The NXR Podcast - February 17, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Did Women's Suffrage Ruin America?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - “The Judaizers” Are Still Deceiving Today with Andrew Isker S04E06 THE LIVESTREAM - Yes, The Gospel Changes Genetics

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 12 minutes

Words per minute

184.56

Word count

24,366

Sentence count

503

Harmful content

Misogyny

88

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

74

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

For decades, liberals have assured us that history only moves in one direction toward so-called progress. They built their entire moral framework on the idea that the past was oppressive, the present is enlightened, and the future is an inevitable march toward egalitarian utopia. But lately, reality has been catching up with their delusions across the political spectrum. A once unthinkable idea has resurfaced, the repeal of the 19th Amendment. What was once the domain of obscure reactionary circles is now a growing conversation in mainstream politics. Even Project 2025, the policy blueprint that sent the left into a full-blown panic, was accused of making this one of its long-term goals. Why? Because history isn t just some endless progressive revolution, it is the unfolding of God s created order. And that order, no matter how much they resist it, always reasserts itself. We are witnessing the slow but certain return of nature. The world was never meant to be built on their abstractions. The past they despise is now returning. And the real question is, who will have the courage to welcome it?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 for decades liberals have assured us that history only moves in one direction toward so-called
00:00:34 progress they built their entire moral framework on the idea that the past was oppressive the
00:00:41 present is enlightened and the future is an inevitable march toward egalitarian utopia
00:00:48 but lately reality has been catching up with their delusions across the political spectrum
00:00:54 a once unthinkable idea has resurfaced, the repeal of the 19th Amendment. What was once the domain
00:01:03 of obscure reactionary circles is now a growing conversation in mainstream politics. Even Project
00:01:11 2025, the policy blueprint that sent the left into a full-blown panic, was accused of making
00:01:18 this one of its long-term goals. Why? Because history isn't just some endless progressive
00:01:25 revolution. It is the unfolding of God's created order, and that order, no matter how much they
00:01:32 resist it, always reasserts itself. We are witnessing the slow but certain return of nature.
00:01:39 The distinctions between men and women, once blurred by Marxist ideology and evangelical
00:01:47 cowardice, are becoming undeniable once more. Feminism is collapsing under the weight of its
00:01:54 own contradictions, and the left, which once mocked the idea of patriarchal governance,
00:02:00 now finds itself terrified by the growing number of men and women that are rejecting their lies. 0.82
00:02:08 For over a century, the progressives, alongside their naive Christian allies, 0.57
00:02:14 labored to erase the natural order, calling it justice, while dismantling the very structure 0.99
00:02:21 that held civilization together. But they were wrong. The world was never meant to be built
00:02:27 on their abstractions. The past they despise is now returning. And the real question is,
00:02:35 who will have the courage to welcome it? This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors,
00:02:41 Armored Republic, and Reese Fund, as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors.
00:02:48 You can join our Patreon by going to patreon.com forward slash rightresponseministries, or you can
00:02:56 donate by going to rightresponseministries.com forward slash donate. Tune in now as we welcome
00:03:04 the return to God's natural order.
00:03:11 all right all right welcome back here we are it's a monday afternoon for those of you who
00:03:21 are new to the channel uh a very merry ga good afternoon we've got our very own michael belch
00:03:27 he's an elder in our church covenant bible church by the way if you're looking for a church
00:03:31 you live in the central texas area we're about an hour north of austin uh 35 minutes i drive to
00:03:37 the Capitol pretty frequently 35 minutes not far at all cool not far at all um far enough to keep
00:03:43 the police from being defunded right but but close enough to where you could technically you know
00:03:49 go to the Capitol you could go and work for Elon or Oracle or Apple or whatever so anyways if you're
00:03:54 looking for a church go to covenantbible.org not covenant bible church that domain was already
00:04:00 taken that's the only reason we don't have it covenantbible.org uh to check out the church so
00:04:05 We've got Michael Belch.
00:04:06 He's an elder in the church.
00:04:07 We've got Wesley Todd.
00:04:08 He's a faithful member in the church and myself and one quick couple of announcements real
00:04:14 quick and then we'll hop into the episode.
00:04:15 So if you're new to the channel, we live stream on Monday, Wednesday, Friday at 3 p.m.
00:04:20 Central Time.
00:04:20 Monday, Wednesday, Friday, three times a week at 3 p.m.
00:04:23 Central Time.
00:04:24 We also have the Friday special.
00:04:25 Right now it's a series with myself and Pastor Andrew Isker on the subject of Israel.
00:04:30 How should we view modern day Jews today?
00:04:32 Are these the people that are being addressed in the Bible? 0.99
00:04:35 Are there any lasting future promises for them, physical or spiritual?
00:04:41 All those things.
00:04:42 It's a nine-part series.
00:04:43 It's dropping weekly every Friday at 8 p.m. Central.
00:04:46 We call that the Friday special, a deep dive multiple-part series.
00:04:50 It's a nine-part series with myself and Isker.
00:04:52 And Q2, starting in April for the Friday special, it's going to be myself and Dr. Stephen Wolfe
00:04:57 on all things Christian nationalism.
00:04:59 So there's a lot of great things happening.
00:05:01 All that said, the next cool thing that's coming up pretty quick is about six weeks from now,
00:05:06 we have our conference. We've titled it Christ is King. The subtitle is How to Defeat Trash World.
00:05:13 So we have the Christ is King conference. It's happening April 3rd, 4th, and 5th,
00:05:17 the year of our Lord, 2025. It's a Thursday, Friday, and a Saturday. You'll see a commercial
00:05:22 in this episode just a little later on that'll tell you all the speakers. But there's two
00:05:26 important events, sub events at this conference that I want to go ahead and put on your radar.
00:05:32 We want you to be able to sign up now. So one of them is we are officially having a singles mixer
00:05:38 and it's not just going to be organic where you're just kind of walking around hoping to
00:05:41 have a conversation, but it's going to be really intentional and designed and organized. And so we
00:05:47 have somebody on our right response team that's going to be heading up that event that's happening
00:05:52 during the conference, kind of like a speed dating scenario where you're getting a woman and a man
00:05:58 getting to talk to each other for a couple minutes, and then going down, we're going to have tables
00:06:02 lined up in a separate room, and hopefully relationships will come out of this. By God's
00:06:06 grace, I've already got to officiate one wedding of two individuals that met themselves at one of
00:06:11 our previous conferences, and I'm hoping that this year, by the grace of God, I'm hoping that
00:06:16 10 marriages would come out of this conference now what we're lacking is we put a cap on it we 0.96
00:06:22 can't accommodate everyone so we're going to have 20 guys and 20 gals uh we are full on the guys
00:06:28 but we are lacking on the gals we believe by the grace of god they're out there ecclesiastes
00:06:34 sometimes discourages me a little bit where it says you know i found one upright man among a
00:06:38 thousand but not one woman among them all but i believe that maybe there's you know particular
00:06:43 the context to that and that it's not for all places at all time. There are godly women. I 0.94
00:06:47 believe it. They're in our church. I pastor them. It's a privilege. So if you're a godly single
00:06:51 lady and you would like to come to the conference and register for this singles event, I think 1.00
00:06:56 currently we have about 10 gals and we're full already with 20 guys. So we need 10 more single 1.00
00:07:01 godly women who want to come to this conference and participate in the singles event. What you 1.00
00:07:06 would do if you're one of those women is you go to our conference website, so notrightresponseministries.com 1.00
00:07:13 but go to rightresponseconference.com. Again, that's rightresponseconference.com and go ahead 1.00
00:07:21 and scroll down past the registration for the conference and you will find the singles event
00:07:26 and go ahead and register today. Second thing with the conference is that we also officially,
00:07:32 people have asked, some people asked being, I think, strategic and shrewd. It's perfectly
00:07:36 ethical and fine, but they're saying, hey, look, I'm a business owner. I want to come to the
00:07:41 conference and i'm going to come either way but i would love to be able to write it off ethically
00:07:45 legitimately as a business expense and uh is there any kind of official business type content and so
00:07:53 what we're doing is we have decided officially just now that we decided 15 seconds ago that uh
00:07:59 we're going to have a business networking lunch and so we're going to cater lunch um and so we're
00:08:04 not trying to charge an arm and a leg but we do want to at least cover um lunch plus the delivery
00:08:10 and the tip and the tax and stuff like that.
00:08:12 So we're going to charge $25.
00:08:13 Okay, so for $25, same thing,
00:08:16 go to rightresponseconference.com, scroll down.
00:08:19 You'll see where you can register for the singles event.
00:08:21 You'll also see where you can register
00:08:22 for the business networking lunch.
00:08:25 Business networking lunch.
00:08:26 Do they have to be registered for the conference first?
00:08:28 Yeah, so for both of these,
00:08:29 if you want to come to the singles event,
00:08:31 you do need to be registered for the conference.
00:08:33 If you want to come to the business networking lunch,
00:08:35 you need to be registered for the conference.
00:08:37 So these are sub-events within the larger event
00:08:40 of the conference. So it's not just open to the public. It's for our conference attendees. So
00:08:46 register for the conference at rightresponseconference.com and then scroll down on
00:08:50 that same website, same page and register for the singles event. If you're a godly single gal
00:08:54 and register for the business networking lunch, that's going to cost you 25 bucks. It's just to 1.00
00:09:01 cover the food and we'll organize, put a little bit of organization on that. And I'll be a part
00:09:07 of that event as well so i'll be there for the business networking lunch and i would love to meet
00:09:12 every single one of you and and even talk about ways that maybe if you're interested you don't
00:09:16 have to the main thing is for you to network with each other but if you're interested how you could
00:09:20 also network with right response and that maybe we could try to give a little bit of visibility
00:09:24 to your business we would love to see christian business owners thrive okay that's uh that's all
00:09:31 of our talking shop you know covering uh the bases and we are ready for today's episode michael belch
00:09:36 this is yours you outlined it that cold open i just got to brag on on michael and wesley and
00:09:42 nathan so i my job's fairly easy in this regard i i sit my butt down in uh in this leather chair
00:09:50 and nathan puts something on the teleprompter and uh and it usually takes a couple tries because
00:09:56 like ron burgundy he will read anything that's on that teleprompter so if there's a misplaced
00:10:01 comma or something then i you know then i mess it up but um what what happens is that michael and
00:10:06 they alternate writing the show and included in that task is writing a cold open and inner
00:10:12 introductory you know framing of the episode and so then i pre-record that put it on the
00:10:17 teleprompter and read it and then nathan to brag on him for a moment uh he's our our tech director
00:10:23 he then takes that and adds music and b-roll and all these kinds of things and and that's
00:10:28 like impressive to do in any podcast context like new christmas does great cold opens and it's all
00:10:36 i'm always impressed oh yeah but to brag on right response a little bit just for a moment
00:10:41 it's one thing to do an incredible 20 minute long cold open that's nobody should disparage that
00:10:46 that's amazing um but it's another thing to do it the day of three times a week right not every
00:10:53 two this is for life exactly because we're live streaming so this is literally this is the day of
00:10:58 that morning um you guys are are writing it getting it to nathan um who records it with me
00:11:05 real quick and then he's doing all all the music sound editing and b-roll for a anywhere from three
00:11:13 to five minute long cold open and he's doing it three times a week in addition to all his other
00:11:18 responsibilities for a video that's going to be live that afternoon really impressive so way to
00:11:24 go nathan yeah way to go all right so this is michael's episode lead us off i would love to
00:11:29 jump into the episode but joel we've had some some super chats that we need to hit so nathan
00:11:35 let's go back up to uh yeah a bunch here so we've got uh some chd super chat uh thank you very much
00:11:43 chd yes and shout out to the angry feminists amen granddad farms super chat 49.99 thank you 1.00
00:11:50 very much granddad farms very generous whoa super awesome that's a family i've talked to them before
00:11:55 on x wonderful supporters wonderful people thank you so much 50 50 guys seriously that that means
00:12:02 the world that's really generous and we will put that money to noble work everything that you give
00:12:07 just for the record everything that you give um is going towards a non-profit christian ministry
00:12:12 that is our whole objective is to resource christians not just within the ecclesiastical
00:12:19 you know the church institute but in every single realm of society and life to push for the crown
00:12:25 rights of king jesus so thank you amen so much granddad farms okay so he said idaho is on board
00:12:30 with repealing the 20th century if not longer appreciate you gentlemen same to you granddad
00:12:34 idaho the house put out a resolution asking the supreme court to revisit a bergerfeld versus
00:12:40 which would be the gay marriage ruling so the house came out and said hey i saw why don't you
00:12:44 redo this one so i'll lead in the way to go dude all right we gave a lot of credit to granddad farms
00:12:50 but this one okay so this is uh ben huffsteadler i think so yeah okay ben huffsteadler uh he gave
00:12:57 us a hundred dollar super chat god bless see all you have to do is do an episode that the people
00:13:02 it's a i'm telling you it is a crowd pleaser right when you think of what gets the people going
00:13:08 right what what is what is so well such a centrist moderate position well within the bounds of the
00:13:16 overton window like beloved a position that's that's just beloved by all repeal the 19th
00:13:23 amendment the people love it the super chats begin to flow right if you we need it we need
00:13:30 the support if you are a 19th amendment repealing fan super chat get it in you can do it god bless
00:13:38 so this is from ben huffsteadler a hundred dollar super chat incredibly generous thank you he says
00:13:44 wes could you read it said this let's go guys appreciate you all always watching how do you
00:13:49 suggest talking to the new age christian if it's unquote christian male regarding a proper christian
00:13:55 woman conduct head covering submission etc side note still waiting on the emo joe music single
00:14:01 to drop hashtag pick color for life um piccolo yeah like i would play piccolo at the conference
00:14:08 so really great chance that that does not happen but i will keep it in the back of my mind we'll
00:14:15 hit this question at the end because michael's got a lot of material yeah that takes that takes
00:14:17 more time but uh we so appreciate your generosity and we will hit it michael uh can you hit those
00:14:22 last two yeah so this is from uh bo cannington good to see you again bo thank you thank you again
00:14:26 for your generosity uh just supporting your ministries keep it up god bless you you too
00:14:30 bo thank you very much and cole billiott a super chat 499 says cole from politica christiana here
00:14:38 can y'all speak to the relationship with prohibition the 19th amendment um dr yeah i don't
00:14:45 we might touch on that some um good connection though the problem with feminism in the early
00:14:50 19th century is it was touching everything yeah yep and that that page politica christiana that's
00:14:56 an instagram page he puts tons of great stuff from the founding fathers actually a lot of american
00:15:01 history cool so go check him out politica with an a christiana on instagram on instagram okay yep
00:15:08 and uh christianity unplugged thank you very much for the five dollars repeal the 19th amen well
00:15:13 we're going to get into that it's not quite so simple actually unfortunately uh but we'll we'll
00:15:17 be we'll be getting to that as we go uh the funny thing joel is that you mentioned you know we are
00:15:22 hitting this, and you were speaking sarcastically,
00:15:24 this middle-of-the-road, milquetoast position.
