THE LIVESTREAM - Denominationalism Is Dead
Episode Stats
Length
2 hours and 22 minutes
Harmful content
Misogyny
13
sentences flagged
Toxicity
32
sentences flagged
Hate speech
96
sentences flagged
Summary
In this episode, Pastor Joel and I talk about why you don't need to be thinking about which denomination to join, and why you should be looking for a church within a 50-mile radius of your home that has discernment, that knows what time it is, and that excommunicates you for reading Pat Buchanan.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:07.660
When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm so that
00:00:12.440
our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:16.280
You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries
00:00:21.860
We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:30.000
hey pastor joel i was just wondering you know i'm kind of shifting in my convictions and i think i
00:00:39.020
might be a little bit more presbyterian than baptist these days what do you think you know
00:00:43.220
what denomination should i join should i be presbyterian should i be baptist or you know
00:00:48.320
maybe lutheran or maybe anglican the wrong question it's the wrong question we're going
00:00:53.720
to tell you exactly why in this episode you do not need to be thinking about which denomination
00:00:58.860
to join. It's not that it doesn't matter. Your creeds certainly matter. Your confessions also
00:01:04.840
matter. There's a high watermark for Christendom, and it is in the rear view mirror by at least a
00:01:11.120
couple centuries at this point. Can we get back there? Can our children or children's children
00:01:16.320
return and take Christendom even to higher levels than ever seen before, pushing for the crown
00:01:23.140
rights of King Jesus over and across the earth? Yes, absolutely. But in this moment, it's bleak.
00:01:31.340
In this moment, it's dark. We have to understand that right now, there is no retreat. There's no
00:01:39.680
surrender. But we are losing. We will not always lose. But if we can't ever admit the reality
00:01:47.180
that it's not great, then we're naive. We're arrogant. We're fools. Right now is not the time
00:01:56.120
to be choosing your particularities with each doctrinal conviction and deciding what denomination
00:02:02.840
you are. That's not where we are. You need to be looking, is there any church? And if there's one,
00:02:10.480
you are exceedingly blessed because right now the pickings are slim. Is there one church with
00:02:17.100
a 50-mile radius of my home that has courage, that has discernment, that knows what time it is?
00:02:24.820
Is there one church within a 50-mile radius of my home that will not excommunicate me for reading
00:02:31.600
Pat Buchanan? Is there one church within a 50-mile radius of my home that will not join the Zionist
0.95
00:02:39.180
mob, the feminist mob, the anti-racism mob, and try to destroy my life, dox me on the internet,
0.75
00:02:47.100
and make sure I'm unemployed so that I can't feed my kids.
1.00
00:02:51.220
Is there one church, one within a 50-mile radius?
00:03:02.540
Oh, it's a Presbyterian church, but I happen to be Baptist.
00:03:07.880
You do not need to be thinking in terms of denominations
00:03:14.500
You look, especially on the East Coast, right, where we were first settled in these United States
00:03:20.540
by Christians, and you see the remnants of the high watermark of Christendom. You go down the
00:03:26.800
main street in the downtown area of virtually every town on the East Coast, and what you will
00:03:32.320
find is church after church after church on every single street corner. Why? They could afford
00:03:38.180
division over theological particularities because they were victorious, because they were winning.
00:03:45.460
But when we're shrinking back, when the enemy is playing his hand and he has the upper hand,
00:03:52.100
that's when we link arms. That's not when we can afford to fracture. That's when we link arms.
00:03:59.260
That's when a guy shows humility and will lead his family in a Presbyterian church while he has
00:04:05.200
Baptist convictions because he knows we need to win the war. All of the particular convictions,
00:04:14.500
many, many churches that separate over this issue or that issue, that's when we win. When we win,
00:04:21.960
we can afford to have these divides. So you don't need to be thinking, what denomination am I on the
00:04:29.060
basis of what are all my thousands of particular theological convictions. Instead, you need to be
00:04:35.720
thinking, which church will have my back? Which session of elders won't seek to ruin my life?
00:04:44.640
Oh, there's one decent Anglican church within a 50-mile radius that knows what time it is,
00:04:51.960
has discernment, has courage. Well, then as for me and my house, we're going to be Anglican,
00:04:57.420
at least for the foreseeable future. And if there is no singular church, not even one Baptist,
00:05:04.060
Anglican, Lutheran, Presbyterian within a 50 mile radius, then you do everything within your power
00:05:10.660
to either move or plant a church. Those are your options. Those are your only options. Now what's
00:05:19.240
not an option is being churchless. You must get your butt in a church. You cannot give up
0.99
00:05:26.580
on the bride of Christ. Even if she's in disarray, God always preserves a remnant.
00:05:34.880
Find her, join her, and be faithful. We're going to break it down today's episode. Tune in now.
00:05:50.760
All right, we saw one of the comments there. Somebody picked up on this. It was unintentional,
00:05:56.060
i promise but he said joel said the words creed and he also said take it higher can you take me
00:06:04.200
i think it's time right i mean i don't know it's what the people want it's what the people want
00:06:09.940
brian sauve that's a shout out to you uh you're gonna have to record a creed song get it on the
00:06:14.760
internet uh it was santa baby like two years ago very painful this one a lot funner come on it's
00:06:20.920
great this is a good one the people want it give the people what they want all right this is our
00:06:25.320
episode we're talking about denominationalism being dead and here's the deal it's dead because
00:06:30.960
no one can keep their arms linked for longer than 15 minutes right now at every step of the way it's
00:06:38.800
like every six months the lord gives us a new providential litmus test and you see a team that
00:06:44.820
you thought previously you were on divide right down split right down the middle and fracture
00:06:51.280
we're splitting the penny a million times over and that's why by the grace of god and i mean
00:06:57.280
truly by the grace of god because i was about this close 2022 2023 you know we're out here
00:07:05.720
independent planting a church in georgetown we started in 2021 so at that point we're about a
00:07:12.400
year two years in and i was feeling that need of i want extended body and fellowship with brothers
00:07:20.360
in Christ. I don't want to just be a one-man show. I don't want to be independent. I don't
00:07:25.680
want to just do my own thing. I know that there is a strength in accountability within a local
00:07:31.180
church and outside of a local church. So whether it's a fellowship or some affiliation or a network
00:07:37.040
or denomination, I felt that. I felt it intensely. And I'm telling you, I was close, very close on
00:07:44.620
multiple occasions to just throwing in the towel and saying, you know what, it's not perfect.
00:07:50.360
but it never is. And maybe it's just my own pride or my own stubbornness. And I'm going to join
00:07:55.560
this denomination or this group, this movement over here, submit myself. And if I had,
00:08:03.140
if I had, it would have been detrimental. Absolutely detrimental. You know what I'm
00:08:10.580
talking about. You know who I'm talking about over the last two years. Correct me if I'm wrong.
00:08:16.280
over the last two years have you not sat here just like me watching from the outside looking in
00:08:23.760
and seeing entire denominations that we thought were based and christ-built turn on local churches
00:08:32.340
turn on sessions of elders turn on independent members in one of those congregations and wrongfully
00:08:39.480
excommunicate them because they denied the trinity right heresy top-tier theological
00:08:44.800
disagreement no because they held to some revisionist world war ii history because they
00:08:53.100
said something about ben shapiro because like we've seen these petty disagreements elevated
00:09:01.400
to the level of excommunication where men dragged before ecclesiastical courts for their twitter
00:09:08.680
page being i don't know just just slightly to the the right of the israeli wire and all of a sudden
00:09:18.660
they're being tried in ecclesiastical courts for whether or not they're regenerate whether or not
00:09:24.240
they're even we just saw this a month ago a man said hey i don't want america to be india we
00:09:29.100
talked about this and his pastor said you're gone from our church yeah that's what it culminated in
00:09:33.160
my kids to grow up in america we're not exaggerating making it uh he was talking about
00:09:37.220
immigration h1b he didn't say hey i hope that india gets bombed off of the face of the map or
0.99
00:09:43.500
oh i hate indian people and i hope they all go to hell or oh he didn't say anything like that
0.98
00:09:48.540
he was just saying i i hope that india stays in india at least for the most part so that america
0.99
00:09:55.700
can remain america because i grew up as a kid in america and it was pretty great and i'd like for
00:10:01.740
my children to have a similar experience kicked out of his church and and not just that but certain
00:10:10.020
individuals in his church also turned the turrets on his personal business and got him bombarded with
00:10:17.440
one star negative reviews calling him a racist so it wasn't just hey you can't be a part of our
00:10:22.500
church it was also we need to steal your livelihood we we won't be happy with you excommunicated we
00:10:29.140
won't be happy until your children are on our doorstep begging for food that's the state of
0.70
00:10:35.960
the church today yeah and so my point is if you find a good church i feel like the billy madison
0.65
00:10:42.700
is like oh hold on stay hold on as long as you can yeah but i'm really more of a paedo baptist
00:10:49.660
and they're credo bad dude you don't know what time it is you think that we're in a position
00:10:54.760
where we have the luxury to wish that it was a paedo-baptist church instead of a credo-baptist?
00:11:00.420
No, no, sir. That is the reward for total victory, total Christendom. That's when you can afford for
0.71
00:11:08.620
there to be a church on every single street corner. They're all courageous. They're all wise.
00:11:14.340
They're all godly. They just differ on the particularities of theological conviction,
00:11:19.920
and you have your pick of the lot and it just all it all it really um distinguishes is do i have a
00:11:26.680
five minute drive to church on sunday or a six and a half minute drive on sunday that time used
00:11:32.520
to exist and by the grace of god i believe it can exist again but that time is not now so you should
00:11:39.460
not be thinking about what network or denomination do i join you should be thinking what one church
00:11:45.820
despite disagreement on particulars if it's secondary and tertiary theological issues
00:11:52.000
what one singular church not network of churches what one individual church despite some of these
00:11:59.440
disagreements theologically can I join because the ethos the spirit of this church and its leaders
00:12:06.620
and its people are aligned with me they know like the sons of Issachar they know the times and what
00:12:12.860
Israel ought to do, right? In this case, the church ought to do, the people of God ought to
00:12:18.220
do. And then you do everything you can. You move heaven and earth to get in that church, join that
00:12:23.800
church, be faithful in that church. That's where we are. To draw a parallel to masculinity, right?
00:12:29.960
The red pill movement was big a couple of years ago because a lot of men, honestly, they worked
00:12:33.840
remote. They worked some type of corporate job and they just, they had to be taught, hey, being a man
00:12:38.480
means taking responsibility. Being a man means being disciplined. And you can teach someone
00:12:43.780
all about it. They can read all of the articles. They can watch all the video courses. They can
00:12:47.560
listen to all the podcasts. But practically speaking, flesh and blood on the ground,
00:12:52.040
there's an aspect to it that can never be taught. In the same way with the church,
00:12:55.960
you will have people intellectually, you are on the same page. We've had this in our own church.
00:13:01.660
There's been great guys. And on every single theological issue, it was check, check, check,
00:13:07.440
check man there is perfect overlap on what we thought were all of our views but then the flesh
00:13:12.860
and blood difference uh disagreement happened oh actually we're not as close a fit as we thought
00:13:18.300
we were we checked all of these boxes intellectually right well i agree with you here well i agree with
00:13:22.760
you here well i agree with you here but then you got down to it oh this masculinity guy that talks
00:13:27.740
a big game that's listened to all this and knows all these things he doesn't have a single callus
00:13:31.380
on his hands and he can't do a 10-hour work day and so the same way when it comes to the church
00:14:11.320
It's not as though, well, he's good on this, but also as a one is Pentecostal.
00:14:20.800
And he's a good guy that's been in the trenches, prays for me, cares for my family, preaches faithfully.
00:14:28.020
Yeah, that's your guy more than he checks every single box, but push came to shove.
00:14:31.720
Had no spine whatsoever, and that fed me to the wolves.
00:14:34.740
Right. And what we're saying, I think, is not that at one point in time, the church that you
00:14:41.380
were a member of was a matter of idealism, and now it's a matter of pragmatism. What we're saying
00:14:46.880
is it's always been a matter of pragmatism. It's just we're all men of our times. At a time in the
00:14:50.980
past, Christendom's flourishing, and you can actually afford to be an idealist on theological
00:14:56.180
matters. But the church has always recognized pragmatism in church membership. There's always
00:15:02.760
a matter of location. There's a matter of demographics, right? Am I going to a church
00:15:07.260
that is all 65 plus, and I have three young children? Does it make sense for me to be in a
00:15:12.180
church like that? And so all of these things are things that men ought to consider when they're
00:15:16.000
thinking about church membership. And what we're simply saying is that you can't afford to sacrifice
00:15:21.920
the four or five other important dimensions simply for theological purity, because you're not going
00:15:28.060
to find that church anywhere right that's a really good point antonio um it's not that it was shifting
00:15:33.800
from you know uh once it was theological and that was the emphasis and now it's pragmatic and more
00:15:39.480
practical who's going to have my back and that's the emphasis no it was theological because you
00:15:44.620
could afford now listen you can always afford theological convictions when it comes to think of
00:15:51.240
theological triage when it comes to top tier primary theological doctrine right salvation
00:15:57.140
soteriology, doctrine of God, theology proper, these kinds of things, you can always afford
00:16:02.720
In fact, if you're living in a time where all these things are being denied, then it's
00:16:07.480
like Athanasius, you know, it's contramundum against the whole world, even if you're all
00:16:12.380
So you stand your ground if we're talking a matter of heresy, right?
00:16:15.980
A denial of top tier primary theological issues, a denial of those things is a matter
00:16:23.740
so it doesn't matter what age the church is in, you always prioritize that. What we're talking
00:16:28.900
about is the secondary and tertiary theological convictions, and in prior times, thinking 100
00:16:36.360
years ago, certainly 200 years ago, certainly 300 years ago, in the West, by and large,
00:16:42.380
in the last couple of centuries, these second and third tier theological issues seem to be
00:16:48.660
the sole emphasis of distinguishing between which church or denomination or whatever you were going
00:16:55.800
to be a part of. And the reason why is not because back then people cared about theological
00:17:00.520
convictions, again, talking about secondary and tertiary, and now they care more about pragmatism
00:17:06.000
over theological issues. No, it's because back then pragmatism was assumed. You could assume
00:17:12.160
that 99 percent of churches 200 years ago weren't raging feminist they were not communist they were
00:17:21.200
not um um anti-racist liberals you know or or raging zionist or whatever uh the the pragmatism
00:17:30.400
it's not that we used to care about theology but now you know joel's become more of a pragmatist
00:17:34.900
and i don't like that transition i think that shows that he's compromised no we were always
00:17:39.160
pragmatists but pragmatism that element that's not all we were but it was always there it was
00:17:44.700
always a part of the equation and the reason that it wasn't always emphasized is because for the
00:17:49.860
most part every denomination and every single church was on board every single church in the
00:17:56.360
west a couple hundred years ago was on board with these basic cultural practical elements of not
00:18:04.500
being feminist of of not being communist of not you know this that and the other and so when that
00:18:12.140
was in line and every church was pretty much on board it's not that pragmatism did not matter
00:18:18.480
then it's that pragmatism did matter then but it wasn't thought about it wasn't spoken about
00:18:23.880
because it was an assumed today it's not and that's why we're having to bring it up so we're
00:18:30.720
not saying these cultural and practical familial elements like will my church love me and my
00:18:37.500
children will my church get my back and not excommunicate me and try to destroy my business
00:18:43.140
we're not saying that this has elevated above all theological issues we're saying at this moment
00:18:49.860
because the church is in such sad shape in such disarray this pragmatic element has at this point
00:18:59.000
risen to a priority above theological convictions in the secondary and tertiary categories,
00:19:07.120
never primary. I think that that's a fair argument. Yeah. We've mentioned this before as well,
00:19:12.900
especially if you were reformed, the Young Restless Reform Movement, you very much so had
00:19:17.720
the sense that church was always kind of the launching pad for everything. So it was matchmaking.
