The NXR Podcast - August 14, 2024


THE LIVESTREAM - Aristotle, Multiculturalism, & The UK Riots

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW - Where You Live Matters - with Contra Mundom THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - The Grays | Ep 7 with @TheCultishShow

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 59 minutes

Words per minute

195.15

Word count

23,281

Sentence count

691

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

53

sentences flagged

Hate speech

99

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Reformed Christians are skeptical of the writings of pagan philosophers such as Aristotle, Plato, and Plutarch. After all, these men did not possess the gift of regeneration, the Holy Scriptures, or the Holy Spirit. But as we grapple with the reality of forced multiculturalism, unchecked immigration, and burning cities in the UK, it is time to consider the possibility that the great Western thinkers that our Reformed fathers extensively relied on, quoted, and debated, left us great wisdom and insights for our struggles today. Tune in as we discuss the Reformation tradition, Aristotle, and his writings on the possibility of functional multiculturalism.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Reformed Christians are skeptical of the writings of pagan philosophers such as
00:00:07 Aristotle, Plato, and Plutarch. After all, these men did not possess the gift of regeneration,
00:00:14 the Holy Scriptures, or the Holy Spirit. But as we grapple with the reality of forced
00:00:21 multiculturalism, unchecked immigration, and burning cities in the UK, it is time to consider 0.82
00:00:29 the possibility that the great Western thinkers that our Reformed fathers extensively relied on, 0.99
00:00:35 quoted, and used left us great wisdom and insights for our struggles today. Tune in now as we discuss
00:00:44 the Reformation tradition, Aristotle, and his writings on the possibility of functional multiculturalism.
00:00:59 all right all right we're a duo again yep so okay for those of you who are just now
00:01:06 tuning in uh we the last couple weeks it was just me and michael and uh these two weeks it's just me
00:01:12 and wesley and then we'll have all three again with without michael here i think i'm gonna start
00:01:15 telling you how i really feel time to let loose uh no so we've got a nice light topic aristotle
00:01:22 multiculturalism and the uk riots and they've kind of all blended together this whole conversation
00:01:28 some of the things that have got me thinking specifically on this topic. They do come from
00:01:31 social media. However, this live stream, this article that I wrote, it's not intended to be
00:01:36 a referendum or a response to any thinkers. I would say there's good men on both sides who
00:01:40 would say maybe we should avoid using these men. There's greater wisdom that can be found.
00:01:44 And others that would say, hey, they had some good insights. Maybe we should rely on them more.
00:01:49 So I think there's good men on both sides. This isn't intended to be a response, a hit piece,
00:01:53 anything like that. But something that we've been thinking about, and I say we more,
00:01:58 this church here and in Georgetown. We're starting a classical school, and I'm actually not involved
00:02:02 in it, but you are, Joel. Michael is. Brian Hensley is the headmaster, doing a great job,
00:02:06 and it's going to be St. George's Classical School. So, it's going to be a Christian school,
00:02:10 but not just Christian. So, it's not as though it's mathematics homework, and at the top is a
00:02:14 verse, and there it is. It's a Christian school. It's going to be a classical school. It's going
00:02:19 to be rooted and grounded in the Western tradition, in Western thought. So, we've been doing a book
00:02:24 Club, and I know myself, I've been reading Seneca this year, Letters from a Stoic. And what I've
00:02:29 come to realize, what I've been becoming more aware of as I read them, and then I go and I read
00:02:35 Calvin and I read Luther and these other guys, is there's a connection between them all that feels
00:02:41 really foreign to us neo-Calvinists. So for myself, I came into the doctrines of grace probably over
00:02:46 10 years ago now. But one thing, if you kind of came into Calvinism at that time, was total
00:02:51 depravity. That man is a sinner, that he is totally depraved, he can't save himself. The heart of the
00:02:57 sinful man, it says in Romans, Paul, is hostile to God. It doesn't submit to his law, and it cannot.
00:03:02 But what functionally happened kind of then, I think, and you can tell me if you felt the same 1.00
00:03:06 way, was we put unbelievers in this category of, yeah, they're helpful, yeah, they maybe point out
00:03:11 some good things, but really everything that maybe you could find in there, we can probably already
00:03:16 find in scripture. And so, helpful, but kind of the unnecessary category. And we did that. And we
00:03:22 took Plato, and we took Aristotle, and we took Plutarch and Seneca. We also took functional
00:03:27 things like weightlifting. We also took things like eating healthy, starting businesses, having
00:03:32 a vocation. We kind of took a lot of these things for one reason or another. We put them in this big
00:03:38 grab bag. We said, well, personal piety, devotion. Those are the things that matter more, and they
00:03:45 do matter and they do matter most but they matter at the cost of these other things and as now as 0.97
00:03:51 we see cities burn in the uk as we grapple with the unchecked immigration that's happening at our
00:03:55 border i think what some of us are realizing is that we left behind a lot of good stuff we left
00:04:03 behind great thinkers like i just i can tell on myself aristotle much much much smarter man than
00:04:09 i am much smarter man than you much smarter man much smarter man than the listener and that doesn't
00:04:14 mean in areas of salvation, theology proper, but these were men that spoke 10 languages,
00:04:20 that traveled all around the world, that walked and lectured and debated daily.
00:04:25 And so maybe what I'm coming to learn is that epistemic humility about where we are, about
00:04:31 where we come from, and about those that came before us is probably going to go a lot farther
00:04:36 than having a bit of a reductionistic modern view, that it's me, it's myself, it's my Bible,
00:04:42 and I'm just going to try to do this politics thing.
00:04:45 I'm just going to try to do this economics thing.
00:04:47 I'm just going to try to do it all on my own.
00:04:50 I'm going to make it up as I go.
00:04:52 And what's funny is you do that and you come up with something.
00:04:55 And even if it's not bad, you then realize,
00:04:57 yeah, actually, the Westminster Confession just said all of this
00:05:01 a lot better than I could have.
00:05:02 And I could have saved myself the time.
00:05:05 Could have just read them.
00:05:07 Could have just relied on them.
00:05:08 And that goes for theology, certainly.
00:05:10 Calvin, Edwards, Augustine, the forefathers that we have in the faith.
00:05:14 But I think it goes a little bit beyond that.
00:05:16 I think the ancients knew some things.
00:05:18 Like I said, I'm reading Seneca's letters from a Stoic.
00:05:20 He's got some great stuff in there on friendship, on vocation, on being disciplined.
00:05:26 Discipline, friendship, these things matter.
00:05:29 Westminster Confession, I believe it's 1-6.
00:05:30 It talks about affairs that are common to human society and to civility,
00:05:34 that there is the Word of God and there is salvation, and those are of utmost importance.
00:05:39 but there are other common things that matter and we should dedicate thought to them consideration
00:05:45 to them and again not have this this mindset of just it's me and myself it's just these modern
00:05:52 readers it's just these modern authors i'm gonna do this a la carte right so don't know if you have
00:05:57 any thoughts on that no i agree um what was the quote do you have the quote that uh eric con posted
00:06:04 it on twitter last week sometime and then other guys dealt with it james white he had a rebuttal
00:06:11 and i think he dealt with it on the dividing line yeah what was it just about like um multi-ethnic
00:06:17 nations and that's not a great idea yeah so um this would be the quote this is from a author
00:06:24 gulliam is his name and so he said this of aristotle he said a multi-ethnic society is
00:06:30 necessarily anti-democratic and chaotic for lax philia profound flesh and blood fraternity of
00:06:36 citizens tyrants and despots divide and rule they want the city divided by ethnic rivalries
00:06:42 that's the background of the quote that kind of kicked off right use aristotle can we not what
00:06:47 is he saying here is it helpful for the christian and then what and then what did aristotle say
00:06:51 uh so aristotle said a couple things so um the ancients they didn't really use terms like
00:06:56 ethnic race culturalism like we do but aristotle said this for example this is in politics book
00:07:02 five and so book five is actually dealing with the question of revolution so aristotle's going
00:07:07 through and he's lecturing through the polis the city state and in book five he deals with
00:07:11 revolution so what are the things that disrupt tranquility of peoples and of cities and he said
00:07:15 it is the habit of tyrants to prefer the company of aliens to that of citizens at tables and in
00:07:21 society citizens they feel are enemies but aliens will offer no opposition to the tyrant
00:07:27 He also said, dissimilarity is conducive to factional conflict.
00:07:31 Those who have admitted joint settlers or later settlers of a different race have for the most part split into factions.
00:07:37 And again, he's observing.
00:07:38 He sent out, I think we were talking about this before, Aristotle, as part of his research,
00:07:43 actually sent out over 150 of his students to go gather the constitutions of different city-states.
00:07:49 So he has the students going out all over, gathering constitutions, and they're coming back to him and reporting.
00:07:54 This happened at this city. This is how this city was underdone. This is how this constitution
00:07:59 deals with the foreigner, with the citizen, with political affairs. And so he's relying on all that. 0.64
00:08:05 And so when he begins to lecture on division, lectures on the difficulty, lectures on revolution,
00:08:11 he draws examples and says, this is what happened in this city. These people were expelled by
00:08:16 foreigners that they let in. This is what it led to here, just a massive wealth of information
00:08:21 about the ancient world
00:08:23 that he relied on
00:08:25 to kind of come
00:08:25 to those conclusions.
00:08:27 Right.
00:08:27 I'm trying to look for
00:08:29 a specific,
00:08:33 there's something
00:08:34 that I wrote in response.
00:08:36 I found it.
00:08:38 Let's see.
00:08:41 This was the quote
00:08:42 that Eric Kahn posted.
00:08:46 He said,
00:08:48 it's similar to everything
00:08:49 that you've already quoted
00:08:50 from Aristotle,
00:08:50 but um this is uh well it's not even a quote from aristotle somebody commenting on it but uh it
00:08:58 says for aristotle democracy is possible only with homogenous ethnic groups while despots have
00:09:05 always reigned over highly fragmented societies that's what you said and then it goes a little
00:09:09 further and says a multi-ethnic society is thus necessarily anti-democratic and chaotic for lax
00:09:16 philea this profound flesh and blood fraternity of citizens tyrants and despots divide and rule 0.69
00:09:24 they want the city divided by ethnic rivalries the indispensable condition for ensuring a
00:09:30 people's sovereignty accordingly resides in its unity ethnic chaos prevents all philea from
00:09:37 developing and eric khan reposted it torba posted that initially eric khan reposted and said
00:09:44 aristotle was uh right and a bunch of people were upset with him uh kade kdub chris uh he's a
00:09:52 african-american christian reformed baptist uh who i believe also is like a christian rapper
00:09:58 and i've uh engaged him in a masters right i think i don't i don't know okay i don't know i
00:10:04 know he's definitely friendly to uh the john mccarthur camp but uh he retweeted eric so eric
00:10:10 Like, you know, Andrew Torba posts this thing about Aristotle saying, you know, multi-ethnic society is always, you know, multi-ethnic society that has a democratic form of government is going to be exploited by civil rulers and devolve into factions.
00:10:27 And so, you know, Torba is the one who posted that.
00:10:29 And then Eric Kahn reposted it saying Aristotle was right.
00:10:32 And then Chris reposted Eric saying racist would really hate heaven.
00:10:36 Thankfully, none will be there.
00:10:38 Now, it's debatable whether or not Chris was saying that Aristotle was a racist or Andrew Torbaugh was a racist or Eric Conn was a racist.
00:10:47 So there's debate there, I hope, to give him the benefit of the doubt.
00:10:51 I hope he's simply saying that Aristotle is a racist and won't be in heaven. 0.81
00:10:57 I would say Aristotle likely, sadly, won't be in heaven, not because he's a racist, but because he wasn't a Christian.
00:11:03 He didn't have the gospel, and he did not trust in the Lord Jesus Christ.
00:11:08 But all that being said, you know that Chris, you know, he may not be discounting Eric Kahn and Andrew Torber's salvation by his post.
00:11:17 Racists would really hate heaven.
00:11:19 Thankfully, none will be there.
00:11:20 But at minimum, he's, you know, giving him the most charitable reading.
00:11:24 He's saying that Aristotle won't be in heaven.
00:11:27 And one of the major reasons why is because of his alleged racism.
00:11:33 and uh and therefore you would have to assume that chris uh does not think that it's uh it's
00:11:40 he doesn't see it as a positive thing that andrew torba uh is posting this and that eric
00:11:46 is posting it saying aristotle was right right so anyway so then i i posted you know get through
00:11:52 you know my two cents into into the discussion um eric con is a friend and uh and so you know
00:12:00 But I really feel like he had a point in saying, you know, that Aristotle's right on this because I think Aristotle's right on this.
00:12:06 And I should say, we're not saying this with joy or glee.
00:12:09 This is an observation of something that could be true.
00:12:12 We're saying, maybe even unfortunately, we're recognizing the reality of the fall.
00:12:18 Yeah, we're not saying, isn't this great?
00:12:20 Like if I said, you know, hey, people who walk off the side of a cliff, they don't sprout wings, they're not able to fly, and they usually fall to their death.
00:12:28 that's not like i'm not wishing for that to be true i'm just acknowledging that observation
00:12:32 observation that it is true exactly so anyway so the the whole thing from aristotle saying you know
00:12:37 uh there's a few components here one is implicit uh but two are explicit um so the three three
00:12:44 components in total so aristotle is basically saying um i would say three ingredients of what
00:12:48 aristotle is describing one um a multi-ethnic state many you know a mixture of many different
00:12:55 ethnicities. That's one. But he's not just saying, hey, a multi-ethnic state won't work because
00:12:59 people aren't supposed to mix and every ethnicity should stick to themselves. That's not really what
00:13:05 Aristotle said. It's not even close to what he said. That's just one component. He's saying
00:13:10 multi-ethnic state, then that's one ingredient in this concoction. The second is multi-ethnic
00:13:19 state with a democratic form of government with democracy so it's multi-ethnic plus democracy
00:13:25 where everybody gets to vote or at least you know some of the people most of the people whatever
00:13:29 um and uh and then the third component those are the two that are explicit democracy is a form of
00:13:35 government multi-ethnic is is the you know composition the composition the polis that
00:13:40 makes it up and then third would be um implicit which is um but i think we can assume uh accurately
00:13:47 from Aristotle, is also being not Christian. So a multi-ethnic state, but a multi-ethnic state
00:13:55 that doesn't have the gospel, that's not Christian, and that also has a democratic
00:14:00 form of government. So multiple ethnicities in one nation, that one nation not being a Christian
00:14:06 nation, and that one nation of multiple ethnicities that are not Christian also having
00:14:11 a democratic form of government and in that scenario with those three ingredients
00:14:17 um eric khan is saying i think aristotle's right right and i happily will uh agree with eric khan
00:14:25 not because he's my friend i love eric and he is my friend but i'm happy to agree with eric and
00:14:30 saying that aristotle was right in this case because uh eric is right to say that aristotle
00:14:36 right in this case yeah in a non-christian nation with multiple ethnicities and a democratic form
00:14:41 of government um factions um from what we can observe throughout human history would be
00:14:47 inevitable um and none of that making that observation none of that is racist right um