00:15:27 And, of course, the implication is
00:15:28 that base people actually don't want
00:15:30 the middle-of-the-road milquetoast
00:15:32 position. They want
00:15:34 what's biblical and natural and historical.
00:15:37 However, this
00:15:38 issue of repealing the 19th Amendment
00:15:40 is quickly becoming
00:15:42 milquetoast.
00:15:44 I remember when I first heard this question,
00:15:46 it was kind of like when I heard the idea that
00:15:48 the argument that
00:15:50 the abolitionists of abortion argue for.
00:15:52 It took me a minute, and then I thought, yeah, it should be illegal in all cases, right?
00:15:56 When I heard about repealing the 19th Amendment, I kind of thought for a little bit, and I 0.97
00:16:00 thought, well, actually, yeah, this seems logical.
00:16:03 But at the time, I remember when I heard that, that was like the most fringe thing I could
00:16:08 imagine.
00:16:09 And I remember my brother and my brother-in-law and I had a conversation.
00:16:12 It was kind of in hushed tones.
00:16:13 It was like, what do you think?
00:16:14 I was like, well, what do you think?
00:16:15 And we all agreed.
00:16:16 And now it's so mainstream that places like Kim Poole, Pearl Davis, it's on Twitter.
00:16:22 threats like i remember i addressed it with um i think with joshua haimes who has a podcast he's a
00:16:29 good christian guy and i he asked me in an interview when he was just starting uh podcasting
00:16:35 and i think i could be wrong but nathan it was i was at a conference and i think it was 2019
00:16:41 no this was like 2022 2023 oh yeah you know you're right you're i'm sorry that's way too
00:16:47 or 2022 i think it was 2022 like october okay 23 okay so 23 yeah then so this is like fall of
00:16:58 2023 yeah so we are what we're coming up like two years a year and a half yeah a year and a half
00:17:04 so that just gives the reason why it matters is um i got i i remember it went viral i got tons
00:17:10 of death threats and i guess that could happen today probably will we've got what like we've got
00:17:14 no probably won't honestly because um you've got two different categories of um the insufferable
00:17:23 hate watchers you've got the true like leftist progressive uh unbelievers who hate christ hate
00:17:30 the church hate christianity and they're the ones who would probably make it go viral you know and
00:17:34 clip you out like your right-wing watch yep but um but these days are much more devoted hate watchers
00:17:41 are um effeminate christians right who have nothing better to do but comb through eight
00:17:49 hours of content weekly um and try to clip anything they can to uh to destroy our ministry
00:17:57 because they're mad about something so anyway so those guys i don't think actually uh because i
00:18:05 think those guys as much as they hate us actually agree on repealing the 19 they can see where we're
00:18:09 coming from they see where we're coming yeah so we probably won't go viral but the point is we did
00:18:13 go viral a year and a half ago not that long ago and all that is to substantiate michael's point
00:18:18 that i mean we're talking about the overton window shifting at the speed of light so an interesting
00:18:25 case study about this is um a man who ran for and actually won a u.s representative seat in the state
00:18:33 of michigan and when he was in college he went to stanford in 2000 he started a think tank it was
00:18:40 just kind of a local campus network and he wrote a paper on that think tank website that completely
00:18:47 called for the the total uh abandonment and appeal of the 19th amendment and in it he and he's based
00:18:53 he says you know women are not fit by god for political rule and he went through all the things
00:18:58 that we talked about last Friday on our episode.
00:19:01 And then he ran for election in 2020 or 2022,
00:19:05 and all of this resurfaced.
00:19:08 And actually, he backpedaled significantly,
00:19:11 but it still came out.
00:19:12 CNN had it out.
00:19:13 They had it all over their headlines
00:19:15 for his election cycle.
00:19:18 His campaign tried to kind of help him
00:19:21 weasel out of it by saying,
00:19:22 well, he was in college,
00:19:23 and he doesn't hold that position anymore.
00:19:25 Nevertheless, he still beat the Republican incumbent, even with that in his past and blasted all over the headlines, which I take as an interesting case study of where we are now.
00:19:38 He he could not publicly totally endorse it, but he had that in his past.
00:19:44 And the things that he said were unbelievably based.
00:19:47 They were not just what a lot of people talk about where they say, well, it's because men still get drafted.
00:19:51 So we either have to draft women or we have to get rid of the 19th Amendment.
00:19:55 Now, his was nature and God's design, and it was full-on patriarchal. 0.86
00:20:02 Good for him. 0.77
00:20:03 He still won his representative seat and Trump endorsed him, which I think is, you know, an interesting commentary on the times that we live and the direction that the Overton window is still pushing right now.
00:20:18 i grew up like just conservative republican all the way never in all my time growing up until my
00:20:25 mid to late 20s did i ever hear that idea nobody talked in those categories at any platform at any
00:20:31 level in any popular discourse right whatsoever yep right i never even thought about repealing
00:20:37 the 19th until probably about 2020 and then publicly said it like 2022 and then with joshua
00:20:45 hames 2023 right and now i'm like oh yeah that's that's one of my more tame positions yeah so our
00:20:53 goal this episode is not to retread everything that we did on friday right but i do just want
00:20:57 to in case you're just catching this for the first time um it's important to point out that
00:21:03 the arguments that we're making and really the best arguments against something like the 19th
00:21:07 amendment is not simply equality and it's not fair that women get don't get drafted that's not the
00:21:13 argument that we're making we're making a patriarchal argument from creation from the
00:21:18 bible and even from christian tradition um over over centuries and millennia um and and that's
00:21:24 not like like i said we're not going to go through all of that right now um but it's interesting to
00:21:29 me that um that this has been the dominant approach for christian civilization for pretty
00:21:38 much since the beginning there's been no christian civilization that has ever put women forward
00:21:43 voluntarily into the public sphere in this way.
00:21:48 What's interesting to me also is that this actually is a question
00:21:51 that has been discussed in America's history a lot,
00:21:55 even from the very beginning.
00:21:57 Even from the very beginning, there were questions about,
00:21:59 well, we're starting something new. 0.98
00:22:01 Should women be allowed to vote?
00:22:02 And Wes and I were chatting before this about how
00:22:04 whether the church is leading or not,
00:22:09 the church always affects culture. 0.97
00:22:10 And one of the reasons why when the Constitution was being debated and even leading up to it and after the time it was ratified, there were already questions about whether or not women should be voting and participating in public life.
00:22:23 And part of it was the Quaker church polity, which allowed men and women to speak in services.
00:22:32 And so because they had that position, they were saying, well, this has to flow outward into the political and public sphere as well.
00:22:39 And so from the beginning, actually, there were calls that women ought to be given the vote.
00:22:45 And John Adams, I'm going to read a quote from John Adams.
00:22:49 He reacted very, very strongly against this.
00:22:52 So Nate, we'll take that first quote from Adams.
00:22:58 He said, this is, yeah, why exclude women? 1.00
00:23:02 Because their delicacy renders them unfit for practice and experience in the great business of life 1.00
00:23:08 and the hardy enterprises of war, as well as the arduous cares of state. Besides, their attention
00:23:14 is so much engaged with the necessary nurture of their children that nature has made them the
00:23:19 fittest for domestic cares, and children have not judgment or will of their own.
00:23:26 Depend upon it, sir. This is in a letter. It is dangerous to open such a source of controversy
00:23:31 and altercation, as would be opened by attempting to change the qualifications of voters.
00:23:36 there will be no listen to this he says we can't go tampering with this he says there will be no
00:23:42 end of it new claims will arise when will we demand demand a vote lads from 12 to 21 will
00:23:47 think their rights not enough attended to and every man who has not a dime will demand an equal voice
00:23:54 with any other in all acts of state it tends to confound and destroy all distinctions and
00:24:01 surrender all ranks to one common level you want to talk about prophetic and you want to talk about
00:24:07 a man who understood what's what yeah that's an incredible quote john adams this is the same
00:24:12 very same john adams who says the constitution is only fit for religious moral people wholly
00:24:17 unfit for any other good grief yeah the early the early centuries of america it was a white
00:24:23 free proper owning men that could vote like that's just who voted so we had a democracy and 0.61
00:24:27 And they saw that as good because they were coming out of a monarchy, a tyranny of a king that could abandon and say, oh, I'm not going to protect you.
00:24:34 I'm not going to do trade with you.
00:24:35 I'm going to let parliament levy taxes.
00:24:37 So coming out of a monarchy, they come to a democracy.
00:24:39 And there were a good number of men that had a stake in the future that were free.
00:24:43 They weren't slaves that they could vote.
00:24:45 And those people did decide and pass bonds and chose their delegates.
00:24:49 So the House of Representatives, the Senate, that's that's how it worked.
00:24:53 And for the most part, it was over 21, land-owning.
00:24:58 And at that point, if you own land, it meant you had an education, it meant you had a stake.
00:25:02 The other thing was that the men who fought in the Revolutionary War, the War for Independence,
00:25:08 I mean, when you read their documents, they said,
00:25:10 we pledge our lives, our honor, and our sacred for our lives, honor, and fortunes,
00:25:15 sacred honor and fortunes to this endeavor.
00:25:18 I mean, there was a sense where they really were all in it together.
00:25:20 They had put everything on the line.
00:25:22 and it was fitting to have a society where men of that caliber and that commitment had a say
00:25:29 and what was going to go on after the war right having people i think we said this on friday in
00:25:33 our episode but having people who it's um they had a stake uh when it comes to the past uh fathers
00:25:42 i've said it before like um honor towards your fathers in the past and hope for um for your
00:25:50 sons in the future you know like so you're looking at you know in both directions with
00:25:55 the corridors of time that you're saying i have a stake in this place it's my home it's not just a
00:26:01 set of propositions or an economic zone but it's my country these are my my kinsmen it is my home
00:26:07 and and i can trace that back in terms of heritage fathers looking back and i actually have posterity
00:26:14 I have a stake not only in the country's past, in its history, but in its future.
00:26:21 I actually am raising the next generation that will then, Lord willing, raise the next generation.
00:26:28 And then the free aspect, you know, like, you know, in terms of like a general equity type principle of application,
00:26:35 I would look at that and say, you know, today, like, we don't have slavery.
00:26:40 We do.
00:26:41 We have plenty of slaves, you know, but we don't have slavery like we once did.
00:26:44 it's changed, the nature of it. But I would still look at the same principle. So I would say that
00:26:49 if you are dependent on the state, which means ultimately the state produces nothing,
00:26:57 therefore the state doesn't have money, right? The United States government doesn't have money.
00:27:01 All it has is your money. That's all it has is your money. So when you're receiving state handouts,
00:27:07 What you're receiving is the taxes of your fellow citizens.
00:27:14 You're taking somebody else, your neighbor's money.
00:27:17 You're taking your neighbor's money.
00:27:18 And I would just say that if you're on welfare, I would like to see welfare abolished.
00:27:22 Now, I'd like to see it done humanely.
00:27:26 And I recognize that there would be a process involved.
00:27:29 It would take time.
00:27:31 But I would like to see welfare abolished because I do believe it goes against the Scripture.
00:27:35 that said though in the meantime you would think that at minimum yeah if if you're not paying taxes
00:27:43 and instead not only are you not paying taxes but you're actually receiving taxes from others
00:27:49 then no you know you don't get an equal voice to someone who is paying for your food and your
00:27:58 rent and you're of course of course not aristotle called that out it was like the rich and the poor
00:28:03 said you got to be very careful so like in the athenian states for instance it was it was men
00:28:08 that were free and uh often they had to have military service but the point with the rich
00:28:12 and the poor is like if you make suffrage universal and you give it to all the poor will be greater
00:28:16 in number that's how resources are distributed and they're going to demand of the rich so policies
00:28:20 and candidates that want to say well we distribute wealth we'll give free handouts and you give all
00:28:25 of the poor all of the slaves and you add women into that too you'll have a mass of 80 of people
00:28:30 that want the stuff that the rich have and so all of these states from athens from rome and others
00:28:35 if there was voting it was very carefully guarded you had to be the son of a citizen you had to own
00:28:40 property you had to have some of them even the time to do it so that had to be your profession
00:28:45 was to vote you had to have military service you had to be all in ties to it and so in that way
00:28:50 you didn't have masses of people with little to their name voting to take it from the rich well
00:28:55 said and the reason why we're mentioning this right here at the outset is because yeah we are
00:28:59 not 19th amendment respecters but beyond that to be a little bit to not just pick on you know
00:29:05 women having the vote um we really what we despise is universal suffrage yeah it's not just it's not
00:29:13 just the 19th amendment um but all together and here's the funny thing is like pretty much every 0.52
00:29:18 red-blooded american right whether you're you're white black male female pretty much everyone
00:29:25 disagrees with universal suffrage and what i mean by that is nobody thinks that two-year-olds should
00:29:31 be voting yep right right so everybody at some point it's kind of like the argument like everybody
00:29:35 is a cessationist at some point right like like nobody thinks that we have apostles of christ
00:29:40 who are eyewitness you know eyewitness you know people to the the you know the uh to jesus christ
00:29:46 himself to the resurrected christ and are being commissioned by him for writing new books of the
00:29:51 bible to be added to the canon today right so like no matter where you land on that theological issue
00:29:55 of you know continuationism cessationism everybody is a cessationist at some level and to be fair
00:30:01 everyone's a continuationist to some level because we still think there are certain spiritual gifts
00:30:05 like mercy helps administration teaching uh that still exists so everybody believes in some part
00:30:10 something's continued and also to some so some part something sees so the the question is simply
00:30:16 at that point a matter of degree so a question of the matter degree nobody believes in boundless
00:30:22 universal suffrage we all agree that there are certain there are certain elements and certain
00:30:28 sectors of the populace whether you limit to children or on on the other end it's like if
00:30:33 somebody has dementia right right if somebody's is felons you know and this is strictly hypothetical
00:30:38 i i would never stoop so low to give a you know but if if somebody has dementia and doesn't know
00:30:44 where they are they shouldn't be able to vote much less be the president of the united states
00:30:50 So whether it's the very elderly, we love the elderly, but those who literally are starting to, their mind is beginning to degrade, or the child, you know, everybody, I think, just about, with common sense, agrees, yeah, voting shouldn't be everyone. 0.73
00:31:11 And not only that, but this has been, Wes, like you said, this has been kind of a no-duh for most of history.
00:31:18 Now, Nate, let's show quote number two.
00:31:21 This is from a political writer and thinker named Michael Walsh.
00:31:25 And he says this.
00:31:27 In no previous historical iteration of either a republic or democracy was universal suffrage allowed or even contemplated.
00:31:34 The Greeks and the Romans had a quaint notion that only productive male citizens, especially those who put their lives, honor, and sacred fortunes.
00:31:40 There's the line again.
