The NXR Podcast - August 21, 2024


THE LIVESTREAM - Does Christian Nationalism Have A Racism Problem? - Live with Eric Conn

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE SERMON - The King’s Herald | Matthew 3_1-12 THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Scientology | EP 8 with @TheCultishShow

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours

Words per minute

187.69

Word count

22,686

Sentence count

747

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

45

sentences flagged

Hate speech

106

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the Right Response Ministries Live Stream, we are joined by special guest Eric Khans to discuss racism within Christian nationalism, and whether or not Christian nationalism has a problem with racism within its ranks.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 if there's one accusation that flies fast and thick against christian nationalism it is the
00:00:08 accusation of racism sadly even many christians are quick to levy the term against their brothers
00:00:17 rarely stopping to consider the bible's actual teaching on the topic and the dubious recent
00:00:24 origin of this term of racism join us now with special guest eric khan as we discuss
00:00:31 how concerned christians should actually be about this so-called racism and if christian nationalism
00:00:39 does indeed have a racist problem within its ranks
00:00:51 all right we are back ga ga it's not an m anymore we've got eric con with us nathan
00:00:59 uh turn it over to eric just for a second eric thanks for coming on the show
00:01:02 guys thanks for having me what a pleasure awesome okay so eric wes myself we've all been in a bit
00:01:10 of a dust up for a little while now um going back and forth on in twitter land which from now on i
00:01:17 guess we have to call it x because once the progressives come out and say you know that
00:01:21 it's conservative and right-wing you know to call it x then you have to start calling it x so
00:01:26 anyways but on x there's been a dust up and some controversy over um aristotle that was that was
00:01:33 one and we've addressed that a little bit and we can talk about that a little bit more but then
00:01:36 other guys have started besides just on x uh even on youtube you know other guys have done some
00:01:41 videos where they've talked about eric khan they've talked about me they've talked about
00:01:46 Stephen Wolf. They talked about, you know, different guys. And basically, you know, in a
00:01:51 nutshell, it all comes down to, you know, Christian nationalism is, you know, white Christian
00:01:55 nationalism. It's racist. And that's been going on for a while, but it seems as though it's heating 0.98
00:01:59 up a little bit. And so we want to respond. So we're actually going to be showing some video
00:02:02 clips today and having Eric respond because they, in this video, they, you know, they talk about
00:02:07 Eric Kahn. They also talk about Joel Webin. So Eric and I will both be responding to things,
00:02:11 but we're going to do something a little bit different right here from the outset. And it's
00:02:15 going to take about seven minutes to do, but it will be seven minutes incredibly well spent.
00:02:20 We are going to read the entire article that this week, our very own Wesley Todd wrote for us.
00:02:27 And the reason why is just for those of you who are tuning in and you don't keep up with the
00:02:31 live stream every Wednesday, what we do is Michael, who is out of town this week, Michael
00:02:36 and Wes, they alternate taking turns every other week writing an article that corresponds with our
00:02:42 weekly show. And so what we're doing as a show is lockstep with the article that they've prepared
00:02:49 ahead of time. So that's why we have, you know, with the show, we'll be able to show, you know,
00:02:54 graphics and statistics and all these things and sources and, you know, in quotes, you know,
00:02:59 to back up the arguments that we're making, because this is a show that's live, but it is a
00:03:04 show that is thoroughly prepared. And if for the record, if you ever want to have access to the
00:03:08 whole article and be able to read it on your own time and be able to have it in written form so
00:03:13 that you can cite it as you're arguing, you know, with your progressive uncle, you know, whatever
00:03:16 at Thanksgiving, then, you know, all you need to do is join us at patreon.com forward slash
00:03:22 right response ministries, patreon.com forward slash right response ministries. You'll get a
00:03:27 bunch of perks, but that's one of them. All of our Patreon members have access to the full article
00:03:31 every single week that corresponds with the live stream. Okay, here we go. So this is the title of
00:03:35 the article. I'm going to read some. Wes is going to read some. I'm going to read some. We're going
00:03:38 to go back and forth so that it's super engaging and you don't get bored. But this, I mean, the
00:03:42 content alone, it stands on its own two legs. Here we go. Does Christian nationalism have a racism
00:03:48 problem? That's the title. Does Christian nationalism, a loose collection of conservatives, 0.52
00:03:54 elected officials, and reactionaries have a problem with racism and racist within the movement? Well,
00:03:59 it depends on who you ask. To some, the answer is unquestionably yes. For others, it depends
00:04:05 on what those words actually mean. Take the definition of racism, for instance. It is well
00:04:11 known that the meaning is as slippery and malleable as the day is long. While more formal
00:04:17 dictionary definitions ground its meaning in a belief in superiority of particular races,
00:04:23 that would be Merriam-Webster in Oxford, other sociologists have described it as a systematic,
00:04:29 this would be Beverly Daniel Tatum, or global, not or, but and global, this is W.E.B. Du Bois,
00:04:37 and or structural, that'd be France, Fannin, phenomenon. So a systematic, global, and
00:04:44 structural phenomenon. This means that racism can functionally take on any meaning it needs to,
00:04:51 sometimes even having nothing to do with race or ethnicity at all. As someone once observed,
00:04:57 a racist is someone who is winning an argument with a liberal. Now, when the origins of the term
00:05:03 are considered, the meaning is thrown into even more question. The term racism or racist only
00:05:09 appears in French, German, and English literature for the very first time in the late 1880s,
00:05:15 likely for the first time in 1888 by French anarchist Charles Mulatto. However, the term
00:05:24 itself did not see any widespread use until after 1930, a fact some link to the use of the term by
00:05:31 communist revolutionary Leon Trotsky in his writings. Whether Trotsky brought the idea to
00:05:39 public consciousness or not, a simple explanation of the use of the words racism and racist in books
00:05:46 and publications dating back to 1800 shows absolutely no use of either expression leading
00:05:52 up to 1930, and very insignificant use until 1960. Meanwhile, other common expressions relating to
00:06:00 race and ethnicity have clear precedent even prior to 1800. This means that no English, that would be
00:06:07 the Westminster Divines and London Baptists, French, John Calvin, or German theologian, Protestant, or
00:06:13 Roman Catholic, would have used the concept of racism in any capacity before or during the course
00:06:19 of the Protestant Reformation and the Enlightenment.
00:06:22 Additionally, any contemporary American theologians who wrote and lectured prior to the 1960s
00:06:29 would have never considered, used, or applied the concept to Christian life.
00:06:35 All right. 0.99
00:06:35 Can we actually just show, I don't know if we'll get a chance to go back to these.
00:06:38 Yeah, let's show them.
00:06:39 Let's show these two charts quick.
00:06:40 This first one here is the use of the term racism or racist.
00:06:45 And this is a Google Engram viewer, and it's not just a raw account.
00:06:47 Like, how many times does this word appear in books since this time period?
00:06:51 Because more books are being written, so naturally the count will go up.
00:06:53 This is a percentage of all words.
00:06:55 So if you're looking at this, I'll describe it for anyone that's maybe listening.
00:06:58 The use of these terms, there is no use prior to really about 1940.
00:07:04 None.
00:07:04 And these are not rookie numbers on this chart.
00:07:06 We've got to pump these numbers down.
00:07:09 Right.
00:07:09 We should be seeing it cap off and decline.
00:07:11 But it's really even 1960 that you see the use of these words, publications, book, public
00:07:16 consciousness go up. And this isn't just because we started thinking in a new way about race or
00:07:21 some words evolved. If you can show the second figure, Nate, this is the term race. Now, the
00:07:26 term race has a long history of being used. It was used prior to the 1800s. You go back to Calvin,
00:07:31 he's writing in 1500s. He uses the term race to speak of different groups of people. So there's
00:07:36 clear precedent for understanding race, nation, ethnicity, but racism and racist as words did not
00:07:44 exist in our public consciousness less than 100 years ago. And with Calvin using the word race,
00:07:49 I assume that he only ever used the term race to describe the one human race. He never used it to
00:07:54 say that there are different races of people. Never. Right. Okay. No, he did. Yeah, that's a
00:07:59 normal way of speaking. It is okay. You can speak that way without being immoral. All right, go ahead.
00:08:03 So part two. So despite the recent and dubious origins of the designation, an astute Christian
00:08:09 could attempt to make the argument that while the word racism or racist itself may be new,
00:08:15 the sin denoted is the more ancient concept of prejudice and or partiality. Defined this way,
00:08:21 racism, considered biblically, would merely mean prejudice and bitterness against a certain race.
00:08:26 For example, Pastor John MacArthur operates with this definition in a 2018 piece
00:08:30 on social justice. But these definitions still seem to fall short of a meaningful
00:08:34 and helpful conception of racism. For example, prejudice is simply the compounding of
00:08:39 before and judgment in Latin. To have prejudice is simply to pre-judge. Are there not times that
00:08:45 require making a judgment prior to every fact being known? We pre-judge intentions very often,
00:08:50 matters of trustworthiness and safety. Paul himself seems to carry a prior judgment about
00:08:55 the Cretans when he describes them as evil beasts, liars, and lazy gluttons in Titus 1.12. 0.98
00:09:01 Some level of pre-judgment is clearly not off-limits for the Christians, 0.98
00:09:04 although as all actions it should be carried out with prudence.
00:09:07 In regards to partiality, perhaps a brief exegesis of James 2 would be helpful.
00:09:12 James 2 is frequently cited as a New Testament passage that condemns actions of favoritism,
00:09:16 partiality, bias, etc., and could be reasonably construed to include racism.
00:09:21 In verse 1, James commands,
00:09:22 My brothers, have not the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory, with respect
00:09:26 of persons.
00:09:27 James roots this in the great commandment to love one's neighbor and concludes the thought
00:09:31 by explaining,
00:09:32 If you have respect of persons, ye commit sin, and are convinced of the law as transgressors.
00:09:38 Thus, with full biblical authority, we can confidently assert that respecting of persons
00:09:42 within the context of faith transgresses the command to love our neighbor.
00:09:46 But what kind of respecting of persons is being forbidden here?
00:09:49 Is all respect of persons, including kings and emperors, that other apostles like Paul
00:09:53 and Peter command us to honor and respect, is that forbidden?
00:09:57 Calvin rightly observes that if this verse should read,
00:10:00 he sins who respects the rich the sentence would be absurd instead per calvin the key distinction
00:10:07 is favored rendered to the rich alone combined with the treatment of the poor with contempt
00:10:13 respect is certainly due to all manners of people including magistrates kings elders leaders and
00:10:18 earthly masters but in the body of christ the church elevation of earthly prompt and denigration
00:10:23 of the lowly has no place as calvin comments when the esteem or value of riches or of honor
00:10:28 dazzles our eyes the truth is suppressed which ought alone to prevail in other words james is
00:10:34 not warning against respect for the rich or any other social class as an entire group since
00:10:39 obviously respect is due to emperors and kings with wealth it's even a group designated by god
00:10:43 as his servant and deserving of honor but james is warning against rolling out the red carpet and
00:10:48 church for the well-off individual attendee while shooing away the less socially desirable based on
00:10:54 this exegesis, there seems to be little overlap with the modern conception of racism. And if
00:10:59 anything, the evangelical church is in need of repentance for partiality against whites,
00:11:04 as illustrated, for example, in prominent pastors speak of hiring less qualified pastors
00:11:08 instead of Anglo pastors, simply because these less qualified pastors are African American.
00:11:13 That would be Matt Chandler in 2018, who said exactly that.
00:11:17 Last portion of the article. Here we go. To offer one final possibility for a biblical
00:11:21 definition of racism, what about actual violence and mistreatment rooted in hatred for a certain
00:11:27 race? An example would be the story of Eugene Williams, a black teenager who was killed after
00:11:33 he unintentionally drifted his raft into an unofficially segregated white beach off Lake
00:11:39 Michigan. White men on the beach hurled stones at the raft after it crossed, eventually knocking
00:11:44 Eugene into the water where he drowned. The first officer to arrive at the scene initially refused
00:11:50 to take the murderers into custody, sparking the 1919 Chicago race riots that left dozens dead and
00:11:57 hundreds injured. A number of heinous sins and crimes were committed against Eugene Williams,
00:12:03 who was murdered and then denied justice, violating both the Sixth Commandment and the
00:12:08 Noeic Covenant, as well as probably the Ninth Commandment and lying, producing false witnesses.
00:12:13 but it is exactly these prohibitions against murder theft and injustice and envy that make
00:12:21 the category of racism largely redundant cain murdered abel over anger that his sacrifice
00:12:28 was accepted it would have been it would not have been more or less excusable of a sin
00:12:34 if it had been for racial reasons the sin was the murder the reason is largely incidental
00:12:41 Similarly, violence, theft, threats, and injustice are in and of themselves sin,
00:12:48 and the motives seem to often be of little account in the biblical narratives.
00:12:52 If anything, some passages even allow for different treatment of native Israelites as a race versus foreigners, other races,
00:13:01 such as Deuteronomy 23.20.
00:13:04 An equivalent today would be the allowance of American citizens to charge interest only to
00:13:10 immigrants or those who hold green cards, charging financial interest, a policy that the ERLC would
00:13:18 trip over itself to condemn and oppose. But God's perfect and just law makes no such apology,
00:13:25 and in fact even ties this command to blessing in Deuteronomy chapter 23 verse 21. While hatred
00:13:33 in the heart is certainly a sin. Matthew 5 verse 22 tells us that in-group preference seems not to
00:13:40 be. We are to prefer family, kin, and nation, and this preference is not sinful when other matters
00:13:47 of justice, love, and mercy are not neglected. Thus, granting that racism may only be a sin
00:13:54 when it serves as a motive to other sins, including hatred in the heart, we are equipped to answer the
00:14:00 question. So does Christian nationalism have a racism problem? Is it a movement marked by racial
00:14:06 animus as the foundation for patterns of actual violence and abuse, theft and hatred? The answer 0.95
00:14:14 is no. Knowing crime statistics is not racism. Assuming racism is properly defined, opposing
00:14:22 immigration, illegal and legal, is not racism. Advocating that a country share common values,
00:14:29 a place and a people is not racism. Noticing and speaking up about patterns of behavior and that
00:14:37 destroys a social trust is not racism. Wanting to live in a safe and commodious nation is not
00:14:44 racism. The Christian is bound to the word of God for its definitions of right and wrong,
00:14:50 and none of these actions even begin to qualify as sins. Could racial hatred be harbored in the
00:14:56 heart, but never making its way to visible sin? Certainly. But only the final day when Christ
