The NXR Podcast - February 22, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Are “Trad-Wives” Just A Sham?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Yes, The Gospel Changes Genetics THE LIVESTREAM - Kash Patel’s American Dream

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 11 minutes

Words per minute

185.51

Word count

24,340

Sentence count

991

Harmful content

Misogyny

70

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

65

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we are joined by special guest Erika khan to discuss patriarchy and Christian femininity. Erika is a writer, speaker, and advocate for traditional femininity and patriarchy in the public sphere. She has been a voice in the online push for Christian homemaking, submission, and submission to her husband, Tony. But as of this past week, everything about Patriarchy Hannah has unraveled.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it.
00:00:04 It's annoying.
00:00:05 Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm so that
00:00:12 our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries
00:00:20 aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 If you've spent any time in Christian Twitter circles over the past few years,
00:00:32 then you've probably come across the name Patriarchy Hannah. 0.52
00:00:36 With her bold advocacy for traditional femininity and biblical patriarchy and the trad wife lifestyle,
00:00:43 she built a following of nearly 30,000 people and positioned herself as a voice in the online push for Christian homemaking and submission. 0.63
00:00:53 She claimed to be a devoted wife, married to a contractor named Tony, and a mother to 14 children.
00:01:01 Her posts were filled with strong rebukes of modern feminism, 0.98
00:01:05 encouragements for women to embrace submission,
00:01:09 and even some sharp critiques for other Christian women in the public sphere.
00:01:15 But as of this past week, everything about Patriarchy Hannah has unraveled.
00:01:20 The account has been exposed as a fabrication, run not by a married mother of 14 children, but by a single childless woman named Jennifer, a 37-year-old from Arkansas.
00:01:34 A deep dive into public records, receipts, and past online activity revealed that her husband, Tony, doesn't exist.
00:01:43 Her family life was invented, and the house that she claimed her husband built was actually constructed by a completely unrelated developer.
00:01:52 Now, some are celebrating this revelation as proof that the entire online patriarchal movement is built on deception.
00:02:00 They argue that trad influencers are merely cosplayers, and that many who follow them are fetishists.
00:02:08 So what does this all mean?
00:02:09 To be sure, Patriarchy Hannah deceived many, and it's worth noting that she has publicly apologized.
00:02:16 But this does not mean that the goals of patriarchy and the Trad Wife movement are illegitimate.
00:02:23 If anything, it shows that Christian women, and Christian men for that matter, are in vital need of real-life discipleship.
00:02:31 The women, in their case, require discipleship in how to keep their homes, how to be lovers of children, and how to joyfully submit to their own husband.
00:02:41 This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund, as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors.
00:02:51 You can join our Patreon by going to patreon.com forward slash rightresponseministries
00:02:58 or you can donate by going to rightresponseministries.com forward slash donate.
00:03:06 As we have said before, sometimes you have to LARP before you can fly.
00:03:12 Rather than disparaging the LARPers, we should continue to extol godly femininity
00:03:17 and all women who aspire to develop it. 0.76
00:03:21 Tune in now with special guest Eric Kahn as we set the record straight and defend the lost virtue of patriarchy and Christian femininity. 0.98
00:03:42 That's it, boys. Pack it up. It's time to go home. We're so over. 1.00
00:03:46 as far as i can tell from the interweb um a woman lied therefore feminism is true 1.00
00:03:52 all the waves of it one two three and four one two three and four that's right one woman lied 1.00
00:03:58 feminism is true pack it up patriarchy it's so over today we are joined by a special guest
00:04:05 my spirit animal who honestly at this point let's just let's be honest i'm not even proud
00:04:10 about this but um it is the sad reality that i must admit uh there was a time when people would
00:04:15 say you know you um you know if you're not careful you're going to be just as um just as hated
00:04:22 online as eric khan and now people say who's eric khan eric welcome to the show thanks for coming
00:04:31 introduce yourself awesome thanks for having me yeah absolutely joel i'm happy to pass that
00:04:35 mandle on to you by the way on the interwebs congratulations and condolences yeah seriously
00:04:42 seriously okay so this is what we're gonna do uh we have our very own wesley todd we've got
00:04:47 michael belch uh myself and eric con is a special guest the reason we invited eric one because he's
00:04:53 a friend and we love him uh two because he's been i think a really consistent and steady faithful
00:04:58 voice on this subject of biblical patriarchy for quite a while um multiple years and i remember
00:05:06 you know even i don't know when did you start uh would you start a hard man podcast when did that
00:05:12 start uh so it started in 2020 uh really kind of hitting that hard about april i think of 2020
00:05:19 covid was kicking off that's when we started cool yeah i just i remember listening to it i was going
00:05:25 to say about five years ago and so that checks i wanted to make sure i didn't say five years ago
00:05:29 and you're like i started it you know last week you know but uh so that yeah the math checks out
00:05:33 there. And I remember being blessed by your content and learning a lot from it, your podcast,
00:05:38 as well as It's Good to Be a Man. I remember listening to that back in the day. So we want
00:05:42 to have Eric on because he speaks to this topic quite frequently, also because he's a friend and
00:05:46 also because you and I were both named recently in a podcast. And we're going to show some clips
00:05:54 from that. And we're going to do our best not to be bombastic and not to be unnecessarily, you know,
00:05:59 we don't want to be mean-spirited, partly because we want to be consistent with our view. We believe
00:06:06 in biblical patriarchy. We believe that's what the Bible espouses, gender piety, whatever term
00:06:10 you want to use. And so, because of that, we don't want to unnecessarily pick fights with 0.88
00:06:17 the fair sex. Now, that said, if the fair sex chooses to pick a fight with us, we'll finish it. 1.00
00:06:26 No, I'm just kidding. No, but if the Ferris X chooses to pick a fight with us and their platform is significant enough within, you know, meaningful Christian circles, then there are times where it just simply merits clarification. 0.81
00:06:39 That's how I feel. What do you think, Eric?
00:06:42 Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I've been told picking fights with women online is like kicking puppies on stage.
00:06:49 so we try to avoid that if at all possible uh but yeah i think especially as we think pastorally
00:06:54 just for our ladies um you know we'll talk about ali bestucky i think in a minute uh but we had
00:07:01 people in our congregation asking about that in the patriarchy hannah situation so i think in that
00:07:05 case you know it definitely warrants a response hopefully you know to be pastoral and encourage
00:07:11 our ladies no patriarchy is not dead no the principles didn't fail just because uh you know
00:07:16 somebody was grifting or you know larping in a you know unrighteous way right amen yeah so we
00:07:22 want to bring clarity to this uh primarily for women i feel like most of the guys don't really
00:07:28 care you know except for the bad faithless like the guys who were already soft complementarian
00:07:33 and already didn't like patriarchy and are just looking for you know they had a confirmation
00:07:37 bias and this is the confirmation you know so they were just looking for um low-hanging fruit
00:07:42 a gotcha kind of moment uh so there's some of those those guys um but other than those guys
00:07:47 most of the you know the men who are in patriarchal circles are like so what why is why is it a big
00:07:53 deal but i think some of the women um are genuinely hurt in part because i think some of them um
00:07:59 really did interact with patriarchy hannah at you know some of them you know lesser and more degrees
00:08:04 depending on the person but some of them you know really you know they were following her page
00:08:08 pretty intently and learning things from her, maybe even interacted with her some in private
00:08:15 messages or whatever it might have been, or tuned into her podcast, or tuned into a lot of the
00:08:22 spaces that I didn't really, you know, I think I listened to one that Michael Foster was leading,
00:08:30 but she was an administrator on that Twitter space. And then, and there might have been one
00:08:36 more. But I did notice, you know, because your, your phone, every time you open the X app, it
00:08:41 alerts you, you know, what these spaces are happening. And I did notice, you know, she did
00:08:45 a lot of spaces. And so I think there were women who, you know, whether it was following her
00:08:48 account on X or hopping in the spaces that were done on a semi regular basis, pretty frequently.
00:08:54 Most of the ones that I saw, I was alerted because they were led by Michael Foster, you know, he led
00:08:58 at least a couple dozen with her. And, and when I say with her, I don't mean like she was speaking
00:09:04 all the time but she was the administrator i guess i i don't even know really how it works but
00:09:09 apparently um i don't know you there's such a thing as being good at hosting a space and she 0.67
00:09:14 was doing that and for a lot of guys in our circle so for those women who were you know in you know
00:09:20 having those relational touch points um some of them were hurt and so i think it merits um as best
00:09:27 we can like uh some encouragement to those women um some clarifications of what biblical patriarchy
00:09:33 is, um, and, and the path forward so that we can move on. And that's kind of what we want to do.
00:09:39 So Eric, if there's anything that you want to say, go ahead and say it. If not, we'll go ahead
00:09:43 and throw on the first clip from a recent podcast from Ali Beth Stuckey. Yeah, I think just the one
00:09:50 thing it kind of to contextualize everything. One of the things I've heard is, you know, Joel,
00:09:55 you and Eric, you know, you platform this lady. And just to be clear, uh, I was invited to, uh,
00:10:01 I think it was billed as I talked to my husband, Tony, who we now know didn't exist.
00:10:06 I've talked to him.
00:10:07 This is mainly for ladies who have questions about your ministry and patriarchy.
00:10:11 So I went on there and was just answering objections.
00:10:15 This is pretty standard fare, I think, for anybody who's in public space that you get requests to do podcasts.
00:10:21 And so we did that, interacted with some posts.
00:10:25 Most of the stuff I saw from her over the years was, you know, I thought decently solid.
00:10:29 and uh so that's kind of limited uh i definitely wouldn't say like oh yeah we platformed uh this
00:10:36 person but um yeah that's kind of the extent of of at least my involvement right yeah same with
00:10:43 me i went on one of her podcasts so same thing neither eric or i uh had uh hannah patriarchy
00:10:49 on our platform but you went on her podcast once i went on her podcast once um and same thing i you
00:10:54 know, I specifically asked her, I remember it was probably close to two years ago at this point. So
00:11:00 it was after the clip went viral of me talking about a husband's authority in the home. And what
00:11:04 does that mean? Is it merely hypothetical? Is it just ethereal? Or is it actual authority? Are
00:11:10 there practical implications? And I use as an example, that a husband has authority even over
00:11:15 the spiritual diet of his wife and children, not just the children, but also his wife, that he
00:11:20 actually has the authority to say you know what i don't want you to read that we can read that
00:11:24 together at a later time right now i don't have time for it so in the meantime let's go ahead and
00:11:29 read something else and people are like what you can't you can't say that and of course the answer
00:11:33 is uh yes you can you absolutely can a husband has authority or he doesn't and i'm of the
00:11:40 persuasion that he does uh wives submit to your husbands in everything so um it was after that
00:11:46 And complementarians lost their mind because they're like, wait a second, this guy actually
00:11:51 believes male headship and he's not keeping in step with complementarianism, which is
00:11:56 the facade of male headship, but doesn't actually follow through in practice whatsoever.
00:12:02 So the complementarians who are functionally egalitarians were very, very, very offended.
00:12:07 And so she asked me to come on her podcast and she even told me up front, I remember
00:12:10 her saying, it's really small.
00:12:12 it's just you know basically a few women that listen and i don't know i don't know the metrics
00:12:17 of her podcast i you know that's i think that's probably true and um and so anyway so i was like
00:12:22 hey do you want to do video and she was like no audio only that checks out now now that makes
00:12:26 sense um and then you know right before we recorded you know she gave me a link and i tuned in when
00:12:31 the day came and i asked her specifically i said is your husband going to be a part of it you know
00:12:35 do you have his permission i asked those questions and she said oh yes absolutely um before any of
00:12:40 this is released. He's, he's outworking. He's giving me his permission. I'm going to record
00:12:44 it. And before I release any of my podcast, he always listens to the audio and goes over it
00:12:49 first. And I was like, great. So yeah. And I'm sure it was probably something similar with you.
00:12:55 All right. Are we ready to get into our first clip? Yep. Okay. Here we go. I truly think that
00:13:02 this is like intentional. I think that she's trolling these people. I mean, it's just so,
00:13:07 so silly and i'm just like curious did these men check with hannah's husband before going on her
00:13:12 podcast because these men have criticized me for having a platform now it's interesting because a 0.81
00:13:18 lot of these men like you know people like joel webin who have told me you know i shouldn't be
00:13:23 on the uh you know front lines of the culture wars all right there's our first clip what do
00:13:33 think man this joel webin this joel webin guy seems really terrible uh based on that i'm kind
00:13:39 of offended at you joel okay she's about to name you too there i know i know i know uh it is actually
00:13:46 interesting though obviously we answered one of the objections uh already but of course you know
00:13:52 she was uh telling us that her husband was involved tony who doesn't exist uh of course
00:13:58 we know that i do also think it's interesting though because there's this desire to portray
00:14:04 all of the patriarchy camp as particularly larpy in the past she's called it the red pill
00:14:09 manosphere trad wife uh kind of interesting because i've never associated with those labels
00:14:16 if anything i've generally criticized them but i think you know this i think she's smart this
00:14:21 is a smart play associate uh an oppositional theological position with probably the easiest
00:14:28 target which would be you know somebody who just got caught lying as though that represents all of
00:14:34 us uh in our camp which of course it doesn't we're leaning back on the reformers and calvin
00:14:39 and knox and vermigli and luther and and stuff like that but uh that of course is not going to
00:14:45 be the talking point here yeah right well said i wanted to pick up too eric you're like well i
00:14:49 never associated with the label which is true i've followed you for years and you've never been like
00:14:53 I'm the red pill guy. I'm the trad guy. But I think the reason that you don't, and I would
00:14:58 think say this of all of us in the room, is movements like that, and that includes good
00:15:02 one, like Trad Wife and all of those, they inherently take people that are very susceptible
00:15:06 to wanting to be involved in something. So imagine you don't have a great home life and you hear
00:15:11 someone come along and they say, you know, the real problem in your life is, you know, you're
00:15:14 not submitting to your husband, you're not dressing modestly, you're not taking care of
00:15:17 things in the home. If you're unhappy with the way your life is or unhappy with your marriage,
00:15:21 Well, great news.
00:15:21 I have this wonderful pill.
00:15:23 And there's a lot of people, whether that be the Trad Life Movement.
00:15:26 I remember social justice, for instance.
00:15:28 I never posted the black square, but there were so many people that were like, this is
00:15:31 the thing I'm going to attach to.
00:15:33 This is the thing I'm going to make to be my identity.
00:15:35 This is the thing I'm going to get to be invested in.
00:15:37 And there's a lot of people that they'll get in a movement and they'll go and they'll
00:15:40 have steam for two years and then die off.
00:15:42 And then it'll be something new and they're on to something else and this and that and
00:15:45 the other.
00:15:46 So you said that I've never associated with it.
00:15:47 And I think that's a good instinct to have. 0.99
00:15:49 If everybody's posting a black square for social justice on Instagram, probably not 0.59
00:15:52 the best time to do it. 0.98
00:15:54 Tons of people are dressing up.
