a hierarchy, you know, in heaven.
00:32:21 And so.
00:32:22 And Paul bears that out as well.
00:32:24 Now, maybe this is more with the evil spiritual force, but you have principalities and powers and thrones and dominions. These are spiritual forces, and there is ranking. Now, I don't know if we can have a completely fleshed out view of that, because I don't think the Bible gives us enough detail to do that, but to the point that we can say, yeah, there is some sort of hierarchy and difference in not just rank, but ability.
00:32:49 right um so yeah so it one uh explanation is ezekiel and revelation could be metaphorical
00:32:56 symbolical language the the second explanation is even if it is exactly literal literal a physical
00:33:01 description um then okay great then some angels look really weird but that doesn't mean all angels
00:33:08 look really weird and it seems if anything you could you could buy by uh maybe not explicit
00:33:14 argumentation but implicit you you could say that it seems like at least some angels if not the
00:33:18 majority of angels don't look weird. And those that God commissions to have earthly visitations,
00:33:27 they look a lot like us and we are made just a little lower than them. And they are physical
00:33:31 and they're not merely spiritual. They're spirit and body just as we're spirit and body, both made
00:33:35 in the image of God, looking very similar in many regards. And if they're in rebellion against God's
00:33:41 will because they've fallen to earth, then absolutely plausible that angels could procreate
00:33:47 with, um, with female human beings. That's, it's, uh, it, we could be wrong. We're not omniscient,
00:33:54 but, um, to say that that view is crazy, um, is, um, I just think you're, you know,
00:34:01 you can't back that up. You can, you can say you think it's wrong, but it is, I think it's
00:34:05 certainly a permissible, plausible, reasonable interpretation of scripture.
00:34:10 Yeah, I would agree. And if I can, um, just finish up one other point we were talking about a few
00:34:14 moments ago with the in this eternal state that we're going to have physical bodies in a physical
00:34:19 world that is so foreign to like the modern pop cultural view of of heaven of the eternal of our
00:34:28 afterlife um we so many people think that we're just going to become spirits and stand you know
00:34:34 sing songs 24 7 around the throne and you know for a lot of people that's disheartening because
00:34:40 it seems like that wouldn't that be really boring i don't know that this is really what i'm
00:34:44 looking forward to. And that doesn't sound exciting. Well, that's not what it's going to be.
00:34:48 It's so much more than that. And we're going to have, like I mentioned, physical bodies in a
00:34:55 physical world where there is no more curse, no more sorrow, no more tears. And we get to enjoy
00:35:00 that for eternity in God's presence. So it'll be far better than we can imagine. So I just,
00:35:07 I think it's important for people to think rightly about what our future holds and that
00:35:13 this topic plays right into that. But I guess another objection I hear to what we've been
00:35:18 talking about, and this will shift the gears a little bit, is, Joel, how dare we say that
00:35:23 angels can create life, right? And you've probably heard that. And well, if that's your objection,
00:35:31 good. I'm glad you're thinking that because we don't want to sit here and say, yes, angels are
00:35:35 just as powerful as God. That's not at all what we're saying. They are created beings.
00:35:38 um but look in the mirror and if you have children ask yourself this question did you create life
00:35:46 you procreated and that's what we're talking about here we're not talking about creating
00:35:52 life from scratch from nothing we're talking about procreation um but even before you go
00:35:57 too far down that road people say well but they had to create a body in order to be able to do
00:36:01 no remember we've already talked about how we think they have bodies but um look back at exodus
00:36:07 chapter 7, and this is the passage that everybody's familiar with, with Moses and Aaron coming before
00:36:12 Pharaoh, and Aaron throws down his rod, and it becomes a serpent. And then it says this, it says
00:36:17 that Pharaoh called his wise men and sorcerers, so the magicians of Egypt, they also did in like
00:36:24 manner with their enchantments, or with their dark arts, through their occult abilities. Every man
00:36:29 threw down his rod, and they became serpents. They did the same thing that Aaron, that God did to 0.60
00:36:36 aaron's staff now i'm not saying that every single fallen angel or evil spirit can do the exact same
00:36:43 thing i'm not saying they can do that whenever they want but for for his purposes at this point
00:36:49 god allowed them to do that they had the ability to do that and of course we know what happened
00:36:53 aaron's rod swallowed theirs up showing that the god of israel yahweh is still more powerful than
00:36:59 them no matter how impressive that feat was right but but they transformed sticks rods into
00:37:07 serpents so i think we we have to be careful and you were i think you were talking about earlier
00:37:13 that we um almost like a gnostic view we it's it's weird we we over spiritualize and at the
00:37:23 same time under spiritualize yeah it's it's like christians today modern evangelicals especially i
00:37:29 I I've been thinking about this a lot lately lately I think on one hand we've adopted way
00:37:34 too much of Darwin uh so on one hand we're like we're um we're we've been disenchanted
00:37:40 since I think since the enlightenment which the enlightenment you know I think was really the
00:37:45 beginning of of the dark ages of secular humanism and then you know and the the dark so-called dark
00:37:51 ages I think actually weren't quite as dark as our modern historians try to make them out to be
00:37:56 when people actually still believed in God, or even if they weren't Christian, they believed in
00:38:00 God's pagans. G.K. Chesterton talks about, you know, paganism is, and C.S. Lewis says the same
00:38:06 thing. The step from paganism to Christianity is a smaller step than the step from Darwinian
00:38:12 secular humanism. You know, when the world has completely lost its enchantment and the world is
00:38:17 just material, you're just a raw materialist. So on the one hand, I think Christians have bought 1.00
00:38:21 that narrative of, you know, modern post-modernism and secular humanism that, um, on one hand we've
00:38:28 under spiritualized and we're materialist. The world is just stuff. On the other hand, uh, it's
00:38:33 weird. I don't know how we do it, but, uh, we simultaneously over spiritualize. So anything we
00:38:37 read in the Bible, um, we, we think it's fantastical and spiritual, but then we think
00:38:43 that we live in this world that's entirely material and, and physical. And, and so then
00:38:48 what we do is we just we we create this massive chasm between heaven and earth the the you know
00:38:54 what god does this here and and then what happens here and what happens here all can be explained by
00:38:59 uh newton and this and that you know and there's nothing supernatural at all and then over there
00:39:03 it's it's there's nothing physical at all it's all spiritual 17th dimension and and i think that's
00:39:09 the framework that that moderns uh westerners uh have even among christians that makes the
00:39:17 procreation between angels and women seemed preposterous um but the ancients didn't think
00:39:22 like that that's a fairly modern view you know that didn't happen until you know at a certain
00:39:28 point in church history not it didn't happen for what 400 years for 400 years nobody even thought
00:39:33 the sethite view wasn't it augustine that was the first augustine was the one who popularized it
00:39:38 you know and gotcha a couple generations before him there are a few people who held it but yeah
00:39:42 he popularized it and then that dominated from then on.
