The NXR Podcast - February 07, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Conservatives Built Nothing - Can We Fix It? w John Doyle

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Trump Is A Zionist!? USA to Conquer Gaza!? THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Dispensationalism Has Had Terrible Consequences

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 47 minutes

Words per minute

181.43

Word count

19,419

Sentence count

518

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

32

sentences flagged

Hate speech

51

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

For the last half century, conservatives have prided themselves on winning elections, cutting taxes, and deregulating markets while ceding nearly every artistic, literary, and cultural institution to the radical left. But now, with President Trump s victory, we have a window of opportunity to build something real, a culture rooted in truth, beauty, and Christian ideals.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 conservatives today love to mock the excesses of woke culture blue-haired activists screaming
00:00:33 about oppression corporate hr departments policing pronouns hollywood churning out another soulless 0.96
00:00:40 cgi-infested morality play and it's easy to laugh but let's be honest what has conservatism 0.94
00:00:48 built in its place for the last half century conservatives have prided themselves on winning
00:00:55 elections, cutting taxes, and deregulating markets while ceding nearly every artistic,
00:01:02 literary, and cultural institution to the radical left. But now, with President Trump's victory,
00:01:09 we have a window, an opportunity to build something real, a culture rooted in truth,
00:01:16 beauty, and Christian ideals. This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors,
00:01:22 Armored Republic, and Reese Fund, as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors.
00:01:29 You can join our Patreon by going to patreon.com forward slash rightresponseministries,
00:01:36 or you can donate by going to rightresponseministries.com forward slash donate.
00:01:43 For my entire lifetime, conservatives have been in survival mode. But for the first time in the
00:01:49 providence of God, it seems as though we may have some tailwinds. So how do we turn this momentum
00:01:55 into a lasting cultural legacy? Let's get into it with special guest, John Doyle from Heck Off
00:02:02 Commie. Welcome, welcome, welcome. Here we are. We've got John Doyle from Heck Off Commie. He's
00:02:17 going to be joining us at the top of the second segment which will begin around 3 30 p.m central
00:02:23 time if you're new to the channel welcome we're glad to have you here do us a favor and go ahead
00:02:27 and subscribe to right response on youtube go ahead and follow us on x our videos launch there
00:02:33 as well our handle is at right response m at right response m if you want to follow us on x if you
00:02:40 can give us a like to this video to help boost the algorithm and the best thing that you can do
00:02:44 honestly is sharing the video. If you're willing to share it on your YouTube or share it on your
00:02:49 X channel, we would greatly appreciate that. Like I said, we've got John Doyle, he's going to be
00:02:55 hopping on at the top of our second segment, which will begin at 3.30pm Central Time. And for those
00:03:01 of you who are new to the channel, our schedule each week is Monday, Wednesday, Friday, we live
00:03:07 stream on Monday, Wednesday, Friday, we start at 3pm Central Time. And if we have a guest, which we
00:03:11 do probably about half of the episodes. We have different guests from different ministries or
00:03:16 different businesses or different channels that come and join us, and we usually have them join
00:03:21 us for the second and sometimes third segment as well. All right, so that being said, let's go ahead
00:03:25 and start to lay out the framework for this episode, and then we'll invite John on. Michael,
00:03:30 lead us off. All right, really excited for today. Good afternoon, gentlemen. Good afternoon to those
00:03:35 of you watching live. Appreciate you all being with us. Today, we're going to be talking about
00:03:39 the moment that we're in, but specifically, is it possibly time when conservatives and Christians
00:03:47 could, again, begin to build culture? Now, as I was doing some research for this, I started
00:03:54 Googling around conservative culture building, Christian culture building, Christian conservative
00:03:58 culture building, and I realized, like, this is actually something that Christians think about a
00:04:03 lot. The problem is, almost all the searches that I was finding were how to build a vibrant church
00:04:09 culture, how to have a church culture that is different than the world, how to have a church
00:04:13 culture that is like the world. And the idea of culture, at least whenever I put the label
00:04:18 Christian, sometimes even conservative, in front of it, I was getting how to have a conservative
00:04:24 business culture, or how to have your church have a certain type of culture. And it kind of
00:04:31 surprised me, and I thought for all of our talk about culture, culture, culture this, culture that,
00:04:36 I actually think in a lot of ways, we have no idea what we're talking about when we talk about
00:04:41 building culture. What is culture? How do we build culture? What is it? And I did some reading of
00:04:47 some really great articles, and we'll share some quotes from those later on. But if you listen at
00:04:54 all to Jeff Childers from Coffee and COVID, just this week, he was pointing out the fact that
00:05:00 that a lot of things that tend to build and change
00:05:05 in culture have been stagnant in America
00:05:07 for the last 25 years.
00:05:09 So music has been figured out by computers
00:05:11 and it's just on a repeat loop.
00:05:13 There's really no new innovation
00:05:14 or nothing of note coming from music.
00:05:17 Movies are bigger budget and more action,
00:05:20 but they're not really like,
00:05:21 there's been no culturally defining
00:05:24 since the Lord of the Rings, really, I would say.
00:05:26 Even he was pointing out,
00:05:27 and I didn't do the research here,
00:05:29 so I'm taking his word out of it, but he was saying even fashion trends have like just kind
00:05:33 of stalled. And he said, if you go to a restaurant, it used to be that, you know, clothing from the
00:05:37 seventies and from the eighties. And he said that, well, you know, by and large, even fashion has
00:05:43 just kind of been on autopilot. And it got me really thinking about what it is that we're
00:05:49 trying to accomplish when we talk about Christian culture, conservative culture. And a lot of what
00:05:56 we have had to do because we've been living in negative world is reject or react against or
00:06:04 respond to woke culture or DEI culture. And so some of the best examples of building culture
00:06:11 that we get, Nate, you can put the picture of the movie poster on the screen, is we get things like
00:06:17 the Daily Wire's Lady Ballers, right? Which, okay, great, fine, funny movie, I guess. I didn't see it.
00:06:22 But this is a reaction movie.
00:06:25 This is a reaction against something that's going on in culture rather than building culture.
00:06:30 And even before the episode started, Wes and I were talking about how rough the years were back when, you know, the best that Christianity had to offer was movies like Fireproof.
00:06:40 Which, for the record, love the heart of the people that said, we're going to make an explicitly Christian movie.
00:06:45 We're going to put a gospel message in there.
00:06:47 We're going to do our best.
00:06:48 So we're not here like, so you actually did try to make some culture and it was terrible
00:06:52 and can't believe it.
00:06:53 Yeah.
00:06:53 Praise God for the energy and the heart behind it.
00:06:55 But like we're going to talk about, there's just a piece of the puzzle missing.
00:06:58 Yeah.
00:06:59 Yeah.
00:07:00 So for lots of reasons that are understandable, I'm not here just to necessarily throw shade.
00:07:04 Like we have been, and as we found out with the USAID and the funding of all these wicked
00:07:12 and counter-natural impulses.
00:07:15 Like we actually, Christians and conservatives
00:07:17 have actually been fighting against a wave
00:07:20 and an effort to create aberrant and distorted culture.
00:07:25 And so it's not necessarily,
00:07:28 it's understandable why some of our response
00:07:31 to culture has been reactionary. 1.00
00:07:32 We have to reject the woke, we have to reject the gay, 0.96
00:07:34 we have to reject the feminist. 0.77
00:07:37 And yet it leaves us at this point
00:07:40 that I think is catching some of us off guard,
00:07:43 where, as Joel said in the cold open, the tailwinds, right?
00:07:47 Maybe we're at a moment now where we can stop reacting
00:07:51 and start actually creating something.
00:07:53 The last thing I wanted to say about this,
00:07:55 just kind of by way of introducing the topic,
00:07:57 is, I don't know, this week or last week,
00:07:59 we talked about the idea that Christians tend to view
00:08:08 the gospel as countercultural. And we talked about that in one of the early previous episodes
00:08:15 recently. And I heard growing up all the time, Christianity is countercultural. The gospel is
00:08:21 countercultural. Everything about the Bible and the Bible's message is countercultural. And so we 0.94
00:08:27 had this phrase that we coined in the 90s and the 2000s, the economy of mercy, which I understand
00:08:32 what we're saying. There was a good Switchfoot song about that at the time. But this idea that
00:08:38 everything in the kingdom is upside down uh from what we would see here in the world and of course
00:08:43 there's there's like so many things there's a spiritual reality and a spiritual truth there
00:08:47 but after the episode i was thinking about that a lot and i thought if a christian is told
00:08:53 that the gospel in the bible is by definition and always counter-cultural then there's no place
00:09:02 for christianity in building culture right there's no place in um thinking as a conservative or as a
00:09:11 christian of how i'm going to build culture because if you actually had a christian culture
00:09:15 yes uh in society at large then the church would have to be antagonistic to it 100 it's basically
00:09:23 the church just saying it's it's the same as liberals you lick your fingers stick it up in
00:09:28 the air and see which way the wind is blowing so that you can go with it but if we're not careful 0.98
00:09:32 you know christians can be merely contrarians we would just do the opposite we're still licking
00:09:36 our finger putting in the wind seeing which direction the wind is blowing and then and then
00:09:40 we just determine the opposite so if you actually have a christian culture in society at large
00:09:44 then the church actually has to embody some kind of anti-christian culture which to be to be frank
00:09:51 i think that is kind of what um conservatives have done and we've we've got to find a way to
00:09:57 shake it um this is part of what i'm probably going to be discussing uh at the new christendom
00:10:02 conference uh coming up in june i'll be one of the speakers there i'm honored to uh to go get
00:10:06 to go back and and do that now for a second time um but my talk from last year when they had me
00:10:13 was i talked about you know basically the whole point was um you win by winning um you know like
00:10:19 it was pretty simple but but quite novel for uh many christians uh even today still uh haven't
00:10:26 quite got the memo um but especially um midway you know summer of last year uh that was you know
00:10:32 i think a lot of people were tempted to um you know they just had this mindset of we win by by
00:10:38 losing like it's an over-realized um doctrine of you know theology of the cross and over-realized
00:10:45 suffering kind of a john piper um poverty gospel you know so like you win by losing you win by
00:10:53 dying you know um and and so and and so then all of a sudden you know christianity can can become
00:10:59 in a sense suicidal um because you actually think that that's the goal you actually think that that's
00:11:04 um that becomes the metric for success is how much are we being persecuted baptists are notorious
00:11:10 with this baptists have a a very uh unusual um peculiar relationship with persecution on the
00:11:16 one hand they fear it more than anything else right there's so many baptists that we can't you
00:11:20 know i remember in 2022 you know advocating for christian nationalism and baptists were some of
00:11:25 the biggest opponents to that idea and they're like we can't have christian nationalism because
00:11:29 if we do then you know if you have a state that's christian then they're going to start you know
00:11:35 inflicting punishments and persecution on the baptists you know for not baptizing our babies
00:11:40 we're going to get flogged or beaten or thrown in jail and i'm like i mean even when you look
00:11:45 historically when those things actually did happen you're talking about the numbers are so
00:11:50 small especially by comparison when you think of all the abuses under secular humanism right this
00:11:56 idea this myth of neutrality uh by having a neutral state a non-relate it's not christian it's not you
00:12:01 know it's a secular state um well what's what happened what's the worst that could happen under
00:12:06 that i don't know maybe 70 million dead babies right and you're you're like honestly if a few
00:12:12 baptists get flogged well um i i would i would take that personally i if it means that that me
00:12:19 and and a couple other dozen baptists are mistreated yes is that sin yes would that be 0.51
00:12:25 wrong yes um but i'd take that any day of the week over 70 million dead dead babies like a grown man
00:12:31 being sore for a couple days versus the death of a child yeah yeah so yeah so anyways baptists have
00:12:37 this weird religion on the one hand um the baptist is notoriously afraid of persecution
00:12:42 the baptist has the loser theology runs so deep in the baptist mind that uh because that's that's
00:12:51 a funny thing is it like again back to 2022 and the christian nationalism you know uh um 0.88
