The NXR Podcast - April 09, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - If This Fails, America LOSES BIGLY.

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Yes, The Gospel Changes Genetics - ICYMI THE LIVESTREAM - Karmelo Anthony, White Flight, and the Bible Belt

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 2 minutes

Words per minute

165.57

Word count

20,342

Sentence count

604

Harmful content

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

38

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

For over a century, duties on foreign goods weren t a last resort. They were the default. Now, in a global economy where everything from lettuce to lithium is imported, the word "tariff" triggers panic in boardrooms and headlines across cable news. To help us break this down, we're joined by Ron Dodson, someone who understands the mechanics behind tariffs, the fragility of modern markets, and what's really at stake in this economic tug of war.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 Before the income tax was ratified in 1913, the U.S. government funded itself the old-fashioned way,
00:00:35 almost entirely, through tariffs. For over a century, duties on foreign goods weren't a last
00:00:41 resort. They were the default. Now, in a global economy where everything from lettuce to lithium
00:00:48 is imported, the word tariff triggers panic in boardrooms and headlines across cable news.
00:00:54 And this month, that panic is starting to look justified.
00:00:58 Markets have swung wildly.
00:01:00 Smaller nations are blinking and falling in line with Trump's tariff threats.
00:01:04 But China and a handful of economic powers are digging in.
00:01:09 This standoff could drag on for months.
00:01:12 And if it does, the impact won't just hit portfolios.
00:01:16 It'll hit paychecks.
00:01:17 It'll hit grocery prices.
00:01:19 And come November, it could hit the ballot box.
00:01:23 Here's the reality.
00:01:24 If this strategy works, it could rewire global trade in America's favor. 0.76
00:01:30 But if it backfires, working families will be left holding the bag,
00:01:35 and Republicans will get crushed in the midterms.
00:01:39 This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund,
00:01:45 as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors.
00:01:49 You can join our Patreon by going to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries or you
00:01:57 can donate by going to right response ministries.com forward slash donate. To help us break this down
00:02:05 we're joined by Ron Dodson, someone who actually understands the mechanics behind tariffs,
00:02:11 the fragility of modern markets, and what's really at stake in this economic tug of war.
00:02:18 So, let's dive in.
00:02:29 All right, GA, good afternoon.
00:02:31 We're glad to be back in the studio.
00:02:34 We took a little bit of a break for our conference, Christ is King, How to Defeat Trash World.
00:02:38 I had a thousand people who came out to participate in that conference.
00:02:42 It was incredibly encouraging.
00:02:44 And we're back and we're ready to go.
00:02:46 And as soon as we got back, we've got plenty of news every single, basically every 30 minutes from the White House with Donald J. Trump.
00:02:55 And so today, as we already announced, we have a special guest, Ron Dodson, who actually knows what he's talking about.
00:03:01 I don't on this subject, but I'm here along for the ride and I've got a few thoughts.
00:03:05 We're going to be bringing him in, but quickly, because we want to get to our guests as quickly as possible.
00:03:10 Michael and Wesley have prepared some charts because if you're not chart maxing we all know
00:03:16 charts save lives right Donald Trump that chart saved his life so if you're not chart maxing
00:03:21 it's like what are you even doing on your podcast so we're going to show some charts and try to talk
00:03:24 a little bit about historically what tariffs you know what we've had in the past and what we have
00:03:29 now and we're going to try to do that in just a couple minutes and then hand it over to Ron so
00:03:33 Michael you want to start absolutely the one thing I want to say before we dive into some of this
00:03:37 historical evidence and charts is that the world is not what it was when the country founded or
00:03:43 even leading through the 1800s. That's obvious, right? Like the government did not need as much
00:03:49 money just as a simple one-to-one comparison. The government did not claim that it needed as
00:03:55 much money to function as it claims it needs now. And so it is a little bit of comparing apples to
00:04:01 oranges if you account for the fact that what the government says it needs is spending for
00:04:06 entitlement, spending for Social Security, all of these things. Nevertheless, I think we all know
00:04:12 it was President Trump who said, well, you know, when President McKinley was president, tariffs were
00:04:17 the main way that we funded our government. And it's true. For most of U.S. history, tariffs have
00:04:23 accounted for all or most, I can't even say most, but for the first couple, you know, 150 years of
00:04:29 U.S. history, tariffs accounted for all or most of the money that the U.S. government brought in.
00:04:34 So, Nate, let's go ahead and start with graph number one.
00:04:38 This is a graph that shows tariffs revenue as a share of total federal receipts, right?
00:04:45 And so you can see that from the very beginning, from the very first Congress where they passed the first law that taxed foreign goods coming in,
00:04:54 it was 100% of our income, the federal government's income.
00:04:58 And then it actually stayed about that high until the late 1800s.
00:05:03 1800s. And then it dropped precipitously. And then we had the Civil War, of course, during that time.
00:05:10 And then a variety of historical trends. And now you see the yellow on the end. And of course,
00:05:18 tariffs account for almost none of the percentage of U.S. federal receipts, which whatever you think
00:05:25 about tariffs or your position on them is they have been a primary way that the U.S. has funded
00:05:32 itself for a very long time. Nate, let's look at number two. I find this one particularly
00:05:39 interesting because it shows the tax revenue as percent of the GDP. Now, I realize that we are
00:05:47 suspicious of measuring all financial stability by just the GDP metric. Nevertheless,
00:05:54 nevertheless, this was federal GDP. And what's interesting to me is that when tariffs were a
00:06:01 much higher percentage of the money that the U.S. government was bringing in, it was, as far as the
00:06:07 entire GDP, a much lower percent. You look all the way to the right there, and most of the GDP
00:06:13 is accounted for by U.S. government spending or taxing of some sort, whether it's some tariffs
00:06:21 or whether it's income tax or whether it's payroll tax, which for those of you who are
00:06:25 watching, payroll tax is things like Social Security, Medicare, that's not income tax.
00:06:31 It's what your employee or employer is withholding from your paycheck to go for some of these
00:06:37 social welfare programs.
00:06:39 And so the surprising thing about this is not just that taxes, payroll tax and income
00:06:46 tax have overtaken the tariff.
00:06:48 It's the percentage of total GDP that is accounted for by U.S. government taxation of some point of some sort.
00:06:56 And I'm sure with with Ron, we can get into the question of, you know, is GDP the best metric to measure the the health of a nation's economy?
00:07:07 But nevertheless, it's surprising. I wanted to show Nathan, I wanted to show just these last three images quickly.
00:07:13 You can just scroll through them as I'm talking.
00:07:16 But this was from the very first Congress, and this was the list of things that they
00:07:21 allowed the federal government to put taxes on.
00:07:24 So essentially, those would be tariffs.
00:07:27 They called them duties at the time.
00:07:29 But they have a very specific list here, and I'm not going to read through all of it.
00:07:33 But for the listener, they have things like distilled spirits from Jamaica, other distilled
00:07:38 spirits, molasses, Madera wine, malt, all sorts of things.
00:07:42 These are products that were coming in from other countries.
00:07:45 And as I understand it, kind of the last bit of historical data that I'll give here, initially, Alexander Hamilton especially was in favor of tariffs because he saw that the U.S. needed protection to build up its manufacturing base.
00:08:01 Even though they had been a colony of Great Britain, they didn't actually have all the manufacturing facilities that they needed to be self-sufficient.
00:08:10 And it would be probable that if goods were available from other countries that already had those manufacturing productivity plants set up, that what we would do is we would just import them all from other countries.
00:08:23 And so Hamilton and others, this first Congress, they passed quite a few tariffs, which was allowed in the Constitution and Article one.
00:08:31 But it was so that America would be incentivized to build up its manufacturing.
00:08:37 So it would be cheaper for the country and for Americans to build a factory and then sell their goods in America.
00:08:43 And it was really quite well thought out that they thought we can't just rely on Jamaica's rum.
00:08:51 We should have rum distilleries here.
00:08:53 And so they put tariffs on foreign goods so that it would kind of cause and incentivize Americans to build factories here and sell their goods here and get the best possible cost for it.
00:09:03 So, Wes, anything you wanted to add about this?