00:39:45 And then Calvin doesn't even have to make an argument.
00:39:48 He just says,
00:39:48 Oh,
00:39:49 that fallen angel view. 0.82
00:39:50 We all know that's silly, 0.80
00:39:51 which is very like, 0.62
00:39:53 that's a,
00:39:53 what I would call rare,
00:39:54 uh,
00:39:55 rare Calvin L,
00:39:56 uh,
00:39:57 lose.
00:39:58 Um,
00:39:58 because I like Calvin,
00:39:59 as you know,
00:40:00 uh,
00:40:00 you know,
00:40:01 and,
00:40:01 and he usually is a robust in his argumentation for any point that he ever
00:40:05 makes.
00:40:05 But that one,
00:40:06 um,
00:40:07 he doesn't make a few times where he just kind of either throws up his
00:40:09 hands or he just kind of mocks it because he doesn't like it.
00:40:12 But,
00:40:12 Yeah, usually he does do his best to exegete the text.
00:40:16 And so whether you agree or disagree, you can at least respect that part of it.
00:40:19 But yeah, in this one, he, yeah.
00:40:22 But another passage that I think is important to think about, and I think you and I would probably interpret who this is talking about differently or how, what's being referred to.
00:40:30 But in 2 Thessalonians 2, 9, it's talking about the lawless one.
00:40:34 You know, a lot of times, like dispensational, premillennial, pre-tribency, this is like the Antichrist.
00:40:38 But not even talking about that.
00:40:40 look what it says about this the lawless one whoever or whatever that might be the coming
00:40:46 of the lawless one is according to the working of satan with all power signs and lying wonder
00:40:51 so how much ability how much power does satan have or some of these evil
00:40:59 spiritual beings it says here all power signs and lying wonder and say fake power and fake signs
00:41:08 it's he's deceiving people with these real things is what it's describing so that they do have
00:41:14 tremendous ability and i think it's it's dangerous for us to underestimate them but at the same time
00:41:19 i think it's people overestimate them as well that you know like say they some people think
00:41:25 satan's omnipresent that he's he's tempting them right now and all that a lot of people think he's
00:41:30 omniscient they think satan can read your thoughts yeah you know i mean i think satan is better than
00:41:37 like if a human humans are not omniscient we can't read thoughts but if if the best
00:41:41 human interrogator can pick up on you know mannerisms and social cues and and be in a
00:41:47 room with someone without them saying and get really close and just watching them into the
00:41:51 so i think you know satan is like you know um you know exponentially uh more talented and
00:41:59 perceptive like he's he's nothing to be trifled with he satan is greater than you he's not greater
00:42:04 than God, but he, you know, greater is he that is in you, not you, but he that is in you than
00:42:08 he who is in the world. Um, but so, but, but if it's just us apart from God, Satan is, is not our
00:42:13 peer. He is, he is, um, vastly superior to us, but not infinite. And so, uh, I think Satan, um, is
00:42:19 very, very perceptive and very good at, at, um, at, um, concluding and, and deriving, um, uh,
00:42:27 deliberating our, our thoughts and, and, and knowing our temptations and those kinds of things.
00:42:32 but he some people think like if i just think a thought in my mind they attribute
00:42:37 attributes that are exclusive to god to satan satan is not an equal to god all right that's
00:42:44 it guys i tried to warn you the time has finally arrived our early bird pricing is gone but don't
00:42:50 despair we've gone above and beyond to make this conference affordable to all so even now it's only
00:42:56 170 bucks for an adult it's cheap for teenagers and free for kids what am i talking about well
00:43:03 i'm talking about the christ is king conference how to defeat trash world it's happening april 3rd
00:43:09 4th and 5th the year of our lord 2025 that's a thursday friday saturday three full days jam
00:43:16 packed with eight main sessions three panels and an extraordinarily based lineup of speakers we've
00:43:22 got Steve Dace, Orrin McIntyre, Andrew Isker, David Reese, Stephen Wolfe, Eric Kahn, John Harris,
00:43:30 Aidy Robles, Dan Burkholder, Ben Garrett, Dusty Devers, the Christian Prince himself, and yours
00:43:36 truly, Joel Webber. Sign up today. Don't miss this conference, and I'll give you a little bit of a
00:43:42 secret here. There's a couple more potential speakers in the wings. I haven't completely
00:43:48 confirmed yet, so I cannot disclose, but I'll say this. If it happens, it's going to blow your mind.
