The NXR Podcast - March 26, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - How the Statue of Liberty Lost Its Meaning

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - The State Must Correct The Church THE LIVESTREAM - What About Constantine, Martyrs, and Persecution?

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 52 minutes

Words per minute

178.1

Word count

20,027

Sentence count

690

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

71

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

For nearly 140 years, the Statue of Liberty has stood in New York Harbor, torch held high, a symbol of freedom and hope. But last week, a French politician made headlines by saying they want her back. How did a monument to liberty become a rallying cry for open borders? And more importantly, what does this shift reveal about the way modern America understands itself? Today we re going back to the real history, breaking down the myth and pointing towards a better vision.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 For nearly 140 years, she has stood in New York Harbor, torch held high, a symbol of freedom and hope.
00:00:35 But last week, a French politician made headlines by saying they want her back.
00:00:41 Give us back the Statue of Liberty, Raphael Glucksmann declared,
00:00:46 arguing that America has abandoned the values she used to represent.
00:00:51 He even quoted the famous poem inscribed at her base,
00:00:55 Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.
00:01:01 But here's the problem.
00:01:03 Those words were never part of the statue's original meaning.
00:01:06 When France gifted the statue to the United States in 1886,
00:01:10 she was named Liberty Enlightening the World.
00:01:14 She was not meant to symbolize mass migration, but the ideals of ordered liberty.
00:01:19 The kind of liberty that could only be sustained by a virtuous and free people.
00:01:25 She was a monument to the political and spiritual inheritance of Christodom, a testament to the unique civilization that made true freedom possible.
00:01:35 Yet over time, that meaning was rewritten.
00:01:38 Lady Liberty was no longer a symbol of Christian self-government, but of open borders and a rootless multicultural myth.
00:01:47 So what happens when a nation forgets what made it free in the first place?
00:01:51 Today, we're setting the record straight.
00:01:53 This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund,
00:02:00 as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors.
00:02:04 You can join our Patreon by going to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries,
00:02:11 or you can donate by going to right response ministries.com forward slash donate.
00:02:18 The Statue of Liberty was never meant to be a symbol of mass migration,
00:02:22 Yet somehow, that's the version of history that we've all been sold.
00:02:27 How did we get here?
00:02:29 How did a monument to liberty itself become a rallying cry for open borders?
00:02:34 And more importantly, what does this shift reveal about the way modern America understands itself?
00:02:42 Today we're going back to the real history, breaking down the myth and pointing towards a better vision.
00:02:49 So, let's begin.
00:02:52 hello hello hello yes the rumors are true it is white pill wednesday our guy our very own
00:03:08 andrew isker the viking he was just recently in florida uh he recorded on tucker carlson's show
00:03:16 it should be airing uh in the very near future and for those of you what do you mean florida i
00:03:21 thought tucker was in maine he has studios in both of those states and apparently florida is
00:03:27 kind of the winter home and so uh both cj angle and andrew isker contramundum they got to go
00:03:33 to florida and andrew isker got to record on tucker carlson's show and so we'll be seeing
00:03:40 that in the near future uh it is a white pill wednesday because of that news but really that
00:03:44 news follows on the heels of other news that we've already addressed but it's worth mentioning
00:03:48 again which is uh that in the span of i think one week maybe two weeks at most but i think just about
00:03:54 a week uh you have pictures of andrew isker uh recording with tucker carlson going on one of
00:04:01 the biggest media platforms in the country in the world and then you also have a picture of william
00:04:06 wolf um with donald trump the president in the oval office most powerful man in the free world
00:04:12 yep and i know it's it's a rough day um for the anti-christian nationalists you know it's a tough
00:04:18 time everybody should check in james lindsey hardest hit yeah check in on james lindsey make
00:04:23 sure he's doing okay um people having a hard time neil shenvey probably having a hard time but
00:04:27 um it has been said again and again and again by the detractors that christian nationalism
00:04:33 and i'm not just you know putting words in people's mouth the the one of the specific 0.96
00:04:38 lines of argument was that Christian nationalism is an acute, fringe, insignificant, pathetic 0.93
00:04:46 little movement of 14 guys from their mom's basement, and there's no way it can ever amount 0.98
00:04:52 to anything. But the Lord, not to try to over-spiritualize here, but we are Christian
00:04:56 nationalists, lest we forget, the Lord does not despise small beginnings. And this seems to me
00:05:04 very much like God's MO, that he would use small things and insignificant people, but to accomplish
00:05:13 great ends. And so God is doing an amazing thing. We're grateful for it. Help us out on this one.
00:05:18 We're basically going to make the argument today that the Statue of Liberty, not from its outset,
00:05:22 not from its origin, but that it was hijacked and very much today has become just a monument towards
00:05:29 porous borders and a full-fledged invasion of the third world. But before we get into 0.87
00:05:36 multiculturalism and all that kind of stuff, before we get into that, help us out by liking
00:05:39 the video. Like the video, comment in the chat, boost the algorithm. If you haven't already,
00:05:45 please subscribe on YouTube and click the bell so that you're notified by all the content that
00:05:50 we put out on Monday, Wednesday, Friday at 3 p.m. Central Time. Three times a week,
00:05:54 the live stream happens 3 p.m central time on monday wednesday friday so subscribe to the page
00:06:00 click the bell to be notified by all of our content go ahead and like this video and the
00:06:04 biggest thing that you can do honestly is share this video help us out by sharing this video
00:06:08 and then the last thing is you got to get ready for the conference the conference is coming
00:06:13 it's crazy to think but uh one week not weeks certainly not months but just one week from today
00:06:19 people will be flying in from all over to come to our conference it's it will be starting one
00:06:26 week from tomorrow on on thursday april 3rd uh we're gonna have a speaker's dinner for the
00:06:31 speakers on wednesday night so one week from today uh you know michael and west and i will
00:06:36 be going and and getting to spend some time with steve days and calvin robinson warren mcintyre and
00:06:42 all you know all the guys uh andrew risker will be there and we'll be um shamelessly um humiliating
00:06:48 ourselves by, you know, uh, going up to Isker and be like, what was Tucker like? What'd you talk
00:06:55 about? You know, we'll be asking all those questions and, uh, you know, and then probably
00:06:59 shouting them from the rooftop, you know, at the conference and telling you, you guys everything.
00:07:03 Um, but yeah, so I mean, this conference is right around the corner. So go to right response
00:07:07 conference, not ministries, but right response conference.com to register right away. And, uh,
00:07:13 we're just, we're trying to, to be as generous as possible. I told you guys, you know, in our
00:07:18 episode on monday uh the cost for this conference i won't rehash that again but uh if if you're
00:07:23 curious um it's expensive and and and we are this is not some huge profit making uh event it really
00:07:30 isn't we've made it as affordable as possible i think uh we have close not quite but like 100
00:07:36 to 200 people uh adults who um are coming for free um because of extenuating circumstances
00:07:43 or whatever some kind of volunteering to help out yeah exactly but yeah so um we're not trying
00:07:50 to gouge people and so even now bottom of the ninth you know it's it's the last hour you still
00:07:55 get a denarii um and so uh we are giving a promo code even now if you go to right response conference
00:08:01 dot com and in the promo code if you type in christ is king christ is king all caps no spaces
00:08:10 then you'll still get 25% off. So we are in our final pricing. The early bird pricing, I believe,
00:08:16 was $130 or $140. Not that expensive. $140. So now it's $200. But that means because it's a week
00:08:26 away. It's late registration now. So it's $200. But if you use CHRISTISKING, all caps, no spaces,
00:08:32 it'll bring you all the way down to $150, where you're only paying a little bit more than the
00:08:37 early bird pricing. So I encourage you guys, we still have some space because we've got about
00:08:42 1,000 people coming. So it's not like, oh, they still have space because nobody registered. We've
00:08:47 got 1,000 people who are going to be there. Praise God. He gets all the glory. But we just got a
00:08:53 great deal on this venue where the venue we used last year, we could only sit about 850 people.
00:08:59 And this venue costs just about the same amount. It might even be a little bit less. So we went
00:09:04 with it and it just happens to be able to fit double the amount so we still have we still have
00:09:08 space so it's not that we you know that nobody's coming to the conference we've got a thousand
00:09:12 people coming uh we just we've got um an affordable big conference venue so we still have space go to
00:09:19 right response conference.com christ is king all caps no spaces in the promo code and register and
00:09:26 then lastly most of you guys have probably made up your mind by now uh whether or not you're coming
00:09:30 in person. So that's for the deep, profound procrastinators in our audience, which I'm sure
00:09:36 there are some. But for most of you, you're like, Joel, I'm not making, the decision's already been
00:09:41 made. I'm not making a decision a week before to come to the conference in person. But I would
00:09:46 be interested in watching it online. Okay, so this is for you. Last announcement, we'll get
00:09:50 into the episode. Go to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries, not conference this
00:09:57 time but ministries patreon.com forward slash right response ministries okay and if you join
00:10:05 our patreon membership at the gold tier silver silver tier gets you ad free content and early
00:10:11 access to our friday special and so there's a value there right now you can get all 10 episodes
00:10:16 of our second season of the friday special with dr stephen wolf on christian nationalism
00:10:20 but if you want the live stream for the conference we're reserving that for the gold tier which is
00:10:27 $10 a month. And yeah, I've said it before. I'll say it again. If you're tight with money, I get
00:10:34 it. You could sign up and live stream the conference next week and then cancel. And it
00:10:39 would cost you a grand total of $10. So $10 to be able to live stream all seven main sessions and
00:10:46 the three panels of this conference. You're going to be getting over 10 hours of content. So you're
00:10:52 paying a dollar per hour of content, and you can sign up and cancel if you need to do that
00:10:58 financially. No harm, no foul. No offense taken. We get it. So that's a good deal. That's a good
00:11:04 deal. Don't miss out on that. Go again to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries.
00:11:10 And again, sign up for our gold tier to live stream the conference, which is again happening
00:11:16 in the first night, first session will be eight days from now, Thursday, April 3rd.
00:11:24 It is coming up quick.
00:11:25 Okay, Michael, you want to take us away?
00:11:26 All right, very good.
00:11:28 Well, some of you probably saw the news last week, and it wasn't the biggest story in the
00:11:33 world, but actually, to me, it was just funny.
00:11:36 It was funny.
00:11:36 But of course, as President Trump is changing kind of the, well, he's giving Americans permission
00:11:45 to be American, to love their nation, and prioritizing America, putting America first. 0.78
00:11:51 This, of course, has been interpreted as this hateful, evil, unkind and uncharitable racist
00:12:00 shift in the American ethos, right?
00:12:05 And so internationally, the claim is being made that America has been rotten at the core
00:12:12 and the fruit is now showing and everything that Trump is saying is simply the rotten fruit of the
00:12:18 dark, polluted heart of racism and anti-Semitism and misogyny, all these things. And so the
00:12:25 international, the liberal international world is objecting in some ways to what President Trump
00:12:32 has been doing and trying to reinforce our immigration, our tariffs, saying that no,
00:12:37 actually America is for America. Just that statement alone has been enough to set the
00:12:42 internet and the news and even international diplomats apparently on fire. And so as the
00:12:47 cold open says, there was one particular member of the left-wing party in France. His name is
00:12:57 Raphael Glucksmann. And he, in an interview, said, well, maybe it's time for France to take the
00:13:04 Statue of Liberty back it was a gift from France originally that part of the history is true
00:13:09 and uh apparently America has abandoned um the spirit in which France gave us the Statue of
00:13:17 Liberty to such a degree that um he is promoting the idea that we no longer deserve it that France
00:13:25 should take it back I think we should and if you're wondering he is yes yes um yeah if you're
00:13:32 wondering every single time rafael gluxman yeah i literally just pulled it up yes of course every
00:13:39 single time but uh what i was going to say kind of in in that vein is uh you can't have the statue
00:13:44 back i'm sorry uh there's a certain point where even if something wasn't meaningful and even if
00:13:48 it was a psyop from the beginning which it wasn't and we're going to get into that right the statue
00:13:51 of liberty itself um i think signifies something wonderful we'll talk about that so you can't have
00:13:56 the statue back um but what you can have back is the plaque the plaque the poem on on the statue
00:14:03 but the thing is that doesn't go back to france if we want to you know if we're talking about
00:14:07 biblical restitution then it needs to go back to the actual source we'll give it back to israel
00:14:11 there we go all right um the irony is of course if the statue of liberty means what the liberal
00:14:18 modern perspective on globalism and multiculturalism claims that it means then france actually would be
00:14:24 the perfect place for the statue.
00:14:25 He's not wrong there.
00:14:26 France still is the bastion of all of the virtues
00:14:29 that are destroying the West.
00:14:31 And so if we were to grant the premise,
00:14:33 which we're not,
00:14:34 that the Statue of Liberty means what he thinks it means,
00:14:36 then actually it would belong in France.