00:15:55 They're teaching everything in the closet, replacing it with a line of dresses, starting
00:15:59 the sourdough baking company.
00:16:00 Probably that six-month time period is not the best time to be like, you know what?
00:16:04 I got to start mine too in my neighborhood.
00:16:07 The best type of movements, the best types of change, it's over years and they're habits
00:16:11 that are kept up for life.
00:16:12 And that's just not conducive to something that's a flash in the pan, very exciting,
00:16:15 has a lot of people that are really into it all of a sudden.
00:16:18 that doesn't create the ground the soil for a good pattern of life that lasts yeah there's a
00:16:24 lot of things that multiple elements that can be appealing one like you already said Wes is just
00:16:29 the desire for community belonging relationship which is a good desire right so a lot of people
00:16:34 who get pulled into flash in the pan type movements it really can be simply that they're
00:16:41 lonely that can be a big part of it is just wanting friendship in addition to that there's
00:16:47 not just the desire for community but also the desire to be seen as virtuous and so um whether
00:16:53 it was social justice and the black square it's like look at me i'm virtuous um or whether it's
00:16:58 you know trad life you know like so if uh women are you know constantly flooding social media
00:17:04 with pictures of themselves in bikinis and you're showing a picture with you and your children in a 0.97
00:17:09 sundress um that's good and i would love for social media to be flooded with that instead
00:17:14 that is objectively good. But the desires, in terms of your incentives and motives, hidden
00:17:19 motives of the heart, it could be to honor God. It could also be simply to be viewed as being
00:17:23 virtuous, morally superior to those who are scantily clad. But a lot of that gets down to,
00:17:30 again, I think the thing that I want to point out is those don't have any bearing over whether or
00:17:38 not something is objectively moral and true. What you're talking about is at the individual
00:17:44 level what the incentives or hidden motives of their heart, inward motives, might be for somebody
00:17:49 hopping on board. But the fact that a movement or a set of doctrinal principles or whatever it might
00:17:56 be, or even an individual local church, that it might attract people for the wrong reasons,
00:18:01 it's a fallacy to say that that definitively and objectively means that this church or this
00:18:07 movement or this doctrinal belief system is somehow inherently flawed, that it's morally
00:18:14 flawed because it attracted uh the wrong person that's just um that's that doesn't um that's
00:18:21 that's guilt by association that's a fallacy um and so uh that that's the only thing that i would
00:18:27 want to add to it michael do you have anything you want to say well i do i want to um be up front
00:18:31 almost a year ago i didn't look back and see the exact date that we did it but about a year ago we
00:18:36 did an episode and it was which way western woman and it was witchcraft or trad wife right and so
00:18:43 So, you know, in that episode, we were commending the virtues of the Tradwife movement.
00:18:47 However, Eric, something I heard you say once a while ago, well, this is years ago, you said that one of the problems in the 50s and 60s was that as the domestic duties became easier because of machinery and canned goods, things like that,
00:19:08 one of the failures of men was that we did not figure out how to continue to involve our wives
00:19:16 women in the process of the creation mandate of being fruitful of subduing the earth and we kind
00:19:23 of in some ways like modern society just left women kind of twiddling their thumbs so i'm i'm
00:19:29 curious eric what you think um you know sourdough and sundresses is not enough right but i think we
00:19:37 would all say it's a step in the right direction but i'm curious um if your perspective is still
00:19:42 well we need to be creative and thoughtful about how we encourage our wives and dads their their
00:19:51 daughters in knowing how to be keepers at home when the roomba vacuum can you know can clean the 0.97
00:19:59 floor for them right um so i'm i'm just curious yes trad wife is a good impulse in the right 0.87
00:20:05 direction, but it's not enough, obviously. Yeah, I think really what it's, trad wife is like the
00:20:10 tip of the iceberg, but I think what women and men, too, who are interested in this sort of topic,
00:20:15 I think what they're actually looking for is an old principle that we would have called in
00:20:19 Christendom, the productive household. So when you read Proverbs 31, you see a woman who is working,
00:20:25 she's busy with a number of activities that are associated with her household. She's actually
00:20:30 involved in some ways, usually, at least in a tertiary way with her husband's business,
00:20:35 whether that's maybe doing some bookkeeping, your husband's a welder or something like that,
00:20:40 and you're involved in it somehow, the daughters would have been involved in those things too.
00:20:45 So I think really the 50s is kind of, as Christendom falls apart, and the productive
00:20:51 household is gone, they still maintain a little bit of the moral virtue of the household.
00:20:56 But it's really more of what we think of today as like the nuclear family,
00:21:00 Yeah, leave it to Beaver. There's a dad, there's a mom. But it's already broken down a little bit at that point because dad's going off to a job by himself. Mom just kind of stays at home. Kids go to a public school. It was definitely more wholesome than today, but it's still a denigration of what the biblical household, I think, pattern is supposed to be.
00:21:20 So, yeah, particularly having women see that the sourdough is just part of a bigger hole and a bigger vision for the productive household. 0.70
00:21:30 And I think one of the things that we've tried to do, you know, I said we weren't involved in the Red Pill, Manosphere, Trad Wife, whatever. 0.97
00:21:37 But one of the things we definitely have done, and I think Joel's done this as well, is we've looked at those cultural trends and we've seen some of those hungers for the old productive household.
00:21:46 And we've said sort of in the, you know, Paul going into the area of Pegasus and saying, yeah, actually, some of the things that you're talking about, it's the unknown God.
00:21:54 But let me tell you the real story here. The reason we have so much father hunger in the land is actually because something has gone catastrophically wrong with society.
00:22:04 And so we want to correct some of those errors. We do want to speak to the guys who are really hungry for, you know, Andrew Tate content, for example, without saying, yeah, I'm part of the red pill movement.
00:22:15 We're obviously going to critique Andrew Tate, but we're going to speak to that desire.
00:22:19 And I think you see that across society, that people really are longing, and wives in particular,
00:22:25 not just to be cute on the fainting couch, but to actually be involved in the work that
00:22:31 her husband is doing and then bringing the children into that work as well.
00:22:35 Sourdough could be a part of it, but it's actually a much greater vision than just that.
00:22:40 Right, because it's getting at virtues underneath, like what are dresses getting at underneath?
00:22:44 modesty and beauty modesty without being frumpy modesty with elegance feminine feminine beauty
00:22:51 right what is sourdough getting it underneath provision right submission warmth so by all
00:22:56 means take the things underneath what we talk about all the time with masculinity what like
00:23:00 what is working out getting underneath longevity longevity of life stability security protection
00:23:07 right discipline what about a guy who's being ambitious and trying to make more money so long
00:23:12 as he's doing it ethically without neglecting his other duties, well, that's provision.
00:23:17 Like these are, this is the right direction.
00:23:19 So, these are things that we don't want to disparage.
00:23:21 These are things that we want to encourage, and we want to encourage them and then come
00:23:25 alongside them and start to provide some of the theological, biblical underpinnings, like
00:23:30 Eric was talking about, for them to say, this is right, let me tell you why.
00:23:34 This is good, let me tell you why, and show them the biblical reasoning, and then also
00:23:38 show them historically how this is how all the world has thought, even outside of Christian
00:23:44 nations, even pagan nations have thought this way. All the world has seen a difference between men 0.67
00:23:50 and women and the function of women in society and predominantly that being in the home. 1.00
00:23:55 This is common knowledge for the vast majority of all of human history, and it's certainly true 0.63
00:24:01 to the scripture. So, if we see something like that in the culture at large, yeah, trad wives 0.99
00:24:08 and sourdough beat the hell out of OnlyFans, right? So, when we're living in OnlyFans culture,
00:24:17 and then you see even just the sparks of a potential sundress and sourdough movement,
00:24:25 then yeah we want we want to encourage that and say that's great and then and then add some of
00:24:31 the robust underpinnings theological underpinnings for why but we don't want to disparage it um and 0.99
00:24:37 say well no that's not really what femininity is because we're actually intimidated by wives who
00:24:43 are staying home and wearing dresses and making sourdough because we actually secretly want to be
00:24:48 able to protect our own wives and their 40 hour a week career or whatever outside of the home
00:24:52 So that's, to me, that does not sit well with me.
00:24:59 So one more thing that I wanted to add with the clip, Nathan, can you play, not the next
00:25:03 one, but can you go back and play the clip that you already did one last time?
00:25:06 I have one more point to make.
00:25:09 And gullible.
00:25:11 Hannah also hosted two of these people, Eric Kahn and Joel Webin, on her podcast, Patriarchy
00:25:17 Country.
00:25:18 I truly think this show, who is also a working mother, and also a few years ago, Joel Webin
00:25:27 really, really wanted to be on my show, was asking and asking and asking to be on my show.
00:25:33 I did not want to do it.
00:25:35 I just finished feeding him and he just like cuddles up on me like this.
00:25:38 How am I supposed to put him back?
00:25:40 That's all right.
00:25:41 Technical difficulties.
00:25:43 It happens to everyone, including Nathan.
00:25:44 So here we go.
00:25:45 So that was actually our second clip, but it's okay because it basically makes the same point as the first clip.
00:25:50 So we'll go ahead and just address, you know, both in one fell swoop.
00:25:54 But I wanted to say from the first clip and the sentiment there is there again in the second.
00:26:00 But, you know, Ali mentioned that, well, you know, people like Joel Webin or Eric Kahn, they don't think that I should have a podcast.
00:26:07 They don't think that I should.
00:26:08 And she specifically said they don't think that I should be on the front lines of the culture war.
00:26:12 And so I just want to, I mean, I think I've said it in the last week, but might as well go ahead
00:26:17 for the record and say it again. That is correct. That's correct. I do not want women on the front
00:26:24 lines of battle. No, I don't think that it's pleasing to the Lord. There's a number of reasons 1.00
00:26:31 for that, but I'll give at least one. I've given it before, I'll give it again. Men should be strong
00:26:37 and physical strength in a man's youth eventually coupled with grace gives way as we've talked about
00:26:44 before gives way to spiritual strength as he gets older so there's something in our youth
00:26:51 at the physical level that God is saying he's conveying to us through nature by means of nature
00:26:56 saying this is the general direction that my I have in my will for you so he makes men typically
00:27:04 in general, young men are physically strong. And that says something about the spiritual telos
00:27:09 of a man, strength. So, that physical strength then gives way to gray hair, a crown, wisdom,
00:27:16 spiritual strength, that he remains a protector. He may not be able to bench the same amount,
00:27:22 but he's actually an even stronger protector and provider for his people as he ages. That
00:27:28 physical strength gives way to spiritual strength. So, too, with a woman. God makes, in a general 0.67
00:27:34 sense, women are beautiful. Now, that external beauty, the physical beauty that a woman possesses
00:27:42 in her youth, eventually, the scripture says, and we see in our experience, that it eventually fades, 1.00
00:27:47 that beauty is fading, charm is deceptive, but a woman who fears the Lord is to be praised. 0.63
00:27:51 But that physical, that's God speaking through nature, that physical beauty that embodies 0.99
00:27:57 women in their youth, that that is to give way to greater and greater degrees of spiritual beauty.
00:28:04 Now, speaking of the spiritual beauty, 1 Peter talks about this and explains exactly what that
00:28:10 is. It's not an external physical beauty that's perishable, but an imperishable beauty of the
00:28:15 heart. So, an internal and eternal. It's imperishable. So, it's internal and eternal
00:28:21 beauty. And then God defines this beauty that is precious in his sight with two predominant
00:28:28 characteristics. Number one, that it's quiet. And number two, that it's gentle. It's a quiet
00:28:35 and gentle spirit. And so the reason, this is just one reason. There are a number of reasons.
00:28:40 There are practical reasons, psychological reasons, political reasons. There are all kinds
00:28:44 of reasons. But this is one theological reason. No, I don't want to see any woman. It's nothing
00:28:49 personal against Ali Bestucki, but I don't want to see any woman, and especially any Christian
00:28:54 sister in the Lord, on the front lines fighting a war. Now, I understand that it's not physical
00:29:01 battle, but to be on the front lines of the culture war, it requires at least some degree.
00:29:09 It's not the only tool in your toolbox, but it will be used. It is necessary. You don't only
00:29:15 use a hammer when you're building a house, but you can't build a house without a hammer.
00:29:19 You're going to have to use it at least some.
00:29:21 Well, here's a tool on the culture war, because it is a war.
00:29:25 It is a right sentiment that we've called it.
00:29:29 We haven't just called it the cultural project or the cultural cooking, cultural baking,
00:29:35 you know, cultural nursing.
00:29:37 No, it's called the culture war.
00:29:40 And there's a reason for that label and the reason why it stuck, because it is really
00:29:44 a war.
00:29:45 And when you're in war, even if it's not physical battle, that cultural war, one of the tools,
00:29:49 like a hammer, it's not your only tool to be used all the time, even in the case of men,
00:29:52 but it is necessary, it will have to be used occasionally, is being polemical.
00:29:59 And the mere fact of being polemical, to be polemical is to not be quiet and gentle.
00:30:09 You cannot be polemical and quiet and gentle at the same time, which according to God's Word,
00:30:14 if we're going to trust that God's word is true, a quiet and gentle spirit are the two
00:30:20 predominant defining characteristics of inward feminine beauty that is pleasing in the sight of
00:30:26 God. And so a woman who is on the front lines fighting the culture war is going to be polemical. 0.91
00:30:34 And Allie is at times. She's being polemical in this video towards us. She's, you know,
00:30:39 being a little snarky, a little bit of sarcasm. It's, you know, she's warring. It's a fight.
00:30:46 She's fighting. And in being polemical, you cannot be gentle and quiet, which means that those are
00:30:54 two of the premier characteristics of beauty, according to God's word, for women, inward beauty,
00:31:01 then you can't be beautiful. In other words, if we send our Christian sisters in the Lord to the 0.96
00:31:08 front lines of the culture war, then we are requiring of them, maybe not every second of
00:31:15 every podcast or everything, but we are requiring by necessity that at least in some significant
00:31:23 degree, they will have to sacrifice their beauty in order to engage in that polemic.
00:31:32 You can't do both.
00:31:33 You can't be polemical and beautiful as a woman, feminine beauty, according to God's 0.98
00:31:39 definition of what beauty is.
00:31:42 And we, given the choice between warring sisters in Christ or beautiful sisters in Christ,
00:31:49 we want our sisters in Christ to be beautiful.
00:31:52 So back to that first clip, we won't play it again because we're having a little bit
00:31:58 of challenges, but that first clip, she said, you know, Joel doesn't think that I should
00:32:01 be in the culture war.
00:32:02 that is correct that is correct and and my opinion has not changed um and that that is because um i
00:32:09 i don't think that uh the culture war is just that it's a war and war is for men um in the physical
00:32:16 sense when there's bullets and in the spiritual sense the culture war is different than building
00:32:21 culture that's right right women have been authors and painters and you know keepers of 1.00
00:32:29 helping produce their household livelihood. 1.00
00:32:33 Building culture is different than what we're talking about with the culture war on the front lines,
00:32:37 trying to beat back negative influences and sinful beliefs that are shaping how the culture builds itself.