00:14:53 not only was eric khan not racist and saying aristotle's right or andrew torba is not racist
00:14:58 by retweeting this quote this uh picture from aristotle but aristotle himself uh now maybe
00:15:04 he was a racist, but you'd have to demonstrate it from some other proof. In this particular
00:15:09 thought and concept of Aristotle's, nothing there is inherently racist. Because notice what he's not
00:15:16 saying that multi-ethnic states with a democratic form of government and then implicitly that are
00:15:21 also a state that's not Christian are inherently divided and not beneficial. Aristotle, that's all 0.73
00:15:31 says he doesn't go further that and say and also um secondly uh this one race is superior to all 0.82
00:15:38 the other ones and so that one shouldn't be tainted by the lesser inferior really like that's
00:15:43 that's not in the quote you know like if aristotle thought thought that then great you know then then
00:15:48 go ahead and show that and and then use that screenshot of that quote from aristotle to say
00:15:53 that aristotle's racist aristotle was the og too on critiquing democracy because exactly that he saw
00:15:58 that the rich and the poor, when you gave them kind of this equal standing and to have
00:16:02 contribution to the democratic rule of the city-state, that they would become factions
00:16:06 against one another. That the poor would want greater handouts. They would want
00:16:10 policies that would favor them. And so he was the OG of being negative. He also
00:16:14 didn't allow women to vote either. He was pretty OG on that. But 1.00
00:16:18 really perceptive in recognizing. It's funny, someone did it. It might have been Andrew
00:16:22 Isker. But he overlaid a voting map. And he overlaid it with
00:16:26 the ethnic demographics of the city and of the state what you realize is that um they match
00:16:32 pretty closely that democracy typically ends up being a bit of a popularity contest between
00:16:37 different factions well yeah exactly that's and that's all it is the reason why i have grown to
00:16:42 despise democracy is um because uh it's not we the people it's uh we we the some uh some people
00:16:51 and who are those people uh non-elected officials uh like what democracy what it uh gives uh lends
00:16:59 its strength to is instead of having um elected officials uh that have power is um a raw universe
00:17:06 because that's what we have is a universal democracy um everyone is allowed to vote right
00:17:11 everyone and just for the record you know yeah i think the 19th amendment should be repealed i
00:17:16 think that because well first and foremost because i'm a christian um you know and that is that is
00:17:20 the Christian position. Oh my gosh, you're saying that? Yes, that is the Christian position,
00:17:25 is that households should not be divided against one another. So it's not just elevating a male
00:17:30 vote, but it's elevating the household vote. We're saying that society, if you break it down to the
00:17:37 basic building block, is not atomistic as individuals, but molecular, being households.
00:17:43 The way that God sees humanity is He breaks them down to families. And so it's not just
00:17:50 random individual atoms all, you know, bouncing around together and, you know, 350 million atoms
00:17:56 bouncing together in one nation on one piece of land, but it's families. And so by repealing the
00:18:05 19th Amendment, just for the record, it's not just trying to take away a female vote, but it's trying
00:18:09 to say, no, there's a family vote. There's a household. And it's like, well, where do women 1.00
00:18:15 get their voice. Where women get their voice is from their father, from their husband. If they're 0.97
00:18:22 not married, it's from their father. If they're not married and their father's dead, it's from
00:18:25 their brother, it's from their uncle. It's the men in their lives that love them. It's the men
00:18:29 in their lives that love them. And also, it's worth noting that politics is warfare. That's
00:18:34 what politics is. It's war without the bullets, war without the blood. But politics very often,
00:18:41 unfortunately, in a fallen world, it is a war of ideas that's a cold war, but often,
00:18:51 sadly, heats up and becomes a hot war. It becomes a literal war. Many of the policies,
00:18:57 the people that you vote for and the policies that they put into action can lead to war or not.
00:19:07 And so it also makes sense that the people who are voting for said officials who may make certain declarations of war or put in certain policies that inevitably lead to war, it would make sense that the people who get to vote are the same people who have to go and fight.
00:19:24 so the idea that you know that you would have half of the population
00:19:28 that is now i know that's changing and that that too 0.98
00:19:31 is absolutely wicked and a tragedy that women could 0.64
00:19:35 eventually conceivably be drafted into the military not only serve
00:19:39 by their own volition but actually against their will be drafted and that's
00:19:43 a real conversation that wicked nations in rebellion against christ like ours
00:19:48 are actually having those conversations but traditionally
00:19:51 women were not serving in the military at least not in combat roles and uh and we you know not
00:19:57 that long ago wouldn't have even dreamed of ever drafting them and so uh at that period of time
00:20:01 which is not you know a thousand years ago you know we're talking about just you know a matter 0.99
00:20:05 of a couple decades uh when women could not be drafted uh in these united states and they also
00:20:11 were not fighting in combat roles it would make sense that the people who are going to vote
00:20:15 and that vote carrying the power to lend towards outcomes of war where lives can be lost would be
00:20:21 the same people who would have to back that vote up right so if we're all going to vote for you 1.00
00:20:27 know um president you know president idiot you know uh mr idiot for office and mr idiot's going 1.00
00:20:34 to start world war three um well you know uh the people who are going to go and die in world war 1.00
00:20:40 three are the people who voted into office you know so still a tragedy but at least it's kind of
00:20:45 fair. It's not fair if a bunch of people who don't own land, have no stake in the country in
00:20:53 its future, don't have children, aren't, you know, married statistically or are far less likely to be 0.98
00:21:00 married, and also are not going to have to fight in any war or face any of the repercussions,
00:21:06 in many cases also don't pay taxes, but instead are a burden on the tax system. To give those
00:21:11 people a vote um you know is uh absolutely um i mean it's just amazing it's it is it's stupidity 1.00
00:21:20 so aristotle called out too like one of the reasons he didn't allow it was slaves women 0.99
00:21:24 and children was also the time for because democracy was more than a vote too it was
00:21:28 arguing in the public square it was debate it was policy someone called that out in the comments
00:21:32 that it was much more robust and aristotle also wanted citizens to have the time to actually
00:21:36 dedicate to it to be able to go there to read to think to reflect on it so if an individual was a
00:21:43 manual labor worker for the entire day he didn't want those people then showing up and voting for
00:21:48 the person that's advertising free five hundred dollar checks free citizenship this that or the
00:21:53 other he identified those exact same problems of people need to have skin in the game and be able
00:21:57 to do the job well if they want to contribute to the well-being of the polis so i think one of the
00:22:04 you know, from a strategic standpoint, so I can argue, you know, biblically, it's very easy to
00:22:08 argue to repeal the 19th Amendment. Strategically speaking, politically speaking, I think, you know,
00:22:14 probably the more tactful line, you know, line of strategy is just to show the idiocy of universal 0.98
00:22:24 suffrage. So right now, for, you know, all intents and purposes, that's, I think, what a lot of good 0.91
00:22:30 Christian men should be arguing is just showing that universal suffrage is a bad idea. So rather 0.85
00:22:34 than saying, oh, women voting is a bad idea, just say, hey, the idea that we let anyone and everyone 1.00
00:22:38 vote, maybe that's a bad idea. Because with, you know, that kind of democracy, so Aristotle's not
00:22:45 even, he's, you know, like you just said, he's talking about a form of democracy that would be
00:22:51 a lot more sensical. But the form of, yeah, the form of democracy we have today allows, you know,
00:22:57 I mean, think about it. Like, if you go to the hospital, you know, you have to show some form
00:23:01 of ID. If you're going to drive a car, you know, you have to have an ID. If you're going to get on
00:23:06 an airplane, you have to have an ID, and, you know, you're probably also going to have to endure
00:23:09 a cavity, you know, search. And so, you know, but like, in everything that we do, you're going to
00:23:15 have to show some proof of ID, except for voting. Voting, you can go to a ballot box, and in the
00:23:22 united states of america uh that has uh even on the box four different languages mandarin and
00:23:28 spanish you know and like um it's it's i mean it's it's basically begging it's saying hey
00:23:34 please come and vote in our elections please feel something anything out you who are non-citizens
00:23:39 yeah um so it's i mean it's absolutely insane what we're doing uh so in that form of democracy
00:23:45 ultimately um it that a raw democracy which none of our founders had anything positive to say about
00:23:51 that form of democracy um a raw democracy devolves um inevitably always into an oligarchy
00:23:58 and uh an aristocracy you know that might work that i think there's there's some merit i'm not
00:24:04 saying it's the best form of government but there's an argument to be made for that being
00:24:07 a better form of government and really the only difference between an oligarchy and aristocracy
00:24:12 is that an oligarchy is um it's an aristocracy with a bunch of thugs people who are unqualified
00:24:19 for the role. And so it's like, well, how do you get that? Well, you get that from a raw democracy
00:24:24 because then all of a sudden, if anybody and everybody can vote, then really what you're
00:24:30 doing is by elevating everyone, what you've done is you've actually taken the voice away from all
00:24:37 the people that matter, all the people who have a stake in the country, they're rearing children,
00:24:41 they're planning to have posterity to the fifth and sixth and tenth generation, they own land,
00:24:47 they pay taxes, they work hard. All those people, their voice is silenced. And what's replacing that
00:24:55 is Taylor Swift, which a poll was recently done, as you know, that 20% of the people who filled
00:25:01 out this poll said that they would vote for whoever Taylor Swift was voting for. But she's
00:25:08 not an elected official, nor is she qualified for the role. You have a woman who has made
00:25:13 a multi-billion dollar
00:25:15 career writing songs about her 0.98
00:25:17 bad taste in men
00:25:18 all of a sudden having sway over
00:25:21 20% of the country
00:25:22 in which person to vote for
00:25:24 I mean you can't even
00:25:26 you can't even, the Babylon Beat
00:25:29 couldn't even write this kind of
00:25:31 and our scale is so huge, like think of the
00:25:33 founding fathers, you have 13 colonies that are
00:25:35 much less populated, but now we're talking
00:25:37 about 150 million
00:25:39 potential voters, and that
00:25:40 that changes right um i don't like aristotle someone that doesn't even include all the dead
00:25:45 people who vote right that doesn't the dead people the people that aren't on the rolls right uh so
00:25:50 the city-state even a critique of democracy at that smaller level how much more so when you have
00:25:56 people that can be influenced by the internet and social media that can reach out to millions of
00:26:00 people instantaneously right versus a small concentrated group of people that are tightly
00:26:05 together and that's the whole phenomenon of you know kamala harris right like um i think you know
00:26:12 there's an instinct matt wall said something along these lines but there's an instinct you know for
00:26:16 people on the right to say like um you know that uh the crowds that are assembling at like harris
00:26:22 campaigns that this is ai it's not real like you know you just you you want to deny it you know
00:26:27 and it's true that uh there were ai you know photos uh but the ai photos were from um an account that
00:26:34 that made them it was a satire account um you know and for every ai picture you know made by this you
00:26:41 know this you know anon account um there you know that for every one of those ai photos there were
00:26:47 10 real real photos um from multiple different accounts and videos exactly of uh no like so so
00:26:53 the the real line of attack i think for conservatives and you know at this point i
00:26:59 think it's better just to say those on the right because um conservative is not really a good word
00:27:03 Because right now to be a conservative, David French, Warren McIntyre made this point.
00:27:07 He's actually a good example of a conservative because what he's trying to do is conserve the status quo, what we currently have.
00:27:14 And so for David French, what that means is not getting us back to 1776 or the 13 colonies and even before that in the 1600s.
00:27:22 It's conserving the present, what we presently have now, which is giving all of your efforts and all of your fealty to the Civil Rights Act.
00:27:31 And so for someone like French, he really is a true conservative.
00:27:39 He really is, the more I think about it.
00:27:41 Because voting for Harris is the right move for someone who wants to preserve the god of civil rights.
00:27:50 And that is currently, that is what our nation pretty much is.
00:27:55 And so really, we need a better word.
00:27:56 So dissident right or Christian nationalist or something.
00:27:59 But conservative, sadly, conservative probably needs to be a term that we don't use anymore.
00:28:05 In some sense, we're progressives, right?
00:28:07 Like the liberal progressives really should be called regressives, because what they want
00:28:11 to do is actually regress and destroy everything.
00:28:13 We're true progressives.
00:28:14 We want to get us, you know, push us forward in the direction that God would have us.
00:28:17 So all that being said, you know, Matt Walsh was saying the line of attack with Kamala
00:28:21 Harris, you know, how do you explain that phenomenon of somebody who got less than 1%
00:28:25 of the vote in 2020 in the primaries, presidential primaries?
00:28:28 and then now you know has quadrillion billion you know people showing up to her rallies
00:28:33 well you don't try to just dismiss it by saying something that's categorically false like this is
00:28:38 all made up it's ai there are actually zero people there that well that's not true um no there are
00:28:43 tons of real videos and real pictures there are a ton of people there um and and you have to deal
00:28:48 with that and grapple with that the explanation is not just to to somehow sweep it under the rug
00:28:53 and pretend it doesn't exist the real explanation is to say this is the total state this is what
00:28:59 the total state does this is what the media does the media is capable of drumming up sensationalism
00:29:05 around anyone uh you know whether it's the hawk to a girl you know or whether it's you know somebody
00:29:11 who at least initially appeared to be more conservative like oliver anthony like the media
00:29:15 can take anyone uh whether they have uh skills or no discernible skills at all like hawk to
00:29:21 and kamala harris right two peas in a pod neither one has achieved anything in their life and yet
00:29:26 the media can make both of them a star um that's that the media is powerful and that's my point
00:29:32 in a raw democracy uh you really you don't have democracy you have oligarchy and the true oligarchy
00:29:39 is the media the media becomes um the true rule and so instead of elected officials you have
00:29:45 unelected, you know, journalist just dictating. It's a dictatorship, you know, but just with,
00:29:52 you know, a hundred dictators or a thousand dictators, you know, who are in lockstep with
00:29:56 one another instead of one. And they determine the course and the future of the entire nation
00:30:00 by simply putting pen to paper or getting behind a camera and willing what they want to be true
00:30:06 into existence. We were watching Tucker Carlson, he was on Sean Ryan, and he was asked as a viewer
00:30:11 question, who is the most powerful group of people right now in America? And he answered,
00:30:15 it's the McKinsey, Harvard, Fortune 500 types that run and are embedded in these media corporations
00:30:21 that are embedded in influential positions that when they say goes, what they say goes on a policy
00:30:26 and an idea on a person, that's what happened. Those are really powerful people because of the
00:30:31 amount of people they can influence, the money they have, the reach of legacy media. They are