00:19:21.780
Where do I find someone to marry? Well, that's my local church. I want to start a business. Who do I
0.95
00:19:25.460
started with? Somebody in my local church. Where do I have my friends? Where do I have my fellowship?
00:19:29.220
Where do I have my community? Well, it's Sunday morning and it's Sunday night, and it's my gospel
00:19:33.340
group on Mondays. It's my men's group on Tuesdays. It's prayer meeting on Wednesdays, men's prayer
00:19:37.840
breakfast on Saturdays. This local church, this idea, it's everything. It's your friendships. It's
00:19:42.280
where you find people to marry. It's where you do business. And a lot of us had that mindset. Well,
1.00
00:19:46.120
the church is all of those things. And there are certainly times, especially when you're under fire,
00:19:51.240
that the church will be that. That the church is where it's going to be where men band together
00:19:54.240
run for political office where they start businesses. But practically speaking, your
00:19:58.260
church doesn't have to be that. In a time past, it wasn't the case that every single marriage that
00:20:02.920
came out, every single friendship was always going to be tied to the local church. Men would have
0.88
00:20:07.640
friends, acquaintances, business, all these different things. And then on Sunday, one day
00:20:11.560
of week in the Lord's Day, they may go and spend time with people they don't actually see very much
00:20:15.740
during the week. Now, that's not to say they were lacking in friendships, lacking in opportunities,
00:20:19.420
lacking in starting businesses, but it is to say, hey, I'm in a church and people aren't necessarily
00:20:24.720
starting businesses here. They're not doing this or doing that. That's great. You have a whole
00:20:29.540
town. You have a whole area, a whole city. You have, due to the internet, you have people all
00:20:33.680
over the country you can do that with. It does not have to be your local church. No, feel in your
00:20:38.480
conscience bound. Hey, it's a small church. I live in a small town. The church in it is small.
00:20:43.640
These guys have to be all of it. No, not at all. You can say, hey, I go here on Sunday morning.
00:20:50.540
I take the Lord's Supper, take the sacraments, participate in baptism.
00:20:54.740
I encourage, sing, attend the message, encourage my pastor.
00:20:58.660
And the other six days of the week, I'm working.
00:21:03.260
And the seventh day is the Sabbath to the Lord your God.
00:21:08.500
feel your conscience freed from the need for your local church to be everything.
00:21:12.980
That's great if all your friendships and everything come from it.
00:21:17.560
if you have a little bit of different communities Sunday versus the rest of the week very well said
00:21:22.280
all right so this is what we're going to do for this stream I want to spend some extra time on
00:21:27.820
super chats today I want to get to it sooner so I want to let everybody know especially if you're
00:21:32.900
a new listener you may not be aware what we do is we typically have three segments right so this is
00:21:37.840
segment number one we're about to go to our first message from our sponsors then we'll come back
00:21:42.600
we're going to flesh out this idea a little bit more then we'll do our last commercial break and
00:21:46.340
then the third segment is our super chat so here's the drill uh you send in a super chat this is the
00:21:52.140
the unspoken deal but it's kind of spoken because i'm speaking it right now the unspoken deal that
00:21:57.660
we've made is if you write a comment or a question and you send it to us as a super chat your comment
00:22:03.460
or question will be read live on the air this is a live broadcast so it will be addressed live on
00:22:09.840
the air so start sending those in now and for anybody who's new to the channel just so that
00:22:14.740
you know our schedule. We broadcast live three times a week. We do Monday, Wednesday, and Friday
00:22:20.540
at 3 p.m. Central Time, and we are broadcasting live simultaneously on two platforms. We do YouTube
00:22:27.040
and X, all right? So YouTube and X. If you're on YouTube, subscribe and click the bell. Do it now,
00:22:33.160
subscribe, click the bell. If you're on X or if you're not on X, make sure to go over and follow
00:22:37.820
us there the handle is at right response m as in ministries at right response m same thing give us
00:22:45.700
a follow and click the bell so that you'll be notified so youtube and x that's where we're
00:22:50.680
broadcasting live simultaneously three times a week monday wednesday friday at 3 p.m central time
00:22:56.380
within about one to two hours after the stream is cut once we're done then we upload it to our
00:23:02.240
website our app and your podcast platform apple spotify xyz okay so i want to have time for super
00:23:09.240
chats get them in now get them while they're hot send in the super chats we'll do that in the third
00:23:14.060
segment we're going to go to our first commercial break we'll come back probably for a shorter
00:23:18.440
segment about 15 20 minutes flesh out this idea a little bit more a little bit more practicalities
00:23:24.400
go to our last commercial break and then start dealing with the super chats which means
00:23:28.660
If you're watching, if you're caught up to speed right now, within about 20, 25 minutes, we're going to be doing the super chats.
00:23:35.500
So get them in. Let's go to our first commercial break now.
00:23:39.020
The silver is mine and the gold is mine, declares the Lord of hosts.
00:23:44.180
Yet your retirement dollars keep shrinking daily as Washington prints money out of thin air.
00:23:51.240
Genesis Gold Group aligns financial guidance with godly principles when others serve only profit.
00:23:58.660
Their faith-centered approach to gold IRAs stands apart in an industry that has forgotten
00:24:08.500
Why gamble your family's future on Wall Street's paper promises?
00:24:18.400
Genesis Gold Group transforms your vulnerable retirement accounts into physical gold, something
00:24:24.580
real, something tangible, something that God created with inherent value.
00:24:31.200
Their faith-driven experts walk you through every step, helping you shield your life's
00:24:39.360
No high-pressure tactics, no hidden fees, just guidance rooted in timeless principles
00:24:49.220
Watch your retirement evaporate through inflation or secure it in God's precious metal.
00:25:02.080
You can visit today for your free book, The Bible and Gold, and join the thousands of
00:25:07.940
believers who sleep soundly knowing their future is anchored in something unshakable.
00:25:18.620
Safeguarding Your Legacy with God's Timeless Treasure.
00:25:48.620
culture of excellent financial management. He starts with your goals, your tithing plan,
00:25:55.200
your retirement, and the legacy that you want to build for your generations. And then he works
00:26:01.080
backwards to build a real actionable plan to get your family on track. Now, many of my personal
00:26:08.660
friends have benefited from the financial wisdom of Joe Garracy that he shared for their specific
00:26:14.820
situations. Do you want to work with someone who strives for alpha with your investing, hates taxes,
00:26:22.020
and brokers insurance? Start planning smart. Call Joe Gerasi at 615-767-2555. Again, that's
00:26:34.860
615-767-2555. Or you can find him by going to backwardsplanningfinancial.inm.com. Again,
00:26:49.160
that's backwardsplanningfinancial.in, as in Nancy, m, as in ministries, dot com.
00:26:58.480
Hey friends, Gray Toad Tallow is a family business making skin care the way that it should be.
00:27:04.860
simple and clean. The company began as a personal mission to find healthier, more affordable
00:27:10.540
solutions to common skin problems without the chemicals that are found in most products today.
00:27:16.560
Now that search led to crafting balms from grass-fed, grass-finished animals that were
00:27:22.800
naturally rich in vitamins and healthy fats, which is exactly what your skin craves. These balms
00:27:30.380
fight dryness, they calm eczema, and psoriasis along with other stubborn skin issues without
00:27:38.860
containing all the nasty toxins. Gray Toad Tallow offers everyday soaps, balms, and beard balm for
00:27:47.320
men. To experience some of their products, grab a balm sample pack. Each batch is made with care
00:27:54.800
in their home and shipped directly to their customers. For skin care, the way that God
00:28:00.880
designed, natural, clean, and effective, visit graytoedtallow.com. Use code WRITE15 for 15%
00:28:11.860
off your order today. Again, that's graytoedtallow.com. And if you want 15% off,
00:28:24.800
all right for our second segment this is the question of the hour i talked about different
00:28:31.280
protestant denominations i applied the principle within the protestant realm but what about
00:28:36.520
catholics what about eastern orthodox does the principle cross over the aisle even to the realm
00:28:42.300
of protestant versus catholic versus eastern orthodox to kind of frame this segment that's
00:28:48.160
what we'll be dealing with and then we'll get to the super chats in our final third segment but to
00:28:52.260
frame this i'm going to use one of the super chats preemptively this is from located goose he gave us
00:28:57.680
five dollars we appreciate that thank you he said christian unity with catholic and orthodox
00:29:02.960
relatives that seem to bear real christian fruit so he's asking like what about christian unity
00:29:09.440
with catholic and orthodox relatives that seem to bear real christian fruit what do you think about
00:29:16.120
that all right so that's the question that's what we're going to be dealing with does this principle
00:29:20.020
that we've been outlining saying, hey, don't be looking for a denomination with all your
00:29:24.580
theological particularities in the secondary and tertiary theological categories. Rather be looking
00:29:30.000
for a local church, not a denomination, but one independent local church where you'll align with
00:29:36.700
the elders, with the congregation, and the big things in terms of, they're not going to
00:29:41.420
excommunicate me. They're going to get my back. They know what time it is. They have a spine.
00:29:45.200
they have courage and we agree on the top tier primary theological convictions that's a non
00:29:50.520
negotiable but we may have some particular theological distinctions disagreements in the
00:29:56.920
secondary and tertiary category so that's the principle as we've espoused it thus far does
00:30:02.740
this principle apply further beyond just presbyterian to baptist to anglican to episcopalian
00:30:08.640
to methodist to x y and z lutheran does it apply across the protestant aisle all the way to catholics
00:30:14.760
and to EO. That's what we're going to be fleshing out in the second segment. Wes, what do you think?
00:30:22.940
There's something really to be said for worshiping in a place where you can do it in good
00:30:27.040
conscience. So even with the Baptist example, let's say you find a Baptist church, and honestly,
00:30:31.080
the man there, like we described, like the quintessential man of the people, the pastor
00:30:35.160
there is objectively a good man, a good father, a good husband, all the qualifications of elder,
00:30:39.920
and he's a guy with calluses on his hands that's not going to kick you out. But Sunday morning,
00:30:44.340
There's an American flag on one side of the stage, an Israel flag on the other.
00:30:49.560
But still, if you're a right response top guy, you enjoy what we say, you have some major differences with that.
00:30:56.340
And that objectively, again, we've said, hey, prioritize more church that's not going to kick you out.
00:31:00.700
Prioritize leaders that care about you and care about your soul.
00:31:04.560
Objectively, that's still going to be a tough pill to swallow.
00:31:09.120
In this case, it's a disagreement over dispensationalism.
00:31:11.340
is expand the concept again and say you're a baptist in a tiny town and all the baptist churches
0.94
00:31:15.780
are gay all the presbyterian churches are gay but there's a catholic church that maybe it's a priest
0.89
00:31:20.340
that's online that's known as being based can you go there and our answer would be and we all kind
0.99
00:31:25.500
of agreed it would be a no and that's not necessarily uh because maybe he's not a good
00:31:30.440
guy it's because you can't go there the difference is as large as they are they're real and they're
00:31:35.940
meaningful you can't go there every sunday and not begin to chafe at it because like we were saying
00:31:41.240
in terms of theological triage, primary, secondary, tertiary, because the difference is when it comes
00:31:47.540
to Catholic versus Protestant versus EO, they stretch all the way up. Not every single thing,
00:31:53.560
but there are some things that stretch all the way up into that primary category. It's definitely
00:32:00.000
some secondary and tertiary differences, but there are also some primary differences. Now,
00:32:05.520
what do we not mean by that? We don't mean, therefore, Catholics are our biggest enemy,
00:32:10.160
or we hate them or we can't partner with them or love them or have meaningful friendship with them.
00:32:17.240
You guys who've been following the ministry, you know that that's not the position that we've taken.