00:32:45 Right. Eric, what do you think?
00:32:47 Yeah, I think that you guys make some really good points.
00:32:50 I think the other is just practical, facing up to the practical things that are going on, too.
00:32:54 So having spent a lot of time in the media industry outside of a particularly reformed or Christian space, you've got to think about the cultural context and what a marketing guy is thinking through.
00:33:06 He's saying you've got a pretty blonde lady and you've got an audience of women.
00:33:10 So how do you market to them? You get somebody to speak their language. 0.68
00:33:14 You feel like you need something like that. That's really a big factor here.
00:33:19 The other one I would say, though, is when we're addressing principles, just like in the book of Acts, when you start telling the silversmiths and the magicians that what they're doing is not a good thing for them to be doing. 0.76
00:33:32 Well, what ends up happening is it causes an economic problem.
00:33:36 And so I think for Ali and for other people, they're very successful.
00:33:41 And I think in the past, this is why, you know, you'll tend to hear quips from them like you're jealous of my platform, yada, yada.
00:33:47 we're like no actually it's a principled issue um but but you've got to be aware of that the
00:33:53 other thing i think that's really it's kind of just in the cultural water particularly with
00:33:57 mainstream evangelicalism for some time now is you've had the jen wilkin effect where we had 0.75
00:34:03 this idea that um the only way that you could serve women was to have a female version of a
00:34:08 pastor and so we did that with women's ministries and so i actually view this as just an extension
00:34:14 of the same thing where it's like well men addressing political issues wasn't enough
00:34:19 we need a female version of that in order to be effective and of course again on principle we
00:34:25 don't think that's the case i also think um going back to something that west said about movements
00:34:31 this is one of the particular reasons that we we want to ground what we're saying not in novel
00:34:37 innovative 1980s complementarian theology but in the reform tradition as a whole right so 200 years
00:34:44 and plus older and we say when you stack up something like alibeth against all of that if
00:34:50 you go 200 years ago they they would be laughing that this conversation is even happening right
00:34:56 yeah a little just a bit on the war maybe we'll hit our first commercial break but um that's the
00:35:01 positive side the polemical the attack the aggression but on the negative side i mean i'm
00:35:05 sure joel and eric get much more than i do but the messages the insults and everything that i receive
00:35:10 i would never want my wife to be on the receiving end they don't bother me whatsoever but anyone
00:35:14 that has some level of a public platform and speaks strongly on the issues of today they're
00:35:20 going to be on the receiving end of hate of vile disgusting things that should never be hurled at 1.00
00:35:25 a woman most certainly in regards to this and so by saying no i don't wouldn't want my wife doing
00:35:30 a podcast on this i wouldn't want her speaking i wouldn't want her authoring related to these
00:35:34 issues you're shielding her from being exposed to nastiness they have just no place being exposed
00:35:39 to i love them i want you to sleep great at night and so we're not going to involve you in this
00:35:43 culture war and i will happily take the heat because i can take a thousand or whatever it
00:35:47 would be and uh and not lose not lose a wink but uh but for you out of love i just know this is to
00:35:53 protect you yeah amen well said yeah sometimes people ask like how come you don't um how can
00:35:59 we never see your family you know like how come your wife doesn't ever jump on a podcast with you
00:36:04 or anything like that.
00:36:05 And the, you know, the short answer is because I love my family,
00:36:09 because I love my wife, right?
00:36:11 There's about 100,000 people that appreciate Joel Webin by the grace of God.
00:36:16 And there's 10 million that hate me.
00:36:18 That's right.
00:36:19 You know, like, and so people...
00:36:21 They're a vocal 10 million, Joel.
00:36:23 They are.
00:36:24 And, you know, so like my wife, Megan, she'll ask, you know, from time to time,
00:36:28 you know, like, you know, so what are people mad at you for, you know, today?
00:36:33 what's what's the new thing and and you know a lot of times i'll just say well nothing i mean
00:36:42 people are mad that's true i won't lie to her but um nothing important you know i i will catch her
00:36:50 up maybe maybe once every couple weeks maybe once a month if there's something really significant
00:36:56 that I think, you know, might actually, you know, that she would, you know, it could come up in
00:37:03 conversation, you know, with other women in the church that they might ask her about, you know,
00:37:08 or maybe her parents, you know, might have seen something online, you know, if I get picked up by
00:37:13 like some major, you know, news station and my email is getting flooded, you know, because some
00:37:21 clip went viral, you know, or something like that. And it's almost, you know, like close to being a
00:37:26 national story so like you know she could have an aunt or an uncle that hear you know about then
00:37:31 something like that i'll you know i'll clue her in um and and let her know what's going on so that
00:37:36 she can be prepared not caught off guard like if she's going for a walk with her mom and her mom
00:37:40 asked a question or a woman in the church but other than that no um i don't sleep very great
00:37:47 um but my wife sleeps like a baby she's living her best life now she's got her five little babies
00:37:53 living the dream and she's happy and she has her friends in the church and good relationships with
00:37:59 her family. And she does make her sourdough and she wears beautiful dresses and she's healthy
00:38:04 and she's happy and she's beautiful. And no, why is your wife not podcasting with you?
00:38:11 Because I love her. That's why. I'm not bringing her into this world. No, I'll go to war for her.
00:38:19 And that's why I'm doing it.
00:38:20 I'm doing it, number one, for the glory of God, number two, for the good of His people,
00:38:24 for the good of the church, Christians, and number three, because I have a wife and children.
00:38:30 And as Stephen Wolf would say, I don't have any fancy titles, although he literally does.
00:38:35 He has a doctrine in political philosophy.
00:38:38 I don't have any fancy titles, but I am a father, and I want my children to live in
00:38:42 a Christian nation.
00:38:44 That's why we do what we do, for the glory of God, the good of His people.
00:38:48 and for our children and our children's children.
00:38:51 We want them to live in a Christian nation. 1.00
00:38:53 So no, I'm not going to bring my wife
00:38:55 into battle with me, podcasting,
00:38:57 in the same way that if I got enlisted
00:38:59 because we went into World War III,
00:39:02 you know, because...
00:39:04 For Ukraine. 0.91
00:39:05 It would be Israel, let's be honest.
00:39:07 But if we get, you know, I get drafted,
00:39:11 no, I'm not going to take my wife with me
00:39:14 and my daughters with me into battle.
00:39:16 and i'm also not gonna i'm not gonna subject them to the internet to be hated by 10 million people
00:39:22 so um oh one more thing so since we did play the second clip we might as well address it real quick
00:39:28 and then we'll go to our first commercial break the only thing there that's worth addressing
00:39:31 is that um uh it's you know i've seen it online and ali said it in that clip but i've seen online
00:39:38 where people are like well you're hypocritical and i heard that you paid ali to go on her show
00:39:43 and this, that, and the other. And I think there's two things worth noting. Number one, 0.97
00:39:47 the simplest thing that I can say is that by God's grace, I've actually changed. And here's,
00:39:55 this is what I don't like a lot of times about older ministers, guys who are fathers in the
00:39:59 faith and we appreciate them. We want to be as respectful as we can. But one thing that really
00:40:03 is disappointing and exasperating, I think for spiritual sons, when we see older men in the 0.53
00:40:09 ministry who are, they don't just do this once or twice, but they're kind of like uniquely marked
00:40:14 by it. It's kind of like their MO. It's something that they're known for because they do it with
00:40:18 such frequency. One of the things that's often done is that guys will get caught in some kind
00:40:26 of inconsistency. And instead of an apology, there's a double down. There's, well, I'm going
00:40:35 to write this many extra blogs. And it's not an apology. It's actually an indictment because at
00:40:41 the end of it, what you're really communicating is, I need you to apologize for being so stupid 0.99
00:40:46 that you misunderstood me. So I'm not going to do that to you guys. What I'll do instead is it was 0.77
00:40:53 early 2020, pretty quick after COVID happened in March. I think it was April, May, something like
00:41:01 that, maybe June. So, about five years ago, and I had just written a book called Am I Truly Saved
00:41:08 on the Assurance of Salvation? And we reached out to multiple Christian podcasts, Just Thinking
00:41:12 was one of them, with Virgil Walker and Daryl Harrison. So, we reached out to multiple Christian
00:41:18 podcasts and asked them if we could do advertising with them to promote the book. And Allie was one
00:41:25 of the podcasts that we reached out to. And I can't remember the price. I think it was about
00:41:28 $700 for one commercial, which I'm sure her price is a lot higher now. She has a much
00:41:33 larger platform. And I'm not saying that, you know, that she was gouging us. I think that was
00:41:38 a fair price. So we paid $700 for one commercial for my book. And then I followed up when they
00:41:44 said yes to that, to promoting the book. And we agreed on the price. They sent the invoice and
00:41:48 we paid it. Then I followed up and said, Hey, you know, while we're at it, I'm pastoring in
00:41:53 California. COVID is kind of a big thing. And we've taken a stand on that issue when a lot of
00:41:58 other churches haven't. And we took a stand early. Would you be willing to have me on for a short
00:42:03 segment to talk about that? And she said, yes. Now, she says she didn't want to. I think that's
00:42:09 probably true. I don't think she's lying. I bet behind the scenes she's like, eh, not really
00:42:13 interested. But she made an exception and probably in part because we had just become customers by
00:42:19 paying for an ad. And to be frank, that was my strategy. My strategy was I'm going to pay for
00:42:25 the ad because I really do just want to promote the book. And after having paid for an ad to
00:42:29 promote the book, then I'll make a request. Can I go on your show? Because that's kind of
00:42:33 a decent strategy because then the person feels a little bit beholden to you.
00:42:37 So I think Ali's telling the truth. I think I'm telling the truth. I think that both of these
00:42:40 things actually consistently meld with one another. So I think she didn't really want to do
00:42:46 it, but we had just, you know, given her money to pay for an ad. And so she decided, oh, what's the
00:42:51 harm, you know, we'll throw them in on a 10 minute slot. And that's what she did. And I talked about
00:42:55 COVID. Now later, as you'll see here in a moment, after our commercial break, we'll play another
00:43:00 clip. You know, she goes further and saying, well, it's not just that, but Joel, you know,
00:43:05 celebrated Candace Owens when she played a clip from Joel's podcast on her show. I don't know if
00:43:13 I celebrated Candace Owens. I can't remember how, maybe Allie didn't say it like that, but something
00:43:17 along those lines. But I did celebrate the clip from my show being played on Candace
00:43:23 Owen's show. Absolutely. I hope she plays a few more. And if she invited me to be on
00:43:28 her show, I would say no in principle. No, I would say yes. If Laura Ingram said, hey,
00:43:34 do you want to come on for a short segment with Fox News? I would say yes. Now, if Laura
00:43:40 Ingram also asked me in private or in public on her show, what do you think I should do
00:43:46 with my life to honor God, I would say, quit your job and go home. That's what I believe.
00:43:54 Those two things can be true. That's not hypocrisy. That is being shrewd and calculated
00:44:01 and strategic. I'm going to take whatever platform and opportunity I can to get out a message,
00:44:08 not to make much of me, but to make much of Christ and get out a message that I believe
00:44:13 is absolutely necessary. And a message that I think has been suppressed in our country
00:44:20 for decades, whether it's something when all the churches are folding like a cheap suit on COVID,
00:44:26 yeah, I will take whatever opportunity I have to encourage pastors and Christians to be courageous
00:44:32 as I possibly can, even if it means going on a female's podcast. I did a podcast with
00:44:38 pearly things, uh, Pearl Davis, I would do it again. If I had the opportunity, I would do it
00:44:45 again. Why? Because she has a large platform with a lot of followers and I have a message that I
00:44:50 want to get across. Um, so yeah, so I, I just, I don't see any, any conflict or inconsistency with
00:44:57 that. Now, all that said though, I will, like I said, I don't want to just clarify. I also do
00:45:02 want to admit, I've changed. So, in 2020, I did have different views than I had today. I would
00:45:09 have been more, I started embracing biblical patriarchy, and at the end of 2018, taught on it
00:45:16 in 2019, took four weeks to go through the first 15 verses of 1 Timothy chapter 2,
00:45:24 lost about a third of the church that I was pastoring. In four weeks, we lost about a third
00:45:29 of the church. So, it was 2018, 2019 that I really started to embrace more of a patriarchal view,
00:45:37 but it was still softer and less robust and fleshed out as what I hold today. So,
00:45:44 part of it was a strategy, and then part of it was that I really have, by God's grace,
00:45:50 evolved, um, in my doctrine. And, and the, the, the statement of, um, I, I've been the same for
00:45:59 30 years, brother, that's not the brag you think it is. Um, I think that there is something to be
00:46:07 said for, I, you know, I've noticed people say, well, wouldn't it be great to come into these
00:46:11 positions and not make major doctrinal changes at least before becoming a pastor? And I would say,
00:46:15 yeah, that is absolutely ideal. And in better times throughout church history, in better times
00:46:22 of Christendom, that would have been the norm. The ideal would have been the norm. I think the
00:46:26 reason it's not the norm today is not just because an individual is, you know, choosing to, you know,
00:46:33 just sow his wild theological oats and, you know, and be an edgelord. I think the reason why you see
00:46:40 guys like me, and, you know, the Ogden guys, I think, are an example of this also, shifting
00:46:46 in our theological convictions over time is because the church in America has been in complete
00:46:53 disarray. So, you say, well, you should have gone to seminary, and you should have even gone
00:46:59 further and got a PhD, and you should have waited, and I don't know if I should have gone to seminary,
00:47:04 I don't know if I should have got a PhD, I do think I should have waited before entering the
00:47:08 ministry. I'll admit that. But my point is that I don't think that would have fixed it. And how do
00:47:14 I know? Because there's a bunch of guys with MDivs who suck. That's how I know. I know because I see 0.99
00:47:22 those guys who did go to seminary and their theology on especially these kinds of subjects
00:47:30 like biblical patriarchy is absolutely deplorable. And my prayer for those guys is that they would
00:47:37 be willing to humble themselves and change. It's like, well, I've never changed. What is repentance
00:47:44 other than change? That's what repentance is. It's changing. And so, yeah, I want to be
00:47:52 a minister and beyond that, beyond just being a public voice or a pastor, I want to be a Christian
00:47:59 and I want to be the kind of Christian that's going from glory to glory to glory, that's being
00:48:05 further and further progressively conformed into the image of Christ day by day that I want to be
00:48:11 able to say five years from now, the same way I can say today, I have better theology than I did
00:48:16 five years ago. I hope five years from now that I can say that again. I think that that's the goal.
00:48:22 I think that's the goal. And I understand that you can give people theological whiplash
00:48:26 by changing too quickly or changing on major issues. But I just think that you have to realize,
00:48:33 the sons of Issachar, you have to realize what is a product of the individual person being just
00:48:40 unstable and just kind of going back and forth to wishy-washy? What's a product of that,
00:48:49 the individual person? And then separating that from what is a product of just the larger lay
00:48:56 of the land in Christendom, as it pertains to today, there's no way to get the training back
00:49:04 on the rails apart from ministers and pastors and Christians making major theological changes.