00:30:35 powerful, powerful, powerful. And like you said, none of us elected them. None of us asked for our
00:30:40 mackenzie ruling elite we just got them because they navigated and they got in there and now they
00:30:46 hold immense power so all those things being said in that kind of democracy and and in aristotle's
00:30:53 defense he was talking about a democracy that's uh that's better than our current democracy and
00:30:58 what i just described much smaller where you know where kamala harris you know could get less than
00:31:02 one percent of the vote and then four years later um become a sensation um that everybody loves
00:31:09 just because the media wills it to be so.
00:31:12 So the form of democracy that we have,
00:31:14 Aristotle would have, if anything,
00:31:15 worse, more severe warnings to issue.
00:31:18 But the point is,
00:31:19 with our current kind of democracy,
00:31:22 and Andrew Torba retweeting this,
00:31:23 and Eric Kahn retweeting this,
00:31:25 and our current multiculturalism that we have,
00:31:29 where we are importing,
00:31:30 we're not importing Christians, 0.98
00:31:33 we're not importing Europeans and Brits 0.60
00:31:36 and the French.
00:31:37 like we are importing the third world um in many cases not exclusively i'm not saying that's it but
00:31:43 but in many cases we are importing the third world uh doing it illegally but intentionally
00:31:49 it like it's by design it is on purpose um and then allowing uh for them to vote not in terms 0.58
00:31:56 of policy but by enacting policies that uh that ensure that it can't be stopped right like because 0.79
00:32:03 oh it's voter suppression to ask for a driver's license why because well we all know that black 1.00
00:32:07 people are stupid and they could never figure out how to get a driver's license right how insulting 1.00
00:32:11 is that you know like and yet at the same time it's become a common trope for me to sit here 1.00
00:32:16 and say well democrats are the true racist like of course they are but we we've got to have you
00:32:20 know that that line of rhetoric we've got to do better as you know people on the right if we're
00:32:24 going to win um like could you imagine if the if the uh roles were reversed the tolerant left right
00:32:30 back at it like yeah we've been saying that for 20 years no gonna win we don't need to just point 0.99
00:32:34 out that the left has no standards and that they're hypocrites. Of course, they have no 0.97
00:32:39 standards and they're hypocrites. And how are we going to beat them? By pointing out that they're 1.00
00:32:42 hypocrites? No, because they have no shame. They'll just continue to do it. The way that you beat them 0.99
00:32:46 is you actually seize real power, and by the grace of God and his loving kindness, you crush them.
00:32:52 That's how you do it. You have to win. You have to wield real power and crush them.
00:32:58 So all that being said, I retweeted Eric trying to give him a defense and also just say what's
00:33:03 true i said um uh this particular quote from aristotle is not racist it doesn't assert the
00:33:08 superiority of one ethnicity above another i said here's a you know another point uh eric didn't
00:33:13 condemn uh multi-ethnic nations like by saying aristotle was right uh well then he's he's just
00:33:20 agreeing with what aristotle said and technically aristotle did not uh explicitly outright condemn
00:33:25 um multi-ethnic nations um he's primarily what eric is concerned with by sharing aristotle and
00:33:32 I think part of what Aristotle's getting at is not just the emphasis on, hey, maybe multi-ethnic
00:33:36 nations aren't a good idea, but multi-ethnic nations with a democratic form of government.
00:33:41 And so I know, knowing Eric, that Eric's primary, primarily was condemning not multi-ethnic nations, 0.53
00:33:48 but our current democracy, which plays off of ethnic differences to garnish further power for
00:33:53 the elite ruling class. And then another point I said, Aristotle is generally correct, in my view,
00:33:59 He's generally correct in this particular point, that a multi-ethnic nation with a democratic form of government is going to bring about bad results and division. 1.00
00:34:11 I think Aristotle is mainly correct in that. 1.00
00:34:14 But then I said, however, in a Christian nation, I would like to believe that Aristotle would have been proven wrong. 0.71
00:34:20 However, all of you have spent the last two years assuring us that we can't have a Christian nation.
00:34:26 um and then lastly i said oh by the way because you know k dub said you know racist won't be in
00:34:32 heaven i said and by the way i'm looking forward to seeing jonathan edwards and rl dabney in heaven
00:34:36 and worshiping with them for eternity so my point is saying uh it's just funny to me that all the
00:34:43 people who are objecting to this quote from aristotle not all of them um i would disclude
00:34:49 James White from this, but a lot of them, like Chris, K-Dub, and many others of like
00:34:55 the MacArthur camp and that kind of thing, like Calvinistic Baptists, like guys who aren't
00:35:01 really Reformed but are Neo-Calvinists, like what you said earlier.
00:35:07 That camp is balking at the idea that Eric Kahn, who is a pastor, a Reformed pastor and
00:35:17 claim to love Jesus would positively retweet Andrew Torba, and God forbid, you know, and who's
00:35:25 tweeting Aristotle, you know, and Aristotle, what's the big point that Aristotle's making? 1.00
00:35:30 That multi-ethnic nations are a bad idea. And so Eric Kahn, you know, like, this is terrible. I
00:35:35 can't believe you're doing this. Well, all the people who are balking at that, and so greatly
00:35:38 offended by that, are the people who literally spent the last two years, I can show you all the
00:35:43 receipts, just what they said to me over the past few years, these are the people who were
00:35:49 absolutely, utterly insistent that there's no such thing as a Christian nation, and you can't ever
00:35:55 have a Christian nation. You can't legislate the first table of the law, and you can't, you know, 0.99
00:35:59 all these, like, you must have a nation that, yeah, it honors God in some sense, and maybe the
00:36:05 second table of the law, you know, you pull from the Bible as it pertains to our love for our
00:36:10 neighbor, but you absolutely can't have blasphemy laws or blue laws or Sabbath laws, and the nation
00:36:16 absolutely cannot prefer one religion like Christianity above other religions, and the
00:36:21 nation absolutely cannot self-identify in its own documents, like a preamble to the Constitution,
00:36:28 having the Apostles' Creed. It can't identify as a Christian nation because the only thing that can 0.98
00:36:33 be Christian is an individual. You can't have a Christian family. You can't have a Christian nation. 1.00
00:36:37 you can't have a Christian school, you can't have a Christian anything. That group, the you can't 1.00
00:36:43 have a Christian nation and Christian nationalism is the devil. That group is the group that's 1.00
00:36:49 balking at this. And that's the irony, the hypocrisy, is that I'm saying, no, I think
00:36:56 Aristotle's right, given those three components, two being explicit, one being implicit. The two
00:37:02 being explicit is multi-ethnic being uh the what compromises you know the population of a nation
00:37:09 being multi-ethnic democratic form of government which i've already you know we've spent weeks
00:37:15 talking about how we think that's probably not a good idea but then also implicitly the third
00:37:19 component that's implicit is for aristotle is uh an absence of christ that it's not a christian
00:37:25 nation in that scenario aristotle is right if you have a democratic form of government 0.97
00:37:30 which i think is stupid and um you're importing the third world and throwing a bunch of people 0.97
00:37:37 who have very little in common um uh together in in some milieu a soup uh and uh you top it off 0.99
00:37:45 uh by saying oh and there's uh christian nationalism is the devil and christian nationalism
00:37:50 is is uh that's just the third reich and hitler and that's a cult and um yeah okay well then
00:37:55 then you're just proving aristotle's point yeah uh but if you would let us have some christian
00:38:01 nationalism and stop being insufferable and and do a little you know do the reading as stephen
00:38:06 wolf would say and you know just just grow up a little bit and read a little bit and educate
00:38:11 yourself read some calvin read some you know uh some some luther read you know if you looked into
00:38:17 some of these things and realize oh we can have a christian nation because not only uh is it
00:38:22 theoretically possible, but we could have it in the future because we literally had it in the past,
00:38:26 and we didn't just have it a thousand years ago. We had it arguably 150 years ago, and we didn't
00:38:30 have it on the other side of the world. We had it here. So we've had it before, and we've had it
00:38:34 here, and if God would be so kind, we could have it again. So if you take that approach and say,
00:38:39 one, we can't have a Christian nation. My bad. I was wrong about that. Sorry for being a troll
00:38:42 the last two years. I'm on your team. Let's work towards a Christian nation. Let's honor God.
00:38:47 And then two, we've got all these different ethnicities that are already here, and those who are illegal should be deported, but for everybody who is a legal citizen, we're going to have to learn how to figure something out, and so let's emphasize the Christianity, and also as we emphasize being a Christian nation with an inter-ethnic population, let's also maybe work on our form of government and make sure that we actually get back to representative government
00:39:15 and more of a republic or some other kind of form.
00:39:20 Or original constitution, the civil rights one.
00:39:23 Exactly, rather than the Civil Rights Act as a de facto,
00:39:26 as Christopher Caldwell argued a de facto constitution
00:39:30 that replaced the actual...
00:39:32 So let's try to get back to the actual constitution
00:39:34 instead of this de facto civil rights constitution
00:39:37 that replaced it, because for all intents and purposes,
00:39:39 that's what it did, it replaced it. 0.63
00:39:41 So let's get rid of the imposter constitution of civil rights.
00:39:44 um let's also get rid of a raw democracy where um not only can everyone vote but we're actually
00:39:51 um we're actually going out of our way government officials are going out of their way to make sure
00:39:55 um that the least vested uh members of our society have a vote that criminals have a vote
00:40:01 non-tax-paying citizens have a vote non-citizens have a vote uh democrats what think about like
00:40:07 what what is a democratic party uh what is their stance what's their their platform when it comes
00:40:12 of voting they want to lower the age of voting right so they want children voting um they want
00:40:17 single uh women without children voting uh they want uh non-citizens voting so like what what do 0.65
00:40:25 they want like to sum it all up um what they want is destruction yeah that's what they want they
00:40:31 they absolutely because they know in terms of their policies their policies are not good for
00:40:36 the most outstanding citizens of these united states i just saw today for any committed member
00:40:40 of the united citizen of the united states who pays taxes works hard and is virtuous
00:40:44 the democratic policies are his enemy so then what do they have to the only way they can win
00:40:50 elections is to make sure that that the bad guys get a vote that's what they've always been about
00:40:56 married men married women and unmarried men are the three groups republicans typically carry 0.93
00:41:00 and it's single women the democrats that's that's the group holding them up and there's other 0.99
00:41:05 factors in there that somehow hold them up right because what do you call a married woman right 0.97
00:41:10 you call her a conservative, right? 1.00
00:41:12 Like women are liberal until they get married. 0.68
00:41:14 And it's like, well, what changed their mind? 0.83
00:41:16 Like, well, a man, that's what changed their mind.
00:41:18 And that's good.
00:41:19 And right now that's part of God's pattern
00:41:20 is that you get married, 0.57
00:41:21 you come underneath male headship,
00:41:22 even if you don't like to call it that
00:41:24 and you want to deny that that's what's going on.
00:41:26 But what happens is you come into a relationship
00:41:28 with a man who ordinarily, if he's a good man,
00:41:31 he loves you and you see his love
00:41:33 and commitment towards you and towards your children.
00:41:35 If God would be so gracious as to open your womb
00:41:37 and give you offspring,
00:41:38 spring you see that man provide for you provide for the children and then that man says this is
00:41:42 what's good um and this is what's best for our household and the average woman in that kind of
00:41:48 scenario she says okay i trust you and children to bring men to the right i think torva and jd
00:41:53 vance as they got married and had children then that's right like oh i'm rethinking these things
00:41:58 right if you're a young man and you want to be radicalized get married and have a kid have
00:42:02 daughters yeah have oh my gosh i've got my fourth daughter now on the way and uh there are two
00:42:07 things in life uh that that make me you know the meme come come to life where it's like after a
00:42:13 careful consideration i've decided to become worse like what what makes me become more and more
00:42:16 radicalized are two things uh with every daughter that i get i get like 10 times more radicalized
00:42:22 and every trip to costco i was about to say and every time i smell weed i just get another 15
00:42:27 more there's a few things yeah you smell weed and it's like i'm gonna christian nationalism even
00:42:32 harder i went to costco and i i don't even think i'm in america anymore and now i'm more of a
00:42:38 christian nationalist and i've got my fourth baby girl on the way and uh there's no brakes on this
00:42:42 train at that point with the fourth girl on the way at that point it's like all right i'm gonna
00:42:46 become you know the christian uh franco i'm gonna do it myself i'm gonna do it myself gonna pick up
00:42:52 the team put them on my back you know and here we go so um but my point is commercial break yeah
00:42:56 we'll go to but real quick to just to land the plane my point is just to say that um eric khan
00:43:02 and andrew torba were not being racist by sharing this concept of aristotle and for the record we're
00:43:07 not sitting here and saying well aristotle is infallible of course he's not and we're not even
00:43:11 saying that he's as good as calvin or something like calvin had some some strong negative things
00:43:15 to say about aristotle but also positive things that we'll get to um as well but uh but we can
00:43:20 recognize uh that that aristotle as as a human being made in the image of god um was able to
00:43:27 look to the light of nature and discern accurately some things that God has baked into the fabric of
00:43:32 the world. And I think this is one of those things. Aristotle realized that if you take people who
00:43:37 are strangers to one another and have very little in common, they don't have religion in common,
00:43:41 they don't have culture in common, they are strangers and aliens to one another, and you 0.86
00:43:46 put them in the same place, and then you give all of them a little piece of the pie. You give every
00:43:51 single one of them a vote over the future direction and decisions of that nation, they are naturally
00:43:58 going to be played upon by corrupt, you know, overseers and rulers in order to go against one
00:44:05 of them. Like somebody's going to be running for office and they're going to want to get more votes
00:44:10 and so what are they going to say? If all the white people are voting for the Republican, then
00:44:15 then the democrat candidate is going to say well you know for all you black people uh what i promise 1.00
00:44:21 is that um we'll do a bigger welfare checks and uh and also you'll be able to murder your babies 0.98
00:44:28 all the way up to 40 weeks and for anyone who's like oh man that one was too real um well yeah
00:44:34 it's real that's that is what democrats have been doing for a very long time in order to get the
00:44:40 black vote and i'm not saying every black person sees those things as virtuous they don't but
00:44:45 sadly a lot do yeah a lot do and that's just that is the current state of of our nation and we're 0.97
00:44:51 not going to get out of this mess if we can't even say it if we can't even acknowledge this is where
00:44:55 we're at and if we're going to fix it one let's be a christian nation and for all people who love
00:45:01 jesus and claim to be christians who keep telling us and insisting we can't have a christian nation
00:45:05 maybe just sit a few plays out. So first, let's actually try to have a Christian nation from top
00:45:11 to bottom. And then secondly, let's figure out how to get along with the different ethnicities
00:45:18 and how the gospel brings reconciliation for everybody who's already here. But maybe let's
