The NXR Podcast - February 21, 2024


THE LIVESTREAM - Eastern Orthodoxy - The One True Church?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW - How One Household Can Rival A King with David Reece THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Gentlemen, I Regret To Inform You… Boomers

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 21 minutes

Words per minute

193.24

Word count

15,774

Sentence count

517

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

20

sentences flagged

Hate speech

38

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we discuss Eastern Orthodoxy and the Eastern Orthodox Church. What does it mean to be an Eastern Orthodox Christian? How does it differ from the rest of the Christian faith and what does it have in common with it?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 for the better part of 2000 years the question of who gets to interpret scripture has been the key
00:00:08 challenge to the church the answer to questions of faith doctrine and praxis often depend on the
00:00:15 interpretation and application of a particular text or passage of scripture and have historically
00:00:21 resulted in fierce disagreement in the face of this uncertainty a variety of new institutions
00:00:28 and movements often cults have sprung up in the last several hundred years claiming divine
00:00:34 authority to interpret the scripture either by virtue of a supposedly restored apostolic
00:00:41 succession or by some form of continuity within early the early church the mormon church claims
00:00:49 their quorum of the 12 apostles is the restored priesthood of christ on earth jehovah's witnesses
00:00:56 assert that first century biblical christianity was restored through the new world translation
00:01:03 of the bible and the watchtower and track society in philadelphia and in recent years in the west
00:01:11 an old authority is seen renewed interest and conversions the eastern orthodox church which
00:01:18 claims to be the one true church and to alone possess the authority to interpret scripture
00:01:24 but does their claim of direct continuity with apostolic and early church practice
00:01:31 hold up to scrutiny? Tune in now as we discuss.
00:01:43 All right, so this is what we're doing today. Before we get started, we're going to be talking
00:01:47 about Eastern Orthodox Church, the Eastern Orthodox Church, and Wes is going to be leading
00:01:52 us in this discussion. He's done a lot of research, but a couple of things that you need to be aware
00:01:56 of. If you are just kind of tuning into right response, this YouTube page, our ministry, and
00:02:01 you don't really know how things go. Well, this is how it goes. Uh, if you want the article every
00:02:06 single Wednesday, we live stream at 4 PM central time, a variety of topics. Uh, this will be at
00:02:11 least one week. It may end up being a multiple part series that we do, uh, in sequence, uh,
00:02:17 consecutively, or it may be something that we break up. We do EO Eastern Orthodoxy, and then
00:02:21 we do something else for a couple weeks and we come back to it. But it's a big conversation. And
00:02:26 so we're likely going to do more than one week. And this is one of the conversations that I would
00:02:30 say listening to the podcast is going to be incredibly helpful. But being able visually to
00:02:35 see the graphs, the statistics, the quotes, seeing these things in front of you in written form will
00:02:42 be vital for properly understanding Eastern Orthodox theology as well. So you can do that
00:02:49 by joining us on Patreon. All of our Patreon members get access to every single article,
00:02:55 every weekly article that is written preemptively to aid our discussion in our Wednesday live
00:03:01 stream. So every other week, Michael will write an article. That'll be the topic and the focus
00:03:07 for our conversation that Wednesday, our live stream. And it's not just in bullet point form,
00:03:13 but Michael and Wes are alternating each week writing a 750 to 1500 word article that's
00:03:21 thorough with citations and quotes and those kinds of things. So if you want all of this
00:03:26 and more in written form so that you can really retain the information and comprehend it well,
00:03:31 then join us on Patreon. All you got to do is go to patreon.com forward slash
00:03:36 right response ministries again that's patreon.com forward slash right response ministries and you'll
00:03:43 be able to get the article every single week that accompanies our wednesday live stream
00:03:47 conversation beyond that we also have a show that airs every monday at 4 p.m central and every friday
00:03:53 at 4 p.m central monday i'm piping in remotely notable guests from all over the world like-minded
00:04:00 christian thinkers and then on friday we're actually flying a couple guests in person into
00:04:05 the studio to do a multiple-part series. Right now, we've got Andrew Isker and Eddie Robles
00:04:10 covering Andrew's recent book, The Boniface Option, a nine-part series. That's what's
00:04:15 happening right now with Q1 of 2024 with our Friday special, 4 p.m. Central Time on Fridays.
00:04:22 And then next quarter, we're jumping into a 10-part series with the co-host of Haunted Cosmos. That's
00:04:28 Brian Sauve and Ben Garrett. We have already finished. We just recently finished the recording
00:04:34 for that. And now Nathan, who is our tech director, he's working with a Friday special.
00:04:39 We try to achieve our highest level of quality of production. And so he's working on cold opens
00:04:44 and B-roll footage and music and all these things to make it just a well-crafted piece,
00:04:51 multiple pieces of content. So that's kind of the layout. It's Monday, it's Wednesday and Friday.
00:04:57 Wednesday is a live stream with Michael and Wes, and there's an accompanying article that you can
00:05:02 get by joining us on patreon also by joining us on patreon last couple things is uh if you join us
00:05:07 at the gold member level which is just ten dollars a month uh what you'll be able to do is live stream
00:05:13 our upcoming conference so we have our new conference uh for 2024 uh it's happening march
00:05:18 1st 2nd and 3rd that's a friday through sunday so it's in less than two weeks coming up right
00:05:24 around the corner with doug wilson with brian sauve with ben garrett with eric khan uh with
00:05:29 Dusty Deavers is going to be a surprise appearance that I'm ruining the surprise. But I just talked
00:05:35 to him last week. I was just thinking last minute, man, we got to get Dusty here. He's doing great
00:05:39 work for the kingdom of God. And right wing watch is constantly clipping him out and putting it on
00:05:45 social media, saying we're very troubled, very concerned, which makes me think it's like the
00:05:50 Spider-Man meme. It's like, I already like Dusty Deavers. You don't have to sell me on it. So
00:05:55 anyway, so Dusty Devers is going to come. And so we're excited about that. I'm going to be
00:06:00 surrendering some of my speaking time to Dusty just to last minute, work him into the conference
00:06:04 because we were already full. But if you want to go to the conference in person, it's not too late.
00:06:08 We've got about at this point, 40 or 50 seats that are left open until we hit the fire code
00:06:13 and we're maxed out. All you have to do is go to right response conference.com, right response
00:06:18 conference.com. It's late registration. It's full price, but here's a little secret to help you out.
00:06:24 if you put haunted cosmos in the promo code, cause we're doing a live haunted cosmos show
00:06:29 at the comp. Oh, you're right. It's just haunted. So if you just put haunted, it could be all
00:06:33 lowercase or all caps. I think you can do it, slice it any way you want, but just put the word
00:06:38 haunted H a U N T E D in the promo code and you can get 20% off. So you'll see, man, this is kind
00:06:45 of pricey. Well, that's cause it's a week and a half away. It's a late registration. It was not
00:06:49 always that price, but you could still get 20% off if you use that promo code haunted. So go to
00:06:54 right response conference.com if you want to come in person. And then lastly, back to the Patreon
00:06:58 at the gold member level for just $10 a month, you can live stream the whole conference. It'll
00:07:04 all become public content eventually, but it will take a while for Nathan on the backend to be able
00:07:11 to upload every single session. And we have two live panels. And so we're, we're probably looking
00:07:17 at different pieces of content slow dripping out one piece of content per week over the course of
00:07:22 the next two to three months so there's some pieces of content there will be certain lectures
00:07:27 from doug wilson or a panel with the haunted cosmos guys or whatever something from dusty
00:07:31 deavers that may not come out for 10 weeks you know it we may be all the way into you know the
00:07:37 month of june by the time uh we get out the last bit of the conference but if you want to be able
00:07:41 to have immediate access to it, to watch it live, or at least have it on file to when you can watch
00:07:47 it, you know, whenever at your convenience, all you have to do is join us. Again, it's patreon.com
00:07:53 forward slash right response ministries. Join us at the gold member level. And, you know, another
00:08:00 little secret. If you don't want to support us every single month, that's fine. No hard feelings.
00:08:05 Then just sign up for a month, get the content, watch it, and just make sure that you apply it
00:08:10 and you seek to live faithfully for the glory of God, and then cancel your membership, and no harm,
00:08:15 no foul. So those are the things, and without further ado, Wes, kick us off. All right. So let's
00:08:21 start with a general overview of Christianity, kind of as it exists today in 2024. So Christianity
00:08:27 is the highest proportion of all religions in the world, about 30%, so 2.3, 2.6 billion out of about
00:08:34 8 million individuals that live on the earth. So about 30% of that 2.3, 2.6 billion number,
00:08:42 1.3 billion are Roman Catholics. So Roman Catholicism, just by way of kind of a high
00:08:47 level overview, they're distinct in that they would say the Bishop of Rome, the first among
00:08:51 equals, is the vicar of Christ on earth. And so they are the one true church, they possess the
00:08:56 authority, they possess continuity with the apostles, and the Pope is the current reigning
00:09:01 figure representative of christ on earth that's about 1.3 billion and they have an advantage a
00:09:07 distinct financial advantage because of the compounding interest uh working off of centuries
00:09:13 of all the indulgence money they've got i mean it's hard to line right in right it's hard to
00:09:18 compete with the guys that told everybody they could get their loved ones out of purgatory
00:09:21 for the small price every time a coin of the coffer clings sold from purgatory springs you
00:09:26 get that kind of cash you get purgatory cash working for you with compounding interest
00:09:30 goodness gracious well they also baptize infants and so you would have i would bet a lot of that
00:09:35 1.3 billion number that's true maybe baptizes infants potentially confirmed at 16 first communion
00:09:40 but have never darkened the doors of the roman catholic church since true and it's not like
00:09:44 any other church doesn't have this problem either right but probably a big portion of that is
00:09:47 nominal so that's the biggest proportion they are the biggest three billion um i don't know that i
00:09:51 would call them maybe these individual different churches but different traditions with under the
00:09:55 christian banner yeah it's roman catholicism second biggest is protestantism about 800 million
00:10:00 to one billion. Protestantism is different in that there's not one single ecclesiastical body
00:10:05 unnecessarily located in one area. There's a couple of different denominations. For the record,
00:10:09 there are not 9,000 Protestant churches. This is used all the time. Like, oh, how can we know
00:10:14 what the one true church is? There's all these different traditions. We've got to go back to
00:10:17 Catholicism or Orthodoxy. There are not 9,000 different churches or denominations or institutions.