00:12:56 debates that were happening you know online um baptists outnumber presbyterians in our country
00:13:02 10 to 1 and yet the loser theology runs so deep they they inherently believed that if we had a
00:13:09 christian state it would be presbyterian it would be paedo-baptist instead of credo-baptist 10 to 1
00:13:16 we outnumber them and they're thinking yeah but if the state becomes christian it'll be some other
00:13:22 brand of christianity because we're baptist and we lose we lose right that's like if there's
00:13:27 anything the baptists do it's uh they baptize upon a profession of faith and they lose right
00:13:31 that's you know that's the mo on the other hand back to this relationship with persecution that's
00:13:36 so weird i can't quite comprehend it they're afraid of persecution more than anything in the
00:13:41 world and it's also their secret fantasy like their greatest aspiration the the baptist uh
00:13:50 silent quiet unspoken greatest ambition and dream that that he could possibly have is that one day
00:13:57 he would be you know john bunyan and imprisoned you know for preaching without the proper you know
00:14:02 papers and that that so it's like the baptist is terrified of persecution sacralism or whatever
00:14:08 you want to call it he's terrified of persecution and also he's rooting for it he's in the same
00:14:16 breath it's like like we can't do that because um if if we had a christian state baptists would
00:14:21 be persecuted more than an anti-christian state yes i like number one i don't know how your math
00:14:28 adds up with that but then number two uh we can't do it um because baptists would be persecuted if
00:14:34 we had a christian state and then dot dot dot the fine print is and also that would be awesome so
00:14:40 so anyways all that being said the baptist is committed i said one thing but you know to be
00:14:44 fair it's two baptizing upon a profession of faith and ensuring that we lose in every meaningful
00:14:50 battle that you could possibly undertake that's that's kind of where we are so all that being said
00:14:54 baptists um it was a lot of baptists that were against christian nationalism they also around
00:15:00 that same time and still to this day are very much against christian culture they they don't
00:15:04 want a broader christian culture because they think that a christian culture means a that it
00:15:08 necessitates a nominal christian culture and a nominal christian culture will produce uh nominal
00:15:14 christian institutions nominal christian seminaries that will train nominal christian pastors with
00:15:19 nominal christian doctrine so that you'll have nominal christian gospel proclamation so that
00:15:24 you'll have ultimately a bunch of you'll you'll have a um an epidemic of false assurance you'll
00:15:30 have a bunch of people who think they're christians but they're not um and and i just i
00:15:35 reject that i outright reject it basically to sum it up to make it simple what they're saying
00:15:40 is that is that a christian state would necessitate a faithless church and i don't know i i i don't know
00:15:51 how you in principle like now you can point historically to certain periods in time where
00:15:56 that happened we had a christian state it was a christian society at large and uh the church
00:16:01 whether it be in england you know or something like and the church to chose to embrace certain
00:16:06 abuses or compromises or things like that that so that is possible that you could have um this
00:16:12 this overlap where christianity is not just within the church but there's christianity and the
00:16:17 government as well in the state in the civil realm and then the church gets lackadaisical
00:16:22 or the church uh gets too big for its britches and you know starts to um to put into play
00:16:29 indulgences you know or things like that so um there are historical moments where that's happened
00:16:34 But in principle, there's nothing biblical that necessitates, as a principle, that a faithful state means that you must have, therefore, a faithless church.
00:16:49 I'll say that again.
00:16:50 Biblically speaking, historically, you can point to case studies.
00:16:54 There will always be anomalies.
00:16:56 But that's experience.
00:16:59 So in practice, you can find examples, but in principle, not practice, but in principle, there is no biblical,
00:17:07 principial argument that says a faithful state necessitates a faithless church.
00:17:15 Nothing.
00:17:16 You can't make that argument from the scripture.
00:17:19 So then as Christians, should we want the state to be anti-Christian or should we want it to be Christ-esteeming?
00:17:29 And I would think that it would be the latter, that given those two choices, we would want a
00:17:34 state that exalts Christ rather than blasphemes Christ. And so then if you can accomplish that
00:17:41 by the grace of God, and it has been accomplished before, so this is not mere theoretical talk,
00:17:46 we're talking about something that I believe, first and foremost, the scripture supports.
00:17:51 And secondly, not only do we have a principle from scripture to support it, but we also have,
00:17:56 in this case, both. We have the principle from Scripture and the history. There are moments where
00:18:01 you have had a Christian state. And so, if it's happened before, and we're not talking about
00:18:07 something that happened 3,000 years ago, if it's happened before in our history, in our recent
00:18:12 history, and here in these United States. So, it's happened before, it's happened recently before,
00:18:19 and it's happened here before. If that's the case, then I believe that by God's grace, maybe it could
00:18:25 be achieved again and if slash when it's achieved again then conservatives and christians and i know
00:18:35 it's hard guys but even baptists if we have a christian state and a broader christian culture
00:18:41 baptists will have to find a way to embrace christian culture within that macrocosm and not
00:18:49 be just a contrarian as a microcosm within it and i feel like that that's all my whole life that's
00:18:56 all reformed christianity has been that's literally all it's which microcosm are you a part of right
00:19:01 so you have the macro is seeker sensitive christianity so then the micro is john macarthur
00:19:07 but if you're really it's like inception like leonardo dicaprio but if you're really enlightened
00:19:11 then you'll be a dream within a dream within a dream you'll be a microcosm within a microcosm
00:19:15 within a mic so it's like you've got seeker sensitive christianity at the macro level then
00:19:20 you got john mccarthur but then once john mccarthur picks up enough momentum and he's got a big enough
00:19:24 ministry well now you need a contrarian for john mccarthur who was already a contrarian to the
00:19:29 you know and so now you have the anti-seeker sensitive but also anti-john mccarthur but
00:19:34 you know and then it just and it just splinters and splinters and splinters and splinters and
00:19:39 every group is just merely a contrarian reaction to the other group nobody's actually building
00:19:44 anything. We're just all pointing and criticizing everything. No one's building anything. You're
00:19:50 just criticizing everything. And that's where we are. And the last thing I'll say is I think part
00:19:55 of that is because of the bad theology and things I've already addressed. But I think also part of
00:20:01 it is because we're so used to losing. We're so used to the majority being against us. We are so
00:20:08 pessimistic in our our view of the world um we we ultimately we we just we think that we we really
00:20:16 do believe that we lose down here and so um that said what do you do if god in his providence
00:20:22 decides to shake things up and it looks like that might be what's happening i understand that there's
00:20:28 a lot of people you know who think it's all just a psyop you know the nothing nothing ever happens
00:20:32 bros you know like this you know trump's got you right where he wants you he's just making you
00:20:37 think you know this and that but really he's gonna you know he's about to pull the rug out
00:20:41 from underneath you and it's going to be even worse than kamala you know and um and and yeah
00:20:47 sure that's a possibility but for a moment could we just consider what if it's not like what if
00:20:54 at the larger level culturally with society as a whole beyond merely the church what if things are
00:21:00 improving what if things are improving and if that's the case then then christians have to
00:21:07 shift and this is kind of what i want to talk about at new christian press um christians will
00:21:12 have to shift from survival mode to um to taking the next hill and securing the next victory and
00:21:21 then moving on and going for more going for broke i i think all this back to our topic today with
00:21:26 culture i think part of the reason we don't have much of a culture is because um culture creating
00:21:33 requires a high risk tolerance it requires risk so even when i think historically
00:21:40 of great cultural that you know people always say like white people don't have culture
00:21:44 it's like have you seen an opera a symphony a ballet have like have you been to france 0.94
00:21:51 have you been to england like what do you mean white people don't have a culture
00:21:56 White people have an incredible culture.
00:21:59 And not just an incredible culture among all these other cultures that are equally incredible. 0.99
00:22:04 No, not every culture is equal. 0.57
00:22:06 And European culture, for the last thousand years, has been in large part a superior culture.
00:22:14 Precisely because, not despite, but because it has been so heavily influenced by the Christian gospel and the Christian faith.
00:22:22 we have had not only have we had a culture we've had an incredible culture but it's been the
00:22:27 dominant culture for so long that it's like a fish swimming in water you know two fish swimming
00:22:32 by and one of them says the water sure is nice today and the other one says what's water you 0.55
00:22:36 know so what what is christian culture what is european culture what's white culture because
00:22:40 because we've been living in it like a fish in water what's all you know for centuries for
00:22:47 centuries. But my point is that during so much of these moments where Christendom is shining,
00:22:54 or as Bunyan, to use him as an example, John Bunyan in Pilgrim's Progress, he would say,
00:22:58 when religion is walking through the streets and being praised by the populace on the sidelines,
00:23:04 and she's walking in her robes and her glass slippers, she's well adorned, she's appreciated
00:23:09 rather than despised. In those moments, which we have had many in European and American culture
00:23:15 throughout Christendom over the past several centuries, in those moments, here's one of the
00:23:20 things that you have. You have tailwinds. And with tailwinds comes prosperity, opulence,
00:23:28 and with that comes opportunity to where you can afford to risk. So when you look back and you
00:23:34 think, who are some of the great minds? Not just with theology, Jonathan Edwards, Martin Luther,
00:23:40 um but but even when you look at uh beyond that again culture like when you look at music
00:23:46 beethoven mozart all that like what's one thing that they have in common they're all rich
00:23:51 like sometimes i think like how did how did luther afford to write all the time
00:23:56 oh that's right he had servants yeah how could edward just sit and go on his horse
00:24:03 for 12 hours and think all day oh slaves there were a lot of writers who were impoverished
00:24:10 accomplished but yes but they they gave up some of the other things in order to produce their art
00:24:16 right they gave up they created somehow they created a surplus whether it was depriving
00:24:20 themselves of relationship or or of a temporal comforts or whatever but but in order to create
00:24:26 culture you have to take risk and in order to take risk you have to have an opportunity you
00:24:31 have to have a surplus and i think so so when when you think of recent conservative christian
00:24:37 culture this is what like this is what you think of you think of homesteading right well what is
00:24:43 homesteading like what like what does that spring out of oh i know what that springs out of that
00:24:47 springs out of thinking the world's about to end that springs out of i've got five kids i need to
00:24:52 be able to feed them when china invades you know or whatever and so you know we're in addition to 0.72
00:24:59 my 40 hour a week job you know we're we're doing a garden in the backyard you know and and we're
00:25:05 and who are we learning from who's inspiring us a guy who is self-sufficient by homesteading and
00:25:10 what he neglected to include is the fact that he actually made all of his money in software
00:25:14 engineering behind every homesteading wife on instagram is a man who works in software
00:25:19 and just seriously all of them all of them all of them but i read this book called i won't say it
00:25:27 because i don't want to you know disparage him yep that guy too uh-huh all of them so the point
00:25:32 is i'm not you know trying to poo poo you you want to just start good habits and do something
00:25:37 together as a family touch grass learn where your food comes i like there's there's plenty of good
00:25:42 reasons to do it um i don't think practically for survival like if you just practically want to
00:25:47 survive if everybody's starving uh then your neighbors are going to get into your garden
00:25:50 right have you ever read peter rabbit you know i'm familiar with that book that's what's going
00:25:54 to happen so if it's just survival go to costco buy a bunch of the buckets lock it up in your
00:25:58 garage you know and there you go there's your survival um but there are good reasons to homestead
00:26:04 and these kind of get your chickens and get this and get that one to have food that's not poison
00:26:08 that makes sense that makes sense but in addition to that um just to do something as a family and
00:26:13 teach good work habits and to you know to all there's plenty of of um virtue virtue reasons
00:26:19 besides just mere survival practical reasons but here's my point i think that not historically so
00:26:26 now i'm shifting to the microcosm recently over the last decade and a half as we've gone you know