00:45:22 stop importing by the millions more people from other countries that are incompatible, 0.77
00:45:29 currently incompatible with these United States like Somalia. And so let's stop the immigration 1.00
00:45:35 uh let's try to be christian and then also uh let's maybe not have a raw democracy which our 0.99
00:45:42 founders abhorred but actually go back to some of the forms of government that were less democratic
00:45:47 um that we originally had those sound like really good ideas and i think that's that's all you you
00:45:54 could read what aristotle said in that quote and um and and that be your takeaway and say you know
00:46:00 what? Aristotle was essentially, for all intents and purposes, he was right. And anybody who's
00:46:05 retweeting him and echoing his sentiments and saying, yeah, I think Aristotle was right.
00:46:09 If you're going to respond by saying, that's racist, then you're just, that's great, but just
00:46:16 put out another rap album. But don't speak to politics because you're just, you're not,
00:46:21 it ain't for you. All right, let's go to our first commercial break.
00:46:24 right response ministries 2025 conference is a go this is three days full jam-packed
00:46:35 conference with eight main sessions three to four hour and a half long panels and an all-star
00:46:41 super based lineup of speakers 15 speakers in all who are they steve dace jeff durbin
00:46:48 Orn McIntyre, Stephen Wolf, Brian Sauve, Andrew Isker, John Harris, Eric Kahn, Aidy Robles, Dan
00:46:56 Burkholder, the Christian Prince himself, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, David Reese, and yours truly,
00:47:02 Pastor Joel Webin. Again, this is April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, 2025, and the early registration is open
00:47:10 right now. This is the longest conference with the most speakers we've ever offered, and yet,
00:47:16 It is our all-time lowest price.
00:47:19 The early registration available today
00:47:21 is only 140 bucks for an adult.
00:47:24 So go to rightresponseconference.com.
00:47:27 Again, that is rightresponseconference.com
00:47:31 to register right now
00:47:32 because the early registration will not last long.
00:47:36 Are you a Christian struggling to find companies
00:47:39 that align with your values and beliefs? 0.83
00:47:41 Well, then Squirrely Joe's has you covered
00:47:43 for all your coffee needs.
00:47:45 All of their coffee is hand-selected and roasted fresh every day by a family of fellow believers.
00:47:52 Try them out and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your investment supports
00:47:57 a company committed to following God's teachings and upholding truth and righteousness,
00:48:03 ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the growth of God's kingdom.
00:48:07 Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil.
00:48:11 Right Response listeners have access to an exclusive deal.
00:48:15 Your first bag of coffee is free.
00:48:18 All you have to do is cover the shipping.
00:48:20 So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash Right Response.
00:48:25 Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com forward slash Right Response
00:48:30 to claim your first free bag of coffee today. 0.97
00:48:34 Visit thewordsoap.com today.
00:48:36 Again, that's thewordsoap.com. 0.89
00:48:39 Everyone needs soap. 1.00
00:48:41 So wash yourself in the Word.
00:48:47 Okay, guys, we're back.
00:48:49 Help us out real quick.
00:48:50 We're trying to get our material out to as many people as possible.
00:48:53 And one thing that helps with the algorithm, as you know, is hitting the like button.
00:48:57 So if you could go ahead and give us a thumbs up for this video, if you're watching right
00:49:00 now, or even if you're not watching live and you watch this a little bit later, hit the
00:49:04 thumbs up.
00:49:05 And also feel free to leave a comment.
00:49:07 In our last segment, we're going to try to address some of the comments, especially if
00:49:11 you pose your comment in the form of a question.
00:49:13 So if you've got a question, we've got one more segment here, then we're going to go
00:49:17 to our final commercial break, and then our final, we'll come back for one final segment
00:49:21 for the show today, and we'll try to address, engage with the comment section, especially
00:49:25 questions.
00:49:26 So help us with the algorithm by liking the video and also leaving a comment, especially
00:49:30 a question if you want it to be addressed at the end of the episode.
00:49:33 and uh that being said uh last uh little um item of business is you just saw the commercial
00:49:39 for our conference and uh our early bird registration uh we don't say exactly the
00:49:45 date and the time that that's ending uh in that commercial so i want to make it uh really plain
00:49:49 to everybody who's watching right now that's going to be over at the end of this month i believe
00:49:53 august has 31 days right 31 days nathan says yes so we've got 31 days in the month of august so i
00:49:59 think it's going to be um 11 59 p.m central time is that right nate all right so that's the close
00:50:07 11 59 p.m on august 31st central time so 11 59 p.m central time on august 31st which means you've
00:50:17 got whatever that is it's like two and a half weeks something like that so you don't have much
00:50:22 longer uh the price is going to go up right now it it really is incredibly cheap this is affordable
00:50:27 because we've done Friday and Saturday
00:50:30 with a holdover for the Lord's Day on Sunday.
00:50:33 That's just been our gig for the last couple of years
00:50:36 with our conference,
00:50:37 but we're breaking out of that mold
00:50:38 and we're adding a whole extra day.
00:50:40 So instead of Friday and Saturday,
00:50:41 this is gonna be a Thursday and a Friday,
00:50:44 full day Friday, full day Saturday,
00:50:46 and again, holdover for anybody
00:50:47 who wants to join us for the Lord's Day.
00:50:49 So you get a whole extra day.
00:50:50 We've got like 15 speakers without any exaggeration.
00:50:53 I think it's literally 14 or 15 speakers.
00:50:56 You've got Steve Dace.
00:50:57 you've got jeff durbin you've got warren mcintyre you've got all the augen boys you know you know
00:51:01 ben and brian and dan and uh eric and you've got um dusty deavers you've got uh david reese you've
00:51:08 got uh contra mundum you know with uh uh andrew isker you know boniface option he's coming out
00:51:14 so it's it's gonna be a fantastic uh conference we're gonna have eight main sessions and those
00:51:20 are each going to be about 50 minutes to an hour uh but eight main sessions uh traditionally we've
00:51:24 done the last couple of years, seven. So we're adding another main session. And then the big
00:51:28 thing that we're adding is panels. We're going to have 90 minute panels and not just one. Traditionally,
00:51:33 we've done one or two. We're going to have four. So we're going to have four main panels, each one
00:51:38 an hour and a half long. Some of them might even go a little bit longer where we're going to have
00:51:41 Steven Wolf. He's one of the guys I forgot to mention. He's going to do a main session, but
00:51:45 he's also going to be on the panels. We're probably going to set up a little bit of an
00:51:49 informal or friendly in-house, but debate between some of the more natural law, Christian
00:51:56 nationalist, Stephen Wolf types, and some of the more theonomic types like David Reese or Jeff
00:52:03 Durbin or Dusty Devers. And I find myself in the theonomic camp, but very friendly and sympathetic
00:52:08 to the Stephen Wolf crowd. And so, I might moderate and be somewhere in between. Me and
00:52:12 Iska would probably be very similar in that regard. Iska, he went to Greyfriars and loves
00:52:18 Doug Wilson and kind of cut his theological teeth with Rush Dooney and the Reconstructionist
00:52:23 and Van Til and all those kinds of things, and now he finds himself still very much agreeing
00:52:28 with a lot of those things and still comfortable with the term theonomic, but maybe not quite as
00:52:33 proud of the label as he might have been a few years ago, and more open to, okay, I think that
00:52:43 there's something to this protestant magisterial reformed tradition that uh that calvin held to
00:52:48 and and you know this this natural law christian nationalist position that you know most notably
00:52:53 in term in recent years has been outlined by stephen wolf it seems like that's kind of if
00:52:58 you're looking for the ark it's like what what it you know it just seems random you know guys are
00:53:02 you know they're switching teams and like what's what's the pattern here here's the pattern um
00:53:05 libertarian theonomic and then christian nationalist yes that's pretty much the pattern
00:53:11 is uh it's like um who i can't remember is this saying has been attributed to a ton of guys um
00:53:18 i think even uh thomas jefferson i don't know if he said it but it's been attributed to a lot of
00:53:23 guys it's the old saying that says uh if uh if you're not a liberal when you're young you don't
00:53:27 have a heart and if you're not a conservative when you're old you don't have a brain uh likewise i
00:53:32 would say for uh for men um if you're not uh a libertarian when you're young right if you're a
00:53:37 man and you weren't a libertarian in your 20s and you didn't absolutely love ron paul
00:53:41 then you know then i question uh whether or not you really are a conservative christian
00:53:45 you know so like when you're 22 years old um and if it was eight years ago uh you should have been
00:53:51 uh ron paul maxine and and libertarianism will save the world um but now that you're older if
00:53:57 you're in your 30s now that your brain's fully developed right if you're in your 30s and you're
00:54:01 still libertarian right like you know like a little bit of friendly fire here these are friends
00:54:07 that i'm not going to name but everybody will know who i'm talking about um if it's 2024 and 0.95
00:54:12 they're trying to chop off the genitals of children and uh and we're underpopulated and
00:54:16 not even hitting uh the uh the the levels needed in reproduction in order to sustain our own society 0.67
00:54:24 and you're demonizing uh tax child tax credits which is just reducing the amount you pay not
00:54:29 giving you money exactly they're not giving you money it's not theft they're not taking from the
00:54:33 rich and giving to the poor. Because you know who has children? People who pay taxes ordinarily.
00:54:38 And so they're actually, what the government is doing, and is the government tithing? I'll even
00:54:42 argue it from a theonomic perspective. Anything that rivals the tithe is theft. If the state
00:54:47 rivals God, God takes the tithe, that's 10%. If the state is asking for the same amount or more
00:54:51 than what God asked for, then it's theft, which means taxes, all taxes combined should be 9% or
00:54:56 less. 9% or less. Are you being taxed more than 9%? Yes. Do we have certain officials who are
00:55:03 saying that if I come into office, if you vote for me, and you have four children, then you will
00:55:09 get this amount of money? Well, did the government take more than 9% of your money? Then they're
00:55:14 giving your money back. They're not taking someone else's money and giving it to you.
00:55:20 What that policy does is they say, we're stealing from you, and we're still going to steal from you,
00:55:24 but we're going to steal less from you because you're doing something virtuous that helps all
00:55:29 society. You're saying incentivize is good? A government could do that?
00:55:33 So if you are, if your libertarianism under the, under the, you know, the guise of theonomy,
00:55:39 you know, like theonomic libertarianism is, is causing you in 2024 when they're castrating
00:55:45 children to, to stand in the way and make theological arguments against a tax child
00:55:50 credit then my goodness you just uh god bless you uh you'll always be friends you'll always be
00:55:55 brothers but you have lost the threat so the arc is libertarianism the theonomy you know and then
00:56:01 christian nationalism and i think i can hold on to my general equity theonomy and still be a
00:56:05 christian nationalist and appreciate natural law because honestly let's be honest for calvin for
00:56:09 all the reformers natural law was synonymous with the decalogue that's what natural law was it was
00:56:13 the ten commandments the ten commandments were simply uh god's specific application of natural
00:56:18 law so i don't i actually don't think that they're incompatible but anyways um that's that's what if
00:56:24 you're wondering like why are these guys changing because uh by god's grace we're growing up that's
00:56:28 why all right so anyways all that being said you want to see a debate you know see that but fleshed
00:56:33 out with other guys and maybe get heated you know maybe i don't know maybe we even get to maybe we 0.79
00:56:37 can rile jeff durbin up enough to see some of his uh kung fu you know that would be a good battle
00:56:42 like an older martial arts you know he's kicking steven wolf in the face you know like that i mean
00:56:46 Wolf's not a small dude, though.
00:56:47 That's right.
00:56:48 He's a hard-working...
00:56:48 Well, Wolf will probably be armed.
00:56:51 That is also true.
00:56:52 So that's the problem.
00:56:53 So Jeff Durbin, he's got the fighting skills, but Wolf might have a handgun on him.
00:56:57 So if you want to make sure that you don't miss some high-quality theological entertainment
00:57:03 and political and cultural commentary, then you are not going to want to miss this conference.
00:57:07 So April 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
00:57:09 That's a Thursday, Friday, Saturday.
00:57:11 Feel free to stick with us for the 6th, for that Sunday, the Lord's Day.
00:57:14 uh but you've got three full days plus you know three and a half if you count the lord's day
00:57:18 the third the fourth and the fifth of april 2025 and uh you got two weeks two weeks and then uh
00:57:24 we're done with the early bird registration and we've never done we're adding a full day
00:57:29 we're doubling the speaker lineup we're we're quadrupling the panels and um and yet we are
00:57:35 offering the lowest price we ever have we've never offered uh this price it's a hundred i believe it's
00:57:39 140 bucks i've been everyone and that is absolutely true so it's 140 bucks but it's
00:57:43 going to go up a good bit because honestly it's too cheap and we're going to we're not trying to
00:57:47 gouge people uh but we're also trying to we have a a duty to practice good christian stewardship
00:57:53 with the resources that people give to us and the form of donations and supporting this ministry and
00:57:58 all these kinds of things and uh we will lose money if uh if we don't raise the price because
00:58:03 140 is too cheap the venue alone and flying out 15 different guys and trying to treat them well
00:58:08 giving them honorariums and all these different things um the conference will probably cost us
00:58:12 about uh we've done the math because a lot of guys i'm just doing this because a lot of guys
00:58:16 are not forthright about money especially with conferences uh so i want to shoot you straight
00:58:20 the conference is probably going to cost us about 85 grand is what we're projecting and um and if
00:58:25 we have you know 800 to 1000 people which is what we had this year uh we had 850 people and we do
00:58:31 it all at uh the 140 rate and that's only for adults and then we do super cheap for kids and
00:58:37 if you're under 10 you're free um and so uh if we do that rate um we we will barely uh just a little
00:58:44 bit above breaking even for uh what we're predicting as the cost of this conference so
00:58:48 we have to raise the rate but you still got two weeks to get in at a buck 40 and uh you can watch
00:58:53 jeff durbin and steven wolf get into a boxing match yeah all right it'll be great all right
00:58:57 we'll go to questions soon but i want to give a modern example right talking about aristotle
00:59:01 multiculturalism so you've probably heard about the riots in the uk so it's this little town it's
00:59:06 less than 100,000 people.
00:59:07 It's called Southport, England.
00:59:09 And there was a terrible attack there.
00:59:11 A man went into a children's dance studio,
00:59:15 stabbed like 10 people and killed three children.
00:59:18 And so immediately what happened
00:59:19 on like telegram and messaging groups
00:59:21 was some people started spreading the message
00:59:23 that it was Muslim and it was an immigrant
00:59:24 and people took to the streets.
00:59:26 They accosted the prime minister
00:59:28 when he came to pay his respects.
00:59:30 How long, how many more are you going to let in?
00:59:32 Violence broke out.
00:59:33 There was arrests made.
00:59:35 Now what's interesting is,
00:59:36 so that happened it actually turns out the man wasn't muslim and wasn't a first generation
00:59:41 immigrant his parents were from rwanda but he had moved to southport in 2013 but what i think this
00:59:47 illustrates is right now these riots are ongoing it's funny because you had the aristotle debate