00:49:14 Like, we're in rough shape, guys. If this was the mid-1800s, and you had a guy who was every
00:49:22 five years making major theological changes, then yeah, I would be right there with you saying,
00:49:27 what's up with that? That's kind of weird. But it's not the mid-1800s, right? It's the year of
00:49:34 our Lord, 2025, where for at least 70 years here in these United States, the church has been
00:49:41 atrocious in much of its doctrine, and the only way out of it is for people to build the plane
00:49:48 in mid-flight and admit as they're learning, I was wrong, I'm changing and now doing this.
00:49:55 So I think it's a component of two things with Allie and her show five years ago. One,
00:50:01 I've changed. I was more wrong then, still wrong now, I'm sure, but more wrong then five years ago
00:50:09 than I am today because I'm trying to change. That's one, I changed. Number two, there is a
00:50:15 difference in going on someone else's platform versus having them on yours. There is something
00:50:20 to be said for some degree of measured pragmatism and strategy. Eric, do you have any thoughts
00:50:28 about that before we go to our next commercial? Yeah, I think particularly just the element of
00:50:33 change. You mentioned Ogden. We've had some of that too. I always think it's funny because
00:50:37 people will dunk on Brian. They find some picture from 15 years ago when Brian had a soul patch and
00:50:44 you know maybe a little bit of a hipster look to him and they're like oh isn't this funny
00:50:49 but i think you know i'm old enough to remember i kind of grew up in a time period before social
00:50:54 media before everything was online there is no twitter from when i was nine years old because
00:50:59 well twitter didn't exist and now x so i think part of it is uh giving guys grace uh to say that
00:51:07 yeah because of the times that we're living in there's been a ton of change think about martin
00:51:11 Luther and the Reformation, though. So much change was happening then because it was a very dark
00:51:16 period in the church. And nobody today looks at Martin Luther and says, wow, you sure changed a
00:51:20 lot. That's a knock against you. No, in fact, we have conferences celebrating the things that he
00:51:24 taught because it was bringing light back to the church. And then I would say this too. There's a
00:51:30 dynamic in which anytime you try to do the work of reform retrieval, this historical work, it's
00:51:37 necessarily going to be a situation where people hate you people are opposed to you people take it
00:51:42 personally and one thing i'll just continually go back to even with ali bath this really isn't a
00:51:48 personal thing uh between you know say me and her or any anyone else in our camp and her it's more
00:51:54 of a principled issue particularly when we think about our women and i don't want our women being
00:52:00 reared in an environment spiritually where they feel like having an opinion on everything
00:52:06 politically and being very loud about it is the only way that they can be a glory as a woman
00:52:11 instead i want them like you said to feel at peace in the home my wife is much the same way
00:52:16 she doesn't even usually ask me about twitter she said i you know i know it's bad i know they're
00:52:21 probably coming after you thank you for shielding me from that the home is peaceful because i don't
00:52:27 have to know all of those things and so i think just for our ladies um if if people can see the
00:52:33 inside of the church and see what we're teaching and then what the fruits of that is. It's actually
00:52:40 happy women, happy homes, and as Michael mentioned, a rich culture building within the home that just
00:52:47 emanates out of the walls into the church in really a joyful way.
00:52:52 Amen. All right, let's go to a commercial break. We'll be right back.
00:52:56 Our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants to help you with one money move that'll implicate
00:53:01 itself in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day. They help you to avoid
00:53:07 taxation and to draw compound interest to your money. Now, if you're a high net worth individual,
00:53:14 someone who has maybe even $10 million in net worth, then they can help you even more. W-2
00:53:20 workers, contract workers, business owners, it's all about cash flow and making tax deferred gains
00:53:27 on all your money for the rest of your life.
00:53:30 Don't avoid this.
00:53:31 It's a big move, but it's a great time to make it.
00:53:34 Click the link below
00:53:35 and you can get on Chuck DeLaterrante's calendar
00:53:38 and he'll go over your background
00:53:39 and what you want to accomplish.
00:53:42 And he's going to help model a program
00:53:44 that exactly fits your needs.
00:53:46 So go ahead and send an email
00:53:47 to chuckatprivatefamilybanking.com.
00:53:51 Again, that's chuckatprivatefamilybanking.com
00:53:55 or you can click the link below.
00:53:57 Make a free discovery call now.
00:54:00 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God
00:54:04 and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:54:08 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
00:54:11 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
00:54:15 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:54:18 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:54:23 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
00:54:30 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:54:36 There it is. We found the Qatar money right there.
00:54:39 David Reese.
00:54:42 Who was it that accused us of taking Qatar money?
00:54:45 Joel Berry.
00:54:46 That's the one and only Joel Berry, yes. 0.98
00:54:49 Mr. Zionism himself, Joel Berry. 0.98
00:54:50 Mr. Zionism. Yeah, we're using all that Qatari money to build Christian nations. Isn't that 0.92
00:54:57 something? There we go. Yeah, it's a bold strategy for the Muslims, huh? Let's see if it works out
00:55:02 for them. It is. We're going to fund guys to build Christian nations to help Islam. Okay,
00:55:09 we'll see. All right, so we're going to go ahead and just hop into it. We want to play this last
00:55:14 clip, Eric, and get your thoughts, get my thoughts, see if Wes and Michael have something that they
00:55:18 want to add and then we're going to start dealing with the chat we've got a ton of questions
00:55:22 and i assume that we have a ton of questions because they all want to hear from me no i'm
00:55:28 just kidding um i think part of it's because you're here so eric if you're willing um yeah
00:55:34 probably it's about four o'clock right now i think we can be done by five can you give us another
00:55:38 hour to do this clip and then do some questions yeah that's great great okay uh nathan is going
00:55:44 to play this, but it's already just the way that the tech works. He's already into the clip a
00:55:48 little bit. So for the listener and the viewer, please, um, please forgive Nathan. Uh, he's doing
00:55:53 his very best and he does an awesome job. He's going to play it. And then he's going to have
00:55:57 to immediately rewind it because it's going to, it's going to kind of like start right in the
00:56:00 middle. He'll rewind it and then he'll let it go. And we'll see the whole thing here.
00:56:04 Khan also said that women should not be arguing with men on Twitter using insults like heretic
00:56:10 without addressing the issues through proper channels like their husbands and their church.
00:56:15 Okay, what's funny is that I have never argued with any of these people on Twitter,
00:56:20 but he and other men like him have repeatedly tried to goad me into a debate for attention.
00:56:26 They've picked fights with me, with other women, even though I've never given them the time of day.
00:56:34 And so they are extremely catty. 0.86
00:56:37 They pick lots of fights.
00:56:38 they get into lots of little arguments. And at the same time, they will be like, no, we're on
00:56:44 the front lines fighting the culture war. And women shouldn't be on here, bro. It's a podcast. 1.00
00:56:49 Okay. It's a podcast. And one thing that women are really good at doing is talking.
00:56:57 So let me go first, Eric, and then I'll throw it to you. So just to provide some hit. Yeah, 1.00
00:57:02 I know it's rough. But just to provide some history for the listener, a lot of our listeners
00:57:07 may be aware of this, but for those who aren't, um, so that part, you know, I tried, I tried to
00:57:12 defend Allie earlier and say, yeah, I think both of these things could be true. Like I didn't want
00:57:15 to have them on the show, but also I did, you know, because they paid for an ad, um, which that
00:57:20 does, the details do matter. Like if you want to give me a hard time because we paid Allie for an 0.96
00:57:24 ad and I also asked if I could do a segment, that's fine. But what you see online is people
00:57:29 saying, well, he paid to go on the show. Well, no, we didn't. We paid for an ad. I asked to go
00:57:33 on the show. She felt obligated by her own admission because we paid for the ad to oblige 0.99
00:57:39 that request. So there I wanted to defend her and say, yeah, I think that's probably true when she 0.98
00:57:43 says I didn't really want to have Joel, but I went ahead and did it anyways. I think she's being
00:57:47 truthful. That last clip that we just watched is not truthful. And you know what? I'll say this
00:57:53 again to try to steal man and give as much charity as possible. Sometimes when we say things that
00:58:00 aren't truthful, it can be nefarious, it can be malicious, that we're intentionally being deceptive.
00:58:05 It also, it's not always our fallibility, it can also be our finitude, right? It could be just the
00:58:10 fact that we're creaturely, and we don't have steel trap perfect, you know, memories all the
00:58:15 time. So, giving the benefit of the doubt, maybe she's not trying to be deceitful here, but maybe
00:58:20 she just forgot. But I remember, because for me, it was a bit of an ordeal, and so it's more
00:58:27 memorable. But the way that this started, it started when Allie Beth quoted, she read
00:58:35 verbatim for about five, six minutes or so, a portion of a transcript of my sermon on her show 0.72
00:58:44 and then mocked it. And then multiple women at the time, this was about two and a half years ago.
00:58:50 23, I think. Yeah. Two years ago, something like that. Multiple women in our church,
00:58:56 their husbands approached me because their wives were struggling with that, you know,
00:59:00 because their wives at the time, now at this point, I don't know if we really have anyone
00:59:05 in our church who listens to Allie Beth or definitely few. And I don't say that as like
00:59:11 a dunk or anything. It's just like the people who are big fans of Allie Beth are probably not big
00:59:16 fans of me. You know, it's just like, we don't have as much overlap. There was a time where we
00:59:20 had more overlap and now not so much. But when she read that transcript from my sermon and then
00:59:27 proceeded to make fun of it and say why it was theologically wrong and why it was also just 0.99
00:59:33 stupid and dumb, that affected me at a pastoral level. I had to do meetings with people and I had 0.99
00:59:40 to explain things to people. For me, I'm not just a podcaster. Yes, I podcast, but I also am a pastor.
00:59:49 And so, I'm shepherding people's souls, and if you have women in your church who think very highly of Ali Bastaki, because they had previously had listened to her for years before even coming to our church, and had gotten some of the polemical, you know, boss babe, kind of catty, snarky stuff that's maybe not so good for their soul.
01:00:13 but also, I'm not going to say that's all it is, also some things that are objectively theologically
01:00:18 true and some good counsel along the way and this and that and the other. And so, they've benefited
01:00:22 from her. They've been blessed by her and they have a history of maybe they listened to her for
01:00:27 two years, three years, four years, and then came to Covenant Bible Church. And it was primarily
01:00:33 the families that were new to our church. And Eric, I'm going to let you, because I think you
01:00:36 guys have a similar experience. So, you're talking about not just one, but a handful,
01:00:41 multiple newer families to our church that have only been there maybe six months or a year at most
01:00:46 that have been, you know, the wives have been fans of Ali Bestucki and have benefited from her.
01:00:53 And then, you know, they hear their pastor preach a sermon and they weren't bothered by it because
01:00:57 they heard the whole context, the whole sermon. They know me and they thought that's true. That
01:01:02 was good. But then that, imagine that next week they're listening to their favorite Christian 0.99
01:01:07 female podcaster and she is saying now ali didn't name me which i appreciate it i appreciated that
01:01:15 but for me it was it was a local pastoral challenge that was presented by this not a
01:01:20 public image challenge it wasn't for my podcast it was for my pastoral ministry when she quoted
01:01:26 word for word five six minutes straight of a manuscript the manuscript for my sermon 0.91
01:01:31 all the women in my church in public people maybe didn't know but the women in my church 0.99
01:01:36 they knew exactly whose sermon that was. I heard that sermon last week. I know who that is. 0.96
01:01:44 And she's saying, my pastor is silly and stupid. And more importantly than that, 1.00
01:01:52 theologically and biblically unfaithful and wrong. Maybe I should be concerned. 0.99
01:01:59 you know, so that created, and that was the first occurrence. So, let the record be clear and be
01:02:11 straight. We were teaching, guys like me, guys like Eric, guys like Brian, we were teaching the
01:02:18 principles of biblical patriarchy, including not just that you should have, you know, not just
01:02:23 complementarianism that you, as long as you have, you know, um, male elders and only men preach on 0.95
01:02:29 the Lord's day, then women can do everything else, including being, you know, they don't have the
01:02:34 title, they're not ordained, but they actually can be the shadow elders who actually tell their
01:02:37 husbands what to do and really run the church. And they can also preach in all these other contexts
01:02:42 and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Um, we're not complementarian. We are patriarchal. And so we've
01:02:48 been teaching these principles of biblical patriarchy um for you know the last few years
01:02:53 and and i don't know about you eric maybe your story's different you can speak for yourself but
01:03:00 for me i had not and i know this i had not named ali bestaki once not once as i was talking about
01:03:08 what i see as a problem of women who are not elders they're not preaching on the lord's day
01:03:13 but they're still doing a lot of polemical, theological warring in the public sphere. 1.00
01:03:21 Just in a nutshell, in general, I don't want to see women in the public sphere. You mean they 1.00
01:03:28 shouldn't hold political office? Correct. You mean you don't want to see them podcasting? Correct.
01:03:35 Well, but what about in the marketplace, you know, with nine to five careers? No,
01:03:41 not that either like i i don't want to see women holding positions in the public square i don't 1.00
01:03:49 um not just i don't want to see women in combat positions in the military that's 1.00
01:03:53 finally we've gotten there we've finally gotten to the point as a culture we can say yeah female 0.98
01:03:57 people you know female females in the secret service might be a bad idea i'm glad we've 0.72
01:04:02 gotten there but the president almost died well maybe not now that the president has almost died 1.00
01:04:07 because yeah, now we can say that. Yeah. So I'm glad we can say that. That's an improvement. Praise
01:04:12 God. But I want to go way further than that. Way further than that. So we were talking about those
01:04:17 kinds of things before. And I think that Allie must have heard something and it bothered her,
01:04:25 but I had not named her. But then she, and again, to be clear and be honest, she did not name me,
01:04:31 But she did verbatim read a transcript, not just two sentences, a whole portion of one of my sermons out of context to where every single woman in my church knew that she was talking about me and I had to address it.
01:04:47 So when she says, you know, these guys are catty and they want to pick fights, I just think it helps to remember the details of what actually happened.
01:04:59 Eric, do you have any thoughts?