00:43:53 So register at rightresponseconference.com. Again, that's rightresponseconference.com.
00:43:59 Register today. Are you a Christian struggling to find companies that align with your values
00:44:04 and beliefs? Well, then Squirrely Joe's has you covered for all your coffee needs.
00:44:09 All of their coffee is hand-selected and roasted fresh every day by a family of fellow believers.
00:44:14 Try them out and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your investment supports a company committed to following God's teachings and upholding truth and righteousness, ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the growth of God's kingdom.
00:44:31 Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil. 0.58
00:44:35 Right Response listeners have access to an exclusive deal.
00:44:39 Your first bag of coffee is free.
00:44:42 All you have to do is cover the shipping.
00:44:44 So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response.
00:44:49 Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response to claim your first free bag
00:44:56 of coffee today. 0.94
00:44:57 Visit thewordsoap.com today.
00:44:59 Again, that's thewordsoap.com 0.76
00:45:02 Everyone needs soap, so wash yourself in the Word.
00:45:10 Yeah, and he does have power as well.
00:45:13 You look at the beginning of Job, he's able to call down fire from heaven, whether that's lightning or actual fire.
00:45:18 So he's able to do certain things, but again, it's only when God permits it.
00:45:22 Because if you think of Elijah and the prophets of Baal, you know, when they're having this competition about lighting the altar on fire.
00:45:29 Well, according to the book of Job, Satan is capable of doing it.
00:45:33 So if he's there, if he's one of the rebels who are there behind the prophets of Baal, he can't do it that day because God's not allowing him to do it that day.
00:45:43 But he seems to be capable of that sometimes.
00:45:46 So, yeah, my point is we shouldn't just automatically assume we know the abilities or capabilities of angels when the Bible tells us a fair amount of some things that they can do that are far beyond our ability.
00:46:00 But at the same time, and what you said is exactly right, greater is he who is in us than he who is in the world.
00:46:05 So we don't need to fear them, but we should have a healthy respect for them.
00:46:11 Yeah, amen.
00:46:12 um going back one more thing and then and then i'll just uh you you i'll let you steer the
00:46:17 conversation for where you want to go next but um with the tower of babel and in terms of princes
00:46:22 and principalities principalities i i you know understand that as uh regions areas and then
00:46:28 princes being you know uh fallen angels that were um set up over um you know that had dominion over
00:46:35 certain principalities and regions um with that i and this is just another genuine question that i i
00:46:41 I don't know the answer, um, would, I certainly see that being as like regions being indicative
00:46:46 of nations and peoples and things like that.
00:46:48 Um, but, uh, would there be, or possibly be, uh, fallen angels over the realm of the ocean
00:46:57 that might like a fill it, you know, Philistines that that's where, you know, giants ended up
00:47:02 like Goliath and his brothers, you know, and we know that, uh, Joshua killed a lot of them.
00:47:06 The ones that, that, um, got away, went to Gath and, you know, Goliath is from Gath or,
00:47:10 you know and then gaza and some other places and then and then later on you know in the time of
00:47:14 david that you have the philistines they have giants uh you know descendants from the nephilim
00:47:19 but then also like one of their they've got their polytheists but one of their chief gods is a fish
00:47:25 god dagon you know and so and then i'm thinking about that and then i'm thinking about the greeks
00:47:30 and and maybe it's the same thing but just the greeks have a different name for them a different
00:47:33 conception you know but like um you know or the romans and like uh poseidon and and i'm wondering
00:47:38 Could one of these kind of Elohim, you know, sons of God, have not just a realm over land and a people group, a nation, but over the ocean or part of the ocean or something?
00:47:54 What do you think about that? 0.99
00:47:55 Yeah, I don't see why not.
00:47:56 I mean, Adam was given dominion over the rule over the birds of the air, the fish of the sea, you know, and the beasts of the earth, obviously.
00:48:05 So mankind was supposed to rule this earth as God's vice-regioner, and yet Adam, in a sense, yielded that dominion when he rebelled, when he sinned. 0.70
00:48:17 And then what we see at the Babel event, man rebels again, and God puts them under the subjection of these other entities.
00:48:25 So if the original dominion mandate included the fish of the sea, which it does, then, yeah, I don't know why they wouldn't also have that as well. 0.79
00:48:39 And then going back to what you said earlier, you said, you know, the ability to call fire out of heaven, but like any creature, not just angels, but any creature, only underneath the banner of the sovereignty of God, what he allows.
00:48:51 And so not able to call down fire on that particular day,
00:48:53 the showdown between the prophets of Baal and Elijah,
00:48:56 but able to do it in the book of Job.
00:48:58 Another example from the book of Job is Satan had the power to control wind.
00:49:03 And I know that almost sounds blasphemous
00:49:05 because the disciples say to Jesus on the boat in the middle of the storm,
00:49:08 who is this who has authority to where even the wind and the waves obey him?
00:49:12 And certainly Jesus is God.
00:49:14 And so he has the supreme authority over the created order.
00:49:17 But that doesn't necessarily mean that there's no other creature that he's given also that ability.
00:49:25 And so I'm thinking of when, just to explicitly state the example, it's when God gives permission to Satan to torment Job, but before he has authority to afflict his body.
00:49:35 And then later on, he can afflict his body, but he can't kill him.