00:59:50 and then you have simultaneously in the uk enjoying the blessings of multiculturalism
00:59:56 of people sharing a space together such a blessing how horrific is it to like i feel like i hear and 0.94
01:00:02 this happened just in the u.s this week about a terrible thing an immigrant or a migrant does
01:00:06 to girls specifically every single week it just it almost desensitized this just happened up in
01:00:13 massachusetts a migrant tried to do something terrible to a 15 year old girl was let go
01:00:17 on 500 bail 500 bail and it's funny i was with my grandma so i was on vacation and she was talking
01:00:24 about she grew up here in the east coast and she was talking about how five six seven years old
01:00:28 she would just go to school she would go and play in the playground her parents didn't have
01:00:33 a second thought she would go to the corner store buy cigarettes for her mom at six years old they
01:00:37 were a close-knit tight society but but what they had is is they shared something and when you see
01:00:45 people reacting like a muslim immigrant yeah of course they must have done this people know that 0.72
01:00:50 it's not close people that have shared space for decades on end that know one another that go to 1.00
01:00:55 church that do terrible atrocities. What you're witnessing is, for one, a breakdown of law,
01:01:00 of God's law in society that restrains evil. The gospel also, the UK is rapidly apostatizing. The
01:01:06 Church of England is dying. So those things are happening. You're losing the Christian religion,
01:01:11 you're losing the restraint of law, and then you're observing what happens when people try 0.97
01:01:16 to share a space. You're literally watching it. Go watch the fireballs, go watch the arrests.
01:01:21 uh there are people now the uk has declared war none of the immigrants doing these terrible things
01:01:26 the ones that are actually criminals on the native britons themselves yeah i saw arresting them
01:01:30 it's like uh some kind of um you know civil servant runs into the office of the prime minister
01:01:35 of england and says uh sir they're rioting in the streets and burning down buildings you know and
01:01:41 and hurting women and children and he's sipping his coffee casually and he says oh i'm sure they 0.92
01:01:46 have a reason for their grievance and he says no sir i mean the white people he spits out his 0.97
01:01:51 coffee the prime minister he's like arrest them all off with their heads there's a 61 year old
01:01:57 man sentenced to i think 18 months in prison i saw for a facebook post for yeah for saying who
01:02:03 is all law yes there was that i mean there's so many of them well that one was different i'm sorry
01:02:07 that wasn't facebook that was a guy who shouted like who the f is all right um i wouldn't have
01:02:12 had the f word in there but a fantastic question who's all along the answer of course being uh he
01:02:17 is no god at all but exactly um but but the fact that you would go to jail for 18 months for that
01:02:21 and i think we're these are two separate accounts that we're both referencing another one facebook
01:02:25 one yeah 20 months insane insane and so sorry all i was gonna say is if you don't want a christian
01:02:33 society this is what you get and and i don't know about you but but i want high high trust society
01:02:38 i i want a people that share a space that share a religion and um i i think greg bonson he asked
01:02:46 in a in a sermon how many times can a man see what's in front of his face and still pretend
01:02:51 not to know the answer yeah how many times can you see and hear about these horrific stories
01:02:57 not even to men and women that are old mature that have lived life to children to children and
01:03:03 to teenagers death and other terrible things done to them how many times can you see this happen
01:03:07 and not think, we need some borders and we need strong rule of law.
01:03:13 And if you put your head in the sand, no, no, no, we must welcome all.
01:03:16 I just saw today an LCMS, so this would be the Lutheran Church, Missouri Synod,
01:03:21 a Lutheran pastor saying, well, having kids to grow the church,
01:03:24 eh, take it or leave it, they don't all stay.
01:03:26 But immigration is the real way that the Great Commission comes to us. 0.98
01:03:31 How many times can you see this happen? 0.99
01:03:33 It's a lack of love for your people in many ways.
01:03:36 to welcome their destruction, to do nothing about it,
01:03:40 to then resist the means, law and gospel,
01:03:42 that could actually rectify it.
01:03:45 I don't know that I have words for that level of
01:03:48 just laying down and taking it.
01:03:51 It's the benefit versus risk.
01:03:55 Risk-benefit analysis, cost-benefit analysis.
01:03:58 So the cost is, you're saying,
01:04:03 how long can it be right in front of your eyes? 0.96
01:04:05 You know, like, you know, your neighbor's children, your native neighbor, like you're a Brit and has lived there for, you know, 10 generations and a fellow, you know, Brit, 10 generations, you know, heritage, you know, Great Britain, their little girl gets raped and stabbed, right? 0.61
01:04:24 And so, and it's right there in front of you.
01:04:26 But the question is cost-benefit.
01:04:28 so um it wasn't your little girl and uh and you know that it could be next time it could be but
01:04:34 you're you're just you're you're weighing the risks right so you're saying yeah it could be
01:04:38 but still statistically it's uh it's an unlikelihood but what is is not unlikely but but
01:04:43 rather a guarantee is that if i speak out against this um even if i speak out against it charitably 0.84
01:04:49 on facebook i can go to jail yeah like the reason so i don't think it's just stupidity and i don't 0.98
01:04:54 even think that it's apathy i think that um the rulers are so sinister and wicked uh that they 0.97
01:05:01 have made it they basically said like if um if you don't speak out uh rape and pillaging from the
01:05:08 third world on your doorstep will continue um but it might just be your neighbor and your family 0.99
01:05:13 might be okay but if you do speak out um we'll rape and pillage you by putting you in jail and 0.97
01:05:20 taking everything you have uh so it's really just a cost-benefit analysis um if i don't say anything 0.99
01:05:25 then uh my daughter might get raped by a somalian if i do say something um then my daughter will 0.87
01:05:32 grow up without a father because the prime minister of great britain will put me in jail 0.97
01:05:36 yeah that's that's your choice i know those are strong words but we just need to say it like it
01:05:41 is that's the choice and that is i think why still a lot of people it's right there in front
01:05:46 in their face and has been for decades and you're quiet and and unchecked that's coming here in 10
01:05:51 years you're going to face the same dynamic if things don't change um i feel like we're going
01:05:55 to be up against exactly that the the department of justice showing up your doorstep up sir that
01:06:01 facebook post was a little racist and we're going to take you here and you're going to have to do
01:06:06 some re-education you spoke out against this you didn't want so and so freed you you wanted this
01:06:11 that or the other i i don't feel like we're that far away it would have been unthinkable i'm sure
01:06:15 in great britain 2015 we're not gonna be arrested for facebook posts they're not gonna take our
01:06:19 knives away right we're not gonna have literally i saw i think it was in ireland it was a small
01:06:23 town of 200 people or i think it was about 100 people and they dropped off about 150 migrants
01:06:29 at a hotel there and said they will be housed here do not stop it don't say anything against
01:06:33 it or we'll arrest you again 10 years ago you wouldn't they would never the government wouldn't
01:06:38 show up and do that oh yeah they will and it could happen here too um all right so what final
01:06:44 points do you want to make and then uh we'll go to our last commercial and get to questions but
01:06:48 what what final things on our topic today do you feel like maybe we left on said um
01:06:54 we were talking about a little bit the gospel's primary mission is not um ethnic reconciliation
01:06:59 but that is an effect of it that the gospel reconciles man to god first and foremost that's
01:07:04 to reconcile sinful man to a holy god absolutely because the gospel the word literally in greek
01:07:10 means good news. It is the good news of the life, death, resurrection of Jesus. Jesus reconciles us
01:07:15 to God primarily, but individuals, so a husband and wife, also through the work of the gospel,
01:07:19 help are reconciled to one another, have a home rightly ordered. So it is the gospel. It can help
01:07:24 create ethnic unity, but also the law does. The law helps us. It restrains evil in one of its
01:07:30 functions. That can also create a commodious, harmonious society for people to share. So it's
01:07:37 not just gospel, because you'll hear ministers do this. They'll get up and they'll talk about
01:07:40 the work of the gospel, ethnic unity, and all these things. And it does, at some level, help
01:07:44 reconcile people, but also what law does, where evil is restrained, where people know what's
01:07:49 expected of them. There's a societal, cultural expectation that's enforced, some of it explicitly
01:07:54 in law, but then some of it's getting into the hearts of people where they say, there's nothing
01:07:58 against this, but you still can't do that. Yeah, one thing that helps my kids get along really well
01:08:03 um is the fact that uh that they know that their dad will discipline them if they don't get along
01:08:10 yeah right like that that really helps you know so like we have you know i mean there's still
01:08:15 fights and factions in my home because i have a six-year-old and a four-year-old and a three-year-old
01:08:19 and one-year-old and another on the way you know so like i've got little little kids um and little
01:08:25 kids uh sometimes they're not perfectly behaved you know but um but by and large with children
01:08:31 as young as mine are um they they do really well and and are growing in consideration of one another
01:08:38 and preferring one another and sharing and all these kinds of things um but they're doing that
01:08:42 not just because of the gospel um they're doing that primarily because of the law they're doing
01:08:48 that because exactly because because by god's grace and i don't do this perfectly because i
01:08:53 too am a sinner but by god's grace their mother and i are doing our best to legislate as parents
01:09:00 in our household god's law accurately and fairly for our children in our home and um and i think
01:09:07 you know for our oldest um i think that she's showing the the most signs of maturity and
01:09:12 preference of others and selflessness and all these kinds of virtues and fruit of the spirit
01:09:16 because uh she's got law in the form of mom and dad's discipline but she also i believe has gospel
01:09:24 I do believe God alone sees the heart, but her mother and I, we believe that she is regenerate,
01:09:31 that she belongs to Christ. I don't think that all my children are regenerate. I believe that
01:09:35 all my children are elect. I do believe that. And I believe that you can have that view,
01:09:40 even as a Baptist, that we can affirm covenant succession. But I don't believe that they're all 0.87
01:09:44 regenerate from the womb. So the majority of my children, as far as I can tell, God alone sees the
01:09:49 heart. I look at the outward appearance and measuring fruit and those kinds of things. But
01:09:52 as far as I can tell, doing my best as a father to exercise discernment, the majority of my
01:09:57 children are unregenerate. In other words, the majority of my children, the gospel has not yet
01:10:03 changed their hearts. And yet they're still growing and improving in their outward behavior.
01:10:09 Their heart is still totally depraved and needs the gospel of Jesus Christ. But in their outward
01:10:12 behavior, there is day by day great improvement. Because you know what? The law of God revives the
01:10:19 soul. I don't like that. I don't like that. I don't like that interpretation. That's not
01:10:23 an interpretation. That is a literal quote from the Bible. It's so incredible. It says makes wise
01:10:28 the simple. You could take a simple person as little to offer society. Like a two-year-old.
01:10:32 Like a two-year-old. The law of God that sets them straight. So we'll go to our final commercial
01:10:37 break. I think we had a couple of questions. We'll look for them. Leave any more in the comments and
01:10:41 we'll get to them in this final segment. All right. Are you desiring to change your financial
01:10:46 trajectory and build multi-generational wealth for your children and grandchildren? Our sponsor,
01:10:51 Private Family Banking Partners, invites you to join a growing number of like-minded individuals,
01:10:57 families, and entrepreneurs who are working together to form a unique part of the parallel
01:11:03 economy. With Private Family Banking, you will learn how to establish a privatized banking system
01:11:09 that will increase the value of the money and savings that you already have
01:11:14 flowing through your life. Join this growing community today as a part of putting post-mill
01:11:19 talk into post-mill action by contacting a private family banking partner today by emailing them at
01:11:26 banking at privatefamilybanking.com. Also see the show notes below to schedule a discovery call and
01:11:33 get a free copy of the ebook, Protect Your Money Now, How to Build Multigenerational Wealth
01:11:39 Outside of Wall Street and Avoid the Coming Banking Meltdown.
01:11:44 Our beef supply is under attack.
01:11:48 More than ever, the industry for fake industrial produced meat is underway. 1.00
01:11:53 As reformed post-mill Christians, the founders of Dominion Ranch 0.96
01:11:57 seek to honor Christ's rule and continue building His kingdom on earth
01:12:02 by supplying Christians with high-quality beef for the journey.
01:12:07 We believe in excellence, and that is why Dominion Ranch works as a collective
01:12:12 with multi-generational ranchers across Texas
01:12:15 to bring you the best in great tasting and nutritious beef.
01:12:20 Our motto is that kingdoms were never built on salads alone.
01:12:24 Eat beef and subdue the earth.
01:12:27 And one more thing,
01:12:28 don't forget to enter the Dominion Ranch Super Summer Giveaway
01:12:31 for some delicious Wagyu beef,
01:12:33 a mouth-watering addition to your freezer.
01:12:36 Click the link in the description and enter to win.
01:12:39 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God
01:12:44 and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
01:12:48 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
01:12:52 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
01:12:55 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
01:12:59 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
01:13:04 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain
01:13:08 our capacity to do things here.
01:13:10 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
01:13:16 All right, we're back.
01:13:18 Here's a question that I thought was good.
01:13:19 I'm going to have Nathan, our assistant, scroll up to it.
01:13:22 Here it is.
01:13:22 It's from Corey.
01:13:24 He says, does your congregation pretty much align with your views, Pastor Joel, or is
01:13:28 there some conflict over certain issues?
01:13:31 I know that that doesn't exactly pertain to our topic today, but it is something, a
01:13:36 common question that i receive from time to time because anybody who watches our show right if
01:13:41 you're not a member in our church and wes i'll let you speak to this too because you you would have
01:13:44 you know an insider point of view as a member of our church but anybody who's not and on the
01:13:49 outside looking in and they're just maybe watching the sermons online or watching you know the live
01:13:52 stream or the friday special you know or theology apply the interview that i do on mondays they're
01:13:57 watching the podcast they're on the outside looking in and they know that um joel webin uh
01:14:03 is um you know he's he's nothing if not opinionated right he has you know he has strong
01:14:09 views right he holds strong views he has convictions and so it might surprise the listener
01:14:14 i appreciate the question coy uh to know that uh we actually have a fairly wide array and i would
01:14:19 argue wider than i wish it was but uh but we're not going to just bludgeon people over the head
01:14:24 we're going to take time and shape people over time uh through properly dividing the the word
01:14:30 of God, teaching the word of God and shaping, discipling people. But our church, I think a big
01:14:34 part of it is just the context of our church in terms of the timing that it was planted. We planted
01:14:39 our church in my living room with 12 adults, including my wife and I. It was like 20 people,
01:14:46 including kids. We did it in our living room, putting out our dining room chairs and using our
01:14:51 couches and kids sitting on the floor. It was in the living room of our home. And we started the