00:09:05 I was just going to say the brilliance of that is you still get the rum.
00:09:08 There's obviously more more necessary items on that list, like shoes, for example.
00:09:12 You're bringing them in.
00:09:13 But what you're offering then to those that are onshore is opportunity.
00:09:16 So, all right, we're having to bring in these spirits or to bring these shoes.
00:09:19 And it's costing.
00:09:20 It's just more expensive to do so.
00:09:21 You've got to ship them.
00:09:22 That's not as safe.
00:09:23 here's an opportunity we're providing the advantage for you to do it here and even still
00:09:28 today i know in a global economy it's very easy to not think about nations and boundaries and
00:09:33 manufacturing but if you think about something is made exclusively in china like for an example
00:09:37 creatine very popular sports product i don't believe it's manufactured anywhere else in the
00:09:42 world except for it might be germany or either china so you have one place where it's manufactured
00:09:47 you begin to think about that especially with tariffs wait if it's being taxed big time as
00:09:52 coming in that's a huge opportunity for me to do it and have no tariff whatsoever and so i think
00:09:57 it's a really brilliant plan that again you're not without creatine you're not without these
00:10:01 things that can still come in but it's it's giving the people of a nation the opportunity to do it at
00:10:06 a much better cost with much less overhead because you don't have to ship it you don't have to pay
00:10:10 tariffs all of that all right super helpful let's go to the expert now ron dodson thanks for coming
00:10:17 on the show what do you think about uh is this going to be like one of those billy madison
00:10:21 scenes where like you were awarded zero points everything that you've said is not
00:10:24 are we on track so far what do you think joel may god have mercy on your soul
00:10:30 go ahead well thanks for having me guys uh i mean you we went through quite a bit in that open so
00:10:41 there's a lot to talk about i think the thing i'd love to mention first is we went originally from
00:10:48 economics as being a descriptive social science to, in the last hundred years or so,
00:10:58 it turning into this prescriptive hard science, and it has failed. And the reason it has failed
00:11:04 is because it denies a biblical truth. It assumes that the individual human is fungible,
00:11:12 as opposed to uniquely created by God and bearing his image. 0.74
00:11:17 And we know that that is the case.
00:11:22 And so economics in this gets to your question of is GDP a good way to measure the health of a country?
00:11:31 And the answer is no, because it assumes this fungibility, this aggregate measure of humanity.
00:11:39 And especially as we've turned into with mass immigration and so on and so forth, a factionalized salad bowl rather than a well-heated melting pot, that's impossible.
00:11:59 So the assumptions are wrong. So that's my, I think Charles Haywood wrote an absolutely
00:12:06 excoriating piece against GDP as a national measure about a month ago. And if you're not
00:12:14 familiar with The Worthy House, I highly recommend the work of Charles Haywood. But he did a very
00:12:20 good, oh, if you listen to it, half hour, 45 minute takedown of GDP as a measure. So I really
00:12:28 recommend that. However, you've got to measure certain things somehow, and it does give
00:12:35 whether or not the federal government should be that which is doing it is, I think, a valid
00:12:42 question. I think these measures would be much better served coming from private sources or
00:12:51 even the states, but it is what it is and it's what we have. With regards to tariffs and the
00:13:00 percentage of income, I think the key thing is, wow, the amount of money our government takes in
00:13:08 is enough. It needs no more. It could do with a lot less. It's just mind-blowing that our
00:13:18 federal government, and this isn't even including the states, that our federal government takes in
00:13:26 over 20, was it close to 25% there at the end of total, if you're going to look at GDP, of total
00:13:35 GDP is sponged up by the federal government. And make no mistake, you know, income taxes and payroll
00:13:44 taxes, it's all coming out of your back pocket. So they can, you know, Social Security, this
00:13:53 quote unquote IOU, don't look too hard into that system or you'll get blackpilled really quick.
00:14:00 It's all just taxes. It goes into the general fund one way or the other and our deep state
00:14:06 spends it. With regards to tariffs as a means to generating income, you know, the world has
00:14:20 gone to a system over the last hundred years following our lead largely in taxing productivity.
00:14:29 Whether or not that's the, I would argue that that's just simply immoral, that the role that's taxing a person's blessing and productivity is the role of the church, or at least the kingdom, the churches being the mechanism of that.
00:14:52 Now, I don't even like calling it a tax. Our tithes are a voluntary free will offering. We've been given this guideline by God. But it is in the taxing of transnational transfers that is the role of the state, because the state is there to protect the borders and protect the safety within.
00:15:15 So I just find it somewhat immoral that the federal government that is distant from us, and we are a collection of states of different peoples, that the federal government would choose to raise its income by taxing us, taxing what we make and disincentivizing income.
00:15:38 That seems strange to me, but we all know the real reason is, well, number one, they could collect a lot more money that way.
00:15:45 But the real reason is, is they can exert a tremendous amount of influence over what we do.
00:15:54 The tax code, if it were simply about raising money, it would tax our top line, not the bottom line.
00:16:02 There would be no all these manipulative exemptions and and deductions, and it would be a low flat percentage.
00:16:14 But instead, we see a tax code that would fill up this room in all its rulings and regulations.
00:16:20 So it's Talmudic. And even that's probably gracious. So show me voting nay against the
00:16:31 entire system. And I think personally, I think the current it's due for a massive rethink. And
00:16:37 I think Trump is serious when he says, look, let's let's have the federal government tax
00:16:43 the world for the opportunity to do business here. And let's not tax at the federal level,
00:16:50 the productivity of the citizens of what a tremendous unlocking of value and talent that
00:16:55 would be. How many people, how many smart, capable, talented people, their entire lives
00:17:02 are given to tax preparation as a way to make a living? And how would they be unlocked if they
00:17:10 were allowed to go into productive industries. I think the questions that have been raised
00:17:25 by the president in bringing tariffs to bear and questioning the income tax is set up to unlock
00:17:33 tremendous amounts of talent and value within the American economy. Now, that can't be done
00:17:40 overnight. It is a transformative process. And anytime you transform things, there are eggs that
00:17:47 are broken when you're making that new omelet. And we need to be sensitive to that. I really
00:17:55 believe that collateral damage in any kind of liquidity event is real. I know some people in
00:18:01 banking, you know, last night, the basis trade about locked up. And there were some people in
00:18:06 my business that were not sleeping well last night, but, and we need to, and we need, you know,
00:18:13 not that we need to be too concerned with the health of hedge fund managers. You know, we all
00:18:19 do pretty good. Most of us do, but collateral damage is a real thing. And we, and we need to
00:18:26 think about that. But that being said, I'm a huge fan of what's going on. I'm a big fan of what
00:18:33 Besant's doing. I think he's very impressive, even though I might disagree with some of his
00:18:38 life choices. I think he is a guy who talks like a trader. He was a very successful macro trader.
00:18:47 He knows the levers to pull. And show me voting eye on all this. I'm very impressed.