00:49:38 But in the first phase of torment, you can do anything to him, but you can't hurt his physical person.
00:49:42 And one of the things that he does is he kills all of Job's children by sending a great wind.
00:49:50 It seems as though he has power and control over the wind to cause the house where Job's children are to collapse on them and kill them.
00:49:58 And so back to my Poseidon theory, is it possible that, you know, fallen angels could have dominion over the sea, and then within that dominion over the sea, even a measure of control in what God may allow over wind and waves?
00:50:16 Yeah, I think that's totally reasonable.
00:50:18 Yeah, Job 119 is the verse that you're citing, that suddenly a great wind came from across the wilderness and struck the four corners of the house.
00:50:24 And yeah, so I think that's entirely reasonable.
00:50:28 and consistent with what we see in scripture.
00:50:30 Cool.
00:50:31 Poseidon is a real being,
00:50:33 but it turns out shock.
00:50:35 All the Percy Jackson fans right now are excited.
00:50:37 So you heard it first,
00:50:38 Tim Chafee,
00:50:39 he has confirmed my theory.
00:50:40 Poseidon is real.
00:50:42 That's the good news.
00:50:43 Bad news. 0.99
00:50:44 He's a demon. 1.00
00:50:45 Or Neptune for you Romans out there. 1.00
00:50:47 Yeah, there you go. 1.00
00:50:48 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:50:49 Neptune, old Neptune.
00:50:50 All right.
00:50:51 So rest of the episode,
00:50:52 I don't have a whole lot more time,
00:50:54 but why don't you take 15, 20 minutes
00:50:56 and just anything you want to talk about.
00:50:58 You get the objections more than I do
00:51:00 because this is, I like this stuff,
00:51:01 but this is your specialty.
00:51:04 So why don't you just cover any base
00:51:07 that you think our listeners,
00:51:08 after all four episodes,
00:51:09 might still have this hanging,
00:51:11 looming question or objection.
00:51:12 Okay.
00:51:13 You know, get all your thoughts out.
00:51:15 Well, because we're not going to be able
00:51:17 to cover everything first,
00:51:18 you got to buy the book Fallen.
00:51:19 There you go.
00:51:20 Many people have.
00:51:21 So the sales have gone up
00:51:22 since your videos went up.
00:51:23 So I like that.
00:51:24 Awesome.
00:51:24 and keep keep on supporting it i appreciate that and uh several positive reviews too so i'm glad
00:51:30 for that thanks for doing that hold it up one more time uh tim just because some people will
00:51:34 um be watching but then also let's say the name because some people only listen
00:51:38 yeah fallen the sons of god and the nephilim by tim chafee that's me amazon uh is that where you
00:51:44 want them to go on amazon or if they go to my website they can still get 15 off and a signed
00:51:50 copy as well. So we've seen an increase in sales in both. So that's great. So one thing you and I
00:51:56 talked about before we came on, we talked about how there were no female angels, but we do think
00:52:01 that there probably were female giants, or at least I think there probably were. So the reason
00:52:08 for that is, first, the Bible never says they're not, that there aren't. So that doesn't prove
00:52:15 there were, but it does talk about certain clans like the Emim and the Zuzim. It talks about how
00:52:21 they were a people as great and as tall as the Anakim. So as a people group, they were tall.
00:52:28 And of course, if there's going to be an entire clan where they're perpetuating these giants,
00:52:34 you need females as part of that. As we've talked about, you need male and female. So it seems as
00:52:38 if the entire people group were giants, meaning that there would be female giants.
00:52:43 um maybe a parallel speaking of greek mythology like we were just talking about um you had the
00:52:49 amazons uh who were like these demigods goddesses um they they were often considered to be a giant
00:52:57 tesses um the we talked about before with the potential connection to like the odyssey
00:53:03 uh when he when his men land on the when he goes to the island of listrigonians there are
00:53:08 giantesses there that are described um again that doesn't prove my point but it's just it's
00:53:15 completely consistent with it um so and you have that in other mythologies as well that
00:53:20 seem to i think what we're seeing in some of these mythologies are um distorted echoes of
00:53:28 what really took place on this planet in some cases so when you have the gods coming down and
00:53:34 marrying women and having demigods the giants and everything i i think that is going right back to
00:53:40 what happened in genesis 6 and also afterward after the flood and so some people will look at
00:53:45 that and say well you're just borrowing from greek mythology aren't you sam i mean this whole fallen
00:53:48 angel view that's just copying greek mythology actually it's the other way around that's right
00:53:52 and what i found to be really ironic well let me i wouldn't say quite the other way around it's not
00:53:58 what both are describing what really happened one is describing it perfectly accurately because
00:54:05 part of god's inspired word that's the bible the other one is the distorted version of that that's
00:54:10 been passed down generation after generation after generation and it gets distorted a little bit
00:54:15 and embellished but what i found really interesting is a lot of times that people who hold the set
00:54:19 they'll use this objection that oh you're just borrowing greek mythology actually the shoe is on
00:54:26 the other foot because what we are doing is just interpreting the text for what it says and we
00:54:31 don't have to spiritualize the meaning of anything that we don't have to look for a non-straightforward
00:54:36 meaning on this passage and what's happening is that in so many of these cases they're resorting
00:54:41 to allegorizing the text well where did allegory as a hermeneutic come from and you can trace it
00:54:48 back to the uh greek philosophers in about the sixth century bc and there's a book by i think
00:54:57 his name is luke bassan he there was his um he's a french guy that was his dissertation um but it
00:55:03 was called how philosophy saved myth and what he was talking about is the the philosophers in the
00:55:09 sixth and fifth centuries bc uh the greek philosophers that the greek people loved homer
00:55:14 and Hesiod. This was, in a sense, their Bible. This was their story of origins. This is what
00:55:20 happened in the past. This is where they came from. And they didn't want to get rid of those
00:55:24 stories because as people started to become more and more modern and realize that some of these 0.55
00:55:29 things sound a little ridiculous. And do we really like the idea of Zeus coming down and marrying
00:55:34 and having offspring with this woman, and yet he's supposed to be with Hera? And then, no,
00:55:39 he's also going down and having an affair here and now an affair here. And they don't seem like
00:55:43 the most moral of characters. So people started to disbelieve in them. And so what the philosophers
00:55:50 did is they invented this new hermeneutic, which is that you allegorize it, you've changed.