00:15:03 reveals the hearts of men will vindicate or condemn an individual's heart. For now, we believe
00:15:10 that the best about our Christian nationalist brothers, laboring for a better Christian future
00:15:15 alongside us, and strive to be marked by joy, ambition, and godliness, character traits that
00:15:22 will choke out the seeds of all improper hate, inordinate lust, envy, and malice. 1 Timothy 1
00:15:29 5-7 says this, the aim of our charge is love, that issues from a pure heart and a good conscience
00:15:36 and sincere faith. Certain persons by swerving from these have wandered away into vain discussion,
00:15:43 desiring to be teachers of the law, but without understanding either what they are saying or the
00:15:49 things about which they make confident assertions. Here we are, Eric, throwing it to you. What do
00:15:56 you think? Well, I think, first of all, guys, that was brilliant. I think you should have more of
00:16:00 that. Wes, well done. Thank you. Wes, I don't know if Wes gets a promotion, but I give Wes a promotion.
00:16:06 Perfect. Without pay. A higher title, maybe a new fancy tie, but absolutely no pay bump.
00:16:13 that's great what what what a deal yeah i think so much of this you guys are exactly right
00:16:20 uh and so much but i think for christians and and how we think through these issues
00:16:25 you notice that spike uh starts in the 40s on terms like racism uh as you guys pointed out
00:16:30 not being used before but notice the jump in the 60s right what happens in the 60s you get the
00:16:37 civil rights 1964 amendment and then really what becomes a bureaucracy of the u.s government
00:16:44 that is pushing the legislation and really this total ideology of racism into all the culture
00:16:51 we get things like affirmative action so you're actually creating laws that are prejudiced against
00:16:57 particularly white people and i think because of that christians are unaware of the ways in which
00:17:02 we have actually been catechized, not by the scriptures, not by reformed theologians,
00:17:06 but by really this influx of leftist Marxist. This is the CRT that we see now infiltrating
00:17:16 the culture. And so I think what's concerning, particularly, you mentioned Matt Chandler,
00:17:22 but most pastors in America haven't seen that traditionally as a problem that he even said
00:17:29 that. And he's outspokenly saying, you know, I'm going to act in a manner that is showing
00:17:34 partiality. And there were a few fringe people, you know, count us among them who called that out
00:17:40 in the beginning. But where were the denominational heads of the PCA in the SBC? They were actually
00:17:46 kind of in lockstep. So I think because of that, now you've got all this reverse catechesis that
00:17:52 we have to do to really get rid of race brain. And I think a big part of it, too, a lot of people, 0.85
00:17:57 you know, the big hubbub was I had retweeted Andrew Torba, who was he had screenshotted or
00:18:04 taken a photo of somebody talking about Aristotle. And people say, well, you know, you can't the
00:18:11 Aristotle was the problem. I say, OK, fine. But let me read a quote from Rush Dooney.
00:18:16 This is what Rush Dooney said about immigration. He said, the problem, of course, is that now we
00:18:21 have had a great deal of illegal immigration. We have immigration laws that no longer follow
00:18:26 the older pattern and concentrated on European countries. We allow many, many peoples in who
00:18:32 have nothing in common with us, who are Muslims or members of other religions. And it appears that 1.00
00:18:37 there is an effort to break the Christian heritage and character of the United States.
00:18:42 So for our reform brothers, if you happen to be theonomic, of course, you're going to appreciate 0.99
00:18:49 Rush Dooney. But look, even in the 80s, these guys were talking about the problem in language
00:18:55 that now if you if some if one of us had said the exact same thing people would have said look
00:18:59 they're racists well and that happened eric i have said the exact same thing at your conference
00:19:04 and people said i was racist that's right and and i think it's interesting too because i was
00:19:10 recently speaking with a a pastor in the south in florida and he's latino and he said you know
00:19:17 it's funny because i i petitioned our denomination to have a latino reformed church and they were
00:19:23 like great and he said i i can only imagine what would have happened if i had petitioned to have
00:19:28 a white anglo protestant church you know what there would have been outcry over that and i
00:19:35 think what's really hard in these conversations people don't realize the the extent to which
00:19:40 they've been propagandized so when you think about unpardonable sins in our camp i mean even
00:19:47 to be accused of racism as we were joel recently right as you mentioned with the conference but
00:19:53 also on Twitter, to even be accused of it is the unpardonable sin. And we have to step back
00:19:59 and ask ourselves, have we even defined the sin clearly? I think you guys have shown that we
00:20:03 haven't. But if we haven't defined the sin as a biblical sin, why is it to the level of it's
00:20:10 really like a death penalty sin in our culture's view to do or say anything that's racist? And
00:20:16 we have to ask how we got to that place. Right. That was great, Eric. Thank you.
00:20:21 um let me give an example real quick um this is something that a fellow pastor who who's a godly
00:20:27 man i i respect him plenty plenty of respect for him grateful for him um but i said something that
00:20:35 you know i didn't say it directly to him but it was passed along i said something to someone and
00:20:39 that someone said something that you know and it got to him and uh and he couldn't believe it you
00:20:43 know it took him it took him back and um he's like i you know can't believe joel said that and
00:20:48 his first instinct was, that's racist. And I'm going to actually give the example here,
00:20:53 and it won't help me, you know, right-wing watch will pick it up. It's not going to help, but
00:20:56 well, it will help because right-wing watch will pick it up, you know, so we'll get, you know,
00:20:59 whatever, a million more views. But I'm going to share it. And some of you listening, you'll
00:21:04 listen to this and say, well, I think that's racist. But it's not. This does not contradict
00:21:11 the law of God in the book of James or prejudging the kinds of things. It's not that we can't
00:21:18 prejudge at all, right? So think of it like this, Matthew 7, judge not, right? You know how you
00:21:23 reformed Christian, you get upset when people misquote Matthew and they say, you know, they
00:21:26 basically boil down the entirety of the 66 books of the Bible to one verse, judge not. And you know
00:21:32 how you're going to point out, just like I would point out, you say, well, that's the first five
00:21:35 verses of chapter 7 of Matthew. But then verse 6 says, don't throw your pearls before swine, you
00:21:39 know, or give what is holy to dogs. And how do you know who swine are? And how do you know what
00:21:44 a dog is except for making a judgment so clearly what's being condemned you know in the book of
00:21:49 matthew that jesus is condemning the sermon on the mount is not all forms of judgment but
00:21:52 sinful judgment wrong judgment i think the same applies with pre-judgment which is that's what
00:21:58 prejudice is pre-judgment so when when james is saying um don't say to the rich person who comes
00:22:05 into your assembly so first what's the context it's the church so when a rich person walks into
00:22:10 your assembly. Don't say to the rich person, hey, come and sit right here at my right hand. And you
00:22:15 poor person, what are you doing? You peasant taking up this rich person's chair, come and sit 1.00
00:22:21 at my feet. James is saying, yeah, that's not a good look. The Lord is not pleased with that.
00:22:26 That's wrong. And that would be wrong. He uses the example of class and economic status, but that
00:22:33 could also be applied to race. So if you said to a white person, hey, come and have this nice chair,
00:22:37 and to the black person, hey, go and sit at my feet. 0.81
00:22:39 That's wrong, or vice versa, which is, let's be honest, 0.98
00:22:42 what's currently happening in the church
00:22:44 for the last 15 years, easy if not longer, 1.00
00:22:46 is, hey, black person, come and take this job 0.97
00:22:48 and you can be a campus pastor, you know? 1.00
00:22:50 And then, oh, sexual sin comes out.
00:22:51 It turns out that, you know, you weren't qualified. 0.99
00:22:53 And white guys, sorry, we had to look over you 0.52
00:22:55 even though you were more qualified
00:22:57 both in your life and doctrine, even your character.
00:22:59 You weren't cheating on your wife,
00:23:01 but you missed out on a pastoral job opportunity 0.99
00:23:03 because we had to get the black guy to fill that slot.
00:23:06 That is literally what's happening currently.
00:23:09 So that's not like just a...
00:23:10 So we are literally doing what James says, except instead of economics, it's applied
00:23:14 to race, and it's putting down the white guy to elevate the non-white person of color. 0.51
00:23:20 But here's the point.
00:23:21 In the context of the church, that is a prejudgment.
00:23:25 So in the same way that Matthew 7 does not demonize all forms of judgment, but sinful 0.55
00:23:29 judgment, because you have to make a judgment to know this person's a swine and I shouldn't 0.96
00:23:33 give them my pearls. 1.00
00:23:34 So, too, in the book of James, and also elsewhere in the Sermon on the Mount, I would argue,
00:23:38 and I think Wes argued beautifully in the article that we just read, that not all forms
00:23:43 of prejudgment are a sin.
00:23:44 In fact, we often, we have to use prejudgment on a daily basis.
00:23:50 If you're walking down the street with your wife and children, and you see some guy who's
00:23:57 kind of, you know, he's skitsing out a little bit, you know, and he's dressed in shabby
00:24:02 clothes, that is not what James is talking about.
00:24:04 oh, see, you're prejudging the poor. No, you're prejudging somebody for all intents and purposes
00:24:09 is showing nine out of 10 signs of being a meth addict. And therefore, with a greater inclination
00:24:16 towards violence and threatens the safety of your family, which you're obligated morally by God to
00:24:21 protect. Okay, that's totally different. So here's the example that I got to my pastor friend,
00:24:25 and he's like, oh, I don't like that, Joel. Are you sure you're not racist? The example that I gave,
00:24:30 not to him directly but somebody else and it got to him was you know somebody in my church was
00:24:35 asking he was asking you know what I'm trying to understand what is actually racist what you know
00:24:40 how do we define racism how would the bible define it you know what actually is a sin and what's not
00:24:45 and so I gave him an example I said well recently you know I have some heart troubles and so I have
00:24:52 to see a cardiologist once a year and eventually we'll probably have to have heart surgery on some
00:24:56 some things and I won't get into the details, but always kind of had a bad heart. And so when we
00:25:01 moved to Texas, I needed to get a new cardiologist. And so my wife, she does a lot of this for me
00:25:07 because before we had kids, she was an RN and she knows a lot more than I do. And I actually,
00:25:12 I let her read those books. She read some medical books. Yeah. And so she's doing the research and
00:25:17 looking at these things and she shows me two doctors, both within the same practice, same
00:25:22 company, hospital, and saying, you know, do you like one over the other? And one was a young
00:25:29 white dude, and one was a young black dude. And I said, I prefer the young white dude. 0.65
00:25:34 And this is why. The reason why is not because I'm white, but because we currently live in a 0.56
00:25:40 historical moment in the West, and particularly in these United States, where I know that both
00:25:46 of these guys could be perfectly qualified. But I also know that if there's a chance that one of
00:25:51 was not qualified and was given a free pass it'd be the black guy i know that that young white guy 0.56
00:25:57 there's no way he got a free pass there's no way i know that that and and for the record let's take
00:26:03 white guy out of the equation let's say it was a young black guy and a young asian guy i picked
00:26:07 the asian guy yep because he i know had to earn it and the black guy might have earned it and this
00:26:13 is the tragedy the tragedy is he could have been a fantastic doctor i i don't know now now when i 0.87
00:26:19 was talking to this member of my church, then I said, now let me give another hypothetical. That
00:26:23 was a real example. Let me give a hypothetical example. Let's say that the black doctor,
00:26:29 there's a white guy that I don't know from Adam, and there's a black doctor who's a member in our
00:26:32 church. He's a member in good standing. He's a brother in the Lord. I know him. I've had dinner
00:26:37 with his family. Then I'm going to him because I know him. So it's not a universal blanket judgment
00:26:43 against a particular person on the basis of their skin pigment. That's not what we're talking about.
00:26:48 but but the point is that was a pre-judgment that i made with the original example i i didn't know
00:26:53 either guy so i'm pre-judging i'm not judging by hey let me sit you down and interview you and get
00:26:57 to know you and ask you questions and you know what did you score in your incats you know and
00:27:01 all i didn't do any of that i'm i'm pre-judging not judging after the facts but pre-judging before
00:27:06 the facts and i'm making um a a bias a a an emotional heartfelt bias based off no i'm making
00:27:13 is statistical analysis, a prejudgment based off of statistics. I know that the likelihood of if
00:27:21 one of these men, maybe they both got in to their profession on merit, and I hope that they did.
00:27:26 But if one of them didn't, statistically speaking, there was a far higher likelihood that the young
00:27:32 black man, as a doctor, that he got a pass and did not have to prove as much merit. The white guy,
00:27:39 statistically speaking there's far less likelihood that he got a pass if anything the system would be
00:27:45 against him he would have to score even higher and these are things that are on the books harvard
00:27:49 it's on the books you have to have a higher sat score based off of race right so these are this
00:27:55 is not speculation this is not you know putting on the tinfoil hat this is um i can you know i'm
00:28:01 just believing my lying eyes i know how to read so that would be an example so but here's the thing
00:28:06 That is a prejudgment.
00:28:08 In that case, that is a prejudgment on the basis of skin pigment, and none of that goes
00:28:13 against what James says in the Holy Scripture.
00:28:16 Well, that same prejudgment that you're not allowed to do, Eric, you were talking about
00:28:19 this deathly thing that once you're accused of it, there's no way out.
00:28:22 This happened in Florida at an SBC church, FBC Naples, an SBC church, First Baptist Church
00:28:27 of Naples, where a black pastor narrowly failed to be chosen by the congregation, and a kind
00:28:33 of inquisition went out.
00:28:35 They found this deacon.
00:28:36 they hung him out to dry to the whole SBC in a letter
00:28:39 claiming that he instigated resistance to this man
00:28:42 being appointed to the office of pastor
00:28:44 because of racism they said they vowed to deal with this
00:28:47 sinful cancer and actually even church disciplined him
00:28:50 so they took this man who said hey I don't think this man's qualified
00:28:53 he didn't say why so he didn't give it away
00:28:56 some other members joined him they voted against
00:28:58 and that prejudgment I can't see the heart but I've got a good guess
00:29:02 they did that they hung this man out to dry and now his name
00:29:05 is in the mud and this incident is now forever known i remember jd greer talking about it it's
00:29:10 forever known as this terrible racist thing that happened in the sbc proof we still have more to do
00:29:15 so you can't prejudge but most certainly the so-called anti-racist they'll look into your heart
00:29:20 and they'll figure out motive uh whether you even have it or not right eric thoughts yeah well i i
00:29:26 think i know i know you guys have covered it on the show but i think for people who are wondering
00:29:30 on these issues particularly would encourage them to read jeremy carl's book the unprotected class
00:29:34 he goes through this and documents as you said harvard uh you know sat scores all that but
00:29:41 there's actually been a number of cases in the medical profession and he cites one of the case