00:31:42 on the line for their city, nation, state, or empire,
00:31:45 and who bought their own weapons and armor, by the way,
00:31:48 could earn the right to vote.
00:31:51 There was some sense where it was passed down through citizenship,
00:31:54 but then also there was, as Wes said,
00:31:57 sometimes provisions for men who fought in war,
00:32:01 they could earn citizenship if they survived long enough
00:32:03 to come back to Rome and kind of be,
00:32:07 not necessarily the same thing,
00:32:09 but kind of commissioned as an officer
00:32:10 would be kind of a similar way of thinking about it now or being a veteran who returned in good
00:32:16 standing that sort of thing so this this has been this has been uh kind of normal human thinking
00:32:23 about this topic and Wes and I were talking both Wes and I moved to Texas and Wes it would be good
00:32:27 for you to share the comment that you said about voting in Texas elections yeah so it's very easy
00:32:33 you know for three white men that are you know property owning have children members of Protestant
00:32:38 churches i was adopted i don't know my birth father as far as we know as far as we who are 0.60
00:32:44 you calling white you could be an albino yeah who knows jolt can't vote okay so it's very easy for 0.63
00:32:50 three of us to sit here and say like well universal suffrage is a farce which of course it is but
00:32:54 here's the deal i'll take texas for an example i didn't grow up here i didn't even grow up in the
00:32:58 south i grew up in the north in pennsylvania new york moved to texas a couple years ago i should
00:33:04 not be allowed to vote here i don't have a connection to this land like my children maybe
00:33:08 even my grandchildren yes they should have the right to if they stay here and they put down roots
00:33:13 but if tomorrow morning a decree went out you have to have three generations of continuous living
00:33:18 productive employment uh living according to law no felonies ownership membership in a church if
00:33:24 that's required and i would lose my right to vote in texas and never be able to gain it in the rest
00:33:29 of my life i would be perfectly fine with that i would sleep i would be happy to not have to go
00:33:34 i can't vote yes i can't just be like i don't have to go to the municipality now once every
00:33:39 two years and like look at a bunch of names and be like gosh these all sound terrible like i'd be
00:33:44 fine with that right and you would know that those who could vote exactly those just laws those who
00:33:49 could vote in your state where you're raising your children um would be the most informed
00:33:55 responsible moral upright voters that you could possibly have you would know that that um you
00:34:01 couldn't vote but the um but the state of texas would only improve exactly yep and so it's great
00:34:08 i think i have good ideas and make good choices on bonds that this or the other but i could
00:34:12 recognize even though i in the macro in the individual i think would be a very capable voter
00:34:18 by god's grace i can recognize if that was taken away for even more capable those who may be voted
00:34:23 more reliably as a whole and i'm not part of that group because of children or ownership or
00:34:28 heritage or whatever be perfectly fine with that so if you're here like i don't like that idea of
00:34:32 taking that right away like who cares you go vote every two years you don't have something in your
00:34:37 calendar now yeah the question is not about what about my rights the question is um what is going
00:34:42 to be good number one for the glory of god um and according accordance with his word number two
00:34:48 what is going to be good for our country and the future of our country are my children my posterity
00:34:54 not just well what about my independent atomistic you know individual right um no like voting to be
00:35:04 frank like just like universal income is not a right universal health care is not right right
00:35:09 there are there what is it active rights and passive rights is that the delineation like so
00:35:14 there are certain rights like like life natural rights yeah natural rights that are god-given
00:35:20 inalienable rights that every single human being has the individual actually has you have a right
00:35:24 to self-defense right you have a right to um to not just be plowed over and exploited by by the
00:35:31 judicial system and the law and those kinds of so it's the right to um defend yourself in court and
00:35:36 those kinds of things the right to true religious worship but you don't have a right and i'm gosh
00:35:40 I'm going to sound like just a normie conservative, but these things are true.
00:35:44 But you don't have a right to other people's labor, right?
00:35:47 So when it comes to a right to health care, what you're saying is that somebody else who spent their life acquiring the skills and the knowledge to be a health care professional, a doctor,
00:35:59 that he somehow has a moral obligation under the law
00:36:04 to devote toward you a certain portion of his time,
00:36:07 his energy, and his resources,
00:36:10 that he owes it to you.
00:36:11 So what you're essentially doing
00:36:13 is you're taking every healthcare professional
00:36:16 and no longer treating them as a professional,
00:36:18 but enslaving an entire class of people
00:36:21 based off of their profession.
00:36:23 Because you chose to go into the field of healthcare,
00:36:26 we have now determined that all of you are slaves.
00:36:29 How did you get there, Joel?
00:36:30 What's the correlation?
00:36:31 Because they don't any longer have ownership over their own time and labor and skills.
00:36:38 The government must provide them to you.
00:36:40 The government must provide them to you.
00:36:42 So all that being said, there are certain rights that are inalienable, like the right to life and self-defense and these things.
00:36:49 And then there are other rights that when you say, this is my right, what you're really doing is you're infringing upon someone else's rights.
00:36:56 You're saying, you don't have a right to your labor, or you don't have a right to your money, right, because of welfare.
00:37:02 I have a right to the money that you have acquired by your work.
00:37:06 20% of your income.
00:37:06 And it's the same with voting.
00:37:09 Not exactly the same, but voting is not an inalienable—there are distinctions, but it is not an inalienable right, like the right to self-defense.
00:37:17 If it was, then anyone who lives in a monarchy is somehow unnatural.
00:37:23 Right, well, then you would have to—
00:37:24 Yes, end against.
00:37:25 And some Christians do this, sadly. So, I understand why people might be confused about
00:37:29 this. And when I say some Christians, I mean 90% of them. But some people would go so far as to say
00:37:34 it's not just that equal weights and measures and just laws are prescribed in the Decalogue,
00:37:40 in summary law, moral law, and also through the general equity of the civil codes. But not just
00:37:46 that, but forms of government are explicitly prescribed in Scripture. So, that a constitutional
00:37:53 republic is the only the only moral system of government and monarchy is not just a different
00:37:59 system it's not just different it's immoral it's sin it's actually sin um i know guys who would go
00:38:04 that far now i disagree that said i do think that a constitutional republic is ideal if you have a
00:38:10 society that's fit for that but that requires we always forget our constitutional republic
00:38:15 that we used to have we now you know pretend we have it you know but what we used to have 0.84
00:38:19 it didn't just spring up out of the ether one day it came out of a thousand years of chrysidom
00:38:25 or at that point about 700 years of chrysidom and and what was the common form of government
00:38:32 for that 700 years of chrysidom monarchy right so monarchy was the shoulders it was the giant
00:38:38 shoulders that a constitutional public republic eventually stood upon so after the populace a
00:38:45 people being shaped by christian ideals from a christian monarch for seven centuries then the
00:38:52 people were ready then they were ready for self hard rule of law too that's right like crushing
00:38:58 that's right public execution yeah cutting out 10 20 15 or whatever of the criminals
00:39:04 they were gone gone for centuries and generations once you culled all of that
00:39:09 had a monarchy instructed for centuries in christianity that was about the point
00:39:13 where men that own property that's right then you were ready for uh self-representative
00:39:20 government but even then um it still wasn't universal it still wasn't for everyone it was
00:39:26 for every household every free tax paying law abiding household and even in that case each
00:39:33 household had one representative namely the head of household the father husband yeah yeah so we
00:39:40 just we forget all these things you don't know the universal universal right to voting is not a
00:39:46 thing it's like well that's that's what the bible teaches what bible maybe the schofield bible i
00:39:52 was about to say the post-war war ii bible right all right we're gonna hit our first commercial
00:39:56 break when we come back we're gonna be talking about some of the roots behind uh the push for
00:40:02 women to to gain the right to vote our sponsor private family banking wants to help you with 0.97
00:40:07 one money move that'll implicate itself in multi-generational wealth building starting 1.00
00:40:13 the first day. They help you to avoid taxation and to draw compound interest to your money.
00:40:19 Now, if you're a high net worth individual, someone who has maybe even $10 million in net
00:40:24 worth, then they can help you even more. W-2 workers, contract workers, business owners,
00:40:30 it's all about cash flow and making tax deferred gains on all your money for the rest of your life
00:40:38 don't avoid this it's a big move but it's a great time to make it click the link below and you can
00:40:43 get on chuck de la dorante's calendar and he'll go over your background and what you want to
00:40:48 accomplish and he's going to help model a program that exactly fits your needs so go ahead and send
00:40:55 an email to chuck at privatefamilybanking.com. Again, that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com
00:41:03 or you can click the link below. Make a free discovery call now. America is a country that
00:41:08 was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God and not to have their
00:41:12 consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men. Reese Fund exists in order to see the 10
00:41:17 commandments properly applied, not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
00:41:22 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:41:26 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:41:31 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them
00:41:34 to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
00:41:38 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:41:44 All right, welcome back.
00:41:46 We want to transition now into talking a little bit about
00:41:49 some of the roots of the movement that pushed for women to have the right to vote.
00:41:56 Honestly, this is a fascinating historical time period, and there were a lot and a lot of moving
00:42:02 parts. And so we're not going to do it justice here. I found it super interesting as I researched
00:42:09 and as I've researched in the past, like just from a purely conceptual idea, like what was going on.
00:42:16 And again, I'm more and more convinced that we need to take hope in the fact that even
00:42:22 when we look now back at the beginning of America and we say, oh, they had everything
00:42:27 right.
00:42:27 It was so stable.
00:42:28 It was so solid.
00:42:29 And it was.
00:42:29 And they had a lot more right than we do now.
00:42:31 But even then, there were always moving parts, always moving pieces.
00:42:35 And that should give us encouragement because we live in a time with a lot of moving parts
00:42:39 and a lot of moving pieces.
00:42:40 And all it takes, while it's, Joel, you're famous for saying this, it's not easy, but
00:42:45 it's simple.
00:42:45 all it takes is for us to be wise and courageous and to live in the time that god has put us in
00:42:50 and and to act accordingly right so it's not complicated yep but it is hard yep you know
00:42:56 or it's not easy but it is simple yep you know yeah i found it really encouraging i'm sorry
00:43:00 michael but uh yesterday you said like it's 80 years that things typically happen so the
00:43:04 revolutionary war 1776 1780 to the civil war yep civil war then to world war ii and we are we are
00:43:11 on the cusp of a generation that is things are changing quickly the american caesar yep american
00:43:17 caesar he's coming back baron trump he's coming we took two l's and now we're gonna we're gonna
00:43:21 take the w yeah there we go yeah seriously good so there was a i mentioned already the quaker
00:43:26 um influence in this but there was a very deep spiritual movement going on underneath the push
00:43:35 for women's equality in the vote and what's really interesting is the way that in the first
00:43:43 wave of feminism as they were pushing for and by the way they were pushing for a lot it was a whole
00:43:47 movement they were pushing for temperance that's true they were pushing for universal suffrage
00:43:52 they were pushing for many many other public policies rather than just the the right for
00:43:59 women to vote um they were pushing for divorce laws um they were pushing for all sorts of things
00:44:05 but underneath they're pushing against head coverings in church absolutely yep that was a 0.66
00:44:09 big one yep that's absolutely right underneath it all was a sense of uh they would not have
00:44:15 articulated it like we do now the divine feminine but there was a sense of spiritual empowerment for
00:44:21 women as well um and the movement for for being in a christian time was incredibly anti-christian
00:44:30 like no one could come out and say we hate christianity we want to do away with all of it
00:44:35 that just would not have been viable but even people that are now regarded as heroines in
00:44:40 history uh people like um elizabeth katie stanton she said this about the movement uh so nate this
00:44:47 is the third quote um she said the bible and the church have been the greatest stumbling blocks in
00:44:54 the way of women's emancipation um and and so in a very real sense the the bible still is that's
00:45:03 the church is not we used to have two safeguards that's right that's right but now we only have
00:45:10 one sadly the church is and i'll throw this in here too uh jewish women were a big part of the
00:45:15 women's suffrage movement they were involved they organized they rallied they funded no and you're
00:45:21 i believe it or not jewish women were a part of this movement i can't believe it but you're i
00:45:26 don't know if you're going to talk about it here communism and socialism yep stemming from the
00:45:30 same branch carl marx the communist manifesto marx was jewish there's a revolutionary spirit
00:45:35 that contributed not all of them like elizabeth katie stanton was not jewish for instance but
00:45:39 they were very much involved in pushing suffrage and temperance and all these things yep and
00:45:43 probably i imagine there was probably i think you said this west so i don't think i'm just imagining
00:45:47 right but um like with a like a christian version of pushing women's rights and then a non-christian
00:45:52 yes like like a spiritual the jewish women who were involved in that trying to stop you know um
00:45:59 you know stop the patriarchy where you know they they did it through a um a thin christian veneer 0.96
00:46:05 for for those who would you know that that that that kind of controlled opposition would would
00:46:10 be more compelling more persuasive and then they also did just through a secular yes vein as well
00:46:15 yep in fact nate we could jump right over to the screenshots then um this was from a track that
00:46:23 would push that was put out by actually a catholic um group and one of the things and i have it over
00:46:31 here on the right these are little snippets from that tract it says this it says first there are
00:46:36 Millions of socialists in this country, and all are unanimous for women's suffrage
00:46:43 because they hope, by the women's vote, to help themselves politically.
00:46:49 All socialists are opposed to anything Christian, but they bitterly hate and attack Catholics.
00:46:55 Why should Catholics join themselves with such—I can't read that last word.
00:47:00 Such a body. 1.00
00:47:00 A body.
00:47:01 I can read this next one, too.
00:47:02 And then the next one, second, the great cry of the suffrage body is for the individual liberty.
00:47:08 They demand the vote because they object to their husbands, fathers and brothers voting for them.
00:47:14 And so it makes, it's so interesting to me, the connection with the Jewish influence in the communist and socialist revolutions in Europe. 0.54
00:47:22 So the socialists were like 100 unanimous is what that quote said.