00:14:39 Yeah, exactly.
00:14:39 Yeah, it's like, well, you don't stand for the ideals
00:14:42 that the statue was intended.
00:14:45 Well, no, it wasn't intended.
00:14:46 But the ideals that have slowly and progressively over time
00:14:50 been attributed to the Statue of Liberty,
00:14:52 that is true.
00:14:53 And those ideals, you're absolutely right.
00:14:56 Nobody models those better than perhaps France. 1.00
00:14:59 Like the ideals of getting rid of every single border and allowing your own native people to be completely invaded by the third world and particularly by Muslims and people who hate liberty. 1.00
00:15:12 Then, yeah, in that sense, the Statue of Liberty belongs to no one better. 1.00
00:15:16 It's nowhere more fitting than France.
00:15:18 As France continues to commit national suicide, which is really, it's angering, but it's tragic, especially to the French people.
00:15:31 But yeah, if you guys, you're right.
00:15:33 You're saying, well, America doesn't, America is, we, the French, a suicidal people, gave this to you to ensure that you too would join us in suicide.
00:15:45 And you guys are backing out of the deal.
00:15:47 it seems like, you know, that you've got, you've elected some leaders who at least want to commit
00:15:52 suicide slower and maybe not at all. And so you don't deserve this stat. You give it back.
00:15:57 Those weren't the terms we gave it on. That's right. Yeah. That's basically what's going on.
00:16:00 Well, to add a little levity to this, if you didn't see it, it's worth watching. Well,
00:16:05 you're going to watch it now if you're watching the live stream, but we're going to play
00:16:07 a response from the White House press secretary when asked about this exact question. And I think
00:16:13 it's pretty great. A French politician requesting the United States return the Statue of Liberty,
00:16:20 Raphael Glucksmann, a member of the European Parliament, he says, give us back the Statue
00:16:25 of Liberty to the Americans who have chosen to side with the tyrants. The White House press
00:16:30 secretary steps up. My advice to that low-level French politician would be to remind them that
00:16:36 it's only because of the United States of America that the French are not speaking German right now.
00:16:40 I can just imagine Donald Trump just being like, you know what?
00:16:44 They want the Statue of Liberty back.
00:16:46 They can have it back.
00:16:47 And to actually take it down and ship it back.
00:16:49 Yeah. 0.87
00:16:50 Or maybe just to sink it and create an artificial reef for divers.
00:16:53 Look, we don't need friends.
00:16:55 We don't need their baguettes.
00:16:56 We don't need their statues.
00:16:58 We got our own statues.
00:16:59 We can make our own bread here. 1.00
00:17:00 I want to bring all the bread back to America.
00:17:02 And we don't need their statues.
00:17:04 They can have their statues.
00:17:04 now it pains me greatly to point out historically that one of the reasons why america was able to
00:17:15 win its independence was because france cast his law in with us in the war for independence
00:17:22 the revolutionary war it's a painful memory so we do have to at least acknowledge that um we do
00:17:29 have something of a partnership going back with the french a long way but actually that is kind
00:17:34 of what led to the collaboration or at least the gift of the Statue of Liberty towards us is
00:17:39 the French Revolution, if I'm right, historically came several years after the American Revolution.
00:17:46 And in principle, they said, we want what America has. In theory, they said, oh, except for without 0.59
00:17:53 the Christianity. We'll take the Rousseau, we'll take the humanism, and we will gain our quote
00:18:00 unquote independence and freedom um but in a lot of ways france even though it sided with us
00:18:05 we quickly outpaced it and it even in its revolution ended up kind of looking up to the
00:18:11 american um spirit that had been created when when america became a nation um in 1780
00:18:19 oh now i'm putting me on the spot here but 1776 no that's when we signed the declaration
00:18:24 but i'm saying like when we actually formalized and became a nation in 1788 we ratify the
00:18:28 okay thank you yeah so um there is a little bit of history we do have to acknowledge that uh going
00:18:36 back that far at least we are indebted to the french uh to some degree yeah so we want to
00:18:42 used to be a great people they did yeah there's no denying yep charlemagne charlemagne fantastic
00:18:47 used to be great people they have not been a great people for a great period of time but they used to
00:18:52 be a great people yeah so we want to go over a little bit of the history of the statue of liberty
00:18:57 And I want to say at the beginning, it is good for a man and a church and even a nation to have a reputation for being magnanimous, right?
00:19:09 It is actually a glory to a nation that people from around the world would recognize the prosperity that God has given to us and say, I want to get me some of that, right?
00:19:20 Like it is the nations at the bottom of the barrel that don't have any immigration problems because no one's trying to get in.
00:19:27 And so there is a sense where a Christian nation, if it's blessed by God, ought to be magnanimous, right?
00:19:35 There ought to be a sense of America always considered itself to be a city on a hill, not the Christian city on the hill, but a city on a hill casting a light.
00:19:46 And that's really what the Statue of Liberty gets into, casting a light of some sort to the nations of the world for them to perhaps look up to, to emulate, to try and aspire to be.
00:19:57 Magnanimity is not a bad thing for a nation to have.
00:20:01 In fact, that is kind of the, Joel, you talk a lot about the glory of the husband or the father, the father more than the husband, who will condescend to his children and how even that condescension is a glory to the husband.
00:20:17 And so we don't want to go so far that we say, well, we have no role in the world, actually.
00:20:26 That we as a people, we as a nation have no role in the world.
00:20:29 I think that if we can recapture ourselves over the next decades, we want to assume the role that God has given us in the world.
00:20:35 There's nothing inherently wrong with empires.
00:20:39 But you kind of, that's, to me, I've been thinking a lot about this for the past few years.
00:20:44 like so you know i've gone i feel like i've gone through all the phases of like all right strict
00:20:49 isolationist that's it i've had it you know build build three walls you know and like let's build a
00:20:54 dome you know over america like nobody in nobody out and we don't let the rest of the world just 0.72
00:21:00 crumble you know and burn to ash and that you know it's not my you know not my circus not my clowns
00:21:07 you know, it's not my problem, America. But there is, I mean, God has used empires throughout
00:21:15 history. But here's the deal, you just, you have to make up your mind. You have to make up your,
00:21:19 like, pick a lane. What America, what's been so terrible as of late, and when I say as of late,
00:21:24 I mean for decades, for America, is that it's fulfilled the duties of an empire without
00:21:30 receiving any of the blessings and the rights of an empire. So, we've provided the whole world
00:21:36 with um we've policed the whole world made made the world safe made shipping you know in all the
00:21:42 oceans and lanes you know safe and done this pirates right now yeah and we've done it for
00:21:47 every country in the world to where every country has been lifted up out of abject poverty um but
00:21:53 we've done it for free we've done it for free with no expectation of of of any fidelity being
00:22:00 returned to us no like and i think that's a lot of what trump is kind of getting at he's like we've
00:22:06 like the whole world all the nations of the world have been ripping us off for decades and decades
00:22:10 and decades and we've been letting it happen so i don't think you know the more i thought about like
00:22:13 i am a nationalist don't get me wrong i'm a nationalist and america first 100 and i mean
00:22:18 actual america first not israel first but america first um that said if america we got to get our
00:22:24 you know get the you know clean your own house first so we got to get our own house in order
00:22:28 first um but eventually i don't want to say like you know again you've heard me say this there's
00:22:34 timely principles and timeless principles so when i say america first uh pull everything back
00:22:40 build three walls you know uh millions have to go back let's you know let's focus at home
00:22:46 that's a timely principle the timeless in terms of the timeless um i would be perfectly fine if
00:22:53 if not not today but eventually eventually when things are in order at home and america is
00:23:00 prospering and america doesn't have people pushing uh old old women into uh the the train tracks on
00:23:08 the subway you know and lighting people on fire you know and like okay like if we can get our
00:23:14 house in order if we can do that um then in principle uh i don't have any theological or
00:23:21 biblical argument against um america eventually um being empirical but but if we're going to be
00:23:29 an empire, function as an empire, as an actual empire. Don't just assume the duties for free
00:23:37 so that every other country benefits except for your own people. That's not an empire. That's
00:23:42 just making your own people a tax farm. And then also, if you're going to be an empire,
00:23:47 do not export our sacred democracy. Do what empires do and have a better form of government
00:23:53 that anyone who falls underneath the empire is subjugated to, not democracy.
00:24:00 I do not want a democratic empire that includes nations with people who don't even know how to read.
00:24:07 You're telling me 20 years in Afghanistan, billions and billions of dollars. 0.94
00:24:11 We tried to set it up. 0.99
00:24:12 And leave it there.
00:24:12 And leave it there.
00:24:13 And it was all for nothing because it didn't work?
00:24:15 Correct.
00:24:15 Because the people were not compatible with it?
00:24:16 The people were not.
00:24:17 That wouldn't happen, would it?
00:24:17 They were not fit for self-governance.
00:24:19 We wouldn't waste two decades trying a nation-building project, multiple of them, for all of them to fail.
00:24:24 Oh, we would, Wes.
00:24:25 Oh, that's exactly what happened.
00:24:26 We would.
00:24:27 No, it's funny because sometimes it's like, man, well, you know, all the nations, maybe egalitarianism is true, you know,
00:24:32 because it's like all the nations of the world that, you know, like everybody has like nuclear weapons, it seems like,
00:24:37 where, you know, at least everybody's got tanks and jets and bombs and this and that.
00:24:40 And, you know, like even some of these third world nations, you know, and Islamic nations, you know,
00:24:45 it's like uh man they they really developed quickly because i feel like i blinked my eyes 0.64
00:24:50 you know just like 15 minutes ago they were throwing rocks and now they've got you know
00:24:53 jets and planes and they're manufacturing ak-47s yeah it's like oh wait it all came from us and
00:24:58 russia and russia to be fair okay yeah go ahead um okay so the statue of liberty was originally
00:25:05 given as a gift to the united states from france and it was it was supposed to be called originally
00:25:11 liberty enlightening the world um west this might be a good place for you to talk about um cj angle's
00:25:20 tweet about liberty and probably what they meant at the time and really what's really at stake here
00:25:25 with the way that the definition of liberty has been co-opted in the modern time so maybe we can
00:25:30 pull up that tweet that that west had prepared yes let's pull this up from cj this is cj is a great
00:25:36 thinker really appreciate everything he says and so he's responding through listening to when we
00:25:40 say cj angle we mean cj he just took a picture with tucker carlson angle the one and only yeah
00:25:46 uh so he's responding to joel barry who below this he said basically really it's not left
00:25:52 versus right anymore it's tyranny versus liberty right the key tension today is well you've got
00:25:58 tyranny on the one side and liberty on the other and cj says this left versus right so politically
00:26:04 left politically right is so inextricably caught up in liberty versus and tyranny versus liberty
00:26:09 that this claim has actually always been wrong the claim that oh it's about tyranny versus liberty
00:26:14 it's a contest catch this between different frameworks and meanings of liberty and tyranny
00:26:21 it's important to remember that the 20th century was built on the rhetoric of freedom we talk a
00:26:26 lot about repealing the 20th century there's a lot of terrible things that happened because we said
00:26:30 hey heart seller act we want freedom we want liberty we want anyone to have the freedom to
00:26:34 come here and to be an american so there's a lot of bad things that came even under that word
00:26:39 liberty and so what he's getting at here is there's different frameworks like as an example uh the
00:26:45 christian religion and its prescription for the state we just talked about this on monday is if
00:26:51 you look at it one way tyrannical you can't worship other gods you can't publicly blaspheme
00:26:56 you can't commit adultery it be known and you continue on your life there's penalties from
00:27:01 the civil magistrate so someone today many people today they look at that and they go that is
00:27:05 tyranny a christian state that wouldn't allow these different things that would be tyrannical
00:27:10 but we look at and we say that would be a blessing as james says the law of christ is the law
00:27:15 of liberty there's a lot of talk in the new testament about liberty now what is that liberty
00:27:20 is it liberty to be degenerate liberty to blaspheme like oh my goodness i'm so set free by christ i
00:27:26 can now go in the public square and shout the most obscene things of course not and it's not
00:27:31 tyranny in the true and the good sense in a real framework that we would ascribe to that's not
00:27:37 tyranny at all if anything that's providing them the freedom the freedom to who not the blasphemer
00:27:42 but for a family to go on a walk on a saturday night right and not hear rap music full of
00:27:46 profanity assaulting their eardrums you're always going to be infringing on some level of liberty
00:27:51 so the ideal is not the maximum amount of liberty in every possible thing in every possible dimension
00:27:57 No, it's only going to be a balance of what type of liberty we want.
00:28:01 The freedom to start a business, the freedom to attend a church, the freedom to not be
00:28:04 assaulted by rap music, the freedom to not have your food packed full of dyes and chemicals.