00:29:45 i can't remember the gentleman's name but basically where this black doctor made it all the way up
00:29:50 through into plastic surgery in california and a lot of people end up dying because it's essentially
00:29:56 a dei hire the other thing i think that's interesting about it and what we have to just
00:30:00 be aware of because of the era of civil rights you you are at the point where to call someone
00:30:08 racist is it has power right it has a weaponized power to cancel to destroy but i think it also 0.67
00:30:16 for for particularly guys like jd greer and white pastors part of the problem is they're deathly
00:30:21 afraid of this conversation right they're deathly afraid of ever being accused of anything related
00:30:26 to being racist um and so this is they've actually taken part in part of that cancel culture
00:30:33 but also it it means that you have to distance yourself from the old dead guys of the reformed
00:30:40 tradition um and so you i think you'll see more and more of this uh happening because you're
00:30:46 going to have to like what do you obviously rl dabney you know very unpopular if you if you
00:30:50 reference him you're an automatic racist uh but even guys like jonathan edwards i mean this was
00:30:55 a big deal at the Desiring God conferences. John Piper had done a biography, one of his 0.52
00:31:00 biographical sketches on Edwards, and so much time had to be devoted to how could we be platforming
00:31:08 and saying anything positive given Edwards' views on slavery and his defense from Scripture and all
00:31:14 those things. So I think moving forward, the real issue is I think we need to, particularly as
00:31:20 pastors just refused to play that game uh one of the things that happened online uh people were
00:31:26 making disparaging comments uh the n-word gets used and immediately you'll see what happens is
00:31:32 like people are calling on me say like you need to come denounce this person and one of the biggest
00:31:38 problems i have with it is it's like i didn't make that comment i don't even know who this person is
00:31:42 Right. But but you saw so many pastors who were lining up and who are like, oh, no, no, like even if it's not even if I commit the racist act and that's in scare quotes, it's it's now also I need to be first to jump on anything that that could be potentially racist and I need to be denouncing it firm and hard.
00:32:02 Otherwise, I, too, will be called a racist.
00:32:06 And again, the other thing about this is there's no due process in any of it, right?
00:32:10 As Wes pointed out, just to be called that, it's assumed that you are that.
00:32:15 And again, we want to talk about biblical justice, where you've defined something unbiblically
00:32:20 with racism, and now you've basically hung somebody in the court of public opinion without
00:32:26 due process at all.
00:32:28 Right.
00:32:29 And to be clear, in that instance that you're referencing on X,
00:32:33 I did come out and I said, hey, this is not the way.
00:32:37 Delete.
00:32:38 And the person deleted it.
00:32:40 And that fixed the problem, right?
00:32:43 Everybody was content then?
00:32:45 No.
00:32:45 No.
00:32:46 No, and that's what I said.
00:32:47 He didn't go hard enough.
00:32:48 He needed to go harder.
00:32:51 He needed to call his pastor.
00:32:52 Yeah, he needed to call his pastor.
00:32:53 You need to hunt him down like Liam Neeson style.
00:32:56 I will find you, Anon. 0.92
00:32:58 you know and i have a very specific set of skills and i will ruin your life uh just like you know
00:33:03 uh everybody ruined thomas acorns but yep you know um anything short of that uh unless when it
00:33:08 comes to racism um unless you see to it that that man can't feed his children for the rest of his
00:33:13 life then uh then you're not going to satisfy you know your opponents and so yeah so anyways
00:33:21 go ahead just part of it with the double standard um so when you look at like hip-hop black
00:33:27 culture music um and i did i looked it up after that incident the the rate at which that word is
00:33:33 used uh is astronomical um and so like again we're judging on two standards uh based on your
00:33:40 skin color some people can say it some people can't again biblically you would have to say well
00:33:45 why is that if it's so bad why is it so frequently used right that's a good question all right let's
00:33:51 go to our first commercial break and then what we're going to do is we're going to come back
00:33:54 and we're going to show some clips of a group that I can't remember, but I...
00:33:58 Good Fight Ministries.
00:33:59 Good Fight Ministries, which they seem like good guys, just of the boomer variety, which
00:34:07 by the way, boomer is not an age, it's a state of mind, it's a state of heart, but definitely
00:34:13 a boomer take on Khan and me and other Christian nationalists, but they said some things that
00:34:19 I think are still worth addressing, mainly, not that we haven't addressed these things
00:34:23 a million times over steven wolf you know he's probably exhausted at this point how many times
00:34:27 he's addressed all these things so we've addressed these things multiple times eric has i have um
00:34:32 but i thought that it would be good to to show their clips because i thought it could be good
00:34:36 not just to address it for the record because the record's already been been made uh you can go back
00:34:40 and search videos and find where we've addressed these kinds of accusations but i thought it would
00:34:44 just be fun in real time to show the video and just demonstrate how easy it is to address them
00:34:49 Yeah, that it's like my six-year-old daughter
00:34:53 would be able to respond to 90%
00:34:56 of what you'll see in these clips.
00:34:58 So that'll be fun.
00:34:59 Let's go to our first commercial break.
00:35:03 Right Response Ministries 2025 conference is a go.
00:35:08 This is three days, full jam-packed conference
00:35:12 with eight main sessions,
00:35:13 three to four hour and a half long panels
00:35:15 and an all-star, super-based lineup of speakers,
00:35:19 15 speakers in all.
00:35:21 Who are they?
00:35:22 Steve Dace, Jeff Durbin, Orne McIntyre,
00:35:25 Stephen Wolfe, Brian Sauve, Andrew Isker,
00:35:28 John Harris, Eric Kahn, Aidy Robles,
00:35:31 Dan Burkholder, the Christian Prince himself,
00:35:34 Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, David Reese,
00:35:37 and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webin.
00:35:40 Again, this is April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, 2025,
00:35:43 and the early registration is open right now.
00:35:47 This is the longest conference
00:35:49 with the most speakers we've ever offered
00:35:52 and yet it is our all-time lowest price.
00:35:55 The early registration available today
00:35:57 is only 140 bucks for an adult.
00:36:00 So go to rightresponseconference.com.
00:36:03 Again, that is rightresponseconference.com
00:36:07 to register right now
00:36:08 because the early registration will not last long.
00:36:11 Are you a Christian struggling to find companies that align with your values and beliefs?
00:36:17 Well, then Squirrely Joe's has you covered for all your coffee needs.
00:36:21 All of their coffee is hand-selected and roasted fresh every day by a family of fellow believers.
00:36:27 Try them out and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your investment
00:36:32 supports a company committed to following God's teachings and upholding truth and righteousness,
00:36:38 ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the growth of God's kingdom.
00:36:43 Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil.
00:36:47 Right Response listeners have access to an exclusive deal.
00:36:51 Your first bag of coffee is free.
00:36:54 All you have to do is cover the shipping.
00:36:56 So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response.
00:37:01 Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response
00:37:06 to claim your first free bag of coffee today visit the word soap.com today again that's
00:37:13 the word soap.com everyone needs soap so wash yourself in the word
00:37:19 all right we're going to go ahead and check out those clips but before we do i want to address
00:37:27 something in the comments so a few people at this point have mentioned well joel gave this example
00:37:32 of choosing doctors and exercising prejudgment and arguing that it's a form of of morally
00:37:39 permissible prejudgment um where he decided that he's going to pass over uh the black doctor that
00:37:45 he doesn't know from adam in order to choose the white doctor that doesn't know from adam because
00:37:49 of jeremy carl what he has outlined the things that are statistically there i mean they're
00:37:54 written down it's it's you know it's proven uh there's a statistical likelihood that the white
00:37:59 guy had to get there on the basis of merit, and that's far more likely in our current cultural
00:38:05 moment than the black guy. Sadly, we wish that wasn't the case, but it is. But I noticed in the 1.00
00:38:11 comments that some people are saying, yeah, but then Wes gave an example where Joel's saying it's
00:38:17 okay to have his prejudgment, but then Wes gave an example of a prejudgment that was imposed on a
00:38:23 white guy, and that's not okay. Can you explain a little bit more of this white deacon and what
00:38:29 happens so that people can see the difference yep so uh it was a black pastor someone noted why did
00:38:34 they prejudge the white pastor it was a black pastor and it was a congregational church so in
00:38:38 the congregational church the members of the church have to affirm and actually take a vote
00:38:43 on it and then if the the member or if the the candidate that's put forward it was 81 i believe 0.59
00:38:48 at fbc naples so real quick but this is a black so he's not a pastor yet this is a black man
00:38:54 who's up for the pastorate he's a can't like elder candidate exactly and then they had to
00:38:59 approve him through a congregational vote of 81 sbc church and he didn't get it exactly he fell
00:39:05 a little bit short of it and then what happened and so then a so then they looked at like how
00:39:12 could we not possibly put this black man forward how could we consider him not qualified right and
00:39:17 the individuals that voted against him as i understand it they had a myriad of different
00:39:20 reasons so some of them maybe it was his teaching capacity maybe some had concerns about his
00:39:24 character and there was a group of individuals because it's a big church that had gathered some
00:39:28 signatures and said hey we don't think he's the right fit and they pinpointed on a man his name
00:39:32 is uh david i believe david doral uh as a man that kind of instigated this and they said because you
00:39:40 oppose this man whatever the reason would be we don't care this is a white man exactly this white
00:39:44 man it must have been racist you oppose this ordination and the reason for it there was no
00:39:49 text of him calling him any names. There wasn't any evidence brought forward. It was literally
00:39:54 simply because the congregation did not quite vote to the level to ordain him that the reason
00:40:00 for that must have been racism. Right. So you congregation did not vote to approve this black
00:40:06 elder candidate to actually approve him with an 81% vote so that he would be ordained as a pastor
00:40:12 this church and um and this particular white man in the congregation who had a petition and was kind
00:40:19 of getting people on board with not voting for him um his reason for doing that must have been
00:40:26 racism and more broadly was concerns about transparency at the church the absence of the
00:40:30 vetted elders there was some maligning of a previous longtime former pastor that had been
00:40:34 there this bob codwell so they had concerns it's like i think of uh david platt and mclean baptist
00:40:40 huge church lots of resources and there's a shadow kind of elders and government there
00:40:45 and so this man said hey i have concerns let's forestall maybe the installation of this man i'm
00:40:50 not sure if he's the right fit and him doing that the verdict was from this kind of shadow elder
00:40:55 group must be racism racism must be stamped out and they put them under church discipline
00:40:59 yep so for the guys in the comments who are saying well it seems like a double standard here
00:41:03 um this is uh hopefully this clears it up for you and if it doesn't um well then you're wrong
00:41:10 but uh the difference is not that one is pre-judgment of a black guy this pastor who or
00:41:17 you know elder candidate who was up for eldership who didn't get the vote and uh that the white you
00:41:21 know guy in the congregation was saying hey i don't think we should vote for him because i have
00:41:25 concerns about character and teaching capacity and blah blah blah blah blah and and then you know
00:41:29 people just assumed that the white guy's being racist against this elder candidate because he
00:41:33 happens to be a black elder candidate the reason why that pre-judgment assuming the white guy's
00:41:38 being racist is different than the prejudgment i described in the case of a black doctor the
00:41:43 difference is not prejudgment towards a black man is acceptable and prejudgment towards this white
00:41:48 man is not acceptable here's this is going to blow your mind this is a shocking revelation
00:41:52 the difference that makes one immoral and one acceptable is not the color of those two guys
00:41:57 skin but that one prejudgment is true and the other one is false let me say that again one was
00:42:06 true and the other one was false so when i say hey if there's two doctors and i don't know either
00:42:12 one from adam but i know statistically speaking statistically speaking and and i'm not celebrating
00:42:19 i'm not like yay i love this i wish i wish it wasn't this way but i recognize that in the year
00:42:24 of our lord 2024 in these united states of america that sadly because of of critical race theory and
00:42:31 anti-white discrimination which is on the books in universities when it comes to sat scores and
00:42:38 all these different things when i say hey i don't know either of these guys from adam but i know
00:42:44 statistically speaking there is a higher likelihood that the white guy had to earn his position by
00:42:50 merit and the black guy has a lower likelihood of having earned it fully by merit when i pre-judge
00:42:58 in that way, I'm making a prejudgment that's true. It's true. That is a statistical, factual, 1.00
00:43:07 accurate analysis. An entire book was just written, read it, by Jeremy Carl, right?
00:43:14 Anti-white discrimination. That is a true prejudgment. When this local church prejudged
00:43:21 that a white individual who had concerns about a black elder candidate, when they assumed that
00:43:27 his concerns were solely due to the color of this elder candidate's skin, the reason why that was
00:43:33 wrong is because it was not true. You see how that works? So it's not pre-judgment against the black
00:43:39 guy is wrong because he's black and pre-judgment against the white guy, you know, that's acceptable,
00:43:44 you know, but like, no, no, no, it's not about that. It's are your judgments. It's the same as 0.86
00:43:48 pre-judgment standards, same for judgment standards. So Matthew 7, what judgment is
00:43:54 permissible according to Christ himself, Matthew 7, verse 6, do not give to dogs what is holy or
00:44:00 to swine. Throw your pearls before swine. What kind of judgment is permissible in the mind of
00:44:05 Christ? Right judgments, accurate judgments. When you rightly judge, I'm not going to give pearls
00:44:11 to this person. When you make that judgment or decision, it's because you've made a judgment.
00:44:16 You've judged that this group of people, this person or this individual is a swine. I'm not 0.60
00:44:21 going to preach the gospel to this person for the 10,000th time and give what is holy to them
00:44:26 because they have denied it and trampled underfoot every single, again and again. And the same way
00:44:31 that Paul says, I will no longer go to the Jews, but instead I'm going to be an apostle to the
00:44:35 Gentiles. Like that was not unrighteous. That was not wicked. That was not sinful. But here's the
00:44:40 thing. The reason why that kind of judgment is permissible is because it was a right judgment.
00:44:45 You're judging something rightly. So too, making a prejudgment. Now we should be careful with
00:44:50 pre-judgment. But there are times, inescapable moments in our lives, we're making a pre-judgment.
00:44:55 Every time you choose a doctor, you are making a pre-judgment. Why'd you choose that one and not
00:45:00 the others? There's some kind of reason. I actually had a biblically permissible reason
00:45:06 and a factually, statistically true reason. Now, for those who make a pre-judgment that is