00:10:22 There's about six different traditions, and there's some minor differences within them. So
00:10:25 So there's Southern Baptists and Reformed Baptists.
00:10:28 But we agree on 98% of the ideas, 98% of doctrine.
00:10:32 We just have some fences between us to allow us to work within our own convictions.
00:10:36 So really, Lutheranism, Presbyterianism, Anglicanism, Baptists, probably Episcopalian, Methodists, and Methodists would be about the six traditions under Protestantism.
00:10:47 Finally, you have the Eastern Orthodox Church.
00:10:49 They're much smaller, so they're about 200 million worldwide.
00:10:52 They actually decreased in share since 1910.
00:10:54 So in 1910, Eastern Orthodoxy was about 20% of the known world, give or take.
00:10:59 That's dropped to about 9%.
00:11:01 Now, to be fair, to give credit where credit is due, that's on the heels of one of the most godless, atheistic regimes the world has ever known, namely communism, which happened in Russia, a predominantly Eastern Orthodox geographical area. 0.90
00:11:14 So we do have to acknowledge that they exterminated religion as best they could. 0.63
00:11:19 They killed priests. 0.96
00:11:20 They killed adherents.
00:11:21 if you demonstrated any level of public faith, anything aside from complete piety in your prayer
00:11:26 closet, you were sent to exile, you were sent to the gulags, and that did a number. But all said
00:11:31 and done, that means Eastern Orthodoxy now, about 9%, probably a little less of the religious world
00:11:36 as we know it. So that's kind of an overview of Christianity. Could you break down maybe a little
00:11:41 bit within Orthodoxy? There's Russian Orthodoxy, Greek Orthodoxy. Are they all under the same
00:11:46 banner? Are they separate? They're not. So they'll kind of give this impression that we are this
00:11:51 a unified church. So you see divisions within Protestantism. Even Catholicism has its different
00:11:55 sects. So they'll say, well, there's division in Protestantism, division within Catholicism,
00:11:59 but the Eastern Orthodox Church is its unified body. That's just not true. You have the Oriental
00:12:03 Orthodox, for example, that are separate. They're Maya physite. They have a different doctrine and 0.99
00:12:07 understanding. The person of Jesus is in relation to human nature. They're maybe 10, 20 million,
00:12:13 so much smaller. You have the Assyrian Church of the East. So these would be three Eastern
00:12:18 Orthodox, all claiming to be the one true church. Three different churches kind of under this 0.88
00:12:22 banner. Many other smaller ones, many other regional ones. Like you mentioned, the Greece
00:12:26 one. There's some like Ethiopian. I think some also in Europe. Kind of little offshoots, all
00:12:31 kind of claiming, well, we're the apostolic successors. We're the apostolic inheritors.
00:12:36 We're the one true church on earth underneath this banner of Eastern Orthodoxy. So they're 0.99
00:12:40 not in communion with another, somewhat fractured, but broadly speaking, Eastern Orthodox,
00:12:44 That's right around the 200 million.
00:12:47 Geographical distribution of Christianity. 0.95
00:12:49 I consider this a strong apologetic for the Christian faith.
00:12:52 So if you could pull up the first graph, Nathan, you'll actually see that most of the religions in the world that have some level of adherence, they're broadly centered on a specific geographical region. 0.93
00:13:03 You can see Hinduism, Buddhism, folk religions, all of them really focused.
00:13:07 Hinduism is super diverse, huh?
00:13:08 That is every clime and place, people of all nationalities.
00:13:13 No, these religions, they're very centered on where they started.
00:13:18 They kind of haven't originated from there.
00:13:20 You probably attribute that to they don't have a belief system that kind of coheres them across climates and across geography.
00:13:26 They're mostly folk religions.
00:13:27 They take on the idiosyncrasies, the location that they are.
00:13:31 But there is a religion, and it's Christianity, that's made up very broadly of a number of different continents,
00:13:37 a number of different countries. All different peoples are represented in Christianity. This is
00:13:41 Jesus's prediction. This is prophecy in John chapter 12. When I'm lifted up, I will draw all
00:13:46 peoples to myself. And there is a religion that is drawing all peoples across the world,
00:13:50 everyone who has faith in Jesus, and that's Christianity. It's not a folk religion. It's
00:13:56 not just a religion that kind of started in the Middle East and has stayed there.
00:13:59 I think of Islam, for example. It's very inaccessible to Westerners. It's very difficult
00:14:04 for westerners to to access it because when it's even written they say well the language
00:14:08 and the words of the quran i have one at home we can only give you what this would mean we can't
00:14:12 give you the actual word of god yep the arabic is the purest form we can't give that to you
00:14:17 and there's certain locales like geographic locales like you must make a um in different
00:14:23 world religions pilgrimage to mecca you know exactly where it's christian that's the whole
00:14:27 idea you read the book of hebrews in the new testament and the whole idea is um it's uh it's
00:14:32 not just don't go back to a salvation by works, but it's no, don't go back to the physical
00:14:38 geographic location of Jerusalem because it's soon to be destroyed. I believe that the author
00:14:43 of Hebrews, well, one, I think it was the Apostle Paul. Two, I do believe that pretty much the
00:14:48 entirety of the New Testament in its writing is pre-8070. I think the Apostle Paul is writing
00:14:53 the book of Hebrews. I think it's a little bit later, but still not as late as some guys would
00:14:58 dated out. And so later, meaning like AD 67, AD 68, just a few years before the destruction of
00:15:05 Jerusalem. So Paul is saying in the spiritual sense, don't go back to Jerusalem, AKA Judaism, 0.86
00:15:10 to the animal sacrificial system, to the priest and to certain washings and all these different
00:15:16 traditions and rituals, because that's not ultimately what pardons sin and what saves
00:15:21 the sinner's soul. But ultimately it's by grace alone, through faith alone, and Christ alone.
00:15:26 So don't go back to this as a spiritual system, but trust in Christ, don't hedge your bets,
00:15:30 trust in Christ alone.
00:15:31 But then also in a literal physical geographic sense, he's saying, don't go back to Jerusalem,
00:15:36 but follow the words of Jesus in the Olivet Discourse in Matthew 24, head for the hills,
00:15:40 run when you see the day of desolation.
00:15:42 God is about to judge Jerusalem for rejecting her Messiah, and this is going to happen in
00:15:49 real terms.
00:15:49 So it's not just the fires of hell that you're eternally spiritually avoiding, but literal
00:15:54 fire and destruction from titus sacking jerusalem and destroying the temple and that's going to
00:15:58 happen just you know a few short years just like the opening of the book of revelation uh the time
00:16:03 is soon not 2 000 years soon but actual soon and so so but the point is in all of that you see
00:16:09 in new testament books of the bible hebrews being um a perfect case study um you see all of a sudden
00:16:15 the geographic locale of the christian faith uh decentralized even the book of acts is another
00:16:21 great example the first 15 chapters is primarily following peter and it's primarily centered the
00:16:26 christian church uh the christian faith is centered in jerusalem but the second half all of a sudden
00:16:31 the center has moved from jerusalem to antioch and from peter to paul and then and that's all
00:16:36 just within a few short years that's still well within the first century and now 2 000 years later
00:16:41 christianity has spread over uh every corner of of the earth and and there's no impetus there's no
00:16:47 no text of scripture or commandment of scripture or precept uh that requires a christian uh that
00:16:53 in order to have access to god uh you would have to be in a certain place at a certain time there
00:16:58 is no pilgrimage there's no mecca there's not in any earthly literal sense i'll do you one there
00:17:03 uh so the tradition of going back to jerusalem to do pilgrimages um it was established later on
00:17:11 like three, 400 AD at the earliest.
00:17:14 And before that, there was nothing like that at all.
00:17:17 And the group that started that 1.00
00:17:19 was a bunch of rich, bored women 1.00
00:17:23 who decided I need to do something 1.00
00:17:25 really especially spiritual.
00:17:29 And their husbands kind of, okay, fine.
00:17:30 We'll finance a pilgrimage. 0.85
00:17:32 The first generation of boomers, right? 0.61
00:17:34 Like we're going to do a trip to the Holy Land. 0.86
00:17:37 It's gonna be expensive.
00:17:38 We're gonna, you know, other people should do it too.