0.95
00:32:20.540
And we've received a lot of flack from some of our more autistic, reformed Protestant brothers in Christ,
00:32:28.780
who we also love but we disagree when it comes to what extent can we partner with Roman Catholics
00:32:36.620
and with eastern orthodox people you know what extent can we partner now what we're saying
00:32:43.480
is that when it comes to i've got to have a local church that loves my family um that preaches the
00:32:52.260
bible and that's not going to excommunicate us that that has a general sense the ethos the the
00:32:57.840
spirit of is a car knowing the times that has a spine that has courage when it comes to this
00:33:04.280
yes we think that you should be able to step across at least temporarily it may be a year
00:33:11.540
it may be five years it may be 10 years i don't know let's see let's see if we win let's see if
00:33:16.180
we can get some victories right now i don't know about you but the oh mr president it's too much
00:33:20.660
winning i'm not feeling it i'm not feeling too much winning in fact i'm not feeling hardly
00:33:24.760
any winning so we're not there and maybe we're there by the grace of god in one year five years
00:33:30.360
10 years 15 years 20 I don't know but until we're there temporarily being willing to step across
00:33:36.300
denominational boundaries we think is vital that it's absolutely necessary that finding a church
00:33:42.740
that won't excommunicate you that disagrees on mode of baptism is of more value that there's a
00:33:50.160
greater immediate urgency in that and finding that caliber church than finding a church that
00:33:57.100
agrees with you on every, you know, secondary and tertiary theological issue. But there are primary
00:34:03.260
distinctives. There are primary differences when we're talking about not just Presbyterian to
00:34:08.580
Baptist denominationally, but we're talking about Protestant to Catholic to EO. So with these guys,
00:34:15.520
what does that mean? What it means is that you have six days a week. You have six days a week
00:34:22.260
where you can partner and link arms and love and be charitable and be on mission together in the
00:34:29.620
realm of politics and culture fighting political battles fighting cultural battles you can join i
00:34:37.400
wouldn't just say you can i think that if you don't if you're not willing to link arms with
00:34:43.140
catholics and eastern orthodox to fight monday through saturday political and cultural battles
00:34:49.940
then you are committing an unforced error. You are unnecessarily splitting the ranks and we're
00:34:59.120
not going to win. We are not going to win. You are causing our team to fall on its sword
00:35:05.360
unnecessarily. You are choosing to be so autistic that you cause the broader body of Christ to
1.00
00:35:14.500
commit cultural and political suicide i think that that is foolish however i think that there
1.00
00:35:20.440
is also an error on the other side of the road another ditch that you can fall into that you
00:35:25.640
can say well because i have these catholic friends or if you're catholic these protestant friends or
00:35:30.880
these eastern orthodox friends and although i disagree with you know their infatuation with
00:35:35.880
essential oils i'm looking at you eo bros um you know although i disagree with this you know we
00:35:41.400
found so much commonality so much commonality in the realm of of fighting the cultural battle and
00:35:47.820
fighting the political battle and and there's so much camaraderie and a sense of brotherhood
00:35:52.840
monday through saturday why don't we just transfer that over into sunday as well and what i'm saying
00:35:59.780
is that you can't yeah and we love catholics and we love eastern orthodox um but you can't
00:36:07.640
At the end of the day, what we're talking about is a balanced, I know we don't like this word,
00:36:12.780
but nuanced view. What we're advocating for is more unity in culture and politics,
00:36:20.080
the broader team pushing back on the communist. We're advocating for that broader unity,
00:36:28.200
but we're not advocating for that on Sunday morning when it comes to the pew. We're not
00:36:35.740
advocating that um in the theological category we're saying you can overlook temporarily tertiary
00:36:41.980
and secondary issues you cannot even temporarily overlook primary disagreements at the end of the
00:36:49.240
day the divide between rome and protestants still exists and at the end of the day eventually when
00:36:57.400
we've pushed back the orcs then dwarves and elves you can decide which you know who gets to be who
00:37:04.780
protestants or catholics but the dwarves and elves still have their disagreements and they
00:37:09.080
matter they are still distinct and you're going to eventually have to hash that out now i i will
00:37:15.220
end by saying this we've said it publicly a few times but if you're new to the channel i want you
00:37:19.840
to hear this too my prayer for roman catholic friends is not that rome is utterly removed
00:37:28.120
but that it is rather restored. I hope that Rome is restored. And I'll go further than that. Not
00:37:37.580
only is it my hope, not only is it my aim, not only is it my prayer, but it's also my inclination.
00:37:44.760
It's what I lean towards. I think that if I had to guess, if I were a betting man,
00:37:52.120
I believe that in the providence of God, that the schism between Protestants and Catholics,
00:37:59.180
that God would prefer to reconcile, repent. You can't reconcile apart from repentance.
0.62
00:38:06.560
There are some things Protestants must repent of, by the way, and some things that Catholics
0.97
00:38:10.900
must repent of. But when I think of the heart of God, the nature of God, and the providence and
00:38:17.480
plan of God, I believe it's more likely, if I were to guess, that God plans to reconcile rather than
00:38:24.720
utterly remove one or the other. I think that it is possible, not because Protestants are so great
00:38:33.180
and not because Catholics are so great, but because God is so great and exceedingly kind,
00:38:39.040
I believe that it is possible for God to restore even a 500-year-old rift. I believe in the power
00:38:46.220
of the gospel, and the gospel, which is the power of God unto salvation, the power and potency for
00:38:53.000
the gospel to change even massive, massive divides, and to heal even gaping wounds. I actually believe
00:39:03.960
that that's possible, but until that happens, and that should be our aim, and that's our prayer,
00:39:09.040
but until that happens then no on sunday that is the one day a week where those distinctions
00:39:16.480
absolutely persist those differences absolutely matter and we can't pretend that they don't
00:39:24.540
but monday through saturday those six days of the week that's when protestants and especially some
0.86
00:39:31.160
of the reformed autistic bros have to stop dressing up in costumes and larping and trying
0.55
00:39:37.660
to relive the Reformation. I don't want another Reformed five solos tulip conference. We have
1.00
00:39:46.820
been running it back with that every year from every Reformed ministry forever, forever, for
0.99
00:39:55.380
half a millennia. It's enough. Right now, that is not the main topic of conversation. Right now,
0.98
00:40:03.960
the main topic the most urgent issue that we should be thinking about monday through saturday
00:40:09.440
is will we still have a country will my kids grow up in america um will will there be an economy
00:40:18.160
in six months you know like what what is going on um mass deportations must happen mass arrest
00:40:27.320
must happen these are the things that we should be working towards politically and culturally
00:40:32.760
monday through saturday and we need to receive and welcome every fighting man we can get whether
00:40:40.820
he's protestant catholic or eastern orthodox but you have to if you're catholic you need a catholic
00:40:47.420
church if you're protestant you need a protestant church if you're eo you need an eo church one day
00:40:53.940
a week on sunday and it needs to be somewhere that you can drive your family to weekly to
00:41:00.500
participate in communion with the people of god in the church and if you don't have that if you
00:41:07.860
don't have that then you either have to plant it or you have to move those are your options
00:41:14.720
Antonio any thoughts no well said I would just you know call back to the that we talked about
00:41:19.140
the dimensionality of church membership and the pragmatism involved in that you can just think
00:41:25.220
you know a loose analogy uh you think about relationally just with a friend the the more
00:41:30.320
distinctives you overlook there are trade-offs um you know the the less things you could do with
00:41:35.280
the friend if they're not interested in you know half as many things as another friend that friend
00:41:39.600
has a limiter scope uh you know in terms of things that you guys could find unity in and so very
00:41:45.740
similarly as we talk about you know protestant denominations and then we look at eo and catholicism
00:41:51.120
in comparison, what we're saying is there's more distinctives. And as a consequence, there's more
00:41:55.880
trade-offs, there's more friction, there's more chafing. And at some point, those things, just
00:42:01.100
thinking pragmatically, start to outweigh any potential benefit you would get from the thing.
00:42:08.120
So even if we just think very pragmatically, my conscience would be violated, theologically
00:42:13.940
speaking, but would I even be as close to these people as I would in a Protestant church? Probably
00:42:18.360
not. There's more distinctives. There's more trade-offs. Conversations, the things that you do
00:42:23.840
outside of church in the way that, going back to Wes's point, that the extent to which the church
00:42:29.300
actually, any activities transition into the week, the other six days of the week,
00:42:35.860
those things become more limited. And so we're talking about robust church membership. We're
00:42:40.440
talking about, pragmatically speaking, just finding good relations in the church and building
00:42:46.720
a life to the extent that you can in the church, those things are going to be more limited if you
00:42:52.600
violate that sort of those clear traditional distinctives of Catholicism, EO, and Protestantism.
00:42:58.000
So that's how I think about it. I would say well said.
0.98
00:43:00.500
Yep, that's well said. All right, let's go to, like I said, we're going to spend some extra time
00:43:04.480
with the Super Chats today. Let's go to our final commercial break. Remember, if you have a question
00:43:09.680
or comment and you want it to be read live on the air, then send it in as a Super Chat.
00:43:14.440
We are seeing, if you're ever wondering, I always put myself in the position of the viewer,
00:43:21.620
if you're actually watching the video on YouTube or X or whatever.
00:43:25.300
If you're ever wondering, why are their eyes doing this?
00:43:29.260
Why are they like, is there a butterfly in the room?
00:43:33.880
Maybe a Nephilim or something that they're looking at.
00:43:37.020
We've got screens all over the room, and that's our way of being able to stay up with the chat.
00:43:43.760
sometimes i don't think you guys even care because we're talking about something and you guys are
00:43:47.740
just arguing about something that has literally nothing to do with the topic whatsoever
00:43:50.940
we don't take offense and it just sounded like i take offense i really don't take offense that's
00:43:56.440
fine um you know so sometimes you guys are having your own powwow and you probably don't care if
00:44:00.760
we're watching or not but every single live stream we are watching so your comments and your questions
00:44:06.760
your chat is not in vain however we simply don't have time to get to every comment and every
00:44:13.520
question there are tons of them and so what we decided you know a few months back is we've got
00:44:18.900
to prioritize the people who are supporting this ministry so the super chats that's kind of the
00:44:24.820
unspoken agreement is and sometimes we i mean we've stayed on here doing super chats for over
00:44:30.160
an hour because we're going to get to every single one they're going to get read live on the air so
00:44:35.260
if you have a comment or you have a question and you want it to be addressed and read live on the
00:44:40.280
air send it as a super chat if it's not a super chat we're reading it throughout the show but
00:44:45.500
we're not going to be able to have time to address it because at this point we just have too many
00:44:49.700
super chats so that's what we're going to do again one last time if you're watching on youtube
00:44:53.460
subscribe click the bell if you're watching on x make sure that you follow us and that you also
00:44:58.800
click the bell we'll go to our last commercial break we'll come back in just a couple minutes
00:45:03.120
and we'll start the super chats here we go when we think about what powers our modern world fighter
00:45:08.960
jets clean energy even the phone that's in your hand we rarely stop to ask the question what powers
00:45:15.840
are power see it all comes down to a handful of critical minerals and most of these minerals come
00:45:22.720
from overseas now that is a problem saga metals is working to fix this problem their mission
00:45:30.080
build a secure, independent future for North America by developing domestic sources of titanium,
00:45:37.440
lithium and uranium, the materials that our economy and defense depend on.
00:45:43.920
Their flagship project in Labrador, Canada spans 160 square kilometers with a 15,000 meter drill
00:45:52.640
program underway driving a potentially world-class titanium resource. Saga has also partnered with
00:46:00.720
global mining leader Rio Tinto, which can invest up to $44 million in Saga's lithium project,
00:46:08.340
a major vote of confidence. Now, Saga Metals trades publicly under SAGMF in the U.S. and
00:46:17.760
S-A-G-A, that's Saga, in Canada. With the race to secure supply chains heating up,
00:46:25.380
a company with assets like these won't stay under the radar for very long.
00:46:30.220
So learn more at SagaMetals.com. Again, that's SagaMetals.com.
00:46:42.160
The danger of centralized power is often represented by the word king.
00:46:52.800
is about helping people to have increased power
00:47:13.760
and in a republic, there is no king but Christ.
00:47:17.760
We are free craftsmen, and we are honored to be your armor spread of choice.
00:47:47.460
so insufferable so he's talking about eastern orthodox why are the ortho bros so insufferable
00:47:53.240
his wording not mine just for the record i'll start by tipping the hat give a little bit of
00:47:59.640
credence to the ortho bros on patriarchy fantastic they're pretty good i mean if we're doing i you
00:48:08.520
know there's always some you know bad apples in every bunch but if we were doing uh percentages
00:48:15.440
and we take every protestant church in america and then we take every eastern orthodox church
1.00
00:48:22.620
in america and we say how many what percentage of the protestant churches in america are feminists
00:48:30.360
and then we say what percentage of the eastern orthodox churches in america currently right now
00:48:35.580
today are feminists uh well the eastern orthodox guys the ortho bros as we you know charitably
00:48:43.320
refer to them they're going to eat our lunch what percent of churches had a woman preach on sunday
00:48:48.680
right protestants orthodox correct orthodox would be zero essentially if we also said
00:48:54.360
sadly if we said what percentage of protestant churches and that includes the main lines
00:48:59.720
have a rainbow flag out front on the building zero orthodox zero protestants a lot more than
00:49:08.680
we would like to admit and not zero if we say okay well maybe culturally they're a little bit
00:49:13.740
more conservative normie albeit but somewhat conservative uh but they're teaching uh prosperity
00:49:19.840
gospel health wealth you know word of faith joel osteen joyce meyer you know all these benny hen
00:49:25.960
um protestant pretty rough pretty rough so i wanted to say that just to give a little bit
00:49:33.500
of credence and honestly one more um the ortho bros a high percentage of them are not zionist
00:49:41.200
they are uh j-pilled as the kids say you know they're red-pilled on the israel question they
00:49:48.620
are not dispensationalist we'll just say that uh they the ortho bros have uh shown far more
00:49:55.340
resilience to the power of schofield than the protestants have at least modern protestants
00:50:00.600
in america today so give them a little bit of credence tip the hat where it's due uh that said
00:50:07.800
in terms of insufferability well i i'll speak for myself here um there's the behavior aspect
00:50:16.880
disposition and you know kind of the way that some of them not all but some of them conduct
00:50:22.440
themselves online uh but then also if we're saying just the positions and some of their
00:50:27.660
you know just the way that they think and and some of the things that they might emphasize
00:50:33.340
um getting a little bit more doctrinal so not just disposition you know the way they behave
00:50:38.320
themselves online but doctrinal their position um i'll speak to that second part their position
00:50:44.860
doctrinal um aside from some of the the clear theological distinctions that we would have
00:50:52.040
between Protestants and E.O. Geist, there's just a general sense in which Eastern Orthodoxy is
00:50:59.820
precisely that. It is Eastern. It is not Western. The divide from Augustine, you know, these kinds
0.71
00:51:06.120
of things. And so I think part of, you know, the bristling that, you know, both Protestants and
00:51:12.780
Catholics in the West feel when it comes to our Eastern Orthodox friends is this sense of it's
00:51:20.480
it's foreign to the west eastern orthodoxy is foreign to the west it is not western and uh and
00:51:27.900
and so that's there's there's uh i heard someone once say uh he he kind of he called it the the
00:51:34.840
mr miyagi complex and he said you know part of what's happened in the west because of the post
00:51:40.540
war consensus because of you know two world wars you know in the west brother wars you know
00:51:46.460
Christians fighting against Christians, Europeans fighting against Europeans, and all the
0.74
00:51:54.240
deracination that came about as a result of that, one of the premier elements that we face in the
00:52:03.680
West is fatherlessness. It's this profound sense of young men feeling estranged from any kind of
00:52:14.140
father figure and and especially not not just including but especially spiritual fathers and
00:52:21.240
so the mr miyagi complex is the idea that you know if you ever watch the karate kids you know
00:52:25.940
you've got typical white boy in the 90s or maybe it was the 80s i can't remember when the films
00:52:30.440
were made but in that time period 80s 90s typical white boy who has an absent you know he's he
00:52:38.040
doesn't have a father and uh and so what happens well thanks to the heart seller act you know
00:52:43.880
there's uh mr miyagi you know and and they cross paths and mr miyagi he fills the void he fills
00:52:51.920
that role of a father he teaches him discipline he teaches him self-defense he teaches him hard work
00:52:59.040
he teaches him patience and concentration and all those kinds of things that typically the father
00:53:04.980
would play that role but because the father is missing then there's this older you know ancient
00:53:11.720
wise asian man who fills the father role and i do think that there's some element of that in the
00:53:20.240
west because we're deracinated because we're severed from spiritual fathers in the west
00:53:26.460
because of clear compromise both from catholics and from protestants for decades and decades now
00:53:34.360
there we've been vulnerable and and so for there to be this um this strong masculine presence
00:53:42.340
it's eastern so it feels foreign on the one hand it's not western it's eastern but it's still it's
00:53:49.300
strong on patriarchy it's strong against zionism and against feminism and some of these things
00:53:55.740
and it's distinctly masculine and feels fatherly although it's foreign on the one hand it's fatherly
00:54:03.780
on the other. And when you have a bunch, I mean, you have an entire generation of Western young
00:54:10.620
men who feel fatherless, then that's going to be appealing. I don't think that it's the long-term
00:54:17.640
solution for the West. I don't. I'm not Eastern Orthodox. I don't know what to tell you. I'm just
00:54:23.120
not. So I don't think it's a long-term solution, but I can see why there has been not just a slight
00:54:30.040
tick up let's be let's be honest um it's still the minority report here in the west eastern
00:54:35.720
orthodoxy but if you look at it in terms of where you know where it was even just 10 years ago and
00:54:42.620
where it is today um eastern orthodoxy its presence in the west and here in these united states has
00:54:49.260
grown exponentially over the last decade and i think it's largely because of this fatherless issue
00:54:56.600
that I've been espousing. I think that if that changes, if Protestants and Catholics get it
0.95
00:55:04.380
together and start producing a strong masculine ethos that fills that fatherless void for young
0.73
00:55:13.080
men in those traditions, then you'll see Eastern Orthodoxy start to kind of file back because it
0.98
00:55:21.040
is again at the end of the day foreign to the western experience so why are eo bros insufferable
0.87
00:55:28.740
well disposition behavior online that yo guys i mean let's just be honest they live online they're
00:55:34.100
not touching grass very often they live online so anybody who lives online um will feel insufferable
00:55:41.960
from time to time aside from that in terms of not disposition behavior but position aside from the
00:55:48.360
clear theological distinctives. There's just the overarching sense that it's foreign. It's Eastern.