00:45:12 solely based on some kind of bitterness or inner heart hatred with no statistical analysis,
00:45:19 would then yeah then that's a that was would be a wrong prejudgment so that's the difference
00:45:23 um all right so we got to get to these uh video clips let's go to the first one
00:45:27 just say it's going to become worse and worse but in him talking about we're looking he's a green 0.84
00:45:34 we've got to have this dictator come that just blows me away chad that he so it is really a sad 1.00
00:45:41 thing to watch and to see there's a lot of great brothers in christ that are like what on earth 0.85
00:45:47 like, our black brothers in Christ that are like, what on earth are you talking about?
00:45:51 Where are you going with this? 0.98
00:45:52 It's absolutely demonic.
00:45:53 Yeah, it's demonic.
00:45:55 They're quoting Aristotle, you know?
00:45:57 Why don't they quote him on homosexuality and all these other things, you know?
00:46:01 But they're quoting Aristotle, basically, the quote Aristotle's saying, 0.98
00:46:05 you really can't have a democracy if you have different ethnic groups. 1.00
00:46:08 And they're saying he was right, you know? 1.00
00:46:10 And, of course, these guys are white, so I guess they want to be around just a lot of white guys, 0.57
00:46:14 which is, to me, it just breaks my heart 0.82
00:46:17 because I don't know if there's anything more beautiful
00:46:19 than the gospel itself and the effects of the gospel
00:46:23 when you see people in our fellowship.
00:46:27 We have all different races, African-American and Asian
00:46:33 and Hispanic, a lot of Hispanic people and white folks and so forth.
00:46:36 And I love seeing different ethnic groups worship together
00:46:40 because it's, you know, what Aristotle's saying,
00:46:42 you know what? Guess what? Without Jesus, yeah, nation's going to be against nation,
00:46:48 which is ethnos against ethnos in the Greek. Without Christ, there isn't really hope for
00:46:52 this world. But in Christ, guess what it says in Revelation 7, 9 through 14, when John sees this
00:46:57 great multitude that no man can number, they're united as one in Christ in the heavenly kingdom.
00:47:03 They've come out of great tribulation. And the elder says to him, these are those that have
00:47:06 come out of great tribulation, and they've been cleansed by the blood of the Lamb. So these guys,
00:47:12 you know they're not gonna really want to be in heaven because guess what not with jesus and all
00:47:16 the different ethnic groups because guess what it works in jesus because we're all of the same blood
00:47:20 all right eric nice softball for you do you think you could respond to that do you think you can
00:47:26 handle it so he raised some tough objections you up for it yeah it's tough well you put some
00:47:32 pressure on me when you said that your six-year-old daughter could answer these and then
00:47:35 i mean how do you fail at that how do you fail yeah yeah so i i think there's a few things to
00:47:43 notice uh and i would comment on the video and also kind of similar responses that i saw on
00:47:47 social media number one is the superlatives that are used to open right it's like this is demonic
00:47:53 this is horrible it breaks my heart you notice how much of that and how little actual argumentation
00:47:58 is happening um so that would be one of my you know explain what you mean okay why do you think
00:48:04 it's demonic you didn't actually present an argument for that and i did happen to listen
00:48:07 to more of the interview and they never really get to that i'm sorry yeah yeah it was it was it
00:48:13 was a trial um so i think there's that portion of it the other thing is the assumption uh that a lot
00:48:19 of people are making about christian nationalists that they're saying what we're saying is we only
00:48:23 want white people in the kingdom and that is of course not what we're saying um i think also the
00:48:30 understanding of ethnos right so if we're talking about and i'm just going to use the
00:48:36 dictionary definition here but ethnicity as a social group of people who share a common culture
00:48:41 language and religion who have distinctive characteristics that differentiate them from
00:48:46 other groups um when they're quoting in revelation or referring to revelation that there are multiple
00:48:54 nations worshiping before the throne it never says that the nations are no longer distinct
00:48:59 and no longer says that they lose all those
00:49:01 attributes about what it meant for them to be
00:49:03 an Ethiopian Christian for example
00:49:05 yes we'll be part of the 0.86
00:49:07 same kingdom no I
00:49:09 don't I you know I
00:49:10 am rejoicing actually in the fact
00:49:13 that those brothers will be there
00:49:15 with us and yet for
00:49:17 all that we still have our
00:49:19 distinctions that God put there
00:49:21 and so we don't have to hate the
00:49:23 distinction it's actually a
00:49:25 good thing and so I think
00:49:27 there there's also a confusion i think in many christians minds um of of uh national political
00:49:35 realm versus the church so i think they have some kind of idea that like our church is just white
00:49:41 people i mean we have black people we have portricans we have cubans we have mexicans right
00:49:46 so on that we're not actually disagreeing with the fact that all those people are welcome
00:49:51 in the ecclesiastical body of the church right um when you look at the nation however and we're
00:49:58 saying okay can you have for example the easy one is islam islam or probably hinduism can you bring 0.91
00:50:06 these people in and allow them to build their statues to whatever calf god they're building 0.86
00:50:11 their statue to can you allow that to happen in your nation and it not tear the nation apart
00:50:17 can you have this syncretistic pluralism?
00:50:20 And I think that's where they're actually just not making a distinction
00:50:23 between the nation and the church
00:50:25 and how you have to protect each one according,
00:50:29 you know, the nation.
00:50:30 You have the civil magistrate who carries the sword.
00:50:33 It's not the realm of the church.
00:50:36 But again, I don't think that they're even working on a paradigm
00:50:40 that allows them to think in categories that way.
00:50:43 Right.
00:50:44 Let me, so my two cents,
00:50:46 a couple things that i would pick out i think that's everything you said is good the superfluous
00:50:51 of um you know breaks my heart and demonic and all those kinds of things but what i would add
00:50:56 is um right there at the very end when he said you know these guys won't want to be in heaven
00:50:59 you know because i look at revelation and it says you know that there was a great sea and a great
00:51:02 number you know greater than anybody could count um you know made up of every tribe tongue and
00:51:07 nation um yeah that's great but um i thought we already went through this with the woke wars of
00:51:12 you know, 2017, 18, 19, 20, heaven does not have to be, the ethnic diversity of heaven does not
00:51:20 have to be represented in every single individual local church, right? It's, I mean, Votie Bauckham's
00:51:28 church doesn't represent heaven. He's currently with Conrad Mbewe in Zambia, and I have it on
00:51:33 good authority that there's not a whole lot of Asians or white people, you know, or Hispanics
00:51:37 in their church their church is is as far as i know it is almost if not entirely black monoethnic
00:51:45 it's monoethnic there are only black people in that church and god is furious about it absolutely 0.98
00:51:50 you know you know that this is sin and you know if voddie bacham watched this he would you know 1.00
00:51:54 he'd be laughing right along with me and saying yeah of course this this is stupid um not every 0.99
00:51:59 individual local church has to be perfectly ethnically diverse it depends where are you 0.99
00:52:05 And who are you? Who are your people? Where are your people? Where do you live? If you live in
00:52:12 Oklahoma and it's a particular, you know, county that's predominantly white, your church, guess
00:52:17 what? Shocker, probably going to be predominantly white. If you live in a border state and there's
00:52:24 a lot of Hispanic people there, then you're probably going to have a lot of Hispanic people
00:52:27 in your church. That's all that is perfectly permissible. There is nothing. So this idea that,
00:52:32 well heaven is perfectly diverse and so these guys aren't going to like heaven that's not what
00:52:35 we're talking about um of course heaven is going to be diverse because god is saving christ is
00:52:40 saving people from among every tribe tongue and nation the gospel is is going out like a little
00:52:44 bit of leaven through the whole batch of dough like mustard seed growing into an earth encompassing
00:52:48 tree and reaching all the nations and praise god for it but all the nations being in heaven doesn't
00:52:53 mean that all the nations have to be in our country that's the point the point is that that um heaven
00:53:01 right but you do not have the apostle paul uh going to ethiopia and saying you need because
00:53:06 all the nations will be in heaven then you need all the nations in your country now that is not
00:53:13 in scripture some uh reasonable degree of of immigration that's legal and i as a christian
00:53:21 nationalist if i was christian caesar for the day i would argue that it would need to be um
00:53:25 it would need to be legal not just legal but there would need to be a profession of christ
00:53:29 from the adults, at least from the parents. So they would need to be Christian immigrants, 0.88
00:53:34 legal immigrants, and they would also need to be contributing immigrants, meaning that they're
00:53:38 coming and they're bringing a skill that our country currently has need of. They're engineers,
00:53:42 they're doctors, they're whatever. If you have something to contribute, if you are going through
00:53:50 legal process, and if you're not coming to just, you know, so that we can import Hinduism,
00:53:55 but you're coming as someone who loves the Lord Jesus Christ and loves America and wants to be
00:54:01 an American and not just as a set of propositions or an economic zone but you've done your homework
00:54:07 you've read the Declaration of Independence you've looked at American history and you're like I love
00:54:11 that your people will be my people and your God I've given up Hinduism your God will be my God
00:54:17 I want to be a Christian I see Christ the triune God is the one true God I want to be a Christian 0.92
00:54:22 your God will be my God and your people, your history, your heritage. I love that. And I know
00:54:27 it's not mine, but I hope by God's grace, generations down the line, that my children's
00:54:30 children would be Americans because America is wonderful and Christ is glorious. And also I'm
00:54:37 an engineer and I can fix that bridge over there. And all right, we'll take 250,000 of you a year
00:54:42 for the next hundred years and no more. That is not racist. And you can say how you can put it,
00:54:51 whatever it breaks i'm sure the good fight if they listen that they're like i probably just broke
00:54:56 both of their hearts their hearts are just wide open just broken but i'm sorry that that is not
00:55:01 none of that is racist that uh countries are allowed to do that and and the last thing i'll
00:55:06 say is the aristotle thing that you know torba and con shared and and then i read it was it was
00:55:11 torba you know sharing it and then it was con resharing torba saying aristotle was right and
00:55:15 then i reshared con um but here's the thing uh number one no one said aristotle was right about
00:55:21 everything he ever said no one said that once two there were three components we talked about
00:55:27 this last week three components in that portion um that's talking about aristotle's thought on
00:55:32 this matter three components two explicit one implicit the two explicit is this um multi-ethnic
00:55:38 nation second democracy is the form of government so when eric khan says aristotle's right he's not
00:55:46 saying aristotle's right multi-ethnic countries don't work ever no he's saying aristotle's right
00:55:51 and what aristotle said what did aristotle say multi-ethnic with a democratic raw democratic
00:55:57 form of government that devolves into an oligarchy which is what we currently have now
00:56:01 and then the third and i would argue that it's implicit but the third implicit element is
00:56:08 element number one multi-ethnic element number two democratic form of government element number
00:56:13 three, because it's Aristotle and he's not a Christian. The third is Christless. And what
00:56:19 have all these guys, Eric, I don't know if you remember this, it doesn't feel that long ago for
00:56:22 me, but what have they been insisting on for the last two years? They've told me, I don't know if
00:56:27 they told you, but they told me that if there's anything we cannot have, it's a Christian nation.
00:56:32 So I'm simply saying that if we can't have a Christian nation, I tried, I thought that was
00:56:38 a good idea. I threw my hat in the ring for a Christian nation that distinctly honors Christ,
00:56:43 that adopts a Christian preamble, like the Apostles' Creed to our Constitution. But I was 0.94
00:56:48 told by all these guys who were getting mad on X about you sharing Aristotle, these are the very
00:56:52 same guys who told us we cannot, under any circumstances, have a nation that is Christian.
00:56:57 There's no such thing. So if we're conceding to their point, not our point, their point,
00:57:04 that there's no such thing as a Christian nation, you cannot have a Christian nation, 0.77
00:57:07 and our nation is going to just devolve more and more into apostasy from Christ. So you're going 0.94
00:57:12 to have a Christless nation with a raw mob rule, kangaroo court, democratic form of government,
00:57:19 then yes, with those two ingredients, then the third ingredient is true. The more multi-ethnic 0.98
00:57:24 it is, the more factions and divisions you will probably have. 0.99
00:57:27 I'll give you Japan. Not a Christian nation. Democratic. 98% Japanese. And they are commodious. 1.00
00:57:33 They have safe cities. They have a lot of cohesion. So not Christian. It's not a Christian
00:57:37 nation it is democratically ruled and it's 98 monoethnic right and for the record what we're 0.56
00:57:43 saying is we're not saying oh you can't have different ethnicities but what we're saying is 0.69
00:57:48 um you can't have both you can't have different ethnicities democratic and christless so let's
00:57:55 let's be a christian nation that loves christ and has that as our common denominator be be rooted in
00:58:01 christ uh where it's not uh multiculturalism it's like stephen wolf talked about it's monoculture
00:58:07 there may be different ethnicities but there's one culture and the culture is a an anglo-protestant
00:58:13 culture anglo not meaning that you have to be white of skin but that you that you adopt that
00:58:18 that um that chrysidum brit distinctly british and certainly european protestant culture that
00:58:25 is hundreds centuries of years old it's tried and tested and true um one of the things that
00:58:31 stephen wolf said at the end of his talk at the new christian conference is he he said well here
00:58:35 are a few of my favorite anglo-protestants and he said clarence thomas is one of my favorite
00:58:39 anglo-protestants because he is for all intents and purpose purposes he he embodies that culture
00:58:45 that that that historic centuries old tried and true culture of anglo-protestantism that's that's
00:58:52 what we're saying is um but to share that aristotle thing that says um hey multi all these
00:59:00 different nationalities under one roof with a democratic form of government where your leaders
00:59:05 oligarch leaders are going to be vying they're going to be bringing up grievances to vie for
00:59:11 this person's uh this group's uh preference for to get their vote against this group that is a
00:59:17 recipe if it's criceless if it's an oligarchy mob rule democracy and it's um and it's all these
00:59:23 different nationalities under one roof without you know generations to assimilate um then that
00:59:29 is going to be divisive that's what i took aristotle saying there i we were not making
00:59:35 zero comment on everything that aristotle has ever said we were making a comment on what he said
00:59:40 right there being shared on x and and i'll say it again aristotle was right he was right
00:59:46 eric yeah i thought the other thing i think that is in play here is the conception that
00:59:53 stephen brings up right in his book christian nationalism it's actually very simple but it's
00:59:58 amazing how this gets warped in our culture today. So he makes the assertion that a nation
01:00:03 ought to be able to act in the interest of its own interests. And it's funny because in America,