00:18:56 yeah cool thank you um so can you this is pretty basic but could you talk just for a moment about
00:19:05 you know i i think the temptation sometimes of uh christians especially post-millennial christians
00:19:12 is well free trade you know and and all taxes are bad you know and um you know somebody makes
00:19:18 something you know a widget on the other side of the world and he wants to sell it here and why
00:19:21 should we have to pay any taxes you know but but as you start to think about these things a little
00:19:26 bit more it's um like it it destroys at some level like unfettered free trade without any
00:19:34 regulations whatsoever is an enemy of national sovereignty uh that's impossible to um to really
00:19:42 be america first if um if there's you know financial incentives for us to export all of
00:19:48 our manufacturing and all of our jobs and all these kinds of things to where you know future 0.52
00:19:53 generations don't have any opportunities that uh they can buy cheap things you know from china that 0.99
00:19:59 break you know in six months but uh but they can't actually get a job with livable wages 0.72
00:20:04 their wife has to enter the workforce every single household is two income uh then the kids have to
00:20:10 be pawned off on the state you know in public schools and grow up to be democrats and you know
00:20:15 rinse and repeat and do it all over again and that's kind of where we've been for a while and
00:20:19 so i you know i i appreciate free trade as much as you know the next guy but um but as i've you
00:20:27 know looked into these things further a lot of my opinions have started to change and um you know
00:20:33 even you know there there are some streams of post-millennial reformed christians where
00:20:39 you know they have a bible verse you know i'm not saying that they don't have any exegesis to
00:20:45 support what they're doing i i know that they do and i'm friends with some of these individuals but
00:20:49 at some level it just becomes financial libertarianism walking around in a christian
00:20:54 skin suit and uh you know like the like the famous gk chesterton quote you know if man will
00:21:00 not have 10 commandments he will have 10 000 to which i would respond yes and amen i i that you
00:21:06 know the spirit of that quote i appreciate and resonate with very much but i can see certain
00:21:11 guys in the industry of finance you know appealing to mosaic laws and these kinds of things but the
00:21:18 real appeal for them is not necessarily the glory of god and the good of his people but
00:21:23 less regulation so that um we can continue to be really rich so all that being said i guess my
00:21:30 question is with all these tariffs it's like yeah it's going to hurt your 401k at least temporarily
00:21:36 and um and we've already seen the volatility you know things bouncing back even this afternoon
00:21:41 or late this morning when trump announced a 90-day pause um with all the countries that
00:21:47 were willing to come to the table and bargain a little bit and play ball. And then increased
00:21:52 tariffs were threatened to China because of their refusal to play ball. And so these things can go
00:22:02 back and forth. The pain could be long term. The pain could also be very temporary and there could
00:22:08 be a V-shaped recovery. All these things are possible. But for me, as a novice, and I admit
00:22:13 that looking in uh i you know i have some investments they're not doing great uh but i
00:22:19 would rather my investments not do great but my son be able to grow up and get a job and feed his
00:22:23 family and so for me i'm pretty pro tariffs and so i guess my question is like like if we just
00:22:32 have unfettered free trade i don't know how to do that without also fully embracing globalism
00:22:37 It seems like sovereign nations are just not possible.
00:22:42 How should we think about that?
00:22:45 Tariffs and nationalism.
00:22:47 I think it's a great question, Joel.
00:22:50 We go back, you know, the godfather of all this is Adam.
00:22:54 Well, God is the author of what really is we call free trade, but it's free price discovery.
00:23:03 even Jesus when he talks about one anothering the the arm length the arms length transaction
00:23:12 where both people are able to say thank you both people are blessed that is a manifestation of
00:23:19 of this free price discovery but it reflects the will of God that men should be
00:23:25 economics in that sense is a God-given thing you know and and ancient but when Adam Smith was
00:23:32 talking about it in a transnational standpoint and he spoke of wealth of nations
00:23:39 what most people don't realize is smith uh was assuming he wrote in the context of christendom
00:23:47 and he assumed uh common presuppositions with your trading partners and what does that mean
00:23:53 presuppositions well these are just common the common uh basic values we would say some people
00:24:01 you know in uh we used to have a you know worldview was kind of there's problems with
00:24:07 that term but but you'd say we have common worldview view of the world of why what is
00:24:14 what conservatives would say need to be conserved we we hold none of that in common
00:24:20 with the chinese communist party and i've got absolutely let me be perfectly clear before i
00:24:27 go down this road because because i'm going to say some pretty direct things but i have
00:24:33 no quarrel with the chinese people my uh we used to host uh we used to host chinese exchange
00:24:41 students i had i had the daughter of a communist party official stay in my house she came to faith
00:24:48 in Christ while staying with us. I have my two goddaughters are Chinese. I have a great love
00:24:56 for the people. The Han are an incredibly gifted people. That being said, you know, through no
00:25:09 help of ours, because we abandoned Chiang Kai-shek and may have been prudent, I don't know.
00:25:17 I don't think it was. But the communist Mao took over and the communists won that deal. And these are not the regime that rules China. These are not our presuppositional partners. These are not people who would agree with what we would consider should be the basics of life and should be conserved.
00:25:41 So Adam Smith would think it crazy that that China, number one, was admitted to the, you know, to the World Economic Forum and given full trading partner status, even understanding why why Nixon did certain things back in the 70s.
00:26:04 I'm speaking of the of the changes that came about in the later on in the 90s. Adam Smith would have would have never countenanced that. And so so our understanding of free trade is is is a is kind of a bastardization of of of what would be Christian wealth of nation understanding.
00:26:27 So let's take that. Should the United States have a commonwealth with other Christian nations 0.61
00:26:36 eventually to where we generally have open trade among the Christian brotherhood, so to speak?
00:26:45 I'm great with that. Absolutely. But free trade in its modern understanding of frictionless
00:26:53 capital movements at light speed that are borderless does nothing but hollow out,
00:27:03 as you said, national sovereignty. And again, hey, look, my industry is largely based on this
00:27:12 of finding arbitrage across national boundaries, setting up a rentier relationship there and then
00:27:22 levering it to the hilt. It's not what I do, but that is hedge fund 101, but it's not good.
00:27:32 Just for disclosure purposes, I do statistical volatility arbitrage. So I basically sell
00:27:40 insurance into the market. So I would like to think of myself as a good guy, but just for
00:27:49 For clarity's sake, but Nick Land, I don't know if you're familiar with Nick Land, if
00:27:55 your listeners and viewers, Nick Land, continental English philosopher, prominent in the last,
00:28:04 probably one of the more prominent philosophers of the last 30 years or so. Nick's a couple
00:28:10 years older than me, 60, has written a ton on this about how these capital being able to move
00:28:21 across borders, what that has done, and I'm going to simplify, Nick is a very esoteric writer,
00:28:29 but what he said is, is that has basically meant that dollars are now that have a truer
00:28:38 citizens have the true rights of citizenship more than the citizens themselves because dollars have
00:28:46 more rights than citizens okay so that and that's a it's it's very much related to corporate
00:28:54 personhood and we can talk about that as well but these things absolutely erode as as international
00:29:02 frictionless capital movements, free trade, we can call it that, as that has risen in importance
00:29:10 and the Eurodollar market has risen, and those are just dollars that are created by banks
00:29:16 offshore with no supervision of the U.S. Federal Reserve, whether you're a fan or not of the
00:29:23 Federal Reserve, it's the system we have. Those notes are Federal Reserve notes. And so the
00:29:28 federal, we should have some governing authority over them. But as this is all moved, you've seen
00:29:34 with it the erosion of the rights of U.S. citizens. So this whole process is known as, in a way,
00:29:44 as financial Dutch disease. And the Dutch disease is named after, in Holland in the late 60s,
00:29:54 early 70s they found in in in dutch territorial waters they found tremendous reserves of natural
00:30:00 gas and and traditionally holland is one of the bread baskets of europe uh it was really a farming
00:30:07 nation and uh you know the the the the netherlands the the hot the lowlands of europe which is in
00:30:16 very well watered and very fertile soil but when these natural gas reserves were found the entire
00:30:22 economy pivoted and all the talent went towards natural gas and it hollowed out the rest of the
00:30:29 nation. Well, we've seen that in the United States with the financialization, this financialization
00:30:36 of the U.S. economy to where if you're a smart, if you're very, very smart and you go to a top
00:30:44 university, you're going to study finance and you're going to go into this industry to where