00:55:54.540
We are Western. And I think that's part of what makes it feel insufferable. But I think there's
0.98
00:55:59.480
a reason why, despite the foreign element, it's still grown as much as it has over the last
00:56:06.240
decade in the West. And it's because the West is currently fatherless. And the Mr. Miyagi complex
00:56:12.780
is real. So that's my answer. Ready to go to the next one?
00:56:16.440
I was going to say, churches that did good during COVID got a boost.
00:56:20.540
And Eastern Orthodoxy, I think, got a lot of that boost for coming up on four or five years since COVID.
0.58
00:56:27.540
Practically speaking, they are a very small percentage of churches in America.
00:56:35.600
They had a bit of a growth, but it seems to be tempering off.
00:56:38.580
And so we'll see how much staying power it has here.
00:56:45.560
homesteading sent five dollars thanks for the five bucks question what is your current view
00:56:50.720
on pedo baptism and what would convince you to switch baptize your babies versus don't
00:56:55.780
also how much do you list dislike minnesota um that's a great question i love minnesota
00:57:01.300
but i don't love somalia and so unfortunately you love minnesota cheese curds cold weather
00:57:08.280
minnesota like minnesota 50 years ago don't you know right does that count is that minnesota like
00:57:14.180
minnesota nice isn't that like literally a midwest nice yeah yeah yeah i'm down for that people are
00:57:20.660
nice to you but it's negative 30 degrees right well here's the deal though like let's be honest
00:57:25.140
all of america is getting rocked by immigration but the fact that minnesota has gotten rocked
00:57:32.020
a little bit more should we say than others it might be precisely because of the minnesota
00:57:36.780
niceness that made them so uniquely vulnerable. So, yeah, I think I would have enjoyed visiting,
00:57:44.240
not living, but visiting Minnesota 50 years ago, certainly not today. And the Minnesota niceness,
00:57:49.920
they might need to make some adjustments to that because it might be why Minnesota has become
0.92
00:57:55.120
Somalia. To answer the question, pedo, credo, those kinds of things, over the years, I have
00:58:01.820
evolved. Um, I'm not going to sit here and pretend like I haven't. Um, I get it. I get it. There was
00:58:08.060
a time, you know, if you'd asked me five years ago, I mean, I think pretty much everybody knows
00:58:12.940
that my, my public facing persona on this issue of baptism has been very, let's, I think we can
00:58:20.420
say very pedo friendly, very infant baptism friendly. Um, most of my relationships at this
00:58:27.880
point are with paedo baptist if not pretty much all of them uh so i've been very friendly for a
00:58:35.020
while that's not a recent development i'd say for the last four years um i've i've been um i've had
00:58:41.820
a lot of respect for presbyterians anglicans you know you fill fill in the blank um yes it is true
00:58:49.420
I have not personally officially made the switch, but what I will say is the older I get,
00:58:57.400
I'm never going to care about anything less than the Bible. But the older I get, I start to care
00:59:03.340
about other things in addition to the Bible, in addition to the Bible. And I understand, you know,
00:59:09.940
when people are biblicists, which sounds like a compliment, that sounds like a win, that is not
00:59:15.180
the w that you think it is biblicism is a problem right it's just me and my bible i'm not a calvinist
00:59:22.080
i'm a biblicist you know i'm not arminian i'm a biblicist i um you think that's a brag uh it's
00:59:28.800
it's actually not um this is what i've realized and it took me a while to to get there but over
00:59:34.800
the last few years i've said it a number of times i'll say it again everybody is confessional it's
00:59:39.720
not whether but which everyone has a confession it's either a tried and true historic confession
00:59:44.440
that stood the test of time that was comprised and written by better wiser men than you or
00:59:52.960
it's your own ad hoc confession that you're subconsciously writing in your head as you go
00:59:59.920
along through life but everyone has a confession you do it's either pastor fred's confession
01:00:04.820
you know whatever whatever he thinks in the moment in your you know independent fundamental
01:00:10.280
Baptist Church or it's the Westminster Confession or the LBC Confession or whatever. So everybody
01:00:19.800
is confessional. The question is just, is it a good confession? Is it an old confession? Is it
01:00:26.520
a well-reasoned confession? And so the more I grow and the more I look at history, not substituting
01:00:34.060
the Bible for history, but the more I look at history alongside the Bible, and I'm weighing
01:00:38.700
both of these the bible being the only infallible the only infallible arbiter of truth but history
01:00:45.520
although not infallible still waiting it's still waiting when the vast majority of the church held
01:00:52.100
one particular position over and against the other for centuries and centuries and centuries
0.74
01:00:57.180
to slough that off and pretend as though that's not significant is foolish and so when i look at
0.62
01:01:03.640
history and then also as i've begun to care more deeply about politics and when i look at
01:01:10.720
national bonds and i look at um a national conception of the polis you know um and i think
01:01:19.120
of the ways that uh that that pedo-baptism and and and and that particular scheme of covenant
01:01:26.440
theology incorporates the whole national polis. I get it. I get it. So have I officially switched
01:01:36.700
teams? No, I have not. Will I? I don't know. I don't have an answer for you guys. I don't plan
01:01:43.840
on it. But do I understand? Am I sympathetic? Do I have a sneaking suspicion in the back of my mind
01:01:52.320
that there are profound reasons for the paedo position. And yeah, yeah, of course I do. I want
01:02:00.440
Protestants ultimately to come out on top. America was a Protestant nation. I would like it to remain
0.86
01:02:06.580
that way. I don't know. I don't know if that's going to happen, but I hope that it does. I will
01:02:11.740
admit if it does, if Protestants win, I do think that it will be paedo baptism. I think it'll be
1.00
01:02:20.280
some version, some Paedo-Baptist version, be it Anglican or Presbyterian or something
01:02:25.880
that ultimately wins the day. I understand that the SBC is the largest Protestant denomination
01:02:32.400
in America, but we've talked about this before. I'll say it again. I think part of the reason
01:02:38.260
why Baptist churches are as prevalent in America as they are is because they fit within the
01:02:45.660
american spirit they honestly it's the perfect church version embodiment of the american spirit
01:02:54.060
but here's what i mean by that i don't mean the american spirit that you and i know and love
01:02:59.140
i mean the worst of the american spirit i mean the rebellious american spirit where everything
01:03:06.920
is atomized. Everything is individual. Everything is severed. Just me and my land and my guns.
01:03:16.800
No king here. We have no sovereign here. No one's in authority. Yeah, we've done that in America
01:03:24.800
for a couple centuries now. IQ has gone down. Lifespans have gone down. Drag queen story hour
01:03:32.340
has gone up. I don't, I mean, at what point can we say the verdict has come back in and that our
01:03:40.980
independent spirit might have just been a euphemism for a rebellious spirit? Americans
01:03:48.440
hate authority. And I think Baptists on the ecclesiastical side of the aisle embody that
1.00
01:03:56.960
particular element of the American spirit, namely a hatred of authority, better than pretty much
01:04:03.160
any Christian expression, any denomination in the nation. And I don't know if that's a good thing.
0.86
01:04:11.560
And when I look at Baptists as a whole, I have some great Baptist brothers who share a lot of
01:04:18.200
alignment with me. But if I look at Baptists on the whole, most Baptists are retarded. I mean,
1.00
01:04:25.540
even just like seriously i'm saying that you know um facetiously you know using the r word in in a
01:04:32.640
facetious way but honestly like even if we were to to use it in the technical sense if we if we
01:04:38.620
were to speak of that um i mean you you measure the average iq of the average baptist pastor and
01:04:47.680
then pair it up with the average iq of the average anglican pastor presbyterian pastor lutheran
01:04:53.300
pastor i mean guys that's just i love baptist i am a baptist but let's let's be honest um
01:05:00.940
baptist is kind of like uh i don't know it's it's kind of like the uh the lightweight
01:05:06.420
you know championship like who you know who's the best fighter under 100 pounds featherweight
01:05:12.060
you know featherweight championship um that's just that's what it is it's like it's it's kind
01:05:18.760
of a blue-collar anti-intellectualism, anti-authority, anti-partnership, anti-facts and
01:05:29.180
logic, anti-reason. I mean, it's just, it's not great. It's not great. And I'm willing to admit
01:05:36.700
it. And I pastor a Baptist church. I still hold to those convictions, but I'm at the point now
01:05:43.580
where the best answer I can give you to this question is, I'm certainly not going to fight
01:05:49.420
about it. I'm certainly not going to make that the centerpiece of my ministry and my theological
01:05:56.200
convictions. I'm not going to say, you know, Joel Webin, you know, what are the top, you know,
01:06:02.520
100 things that you're fighting for? Credo baptism would not make the list, not even the top 100.
0.98
01:06:10.280
it wouldn't make the list. And so I, and I think that's kind of, honestly, I think that's in line
0.99
01:06:17.120
with the whole title of this episode, the whole point of this episode. Mode of baptism is a
01:06:24.060
secondary theological issue because that's what we're talking about at the end of the day. People
01:06:29.180
will say, well, baptism, you know, that's primary. No, it's not because we're not talking about
01:06:33.220
baptism. We're talking about mode of baptism. It's mode of baptism. In every case, we are
01:06:42.020
assuming that we are baptizing someone with water in the name of the Father and of the Son and of
01:06:49.140
the Holy Spirit. So we're talking about a water baptism into the name of the triune God. A
01:06:57.080
christian church baptizing an individual with water into the name of the triune god we're like
01:07:04.720
we're not debating that we're not talking about some alternative to that so it's all within that
01:07:10.820
frame and then the question is simply is it immersion or is it pouring sprinkling is it
01:07:18.900
after conversion or after someone says they're converted i mean let's be honest how many baptists
01:07:26.160
have been baptized two, three, four, five, six times, right?
01:07:31.660
I mean, how many Baptist kids have been baptized every year
01:07:35.960
at their Christian camp, you know, summer camp?
01:07:41.380
and they're looking forward to their 12th baptism.
01:07:52.840
Baptists, honestly, I mean, let's just be honest.
0.81
01:07:55.180
Baptists probably baptize just as many unregenerate people as paedo-Baptists do,
0.60
01:08:02.880
if we're being honest. Now, I understand that intent still matters. The Baptist is at least
0.98
01:08:08.080
attempting to baptize a believer, whereas infant baptism, they're not, right? So I'm not going to
0.96
01:08:14.900
pretend that that difference doesn't exist in terms of the difference of intent. But my point
01:08:20.560
is its mode of baptism. It's not baptism wholesale. It's mode of baptism. Both are baptizing with
01:08:27.440
water. Both are baptizing someone that they believe is a part of the new covenant, right?
01:08:32.920
Whether it's their new covenant, but not yet regenerate, decretal elect versus just the new
01:08:38.840
covenant being broader, stretching broader than that. And both are, of course, baptizing into the
0.96
01:08:43.740
name of the triune God. And so because of those things, it is, whether people want to admit it or
01:08:49.800
not. It is a secondary theological issue. And because it's secondary and because I believe that
01:08:55.620
these arguments are the luxury of Christendom when it's victorious and not a luxury that we
01:09:03.920
can afford when Christendom is on the ropes, then it's just not going to be a major emphasis
01:09:25.460
be very friendly in my partnerships across the aisle,
01:09:50.460
Any examples of nations that went multicultural
01:09:52.760
that were able to regain their national identity?