00:55:55 Zeus isn't really a god. He's just now this force. He is now, he stands in for something else. So
00:56:01 that way we can keep the stories of Homer and Hesiod and we can still enjoy them. But we
00:56:06 understand it's not real. It's not reality in any way. We just reinterpreted it. It means something
00:56:11 else and then of course that idea that kind of philosophy made its way to alexandria which is
00:56:17 where a lot of this allegorical interpretation came from and the augustine got that from ambrose
00:56:26 that whole approach and so you the the set site view is actually the one that is borrowing from
00:56:33 greek mythology and so it's very ironic i know that might have sounded around a roundabout way
00:56:38 to get there. But the Fallen Angel view is a very straightforward view, which is why it was the
00:56:43 earliest view and the only view that we know of during the intertestamental period and the first
00:56:48 couple centuries of the church. It was straightforward.
00:56:52 Yeah, that's really good. Any other things you want to add? Any other loopholes you want to try
00:56:57 to close?
00:56:59 Yeah, so I get a lot of people asking about some of the modern things that we see. And,
00:57:05 you know tim i'd really like your thoughts on this even after you know hearing what we've talked
00:57:10 about um and i said you know my goal was to create or to write what was really the most
00:57:14 detailed or most serious bible study on this topic available not to get into all of the
00:57:19 sensationalism and so people still say okay but what do you think about these modern reports of
00:57:25 giants like the kandahar giant um this report that back in 2002 in afghanistan uh it's pretty
00:57:32 cool i'm not gonna lie it's a really cool story i'm not saying it's true i'm rooting for it i know
00:57:37 it's it's not plausible but go ahead yeah yeah it's it's it's a cool story these other than some
00:57:43 of our servicemen were killed that's not great right yeah yeah you're right yeah yeah so the
00:57:46 idea is that they they encountered up in the mountains of afghanistan this this 13 to 16 foot
00:57:51 giant who killed a couple of them and then they had to shoot at them with you know the machine
00:57:55 guns for 30 seconds before they finally dropped them and then of course the military came and
00:57:59 whisked them away and nobody knows what happened to the body.
00:58:03 And of course, they describe him with six fingers and six toes, which just so everybody
00:58:07 knows, the Bible does not say all the giants have six fingers and six toes.
00:58:11 There is one man described that way in the Bible, and he is a giant.
00:58:16 But people today who are not giants are born with either six fingers or six toes.
00:58:21 It's just called polydactyly.
00:58:22 And there are a lot of examples.
00:58:23 You can look at x-rays of it.
00:58:24 It looks really weird.
00:58:26 I think we've all seen it before on Prince's Bride, right?
00:58:29 the six-fingered man count rugan um but it's just a it's something that happens it's just
00:58:34 a genetic duplication and it's usually like the the ring finger gets duplicated so you have two
00:58:39 of those and yeah but it could be one of the other fingers as well so yeah giants didn't have to be
00:58:45 like that same thing sort of like with the solomon island giants people ask about that
00:58:49 solomon islands are pretty remote kind of in between uh australia and fiji a little bit north
00:58:54 of that and there are reports of these giants living in caves in the inner parts of the island
00:59:00 and nobody goes there because they disappear and or they get eaten but again i'm not opposed to the
00:59:08 idea that there could still be some remnants of giants existing because i think giants did exist
00:59:12 on this earth and i think the bible describes that but in this day and age when we have cell
00:59:17 phones and so many people no matter which country whether your first world second world third world
00:59:21 So many people have cell phones with cameras. Somebody somewhere at some time or with a drone could get pretty good footage if these, I think, could get good footage if these people are still around.
00:59:34 So until I have some hard evidence of that rather than just anecdotal evidence on the Internet, I'm not going to base my arguments on this at all.
00:59:47 I'd rather just see what the Bible says. And if it says there were giants, OK, there were giants.
00:59:51 Right. Yeah, that's our position. What we're convicted of is that there were giants. What I'm open to is that there might still be giants. But my argument is not that there were giants, and that's what the Bible says, because I can show you giants today. No, my argument is there were giants, because the Bible says there were giants.
01:00:09 Yeah.
01:00:10 And I would have, you know, I think you and I would probably share this as well.
01:00:13 It's a little bit different topic, but it's the same idea that, you know,
01:00:16 there's some people who think there are maybe some dinosaurs existing somewhere in remote places,
01:00:20 like in the Likawala Swamp of Cameroon and the Congo, you know,
01:00:24 it's just this huge unexplored area and there are reports of it.
01:00:27 Well, again, somebody get really good footage of it and maybe I would go for it.
01:00:32 It wouldn't be surprising to me.