00:28:09 That's one type of freedom that's real and that we're striving for.
00:28:13 The freedom to smoke weed and watch Netflix and do degenerate things, that is technically
00:28:17 in one framework of freedom, but it's not at all a freedom that you want.
00:28:21 And so to simplify it, to just say, well, there's tyranny on one hand and there's authoritarianism,
00:28:26 but then there's liberty and we have to be for all types of liberty you miss the conversation
00:28:31 you miss the tension i would say completely uh entirely yeah and we've covered on this show
00:28:37 quite a bit the idea that um virtue true virtue precludes true liberty right and so when the new
00:28:45 testament says that where the spirit of the lord is there is liberty i know that's a spiritual
00:28:49 principles but the founding fathers and the puritans took that to say well we ought to be
00:28:54 able to live in harmony with true liberty, right? Because the really, and the reason why it matters
00:29:00 that we're framing this as a definitional issue, or what CJ did in framing it as a definitional
00:29:05 issue, is while some people, and I agree with you, Wes, some people would say, oh, a state
00:29:10 tamping down on LGBTQ affirming churches, that's tyranny. Well, the thing is, who gets to define
00:29:18 that right right and if it's tyranny according to biblical standards or worldly standards that
00:29:26 that really makes all the difference in the world so i think i think we could all say that when the
00:29:32 word liberty was used now this was already well into kind of the french project rousseau had
00:29:37 already um there's so many postmodern philosophers for the record yes rousseau yeah michael falco
00:29:43 Peter, Jean-Paul Sartre, Philip Derrida.
00:29:46 Derrida is terrible.
00:29:47 French philosophers have been a terrible lot for us in the last 150 years.
00:29:52 So it's hard to say that when they gave the Statue of Liberty as a symbol of liberty, liberty's light, they probably did already have a sense of kind of this more modernist.
00:30:06 But we're going to reclaim that term, and we're going to go back to the liberty that the U.S. meant, right?
00:30:10 Which is ordered, virtuous liberty.
00:30:13 The kind of liberty that can only be produced when there is a moral and religious, self-governed people who are under the, really the restraints.
00:30:23 The only restraints they have is the restraints of the gospel.
00:30:26 Right.
00:30:26 Right. And so in that sense, I think that many of the people early in Christian history could have kind of gotten along and said, yeah, this liberty that we have as an American society and American people is a good and godly and ordered thing.
00:30:40 And so thank you very much, French government. We do have that kind of liberty. But the Statue of Liberty was given about 100 years into the American project.
00:30:48 It was supposed to celebrate or commemorate the 100 year anniversary of signing the Declaration of Independence.
00:30:53 And I bet if we, to be fair, I bet if we went very carefully, by that point already, I would imagine the definition of liberty and freedom was already starting to change a little bit just through the influence of the European and the French philosophers and postmodernists.
00:31:08 We've got a lot of people in the chat, I keep noticing, they keep saying, liberty from rap music.
00:31:14 It needs to happen.
00:31:15 It needs to happen. The people of these United States need to be free from going into public venues and being assaulted by the most degrading, pathetic, it's hard to even call it music, but sounds that have ever been gone across airways. 0.70
00:31:33 All right, let's do this. Let's go to our first commercial break, and then we will come right back. And I want to point out a tweet that I put out when this story first broke last week to get a little bit into the origins, not so much of the Statue of Liberty, which we'll talk more about, but of this particular plaque, the poem, that has been attributed to the Statue of Liberty and has been on the Statue of Liberty for quite some time. So let's go to a commercial break, and we'll be right back.
00:32:01 our sponsor private family banking wants to help you with one money move that'll implicate itself
00:32:07 in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day they help you to avoid taxation
00:32:13 and to draw compound interest to your money now if you're a high net worth individual someone who
00:32:20 has maybe even 10 million dollars in net worth then they can help you even more w-2 workers
00:32:26 contract workers, business owners. It's all about cash flow and making tax deferred gains
00:32:33 on all your money for the rest of your life. Don't avoid this. It's a big move, but it's a
00:32:38 great time to make it. Click the link below and you can get on Chuck DeLaterrante's calendar
00:32:43 and he'll go over your background and what you want to accomplish. And he's going to help model
00:32:49 a program that exactly fits your needs. So go ahead and send an email to chuck
00:32:54 at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:32:57 Again, that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com
00:33:00 or you can click the link below.
00:33:03 Make a free discovery call now.
00:33:05 Private Family Banking invites you
00:33:07 to join their email list right now
00:33:10 to enter into a drawing
00:33:12 to win two free admission tickets
00:33:14 to our Christ is King
00:33:16 How to Defeat Trash World Conference
00:33:18 that's taking place April 3rd, 4th, and 5th
00:33:22 of the year of our Lord 2025.
00:33:24 Now, you can enter to win by simply sending an email to banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:33:33 Again, send an email to banking at privatefamilybanking.com with the subject line that says
00:33:41 April ticket giveaway, okay?
00:33:44 Then provide simply your full name and your phone contact information, and you'll be entered
00:33:51 into the contest to win not one but two free tickets for our conference. America is a country
00:33:57 that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God and not
00:34:01 to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men. Reese Fund exists in
00:34:05 order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied not just as a plaque on the wall but to actually
00:34:10 be used in business as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey. Our goal is
00:34:16 to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:34:20 We want to find manufacturing businesses
00:34:22 and use them to make sure that we can maintain
00:34:24 our capacity to do things here.
00:34:27 Rhys Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:34:33 Okay, go ahead and pull up that tweet, Nathan.
00:34:38 This is something that I put out last week.
00:34:41 I said, I was reading Matt Walsh.
00:34:44 OK, so Matt Walsh said, I don't want to give the Statue of Liberty to France, but I do 0.63
00:34:48 think that we should remove that dumb poem about the huddled masses and send that to 0.51
00:34:52 them. 0.94
00:34:53 But Matt, I got to say, it should go back to the source.
00:34:57 It needs to go back to Israel, not France.
00:34:59 They can attach it to the Eiffel Tower or something.
00:35:02 America is not an international homeless shelter.
00:35:05 Yes and amen.
00:35:06 So then I retweeted Matt and said, agreed.
00:35:08 The Statue of Liberty is an important monument, but the poem on the Statue of Liberty was
00:35:13 a psyop to weaken America by guilting its citizens to receive in mass all the worst people in the
00:35:21 world. Emma Lazarus was her name. There's the dead giveaway, Lazarus. Emma Lazarus was the poet who
00:35:29 wrote The New Colossus, was the name of the poem. She was the daughter of Portuguese Sephardic
00:35:36 Jewish parents. She was motivated by the plight of the Russian Jews, not just Jews, Russian Jews.
00:35:43 who were detained immigrants at the time.
00:35:47 Emma Lazarus serves as a historical example of the sin of empathy 0.91
00:35:52 and its devastating consequences.
00:35:55 So that's the tweet that I put out.
00:35:58 Russian Jews who were detained at the time.
00:36:01 I don't know.
00:36:02 Obviously, there are broader ramifications than what I'm about to say.
00:36:06 I know that this is not exclusive or exhaustive, 0.74
00:36:08 but anytime I think of Russian Jews, I think of Bolsheviks.
00:36:12 that's like 92 of the bolshevik party so that was the the the bolsheviks and the mensheviks the
00:36:18 bolsheviks were the far left party and the mensheviks were kind of the moderate like 92
00:36:21 of the bolshevik party was made up of ethnic jews at the time which soldier calls out because he's
00:36:26 like wait a second we had this party this movement take over russia violently depose our emperor and
00:36:32 all this but it wasn't even the russian people themselves it was people that weren't native to
00:36:35 us so when you say that like that's the reason historically you're literally saying the bolsheviks
00:36:40 and then jewish who typically comprise that party right so this is a young woman who was working
00:36:44 with immigrants at the time in new york predominantly um russian jewish immigrants
00:36:50 that may or may have not you know may or may not have had ties to the bolshevik early 1900s was the
00:36:57 high watermark too of american communism right like that was when it actually had a chance of
00:37:01 winning elections and that was the exact time this was the end of the 1800s going into the
00:37:05 beginning of the 1900s it was in 1883 that she wrote it 1883 that she wrote this poem and the
00:37:09 context again is she's in new york she's working with russian jews who are immigrants and she was
00:37:14 a self-described femme or uh obviously feminist she was a socialist yeah that was her political
00:37:20 party there you go yeah and um and she writes this poem that has been cited should we read it
00:37:27 quick again yeah we should read it nathan go ahead and pull that up if you can but this poem
00:37:32 uh that has been cited again and again and again as like the empirical infallible proof
00:37:38 that america basically can't be a country we're not allowed to be a country america cannot be for
00:37:45 americans but has to be open to the whole world it's it's basically this poem it's it's not
00:37:51 the exclusive you know um source by by any stretch but it is a chief source that's cited as as
00:37:59 the reason why basically this is how a lot of people think that the world is broken up into
00:38:04 two categories only two um that there are americans and then there are potential americans
00:38:10 right like right it's not like there's america with americans and then india with indians no
00:38:16 there's america with americans and then india with 1.3 billion potential americans as ronald
00:38:22 reagan said he's very well addressed i know anyone reagan did not help can come to america
00:38:26 and be an american and and that's and in the context we've shown that clip before but
00:38:29 he uh he he doesn't just say that it'd be one thing if he just said that in isolation but he
00:38:34 says it in the context of saying that this is not true of every other nation on the planet so every
00:38:39 other country he says you know you can move to france and attain citizenship so you can be like
00:38:44 a beer right you can you can be a french citizen you can be um a citizen of great britain you know
00:38:51 or you can be a citizen of uganda or anywhere else and this is a speech that president reagan gave
00:38:57 I can move to France and attain, you know, French citizenry, citizenship. And I can move to Russia
00:39:05 and attain, you know, Russian citizenship. He said, but I'll never be a Frenchman and I'll 1.00
00:39:12 never be a Russian. But he said, but here's the beauty of our country. Anyone from anywhere
00:39:16 can become an American. And the answer, of course, is no. No, you can't. No, you can by going through 0.99
00:39:26 the proper channels. And hopefully, by God's grace, we'll stop this too for a good 50 years
00:39:32 because we've gone overboard. But eventually, as things begin to settle, then yes, there will be
00:39:40 some mitigated responsible forms, you know, policy for immigration. And by going through the proper
00:39:45 channels, you could attain American citizenship. But you cannot simply move to America and even
00:39:54 be a citizen um and then and then that somehow magically make you an american right that's
00:40:00 simply not how it works if i move to japan um and attain citizenship i'm not japanese i'm a i'm a
00:40:08 japanese citizen and i can love japan and all those kinds of things um and if i happen to marry
00:40:14 in to to japanese um by by taking a japanese wife then eventually my children and i would argue from
00:40:23 a biblical perspective their children now getting to the third generation then they would be japanese
00:40:28 so i can be stayed in japan if they stayed in there they also married japanese exactly to that
00:40:32 that's the way it works assimilation here's the deal one of the big principles of assimilation
00:40:38 even in biblically speaking um is through intermarriage right ruth marries in um rahab
00:40:46 marries in, going somewhere when you already have your family, you and your wife, who is of
00:40:55 your race or your ethnic stock and your children, and then you move to America, and you don't just
00:41:01 move to the suburbs somewhere or some rural plot of land, but you congregate with a bunch of other
00:41:08 people from your native country who have also moved there, and there's 10,000 Somalians in this
00:41:14 small little area right and you're all married to Somalians yeah exactly like I mean that's the
00:41:20 concept of America think about this um the fact that we even have this concept little Italy 0.92
00:41:25 little China Chinatown Chinatown like all these different other countries don't do this
00:41:32 not like we do I knew I knew in Taiwan where Hong Kong Vietnamese area was or where the you know
00:41:38 like they the the they do tend to gather even because Taiwan has a lot of workers from southeast
00:41:44 east asia come to do the menial labor kind of yeah kind of like here so that would almost be
00:41:48 like german irish and english in different parts of chicago that's right more than just we have an
00:41:52 enclave of yeah nigeria or something like that but you're talking about on american soil to the
00:41:57 extent where their whole uh congregants of of people who don't even uh they don't even speak
00:42:04 english right right you know what i mean like like you go into that part of town and every sign
00:42:10 is in their nation's language not because they just got there two weeks ago right not because
00:42:14 they're new um but but for generations they never never actually assimilate in and um so no in a
00:42:21 very real sense none of this is is racism none of this is animus or hatred uh but in a very real
00:42:27 sense if that's what we're talking about then yes those people are not american they may they may
00:42:32 have attained american citizenship they may be american citizens but they are not american in
00:42:38 the same way that i'll never be french and that's okay there's a there's a third category too that
00:42:43 we actually our nation does this too and almost every nation does it and there's just simply
00:42:48 legal residency right right a lot of people go to a country for a period of time right and they're
00:42:53 legally residents there but when i was a legal resident in taiwan i had no expectation that i
00:42:57 was going to be a citizen i didn't get to vote i didn't have any say in the political process
00:43:01 much less that i was going to become taiwanese i was just there for a time period i had the
00:43:06 government's permission to be there that meant that i was subject to their laws but also protected
00:43:10 by their laws and then i was going to go back home to my country like and with that's actually
00:43:15 more similar to the historical pattern over time and that's the biblical pattern the sojourner
00:43:20 was not going to stay yeah and and so when the bible says well you know treat the sojourner
00:43:26 fairly don't exploit him don't take advantage of him like um treat him fairly like that's a
00:43:31 biblical principle and so yes anyone who is visiting the united states legally who is a
00:43:37 visitor should behave as a guest and should be treated respectfully as a guest but you don't
00:43:45 get to stay and you're certainly not an american right yeah none of this is novel all right let's
00:43:51 read this poem yep yeah here's the poem here we go nathan's going to put it up not like the brazen
00:43:56 giant of Greek fame, with conquering limbs astride from land to land, here at our sea-washed
00:44:04 sunset gates shall stand, a mighty woman with a torch, whose flame is the imprisoned lightning,
00:44:12 and her name, Mother of Exiles. From her beacon hand glows worldwide welcome, her mild eyes
00:44:21 command the air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame keep ancient lands your storied pomp
00:44:29 cries she with silent lips give me your tired your poor your huddled masses yearning to breathe free 0.99
00:44:38 the wretched refuse the wretched refuse of your teeming shore send these the homeless 0.99
00:44:46 tempest tossed to me i lift my lamp beside the golden door get that out of my face so hard if 0.74
00:44:56 i was like 17 and i just read communist manifesto for the first time seriously that is a communist
00:45:01 poem it is it really is that is a communist poem probably inspired by a jewish woman working with
00:45:09 russian jewish immigrants in new york um probably with some bolshevik you know inspirations in there
00:45:17 um yeah i mean that that poem i mean literally i just i just read it i just read it as as it's
00:45:24 written and i mean it's basically it's basically a recipe for how could how could this country
00:45:30 what's the best and quickest way that we could destroy this country yeah yeah and the the really
00:45:34 important thing about that is most americans only encounter those few famous lines giving your poor 0.91
00:45:42 your huddled masses and we know that it's attached to the statue of liberty and we tend to think that
00:45:47 the statue of liberty is older than it is and so part of our founding and so the i think the
00:45:52 unconscious connection gets made it certainly was for me for a very long time that this is a
00:45:58 christian principle and it's a principle in line with our founding and the reality is you just
00:46:05 said jul is nothing could be further from the truth right yeah i want to read some sections
00:46:10 of an article and here's a little bit of a white pill well maybe not because it went unheeded
00:46:14 but this is an article that was published it was an op-ed by the washington post in 2009
00:46:21 And this writer, his name is Robert Surrow. He actually wrote a book in 1998 called Strangers Among Us, in which he argued that the only way to improve the conditions of lower class workers and unskilled workers was to stop immigration.