01:00:09 we're basically brainwashed to think that we're not allowed to do that. So you're not allowed to
01:00:14 restrict immigration to people who would benefit you. In other words, you're not allowed to restrict
01:00:19 immigration in a way that would benefit the nation because the nation should have no interest. 0.86
01:00:23 um and it's you can see the double standard too because obviously like we have all these
01:00:29 communities you know if if you're in america and you're for the black community that's fine
01:00:34 and you can pick any number you know the chicano movement uh you know mexicans in america who are
01:00:41 all for their culture it's fine you can do that anybody can do that but again the moment that you
01:00:45 say americans ought to act in the american national interests and to rush dunity's point
01:00:50 he saw like america is a anglo-protestant nation and that is largely european and british
01:00:58 uh you know and that's fine for us to say hey we want more people who embody what we believe
01:01:04 about a nation there's actually no problem with saying that that's what you want to do
01:01:09 and i would say the same thing um if you're in uganda if they say this is the uganda value
01:01:15 these are our people culture language religion this is who we are if you don't like that you can
01:01:19 go somewhere else there's no problem with them doing that and i applaud them for doing that
01:01:24 hungary poland they're all entitled to do that but i think that the disease and it's a suicidal
01:01:30 condition of the west is that we believe we have to be destroyed the only way to atone for our 0.79
01:01:36 quote past sins is that we have to be destroyed and we have to actually encourage our own death
01:01:41 you're so i think the challenge here is getting people to wake up and to and this is by the way
01:01:48 king's hall season three one of the big reasons we've looked back to christendom and we're looking
01:01:54 at nations like portugal the world's first global empire these guys did not believe that they were
01:02:00 the scourge of the earth and that they ought to just die because they were so horrible and they
01:02:06 ought to let their country be taken over no they were like we're going to build christendom we're 0.99
01:02:10 going to be christ every corner of the globe we truly believe um that our culture is distinct and
01:02:16 unique and we love it and the spanish you know just to our east they're allowed to believe that
01:02:22 about their culture too that's fine and we're not going to war with them but we're doing you know
01:02:26 we're doing us we have a distinct culture and we're proud of that um even when you get to guys
01:02:31 like martin lloyd jones people ask him they said are you no longer a welshman because you're a
01:02:36 christian and he said well i will say this i'm a christian first but i'm a welshman close second
01:02:42 like he was very proud of being Welsh and I read that and I read his biography it's a banner of
01:02:47 truth and I said that's beautiful that's great when I hear Chuck Knox saying you know give me
01:02:52 the black church or I die I have no problem with that's fine what I have a problem with is that
01:02:58 as Anglo-American Protestants we have to hate ourselves and I think what people are going to 0.97
01:03:04 have to face is you've got to get over that you've been lied to you've been propagandized and
01:03:09 catechized by the wicked regime state and i would just encourage people when you see you know me or
01:03:15 you retweeting something that aristotle said you just have to have this thought maybe we've been
01:03:20 wrong maybe the way that we've believed that culture and ethno should work in america really
01:03:26 for the last you know 60 years maybe we're wrong maybe that's a historical a non-historical way to
01:03:33 look at cultures and then from there just be willing to to hear out the other side of the
01:03:37 argument the problem is it's never going to happen when you've got people who said no you're
01:03:42 automatically a racist anathematized and really what these guys are trying to do is say don't
01:03:47 listen to them they're dangerous you know whatever and uh you know i think that's going to kill the
01:03:54 conversation or has the potential to um and but that's why i would drive people back well did
01:03:58 they make an argument did they make a coherent argument in that video my answer would be absolutely
01:04:03 not. Nope. Yep. Well said. Um, we're going to go to our last commercial break and then we're
01:04:09 going to come back and we're going to deal with, um, one, maybe two more clips, but we also want
01:04:13 to take a little bit of time, uh, to address some of the questions from our live audience. So guys,
01:04:19 uh, do us a favor, just like last week, if you were with us, uh, go ahead and, uh, use this next
01:04:25 segment. And even during the commercial break to start writing in questions. Um, you need to make
01:04:29 it clear that this is a question uh because some kind sometimes you know and i'm not i'm not hating
01:04:34 on you for it but sometimes you uh the chat uh has absolutely nothing to do with uh the topic at hand
01:04:40 and you guys just start arguing with each other and that's fine i get it i would probably do that
01:04:44 too uh but if it's meant to be addressed to eric and myself and wes and it's something that you
01:04:48 want us to address then uh please put it in in a clear format say this is a question for you guys
01:04:53 you know whatever so that we actually get to it so that i know you're not just arguing with you
01:04:57 one of the trolls in the chat, which today there are many, many. All right. So here we go. Commercial
01:05:04 break. Are you desiring to change your financial trajectory and build multi-generational wealth
01:05:10 for your children and grandchildren? Our sponsor, Private Family Banking Partners, invites you to
01:05:15 join a growing number of like-minded individuals, families, and entrepreneurs who are working
01:05:21 together to form a unique part of the parallel economy. With private family banking, you will
01:05:28 learn how to establish a privatized banking system that will increase the value of the money
01:05:33 and savings that you already have flowing through your life. Join this growing community today as a
01:05:40 part of putting post-mill talk into post-mill action by contacting a private family banking
01:05:45 partner today by emailing them at banking at privatefamilybanking.com also see the show notes
01:05:52 below to schedule a discovery call and get a free copy of the ebook protect your money now
01:05:58 how to build multi-generational wealth outside of wall street and avoid the coming banking meltdown
01:06:04 our beef supply is under attack more than ever the industry for fake industrial produced meat
01:06:13 is underway. As reformed post-mill Christians, the founders of Dominion Ranch seek to honor 0.91
01:06:20 Christ's rule and continue building his kingdom on earth by supplying Christians with high quality
01:06:26 beef for the journey. We believe in excellence and that is why Dominion Ranch works as a collective
01:06:34 with multi-generational ranchers across Texas to bring you the best in great tasting and
01:06:40 nutritious beef. Our motto is that kingdoms were never built on salads alone. Eat beef and subdue
01:06:47 the earth. And one more thing, don't forget to enter the Dominion Ranch Super Summer giveaway
01:06:52 for some delicious Wagyu beef, a mouth-watering addition to your freezer. Click the link in the
01:06:59 description and enter to win. America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing
01:07:04 Christians to do their duty before God and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines
01:07:08 commandments of men. Rees Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
01:07:13 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business as though they're commandments
01:07:18 from God that we're supposed to obey. Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build
01:07:25 them up. We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain
01:07:29 our capacity to do things here.
01:07:32 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, Boldly Deployed.
01:07:38 All right, one more quick shameless plug.
01:07:40 We've got a four and a half, almost five page article this week.
01:07:44 Join us on Patreon.
01:07:46 And there's always going to be an article that corresponds with the Wednesday live stream.
01:07:49 So this week, our very own Wesley Todd, he wrote the article.
01:07:53 And so if you're wanting, you know, some of the quotes that are in here, some of the scripture,
01:07:56 the charts that we showed earlier in the episode are in here. So if you want the article for this
01:08:02 week on actually what we're doing in this article, what Wesley did was provided an actual biblical
01:08:07 definition of racism and then juxtapose that with what racism has devolved into today. And what is
01:08:16 racism today? The source, we made it up. We made it up. What is racism today? It's a made up
01:08:23 pretend sin. That is 99% of it. And so the Bible actually does talk about sinful forms of
01:08:30 prejudgment, and Wes does a good job getting into that and what that actually is. But what you'll
01:08:35 find if you read this article, and we've got it for all of our Patreon members, it's available
01:08:38 for you, and every week there's an article that you'll have. But if you read it, what you'll find
01:08:42 is that literally 99% of what is going to be accused of as racism today is not actually
01:08:52 something that the Bible would condemn as a sin.
01:08:54 So we're not saying it doesn't exist at all,
01:08:57 but we need to do our homework
01:08:59 and we need to be scriptural
01:09:00 and not just submit to the post-war consensus.
01:09:03 So go to patreon.com forward slash
01:09:05 right response ministries,
01:09:06 patreon.com forward slash right response ministries.
01:09:09 You guys are putting some good questions in the chat.
01:09:11 I see that, appreciate it.
01:09:13 Let's go ahead and get to at least one more clip
01:09:15 and then we'll come to the questions.
01:09:17 And it's not biblical, Chad.
01:09:18 I'll give you a great quote from Stephen Wolf,
01:09:20 who made the case for Christian nationalism.
01:09:23 He's like the poster boy
01:09:24 of a lot of the Christian nationalist movement.
01:09:26 And he admits that he doesn't really know theology
01:09:29 in the Bible very well.
01:09:31 In fact, listen to what he says in his book.
01:09:33 I assume the reformed theological tradition
01:09:35 because he's a Calvinist.
01:09:37 And so I make little effort to exegete biblical text.
01:09:41 Some readers will complain that I rarely appeal to scripture
01:09:44 to argue for my positions.
01:09:46 I understand the frustration, but allow me to explain.
01:09:49 I am neither a theologian nor a biblical scholar.
01:09:53 I have no training in moving from scriptural interpretation to theological articulation.
01:09:59 Well, then don't write a book as to how, you know, what, you know,
01:10:01 you think the Christian worldview should be on nations, you know?
01:10:05 Yeah, what are you making an argument for if not from the text of Scripture?
01:10:10 This is from a worldly viewpoint, which is exactly what it is.
01:10:12 Unless you don't believe in Sola Scriptura and you're throwing that out the window.
01:10:15 Yeah, this is the flesh right here.
01:10:19 Wow.
01:10:20 It's just so sad.
01:10:21 It's hard to watch.
01:10:23 Eric, do you want to?
01:10:23 I've got plenty to say, but do you want to address it?
01:10:26 Yeah, I've seen this a lot, actually.
01:10:29 The whole contention that Stephen is making, he's making a distinction on categories.
01:10:33 If I'm doing political theory, then I am not doing exegetical biblical work.
01:10:41 So in his mind, it's categorical, and I think that's a fair distinction.
01:10:44 It's a distinction that's been made throughout even church history and political history, especially.
01:10:50 But I think taking that to say that Stephen doesn't know the Bible is not what Stephen is advocating here, or he's not saying I'm biblically illiterate and I wrote this book.
01:11:02 And so you see the host there unable to follow that distinction and then just saying, well, it's clearly not biblical because he says he doesn't know the Bible.
01:11:11 So if he doesn't know the Bible, he's writing an unbiblical thing about a nation, which I think 0.87
01:11:16 is historically kind of ignorant and a bad argument. Yep. Let me add something with that. 0.96
01:11:27 This is something you guys, everybody listening, you have to get this through your head. You just
01:11:31 need to understand. When Stephen Wolf says, I'm not a theologian, that's because Stephen Wolf
01:11:37 still operates, as very few do, and I'm including myself here, so I'll happily confess because it's
01:11:44 true. Stephen Wolfe is a professional. He is an academic. He is an expert. So when he says,
01:11:52 I'm not a theologian, what he means is that he is not a certified expert. What he means is he
01:12:00 does not have a PhD in theology. For Stephen Wolfe, that's what a theologian is. So when he
01:12:06 says i'm not a theologian it's the way that our fathers within the reform it's the way everyone
01:12:11 thought until very recently so it's um there there are tons of guys you know tom thomas jefferson or
01:12:18 you know or or whatever or you know george washington or or these guys they were said i
01:12:24 am not um i'm not a theologian or i'm not um but they were still brilliant men right or wrong they
01:12:31 were brilliant men um stephen wolf knows theology um a thousand times better than the two men in
01:12:39 that video sadly sadly he is he is uh 10 million times the theologian that those guys are uh the
01:12:47 reason why he won't call himself a theologian is because stephen wolf is an old soul he is of the
01:12:52 sort um that still subscribes to an old way of life when uh when titles meant something when
01:12:59 And the reason why I said, I'll admit, because it doesn't serve me, but I will admit, under 0.76
01:13:06 Christian nationalism, you see on X, under Christian nationalism, this will not happen 0.64
01:13:10 anymore. 0.58
01:13:10 To be completely frank, under Christian nationalism, this is my earnest, I mean this from the bottom
01:13:16 of my heart, my earnest prayer.
01:13:17 My prayer is that within my children or at least my grandchildren's lifetime, that Christian
01:13:23 nationalism truly would be achieved, that we would have a great Christian nation, and
01:13:27 that under that it'd be all of Christ for all of life, that all of our institutions, every single
01:13:32 sphere and realm of life would be drastically improved to such a degree that no one in their
01:13:37 right mind would listen to Joel Webin on YouTube. Do you know why? The reason why I have a YouTube
01:13:44 following, the reason why Kings Hall, not to not pick it on you guys, but like the reason why
01:13:50 is because all of our theologians we have them but they all sold us out they all they all stabbed
01:13:59 us in the back they all turned on us that's the problem and so the reason why we're listening to
01:14:04 unaccredited guys because that's what it is these two guys in the video just for the record
01:14:08 these guys those guys are definitely unaccredited i can tell you that but so you know but the reason
01:14:14 why you're listening to unaccredited people is because the credentialed people, they betrayed
01:14:21 you. That's why. So when Stephen Wolf says, I'm not a theologian, he's not saying, I don't know
01:14:25 theology. He knows theology better than I do, probably better than Eric does, and certainly
01:14:30 better than those two men in that video that we just watched. But when he says, I'm not a theologian,
01:14:35 he means by trade. He means, I do not have a PhD in theology. And he still probably at least knows
01:14:42 that sola scriptura does not mean
01:14:44 scripture is the only source of authority.
01:14:46 It is the highest and only
01:14:48 infallible source. It's so funny
01:14:49 for him to act like, oh, well, sola scriptura,
01:14:52 you have to derive all your arguments from
01:14:54 scripture. No, tradition is an authority,
01:14:56 it's just not over and above. Scripture
01:14:58 is the highest authority, so they do
01:15:00 not even know the definition,
01:15:02 and this one is commonly misconstrued, the definition
01:15:04 of the solas. Scripture alone
01:15:06 has the highest authority, not the only,
01:15:08 but the highest. Sola scriptura is not
01:15:10 saying that scripture is the only authority because scripture itself testifies to other
01:15:13 authorities kings parents and pastors and all these so it's the only infallible authority is
01:15:18 the highest authorities you're absolutely right uh but then the last thing i was going to say is