00:30:50 all of the other industries are hollowed out and what is our dutch disease what's the if it was
00:30:57 natural gas for holland what's our dutch disease it's the dollar itself and so um even to the point
00:31:05 of you say well hey the country makes uh has always produced great art and entertainment
00:31:10 our movie business is the greatest in the world when was the last time you went and saw a something
00:31:16 that was a uniquely american uh comedy for instance it's all this you know now we have
00:31:24 superhero movies that are slop that that are slop exactly it's and so so i completely agree now
00:31:34 again if we have common a commonwealth of nations that agree with with us and are
00:31:42 something we need to get in later on the show, geographically tied to us, would it be great
00:31:51 if Canada and Mexico and Ecuador could rise up and be great Christian nations and together we had a
00:32:02 true Christian commonwealth that was tied to us geographically that we could have some level
00:32:08 of freer trade with? Well, sure, I'm great with that. We're a long ways from that right now. I
00:32:14 mean, Canada has turned into a, you know, communism light. And I have lots of friends. By the way,
00:32:20 my wife's from Canada. My kids have, you know, in theory, have Canadian citizenship. They don't
00:32:26 want, I mean, you know, whatever. But I have a real love for the people and traditional Canadian
00:32:33 culture up there it was a great christian nation at once upon a time but we're far from that now 0.99
00:32:38 and in mexico is a one step away from a failed narco state so so but but that would be that
00:32:46 would be the goal is is is moving towards something like that okay i've talked long
00:32:52 enough i'm sure y'all have some thoughts no that's good west you got some thoughts i was
00:32:57 gonna say that's profound that point that you made about being the dollar being the citizen
00:33:01 of the world the 70s and the 80s and 90s you have a market that 24 7 is awake now it wouldn't
00:33:08 necessarily be the stock exchange but all across the world you have trade happening you have money
00:33:13 that can move at the speed of light this is a profound technological turning that our grandparents
00:33:19 just didn't live through never before in human history would you know what's happening in china 0.77
00:33:24 would you be aware of their impending real estate crash would you then be as you think i used to
00:33:29 work for like biotechs when i worked in consulting and i mean in their mind is do we do manufacturing
00:33:34 in the netherlands do we do it in india never before in human history would you have this kind
00:33:38 of global frame of things and i don't think it's at all a coincidence that you have these global
00:33:42 markets you have instant money moving you have your question of i can get this labor i can get
00:33:47 these parts i can get this done for pennies on the dollar and as that happens as that grows and
00:33:52 people see of course the margins on it that all of a sudden we come to a place where americans have
00:33:56 no identity of themselves and it's of course we're interconnected in so many ways to the rest of the
00:34:01 world in a way that's probably not possible for human beings to do well it's impossible to be a
00:34:06 citizen of the world to appreciate every culture to know every place to track every market we're
00:34:10 just we're human we're limited not as a result of the fall so something like the fall creaturely
00:34:15 exactly introduces to us like oh now we couldn't contain or comprehend all this information we're
00:34:21 just we're creatures and we weren't meant i don't think to be interconnected to eight million people
00:34:26 to dozens of financial markets 8 billion people dozens of financial markets billions of dollars
00:34:31 of transaction all the news all the events everything going on and trying to do so has
00:34:36 eroded i mean in many ways for one a sense of place this is home these are my people but we
00:34:42 can do what i love you're forgetting there's 330 million americans and then there's you know like
00:34:49 eight billion potential americans right so we're all american these are all our neighbors we can
00:34:55 him do it being a little bit sarcastic there michael i want to hear your thoughts and then
00:34:59 real quickly i want to hit a couple super chats and one question from neville that i thought was
00:35:03 insightful and let ron answer that question but what are your thoughts well my thought is maybe
00:35:07 it's actually just a follow-up for ron maybe you could touch on briefly um you know we on the on
00:35:13 the show we often talk about what we think would be the ideal but what it what would be a viable
00:35:19 alternative is tariffs the viable alternative to this sort of globalist free trade that still is
00:35:26 global markets it's just controlled global markets and so is there any returning like i agree with
00:35:32 what wes is saying but there's also the the statement that we come back to all the time well
00:35:37 the tubes out of the toothpaste uh you know what is there a viable years or decades long alternative
00:35:46 that we ought to be building towards that would be something different than the almighty dollar
00:35:53 working 24-7 global markets, tracking stock exchanges in Japan, all of these things that
00:36:01 we're talking about? I understand what we say, this is not ideal, but what do we do about that?
00:36:07 What are alternatives that could be built towards?
00:36:10 well that's a that's a big question i again i i don't have a problem with for instance uh
00:36:19 certain rare earths and certain uh other minerals are only god only put in certain places i mean if
00:36:26 you're gonna you know uh uh although i think there's a quite a bit of titanium maybe in
00:36:33 tennessee we've made it to where it's almost impossible to mine in this country so if you're
00:36:38 to get titanium i think you got to go to russia right now uh for instance in rare earths uh well
00:36:44 that's uh you know that's eastern ukraine uh a lot of the rare earth minerals in in china uh if
00:36:51 you're gonna so so uh you know copper and beryllium i think it's uh south america somewhere again
00:36:57 mining's not my game but but god distributed these things i mean forever you know all the
00:37:03 petrochemicals that was in uh the persian gulf now now they're all in my state uh texas um but uh
00:37:11 they're the so so i i think the the goal isn't hey we do away with trade
00:37:19 that's not the idea that the idea is that is that
00:37:25 is that you is that you can't have frictionless capital movements without having
00:37:34 the erasure of borders and again this is coming from somebody who grew up I mean I was a member
00:37:41 of the Ludwig von Mises society you know I grew up reading uh Hayek and von Mises you know I have
00:37:48 price and theory on my bookshelf at home. I really came to a modern understanding. This
00:37:55 is in the early 90s. Yes, I was a nerd. I was reading Hans Hermann Hoppe, who I still find
00:38:03 absolutely breathtakingly brilliant. I think that movement went off the rails when it went
00:38:10 the anarcho-capitalist way because because because the the idea moved from the trading of goods to
00:38:24 to which is good trade is not a bad thing i believe god wants us to trade the problem is
00:38:32 is that if is that if i only have to move this fiat currency then i'm not really invested
00:38:44 i am i i am i am just playing a game and and this i mean this is going to get philosophical and i
00:38:50 don't mean to get pie in the sky but it's it's think about how our capital markets work in the
00:38:56 the U.S. now. Everybody owns everything. No one, very few people buy individual stocks anymore.
00:39:06 You go and buy the S&P and you buy the NASDAQ. We're buying the spiders and we're buying the
00:39:11 cubes and we're so on and so forth. Well, I used to think that everybody owning everything was
00:39:17 called communism and so there's no there's no there's no responsibility and investment just
00:39:27 isn't my dollars it's not just rentier rentier just means i have dollars that i can use to
00:39:34 without work soak up value okay it's not a good thing traditionally you want as little rentier
00:39:42 opportunity and an effective economy as possible. What you want is, because there was a certain
00:39:49 faction that found rentier opportunities and levered those up with usurious rates and you
00:39:57 create these massive returns. That's not really, you're never going to get completely rid of it.
00:40:03 Europe fought wars over this kind of stuff. And again, I don't want to get weird, but-
00:40:10 No, no, no, no, no. You're speaking our language.
00:40:12 Yeah, I think you know what I'm talking about. 0.88
00:40:14 So anyway, the point is, is that you want to encourage, for instance, there are opportunities right now for American smart, hardworking young guys to go make a killing in Africa right now.
00:40:31 That's not free trade. That's investment.
00:40:34 You are going and actually because because there's there's minerals and there's stuff in the ground and there's some, you know, hardworking people who you give them some opportunity to work hard and they will.
00:40:52 OK, unless they have a different set of gifted. Do they have a different set of giftedness than the average American?
00:40:59 Sure. I'm not talking about that. I'm just talking about that's a different thing than me just sending, oh, look, there's this African ETF and I'll just throw some dollars at it at light speed.
00:41:12 And now, you know, again, and I'm not, I don't want to paint with a mop here, but the former is good.
00:41:26 That is God taking his people with different giftedness and using them to minister to one another.
00:41:33 The latter is saying that what's most important is just this, is just these, you know, is just, it's almost like this phantom reality that's going.
00:41:46 And again, I really recommend if you've got the horsepower and wherewithal to read some philosophy, Nick Land is great on this stuff.