01:10:03.020
I don't think it's, it's really tough to find in history
01:10:05.800
um a good example of what's happened in the west in the last century that's what i was going to say
01:10:11.520
globalism is what we're talking about yeah and has globalism been defeated before no because
01:10:17.020
we're talking about cultures so like russia for instance before and during the communist revolution
01:10:21.160
russia contained a number of different ethnicities and cultures right ukraine versus the northern
01:10:25.800
parts of russia there was distinct people that had distinct ways of life that all kind of shared a
01:10:30.140
country together but practically the difference between a ukrainian and someone in russia they
01:10:35.920
were much smaller right common ancestry typically common language common economy when we're talking
01:10:41.580
about and what cody's talking about here with multicultural uh is india and america and
01:10:46.720
honestly the only thing that has made that possible mass air travel global financial markets
01:10:51.220
and globalism those haven't been done before so i don't know of an example let alone in
01:10:55.940
and democracy democracy yep the incentive to import those people i don't think that that's
01:11:01.680
happened even the examples you could say for example like uh germany like practically speaking
01:11:05.720
immigration went low there's still 80 to 90 percent in german nobody's reached the point
01:11:09.760
where they're 60 50 percent of your founding stock is the only thing that's left after a
01:11:13.940
mass immigration a matter of a couple generations right it's just happened so quick and so
01:11:18.380
intentionally that it's really it's really difficult to find an analogy even a loose
01:11:22.800
analogy in history that we can, you know, learn from really. So, yeah, it's tough. I would say
01:11:30.260
as a matter of history, just generally speaking, the regaining of a national identity without scars
01:11:37.140
feels very unlikely to me. I mean, it's just as a matter of history, as history unfolds,
01:11:42.440
whatever emerges out of this multicultural West that we have will be distinct if only because
01:11:48.620
it's scarred by multiculturalism itself, it will feel distinct from the national identities that
01:11:55.600
were previous to the sort of globalistic regime. And so it's really tough to know what that will
01:12:01.900
look like. But I'm white-pilled. I think what we're doing and a lot of what we talk about is
01:12:08.140
actually kind of trying to articulate what that recapture would look like. There's no great
01:12:12.740
playbook for it and so we really are in a lot of in a lot of ways thinking on our feet as as as the
01:12:18.980
consequence and one other thing i'll just say is that i've i've i have a sense that the consequences
01:12:24.060
of globalism haven't even fully materialized yeah again because it's so new we are like daily
01:12:29.960
things are popping up that that it's like oh okay that's another terrible case in point of why this
01:12:37.980
system is terrible so so we're thinking on our feet we're trying to figure out what the what
01:12:41.720
what these problems are what exactly we're trying to fight and so it's it's going to be tough to
01:12:46.520
to look in history and find some some playbook yeah you're right i can think of one historical
01:12:52.420
example where everybody tried to be you know in one place the same place and you know and partner
01:13:01.340
together um and and not be distinct and not spread out um and it would be the tower of babel
01:13:09.580
that's kind of the example that i think of god hated it god judged them for it uh confused their
01:13:16.940
languages made the distinctions exasperated to the point where they could not stay together
01:13:23.700
even if they tried and my my prediction would be that something similar would happen um not in a
01:13:32.020
supernatural or preternatural sort of way uh but but a providential sort of way i think that um
01:13:39.300
um i think that uh that you know that that we will you know mankind failed the first time
01:13:46.740
in its attempt to build a tower that stretched to the heavens that rivaled god to make a name
01:13:52.500
for himself so that he would not be scattered over the face of the earth um it failed the first time
01:13:57.920
and i think it'll fail this time as well i mean what we're living in in the west is basically
01:14:03.900
just a modern um modern tower of babel we we have essentially um humored ourselves into thinking that
01:14:12.580
our advancements in technology somehow um can overcome natural distinctions um to the point
01:14:20.980
where we no longer have to have distinct nations and distinct peoples and uh that we can you know
01:14:28.520
this time it's a digital tower, you know, whether it's, you know, uh, AI or whatever,
01:14:33.780
fill in the blank, but we're doing it again. We're building a tower, um, and saying, Hey,
01:14:38.260
we can all be in the same place and do the same thing all together. And I think we're already
01:14:44.760
finding that, uh, that it's, that it doesn't work. And, um, and I think ultimately the tower will
01:14:51.500
collapse. The question is, uh, you know, this time, what will become of the people? Will, uh,
01:14:57.420
will the people be dispersed in God's kindness? Because the Tower of Babel was a judgment,
0.95
01:15:03.060
but it was a judgment wrapped around a mercy. There was a kindness there because there's two
0.52
01:15:11.240
options really of what could happen. God in his kindness can disperse the people and then the
01:15:17.460
tower falls later. Or God can not disperse the people. They can remain there, be determined in
01:15:26.400
their hubris to build this tower that rivals god to make a name for themselves and the tower
01:15:32.760
collapses while they're still all a part of this building project and the people are destroyed
01:15:37.820
with it and so that's that's my question is just um will we destroy ourselves with ai or this that
01:15:47.100
or the other with you know the the next babble project uh that globalism is trying to accomplish
01:15:53.540
or will the distinctions, the natural distinctions that God has set,
01:15:58.520
will they prove to be insurmountable to the point that we'll give up the project
01:16:04.140
and everyone goes their own way and separates once more,
01:16:10.040
goes home and abandons the project but at least spares their life?
01:16:18.380
But that third option of we come together, we stay together, we build a tower,
01:16:26.560
I can guarantee you that that will not be the result.
01:16:52.720
kind of living under one banner, one national banner, you could say. And I think just the
01:16:58.600
reality of it, and the Tower of Babel is a great biblical example of it, is that when you try to
0.85
01:17:03.960
artificially bring together ethnic groups, what you're doing is fighting against nature.
0.92
01:17:09.600
It truly is like fighting gravity, like you're launching a rocket, and you have to expend so
0.97
01:17:15.420
much energy to pull these people together. And at some point in history, and we see this in
01:17:20.800
history, you just see fragmentation. It's just like, oh, can't hold it together anymore. And if
01:17:25.660
I had to go and make a prediction, and I'm not saying in the short term, this could be 50 years,
01:17:29.220
it could be 100 years, I think what you're looking, sadly, and this isn't exactly what I want,
01:17:34.260
but I think what we're up against in the West, and particularly here in the United States,
01:17:37.940
is geographic fragmentation. I think just having, you know, this massive land mass where it's one
01:17:44.160
nation and all of these different ethnic distinctives living in it, even if you just
01:17:48.040
think about the white population you think about the midwest you think about the south and the
01:17:51.880
east coast uh they're distinct and so it's it just as time progresses it's going to be increasingly
01:17:57.320
hard even to hold these groups together um and so that's just that's my prediction i think that's
01:18:03.040
probably the likely conclusion of this um but uh but again it's a it's a something we're figuring
01:18:08.420
out day to day year to year yep all right uh located goose he gave us another ten dollar
01:18:14.260
super chat we appreciate that he said please speak more to how we are to honor our parents
01:18:18.500
i have a mother-in-law who actively schemes to drive my wife's heart to discontentment i need
01:18:25.080
to make stronger boundaries but i want to honor her well that's a good a good sentiment that you
01:18:30.560
want to honor her but also a good sentiment that you need some boundaries if she is disrupting the
01:18:36.680
unity of your marriage then that's a problem we will do more of that in the future i think that
01:18:41.000
That was a hit that a lot of people were blessed by that.
01:18:50.240
I believe just on Wednesday, our last live stream.
01:18:56.020
I think I probably spent 20 minutes or so on it.
01:19:03.100
I don't want to hit it again right afterwards today.
01:19:09.420
so it would have been during the third segment with the super chats and one other thing that
01:19:13.500
i think we could do is um perhaps uh nathan and john um on our our tech side with right response
01:19:22.940
ministries maybe they could clip that out just so that it's a it's a video that stands alone and we
01:19:29.180
could we could post that on youtube and x maybe over the weekend or on monday early next week
01:19:35.900
week just so that it's more accessible and easier to find and hopefully it gets more views and more
01:19:42.180
people see it so maybe if we give that a catchy thumbnail and a catchy title and just make it its
01:19:47.620
own standalone 20 minute video but I definitely covered I was pretty thorough covered a lot of
01:19:53.000
bases and so is there more to say on the topic absolutely but because I was pretty thorough and
01:20:00.100
we did it just on Wednesday I don't want to dive in for another 20 minutes on it today
01:20:04.920
but we'll hit the topic I'm sure again in the future because that is an issue that is sadly
01:20:11.480
not going away. So our next one is from Anfuan. He gave us $5. We appreciate that. He said the
01:20:17.520
easiest question. I was reading the head here. This one is I think really insightful. So first
01:20:22.860
let me just say Anfuan you nailed it. This is really well said. I'll read it. Here we go.
01:20:28.540
The easiest question to snuff out fake America first politicians. Guys because guys are going
0.86
01:20:34.800
to start using it in the same way that never trumpers all of a sudden became maga when they
01:20:39.340
could you know see which direction the wind was was blowing you know and like um you're gonna see
01:20:45.000
it you're gonna see it with america first i think america first is going to replace uh maga and so
01:20:51.780
you will see the opportunist all of a sudden who are fighting it tooth and nail every step of the
01:20:56.240
way uh as soon as it gets the upper hand and it becomes clear that america first is inevitable
01:21:04.360
then the same guys who were completely opposing the movement
01:21:09.120
will turn around, run out in front of the movement,
01:21:21.020
How will you be able to discern who is America First in name only?
01:21:28.640
the best question to ask to snuff out fake America first politicians is simple. Do they
01:21:35.460
think the crucifixion of our Lord was worse than the Holocaust? I think that's well said.
1.00
01:21:42.800
Yeah. Was it Andrew Clavin who recently went semi-viral for a clip where he was basically
01:21:49.840
talking about how the Holocaust was another crucifixion? He said it a little tongue-in-cheek.
01:21:56.480
he came back and clarified later and kind of gave a little bit of a disclaimer but he said something
01:22:01.040
to the effect of the holocaust in Auschwitz they were kind of a reenactment in case you missed it
01:22:06.220
the first time and crazily enough john piper even said that back in the day in an article
01:22:10.560
on Auschwitz that something that it was very similar to the crucifixion that's because it
01:22:15.720
at this point has become a religious conviction yeah it's not just uh history or facts it is a
01:22:21.800
religiously held idea and uh that question the second someone pauses or they have to kind of
01:22:28.500
repeat it a second time slowly while they gather their thoughts oh yeah not okay have you seen the
01:22:33.520
viral video of the i think it was a jewish rabbi who said something the effect of they killed
0.78
01:22:38.060
one jew you should think the holocaust is way worse because they killed well and and not just
01:22:43.580
that he said i i know exactly what you're talking about with some some rabbi um who said he basically
0.94
01:22:50.300
he said uh not just the holocaust but even in in a present tense that it's ongoing and continual he
01:22:57.140
said uh he said christians should have no problem you know christians should love jews you know they
01:23:01.620
should be you know they should be the most pro-israel people in the world because he said
01:23:06.040
after all you worship a jew who saved you the christians by his blood and he said but the
01:23:13.340
reality is that that jews are dying and bleeding every day to save you and the point that he was
01:23:20.440
making is basically uh it's like you hear that it's blasphemous right he's like he basically is
01:23:26.500
equating every single jewish person to the status of our lord and savior jesus christ the son son
01:23:32.140
of god saying you're not just saved by the blood of jesus the god man but you're saved by jews and
0.77
01:23:40.300
But every day, Jews are bleeding to save you.
1.00
01:23:49.240
the hottest place in hell reserved for this man
1.00
01:24:00.040
I hate to even repeat it because it's so blasphemous.
01:24:07.480
yes he said we're saving you should be worshiping us right but the final thing i wanted to add to
01:24:13.020
that so you're right that that happened uh crazy but that happened love it um but but the final
01:24:18.200
point i wanted to make is is blasphemous as that is um let's be honest that it it really wasn't
01:24:26.100
that unique when i thought about it when i when i reflected at first it was just kind of shock
01:24:30.160
like i can't believe he said this uh but when i thought about it in retrospect a little bit more
01:24:35.320
I realized this is actually the position. They wouldn't use those words, those who at least
01:24:42.680
profess to be Christian. Guys who profess to be Christian typically know better than to use those
01:24:49.660
words, unless you're Andrew Clavin. But they wouldn't put it in those words, so it wouldn't
01:24:56.580
be as blasphemous on its face. But the concept, the principle, is actually, I would say, it's the
01:25:04.060
majority report it is it is the general consensus of of every zionist dispensational christian
01:25:13.500
every neocon conservative christian and what i mean by that is it you tell me if i'm crazy but
01:25:20.940
isn't the general consensus on the political side so they want to put it into they want to
01:25:26.340
throw jesus in there and say every jew is like just as great as jesus and blah blah they want
01:25:31.140
to use as much of the religious language but politically speaking um they absolutely the
01:25:36.840
average the average zionist gop conservative republican who claims to be a christian
01:25:43.320
spiritually religiously um will constantly use this line of reasoning they'll say the reason why
01:25:49.700
america must must not abandon our greatest ally israel is because israel is sacrificing for us
01:25:58.140
Israel is on the front lines in the Middle East holding the Muslims at bay like they literally
0.66
01:26:06.020
they they they speak as though imagine like you know like it's Gondor or something like that you
0.99
01:26:12.040
know or or Helm's Deep you know and just being attacked by this hordes of orcs and and they
01:26:19.620
basically act as though the inner circle the inner city is the West America you know France
01:26:27.740
england um but the gates the gates is uh israel and the only reason we don't have
01:26:35.820
more islamic presence in the west and more islamic conflict in the west and we'll just
01:26:44.500
say america because we're in america is because um it's being mitigated at the source in the
01:26:51.280
middle east by israel um but that is that is just so far from the truth just a little bit of research
01:26:59.800
uh and and what you'll see i'm just gonna say it i'm just gonna say it in every single time
01:27:05.220
situation here um there are two types of jews there are conservative jews that are you know
01:27:13.620
if they're here in america you know they would be part of the gop they would vote republican those
01:27:18.260
And same thing in Israel. There are conservative Jews and there are liberal Jews. But this is how
01:27:23.440
the two work in tandem. Conservative Jews start wars in the Middle East with Muslim nations that
0.92
01:27:32.660
disenfranchise them and cause them to have to leave. Then liberal Jews in the West,
0.87
01:27:40.980
holding political office, congressmen, senators, whatever, lawmakers in America,
0.99
01:27:46.460
they then write the policies and get them enacted to then take all these Muslim displaced refugees
1.00
01:27:54.040
into our Western countries. So conservative Jews displace Muslims in the Middle East.
0.84
01:28:00.980
Liberal Jews open the doors of Toledo to let the Muslims in to the West. Israel is not mitigating
0.92
01:28:09.100
the Muslim invasion in America. Israel is facilitating the Muslim invasion in America.