00:46:43 Now, he was still kind of on the liberal perspective, but he was already seeing how terrible the idea of unlimited immigration was.
00:46:51 And so he wrote that in 1998, and then the Washington Post published his op-ed, which I'm going to read portions of, in 2009.
00:46:59 And so it always is good for me to run across people who have been saying things that we kind of are stumbling upon now and to realize we're actually not the first people to tread this ground.
00:47:15 That is good.
00:47:15 One, it keeps you humble.
00:47:17 And I'm painfully aware of that.
00:47:19 I have not had a single novel idea in my entire life.
00:47:23 It all comes from better men than me.
00:47:25 So one, it keeps you humble.
00:47:26 but then two it's also you're right it's a white pill it's not just humbling but it's also
00:47:31 optimistic and encouraging because um it lets you know that you're not alone that you know there are
00:47:37 other people who've been working towards this like i continue to have you know people will reach out
00:47:41 and i have meetings with people and they'll encourage you know us and say hey you know how
00:47:45 can we support the ministry or this that and the other um and then they'll tell me all about like
00:47:50 their story i'll ask like you know so how did you get in and and i always realize that like i'm the
00:47:55 new kid on the block you know like i'm the guy who started thinking about these things three years
00:47:59 ago and they're like oh yeah well i was a part of this society that you know pat buchanan set up
00:48:03 you know 20 years ago and you know me and my buchananite friends you know have this book club
00:48:09 you know and do this and do that or whatever you know and for 20 years we've been talking about
00:48:13 these things i'm like and they're only supporting me they're not supporting me because i'm a genius
00:48:17 because i'm not even close and they know that and i know that everybody knows that but they're
00:48:21 saying yeah but um not everybody not everybody can do what you're doing they're like um so we're
00:48:27 supporting you because you're you're mainstream you're helping to mainstream these ideas right
00:48:32 you're helping to mainstream these ideas we're not we're not um supporting you because you're
00:48:36 an expert there are other other guys who are experts i'm i've never claimed to be an expert
00:48:41 because i'm not uh but what we are doing is uh you're you're helping to distill these ideas down
00:48:47 to the masses, where it's palatable, it's understandable, not palatable meaning that
00:48:53 you're taking the punch out. If anything, sometimes I add a punch or two. It's like,
00:48:57 hey, here's something that's offensive, and I'd like to make it even more offensive
00:49:00 by adding some of my own thoughts. So it's not palatable in that sense, but palatable,
00:49:06 just digestible, understandable, and also applicable. I think that's probably the main
00:49:14 thing that we're doing together is saying uh this this is relevant and it matters it's pertinent
00:49:20 it's applicable see how it would affect uh your life right here and also right here and how it
00:49:25 would change this and see how that matters and how that's a daily thing it's not just theoretical but
00:49:30 it's practical um and so so yeah it's incredibly humbling to know um greater minds have thought
00:49:38 of these things and they did a better job and they've been doing it for tale as old as time
00:49:42 Number two, it's humbling, but it's also encouraging.
00:49:45 We're not alone.
00:49:46 There are better minds than us, but we do need people doing, everybody has their part,
00:49:51 just like a chessboard, you know, there's pawns and bishops and rooks and knights.
00:49:55 Everybody has their part.
00:49:56 And some people, they're the academic, they're in the ivory tower, or they're in the think
00:50:01 tank, you know, and they're brushing shoulders with some of the best minds and they're writing
00:50:06 the dissertations and the long form articles and these kinds of things.
00:50:09 and then other guys are starting their businesses like they're funding it right there's the
00:50:13 millionaire class that has money and can fund you know uh right-wing ideas and and goals and
00:50:20 endeavors and then there's there's media you know there's media guys who are good at distilling and
00:50:26 even within the media guys there's guys who speak to one particular type of person an audience and
00:50:30 then those who speak to another type of like people don't go on joe rogan because he's an expert
00:50:36 right can we just realize that guys you need to understand media for a second okay uh joe rogan
00:50:41 is not an expert right like the guy the thing he's probably most well versed in is mma fighting
00:50:47 and um and the like the dark alleys of 4chan when it comes to aliens like that's like that's
00:50:54 his expertise so why do millions and millions of people watch joe rogan because he's entertaining
00:51:00 so when i say he's not an expert don't get me wrong i'm not dogging on joe rogan that when i
00:51:06 say he's not an expert i'm not saying he's not talented joe rogan is highly talented very gifted
00:51:11 but he's gifted in his field and his field is not the field of being an academic or an expert
00:51:17 his field is is being able to gain the attention and the intrigue of the masses and so guys would
00:51:26 will support someone like joe rogan knowing that yeah joe rogan doesn't he's not an expert on world
00:51:31 war ii and neither am i but joe rogan can get a bunch of people talking about it right by having
00:51:37 daryl cooper come on the show and open it up to this like that matters that absolutely matters so
00:51:44 one be humbled as we're having these conversations there are better men than us who have been having
00:51:49 these conversations not just on american soil in the last you know few decades you know like
00:51:54 pat mucannon but um for centuries for centuries better men than us uh so be humble but number two
00:52:01 be encouraged the same thing that humbles us you're you're not original you're not unique
00:52:06 it's also the same thing that encourages us you're not original also means you're not alone
00:52:10 yeah can i say a brief word on the huge scope of immigration in the united states before we
00:52:14 jump into this yep so daryl cooper does a really good job of explaining this so like the 1790
00:52:19 immigration act for example it's uh any free white peoples of good moral character were allowed to
00:52:23 immigrate we look at that today and we say well that's really restrictive it actually was one of
00:52:27 the most expansive in its time at the time because america was huge if we were just going to be an
00:52:31 english colony as we originally started because there are just not enough english people there
00:52:36 or here right to fill a massive continent so america really really opened itself up and it
00:52:42 said you know whether it be europeans irish or the italians like it opened itself up but after we
00:52:47 filled the country here's what happened we had a trouble turning the spigot off yeah and so we got
00:52:51 into our ethos like there's always room out west there's always you know adventure to be had always
00:52:57 for people that want to settle but once it was settled how do you press the off button on
00:53:02 something that's been in our psyche for 150 200 years and so what you're catching is some of those
00:53:07 those ideas and we look at it now like holy cow we are full there are a million like it's just
00:53:12 it's too crowded we're not being settled anymore but you have to understand they came on the backs
00:53:17 of we've got to fill this country up we have so much to do so much opportunity this land is so 0.99
00:53:22 wonderful so we brought a bunch of people in and we kept letting them in and then as fulham's like
00:53:26 stop it's like no no no this this train doesn't stop like heart cellar immigration act and other
00:53:31 things like that so that's some of the context even for this that there was a time when we needed
00:53:34 more people and now we're in the time where we need less yeah and let me just say real quick
00:53:38 when when west says we're full i i you know i'm post-millennial and um and i think we could have
00:53:46 a lot more people on the planet than what we currently have if anything you know i like elon
00:53:51 musk is a little crazy on some things but i think he's right about this one we the far greater more
00:53:55 more pertinent urgent threat is underpopulation not not overpopulation so we can have more people
00:54:01 um but but we are full uh in terms of you know 330 million people whatever it is you know here
00:54:08 in america america is a huge country huge country um you could have more people but um you need a
00:54:17 particular type of people uh america is full in the sense that for a time there were people who
00:54:23 were coming they weren't they weren't coming for a handout they weren't coming for a blank check
00:54:28 they weren't coming to have you know state provided housing and all these kinds of things
00:54:33 they were coming and it was like yeah there's a wilderness out there and um it's yours if uh if
00:54:40 you can take it if you don't get killed by bears you know and cougars and all this kind of stuff
00:54:46 and if you contain the land and also you know there's also some uh indigenous people out there 1.00
00:54:51 that uh will try to kill you and eat you you're gonna have to fight them yeah and you're gonna 0.97
00:54:54 have to fight them and uh and we are giving you nothing right and uh so you can go out there with 0.98
00:55:00 your family no planes no no no uh you know car to take like you're going to take a wagon and you're
00:55:07 going to go out there and and hopefully you don't die of dysentery on the way just think organ trail
00:55:13 remember playing that game yep like i'm aging myself here but um if you can make it there
00:55:17 without dying and then secure your property without dying and build a house and all these 0.57
00:55:23 kinds of things and not die from disease or indigenous people trying to eat you 0.99
00:55:26 um or bears trying to eat you starvation parasites trying to eat you all the things that want to eat
00:55:31 you um if you can make it then uh then it's yours that is not where we're currently at um
00:55:38 that people are not coming there so my point is there actually is still land to settle
00:55:43 right that like we we could have we could have a billion people i believe that um not a billion
00:55:50 people in the same way that india has a billion people but like we could have a billion not
00:55:54 tomorrow. None of this happens slowly, but over time, I'm just saying theoretically, we could
00:55:59 have a billion people, three times the population here in these United States of America, if it was
00:56:05 150 years from now, and we solidify the core and the ethos of who we are as a people and the stock
00:56:12 of people also, and then built out our posterity from there with a mindset of continuing to build
00:56:21 and develop and settle um and if the government and bill gates didn't own all the land yeah that
00:56:27 would also be key right freeing up some of the land uh then yes you could conceptually have more
00:56:32 people so when west says we're we're full he's not saying that the cultural mandate has ended
00:56:37 that be fruitful multiply has ended he's not giving people license to have you know your 1.5
00:56:42 children instead of um instead of being fruitful multiply well like what i am saying is drive on
00:56:48 35 to austin in the morning and you will go there are too many people that's right because everyone
00:56:53 wants to live there right no one's so much land in texas exactly but no one's going out and starting
00:56:59 new towns and doing this and doing that because we've lost that innovative spirit when trump this
00:57:04 was like what you know well in the middle of biden's presidency but and he hasn't mentioned
00:57:11 it since so it could have just been a trump thing i think i remember him he mentioned like if i
00:57:17 become president again i want to start 10 new freedom cities and like basically it's like
00:57:21 free land if you're going to go in and put the work into building the city and i thought
00:57:25 that is exactly what we need like absolutely and that's what some of the old like presidents did
00:57:31 it's like you you go out here and and you actually we will give you this land yep we'll give you this
00:57:36 land from the louisiana purchase or whatever we'll give you this section of land um but you've got to
00:57:41 take it right you've got to do all the work yourself a couple guys in the chat uh just great
00:57:46 insights i think um so jeremy kearns uh he says how do we have 100 viewers and only 50 likes
00:57:53 hit the like button guys to eliminate the post-war consensus man that's profound i think
00:57:58 that's really good and the defiant baptist uh really great point that heroes uh raises here
00:58:03 he says hit the like button or you'll get dysentery and die in organ yeah and so that's 0.96
00:58:08 I think, I'm pretty sure that's true.