00:26:31 erin wren's you know positive neutral and negative world as we've shifted into negative world
00:26:36 a lot of conservative thinking if there is any conservative culture whatsoever it's all been
00:26:42 built around survival it's all been built around a minority mentality a remnant mentality and so
00:26:51 those are the scriptures that get the limelight is you know little flock a remnant um the few
00:26:58 the proud and this survival kind of mentality and how to uh how to be off the grid or uh here's a
00:27:05 parallel economy right so then the businesses that do start um it's you know the big thrust
00:27:11 is not necessarily having an innovative product but uh simply hey you don't want to support you
00:27:17 know what guys who hate you do you so give your money to us well okay what do you provide well
00:27:22 we provide a product exactly like theirs except a little bit lower quality and a higher price
00:27:27 and an american flag on the tag and an american flag right exactly um you know but then whenever
00:27:32 there's some serious conservative you know issue um you can count on us you know not to support it
00:27:38 and actually turn and turn on our own base like um like black rifle coffee did with kyle rittenhouse
00:27:45 right you know uh conservative like with conservatives like these you know um you know
00:27:50 who needs liberals so all that being said i think that we're entering into a period where for the
00:27:55 first time in a while uh we're about to have some series i think we have them now and it's only
00:28:00 going to pick up not headwinds but tailwinds and with tailwinds comes a surplus and with surpluses
00:28:07 we must be able to shift the mindset from survival culture to thriving culture we now have
00:28:14 excess. We can afford to not just conservatives, what's your culture? Homesteading in the backyard.
00:28:20 No, we can actually take risks. We could actually produce great art. We could do things like
00:28:25 Christendom passed. How did that guy afford all the time of the day to write? Well, because he
00:28:33 actually had some means, and he had other people that he could afford to pay to do menial tasks.
00:28:38 We are entering that season of life, not because we're bringing back slaves. I'm not saying that.
00:28:44 but whether it's our ai slaves that's what i'm saying so technologically so whether it's ai
00:28:50 um the fact that you have jd vance who just now basically today canceled cancel culture he said
00:28:56 yeah i disagree with what that young guy said under a pseudonym um i think that that's uh atrocious
00:29:01 but uh he shouldn't have his life ruined uh elon uh i think you should hire him again and then
00:29:06 elon said yep i think we're going to bring him back yep and he's getting a second chance so
00:29:10 if we're not in survival mode because cancel culture is dissipating and the economy may be
00:29:18 improving and your workplace may not be going into a den of lions where the slightest slip up
00:29:27 and you're fired. If all these things are changing, if we really are going to deport
00:29:32 millions that are a drain, a constant burden on our wallets, and all of a sudden everybody has
00:29:40 a little extra money in their pockets, a little lighter step, skipping their step, a little less
00:29:46 worry about being canceled and having their lives ruined, then homesteading probably shouldn't be
00:29:51 our culture moving forward. I know why it was looking back. It probably shouldn't be moving
00:29:57 forward. Even guys like I so appreciate Andrew Torba. I really do. People will be like, oh,
00:30:03 you're endorsing Andrew Torba. Well, he said this anti-Semitic thing or he said, well, this is where
00:30:06 i wish i physically had a copy of the donald trump card you know that says who cares right
00:30:11 you can play this card you know and everybody has to just buzz off um but i don't agree with
00:30:16 everything that torba says um but i believe he's a christian brother i love him and appreciate him
00:30:21 and i'm not going to be ashamed of him so publicly i like andrew torba deal with it i don't know what
00:30:28 to tell you that said during negative like the height of negative world he started gab a parallel
00:30:34 uh economy business for free speech um this is what most people what most conservatives would
00:30:43 be tempted to do and would have done all of a sudden the wind starts shifting the vibe shift
00:30:49 is happening like think about this elon musk buys twitter turns it into x and starts loosening up
00:30:56 replaces fires 90 of the staff gets rid of the fact checkers and replaces them with community
00:31:00 notes and right now even today is like yeah i'm going to hire back that guy that you know that
00:31:04 the left tried to cancel. We're no longer going to cancel our own. You would think that someone
00:31:08 like Torba, he would have every financial, practically speaking, every financial incentive
00:31:13 to say, it's just a psyop, Musk, you know, and just post every single day, right? I mean,
00:31:21 this is what he's known for anyways. Why not lean into it? Just post every single day the picture
00:31:24 of Musk wearing the tiny hat and going to the magical wall and praying, you know, and pictures
00:31:29 of Trump. Torben didn't do that. He refused to be a contrarian. He refused to be an incessant
00:31:37 black pillar. And this isn't just somebody who has those convictions. His livelihood is tied up 0.96
00:31:44 in this. Because think about this. If X really does become a free speech platform like it is
00:31:50 currently, then who needs Gap? Who needs Gap? You are literally working for your number one
00:31:58 competitor by encouraging every like encouraging elon and working with him who does that that is
00:32:04 so counterintuitive you want to talk about being countercultural who does that i'll tell you who
00:32:08 christians who who actually don't just want to win personally but actually want to see the glory and
00:32:16 the fame of jesus win they want the knowledge of the glory of god to cover the whole earth as the
00:32:21 waters cover the sea. Torba actually wants to win, even if it means him personally. It's almost like
00:32:28 I'm not making a one-to-one comparison. It would be blasphemous. Just I want to paint the picture
00:32:33 in your mind. This is a much lesser degree, but similar concept. When Jesus comes on the scene,
00:32:40 John the Baptist says, he must increase. I must decrease. It's like Elon Musk comes on the scene
00:32:46 who is not jesus understand the analogy it's merely analogy and torba instead of saying he's
00:32:53 trying to pull the wool over your head this is actually a psyop he's actually you know he wears
00:32:57 the tiny hat he's actually a zionist he instead he says all right maybe gab has served its function
00:33:03 right there was a season where we needed gab it was the only place we had um but if the whole world
00:33:10 can speak freely that's better i want what's better for humanity and for the glory of god
00:33:17 not just for andrew torba and that's the position he took conservatives are going to have to think
00:33:22 like that and and for some of you guys it's going to mean that durable trades is not actually going
00:33:29 to be the focus for the next four years and i understand why it was for the last four years
00:33:33 but it may not be the next move durable trades chickens in the backyard i should start a gab
00:33:40 account um are are we posting enough on rumble um because all of a sudden survival culture
00:33:48 doesn't have to be our fate thriving culture with a surplus with tailwinds that allows for
00:33:56 risk taking and it's people who take risk that's your great artist that set culture for centuries
00:34:03 it's the guy who took a risk it's the it's it's the musician who did something new innovative
00:34:09 And honestly, people who are barely hanging on, people impoverished, people afraid, people
00:34:16 scared, they don't set culture because culture requires art.
00:34:20 Great art requires courage.
00:34:23 And we are now in the promise of God being placed positionally where we can exercise
00:34:29 courage without it meaning the end of our family and our children.
00:34:35 And so I think we're going to see more conservatives and Christians stepping out,
00:34:40 taking courage. But don't wait 10 years. The wind is shifting now. The sons of Issachar know the
00:34:48 time. Seize it. Don't wait. Don't be late to the game. The Lord is doing something. He's doing 0.99
00:34:55 something new. Move with God. Move with God. Let's go to our first commercial break, and we'll come
00:35:02 right back with John Doyle. Our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants to help you with one money
00:35:07 move that'll implicate itself in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day. They help
00:35:14 you to avoid taxation and to draw compound interest to your money. Now, if you're a high
00:35:19 net worth individual, someone who has maybe even $10 million in net worth, then they can help you
00:35:25 even more. W-2 workers, contract workers, business owners, it's all about cash flow and making tax
00:35:33 deferred gains on all your money for the rest of your life. Don't avoid this. It's a big move,
00:35:40 but it's a great time to make it. Click the link below and you can get on Chuck DeLaterante's
00:35:45 calendar and he'll go over your background and what you want to accomplish. And he's going to
00:35:50 help model a program that exactly fits your needs. So go ahead and send an email to chuck
00:35:56 at privatefamilybanking.com. Again, that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com. Or you can click the
00:36:04 link below. Make a free discovery call now. America is a country that was founded for the
00:36:09 purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God and not to have their consciences
00:36:12 ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men. Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten
00:36:17 commandments properly applied, not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in
00:36:22 business as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey. Our goal is to find
00:36:27 businesses and to buy them and to build them up. We want to find manufacturing businesses and use
00:36:33 them to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here. Reese Fund, Christian
00:36:38 Capital, boldly deployed. All right, we're so back. Here we are. We've got John Doyle. He's
00:36:47 going to be joining us uh let's just make sure the tech is working john can you hear me yes sir
00:36:52 all right welcome to the show thanks for coming on great fit yeah thank you for having me uh tell
00:36:58 our listeners just a little bit about yourself what do you do how can people follow you let's
00:37:02 start with that sure yeah i just talk about politics on the internet and if you have any
00:37:08 interest in that you can find me at youtube.com slash john doyle or uh twitter at comrade doyle
00:37:14 Cool. All right. So I've got Michael Belch and Wesley Todd with me. Michael has kind of outlined
00:37:19 this episode and he's got some questions queued up that he wants to ask you.
00:37:24 Sure. Thanks for joining us today, John. In preparation for the episode, we listened to
00:37:29 the video that you did about a year ago on white conservative psychic culture. And one of the
00:37:36 things that you mentioned in that video was that part of it was because we live in a time at the
00:37:43 then where degeneracy is promoted and promulgated and pushed. And one of the big questions that
00:37:49 we're trying to answer with this episode is, even before we get into culture making and why it
00:37:55 matters, are we seeing for the first time in a while a time where true culture, which is the
00:38:02 admiration of the good, the beautiful and the true, can that have a hearing in the public square
00:38:08 now is is what trump is seeking to tear apart and undo are we seeing the dawn of of possibly
00:38:13 conservatives and christians being able to uh like you said in the video like it has to be profitable
00:38:20 for culture makers to some degree to make the culture or else they won't be able to are we on
00:38:24 that tipping point do you think i think we could be in a very real sense simply because so much of
00:38:31 what has allowed these people to spread evil and ugliness throughout society is that they are
00:38:35 rewarded for doing this monetarily. And through Trump attacking something like that USAID program,
00:38:41 which is literally just like a patronage network that pays all sorts of activists and NGOs and
00:38:47 people who are right now responsible for making culture very, very handsome salaries to just
00:38:51 spread ugliness and evil throughout society. If that incentive goes away, these people are going
00:38:55 to be unemployed and they probably all have significant student debt. And so their lives
00:38:59 are going to be ruined because they've been living in service of evil. And when that goes away,
00:39:03 when you no longer are just walking throughout society and seeing such evil and ugliness like
00:39:08 pushed in your face i think that people will tend to sort of heal and go back to making things that
00:39:13 are more wholesome and reflective of a more wholesome spirit which really is just what
00:39:16 culture is i mean i think it's just a natural reflection of the spirit of the people and if
00:39:21 that spirit is corroded and polluted it's going to look a certain way but if it's allowed to sort
00:39:26 of exist and become more wholesome then it's going to exist in a much more wholesome way which is i
00:39:30 think what we've seen for a very long time in this country until the past maybe uh 60 years or so
00:39:34 and so i'm optimistic on the basis of that and i think people too are just repulsed by it i mean
00:39:39 they're sick of having to see like these like fat models on billboards in times square they're sick
00:39:44 of seeing you know children treated like prostitutes and netflix programs um they're just 0.90
00:39:49 like fed up with it but they didn't really have an avenue for reproach until thankfully by the
00:39:53 grace of God, this administration. Yeah. Well said. I think it's profoundly encouraging because
00:40:01 like you said with the patronage network and the money going away, like right-wing propaganda,