00:41:56 uh xenocosmography is his twitter too and he's a fun he's a he's he's healthy again and he's active
00:42:03 on twitter and he's a fun he's a fun follow and absolutely brilliant i mean the guy nick's got to
00:42:10 be 160 iq kind of guy but um but uh oh you asked about something else golly uh how do we get off
00:42:19 you asked one other thing uh that i meant to answer no i think i think you hit i think you
00:42:23 hit on what i was getting at so yeah thank you let's let's do this real quick i want to get to
00:42:27 the super chats i want to uh to try to address a couple questions and then we need to go to a
00:42:32 commercial break so first um this is from ben huffsteadler who is almost single-handedly keeping
00:42:39 right response ministries afloat he gave us a 200 super chat god bless you um i don't i don't want to
00:42:46 i don't want to just grift here but i'd like to think you know that somebody today could beat
00:42:52 Ben Huffsteadler for the largest super chat. I think somebody's got it in them. They can do it,
00:42:58 but if not, he's the reigning champ. So this is Ben Huffsteadler, a regular giver towards our
00:43:04 ministry. Incredibly grateful for you. Thanks, Ben. He said, stay bold, gents. People are being
00:43:09 changed by your work. Attended the conference via online this year. Already bought tickets for the
00:43:15 next year. See you in June this year, though. So I imagine he's going to the new Christendom
00:43:19 conference. I'll be there speaking. I'm excited about that. And then he said, smash the like
00:43:24 button or Trump will put personal tariffs on you. Amen. So true, King. Yep. If you are not liking
00:43:31 this video, if you're hiding out in the chat and you haven't given us a thumbs up and you haven't
00:43:35 liked it, Trump will personally, he will come to your house, 125% tariff and your entire family
00:43:41 will starve. We don't make the rules, but under Christian nationalism, you will like this video
00:43:45 or you will starve all right simple as that okay this is chase cormick he gave us a hundred dollars
00:43:50 super chat that's pretty big pretty generous we appreciate you chase thanks so much he says
00:43:55 thank you for these streams they've been really helping my new wife and i and new wife we're
00:44:02 going to assume he's newly married and not that he got rid of his old wife and trader
00:44:05 so newly married uh my new wife and i has been helping us tremendously and he said joel i have
00:44:12 a question about your sunday sermon uh-oh let's see what did i say uh my wife was confused when
00:44:18 you were talking about the small g gods lowercase g gods uh being real gods i think i know what you
00:44:26 mean but you can you help expound on that a little uh since it's not the topic for today
00:44:30 um i'm not going to talk about a whole lot but because you gave a hundred dollar super chat i'm
00:44:34 going to talk about it briefly so um this uh this is what i meant i was simply saying that i think a
00:44:40 lot of the Old Testament gods, that they weren't just, you know, carvings on a piece of wood,
00:44:45 that it wasn't just... They weren't figments of their imagination. They weren't figments of their
00:44:48 imagination. Now, Paul does talk about, you know, that an idol is no God at all in the New Testament.
00:44:54 So Paul does say this, but I really believe that during Old Testament times, I think there's still
00:44:58 remnants of this truth, even to this day, and especially during the interim period between
00:45:03 the, you know, the first coming of Christ and then AD 70. I think, you know, these things were
00:45:08 being wrapped up but especially in the old testament pre-incarnation of christ is life
00:45:12 death resurrection and ascension before that happened uh these were real gods and so what
00:45:18 i was saying is that uh when when you're talking about molek or you know the asherah poles or
00:45:22 you know the ball uh balls whatever you may be looking at i i really do believe that these were
00:45:28 real gods lowercase g uh meaning that they're not um they're not the one true triune gods
00:45:35 They're not the creators, so they're still creatures, but angelic beings that were gods,
00:45:42 sons of God, Job.
00:45:44 Fallen, right?
00:45:45 Yeah, fallen gods.
00:45:46 But Job, the first two chapters of Job talk about that, this divine council where there
00:45:50 are the sons of God, and I take that to mean angelic beings that are present, and the Satan,
00:45:56 Satan, he's one of them.
00:45:57 And I would hold that he was one of the chief of these fallen gods.
00:46:01 psalm 82 1 for example god has taken his place in the divine council in the midst of the gods he
00:46:07 passes judgment that's right so when we say we're not saying equal to the triune god so there's only
00:46:11 one creator only one creator so every other lowercase lowercase g god is a creature um but
00:46:19 if we if we're under the impression uh that there weren't fallen angelic beings uh lowercase g
00:46:26 gods that they that they were just figments of people's imagination or if we just say that
00:46:30 because they're creatures and they were creatures and are creatures uh that they're equal to us and
00:46:36 not vastly superior in terms of their capabilities their intelligence and their power then we're
00:46:41 we're being naive uh satan in the book of job had the power even over weather he caused a great wind
00:46:48 to blow and the house of job's children fell upon them and killed them um and so i believe that even
00:46:54 jesus uh throughout the gospel narratives and that's the particular text that uh that we were
00:46:59 preaching jesus casting out uh the the demons but that comes on the heels of him crossing the sea
00:47:05 where there was a great storm and i think that that was a demonically um cultivated uh storm i
00:47:11 believe that there were old gods ball one he was known for many things but one of the things that
00:47:14 he was known as was the storm god and asherah was also known as the god of the sea um and in
00:47:22 different cultures they went by different names you know old neptune you know or or poseidon you
00:47:27 know different gods for different cultures but i think they all actually represented a real being
00:47:32 a created being but a powerful being and and had power over different regions so principalities
00:47:37 were regions princes demonic princes were the actual powers the actual angelic fallen angelic
00:47:44 being themselves and so i believe over different earthly regions including the sea and the mountains
00:47:48 and this place and that place you know the prince of persia that we see in the book of daniel
00:47:52 uh that there were certain gods uh lowercase g gods angelic beings fallen that had rebelled
00:47:58 against god that were assigned to these different domains had real capabilities real intelligence
00:48:03 real powers uh but jesus he came into the house the earth the devil has been cast down to you he
00:48:10 bound the strong man and now we as the new testament church um are are plundering the house
00:48:16 and um but i i do believe that you know that there still is demonic activity today but it's not like
00:48:22 it once was so that's what i was when i said they're real gods what i meant is um that it's
00:48:27 not just you know just carved images i believe that especially in old testament times uh that
00:48:33 these were real creatures powerful creatures underneath the ultimate sovereignty of god they
00:48:38 weren't the creator they were creatures uh but but they were real that people were actually
00:48:42 worshiping real gods and there was a reason why people would give their first child to molek
00:48:47 because they would actually um they would actually get 10 children in return um that the real really
00:48:54 were fertility gods they really were gods of harvest they were gods of the hunt they were
00:48:58 gods of the sea they were gods of all these different things so that's what i meant uh and
00:49:02 here's the question we'll turn it back to uh ron and then we'll go to our commercial break
00:49:06 uh the question is from neville and he says matthew 17 25 and he admits you know he says
00:49:13 is this relevant he admits that this is not necessarily the chief uh purpose um or interpretation
00:49:18 of the text but but i think that that there are implications i think it's insightful he says
00:49:23 of whom do kings of the earth take custom or tribute their own children or strangers that's
00:49:30 verse 25 and then verse 26 matthew 17 26 peter saith unto him of strangers jesus saith unto him
00:49:38 appreciate that king james there um then the children are free and so he's asking ron uh
00:49:45 neville's asking is there some kind of implication that we could take for kings of the earth today
00:49:50 when it comes to sovereign nations and saying no um as a civil father as matthew henry and many
00:49:56 many you know reformers would say as a and and certainly before the reformers uh whether it be
00:50:01 you know to truly or or whether it be you know augustine or different guys that um no as a civil
00:50:07 father there's a particular special duty to your citizens the natural citizens of of your country
00:50:14 where god has appointed you and and that you're not going to extort them and you're not going to 0.98
00:50:20 put the primary burden on them but that you would deal with different measures with foreigners that
00:50:26 if they want to benefit from your people and your resources and your land then they're going to have 0.95
00:50:32 to pay a different price than what you would charge to your own natural citizens.
00:50:36 Could we take that away from that text in Matthew 17, 25, and 26?
00:50:40 Ron, what do you think?
00:50:42 Man, amen.
00:50:43 What a great application, a terrific verse, one that I wasn't thinking of immediately.
00:50:48 But yeah, a king owes, a state owes its first loyalty to its own citizens.