00:58:10 That's not even the worst thing that could happen to you in Oregon.
00:58:13 Yeah, that would actually be a mercy.
00:58:14 That would be a mercy.
00:58:15 You're in downtown Portland like, strike me now, Lord.
00:58:18 Seriously, if you're in Portland and you die of dysentery, that's the Lord's mercy.
00:58:21 That's an easy way to go. 0.99
00:58:23 But great point defined by a Baptist. 0.98
00:58:25 If people don't hit the like button, they're risking dysentery. 0.98
00:58:28 Okay.
00:58:28 Yeah.
00:58:29 So I want to get into this op-ed from the Washington Post in 2009.
00:58:34 Nate, I don't know if you pulled up a version of this article or not.
00:58:37 Yeah, there we go.
00:58:38 So I'm going to be kind of jumping around it a little bit.
00:58:41 So he says this.
00:58:42 I'm going to read a couple paragraphs, and then we'll get you guys' take on it.
00:58:44 He says, I'm talking about, give me your poor, your tired, that poem,
00:58:49 The New Colossus by Emma Lazarus,
00:58:51 which sometimes seems to define us as a nation even more than Lady Liberty herself.
00:58:58 Inscribed on a small brass plaque mounted inside the statue's stone base,
00:59:03 the poem is an appendix added belatedly,
00:59:06 and it can safely be removed, shrouded, or at least marked with a big asterisk.
00:59:12 We live in a different era of immigration,
00:59:14 and the Schmalsy sonnet offers a dangerously distorted picture 0.97
00:59:19 of the relationship between newcomers and their land.
00:59:22 The most enduring meaning conveyed by Lady Liberty,
00:59:25 which is the actual Statue of Liberty,
00:59:27 has nothing to do with immigration.
00:59:29 And I say, let's go back to that.
00:59:31 The statue's original name is Liberty Enlightening the World.
00:59:36 And the tablet that the lady holds in her left hand reads July 4th, 1776, to commemorate the signing of the Declaration of Independence.
00:59:45 Lady Liberty celebrates U.S. political values as a force for the betterment of humanity, as well as the bond of friendship among freedom-loving nations.
00:59:53 That's a powerful and worthy message.
00:59:54 Now get this.
00:59:56 And the message would have been the same if the statue had ended up in Philadelphia or Cleveland.
01:00:02 Both were possibilities when New York was having trouble raising the money for the pedestal in the late 1870s.
01:00:08 France built the statue, but the U.S. agreed that if you get it over here, we'll build a suitable pedestal for it.
01:00:14 New York was broke all the way back then.
01:00:16 What's that?
01:00:17 I said New York was broke all the way back then.
01:00:18 That's right.
01:00:19 Tale as old as time.
01:00:20 Yeah. 0.98
01:00:21 Far from Ellis Island, no one would associate the Statue of Liberty with immigration.
01:00:27 Too bad, because on this subject, Lady Liberty misleads more than she illuminates,
01:00:31 especially with Lazarus's added spin.
01:00:34 In Lazarus's vision, the statue would be called, quote, Mother of Exiles,
01:00:39 and it would stand by the, quote, Golden Door,
01:00:43 welcoming, quote, Huddled Masses yearning to breathe free, end quote.
01:00:47 That is a distinctly political perspective on immigration,
01:00:50 the United States as a refuge for the oppressed.
01:00:52 The truth is that our political values do not explain who comes here or why.
01:00:57 Economic imperatives, this is what you were getting to earlier, Wes.
01:01:00 Economic imperatives, much more than political aspirations, have always driven immigration in the United States.
01:01:07 Planters, merchants, servants, and slaves vastly outnumbered pilgrims and Puritans.
01:01:12 Since the mid-1980s, refugees and asylum seekers have accounted for less than a fifth of the immigrants admitted to the permanent residence here.
01:01:20 The United States draws immigrants for a lot of good reasons, but our political values are only part of the appeal.
01:01:26 When our economy grows, it creates more jobs, and I'm going to skip through this part. 0.97
01:01:30 And then he says this,
01:01:31 Our family legends and historical fact teach us that immigrants have been the ambitious and the adventurous,
01:01:37 the ones battling storms to get to a better place, and they have rarely been the poorest of the people,
01:01:43 if only because it takes money to travel.
01:01:45 Some have made it here with the help of employers and refugee aid programs, 0.97
01:01:49 but even they had to show more pluck than you'd expect from, quote, huddled masses. 1.00
01:01:55 Pluck, I like that. 0.87
01:01:55 Yeah, a term that describes those who get behind, who get left behind, 0.92
01:01:59 better than those who get up and leave.
01:02:02 Grit is another word we should bring back.
01:02:04 Grit. 0.64
01:02:04 Grit and pluck.
01:02:05 Yep.
01:02:05 Yep, absolutely.
01:02:07 What do those words even mean?
01:02:09 Nobody knows, but it's provocative and it gets the people going.
01:02:12 There it is.
01:02:13 All right, that was good.
01:02:14 Interesting to me that the statue was...
01:02:16 Who wrote that again?
01:02:17 This was...
01:02:18 Robert Surrow?
01:02:19 Yeah, Robert Surrow.
01:02:21 In 2009, you said?
01:02:21 2009, yep.
01:02:22 Washington Post published this.
01:02:24 All right.
01:02:24 So, where democracy dies in darkness.
01:02:26 Yeah.
01:02:27 Interesting to me that this was never actually intended to have a connection to immigration.
01:02:34 It was placed in proximity to Ellis Island, and because of the poem, and what I'm going
01:02:38 to read here in a minute, it ended up being associated with immigration, but originally
01:02:42 it was just to commemorate the American spirit of liberty and independence.
01:02:48 Right.
01:02:48 So, yep.
01:02:49 Right.
01:02:50 All right, I want to read a very short reading next.
01:02:52 This is from the same article.
01:02:53 This is just two paragraphs.
01:02:55 He goes on and he says this.
01:02:57 Perhaps the poet can be forgiven.
01:02:59 I'm not going to be so charitable.
01:03:01 Her experiences informed her verse, and she wrote it to advance a very specific cause.
01:03:06 This is true.
01:03:06 Yes, she did.
01:03:07 Yes, she did.
01:03:07 But we do her no injustice by deciding that the words do not serve as an ode to immigration today.
01:03:15 And then this is what we've just documented.
01:03:16 Born into a wealthy family that traced its roots to New York City's earliest Jewish residents, Lazarus was a social activist as well as an accomplished writer.
01:03:26 She lent a hand at the station on Wards Island where destitute immigrants were detained, and she helped set up training schools in the tenements.
01:03:34 When she wrote the poem in 1883, she was a prominent advocate for Jews fleeing the pogroms of imperialistic Russia.
01:03:41 So, already covering what we went over there.
01:03:44 Before we go to the break.
01:03:45 what jews were in imperialist russia well yes definitely the programs i mean we've both listened 0.86
01:03:52 to like martyr maid you know uh fear and loathing in the new jerusalem but uh yeah i mean there
01:03:58 were significant persecution on all ends some certainly bolsheviks but then others definitely
01:04:02 just fleeing right yeah but you're gonna that's the point is that some were genuinely being
01:04:08 persecuted and fleeing right but some we had this huge problem with sicily so little uh island off
01:04:14 of italy and we because of the war world war one we opened up the floodgates to immigration there
01:04:19 so normally there were very strict caps and quotas but during world war one we said well
01:04:22 if you're from sicily there's war going on you're welcome to come in do you know how all the mob 0.95
01:04:27 boss families ended up getting here and wrecked destruction upon our nation so like same thing 0.60
01:04:32 like you have a group of people and many of them i do not doubt there were christian families mothers
01:04:37 children their entire world that they've known has been destroyed there's nothing to go back to
01:04:41 and they flee to america america says there's no cap there's no quota come on in i don't doubt
01:04:46 there were some of those and also who came in were violent thugs that's trump's whole point
01:04:51 about now with exactly you know with the gangs and the trend of aragua and the ms13 and yep so
01:04:57 when it even like comes to her poem and everything like that like like a magistrate can say and he
01:05:01 does no injustice i i pity as a human being right those that perhaps are being persecuted those that
01:05:08 especially are innocent but at the same time we have communism on the rise we are struggling
01:05:13 already with our national identity i'm sorry you can't come in right no injustice no wrong no
01:05:19 wickedness has been done right yep i want to hit this last part of the article and then finish it
01:05:25 up before the next break because this traces how did the statue of liberty become the symbol of
01:05:31 modern immigration and this to me is what actually gets pretty interesting so i'm going to read a
01:05:35 couple more paragraphs from the article it says it took a long time for lady liberty and the huddled
01:05:40 masses to become completely intertwined most of the early mythologizing of the statue played on
01:05:46 its patriotic appeal not on its immigration appeal the poem written for a charity auction that raised
01:05:52 money for the statue's pedestal was never commercially published and got no mention at
01:05:57 the statue's grand opening in 1886 lazarus died a year later at the age of 38 in 1903 her friend
01:06:03 from New York's high society, Georgina Schuller, had the plaque made to honor Lazarus. There was
01:06:10 no ceremony when it was placed on a stairway landing inside the pedestal. For decades, it went
01:06:16 largely unnoticed, a memorial to a writer and reformer who died young rather than a defining
01:06:22 inscription for the statue. Immigrants arriving in New York celebrated the statue, but as John
01:06:28 Higgum, the great historian of American immigration, tells it,
01:06:34 The poem and the image of the Statue of Liberty as a symbol of welcome
01:06:38 gained broad currency only after the immigration ships stopped coming.
01:06:44 The Golden Door was slammed shut by the highly restrictive national quotas
01:06:48 enacted in 1924.
01:06:50 Then, during the Great Depression and World War II,
01:06:53 it became popular to herald immigrants' contributions
01:06:55 in the interest of national unity.
01:06:57 and the statue became part of the lore.
01:07:01 The poem was rediscovered and popularized
01:07:03 as part of unsuccessful campaigns
01:07:05 to open the United States
01:07:07 as a refuge for Jews fleeing Nazi Germany, 0.53
01:07:10 a new version of Lazarus' cause.
01:07:13 In 1945, with that point moot,
01:07:17 Schuller's plaque was moved to a prominent spot
01:07:21 near the pedestal's entrance.
01:07:23 The immigration door remained shut after the war
01:07:25 and the share of the population
01:07:27 that had been born abroad dropped to historically low levels as the Europeans who had come through
01:07:33 New York, Harvard, died. By 1970, the foreign-born made up less than 5% of the population,
01:07:39 a third of what their share had been around the turn of the century. With the newcomers arriving, 1.00
01:07:45 the myth-making went into full swing, and this is what to me is so interesting. Eleanor Roosevelt
01:07:51 quoted Lazarus in an advertisement she recorded for John F. Kennedy's presidential campaign,
01:07:56 And in 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson used the Statue of Liberty as a backdrop when he signed legislation that increased immigration from countries most disadvantaged under the old quota system.
01:08:09 The apex of Lazarus' vision came with the statue's centennial in 1986, a massively commercialized four-year fundraising campaign collected more than $270 million to restore both the statue and Ellis Island, linking the two more than ever before.