01:00:34 As a Young Earth creationist, dinosaurs were on the ark and they got off the ark
01:00:37 and they didn't live that long ago i think they're probably extinct but maybe there's still
01:00:42 a few around um i don't need them around to believe it that that they were there and that
01:00:47 they were on the ark but um yeah so i think that's a very similar idea we because this
01:00:53 scriptures tell us something we believe that to be true and as a result yeah this could still be
01:00:57 going on but let's not let's not focus on the modern um sensational idea like some people do
01:01:06 those are the youtube videos i get a lot of views it's true if i made a video that said i saw the
01:01:12 island the giants on solomon island then i'd probably get a lot of views but um i'd rather
01:01:17 focus on what scripture says same thing goes for the the reports about north american giants in
01:01:22 the 1800s and early 1900s six fingers six toes red hair double rows of teeth it's very similar
01:01:28 to these other ones again plausible within the realm of possibility sure do i really think they
01:01:33 were there i not i don't think so but maybe i yeah it's it's not a big deal to me one way or the
01:01:41 other um or related to that did you know some people think that we need the nephilim because
01:01:46 they built like the great pyramid right we need really big people to build really big things well
01:01:51 no you you need smart people ingenious people to build really big things um people are
01:02:00 people who do construction and figure things out like this are very intelligent and they are
01:02:06 capable of of doing things that are my mind doesn't work that way um i watched a demonstration
01:02:12 of how maybe they would have got some of the obelisks up you know if you've seen the movie
01:02:15 the ten commandments you have the push pull men you have you know 10 000 people getting ready to
01:02:19 move the stone and one demonstration was what if they just use a giant kite and use wind power
01:02:24 and you just cut the rope at the right time then you just think you work smarter not harder
01:02:30 And maybe that is how they did things.
01:02:33 Now, I'm not saying just in every case, but over in Israel, you can see in certain locations.
01:02:42 What's the name of the city that we visited?
01:02:43 The ruins that we visited. 0.97
01:02:46 There is a, I think it's Bet-Shien.
01:02:49 It's just south of Galilee, of the Sea of Galilee.
01:02:53 And pretty close, just east of Mount Gilboa.
01:02:55 there's a place where you can see
01:02:57 like this
01:02:59 almost like how they would have moved the big
01:03:01 stones that you see down
01:03:03 in the western wall and everything
01:03:05 the ashlar
01:03:07 stones during Harrod's time they would actually
01:03:09 build the wheels around them and then
01:03:11 stones become the axle
01:03:12 so
01:03:15 that's how you move something really big well my mind
01:03:17 I would have thought how do we get enough people
01:03:19 to lift this thing up and carry it or
01:03:21 roll it across logs or something well how about
01:03:23 you just make that the axle and you roll it
01:03:25 hmm so yeah people are creative we don't have to think that really big people needed to be here to
01:03:33 move these really big things yeah that's a really good point um yeah it's entirely possible the
01:03:39 giants uh did set up stone hinge or something like that but uh but it's not yeah i'm not yeah
01:03:43 and i should clarify i'm not saying that they didn't help obviously if you have somebody who's
01:03:47 four times the strength that could help that's helpful so that's possible but you're right it's
01:03:52 not absolutely necessary. And, but, you know, so whether it was giant, you know, it may have been
01:03:56 giants or it may have been just know-how, ingenuity, which is possible just because man's
01:04:01 created in the image of God. And contrary to popular belief, we're not the first generation
01:04:06 of intelligent people. In fact, I would argue our generation is kind of a little bit dumber than I 0.99
01:04:12 would like. And I think some past generations were actually smarter than us. We may have more access 0.99
01:04:17 to technology and things like that, but I don't think that we're necessarily smarter. So there
01:04:21 were genius people in the antediluvian age and geniuses after. And also I was going to say whether 0.90
01:04:28 giants aided and helped or whether fallen angels taught their offspring and then descendants taught
01:04:35 them certain techniques and skills and tricks of the trade and carried down, passed down certain
01:04:44 technologies that allowed without the aid of giants, giants still existing, but without the
01:04:49 of giants, just having knowledge of certain engineering and mechanics and physics to be
01:04:57 able to make things happen. That's entirely possible. And in terms of just, so knowledge
01:05:03 and fallen angels passing down knowledge and then man himself being created in God's image and being
01:05:07 smart and having certain people that were genius, just like we have today, certain people that are
01:05:10 really smart. And then also giants as possible could come to the aid with certain things. And
01:05:18 then uh the last thing i was going to say also just uh sheer numbers you could have just a lot
01:05:22 of people you know moving like you know um you know in charles heston you know like uh you know
01:05:27 the um the ten commandments like just a lot of people moving something big and and with uh that
01:05:33 you know in ancient civilizations i think that's another thing number one we're not the first
01:05:37 generation to be smart but i also have a sneaking suspicion this one i can't prove as much but i
01:05:42 have a sneaking suspicion that we're not the first generation to be uh large numerically um i i i
01:05:49 understand statistically um in terms of um you know the entire population combined a cumulative
01:05:57 population of people up until the time of christ you know a lot of people argue being relatively
01:06:02 small um i i think that's true if we're saying post-flood to the time of christ um i think that's
01:06:09 true looking looking at the population how it's exponentially grown and sadly uh the west needs to
01:06:15 uh be fruitful multiply because we're starting to shrink but um but i do have some suspicions
01:06:21 just speculation ideas about um you know before the flood uh with you know in the case of adam
01:06:28 and several 900 year plus lifespans and um and in terms of fertility there's nothing in the bible
01:06:35 that tells us, you know, that a woman is, you know, like Eve is, we don't know. I mean,
01:06:39 she could have lived for 700 years, 800 years. Um, and she could have been fertile for 600 years 0.64
01:06:44 and, um, they're being fruitful and multiply. Like we, you know, I mean, Adam and Eve, you know,