00:17:40 get your get your seat get your ticket well that gets into exactly some of the tendencies within
00:17:45 eastern orthodox we can talk about the intellectual development but there's a real tendency in human
00:17:49 beings to latch on to a place to latch on to an aesthetic to latch on to a tradition or a way of
00:17:55 doing things this place this kind of building yes these uh icons must be present these you know
00:18:01 all right exactly and my spirituality is mediated through these i need the priest or i need this
00:18:06 substance or i need this or i need to go this type of church to mediate my relationship with god
00:18:10 but the one of the reasons christianity it's so global is it says no none of that is mediated
00:18:15 it's mediated through faith it's your faith in jesus that connects you to him and if you are on
00:18:20 just an island and you find one other believer you can actually on the lord's day be a church
00:18:25 you can gather together worship the resurrected christ hopefully you have some type of bread or
00:18:30 wine if you don't you're actually probably about to starve but you can be two people on a deserted
00:18:34 island in the middle of nowhere and you can worship god bread wine the word it's word centric
00:18:40 and it's what i hear you saying west is that christianity is global and decentralized for
00:18:45 the same reason that soccer is global because all you need is two trees that's actually true
00:18:50 and a ball no but seriously you know like like water polo is not a universally you know appraised
00:18:56 sport you know or the winter olympic skiing you know or whatever lacrosse uh because they're you
00:19:01 know it's like well yeah you you kind of have to have some money you have to have access to a pool
00:19:05 you have to have access to this yeah access to that do you have a ski lift you know and access
00:19:09 to that on a regular basis and no most of the world doesn't but uh to find two trees next to
00:19:14 each other to make a goal you know and uh to have a ball you know one ball you know and it's like
00:19:20 okay you can do this in the sudan you can do this in brazil you can do this anywhere and the only
00:19:25 place really you probably don't do it is in america uh because we actually do football we have
00:19:29 entertaining options yeah exactly we have good options instead of an excuse for getting grown
00:19:34 men to jog that's all soccer is it's just it's just complicated jogging okay well yeah we're
00:19:40 roasting it sorry all right sorry and last thing we'll say maybe before we go to the break so we
00:19:44 can pull up the second graph so christianity is global but despite what you may maybe see online
00:19:49 from your eo friends eastern orthodoxy this is a map of its distribution eastern orthodoxy is
00:19:54 primarily centered obviously in the east but also north in russia this is because 1054 the great
00:20:00 schism so rome and constantinople kind of the new rome separated so that was kind of the western
00:20:05 break but also you had muslims hordes invading from the south invading from the east and eastern
00:20:10 orthodox eastern christianity actually kind of escaped to the north moscow is sometimes called
00:20:15 the third rome now that's primarily where it's lived since then it's a predominantly predominantly
00:20:19 eastern religion i mean you can look at whole continents here since there that's exactly where
00:20:25 different he's a succession there's moscow and moscow uh did i say moscow uh or actually they're
00:20:32 both moscow huh uh they might be the russian one the russian both moscow not moscow idaho
00:20:38 it's not helpful moscow russia so uh eastern christianity kind of escaped to there and that's
00:20:42 where it's lived mostly since but if you look at this map you can see whole countries with no
00:20:48 meaningful presence so again parse this through the claim of the eastern orthodox church we are
00:20:52 the one true church we have continuity with apostolic doctrine apostolic teaching we and we
00:20:57 alone we and we alone yeah later on so now you would have some eastern orthodox and they would
00:21:02 say well other individuals can be saved outside of the church 9th to the 19th century you cannot
00:21:07 find any eastern council or eastern father that would teach that they would say if you affirm the
00:21:12 filioque for example that the spirit proceeds both from the father and the son you are damned
00:21:17 16th century, the Council of... 0.94
00:21:18 That was damnable within Eastern Orthodoxy? 0.99
00:21:20 You would have some fathers that would say, yes, if you affirm this, you are dark, you 0.94
00:21:24 are lost without light.
00:21:26 16th century, Council of Jerusalem, so this is 1674.
00:21:29 There was a priest that was preaching a little bit, might have actually been a bishop, teaching
00:21:34 a little bit too much Protestantism, kind of sounded like Catholicism.
00:21:37 They damned that as well. 0.96
00:21:38 So Eo damned St. Cyril? 0.72
00:21:42 Yes, I think it actually was. 0.97
00:21:43 Yeah, he actually was a fan of Calvin.
00:21:45 Yep. 0.99
00:21:45 And so he brings that over and they say, damn. 0.99
00:21:47 EO damned Augustine then? 0.99
00:21:49 St. Augustine? 0.97
00:21:49 Hardest hit?
00:21:50 Well, they don't necessarily connect the dots all the way back, but they're not fans of
00:21:55 Augustine either, necessarily.
00:21:57 And again, there are Eastern Orthodox now, which they'll probably come into this video
00:22:00 and say, no, no, no, you can be saved outside the church, but the Eastern Orthodox church
00:22:03 is the fullest expression of it.
00:22:05 And you can claim that.
00:22:06 I saw several modern, like within the last 20 years, churches doing, not during the homily, 0.70
00:22:16 but during the chants, they were chanting anathemas on all Protestants.
00:22:22 It's still, I mean, this is still a big divide.
00:22:25 They still, it's very exclusive.
00:22:27 We are the one true church and no one else is.
00:22:29 And if you live, I mean, my goodness, there's not a single church, it looks like, in Australia
00:22:33 or New Zealand, Eastern Orthodox.
00:22:35 well you're you're fresh out of luck i mean you can maybe read that bible but you don't have the
00:22:39 so you're saying from the ninth to the 19th century if we play this out like the logical
00:22:44 implication of that is that most of the globe is just in hell yeah exactly yeah okay and there is
00:22:53 no church there there's no option right you would have to i don't know immigrate or something like
00:22:57 that um and and i'm not sitting here saying you know eceo not the one true church reformed baptists
00:23:04 we are i'm not making that claim when again as we talked about earlier the true church is
00:23:08 individuals who have repented of sin place faith in jesus gather on the lord's day for the preaching
00:23:13 of the word the administration of the sacraments you could add church discipline to that and i
00:23:17 mean like our beliefs it's so hard to even find what the eo believes if us as baptists if you
00:23:21 want to know what we believe here it is concisely laid out in our confession of faith right we lay
00:23:26 it out with scripture we lay it out concisely we use logical rigorous reason patterns to say
00:23:31 this is self you know not self-contradictory this is how it all coheres and makes sense
00:23:35 uh but that's like there's an answer to find in the yo what do you believe like the protestant
00:23:40 can answer that yes even if the answer even even if one protestant on certain points would disagree
00:23:45 with another but there still is an answer whereas that's been my experience that you know like and
00:23:49 talking to some eo guys is there's just not answers it's more of like well have you ever
00:23:54 been to an eo service you got to be there you got to feel it you got to you got to experience you
00:24:00 know and um and the homilies tend to be short you know like kind of 20 minute ted talk kind of thing
00:24:05 you know so short on a sermon not much exposition not much explanation um but but lots of robes
00:24:12 lots of tassels lots of incense lots of candles lots of you know stained glass it's sensory yeah
00:24:18 exactly exactly i watched i watched a couple of services it was beautiful the chanting the singing
00:24:22 it was quite beautiful i mean it really was you can tell that they've put a lot of work over the
00:24:27 years into this service. And that might be somewhat of a gap in Protestantism that we've
00:24:32 somewhat fully neglected some of the beauty that we can adorn our church buildings and our services
00:24:38 with, not as distractions, not as items of worship like icons, but God is glorified when we make
00:24:43 things beautiful and good and right and ordered that they show in the preparation and the talent
00:24:48 and the time that we're offering to God as service. Some of that is, I'm not going to turn and friendly
00:24:53 fire on protestants the protestants could take a cue from that that we can adorn our buildings with
00:24:57 uh with remembrance of of heavenly things we can look forward to heavenly life and it doesn't have
00:25:03 to be ugly vaulted ceilings speak to it says something just speaks to the transcendence of
00:25:07 god uh natural light coming in speaks to uh hope and jesus who is light of the world and the
00:25:12 resurrection piercing through the darkness like there's you know all these uh everything is
00:25:17 theological um it's either bad theology or good theology but there is no neutrality there's no
00:25:21 no um theological uh vacuum in the world everything that we do our theology as doug has said you know
00:25:28 comes out of our fingertips and it comes and everything we do from our vocation to our
00:25:32 families and even to the way that we would design um an architect a church building so what we said
00:25:37 earlier about you know like well soccer all you need is two trees and a ball you know and and the
00:25:41 protestant christian faith all you need is a bible water and uh wine and bread uh that is um that is
00:25:47 objectively true but that's not to say that when we do have the resource that resources that we
00:25:52 shouldn't prioritize them for things that are beautiful uh the the true the good and the
00:25:57 beautiful all the way down to the church building and so i think protestant you're right protestants
00:26:00 um if if they can't afford it then stop building the amphitheater um you know like that it's just
00:26:07 a metal box it can get as many butts in as many seats as possible so that you can put on a concert
00:26:13 you know once a week uh stop doing that uh that ugly you know ugly do do a cathedral um assuming
00:26:21 that you can and that god provides the resources be willing to to work towards and that may be a
00:26:26 50-year work that's i think part of the reason protestants haven't done it is um partly because
00:26:31 of their eschatology believing jesus is coming back next thursday uh if we start a 50-year you
00:26:36 know cathedral project it'd be a waste of resources and time the cathedral the great cathedrals in
00:26:40 europe they took 400 years yeah those guys did not believe jesus was coming back next thursday
00:26:44 you don't start a 400 year project no um if if you are a dispensational pre-mill christian so i
00:26:51 think that's part of it is that within protestantism um i you know i think that the lion's
00:26:56 share of eschatology at least for the last you know 100 150 years has been this dispensational
00:27:01 premillennialism that jesus is coming back any second and um which no man knows the day or the
00:27:07 hour he could uh but but i'm not saying jesus couldn't come back tomorrow he could um but uh
00:27:14 a lot of protestants they're not saying that he could they're saying he will right like so i talked
00:27:18 to somebody today saying he was telling me his testimony a story and said yeah my dad always
00:27:22 told me you know growing up that uh um jesus will come back in my lifetime you know i will like like
00:27:29 as confident as he is about uh the gospel itself he is confident jesus will return in his lifetime
00:27:34 and that has been many protestants and so so yeah so we could take a page out of eo's book in that
00:27:40 regard but it shouldn't be as a substitute it's not uh well we don't really have uh facts and
00:27:45 logic um so we're gonna we're gonna do a little extra incense seven more candles and uh ornate
00:27:53 ornate designs yeah let's go to a break and then we'll discuss the intellectual formation of the
00:27:57 east and the west private family banking partners is on a mission to help christians live out the
00:28:03 Dominion mandate by making a stealth-like move away from the mainstream banks and into their
00:28:10 own privatized banking system. This innovative system is designed to guarantee uninterrupted
00:28:16 compound interest and tax-free growth without exposure to typical stock market risk. To join
00:28:24 this growing community that is already building wealth unto future generations and converting
00:28:30 post-mill talk into post-mill action, contact Private Family Banking partner Chuck DeLoderonte
00:28:39 at his email, chuckatprivatefamilybanking.com. That's chuckatprivatefamilybanking.com.
00:28:49 Set up an appointment and receive a free copy of Chuck's new book, Protect Your Money Now,
00:28:55 how to build multi-generational wealth outside of Wall Street and avoid the coming banking
00:29:02 meltdown. Go to the links in the show notes below. All right, so we're back. We're going
00:29:09 to go ahead and dive into some of the intellectual differences that actually make engaging with
00:29:14 Eastern Orthodox apologists difficult. So James White put his finger on this. There are Eastern
00:29:19 categories of thought that us as Westerners were just not familiar with. They don't make sense to
00:29:24 us. The Western intellectual tradition, it made use of a lot of the Roman, a lot of the Greek
00:29:29 philosophical. I don't want to say adapting them as if it was a bad thing, but like Augustine used
00:29:33 Platonic forms, Platonic thought, Thomas Aquinas adopting, of course, Aristotelian logic. Because
00:29:39 of the development then is the Great Schism. You have 1054. The West breaks off. That tradition, 0.97
00:29:45 of course, intellectually continues to develop. This is how we get the scientific method.