00:51:00 and tribute comes from outsiders. You see this with Abram and Melchizedek where Abram gives a
00:51:11 tithe to the king of Salem, Melchizedek, Melchizedek, king righteous. And what does
00:51:19 Melchizedek give him in return? He gives him bread and wine. That's probably nothing to do with 0.68
00:51:26 this. I wanted to say, so that's absolutely a perfect application of this. It is the domain
00:51:34 of, it is not the domain of the earthly state to tax its citizens this way. Everybody goes to Rome,
00:51:43 give to Caesar what is Caesar. Jesus was specifically talking to Pharisee, to the 0.90
00:51:51 Pharisees who he knew would pledge their loyalty to Caesar rather than him. So, I mean, that gets
00:52:04 misapplied. But I wanted to mention about your sermon, amen. Great stuff, Joel. Michael Heiser
00:52:11 is great in speaking on this stuff about the divine counsel. And in just the Hebrew word,
00:52:19 elohim has the sense of both gods and judge you see this uh uh paul mentions this idea a little bit
00:52:29 on mars hill at the area pagos um so uh great stuff uh and i would you know also uh the idea
00:52:38 of stoicheia of the elemental principles or the old you know the old um means of the the old the
00:52:47 old covenant the old world was administrated by uh we know by angels and paul says you know the new
00:52:54 the the manifestation of the new covenant is that men now rule the world um don't you know that you
00:52:59 will that's right one day judge the angels right so absolutely fantastic application all the way
00:53:04 around somebody's been uh jim jordan maxine huh ron when you know it angels and now men rule the
00:53:13 world hey that's i i can i cannot uh i cannot escape my uh mentor uh who has had an immense
00:53:22 impact on me god bless you jim jordan uh biblical horizons.com go there now you will not be sad
00:53:30 don't go there right now i mean now after you've after you've finished listening to me and joel
00:53:38 of course of course well uh well said yeah jim jordan is great um let's go ahead and go to our
00:53:44 first commercial break and then we'll come back and uh we'll deal some more with the chat if you
00:53:48 guys have questions for us go ahead and put your questions in um it doesn't have to be a super chat
00:53:53 we try to prioritize the people you know who are being generous but uh if you just want to put a
00:53:57 question in just make it clear say question colon mark you know and then da da da da you know so
00:54:02 make it clear there's a question we're going to go ahead and bifurcate those in the chat over
00:54:05 and try to deal with those
00:54:07 and give as many of those questions as we can
00:54:09 while we still have Ron on the line
00:54:11 because we'll be able to answer some of them
00:54:14 and he'll probably be able to answer more of them.
00:54:16 Especially if they're finance related.
00:54:17 Yes, especially if they're finance related.
00:54:19 Yes, exactly.
00:54:20 And I would love, because I'm a sucker for this
00:54:23 and I did not tell Ron ahead of time
00:54:26 because sometimes you just ask forgiveness
00:54:28 instead of permission.
00:54:30 But I just like to just be a little bit
00:54:33 of uh just a degenerate predictor concluder uh what's going to happen so i'm going to try to ask
00:54:40 ron a little bit of you know what what do you what do you foresee what do you what do you think
00:54:44 is going to happen you know as we as we start to broaden you know out and think like are we coming
00:54:49 into a recession what's that going to look like you know and and obviously all that will be
00:54:53 alleged with a grain of salt you know none of us are a prophet or the son of a prophet but it's
00:54:57 still fun to to look ahead and see uh see what might be coming down the pipeline all right so
00:55:03 here's our first commercial our sponsor private family banking wants to help you with one money
00:55:08 move that'll implicate itself in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day they help
00:55:14 you to avoid taxation and to draw compound interest to your money now if you're a high
00:55:20 net worth individual someone who has maybe even 10 million dollars in net worth then they can help
00:55:26 you even more. W-2 workers, contract workers, business owners, it's all about cash flow and
00:55:33 making tax-deferred gains on all your money for the rest of your life. Don't avoid this. It's a
00:55:39 big move, but it's a great time to make it. Click the link below and you can get on Chuck DeLaterante's
00:55:45 calendar and he'll go over your background and what you want to accomplish. And he's going to
00:55:51 help model a program that exactly fits your needs. So go ahead and send an email to chuck
00:55:56 at privatefamilybanking.com. Again, that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com. Or you can click the
00:56:04 link below. Make a free discovery call now. America is a country that was founded for the
00:56:09 purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God and not to have their consciences
00:56:13 ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men. Reese's Fund exists in order to see the Ten
00:56:17 commandments properly applied, not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used
00:56:22 in business as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:56:26 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up. We want to find
00:56:32 manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do
00:56:36 things here. Reese Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:56:40 all right we are back uh mr ron dodson would you do me the great honor of just trashing all of
00:56:54 your credibility right here live on the show and making some degenerate predictions of what might
00:56:58 happen in the future what do you think well uh you can say allegedly as many times as you need
00:57:07 to say it. No, it's okay. I mean, I don't, I, uh, I, I'm not worried about anything. Uh, past
00:57:15 performance is no indication of the future. It actually is, but go ahead. Anyway. Uh, if you,
00:57:24 if you look at the delinquency rates in, in the, uh, in the market, uh, or in the, in the economy
00:57:32 right now, then you'll see that we've probably been headed towards some type of shallow recession
00:57:39 since late Q3 last year. And what am I talking about? Well, if you look at delinquency rates
00:57:49 on credit card loans. Well, that number has risen from a low in the third quarter of 2021
00:58:03 and is now about 2x what the long-term trend is. If you look at, and by the way, a lot of the
00:58:17 numbers, the employment numbers and everything seem to have been pretty cooked because the
00:58:21 revisions have just been ridiculous lately. That shouldn't surprise us. The deep state
00:58:26 collects and runs a lot of this stuff, and they sure didn't want Trump elected.
00:58:32 If you look on the delinquency rate on single-family residential mortgages booked in domestic
00:58:40 offices, that has actually been down. So I don't think we're looking at a, or has been
00:58:47 uh hasn't risen so you're not talking about a deeper section where people are a lot of people
00:58:53 are losing their homes you know like we had in uh uh you know late 07 through a 08 and early 09
00:59:01 which was just a real disaster if you look at the delinquency rates on consumer loans all commercial
00:59:08 banks and so these are consumer loans uh you're you're talking about a tremendous rise again since
00:59:16 a trough in the third quarter of 2021 those have risen precipitously if you're looking
00:59:23 at the delinquency rate on commercial real estate loans uh uh those have been rising uh over the
00:59:32 past uh 18 months um delinquency rate on credit card loans not among the hundred largest in size
00:59:41 by assets. So you're talking about the lower credit quality. Those have been greatly elevated.
00:59:50 Delinquency rate up close to 8%, which doesn't sound crazy, but it's much higher than normal.
00:59:59 And then delinquency rate on all other consumer loans. And by the way, you can look at this data.
01:00:08 you don't have to be a professional hedge fund manager like me you can go to the federal reserve
01:00:13 bank of st louis which is the fed federal reserve bank that uh that collates all this data um and
01:00:21 uh again since the trough in quarter three of 2021 that number is accelerating and going up so
01:00:29 so you're seeing this the the lowest quality of of consumer credit really performing poorly
01:00:38 These are leading indicators as far as possibly a shallow recession. And then, you know, changing any type of regime in an economic sense is going to have, like we said before, it's going to have a certain amount of collateral damage that harms liquidity.
01:00:58 And so I think that is a I wouldn't be shocked if if I don't think that, for instance, Joe Sixpack, this the tariffs are not going to impact him nearly as much as as the doomsayers are saying.
01:01:17 Why do I say that? Well, I mean, if he wants to go buy a 75 inch TV screen, I mean, that might be impacted, although those are mostly made in South Korea.
01:01:27 Um, the, the, what, but the, the, there's a, there's a, there is a concept in, in economics
01:01:37 called the elasticity of demand that is, that is poorly appreciated.
01:01:44 I'll put it that way.
01:01:46 So medicine, for instance, and we do have a problem.
01:01:49 Most of our medicines are made overseas and that's, we'd make some of them here, but,
01:01:53 But we need to reshore that in a bad way.
01:01:58 But that's inelasticity of demand.
01:02:00 If you need medicine, you've got to have that medicine.
01:02:05 But consumer goods are largely, these are washing machines or TV screens or whatever it is, guitars.
01:02:17 We're right back here, over there.
01:02:20 A lot of those are made overseas.
01:02:23 but these are economic decisions, purchase decisions that are made by choice and not by
01:02:32 need. And that's a very elastic demand. So due to elasticity of demand, a lot of these
01:02:39 tariffs won't be inflationary in that sense. We make our own fuel and we make our own food.