0.99
01:28:18.060
So one, it's just politically, factually false on its face that Israel is a great ally that merits
0.99
01:28:26.780
our support because they're helping us face the Muslim problem on the ground at the front gate
0.95
01:28:34.140
in the Middle East before it gets to us. No, they're actually causing it to get to us faster
1.00
01:28:40.180
and in greater numbers. So it's first wrong like that. And even if they were right,
01:28:46.420
even if they were mitigating Muslim Islamic invasion in the West to compare, therefore,
0.79
01:28:53.620
Jews and their sacrifice and some of those who have died, October 7th, whatever it is,
01:28:58.380
to the blood of Jesus that actually eternally saves men from hell saves them from their sin
0.65
01:29:05.080
and say well you worship one Jew why not worship all Jews because Jesus isn't the only Jew who
0.56
01:29:11.240
bled and died to save you there are Jews who are bleeding and dying to save you every day
01:29:16.160
well that is not only factually wrong so I already said politically why it's wrong well that's just
0.96
01:29:22.000
saying hey since we're already politically and historically wrong about Jews and the way that
0.96
01:29:26.560
they serve western countries uh well let's go ahead and be wrong spiritually as well with a
0.95
01:29:31.380
just a dash of blasphemy on top um and just you know like why not just be shameless and uh and
01:29:39.280
just atrocious in our rhetoric so um that's one of those situations where i gotta say i absolutely
01:29:45.180
hate it absolutely hate it um that will not be tolerated um and if that makes me anti-semitic
01:30:22.760
America first. Amen. Amen to that. Next one, Wild Card sent $2 and says, thank you for your
0.99
01:30:30.180
ministry. And then there's a chat attached here that says, I'm in the Bible belt, but all the
01:30:35.140
churches in my area seem to be beholden to the modern world. For instance, every church closed
01:30:40.260
down for COVID. My question with that would be how long? How long? To close down for COVID at all,
01:30:49.160
I think was a failure. And I've said this publicly several times, which I think is one of the reasons
01:30:55.100
why people are willing to follow this ministry. Not because I'm right about everything all the
01:31:00.520
time, but because sadly, the distinction between pastors and politicians, the line between pastors
01:31:09.360
and politicians is virtually, doesn't even exist these days, right? If that was a Venn diagram,
01:31:15.740
you got politicians on one side and then you got pastors on the other that's just a circle
01:31:19.760
and what I mean by that is both pastors modern pastors and modern politicians one thing
01:31:27.120
common denominator that both of them do relentlessly is they never ever ever admit
01:31:33.660
when they're wrong they will actually change they'll change with public sentiment they'll
01:31:37.800
change not with the science but with the political science so as the winds change they will change
01:31:44.140
um but when they change they they'll just like face like flint they'll never admit it and they'll
01:31:51.660
just they'll just they'll do it and do it and and never admit the change until until you and i just
0.98
01:32:00.240
forget you know and um and i i hate that i hate treating people as though they're so stupid that
0.92
01:32:07.700
they can't recognize hey you know you might have noticed that uh what i'm saying today is the exact
0.99
01:32:13.480
opposite of what I said three years ago or five years ago or whatever. And I find that disgusting.
01:32:21.540
And so my point is, with those churches, I would encourage you, one, how long did they close? I
01:32:29.440
think to close it all was a mistake. But one of the reasons people follow me is because I've been
01:32:35.120
willing to admit my mistakes. And here it is, one of my mistakes. Granted, we were in California
01:32:40.020
at the time, pastoring a church there. There were extra restrictions. It was one of the most
01:32:46.220
difficult states to be in during the COVID lockdowns. But at the end of the day, I have to
01:32:51.020
admit that's still no excuse. We shut down our church for four weeks. So one, I would ask how
01:32:58.380
long did they shut down their church? 11 months, year and a half, or four weeks? There is a
01:33:04.960
difference. Both are wrong, but not equally wrong. Second, and this one's even bigger, bigger than
01:33:10.840
how long did you shut down during COVID? A bigger one is when you reopened, was there ever any public
01:33:17.640
acknowledgement from the pastor that he did the wrong thing, that he messed up? Because my first
01:33:25.480
sermon, when we reopened after closing for only four weeks in California, and we got kicked out
01:33:30.340
of our building. But here's the deal. We could have met in the field. We could have made it
01:33:36.740
happen. So it's not just we couldn't make it happen. I'd love to say that. I'd love to say
01:33:41.880
that. I'd love to say I did no wrong. But here's the deal. More than having people respect me,
01:33:47.060
you know what I really want, life goal, really want? To not go to hell. That's what I really
01:33:52.160
want. Like Joel Webbins, greatest life goal, not going to hell, which means at the end of the day,
01:33:57.580
if I lose respect from people, what I can't afford to lose is God's good graces. What I
01:34:03.440
can't afford to lose is a clear conscience before the Lord. And so I have to just call a spade a
01:34:08.560
spade and I have to admit my mistakes if I actually made them. The reality is that we didn't have a
01:34:14.200
church building. We were renting from a public school. We got kicked out of our space. There's
01:34:17.500
all these things. But if I had resolve and I had pure conviction and I made the right decision
01:34:28.260
from the start, then we would have found a way to do church if it was in somebody's home,
01:34:33.120
if it was in somebody's backyard, if it was in a field. But we still closed down for four weeks
01:34:38.800
because I was wrong. But here's the deal. By God's grace and only by God's grace is not to boast in
01:34:46.500
me, when we did reopen my first sermon to the church, the first half of it was me apologizing
01:34:55.280
for making the wrong decision and using the scripture, using the scripture and preaching
01:35:02.100
a sermon from the scripture to explain why the decision to close our church for four weeks
01:35:09.140
was a sinful decision, why it was the wrong decision. And so that would be my question.
01:35:15.440
As you're looking at churches, I mean, your overarching point is well taken, and you're right.
01:35:22.960
The church in general is just modern, limp-wristed, effeminate, and compromised. Absolutely.
01:35:30.380
But if you're using as your sole metric for making that assessment, how churches, local churches in
01:35:38.240
your area responded specifically to COVID and just a pass-fail system of did they close or did they
01:35:44.540
not. And well, they all closed. So therefore, all of them are faithless. I would add a little
01:35:50.740
nuance to that. And I would say they all closed. So therefore, yes, they all sinned. They all missed
01:35:56.320
it. They all messed up. But then the question is, for the Christian, is not if he's sinless,
01:36:02.980
if he never messes up, but does he repent? And the same context where the failure occurred is
01:36:09.740
the same context where the repentance must occur. So to shut down the church is a public failure.
01:36:16.380
It's not a private failure behind closed doors. You publicly failed. And so therefore, when you
01:36:23.500
right the ship, when you fix the mistake, your repentance needs to be public. So when those
01:36:32.140
churches reopened, that would be the repentance in action, in deed. We closed, that was the wrong
01:36:38.440
action. We're opening. That's the right action. But true repentance is both in the same context
01:36:44.360
where the sin occurred. So if it's a public sin, like closing the church, it needs to be a public
01:36:49.500
repentance. And if it's true repentance, it also must be repentance in deed and in word.
01:36:55.860
Deed and in word. So not just shifting on a dime, pivoting on a dime in terms of the action. The
01:37:02.520
action we close the church now the action is we open the church but also saying it say it say it
01:37:09.840
don't just change your actions when you realize that you know public sentiment is shifting you
01:37:15.480
know and and the opinion the consensus is changing but also name it and say hey guys you might notice
01:37:22.540
um that four weeks ago four months ago whatever it was we sent out an email and said we're not
01:37:28.540
having church for this reason and that reason and that reason. And today we are having church
01:37:32.640
and that's the complete opposite decision. And I'm not going to sit here and treat you all as
01:37:39.020
though you're stupid, that you can't comprehend that we did one thing and we're now doing the
1.00
01:37:44.460
exact opposite. I'm going to give you a little more respect than that. You might notice we're
1.00
01:37:49.600
doing the complete opposite. So here's why. Here's an easy way to reconcile these two
01:37:54.920
directly contradicting decisions. The way to reconcile it is this. One decision was wrong.
01:38:01.180
I was wrong. This decision is right. Please forgive me. That's all it takes. That's all it takes.
01:38:10.120
Walk in the light as he is in the light. We will have fellowship with one another, and the blood
01:38:14.680
of Jesus Christ, his son, will cleanse us from all sin. That's 1 John 1, verse 7. Notice, to walk in
01:38:23.540
the light is not to walk in sinless perfection. No one achieves sinless perfection in this life.
01:38:29.500
Only Jesus was truly sinless. To walk in the light is to walk exposed, to walk honestly,
01:38:36.900
to walk truthfully. So it's not walking without any faults. It's walking in such a way that we
01:38:43.660
still sin, but we're honest with our faults. But notice the result. If, right, there's a condition.
01:38:49.180
if we walk in the light as he is in the light, then what's the result? Then we have fellowship
01:38:55.000
with one another. One of the major hindrances of unity and relationship and fellowship
01:39:01.800
is the refusal to walk in the light, which is a refusal to repent, a refusal to apologize,
01:39:10.100
a refusal to be honest about our faults. So I would be looking not, I would not make my standard,
01:39:17.420
it must be a church that never closed down at all i would make my standard well is it a church that
01:39:23.040
closed down for a year or for a couple months there is a difference there and then the biggest
01:39:27.980
question is and when they reopened what did they say did they ever own it did they ever admit that
01:39:35.300
they messed up hey that guy admitted it i would follow you all the way to mordor um that that's
01:39:42.660
a guy that i'll fall i will follow a a flawed man who is a humble and honest man so look for that
01:39:51.240
now if you can't even find that in your area then see point a all the way back to the beginning of
01:39:56.680
this episode then you either got to plant a church but only if you're biblically qualified to do so
01:40:01.540
and if you're not and don't feel called to do that then you have to relocate your family to find a
01:40:08.400
church somewhere else because the third option of being churchless is not an option you are not
01:40:14.680
permitted by god to be a lone ranger christian you must participate in the body of christ and you
01:40:21.800
have to make it happen one way or another all right let's read the next one all right we have
01:40:26.600
20 super chats still left oh my goodness okay we'll go fast hhs 9045 what is your advice to
01:40:51.140
If you're in that denomination, you're a pastor in that denomination,
01:41:01.020
those organizations they probably are not where right response is you're sitting here listening
01:41:05.500
i'm assuming you probably align more with us than like a tom hicks would for example so as much as
01:41:10.240
possible i think stay on topic church preaching administering the sacraments being reformed
01:41:15.640
baptists doing reformed baptist things and then outside of that any political or business
01:41:20.180
aspirations that you have yeah yep okay uh next one antonio chase uh cormick sent ten dollars and
01:41:27.340
says, how important are the congregants of the church you attend as far as influence and possible
01:41:32.440
suitors for young adult children? So this is something I think we've talked about doing a
01:41:37.660
further deep dive on in terms of arranged marriages, what that has looked like historically,
01:41:45.040
and what that would look like today. Obviously, it's not a common thing today, but it's certainly
01:41:52.800
something that we we talk about church the church you attend the church you want to move to that
01:41:57.740
being a consideration who are my children going to marry are children being raised up in this church
01:42:02.700
that I I can respect and I see their development and I see how they're parented and all of these
01:42:08.500
things are things that you should consider in terms of the church that you attend and the the
01:42:14.200
kinds of people that make up the church and so but I think well I think we'd like to do a deeper
01:42:19.000
dive on this and what specific applications there would be for so many people who are asking this
01:42:24.760
very question. Yeah, absolutely. But the short answer is it's extremely important. But what I'll
01:42:31.040
say is that it's kind of like a chicken or the egg situation. Like one leads to the other. And
01:42:36.340
what I mean by that is if the church and its leadership are courageous and solid, then they
01:42:43.680
will attract a congregation uh they will attract families um that's that are like-minded so um if
01:42:52.300
you find a church because this is what i hear from people all the time it's like well my pastors are
01:42:56.820
kind of cowardly and compromised and this that and the other but there's some great people in the
01:43:00.700
church guys i gotta be honest um there's not um and this is what i mean by that um i know those
01:43:12.060
guys. I know those guys personally, and I don't mean the pastors. I mean the congregants who are
01:43:15.980
great congregants in the church, despite the fact that their pastor's a limp.
01:43:22.920
Your great, courageous men, church men, not pastors, but the congregants themselves,
01:43:30.600
do not tolerate, maybe for a season, they do not sit there year after year after year,
0.99
01:43:37.060
leading their wives and children to a limp-wristed church with an effeminate libtard pastor. They
0.99
01:43:44.680
don't do it. And so what I've found is that, well, you know, the pastors aren't great, but the
01:43:49.160
congregants really are. What I found is that those great, courageous congregants, even the
01:43:54.880
congregants themselves, when they're pressed and pressed and pressed, turns out that they haven't
01:44:00.880
actually just been tolerating that pastor. They've been comfortable in that church because they
01:44:05.140
actually are like that pastor they themselves have far more in common with that liberal pastor
01:44:11.540
than maybe they're willing to admit it might seem a little spicy or courageous from time to time on
01:44:17.140
x and the social media platforms but push comes to shove the reason why they've been willing
01:44:23.420
they've been content to be a part of a church with a liberal leadership for again not just talking
01:44:30.220
about a few months but for years in those cases is because they themselves are given over to more
01:44:36.160
liberalism than they may even be aware of so all that said the congregants of a church the caliber
01:44:42.920
of the congregants not just the leaders it matters immensely however if you find a church with the
01:44:47.820
right leaders the congregants will follow next fraternity of benjamin sent five dollars thank
01:44:53.840
you i'm assuming benjamin for those of us with ties and roots in a particular region of the u.s
01:44:59.320
How would you recommend finding the closest churches that won't longhouse us?
01:45:07.780
I think one way is to look for men that are standing out and speaking up on social media.
01:45:11.860
So you see a pastor that preaches a good sermon or went to his courthouse, look up where he pastors.
01:45:17.100
And eventually, I mean, there's people, Joel, that like they've watched you for six months and all of a sudden they're like, holy cow, I live 20 minutes away from him.
01:45:24.340
so don't let a pastor go by someone who's speaking someone who in their bio for example says that
01:45:29.720
they're a pca minister don't look at someone that's being brave standing out speaking out
01:45:34.020
and say uh and just go ah maybe he ministers somewhere keep saying does he live near me
01:45:39.540
does he preach near me is he an hour away could i make the drive that would be the best bet i think
01:45:44.040
yep yeah yeah you're right on social media the people that you are following that are ministers
01:45:50.000
look into it you might be surprised oh my goodness I've been following this guy
01:45:54.900
benefiting from his x account or whatever his podcast and I just never took the time to see
01:46:00.440
where he lives but it turns out he passes a church 30 minutes away many such cases all right
01:46:05.320
next one Antonio yep uh located goose and another five dollars and says how should I view the
01:46:10.660
salvation of catholic and EO family members based on the doctrine they confess how much grace is
01:46:16.480
there in error salvifically it's a great question uh we've answered this before a short answer for
01:46:23.700
the sake of time because we've got a lot of super chats today is um there's a difference between
01:46:29.620
catholicism and catholic there's a difference between the catholics themselves and the doctrine
01:46:36.160
of rome catholicism and so uh keep that in mind um and and i'm not just picking on the catholics
01:46:42.900
the same for Protestants. But the actual people, the actual Protestants versus Protestantism,
01:46:50.060
you know, or the actual Catholics versus Catholicism, very often, it is very common
01:46:55.800
that there is quite a difference between the two. There are many Catholics that I have had
01:47:04.100
conversations with over the years that aren't even aware of all the doctrines of Rome. You ask
01:47:13.180
them, hey, do you believe that you're a Christian? Do you believe you're saved? Yes. Then you ask
01:47:19.260
them, why? And as they begin to answer that question, why? It's usually a fairly simple
01:47:26.440
answer well i'm saved because jesus christ the son of god died for my sin and i have faith in him
01:47:34.480
you know what i mean so um i i think there's a way that we can main my point is and i think
01:47:40.920
that's a charitable way of kind of walking the tightrope on this very controversial issue
01:47:47.800
is um doing your best to bifurcate between the doctrines themselves and the people catholicism
01:47:55.860
and Catholics. I've said it before. I say it kind of tongue-in-cheek, but I do actually believe this
01:48:00.940
is the case. I believe that there are many Catholics, many Catholics who are genuinely
01:48:09.740
saved going to heaven because I believe that there are many bad Catholics.