01:08:24 at the grand event on liberty weekend president ronald reagan spoke of his belief that the quote
01:08:31 divine provident that divine providence had made the united states a home for a special kind of
01:08:36 people from every corner of the world who had a special love for freedom unabashed he called it 0.95
01:08:41 he said call it mysticism and you if you will one more here the foreign born real quick yep
01:08:47 common reagan yeah yep roosevelt and johnson before very common roosevelt too i have to tell
01:08:53 people all the time because my daughter one of my daughters is named eleanor oh i have a son named
01:08:59 franklin and i have to like people look at me it's time to change names oh i know they're great
01:09:05 names but like all my you know right-wing friends like i'll introduce my children you know at church
01:09:10 you know to a new family that's visiting i'll be like this is eleanor and this is franklin and
01:09:14 they'll kind of look at me and i'll be like no relation go ahead um so nate let's pull up the
01:09:19 quote that I had from you. This is the quote from Austin Bramwell. So in commenting on this whole
01:09:28 issue, writer Austin Bramwell, this is for, I forget which article now. First, he says this,
01:09:35 first, the peoples of the third world are not oppressed in the way that Lazarus believes the
01:09:39 peoples of Europe were oppressed. On the contrary, they have nearly all thrown off the yoke of the
01:09:44 ancient lands of Europe and set up independent governance. In other words, they're coming from
01:09:48 independent nations they have no need for america because they are already free second they are not
01:09:54 homeless on the contrary the peoples of the third world have their own nations peoples and traditions
01:10:00 which they retain when they come here often with the encouragement of their home countries and so
01:10:05 what i really found fascinating doing the research for this was that this was not originally attached
01:10:11 to the statue of liberty yeah it was a political narrative mythology making process in the 70s 80s
01:10:19 and 90s well 70s and 80s especially to kind of justify a push to reopen immigration especially
01:10:29 to countries that were considered to be more disadvantaged at the time can i ask something
01:10:33 without everyone getting mad like freedom like is calcutta india like really that oppressive
01:10:39 like day to day is the average ordinary citizen like he's given a diet with two options like no
01:10:45 opportunity for work and we say this all the time like well they're here for freedom like is nigeria
01:10:49 really like not that free all right just in my mind i there are certainly places with totalitarian
01:10:55 rule and a great example would be north korea but these people broadly that we're speaking about
01:10:59 that are coming here and we're using this language or taping it over with liberty and freedom and all
01:11:03 these things i don't feel like they're actually leaving places that are in and of themselves
01:11:07 authoritarian and restricted they're leaving places that are not prosperous exactly they're
01:11:12 not leaving them right i hear from missionaries all the time uh talking about um african countries
01:11:20 you know where they've done mission work or talking about you know in asia or different
01:11:24 places in south america and they're like there's a ton of opportunity because there's literally
01:11:30 like quantitatively more freedom there's not all the regulation and red tape there's not a lot of
01:11:36 regulation exactly you can just you can just equipment you can just build engineering like
01:11:40 you know like you can just build something you don't have to get all these permits you don't
01:11:43 have there's not all the red tape uh so and they said like there's actually like a lot of americans
01:11:47 who are moving you know to this place or to this place or to this place and setting up shop and
01:11:51 building you know whether it's a resort or or it's this or it's that you know and set it like
01:11:56 there's there's there is literally more freedom more freedom um people are not moving to america
01:12:03 from these countries for freedom they're moving to america to take what has been produced already
01:12:09 by americans because the place they're leaving is oppressive no because it's poor right that's
01:12:14 what it is there is in india there's the caste system and if you're part of the lower caste
01:12:19 it's horrible but those are not the people who are immigrating here because they can't they don't
01:12:23 have the opportunity to do it second what people let's let's take a hard-working person that comes
01:12:31 here to build what they gain in america that they don't have back home is the good chance that if
01:12:39 they build something it's not just going to kind of come in and be stolen by some politician or
01:12:43 gang like so there is opportunity but the security the law-abiding culture that you that the u.s has
01:12:49 traditionally had is actually not present in a lot of places and so someone could build something
01:12:53 but if you can't afford the security or if you're not a u.s investor with a security team or greasing
01:12:58 the palms of the politicians locally there is a sense where you could build and the very next day
01:13:04 it'll be that's true less regulation yeah but also less protection but that's not freedom to your
01:13:09 point west and i think of the example of china for example china is very pro-censorship like
01:13:13 there's stories about its genesis its founding all these like they just they're not allowed to
01:13:17 know so there are certainly real countries where people will look across to america where you can
01:13:22 say and criticize the government where you can keep your wages most certainly there are millions
01:13:26 of people like that who are looking across but of those that we're dealing with the examples i gave
01:13:31 typically we're not looking at those type of governments many many ways because they're
01:13:36 actually they're not very technologically advanced a lot of the mythology was built
01:13:40 when there were um very oppressive dictatorships in central american countries communism was
01:13:47 setting up a footstep or a on our doorstep in cuba and the dominican republic several other
01:13:54 various uh central american countries there was very oppressive forms of government in the 50s
01:14:02 60s 40s and so part of the mythology that was crafted through the statue of liberty
01:14:07 was in a time where we did actually have some fairly near neighbors who were living actually
01:14:12 in a situation where um freedom as we're saying now even of going out and starting a business
01:14:18 largely it was it was quite difficult what we have to recognize is we are living in different
01:14:23 times and people are coming for different reasons that's right than they were before we used to have
01:14:27 settlers now we have immigrants yep times have changed we need to recognize that and honestly
01:14:32 that's that's part of i think properly understanding politics is um it's not ideology it's not timeless
01:14:40 you know one size fits all for all times and all places ideology that you can just just do this
01:14:45 um know that the realm of the political takes in into account the circumstances right um this
01:14:52 this was working. Now the context has changed, and so now we need to adapt, or we need a different
01:14:58 set of laws, or we need a different strategy, because we have different people. We have this,
01:15:02 we have that. Even, and people hate this, but like, this applies to everything, even
01:15:09 the Constitution. This does not apply to the immutable moral laws of God. Those are timeless,
01:15:16 but in terms of of how they're particularly applied to a people in a place in a time
01:15:23 such as the american constitution right like i i know at this point it's ad nauseum quoted again
01:15:30 and again and again but just in case any of our listeners right now think i'm you know what i'm
01:15:34 saying is heresy um and i've never heard the quote um the the constitution was was written and created
01:15:41 for a moral and upright people, religious and moral people, and is wholly unfit for any other,
01:15:48 John Adams. The Constitution, even that mold of government, a self-governed republic,
01:15:57 a constitutional self-governed republic, what that assumes and presupposes is a people who are fit
01:16:06 for self-governance right right we currently no longer have those people right i mean i don't i'm
01:16:12 not saying we don't have them at all i think some people are uh but we are not a nation we're
01:16:16 across the board yeah we're not characterized by that anymore we're characterized by mobs of people
01:16:22 raiding cvs pharmacies amazon delivery trucks and amazon delivery trucks and breaking out into
01:16:29 brawls in you know every high school is has is honestly has more um more fights and and is
01:16:37 arguably more dangerous than a lot of prisons right um that we because you have unruly people
01:16:44 who are not capable of self-governance uh one day maybe we can aspire towards that again but we
01:16:50 always forget that our constitutional republic of self-governance um that that it doesn't just
01:16:57 appear magically out of the ether. It's not in a vacuum. It is sitting on top of a millennium
01:17:07 of monarchy, of pretty strict rule, pretty strict rule where pagans were shaped and formed by the
01:17:19 gospel into Christians, and then with kings and lords. They are then further shaped and tutored
01:17:27 by the law of God. That's one of the functions of the law. It's a mirror. It reveals to us the
01:17:32 holiness of God, and by way of consequence, reveals our sinfulness and our need for a Savior.
01:17:37 The law of God doesn't save, but it's a mirror that shows us our need for Christ. Charles Spurgeon,
01:17:42 a man cannot appreciate the beauty of Christ unless he first comes to see the need for Christ.
01:17:45 That's the first use. The third use of the law is that it's a guide, a compass. It's a lamp unto
01:17:51 thy feet, as David says, a light unto our path. So, for the Christian who already is now converted,
01:17:57 the law first reveals his sin and need for conversion, need for Christ. The first use, 0.88
01:18:02 mirror. Third use, compass, guide. Upon being saved, the law then shows us the path to salvation. No,
01:18:11 from being saved, it shows us the path from salvation. Now that I am saved, not by my works
01:18:16 of obedience to the law, but by Christ's perfect finished obedience on my behalf that was received
01:18:21 fully as an act of grace and faith being merely the empty hand that lays hold of that grace.
01:18:27 Now that I am a Christian, the law doesn't show me how to be saved, where to go to be saved,
01:18:32 but it shows me how to respond for the free salvation I've already received. 1 John 4, 19,
01:18:37 We love because he first loved us. So, because God loved us freely in the gospel, in Christ,
01:18:43 we now cannot help but love him in return. And because we love him, the first question that
01:18:48 that raises, if we love him, is, well, God, how can I show you and demonstrate my love for you?
01:18:56 And Jesus answers this question by saying, obey my commandments. And so, the law comes back in.
01:19:00 So, that's the first, the bookends, the first and the third use of the law, mirror and a compass.
01:19:03 In the middle, you have tutor and shield, tutor and shield. The second use of God's law is that
01:19:11 the law of God, insofar as it's legislated and enforced by the civil magistrate among a particular
01:19:18 society, then the law of God works as a shield, restraining evil of the heart? No, right? Total
01:19:25 depravity still remains intact, but it does restrain as a shield outward manifestations of
01:19:32 evil, evil actions, that more would murder if it wasn't for laws against murder, and enforcing
01:19:38 those laws through the proper sphere, the civil magistrate. So, it restrains outward manifestations
01:19:44 of evil, shield, and then also functions as a tutor, the pedagogical function of the law,
01:19:48 that it shapes and teaches the people. Again, it doesn't convert, the gospel converts, 0.55
01:19:56 But what it does is it, over time, this doesn't happen in 15 minutes, but over generations, righteous laws being applied with prudence and wisdom by the civil magistrate begin to shape the consciences of the people to make them more acutely aware of what is moral and what is immoral.
01:20:16 And then that understanding of intrinsic morality, again, doesn't save people, but sets the proper backdrop for the gospel preachers and the church to do its ministry, word and sacrament, grace, ministry of mercy, gospel, to where now the gospel doesn't fall on deaf ears of people who are already self-righteous, but it falls on the ears of people who have been trained and tutored by the law of God to recognize that in themselves,
01:20:42 even if their law abiding in their outward actions, that their hearts are still wicked and evil
01:20:47 because they have evil desires that breach the law. And therefore, they're aware of their need
01:20:52 for Christ. And so, now the gospel is coming on much more fertile soil. And so, it's hand in
01:20:59 glove. It works in tandem. The civil magistrate with the church, the state and the church working
01:21:04 together, not the state being the church, not the church being the state, but still working together
01:21:09 without this severing that we've kind of invented, there is some overflap and flow
01:21:16 back and forth where they work together, gospel and law, law and gospel. And the point is with
01:21:23 all this, that over time, that with strict laws and with kings and monarchs and these kinds of
01:21:31 and feudal lord systems and all this kind of stuff, then over generations, over a thousand
01:21:36 years over a millennium from King Alfred all the way to present day, then yes, that eventually
01:21:42 trained the populace. And even then, it wasn't all of England. It was some, some people who were
01:21:50 the most responsible, the most fit, the most endeavoring. They took upon themselves the risk
01:21:58 of life and limb to cross the ocean, to go to a place that was unsettled with nothing that was
01:22:03 waiting for them and those people were um were fit for self-governance in a constitutional republic
01:22:10 right look at america today watch tiktok videos and tell me that that our current population
01:22:17 is fit for that kind of governance when i see people trashing movie theater you know what i
01:22:23 think man i want these people voting i need them picking my my mayor my city council no of course
01:22:30 not yeah so we just we have to keep these things in mind um right nation of immigrants no a nation
01:22:36 of settlers and their posterity yes um but but we've got a long road right now to get back to
01:22:45 that and uh a lot of people um have to be returned to their their home of origin and that's not
01:22:52 inhumane it's you have to go back home but then there are also a lot of people who have no home
01:22:57 to go back to this is the only home they have heritage americans and for them um they need to
01:23:04 then put things back into order and become a moral and upright religious people once again
01:23:10 christianity needs to win the day i i i am confident that secular humanism is dying right
01:23:17 i am not confident that christianity is winning right i am confident as a post-millennial that
01:23:23 Christianity will eventually win. But there's a return to nature right now, because things are
01:23:32 out of order, and nature abhors a vacuum, and the left has overplayed its hand. And so people are
01:23:40 saying, no, this is ridiculous. We're going back. So the rubber band is snapping back. Nature is 0.87
01:23:46 healing, as the kids say. Nature is healing, and it's healing fast. And that's great. However,
01:23:52 However, it's worth keeping in mind that there is more than just one worldview, at the risk
01:24:00 of Dr. Stephen Wolfe getting upset with me for using the word, but there's more than
01:24:04 just one set of principles, belief system, that adheres to natural order.
01:24:12 Christianity works well with nature, because it's the religion of the God who made nature. 0.58
01:24:17 but um islam adheres to nature paganism actually adheres to nature secular humanism is the 0.89
01:24:27 abhorition that's the misnomer and it it's quickly sprung up and it's quickly dying um the vacuum
01:24:35 will be filled but i'm just i'm just letting people know the listener you need to be aware
01:24:39 of this if you think that secular humanism dying that that guarantees that christianity will fill
01:24:45 its place, you've got another thing coming. You've got another thing coming.