01:04:59 yeah i think in particular um i want to give credit here i think it was jeff wright and
01:05:05 bendelwary uh who i first heard this from but one of the problems i think when you put a woman
01:05:10 in the polemical role culture warring something she's not designed to do 1.00
01:05:15 generally her fight mode is mama bear and you kind of see that sort of thing happening
01:05:21 i would also say in listening to the clip with ali what she just said um i think there's quite
01:05:28 a bit of continued reading of you know motive and intent in there i keep hearing things like
01:05:35 these guys are chasing clout and they're just jealous of my platform and um i i won't even
01:05:41 respond to them here i am above it all but that's actually going back to what you said about a year
01:05:46 ago when this all kicked off i remember her you know citing from the sermon of course we all kind
01:05:51 of knew what she was talking about going after it pretty directly word for word it quickly became
01:05:56 a thing where people knew who it was about but also what she was doing on our end we were
01:06:01 responding in general at the time not specifically to her and like she would do a screenshot of
01:06:08 one of my posts try to cut off like half of my face but you could clearly anybody who knows it
01:06:13 was still me but her whole thing was like well I don't I don't want to give these guys a bigger
01:06:18 platform because they just want my platform blah blah blah I think all of that is look it's
01:06:23 fundamental misunderstanding, again, about the personal nature of the agon of ideas. When we
01:06:29 come into Twitter, Oren McIntyre has said this, when we come into Twitter, it's like the Coliseum
01:06:33 and now acts. People come here for blood. It's a bit of a blood sport. Not saying we all have to
01:06:38 play that game identically, but it's an exchange of ideas. So if you come out in the marketplace
01:06:44 of ideas, you exchange an idea and then in bad faith, try to dunk on people and then act like
01:06:49 the victim i mean for a lot of people that's probably not going to be a very good look i also
01:06:54 think it's you know inherently dishonest and to the personal i guess the personal and the pastoral
01:07:00 the reason it became an issue for us is because we had people in the church uh who were in the 0.99
01:07:06 process of you know leaving because uh you know it's generally a woman running her household
01:07:11 she's listening to allie beth stuckey she's wildly offended that we would ever disagree 0.97
01:07:17 with anything that Allie Beth said and then goes on listening to Allie Beth as the conflict 0.82
01:07:23 goes on and felt the same way. It was like, I would say I was disagreeing with Allie Beth
01:07:29 and she would say, you're attacking her. And that's, again, that's a very feminine coded way 0.97
01:07:36 to look at how conflicts work. Women are generally peacemakers. I do think it's funny. 1.00
01:07:41 um maybe it's a it's a show of no bad blood but i think like two weeks after that kicked off
01:07:47 uh ali best dad uh their publisher reached out on their book and said do you want to interview
01:07:52 ali best dad i was like sure why not like you know he's a nice guy we had a good conversation
01:07:57 and uh you know i i had mentioned it then and in our conversation uh i've actually emailed uh the
01:08:05 show, relatable. I said, look, you know, if you want to talk offline, not trying to chase clout
01:08:11 or whatever, but would love a, you know, a discussion with your husband or whatever,
01:08:16 whoever you want me to talk to. But yeah, would be more than happy to address it in a fair and
01:08:22 equitable way. But look, I think it comes back to this bottom line. It's jeopardizing money and
01:08:27 career. And anytime you have that, you know, understandably, you're going to have somewhat
01:08:31 of a hostile hostile response right well said yeah yeah i remember you asked me eric i think
01:08:38 it was about a year ago you said uh we were talking he said joel would you would you be
01:08:44 willing to uh to talk to ali about this as things were kind of a little bit you know some drama in
01:08:50 the public sphere and i said eric i would be more than happy to talk to her husband
01:08:54 i would love to talk to her husband that sounds great west michael do you guys have any thoughts
01:09:00 i was just going to mention what eric mentioned too about um while she while some of the clips
01:09:06 that we showed i think she was fair she said you know when i interviewed joel i didn't actually
01:09:11 disagree with him at the time yeah that's true but definitely that last one was pushing into it
01:09:19 impugning motives uh weighing in evaluating motives they're doing it for platform for clout
01:09:25 but eric brought that up already so i'll i'll leave it there yeah okay wes i can't believe
01:09:29 she gets a couch and i've got chairs we need a nice leather couch in the studio
01:09:33 yeah that's it that's all that's that's all i have that that's all yeah he wanted to that's
01:09:41 all you got he's yeah he's chiming in for a couch i love that the other thing i would say you know
01:09:45 you hear this from lots of uh social media people the clout chasing uh there there's a level i think
01:09:51 where we all have to be a little bit honest and say if you're on social media if you have a media
01:09:56 a company let's be real we're we're all trying to grow audiences and it doesn't necessarily have to
01:10:01 be nefarious we just believe that our message is important and we want to get the message out so
01:10:06 if ali said to me hey i just think you're trying to grow your media company i'd be like yeah aren't
01:10:10 you i mean isn't that what anybody in this space is doing so let's just be honest about that that's
01:10:16 i'm so glad and that's the one thing that i wanted to bring up you're absolutely right um you know
01:10:20 people say well i think jewel's just platform building so everyone with a platform is platform
01:10:25 building like you know and a lot of times there's people who like you know really love like you know
01:10:31 someone like john mccarthur who has a massive platform and you know i always tell him i'll say
01:10:35 look here's the deal somebody at some point in his ministry john mccarthur's ministry
01:10:41 went to him and said i think your preaching is really good i think it could benefit more than
01:10:48 just the local church a broader wider audience i would like to record it with tapes or record it
01:10:53 with video cameras and at some point right if john mccarthur did not want a platform then he could
01:11:00 have said no he would have said no at some point at the at the end of the day i'm not saying he's
01:11:05 doing it himself that he's showing up you know like three hours before the sunday sermon and
01:11:09 you know plugging in the cameras i'm not saying that he's doing it himself but he still gave his
01:11:14 consent like somebody came to him and said we think you have a gift and a message that would
01:11:21 benefit a broader audience and we'd like to do this x y and z and we need your permission and
01:11:27 john macarthur said yes i give you permission to help me build my platform i want to build
01:11:35 a platform and i'm not trying to pick on john macarthur because there's nothing wrong with that
01:11:40 this has been happening since the printing press with reprinting sermons in england right it wasn't
01:11:46 the sermon it um william perkins didn't do that it was the publisher that pursued it and then
01:11:50 William Perkins said, okay, let's do it.
01:11:52 But he gave his consent.
01:11:53 He said, yes, I would like for that to happen.
01:11:55 Charles Spurgeon, like his, you know, the Monday paper would always include, you know,
01:11:59 in London, his sermon, you know, from the London tabernacle, you know, Metropolitan,
01:12:03 you know, whatever.
01:12:04 And he gave his consent for that.
01:12:06 So, everybody that you've heard of, other than if it's a flesh and blood relationship,
01:12:11 like with your dad or with your local pastor or everybody else that you've heard of, but
01:12:16 you've never met, you don't have a personal relationship with, you've heard of them because
01:12:20 they made, at some point along the way, they made a conscious decision to build a platform.
01:12:26 And that decision in and of itself is not, there's nothing inherently wrong with that.
01:12:31 It's the same as, it's back to the trad wife, sourdough and sundresses. Nothing wrong with
01:12:35 sourdough and sundresses. In fact, I can make the argument that that's actually even good. There's
01:12:40 actually, if anything, there is something inherent in that, and it's inherently positive,
01:12:45 certainly in terms of comparatively to dressing immodestly and just, you know, using Uber Eats
01:12:54 or something for every meal for your children that's unhealthy and blah, blah, blah, and it's
01:12:57 not natural. So, there's actually something, not only is it not inherently bad, it's actually
01:13:02 inherently good. It could also be still bad, even though it's on the surface, it's inherently good.
01:13:08 It can still be bad if there are inwardly bad motives, right? I'm just trying to be seen,
01:13:13 the praise of men or whatever it is with the trad wife thing. Same concept, that same concept, 0.61
01:13:19 now apply it to platform building. Salvador is not inherently bad. Platform building is not
01:13:25 inherently bad. The question is the motives. And that's up to the individual, especially if it's
01:13:31 a follower of Christ, for them to be able to say, as David did, search me, O God, if there's anything
01:13:38 that's not upright. Search my heart. Purge from me any sinful motives, any sinful incentives,
01:13:46 any Qatar money, any of that, Lord, just purge it out. But that's ultimately up to each individual.
01:13:56 That's their responsibility before the Lord, and they need at a personal level, not the masses
01:14:01 online, but flesh and blood relationships in their life to hold them accountable. Their elders,
01:14:07 their spouse, those people in their life to say, hey, I just want to make sure that at the end of
01:14:12 the day, that it's for the glory of God. It's for the glory of God. And checking, for lack of a
01:14:19 better phrase, checking your heart, examining yourself, try me, Lord, search me, Lord,
01:14:27 are my motives true? But platform building, aside from there being bad motives, all things being
01:14:32 equal. Just the act of trying to build a larger mechanism for getting a message out to more
01:14:38 people, there is nothing inherently wrong about that. In fact, that can be really good if the
01:14:45 message that you're trying to communicate is something that's true and biblical and pleasing
01:14:49 to the Lord. So, this idea of like, well, I just feel like these guys are platform building.
01:14:55 Yeah, that's right.
01:14:56 And so are you.
01:14:58 So are you.
01:15:01 Everybody with a platform is platform building.
01:15:04 Okay, any other thoughts?
01:15:06 Go ahead.
01:15:07 Yeah, I was just going to say, some of it too is just, I think people weighing the internal
01:15:12 inconsistencies that many of us have, right?
01:15:15 You're at ShepCon, since you mentioned John MacArthur.
01:15:17 You're at Shepard's Conference, and you're there to see all your favorite preachers.
01:15:21 and then maybe there's somebody outside your camp you look at maybe like us and you go
01:15:24 man this is crazy they host conferences and they want attention i can't believe them and then you
01:15:30 know it's like john mccarthur has his face on a fresca can and i'm like actually i thought that
01:15:33 was pretty cool i mean it's kind of funny uh that's cool i think a lot of it is that and then
01:15:38 i also think too uh when you look at these worlds this kind of related to patriarchy hannah which
01:15:42 obviously ali brings up um but when you you look at something like that in the g3 shepcon world
01:15:50 steve lawson falls and nobody says man i bet reform theology is just not even true 0.96
01:15:57 right right well in the same way it's like you have somebody who does something that's dumb 0.93
01:16:01 says sorry uh and we all admit like that was a really dumb that's bad don't do that uh lying
01:16:08 is bad i think we can all agree on that one um but but the same camp and i'm not saying everybody
01:16:14 there but like with ali bath in particular uh i think it's just a useful tool and a cudgel
01:16:19 to say you know oh man i can't believe it you've uh you know it's all it's all patriarchy is all
01:16:27 wrong because of this one person who did a bad thing is it no let's just be more consistent
01:16:31 obviously there are people who fall that's unfortunate and we stand on timeless truths
01:16:36 and we just keep going with that that's so well said yes you and i each one time being assured
01:16:45 that she had her husband's permission
01:16:47 and that he was going to listen
01:16:48 to the recording
01:16:49 before it was published publicly.
01:16:53 Went on her podcast,
01:16:55 Patriarchy Hannah,
01:16:56 each of us,
01:16:57 one time,
01:16:58 an audio-only podcast
01:17:00 to be heard by,
01:17:02 as far as we were both informed,
01:17:04 a few dozen women. 1.00
01:17:07 Maybe a hundred. 1.00
01:17:09 Two hundred max.
01:17:12 And then it comes out 1.00
01:17:14 that patriarchy Hannah lied. She was living a lie. And all the Calvinists, right? We're not 1.00
01:17:25 talking about the pagans. Of course, they love it. But the Calvinists, the reformed camp of
01:17:32 evangelicalism, they come out and say, here it is, the smoking gun, inarguable, irrefutable evidence
01:17:40 that patriarchy is false, that the whole thing is, it's a false doctrine because the fruit is false.
01:17:47 Whereas, and again, we went on her audio only podcast once. This same guy's criticizing
01:17:56 platformed Steve Lawson at every conference, at seminaries, publishing books, Ligonier cruises
01:18:06 for a decade or or more they were platforming him on the largest platforms and not once
01:18:14 but hundreds of times between the number of podcasts uh the number of speaking engagements
01:18:21 and conferences and seminaries and cruises and all these things for a a decade at least
01:18:28 hundreds of times on massive platforms and he in the very same way let's be consistent here
01:18:37 steve lawson just like patriarchy hannah was also living a lie living a lie the only difference to
01:18:47 be fair to patriarchy hannah is that she apologized yep quickly and publicly and for
01:18:54 the record, I'll say this because I don't think it's private. I don't think she would mind. But
01:19:00 you and I, Eric, we don't have a relationship or a friendship with her. One, because she's a woman. 1.00
01:19:05 I don't have female friends. My wife has female friends. And by proxy, adjacent, I know those 1.00
01:19:11 women who I'm friends with their husband and they're friends with my wife. That's about it.
01:19:15 So we don't have relationships with women. And so for that reason, that reason alone, 0.99
01:19:20 neither eric or i had any any relationship with patriarchy hannah we went on her podcast one time
01:19:26 i i was in a space that she was hosting one or maybe two times by that metric if that's
01:19:34 relationship then michael foster was 10 times a friend of patriarchy hannah than eric or myself
01:19:40 right so and i and i just to be clear i don't think michael foster did anything wrong but you
01:19:46 just if you're going to give me and eric a hard time let's you just got to equal weights and
01:19:49 measures. If you're mad at me and Eric, then you should be done with Michael Foster, if we're
01:19:54 being consistent. So all that being said, here's the point. We don't have a relationship with
01:19:58 patriarchy, Hannah. However, she messaged us, and I think it's appropriate to say this. I don't
01:20:04 think she would mind. This is one of the only private messages I've ever received from her,
01:20:08 and she messaged both of us together. So it wasn't just her with me or her with you, but
01:20:11 a message to both Eric and I, and it was just, was it last night or two nights ago?
01:20:17 two days ago yeah uh that's i think it was on i think it was on wednesday yeah and it was a
01:20:25 i would say you correct me if i'm wrong but a pretty profuse heartfelt i i don't i don't see
01:20:31 her heart god alone sees a heart but in terms of the words that she sent uh profuse heartfelt
01:20:37 apology because and i think the reason and here's the deal because you know the the bad faith
01:20:42 listeners will say well the fact that she sent you a person not just the public one that she posted
01:20:46 but a personal apology to you and Eric, that just confirms that you and Eric actually did platform
01:20:50 her and you were probably best friends with her and talking to her on a day. No, I think she reached
01:20:56 out to me and Eric, not because we had any kind of engagement or relationship with her. I think
01:21:01 she reached out to me and Eric because she noticed and saw online that me and Eric are the main
01:21:06 guys, the main object of criticism. Nobody's upset with Michael Foster because he's not quite
01:21:15 is outspoken about these things as eric and i am he was but not recently and so eric and i we got
01:21:23 a personal apology from patriarchy hannah not because of a personal friendship or close vicinity
01:21:30 but because she noticed and she said this in her apology i noticed that you guys are getting the
01:21:36 brunt of uh of criticism because of my failure my sin and i'm so so sorry and so i just want to say
01:21:44 back to steve lawson the main difference they both were living a lie the main difference is that one
01:21:50 was platformed legitimately platformed on real serious large platforms hundreds of times for a
01:21:58 decade and when he fell and it proved that he was pulling the wool over people's eyes
01:22:04 and and was deceiving people living a lie for years and years nobody said oh time to pack it
01:22:12 in. Calvinism's not true. Oh, time to pack it in. The sovereignty of God, I guess it's just a farce.