01:02:48 Those are the things you've got to have. We make our own housing because it's got to go here.
01:02:53 So, you know, there's an issue with lumber, although we ought to be, we've got the world's
01:02:58 biggest forests, so we ought to make them, you know, that you can still farm the, you
01:03:05 know, we ought to have no problem sourcing lumber.
01:03:08 That tends to be a regulatory issue, but I think Trump is all over that.
01:03:12 So, anyway, elasticity of demand, I think will be okay, but I do see a high likelihood
01:03:20 of at least a shallow recession, hopefully only one or two quarters. Now, that's domestic.
01:03:31 What do I see middle term? Well, if this continues, there could be, we could push,
01:03:38 we really could push the Chinese into a corner. I think that is part of what's being intended, 1.00
01:03:45 actually, because for a lot of reasons, but there's a chance that China could move on Taiwan.
01:03:56 Now, do I think that they will attempt a very dangerous invasion? I kind of doubt it. That's a,
01:04:05 although if anybody's seen the latest pictures of the ramp ships they've built,
01:04:10 very, very impressive, the engineering on that, where they can send tons of soldiers and material
01:04:17 on shore really quickly. But I wouldn't be surprised if in late Q3, early Q4, if we haven't
01:04:27 come to some kind of understanding, if there wasn't some type of blockade of Taiwan, and then
01:04:32 the U.S. would have some real decisions to make. How important to us is Taiwan? Now, you know,
01:04:40 I tend to follow the John Mersheimer School of Geopolitics, which is the realist school. And
01:04:49 Taiwan sits right off, you know, 40 miles off the coast of China. And we, again, we abandoned
01:04:59 Chiang Kai-shek way back in the day. I think Taiwan eventually is going to be Chinese. 0.99
01:05:06 It's culturally and linguistically and genetically China. The hope for Taiwan is us helping to 0.98
01:05:17 reform China, not somehow miraculously defending. I wouldn't be real happy if I had sons. I have
01:05:24 two daughters, but if they got drafted and sent to defend Taiwan, I wouldn't be real happy with
01:05:28 that, just to be perfectly honest. So we've got to be real smart about, you know, I published a
01:05:36 paper internally during the first Trump administration about suggesting that West
01:05:43 Texas is pretty open and empty. We could move all of Taiwan's semiconductors, people and practices
01:05:49 here. Give them all citizenship. Give them free land. And we should have a Texan Shenzhen 1.00
01:05:58 build a couple of nuclear plants to power it and let's go.
01:06:04 Why something like that hasn't been pursued, I don't know. Politically, maybe it's difficult,
01:06:10 but it seems like that would be smart. So that's what I foresee in the middle term and how we
01:06:19 respond to that is it would drive a lot of our economic, you know, economics. I'm not a big fan
01:06:27 of, you know, the realities of what's happening in geopolitics with regards to the reason we have
01:06:35 this global globalization is the United States had the world's most magnificent, I sound like Trump,
01:06:42 the most magnificent Navy in the world. And we could police all these shipping lanes. And you're
01:06:48 seeing now that policing Malacca, the Malacca Strait, which is there at Singapore, and I love
01:06:54 Singapore, Lee Kuan Yew, a real hero. But we can't police Malacca and the Dardanelles and the
01:07:02 Bosporus. We can't police the Suez and we can possibly police and retake the influence over 0.97
01:07:10 the Panama Canal. But these other choke points, due to the change in calculus of war, it's just
01:07:15 too hard to defend a carrier battle group against drone and hypersonics now. So you're going to see
01:07:22 a regionalization of the world. I just wrote about this in the American Mind, the Claremont
01:07:28 Institute publication that was published yesterday. And so I think regionalization is
01:07:36 just what's going to, that's the new reality. So even if we weren't concerned about our own
01:07:42 citizens even if we weren't concerned about this dollarization and dutch disease we'd still be 0.89
01:07:47 pursuing a lot of these same exact goals because it's the new reality uh that that is facing us
01:07:55 the worldwide global hegemony is uh i think we're uh seeing the waning uh days of that
01:08:04 yeah yeah yeah it does it seems like the whole world is there's a snapback to nationalism go
01:08:11 i was going to say i i like the chinese tariffs for one reason in that we just get a bunch of
01:08:17 junk again about sheen and timu those have discipled in many ways the american consumer 0.51
01:08:23 to want to buy just cheap mass produced we couldn't make it here there's no way we could
01:08:28 make those products here at price pay a livable wage all of that but we have gotten almost
01:08:33 addicted i would feel like in a sense to just some of it's even straight up toxic it has metals and
01:08:38 lead in it it's cheap it's toxic it's made in sweatshops and factories and manufacturing
01:08:44 conditions that are terrible but we've become become addicted to it you think of like a kid
01:08:48 that has a sugar addiction that's what we've become and so i would love to see especially
01:08:53 these go on long term it'll have all of its other ramifications like ron you just talked about
01:08:57 but it'd be really good for americans to start thinking about well actually maybe the my priority
01:09:02 shouldn't be can i get this for the lowest possible price and i don't care if it's just
01:09:07 rebranded for the same plant as everything else comes from and i don't care no like start thinking
01:09:12 about can i buy american who's actually making this are they being being paid a livable wage
01:09:17 am i just exporting you know just big pennies on the dollar so at least as far as china is concerned
01:09:22 specifically because the service we give them it's not military we're not protecting their borders
01:09:27 we give them 300 million people that are consumers at the end of the day that's one of our big
01:09:33 exports so i'm excited for that it's the it's the mcdonald's happy meal toy that your kid plays with
01:09:39 at mcdonald's and then you throw away at the gas station on the way home right well a lot of the
01:09:45 a lot of the chinese products that you're speaking of are actually stolen u.s tech
01:09:50 there's countless countless stories of uh innovation and uh and engineering prowess 0.91
01:09:59 on these consumables, and I did a Twitter thread on this today, or no, I wrote on my
01:10:07 substack today about this, of these American ideas, and then you form a company, you have
01:10:16 a good idea, you have this amazing product, and then you go to try to manufacture it here,
01:10:21 and due to regulation and other things, it's not just because Americans, you can't afford
01:10:27 a living wage. I think you can pay a living wage and still make, maybe not cheap, but not
01:10:33 ridiculously expensive products. But the issue is that you have the regulatory hurdles to opening
01:10:41 a manufacturing business, to powering that business and having the real estate is ridiculous.
01:10:50 And by the time you jump through all those hurdles, you could have already just contracted 1.00
01:10:54 a chinese factory uh to do it for you the problem is is uh they then steal the idea uh they turn 0.89
01:11:03 off their phones uh you have no recourse and you turn around and three day uh you know three weeks 0.94
01:11:09 later you see your product under some new name uh being uh uh marketed on amazon and timu so
01:11:17 uh so that is a real problem swiss and how many watchmakers there have spent 100 200 300 years
01:11:26 perfecting beautiful watches that i think bring glory to god like rolex and then china they'll
01:11:32 go and they'll make and everything externally about it like internally obviously it's not
01:11:35 machined to that caliber it's not precise it's not going to last as long but hey it gives the
01:11:40 american consumer it's 98 similar and exactly like you said you have you have a trade you have
01:11:45 something good you have something beautiful that people work really hard for and then they say well
01:11:49 we can make that for pennies on the dollar and just slap a logo on it obviously literally copying
01:11:53 it with the logo there's copyright laws and stuff but they they still get to america if not knock
01:11:58 offs that look very much similar but have maybe a different brand yeah yeah i was just showing you
01:12:03 talking about swiss watch i was just showing my vintage breitling here nice yeah the i when i
01:12:10 became a pilot. That was my gift to myself. So 33 years ago, y'all. One day you'll be able to say
01:12:19 you're old. All right. Well, let's see if we can get to some of the questions. I have a question
01:12:27 about tariffs, though, if you don't mind, Joel. Ron, there's been some speculation, and the Trump
01:12:34 administration has been holding their cards pretty close to the vest. There's been some speculation
01:12:39 about what Trump is actually doing with this tariff.