00:29:48 You have the Enlightenment, revolutions in science and in intellect and philosophy and all these
00:29:53 different things, that's predominantly in the West. The Eastern, just broadly speaking,
00:29:58 Eastern philosophy has a more mystical and experiential element to it. So you can think
00:30:04 of some of the early impactful philosophers, so Plato in the West, we'd have Confucius maybe in
00:30:08 the East where it's a little bit different. Michael, you've actually done missionary work
00:30:11 in the East, so you'd actually be maybe more qualified to speak just a little bit of the
00:30:16 different ways Eastern and Western thinkers, when it comes to different things, the way we think
00:30:21 about it yep uh yeah i did i served in taiwan for six years um and it is definitely true the idea of
00:30:31 an eastern and a western mentality on even just truth what is true what is definite what is
00:30:39 objective um i can't speak to particularly you know taiwan is not eastern orthodox it's
00:30:45 folk religion animism and buddhism but that idea of uh the eastern view on spirituality was
00:30:51 definitely there and one of the things that was interesting was that most people do not have a
00:30:57 any sort of um systematized belief like you mentioned a moment ago joel you can ask us in
00:31:07 the 1689 confession what do you believe well if you ask a lot of people at least in taiwan
00:31:13 I don't know.
00:31:13 I don't know what I believe.
00:31:15 They know what they do.
00:31:16 They know what their mom would have them do
00:31:18 and what idols they would worship to
00:31:20 at what times of the year
00:31:21 and what sacrifices and offerings they would take.
00:31:25 They know that, you know,
00:31:27 uncle so-and-so prayed to this God
00:31:29 and then, you know, his business did well.
00:31:32 And so that's just kind of what we do.
00:31:34 We pray to that God now.
00:31:35 But there's also a sense where
00:31:37 there's not a strict importance on logical consistency.
00:31:43 Like, it's not a jarring concept at all
00:31:47 to hold in your mind at the same time
00:31:49 two different ideas that we would say
00:31:51 are logically exclusive, mutually exclusive.
00:31:57 The idea of a logical base of reality
00:32:00 and a belief system.
00:32:02 One example is you can have,
00:32:04 you can worship one God and another God.
00:32:08 And when you start saying,
00:32:09 well, aren't these two gods seemingly
00:32:11 contradictory or at odds, it's like, well, they don't care. I serve this God. I worship this God
00:32:16 for this reason. And yeah, I go over here and I worship this other God. And, you know, this God,
00:32:22 I just go to when I need this. I need an A on my test or I need my family to be safe. And
00:32:26 even though there's this other God who's supposed to be my regional God, I don't really pay him
00:32:32 much service because, you know, we prefer to do this other obeisance or worship to this other
00:32:39 god the last thing i would say is um for eastern religion it is not taught systematically right
00:32:49 it's not propositional it's taught by your mother doing something all the time and then that's what
00:32:55 you do it's taught by um your your grandmother or your father participates in this festival
00:33:02 and so people would be easier it would be easier for them to say this is what we do
00:33:08 as our belief but to ask what do you believe what are the tenants yes of your belief no idea
00:33:15 no idea what does that do wes for assurance i literally was going to go to that so when it
00:33:22 comes to i mean this is the key question to get right but also should be at the core of your soul
00:33:27 how is a sinner made right with god right how is a man justified and how can he know and how can he
00:33:33 know so how am i made right with god objectively and how do i know that i've been made right with
00:33:37 god so we'll come to justification and again in the west we've we've laid out painstakingly
00:33:42 especially in the reformed tradition catholicism has this too so catholicism is actually closer
00:33:47 in some ways to protestantism right than eastern orthodoxy so catholicism has a system of grace
00:33:52 a thomistic one where grace is metered out this way or the other but in protestantism us as
00:33:56 protestants very carefully defined is justification sanctification glorification we make it extremely
00:34:02 clear that justification is only on the basis of faith now that justification is of course
00:34:08 borne out in your sanctification and your works not as the basis for why you were justified but
00:34:13 as evidence that you were in fact justified right we're saved by faith alone but saving faith is
00:34:18 never alone so it's the faith alone that saves but if it is in fact a saving faith it will always
00:34:23 manifest itself in good works, but it's not faith plus works equals salvation. It's faith
00:34:29 equals salvation plus works. Exactly. Well, I was listening to an explanation of some of this,
00:34:36 and they quoted a lengthy quote from Theodora, and she apparently had appeared in a vision
00:34:44 to some other saint, and she was explaining in this vision... On a piece of toast?
00:34:50 No, no, this was a dream that this guy had.
00:34:53 Theodora came and appeared to him, and she said that she had,
00:34:57 after upon death, she had ascended to heaven,
00:34:59 but her whole way to heaven had been plagued by devils and demons
00:35:02 trying to stop her progress of getting up to heaven after death.
00:35:06 And she said, apparently, in this vision,
00:35:09 that as the devils and demons were pointing out all of these sins that she had done,
00:35:15 The angels were flying down and pouring through her life kind of like in a file book and looking for all the good works that she had done.
00:35:24 And she listed off her fasting on Wednesdays and Fridays and her Lenten and the times that she spoke and didn't speak.
00:35:31 And she said the angels were able to find enough of the good works that she had done in service of the church that that propelled her on up into heaven.
00:35:40 And this is apparently, Theodora is a saint in the Eastern Orthodox Church.
00:35:48 And that, to me, as I was reading that quote, it seemed to remove faith entirely from it.
00:35:54 The faith of Theodora was only that if enough evidence of her earthly righteousness can be found, then God will allow her to come into heaven.
00:36:03 Right.
00:36:04 and the biggest concern i just want to make sure that i'm hearing your your point the biggest
00:36:08 concern is that they would consider a woman to be a saint well oh wait it was about faith and
00:36:14 words my bad i miss that i miss that yes no you're right there are women who are saints yeah um i was
00:36:20 gonna say oh i forgot to ask you guys what what are you giving up for lent oh my goodness i i've
00:36:26 decided i'm going to eat more bacon this year that's right this year i've given up lent for
00:36:30 Yeah, there you go.
00:36:30 That's perfect.
00:36:31 I'm giving up Lent for Lent.
00:36:32 What I usually do for Lent is I try to do something that I think the Pope would disapprove of.
00:36:36 I try to do more.
00:36:37 I never give anything up.
00:36:38 I try to do more of something.
00:36:40 More bacon.
00:36:40 After careful consideration, I've decided to become worse.
00:36:43 Upon reviewing all the options, I'm going to do worse.
00:36:46 Okay.
00:36:47 Back to you.
00:36:47 Let me read from Philippians 3.
00:36:49 I mean, this is the core of the gospel.
00:36:51 Philippians 3, verse 8.
00:36:52 deed account everything is lost because of the surpassing worth of knowing christ jesus my lord
00:36:57 for sake i have suffered the loss of all things and count them as rubbish in order that i may
00:37:00 gain christ and be found in him not having a righteousness of my own that comes through the
00:37:06 law but that which comes through faith in christ the righteousness of god that depends on faith
00:37:11 twice there he's hammering it home the righteousness of god is dependent on one thing faith in jesus
00:37:18 it was funny on twitter redeemed zoomer he's been on the show before he just opened form he said uh
00:37:23 okay for eastern orthodox how are you saved and it was a variety of responses and some of them were
00:37:28 trust and faith in god he does good on on you yep he does and uh but it's a wide variety like well
00:37:33 saint toothbrush in the seventh century said x y and z well actually actually there was a bunch
00:37:39 of different things like you had to participate in this and he said okay protestants how is one
00:37:44 saved and the answer just little variations trust in jesus trust in jesus repent of sin faith in
00:37:50 jesus and that shows the clarity between these two religions and that's not to say someone like
00:37:54 jay dyer wouldn't have an answer well how are you justified he would get into explanations of
00:37:58 theosis which is participation in the divine being but it'd be really tough but it'd be much more
00:38:03 complex and then i would go across the stream to father josiah or something like that and he would
00:38:07 say well it's actually done this way and then someone brought up a good point saint gregory
00:38:11 Palamas. This is huge in their tradition. He's making a huge comeback. He was forgotten for
00:38:16 500 years, but then you would go to that person and they would say, well, it's faith and deeds
00:38:20 all over the place. And again, I can pick that book up and I can explain to you what myself and
00:38:26 every other individual, thousands of them, confess on justification. Presbyterians with
00:38:30 Westminster Confession of Faith can say, this is what we believe in justification, not just
00:38:34 salvation, like on the church, on the civil magistrate, on the last things, all of these
00:38:39 different things we've clearly laid out because we've done the reading we use these western
00:38:43 intellectual frameworks of logic of non-contradiction of applying and saying do all these things mesh up
00:38:50 are they consistent again and again referencing scripture so you're going to open this book and
00:38:54 every single tenant in it is going to have verses we believe this because this we believe this
00:39:00 because this bible bible bible bible and even if you disagree with it so you'll say well i'm
00:39:04 presbyterian disagree with this okay but they're also appealing they're going to cite bible they're
00:39:08 gonna cite bible yeah right real quick one thing that i find funny about um it's just since you
00:39:12 mentioned redeemed uh zoomer who i think is he's you know he's young and uh but but super sharp
00:39:18 tons of potential i like him um but i you know i i you know there's there's things i would disagree
00:39:23 with but uh one of his big things is trying to you know uh get protestants he's protestant you
00:39:28 know and he's and he holds to reform soteriology and those things but uh but he's regularly trying
00:39:32 to get protestants to stay in mainline denominations you know your mainline methodist
00:39:36 anglican you know presbyterian so like he's currently um a member in a pcus gay church you
00:39:42 know so pcusa you know the women pastors i'm not saying there's one in his church i don't know if
00:39:47 there is or not but but they have tons of female pastors gay affirming rainbow flags all that kind
00:39:52 of stuff uh but he's his whole strategy and and you know incentive the motive is uh we need to
00:40:00 recapture you know uh conservatives can't continue to just flee and and retreat we need to stand our
00:40:05 ground this is why we've ended up where we are and i think there's a bit of truth in that you
00:40:09 know uh so we need to stay and fight and not just start you know um another church and go and church
00:40:14 plant or join the reformed baptist meeting in a bowling alley you know and he'll give a hard time
00:40:19 to basically churches you know protestant churches with good doctrine he'll give a hard time to them
00:40:23 because of uh you know they're they don't have a nice building i mean that literally i mean he
00:40:28 just that's on level that's that's what he says um and then the irony though is uh you know that
00:40:33 he's very much against eo and saying no no no they deny the basic tenets of the faith and he's
00:40:38 right on that but i saw somebody comment you know they said uh he said uh this has got to be
00:40:43 excruciating for redeemed zoomer that his whole ministry has been stay in protestant churches
00:40:49 with lady pastors and rainbow flags and bad doctrine because they have nice resources in
00:40:54 a pretty building and then the guys that he's influencing all end up going to eo
00:40:59 do we not see the correlation does he not like the big bubbles on top of the building that must
00:41:04 be it he's like yeah this is because that is literally what it is it's like you know join
00:41:08 the pc usa church you know and then uh because they have a nice building we should take it back
00:41:14 and then you know and then everybody's like well why don't i go to the eo church that's uh its
00:41:19 doctrine is just as abysmal as your lady pastor's doctrine um but uh at least there they both have
00:41:24 bad doctrine and they both have nice buildings but at least here it's a dude and masculine yeah
00:41:29 I'll give credit to the Eastern Orthodox.