01:15:22 arguing from the reformed tradition um what stephen wolf is he's saying calvin did the exegesis
01:15:27 he's saying luther has done the exegesis the exegesis has been done and so then i'm taking
01:15:33 the reformed tradition and then i'm arguing for a political a political theory off of that which
01:15:40 well, it's Calvin's theory, from the Reformed tradition.
01:15:43 I'm not going to rewrite every other book to get to this book.
01:15:47 And that's part of the reason, to be honest, that's part of the reason why the church,
01:15:50 evangelicals, are constantly regressing.
01:15:53 And I'll admit, as a Baptist, we are the worst, the absolute worst with this, 1.00
01:15:58 is because we despise tradition.
01:16:00 And we can't ever stand on the shoulders of giants who came before us
01:16:03 and pushed the ball further down the field.
01:16:05 Instead, what we have to do is we have to start from square one,
01:16:09 do all the work ourselves and and what's the final analysis well we do all the work that our
01:16:14 fathers are already done and we do it more poorly than they did oh i can't i can't trust you know
01:16:19 that that calvin was right so i need to go back and i need to do this and i need to do and then
01:16:23 and then what you end up with is like a paper mache equivalent of calvin's institutes and all
01:16:29 these guys you know because you couldn't just you couldn't just that's what wolf is doing he's
01:16:33 saying i'd like to make some progress here so i'm going to stand on the shoulder of giants i'm not
01:16:38 going to write bondage in the will again it's already been written i'm not going to write the
01:16:42 institutes of the christian religion again it's already been written i'm not going to do that
01:16:47 that work has already been done so then from the basis of that work the reformed tradition i'm then
01:16:52 going to argue how would the reformed tradition apply consistently within the political realm
01:16:57 with a polis and that's what he does but unfortunately people read that introduction
01:17:03 from wolf and it's usually baptists i'll admit um and baptists are so today's baptists modern 0.98
01:17:10 baptists are so stupid that like i like i can't even i won't even name them i'll try to be kind 0.98
01:17:15 but like the number of times i've seen it on x where they're like look steve a wolf right here 1.00
01:17:19 he's telling on himself and conceding the point admitting that uh that he he uh doesn't he's not
01:17:24 arguing from the scripture and these are like these are reformed guys too i'm seeing reformed
01:17:29 baptist like oh guys guys that i love that are brothers and i'm like oh no like like you're
01:17:35 telling the entire world that your iq is less than 85 why would you do that brother like i want you
01:17:40 to continue to have a job i want you to be able to preach the word of god and be qualified like 1.00
01:17:43 why are you telling everyone that you're an idiot what like aren't like aren't you embarrassed i 0.99
01:17:48 like i've seriously like there's so many times i'm thumbing through x and i'm looking at my my 1.00
01:17:53 my reformed baptist brothers and reading there and i'm like oh and i physically like like sometimes
01:17:59 my wife will say like like what is it because i'll start turning red i'm so embarrassed i'm like
01:18:04 dying of cringe um so anyways that that just that clip but that was pretty much it like those are
01:18:11 the clips and it's just more like that you can go watch the video from you know good fight ministries
01:18:15 but it's just that's all it is it's just uh the most cliche uh things that steven wolf and we
01:18:21 have addressed again and again and again and again with zero substance um it really is uh
01:18:27 brian so they said this on x the other day um he said he said i finally figured out what steven
01:18:32 wolf is he's an iq test and the promise of god like that's what steven wolf is is he's an iq test
01:18:38 and uh and the results are devastating they're not looking good they're not looking good eric
01:18:44 anything you want to add yeah the other thing i think is interesting going back to calvin you
01:18:48 know, Stephen was doing this in response to a lot of the Aristotle stuff. He said, you know,
01:18:54 Calvin required that his students read Aristotle. It's not that he was favorable to everything
01:18:59 Aristotle said. You can look at early church fathers, lots of people. So I find it kind of
01:19:04 odd that reform, especially reform pastors are like, how could you possibly lean on anything
01:19:09 that Aristotle said? You know, and one of the things I pointed out in one of our podcasts
01:19:13 following that whole incident, that dust up, I said, you know, R.C. Sproul has like a six-part
01:19:19 series on Ligonier on their website on Aristotle. It's quite good. But I don't remember anybody
01:19:25 freaking out when, you know, R.C. Sproul did that. And so I would just point people back to the past.
01:19:32 Yes, sola scriptura means it's the ultimate authority and infallible, as Wes pointed out.
01:19:38 That doesn't mean that we disregard everything else that's happened. Certainly the early church
01:19:42 fathers for the most part you'll find that they were very influenced by plato aristotle they had
01:19:48 read these things later in church history obviously people had read virgil um even the
01:19:53 founding fathers like the most read book among them was plutarch's lives because obviously they
01:19:58 felt that there were important things to be gleaned this would have included people like jonathan
01:20:02 edwards so i would just encourage people uh maybe steer away or be cautious kind of this biblicist
01:20:09 argument of, well, I don't see
01:20:12 the words Christian nation or Christian
01:20:13 prince in any particular
01:20:15 verse, therefore it can't be biblical.
01:20:18 It's just not typically a historical
01:20:19 Christian way of looking at the world. 0.99
01:20:22 Right. Yep. Well said.
01:20:24 Alright, let's take some questions here at the end.
01:20:26 What do we got, Nathan?
01:20:27 You'll have to scroll through.
01:20:32 Maybe start from the top, so the
01:20:33 ones asked first. Yeah, we should start from the top.
01:20:36 Prioritize.
01:20:37 uh are you are you pointing out one with the cursor i can i can tackle the top one quick
01:20:44 the question is from august doesn't this whole discussion boil down to bearing false witness
01:20:49 kind of when you call someone racist you would be bearing false witness against them
01:20:53 and i think that's fair and i would add uh when we take away from god's law that is say something
01:20:59 that is a sin and call it not a sin that would be antinomianism but when we add to it and we
01:21:03 add additional categories when we say, if you do X, you're in sin, you're in transgression of God
01:21:09 and his law and his character, but that's not actually in the scriptures. It's not actually
01:21:13 a violation of God's law. That would be the sin, not the heresy necessarily, but the sin of
01:21:18 legalism. And so, yes, it is a sin to bind the consciences of Christians by calling them a name, 0.66
01:21:24 so bearing false witness, you're being racist, you're committing the sin of racism, when in
01:21:30 fact, all they've done is maybe cited a crime statistic or said, hey, I have some concerns
01:21:34 about immigration levels, this, that, or the other. So I would say at some level, you could
01:21:38 boil it down. I don't know if you would agree. Probably it does boil it down to you cannot bear
01:21:42 false witness against brothers that are not actually sinning against the commands of God.
01:21:48 What do you think, Eric? Does a lot of this boil down to bearing false witness?
01:21:53 I think, I agree. I think there is definitely false witness involved, but I also think you have
01:21:59 to factor in bad faith actors um and and the reason i factor that in is because several of
01:22:06 the people who were most vehemently opposed or vote you know vocal in attacking us um i had
01:22:14 reached out to several of them on twitter on x in dms and i said hey i think a lot of this if we
01:22:20 talked about it we might be able to clear it up and i didn't have a single person respond back
01:22:25 and say yeah i'd be willing to talk to you um it was pretty much you know one said i'm conflicted
01:22:31 i don't know that i can do that and i said well hold on you don't know that you can talk to
01:22:36 another brother in christ to get a better understanding of what his views are you don't
01:22:42 even think that you should do that what would prohibit you from doing that in fact again to
01:22:47 making claims that somebody's a racist i would probably want to be pretty sure i understood their
01:22:52 position before i said that so that's why i say like i i think there's just not a lot of in a lot
01:22:57 of these instances they're trying to destroy you they hate your ideas they don't like you
01:23:03 and they've already decided that and it's not really a fair fight in that way right yeah it's
01:23:08 it's not really that they think that we're racist um it's that they don't they already you know
01:23:14 decided they didn't like us two years ago because of our eschatology or because of what whatever
01:23:19 you know it was you know it was because of um post-millennialism it was because of patriarchy
01:23:24 right like these are the same guys you know um it's because you're not baptist enough you know
01:23:30 or like or whatever it is um you know you're too covenantal you know um so whether it be our
01:23:36 covenant theology or our you know gendered piety or um or uh an eschatology of optimism um they
01:23:46 already decided that we were borderline heretics and so they're just but they know they can't quite
01:23:51 make that argument because we're not so so they're just looking for uh the opportunity and so uh
01:23:56 racist is a good one size fits all you know like when in doubt if you can't beat someone
01:24:02 in a terms of uh you know an argument from from the basis of substance then call them a racist
01:24:08 that's it and and if you can't call them a racist and beat them if you're losing even at that 0.51
01:24:12 than write a rap song calling them racist we saw that apostate kevin young i was gonna say he did
01:24:18 that to jay chase davis he made a joke about monkey pox not at all related anything race
01:24:23 right call the racist nothing was even mentioned about race in this yeah no that that that is not
01:24:28 uh racist uh let's let's get our made-up sins you know categories correct that's uh that's
01:24:34 homophobia aka uh godly righteous indignation towards sodomy so yeah were you gonna say something
01:24:42 Eric? Yeah, I think the other thing is, just on our side, in our camp, one of the things we have
01:24:47 to be aware of is just the historical phenomenon. So if you go back to, say, France, and Jean
01:24:54 Raspell and his book, I'll think of the title here in a minute. Somebody's going to probably
01:25:00 put that in the comments. But Writing Against Immigration, it's a banned book. He was a Roman
01:25:05 Catholic, but Writing Against the Problems, you read that, and you go back and you say, okay,
01:25:10 well what did they say to him and to the other people who said maybe mass influx of islam into
01:25:15 france in the early 20th century is not a good idea immediately you're gonna it's the name calling
01:25:21 right you're a fascist um so i think just being aware of that like we're gonna have to navigate
01:25:27 those waters and realize that you know the the the pithy quote right when the their argument has 0.99
01:25:33 failed they'll call you a racist and a fascist and a nazi and all those things no it's coming
01:25:37 and, you know, more or less, a lot of times
01:25:40 that could mean you're over the target.
01:25:43 Yes. Okay, next
01:25:44 question. Camp of the Saints is the book, I'm sorry.
01:25:46 That's a good one. This was a
01:25:48 good question from Roland Scooter. He
01:25:50 said, question, can a Western Christian nation 0.56
01:25:52 still limit non-Western Christian
01:25:54 immigration? So let's say it's, you 0.99
01:25:56 know, these United States of America,
01:25:58 the person, you know, that wants
01:26:00 to immigrate into the country is
01:26:02 a Christian, so they're devoted 0.99
01:26:04 to Christ, but it's from a 0.85
01:26:06 non-Western nation. So it's a Christian Somalian, you know, or it's a Christian somebody from the 0.92
01:26:12 Sudan or whatever. Um, and so he's asking, you know, if they're Christian, uh, do you have to
01:26:18 let them in basically, or can you still limit and say, yeah, you're a Christian and that's great. 0.92
01:26:23 Um, but, um, you're from a non-Western, uh, uh, nation that's less compatible in terms of its 0.96
01:26:30 culture um with our nation and therefore we're going to take you know we're only going to take 1.00
01:26:37 10 000 christian somalians whereas we're willing to take um 500 000 uh christians from ireland
01:26:45 on an annual basis and my answer i'll let you guys go and i can give some reasons why but
01:26:50 my short answer would be um absolutely yes yep yes you're allowed to do that eric wes
01:26:57 yeah no i would say absolutely you are um certainly there's going to be a number of
01:27:02 factors right if it's like let's say somalia and you have you know 10 000 somalian christians who
01:27:09 are fleeing muslim persecution right that may factor into the decision right that you want to
01:27:14 be hospitable to brothers in christ but the question is can you and and i think the answer
01:27:20 is yes yeah the our the nation is under no moral obligation from god to let everyone who professes
01:27:26 Christ in. Nope. I was going to say too, commodious living, it is at some level, so we share Christ,
01:27:32 but it is a function of sharing other particulars. The family unit, a husband, wife, children,
01:27:37 they share a home, they share a diet, they share holidays, they share a religion, they share all
01:27:42 of those things and those help towards a commodious experience. The family writ large, broader going
01:27:47 to the national level, the more you share, so again, a language, a background, a heritage,
01:27:52 the holidays that you keep, the more that you share of that, the more generally, at an earthly
01:27:57 level, commodious life is going to be. And so telling people, even in earnest good people that
01:28:01 are Christians, I'm sorry, you barely speak this language. You don't know any of our holidays. 0.98
01:28:06 You have no familiarity with even how to drive here. It's just not going to improve life for you.
01:28:11 You're going to be out of place. You're not going to recognize anything. Me, myself, it's going to
01:28:16 be more difficult for us here in this nation. It's not a good deal for either end. And so we want you
01:28:20 to sanctify and work hard in your nation to make it better where you actually know what's going on
01:28:24 there. The Christian nation absolutely can, is not required to, but can, and maybe more often
01:28:29 than not should say, we're sorry, we're here for us. Amen. And that's the beauty of Christian
01:28:35 nationalism is, you know, one of the ways that it gets painted by, you know, the opponents of 0.58
01:28:41 Christian nationalism is that it's, you know, this exclusive white American thing. It's not.
01:28:47 When I say I'm a Christian nationalist, what I'm saying is that I want to see every single one of
01:28:53 the nations become Christian. And because I'm post-millennial, not only do I want to see it,
01:28:57 I believe that it will be done. I may not see it, may not be done in my lifetime,
01:29:01 but all the nations will be Christian. I absolutely believe that. So it's not arguing
01:29:07 for American superiority from here until the end of time, that if Christ tarries for 10,000 years,
01:29:14 that America will always exist and will always be the best nation on the planet. No, no, no. It's
01:29:18 just saying America should be Christian and so should Somalia and so should China and so all 0.80
01:29:22 of them should be Christian. And one way to ensure that the nations become Christian is if Christians 0.92
01:29:31 actually work on their nation. And for anybody who's like, well, that sounds a little bit 0.73
01:29:37 hypocritical, didn't you write fight by flight? I did, but I did not leave Somalia. I left California
01:29:44 to another state in my nation and it's also just for the record i've said it several times but
01:29:50 there's always new listeners who don't know it's the state that i was born and raised in yeah um
01:29:55 i didn't flee my heritage of california to go to foreign texas um no i actually i chose to flee
01:30:03 texas where i was born and raised um that i loved to go to california with a missionary mindset
01:30:09 because people needed jesus and then once i started having kids and grew up a little bit i realized
01:30:14 California is probably not the best place to raise a family. And yes, people here need Jesus,