01:14:55 first sunday which happened to be an easter sunday of april 2021 april 2021 and so uh and we had just
01:15:02 a couple months prior you know um moved uh from california to texas which for me for the record
01:15:08 was actually not going somewhere where i was not native uh but actually coming home texas is where
01:15:14 i was born and raised um it was the choice to go to california that was actually the outlier and so
01:15:19 so all that being said you were still on the heels of covet yeah and texas did better than
01:15:24 some states, but not great. Greg Abbott was pretty much just, he didn't really have any
01:15:30 courage or spine. He just, whatever Ron DeSantis would do, he would just mimic that a few months
01:15:35 later. And so Texas got rocked, not as much as California, but it got rocked by COVID as all
01:15:43 the nation did. And then of course you had the summer of love and mostly peaceful riots burning
01:15:49 down half the country and so uh so i was just you know on those two things among other things but i
01:15:54 was outspoken about those two things um and we you know so i'm just preaching to my friends my wife
01:16:00 and kids and some of our close friends who moved with us you know from california in the church
01:16:04 that i pastored there and uh but we were recording the sermons and putting them online and people
01:16:08 are watching it and uh and it took off because they saw you know strong stances on covid and
01:16:14 and wokeness yep strong stance against you know the branch covidians and wokeology and so uh but
01:16:22 then my point is what does that get you because there's a ton of people who hate wokeness and
01:16:25 hated the the covid tyranny but are not necessarily 1689 second london confession you know uh reformed
01:16:33 baptist post-millennial like and to be honest a lot of the people that we got initially and still
01:16:38 to this day continue to get um we're staunch you know dispensational pre-mill guys right so they're
01:16:44 like they're like we see the writing on the wall like we're with you joel uh no vaccines uh no mask
01:16:50 uh stand up to covid tyranny and uh wokeness is a virus and also um this is these are the signs
01:16:58 the end times are upon us and jesus is coming back you know to rapture the church but you know
01:17:02 i'm different than all those you know all those uh normies out there and i'm like oh you're different
01:17:07 like you're you're post-millennial you know or you're you're reformed all-millennial like no
01:17:11 i'm different i'm a post-trib uh you know i'm a mid-ax dispensational exactly so like with like
01:17:18 that was most of the church initially um so to answer your question cory uh eschatology most of
01:17:25 the church uh was not post-millennial at this point i would say over half of the church is
01:17:28 post-millennial because they've been shaped over time through the preaching and discipleship um and
01:17:34 and then also just on their own reading and studying the word of god for themselves and
01:17:37 coming to that conclusion but initially a lot of the people who really took a stand were the salt
01:17:44 of the earth and who's the salt of the earth dispensationalists honestly like let's just be
01:17:50 honest i hate i despise dispensationalism but dispensationalists the people are some of the
01:17:57 the sweetest people on on the planet like i remember doug wilson said you know like stephen
01:18:03 wolf when he had you know his his infamous tweet you know a year ago whenever it was that uh why
01:18:07 white evangelicals are the lone bulwark, you know, against the moral insanity of America.
01:18:11 And he's right. He was making a statistical argument, not each and every individual, 0.74
01:18:15 but in a group dynamic in general, white evangelicals are the most conservative
01:18:20 voters in the nation. And by that metric, you know, therefore, they are the main dam
01:18:28 that is holding back the floodgates of moral insanity. So Stephen Wolfe, I don't think he
01:18:32 did anything wrong. I think that that was fine. But Doug Wilson said, you know, well,
01:18:36 if we're going to say that then it's also fair you know steven wolf i would i would ask you
01:18:40 request that you say another set of 11 words that um dispensational pre-millennials um are the lone
01:18:47 bulwark um and now i don't know why doug was trying to get steven to say that to me it doesn't
01:18:52 make any sense but uh that's not the point the point is steven wolf was right about white
01:18:56 evangelicals but so was doug wilson and so anyways all that being said uh dispensationalism i despise
01:19:02 because i think it's a bad doctrine it's led to endless wars in the middle east and you know
01:19:05 and zionism and all these different things that i i think yeah i despise because i think the lord
01:19:10 jesus despises but uh aside from that dispensationalist the actual people um they have
01:19:16 stood up against lgbt and they stood up against covet a lot of like i'd like to sit here and say
01:19:21 it was all the reformed guys who have a historical grammatical literal and also typological
01:19:27 christological typo you know typology you know hermeneutic of the word of god and can track their
01:19:32 you know theological traditions back to calvin and luther and zwingli they their theology was
01:19:39 tested and tried and it proved through its fruit to be the true doctrines because in 2020 it was
01:19:45 the reformed that took a stand against covet nope i wish that was the case that guys like let's just
01:19:52 be honest that was not the case calvary chapel kicked most presbyterians butts in terms of
01:19:59 Courage, spying, and just raw instinct of knowing the times.
01:20:03 Yeah.
01:20:04 Calvary Chapel in Southern California.
01:20:06 Jack Hibbs did way better than R. Scott Clark.
01:20:09 Yeah.
01:20:10 Which that one actually isn't shocking because it's R. Scott Clark.
01:20:12 Mark Dever.
01:20:13 1689.
01:20:14 Yep, better than Mark Dever.
01:20:15 They were closed.
01:20:15 Yep, exactly.
01:20:16 So the point is because we planted our church in that context,
01:20:23 that was the time, April 2021,
01:20:25 on the heels of COVID and the heels of wokeness,
01:20:28 and that's kind of where we kind of that was our our rise to stardom we're not stars you know we
01:20:32 got we're we're little little fish you know like but we've got a youtube channel with a hundred
01:20:38 thousand people and you know and plenty of other people have a million so we're not a big deal by
01:20:43 any stretch but the little bit of accolades that we did gain uh came from taking a stand on those
01:20:49 issues at in a timely manner uh when when they were that was what everybody was wrestling with
01:20:55 what do we do do we close our churches do i do i get the 14th booster do i you know should i wear
01:21:00 three masks in the shower alone by myself you know like that that was you know um it uh should uh 0.93
01:21:06 should i give black people all of my stuff am i terrible for being white you know like that like
01:21:10 that's what was going on yep and uh we took a stand but the reality is my point is that stand 0.89
01:21:15 appealed it did not just appeal to people who have theology like mine it appealed to pre-mill guys
01:21:21 dispensational guys we have a ton still to this day we still have maybe not a ton but i'd say we
01:21:27 have uh at least a dozen maybe two dozen arminians yep in the church um so most people are calvinist
01:21:33 and and reformed in their soteriology um but i'd say it's probably 80 like i'd say 70 percent is
01:21:39 post-millennial at this point in the beginning it was less than 50 um i'd say 80 85 percent are
01:21:45 reformed in their soteriology but there's a good you know 12 to 25 people adults that are arminian
01:21:51 and uh and they know and it's and i'm not being shy about that ever and so they know exactly what
01:21:57 i believe but they're willing to be there also here's another one uh baptism we have a ton of
01:22:01 people this one i can't say ton uh who are of the persuasion of pedo-baptism that is their um that's
01:22:08 their position and uh but they love our church and part of the reason they don't go to a presbyterian
01:22:13 church is because the opc church down the road and the pca church down the road uh closed for 15
01:22:18 months during covid you know and uh and then if they did open up uh they had two services and in
01:22:24 one of the services it was you know masks are optional but the other one they're required
01:22:28 and uh and they wouldn't even sing and uh the pastor his wife and their kids uh which service
01:22:34 do you think they went to the non-singing we won't obey ephesians colossians when it says when
01:22:39 we gather to address one another with songs i was on an opc website i was looking for someone who
01:22:44 came from it we're gonna go to that service in 2024 still we're advertising masks and covid
01:22:48 requirements like as in two weeks ago right a current church obc church still meeting right so
01:22:53 i have i have presbyterians in my church why because presbyterians uh they think that i'm
01:22:58 wrong about baptism they're kind and charitable and respectful towards me as a pastor holding
01:23:02 the view that i do but in the you know but that is their position they think uh joel's wrong about
01:23:07 baptism but he's the most covenantally minded baptist we've ever met and so we appreciate that
01:23:12 But we would rather go to the Baptist church that knows what time it is than the Presbyterian church that is sitting in the garage revving the 12-cylinder engine, the V12 engine of all the great riches and theological treasure of Voss and Gahardus Voss and all these Reformed treasures.
01:23:39 But they never take the car out of the garage and never drive it.
01:23:43 And so Joel's over here with his little six-cylinder Honda Civic,
01:23:48 but he's souped it up as much as you possibly could.
01:23:51 And he's out here drag racing.
01:23:54 He's doing jumps. 1.00
01:23:54 Yeah, and doing jumps with his little Baptist Honda Civic. 0.98
01:23:59 And the Presbyterians, what's the point in being a titan of intellect and theology 1.00
01:24:04 if at the end of the day, you're a freaking coward? 1.00
01:24:07 You are. 1.00
01:24:09 And that's not all Presbyterians, but it's a lot. 0.98
01:24:13 Sadly, it's a lot. 0.67
01:24:14 And so to answer the question, good question, Corey,
01:24:17 the answer is that we have a vast array of people of different positions.
01:24:22 And the way that I preach, and this is the last thing I'll say,
01:24:25 the way that I preach is different than the policies that we hold
01:24:28 in terms of for unity and membership in our church.
01:24:32 When I preach, it's like, well, man, for a guy who has people
01:24:35 of all these different positions, that actually surprises me
01:24:38 because you speak so matter-of-factly you don't speak uh you don't you just don't sound that
01:24:43 charitable when you're speaking on your podcast or when you're preaching you make it sound like
01:24:47 it's you know this is the only way it can be and blah blah blah and this is why that that too comes
01:24:51 from a conviction theological conviction peter says in his epistle that there are multiple different
01:24:56 gifts and he talks about the one who speaks and he's referring to a gift of teaching and oration
01:25:01 the one who teaches the word of god he says let the one who speaks speak as though he's speaking
01:25:06 the very oracles of god in other words uh when a minister of the gospel gets into the pulpit and
01:25:12 begins to preach he should preach uh from the standpoint not of i think or maybe or perhaps
01:25:20 but thus saith the word of god yeah and so when i speak um i the reason i speak a matter of factly
01:25:27 is not because that's my personality because if you talk to me in any other setting if i'm not
01:25:31 sitting behind this table in a podcast or behind the pulpit in a sermon you know this west because
01:25:35 with friends in any other context i'm just like hey you know like all right let's you know let's
01:25:40 have a whiskey let's go watch a movie or like yeah i've got a an opinion on this or an opinion on
01:25:45 that like i'm a lot more laid back yeah um but the reason i'm not in the pulpit isn't because it's my 0.66
01:25:50 innate personality to be so sure of myself and that really i'm just a narcissist and arrogant
01:25:55 uh no i actually kind of have to uh intentionally work myself to be that way um and i do it because
01:26:00 i'm trying to be obedient yeah i believe that the word of god actually commands the preacher
01:26:05 to preach as though he is heralding the oracles of god and not as though he is softly and quietly
01:26:12 sharing his opinion so so that's why i preach that way but in terms of pastorally outside of
01:26:18 the pulpit the way that i shepherd sheep and the and our policies and requirements for membership
01:26:23 are actually um if anything maybe more accommodating than they should be and allows for
01:26:28 all different kinds of theological persuasions to feel at home and loved in our church.
01:26:33 Yeah. I would add, so that's theological. I'm not sure if maybe Corey's question related to
01:26:37 theological or political. So theological, we have somewhat of our diversity, and it's not our
01:26:42 strength. It's not like, oh yeah, we have Baptists, Presbyterians. We have some theological diversity,
01:26:47 but I would say politically and socially, we have little. As in, every single person would be in
01:26:51 lockstep against the left. We will not have a single Kamala Harris voter anywhere in our church.
01:26:56 We have some that wouldn't vote for Trump, but we will not have a diversity of political thought, like, eh, the left, not so bad.
01:27:02 So, a bit of a diversity theologically, but politically, I would say the church is pretty strongly aligned.
01:27:07 The roles of men and women, the importance of children, the need for a Christian nation.
01:27:13 On those, I would say, I don't know, maybe you could say differently, I think of the members, we would all be right there in lockstep.
01:27:20 Yeah, we would want to see a Christian nation again.
01:27:22 We would want to see Christian laws.
01:27:23 We would want to see homosexuality banned again, things like that. 0.72
01:27:27 I'll do a drive-by, just two minutes on a question, 0.99
01:27:30 then there was some for you, Joel.
01:27:31 I don't know how long you want to go.
01:27:32 Okay.
01:27:32 Can you address refugees?
01:27:34 I've heard a lot about immigration, but what about the refugees?
01:27:36 This is Jonathan Johnson.
01:27:38 Yep, this is just a question I've thought of.
01:27:41 There are legitimate refugees, I think, of the apartheid in Africa. 0.94
01:27:45 Imagine you're a white farmer, and they're literally coming to take your farm. 1.00
01:27:50 to butcher you. The stories of what we've done there are just absolutely terrible, again, 0.93
01:27:53 to white families, to children. You fleeing is legitimate, and a nation can, although it does 0.99
01:27:58 not have to, accept refugees. But one word of caution on that, even if you would be doing a 1.00
01:28:04 good thing, if it comes at the risk and the detriment of your own people, and you perceive 0.99
01:28:08 that there could be a possibility, I think a nation has the right, a Christian nation, to say,
01:28:12 we understand you're in a tough circumstance. We can't, however, help because of the risk it
01:28:17 would introduce. And a good example of this was in World War I, the island of Sicily off,
01:28:21 it's actually World War II in the Civil War, island of Italy, Sicily, the U.S. removed their
01:28:28 restriction, uncapped immigration from there on the refugee status. There was war going on,
01:28:33 people wanted to leave the region and the island, so they let them in. And that's actually what 1.00
01:28:36 precipitated the mob crisis that gripped the nation for the next three decades and led to 0.55
01:28:41 the creation of the FBI, was unchecked immigration. And then these groups of subversive actors came in
01:28:47 and began establishing within the ports of New York.
01:28:49 You can read, it's Bill O'Reilly Killing the Mob.
01:28:51 Fascinating book.
01:28:53 But it was all precipitated by this group that claimed,
01:28:55 we're just fleeing this war, we just need shelter.
01:28:59 And then they came in, set up shop,
01:29:00 and got to work doing things that really,
01:29:03 I mean, our nation was in many ways crippled
01:29:05 because they would commit a crime,
01:29:06 but they would cross state lines,
01:29:08 they couldn't track them.
01:29:09 So when something like that is a dynamic,
01:29:11 I don't know, we might be bringing in,
01:29:13 yes, valid refugees,
01:29:14 but also military-aged males 1.00
01:29:16 that are going to come in and do terrible things to our nation,
01:29:18 I think a nation can say, we're sorry.
01:29:21 We're just not going to allow you.
01:29:22 Or if they have the resources and they can vet,
01:29:25 it is also acceptable, I would say, to say,
01:29:27 we're going to welcome in on a limited basis, on a limited number,
01:29:30 some of you legitimately fleeing, especially religious persecution.
01:29:33 I would say a Christian nation can have even above and beyond