00:41:31 You're not going to find a woman priest in the Eastern Orthodox tradition.
00:41:34 You're not going to find a rainbow flag.
00:41:35 And that's part of the appeal for young men, especially. 0.98
00:41:38 As people are coming back.
00:41:40 Yep, red pill guys are going to you.
00:41:42 Yep, right, exactly.
00:41:44 There's an appeal there because when all the, I don't want to say the foundations necessarily,
00:41:49 but when much of the building is being shaken,
00:41:51 there can be this tendency to want to run to something that stood the test of time.
00:41:54 And in fairness, they then look at the evangelical church down the street that meets in a school and has been going on for five minutes and is already on board with social justice.
00:42:04 And they say, yeah, that doesn't seem like the kind of place that's going to weather the sexual revolution.
00:42:08 That doesn't seem like the kind of place where I can dig in and fight for my town.
00:42:12 So then they go and they see a tradition like that that hasn't caved to at least some forms of modernity.
00:42:17 It's got a little bit of mysticism.
00:42:18 It's a little bit different than what we would typically experience.
00:42:21 And that's where some of the appeal is.
00:42:22 And they bring their young families in.
00:42:24 and then other young families come in they see young families there and they form friendships
00:42:27 and some of that is certainly good i would much rather uh you go to an eo church as much as it
00:42:32 pains me to say it uh than to be marching in a pride parade like that is better uh we could do
00:42:38 a lot better than that still though eo has a lot to offer though it's like male priest for the dudes
00:42:42 and essential oil incense for the chicks that's right you know what i mean like what's not the
00:42:46 like i mean they got a little bit of everything for both both genders you know i see the appeal
00:42:51 all right well getting into the uh the social issues so oh this is the trad church this is the
00:42:56 church right that's what you hear is like well i'm gonna go eo and maybe you know yeah i understand
00:43:01 i come from a protestant background and they deny the solas and yeah i do have some concerns with
00:43:06 that but i'm gonna look into it i'm gonna do the reading you know i'm gonna consider it because
00:43:09 here's the deal i don't know exactly what they believe on doctrine everything you've just said
00:43:13 because of the ambiguity and all the all the contradictions so i don't know exactly where
00:43:16 they're at on that but culturally they're weathering the storm so there must be something
00:43:20 good because culturally you know eo is not going gay affirming eo is not you know ordaining women
00:43:26 priests but let's get some stats yes let's pull up the first one this is from pew research it is
00:43:32 2015 i'll be complete disclosures 2015 a lot can change in nine years the church has been around
00:43:38 for a thousand years probably not that much so this is pew research um abortion should be
00:43:43 and 52 percent of orthodox self-professing orthodox christians would say uh legal in all
00:43:50 or most cases um so a little bit over over half yep yep go to the next one nathan
00:43:55 so now this is views about homosexuality among orthodox christians now this is in 2015 so
00:44:02 a berger fell probably happened just right around that time and it's only grown in popularity since
00:44:07 then it is under the decline thank the lord i think we'll see that trend continue to bear out
00:44:11 but in 2015 this is 62 percent of orthodox christians said homosexuality should be accepted
00:44:18 so 53 percent said abortion should be legal in all or most cases yes and then 62 percent said that
00:44:26 um that that what that 62 percent homosexuality should be accepted accepted yep wasn't the
00:44:33 question wasn't necessarily about legal or whatever now the pushback would be well like
00:44:37 we said earlier well eastern orthodox is primarily eastern so you should look to russia or you should
00:44:42 look to greece or some of these other nations greece last week uh became the first orthodox
00:44:46 country to approve same-sex marriage so things aren't holding out very well there now now the
00:44:52 church did put up some sort of fight but the nation's 96 orthodox 96 yep and and they lasted
00:44:58 it held they lasted about nine years nine more years right more years than we did yeah which
00:45:04 just something and maybe they put up with america what percent of america is protestant like it like
00:45:10 evangelical not 96 percent no no fifth so you're talking about 50 or 60 yeah i think it's so we've
00:45:15 got you know about half of the country um and and we folded yeah and that's sad and you know and
00:45:22 that's an indictment to us may god have mercy and may we repent but about half of the country
00:45:27 being evangelical christian and we folded like a cheap suit in 2015 but you're saying but that's
00:45:33 with half the country about 50 maybe a little 50 plus percent but eo in greece you're saying 96
00:45:39 81 to 90 of the current estimates is orthodox so close to 90 around there um and they still
00:45:47 went and supposedly the church protested same-sex marriage that same-sex marriage that they voted
00:45:52 on okay and again supposedly the church protested and maybe they are but does that mean every single
00:45:56 politician voted for it because they're probably members of orthodox church are they being kicked
00:46:00 out for their vote right i don't know i would have to guess it's a reasonable guess i'm not a prophet
00:46:05 or the son of a prophet i guess probably not i'm not but going to russia for example russia has one
00:46:10 of the worst records in the world on abortion a big part of that again is communism uh atheism
00:46:16 which was it's been one of the worst ideologies this world has ever seen so some of the worst
00:46:21 abortion rates going into the 1990s after the usr ussr fell but even still in 2014 so i think
00:46:27 orthodox would be about 60 of the nation only four percent of russians said abortion is
00:46:35 unacceptable in all cases four percent 2016 and 60 of the nation was eo roughly about now that
00:46:42 number has grown of them said to about 13 recently so it is on the rise opposed to abortion that are
00:46:47 opposed to abortion okay but in the u.s it's 40 to 50 and again we're not even a predominantly
00:46:52 orthodox or Roman Catholic nation would probably be at this point half and half only four percent
00:46:58 though in 2014 yep abortion should be illegal 2016 legal not even so eight years ago are you
00:47:05 gonna wow are you gonna show do you have a point in our presentation today where you're gonna show
00:47:10 the comparison between the graph that you just showed of those who said abortion is should be
00:47:16 legal in all or most cases with the eo uh do you have the uh the same the can you show a comparison
00:47:24 of the same thing for evangelicals or protestants or i can tell it i don't have the article right
00:47:29 okay it's so it's in the article so again for those who are late comers join us on patreon.com
00:47:35 forward slash right response ministries and and the wednesday live stream is always accompanied
00:47:39 with an article that has all the stats and all the the quotes and citations so so join us on
00:47:44 patreon become a member and you'll get the article but let's go ahead for the podcast and just say it
00:47:48 so views among abortion someone asked like what is the source for this eo strictly forbids
00:47:53 abortion and homosexuality which which very well may be true in a sense so pure research this is
00:47:59 a sample size of 200 orthodox christians when they were asked abortion should be xyz 52 percent said
00:48:06 legal in all slash most cases 45 said illegal in all slash most cases one percent said they don't
00:48:15 know we'll chalk that back up to the 53 up to 54 so 54 of orthodox christians they say i am orthodox
00:48:22 they were asked about abortion they said it should be legal in most or all cases in 2015 okay this
00:48:28 wasn't this wasn't yesterday same thing homosexuality even higher in 2015 62 in the
00:48:35 U.S. of Orthodox Christians, Pew Research Group, said it should be accepted. Homosexuality should 1.00
00:48:40 be accepted. Another, let's zoom in on this, I think 31% should be discouraged, and then neither,
00:48:48 both equally, was like 4%. So you can say, well, the church doesn't allow this, the church doesn't
00:48:53 allow that. Well, all that can be written down in Word, but in practice, you have many professing
00:48:59 Christians that affirm these things, that see no contradiction between their faith and that.
00:49:03 Now, to be fair, there would be many Protestants in a Methodist church or Episcopal church
00:49:08 who would say the same thing.
00:49:09 But we have a standard that says you're not a Christian and that church itself isn't even
00:49:13 true. 1.00
00:49:14 We can say that.
00:49:15 Well, not only that, though, what you were mentioning earlier, I remember, Wes, at some
00:49:18 point you shared some research with us, and the evangelical Christian in the survey results
00:49:24 was much lower on questions of affirming homosexuality, affirming abortion.
00:49:30 I mean, it was still higher than it should be, obviously, but it was like 33%, I think is what you said, of evangelicals were saying abortion should be allowed in all or most cases.
00:49:42 So there were some, but it was much, much lower than any other.
00:49:46 33%.
00:49:46 Yeah.
00:49:47 So you have the same chart here that said, and this is also, I think it's also 2015?
00:49:52 This would be the same study.
00:49:53 Same study.
00:49:54 Okay, same study, same year.