00:40:06 like what is it? A loving family, a father going to work, a family attending church. The point is
00:40:11 it's free. It's free to make children, for example. So it's really free, and it's just living life
00:40:16 that encouraged people to pursue the good, the true, and the beautiful, and then the other side
00:40:20 to make people think that uh you know flat fat black women and calvin klein is beautiful well
00:40:25 that takes millions and millions and millions of dollars right so that's really encouraging that
00:40:29 our stuff free easy wonderful awesome enjoyable to do and for them to do it uh it required decades
00:40:36 of setting up some type of infrastructure to even support for i don't know two three years
00:40:42 maybe people may be believing like oh yeah you know being gay is just the same as being straight
00:40:48 and it all came collapsing down anyway so i'm profoundly encouraged by that right yeah and
00:40:52 something like that could only exist with people tuned into screens all day every day which we are
00:40:57 just the way our society is um and for that propaganda to be just pushing your face at all
00:41:02 times could like you said sustain that suspension of belief for maybe three years or so um but i
00:41:08 mean once push came to shove it all collapsed pretty quickly and people are tired of it
00:41:11 Yeah. Joining that video that you that I mentioned of yours earlier, which to our audience, if you if you want a really great listen, that that video was was fantastic on on John Doyle's YouTube channel.
00:41:27 Do you remember the title, John?
00:41:29 Well, thank you for saying that. Yes, the video was titled Why Conservatives Can't Create Culture, I think.
00:41:35 Thank you. Yeah. Something like that.
00:41:36 That's right. Yep. So two things that you said in that video, I'm wondering if they've changed now, given the current cultural and political climate or not.
00:41:46 One of the things that you said was when you were in college, a lot of the, especially the white students who were having to take the required DEA class, DEI class, sorry, not DEA, they would do what they had to do to get a passing grade, but they just were not buying it.
00:42:02 they were not retaining it.
00:42:03 It was really just water off the duck's back.
00:42:07 And you went through some of the statistics
00:42:08 about the people who think
00:42:10 that the founding fathers were villains.
00:42:12 And really you said like the majority of culture
00:42:14 of the nation, actually most people don't.
00:42:17 The other thing that you said was
00:42:19 culture is the production of the soul of a society.
00:42:23 And so I'm wondering how you would rate
00:42:27 American society right now.
00:42:29 Are we capable right now of producing
00:42:31 good meaningful culture um are is our is the soul of society has most of this the the events of the
00:42:39 past five ten years been water off the duck's back or are we or do we have to do some repair
00:42:45 to the soul of the society before we can expect really any sort of meaningful culture to start
00:42:50 being produced uh to answer the second half first i think that we absolutely can now that the boot
00:42:56 is kind of being removed from our necks.
00:42:59 And I think that what people regard as high culture
00:43:03 or things that become very popular
00:43:04 are started because of those one in one million examples
00:43:07 of people who are very talented
00:43:09 and gifted in their particular fields,
00:43:11 awarded those gifts by something divine.
00:43:14 And when they're allowed to express that
00:43:15 and people are allowed to gravitate towards that,
00:43:17 that ends up creating cultural traditions
00:43:19 which define our society.
00:43:21 And I think what we've experienced in the last few decades
00:43:24 is what people are calling you know stuck culture we seem to be stagnant we're just taking the same
00:43:29 thing and repackaging it releasing it whether that's popular film franchises or tropes in
00:43:35 literature i mean when's the last time like a good book was published like people are reading you know
00:43:38 slop from the new york times bestseller list or stuff that you can pick up in an airport bookstore
00:43:43 but nothing really seems to be profound and i think to be honest with you a lot of that is just
00:43:47 simply related to our immigration policy because you are importing literally tens of millions of
00:43:53 people who have never experienced American culture, which means they haven't been around
00:43:58 long enough to sort of see the rhymes and the repetitions to where they wouldn't want to
00:44:02 participate in it. And then also they're coming from parts of the world, which frankly are just
00:44:07 less intelligent on average. And so they are willing to sort of go into the movie theater 1.00
00:44:11 for the millionth time to watch the superhero movie, because to them, it's like always going
00:44:16 to be a new experience. Whereas people who are maybe a little bit more intelligent, who have
00:44:19 been in America for longer amounts of time, we're not going to just keep buying into the same slop.
00:44:25 You know, we require something that's a little bit fresher, a little bit more intelligent,
00:44:28 whereas other countries just simply are not exactly producing that type of person.
00:44:33 And in terms of the first part of the question, which was, I believe, about people buying into
00:44:38 the sort of like self-hatred indoctrination narratives, I think that's true. And a lot of
00:44:43 people who say that, you know, the country is being taught to hate itself, they are coming
00:44:47 out of an academic tradition, which is just a lot older than the one we have now. And so speaking
00:44:54 from my experience in high school and in the tour of service I did at college before dropping out,
00:44:59 I think it is true that the instinct to be self-hating is not something that's natural
00:45:04 to Americans. And so you can take a DEI class and you can learn about how everybody who ever did
00:45:10 anything great in America was actually evil. And we have to elevate the accomplishments of
00:45:15 everybody else who actually invented the whole world and it was only the evil white people who 0.91
00:45:19 found out about that and then took everything and then made it so it seemed like they invented it 0.82
00:45:22 you don't have people who are like ready to subscribe to that and the types of people who
00:45:27 are seem to already have something bad going on in their own lives which is why if you look at
00:45:32 the people who are the most militantly far left like the antifa mug shots they all sort of look
00:45:38 a certain way they seem to have something going on with them that exists independently from the
00:45:43 fact that they took a class and learned this information. Otherwise, you would see people who
00:45:47 didn't look like they were spiritually ill professing these same beliefs, which of course 0.99
00:45:51 you do. It does infect everybody to a certain extent. But the point that I was trying to make
00:45:55 in that video was basically that if you have people who are doing well spiritually, they're
00:46:01 not going to be ready to hop on the bandwagon for why they should hate themselves. I mean,
00:46:06 if they've done wrong, of course, they're going to want to make right by that. But it is a certain
00:46:10 type of person that we're creating in society, which is anxious and depressed and hollow.
00:46:16 And they are very willing to find a way to rationalize that through indoctrination,
00:46:21 which tells them that they can be saved by the grace of repenting for the sins of their
00:46:26 ancestors being defined as being really mean to Indians or really mean to Africans or what have
00:46:32 you. And the type of person who is not spiritually maladjusted, who goes in and they're clean cut,
00:46:39 good looking, relatively intelligent. They hear that and they laugh at it. And then it's their
00:46:43 choice if they want to go along with it and take the take the A in the class or push back, play
00:46:48 devil's advocate or what have you. But I don't think it's enough to diagnose the problem as
00:46:52 simply like the information is bad. Like, sure, the information is bad. It's dishonest. It should
00:46:56 be corrected. But really, I think why it's effective is downstream from a spiritual crisis
00:47:02 that the country has been experiencing, particularly within the younger generations.
00:47:06 I want to follow up with that, and then I'll pass it back over to the other two guys.
00:47:11 But as I was researching, I came across this really interesting quote.
00:47:14 Nate, this is quote one, if you can put it on the screen.
00:47:17 If not, I'll just read it.
00:47:18 And this is by Jason Jewell in an article called The Conservative Abandonment of Culture.
00:47:24 And he's talking about a turning point in the fork of the road of conservatism in U.S. politics.
00:47:33 And he says this.
00:47:33 He says, a powerful utilitarian bias in the conservative movement relegated these figures, which are the truly artistic figures, and others like them to the margins by the mid-1960s, in favor of a focus on economics, business, and practical politics.
00:47:49 This choice was a strategic error because electoral and policy victories could not check or reverse the eroding of America's moral and cultural foundations.
00:47:59 Conservatives today tend to have, quote, unmusical personalities and, quote, feel no deep existential need for poetry, novels, paintings, symphonies, films, and such, end quote.
00:48:10 By ceding to the left, literature, the arts, and culture more generally, the fields that shape society's moral vision, conservatives unwittingly open the door to woke capitalism and cancel culture.
00:48:23 So this is what you mentioned in your previous answer about high culture.
00:48:28 Is it endemic to the conservative movement or even MAGA, I'm curious, that we have abandoned
00:48:37 high culture?
00:48:37 And is that a problem?
00:48:39 Do we need to recover it?
00:48:41 Yeah, I think it was absolutely a strategic error, which is why a lot of times you will
00:48:46 see this crude attempt to mimic that by creating these very self-referential things.
00:48:52 They will say that an example of right-wing culture would be like if we had a painting
00:48:56 of Ronald Reagan riding a velociraptor shooting like a Mach 10 or something. And it's like,
00:49:02 that's not exactly, it's actually far closer to what you described earlier as simply like,
00:49:08 a father and his family. Most art throughout history is actually conservative or is actually
00:49:14 right wing and they'll ad hoc try to describe it as otherwise, but it is true. Really what defines
00:49:21 like left-wing art is going to be something that is in its nature revolutionary or disordered,
00:49:26 which tends to be something that actually purposefully tries to be ugly or bad simply
00:49:32 to call into question, well, what even is beauty? What even is art? If I make something ugly,
00:49:37 it's not that I'm not a talented artist. It's that I'm actually very profound because I'm
00:49:41 calling into question, what even is beauty? And it's like, this is so self-serving and foolish. 0.99
00:49:45 So a lot of the right-wing artists that we have today are very talented, 0.90
00:49:48 but they simply can't find work because the people who are in charge of funding these artists are
00:49:55 not funding right-wing artists and all of the artists that we have who are left-wing are people
00:50:00 who are very miserable and and spiritually ill and they feel their interest i'll put it this way
00:50:05 their interest in art is not so much uh what the classic interest in art was which was creating
00:50:12 something to pay respect to the divine who awarded you that talent but more so they are so
00:50:18 narcissistic, they are deluding themselves into thinking that they have something to express and
00:50:22 they have something to say. Therefore, we need some sort of communist, egalitarian, utopian
00:50:27 society where I can somehow subsist and live and do nothing all day but create art is what they
00:50:34 say. I need to be able to make art because I have so much to say and so much to express that I need
00:50:38 to be able to sit around all day and just make stuff. And it's like, that's not because you
00:50:43 actually have anything to say or anything to express. You're just so narcissistic that you 0.97
00:50:46 think that whatever your contribution to the world would be should be elevated to the level
00:50:51 of da Vinci or Beethoven or whomever.
00:50:54 So it's a completely different kind of psychology behind what drives the impulse to express
00:51:00 oneself in art.
00:51:02 The only difference is for the last 60 years, it has been the leftist impulse, which has
00:51:05 been rewarded, and the conservative impulse, which has been punished.
00:51:09 Yeah.
00:51:10 John, did you read the New Yorker article, The Cruel Kids Are Back in Town?
00:51:16 You know, I did.
00:51:16 him did okay it was really fascinating I think it was Aaron McIntyre who commented on it he said
00:51:22 the right wing aesthetic when it actually just does it organically so it's not trying to bring
00:51:26 in you know Reagan and the American flag and be really ham-fisted about it we actually like just
00:51:33 organically like coming up in this movement whatever's happening right now it seems at some
00:51:37 level we just instinctually like there's a really kind of classy vibrant I think that would definitely
00:51:43 be the term for what he's describing there from the parties the balls the elegance and of course
00:51:48 there's aspects where they're you know a little bit off the rails on one end or the other but
00:51:52 it's really interesting because uh they're they're setting aside that old kind of republican
00:51:57 that old guard utilitarian it's economics it's culture it's foreign policy and we're really able
00:52:03 actually it seems like what's happening is people just it's not even a formal movement there's not
00:52:08 academic work spurring it but they're like we're gonna we're gonna dress really well uh we're gonna
00:52:12 look great while doing it we're going to be healthy we're going to look good and i'm surprisingly i
00:52:17 i think people are just they're just doing it in a sense i don't know was that your sense that