01:29:35 to say you're a Christian fleeing Islamic persecution.
01:29:38 That's a valid category, but it's not required for us to take the refugee 0.66
01:29:42 if it would do detriment to our own people and to our own family.
01:29:46 well said um let's do this uh so euclid has uh some great points that he made but i want to read
01:29:52 from striker i did euclid a couple weeks ago and euclid i think this striker is getting a similar
01:29:58 question that you do too um striker and euclid are very concerned about my uh my um my compassion
01:30:06 towards steven wolf your friendly north carolina exactly yeah so uh striker says this a question
01:30:12 for Joel. Do you understand that even Wolfe, Stephen Wolfe, has stated his natural law position
01:30:18 is incompatible with theonomy? Why specifically do you think that you can ride the fence between
01:30:23 the two? So this gets, you know, it's Thomism versus, you know, it's Thomas Aquinas versus
01:30:30 Van Til. Part of it is their epistemology, how they arrive at the truths that they arrive at,
01:30:37 how we can know what we know. Um, but one thing I said this a couple of weeks ago, but maybe it
01:30:42 bears repeating. Um, it's probably important for people to know. And I, and I've been consistent
01:30:46 with this, uh, believe it or not. Uh, I, so I have been a classical theist, um, for, uh, at least I
01:30:53 think six years now came into those convictions. It was either 2017 or 2018. Um, I remember having,
01:31:00 you know, some staunch arguments with, uh, my elders at the time. And we were, you know,
01:31:03 because we were all still kind of trying to figure out our theology of god um you know our
01:31:08 theology proper and uh and so you know god is the most uh most pure spirit without body parts and
01:31:13 passions um uh the impassibility you know so like even like sam renahan and uh some of the the
01:31:18 reformed baptist guys from arpka um who was it dolezal who wrote all that is games yeah there's
01:31:25 some you know some divine simplicity right so that god without parts philosophical theology
01:31:29 um and uh and then uh renahan did you know dole is always handling the divine simplicity
01:31:35 god without parts and and renahan was uh handling uh god without passions and at at root you know
01:31:41 passions is you know the divine cannot suffer right the latin you know so he you know god
01:31:46 doesn't die god doesn't suffer those kinds of things and making sense of that without getting
01:31:50 into the nestorian heresy um you know but uh but still making sense of the two natures in you know
01:31:55 the hypostatic union of one person of uh the son uh the second member of the trinity uh god the son 0.62
01:32:01 and that uh that it's true to say that jesus died that's a perfectly theologically true statement
01:32:05 and it's also true to say that god has never died and it's also true to say that jesus is god
01:32:10 and always has been and there was never a single moment that he ceased being god that he paused
01:32:15 being god so um and i don't have time to get into all that but so in that sense uh everybody can
01:32:20 affirm God is without passions in that sense, if you're orthodox and not a heretic. But I do think
01:32:26 that Sam Renahan and the Reformers, I think most of the Reformers would adhere to this, that God
01:32:32 without passions isn't just that he doesn't suffer, but that when the Bible speaks of God,
01:32:36 in terms of theology of God, understanding him, theology proper, it speaks underneath the banner
01:32:41 of analogy. Under the banner of analogy, we have two primary subcategories. We have anthropomorphic
01:32:46 language and anthropopathic language. Anthropomorphic language is speaking of God in
01:32:50 physical terms while recognizing, John chapter 4, God is spirit. And those who worship him must
01:32:55 worship him in spirit and truth. It is true that the second member of the Trinity has taken on
01:32:59 flesh and he is forever now the God-man. He has a body, a now glorified body, where he's seated at
01:33:03 the right hand of God the Father Almighty. But the Father and the Spirit have always, and the Son
01:33:07 previously before the Incarnation always, did not have a body. He's the most pure spirit without
01:33:12 body, parts, and passions. And so, God without body and without parts, divine simplicity,
01:33:18 in philosophical terms, doesn't mean God's simple and that we're complex, speaking, you know,
01:33:23 trying to, you know, insinuate that God's inferior. Of course, that's not true. But simple
01:33:27 in philosophical terms, meaning that God is not divisible. You know, even the, you know,
01:33:32 the Reformers and the Puritans, especially, when they would speak of the attributes of God,
01:33:36 they preferred to use the word the perfections. And attributes or perfections of God isn't 0.76
01:33:41 something that god possesses uh it's not that god has attributes or that he has these perfections
01:33:46 but that he is his perfections and that he's not the uh the comprise um or the uh the sum of all
01:33:54 it's not uh you know like the captain planet thing you know heart uh winds you know it's not uh you
01:34:00 know justice you know equals captain god you know it's that's not the way it works um no uh if you
01:34:06 If you were to separate or somehow detract merely one of the attributes or perfections of God, then the whole thing falls apart.
01:34:14 He would no longer be God.
01:34:15 And so, all that is in God is God.
01:34:18 So, when the Bible says, you know, because that's some of the lousy theological arguments that people make.
01:34:22 They say, God is love, you know.
01:34:24 And so, therefore, you know, like, yeah, God is just.
01:34:26 And yeah, God, you know, he has judgment.
01:34:28 And, you know, he has these other things.
01:34:30 But, you know, that one attribute, namely love, trumps all the other ones.
01:34:35 And so, we can be light on sin.
01:34:36 and how do you arrive there? Well, God has these other things, but he is. That's an ontological
01:34:42 argument of what God is. His very essence is love. Well, one, that's just a bad hermeneutic of reading
01:34:47 the scripture. Two, even by your bad hermeneutic, using that argumentation, well, if God is love,
01:34:53 the Bible doesn't just say he has holiness, but he is holy, holy, holy. The Bible never says that
01:34:59 God is love, love, love. So God is then, therefore, by your own logic, three times holier than he is
01:35:03 loving. And so, my point is, you know, you just shouldn't do it that way at all. Instead, all the
01:35:08 attributes of God are not things that He possesses or has, but God is. And so, when the Bible says
01:35:14 God is love, that is a phenomenal verse of the Bible and a wonderful thing that 1 John tells us.
01:35:18 But it's just as theologically true to say God is justice, God is love, God is mercy, God is,
01:35:24 you know, all these things, God is truth, God is, you know. And so, all that God is, God is. All that
01:35:30 is in God is God. So that's divine simplicity. And then without passions, that's anthropopathic
01:35:35 language. So when the Bible speaks of physical terms of God, his eyes roam to and fro, his right
01:35:40 arm is mighty to save, it's analogous language. It's saying, it's not a lie. It's saying something
01:35:45 true about God, but in a way that human beings can understand. It's true, but it's not literally
01:35:50 true or physically true. So too with anthropopathic language. The Holy Spirit is grieved, right?
01:35:55 That's emotional language, but God does not emote in the literal sense.
01:36:00 God was, his wrath was kindled against Israel, you know, because of this or because of that.
01:36:06 That's emotional language, but it's meant to be emotional language interpreted underneath
01:36:12 the banner of analogy, it's anthropopathic language.
01:36:15 It's saying something true about the character and nature of God, but not literally true
01:36:19 because God does not emote.
01:36:20 God is not fluctuating on a dime, turning back and forth this minute and then back the next
01:36:26 in his emotional state. God is not a man that he should change his mind. Behold, I am the Lord,
01:36:32 I changeth not, so that you, the sons of Jacob, are not consumed. God knows the very end from
01:36:38 the beginning because he ordained it to come about. And so, God is not fluctuating and changing. He
01:36:43 does not change, and that includes a state of mind. That includes even his emotional state.
01:36:48 god does not change so here's my point striker and euclid uh my point is um that's tomism now
01:36:54 i'm not saying that's all of tomism tomism goes further than that but that's tomism as it pertains
01:36:58 to the doctrine of god that is uh tomism theology proper that is classical uh theism and i have been
01:37:05 a classical theist for six years so i've been you know charitable in the way that i engage with
01:37:11 others and very much in the theonomic general you know equity theonomy camp uh so i love moscow and
01:37:17 I love Doug Wilson, I love James White, you know, and I love these guys, but I have disagreed,
01:37:22 and you've probably never heard me say it publicly, but I'll say it today, I have disagreed
01:37:25 with Doug Wilson, who I love and respect, and James White, who I love and respect.
01:37:28 I have disagreed with these great men who are better men than me, on the whole, I've
01:37:32 disagreed with them about doctrine of God for at least the last six years.
01:37:36 And Owen Strand, he, I feel, far less of an obligation to be charitable towards, so I'll
01:37:42 just frankly, you know, come out and say it.
01:37:44 his doctrine of God, his theology proper, is borderline heresy, if not full-blown. It's just
01:37:51 atrocious. And so, yes, I am a general equity theonomist, and I love Van Til, and I appreciate
01:37:57 95% of Rush Stuney. I think he's the best of the Reconstructionists, even better than Bonson,
01:38:02 although I also appreciate Bonson. But I have been swimming in the Thomistic waters, at least 0.98
01:38:09 in my theology proper for quite a while. And so, no, I don't think that Van Til and Aquinas are
01:38:18 compatible in every way. I wouldn't make that point. They're not. They're not. But I think that
01:38:25 the battle royale that will eventually need to be held and hosted—I'd love to host it—the 0.70
01:38:32 battle royale, you know, that will eventually need to be hosted between the Thomists and the
01:38:37 antillions um in terms of epistemology uh because it's not really so much you know
01:38:43 soteriology we're holding to the you know we we're all calvinist guys um and uh but but in
01:38:49 terms of epistemology and and then especially as it applies to the law of god and how it's applied
01:38:55 you know all of christ for all of life and these kinds of things uh that you know to whether it's 0.93
01:38:59 no nobody's you know nobody in our camp is a uh r2k you know uh radical uh two kingdom guy but
01:39:06 But whether it's classical two kingdoms or whether it's more of a Kuyperian view, those things will need to be settled eventually.
01:39:15 I just do not think that that is—I don't think that that's the moment that we're in right now.
01:39:21 I do not think that that is the greatest need of our current cultural, political, and even theological moment.
01:39:28 I think that we have been fractured enough already.
01:39:31 um i think steven wolf uh needs to cut it out from time to time and play nice with the theonomist 0.90
01:39:38 and stop yeah and stop you know being a jerk towards us because sometimes and i've told him 0.57
01:39:43 that offline you know there have been times where i'm like dude come on man like i i know i know you 0.70
01:39:47 don't really have much respect for theonomist and i understand um you know because 90 of them today
01:39:54 are uh theonomy i don't think it has to be this way by necessity but theonomy has become sadly
01:40:00 synonymous with libertarianism from a political standpoint, and boomerism from a cultural
01:40:06 standpoint. What does it mean to be a theonomist? It means to be a libertarian boomer. And boomer is
01:40:10 not, in the same way, you might say, blank is not a state of mind. It's not this, it's a state
01:40:17 of mind. Boomer is not an age, it's a state of mind. You can be a 30-year-old boomer. And I've
01:40:22 met plenty of them. And so sadly, right now, that is how theonomy keeps presenting itself. I don't
01:40:27 think it's supposed to be or it has to be uh but a lot of theonomy currently is just um it's just
01:40:33 the boomer post-war sentiment uh with you know uh kind of some uh libertarian political structure
01:40:42 that uh that's going to counter signal uh child tax credits right you know and so uh so long is
01:40:48 is that's uh how theonomists continue to present themselves then steven wolf you know i still
01:40:53 think steven wolf should exercise a little bit more charity but he's going to continue to
01:40:57 he's going to eat that for lunch he's going to see that on twitter and and slap it down
01:41:03 very easily because it's it's laughable you know it's very easy to slap down so um but i just don't
01:41:09 think that that's the war that we need so i i'd like to see steven wolf uh play nice and uh and
01:41:14 i'd also like to see the theonimus not be insufferable and um and then yeah we can have
01:41:18 the battle royale between uh you know the tomist and the vantillians uh when the orcs aren't at 0.92
01:41:24 our front door uh trying to get inside to chop off our kids genitals yeah but right now you just
01:41:31 that that's where we are and and and yeah so i i just i think that's what i'm going to say you 0.52
01:41:37 would say on a long enough timeline there is an antithesis that is going to have to be reconciled
01:41:42 so it's not indefinitely baptists and presbyterians and the same elder board will never have problems
01:41:47 but for the moment right now there's compatibility because you're working towards the same overarching
01:41:51 goals is that a good summary of your position because the question was how do you not is isn't
01:41:56 there an antithesis here you're saying you're straddling the line but these two seem mutually
01:42:00 exclusive how could one hold both it sounds like your answer is you recognize that at a future
01:42:05 point in time that will come to a head that moment is just not right now is that accurate yes that's
01:42:10 what i'm saying and i'll leave with this striker says unfortunately i think joel demonstrated he
01:42:13 doesn't really understand wolf or wolf's position i do i've read wolf's book and i've also talked to
01:42:17 personally um one of the so this is one of the things that the theonomists don't like all right
01:42:21 so i'll just say it out loud so so that we can go there um one of the things that wolf expresses
01:42:26 the christian prince the civil magistrate you know is appointed by god he's basically the vicar of
01:42:31 christ in the political realm and um almost a popish view but but outside of the church you
01:42:37 know not not within a ecumenical you know standpoint but a civil one and one of the
01:42:42 things that wolf does is um he believes that you know that christ is king of both of these two
01:42:46 kingdoms there's the common kingdom you know and then there's the sacred um you know that's only
01:42:51 the church and then that's which is common it's not that that belongs to satan that too belongs
01:42:54 to christ christ is ruling both of them but he rules by two separate agencies or means so he
01:42:59 rules the church you know predominantly through special revelation and with the state through
01:43:03 natural revelation and in comes natural law uh wolf has explicitly said he says it um in the case
01:43:08 for christian nationalism he's also you know said it in multiple lectures and panels and to me
01:43:12 personally on the phone uh for wolf uh natural law is synonymous with the deck law so when wolf
01:43:17 talks about natural law uh he means thou shalt have no other gods before me do not take you know
01:43:23 you know don't make any graven images don't take the lord's name in vain uh he means both tables
01:43:27 of the law and uh and wolf whether he's right or wrong uh he believes that that is calvin's position
01:43:32 that calvin uh when calvin references natural law that he's viewing that as synonymous with
01:43:37 the deck log and so you guys can disagree with that uh but that is wolf's position um so he
01:43:42 believes that the civil magistrate um is supposed to legislate god's law um but but that god is
01:43:47 speaking to him and and uh that uh you know the god above him is is natural law rather than all
01:43:53 66 books of the inspired text it's not special revelation but natural revelation but natural
01:43:57 revelation uh inso facto it gets you to the 10 commandments it gets you to the decalogue now
01:44:03 here's here's the problem that i think the theonomists have and and i'll be honest i'm
01:44:08 this is something that i'm wrestling with it's a problem that i have and yet at the same time
01:44:11 uh the alternative i have a problem with that too um wolf believes that there is inherently vested
01:44:18 in the civil magistrate uh power and authority wolf at some level right like so he appreciates
01:44:25 rutherford and you know and the puritans you know the reformers and all these guys uh but at some