0.98
01:48:14.840
that's that's my opinion i the average catholic that i talk to is um is not beholden to they're
0.96
01:48:25.660
not um they're not holding to the council of trent they're not uh familiar with with every
01:48:33.340
single tenant of mariology um they're catholic despite those things they're catholic like their
01:48:39.480
main motive for even being catholic is they were born into the catholic church their family has
01:48:44.920
always been catholic there's familial reasons historic reasons cultural reasons and then you
01:48:50.760
know beyond that it's because the catholic church feels old it feels tried it feels true
01:48:58.360
and they're they're looking for something they've chosen catholicism not over historic protestantism
01:49:03.560
with a an objective analysis they've chosen catholicism because when they think of a
01:49:09.000
a protestant church they they just think of the average shoebox mega church um you know it's
01:49:15.820
meeting in a strip mall with you know laser lights and fog machines you know and so that's
01:49:21.660
what they're comparing it to and that's why they've made the decision that they have and i think that
01:49:26.520
all that needs to be considered okay next sean sent five dollars and says big fan of the show
01:49:34.480
i'm a 27 year old male in cleveland ohio grok told me that it's likely the end times will happen
01:49:40.960
in my lifetime thoughts grok said it it's you gotta take that to the bank run for the hills
01:49:46.800
yeah uh that's that's actually funny um i think in general i think ai you know tells you what you
01:49:53.560
want to hear i you know so and it's pulling from the sentiment of the time so christian evangelical
01:49:59.540
sentiment right seems like it right exactly just keep in mind that um you know artificial general
01:50:06.220
intelligence like we have narrow ai that's what we have we're talking about um a very very very
01:50:12.280
fast and thorough search engine but it is not sentient it is not thinking so grok is not
01:50:19.980
thinking and telling you you know it's it's personal you know conclusions grok is just
01:50:25.600
searching the internet like really all i've heard people say it this way and i think it's well said
01:50:31.340
i think you might have said this antonio but all uh all ai is doing is plagiarizing
01:50:37.340
uh at a high level uh quickly yep thoroughly plagiarizing um and so if grok told you that
01:50:46.000
really the way you should interpret it is um this is the general consensus currently among
01:50:53.420
people that i follow in the broader social sphere so if you follow a bunch of evangelicals and then
01:51:00.520
gives you that answer your conclusion should be evangelicals think that jesus is coming back in
01:51:05.560
my lifetime yeah i think this is a quick 10 second aside on ai but if you're interested i think apple
01:51:11.240
just published a paper on ai and what they found is uh their finding was that ai cannot reason
01:51:16.620
and it's nowhere clear close to being able to reason and what they did was uh they created
01:51:21.440
new problems so uh they created problems that wouldn't be on the internet that ai wouldn't
01:51:26.040
have seen before and been able to interpret and use to answer um and uh it did terrible so if you
01:51:31.900
give if you give ai an lsat it's going to have seen the question or a question like it before
01:51:36.480
and it's going to do pretty well it's all pattern recognition and probabilistic sort of uh answers
01:51:41.960
but it's it isn't a reasoning like you said sentient uh being that should we should place
01:51:49.180
any reasonable amount of trust in yep well said all right fraternity of benjamins he gave us
01:51:54.160
another five dollars he said i know georgetown and i know ogden are there any other churches
01:51:59.640
or networks or denominations that you would recommend for finding like-minded brothers across
01:52:04.880
the nation um ogden and georgetown would be two of uh i think um our favorites uh we we are
01:52:14.060
georgetown so that's a little bit biased um georgetown texas if you're looking for a church
01:52:18.820
that's where we're at it's north of austin um i think those are two of the best uh are there any
01:52:24.680
other like major hubs that uh you know that have you know a strong presence and a lot of agreement
01:52:32.420
i mean there there are lots of guys that we have you know lots of theological agreement but i think
01:52:38.760
in in line with today's episode and i think this is probably what people are getting at
01:52:42.900
right is the intangibles it's not it's like okay well these guys agree on being historic
01:52:50.160
protestants confessional you know covenantal this that and the other they're not dispensational
01:52:55.820
at least not on paper they're not this they're not that yeah there's a lot of guys like that
01:53:01.240
but when push comes to shove in terms of the intangibles it's like this guy might on paper
01:53:06.020
be patriarchal but then when it comes to every twitter post and every blog post and every you
01:53:13.120
know church discipline uh situation or counseling session it's always some exception clause you know
0.99
01:53:20.920
where it's like well but technically you know deborah technically abigail technically like
01:53:26.240
so it's like okay you're patriarchal on paper but you're you're complementarian or just egalitarian
01:53:33.500
in uh in practice and so yeah there are a lot of guys if we were just listing off and i don't want
01:53:39.300
to do it because i think it's a misrepresentation i think it's unhelpful and some of you might hear
01:53:44.180
me give a list and go to a place and then be sorely disappointed so i'm not going to give you
01:53:48.160
a full list of um people who just agree with us on you know nine out of ten or 99 out of 100 issues
01:53:56.800
on paper um i think what the question is getting at is who are the people who are kindred spirits
01:54:03.480
they're they're like-minded in heart in practice ogden would be one of them um
01:54:10.280
i feel like maybe i don't know like there's lots of great names i just don't know where
01:54:17.160
in the country you are tennessee tennessee ridge runner project there's ridge runner project that
01:54:22.020
would be an example um that's that's part of the problem is it's tough yeah you can't just say
01:54:28.060
join a church here join this network we can name the individuals but they could be 500 miles away
01:54:33.260
right yeah but it's not it's not that many like i think there are a lot of guys it's growing day
01:54:40.080
by day but in terms of like churches and pastors um that's still few and far between i think a lot
01:54:47.300
of the momentum that we're getting is grassroots it's congregants all right next one this is a
01:54:54.140
super sticker so a ten dollar super chat thank you from hesha and it's describing the sticker
01:54:59.500
it says lemon character doing a victory dance with a monocas in his hand maracas maracas
01:55:05.660
seems like any glasses in my old age seems like it'd be a cool sticker
01:55:10.720
i appreciate that thank you for the super chat all right hhs 9045 uh says dale partridge
01:55:20.000
recently tweeted that christians must grasp uh that they can't fulfill the great commission
01:55:26.220
without political colonization thoughts i think that's true i think that's true i don't the great
01:55:34.020
commission is to make disciples of all nations it's not merely to make individual persons disciples
01:55:40.640
out of nations uh but but the subject that's being made a disciple is the nations themselves
01:55:47.600
and so um it's every component every element of the nation it's the culture it's uh it's the
01:55:54.460
political um system it's i think it's all the way down so like we are actually i believe we are
01:56:01.640
called in the great commission to make christian nations not just christian individual people out
01:56:06.860
of nations but christian nations and a christian nation um that like the great commission the
01:56:13.100
gospel has a totalizing effect it's not content to just save private hearts um christianity is
01:56:21.140
not a private faith it's a personal faith but with a public expression public expression and
01:56:28.280
when you look at christianity in its most powerful moments historically over the last 2000 years
01:56:33.880
it was always there was always a um it spilled into everything it spilled into culture it spilled
01:56:40.800
into academia it spilled into politics um from constantine to king alfred you know all the way
01:56:48.660
down the line. So I think that's absolutely true. If we seek to fulfill the Great Commission,
01:56:55.080
it's one thing if we're seeking to fulfill the Great Commission, believing that the
0.86
01:57:02.020
Christianizing of the political system of a given nation will follow. That's one thing.
01:57:09.000
But that's not what I'm seeing today. I am seeing from a lot of pastors saying that the intent,
01:57:16.000
the actual goal should be to avoid the christianization christianization of a nation
01:57:22.380
politically and to um to actually like we our goal should be to just win private persons for christ
01:57:30.160
and not nations i think it's one thing to say this nation is currently a communist nation
01:57:36.040
but a few people in the province of god will be called to be missionaries even despite this nation
01:57:42.720
being publicly politically hostile towards christ and they're going to go in and save souls and
01:57:48.640
preach christ that's great but when you say um christian nationalism is is the greatest danger
01:57:55.420
to america and our goal is to have that everyone in america would be a christian but that the
01:58:00.600
nation politically and culturally would not be christian um not that it would follow later but
01:58:06.540
but that we don't want that to ever happen uh i think that's just ridiculous i think that's
0.91
01:58:11.840
not just ridiculous, I think that's sinister. I think there's malice, real malice behind that.
0.63
01:58:17.800
I think these individuals who are using that rhetoric know exactly what they're doing. They
01:58:23.100
know what they're saying. And yeah, they're choosing to side against Christ. So I think
01:58:30.580
Dale Partridge is right that the political colonization is, I think that that's rooted
01:58:43.060
not only can be proven exegetically from the scripture,
01:58:47.300
when you look at Christian nations of the past.
01:59:07.040
as a small tie thank you all and have a great great weekend god bless you all yubo have a great
01:59:13.500
weekend as well yeah thank you we appreciate that very kind and then that's followed up by
01:59:18.560
chase cormick gave a 50 super chat also very generous thank you chase he said to clarify
01:59:24.980
my earlier question i've seen the effect attending a church where the theology is not ideal but
01:59:31.320
permissible, it has had a negative effect on my siblings to the point of affecting who they marry
01:59:39.080
and their beliefs. How do I deal with that aspect? Yeah, that's real. What I've realized
01:59:47.240
is that most churches, when people say, well, you're being offensive, or that was harsh,
01:59:52.740
that one especially, right? That was harsh. I've gotten to the point now where I typically just
01:59:58.920
respond by saying, no, I think you mean that was clear. Joel, that's harsh. You mean clear.
02:00:06.040
Most individuals avoid, most pastors avoid the appearance of harshness by pursuing ambiguity.
02:00:16.780
The way that they avoid being labeled as harsh is by avoiding clarity. The best way to not offend
02:00:23.880
to people is to not say anything. It's like, well, pastors, you know, are saying things all the time.
02:00:29.900
Are they? Pastors are talking all the time, but are they actually saying anything? Is there a
02:00:35.640
point? Is there a view? Is there a message? Or is it just word salad? You know, just blah, blah, blah,
02:00:44.560
blah, blah, blah. It's like at the end of it all, at the end of a sermon, at the end of a blog post,
02:00:49.760
at the end of, you know, a tweet. It's like, he didn't really say anything. So my point is that
02:00:57.900
I think what you're describing is a common occurrence where within one local gathering,
02:01:07.800
you could have a wide spectrum of convictions among the congregants because the pulpit is
02:01:14.900
ambiguous because the preaching is vague. And when it's vague, what it allows for is just like a
02:01:22.700
politician, right? You want a big tent. Well, we want a big tent when it comes to trying to get
02:01:28.620
political wins and cultural wins. And that's what we've been talking about in this whole episode.
02:01:32.800
But in a local church on the Lord's Day, we actually don't want a big tent. In the local
02:01:39.440
church setting, we want to be right up front, abundantly clear about specifics, not general
02:01:47.880
vagities, you know, but specifics of our convictions, what we believe, what the Bible
02:01:53.320
says. And what that does is it just, it sets up a fence post. It sets up a border to ensure that
02:02:03.220
people who belong to that church are there because there's a great sense of unity. People always
02:02:10.400
think that unity is achieved by having less divisions, less borders, less fences. No, that's
02:02:20.220
a unity of charity, but there's also a unity of conviction. Ephesians chapter 4 speaks of
02:02:26.660
this type of unity. It's the unity of conviction. It's the unity of the knowledge of the
02:02:33.200
faith. It's a unity of common conviction. So there is a unity of charity despite distinctions
02:02:41.300
in conviction. That's what we were talking about when we want to be unified culturally and
02:02:45.640
politically Monday through Saturday. But in the church, we want to have as much as we can a unity
02:02:50.600
of conviction. And that doesn't mean we're just overlooking disagreements. It means we're preaching
02:02:58.620
and messaging so specifically and so clearly that everyone who's willing to tolerate that church
02:03:06.040
and the message of that church, you can assume that they're extremely aligned. And so the more
02:03:15.140
ambiguous the pastor, the broader the scope of the congregants, where you have libs over here
02:03:21.920
and maybe some conservatives over there. And so the solution for all of that is you're right,
02:03:27.820
And this is what you're saying, Chase, but the solution for all of that is to find a clearer church, a clearer church.
02:03:35.400
And if you don't have that, then the problem, unfortunately, will persist.
02:03:40.800
All right, Julian Stevenson, can you read that?
02:03:43.020
Yep. He sent $5 and says, we're expecting our first child in five weeks. Praise God for that.
02:03:48.960
He says, my father sadly did not lead my family well. Any advice on how I can help my new family love the standard?
02:04:01.160
Yeah, well, I mean, family worship every night in the home.
02:04:06.100
And you set the standard of doing family worship in the home every night,
02:04:13.260
But if you set the standard to do it three times a week,
02:04:17.260
If it's every night, you'll end up doing it four or five times.
02:04:23.840
start early. Don't, my wife and I realized this when our first was about a year old and it's like,
02:04:32.300
can't even talk, you know, they don't really understand what we're saying. But we just
02:04:36.840
realized that even from infancy, we wanted our children to be familiar with worship in the home.
02:04:46.760
So they don't understand the Bible as I'm reading it. They don't understand, you know, the theology
02:04:52.200
behind the hymns and psalms as we're singing them. They're not standing in agreement with the
02:04:58.680
prayers because they can't even comprehend the words that I'm praying. But I wanted all of our
02:05:03.660
children, before they even reached the level of comprehension as a baby, to be familiar with just
02:05:12.240
the rhythm and the presence of daily worship in the home. And so that would be very practical,
02:05:26.580
be in a good church, attend church consistently.
02:05:31.300
I think another one is, to the extent that you can,
02:05:35.300
is surround yourself with families, young families,
02:05:47.860
surrounding your children from a very early age with a cultural milieu, a very homogenous kind
02:05:55.240
of environment. And yeah, so I would say insulate your children in that way, in your relationships,
02:06:01.660
in your church. I think those go a really long way.