00:52:21 cover photo obviously was super popular uh yeah just the edge and the image that it presented
00:52:32 so i think i cut out for a second i think that's just the nature of uh of mankind we we want to
00:52:37 root for you know the strong horse over the weak horse we like people who put effort into their
00:52:42 appearance, things you can't fake. I mean, obviously you can fake large aspects of your
00:52:46 appearance, but there's a difference between putting effort into how you look and what you
00:52:50 would see at any airport nowadays where people are just wearing sweatpants and they've got
00:52:54 portions of themselves spilling out over their clothing. It's just like disgusting and repulsive. 0.77
00:53:00 So yeah, I did. I saw that photo and I saw the coverage surrounding it. And I think that it's
00:53:04 true that anytime that left-wing aesthetics have clashed with right-wing aesthetics throughout
00:53:07 history, right wing aesthetics have always won because they're reflective of something real
00:53:12 and hierarchical and natural and left wing aesthetics pretty much define themselves in
00:53:16 opposition to all of those things. Like they seek to be disruptive and offensive, which when you're
00:53:21 a child, that's attractive to you because, you know, you want to be 12 on a skateboard and flip
00:53:25 people off and, you know, be rebellious. But once you get a little bit older and you start taking
00:53:29 things a little bit more seriously, you sort of fall into place and realize that that's all
00:53:32 immature and anybody who retains those attitudes past adolescents are as we mentioned with the
00:53:38 antifa mugshots always very disturbed dysfunctional people yeah michael i i'm just curious
00:53:46 when you say right-wing and left-wing art has conflicted do you have any offhand examples
00:53:53 that's that's a really interesting idea uh to me no not really uh i'm not an artist i really don't
00:54:00 have any interest in art or art history. But from what I browse on Twitter and from what I see people
00:54:04 who do understand these things talk about, that seems to be the popular sentiment. And I guess
00:54:08 if you can just sort of tap into the cultural zeitgeist, so to speak, and what you would regard
00:54:13 to be something that leftists think is like very profound, very high art, it does tend to be these
00:54:18 things that are like deconstructive and revolutionary. And they seek to, you know,
00:54:22 portray a caricature of like white American Christian society. And it is always vilified
00:54:27 And they always have to have it lose against something that is more enlightened, be that because of inferior cultures or science or what have you.
00:54:36 And the opposite would be the case for truly conservative or right wing art where it is glorifying and upholding these things which have shaped our culture as opposed to denigrating them or as opposed to the sort of like, you know, other fork where they will then try to try to create like a conservative art.
00:54:54 that's like a film about um fighting off a school shooter because self-defense but then the person
00:54:59 fighting off the school shooter is actually a girl because we still have this like retained spirit of
00:55:04 feminism i think daily wire did that film a few years ago so things like that where it wants to
00:55:09 be on the mark but they can't help themselves but always kind of miss it well said michael are there
00:55:18 there any more uh quotes that you wanted to share that we could kind of spark no i'll put i'll pull
00:55:23 some into our conclusion okay great less any other questions that you have um nothing that comes to
00:55:30 the top of my mind all right i would say too uh conservatives have been way too quick the past
00:55:35 couple years and john you talked about this in your video someone anyone it'll be john fetterman
00:55:40 it'll be nikki minaj they'll say something halfway just right wing or whatever and we're so so quick
00:55:46 to be like what nikki minaj turned down the vaccine uh based and we we were so desperate
00:55:53 for any semblance of i don't know if it's identity or or vision or something like that the second 0.57
00:55:58 someone i think of the young turk she's like oh i don't feel a little bit safe walking in my
00:56:02 neighborhood well so be so quick to latch on to that and to prop it up and be like see we're the 0.74
00:56:07 party that that is common sense and even these people are coming into it but if you have a good
00:56:12 thick culture it needs to be almost resistant to change people are going to be wanting to get in
00:56:17 to join it's like no actually the your views your thoughts your aesthetic the things you've said in
00:56:22 the past they don't fit in this is much more carefully managed and curated and for now at
00:56:27 least you don't belong yeah i think there's something uh john to be said for now this this
00:56:35 is not sustainable it's not viable long term but it's something that we can use uh to our advantage
00:56:40 temporarily to kind of as a springboard to launch into a solid conservative christian culture that
00:56:48 actually has merit and can stand the test of time but a training wheels if you will uh to to teach
00:56:54 us to give us some of the momentum to learn how to ride the bike again is just uh the inevitable
00:57:00 phenomenon of um that uh the cool kids so like back to what you were saying like that you know
00:57:07 the, the 12 year old on the skateboard, flipping off the neighbors as he's, you know, bombing the
00:57:11 hill, you know, whatever in, in the neighborhood. Um, well, you can, you can use that to your
00:57:17 advantage, like Facebook. I think Warren McIntyre said this, uh, use this analogy, but there was a
00:57:22 time when, um, your grandma couldn't have Facebook. And so it was cool. You know, there was a time
00:57:28 where you had to have, you know, the college, uh, email, you know, even to, to get a Facebook.
00:57:32 and um and then you know everybody has like at this point like for us um even with right response
00:57:39 um we just kind of gave up on facebook we did facebook for a while and and we just kind of
00:57:45 stopped um and same same with instagram i think instagram is different than facebook facebook is
00:57:51 kind of like uh for senior citizens but uh instagram uh has a younger crowd but it's
00:57:56 predominantly women and you know like on our youtube channel i think it's like 80 87 of our
00:58:02 audience is male um women uh don't really like me very much so instagram's not really a great
00:58:08 platform for me to be on um because it's just stepping into uh a lion's den um and not really
00:58:15 lions it more of like a cat fight um a house cat den but um anyways all that being said i think
00:58:21 we've hit the point now where um being being a leftist isn't cool like it you know like so like
00:58:28 when your grandma gets to facebook once once it's gone everywhere like it's the same with crypto you
00:58:32 know like um when your grandma asks you how she can buy bitcoin you know like maybe maybe uh maybe
00:58:38 you sell you know at least for a while and um and and i think like at this point um everybody
00:58:45 is uh you know everybody's like uh thinks you know like uh white people are racist and the world is
00:58:53 chauvinistic and misogynist and blah blah like and there's a certain point where i i feel like 0.91
00:58:59 gen z like 40 of them are going to be you know like gay furries um but the other 60 are like 0.87
00:59:08 shockingly conservative like alarmingly conservative like all the time like me and 0.76
00:59:13 some of my friends with like new christian press and other guys like people hate us you know on
00:59:19 and we're like wait till you meet our kids like you think like you will beg for us to return and
00:59:24 and try to you know get our kids under control like please like um our our kids think that we're
00:59:30 normies our kids are like so anyway so i think like the tide is turning there's a there's a point
00:59:37 where something gains so much critical mass that it's no longer cool um to just toe the bottom line
00:59:45 and to you know to keep in step and so i think like we're kind of hitting a point now where
00:59:51 wokeness whatever you want to call it the the liberal order um has one it's been been just the
00:59:57 the veil has been lifted it's been proven to be such a farce but also it's not just that it's
01:00:02 being revealed for being ugly and terrible and monstrous and all those things which are true
01:00:07 but also it's just uh it's predominant it's it's predominant and anybody who just uh goes with the
01:00:14 flow that's that's what you're doing you're just going with the flow there's nothing unique there's
01:00:17 nothing original there's nothing novel there's nothing that would stand out there's it doesn't
01:00:21 require any courage it doesn't um and and so there's little reward whereas right now on the
01:00:27 right like yeah cancel culture you know that but cancel culture is fading and now it's kind of like
01:00:31 a reward culture right so like you don't get canceled on the left um but i think we're hitting
01:00:36 hitting a a point in the like the third act in the musical where um on the left like there's still
01:00:43 safety, but there's also, there's, you don't, you don't have any risk, but you also have zero
01:00:48 reward, zero reward. Whereas on the right, it was all risk, you know, and, you know, and zero safety
01:00:56 and zero reward. Well, now the right is still less safe, but the risk is actually lessening.
01:01:02 And, and now there's just, I feel like every week there's, there's an example or a case study or a
01:01:08 story that drops where some some guy on the right who took a risk who did the right thing is being
01:01:14 publicly internationally um accredited with fame and and reward whether it's daniel penny or you
01:01:21 know and um and i think as that starts to happen and it's still the minority opinion um the younger
01:01:28 generation is is going to want to be on that team they're not going to want to be on their grandma's
01:01:34 team you know like they're gonna want to like praise god the boomers are probably not the best 0.95
01:01:40 horse to bet on you know but i think like i'm super hopeful when it comes to gen z i think 0.81
01:01:44 40 of them like i said are gay furries and you can read the statistics for that though you know 0.81
01:01:49 like they'll be dead by 35 and uh and the other 60 are super based and um and are taking risk 0.99
01:01:56 what do you think yeah you're absolutely right about that we even saw a very promising example 0.98
01:02:01 of what you're describing today when you had a Gen Z, a Zoomer young man who was fired by Doge,
01:02:10 by the Department of Government Efficiency, because he had posted some tweets where he was,
01:02:14 making jokes that were racist or something. And popular sentiment online essentially called for
01:02:20 him to be rehired. And then Elon Musk pulled it. J.D. Vance, our vice president, said that he
01:02:27 agrees with the sentiment expressed online that he shouldn't be fired and have his life ruined 0.97
01:02:31 because he was doxed by some, you know, libtard journalist. And then eventually today Trump was 0.89
01:02:36 asked what he thought. And he said, I agree with the vice president. So the mechanisms to cancel
01:02:41 people, which has always been something that the left has used, always called for by the left,
01:02:45 enforced by the left, and the right has always cowered to it. That now is not really a card that
01:02:50 works because the vice president and the president are saying, we don't believe in this. So if you're
01:02:55 on the right and somebody says something that would offend leftist sensibilities at your
01:03:01 organization, what are you going to do? You're going to break from the vice president and the
01:03:05 president. They just gave you a license to kill. They say, you don't have to do this anymore. We 0.98
01:03:08 don't have to be afraid of the left because they don't have power. They're not cool. And the only
01:03:13 time they've ever been able to impose themselves are when they have that artificial sort of nanny
01:03:18 state, tentacles are everywhere, to where people are afraid and they just simply go along with it. 0.71
01:03:22 They post the black square.
01:03:23 They wear the mask.
01:03:24 But now if like they don't have that power, yeah, you can defend yourself on the subway.
01:03:29 Yeah, you can speak your mind.
01:03:30 You can do whatever.
01:03:31 You can be normal.
01:03:31 You don't have to apologize for your ancestors.
01:03:34 And there's nothing cool about that.
01:03:36 Even women who are radically left wing will date guys like me and they can't help but
01:03:41 be sort of attracted to how radical our politics are. 0.89
01:03:45 Because I mean, if men can lie about our nature, I mean, women are really bad at that, especially
01:03:49 because maybe there's some dissonance there between what they say and how they actually 0.53
01:03:53 behave more so with uh than with men but there's nothing attractive to anybody especially women
01:03:58 about thinking that everybody should just be equal and get along and that would just be so nice and
01:04:03 the only thing that's bad is when people are mean and when they're saying that equality is bad
01:04:07 like there's nothing more unattractive to people than that and that is the governing orthodoxy of
01:04:15 the country or at least it was before uh trump was sworn in and i think it's going away and it's
01:04:19 going away very quickly and we're all going to be much better off for it that's just profound like
01:04:25 in the last 24 hours president the vice president richest man in the world said yeah you can say
01:04:30 things might not agree with them you shouldn't lose your job over it it's done and vance even
01:04:34 was like hey uh i don't ever want to see like one of our guys essentially fired because a leftist
01:04:40 news reporter dug something up like think about that profound vibe shift three weeks into the
01:04:46 administration we're done with that we're not canceling people for old tweets anymore
01:04:50 yeah yeah okay i have a question um one more question and then we'll go to our next commercial
01:04:56 break but um so what do you think what should conservatives be focusing on now like you know