01:44:30 level wolf kind of does deny lex rex that the the law is uh the highest authority and that there's
01:44:36 a law above the king and the king just follows the law um he would say that yes natural law is
01:44:41 above the king, and the king should submit to natural law. And submitting to natural law is
01:44:45 a submission to Christ, because Christ is a king of both kingdoms, and just ruling through two
01:44:49 different sets of agencies, not even two different sets of standards and morals, but the natural law
01:44:55 is synonymous with the Decalogue, but it's just another agency, another means. And so he would
01:45:00 say, in that sense, the civil magistrate does need to submit to King Jesus. So there is a law,
01:45:04 you know, there is a king above the king. There is a law above the king, Lex Rex. But it is
01:45:10 intentionally that God does this in the common kingdom, which includes the civil realm and the
01:45:14 Christian prince. He does this through a different set of agency that is far less specific. It's
01:45:18 natural law instead of special revelation, 66 books of the Bible. And he sees this as intentional
01:45:25 on God's part. And this is his design. It's good and holy and perfect and right. God does it with
01:45:29 intent on purpose. And it's so that the civil magistrate would have this inherent vested power
01:45:35 from jesus from god vested in him to where he can make certain laws that are not anti-biblical but
01:45:41 extra biblical so for instance here's you know to throw out here's here's a hypothetical case for
01:45:46 you and it's not that crazy hypothetical because it's something we're dealing with as a nation
01:45:49 right now so is every nation in europe immigration so for steven wolf and the christian nationalist
01:45:56 crowd you know who's more domestic they're going to say um that uh our civil rulers in america um
01:46:04 let's say that we achieve christian national status you know we become christian nationalists
01:46:09 and we've got christians in office and we've got christian princes and for wolf to be fair it would
01:46:13 be plural it wouldn't just be one to be christian princess so we've got christian princes you know
01:46:17 filling congress and you know the senate and the house and you know the oval office the whole nine
01:46:21 yards and governors and you know sit all the way down to city counselors and dog catchers and so
01:46:25 we've got you know christian princes and we are a christian nation uh distinctly so um okay so on
01:46:32 immigration, the theonomist is going to say, well, all you can do is what the law of God says.
01:46:38 The theonomist has, I think, a bad habit of the regulative principle, but not applied merely to
01:46:43 Lord's Day worship on the Sabbath with the church when it convenes, but to every second of every
01:46:48 day. And so the theonomist is going to say, well, there's no mitigating principle in terms of putting
01:46:54 a particular percentage or statistic or number on immigration. Instead, all the theonomist can do
01:47:00 is he can say well uh by god's law what we can do is we can uh take away uh wicked incentives so
01:47:05 what we can do is we can uh the theonorist would uh disassemble welfare which wolf would do that
01:47:10 too but he would disassemble welfare uh because that's theft that's stealing um from one person
01:47:16 and giving it to another person um so uh the theonorist would say okay so you're going to
01:47:20 have less people who want to immigrate if they're not getting free checks and that's true that is
01:47:25 true but what that misses um and they would also say of course no illegal immigration so there's
01:47:31 going to have to be certain standards and you're going to have to do it legally um uh and oh and
01:47:35 to be fair to the theonomists they would uh could also make an argument uh that america is going to
01:47:39 be a christian nation so you also need to be at least um outwardly professing to be a christian
01:47:44 so here's so what are the guidelines for immigration uh one you're not going to get any free money
01:47:48 um so you're going to have to want to work hard the gimme's are over right exactly you're going
01:47:52 have to work hard. So that takes it down from a bunch of people want to immigrate to still a
01:47:56 bunch of people, but less people. Also, you can't be a Muslim, and you can't be a Jew, and you can't 0.86
01:48:01 be this, and you can't be that. You can't be an atheist. You need to be, but I repeat myself, 0.91
01:48:06 I already said Jew. So atheist, Jew, secularist, you need to be a Christian. So that's going to 0.96
01:48:12 limit it even more. And then you've got to come through the legal process that's been established,
01:48:18 and so that's going to limit it even more. So you need to be a Christian, can't be illegal,
01:48:22 And, uh, and it's not going to be a free handout. You got to work.
01:48:26 Here's the problem. I am not convinced.
01:48:31 And I'll say a little bit stronger than that. Um, that's naive. Uh,
01:48:35 I am convinced, uh, that, uh,
01:48:38 that that will take you down from 7 billion people wanting to immigrate to
01:48:41 maybe 4 billion. That's all that does. Because here's the deal.
01:48:45 People don't want to just immigrate to the United States to get free money.
01:48:48 Um, even if we didn't give away free money,
01:48:50 and even if we required a profession of faith and some kind of proof of being a Christian in
01:48:55 terms of outward behavior, you know, or adherence, you know, affirmation to, you know, the Apostles
01:48:59 Creed and the Nicene Creed or however we did that. One of the reasons people want to immigrate 0.99
01:49:04 is not just because they can get free checks. If free checks stopped tomorrow, but we were a
01:49:10 Christian nation, you'd have less free handouts, but you'd have more safety, more safety. And a
01:49:17 ton of people, they want to leave their nations not just because they're poor, but because they're
01:49:21 being ravaged, because they're being slaughtered, because there's crime, because there's danger,
01:49:27 because there's threats. Having a safe nation and a Christian nation, if it was a Christian nation,
01:49:32 you would punish evildoers. So you'd stop stealing and giving free checks, but you also 0.92
01:49:37 would stop allowing criminals to go free. It would be the safest place in the world.
01:49:42 And guess what? The safest place in the world, half of the world, and I would argue over half
01:49:46 of the world would want to live there. And over half of the world that would be wanting to live
01:49:51 there would be willing to go through your legal process to be a legal citizen and willing to
01:49:55 profess faith in the Lord Jesus Christ outwardly, even if it never changed their hearts. So, here's
01:50:00 the deal. What do you do if you have a Christian nation today that, in the theonomic perspective,
01:50:06 you've gotten rid of the prison system, you're flogging people for lesser crimes, and then you 0.93
01:50:14 are uh dealing out capital punishment for capital crimes and uh and then you're doing double
01:50:19 restitution for theft and if the person can't pay indentured servanthood right that's the theonomic
01:50:23 but you're doing that and it's and it's done well it's dealt with crime well and you have virtually
01:50:28 a crimeless society well here's the problem you're going to have five billion people that want to
01:50:32 live there even without the welfare because just the safety alone it's a flourishing place with
01:50:37 opportunity and all that there's still going to be five billion people who want to live there and
01:50:40 you say well wait a second before before you think you want to live here you're going to have to uh
01:50:45 outwardly you're going to have to pledge allegiance to the lord jesus christ and and uh agree to not
01:50:49 break the law and guess what five billion people are going to say yeah we we still want to live
01:50:53 there i'll do that yeah i'll do that oh my goodness well you're going to have to go through
01:50:56 our process okay we'll do that too so then how do you accommodate right so let's get out of peter
01:51:02 pan never ever land and let's come down to the real world for a second how does a country of
01:51:06 330 million people accommodate 5 billion immigrants you don't so i'm sorry theonomist
01:51:15 like i am a general equity theonomist but i'm sorry we don't have an answer to that we just
01:51:21 have to admit the theonomist we like we don't have an answer to that stephen wolf does and he
01:51:26 might be wrong but his answer is that the the christian prince prince is the civil magistrate
01:51:31 actually has real vested authority from the lord jesus christ by virtue of his position and yes
01:51:36 it is still a sense of lex rex, law above the king, that law being natural law, which again
01:51:42 is synonymous with the Decalogue, the Ten Commandments. It's not just migration patterns
01:51:45 of herds of antelope or whatever. It really is God's moral law, the moral law of God found in
01:51:50 the Decalogue, Exodus 20. But beyond that, beyond that, a natural law, he has a freedom so long as
01:51:57 he's not violating natural law, which is the Decalogue, the Ten Commandments. So long as he's
01:52:01 not violating that. He does not have to find a general equity civil code and say, well, Israel
01:52:07 limited, because here's the thing, you can't find it. And that's the point that the theonomists are
01:52:12 going to make as a counter to Stephen Wolf. They're going to say, well, you know, I can find
01:52:16 from the civil law in the Old Testament with Israel, thou shall not steal, you know, and things
01:52:21 against welfare. And I can find things against, you know, the sojourner and the stranger, the
01:52:26 alien. Well, these were immigrants, but they weren't illegal immigrants. So, I can mandate
01:52:32 there must be legal immigration, there must not be welfare and theft, and I can also mandate that 0.94
01:52:38 you need to pledge some kind of allegiance to Yahweh, you know, a Christian. You can do that 0.59
01:52:42 as a theonomist. You can do all those things. But what you can't do from the Old Testament
01:52:46 is find a verse, a civil law, that said in Israel, we would only allow 5% annually immigration.
01:52:56 to back you up so there's no numbers prove you're not straw manning this is i was talking to a
01:53:00 friend james b jordan from 1998 talking about pat buchanan and james b jordan he says uh we don't
01:53:07 believe in nationalism we believe the international catholic universal community the church there is
01:53:12 no christian justification rare jim l here go ahead for using the power of the state to prevent
01:53:17 foreigners from selling their wares wherever they wish so his view could have changed from 1998
01:53:21 but this is not like you're not straw manning or setting up a position no one has real thing
01:53:26 items do say that immigration should be based on religion uh not upon sharing language culture
01:53:31 religion and morality you need to abide by god's law and you need to profess uh faith in jesus
01:53:37 christ and you need to go through legally and not just swim across a river you know and hide out
01:53:41 so like that but that's it if you do that and here's the deal five billion people would be
01:53:45 willing to do that especially and here's and they try all the time um and and here's the deal um i
01:53:50 would argue that there actually would be more people who would want to move to the united states
01:53:53 without the welfare but uh if we also got rid of the crime and it became the safest place in the
01:54:00 world we'd be flourishing we'd be flourishing we'd have clean okay i don't get a check but uh
01:54:03 you've got the richest economy in the world uh the safest uh society in the world houses big houses 0.66
01:54:09 and this and that and the other and like nobody's pooping on the beach you know india's hardest hit
01:54:14 like so like you know like that that's and these are all just statistics and facts and like people
01:54:19 would want to live there. Not just some, billions of people. And there's no mitigating measure.
01:54:26 There's nothing for Israel that said, after all the moral constraints or restraints, there's 0.84
01:54:32 nothing beyond that that said, oh, and by the way, immigration annually cannot exceed X percentage
01:54:37 of the total population of Israel. There is no such verse.
01:54:40 There's no such principle. So there's no particular for sure, no verse, but even the
01:54:44 principle necessarily capped that's right to help the nation isn't there in principle either
01:54:49 stephen wolf is simply doing he's saying yeah but that um to add that principle is um is congruent
01:54:55 with natural law uh which is part of how christ is ruling his agency and it is not anti-biblical
01:55:03 it's extra biblical but it is not against the law of god it is not against the scripture and um and
01:55:09 if we're going to live in reality and not la la land um you're going to have to have that rule
01:55:15 you're going to have and the theonomists uh don't have an answer that's just one i could give example
01:55:20 after example but that's just from immigration um that is that is one arena and that's why guys
01:55:26 like andrew isker who love doug wilson and were trained at gray friars and you know hardcore
01:55:31 theonomists and like that's why uh the guys in ogden ryan silvey and all that like you know if
01:55:37 it was 2021 2022 their theonomy this and theonomy that and like yeah theonomist and you know waving
01:55:42 the banner and they don't say that but you don't hear that as much anymore um them you know raving
01:55:47 about theonomy and so um because uh we we're trying to solve problems right real problems and live in
01:55:56 the real world and uh and i think general equity theonomy is still wonderful because i think it's
01:56:01 the confessional position both the westminster and the 1689 so whenever the civil law does address
01:56:06 something in the Old Testament, I'm going to extract the general equity and apply it
01:56:11 to our world today. And I think that that's what the founders did, right? They cited Deuteronomy
01:56:15 more than any other book, you know, in our founding documents. And that's how our case
01:56:20 law system was developed. And I think it's wonderful. But I don't think that it's anti-biblical
01:56:25 or sin or wrong to also, when civil law to Israel doesn't address something, but it is
01:56:31 a pertinent issue relevant to our culture and time today to say, all right, we're going to
01:56:37 appeal to natural law and reason. And we're going to say, yeah, we need Christians when it comes 0.79
01:56:44 to immigration. We need legality when it comes to immigration. We need no theft and no criminals
01:56:48 when it comes to immigration. So no welfare, no checks. And also we're going to need a percentage
01:56:53 because 330 million can't take on 4 billion.
01:56:58 You just can't.
01:56:59 And any theology that says, well, you have to
01:57:03 because the Bible doesn't prohibit it.
01:57:04 Or it's even permissible.
01:57:05 It is not permissible to import billions of people.
01:57:08 Yeah, and any theology that insists
01:57:10 that you must be open to that
01:57:11 because the law, word of God doesn't expressly, 0.99
01:57:15 you're being silly. 1.00
01:57:17 You're being silly. 1.00
01:57:18 And so if theonomy is going to just become increasingly silly, 0.95
01:57:21 then i guess i'm going to have to stop being a theonomist but i would like to not have to stop
01:57:26 i would like to continue to say yes i am a general equity theonomist who agrees with the vast majority
01:57:30 of rush journey and appreciates um van till immensely in his epistemology and the way that
01:57:35 he deals um with um with uh with the scriptures especially romans and especially when it comes
01:57:41 to apologetics i love presuppositional apologetics although i appreciate you know not so much
01:57:45 evidential but classical apologetics as well um i i would like to i think that we can get along
01:57:51 and that doesn't mean that there aren't any contradictions and that we don't need to have
01:57:54 a battle royale and a showdown eventually but right now the orcs are at the door they want
01:57:59 to trans the kids and uh and we just we can't afford this infighting and so and and i again 0.96
01:58:05 i'll be fair here and say um the theonomists stop being silly and uh and stop being you know
01:58:11 insufferably boomerish um and and then but then for steven wolf also brother you know i love you 0.97
01:58:17 but stop being a jerk and try to be a little bit more patient and especially on twitter and uh i 0.98
01:58:25 know that you think their arguments are silly and maybe they are but you know but try to be a little 0.99
01:58:28 bit kind of because we're freaking trying to win stop making one way or another stop making us
01:58:34 lose so all right that's it uh my family i heard the garage door opened their home we got to go
01:58:38 but uh love you guys thanks for tuning in i hope we engaged at least enough with the chat today
01:58:43 to make it worth your while and we're committing to trying to do this every week great all right
01:58:47 We'll be right back.