01:24:50 Or at least a robust Christianity. It could have a Christianity in name.
01:24:54 A Christian skin suit, just like secular humanism did. 0.85
01:24:57 But be nothing but Nietzschean vitalism. 0.97
01:24:59 Liberalism has been walking around in a Christian skin suit for centuries, but it's not robust 0.82
01:25:05 Christianity. It's not historic Christianity. And so, too, paganism could have some little, 0.75
01:25:10 you know, because we've never really experienced post-Christian paganism. So, I bet a post-Christian 0.99
01:25:15 and paganism would maintain some of the language and vernacular and veneer of Christianity.
01:25:24 But my point is, Christianity is not the default.
01:25:29 Nature is the default, and Christianity, I think, best pairs with nature, because Christianity
01:25:34 is the religion of the God who made nature.
01:25:38 But there is a return to nature, secular humanism is dying, and Christianity will ultimately 0.60
01:25:45 win the day, but it may not immediately win the day. There may be a phase, whether it be a decade 0.86
01:25:51 or a century or half a millennia in between secular humanism and Christianity eventually
01:25:57 winning. And that could be Islam, that could be some weird kind of pagan hybrid that could,
01:26:03 you know, a Darwinian, just raw naturalism based in science, you know, and that has no
01:26:09 religious affiliation whatsoever. But the point is, right now, things are in flux and our nation
01:26:19 is chaotic. There are many white pills to go around of things that are hopeful, but there are
01:26:27 very little guarantees currently at this juncture. And we just need to be aware that
01:26:33 my whole point in bringing this up is the idea of the political is not, true politics is not
01:26:43 ideology. It's not ideology. Ideologues make bad politicians. It's not just one size fits all
01:26:53 always for anyone, anywhere, at any time. So this constitutional republic, I just want to be clear,
01:27:00 i like it i would even be willing to say that it might be the the optimal ideal best form of
01:27:08 government but if it is and i'm inclined to say it is if it is the optimal ideal best form of
01:27:16 government and not a raw democracy that crept in later but what the founders intended a
01:27:21 constitutional representative you know republic if that is the ideal form of government um it is
01:27:28 sitting on top of a millennia of monarchy that shaped people to make them capable of that kind
01:27:35 of government. And we don't have those people, not anymore. All right, let's go to our last
01:27:40 commercial break and then we'll come back. All right, the clock is running out. You need to go
01:27:44 and register now for our Christ is King, how to defeat trash world conference. It's happening the
01:27:50 year of our Lord, 2025, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th. That's a Thursday, Friday, and Saturday. And by
01:27:57 God's grace, we're able to provide for you an all-star lineup. We've got Steve Dace, Calvin
01:28:03 Robinson, Oren McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolf, Eric Kahn, David Reese, Andrew Isker, John Harris,
01:28:10 A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, C.J. Engel, and yours truly, Pastor Joel
01:28:17 Webben. Come on out. Join us April 3rd, 4th and 5th, 2025, Thursday through Saturday. Go to
01:28:25 rightresponseconference.com to register today. Again, that's rightresponseconference.com.
01:28:33 Listen, guys, you probably listen to Right Response Ministries because
01:28:36 you take the Dominion mandate offered to us in Scripture seriously. Well, unsurprisingly,
01:28:43 so does Dominion Wealth Strategist. As the only distinctly reformed financial consulting firm,
01:28:50 they help Calvinistic, covenantal, and confessional Christians to steward their
01:28:55 resources faithfully in a way that actually aligns with God's Word. Dominion Wealth leverages
01:29:01 all corners of the financial service industry as independent brokerage agents, matching you
01:29:08 with suitable products and services from dozens of top industry providers. Their mission is to
01:29:14 equip believers to secure their family's future and build a legacy that glorifies God by building
01:29:22 holistic financial strategies that include budgeting, insurance, debt management, retirement
01:29:29 planning, estate planning, and more. In order to make wealth Christian again with a portfolio that
01:29:35 might even put King Solomon to shame, go and take dominion over your finances today by visiting
01:29:42 www.reformed.money and book an introductory overview right now. All of Christ for all of life
01:29:51 and all of finance for Christendom. All right, to wrap things up here, we want to cover a little
01:30:00 bit of some of the costs of, this is specifically illegal immigration. So we are all aware that the
01:30:07 The financial picture and the situation is much broader than just illegal immigration,
01:30:13 but some of those numbers are hard to get.
01:30:16 And at least illegal immigration, the costs of it have been tracked pretty well.
01:30:20 So, Nate, let's put up that first chart.
01:30:24 This is what kinds of households in the United States are using welfare.
01:30:30 Okay, so the percentage is of that group of people, so U.S.-born legal immigrants or illegal immigrants, what percentage of the households headed by someone of that status is using these kinds of welfare?
01:30:46 So, for instance, any welfare at all, 39% of U.S.-born households are using welfare.
01:30:52 59% of illegal immigrant households are using welfare.
01:30:55 And so you can see that across the board, there are a few cases where illegal immigrants are using less than legal immigrants.
01:31:05 But part of that is just because it's based on legal resident status here.
01:31:09 For anyone listening, it's a small amount.
01:31:11 It's like 5% lower in cash, 1% in housing.
01:31:14 So for any welfare, it's 59% of illegal homes are using it, 52% of legal homes, and then 39% of U.S.-born homes.
01:31:24 Food, this is food stamps.
01:31:25 48% of illegal homes are using food stamps. 0.96
01:31:29 34% of legal immigrant homes are using food stamps. 0.71
01:31:33 And then a quarter, 25% of U.S.-born homes are using food stamps.
01:31:39 This is really interesting.
01:31:42 Nate, let's go to the next quote, the one about American taxpayers shelled out a certain amount of money.
01:31:49 so this is um this says american taxpayers shelled out more than 150 billion dollars on
01:31:55 immigrants in the u.s illegally illegal immigration in 2023 alone the department of government
01:32:00 efficiency estimates newsweek reported that if accurate 150.7 billion dollars spent on illegal
01:32:07 immigration would rival the 151 billion that the government spent in 2023 to provide income
01:32:14 security programs to military veterans and their families in 2023 so in 2023 alone just on reported
01:32:21 illegal immigration uh benefits it was almost exactly what we are paying to veteran um security
01:32:30 programs security programs yeah yeah um which is kind of crazy um it just tells you something
01:32:36 about priorities here's the white pill there's not many in those stats but imagine the prosperity 0.89
01:32:41 49 percent of homes that are headed by an illegal immigrant yeah 49 are receiving welfare yeah just 0.88
01:32:48 imagine the prosperity and all of that drops yep to zero yep same thing like 150 billion dollars
01:32:53 like all the taxes that you felt have been so burdensome it's funny we always hate government
01:32:58 but i've said as people like what if government was read by was run by high caliber men like we
01:33:03 hate it right now because it's bloated and all these different things what a government was
01:33:07 efficient it was run by men that were highly competent i feel like we wouldn't hate it as
01:33:11 much our taxes would be much lower because we're not shelling out for all these programs government
01:33:14 is not inherently evil nope it has been evil in our lifetime in many ways run by a lot of
01:33:21 incompetent people right yes but what if well and it wasn't and and not just the amount that you
01:33:25 would save in taxes um also imagine like all all of you millennials in gen z are like i'm never
01:33:31 going to be able to own a home imagine uh what would happen to the housing market in terms of
01:33:35 affordability if a bunch of houses all of a sudden were available like it's it's simple supply and
01:33:41 demand right um if if 30 you know 40 million people go back and and a lot of that just for
01:33:50 the record is just changing the laws stopping uh the cash handouts a lot of people will self-deport
01:33:56 so a lot of people just go back illegal for sure they need to they need to be sent back but then
01:34:02 even legal immigrants who have only been here for, you know, five years or 10 years or something
01:34:07 like that, a lot of them would self-deport. And if the grand total is that ends up being over the
01:34:15 next decade, you know, if you get Trump for four years, then you get eight more years advance or
01:34:19 whatever it is, you know, 12 years, if 30 million people, now 50 would be awesome, but let's say
01:34:24 30 million people end up, you know, either self-deporting or being deported, it's not just
01:34:30 what you save in terms of what you pay on taxes. But it's also all of a sudden, that many homes
01:34:36 going on the market. Now there's more supply than there is demand prices begin to drop.
01:34:42 People who already own a home are fine. And many of them could refinance as as interest rates
01:34:48 eventually start to come down, which I think they will. Inflation, I understand that there's, you
01:34:53 know, you know, I'm reading a lot of these were put the CPI and PPI and consumer data and all
01:34:58 these different things. This is my prediction. This is a prediction. I can't promise you anything,
01:35:03 but I think that the Fed right now, there's a battle between Jerome Powell and Trump.
01:35:08 Jerome Powell doesn't like being pushed and told what to do. And Trump tells everyone what to do.
01:35:12 And I think Trump happens to be right. But inevitably, what I think is going to happen
01:35:16 is the Fed is going to send us into a recession if he doesn't cut rates. He's going to eventually
01:35:23 cut rates. He's going to probably cut them later than he should. But I think we're going to get
01:35:27 more rate cuts than what the Fed is currently signaling. I think we'll get more, at least three,
01:35:33 because recently he's, you know, signaled like one and maybe two. And then we're talking about
01:35:37 25 basis points, you know, a quarter of a percentage. I think we're going to get a lot
01:35:42 more than that because Trump, he's probably going to, you know, Trump barks a little bit more than
01:35:47 he bites. That's part of his leadership, you know, art of the deal and those kinds of things. And I
01:35:51 think it actually ends up being successful most of the time. I don't have a problem with that,
01:35:55 But as that applies to his tariff threats, right, April 2nd is coming.
01:36:01 I think Trump, even now, is addressing tariffs on automobiles and those kinds of things this
01:36:06 afternoon after the market closed.
01:36:08 And I think we'll find out even just in the next week, especially because April 2nd, I
01:36:12 believe, is next Wednesday.
01:36:14 What we're going to find out is tariffs, which I think actually is a good strategy for lowering
01:36:19 taxes on Native Americans and the rest of the world not getting free lunch all the time 0.98
01:36:25 and just benefiting off of America
01:36:26 with us getting nothing in return.
01:36:28 Terrorists will probably not be as severe.
01:36:31 And that's part of the news
01:36:33 that I think will come back in.
01:36:34 Inflation, I think, actually is stalling
01:36:36 and will do much better.
01:36:38 Yeah, there have been some signs of that.
01:36:41 Consumers is drying up a little bit.
01:36:44 And so those are some of the early signs of recession
01:36:46 that the Fed is starting to signal
01:36:48 and economists are like,
01:36:49 we may have a recession.
01:36:50 But that's going to put more pressure on the Fed
01:36:52 to slash the rates
01:36:54 and so with with rate cuts and these things my point is if if over the next 12 years we get um
01:37:01 mass deportations and a lot of them self-deportations because of changing laws and no
01:37:06 more free money and some rate cuts with potentially i think there is the potential of historically low
01:37:12 rates again then you're talking about people who are in homes it's like well i just lost
01:37:17 two hundred thousand dollars of equity well great um you can refinance at a lower rate
01:37:22 your mortgage was already great if you bought your house you know anytime up until 2021 right
01:37:28 um so you're fine it just benefits everybody else so you don't get to maybe you don't get to move
01:37:33 for a few years as you wait you know and you're going to be okay because you already own a home
01:37:39 i'm speaking as a homeowner right now i would rather lose two hundred thousand dollars of
01:37:45 imaginary money equity that i can't use one way or the other if it frees up if it means that my
01:37:52 house is worth you know two hundred thousand dollars instead of four hundred thousand dollars
01:37:57 for the foreseeable future and i like my house and i just stay put with my family and maybe a
01:38:03 year from now even refinance and get a cheaper mortgage with the interest rates and and then
01:38:08 a bunch of people in my church who don't own homes can finally own a home that is that is you talk
01:38:13 about america first that's a win for your fellow americans and so i i think that there's a lot of
01:38:18 hope with these kinds of things. But it does necessitate. A lot of people have to leave.
01:38:24 And I only point that out because of the chart and saying, economically, it's not just, hey, 0.99
01:38:30 if these illegal immigrants and immigrants stop getting a free handout, then we don't have to pay 0.99
01:38:34 $151 billion annually in taxes. It's not just that your taxes shrink. You combine that with tariffs, 1.00
01:38:41 your taxes shrink even more. You combine that with self-deportations, and there's simply being
01:38:46 more supply than demand on the housing market. And now principles are dropping too. You combine
01:38:51 that also with inflation starting to cool and the Fed cutting rates. Trump likes to talk a little
01:38:59 bit bigger than things sometimes turn out to be. But I think he's probably embellishing some in
01:39:05 typical Trump fashion. But I don't think it's a pipe dream. I think he is generally correct
01:39:10 when he says, when he tweets out things like,
01:39:14 you have no idea how much prosperity
01:39:17 and how rich America is going to be in the near future.