01:05:04 you our first segment um at the beginning of the show before you hopped on i was saying you know
01:05:09 I was talking about Andrew Torba a little bit, who's a friend.
01:05:12 And I was just saying that one of the things I like about him is one,
01:05:17 he's a Christian brother in Christ. But two, he's, he's like, well, you know,
01:05:23 I'll just, I'll just say it. I don't know your position on this and you don't
01:05:26 have to, you just be you. You don't have to abide by, you know, our flavor,
01:05:31 but he's what the kids would call Jay Pilt. And, and there's, you know,
01:05:36 there's no secret to that andrew torba has been posting you know about about the jews for
01:05:42 i don't know 10 years you know i mean i wasn't even on the internet yet yeah yeah exactly yeah
01:05:48 yeah exactly i was still figuring out email you know and torba's over here you know saying it's
01:05:54 the jews you know and um but but here's the thing this is what i love about torba um trump runs
01:06:00 and you know every like what i always tell people you know i'm a christian pastor 0.97
01:06:05 i think judaism is satanic um i i hate it it's a false religion and uh blasphemous christ and so 0.92
01:06:12 i make no apology for that but what i had to tell my church and guys you know guys are like well but 0.99
01:06:16 trump is a zionist he wears the tiny hat he's at the wall and i'm like guys it's the year of our
01:06:21 lord 2025 um you don't you don't get a president in these united states who's not a zionist so you
01:06:27 pick the best zionist you have that's that's just where we are now all that being said here's my
01:06:32 point torba like got a lot of backlash from his own fan base whatever you want to call it his
01:06:40 his primary you know followers um because when trump started campaigning uh torba knows all
01:06:48 that he's not stupid he knows that you know he knows trump's position on israel and this that
01:06:53 and the other and all these things and he just didn't care he's like he again like again and 0.98
01:06:58 again and again every day was like no black pillion allowed i'll block you vote for trump 0.59
01:07:04 he's great i don't agree with everything we've got to um you play you play the hand that you've
01:07:10 been dealt i'm grateful for trump um he has my vote and then not only that right that's one
01:07:15 thing politically but then elon if you're if you're the ceo of gab your whole business model
01:07:22 is parallel conservative free speech right that's your whole thing your whole thing is
01:07:28 you know mainstream is bad and and uh don't you know don't use the platform from the people who
01:07:34 hate you and blah blah um he would have every incentive to say elon musk is a um it's a psyop
01:07:42 um he's he's uh controlled opposition you know he's pulling the wool over your head
01:07:47 um this it's not really free speech um like he'd have every single financial at the level of his
01:07:55 wallet providing for his family every incentive to counter trump and certainly to counter elon
01:08:01 and then you know what torba did instead he's like yeah this is great x is getting better there's
01:08:06 still problems but it's getting better by the day i like elon i'm grateful for him like probably not
01:08:11 a fan of you know putting neurochips in people's brains you know like like obviously we you know
01:08:16 we have some differences in our worldview, but grateful for him. This is awesome. And he just
01:08:21 supported it. He just supported it. And so my point, to put it to you to a question,
01:08:27 I think that in the year of our Lord, 2025, if conservatives are thinking, all right, here's the
01:08:32 plan. Homesteading. Here's the plan. Parallel free speech economy. Rumble. Gap. I'm like,
01:08:42 what world are you living like what that's you are the grandma asking at at the top of at the
01:08:50 top of the cycle how to how to get a wallet so you can buy some uh some bit bit quarters you know
01:08:56 like um if you're thinking about starting you know a gab account and and you're thinking about you
01:09:02 know buying buying chickens and i and i i gave all my disclaimers earlier like you got kids you
01:09:07 want to teach them to touch grass there's good virtue and habit building there's plenty of
01:09:10 reason to do that. But we've been in survival mode. So everything's been small, remnant,
01:09:16 survive, self-sufficiency, because you can't trust anybody and the government's going to kill you.
01:09:23 And so grow your own garden, get your own social media, get your own business, all these kinds of
01:09:30 things. I don't think that's where we are anymore. So like the sons of Issachar in the Bible,
01:09:34 they were honored for knowing the times. And I think for the first time, we have
01:09:40 not just lessened headwinds but but conservatives have tailwinds and so i'm thinking right now i'm
01:09:47 thinking yeah like i still have principles and virtues i'm a christian so there's some things
01:09:52 that i can't take advantage of because i think they're fundamentally inherently ethic ethically
01:09:57 wrong but anything that doesn't fall into that category um i'm i'm gonna i'm gonna use everything
01:10:02 i got i'm gonna use whatever pieces of ai i can and and do it better than everybody else and be
01:10:09 an early adopter i'm going to like i i didn't like twitter i didn't even start a twitter account
01:10:15 until elon bought it but as soon as that happened i was like yeah that like i wouldn't make elon a
01:10:19 pastor in my church but but um but him owning this platform means there's going to be an opportunity
01:10:25 here and i could see the writing on the wall and so i said i'm going to start building this out and
01:10:29 i'm going to say um so all that being said i i don't think i don't think homesteading
01:10:35 and gab accounts is probably like the premier focus for the next four years but i totally
01:10:41 understand why it was and i don't disparage anybody who did it for the last 10 years
01:10:44 andrew torba gave people like me a place to converse when when when free speech was
01:10:52 completely suppressed and so i like thank you sir so i'm not disparaging at all i'm just saying the
01:10:58 times are changing and i think torba is a great example of providing in survival time and also
01:11:03 pivoting in thriving time. I think he's done both phenomenally. And I want to see, do you agree
01:11:10 with that sentiment? And if so, practically for these next four years, what should Christians
01:11:16 and conservatives, where should we put down our plow and start to work?
01:11:22 I would say, yeah, I definitely agree with being a pragmatist, with having an insurance policy.
01:11:27 You never want to put all your eggs in one basket, especially when you have other people who are
01:11:31 depending on you for their livelihoods. I would say that we have a rare opportunity right now to
01:11:36 actually dismantle the ability of these people. Like you said, we have tailwind, we have the
01:11:41 ability to dismantle the ability of these people to like destroy our country. Whereas in previous
01:11:47 Republican administrations, it was about maybe slowing at 5% by having four years where our
01:11:52 taxes were a little bit more advantageous for us or something like that. But now we are actually
01:11:58 dismantling the mechanisms by which these people acquire and consolidate and accumulate further
01:12:03 power, particularly with things like elections or immigration policy. I mean, if we can achieve,
01:12:09 because there's going to be a counterattack. It's not as though the left is going to just
01:12:12 sit on their hands for four years and be like, drat, they really got us, didn't they? And then
01:12:15 it's over. I mean, as we're seeing from these corruption leaks that are coming out, this was
01:12:19 a multi, multi-billion dollar system, which was making a lot of money for so many people.
01:12:23 it's not simply going to go away but if we can do enough damage to not only stop the bleeding
01:12:29 but on our end but prevent the counter-attack four years later we build up four years of momentum i
01:12:35 mean maybe two years later with the midterm elections but we build up enough momentum to
01:12:38 where say someone like jd vance is the obvious successor the country's happy with its trajectory
01:12:43 we don't have you know rampant voter fraud in other states we have more poll watchers we have
01:12:48 the RNC totally under Trump's family or the control of Trump's family. I mean, you create
01:12:53 a scenario where now you can continue doing that damage, you know, four years later down the line
01:12:59 into where if the left gets back into power, I mean, they don't have the option to say amnesty
01:13:04 10 million illegal aliens and consolidate permanent electoral control. They don't have the option to
01:13:09 keep incentivizing and rewarding the mass distribution of evil throughout the country
01:13:14 to demoralize good people and aggrandize bad people, it's just going to be a totally different
01:13:19 playing field. So I would say if there were ever a time to go like, I hate to use this, but like
01:13:23 full on blitzkrieg against these people, it would be now. And then if it doesn't work out, then we
01:13:29 can think about what to do later on. I mean, we're not stupid. We can figure things out pretty
01:13:33 quickly and put things together when we need to. But I would say right now, if you're a young
01:13:37 patriot, go get a law degree, go into debt if you have to. We'll pay it off later. We'll have some
01:13:41 sort of debt forgiveness program for young patriots who save their country. I would say
01:13:46 do something like that. Get involved in government, become as individually powerful as possible
01:13:50 and use that for good. Great. All right. We're going to go to our last commercial break for the
01:13:57 day. But John, I just wanted to say thank you for coming on the show. We'll let you go
01:14:00 and do what you do. If you guys aren't familiar with John's program, he puts out, you correct me
01:14:06 if i'm out of line here but he puts out uh one video per year he records it a million times and
01:14:13 until he uh his autistic mind feels content with the product and then he puts it out and it's
01:14:18 amazing but you am i is that fair i mean it's more than one a year but like i feel like i man
01:14:24 i wish you were producing more content i know you hear that all the time you're probably annoyed by
01:14:28 it but tell it tell us let us into your mind for a moment why do you why why do you not produce
01:14:33 more content. I'm sure you have a great reason. Tell us. It's a great compliment, actually. It's
01:14:39 the biggest problem people have is I don't make enough content. Well, to be honest with you,
01:14:43 I don't have an impulse to self-promote, really, which I know is ironic because what I literally
01:14:48 do for a living is promote myself. But I don't like social media. You go to my Instagram,
01:14:53 I post maybe once a year. And so if we're in a time where Donald Trump is not in office and I
01:14:58 don't really see opportunity to change the course of the country. I sort of just kind of like I'll
01:15:04 make, you know, content because I enjoy it. I enjoy giving my opinion on things, but I don't
01:15:09 really hit the ground running the way that I would if Trump were in office. So now that Trump
01:15:13 is in office, I have been posting more and I will continue to do that. It's just a different ball
01:15:17 game. But yeah, that your description was closer to the truth than the opposite. And so I'll let
01:15:24 you have that one. All right. Tell the listener one more time where they can follow your work.
01:15:30 Yeah. YouTube.com slash John Doyle, or you can find me on Twitter at Comrade Doyle.
01:15:35 And maybe once a year, I'll brighten your season or something.
01:15:40 All right. Cool. Thanks, John, for coming on. Appreciate it.
01:15:43 Yeah. Thanks for having me.
01:15:45 Here's our last commercial break for the day.
01:15:48 All right. The clock is running out. You need to go and register now for our Christ is King,
01:15:53 How to Defeat Trash World Conference.
01:15:56 It's happening the year of our Lord, 2025,
01:15:59 April 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
01:16:01 That's a Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.
01:16:03 And by God's grace, we're able to provide for you
01:16:06 an all-star lineup.
01:16:08 We've got Steve Dace, Calvin Robinson,
01:16:10 Orrin McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolfe,
01:16:13 Eric Kahn, David Reese, Andrew Isker,
01:16:16 John Harris, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder,
01:16:19 Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, C.J. Engel,
01:16:22 and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webben.
01:16:25 Come on out, join us April 3rd, 4th and 5th, 2025,
01:16:29 Thursday through Saturday.
01:16:31 Go to rightresponseconference.com to register today.
01:16:36 Again, that's rightresponseconference.com.
01:16:39 Listen, guys, you probably listen to Right Response Ministries
01:16:42 because you take the dominion mandate
01:16:45 offered to us in scripture seriously.
01:16:47 Well, unsurprisingly, so does Dominion Wealth Strategist.
01:16:52 As the only distinctly reformed financial consulting firm, they help Calvinistic, covenantal, and confessional Christians to steward their resources faithfully in a way that actually aligns with God's Word.
01:17:06 Dominion Wealth leverages all corners of the financial service industry as independent brokerage agents, matching you with suitable products and services from dozens of top industry providers.
01:17:19 Their mission is to equip believers to secure their family's future and build a legacy that glorifies God by building holistic financial strategies that include budgeting, insurance, debt management, retirement planning, estate planning, and more.
01:17:38 In order to make wealth Christian again with a portfolio that might even put King Solomon to
01:17:43 shame, go and take dominion over your finances today by visiting www.reformed.money and book
01:17:53 an introductory overview right now. All of Christ for all of life and all of finance for Christendom.
01:18:02 All right, welcome back. So we're going to kind of wrap up our discussion here,
01:18:07 and conclude some thoughts that we had
01:18:10 and then some comments on what John Doyle said.