02:06:06.800
Yep. All right. Andrew Cox, $20. Thank you, Andrew. We appreciate it. He said,
02:06:11.380
GA, good afternoon, brothers. What would you say to the charge that Stephen Wolfe is historically
02:06:16.360
dishonest and misrepresents the sources that he cites this is not my view whatsoever but
02:06:22.140
one that i've heard passed around in my 1689 federalist circles well there's your problem
02:06:29.420
1689 federalist circles um yeah i mean like i know those circles talking about the rent of hands
02:06:37.760
talking about tom hicks um talking about you know guys who um they they don't want
02:06:47.400
steven wolf to be right they don't want him like it's a foregone conclusion um they don't want him
02:06:53.300
to be right because uh if he's right about the political theory the political theology of the
02:07:02.000
reformers, then they're wrong. And I'll be honest, it's kind of like what I was saying earlier,
02:07:08.860
to just throw myself into it also, into the equation. If Stephen Wolf is right, and I believe
02:07:16.020
he is, about the political theory and theology of the reformers, then some of the insufferable
0.91
02:07:23.320
Baptists are especially wrong, but all Baptists are at least partially wrong. All of them.
0.81
02:07:34.040
The best, I'll just, you know, I'll say it like, the best Baptist, bar none, better than Spurgeon,
02:07:42.100
the best Baptist, bar none, in terms of view of the political, would have been John Gill.
02:07:49.760
John Gill was the closest that a Baptist can get, and God bless him.
02:07:53.860
He's like, the fact that John Gill was a Baptist is probably the only way I can sleep at night
02:07:58.300
still being a Baptist without feeling just so much crushing shame that I cry into the pillow.
02:08:04.440
John Gill, he held at both tables of the law, so that being one through four with the Ten Commandments,
02:08:10.520
as well as five through ten are commandments as it pertains to God, the Sabbath,
02:08:15.480
not taking the name of the Lord in vain, etc., that these are actually binding and should be
02:08:22.280
legislated and upheld by the civil magistrate. So not just the civil magistrate enforcing that
02:08:27.880
we don't steal from our neighbor or murder our neighbor, those kinds of things, but that the
02:08:31.700
civil magistrate actually has a God-given duty, invested interest, and seeing to it that the
02:08:37.040
nation, that the country does not commit blasphemy, for instance, so that blasphemy would not only
02:08:42.940
be categorized as a sin, but it would also be considered a crime. There would be a legal
02:08:48.740
infraction for public blasphemy. John Gill held to that. So my point is the problem that you're
02:08:56.600
probably facing is predominantly stemming from 1689 Federalist circles. You're surrounding
02:09:05.380
yourself by guys who have a vested interest. You have to see the bias. They have a vested interest
02:09:11.320
in Stephen Wolf being wrong. Because if he's right, then these guys are, it's shameful. It's
02:09:22.320
embarrassing for these guys. But the reason I bring up John Gill is just to say that John Gill
02:09:28.740
even as a Baptist, so Stephen Wolf is definitely right in terms of Calvin and Luther and these
02:09:34.740
guys um but uh even in the case of john gill who was a baptist john gill uh would i guarantee you
02:09:44.260
when it comes to the political he would have sided with stephen wolf way more than tom hicks i promise
02:09:52.160
you that okay uh wise final solution west will you take that one wise final solution sent five
02:09:58.660
dollars uh frequent super chatter thanks for the five dollars they said this the lord will reward
02:10:03.980
of Right Response Ministries when you publicly communicate loyalty to the chief law enforcement
02:10:08.800
officer in the country, the chief civil magistrate over Nick. So they're referencing, I believe it
02:10:14.260
would be Donald Trump, the chief civil magistrate, the president over Nick Fuentes. This is a flavor
02:10:19.480
of a comment that the same person has sent before, so we appreciate the donation. Our question is
02:10:24.940
still, again, the same as I think it was maybe two weeks ago when he sent it. We would love to be
02:10:30.800
loyal to donald trump to have his back and to back him up when he shows loyalty to the people
02:10:35.840
that put him into office that's right trump thinks higher speaks higher of miriam adelson jews who
02:10:42.020
donated to his campaign to get certain arrangements and um embassy uh locations in jerusalem they
02:10:50.160
donated to get that and he speaks higher of those people than he does white evangelicals who voted
02:10:54.800
and put him into office three times or at the very least elected him three times put him into office
02:10:59.600
twice so by all means if he was our champion and our chief executive there would be a certain
02:11:05.080
sense of loyalty above and beyond the honor we already give him we are honorable to him we don't
02:11:09.720
we don't we do our best we don't circulate falsehoods about him there's lots of emails
02:11:14.140
that are not looking good right now that's not today's episode they're not founded we're trying
02:11:18.440
to believe the best about him but practically speaking honoring him does not require uh here's
02:11:24.700
all his faults and we have to pretend like those don't exist and exhibit undying loyalty that's
02:11:28.700
right because like no he hasn't been loyal to us he hasn't represented us he hasn't protected us
02:11:33.060
he won't have our vote again his platform won't have our support well said hhs9045 he gave us
02:11:40.840
another super chat ten dollars he said joel what's your strategy for increasing husband-wife
02:11:45.420
theological alignment on toughest applied issues like race and uh views towards israel or or jury
02:11:54.360
what percent alignment is needed for a strong counter-cultural household that's a great
02:12:01.300
question really great question first thing I was saying this is a white pill this should be
02:12:06.580
encouraging is not 100% not 100% your wife is different than you I've heard it said you know
02:12:15.780
before by Michael Foster even said this and it's good to be a man he said your wife is not your
02:12:20.400
best friend. Your wife is your wife. And that's better than a best friend. You need a wife. She
02:12:28.060
is bone of your bone, right? Flesh of your flesh, right? So there's obviously a lot. She's a suitable
1.00
02:12:33.640
helpmate, you know, of your kind. So there's a lot of similarities, but there are massive
02:12:38.060
distinctions. She's not one of the bros. She's not one of the guys. She is built different all
02:12:43.460
the way down to the marrow in her bone. And that's a beautiful thing when it's embraced for what it
02:12:49.560
is so she doesn't have to be perfectly aligned with all your political takes and all your you
02:12:55.920
know cultural takes i always think of pepe the frog meme you know where he's like all dressed
02:12:59.680
up all dapper you know with his tuxedo he said um a lucky lucky little lady to share my extremist
02:13:05.280
political views with a lucky young lady yeah and and the you know the implication is like she's
02:13:11.520
going to be horrified you know and uh but that's okay she so um obviously you don't want to have
02:13:17.780
a 50-year-long marriage where your wife is horrified by your politics for all 50 years,
0.96
02:13:22.640
but she doesn't have to be 100% aligned, but she does need to be generally aligned. So one way to
02:13:28.040
get that alignment, here's one way. Don't talk to your wife the way that you would talk to the GC,
02:13:34.380
right? Don't talk to her the way that you would talk to the boys. Don't lie to her. Don't pull
02:13:39.160
the wool over her eyes. Be honest about your positions, your convictions, and what you think,
02:13:43.260
but use language that would be more conducive to the feminine domestic spirit. You're talking to a
02:13:52.540
woman. It's your woman. It's your wife, but she's still a woman at the end of the day. So talk to
0.95
02:13:57.640
her differently. And then the last thing that I would say is wives are women and women are NPCs.
1.00
02:14:03.700
And I'm not trying to be offensive with that. NPC is non-player character, like in a video game,
0.74
02:14:10.720
if you're not familiar with the reference there's an element of that but even more than that i've
02:14:15.480
heard people define it as it pertains to women as not just non-player character but more specifically
02:14:22.300
naturally pursuing consensus women the feminine ethos is wanting to go along and get along wanting
0.60
02:14:31.800
to agree with the majority and so women typically will be more inclined much more inclined than a
02:14:39.760
man to take whatever position they think the majority of people hold. Now, here's the deal.
02:14:46.980
In brass tacks, in the objective, definitive sense, it doesn't have to be the majority of
02:14:52.140
the population, right? If we have 330 million people in America, it doesn't have to be 50%
02:14:57.840
plus one. But their world, this is one of the things you got to do, make their world smaller.
02:15:05.100
make their world smaller the world of a woman is meant to be smaller she is a lady of the hearth
0.99
02:15:11.160
her world is her home her world is you right you're trying to change the world she is in your
1.00
02:15:18.080
world she is orbiting she's the moon and you're the earth she is orbiting you are her world you
02:15:24.680
and the children your home your local church her few women friends that's her world so here's my
02:15:30.180
point, that's actually really encouraging. You don't actually have to change 50% of a 330 million
02:15:35.720
population nation plus one in order for your wife to finally get on board with your politics.
1.00
02:15:41.000
All you have to do is make sure that not the world, but her world is smaller and that that
0.99
02:15:46.880
smaller world is aligned with you. You go to the right church that holds the right views,
0.68
02:15:52.760
where she develops friendships with the right women, and you speak to her in a loving, gentle
02:15:58.540
way as her husband living with your wife in an understandable manner and even if you hold the
02:16:04.540
minority view for all intents and purposes for her everyday life and her interactions the
02:16:10.840
friendships and relationships she has it's the majority view there and she will naturally pursue
0.99
02:16:15.420
consensus as an npc god bless her and turns out your wife will be a far-right extremist just like
02:16:22.500
you match made in heaven praise god we have got to get these done antonio yes winter's uh oh seven
02:16:28.860
cent two dollars and says is the r word making a comeback it is definitely making so if we're
0.85
02:16:34.340
talking about if we're talking about retarded then then yes it is making a comeback and and
0.85
02:16:39.900
retarded is used in the most loving endearing way possible you don't michael scott i think he said
0.96
02:16:47.700
it best he said you don't call someone retarded because they're actually retarded you call them
0.97
02:16:52.060
retarded when they're doing something retarded right um same thing with uh another word the f
0.96
02:16:58.000
word not not f-u-c you know but i was like you don't say that when you know if they're actually
0.98
02:17:02.300
you actually say it if they're doing something so uh yes i think in an endearing you know tongue
02:17:07.200
in cheek humorous way it is certainly making a comeback all right uh next pavel ten dollars
02:17:12.600
thank you pavel while non-salvific traditions orient one's life towards god that is their
02:17:18.600
purpose as there are many languages but one meaning so there are many traditions but one
02:17:22.980
spirit very kind super chat a picture of a dove and i do not understand that comment um i think
02:17:30.760
i understand it and i i think i gotta admit i don't like it and i think pavel's probably a great
02:17:36.080
guy or girl or i don't know pavel is a strange name but uh no we we got to be careful there like
02:17:44.940
i think to to one extent yes like the the you know the holy catholic church lower case c catholic
02:17:53.460
the invisible church right that stretches back throughout the ages every person who truly
02:17:59.620
belongs to christ and it's one baptism one spirit one you know so we have that in galatians i believe
02:18:06.040
it's chapter three one lord um and so in that sense yes but if it's in the sense to say that
02:18:12.500
the distinctions don't matter at all or that they matter very little then that can be a problem so
02:18:19.820
without knowing the person i don't know their intent in the comment but i do see ten dollars
02:18:24.820
and so i'm going to give the benefit of the doubt that this person's on come back on monday with
02:18:29.580
another ten dollars it's church traditions it's not like uh cultural traditions there yeah and
02:18:35.040
in that case it feels and i would say so then that's true as far as it goes yeah it's not
02:18:39.800
limitlessly true but it is it is true to an extent um that within orthodox churches yes uh one spirit
02:18:47.600
one lord one baptism uh but if we're going to apply that to mormons then no no sir ron don
02:18:55.160
valenti he gave us 20 we appreciate that he said what are your general thoughts about receiving
02:19:01.420
veterans disability many vets receive it in some form regardless of combat history is there a line
02:19:08.580
between being shrewd and providing and acquiring dishonest gain? That's a great question. Wes would
02:19:15.060
be the guy to answer it, but we have no time today. I'm just going to go on record and say
02:19:18.960
we've got to, people who have put their lives at risk for our country are just treated like scum.
0.97
02:19:26.200
Like I just think we take veterans for granted and we got to do right by our veterans. Should
0.91
02:19:32.160
they be on lifelong disability when they're perfectly able-bodied and healthy? Probably
02:19:37.620
not if you're an individual who is a veteran and you, like, should you be shrewd in a system where
02:19:44.240
you're already being robbed through your taxes and try to get some of that back? And can you make a
02:19:48.460
justifiable argument? I think you probably can. This is something where the system itself needs
02:19:54.000
to change. Let's keep going. Nick Bonner. Nick Bonner gave us a $27.99 super chat. We appreciate
02:20:01.740
that he said i'm canadian and somehow still more american first than these frauds so true king
02:20:08.580
well said here is a 70 super chat from nick 488 very generous we appreciate that he said hey guys
02:20:17.060
i'd like your thoughts on the following european supremacy can only be attributed to god's
02:20:23.700
providence i agree with that his hand graced uh the europeans before christ ever walked the earth
02:20:31.380
i think that's debatable but i i know that view uh before they would eventually become the people
02:20:38.920
to wield his son's sword great question i think that that um that's something that's been looming
02:20:44.540
this this sentiment from a few of our listeners it just merits a whole episode so let's just
02:20:49.440
put a pin in that one we'll get to it eventually but talking about europeans and who were the
02:20:54.680
europeans 2 000 years ago and what was god providentially doing talk about plato you know
02:20:59.700
was so we i think that that's uh it's fascinating it's worth a conversation uh next one reformed
02:21:07.260
farmer he gave us five dollars we appreciate that reformed farmer he said my wife just gave birth
02:21:12.180
uh to our second child who is a boy pray that he will be a godly man uh that god would give him
02:21:20.000
give us wisdom to parent him um and uh thank you for your ministry thank you so much reformed
02:21:26.840
farmer we appreciate that lynn p last one here we go five dollar super chat thank you lynn why are
02:21:33.220
so many men converting to eo what would you say to someone in your church tempted to leave uh leave
02:21:40.220
and convert to eastern orthodoxy that's a great question you probably tuned in late because this
02:21:44.980
live stream has been going on for about two or three days at this point um we did address it
02:21:50.420
earlier it's certainly not your fault i think it's the mr miyagi complex i think that's a big
02:21:55.480
portion of it. And so I already kind of addressed that. I would encourage you just
02:22:00.480
rewind the tape, go back a little bit in the episode, probably around the halfway point,
02:22:05.620
you'll find my answer. And I think it directly applies to your question. That's all we got for
02:22:09.880
today. As always, thank you so much for your generosity supporting this ministry. We appreciate
02:22:14.920
it very much. Here at the very end, one last time, please do us a massive favor. Subscribe
02:22:19.780
on YouTube and click the bell. And also follow us on X. The handle is at right response M as in
02:22:26.080
ministries, at right response M. Follow us on X. Click the bell there as well. And if you're
02:22:30.920
listening after the fact on Apple or Spotify, do us a huge favor. Give us a five-star review. It
02:22:37.000
helps kind of trigger the algorithm and get this content out to more people for the glory of King
02:22:42.620
Jesus. That's it for the week. And we will see you Lord willing next week on Monday at 3 p.m.