01:39:21 And we're not talking 50 years.
01:39:22 In just a few short years,
01:39:24 things could, it really could be economically
01:39:27 a golden age for America.
01:39:29 There's a lot of things to be hopeful for.
01:39:31 Okay.
01:39:32 I want to close with just, Nate,
01:39:33 this is going to be the last quote that I gave you.
01:39:35 So I'm skipping to the last one.
01:39:36 And this is from the House Budget Committee.
01:39:41 This is a testimony that was given to them in 2024 on the cost, again, of immigration and illegal immigration.
01:39:51 And to me, this one kind of sums up where we are.
01:39:55 Because the reality is that the mythology that has been built up around the Statue of Liberty, it matters for a lot of reasons.
01:40:02 But one of the reasons it matters is exactly what you're talking about there, Joel, is
01:40:05 the financial cost and drag that it causes on the country.
01:40:09 And so this was from last, just last year, presented to the House of Representatives.
01:40:15 The fiscal situation today is very different from the situation more than 100 years ago
01:40:20 during the last great wave of immigrants when federal, state, and local government was a 0.90
01:40:25 much smaller share of GDP.
01:40:27 Also, at that time, industrial jobs for the less educated were plentiful and paid, by the standards of the day, relatively high wages.
01:40:35 But none of this is the case today.
01:40:38 We need an immigration policy that reflects current realities, and we need to rigorously enforce it.
01:40:44 Otherwise, the fiscal costs will be significant, understatement, as many communities across the country are currently finding out. 0.79
01:40:52 So, there's a lot of reasons for it.
01:40:54 That's just the classic principle of mess around, find out. 0.83
01:40:59 Sounds like $500 billion more to Israel.
01:41:00 That's what it sounds like for me.
01:41:01 That's all my work.
01:41:03 Unfortunately, Wes, you're not wrong.
01:41:05 Good night.
01:41:06 Are we ready for Super Chats?
01:41:07 Yep, we're ready.
01:41:08 Okay, let's do this quick.
01:41:09 We don't have time today for questions.
01:41:11 We've got some other things that are coming up, but we always want to take a moment and
01:41:15 honor the Super Chats. 0.58
01:41:16 If you're listening right here at the end, be aware that we do our best to get to the
01:41:20 questions in pretty much every episode.
01:41:22 And we do three live streams every week.
01:41:24 We usually address just about, I don't think I'm wrong, Nathan, you correct me if I'm wrong,
01:41:30 but I think, don't we address like 80, 90% of every single question, not super chats,
01:41:34 but just questions.
01:41:37 We hit a lot of them.
01:41:38 We hit a lot of them.
01:41:39 So well over half, well over half, 80, 90% of every single question.
01:41:44 But our policy is we will not receive a single super chat that we don't say publicly on air.
01:41:52 And that's because we want to honor you guys.
01:41:55 Unless it's vulgar or not fit to read.
01:41:58 Yeah, exactly.
01:41:59 Disclaimer.
01:42:00 Yeah, and so I'll just give you that warning right now.
01:42:02 You send us a $100 super chat, but it's something that we can't read.
01:42:07 I'm sorry you just wasted $100.
01:42:09 So that one's on you.
01:42:10 Thank you for the $100, but no, we can't read your terrible thing publicly online.
01:42:17 But my point is just to say that we try to do questions whether you give us a Super Chat or not.
01:42:23 But the Super Chats do take priority because these are people who are supporting our ministry.
01:42:28 And we really appreciate you.
01:42:29 So thank you to Rubicon.
01:42:30 That's the first one.
01:42:31 Super Chat for $5 from Rubicon.
01:42:34 He says, I blame Boomer, IFB, SBC, so Independent, Fundamental Baptist, and Southern Baptist Convention.
01:42:42 Those types with hard, dispy views.
01:42:46 so a hard dispensationalism.
01:42:48 They've spent most of their sermons
01:42:50 preaching against dance halls and booze
01:42:53 and prof on Israel Ruckman teaching.
01:43:00 Prof would stand for what?
01:43:02 Prophesying?
01:43:03 Oh yeah, prophecy.
01:43:05 And prophecy, yeah, that's what it is.
01:43:07 So they're preaching against dance halls and booze.
01:43:10 That's a classic Baptist sermon right now.
01:43:12 Yeah, that is.
01:43:13 and then they're focusing on red heifers and prophecy with Israel in their dispensationalism. 0.94
01:43:23 That's absolutely true. There are a lot of problems that have come from that. You're right. 0.97
01:43:27 Thank you, Rubicon. This is from Jeremy Kearns. Jeremy Kearns, $5 super chat, very kind. He says,
01:43:33 really excited to come out to the conference next week. Going to be a blast and we better have
01:43:40 some beer and psalms. Jeremy, thank you so much. We're excited to see you. Please introduce
01:43:45 yourself. We would love to meet you. And there's going to be a lot of things, a lot of hangouts.
01:43:52 We've tried to schedule in time every single evening and those kinds of things.
01:43:58 There's going to be a good time with the boys. We'll put it that way. There's going to be some
01:44:01 good time. We actually are going to, we have a special custom right response Christ is King
01:44:08 cigar that uh that we have that we're going to be selling at the conference nathan what we have
01:44:14 like 600 cigars okay so here's the deal i'm just going to shoot you guys straight 0.94
01:44:19 if you don't buy these cigars i'm dead you're dead i'm dead no yeah that's that's what i'm 0.79
01:44:26 saying look we have 600 cigars and about a thousand people coming to the conference 0.74
01:44:29 if you do not buy these cigars and i come home with 300 cigars then wes michael and myself
01:44:38 um this ministry will not be able to continue because we your home value will drop not because
01:44:43 of interest rates but because it's going to be like this is going to be straight up c.s lewis
01:44:49 style like a study where like the ceiling was black from all of his pipe smoke um so as a
01:44:54 as a ministry to us and to our health and longevity of life um you guys got to buy the
01:45:00 scars and we're going to give you a great deal on them in fact um i'm thinking about we'll probably
01:45:05 sell them individually but we're also we're planning on giving like a super duper like way
01:45:11 cheaper than even the early bird special um for every that's just available for those who are in
01:45:16 person you mean for the next year for the next conference yep so we actually have already settled
01:45:20 the venue and settled the dates and so we're gonna we're gonna announce that at the conference
01:45:24 here's the place here are the dates here's the you know the the big idea of the conference
01:45:29 and then we're gonna um we're gonna say if you if you register this weekend here while you're here
01:45:35 um if you go and register for the conference it's going to be this incredible price cheaper than
01:45:40 we've ever ever done before um and i think i'm also going to throw in uh if you just show on
01:45:46 your phone that you registered uh then you can go in the back and get a crisis king um cigar for
01:45:52 free there you go and then uh and then the rest will sell for 10 but but anyways the point is
01:45:56 there's going to be a lot of downtime, a lot of hanging out.
01:45:58 All right, another one from Jerry.
01:45:59 No, no, no, hold on.
01:46:00 Go ahead.
01:46:01 The deal about if you buy a cigar,
01:46:04 you are automatically entered into a raffle to win the coffee sit-down.
01:46:08 That's right.
01:46:09 Everyone who buys a cigar, not only do you get a cigar,
01:46:12 that's number one, but number two,
01:46:15 you'll have to write your name down,
01:46:17 so you'll go back to the booth.
01:46:18 It'll be right there in the main conference hall.
01:46:20 You'll be able to buy a cigar and write down your full name,
01:46:23 and all those names are going to be entered into a drawing and we're going to pick how many of them
01:46:29 eight ten ten ten we're going to pick ten of the names which means you can't just buy a cigar on
01:46:36 the last day because this has to happen faster so like first night buy a cigar write down your
01:46:41 full name all those names will be entered into a drawing we're going to select ten of those names
01:46:45 to do a special sit down coffee with me michael and wes yep the three of us get coffee with you
01:46:52 on Saturday morning
01:46:53 before the conference
01:46:54 kicks off Saturday morning.
01:46:55 So that'll be really cool too.
01:46:57 Okay, let's go back.
01:46:58 Jeremy Kearns gave us
01:46:59 another $5 super chat.
01:47:01 Wes, go ahead.
01:47:01 All right, Jeremy said,
01:47:02 what Wes is bringing up
01:47:03 is incredibly important.
01:47:04 Freedom is now licensed for sin
01:47:06 with leftist policies
01:47:08 or mooching off of heritage Americans.
01:47:10 Getting back to earlier, 0.83
01:47:10 I was saying it depends
01:47:11 what you mean by freedom.
01:47:12 Yeah.
01:47:13 So thanks, Jeremy.
01:47:14 Thank you, Jeremy. 0.98
01:47:15 When we beat the Soviets
01:47:17 in the Cold War, 0.96
01:47:18 largely we beat them
01:47:19 because we were offering
01:47:20 rock and roll and free love yeah like in many ways that was you know like we had denim and i
01:47:27 mean yep in north korea like denim is like even seen as like well that's capitalist and that's
01:47:31 like wicked so i mean who wouldn't want to live in a world where like oh at least i can pick the
01:47:35 type of jeans i wear yep but all right uh last one jeff halfley good good old faithful jeff thank
01:47:41 you jeff uh five dollar super chat uh he says in most evangelical circles sanctification can most
01:47:49 accurately be described as mastering the art of testosterone suppression so that's absolutely
01:47:55 right and it's not just in evangelical circles which is bad enough because you wouldn't expect 0.63
01:48:00 that in churches uh but it's the same thing in schools um little boys are not just taught but
01:48:06 they're drugged to um to mimic the behavioral patterns of little girls adderall and ritalin
01:48:16 Yeah. I mean, you can look at the statistics. How many girls are on Adderall and Ritalin by comparison to the boys? We have determined as a society in total, both our churches and our schools and our workplaces at every single level, we have determined as a society that we're going to penalize masculinity, that masculinity is a vice.
01:48:42 Energy, ambition, aggression. 0.60
01:48:44 yeah that feminism is a virtue um where what we should be saying is femininity not a feminacy 1.00
01:48:51 feminine traits in a man but femininity a woman who is feminine that that's a virtue
01:48:57 and masculinity masculinity in a man that that's a virtue um but but we have not done that for a
01:49:04 very long time we want people drugged we want them um placated placated yeah because let's be
01:49:12 honest they're easier to govern yep restrained right young men who are zealous and and uh and
01:49:18 who have not been uh doped up and restrained and long housed and all those uh they can be a little
01:49:23 bit difficult at times to pastor i have pastor and be citizens too yeah they might actually get
01:49:29 you in trouble they might actually even have some views um where where other pastors on the other
01:49:36 side of the world might try to take, take you down in your ministry. Um, like that would never
01:49:44 happen. That's too far. But, uh, no, like that, but the reality is, is that, um, it's not just
01:49:53 the state. That's what I'm trying to say. I'm just agreeing with Jeff. He's a hundred percent
01:49:57 correct. Um, evangelical churches fit the mold, um, at every level, whether it's, um, the teacher's
01:50:03 union and schools, or whether it's politicians with the state, or whether it's the hackling
01:50:10 hens of HR in corporate America, or whether it's the pastors and the true elders of every
01:50:18 complementarian church, the pastor's wives, the shadow elders, in every single place,
01:50:25 politically, ecclesiastically, academically, and corporately with business, in every single
01:50:33 place, we are placating men to make them more easily pliable, that they would be malleable,
01:50:42 that they would be placated and easier to govern. That's literally what it is, easier to govern.
01:50:48 And we don't want that. We want dangerous men. We want those men to be virtuous and righteous,
01:50:54 and they will have to be corrected at times. But there's a difference in correcting a young, 0.55
01:51:00 zealous man versus hamstringing him there's there's quite a difference last one michael you
01:51:07 want to read this cameron stevenson thank you very much very generous 20 super chat cheers to
01:51:12 andrew and cj for being featured on tucker's show wait i thought christian nationalism was dead
01:51:17 back from the dead that's right there's one other question i think from uh soli deo glora music and
01:51:22 they just asked about the book club um what are you guys reading and that's something we thought
01:51:27 about we may do it maybe as a full episode sometime maybe even as a patreon exclusive but
01:51:31 definitely want to do exactly that bring a stack of books and say this is how i read so i take in
01:51:35 information because i think that's a great question yep and i learned a lot of my reading habits from
01:51:39 other people who read better than i do cool all right thanks guys for tuning in god bless you we
01:51:44 will see you on friday uh at 3 p.m central time yep
01:51:57 Thank you.