00:47:25 like there's a million socialists in this country and unanimously unanimously if there's one thing
00:47:31 we agree on it's uh women should vote everyone should vote but women in particular in this case 0.77
00:47:36 american communism had its real swell in the 20s and 30s it died down with obviously like the red
00:47:42 scare and everything but that was the the high watermark for the american socialist party
00:47:46 presidential candidates all of that and to the point it was a big movement actually had a decent
00:47:50 size and it was unanimous voting rights for all yep because that that eliminates all hierarchy
00:47:56 and all distinction um and really man did a number on western civilization just that idea
00:48:04 which we don't need to do it's it's old territory for us but again there's more going on here when
00:48:09 we when we say repeal the 19th amendment there's more going on than than hating women right right
00:48:17 uh which for the record for the for the clip's sake we're not saying we need none of us hate
00:48:21 women no but the claim would be that's all we care about all three of our wives my wife voted
00:48:26 yeah yep like and that's another thing just i've mentioned it before but real quick and someone
00:48:30 asked it too real quick so we um we are people who have convictions all three of us are men who
00:48:36 have convictions and principles but there's a difference between being principled and being
00:48:41 an ideologue. An ideologue will, in God's sweet providence, there will be occasional moments where
00:48:49 something really good will be right within his grasp, and he will pick it up and throw it down
00:48:57 and crush it on the floor in the name of the perfect. It's like, if I can't have absolute
00:49:04 perfection now then we'll have nothing good you know we can't have nice things unless we have
00:49:10 everything i want um we are not ideologues right response ministries um is a ministry that loves
00:49:16 theology we love principles we're deeply conservative we hate what what god would
00:49:22 consider to be genuine compromise um and yet at the same time although all those things are true
00:49:28 we are not ideologues in fact we hate ideology so that being said um if there was something
00:49:34 on the docket that like you know to repeal the 19th amendment we would vote for it with our
00:49:40 wives yeah now here's here's the thing you know for all the bad faith listeners and there's
00:49:44 hundreds who listen to every second of every episode hoping that this is the time i'm gonna
00:49:52 get you and shut you down um so for you there's nothing i can say to appease you but you know
00:49:58 those guys the bad faith listeners to our ministry they're gonna think oh well that's that's hypocrisy 0.97
00:50:03 right that's the only category that they could think of is um you think women shouldn't vote 0.95
00:50:07 but you had your wives vote with you for donald trump in 2024 that's hypocritical and we would say
00:50:14 nope um that's strategic so if there was literally on the ballot um a bill for for recalling you
00:50:24 know repealing the 19th amendment we would vote with our wives for that um and the reason why
00:50:31 is because until the female vote is repealed the way i see it and i've said this before but i'll
00:50:39 say it again is that for every man in our country half of his vote was stripped away from him that's
00:50:46 ultimately what's going on your vote was stripped away from it's it's not like it was just like when
00:50:51 the this is the best way i could explain it it's just like when the fed prints money when they
00:50:56 print money they don't actually create money they they actually inflate money they devalue
00:51:02 all the money that's already out there so when they print a trillion dollars what they actually
00:51:07 did is however many trillion dollars were already in circulation they took a little bit away from
00:51:11 that so too with the 19th amendment they didn't create an extra vote they took half of your vote
00:51:17 and so until the 19th amendment is repealed my wife votes with me because what she's doing of
00:51:24 her own volition, for the record, because she's a woman who fears the Lord and actually respects
00:51:30 and loves and submits to her husband, is she saying, Joel, I believe that through sin and
00:51:36 wicked men, half of your vote was stolen from you. But I, as your loving wife, am going to give back.
00:51:45 I'm going to make restitution and give back what was stolen from you by voting with my husband
00:51:51 until the full vote belongs to him.
00:51:54 That's not hypocrisy.
00:51:56 That's social justice.
00:51:59 That's restitution.
00:52:00 It's biblical.
00:52:01 It's just. 0.77
00:52:02 It's right.
00:52:02 Yeah.
00:52:03 So one of the things that I'm seeing in the chat here is
00:52:05 the history of women's suffrage is actually interesting
00:52:10 because the 19th Amendment guaranteed from a federal requirement
00:52:18 that all female citizens of the United States be allowed to vote. 0.97
00:52:22 But the reason why this was actually going on already 0.99
00:52:26 was that the Constitution, before the amendments
00:52:29 that gave universal suffrage in all of its ways,
00:52:32 so 14th and 19th and 24th, 25th, things like that,
00:52:37 before those were passed, the Constitution,
00:52:41 because of its federalism,
00:52:43 actually gave the power of determining who can vote and when to vote to the states and so leading
00:52:52 up to 1919 1920 which was when the 19th amendment was finally passed into law many states had
00:52:59 already because it was within their purview they had already given women the right to vote and in
00:53:05 fact um one of the one of the questions asked about heads of household if you're a widow like
00:53:11 yes they voted that like if the husband died and she took over the farm or the plantation or
00:53:16 whatever because she had a stake she had ownership and yeah yep they were they were black uh property
00:53:21 older widow so it's like she doesn't have a father she may not even have a brother correct 1.00
00:53:25 similar to like your first timothy chapter five widows that would be taking care of the church 0.98
00:53:30 they don't have a brother an uncle or a father or a husband or even sons necessarily to care for 0.98
00:53:35 them so that woman who's there's there's no male line lineage anymore to represent her family name
00:53:42 and yet she still is is alive and has the family estate and and therefore has a stake in the
00:53:48 country in its future that makes sense and that's going to get past her her sons her children and
00:53:53 maybe they're young at that time yeah so um there were uh situations where black property owners
00:53:59 for free black men also voted right um in fact before the 19th amendment was passed
00:54:04 um in 1797 new jersey was already allowing women to vote and then classic new jersey
00:54:11 yeah just taking the l early early we're here gonna be a loser hold on hold on i'm gonna redeem
00:54:17 new jersey just for a second um in 1807 they actually voted to restrict it to only free my
00:54:24 white males no white so yeah yeah gotta love new jersey all right um but 1869 territory of wyoming
00:54:33 1890 the state of wyoming then colorado in 1893 washington 1910 california 1911 this was already
00:54:41 going through the states um oh is this what we talked about before the show your black pill yes
00:54:46 so i do have a black bill here go for it because if we were to repeal the amendments related to
00:54:52 universal suffrage 19th amendment primarily being the one that we're talking about today
00:54:56 that actually doesn't fix the problem for us because the delegated power to determine who
00:55:04 gets to vote is actually in the original constitution up to the states which we support
00:55:09 yes that's great that is a good thing but if we were we were actually going to fix this problem 0.87
00:55:15 we as a nation would have to pass a positive amendment that says only men who are heads of
00:55:24 household and own property and have been here this long etc all the stipulations that we're saying
00:55:28 are allowed to vote it's kind of similar to the abortion issue except in the in the other direction
00:55:33 obviously there's separate topics but also in in the uh in the inverse uh with with abortion
00:55:39 is like dobbs praise god it beats the heck out of row right yep you know right but to be fair
00:55:46 like a lot of our abolitionist friends who we love like they would say dobbs is a wicked decision
00:55:51 right and in the technical sense in the biblical sense they're right right um because the right
00:55:58 just decision is not um you know what states can uh decide to whether or not they want to kill
00:56:06 babies no the just position is uh to actually not just say roe is done and now it's just a state's
00:56:13 issue no the just decision is at the federal level now states can go against it and then and
00:56:18 then the state would be exclusively moral morally responsible for god for that wicked decision but
00:56:24 at the federal level to say uh i'm sorry but under christian nationalism the human sacrifice must 0.58
00:56:30 end that's right the molek worship must end so not just saying uh no more roe but saying uh no no
00:56:36 no no uh we're going it's because because from roe to dobbs is really kind of from like a negative
00:56:40 to a neutral right but the neutral is still negative it's still not just and so what you're
00:56:45 saying is with the 19th now back to our topic at hand um repealing the 19th would kind of be
00:56:51 similar to like a dobbs decision it's like okay we recognize the 19th was wicked um but it wouldn't
00:56:56 really be until two things happen well three things repealing the 19th and then at the federal
00:57:01 level there would need to be a positive amendment that would have to pass they would say um only so
00:57:08 and so can vote whoever however we decide that um and then at the state level there would also have
00:57:14 to be um a positive decision made uh for each state not necessarily if a federal amendment
00:57:20 that supersedes anything in the state unless the state consciously went against it no no like 0.51
00:57:26 Like, no state was allowed to say after the 14th Amendment, no black man can vote, right?
00:57:32 The federal constitution supersedes all state laws. 0.78
00:57:37 So if the federal, okay, but if the federal constitution did that, and the positive amendment,
00:57:43 so not just repeal the 19th, but a positive amendment of this is who can vote at the federal
00:57:46 level, constitutionally, and then let's say, it wouldn't be Texas, but let's say New Jersey,
00:57:51 like let's say new jersey is um no everybody can still vote and they're voting in a national
00:57:56 election you're saying that um it just won't count yes because that's where power matters
00:58:01 because the constitution says the constitution says the powers not specifically delegated to
00:58:07 the federal government in the constitution belong to the state at that point the constitution is
00:58:12 delegating to itself the power to decide who gets to vote and so a state might still try and say you
00:58:18 can go pound sand and then it would be whether or not the federal government has the willpower
00:58:22 to enforce that new voting amendment on new jersey in this hypothetical situation what what is uh
00:58:29 steve dace always says and i think he says it really well which by the way i don't because i
00:58:33 don't want to get him in trouble he steve dace great guy loves the lord coming to our conference
00:58:37 he would disagree with this entire episode probably maybe but we still love him um maybe i don't know
00:58:43 who knows the oversize window it's moving so quick maybe you know maybe by the time we get
00:58:47 to the conference six weeks from now steve dace is going to get up there and be like yep repeal
00:58:50 who knows but uh but anyways but he always says uh we are not we are not a nation of laws
00:58:56 right did you yes we're not a nation of laws we're a nation of political will yeah he said
00:59:01 we're not a nation of laws and never have been yeah we're a nation of political will and always
00:59:05 will be yes something like that which is so true like even when you saw the standoff between like
00:59:11 biden and some of the uh the governors state governors you know of the southern border you
00:59:15 know they were all like one by one all the republican states were it was like come and
00:59:20 take it kind of thing like at the end of the day somebody has to exercise the will the power what
00:59:26 i've realized it the words on the paper they don't really matter that much political will and power
00:59:31 like in arizona abortion on the law in the constitution was illegal none of them would
00:59:37 enforce it there's no political will gay marriage as approval of it in the american public goes from
00:59:42 40 to 30 to 20 one way or another will not be legal it is all downstream they change and they
00:59:48 do matter because then they teach and toodle and uh tutor instruct tutor and instruct uh but
00:59:54 ultimately it's will so and that's why i think the christian caesar happens before yeah 20 years of
01:00:02 well how many states have to ratify that's what i was leading up to this is this is not and it's
01:00:07 look the overtime window is moving fast enough that we're not blackpilling right we're just right
01:00:10 But there's two ways.
01:00:12 There can be a convention of states, which has never been done for a constitutional amendment, or an amendment has to pass with two-thirds of both chambers of the legislative branch, so the House and the Senate, and then three-quarters of the states have to agree to it, ratify it for an amendment to pass.
01:00:32 Well, you know what?
01:00:33 This is what I know about these United States of America. 0.96
01:00:35 we have had in our history two and i repeat only two opportunities to elect a female president 0.98
01:00:43 that's right and we said resounding resoundingly no hell no hell no that's right in both cases
01:00:50 and as brian survey would say america we were so real for that we had two opportunities to elect
01:00:56 a female president we said no both times america you were so real for that yeah yeah so i'm hopeful
01:01:01 Well, this is why, as all of these debates were happening in the states, and then even leading up to the passage of the 19th Amendment federally, people were really opposed to it.
01:01:10 I mean, there were guys who had their eyes wide open to what was going on, and they warned, and they pled, and they argued against it, because they knew, number one, if it does get passed, it's going to be hard to undo, and number two, it's going to do incalculable damage.
01:01:27 This next quote is from Thomas Sedgwick, who was writing in the, I believe this was in the late 1800s, and he just, he saw down what was going to happen if America moved in this direction.
01:01:41 So he said, or William Sedgwick, my mistake, he said,
01:01:44 if women's suffrage would mean a denigration and a degradation of human fiber, which would turn 0.97
01:01:51 back the hands of time a thousand years. Hence, now he was optimistic. Hence, it will probably 1.00
01:01:57 never come. For mankind will not lightly abandon, at the call of a few fanatics, the hard-earned
01:02:03 achievements of the ages. Gosh, he was wrong. Yep. Boy, was he ever wrong. Yep. Yep. And tragically
01:02:09 so tragically now here's the white pill the temperance movement the uh yes not the abolition
01:02:14 of alcohol the prohibition prohibition it it passed it was ratified by the states it was
01:02:19 enacted in the constitution repealed like 10 years later after people were like later on they got a
01:02:22 dose of their own medicine yeah and that's what we kind of covered that a few we've covered that
01:02:26 for right you know the last three years but like but we really covered that i think last week on
01:02:30 a couple of our episodes and just saying it's a simple concept but just but just encouraging the
01:02:35 listener and i feel you know ourselves just encouraging each other that um history history
01:02:41 it was it was in the cold open today history is not just um you know just uh what is the way you
01:02:48 word it a revolution like where it only moves a progression yeah yeah like a progression like a
01:02:53 march towards progress or something like yeah like an eternal perpetual march towards you know
01:02:57 progress which really means you know right you know regress um until the end of time um that's
01:03:03 that's actually you look at history that is not the way history is played out right that's a very
01:03:07 dispensational novel idea that that everything has just gotten worse and worse and worse
01:03:12 or no better and better and better yeah that's not that's the opposite of the dispensational
01:03:18 both of those are immature yeah both of those are immature and people you know for again the
01:03:22 bad faith listener who might be tuning in and saying well that's your view like you hate on
01:03:26 dispensationalism but aren't you you know post-millennial so you think things only constantly
01:03:30 get better that's not the post-millennial view the post-millennial view doesn't say that things
01:03:34 only with a steady incline with no dips and no challenges along the way that they only ever get
01:03:40 better no we're just saying that the overall trajectory is going to be in the positive
01:03:44 direction but that can include in certain times in certain places and those places for the record
01:03:49 could be big like half the world like all of western civilization and those time periods are
01:03:54 not just necessarily 10 years or 20 years, but it can be three, four, 500 years, you absolutely,
01:04:00 on that overall trajectory up, you can have some massive dips along the way. And we would say that
01:04:05 we've been in a dip for quite a while, at least since the Enlightenment. But that's kind of the
01:04:12 overarching macro picture of steady trajectory up, but some big dips along the way. But then
01:04:17 in some of the smaller battles along the way that are more contextual to this nation and this time
01:04:22 period and blah, blah, blah. There's, there's ebbs and flows. In fact, I was, you know, there's
01:04:27 a member in our church that they live two and a half hours away and they come to our church
01:04:33 faithfully, a wonderful family. And my wife and kids and I, we try to go and see them,
01:04:40 you know, making pastoral visits, relational visits as often as we can. So we went on Saturday
01:04:45 and it takes all day. It's a five hour trip, round trip. But we went and packed up the van
01:04:49 and spent the day and had a great time and he was showing me you know he had on the wall picture of
01:04:54 robert e lee and he was showing me a quote from robert e lee that's like i was like was robert
01:04:59 e lee postmill you know it was really really encouraging but he's just talking about standing
01:05:03 at the seashore when you look at history and and when the water recedes when it's pulling back
01:05:09 and you think like this is it you know um not realizing that um like the bigger the ebb
01:05:15 the greater the flow yeah like if the water is pulling way back and you're standing at the
01:05:21 shoreline then uh for all you know it could be it could be ebbing and receding and pulling back
01:05:28 further and further like the tide like when a barge goes down you know and it like sucks all
01:05:31 the way it could be pulling back not just your normal ebb flow ebb flow but then all of a sudden
01:05:36 it just keeps pulling back and back and back and it goes back it recedes 20 30 40 feet then then
01:05:42 50 yards and further and further and you're like what is going on and then all of a sudden comes
01:05:47 a tidal wave yep a revival you know and uh we're not revivalist either we do think that god can
01:05:54 and may send revival we just um i just think we should be busy in the meantime but anyways it was
01:05:59 so encouraging i got the quote here i gotta read it this is robert e lee robert e lee the truth is
01:06:04 this the march of providence is so slow and our desires so impatient the work of progress so
01:06:10 immense and our means of aiding it so feeble the life of humanity is so long that of the individual
01:06:15 so brief that we often only see the ebb of the advancing wave and are thus discouraged it is
01:06:20 history that teaches us to hope amen one more time that is god that is fire uh the truth is this the
01:06:27 march of providence is so slow and our desires so impatient the work of progress so immense and our
01:06:32 means of aiding it so feeble the life of humanity is so long that of the individual so brief that
01:06:38 we often only see the ebb of the advancing wave and are thus discouraged.