01:30:19 but so do people in Texas. And Texas is where me, mom, and papa are, and grandma and grandpa.
01:30:24 I literally, both sides of the family, my wife's parents, my parents, in-laws, outlaws. I have 25
01:30:30 extended family members within a 12-mile radius of where I live now. We left all that when we went
01:30:36 to California because we had to go to the mission field. And after being in the mission field for
01:30:40 10 years, and for the record, leaving a healthy church behind that's doing great, I thought that
01:30:46 it was strategic and wise and prudent to come back home. That does not apply to being a native 1.00
01:30:52 born and raised Somalian and then saying, well, because things are hard and I'm a Christian,
01:30:59 I'm allowed to enter into whatever nation I want. 0.91
01:31:02 I'll go a little farther and say it could be a violation of the fifth commandment to have a
01:31:06 family that worked say your farm for five generations things get hard and you just leave
01:31:10 now there are legitimate cases canada the tyranny there but if it's just things are average and like
01:31:15 i'd rather make 60 000 driving uber in austin like no you might be dishonoring your fathers
01:31:19 who worked and tried to make your country better for generations before you right can i see real
01:31:24 quick josh haywood scroll down a little bit uh josh haywood he says let me see oh you know what
01:31:31 This is a good one.
01:31:31 Right before that, Johnny Johnston.
01:31:34 Johnstonton.
01:31:36 Johnstonton?
01:31:37 How would you say that?
01:31:38 Johnston?
01:31:38 Johnsonston?
01:31:39 Johnsonston. 1.00
01:31:40 Just so many Johns in there. 0.90
01:31:42 I love it.
01:31:43 Okay, he says,
01:31:44 Do any of you have an opinion on white Christian American men finding wives in Asia? 0.88
01:31:50 They are Christian, and by nature, really more so by culture, submissive, and want children, I think is what he's saying. 0.78
01:32:00 so they're submissive uh they want children while women here in america prefer cats and wine to 0.98
01:32:06 marriage and family 100 true i get it what do you guys think i have my answer but eric let's go to
01:32:12 you oh man the cats it always gets me taylor swift with her cat around her neck yeah it's
01:32:18 it's wonderful um yeah i still think that the you know most people i think naturally are going to
01:32:23 prefer uh people from their culture um again uh you know i think most people that i know who've
01:32:31 like traveled to foreign countries i know you mentioned china but i think sometimes we get
01:32:35 like this idealistic view that like european trad wives are just going to be so much better than
01:32:41 american women and so i think some of that is is i've known some of the situations where that's
01:32:47 happened and there's a lot of cultural issues that make even a marriage if it can make a culture not
01:32:52 commodious it can also do that in a marriage um so i think that can be you know maybe it's a little
01:32:58 larpy at least from my perspective that that there's so much better um but but even then you
01:33:03 you get into the cultural distinctives uh language barriers and stuff like that i think that would
01:33:09 make it more difficult so i would tend to say no i still think it's look there are good christian
01:33:15 women in america i know this for a fact and that's certainly where i would have my son start 0.99
01:33:21 Yeah.
01:33:21 That's good.
01:33:22 I was going to say, there are churches that exist, that are full of, like Eric said, good 1.00
01:33:27 godly women. 0.99
01:33:28 I would start there within the states where you share a language and share a culture, 0.94
01:33:31 but I don't see anything necessarily in the Bible that would prohibit it.
01:33:34 The Bible says that a man who finds a wife finds a good thing. 0.93
01:33:37 If you really, for some reason, feel like that is the best shot, I think the Bible would 1.00
01:33:42 permit.
01:33:42 Now, it may not necessarily be the best, but I don't think there's sinning in that.
01:33:47 Right.
01:33:47 I would have the same answer.
01:33:48 I think start at home. 1.00
01:33:49 but i understand what you're saying like america is just absolutely drenched in feminism and 0.99
01:33:55 sadly the church is no exception if the church is an exception it's only the exception in in the
01:34:00 sense that feminism will probably die slower it'll actually be worse in the church than in the world
01:34:05 because the world has moved on transgenderism has you know rosario butterfield said this
01:34:10 transgenderism for all intents and purposes has effectively killed feminism outside of the church
01:34:15 but the church, you know, good old church, always 10 years behind. Feminism is still alive and well. 0.92
01:34:20 There's really only one context in America where feminism still thrives at its peak, and that's 0.98
01:34:25 the evangelical church, sadly. So, I hear you, but Wes and Eric are also right, and I know pastorally,
01:34:33 you know, Eric knows pastorally, there are godly American Christian women who would love to be
01:34:38 wives and mothers. We know this because we pastor them, and so please do not pass over them,
01:34:44 to just get a Filipino wife or whatever. But all that being said, I agree with Wes. I know Eric
01:34:51 agrees as well. Because this is the big question. This would be another, you know, gotcha, we're
01:34:55 going to get you. He's about to hang himself. All right. Nope. You're not going to see me hang 0.99
01:35:01 myself because I'm perfectly fine with inter-ethnic marriage. Inter-ethnic marriage is
01:35:07 absolutely biblically permissible. And there are some groups, which I won't name. I don't think
01:35:12 it's helpful but there are some groups who have uh who have said so far as as actually saying 0.97
01:35:20 that the children of inter-ethnic marriages are um excrement and i don't like it i think that 0.59
01:35:29 that's sinful so um if you don't like that uh that's fine but that's not new chrysidim and 0.95
01:35:37 that is not right response that is not our position so you can use that and say i found 0.96
01:35:42 a smoking gun and you can take that smoking gun and you can shoot that ministry but not ours
01:35:48 because that is not our position we think that that statement the children of inter-ethnic 0.99
01:35:54 marriages are excrement we think that that statement is sinful uh we i think that that's 0.89
01:35:59 an excrement statement i think it's a terrible thing to say and i think it's also most importantly 0.87
01:36:04 it is objectively and biblically untrue so um if you want to marry a wife from an asian country 0.84
01:36:10 I believe it's permissible. 1.00
01:36:12 However, I do think that you should start at home.
01:36:15 I think you have an obligation,
01:36:16 especially to your sisters in Christ here,
01:36:19 who are often passed over by men who,
01:36:23 I don't know, who just...
01:36:25 They're 35 looking for a 22-year-old.
01:36:28 Exactly.
01:36:29 They've postponed marriage
01:36:30 and they have a prolonged adolescence
01:36:32 and those kinds of things. 0.99
01:36:33 So wife the woman at home first, if you can.
01:36:38 but yes of course it's permissible okay another question uh oh yeah okay so josh haywood coming
01:36:44 back to him uh given that we have broken all three of aristotle's rules for a successful
01:36:48 political structure uh what see what what do you see as what do you see as our option to see a
01:36:56 flourishing society form again then the second like you know you know my answer uh what do you
01:37:01 see as uh our options to see a flourishing society okay um yeah i don't think i don't think we're
01:37:08 going to be able to constitution even harder i do not believe we are going to our sacred democracy
01:37:13 our way out of this one um i'll get i'll give my answer it's going to be a caesar it's going to be
01:37:20 a monarchy i'm just i'm saying it i'll come back and explain that if you guys want more explanation
01:37:24 but i'm going to turn it to eric and like what do you think i don't think we're voting our way out
01:37:28 of this i just don't what do you think yeah i don't think so i i think an interesting case study
01:37:34 you know one of the things i like to do is go back in history and say like how how have people
01:37:38 tended to right the ship um and i think there's a number of ways to answer that question i think
01:37:43 one of the things we have to realize and it's it's hard as americans to realize this but somebody
01:37:48 like franco in spain recognized this in his day that perhaps a lot of the ideals that they had
01:37:54 imbibed in in what is our conception of democracy today um is really from the french revolution
01:38:01 right and and so a lot of it was like well we need to obviously they're going to have one solution
01:38:07 for taking back their country um but i think you have to at least look at it because it was
01:38:11 successful um and and they really did restore it largely for a time to christianity um and
01:38:18 and putting down communism and stuff like that i think what franco also realized was democracy was
01:38:25 kind of the perfect host for leftism right and the reason it was like it was it was the republican
01:38:31 party in spain were the commies right and so they were the ones that were like well let's turn it
01:38:36 over the people they used extreme violence to incite uh you know political unrest and stuff
01:38:41 like that in the country it functionally took one strong leader to right the ship now again that's
01:38:47 not going to be the case in every country and i understand in america you know you're going to
01:38:51 have your challenges it might be that you have a sort of aristocratic elite who write the ship
01:38:59 maybe it's a combination of people um i know i've seen people you know positive maybe it's it's it's
01:39:05 a combination of an elon musk type guy with a trump type guy and a lot of other players behind
01:39:09 the scenes you got to work within the system you have um so i certainly think that's true
01:39:15 um everybody i've talked to on this issue right we talk about a christian prince we talk about
01:39:20 a lot of times when those christian princes in history came on the scene it was somewhat
01:39:24 unexpected um even before the civil war in spain nobody was like oh we're gonna we're gonna use
01:39:31 functionally a dictator to write this ship and then they go through a civil war franco emerges
01:39:37 and everybody's like yeah he's the guy um and that's just kind of what happened so i think
01:39:43 some of it's a bit of wait and see um and i don't know that i but i do agree with you joel
01:39:48 i think that if you think that liberal democracy is going to solve this problem
01:39:53 i think that you're i think that's incorrect and historically that has not been true
01:39:58 yeah i was gonna say um i think of gandalf where he says things are in motion now that cannot be
01:40:04 undone i don't think there are options as in like well the heritage project does this right we can
01:40:09 kind of steer well you notice i think of uh russia and the bolshevik revolution it fractured
01:40:13 fractured fractured the czar stepped down early in the 1910s and up to 1917 they had this provisional
01:40:20 government that was barely held together and it was lenin and the bolsheviks that eventually seized
01:40:24 power navigated through it took over commandeered the red army crushed opposition so same thing
01:40:29 happened in 1930s germany there's like six different political parties and then hitler
01:40:33 became chancellor what's going to happen i think is things are going to devolve devolve devolve
01:40:37 fracture fracture fracture and someone's going to come out of that and there's not going to be some
01:40:41 group able to kind of navigate and steer the ship uh we'll see who comes out of that mess one way or
01:40:46 another but i don't know that there's a way to take we were talking about earlier the angry young
01:40:51 men they've been disenfranchised they can't afford a home uh the women that are their options to 0.88
01:40:56 marry are ssri zombies um they have their jobs have been taken away these young men aren't going 1.00
01:41:02 away um something's going to happen with them right we want it to be christian that's the goal 0.64
01:41:08 of everything that we're doing right here christian men grounded in the christian faith
01:41:11 to actually do it right but something's going to happen one way or another we would hope to have an
01:41:15 influence in that we would hope that it would go in a godly manner uh but there might not be
01:41:19 controlling it history may have put in motion uh the things that will lead to whatever comes next
01:41:24 one way or another right the other thing i would say joel real quick i know your answer is going
01:41:30 to be amazing no no no no the one thing i would say to wes's point usually historically what this
01:41:37 always comes down to is who has the political will to act yeah this is something that christians do
01:41:42 not currently in mass have the stomach for which is you've got to be willing to exert political
01:41:47 power to achieve your ends and it can make people uncomfortable but look you read the history of
01:41:54 old testament israel it's you're going to find the exact same thing it's going to be the guy or
01:41:59 a group it could be a few guys but functionally as you know west said you've got to have people
01:42:06 with the political will to act and the stomach for it to push their agenda and as you said
01:42:13 hopefully a christian one that's good yeah i was just going to say both historically and then
01:42:20 in terms of biblical history you know so with israel in the old testament um most of the time
01:42:26 i've said this multiple times at this point but most of the time it's um it's top down revival
01:42:33 and not bottom up i'm not saying that god can't do that god does what he wills and um and if god
01:42:41 wants a bottom-up revival um it won't it won't be because we stood in this way um by god's grace
01:42:47 we're going to do everything we can as Christians and as ministers to preach the gospel, to do the
01:42:52 work of an evangelist, to disciple our children, to wash our wives in the word, all these different
01:42:57 things. So if God wants to change the nation by just converting 50 plus 1% of all the individuals
01:43:04 and giving them new hearts and discipling them and how to apply all of Christ to all of life in such
01:43:09 a way that it filters down into our elections and our politics, great. That's what I'm describing
01:43:13 when I say a bottom-up revival.
01:43:15 If God wants to do bottom-up revival, awesome.
01:43:19 Yeah.
01:43:19 That'd be a lot more painless.
01:43:22 It'd be the easier way, less riding in the streets and those kinds.
01:43:26 So that'd be great.
01:43:27 And if that doesn't happen, it won't be because we didn't want to
01:43:31 and that we weren't working for it.
01:43:33 Yeah.
01:43:33 Because, yeah, I'm doing podcasts, but I'm a local pastor.
01:43:38 I'm preaching the gospel.
01:43:39 We're seeing people come to faith in Jesus. Baptisms are happening all the time with real
01:43:45 converts, people coming to Christ. So yeah, that'd be great. But historically speaking and biblically
01:43:51 speaking, it's usually not bottom up. It's usually top down. What I mean by that is it's not that
01:43:57 preachers go out throughout the people of Israel, preach the gospel, individuals in Israel get
01:44:04 saved, and once over half of them get saved, 50% plus one, they then elect a better king who then
01:44:11 enacts better laws. That's not the way it goes. It's usually the people are degenerate, they hate
01:44:17 God, and they're faithless, right? Because we're talking about Israel, right? Very few times in 1.00
01:44:22 Israel's history are they faithful. Most of the time, they're faithless. But God in his mercy 0.99
01:44:28 causes a succession of three wicked kings in a row to finally end, and Josiah takes the throne.
01:44:37 And then Josiah says to the people, I was not duly elected, and you do not want righteousness 0.64
01:44:43 in the land because you're degenerate. But guess what? I don't care. You will have righteousness 0.79
01:44:48 whether you like it or not. If your hearts are unchanged, who cares? But outwardly,
01:44:54 you are going to behave like people who fear Yahweh. And all the high places built to idols
01:45:00 and the 90-foot statue to some demon Hindu god in Houston, Texas right now, it's all going to
01:45:06 be melted down. In some cases, Moses said, hey, we're going to burn down that idol and you're
01:45:10 going to drink it, right? That is how God did revival in the Old Testament. It was not bottom
01:45:15 up. It wasn't. It was top down. It's wicked people with wicked rulers, but then one righteous guy
01:45:21 in the providence of God. He arises to the top, he becomes king, and he begins to enact righteous