01:22:18 Right? And then some woman with a tiny, comparatively speaking, Steve Lawson versus 0.97
01:22:25 Patriarch, a tiny platform who virtually no one platformed. You and I wouldn't have had her on our
01:22:31 show, but we went on her show as a courtesy one time each. She comes out and everyone's like,
01:22:38 here it is, this is it, it's over, irrefutable proof that patriarchy is a lie. What does that
01:22:46 tell you? That doesn't really speak to the caliber of sin that she committed, although I think it was
01:22:51 serious. And it doesn't speak, the fact that she personally apologized to us doesn't speak about
01:22:55 the vicinity of our relationship to her. She just noticed that me and you, Eric,
01:23:00 were getting the brunt of the criticism. What it says, what it speaks to, I think,
01:23:04 is it shows you what Christian message particularly is currently in our culture today under attack
01:23:12 and needs to be spoken about courageously by men like Eric all the more, right? There was a time
01:23:21 where Calvinism, Calvinism was a little bit icky. It was controversial. It was a cutting edge.
01:23:29 Calvinism still upsets some people. Don't get me wrong. But let's be honest. You want to be hated?
01:23:34 talk about biblical patriarchy the the reason why the double standard and this is a double 0.97
01:23:41 standard steve lawson fails calvinism is still true patriarchy hannah turns out a woman lied
01:23:48 and pack it up boys you're done the patriarchy we buried it six feet under like why what what's
01:23:54 what such a stark difference why because one of those messages is generally accepted even if not
01:24:02 even agreed upon it's generally accepted among evangelicals namely calvinism the other one
01:24:08 is absolutely despised with vitriol like i mean it is it is seriously hated namely
01:24:17 biblical roles of men and women and i i think we would be remiss if that was not included in this
01:24:24 episode any further thoughts from you guys and then we'll go to some questions on the commercial
01:24:29 break maybe before the questions eric you got some thoughts yeah well i think you know that's
01:24:35 what you said is really true i think the other thing is um you have to ask which theologies you
01:24:41 know if it's complementarian if it's biblical patriarchy which one can be syncretized with
01:24:47 the culture at large i think complementarianism that's what it is uh people like it because you
01:24:52 can syncretize it it doesn't disrupt your world quite as much you're like well my husband has a
01:24:57 tiebreak vote. Other than that, I can go out in the world and do pretty much whatever I want,
01:25:01 wear whatever I want, etc. And then I think with biblical patriarchy, it's just it's a cultural
01:25:06 disruptor. And anytime you have people who are disrupting the cultural zeitgeist, you're
01:25:10 obviously going to have heat and attention and frustration from people. And, you know, obviously
01:25:16 you want to make sure you're doing it on biblical principle and you want to do things righteously. 0.97
01:25:20 You want to make sure that you're not just getting a mob because, you know, you're saying dumb 0.96
01:25:24 things. But think about the number of times that Paul starts a riot. And sometimes intentionally, 0.78
01:25:31 he sees the Pharisees and the Sadducees, and he looks at them both and kind of the crowd forming.
01:25:35 And he's like, I'm actually here on account of the resurrection, ladies and gentlemen,
01:25:38 and everybody's in an uproar. And so I think part of this is kind of twofold. One, just for
01:25:45 the people who are listening to say that, yes, you know, speaking up in any form on the hot
01:25:52 button issues, if you're going to poke the idol in both eyes, there's usually going to be a strong
01:25:57 response and you should be prepared for that. And then I think for the people, the other folks who
01:26:02 are speaking to the truth on these issues, I just think I look at it and I say, okay, we're probably
01:26:07 over the target. And I know people don't like that. We have to, with gentleness, continue to
01:26:13 teach the true doctrines of scripture. We believe that they can be defended from the text of
01:26:19 scripture. And so we're just going to keep pressing in. Christ himself said, you know,
01:26:23 you're going to be persecuted. And we just got to square that in our own minds. And I think the
01:26:29 real temptation actually is if your platform does grow and you start making ground, that's really
01:26:35 where you run into danger because you have a lot of people who will come to you and they will say,
01:26:39 hey, if you could just tone that down a little bit, I could get you on this little bit higher
01:26:43 platform show. And of course, you know, for my money, it's like, no, I think I'll just
01:26:49 I'll stick with the old truths and, you know, the old reformed faith and, you know, come what may,
01:26:55 Joel, come what may. All right. More like come what gay. Am I right? All right. Okay. Here's
01:27:02 our final commercial break for the day. All right. The clock is running out. You need to go and
01:27:07 register now for our Christ is King, how to defeat trash world conference. It's happening
01:27:13 The Year of Our Lord, 2025, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
01:27:17 That's a Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.
01:27:20 And by God's grace, we're able to provide for you an all-star lineup.
01:27:24 We've got Steve Dace, Calvin Robinson, Oren McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolfe, Eric Kahn, David
01:27:30 Reese, Andrew Isker, John Harris, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett,
01:27:37 C.J. Engel, and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webin.
01:27:41 Come on out. Join us April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, 2025, Thursday through Saturday. Go to
01:27:48 rightresponseconference.com to register today. Again, that's rightresponseconference.com.
01:27:56 Listen, guys, you probably listen to Right Response Ministries because
01:27:59 you take the Dominion mandate offered to us in Scripture seriously. Well, unsurprisingly,
01:28:05 so does Dominion Wealth Strategist. As the only distinctly reformed financial consulting firm,
01:28:13 they help Calvinistic, covenantal, and confessional Christians to steward their
01:28:18 resources faithfully in a way that actually aligns with God's Word. Dominion Wealth leverages
01:28:24 all corners of the financial service industry as independent brokerage agents, matching you
01:28:30 with suitable products and services from dozens of top industry providers. Their mission is to
01:28:37 equip believers to secure their family's future and build a legacy that glorifies God by building
01:28:45 holistic financial strategies that include budgeting, insurance, debt management, retirement
01:28:51 planning, estate planning, and more. In order to make wealth Christian again with a portfolio that
01:28:58 might even put King Solomon to shame, go and take dominion over your finances today by visiting
01:29:05 www.reformed.money and book an introductory overview right now. All of Christ for all of life
01:29:14 and all of finance for Christendom. All right, we're back. We're going to get into some of the
01:29:22 questions. Eric, thanks for sticking around. We've got about half an hour. We're going to do our best
01:29:26 to be done by five. Michael, why don't you lead us off? Okay. So we've got the super chat from
01:29:32 the earlier in the episode. Nate, if you can scroll up. All the way at the top. There we go.
01:29:36 This is from Ben Huffstetler. Ben, very generous. Incredible. Thank you very much.
01:29:40 Whatever industry Ben is in, Ben, you have to get in that industry.
01:29:43 Ben has been hitting us up with $100 super chats. Yep. Very kind. Single-handedly supporting this
01:29:48 ministry. That's right. He says, thoughts on helping a wife and daughter that is coming out
01:29:54 of new age and into full submission to her calling. We have been transitioning for a few
01:29:59 years now. They are all in. My wife is struggling with not overriding me in conversations. My
01:30:06 daughter is just generally much love. Sounds like generally all in. Yeah. Sounds good. Yeah. Much
01:30:13 love. Thanks again, Ben. Cool. Thanks, Ben. I think that progress matters, right? Wes,
01:30:20 you and I have had conversations about this.
01:30:22 Is there a sense where it should be expected?
01:30:25 Does Christ expect all of our obedience to be perfect?
01:30:29 Hebrews says, be holy and pursue sanctification
01:30:32 without which no one will see the Lord.
01:30:34 There is a sense where we want to hold ourselves
01:30:36 to that standard.
01:30:37 There's also the practical reality of sanctification.
01:30:40 And if your wife and your daughter are moving rapidly
01:30:44 and consistently in that direction,
01:30:46 I would not break that reed.
01:30:48 I would not, you know, diminish that obedience.
01:30:52 I think that it's appropriate if you see specific things that are strategic as your role in your role as a husband to say there's been a lot of progress, but this is a specific issue.
01:31:01 Can we strategize? Can we talk? Can we pray about this? Bring those up.
01:31:05 But if it's just a general how do we move faster?
01:31:09 I don't know. The reality is a lot of people are coming out of perspectives that were wrong.
01:31:13 And that's that does sometimes take a while to change.
01:31:16 So be strategic, be specific, get them around other women who are thinking the same way.
01:31:23 You know, go to a church that is preaching along those lines so that they're hearing
01:31:27 it from the pulpit and they're around other women who are working, not working in that
01:31:34 direction and demonstrating that in their own lives.
01:31:38 And I would say, having seen situations where it doesn't go well, I would be very thankful
01:31:44 to the Lord that he has inclined your wife and daughter's hearts in this direction and
01:31:48 encourage them, challenge them when necessary to grow in that direction.
01:31:52 Well said.
01:31:53 Yeah, I think it's like what I was saying earlier.
01:31:56 You know, the reason why I've had to change is because the train is way off the rails.
01:32:03 It's the year of our Lord, 2025, and America and pretty much all of Christodom in the West
01:32:08 and European countries have been fervently apostatizing against the Lord Jesus Christ
01:32:14 for arguably 70 years, arguably 130 years, and arguably like 300 years, depending from where
01:32:21 you start. We have been in quite a dip, quite a rebellion against the Lord. And so the only way
01:32:30 to right the ship is going to be some pretty significant about-face, full turnaround, deep
01:32:38 repentance and change that said um i do think that um you kind of get to choose as the husband
01:32:47 you don't get to choose what god's word says you don't get to choose what's sin and what's not and
01:32:52 whether repentance is necessary but you you do um just like a parent right it's not exactly the
01:32:58 same the authority of a husband over a wife it is different than the authority over over a child
01:33:04 But as my wife and I are parenting, one of the consistent conversations that comes up again and again is, do we really want to make that a command?
01:33:13 We can.
01:33:14 We do have that God-given authority.
01:33:16 We can make this command.
01:33:17 And just for the record, our kids, because people give grief about this because they're bad faith listeners and they assume the worst.
01:33:23 Our kids are little.
01:33:24 We have seven, five, four, two, and zero.
01:33:28 Five kids, those are the ages.
01:33:29 So we're talking about little kids.
01:33:30 but like as soon as you get home from school you can do it instinctively without even thinking
01:33:35 about it right so you you you come out of the garage you just park the van you open the door
01:33:38 we have a shoe cubby right there by the door to the garage where they come in and right there as
01:33:43 a parent i have a choice i can say all right take off your uh take off your shoes go potty
01:33:49 get changed and uh and and then we're gonna do something um i've just provided for you know
01:33:56 not all five children one of them like i said is zero that you know she's an infant she's a baby
01:34:01 but for you know three or four of my children the toddler we sometimes might give a separate
01:34:05 lower bar command but for at least three maybe four of those five children i've just set a bar
01:34:10 and i've just placed them in a position it's not wrong for me to do it but i do have a choice i
01:34:15 place them in a position to where now i as a parent i'm going to have to follow through if
01:34:18 they don't obey and i've just given to uh three or four kids like three different commands take
01:34:24 off your shoes, go potty, change, get, get, uh, get out of your school clothes. And then,
01:34:30 and then we're going to do something as a family before dinner. You know, we're going to go for a
01:34:33 walk or whatever. So, but, but those, so I need you to go potty, take off your shoes, put them
01:34:37 in the shoe cubby and get changed. Um, and I've got a seven year old, a five year old, a four
01:34:41 year old and a two year old that I've just given three commands to. Um, so basically what I decided
01:34:47 is, Hey, welcome home from school. And, uh, and in about, you know, 90 seconds, um, I'm going to
01:34:53 be spanking i was about to say basically the decision that was just made because it's i mean
01:34:58 you've got about a hundred percent chance with four kids little kids at those ages seven five
01:35:03 four and two and three commands shoes off get changed go to the restroom uh you've got like
01:35:10 a hundred percent chance that at least one of the kids is not going to obey one of those commands
01:35:14 now here's the other thing you actually don't have to give the command now you have to teach
01:35:19 your children obedience you have to sometimes give commands but you don't always you don't
01:35:23 always. So I have to decide, my point is, long way of saying, I get to decide as head of the home,
01:35:30 I get to decide, is this going to be a command? Am I going to make this an ultimatum? And husbands,
01:35:37 you get to do that. Obviously, it's not telling them to go to the bathroom, but you get to do that 0.99
01:35:41 with your wives. You get to decide. So you, right, the train is way off the rails 0.80
01:35:47 in virtually every doctrine under the sun, especially gender piety, biblical roles of
01:35:54 male and female, and their function in society and in the home and in the church. We're way off
01:36:00 the rails and been off the rails for decades. You, by God's grace, are coming to biblical
01:36:06 patriarchal convictions in the Word of God, and you're starting to see what's right. Good. Good
01:36:12 on you. Praise God. Glory to God for giving you that revelation. But now you have the
01:36:16 prerogative. You have the luxury of how fast are you going to make that change with your wife? 0.68
01:36:26 How often? Yes, you do have real authority as a husband in your home. You do. How often are
01:36:31 you going to exercise it? What things are you going to, like, really, that thing? Yes, it is
01:36:39 your authority. It is your authority. You actually do have the authority to say, sweetheart, I'd like
01:36:45 for you to wear a red dress. Much to the chagrin of all the complementarians, you do have that
01:36:50 authority. But here's the deal. You're talking about a woman that you love as Christ loved the
01:36:55 church, your wife, that you're wanting to bring into glory with you as a co-heir and grace
01:37:00 who has been shaped by 70 years of radical God-hating feminism. It's in her bones. 0.82
01:37:10 and you have a choice of how gently you're going to bring her along, whether or not you want
01:37:17 constant friction and war in your home, or whether or not you want some moments of enjoyment
01:37:23 and slowly bringing her along and realizing that, you know what? Feminism is such, it's a such a 1.00
01:37:30 cancer. This, this cancer might not get removed all in one generation. This might be generations. 1.00
01:37:37 it might be my wife repents some over the next 40 years my daughter because of that my daughter 0.99
01:37:44 she's uh becomes the next feminine beauty and then my granddaughter like can you have the humility
01:37:50 and i'm not talking there's that's a separate category from well you're compromising the word
01:37:54 of god like if you're going to be patriarchal then you need to be you know issuing commit like
01:37:58 no no you you do have authority you have that authority that that's what i don't like about
01:38:02 the complementarians is because they basically said say that headship is just like this spiritual
01:38:06 ethereal it doesn't mean anything it practically it means nothing it means i get the tie-breaking
01:38:11 vote that might come up three times over the course of a 50-year marriage i don't like that
01:38:15 i think a husband has real authority that said i have never said and a husband should exercise
01:38:20 that real authority on on anything and everything you know 40 times a day that's never been my 0.99
01:38:26 position and if your wife is a raging feminist and and 99 out of 100 times she probably is because 1.00
01:38:35 we've been off the rails, not picking on her, but just our whole society, men and women alike, 0.80
01:38:41 have been rebelling with every fiber in our being against the Lord God Almighty on this issue
01:38:48 for 70 years and arguably longer, decades. So because of that, your wife probably is a feminist. 1.00
01:38:56 The question is not if she's a feminist, it's just how much of a feminist is she? Some of you 0.99
01:39:00 guys are married to a woman who's a little bit of a feminist, and some of you guys are married to 0.99
01:39:03 one that's a lot of bit of feminist. And if you just came in, husband, to patriarchal convictions
01:39:08 six months ago, two years ago, three years ago, and your wife has been bred by her father
01:39:15 and her mother, and they were bred and trained by their fathers and mothers, like for generations 0.70
01:39:22 to be boss babes, you do have to, you want your wife to go to heaven. So you do have to wash her 1.00
01:39:29 with the word. You do have to disciple it, but you get to choose how many times in a day you're
01:39:34 going to have war in your home rather than peace. There is no verse in the Bible that says you do
01:39:39 have the authority. The Bible says that, but the Bible does not say you have to execute and use
01:39:44 that authority on every single issue 40 times a day. That is actually up to you. That's your
01:39:50 prerogative. And so that's how I would answer the question, Ben. Thank you again so much for
01:39:55 the generosity but that that's what i would say is man just lots and lots and lots of grace
01:40:01 because at the end of the day i i i have counseled marriages i know marriages where um the guy came
01:40:10 into biblical patriarchal views and he's right and it's true and he's and he's being honorable
01:40:15 but but he drew a hard line in the sand right away and uh and you can do that and sometimes
01:40:22 god in his mercy does a miracle in that woman's heart and she comes into those convictions too
01:40:26 and both husband and wife are pinned together and is glorious and sometimes that doesn't happen
01:40:32 and your home becomes a battlefield every every second you walk through the door and it's war
01:40:39 war it's no one's talking the children have a have just this constant sense of unrest
01:40:45 and instability and and worry um you got to be true to the word of god you don't have to
01:40:53 exercise every command all the time i don't have to tell my my kids every time we come home
01:40:58 um three commands actually if i'm more if thoughtful and my wife and i we've had this
01:41:02 conversation like we've gotten to the point where there's some days where it's like the kids are
01:41:05 already falling apart they're having a hard day we're going to um deal gently with the bruised
01:41:11 reads. And so we're actually, we're going to get home and we're just not going to give the command
01:41:16 because we know if we give it, they're probably going to disobey. And we know that it's our job
01:41:21 to remove disobedience from their heart. Rebellion is bound up in the heart of the child
01:41:25 and there's a way to remove it. The Bible gives and it's not just preaching the gospel. It turns 0.96
01:41:29 out if you read the Bible, there's another way to remove it also. So we've got to do some of that,
01:41:33 but we don't have to do it all the time. We also need to have moments of peace and joy and happiness.