01:06:50 had other sons and daughters. We don't know how many, it could have been seven other sons and
01:06:53 daughters. It could have been, um, yeah, 70, or it could have been a couple of hundred, you know,
01:06:59 and that's just one couple. And, you know, and then span that out and exponentially, I heard
01:07:04 one guy and i'm not even saying this is true but i heard one guy his estimation he did like some
01:07:09 it was just it was intriguing i don't know if it was true but it was intriguing the way he did the
01:07:13 numbers and said that there could have been 11 billion people in the 1500 year time period from
01:07:18 adam to the flood uh a larger population than today that's crazy go ahead we have calculations
01:07:26 that the arc showing even if you use the modern growth rate you would get to uh trying to remember
01:07:32 it's like 400 million but even if you go up just like one tenth of one percent suddenly you're up
01:07:37 into like the four billion range and then wow you go up one tenth you get like 18 billion or some
01:07:42 crazy number um so it's very possible they had a high population before the flood so it could be
01:07:48 with a margin of error 400 million to 18 billion yes yeah if i remember the numbers correctly but
01:07:55 it's just it doesn't take much when you got exponential growth so giants could could build
01:08:01 pyramids but also um a few million people working together that's you know that's also uh pretty
01:08:08 pretty yeah and i would say pyramids are post-flood but yeah they absolutely they could
01:08:13 right yeah um i know we're running low on time i got one other thing i wanted to real quickly
01:08:18 bring up because i hear this all the time like oh yeah i believe in giants too i see them playing
01:08:22 on tv in the nba that is not what we're talking about really tall people today are not what we're
01:08:27 talking about um you know you look at the the tv shows there were like the tallest people on earth
01:08:31 and um i i knew the the guy who was the tallest person in america for several years until he
01:08:37 passed away about three years ago i um igor vav kavinski his name was he used to when he was 13
01:08:43 he was my height and he used to come into the store that i worked at and i talked to him a few
01:08:46 times and um he ended up being like 7 7 11 i think he got to or something and um but um that is not
01:08:55 or we're talking about somebody who's got a growth on the pituitary gland
01:08:58 or something, you know, some tumor that causes them to grow super fast
01:09:02 and they're trying to, doctors are trying to slow the growth
01:09:04 or maybe it's Marfan syndrome where usually that affects the joints
01:09:08 and it allows people to get taller, but not super tall.
01:09:11 Maybe they're more like 6'5", 6'6",
01:09:13 but then a lot of times they're weaker as a result too.
01:09:16 We're talking about people who are warriors,
01:09:18 people who are sons of other giants,
01:09:20 whereas in these cases, they're not.
01:09:22 it's not something that is passed down generation after generation it's just one
01:09:27 mutation or something that has caused that particular person so what the bible is describing
01:09:33 something very different people who are not necessarily awkward or clumsy or going to die
01:09:39 at a very early age because of their size or something their their entire clans or groups of
01:09:45 people and generation after generation who are giants i okay one final question for me this
01:09:51 it just came to my mind it's random but if angels male physical angels could procreate with
01:09:58 female physical human beings could one of those fallen angels if he sticks around
01:10:05 um could he then or another fallen angel who didn't sire this particular nephilim 0.79
01:10:13 another fallen angel then mate with a female nephilim to where the angel gene pool is now
01:10:20 at 75% instead of 50.
01:10:23 Yeah, that's, that's interesting.
01:10:25 I don't know why they wouldn't be capable of doing that.
01:10:27 I mean, I, I don't look at it in terms of like the percentage of the gene pool is, I
01:10:32 mean, maybe that's a good way to look at it because I think that they are also made in
01:10:37 God's image.
01:10:38 We talked about how it's not like a one kind of an elephant and a different animal all
01:10:42 together, but sort of the same sort of animal, same sort of creature.
01:10:45 right and so i i tend when it calls them men every now and i tend to think of them as being
01:10:51 fully human um but different because of their parentage um but if that if what you're describing
01:10:58 is the right way and a lot of people who hold the fallen angel view do look at it that way
01:11:02 um yeah why wouldn't you be able to get to 75 or next generation 88 or something
01:11:06 exactly exactly and the only reason i'm asking that is i and i know that this is something that
01:11:11 you would disagree with, but which is totally fine. Your position is, makes a lot of sense,
01:11:16 but it would be possible if the angels are, you know, and this may, you know, I think part of it
01:11:20 deals with, you know, the intent and purpose of the angels and why they're doing this in the first
01:11:24 place. Um, you know, but if, if part of what they're trying to do is, is just completely
01:11:30 pervert, you know, God's creation and those kinds of things, um, but also create a monster, um,
01:11:35 then you know i i wonder if you know maybe nephilim 1.0 you know 50 50 angel human is you 0.61
01:11:45 know and then their descendants being giants is you know gives you eight foot giants you know
01:11:49 nine foot giant you know like like um goliath but i wonder if you can up that angel percentage
01:11:55 dna and if you really could get tall as cedars and not as a metaphor but you know maybe not 120
01:12:03 but i've i've read some you know i've done some reading where you know particular cedars in a
01:12:08 mesopotamia you know uh region um you know is you know 40 50 i don't know i'm just throwing it out
01:12:15 there may not be possible that's a good teaser for our last episode isn't it that's yeah we can
01:12:20 leave it on that hey it's an interesting thought i mean i um i haven't really thought too much
01:12:26 about it because of how i how i viewed the the situation um well and i don't think that's your
01:12:32 calling. I think like, I love, I'm so appreciative. I think it's our last episode, the end of our
01:12:37 last episode. So I want to end by at least saying this, I'm so appreciative of your work. And I
01:12:42 think the, the focus of your work is to make a strongly biblical and plausible argument for why
01:12:49 this is not fantastical. You're not the guy who's doing the YouTube videos of the, of the, you know,
01:12:56 uh, 3000 L's, you know, like the, you know, the, the giant, you know, where, where, uh,
01:13:01 mountains plateaus are just tree stumps that giants who were seven miles tall, like, you
01:13:06 know, that's fun.