01:18:13 One of the things that I was particularly interested in
01:18:16 with that discussion was this idea
01:18:19 that America has an established culture.
01:18:24 And Joel, you mentioned it in the opening bit.
01:18:26 John Doyle mentioned it here in his interview.
01:18:30 And the idea that there is a way of being,
01:18:33 a way of life of the American people
01:18:35 that has been around for a long time.
01:18:38 And one of the things,
01:18:40 and Nate, I don't think I sent you this quote,
01:18:42 so I'm just gonna kind of reference it here,
01:18:43 but that same guy who wrote the article
01:18:44 that I mentioned earlier,
01:18:46 he talked about how there's a competing vision
01:18:49 of what the American founding fathers did
01:18:53 in establishing in America.
01:18:54 And a newer idea is that
01:18:57 they completely broke away from England.
01:19:00 They established something brand new.
01:19:02 it was the revolutionary war right the same way we had the french revolution um the revolutionary
01:19:08 war and it was creating something entirely new our own thing and part of this is our individualistic
01:19:14 impulse as americans right we want to be new we want to be ourselves but uh jason jewell who wrote
01:19:19 that article that i mentioned earlier he argues that actually the war though it was a war between
01:19:26 england and um you know the colonies the united states uh he he argues that the the american
01:19:33 founding fathers were actually um not making a fundamental break with the old uh but they carried
01:19:39 forward the values and the assumptions and in a lot of ways the culture um parts of the culture
01:19:45 that they brought from england and from europe and what they actually were establishing was a new way
01:19:49 of governing themselves but we one of the things that's missing is we talk about conservative
01:19:54 culture. And this goes back to the whole question of what is it to be a heritage American? What is
01:19:58 the heritage of America? The culture of America, even though America has only been around 250 years
01:20:04 coming up, the culture of America and the beauty and like, there's a reason why when I went to
01:20:10 England, I loved to see the castles. And I, you know, we read Shakespeare still in our, in our
01:20:16 schools still to this day, we haven't, we haven't been able to weed him out as though as though we
01:20:23 needed to. But we actually are standing in a European and an English cultural perspective
01:20:31 that I think sometimes we forget. And one of the things in Arne McIntyre and the conference last
01:20:39 year, Stephen Wolf at New Christendom have been mentioning, this is not a new idea to me, but just
01:20:44 if we're going to get serious about creating culture, I think we need to be careful that we
01:20:50 don't assume that the culture that we create in this window, Lord willing, it's a long window
01:20:56 that we have in not just four years. We need to be careful that we don't fall into this idea that
01:21:00 everything that we're going to be producing now is this new culture. We actually need to be pulling
01:21:05 and building on the good culture that the last 60, 80, 100, whatever years has been trying to erase.
01:21:12 And we need to pull that culture back into our consciousness and into what it means to be a
01:21:18 people. It's going to be a new ways, right? Movies certainly didn't even exist that long ago. So if
01:21:25 we're going to make movies, obviously that's a new medium, but the messages, the values, what we
01:21:30 consider and find beautiful and interesting, really we have a project of pulling that across
01:21:36 a 60 or 80 year gap. Whereas in ideal times, that would be developing over time, kind of organically
01:21:44 as one generation passes to the next generation,
01:21:47 passes to the next generation,
01:21:49 we have quite a task, actually,
01:21:51 of trying to pull some of the previous cultural assumptions,
01:21:54 values, and art across a six-year, eight-year gap.
01:21:58 And it has to skip over,
01:21:59 but we have to plant ourselves in that
01:22:01 if we're gonna be serious about reestablishing
01:22:04 what it means to be Americans
01:22:06 and to have Christian culture.
01:22:09 Practically, literally like, well, what does that mean?
01:22:11 What does that look like on the ground?
01:22:13 I remember growing up, my dad read to me,
01:22:14 we read King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table.
01:22:17 I mean, this is a story from like eight,
01:22:19 maybe even longer, 900 years ago.
01:22:21 And it's in old English and all of that.
01:22:23 And he sent me an extra copy he had
01:22:24 for me to read with my son.
01:22:26 Now I could read to my son just modern stories
01:22:28 or look for authors that are currently living.
01:22:30 But if you're gonna establish that connection
01:22:32 to the past and to tradition,
01:22:34 that means you're reading, you're references,
01:22:36 you're framing, all of those things,
01:22:39 you're pulling them back in.
01:22:40 So it's consciously deciding,
01:22:41 i'm going to read king arthur i'm going to read shakespeare i'm going to read aristotle i'm going
01:22:46 to quote i'm going to cite i'm going to use their thinking like literally practically on the ground
01:22:49 what does that mean it means you're reading your children older books yep yep i i still remember
01:22:55 my uh my youngest son right now is reading treasure island and uh he's like dad did you
01:23:00 read this book growing up i'm like yeah i read that book you know i totally inspired and so we
01:23:04 looked into the the the biography of um uh the writer that is spacing my mind right now um but
01:23:12 he was very feeble as a child and his father was a lighthouse designer and so i told my youngest son
01:23:17 about um the fact that the writer of treasure island grew up around ships but he was kind of
01:23:23 weak so then the next day my son comes up to me he goes dad do you think the fact that he was so
01:23:28 weak but he could see the ships coming in and out do you think he imagined himself as jim
01:23:34 Hawkins on the ship. And I could tell, like, my 12-year-old son is imagining himself as Jim
01:23:39 Hawkins on this ship. And the fact that this English writer from the 1800s had written this
01:23:44 story that was just bedazzling and inspiring my son, like, he had a connection all the way back
01:23:51 to Robert Louis Stevenson. That's the guy's name. And I just thought, like, this is actually the
01:23:56 value and the power of culture. Like, he's enthralled not just in a meaningless story,
01:24:00 but a timeless story from not exactly,
01:24:04 but kind of our father, our grandfather culture.
01:24:07 And I loved watching that happen
01:24:09 over a period of a couple of days
01:24:11 when he started the book, we did a little research
01:24:13 and then he came back to me with his own ideas.
01:24:15 I mean, it was such a beautiful, beautiful thing.
01:24:17 But to your point, Wes, you're right.
01:24:19 It comes down to the choices that we make.
01:24:21 There's a reason we still read Pilgrim's Progress.
01:24:23 It's not just because it's got
01:24:25 some good biblical stories in it. 0.96
01:24:26 It is Anglo-Protestant culture.
01:24:30 yeah yeah do you have thoughts i was gonna say there's got to be a place in conservatism
01:24:38 which i don't even like the term christian nationalist is better but we do have to have
01:24:41 a place for creatives like it's true it's kind of right to call them gay and the nerds and
01:24:45 everything like that because a lot of effeminate men graduate gravitate towards the arts they look
01:24:51 to music and they look to art and they look to expression and they gravitate towards those
01:24:55 things so we kind of pick on them it's like well what do you just do like he makes this you know
01:24:59 indie music and makes thirty thousand dollars a year can barely support his family so we pick
01:25:03 on that and there's a good aspect like i said of kind of saying like well come on like what are you
01:25:08 really producing but once you have cultural power and people can be funded or just make a living
01:25:13 doing it there really has to be a place to say like no he doesn't fit into the way you would
01:25:18 traditionally we're going to talk about masculinity lord willing next week he doesn't fit into
01:25:22 traditionally how we would think of masculine men he doesn't necessarily work out now he takes care
01:25:28 of himself he's able if he needed to was called upon to to protect his wife and to protect his
01:25:34 children but uh yeah he makes music for a living or he like works in software that's not really art
01:25:40 so much but like they have these different occupations and we're not taking this just
01:25:44 bucket of male and female and applying it and saying across the board we gotta have all our
01:25:49 men being pastors for example or podcasters or social media wars there are men and they're good
01:25:54 men and they don't need to get on social media at all because it's just they're too easily they
01:25:59 maybe have a pastoral heart a certain kindness they don't need to worry about it we need to
01:26:03 have a variety of guys doing different things and then the ones that are genuinely making
01:26:08 decoration and art and music and all of those things again it can't be effeminate it can't be
01:26:13 gay they themselves can't be but to say no that's actually a really great thing you're doing and 0.96
01:26:18 praise god we have great music that people are listening to and you can devote yourself to it 0.94
01:26:22 and we're not going to pick on you or make fun of
01:26:25 kind of the look that you bring along with it.
01:26:27 We have a place for that.
01:26:30 I want to, my last plug that I really wanted to mention here
01:26:34 is in a world, and guys, go listen to the video by Doyle
01:26:41 because one of the sections he said was so good.
01:26:43 He said, people don't naturally,
01:26:44 like in our fallen nature, of course, we're sinful,
01:26:48 but we don't naturally love perversion.
01:26:52 And he said the perversion of art and culture and society
01:26:57 has been forced down our throats.
01:27:00 And one of the things that we have to do
01:27:03 to reestablish Christian culture
01:27:05 is we have to not only love the beautiful,
01:27:08 but we have to know what the beautiful is.
01:27:10 And I've just been thinking about recently,
01:27:13 why do people love classical music?
01:27:17 Classical music actually is something of an acquired taste.
01:27:21 it's kind of like people who don't really like coffee and so you start with the frappuccino
01:27:25 and then you move down to the hazelnut latte and then you're just in the latte and then you get to
01:27:30 the point where all you drink is you know fair trade organic you know americanos yes exactly
01:27:36 yeah um that sort of thing um recognizing good art beautiful what what is true beauty
01:27:44 sometimes is an acquired taste and in a world of filth in art I would bet that a lot of us
01:27:54 our perspective is just off on what is beautiful and so when you listen to really great
01:27:58 compositions or symphony or something like that like initially it's it's hard to know why do
01:28:04 people like this it just sounds like a bunch of instruments and then you start realizing these
01:28:08 are all someone took the time to arrange all the parts and they're all playing together and they're
01:28:13 playing different volumes and in different times and that the conductor is uh leading and directing
01:28:20 them and not only that but then the music itself it goes through movements and it tells stories and
01:28:24 and but to appreciate all of those things you actually have to learn a little bit about it
01:28:31 right um and and so i i guess one of my challenges is christians let us again love the things that
01:28:39 are beautiful that have endured the test of time and nate i'm gonna i'm gonna at least close my
01:28:42 comments with the quotes two, no, quotes three and four. So that's coming up here, quotes three and
01:28:49 four. And T.S. Eliot, this is quote three, he said, the dominant force in creating a common
01:28:57 culture between peoples, each of which has its distinct culture, is religion. It is Christianity
01:29:02 that our arts have developed. It is Christianity that the laws of Europe have until recently
01:29:08 been rooted in and then quote four this is roger scrutin who is a british conservative
01:29:13 and he said this he said design with beauty in mind and what you create will endure forever
01:29:20 and we we have to recapture what is beautiful right when you look at modern art and you say
01:29:27 that's just dumb but i'm probably missing something reject that right like love what's
01:29:33 beautiful love what's true love what's good and learn about why it's good and true and beautiful 0.97
01:29:38 and start promoting that.
01:29:40 And then maybe we have a generation where,
01:29:44 like with the Tradwives we talked about earlier in the year, 0.96
01:29:47 they're kind of having to fake it 0.70
01:29:48 because they didn't learn it from being a young girl.
01:29:51 So they're trying to bake and they're trying to do these things,
01:29:54 but their daughters won't have to fake it. 0.92
01:29:57 It won't be new to their daughters. 0.78
01:29:59 They will know how to do that almost instinctively.
01:30:02 And we, by God's grace, before too long,
01:30:07 will have, again, bred into ourselves and our society
01:30:10 a love of beauty.
01:30:12 And that starts with what you read your kids,
01:30:14 what you have your kids listen to,
01:30:15 what you do with your free time as a family,
01:30:17 just really practical things
01:30:18 that I wanted at least personally to end with.
01:30:21 Well said.
01:30:22 Yeah, I get so sick of the incessant trope 0.96
01:30:25 of you're faking or hypocrisy or LARPing.
01:30:32 I preached a whole sermon one time
01:30:34 where like the primary point was you got a LARP before you can fly.
01:30:40 And what I'm saying is, I think it was Chesterton who said that hypocrisy is the tribute
01:30:50 that vice pays to virtue.
01:30:53 And I've said this on the podcast a few times, but I think it's profound.
01:30:57 And it really helped for something to click in my mind to understand.
01:31:01 i'll say it again hypocrisy is the tribute that vice pays to virtue it's hypocrisy is vice tipping