01:41:38 and one of the ways that we can have that in our home is by pursuing jesus and loving him
01:41:41 and also one of the ways you can have peace in your home is by having just moments where um
01:41:48 where you're not constantly training i could give the command i would be justified to do so
01:41:54 but you don't it's it's just like the military west it's like um yeah like like the drill
01:42:00 sergeant could say and another mile and another mile and another and he would have the authority
01:42:05 to do so right and and and the the platoon really does need to get whipped into shape but there is
01:42:10 a fine line of like you want to train them but you'd like them to still be alive at the end of
01:42:15 it right the best leader doesn't break he shapes right like that's an actual good leader that says
01:42:20 you've got to get to this destination and i can't do it in three months but give me a year and i
01:42:24 could and he actually gets them there it's not just uh yes sir two out of 100 finally met the
01:42:30 fitness standards right it's i got the majority along with me and they love me for it that's a
01:42:35 good leader amen eric what are your thoughts on the question just how to bring your wife
01:42:39 along she's she's struggling with patriarchy yeah i think particularly in the instance where
01:42:45 somebody's coming out of new age you know coming into patriarchy at all yeah my my first thought
01:42:53 is exactly what michael said you know you're you're talking about a bruised reed and a smoldering
01:42:58 wick and you're thinking about, okay, how can I, when you think about that, you see no flame,
01:43:02 but there's smoke coming off of it. So there's gotta be something going on here. Uh, but in
01:43:06 that situation, the Lord is gracious. He's merciful. You're going to do everything you can
01:43:10 to, to encourage whatever growth you do see. Um, I think being gentle in the way that you lead is a
01:43:16 really good thing. Encouragement. The only other thing I'd add to the discussion is it really is
01:43:20 something that you ideally are not the only voice uh in their lives particularly what we've seen in
01:43:28 community here if you could be in context where you just see modeled other versions of biblical
01:43:35 femininity uh that has an appeal and an allure to it where you'll find wives who are new to our
01:43:41 community saying things like that we didn't even necessarily tell them they just said that woman
01:43:46 you know she carries herself well she's so respectful to her husband i want to grow into
01:43:50 that we're creatures who imitate that's how god designed us so i think also having you know wise
01:43:56 companions uh for them role models to look up to can be a really good piece of advice
01:44:01 now we apply that right to vlad's question as well vlad's great brother and he asked the question
01:44:07 i think it really is closely related to your answer what are some practical methods to help
01:44:11 a wife be more comfortable in submitting in all things becoming less uncomfortable with the true
01:44:15 amount of control a husband has so very much so in that vein but basically saying there could be a
01:44:20 level where like a wife's coming into it and she's like holy cow he has a lot of authority like there
01:44:25 really isn't aside from the extremes go kill your neighbor which no one in the right mind would ever
01:44:30 order but aside from the extremes like he has close to not truly only god is true and ultimate
01:44:36 final authority but he's got a lot of authority and that's that's scary so to apply to that patience
01:44:42 grace and then demonstrating so authority versus prudence you can have the authority but it may
01:44:47 not be prudent to do something demonstrating as much as possible over time when i do exercise this
01:44:53 which is my right and does have to be obeyed i temper it with prudence every time i'm not coming
01:44:58 off half cocked go i like i don't even know but like go whatever it would be you're not saying
01:45:05 silly things saying like i have the authority i'm saying this and it ties directly your wife
01:45:09 comes home from the store and she forgot an ingredient go back to the store right now right 0.83
01:45:13 you know like submission to that is a lot scarier and you could you do have that authority you could
01:45:18 say it and you could say it kindly but you don't have to yep exactly just say it we'll get it next
01:45:23 time and then but then point being comfortable with wait i know i'm not going to come home be
01:45:26 ordered to go back to the store 45 minutes away or you know go clean the chicken coop three times
01:45:31 a day no that authority is only coming in place when it's for the good hey that kid really needs
01:45:35 a spanking and it's for love and it's for kindness or or this isn't modest and it's actually unloving
01:45:40 to you and others around i can see that that's being exercised with prudence i think that's the
01:45:44 way you help grow in comfort no well said good good all right we have a lot of super chats so
01:45:49 gentlemen real quick the only thing i was going to add on that though is just um it's just important
01:45:56 to understand like whether you call it sphere sovereignty or whether you call it you know
01:45:59 classical two kingdoms however you want to frame it whatever theological framework it is important
01:46:03 to understand that in the home, the husband has a, the husband slash father, the measure of
01:46:10 authority that he has, biblically speaking, what the Bible says, right? God's the only one who has,
01:46:15 you know, inherent authority. All human authority is vested authorities. It's an extension of God.
01:46:20 God gives it to them. And so it's not limitless, not in the true sense, but a husband slash father
01:46:26 is the closest in terms of human authority figures. It's the closest to limitless authority.
01:46:33 if you command your wife to do something god forbids that's outside of your authority or if
01:46:40 you um forbid her from doing something that god commands that's outside of your authority um apart
01:46:46 from that as husband slash father um that that human position office head of household has more
01:46:57 authority than any other human office in all of the created cosmos an emperor i mean even kings
01:47:06 it's like well we we don't want to have a monarchy that would be tyranny um and it's like we have a
01:47:11 deep state regime that has cameras everywhere and monitors all of your data and knows exactly what
01:47:16 like no accountability yeah dude kings back in the day they had no clue what the peasants way
01:47:20 over there on the farm like they had a ton of freedom people had actually a lot of freedom
01:47:25 But my point is to say, even in what you would deem as a more tyrannical form of civil government, that king, even if we did have a monarchy, that king still would not, under God, and even if he tried to, he would not be able to pull it off.
01:47:42 So in terms of what God's word gives, affords to him, and in terms of his own human attempts, even if he's trying to be a tyrant, he still does not have as much authority as the head of household.
01:47:52 head of household has a ton of authority um but you because you have that authority you get to
01:47:58 choose how frequently you're going to execute it and what you're going you know what what are going
01:48:04 to be the deal breakers and where when are you going to actually draw a line in the sand are
01:48:07 you going to make are you going to make a fight about everything because you you actually have
01:48:10 the authority to choose not to okay uh let's go we got some more super chats good down a little
01:48:16 uh granddad farms he gives us um five dollars thanks granddad farms we really appreciate it
01:48:22 he says ga good afternoon gentlemen and eric ga and happy friday happy friday okay and then we've
01:48:28 got a nobody special he says is theonomy a trap for unsuccessful men eric what do you think
01:48:35 is theonomy a trap uh that's a super chat from nobody special thank you nobody special
01:48:40 is theonomy a trap for unsuccessful men uh wow that that has a seems like a lot of baggage
01:48:47 attached to it i don't know what the whole context of that question is but uh i would say no not
01:48:51 necessarily uh i've done lots of uh lots of good guys in that camp uh joel joel webin kind of
01:48:59 depending on very successful man no it would be my short answer it could be
01:49:06 yeah okay there you go nobody's special that's you know what you give a hundred
01:49:12 dollar super chat and you get a 45 minute answer
01:49:14 that's not true um yeah i don't really have anything to add to i don't know exactly what
01:49:21 you're getting at but uh we appreciate the support and i agree with eric um okay let's see
01:49:27 daniel bartos oh wow fifty dollars super chat thank you so much for the generosity we really
01:49:32 appreciate it. He says, this is well overdue and not nearly enough for what you men have done
01:49:37 for my spiritual growth and my desires for a greater understanding of God's holy word,
01:49:43 the truth. Stand strong and courageous in the spirit of the Lord. God bless. Thank you, Daniel.
01:49:48 We really appreciate that. Michael here at the bottom, he says, could you do a podcast on how
01:49:55 you do discipline? That's a great question. I've addressed it some in the past. It's difficult
01:50:02 because that's one of those topics. It's not just hashtag based or controversial and you'll get
01:50:07 grief, but we live in a world that hates children. I mean, hates them. And I'm not just being
01:50:14 hyperbolic. I would back that up with scripture. Spare the rod, spoil the child. People always say
01:50:19 that's not in the Bible. You're right. The Bible says way worse than spoil. It doesn't say spare 1.00
01:50:24 the rod, spoil the child. It says that he who spares the rod hates his son. That if you don't
01:50:30 discipline, you actually hate the child, and gentle parenting is not biblical. The Bible tells us how
01:50:36 to discipline. Now, it doesn't mean that that's the exhaustive, exclusive form of discipline. You
01:50:41 can't ever discipline in any other way, but that is a part of discipline, especially in the little
01:50:46 years, the earlier years of life. So in the younger years of life, spanking is a non-negotiable
01:50:55 Christian part of discipline. But because we live in a world that hates children,
01:50:59 the moment that our world that hates God and therefore hates his image as they see it in
01:51:04 children, the moment they see someone loving children, because to discipline a child is love,
01:51:09 per Hebrews chapter 12, God disciplines his sons, those that he loves. The moment that our
01:51:13 child-hating world sees a parent loving children, they will try to take those children away.
01:51:21 They will. They will actually try to take your kids. So this isn't just, oh, I'll get in trouble
01:51:26 on X. You know, I'm in trouble on X every day of the week, every day of the week, no matter what.
01:51:31 It's not about that. But this is one where people will actually, they really will try to ruin your
01:51:38 life, legally take your kids the whole nine yards. So to answer the question...
01:51:42 It just happened a couple months ago.
01:51:43 Someone talked about disciplining his son.
01:51:45 CPS was there and everything.
01:51:47 It was a big deal.
01:51:49 We're not talking just about people.
01:51:50 We're not talking about in England or in Germany.
01:51:53 Right.
01:51:53 No, here in the United States, in Ohio.
01:51:55 Here in America.
01:51:55 Yep.
01:51:56 So to answer the question, yes, I'm willing to go there,
01:52:00 but that's one that we would probably have to take our time to think through
01:52:05 and be strategic.
01:52:08 The wording of it, not the biblical principles of it.