00:49:55 but for protestants it's uh uh 33 percent believe that abortion should be legal in all or most cases
00:50:04 and then again eo is 53 54 percent so a good 20 that's what like like almost not quite twice but
00:50:14 a good 70 percent higher yeah or so yeah and then uh and then with uh homosexuality being accepted
00:50:20 for protestants um i'd have to find it it's not on that picture i wasn't able to find it for i
00:50:28 don't think that year okay specifically but um but still on abortion that's a comparison it's 53
00:50:33 saying legal in all the most cases of eo eastern orthodox guys 53 it should be legal abortion should
00:50:40 be legal in all or most cases 33 for protestants so the whole point though is just because that's
00:50:47 one of the rhetoric that i'll hear from guys especially young men who are you know entertaining
00:50:51 debating you know thinking or have gone eastern orthodox as they're saying well protestants
00:50:56 protestants are effeminate protestants are weak protestant and i mean you don't have to convince
00:51:02 me like i mean that's a lot to that one for sure yeah and that's a lot of what we do with right
00:51:06 response ministries is is uh calling our our own brothers and sisters and our own camp to repentance
00:51:14 and not even just within protestantism not just like pointing to some you know arminian southern
00:51:20 baptist ted talk seeker sensitive you know bart barber you know or something like i'm not not
00:51:26 just somebody like that but like regularly pointing even at each other within the reformed
00:51:30 tradition reformed presbyterian you know whether it be westminster or reformed uh 1689 reformed
00:51:36 baptists like looking at one another and saying i love you but this is wrong you need to repent
00:51:40 you've gotten soft on on this with the pca not the pc usa but the pca which for the most part
00:51:46 is conservative and is certainly reformed um when they you know when and it wasn't all of them but
00:51:52 when when some of them started entertaining the whole revoice kind of thing with greg johnson and
00:51:56 that whole thing like um we were not silent all of us were calling hey stop it stop that repent
00:52:04 of this and that wasn't even um affirming homosexuality in its fullness that was simply
00:52:09 saying that there's a place for same-sex attraction if it's not being acted upon and even then even
00:52:16 then these are guys in our own camp where we're drawing the line and saying that is wrong you need
00:52:20 to repent that's a wrong understanding of concupiscence that a doctrine of sin beginning
00:52:26 at the level of desire the book of james says where do quarrels come from where does it it
00:52:30 does it not start with your evil desires the desire itself even if not acted upon is unnatural
00:52:36 and against the prescribed clear revealed will of god and so the desire itself is not permissible
00:52:42 it is something that you need to name a sin and be actively by grace seeking to put that desire
00:52:47 to death that's in our own house our own camp even at the level of just same-sex attraction
00:52:52 much less actually acting on it um so this is not just uh oh you guys are picking on eo because eo is
00:52:59 um is is cleaning up shop right now and taking you know taking all your prospects you know
00:53:04 protestants are losing young men to eo um that is true um but one of the reasons these young men are
00:53:11 are giving for going to eo is that eo is based eo is masculine eo is is a trad and it's and it's a
00:53:18 bulwark against the cultural insanity no it's not yeah eo is soft on abortion that's the whole point
00:53:24 of doing these that's soft on on on uh same-sex marriage it's soft like no if you're if you're
00:53:31 going to eo because you think that eo is taking a stronger stand against the cultural insanity
00:53:37 then um you are being fooled by the smoke and mirrors literal smoke and murals and incense
00:53:42 and this and that um yeah that guy has a huge beard um and and a big robe and long tassels
00:53:49 and lots of candles um but what does he believe they make the argument too like oh we have a
00:53:56 continuity with the apostolic tradition well the church fathers all affirm that the continuity
00:54:00 in view there is not bishop to bishop to bishop or church to church to church. It's a confession
00:54:05 of the same faith. So when you think about, well, who is most in line with apostolic teaching,
00:54:10 namely scripture that we have written down in objective form, well, I would think the ones,
00:54:14 a church like ours that says, no, this is a sin, no abortion is wrong, no this, no that.
00:54:19 And we will discipline you if you engage in this.
00:54:22 That's true continuity with the apostolic tradition that wrote down a condemnation and
00:54:28 continuity of the old testament of all these things even the sbc with all its problems they
00:54:33 took one of the biggest churches in the whole denomination that accounts for millions of dollars
00:54:38 charitable giving into the sbc so i mean this was like this was a financial hit um and they voted
00:54:45 and it wasn't even close it was like 87 percent almost 90 percent uh voted to kick rick warner
00:54:52 and Saddleback out of the SBC 0.96
00:54:54 because of women pastors. 0.98
00:54:57 And I'm asking, it's a genuine question.
00:55:00 You've done the study for this episode
00:55:01 and on this topic.
00:55:02 Does Eastern Orthodoxy,
00:55:04 do they have a list of churches this year
00:55:06 in 2024, last year in 2023
00:55:08 that they've kicked out of Eastern Orthodoxy 1.00
00:55:11 because 53% of their members
00:55:15 said that it's okay to murder children in the womb?
00:55:18 They'll have a list for the ones 0.90
00:55:19 who did the wrong liturgy
00:55:20 that they're not in fellowship with.
00:55:21 and they will there's churches in america that are on the wrong list or like did it wrong and
00:55:26 they're disenfellowshipped but none of that and hey if you're eo and your church is full of these
00:55:30 people clean house send us the news article and we'll say yes and amen and we'll revise we'll do 0.98
00:55:35 a follow-up say hey this eo church uh is playing for keeps they run this survey again suck on 0.65
00:55:40 justification but you know kick them out on this like prove us wrong right it would be the challenge 0.90
00:55:45 we have the data we've shown it so do we have one more ad yeah let's go ahead and cut to our
00:55:49 last commercial for the day all right everybody's been asking can i live stream your conference and
00:55:55 the answer is a resounding no you will be there in person or you will not be there at all i'm just
00:56:01 kidding you actually can live stream the conference we're excited to announce we're making it available
00:56:06 to anybody and everybody who wants to watch this conference right as it's happening which is march
00:56:12 1st and 2nd that's a friday and saturday of 2024 what conference am i even talking about it's called
00:56:18 blueprints for Christendom 2.0. We've got Pastor Douglas Wilson. We've got Dr. Joe Boot. We've got
00:56:24 Brian Sauve. We've got Eric Kahn. And then of course, yours truly, Joel Webb. And we've got
00:56:29 seven primary sessions in the conference, each one being probably 50 to 60 minute long
00:56:34 sessions, lectures, sermons, whatever you want to call them. And then two live panels,
00:56:40 each being an hour and a half long. Now, one of the panels is on biblical patriarchy. We're going
00:56:45 to have Pastor Douglas Wilson available for that panel, and we decided to get Eric Kahn, because
00:56:50 Eric Kahn, biblical patriarchy, let's just be honest, it's a sensitive topic, but Eric Kahn, I think, is
00:56:56 known as one of the most nuanced, careful, and sensitive individuals, especially on the Twitter
00:57:01 streets. So we're going to have him as a part of that panel. It'll go really well. Then the second
00:57:05 panel is Haunted Cosmos live show. You've got Brian Sauve and Ben Garrett talking about the most
00:57:11 unhinged things imaginable hopefully some things that are actually truthful now there will be some
00:57:17 truthful things you're going to stick to scripture and when they speculate and you know they will
00:57:20 they'll at least let you know that it's speculation and they won't pass it off as though it's in the
00:57:25 infallible word of god so live stream this conference how do you do it go to patreon.com
00:57:31 forward slash right response ministries again that's patreon.com forward slash right response
00:57:38 ministries. A lot of guys charge 50 bucks, 60 bucks, 80 bucks. We are asking that you would
00:57:44 simply partner with us for $10 a month. And let's be real. You could do it one month,
00:57:50 live stream all the content, and then cancel your subscription. And if you do, no harm,
00:57:54 no foul. If you want to stick with us and support this ministry, what God's doing through Right
00:57:58 Response, then praise God. That's great. And we thank you. Either way, technically, it's only 10
00:58:03 bucks. All right. So landing the plane here, calling back a little bit to the introduction
00:58:09 over and over again, you'll hear from different sects, different traditions that some form of
00:58:15 authority has been lost. So they'll look at the division and Protestantism and Christianity as a
00:58:19 whole, and they'll make the claim that we have the restored authority. We're the ones with the
00:58:23 divine right to interpret scripture, to apply it. So the Mormon church, for example, Joseph Smith,
00:58:28 he goes out into the woods because he's torn between, do I join the Presbyterian church?
00:58:31 I joined the Methodist church, and he supposedly receives this vision, and the priesthood,
00:58:35 I remember engaging for a long time with some missionaries, and the priesthood is supposedly
00:58:39 restored, and now through the quorum of the Twelve Apostles, they are this living, active
00:58:43 body on earth that makes the judge in issues of doctrine, of practice, and all these different
00:58:47 things.
00:58:48 Same thing for Jehovah's Witnesses, the tradition in biblical Christianity was lost, and then
00:58:52 Charles Taze Russell with the New World Translation, the Watchtower and Tract Society, are now
00:58:56 a new governing body.
00:58:58 This is the same MO for tons of cults.
00:59:00 Christianity was lost. They can never tell you how. So let's say the scripture was corrupted.
00:59:03 The tradition was lost. It lost its way. Well, how? What parts of scripture? Well, well, well.
00:59:09 And then some older ones. Rome would say that scripture alone, it's not enough. We need a
00:59:15 living, active vicar of Christ in the Pope to help us interpret, to speak ex cathedra,
00:59:21 to speak infallibly, to help us walk through all these things. Same thing with EO. Well, we
00:59:26 have the right. I've seen friends, they've gone EO and they said like, well, Protestants say that 0.97
00:59:31 Scripture alone is the only authority. That's wrongly to in a second. But who gets to interpret
00:59:35 Scripture? Which is a valid point. You can take a look at a passage of Scripture and two people 0.95
00:59:39 might say, it seems from the context, it seems from the historical grammatical surroundings
00:59:45 that it means this. And someone else might seem this. And they disagree. And that is real. We have
00:59:49 to say like, who, what is kind of the final rule? Generally, Scripture interprets Scripture. But
00:59:54 there is a place for tradition in protestantism if i hear one more eo convert say skull sola 0.95
00:59:59 scriptura says that uh the bible is the only authority i'm going to drive to your house and
01:00:04 i'm going to play james white sermons outside of your house till you come out and you give me the
01:00:07 proper definition sola scriptura says that scripture is the only infallible that's right
01:00:13 rule of faith and practice scripture tradition matters other authorities of course there are
01:00:17 other authorities it's the only infallible authority and it's the highest authority that's
01:00:20 all Sola Scriptura means. It's the highest authority. It supersedes all other authorities,
01:00:25 and it's the only authority that does not err. Other authorities can be high, but not as high,
01:00:31 and can be incredibly accurate, but not perfectly accurate. So church history is an authority.