01:45:27 laws before the people have righteous hearts. But the righteous laws, in the pedagogical function
01:45:33 of the law, it functions as a tutor, begins to shape the hearts of the people, and that righteous
01:45:38 law and righteous culture outwardly actually provides the most conducive backdrop for true
01:45:45 gospel preaching to hit the ears of people who are actually aware that they're sinners in need
01:45:50 of the gospel and people actually get converted. This is what God does. He's done it again and
01:45:55 again and again. He did it all throughout the Old Testament. He's done it all throughout church
01:45:59 history. He didn't just stop with Israel for the last 2,000 years in multiple different nations.
01:46:03 He's done the same. And to think that he won't do it in America because God will stop his pattern,
01:46:08 his MO, because he respects our democracy and classical liberalism too much to make us
01:46:14 uncomfortable is, I think, arrogant. So, I'm not the extremist here. It sounds extreme because
01:46:20 you're sold out to the post-war consensus, but what I'm saying is I'm saying what God has always
01:46:24 done, statistically, in terms of likelihoods, it is far more likelihood that God would keep doing
01:46:30 the thing he always has than God doing a new thing that he never has or virtually never has.
01:46:36 And you might say, well, but that's not our founding. Listen, our founding as a constitutional,
01:46:41 number one it wasn't democracy it was a constitutional republic and we don't have it
01:46:44 anymore i'd love if we did but we don't i like constitutional republics wish we had one but we
01:46:50 don't but here's the deal we did not start in a vacuum out of thin air ex nihilo with this
01:46:56 christian constitutional republic you know where that came from it was the product descended from
01:47:00 generations and centuries from another place namely great britain with another government
01:47:05 namely monarchy 1200 years 1200 years of a christian monarchy is what produced
01:47:13 a christian constitutional republic you know what has never produced
01:47:17 a christian constitutional republic ever classical liberalism
01:47:21 that one hasn't classical liberalism is the fruit of christian
01:47:28 classical liberalism has only produced secularism yeah so all right let's let's do maybe
01:47:35 you one more question let's uh scroll down uh one thing that i gotta say we're coming up on the uh
01:47:39 the end of our early bird pricing so this is august 31st 11 59 p.m central time it's over
01:47:46 and the price will go up and it's going up a decent bit but until that point you've got about
01:47:51 a week and a half left 140 bucks for an adult 140 it's one of the lowest prices we've ever offered
01:47:57 for the most value we've ever offered we have like 15 speakers three days eight main sessions
01:48:02 four hour and a half long panels you need to sign up so uh come check out the conference and and
01:48:08 we're trying to get the best of both worlds here we've got steven wolf we've got um we've got
01:48:14 orn mcintyre who is great on like elite theory and you know just wrote the total state you've
01:48:18 got steven wolf you know who's going to come from the classical two kingdom perspective and the
01:48:22 protestant magisterial you know reform perspective the the case for christian nationalism but that's
01:48:27 not the only thing we're doing we also have jeff durbin who is a theonomist we've got david reese
01:48:30 who is a theonomist we've got uh who else we've got dusty deavers you know and so we've got
01:48:35 multiple different perspectives uh we've even got steve days yep steve days who is uh i believe he's
01:48:40 a baptist evangelical right southern baptist yep or something close to it uh but here's the common
01:48:46 denominator with all these guys um they're all fighters none of them are going to just roll over
01:48:51 and say oh well we lose down here all these guys are fighters and uh and some of the differences
01:48:56 between Aristotle versus Aquinas versus Van Til
01:49:01 and all these kinds of things,
01:49:02 or post-mill versus dispensational pre-mill,
01:49:05 which you guys know if you listen to the show.
01:49:07 I'm not a fan.
01:49:09 I do not like dispensationalism.
01:49:12 But Steve Dace is a brother in the Lord, and he fights.
01:49:14 He fights more than, honestly, some of our post-mill brothers.
01:49:19 They say, hashtag that post-mill, we win down here.
01:49:23 But they think we win 50,000 years from now.
01:49:26 and Steve Dace thinks we'll probably eventually lose,
01:49:30 but Steve Dace is saying,
01:49:31 yeah, and we'll lose over my dead body.
01:49:33 I'd rather have that guy.
01:49:34 I'd rather have the guy who's convinced we're going to lose,
01:49:36 like Theo did.
01:49:37 One last time, we'll ride out.
01:49:39 He thought we were going to lose.
01:49:40 We're going to ride to our deaths,
01:49:41 but he's going to fight at least.
01:49:42 I'd rather have that guy
01:49:43 than the guy who's just going to hide out
01:49:45 and say, hey, our great-great-great-great-grandchildren,
01:49:48 they'll win.
01:49:48 So anyways, $140.
01:49:50 It's a good price.
01:49:51 Go to rightresponseconference.com.
01:49:54 Rightresponseconference.com.
01:49:55 sign up for our conference today okay one more question what do we got is that the last one
01:50:02 nathan or are there more can you scroll last one okay here we go this is euclid he says every
01:50:06 democrat in federal office other than a handful of jews and muslims uh claims i'd say a little
01:50:12 bit more than a handful there but uh a handful of jews and muslims claims to be christian
01:50:16 could it be uh that the fight in america isn't against secularists but apostate christians
01:50:23 Eric, what do you think?
01:50:25 Ooh, that's a good question.
01:50:27 It is.
01:50:28 Maybe I take the middle road here.
01:50:31 I do a little, it's called we do a little Tim Keller.
01:50:33 We take the middle way.
01:50:36 But I think it's probably, that's hard to pinpoint.
01:50:39 I would say it's probably a lot of both.
01:50:41 There's certainly a lot of apostasy that has spread across the country.
01:50:46 And at the same point, it's like you've also brought so many people in from other countries 0.95
01:50:51 through illegal forced immigration, they're certainly pagan and were never Christians. 0.87
01:51:00 So I would actually, I'd say you'd have to look probably at the demographics in that. 0.84
01:51:06 You can look at certainly past generations and say apostate for sure.
01:51:09 I don't know about today. 1.00
01:51:12 Good point.
01:51:13 Wes, any thoughts?
01:51:15 I was thinking about the comment because I saw it and I was kind of considering.
01:51:18 I think one thing that's cool that's happening is as we talk, as Christians used to talk,
01:51:22 there's almost been a narrowing and a winnowing that people are like, 0.53
01:51:25 this is why I could never call myself a Christian.
01:51:27 This is why I don't like Christianity.
01:51:29 So hopefully as a rooted and grounded muscular Christianity continues to, I would hope, 0.61
01:51:34 dominate the public square, there will be people that self-select themselves out and say,
01:51:38 I could never touch that name.
01:51:39 I could never be associated with it.
01:51:41 I think that would be really helpful to get people where, because we're in a negative world.
01:51:45 it's not a positive thing to bear the name of christ to have your membership at your local
01:51:49 episcopalian church kind of as a badge when you go to run for public office so in negative world
01:51:54 where it doesn't carry that positive connotation and the christianity that people know and think
01:52:00 of is christianity like ours that gets labeled with all sorts of things hopefully um they'll
01:52:05 do that themselves and they'll say yeah i'm much much closer to a secularist i'm agnostic
01:52:10 and christianity is just not for me right that is a real dynamic like how do you deal with people
01:52:14 that say oh i'm a christian i love jesus and then go on and legislate the murder of children
01:52:19 right yeah it's tough because i think it's both positive and negative um it is a positive thing
01:52:24 and this is something that i think some of us who are like you know like we actually are real
01:52:28 christians uh we're not feminist we're not you know like we actually believe what the bible says
01:52:33 um i think we miss this but i think it matters and it's true um it is a good thing that we have
01:52:38 never had a president of the country um who didn't at least uh profess to be a christian
01:52:43 that's actually a positive thing so like and and this came up a lot in some of the you know
01:52:47 the old gc um you don't all the group chats that you know that with different pastors and guys you
01:52:52 know arguing back and forth when um during the primaries gop primaries uh with vivek ramaswami
01:52:58 and uh you know it was like you know some guys about half of them were saying like we like him
01:53:04 because he seems conservative and he's you know he can speak well he's got good rhetoric
01:53:08 he's really conservative he knows what time it is he's on it and then the other half and i was
01:53:13 part of the other half was saying yeah i like him and maybe you make him uh press secretary
01:53:19 you know or something like that you know like maybe there's a place for him um in in the you
01:53:24 know gop administration lord willing if if um if republicans win um but not president and uh the
01:53:32 reason why is because uh yeah he's conservative um but he's a hindu and once you open that box
01:53:39 here's the deal so it's like yeah but you know joe biden claims to be a christian and and he hates
01:53:44 god yes yes indeed 100 nancy pelosi claims to be a catholic she hates god uh-huh yes indeed um but
01:53:51 once you get once you break the mold for your conservative hindu who actually embodies in many
01:53:57 ways more christian virtues than the professing christian joe biden or nancy pelosi or you know 0.98
01:54:04 go down the list um vivek might be good for four years but then you inevitably will get the muslim 0.96
01:54:12 who um who is not conservative uh in any christian sense um but actually hates the triune god and 1.00
01:54:21 hates the west and hates christian values even more than the secularist and um it is a good thing
01:54:29 that that box has not been opened yet is my point the solution the solution is for the nation to
01:54:34 turn back to christ and that when somebody professes the name of christ it would mean
01:54:37 something the solution is not to say because so many profess christ's name and don't mean anything
01:54:42 by it then we shouldn't uh we should not um say that that the mere profession has any value
01:54:47 no the profession does have the solution is not to say because so many people say they they're
01:54:52 christians and they don't mean it uh saying you're a christian uh uh is uh not valuable
01:54:57 no it is valuable pretense is valuable like when yeah like when king charles you know and people
01:55:03 again the reformed baptists it's it's so embarrassing it's like it's really embarrassing
01:55:09 it is it is hard yeah you don't have you're a hard man over there you want to be a hard man
01:55:14 try being publicly known as a reformed baptist that is like that takes more courage and more
01:55:21 grit than almost anything it's it is embarrassing but like what during the um the um what what was
01:55:27 it uh the what do you call the coronation of uh king charles and you know you have the reformed
01:55:33 baptist coming out and saying like look at this you know and it's terrible and like they're
01:55:37 blaspheming and it's like yeah uh-huh yeah because they don't mean it they are blaspheming in their
01:55:41 hearts. But this is good. The pomp and circumstance matters. The pretense matters.
01:55:49 You don't want to lose this. Even if it's just on the books, if it's just pretend,
01:55:55 if it's all those things, it's not great. No, of course it's a problem. But the solution,
01:56:03 even what Jesus said to the Pharisees, Jesus doesn't say with the Pharisees, hey, you should
01:56:08 stop doing these outward things and do the inward things instead. No, he says, you should continue
01:56:13 the latter, but also the former. When he said, you tithe down to a tenth of your mill and dent
01:56:19 and spice, he doesn't say, you should stop doing all that outward pretense and adherence to the
01:56:25 law of God, and really, you should just love me privately in your heart. No, he says, keep doing
01:56:31 that, but do the thing that matters most. The heart does matter more, but we can't say that
01:56:36 the heart matters in such a way that the outward pretense doesn't matter at all. 0.62
01:56:40 I hope that England becomes truly a Christian nation. 1.00
01:56:43 In the meantime, though, I hope at least it continues to maintain a veneer, outward veneer 0.98
01:56:50 of Christianity, and I hope these United States do as well. 0.91
01:56:53 The fact that we have never had a non-Christian president, have we had a non-regenerate president?
01:57:00 Tom. 1.00
01:57:01 Tom, too many.
01:57:02 Right, Abraham Lincoln, right?
01:57:03 You can go way back. 0.81
01:57:04 So we've had plenty of those presidents who weren't Christians in the true, eternal sense. 0.65
01:57:10 But the fact that they all had to tip the hat to Christianity, that's power.
01:57:14 That's the very power that Eric's talking about, that evangelicals, we have to begin
01:57:18 to develop the stomach to be able to wield that power.
01:57:21 That's what cultural power is.
01:57:23 That's what religious power is, where a guy who hates the unborn children and wants to
01:57:28 murder them by the millions, he knows, yeah, but I at least still have to pay some credence
01:57:32 to the name of Jesus Christ. 0.52
01:57:34 that's a good thing that is actually a good thing and uh and we don't want to lose it we don't want
01:57:40 to lose that so uh let's do the former without neglecting the latter let's get the heart
01:57:43 without uh without losing the veneer uh we need both any final thoughts from you guys we'll we'll
01:57:49 go ahead and end the show no eric yeah yeah just one thing i i think there's also sort of a mistaken
01:57:55 notion among christians that like you have to have a super majority in order to act and it's not the
01:58:03 case obviously you can look back at the founding you can say look mayflower compact you know it's
01:58:08 a nation that really is covenantal to the lord but just to encourage christians i think that you
01:58:13 actually can do a lot even as in a negative world even if you're not the super majority
01:58:19 and there's some debate probably demographically if we are not but it's certainly shrinking but i
01:58:26 think what it is is look the homosexuals and the lgbt community they've been a for a long time a
01:58:33 very vocal minority and were able to force their will and so i think for christians um even if 0.98
01:58:40 you're small you sort of act like you're not like in the best possible sense you you have the
01:58:46 knowledge that god is backing you and you demand these things um even in a country like france
01:58:52 like the abomination that was the olympics right and everything that was going on there there were
01:58:57 still christians in that country that said absolutely not and they had to come out at least
01:59:01 and apologize right so at the very least use whatever power you have and do not give ground
01:59:08 on that do not give up what you do have yeah it's good it's great okay um that's it so let's go ahead
01:59:16 and uh sign off again go to right response conference.com if you want to get the early
01:59:20 bird registration because that is ending very soon it's just a matter of days at this point
01:59:25 and the price is going to go up somewhat substantially.
01:59:29 So go to rightresponseconference.com.
01:59:31 Also go to patreon.com forward slash rightresponseministries.
01:59:34 If you want to sign up and become a Patreon member
01:59:36 so that you can get the articles every week,
01:59:38 and also you get early access and ad-free content
01:59:40 with our Friday special and all those kinds of things.
01:59:42 So there's a lot of perks,
01:59:43 but the one that's relevant for today
01:59:45 is that you will get this article
01:59:47 that reveals the psyop of racism.
01:59:52 racism and so if you want to debunk the the boogeyman of racism from the word of god
01:59:57 west wrote a great article and you can go to again patreon.com forward slash right response
02:00:02 ministries and become a member there eric thanks so much for coming on the show we really appreciate
02:00:06 it absolutely thank you guys all right thanks for tuning in guys and we will see you again
02:00:12 on friday with another episode of the friday special that we've got going with cultish right now
02:00:22 Thank you.