01:52:09 Yeah, we know the principles,
01:52:11 but how to how to be clear enough to where it's helpful to you guys because if we're so vague then
01:52:17 it's not even helpful so we'd have to find a way to be clear enough to be helpful but also careful
01:52:22 enough um to not have our children taken from us because we live in a world that hates kids that
01:52:28 said there are some signs of life some signs of hope on the horizon um whether it's jd vance or
01:52:35 you know elon musk or you know trump's grandkid like just having kids in some of those public
01:52:40 spaces and not just hiding them away the kids are always somewhere else um that is encouraging so i
01:52:45 think there's hope on the horizon that we might have a more child-friendly culture uh in the
01:52:50 future uh but that's an uphill battle and right now um it's it's pretty dangerous okay uh one more
01:52:56 super chat modern waggy wagey like a wage kind of someone that's just like yeah i see ten dollars
01:53:04 from modern wagey thank you so much wes you want to read it sure question from him he says what do
01:53:09 you say to complementarians slash people who do not take the scripture literally great description
01:53:13 that says wives can have careers if they also take care of the home to keep fitting with titus
01:53:19 two five i don't agree so the question being what do you say to those people they're like i'm
01:53:23 complementarian i'm this side or the other and uh as far as titus two five goes women to be keepers 1.00
01:53:29 at home well as long as she keeps the home completes that category checks the box the box
01:53:33 well she can also have a career as well i'd love to hear from eric but uh we've talked about this
01:53:39 before it's not possible to run a home with any number of children well and then have any
01:53:45 semblance of a career i could not do my career and watch my kids and i have two kids three and
01:53:51 one like i just i couldn't do it i know of no situation that does not involve child care for
01:53:58 40 hours a week maybe sending all of them to school so this would be maybe you're done having
01:54:02 young children sending all of them to school which is a different category and maybe a different 0.75
01:54:06 conversation but i just know of nobody 20 to 40 2 3 4 kids any wife that's doing a great job in
01:54:14 the home loving her husband watching her children that would have any reasonable bandwidth for any 1.00
01:54:19 type of meaningful job aside from something like she does nurse one night a week overnight there
01:54:26 are some arrangements where financially it makes sense with the time it makes sense it's not a high
01:54:31 commitment. Hey, I make $400 a week to do eight hours on a Wednesday night to make some great
01:54:37 money for our family. But as far as nine to five, as far as four days a week, there's nothing that
01:54:43 you're doing for one that's more valuable than your children. And there's nothing you're doing
01:54:47 that you're not split in two directions, neither passing the kids off to someone else or ultimately
01:54:52 just not really doing a good job at whatever day job you would have. Eric, well said, Wes. Eric,
01:54:57 What do you think? Yeah, absolutely. I think it's a very simple principle that none of us,
01:55:03 as far as I'm aware, are capable of being in two places at one time. And so when you think about
01:55:08 that, you're like, OK, well, yeah, as Wes said, like unless you farm out 90 percent of the job
01:55:14 to other people, you're not physically capable of doing that. I think the other operative word
01:55:19 there is career. Obviously, a woman can work, meaning that she can serve her household. She 1.00
01:55:25 can help her husband in the productive economy of the home, all those things. But yeah, not
01:55:29 physically actually possible to do two separate things and actually be fully involved in the full
01:55:36 role of motherhood. Good. Well said. Yeah. So much of it, I think, is wanting your wife's labor
01:55:42 to be attached to you as her head. Every wife works, but what we want to see is we want to 0.93
01:55:54 see wives working for um for her man rather than the man um we want to see uh in other words 0.89
01:56:03 and part of it honestly is like believing in the truth and the power of god's word but then also
01:56:09 believing in um the you know he who finds a wife finds a good thing believing in the wife that the
01:56:15 lord sovereignly in in his mercy gave you as a blessing as a gift to you and believing that um
01:56:20 that you employing her will actually benefit your household more than farming her out to be employed
01:56:27 by someone else. That her gifts and her strengths and her ability and her labor and all these
01:56:31 different things under your headship and your direction could actually be more productive
01:56:38 and more profitable than farming her out to some other man who has not made vows to her,
01:56:44 who is not in covenant with her, who has not promised to love her as Christ would love the
01:56:48 church, seeing her as yours. She belongs to you and having her work with you. Like the Proverbs
01:56:56 31 woman is a working woman. It's all attached to the home, but there are things outside of the 0.99
01:57:02 home. She's doing it from the home, but she's doing land acquisition. She sees a field and
01:57:07 purchases it, but she's doing it, number one, with whose money? Her husband's money. So it's
01:57:13 the husband's estate. It's his resources, his money that she's using, and it's underneath his
01:57:18 discretion um and and she's you know she's still doing the the legwork and probably looking into
01:57:23 the fields and comparing and blah blah blah but um but she's doing all this whether it's real
01:57:28 estate or whether it's um i don't know some some side business on etsy or whatever but it's all
01:57:34 it's it's under in terms of like if it was a llc it would be underneath her husband's name
01:57:41 as the llc it was like you know it would be you know eric khan incorporated you know joel webbin
01:57:47 incorporated michael belch incorporated wesley todd it's under under that entity under that
01:57:52 entity and that supervision an extension an arm extending from from that um core unit that she's 1.00
01:57:59 being productive and developing and um all those things so wives can work the question is how 0.99
01:58:04 where um and and attached to who that's very different than just sending the wife out of the
01:58:11 home to report to someone else and the last thing i'll say on that that i always find
01:58:15 ironic is uh guys who say well husbands don't have that kind of authority and a man can't tell
01:58:21 his wife you know but but then they're perfectly fine with women working outside of the home
01:58:26 where they go and typically work for a man and the authority that they're perfectly comfortable 0.99
01:58:32 with him having is all the way down to the exact time that they show up how many breaks they're
01:58:38 allowed to have when they can take those breaks what uh what wardrobe they have to wear down
01:58:45 to the shoes and socks i mean every corporate employer like we're fine here's the deal the
01:58:52 world just hates husbands we just have to be honest about that and and let's be further honest
01:58:57 conservative pastors conservative in in quotation marks for the listener here
01:59:03 conservative pastors hate husbands they don't have any problem they don't have any problem
01:59:10 with a corporate employer saying, here's your dress code. Here's your schedule. 0.62
01:59:20 No, you can't go on vacation without first running it by me. And I might tell you no.
01:59:26 All those kinds of things. And that's one of the biggest things. I can't remember who it was that
01:59:30 I was talking to. I can't remember who it was, but it was really insightful. But just talking
01:59:37 about one of the problems with the wife working, it's not just that the work is out of the home 0.99
01:59:40 rather than attached to the home. That's one principle. But then the other is if she's working 1.00
01:59:46 for someone else, then the house is divided. You have just made a decision as a husband to usurp
01:59:52 your own authority. Because think about that. So, you're the head of the home. You're the head
01:59:57 of your wife. And now you are asking your wife to go ask another man if your family can go on 0.96
02:00:03 vacation think about that for a sec process that you head of the home who are called by christ to
02:00:10 be willing to lay your life down for your wife and are daily washing her in the words and have
02:00:15 been given she's been given the command to submit to you and everything and yet you have to ask your
02:00:21 wife to go ask another man before your family makes decisions and all these conservative
02:00:30 of complementarian pastors are fine with that. They're fine with another man who has not made
02:00:35 vows to her, who will not give his life for her, who does not love her, having that kind of
02:00:41 executive authority over precise details of, you can't go on a break right now. They're fine with
02:00:48 that woman working outside of the home for Amazon that will say, I'm sorry, you can't go to the 1.00
02:00:52 bathroom. So they're going to get mad at me with a video about a husband's authority 1.00
02:00:58 and talking about my young children when my young not my wife but my young children when they need
02:01:04 to go to the bathroom and the example that i was giving was again my children three years old four
02:01:09 years old five years old um it's bedtime hey go potty before bed i was saying a father doesn't
02:01:15 have that authority and so they're gonna make a clip like that go viral like ali bestucky who was
02:01:20 the first person to make that transcript that's what it was about go viral and started this whole
02:01:25 feud. They're going to freak out about that. Meanwhile, they're going to say that it's
02:01:31 perfectly permissible for a man at Amazon Incorporated to tell not children who are five
02:01:38 years old, but a full grown woman who is not their wife, who they've not made vows to when she can go
02:01:43 to the bathroom. So just admit you're hypocrites, you're hypocrites. And at the end of the day, 1.00
02:01:51 you hate husbands and you love feminism and you're compromised eric any thoughts
02:01:59 i don't know joel that was a lot of fire breathing truth right there 0.98
02:02:04 yeah i do i do actually think it's it's it's a lot of the same thing just hypocrisy with that
02:02:10 situation uh the amount of authority uh given outside the home i think it's also interesting
02:02:16 too when you get to uh the complementarian camp they're also willing to let wives go into
02:02:22 environments that are hostile including law enforcement uh it's not safe so physical harm
02:02:28 becomes involved in those things um and yeah again just the woman can actually be safeguarded
02:02:35 and thriving in a home environment where a husband who loves her is making those decisions rather 0.99
02:02:39 than a corporate boss who more than likely sees her as uh you know a disposable line item on a
02:02:45 budget amen michael west any thoughts no it's good it's good okay uh last one cameron stevenson
02:02:55 he said joel did i hear correctly that brian silvey won't be making it to the conference
02:02:59 this year due to his wife expecting uh their child around a baby coming around that time
02:03:05 um no uh that that's not the case i was actually in ogden as uh eric can testify just a few weeks
02:03:11 ago and i told lexi to her face right because i just talked about other men having authority i
02:03:17 said i'm so sorry to hear that brian won't be there for the birth of your next child
02:03:20 because he will be at the conference this is baby number seven at this point like
02:03:25 you're there at that point it's like i'm sorry it's your seventh kid um no yeah he he is going
02:03:32 to miss out uh brian gave me a hard time because he told me like people are like there must be
02:03:36 something going on that they're not being honest about that augen you know is upset with joel
02:03:41 about something um because um you know brian pulling out of the conference because i was in
02:03:45 trouble for something at that it's like just because joel's in trouble i'm always in trouble
02:03:48 i'm always in trouble but they're like joel's in trouble and so brian's backing out and they're
02:03:53 like if it was really a baby they would have known way in advance well here's the truth
02:03:56 i did know way in advance brian told me months and months and months and months ago
02:04:00 and i just in my heart of hearts i considered it i thought about it and i just said no i don't
02:04:06 believe it i don't believe it i just don't believe it's happening and i left his picture on the
02:04:11 conference promo and i just kept running the image with brian right there smiling with his little
02:04:17 handlebar mustache for like four months after he had told me and at a certain point like he was
02:04:22 like all right joel i'm just going to post on x because you refused to announce it i'm just going
02:04:26 to say i'm going to have to announce it for you that i am not coming to the conference so that's
02:04:30 how that shook out that's called denial that was denial i just couldn't believe it it hurt it just
02:04:34 hurt too much to acknowledge it um this is the end of the episode eric thanks so much for coming
02:04:39 on the show any final thoughts for our listeners oh wow yeah i would just say i encourage people
02:04:45 to continue uh pressing in on these issues don't be discouraged when you see either failures or
02:04:51 criticism um but you know there are a lot of good people doing a lot of good work and and point i
02:04:58 always leave people with if you can be a part of a community whether that's georgetown texas
02:05:02 ogden utah anywhere else you can be a part of a community where people are thriving
02:05:07 these sorts of things don't quite impact you as much you realize our people are great we continue
02:05:12 to grow and uh that's an outside distraction just keep doing the good work and and christ
02:05:17 will bless that so just encourage people with that amen so our conference is happening april 3rd
02:05:24 4th and 5th we'd love for you guys to come crisis king how to defeat trash world eric will be there
02:05:28 Dan Burkholder will be there.
02:05:30 The Viking.
02:05:31 Brian Svea will be there.
02:05:32 Brian Svea will be there.
02:05:33 He doesn't know that.
02:05:34 Lexi doesn't know that.
02:05:35 But I know that.
02:05:36 He'll be there.
02:05:37 And Ben Garrett will be there.
02:05:38 And then a host of a bunch of other people will be there.
02:05:41 But then also, just a few months after that, two months after that, in June, Eric, real quick, do you want to plug your conference?
02:05:48 Yeah, absolutely.
02:05:48 June 12th through 14th, Ogden, Utah.
02:05:51 We have a host of wonderful speakers, including our very own Joel Webbin.
02:05:56 And I say our very own, because I feel like you kind of belong to us a little bit, Joel.
02:06:00 That's fair.
02:06:00 That's fair.
02:06:01 For better or for worse.
02:06:04 Yeah, that's right.
02:06:05 For better or worse.
02:06:05 We own all of it.
02:06:07 Yeah, Joel will be there, Brian Sauve, myself, Dan Burkholder.
02:06:12 We've got Stephen Wolf, Andrew Isker.
02:06:14 So it's going to be a really good time.
02:06:15 We're going to be talking about recovering the spirit of American greatness. 0.99
02:06:18 It's time to get back to the Christian Protestant vision for America that built this country.
02:06:24 no more hiding under the longhouse as it were and uh we'll we'll do some networking there's even
02:06:30 going to be some games some i think rock throwing uh scottish style games and no i'm not joking
02:06:36 so joel you'll be participating in that no i'm sure he will be yes your failures will be broadcast
02:06:43 for the world to see so just i'm just saying you better get in shape i can't do it um i will be
02:06:48 there and i will be spectating i'm not going to allow ogden to just video record me to publicly
02:06:55 mock me for the next all right michael you're in yeah there you go somebody better step up
02:07:00 no i'll be there i'm i'm planning to nice and that's what are the dates june what
02:07:04 yeah june 12th through 14th you can find more information new christened press.com
02:07:09 slash 2025 great new christened press.com slash 2025 all right that's it for the show
02:07:16 that ends wraps up the week for us thank you guys so much for listening and all of your prayers all
02:07:22 of your support all of your encouragement we really appreciate it we got a lot of great support
02:07:26 and encouragement for the episode that we did this last wednesday just a couple days ago on genetics
02:07:32 and race and and all these kinds of things wading into those very controversial waters but the church
02:07:38 does need to be able to address these things biblically from the book of special revelation
02:07:42 and natural revelation, the way that God has constructed the world, what God has written
02:07:47 to us in his word, and we need to do it courageously because people have real questions and
02:07:53 we need real answers.
02:07:54 And a lot of you guys, obviously people were upset about it, but a lot of people privately
02:07:59 emailed me or messaged me.
02:08:01 Messaged me as well.
02:08:01 Yeah, messaged Wes, thanking us for being willing to answer some questions that people
02:08:07 have had for a long time that nobody's been willing to answer.
02:08:11 So thank you for your encouragement.
02:08:12 um, it's hard. It is, it does take a toll. We enjoy what we do. We're happy and honored to do
02:08:19 it. Um, but as you guys see publicly, we, um, we get a lot of heat, a lot of heat. And, uh,
02:08:26 and so you guys, those of you who are able to support the ministry financially, um, goes a
02:08:31 long way. Those of you who are willing to reach out and, uh, thank us or encourage us goes a long
02:08:37 way. Uh, those of you who are able to come to the conference and show your support, um,
02:08:42 A lot of people, sadly, Christians, a lot of Christians are rooting for it to fail.
02:08:46 They do not want us to have a thousand people at New Christendom Conference or Right Response Conference.
02:08:51 And you guys being willing to do that encourages us.
02:08:54 It benefits you.
02:08:55 And it also helps to show our Christian brothers and sisters that we love that, no, this is what the Word of God says.
02:09:04 This is not new.
02:09:05 It's not flashy.
02:09:06 It's not novel.
02:09:07 This is a return to the old ways, the old past. 0.91
02:09:10 This is what our Christian forefathers believed.
02:09:13 This is what the Bible teaches.
02:09:14 We are not the anomaly.
02:09:17 The 20th century in Western civilization, in Christendom, that's the anomaly.
02:09:23 And so we look like the anomaly because everybody has been derailed.
02:09:28 But we're actually getting back to the common denominator, the constant.
02:09:33 And when you guys support things like New Christendom, you support Right Response,
02:09:37 You come to the conference in person, even though it's a sacrifice, it's hard, but, you
02:09:44 know, to take off work, it costs money to travel, but when you physically show up to
02:09:49 our conferences, that makes our Christian brothers and sisters who disagree with us
02:09:54 over these things, it forces them to have to reconsider, and that matters.
02:10:01 When something starts to get enough traction, people hate it, but eventually they have to
02:10:07 to reckon with it they have to consider it and um it's not that we're just trying to rub it in
02:10:13 with people who disagree no we want to win and and we want them to eventually change teams and
02:10:19 one of the ways that we do it is if it's just us podcasting you know throwing out podcasts into the
02:10:25 wind and hosting podcast you know uh conferences with 50 people there's nothing wrong with that
02:10:30 but if that's all it is um then then they're never going to give us the time of day it's
02:10:35 my point is it's, it's not even so much us. It's not Eric. It's not new Christendom. It's not,
02:10:39 it's not me. It's not right response. It's you, the listener. It's, it's you guys,
02:10:44 all of you guys, um, come coming, you know, and, and contributing online and the conversation on
02:10:50 X and coming and liking our posts and listening to our podcast and showing up to our conference
02:10:55 and listening to Brian Sovey's music. It's, it's you guys that are making things like biblical
02:11:00 patriarchy, the Bible's teaching on biblical roles of men and women come back into the center
02:11:07 forefront to where the rest of the Christian church has to deal with it. You guys are making
02:11:11 that happen.