01:06:42 It is history that teaches us to hope.
01:06:44 Amen.
01:06:46 Imagine, 0.99
01:06:47 imagine tearing down and burning that guy's stature. 1.00
01:06:51 Maybe, 0.97
01:06:52 maybe it's not just about the civil war.
01:06:54 That is crazy.
01:06:56 Talk about ebbs and flows.
01:06:57 So like there,
01:06:58 there's a little ebb,
01:06:59 you know,
01:06:59 in 2020,
01:07:00 very dark time.
01:07:02 But I would like to think that we're going to get an even,
01:07:05 I think for,
01:07:06 for every confederate statue that was torn down we're going to get a replacement 10 times
01:07:10 rebuilt robert e lee he will rise again uh but but yeah that's all that being said um it's you
01:07:17 know it's like oh well now that we you know now that we have basically universal suffrage and you
01:07:24 know the the wheels are off you know and um there's no going back but you don't know like it in one
01:07:32 sense it's hard to go back but that's one of the arguments that we've been making these past few
01:07:35 weeks is saying on the other hand you know what's really hard to do like that you see a usa has has
01:07:41 been proof of this it's really hard to convince people in third world countries that a boy is a
01:07:46 girl and a girl's a boy how do you do that we'll come to find out when you know all of a sudden
01:07:50 the veil is lifted and we're getting to see uh well it turns out it required billions and billions 0.51
01:07:56 of your tax dollars in order to to carrot and bait and switch and indoctrinate entire cultures
01:08:03 and countries into thinking things that are, they go, they fly in the face of nature.
01:08:08 But to go with the grain, right?
01:08:10 That's when you're trying to, that's when you're trying to make pigs fly.
01:08:13 But when you're just trying to teach a bird to fly, it's natural and it's actually easier.
01:08:18 And so a return to nature is actually going downhill.
01:08:22 It's going against nature.
01:08:24 The progressive revolution is actually the uphill climb.
01:08:28 The return to God's natural order is natural.
01:08:33 It's actually the direction with the least resistance.
01:08:37 Now, legislatively, some of the practical law dynamics get hairy of like easier to give
01:08:44 a vote than take it back.
01:08:46 But again, this is not a prediction.
01:08:49 We've said this, not a prediction, or I'm sorry, not a prescription saying we should
01:08:53 do this, but it is a prediction of what might happen, whether we support it or not.
01:08:58 Yeah, that's where you might get your American Caesar who comes in and says, you know, it's hard to repeal because we've lost all of our ambition and all of our good sense.
01:09:15 and we've created universal suffrage
01:09:17 and we can't get everyone to vote to repeal it 0.97
01:09:21 because we've allowed the most foolish of society.
01:09:28 Like we've basically created a no-win scenario. 0.88
01:09:31 So as a benevolent dictator,
01:09:34 I'm going to seize power and take it away.
01:09:36 Right.
01:09:36 Whether you like it or not.
01:09:37 The Roman Republic had a provision for this.
01:09:39 I know how it ended.
01:09:40 I know that the man that they gave it to,
01:09:42 his name was Julius.
01:09:43 great guy but there was a name after the salad dressing that's right but there was a provision
01:09:50 in their laws that in times of crisis they could hand you know unilateral power temporarily
01:09:56 to a man that they trusted turns out you know as far as the republic went that was the end of the
01:10:02 republic right but a good run but as far as the roman civilization went so i'm not saying we
01:10:08 You can transform into an empire with an emperor permanently.
01:10:12 But I'm just saying all Western civilization has understood that sometimes you do get into a situation where someone just needs to come in and clean house.
01:10:22 President of El Salvador, what do you do with a country overrun with gangs and corrupt judges and bribery?
01:10:27 Turns out you get in, you rewrite the Constitution, you instate term limits because you said I can do this.
01:10:32 You investigate them all for bribery and you say I'll be president for however long I want to be.
01:10:37 and he was re-elected with a 90 percent popular vote the highest approval rating in the world
01:10:44 you can just do things you're done judges that have blocked me and impeached right you're out
01:10:49 you are going to prison all of you you are being investigated that's what we're doing now get with
01:10:55 the program yeah yeah all right we're going to go to our second commercial break and when we come 0.86
01:10:59 back we're going to talk about some of the consequences of women's suffrage okay all right
01:11:04 the clock is running out. You need to go and register now for our Christ is King How to Defeat 0.99
01:11:10 Trash World Conference. It's happening the year of our Lord, 2025, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th. That's
01:11:16 a Thursday, Friday, and Saturday. And by God's grace, we're able to provide for you an all-star
01:11:23 lineup. We've got Steve Dace, Calvin Robinson, Oren McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolfe, Eric Kahn,
01:11:29 David Reese, Andrew Isker, John Harris, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, Dusty Devers,
01:11:36 Ben Garrett, C.J. Engel, and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webin. Come on out. Join us April 3rd,
01:11:42 4th and 5th, 2025, Thursday through Saturday. Go to rightresponseconference.com to register today.
01:11:51 Again, that's rightresponseconference.com. Listen, guys, you probably listen to Right
01:11:57 Response Ministries because you take the Dominion mandate offered to us in Scripture
01:12:02 seriously. Well, unsurprisingly, so does Dominion Wealth Strategist. As the only distinctly reformed
01:12:10 financial consulting firm, they help Calvinistic, covenantal, and confessional Christians to steward
01:12:17 their resources faithfully in a way that actually aligns with God's Word. Dominion Wealth leverages
01:12:23 all corners of the financial service industry as independent brokerage agents, matching you
01:12:30 with suitable products and services from dozens of top industry providers. Their mission is to
01:12:36 equip believers to secure their family's future and build a legacy that glorifies God by building
01:12:44 holistic financial strategies that include budgeting, insurance, debt management, retirement
01:12:51 planning, estate planning, and more. In order to make wealth Christian again with a portfolio that
01:12:57 might even put King Solomon to shame, go and take dominion over your finances today by visiting
01:13:04 www.reformed.money and book an introductory overview right now. All of Christ for all of life
01:13:13 and all of finance for Christendom. I'll give it to you. All right, here we are. So right here
01:13:21 in the chat phil how would you say newfield newfield uh he said would love to write off
01:13:26 your conference crisis king conference april 3rd 4th and 5th as a business expense i saw your
01:13:31 comment earlier today on x i appreciate it was a good idea and i told you that we would get it done
01:13:36 and we have so uh phil and everybody else who's thinking the same thing uh we officially are
01:13:42 going to have a business networking lunch at our conference so go to uh you need to register for
01:13:47 the conference and if you're already registered you need to go back to that page so go to right
01:13:51 response conference not ministries but right response conference.com scroll down and register
01:13:58 if you haven't already if you already have then keep scrolling and then you'll see where it says
01:14:02 you'll see the singles event anybody wants to sign up for the singles event make sure to do that
01:14:06 or go down to the business networking lunch and register we're going to charge 25 just to cover
01:14:14 delivery tax tip and food we're going to cater food uh for that lunch um that's it 25 bucks
01:14:20 free lunch and uh i will be there personally and i'm gonna i want to meet all these christian
01:14:25 business owners i want to meet you guys and see if there's anything i can do um to help give
01:14:29 visibility towards your business we want to see it succeed and then the biggest thing will be you
01:14:33 guys networking with each other and um and i think that that will be perfectly ethical and uh up to
01:14:40 code with tax regulations that you can say, yeah, I'm going to a conference and there's
01:14:45 a business portion of it and I'm going to go ahead and write off this expense.
01:14:48 So Phil and everybody else who's in your boat, go ahead and register for our business
01:14:55 networking lunch portion of our conference today.
01:14:58 Yep.
01:14:58 All right.
01:14:59 We want to touch briefly on some of the impact and the fallout of women's suffrage.
01:15:05 So we'll do that briefly and we do want to save some time at the end for some questions
01:15:10 And we do want to honor our promise to especially the one with the super chat that we mentioned we would touch on earlier.
01:15:16 But if you do have questions along this topic, we'll try and get to some of those as well.
01:15:19 So you can start putting those in the chat as well.
01:15:22 Put question in front of it or you make sure you use proper punctuation with the question mark at the end so that Nathan knows to to market for us later on.
01:15:29 Well, obviously, as we are finding out, elections have consequences, and the vote and the passage of the 19th Amendment had consequences as well.
01:15:40 And there's a lot of different directions we can go with this.
01:15:43 The fact that women were voting gave them the power to vote against their husbands, in part with prohibition, in part with divorce laws.
01:15:52 But in general, too, there's a sense where a woman's nature is going to be more compassionate,
01:15:59 more focused on tending to the needs rather than administrating justice.
01:16:07 And so you can look through history and you can see how largely, and I'm going to quote 1.00
01:16:11 a study here in a minute, largely the result of women voting in the public forum and federal 0.99
01:16:18 issues and state issues has been we need we see pain well what we need to do now is vote 0.99
01:16:26 so that federal or state tax money goes to alleviating that pain right and then what
01:16:33 happens unfortunately is that what people who want to push social change all they need to do
01:16:40 is convince half the population women that there is an abuse or an oppression or a pain or something
01:16:48 like that because a woman's heart is naturally going to go to that and that's beautiful and good 0.89
01:16:51 like that we've we've talked about that a lot of times we want moms tending to skin knees and
01:16:57 and bruises it's it's beautiful yeah like we should be i feel like we've been clear but let's
01:17:02 be clear again um there is nothing about the god-ordained nature of a woman that we despise
01:17:09 it's wonderful but what we're saying is that it's only wonderful when it's in its role right it's
01:17:16 wonderful uh in the same way that a navy seal is wonderful that's right you know but but but all
01:17:23 your navy sealness um is is not you know well unless it's like uh arnold schwarzenator a
01:17:28 kindergarten cop did you ever see you know maybe it comes in in handy in a in a you know children
01:17:34 kind of situation and defending them but the point is that um a hammer is wonderful for a nail right
01:17:40 A screwdriver is wonderful for a screw.
01:17:42 You know, a saw is wonderful for making cuts. 1.00
01:17:45 So we love women and we love their nature.
01:17:49 But that nurturing instinct of someone's in pain and crying out for help and I want to go to them, that is a great instinct for children in your home.
01:18:01 That is not a great instinct for going to the voting booth when you have a full-blown invasion at your southern border and a ton of propaganda from liberal media saying, look at this poor AI-generated picture of a little girl being ripped away by ice from her mother.
01:18:19 And then all these single, white, college-educated Marxist women go to the voting booth and make terrible decisions, whereas their nature, it is in the right direction. 0.99
01:18:33 I know we'll get in trouble with that one, but their nature is in the right direction. 0.97
01:18:36 It's just being funneled incorrectly because you take that same concern and sympathy, maybe not so much empathy, but sympathy and nurturing spirit, and you give them three kids.
01:18:47 and gosh they're going to be they're going to be doing great yep they're going to be doing great
01:18:52 so yeah and this is exactly what has played out a 2002 study in the journal of political economy
01:19:00 this is going to be the next quote this is by two researchers named john lott and lawrence kenny
01:19:05 and they they found that this was the net result of women entering the the voting pool they said
01:19:14 This paper examines the growth of government during this century, so that's the 19th century, as a result of giving women the right to vote.
01:19:22 Using cross-sectional time series data for 1870 to 1940, we examined state government expenditures and revenues,
01:19:29 as well as voting by U.S. House and Senate state delegations and the passage of a wide range of different state laws.
01:19:37 Suffrage coincided with immediate increases in state government expenditures and revenue
01:19:42 and more liberal voting patterns for federal representatives 0.99
01:19:45 because they were now getting pressure from women to cater and to court the women's vote. 1.00
01:19:51 And these effects continued growing over time as more women took advantage of the franchise, 1.00
01:19:55 which is of the right to vote.
01:19:57 Contrary to many recent suggestions, the gender gap is not something that has arisen since the 1970s.
01:20:04 In other words, their point is it arose immediately as soon as women started voting in the late 1800s.
01:20:09 And it helps explain why American government started growing when it did.
01:20:14 The growth and the increase of government spending, the federal government has, in fact, let me get my quote, let me make sure I'm right here.
01:20:24 Within 11 years of the 19th Amendment, per capita government spending had doubled.
01:20:29 Federal government spending had doubled.