01:00:38 Confessions are an authority. Your pastor and board of elders are an authority. If you're a
01:00:44 Presbyterian, your Presbytery is an authority. All these things, Augustine is an authority,
01:00:49 But they're not infallible, and they're not the highest.
01:00:52 Scripture alone is not that it's the only authority,
01:00:55 but it's the only infallible authority, and it is the highest authority.
01:00:59 Exactly.
01:01:01 And in God's wisdom, one of the reasons I don't think he's instituted men
01:01:05 as a highest authority is because men are fickle, men get corrupted,
01:01:09 and they can be very easily swayed with the times.
01:01:11 The Christian man is mature.
01:01:13 He's grounded.
01:01:14 He's not tossed to and fro from every wind and wave of doctrine.
01:01:17 and an unchanging standard like God's word that applies to all people in all places is a much
01:01:22 better infallible highest authority than a council or a synod even of the most learned of men. Let
01:01:27 me give an example from the Eos. We mentioned this earlier, the Jerusalem Synod of 1672. So
01:01:33 there was a bishop, he's teaching a little too much Calvinism. They got together, they condemned it,
01:01:38 but they also said something else interesting. So again, this is the church that would claim 1.00
01:01:41 that their councils and their ecumenicism is binding, that they alone determine the proper
01:01:47 practice, the proper faith, the proper traditions. And what they came out with, this would be the
01:01:52 confession of Doethius, says this. So the question is, should the divine scriptures be read in the
01:01:58 vulgar tongue? This simply just means the common language, so English for us, by all Christians.
01:02:03 This is a council that got together, made a decision, published in 1672. Should the scriptures
01:02:08 be read in the common tongue no i'm quoting right here because all scripture is divinely
01:02:13 inspired and profitable we know necessarily so that without scripture it is impossible to be
01:02:16 orthodox at all nevertheless they should not be read by all but only by those who with fitting
01:02:21 research have inquired into the deep things of the spirit and who know in what manner the divine
01:02:26 scriptures ought to be searched and taught and finally read this is due for family worship
01:02:33 all right do you have an mdiv you don't have you don't have family worship not right now that's
01:02:39 the same as roman catholicism the vulgate you know that the scripture was not only was it in
01:02:43 latin instead of the vulgar tongue just meaning the common tongue that people could read and
01:02:46 understand um but the whole you know i mean it wasn't within roman catholicism it wasn't until
01:02:52 very recently that it even you know uh that the mass was even outside of the latin language so
01:02:57 you had people for centuries and centuries and centuries showing up um and not comprehending
01:03:02 anything and people still roman catholics today michael knolls i appreciate michael knolls for
01:03:07 some things you know but on the daily wire he'll say you know like uh the latin mass is so important
01:03:11 or like shia labeouf you know like i went to latin mass it's so important and here's what they're
01:03:16 saying though because they don't comprehend a single thing not a single thing so what they're
01:03:21 saying is um uh the chants the the bells the whistles the cathedral the way it looks the
01:03:27 robes the tassels the costumes i really appreciate the costumes in this play that i went and watched
01:03:32 it's not substance it's not content it's not precepts it's not truths and even if it were
01:03:40 you can't comprehend them see that the reformed view of faith we're saying faith alone is what
01:03:45 saves and the reformed view of what what faith is comprised of is three basic parts knowledge
01:03:51 assent and implicit trust knowledge assent and implicit trust faith is not merely a feeling
01:03:58 it's not merely um theosis with god becoming one with him and reaching a state of of um
01:04:06 enlightenment yeah it's no faith is um there's substance there is a substance to the things
01:04:13 hoped for the things not seen as hebrew says uh there's there's something that's uh that's
01:04:18 tangible. It can be described. It can be explained. It can be defined. So faith is knowledge,
01:04:25 assent and trust. Knowledge, there's actually an object. It's not just faith in my own faith. It's
01:04:31 not faith in faith, but it's faith in Christ. So there's an object to faith, and the knowing is
01:04:37 knowing the object in which I have placed my faith. So I'm knowing Jesus, certain basic truths
01:04:43 about Jesus, not necessarily everything that can be known about Jesus. Jesus is God. God is
01:04:48 infinite, but knowing the basic tenets of Christ, both his person and his work, his person and his
01:04:55 work, which all that Protestants would agree have been summed up for us in the scripture and then
01:05:00 in summary form in the Apostles' Creed and other various creeds. But I prefer the Apostles' Creed.
01:05:06 I think that that one is one of the most concise and one of the most helpful. So we get both the
01:05:10 person of the triune God and particularly the person of the second member of the Trinity,
01:05:15 Jesus Christ and his work, who he is and what he's done. So Jesus, who is Jesus? If you're going to
01:05:22 have faith, you got to have knowledge of the object of faith. You need to know who is Christ
01:05:26 and what has Christ done. Is he God? Yes. Is he man? Yes. Is he half God, half man? No,
01:05:32 fully God, fully man. These two natures, one person, two natures, these two natures are not
01:05:39 mixed, neither are they divorced or severed. He is the God man, fully God, fully man,
01:05:44 second member of the Trinity, equal in majesty and divine worship and essence, one essence in
01:05:50 the Godhead, three persons within the second person, two natures, full natures, fully divine,
01:05:57 fully human, not mixed, not severed, and that he is the second member of the Trinity in order,
01:06:03 but not order of divinity or worthiness of majesty. He shares an equal essence of the Father
01:06:09 in divinity and majesty, worthiness of worship, all these things. That's who Jesus is. Now what
01:06:15 has he done? What is the work of Jesus? That's the person. What is the work of Jesus? He was born of
01:06:21 the Virgin Mary, incarnate. He lived a sinless life, not just an absence of sin, but a full
01:06:26 presence of righteousness. He fulfilled all righteousness, perfect presence of obedience,
01:06:31 his active obedience as Owen, the reformers talked about, but then also his passive obedience. He
01:06:36 died and he didn't just die as a description or an example of sacrificial love a man who would
01:06:42 give up his life for his friends love has no one greater than this that a man gives up his life for
01:06:46 his friends it's not less than that that's part of it but it's more than that he died as a substitute
01:06:52 he didn't just die as an example of moral sacrificial love he died as payment as atonement
01:06:58 as a substitute behold the lamb of god who takes away the sins of the world he died in the place
01:07:04 of sinners to pay their price for their sin against a holy God. He was raised, not just the
01:07:10 triumph of the human spirit, not just a metaphor, not just his soul, but he was bodily raised from
01:07:15 the dead on the third day. And then he ascended. He didn't just vanish. He went somewhere. He
01:07:20 ascended and disappeared, was hidden from the apostle's view behind the clouds, ascending
01:07:26 upward to a heavenly place, a real place to be seated in honor, in majesty at the right hand of
01:07:32 the Father, and he promises finally to return and to raise the dead, to come for judgment for both
01:07:41 the quick and the dead, resurrection of both the damned and the elect, to separate the sheep from
01:07:46 the goats. That's the work of Christ. So the person of Christ and the work of Christ. And my
01:07:51 point is, all of that, even more concise than I just made it, I did it maybe three minutes, but
01:07:56 more concise than that, in 30 seconds in the Apostles' Creed, any single Protestant Christian
01:08:01 and say they can read that and say i believe that that's the knowledge component of faith that's the
01:08:07 knowledge then the ascent means um i know that ascent goes one step further and says i know that
01:08:12 and i agree that it's true right i have knowledge about the prosperity gospel but i have not given
01:08:18 the prosperity gospel my ascent so i i can i can describe for you the tenets of the prosperity
01:08:23 gospel while not agreeing um and so faith is saving faith the reformed protestant view of faith
01:08:30 is that it's knowledge. Knowledge about what? At least the basics, the lowest common denominator,
01:08:34 knowledge about the person and work of Jesus. Think creed. Not even a whole confession, 0.89
01:08:39 but just creed. It's short. It's sweet. This is the Godhead. Particularly, this is the Son of God,
01:08:44 and this is what he's done for our salvation and what he promises to do.
01:08:48 That's the knowledge. Assent, I don't just know it. I agree with it. And then lastly, implicit
01:08:53 trust meaning uh i know i know it i agree with it and i'm betting the house on it i'm putting
01:09:02 my personal soul at stake i'm not hedging my bets this is what i'm hoping it this is what
01:09:09 because you can you can um you can know about a certain company and a certain stock a certain
01:09:14 investment opportunity and even agree with the knowledge that you know uh that it's a great
01:09:19 opportunity, but still not invest in it. But it's all three. It's knowledge, agreement, assent,
01:09:25 and implicit personal trust. And my point is, that is faith, and that can be described. I wanted to
01:09:32 demonstrate that just briefly for the listener to show. That's the Protestant view, and certainly
01:09:37 the Protestant Reformed view of salvation, that it comes by faith alone, works will accompany it,
01:09:43 but it is by faith alone. We are justified not by faith plus works, but by faith alone,
01:09:48 which will be evidenced by good works because we're born again and can cause to walk in newness
01:09:55 of life and live in obedience to Christ. But it's faith alone that saves. And then what is faith?