01:13:08 It's intriguing, you know, like, you know, I, but you're not that guy.
01:13:11 And, and my point is like, we, we need you.
01:13:13 We need the guy who, um, makes a very reasonable, plausible, and most importantly, biblical
01:13:20 argument for taking the Bible seriously.
01:13:24 And I think that's what you've done.
01:13:25 So I'll be the guy who tries to think of a creative way to get to a 40 foot tall giant, because it just sounds awesome. And I think it's possible, but you'd be the guy who does what you do.
01:13:34 I think both are needed. And I appreciate those kind words. I really do about me, about the book. But sometimes we do, because we can be too careful. Sometimes we don't think outside the box enough to, so it is helpful to have people get very creative and think, I wonder if this, and then one day, and I think Michael Heiser was good at this, but, you know, within the academic community,
01:13:54 here's a guy who's super smart saying things that most academics didn't want to touch with
01:13:59 a 10 foot pole and i'm not saying that he was right all the time but he was he was talking
01:14:03 about some of the weird things that most people well i don't want to talk about that well people
01:14:07 are a lot of people are super curious about this and a lot of unbelievers are very curious believers
01:14:12 are curious why would we not want to um go where they are and try to talk about the things they're
01:14:18 talking about understand their world their worldview and somehow some way connect them
01:14:23 to the gospel and help them see the truth. Amen. And especially in our day and age where I really
01:14:28 think like, sure, technology continues to develop and improve and all these kinds of things. Yet at
01:14:34 the same time, though, in terms of worldviews, it is becoming increasingly evident and blatantly
01:14:40 obvious to even unbelievers that secular humanism is, that dog won't hunt. It's not holding up.
01:14:49 I think in some ways the world is being re-enchanted. The dark enchantment of materialism is starting to fade. We're starting to see that it doesn't work. It's not true that Darwin was a hack and always was.
01:15:06 And so as the world is becoming more enchanted, I think, that I see, I don't know about you, but I see like a phenomenon happening right now, a trend of a exponentially growing infatuation and interest in the supernatural.
01:15:20 And if Christians, out of some desire to be sophisticated and buttoned up in ivory tower, if out of a desire to impress the secular humanist, the scientist who always picked on us, I feel like some creation guys are still trying to get the approval of that atheist scientist.
01:15:41 You're never going to get it. They think you're stupid. Who cares? But if we keep trying to stand 1.00
01:15:45 in that space and be legitimate, legitimate, incredible in the secular humanism space,
01:15:51 meanwhile, the culture is realizing that that space isn't worth listening to and they're getting
01:15:56 enchanted. But by the time they get enchanted, we've successfully moved Christianity over to
01:16:03 this very reasonable, materialistic, natural position. And we've taken all the enchantment 0.98
01:16:10 out of Christianity, but the people actually want enchanted worldviews again, then the only 0.73
01:16:15 options they'll have available to them will be occults, the occult and paganism. And I want to 0.90
01:16:22 say, no, no, no, no, no, no. Christianity, yeah, I'm a Christian. I believe in dragons. I believe
01:16:27 in giants. I believe in fallen angels. I believe in, I personally, I believe that there were
01:16:34 unicorns. Sirens is in the King James Version. And I think there's some creative things to do
01:16:39 with that. And in the wilderness, I don't think it was just snakes, seraphs, and fire. I think
01:16:45 dragons were maybe biting people. And you can't get any more fantastical than this magical world
01:16:52 that God made. Yeah. And, you know, the world may call us foolish, but if the Lord says,
01:16:59 well done, good and faithful servant, that's really what matters. And, you know, Paul talked
01:17:02 about in 1 Corinthians 4 that he said, we are fools for Christ's sake. Okay, well, if the world
01:17:08 thinks i'm a fool for believing in the risen lord and savior and then what his word said so be it
01:17:12 i'm a fool i don't i don't care because i just want to hear him say well done good and faithful
01:17:16 servant and um so i appreciate having the opportunity to talk about this and i appreciate
01:17:21 your um to have me on and and discussing these and making me think through some of these things
01:17:27 that in a maybe the more speculative that i haven't necessarily gone down it's fun to talk
01:17:33 about it and i guess just to speak to the maybe the listeners real quickly just um dig in dive
01:17:39 into god's word and hold that up as the authority um and this is not something that we have to split
01:17:45 the church on you know i see those kind of comments too that uh what a heretic you know
01:17:50 because of a different view on the fallen angel i on this i come on it could be wrong but that's
01:17:56 not heresy yeah so well tim thank you so much it's an honor um i'll let you go and i hope that
01:18:04 our listeners have enjoyed all right joel thanks so much for having me god bless you god bless
01:18:26 You