01:20:31 and um women have a tendency historically of voting overwhelmingly for social programs 1.00
01:20:38 progressive policies and increase in welfare yeah yeah checks out yep and again it doesn't 0.98
01:20:44 mean that women are wicked yep it means that women are kind and generous and nurturing 0.95
01:20:52 and those good god-given instincts are wonderful in their proper place but ill-suited for the
01:20:59 political realm that i like the way pastor andrew isker has said it he said this in his book boniface
01:21:05 option which was a great great book and we even him and myself and ad robles the three of us did
01:21:10 a whole series which you can go and you can find on our youtube channel or our website or
01:21:15 on patreon you can get all 10 parts it's 10 episodes and the whole thing was me and ad
01:21:20 robles and pastor andrew isker covering you know in a 10-part series his entirety of his book
01:21:26 boniface option and one of the can't remember which episode it was but one of the episodes in
01:21:31 that series covering a portion of his book um we addressed women voting and the way that
01:21:36 andrew worded it in the book and then also on that episode that we did together
01:21:40 was i think um really well said he just he said that um politics is war politics is war
01:21:48 without the bullets every time you have a political disagreement what you're ultimately
01:21:51 doing is you're taking two sides of the country on a particular issue and you're rounding up all
01:21:56 of your troops right you're rallying your armies and and then what you do is you you march out and
01:22:04 meet each other uh for battle but but right when you normally would begin firing bullets and there's
01:22:11 a death toll when it's a real hot war instead of doing that you both parties agree both armies
01:22:17 agree that instead of actually firing the bullets what we'll do instead is we'll count your army
01:22:23 how many men enlisted and we'll count the other army how many men enlisted and the bigger army
01:22:29 will go ahead and we'll allow him to win the smaller army will concede and we won't fire a 0.88
01:22:35 single shot it's war without the bullets um and it is improper to enlist women in war yeah yep
01:22:43 that's the argument and and we lose something we we have lost something beautiful let Nate let's go
01:22:49 to the next um quote because i i found this is from from a woman who was was opposed to women's
01:22:55 suffrage um and this is ida m tarbell she says all evidence proves that the adoption of women's
01:23:02 suffrage brings into evidence the bold obtrusive woman whose conduct cheapens the sex and deprives
01:23:09 all other women of a portion of the chivalry and respect which are their birthright yeah when we 0.94
01:23:15 think about chivalry we think about the knights but there was also the ladies and they were
01:23:19 entitled to being treated a certain way honored in a certain way provided for in a certain way
01:23:25 and defended in esteemed in a certain way and what tarbell is saying there is that the women's
01:23:32 suffrage has stolen women of that proper obligation that is owed to them as well that was hold dabney 0.88
01:23:38 wrote a lot on women's rights because there's feminist movements even then there's a big thrust
01:23:42 of his argument he said if you take women and you just flatten the playing field make them equal in
01:23:46 all these different stations you're going to subject women to the barbarism that men are
01:23:51 typically subject to you're going to return her to a primitive state where she is forced to compete 0.98
01:23:55 and do all the drudgery christendom lifted her up christendom esteemed her christendom put her in 1.00
01:24:01 the home where she had the light and children all these different things those women's suffrage that 1.00
01:24:04 ripped her from that threw her to the rat race and said you're going to go compete here you're 1.00
01:24:09 going to work under fluorescent lights for 50 hours a week and use a mechanical breast pump to
01:24:14 pump milk for your child you're going to do that yeah yeah yeah no you're absolutely right west
01:24:18 that's really well said like that's compelling um and in that it was christian that really
01:24:24 provided the barriers the boundaries um that allowed not only for a woman a woman's flourishing
01:24:29 her health her prosperity but we could also include in that her beauty according to what
01:24:35 god considers to be beautiful first peter i believe it's chapter three that says you know that
01:24:39 the imperishable beauty that which is beautiful in the sight of god is the inward beauty of the
01:24:46 heart and then god further he gives further specification of what that looks like what are
01:24:50 the characteristics of a imperishable inward beauty for a woman a beauty of the heart and he
01:24:56 defines it by two primary characteristics a quiet and gentle spirit and when you throw women into
01:25:04 a man's domain um you you take away the the shield and and the the the providence the protection
01:25:13 the barrier that allows for them to embody beauty and you rip that away from them and you basically
01:25:19 do the opposite you say um you you know beauty is a luxury it is and that luxury is no longer
01:25:25 afforded to you in fact we're stripping it away and uh and now in order to survive you have to be
01:25:31 anything but beautiful you have to be snarky delicate right you have to be in the public 0.85
01:25:36 sphere you now have to be um not not beautiful and filled with grace but you need to be polemical 0.85
01:25:42 you need to be snarky you need to be a beast you need to be a warrior you need to be a beast a 0.60
01:25:46 boss babe you need to be bombastic you need to be aggressive be aggressive and so that's why you see 1.00
01:25:52 even you know allegedly conservative female podcasters in the public sphere if it's not 1.00
01:25:57 something that's distinctly for women in the domestic feminine context right it's one thing 1.00
01:26:02 when lexi silvey does a podcast one day a week not five from her home audio only not driving into 1.00
01:26:10 the studio after the kids are already tucked into bed with her husband about cleaning supplies
01:26:16 that's just right to that one like bright heart that's just different can we all admit that is
01:26:21 different than five times a week um going into the studio leaving the home during the day um
01:26:28 and and then doing a podcast that yeah a lot of your audience are female listeners but but but
01:26:35 in terms of the topic of what you're addressing it's um cultural it's political it's far beyond
01:26:40 just the domestic realm of the home for women and you're even engaging with men who we would all
01:26:46 agree are wicked men who need to be put in their place but but you're now you're you're polemically
01:26:52 right aggressively polemically um uh with uh confrontation you're confronting you know men
01:26:59 like joe biden or like truly wicked men but um but you're a woman doing that and and there's
01:27:05 there's nothing quiet and gentle about it and therefore i mean call me old-fashioned but i 0.88
01:27:11 believe the bible and if the bible says that what the characteristics that are defining of true
01:27:16 feminine beauty is quiet and gentleness and you're now i don't see quiet and gentleness as being
01:27:22 compatible with being um polemical in the public square right i don't think that you can do both
01:27:29 you gotta pick you gotta pick right you can't you can't do both and so what we've done by leveling 0.73
01:27:35 the playing field by making uh women equal is we've made women ugly yep it's funny my um 0.80
01:27:42 this was a while ago but my my brother posted on social media um it was long enough ago that 0.93
01:27:50 it may have been facebook um he said something about uh liberal women why are liberal women
01:27:56 always ugly and a friend of a mutual friend of ours who's who's more liberal said how dare you 0.98
01:28:03 like um he he said something about physical appearance he said i i know lots of beautiful 0.97
01:28:08 like attractive uh liberal women um and my brother said it's interesting to me that you assumed that 1.00
01:28:15 i was just talking about face shape or eye shape or whatever i'm saying they are ugly people and 0.88
01:28:21 a lot of them happen to be physically ugly as well right but they're they they are they're
01:28:25 unattractive people they're unbeautiful people in the truest sense in the truest sense and my
01:28:31 Nate, I'm going to go to the last quote.
01:28:32 I'm going to skip the ones before that in the graph.
01:28:35 This is a more recent comment from a feminist at Stanford who was talking about the end
01:28:41 goal of feminism and women's suffrage, what they're going for.
01:28:47 This was on the anniversary.
01:28:48 So this was in 2020.
01:28:49 She was writing about 100 years of women's suffrage.
01:28:53 And she was saying, making the case that women's suffrage was just a stop on the train. 0.92
01:29:00 We need to make sure we keep the train moving along down the track.
01:29:03 And so this is how she analyzed women's suffrage in the broader scheme of quote-unquote progress.
01:29:10 This is Estelle Friedman. She's a Stanford professor.
01:29:13 She said this,
01:29:14 In our time, we witnessed women of color taking the lead and identifying the intersections of race and gender,
01:29:21 whether in Black Lives Matter, reproductive justice, or environmental movements.
01:29:25 Gender runs through all of these. Race runs through all of them.
01:29:27 Our humanity runs through all of them.
01:29:29 and we can never separate entirely any one cause from another. 1.00
01:29:33 Feminism has to expand to question all social hierarchies 1.00
01:29:39 to truly achieve what it professes. 1.00
01:29:43 This has been the goal.
01:29:44 This is why, even though we are saying carefully here
01:29:49 that we want a whole reconsideration of what it means to vote in our nation,
01:29:56 right, like we are starting with removing the vote.
01:29:59 from women that's that would be the the beginning point because the goal from the beginning has been 0.99
01:30:04 the destruction of hierarchy the leveling of the playing field and the disordering of nature 1.00
01:30:11 i do have to just give one caveat with voting patterns and stuff you can slice it by gender
01:30:16 but race is a big one if it was kamala and trump and only white women voted they actually would
01:30:20 have elected trump and this would be comparison to all other racial groups so there are disparities 0.95
01:30:24 even in that and that's some of that professor's getting at she's saying that black women have
01:30:28 been the ones that have led a lot of progressive movements and vote overwhelmingly in the 90 1.00
01:30:34 percent democrat like 92 93 yeah if it was only white single women kamala would have been elected 1.00
01:30:41 yes right um but but white women not just white if it's white married women definitely trump in 1.00
01:30:46 a landslide if it's uh white single women kamala in a landslide if it's white women both married 0.97
01:30:52 and single it still falls for trump yep yep and it's closer than what if it was like white men 1.00
01:30:57 only so men versus women of the same race yep women are less conservative less republican but
01:31:03 still all said and done yep it would be trumped by a little bit yeah that's true okay well let's 0.63
01:31:09 move into some questions then yeah and uh and then we'll we'll land the plane here great so we want
01:31:14 to start with that super chat from the beginning i'll read it again um this is from ben huffsteadler
01:31:19 He says, how do you suggest talking to new age, quote unquote, Christian males regarding
01:31:27 a proper Christian woman, conduct, head covering, submission, et cetera?
01:31:31 Side note. 0.99
01:31:32 Oh, yeah.
01:31:32 OK, that's the one.
01:31:33 So the difficulty of a bunch of men who have been so indoctrinated with the feminism, how
01:31:40 do you begin to talk to them about proper submission, proper roles of women, men, et
01:31:44 cetera?
01:31:45 this is a tough one because i've been thinking about in the back of my mind the whole episode
01:31:49 i have ideas but go for it all right um the tough thing with men you back a man in the corner and
01:31:56 you'd be like listen bucko this is what you got to do or like like confrontation like it rarely
01:32:00 works especially in the moment um there is something to be said for you know mentioning
01:32:05 it when when it comes up like oh you know you're looking to date or whatever have you looked for a
01:32:08 woman that will be supportive and take care of your children at home so certainly working it in
01:32:13 without it being confrontational i think a big way though is them seeing it modeled so you could 0.98
01:32:18 explain in theory to a man what a woman's submission looks like what her care for the home her love for
01:32:23 her children you could explain all of it you could even show pictures and video but also just having
01:32:28 someone over for dinner and them seeing you as the man seated at the head of the table your wife
01:32:32 would you love and care for but the way she defers to you respect you him looking at that assuming
01:32:37 he's unmarried assuming he's kind of a new age christian and then he's looking at that he's like
01:32:41 wow because it's it's nature men by nature god has made nature patriarchal and so men by nature
01:32:48 can recognize oh that that seems like the appropriate fitting status for a man that he's
01:32:54 gracious and kind but he does rule and he is the head of his home and so as much as he if you're
01:33:00 probably ministering to someone or discipling them as much as they can be in a context where
01:33:05 they see a loving submissive godly woman respecting her husband caring for her children
01:33:10 is going to model probably more than most books, articles, podcasts, videos will do.
01:33:17 So work in where you can the actual information, like here's what the church used to think,
01:33:21 here's how we used to conceive of this, but then model it as well.
01:33:24 And I would add on to that, just saying, if he's in a church, if the men of the church,
01:33:30 not their only topic of conversation, but if it's coming up in their conversation,
01:33:33 how do I not just serve my family, how do I rule my family, how do I lead my family,
01:33:37 If that's part of what the men in the church are talking about, that is going to come across.
01:33:44 If that's the kind of books that they're reading, if the pastor is preaching that way.
01:33:48 Wes, you're right, though.
01:33:49 It really is part of the community of the church and the culture of the church.
01:33:55 And some of this is not going to be worked out of guys until they're placed in a situation where they see it modeled, they hear it talked about,
01:34:04 And then they begin to try it and they realize, oh, okay, I actually need to grow myself.
01:34:09 I need to be more assertive.
01:34:11 I need to be more decision-making.
01:34:12 I need to be more responsible.
01:34:14 I need to be more protective.
01:34:16 I mean, I think that one of the reasons why men like complementarianism and egalitarianism
01:34:24 is it absolves them of the responsibility.
01:34:27 And so the only other thing that I would say is a call to true responsibility, not a fake
01:34:32 responsibility of you may need to make sure that you're doing the dishes every night true
01:34:36 responsibility men are gonna that's gonna resound with men like think ahead plan for your family
01:34:43 consider the needs of your wife your wife and your children like be proactive um it you were
01:34:49 calling them to something higher we're not just bashing them over the head with what they're doing
01:34:53 wrong yeah that's good cool billiott we hit this one a little bit the relationship with the
01:34:59 prohibition in the 19th amendment yes absolutely they were closely interlinked these movements
01:35:04 were going out at the same time communism socialism all these different things temperance
01:35:08 and that were closely linked and and part of it was also um i've read that you know part of um
01:35:13 the temperance movement prohibition was uh that that's that you know the pub was you know because
01:35:20 they didn't have social media those kind of things so in a lot of ways the pub was kind of the public
01:35:25 square you think of like the inklings you know you yeah yeah you think of like tolkien and lewis
01:35:30 and stuff and like that's where a lot of the ideas uh would formulate and guys would sharpen
01:35:35 one another and and you know sometimes even you know organize in a formal sense but but you know
01:35:41 regularly in an informal sense organically you would have ideas presented debated sharpened and
01:35:47 then from that place eventually trickling down and being um patronage networks yeah and being
01:35:52 applied you know in in the public square at large but a lot of it it all circulated around men
01:35:58 high caliber leading men um who were sharpening uh like iron sharpens iron with one another and
01:36:05 typically ordinarily we're doing that in the physical context of a pub right and so by shutting
01:36:10 down all the pubs um you were basically shutting down um the place where men gathered right and uh 0.69
01:36:18 And so it was, so yeah, so the suffrage movement had a vested interest beyond just whatever moral issues there might be circulating with alcohol to say, we don't want our husbands leaving the home and spending time with one another.
01:36:35 which i would say real quick as just a pastoral application for um women today especially young
01:36:41 wives and this doesn't any longer relate to pubs or at least not exclusively but um it's vital
01:36:49 that you allow your husband to leave the home on occasion he needs to be present we're not saying
01:36:55 always um but this idea of like your husband saying um like i've heard guys say this you know
01:37:01 like, uh, it's good to be a man, you know, said, um, a lot of people I remember got really upset.