01:31:09 the hat as it were to virtue we think hypocrisy is the worst thing it's not what's worse is that
01:31:16 a society in a culture where there's no need for hypocrisy because there's actually a true absence
01:31:22 of any and all virtue um hypocrisy what that necessitates is that there's at least some
01:31:31 remnant of virtue that still remains within a society to where vice at least has to pretend
01:31:37 at least the vice is is putting on the pomp and circumstance at least the vice is pretending
01:31:43 you a great example of this is you know again baptist my god my god um being a baptist feels
01:31:52 like did you ever read um i think it's the dawn treader the hufflepuffs and the professor who's
01:32:00 left on the island that's what it feels like being a baptist it's like uh not hufflepuffs
01:32:07 that's that's harry potter duffel pods yeah duffel pods there you go i was confusing my 0.96
01:32:18 fiction there the problem though of course is that one of those is super gay and the other one
01:32:24 is timeless uh namely c.s lewis the timeless one so duffel pods there we go get it right 0.97
01:32:29 um you know but basically he's like yeah they're they're ridiculous but they're mine
01:32:34 they're my duffel pods um this is what happened it was the coronation of king charles and the
01:32:42 baptist right on time you know uh came out talking about how atrocious and terrible it was and it's
01:32:50 the worst thing ever that you know this blasphemy of of christ and and and i'm sitting there i'm
01:32:57 like yeah do i think that king charles if i like if i had to bet on it would i bet that he is
01:33:03 genuinely born again regenerate heart that he loves the triune god and he's really going to
01:33:10 be a defender of the faith um no but but what it would like obviously the ideal is that you would
01:33:19 have the shell and it also would be filled right that's the ideal but i'll tell you what's not the
01:33:26 ideal it's it's not the ideal to have nothing better to have the empty shell than to than to
01:33:34 have uh no true center of christianity and virtue and no thin veneer or external remnants of
01:33:44 christianity it's better to have the the mere shell of of a of a chrysidom long past than to
01:33:51 have no shell at all and so all that being said my point is that um yeah hypocrisy is the tribute
01:33:58 that vice pays to virtue uh larping just i was piggybacking off of what you were saying about
01:34:04 the trad wife thing that's the same thing so like the same guys who came out about king charles and
01:34:09 this coronation is terrible we shouldn't do it this is christian nationalism and and it's and
01:34:13 it's it's the perfect example what christian nationalism uh always has been and always will
01:34:18 be a facade hypocrisy a show it's fake um you see it in england and that's really what it is in
01:34:26 america and that's also what the whole resurgence of you know the trad wife thing is and wearing
01:34:32 sundresses and baking sourdough bread um that's you know like you're you're larping that's not 1.00
01:34:38 who you are it's 2025 you know quit quit pretending quit faking quit larping quit being 0.97
01:34:45 hypocritical that's what they're getting at and the reality is this anything in any society
01:34:52 that's deemed as virtuous and valuable will always have, it will always, like a magnet,
01:35:00 be pulling in and attracting pretense. That's what value does. That's what virtue does.
01:35:08 Anything esteemed by any culture, any society, any subgroup of society, any isolated community,
01:35:17 whatever is valuable within a community whatever is deemed as being virtuous it won't just attract
01:35:23 people who are good at it it attracts everyone what happens when skateboarding you know in the
01:35:28 90s and you know tony hawk does the first 900 i remember watching it on the x games you know like
01:35:33 or whatever it was i remember i was watching it with nathan he's my cousin and i remember seeing
01:35:38 it at his house and we're like whoa and then what do you immediately do afterwards you turn off the
01:35:42 tv and me and my kid cousin um we then go and larp uh with skateboarding right we we grab our
01:35:52 skateboards are either of us good no you know but but but tony hawks just did a 900 my goodness
01:35:59 we're going out in the in the in the street we're building our little rink-a-dink ramp you know out
01:36:06 of two by fours and a cinder block or whatever and by golly um we're gonna skateboard because
01:36:12 anything worth doing is worth doing poorly right i mean that's it's true anything worth doing is
01:36:19 is worth doing well as the ideal that's what you work up to that's where you want to get
01:36:23 but really anything worth doing not only is it worth doing well but it's worth doing poorly
01:36:28 meaning it's it's so worthwhile it's worth doing even if you're not good at it it's worth doing
01:36:35 for a season while you're particularly poor at it until you get good at it what i mean think about
01:36:42 that like larping um what what is larping other than um because here's the thing it'd be one thing
01:36:48 if if everybody was lying that's different lying is different than larping so if everybody was
01:36:54 saying i am i am an 11th century crusader i am i am king arthur i am sir lance a lot i am duke
01:37:05 god for it right i i am vlad the impaler that's that's literally who i am and i have impaled this
01:37:11 many muslims for the lord jesus christ like if yeah like find that guy for me right because i'm
01:37:16 under the impression that that guy doesn't exist right you want to talk about larping the anti
01:37:21 crusaders are the ones that are larping um like if there's a guy who really is claiming to be king
01:37:29 arthur and really is claiming to have killed you know this many whatever turks or danes you know 0.99
01:37:35 in the case of king arthur um then sure that guy's an idiot um but what i've witnessed is not guys 0.99
01:37:43 who are lying but guys who are trying not lying but trying and why why why is it trying instead 0.99
01:37:52 of just doing it perfectly because we're exercising muscles that have been silenced
01:37:57 and atrophied for decades because of evil men because of evil men with a post-war consensus 0.52
01:38:07 the post-liberal order because of globalism because of the whole marxist facade of like
01:38:13 well you don't want to be a racist you don't want to do this you don't want to do that
01:38:16 um then then what we've done right like who was it that um who was he died of cancer recently
01:38:24 great comedian great norm mcdonald norm mcdonald right he had a joke and and he he was saying it
01:38:32 as a joke on like a live program and the host just agreed with them not knowing that he was joking
01:38:37 but he said like i was uh i was you know the thing that scares me the most about a terrorist attack
01:38:42 you know is that um if a terrorist attack you know killed and he was very specific in this
01:38:47 this joke um but he's like if a terrorist attack you know did something that killed you know um
01:38:53 you know uh millions i think he said millions you can go back and listen to it but i think he said
01:38:58 like one or two million americans at some you know big event or whatever and one or two million
01:39:03 americans were killed um the um what scares me the most about that is that um for years there
01:39:10 would be an anti-islamic sentiment and and the host not knowing that against muslims you know 0.97
01:39:17 and and the host not knowing that he was joking was like yeah that oh yeah i totally agree i think
01:39:22 he was on the view he was on the view or something it was like i don't think it was whoopi goldberg
01:39:25 but it was you know like one cackling hen you know they're all the same so there's some some
01:39:30 cackling hen like whoopi goldberg or joy breed or you know somebody like that and they're like oh
01:39:35 yeah me too and the point that he was making it was great because they you know hook line and
01:39:39 sinker they fell right into the trap but the point that he was making is that we have been so hamstrung
01:39:45 by this post-liberal order of tolerance and be anti-racist and globalism and egalitarianism
01:39:56 everybody's the same just people are just interchangeable widgets nobody's any different
01:40:01 there's zero hierarchy there's zero patriarchy there's zero nationalism there's no transcendence
01:40:07 there's no um no absolute truth or god above or hell below there's none of that and we've been so
01:40:15 that's that's you want to talk about the dark ages the dark ages that's that's just a anti-christian
01:40:21 psyop the enlightenment is the true dark ages that's the true dark ages and that demonic spell
01:40:28 has come over westerners western christians and we fell for it we all fell for it and um
01:40:36 And so now that some, just a few of us, are starting to wake up, then what does it look
01:40:45 like to honor your father, your ancient fathers, your spiritual fathers, your ecclesiastical
01:40:51 fathers, these fathers?
01:40:54 What does it look like to honor King Alfred?
01:40:57 What does it look like to honor Duke Godfrey?
01:40:59 What does it look like to honor the Puritans, the Covenanters, the Reformers?
01:41:03 what does it look like to honor the church fathers and you know origin and athanasius and augustine
01:41:08 like what does it look like to honor these kinds of men it for for people particularly
01:41:17 who have who have been blatantly unaware of these men because we weren't taught about them
01:41:23 intentionally by design and if we were taught about them we were taught that they were racist
01:41:27 bigots right so what does it look for us to honor honorable men worthy of our honor
01:41:33 but who we've either been lied to about or not told of their existence in the first place.
01:41:41 What does it look like to try to embody that ethos, that spirit of Christian,
01:41:49 courageous, masculine virtue? What does it look like for a generation, particularly of Westerners
01:41:54 today who have never exercised those muscles before in our life? Neither did our parents
01:42:00 or even our grandparents for three generations these muscles have never been used it's going
01:42:07 to look like larping get over it better to larp in virtue than to lie in vice in effeminacy 0.99
01:42:22 in faggotry 1.00
01:42:24 you're the problem 1.00
01:42:27 how dare you insult 0.93
01:42:30 people
01:42:31 who are attempting
01:42:33 to be men and women
01:42:35 who honor and esteem
01:42:38 our fathers and mothers before us
01:42:40 and uphold true
01:42:42 biblical virtue and values
01:42:44 how dare you 0.98
01:42:45 a woman's wearing sundresses instead of yoga 1.00
01:42:48 pants and trying to bake bread 1.00
01:42:50 for her children and teach her daughters to be feminine and not boss babes wearing suits 1.00
01:42:56 and you're going to you're going to mock her as a larper 1.00
01:43:01 yeah that that's that's what if conservatives are going to create culture again if we're going to 0.88
01:43:13 embrace virtue again it has been so long that we have been asleep that it's going to look like a
01:43:21 like a five-year-old child that's how bad we are currently that's how long we've been off the bike
01:43:27 it's going to look like a five-year-old child trying to ride a bicycle without training wheels
01:43:32 for the first time but you got to learn you got a larp before you can fly um that's okay
01:43:41 The way God's made the world, everything gets better with age.
01:43:45 A marriage matures and that there's more warmth and familiarity.
01:43:49 Trees, so both in their stature, their size, their robustness, and also for wood.
01:43:54 Trees that are green, they take wood and it bows when you try to use it to build a house.
01:43:58 Everything from wine to wood to marriage to a home, all of these things, they mature,
01:44:03 they decant, they become more robust with time.
01:44:07 Why couldn't we from Joe Biden's inauguration 2021 through 2024?
01:44:10 war like why couldn't we make culture in that three-year period we didn't have time it takes
01:44:15 time to do that so we got four years it's not enough but if you're going to plant a tree or
01:44:21 you're going to you know start a journey of a thousand miles you know the best time to start
01:44:25 was 10 years ago the second best time is right now michael any thoughts no good we got someone
01:44:32 in the comments his name is templar lux and he says he's basically saying speak for yourself
01:44:38 i am literally a templar my pfp is literally me there is no sarcasm i appreciate christendom
01:44:46 has fallen fallen billions must larp billions must larp well well said yeah christendom has fallen
01:44:51 uh billions must larp um gotta larp before you can fly you gotta start somewhere and um yeah we
01:44:59 we are exercising muscles embracing old virtues that are completely foreign to us um i don't know
01:45:06 anybody who doesn't admit that i admit that like i i admit that um that this is all it's all new
01:45:14 it's all new um but it's true right it's true and when you find something it's i mean the reality is
01:45:23 in the in the technical sense it's all old but it's new i mean it's new to us to our generation
01:45:28 we have been unfamiliar with these things they have been foreign to us and so when you find
01:45:34 something that's new it's novel to you but you realize that it's old it's tried it's true and
01:45:42 it's precious then um you do everything you can to be like that right when you discover
01:45:52 a true person of virtue you attempt like that's right it's um uh imitation is the highest form
01:46:01 of flattery like that's what you do you is like these men were virtuous i see it now i was never
01:46:08 taught about these men or i was taught lies about these men but now that i see these men for who
01:46:13 they are they're virtuous yeah i want to be like them i know i'm not i know i'm not but i'm going
01:46:21 to try because if i try and by god's grace i grow and my son tries by god's grace he grows then um
01:46:30 i'm trying but my grandson he'll be flying so and it rhymes therefore it must be true all right
01:46:36 thanks for tuning in uh god bless you guys stay uh stay tuned for this evening at 8 p.m central
01:46:42 time the friday special continues with myself and pastor andrew isker on the topic of israel
01:47:00 You