01:09:59 The Protestant has an answer. The Protestant can describe for you in detail with scripture
01:10:04 citations. This is what faith is. It's knowing. Knowing what? Jesus. What about Jesus? His person,
01:10:10 who he is, and his work. And it's not just knowing, it's agreeing. And lastly, it's not just agreeing,
01:10:15 but it's trusting it's betting the house on jesus that's saving faith and that is what's required
01:10:21 for justification and so i can i can not only receive salvation but i can know that i have
01:10:28 received that's what the different john at the end of the gospel of john says these things have
01:10:32 been written right if everything was written down the whole world couldn't contain the books these
01:10:35 are just some of the things that jesus taught and did but these things have been written for a
01:10:39 reason what's the reason uh these things have been written so that you might believe so that you might
01:10:44 belief. But then 1 John, when he writes back now in his first epistle, he says, these things have
01:10:49 been written so that you might know that you have believed. The Christian faith is not just
01:10:55 providing substance and evidence, not feelings, but substance and evidence, not just so that you
01:11:01 would believe, but also so that you would, in terms of epistemology, you would have a confidence
01:11:06 that you know you believe. So you're not just a little girl sitting on a hillside with a daisy
01:11:11 in the hand saying picking the petals he loves me he loves me not he loves me he loves me not
01:11:15 leave that for eastern orthodoxy but not the protestant faith we can lay our head on the
01:11:21 pillow and say i know who i belong to blessed assurance jesus is mine amen oh glory is divine
01:11:27 that that's and that means something and i and the robes and the tassels and the nice cathedrals
01:11:32 and the stained glass and the based beard um at the end of the day it doesn't matter those things
01:11:38 they have value. But at the end of the day, we're talking about, can I go to sleep at night and know
01:11:45 that I have union with Christ and that my soul is saved and that I've been justified and that
01:11:52 my sin has been forgiven? It matters. It's not just a trend. We don't pick a denomination
01:11:59 based off of trends. That's silly. I remember me and you, we were at Pride Parade, 0.92
01:12:04 singing songs, preaching, evangelizing. We talked to a Roman Catholic who was there
01:12:09 and I pressed him. I was like, all right, so I want to hear it from you. He was a teacher
01:12:13 at a Catholic school, so well-equipped to answer. How are you saved? When you get to the final
01:12:18 judgment, what are you going to bring forward? And what was he just, again and again, it's a
01:12:23 mystery of how we cooperate with grace. It's a mystery. It's kind of, well, no, we've had 2,000
01:12:28 years and 2,000 pages to get a lot of detail, like you just gave, to know what our faith is
01:12:34 and then to rest our head on it
01:12:36 and not have to punt,
01:12:38 not have to kind of,
01:12:39 well, it's a mystery of how justification
01:12:41 and sanctification of how it works,
01:12:43 synergize the mystery.
01:12:45 There are mysteries to be clear.
01:12:46 There are deep things.
01:12:47 There is a comment,
01:12:48 shallow is clear, deep is murky.
01:12:50 That's actually pretty profound.
01:12:51 There is a depth that is not altogether clear.
01:12:53 You get into some of the metaphysics,
01:12:55 I think too, of the beatific vision.
01:12:57 There is a depth to Protestantism,
01:12:59 but the essentials,
01:13:01 how am I saved?
01:13:02 How should I then live?
01:13:03 they're so crystal clear that i mean we teach them to children right we do that we ask them
01:13:07 questions they answer because they're so clear and mysticism and experientialism and all of these
01:13:13 different things syncretism they don't get you there they're a nice proxy for spirituality i
01:13:18 remember someone telling me like the most spiritual moment in my life was i was just looking out into
01:13:22 the desert in the middle east it was so big and vast i felt so connected with god okay that's
01:13:29 meaningless right like that's just that's just good feelings as you taking in beauty through
01:13:33 your eyes uh projecting onto it a meaning like that doesn't have substance to it don't use
01:13:38 proxies of beautiful buildings don't use proxies of a tradition and wow this goes back so long
01:13:43 uh to substitute to swap out the actual substances there well i've been i've been researching for
01:13:50 next week's article um which will be on witchcraft or paganism or that sort of thing and one thing
01:13:56 is very clear, at least in the U.S., is that in the last 10 or 15 years, more than that, but
01:14:02 decidedly in the last 10 or 15 years, there's been a dramatic spike in the number of people who
01:14:07 identify as spiritual but not religious. And I wonder, I wonder, some of the pull of
01:14:14 orthodoxy, people moving into the EO church, is just a similar symptom. I want something
01:14:21 quote-unquote spiritual not religious not um written down not systematized there's that pull
01:14:31 when you see an eastern orthodox service which is very spiritual which is very emotional it pulls
01:14:37 on those god has given us a spirit there is a sense we want spiritual connection to himself
01:14:43 really yeah um but some of the red pillars are moving into eo and some of the blue pillars are
01:14:51 just moving into wiccan or nature or and i'm not saying eo is wiccan don't don't get that wrong
01:14:58 but the pull of a spiritual experience i think there's some some some similarity there and some
01:15:05 of that is understandable because i think the world is desperate like oren mcintyre has talked
01:15:09 about this but uh and joe rigney has talked about this and multiple guys but um uh the world is
01:15:15 desperate to re-enchant itself correct the enlightenment did a real number on on the world
01:15:20 and uh and the chickens have been coming home to roost um over the past few decades and especially
01:15:26 these past few years and so i think people are realizing um you know whether it be you know
01:15:31 james lindsey and the new atheist you know like like what have we done now of course james lindsey
01:15:36 will never admit that but you know and pretty much no atheist sam harris that they're all like
01:15:40 what we did was good we sought you know our entire goal and we stated explicitly you know
01:15:44 dozens of times was to kill God. And, you know, we killed him, but we didn't want you guys to go 0.91
01:15:51 this far. The left left me, right? When someone like Bill Maher, just for the record, when they
01:15:55 say the left left me, that just shows you that Bill Maher is going to hell. Because what that
01:16:00 exemplifies is an absolute refusal of any personal responsibility and repentance. The dude became
01:16:05 famous. He was already famous, but one of the things that really shot him into the stratosphere
01:16:10 year was a documentary a mockumentary that he made called religious uh religiosity religiosity
01:16:16 religiosity where he went around in the south predominantly and made fun of blue-collar
01:16:22 christians and mocked them for 90 minutes about how religion ruins the world and you guys are 1.00
01:16:28 just stupid neanderthals you know and uh this is the problem with the world well congratulate and 1.00
01:16:33 now he's sitting there complaining that the left has gone too far good dude have some common sense 1.00
01:16:39 wake the hell up what like are you kidding me you sought out to kill the christian god 0.94
01:16:45 and congratulations a bunch of people left the faith we are less christian than we've ever been 0.98
01:16:51 in our history as the united states of america and now they they want to uh to do uh irreversible
01:16:58 surgeries on minors that's you did that bill maher yeah congratulations take like seriously
01:17:04 take some credit bro well done yeah you did that yep james lindsey did that bill maher did that
01:17:09 these guys that's what atheism does um and so my point though is from the enlightenment all the way
01:17:14 up you know to um you know the new atheist of the 90s you know and and and then what we have now
01:17:21 um people are finally realizing okay this was we made a deal with the devil this was a bad deal
01:17:26 and so i think the average person right now is desperate to be re-enchanted they realize
01:17:31 uh uh the science you know uh is uh that science is a cruel master uh that darwin is um is a cruel
01:17:40 priest uh that fauci is is not your friend and and so they're realizing um you know what maybe
01:17:46 the dark ages were you know with religion maybe uh maybe it wasn't quite as dark as revisionist
01:17:53 history has made it to be so people want to be re-enchanted uh but the problem is uh that that
01:17:58 facts and logic, you know, like my facts don't care about your feelings. Well, what people are
01:18:02 realizing is that it's also true that feelings don't often care about your facts. And they're
01:18:07 realizing that both are necessary. It's inescapable that, yes, we need facts and logic. We need
01:18:13 substance. We need truth. We need precepts. There needs to be something that can be touched and held
01:18:18 and felt. But we also do need enchantment. And so I think some guys coming off of just this raw,
01:18:26 rudimentary you know stale white room with the you know with the lab coats and the science you
01:18:32 know are saying like okay like give me some smoke and mirrors because this has just uh i went this
01:18:38 route you know placing you know all my eggs in the facts and logic basket uh but then uh depression
01:18:45 is through the roof suicide is through the roof this is through the roof um so give me some smoke
01:18:49 and mirrors give me some candles give me some incense uh but but i think that's just oscillating
01:18:54 back and forth between two extremes neither one is actually the truth um we don't want to abandon
01:19:02 science and facts and logic uh but but neither do we um neither we don't want facts and logic um but
01:19:09 without any enchantment without any of the miraculous because the world is not just stuff
01:19:14 the world there is spirit that is real um but on the other hand we don't just want um alleged
01:19:22 pseudo-mysticism and spirit, but without any facts and logic or substance. That is the beauty. In my
01:19:30 assessment, of course I'm biased, but that is the beauty of Christianity, and particularly the
01:19:35 Protestant Christian faith, is that the Protestant Christian faith perfectly encapsulates both
01:19:41 material and spiritual, that it perfectly encapsulates facts and logic and emotions
01:19:48 and feelings that it says here's something that can be described and defined and also here's
01:19:52 something uh the the love of christ that will make you weep um this that that is what we need 0.86
01:19:58 we don't need to ping pong back and forth between fauci and and wiccans that is that is ludicrous 0.87
01:20:06 what we could do instead of uh going fauci ruining the world um and and transing kids and then going 0.89
01:20:14 all the way over here to smoke and mirrors and incense and Wiccan and paganism, what we could 0.98
01:20:21 do is we could just stay on the path that built this nation in the first place, the Protestant 0.92
01:20:26 Christian religion. It was not Catholicism. Catholics were here, but it was not a Catholic
01:20:30 project. Jews were here. It was not Judaism. It was not a Jewish project. It was a pan-Protestant 0.94
01:20:38 project. That's what built the nation. That's what will save the nation. We could stop oscillating
01:20:43 between two extremes of facts and logic or baseless feelings go back to the protestant faith that's
01:20:48 where you find both that's where you find truth uh that is the solution anything other than that
01:20:53 will not work that's good so all right well we'll pick this back up is there more that we can you
01:20:58 think we can do a part two part three in the future there's enough probably for 50 parts but
01:21:02 yeah lord lord willing we'll dive back in uh with some more okay and what are appetites for next
01:21:07 week michael you're on on the board uh so gonna be looking at um what does it mean uh in america
01:21:15 that this exact topic of spirituality but particularly witchcraft and wiccan and some
01:21:22 of these dark druidic things are having an explosion a really steep increase the world
01:21:28 wants to re-enchant itself it does yep so we're gonna be diving into that we need to be re-enchanted
01:21:32 yep but not with druids amen all right okay so tune in next week we'll see you then