01:37:07 They were like, I can't believe that this was said. Um, you know, cause they, you know, the
01:37:11 authors pushed back a little bit against the idea of a man's wife being his best friend. He said,
01:37:16 no. Um, and it's not to degrade my wife. My wife is in a position that is vastly superior to the
01:37:24 position of my best friend. She's my wife. Wife is, is above best friend. Um, but no, I have
01:37:30 friendships with men it doesn't mean i don't enjoy my wife or love my wife and i'm not even saying i
01:37:36 necessarily agree i remember even when i read it was like well i mean i know what they're getting
01:37:41 at and i certainly am not clutching my pearls i don't think i think it was completely it was
01:37:45 either right and good and helpful at best and at worst it was yeah you know that ain't it you know
01:37:52 and benign certainly wasn't something for people to lose their minds with but but they did oh they
01:37:56 did um but anyways the point is still true so whether it's not whether wife is is best friend
01:38:03 or not in either case she's certainly not she may be your best friend but i can at least say this
01:38:08 definitively she better not be your only friend she better not be your only friend there are many
01:38:13 such cases there are many such cases oh my goodness and part of the reason there are many
01:38:17 such cases is because men sometimes are pretty lousy at friendship but also um because it's
01:38:24 weird but like sometimes what like like young young women who are married please listen to me
01:38:30 i'm not beating you up please listen i'm trying to give you some pastoral counsel for just a moment
01:38:34 um you want your husband to have friendships and i don't know what it is but i've seen it
01:38:40 in my pastoral ministry where there's like this weird jealousy like almost like he's having an
01:38:45 affair by going to a guy's night right you know and it's like no no no he is um no you
01:38:54 have his allegiance you have his devotion his fidelity his love he is not betraying you by going
01:39:00 and spending time with men it's like well why doesn't he want to spend time with me because
01:39:04 you're not a man it's different right it's different and he's not in the modern work
01:39:09 environment he spends nine to five around a bunch of women exactly his work is surrounded by women
01:39:14 and even if it's with men it's still governed and dominated by female sensibilities female 1.00
01:39:19 you know the the cackling hens of hr you know it's all it's all just our entire world is a female 1.00
01:39:26 longhouse so to allow him once a week or once a month even to get out of the feminine longhouse 1.00
01:39:34 for for a couple hours and go smoke a cigar with some guys or whatever it is um to talk and because
01:39:42 you know what men end up doing in those contexts it's like well there there's nothing productive
01:39:47 they're just no no it's it's only productive it is only productive guys do not get together and
01:39:52 talk about the weather we don't we get together and we're talking about philosophy and politics
01:39:58 and theology it's like the gk chesterton quote where um he says you know people always say um
01:40:03 you can talk about anything except for politics and and uh religion he says i talk about nothing
01:40:08 but politics and religion because there's nothing else worth talking about yeah and that's what men
01:40:12 do um you know and they get together and they talk about those kinds of things and and they
01:40:19 throw out ideas and then and then another man in a truly you know masculine fashion will say 0.92
01:40:23 that's dumb no that's dumb you know and then it'll be like well why is it dumb you know and 0.91
01:40:28 then they start to hash it out and then you know three other guys they pipe in you know and and 0.99
01:40:34 then and then you go back the group chat yeah and then you go back to your wife and your kids
01:40:40 and you kind of are pondering and thinking about it over the next few weeks and then you do it
01:40:44 again and they're all being sharpened and being shaped and and being bettered it so it's it's a
01:40:50 really good thing so uh all that being said uh wives especially young wives um start the habit
01:40:55 early uh do not be threatened by your husband having male friends yeah i do want to hit jenny
01:41:02 weston just said i don't know maybe where he or she is coming from with this the pubs also sent
01:41:07 drunken men home to beat their wives and having spent his paycheck to starving children alcohol
01:41:11 was a scourge on england and america in the early days there was a lot of drunkenness and violence
01:41:18 and you read they they had really grappled with what do you do with men stumbling drunk in the
01:41:23 street every night violent railing abusive like those are real problems and so the temperance
01:41:29 movement part of it was of course like the the men are getting together and i don't like it
01:41:33 and then some real problems of how do you address all of these workers that are drunk blind on a
01:41:38 daily basis and and that's that is a difficult problem to address by the civil magistrate but
01:41:44 it would seem the 19th amendment was not or what the 17th think oh the prohibition um was not the
01:41:51 way to do it so there were real concerns and i understand the problem you have when hundreds of
01:41:54 thousands of men well it's kind of like civil rights right so it's like were there real racists
01:41:58 and were jim crow laws unjust and those yeah sure um but but to have a legislative order
01:42:05 and and a de facto pseudo new constitution that that effectively replaced the actual
01:42:12 constitution of the united states that then became the beachhead to ram through alphabet soup you
01:42:17 know lgbt lmnop rights and everybody says well i i'm in that amendment too you know i'm i find
01:42:23 myself here and i i'm an oppressed minority and i'm an oppressed minority um no something needed
01:42:29 to happen there really was um not just marxism you know made-up sin racism but actual animus
01:42:36 unjustifiable hatred on the basis of ethnicity there were really were not not necessarily
01:42:42 everyone by any stretch but there were some cases of that but there were ways to combat that
01:42:47 without coming up with a set of laws that replaced our nation's constitution and paved
01:42:58 legislatively the way for all the the wokeness that we see today if you don't like wokeness
01:43:04 you should question the civil rights movement you should yep okay all right can we see that
01:43:10 we have a few more super chats that we want to make sure we hit um so bj wins it bjj wins
01:43:17 again oh no above that sorry 80s nostalgia guy ten dollars thanks 80s um he says do you believe 0.92
01:43:24 that female christian teachers on youtube are trying to find a loophole to be able to teach
01:43:28 men many of these women have thousands of followers both men and women and teach theology
01:43:35 i can speak to that i'll try to do it concise i'd be disappointed if you didn't seven words in i was
01:43:39 like yes i don't even know what you're going to finish this with i agree um so so this is what i
01:43:43 think um so i actually am going to go with no um i'm going to give the benefit that i so to again
01:43:50 the question to be fair to the question do you believe that female christian teachers so they're
01:43:54 christian and they're female on youtube are trying to find a loophole to be able to teach men so
01:43:59 we're weighing in i actually motives so we think our motives exactly so um number one we're in the
01:44:04 realm of speculation so it's already we're on you know we're on um thin ice you know um so so i can't
01:44:11 say anything definitively but if you're asking me my my best guess i would actually say no i i don't
01:44:16 think that they're doing it because they want um because they're trying to find a loophole to teach
01:44:21 men i think they're just they just want to teach they just want to talk they have opinions i don't
01:44:26 think they're like i really really hope that this many men tune into my podcast this week because i
01:44:31 really actually want to shape men no i think they just they want to have a podcast they want to be
01:44:36 a celebrity they want to be famous they want to they have ideas they have a dream they want to
01:44:40 have a voice they want to have a platform and i think that they actually would be genuinely
01:44:45 um content if uh if it turned out that their um entire audience was 100 female so long as it was
01:44:53 still a relatively large audience i think they really would honest to god be content at the end
01:44:58 of the day if they found out here's the metrics um you have a podcast that's followed by a million
01:45:03 people it's successful it's large you're you're a micro celebrity um and it's 100 women i don't
01:45:10 think they i think they would love that they'd be like great so i really don't think it's that
01:45:13 they want to teach men i think it's just that they want to be in the public square and publicly teach
01:45:19 um here's here's the only thing that i disagree and this has been my position for
01:45:24 multiple years at this point i've said it before but i'll say it again 0.97
01:45:28 titus two because people always say well then what's the problem with that right older women
01:45:32 get to teach younger women. The Bible allows for that, women teaching women. And if men are tuning 0.95
01:45:37 in, that's not their fault. They're not making men tune into the podcast, so they can't be held
01:45:42 responsible for that. I'm with you. I hear you. Here's the difference. This is where your normally
01:45:48 kind of complementarian, Calvinistic, Titus 2 respecter, alleged respecter, is like, Joel,
01:45:56 I don't see the problem. Why are you being so extreme? Because my exegesis of Titus 2,
01:46:02 which I do believe is a historic exegesis, I don't think it's extreme. I think it is the
01:46:07 correct position. Is it when the Apostle Paul says that older women should train younger women 0.97
01:46:13 and teach them the good, that that headline right there, the good, that older women are to teach
01:46:20 younger women is not a blank canvas for anything that you want to include in that bucket, but that 0.97
01:46:28 the good, right, that's the overarching, like, so what class are women teaching? They're teaching 1.00
01:46:32 a class called the good, okay? And what's the curriculum for this class that they're teaching
01:46:38 to women, the good? Well, Paul actually then begins to list it out. So, I don't think it's,
01:46:43 they can teach anything that you might relatively be able to consider good.
01:46:48 no i think paul then actually specifies what the good is and here's the deal it all has to do with
01:46:56 the home it's um he then says the good and what does that look like what is the good being obedient
01:47:02 to their husbands lovers of children uh not uh given to gossip and slander or much wine um he
01:47:10 lists all these things but what they all have in common is they're all intrinsically applicable
01:47:17 they're not abstract they're not general they're very specific and applicable to the fair sex to
01:47:25 feminine sensibilities so even on on the prohibition side of avoiding gossip or slander
01:47:32 it's um avoiding sins that men can commit men men are not um immune to slander in the same way that
01:47:39 men aren't immune to being deceived people right now are losing their minds they can't i've never
01:47:44 said that men can't be deceived i've said that in general women are more susceptible i believe
01:47:50 to deception than men of course men can be deceived but the question is in general
01:47:56 when paul roots as his argument for male headship he doesn't just cite the order of creation that
01:48:04 man was formed first and that woman was formed from man and for man but he also cites not just
01:48:11 the order of creation but the order of the fall that woman fell first and that in her fall both
01:48:17 the order of the fall she fell first and the nature of her fall the man sinned knowingly
01:48:23 with his eyes wide open the woman sinned after having been deceived and so you're making excuses
01:48:29 for the man no his moral culpability is greater the fact that he sinned knowingly only makes him
01:48:36 all the more guilty not less so i'm not it's not an argument about guilt if anything adam is more
01:48:42 guilty on two accounts number one his position the position of headship and authority he bears
01:48:48 a greater responsibility more responsibility that comes with authority number two not just his
01:48:53 position but the nature of his sin he sinned knowingly he sinned with his eyes wide open
01:48:58 in pure defiance of what god had spoken so adam both in terms of his position having sinned and
01:49:05 the nature of how he sinned, he bears greater responsibility, not lesser. However, when Paul
01:49:12 is constructing this argument, it's all within the context—this is 1 Timothy 2 now, not Titus 2—all
01:49:17 within the context of why a woman should not lead. And it's two prohibitions, not just one.
01:49:24 It's not conflated into one. She cannot teach men or have authority over men. Not teach with 1.00
01:49:29 authority, one prohibition, but teach or authority over men. And when Paul gives these two prohibitions
01:49:35 for women, authority over men or teaching over men, he cites both the order of creation, but also
01:49:42 the order of the fall. So all I'm doing in my theology is I'm simply including both, not just
01:49:49 one, but both of the arguments that scripture makes. Because what Paul does is he then says,
01:49:54 why? Why can a woman not exercise authority over a man or teach over a man? Well, because of the 0.99
01:50:00 order of creation, the natural created order. But also, if that's where it stopped, then that's
01:50:06 where it stopped. But that's not where Paul stops. He goes on, he says, also, not just the order of
01:50:10 creation, woman made from man, that is, man formed first, woman second, from man and for man as a
01:50:16 helpmate, her purpose, her telos. But then, beyond that, not just the order of creation, but the
01:50:21 order of the fall she fell first created second but fallen first and the manner in which she fell
01:50:28 the nature of the fall she fell um with her eyes closed adam fell with his eyes wide open this
01:50:35 doesn't mean that adam is absolved of guilt if anything his guilt is increased and i would argue
01:50:40 it is but what it does mean is that the woman was more susceptible to being deceived can you find
01:50:46 one individual woman who is less easily deceived than one individual man of course in fact you
01:50:52 could do it with thousands i have no doubt but we're talking about group dynamics generalities
01:50:57 in general in general men are physically stronger than women likewise in general i believe that men
01:51:04 are less susceptible to deception than women and i'm basing that off of experience statistics
01:51:10 studies and most importantly scripture and one of the qualities i believe because that the whole
01:51:16 context is in the context of leadership one of the qualities for good leadership is having being
01:51:22 at a higher degree of being impervious towards deception so now all that back to to now titus
01:51:29 chapter two a woman can she cannot teach or exercise authority over a man she can older women 0.99
01:51:36 can teach women. But even the what, not just what they can do, but what are the contents
01:51:44 and the parameters of her teaching, it's all feminine and domestic. So even the sins 0.95
01:51:52 against gossip or slander, can men commit these sins? Can men gossip? Yes, I have gossiped.
01:51:59 Can men be deceived? Yes, I have been deceived. But in generalities, are men as notorious,
01:52:08 as notoriously deceived as women? I would argue no. Scripture, more importantly, who cares about
01:52:13 Joel? Scripture would argue no. No. Are men as notorious or as known for gossip as women? No.
01:52:22 So even a woman's teaching, the curriculum is specified, and it's the good things to esteem, submission to husbands, lovers of children, and the bad things, the prohibitions to avoid. 0.64
01:52:38 And even on that side, it's not just sin in general. 0.96
01:52:41 It's specific sins.
01:52:42 And which sins? 0.99
01:52:43 The ones that tend to be more common among women, which means that a woman can teach, not men, but women. 0.78
01:52:51 if she has a podcast and men happen to tune in that's not her fault but if it is a podcast
01:52:57 for teaching women and the kind of teaching that is actually actually permissible in scripture for
01:53:03 a woman to teach women with then it's going to be teaching a woman teaching women about womanly
01:53:09 things i'll say that again it's not just well as long as it's a woman teaching other women then we
01:53:14 can teach whatever we want that's not what titus 2 says it's there's there's a third requirement 1.00
01:53:19 A woman can teach if she's teaching women, but also if she's a woman teaching women about womanly things. And so if you're doing a podcast that is directed towards women 50% of the time, 60% of the time, but still has on a regular basis, not gentle and quiet characteristics, but bombastic, snarky, sarcastic, polemical aspects in the public square,
01:53:49 where you're belittling men, you're actually going to war, politics is war, against men,
01:53:54 exercising a polemic against men, and it doesn't have really anything to do with the domestic
01:54:00 feminine space, then that's not Titus 2. So all that back to the super chat. Do you believe that
01:54:07 female Christian teachers on YouTube are trying to find a loophole to be able to teach men? My 0.99
01:54:11 answer is no. I don't think that they're in their heart of hearts. They're trying to be sneaky
01:54:17 because they really want to teach thousands of men.
01:54:20 But what I do think is they just want to teach.
01:54:23 And they actually are perfectly content 0.98
01:54:24 if their audience is exclusively made up of women.
01:54:28 But the problem is not that they don't want to teach women.
01:54:31 I think they do want to teach women,
01:54:33 but they don't want to teach women things pertaining to women. 0.76
01:54:37 And that, I think, is also prescribed by Scripture.
01:54:40 Not just that you must teach women,
01:54:41 but you must teach women womanly things.
01:54:44 and that's the part where i think they are finding a loophole and that's where i as respectfully as i
01:54:50 can disagree yeah fair enough we have two more super chats uh west you want to read the middle
01:54:56 one and then i'll read the last one uh bjj wins again thanks so much for the super chat if slash
01:55:01 when does a widow become the head of a house and vote actually like we were talking about it like 0.99
01:55:07 the only ones that would vote would be white men they'd be proper owners and uh i would still stick
01:55:12 to that and so even a man that wasn't married for instance i would still say it would be men that
01:55:16 owned property or citizens of the land real quick when you say you would stick to that
01:55:20 i i won't speak for you i'll just speak for myself but i think you will agree
01:55:23 that in america as it is today heritage america means something however that would not be it
01:55:30 would be predominantly white but it would not be exclusively white so if i was king for a day and
01:55:33 i think west would agree um we would not limit it to white men but we would limit it to free men
01:55:38 and the free citizens the modern day application of that would be free citizens um also i would
01:55:45 argue maybe free from debt not reliant on welfare or taxpayer you know um supplements and uh and
01:55:51 property owning and um and their family men yep exactly and if a black man meets those qualifications 0.70
01:55:57 and many would then go for free citizens that would be property owning i think you still stick
01:56:03 to it i don't think it's at least for me and maybe you would disagree joel i don't think it's the
01:56:07 idea of like there's this head of the household and then sometimes it's men sometimes it's women
01:56:11 i think just men decide the direction of society and if there is a woman that in god's providence
01:56:15 becomes a widow for one we're talking about a tiny amount of women that wouldn't even be able 0.99
01:56:20 to enact or repeal legislation right very small percentage and you say wouldn't be a a formidable 0.99
01:56:26 voting block we just say you will be represented by the civil fathers so that's what i would say 0.90
01:56:31 i would say at a voting level there would be no situation where a widow would rise to that level
01:56:35 she'd be taken care of by the civic fathers the familial fathers support the church fathers even
01:56:40 as they care for widows that were in the church to wash the feet of the saints and all of that 0.86
01:56:43 that would be my position right because really you only come down to the widow is is like well
01:56:48 there's no one to represent her and but i think what you're saying and i i think i agree is no
01:56:53 but in god's economy she actually still does have representation she still has even if she doesn't
01:56:58 have an earthly father a familial father or a familial husband um she's still outside of the
01:57:04 sphere of the household she still actually does have male representation um she has um she has
01:57:11 ecclesiastical fathers her her pastors um she has civil fathers right her representative still
01:57:16 represents her yeah she doesn't get to so she still therefore has a voice and people who are
01:57:21 advocating for her and the lesson from first timothy four is that in general and not in general
01:57:27 in almost all of the situations where something like that happens a woman ought to try to find
01:57:32 male headship to come under if she's a young widow and no children she should probably go 1.00
01:57:38 back to her father's house and be represented by her father if she has older children maybe she 0.98
01:57:43 is now represented in a sense by her oldest son if she's very old she's an elderly widow 0.52
01:57:49 she's probably not remarrying but even there she is uh like you said wes represented by her civil
01:57:55 fathers and even her church fathers who are going to consider her need in their voting for public
01:58:01 issues yep so alicia i think walk yep super chat ten dollars very kind thank you thank you
01:58:09 fellow 1689 love to see it homeschooling family my children instinctively boo when they hear the
01:58:14 name susan b anthony fantastic love to hear it would you consider making a t-shirt that says
01:58:19 repeal the 19th make america patriarchal again i would buy the t-shirt i would buy the t-shirt
01:58:25 and um i would wear it around the house
01:58:29 i would uh if i wasn't preaching that week i might wear it to church but probably not because
01:58:37 i was still under the suit under the suit yeah under the suit yep um you gotta you gotta dress
01:58:42 nice for church um but there you know when i go out in public shopping for instance it's like what 0.95
01:58:49 i thought you were patriarchal doesn't your wife do the shopping yes but occasionally we have to
01:58:53 cooked brisket or steaks and i can't say who's gonna pick my wife with that right exactly there
01:58:58 have been times i'm like all right babe look and we like literally we we will we will take like
01:59:03 half an hour and i'll be showing her pictures you know on the on this exact cut this you know like
01:59:08 very specific you want to look for marbling here in this right but if i have time you know like
01:59:12 for meat i i'll go and do that shopping it's not beneath me i'd love to serve my wife in that
01:59:17 regard servant leadership right um and so uh but yeah if i'm going to the store if i'm going to
01:59:22 heb herbert e butts god bless him um that that is his name and heb dude i just saw a video of a guy
01:59:28 who like it's constantly uncovering all the you know the soy and red red dye six and stuff and he
01:59:34 and people were telling him and telling him and telling him because heb is like a texas thing it's
01:59:38 not necessarily nationwide and they're like please do a review of heb so he finally went and he did
01:59:43 a review and he's like guys it's fantastic and he rips everything apart he was like there are more
01:59:49 um private family owned instead of a major like everything you go to syrup you go to butter you
01:59:55 go to there is a private family owned texas owned option for virtually every single food in the
02:00:02 store and then when you look at the ingredients on the back some of them aren't great but um none
02:00:07 of them are like what you would find at kroger or you'd find oh yeah and he was just like this
02:00:11 is incredible so anyways it love heb i'm a texan um but if i go to heb i'm not wearing that shirt
02:00:18 because but what you are doing is you're facetiming me if you should buy a 100
02:00:22 dollar ham bone for the kitchen counter you know where you face time
02:00:26 with my family those things are good you know and my wife is just rolling her eyes and she was not
02:00:36 being particularly submissive that day but uh she's rolling her eyes as i'm on facetime in the
02:00:40 middle of the store you know holding my son franklin and we're looking at this what was it
02:00:45 it's a serrano ham where it comes with a knife and a stand and you don't have to refrigerate
02:00:51 you just put it on the counter you're like what can i put this on the counter for six weeks and
02:00:54 just be eating ham off of it constantly right but i had no concept i had no concept of the price it
02:00:59 was like 140 bucks but it lasts a long time so i asked you exactly i asked you i was like is this
02:01:04 worth 140 which was a bad idea because wes was like of course yeah yeah of course
02:01:08 Okay, any other?
02:01:14 We just had one last super chat come in.
02:01:16 So from Michael, thank you very much.
02:01:18 $1.99.
02:01:19 Appreciate you very much.
02:01:20 Who gets to vote in Mr. Mom-style houses?
02:01:22 Nobody.
02:01:24 You forfeited.
02:01:26 Again, you have to throw the caveat.
02:01:27 If this is a situation where he's confined to bed or something like that.
02:01:32 There are certain circumstances.
02:01:34 Let me just say, this is the mark of an intellectually unserious individual.
02:01:38 if you take the exception and they continually bring up you take a pattern they continually bring
02:01:43 up the exception they are demonstrating that they are not capable of extrapolating averages
02:01:48 means medians all of these things patterns across time and space they can't do it well i know a
02:01:56 quadriplegic or i know a woman who can bench more okay you are just you're intellectually you're
02:01:59 not in the same league here love you that's great the big boys are going to make laws now no that's
02:02:03 right the person who always um always tries to um play the devil's advocate ultimately to um
02:02:11 stopping any progress that conservatives might actually achieve by bringing up the exception
02:02:17 um is is not a serious person you don't have to be mean towards them or hostile but um but yeah
02:02:23 they they don't get to um they can be in the car they don't get to drive that that because
02:02:28 conceptually that's exactly how we got here if you hate progressivism you have to recognize that
02:02:34 um their number one play you know like like you know give the ball to the tailback and run them
02:02:39 up the middle like the the number one most common play that was done again and again that got us
02:02:44 to our current juncture here in these united states was um pointing to the exception right
02:02:49 so no child left behind you know like um well americans with disabilities act right so exactly
02:02:53 so we've got you know we've got some people um you know uh some ninth graders can't read and so
02:02:59 what's the solution well now no ninth grade is going to get to read you know and it's just
02:03:03 bringing everything down to the lowest common denominator that's how they achieved equality
02:03:09 so they they that's how the leftists worked it was they said but um well this may sound good but
02:03:15 it's not really uh loving because uh we can point to this that's what they did even with
02:03:19 transgenderism right right wasn't that the play they said well but even in nature not just with
02:03:24 surgery but in nature there's the 0.00001 so there's these incredibly rare cases that do 0.89
02:03:33 naturally occur and because of that now um when you go to target uh your wife and your daughter
02:03:42 if they have to use the restroom a dude might be in there with them right so yeah like have you
02:03:49 noticed too like all the advertising it's always like just real quick if you're a conservative if
02:03:52 you're neil shimby i'm just gonna if you're neil shimby and you're using the same kind of
02:03:57 argumentation that was used for transgenderism then yeah like just be honest and don't say oh 0.51
02:04:03 they're you know i'm conservative but they're the woke right just be honest and say i'm not a
02:04:07 conservative i'm a liberal you're not a leftist either i'm not going to be hyperbolic neil shimby
02:04:11 is not a leftist but just say i'm a liberal and i really like the 20th century and i want to stay
02:04:16 there yeah so the thing is it it it does require a specific time type of discernment and wisdom
02:04:23 and you want you know so you've got let's say you've got a family in the church who their child
02:04:29 is born with klinefelter syndrome like you do need in the in the particulars you need people
02:04:34 who are wise and um can bring discernment and biblical principles to those issues but you don't
02:04:42 apply those to the macro scale and use that to make all so so it's not that we don't care about
02:04:48 actual exceptions but those those are so exceptional that they need to be approached
02:04:53 on a case-by-case basis that's right the law and the principles and the patterns of nature
02:04:57 are larger and you can make general statements about them amen real quick this one um is uh
02:05:04 because we don't want to just favor the super chats although we do favor the super chats um
02:05:08 But this is Miss Ingham.
02:05:10 And I just wanted to read it because honestly, I'll admit I'm personally biased.
02:05:15 I found it encouraging.
02:05:17 And so I just wanted to read it out loud to answer her question, but also just for other women who might be listening to the channel.
02:05:23 She said, would you consider creating a playlist specifically for your content that's directed towards women?
02:05:30 There's been a lot of it lately, and it's really helpful and worth hearing again and again.
02:05:36 Thanks.
02:05:36 so i just want to at minimum say thank you that that means a lot um i'm glad that uh despite um 0.99
02:05:44 the uh the popular opinion uh out there in the in the interweb that uh we are you know hate women
02:05:52 are chauvinistic and misogynistic and blah blah blah i'm really encouraged thank you and every
02:05:57 week there are a lot of women that watch this channel constantly and they're in the chat and
02:06:00 they say we love this guy so that's true those of you erin yeah for the women who follow right
02:06:04 response ministries and not hate watching but actually follow it um you my goodness you uh
02:06:11 you are a patriot we honor you thank you so much um i i hope that your husband also enjoys the show
02:06:19 and knows that you're watching and enjoys the show and approves yeah but um but thank you so
02:06:24 much for that encouragement in terms of actually answering the question um i it's just nathan is
02:06:30 uh doing a million things and um but you know what when you're doing a million things what's
02:06:34 a million a one exactly so i will talk to nathan he's the boss around these parts for right response
02:06:40 and uh we'll see if we could uh try to make um some kind of uh what is it called nathan on youtube
02:06:46 when you make a playlist a playlist yeah we'll try to make a playlist okay 80s nostalgia guy 0.57
02:06:52 right at the last minute should a gay man be allowed to vote no but also i don't think the 0.57
02:06:57 state needs to be in everybody's home right in a general christian populace you're not investigating
02:07:02 you're not requiring that's right forms and attestations so no but a couple probably slips
02:07:06 the cracks well said so do we think that sodomy is a sin yes we're christians the bible says that
02:07:11 do we think that sodomy should be treated by the civil magistrate as a crime we would say that not
02:07:16 all sins are crimes but this one is historically in america it was in in many countries in europe
02:07:21 It was, we believe that this one is not only a sin, but it actually is a crime, that it actually has a degrading effect on society as a home, as a whole, and doesn't just stay in the home.
02:07:34 That said, there's a difference.
02:07:37 There are things that are sins only and not crimes.
02:07:40 There are things that are sins and crimes.
02:07:42 But even if it's a sin and a crime, it doesn't mean that it's a crime that needs to be policed.
02:07:49 right so um there are some things where it's like you know what we need to actually this is so
02:07:54 nefarious it needs to be searched out um because it's it cannot be allowed to persist even privately
02:08:02 it is that dangerous um we would say that like so for instance we we don't think that um there 0.69
02:08:08 should be public um public um you know parades or you know towards islam but we also don't think 0.94
02:08:17 that there should be if we were a christian nation um under christian nationalism we would 0.99
02:08:22 not have the um islamic you know the muslim police that goes and rounds up muslims in their homes 0.91
02:08:27 searching for the quran did you read this right critically yeah we would not do that um we we
02:08:33 would say though that uh no you don't get to have any public um islamic holidays it's i'm sorry
02:08:40 like is iran having public uh christian holidays no no so you know like so no we would be a
02:08:47 Christian nation, and we would act accordingly. In the public square, it would be Christ and the
02:08:52 Christian religion that would receive favorability, preference. It is discrimination. Of course it is.
02:08:58 You would discriminate and say, no, things that are Christian nation, things that are Christian,
02:09:03 they get preference. Things that are not Christian do not get preference. However,
02:09:08 there is a sliding scale. Not preferring Islam, it does not necessitate that you're then policing 0.77
02:09:16 and rounding up each and every private muslim worshiping in their home likewise same with 0.98
02:09:23 sodomy um no no gay pride uh parades and any known publicly known homosexuals right would 0.97
02:09:31 certainly not be able to serve in public office um but someone who's privately sinning in that way
02:09:37 is not going to be snuffed out and uh therefore would be able to vote because we wouldn't know
02:09:42 about it yeah that's just that's how that's how it would shake down that's how that's how it shook
02:09:47 out in the past that's how it would shake out again the big idea here is it would it still be
02:09:52 a private sin would they still be held accountable before god on the final absolutely and apart from
02:09:57 mercy and grace it's found uh through faith and repentance of sin and jesus christ alone
02:10:01 then uh then they would go to hell um and and so eventually you know that sin would be held
02:10:07 accountable by god himself um but but the big concern uh as we're talking about you know
02:10:12 culturally and politically is we're saying uh it's not so much that um that this cannot be done in
02:10:18 any isolated private case whatsoever among 330 million people no what we're talking about is
02:10:24 um the public square that at the end of the day um someone i've said it before someone will always
02:10:32 be in the closet every society it's not whether but which every society has its proverbial closet
02:10:38 and um and if the homosexual is not in the closet but rather being celebrated and worshiped and 0.82
02:10:46 praised in the public square than the christian the bible believe in christian will be the one 0.69
02:10:51 in the closet and we believe that that's wrong yep um so it's not whether but which there will
02:10:56 all every society will have its closets and someone's going to be in it it's not whether
02:11:01 someone will be in the closet, but which person will be in the closet. And we believe that it is
02:11:06 more honoring to God and more conducive to the flourishing of society as a whole, which includes
02:11:13 Christians, but also even unbelievers. It is better even for unbelievers in society, for 0.84
02:11:19 Christians to be esteemed publicly rather than homosexuals. I think that that is biblically 1.00
02:11:28 faithful and also an argument that's supported simply by common sense and logic and nature
02:11:35 amen it's not extreme and you know what it's 2025 the year of our lord 2025 and i'm just
02:11:43 going to go on record and say that's a moderate position now that is a centrist moderate position
02:11:47 okay thank you guys so much for tuning in any last words michael or wes nope i think this was
02:11:54 a great stream. I hope you guys were blessed by it. And Lord willing, we will see you again at
02:11:59 3 p.m. Central Time on Wednesday.