01:12:42 And I've heard three, actually four,
01:12:44 you mentioned the one already, 0.92
01:12:45 which is just trying to kind of put China back in its place. 0.96
01:12:48 So that's one. 0.89
01:12:49 But the other three are,
01:12:50 he is trying to revive American production.
01:12:54 He's trying to generate an alternative revenue stream,
01:12:58 either to pay off the debt
01:12:59 or to pave the way for getting rid of the income tax.
01:13:02 And then the other potential option
01:13:05 is that he is simply trying to negotiate
01:13:09 more actual fair trade deals with other countries.
01:13:13 And the thing about it is some of those are mutually exclusive
01:13:16 because if it's about production,
01:13:18 then he doesn't care about the fair trade deals as much.
01:13:21 If it's about generating revenue for the United States,
01:13:26 then maybe it's not so much about building up U.S. production.
01:13:29 So if you were to take your guess based on even,
01:13:32 I know it changes every day.
01:13:33 Like I prepared the outline for the episode last night
01:13:36 And then today things changed with with the 90 day hiatus on the tax on the tariffs.
01:13:43 So if you were to take a guess, what do you think the Trump administration is actually about?
01:13:48 What are they trying to do with this whole process?
01:13:53 Well, I think it's a rebalancing of all of it.
01:13:56 I don't think it's a linear relationship.
01:13:57 I think it's a you know, it's a it's an optimization on multiple axes.
01:14:06 So, you know, like old linear programming, a Lindo issue.
01:14:09 So you are, I think that you are trying to create a different revenue stream for the
01:14:17 government that isn't taxing your own people.
01:14:20 I think you're trying to create some friction for capital flows because that ultimately
01:14:29 increases the value of nationhood, citizenship, all these non, I say non-financial,
01:14:39 uh, uh, everything, uh, you know, in the modern sense is, is, is financialized, but these,
01:14:46 these non-financial issues, uh, can be heightened in value by creating some friction for dollars.
01:14:55 and also you kill you help kill the euro dollar market so um and you know uh what that does is
01:15:05 if there's more i mean i would i'm not a monetarist a strict monetarist but i do think
01:15:11 milton friedman was correct when he said uh inflation is always and everywhere a monetary
01:15:17 phenomenon if you have no ability to control dollars created offshore then you really are
01:15:23 going to have far less control over inflation when you need to have it. So part of this is
01:15:31 a greater control over your own money supply, a heightened value for what it means to be a
01:15:43 citizen of the United States rather than a cosmopolitan citizen of the world, which is
01:15:47 really meaningless all that does is uh is is create we we believe i think we're all on the
01:15:54 same page here that we believe that pareto is reality that generally because of the differences
01:16:01 in giftedness and and the differences in opportunity 80 percent of resources tend to
01:16:07 go to about 20 of the people that's and and and there's not a lot you can do to fix that
01:16:13 We don't live in a, that, that raw, complete and utter egalitarianism is a lie. And, uh, you would have to strip people of identity and borders and all these things in pursuing that. And you're still going to get, so, so I think we all agree that, or at least I would think we agree that some level of Pareto is, is just reality.
01:16:34 But if you have, again, without any resource friction, you get Pareto times rentier times leverage.
01:16:45 And so instead of 80-20, you get 99-1.
01:16:49 And that's obscene.
01:16:52 So we don't want that.
01:16:54 I don't think God's really happy with that.
01:16:57 And so creating some friction and people, very smart people in the market after, if you all remember the flash crash from 2011, some smart people suggested perhaps a tiny, very tiny transactional tax for stocks would help prevent this.
01:17:19 I tend to agree with that.
01:17:21 I, you know, where you would do away with some of the high frequency trading, which all that does is, is it robs market makers.
01:17:28 So now you don't really have market makers anymore.
01:17:30 You just have. Now, again, I don't want to get into a big argument on on on that level of liquidity, but it's the same idea that if you have if you have some level of friction that you you increase investedness.
01:17:47 So do I think Trump is ultimately for increasing the importance of American markets to Americans for the benefit of American citizens? Yes.
01:18:02 Do I think he's trying to increase the level of U.S. control over the currency? Yes. Do I think he's trying to have an alternate source of revenue for the federal government that is less than income tax? Yes, I do.
01:18:22 um and uh so i think all the and do i think that for the trade that is going to be there do i think
01:18:30 he wants a level playing field for all uh parties yes and all you can't maximize one of the you the
01:18:40 idea isn't to maximize one over the other it's to increase the efficient frontier if you remember
01:18:46 from, you know, your microeconomics, your efficient frontier of risk and return.
01:18:55 Well, it's similar among multiple fronts.
01:18:57 You're just trying to get as far onto that frontier while realizing there's multiple goals at play.
01:19:04 That's really helpful. Thanks.
01:19:06 All right. Let's go check out some of the questions.
01:19:10 Nathan's going to take us over.
01:19:11 um okay all right uh darth amalgamate uh amalgamation he asked did you manage to sell
01:19:20 enough of the cigars at the conference so that you didn't have to bring them home and kill yourself
01:19:24 by smoking all of them so it's a thoughtful question because i would have done that uh yeah
01:19:29 we sold them all i actually didn't get a single cigar i didn't either yeah so they're gone you
01:19:34 guys did well thank you uh we appreciate it this is jeff halfley he gave us a couple super chats
01:19:39 thanks jeff we appreciate he said great meeting um oh nope starting up higher uh great meeting
01:19:45 y'all at the right response conference your staff is great uh thanks jeff and then he also followed
01:19:52 up he said that a certain group of individuals reformed christians they're not actually arguing
01:19:57 with you they are instead arguing with their own parents generation and then he has some other
01:20:02 comments uh back on the main thread to kind of flesh that out uh if you can go back real quick
01:20:08 nathan uh scroll up yep scroll down there it is he said 1950s 60s christian right wingers were
01:20:14 anti-feminism anti-crm anti-mlk martin luther king anti-egalitarianism and they were race
01:20:22 realist so i think what jeff is saying is that there is a certain uh sector within the reformed
01:20:29 world that um aren't really arguing with you um they're actually arguing with their dad
01:20:34 uh their dad is probably uh dead at this point uh but he's basically talking about some of the
01:20:40 older guys that are um they're you know they say that you're extreme or you're novel you're
01:20:46 different or you know this that and the other uh but in reality um it's really just kind of
01:20:51 skipping the immediate uh earthly fathers to get back to ancient fathers matthew henry talks about
01:20:57 this you know ancient fathers civil fathers familial there are different kinds of fathers
01:21:01 ecclesiastical or spiritual fathers um oh no i'm sorry that's thomas watson uh but um i think what
01:21:08 jeff haffley is saying is there was a comment uh for all the listeners who weren't at the conference
01:21:12 or haven't had a chance to sign up for our patreon to watch the live stream which i need to remind
01:21:17 you guys about here in just a moment but um there was a moment where basically i i was saying yes
01:21:23 we want to obey the fifth commandment we want to honor our fathers but what do you do um what do
01:21:28 you do if if your immediate fathers meaning the the immediate preceding
01:21:34 generation to your own happens to be a generation that of course there are
01:21:40 always exceptions there are some guys who stood the test of time they went
01:21:44 against the grain they were faithful they were countercultural and and
01:21:48 obedient to God and we praise God for them but on the whole speaking in
01:21:52 generalities the boomer generation in general not universal but in general what 0.99
01:21:58 do you do if that immediate preceding generation to your own is demanding that you honor them
01:22:04 in keeping with the fifth commandment but by honoring them if that honor means agreement
01:22:10 like unfettered allegiance and fidelity and full agreement if agreeing with that immediately
01:22:17 preceding generation to yours would would then necessarily it would automatically you know
01:22:25 translate to a full-fledged rebellion and disagreement with every single other generation
01:22:30 in the history of all humankind because that's kind of where we're at so i think that's what
01:22:37 jeff halfley is getting at i talked about that at the conference briefly but just saying that
01:22:41 yes we want to honor our immediate familial fathers especially your father like your earthly
01:22:47 your literal debt uh we want to honor our fathers as best we can um but um in general um a lot of
01:22:56 a lot of honoring fathers uh what it's going to require is is respectfully but but steadfastly
01:23:05 disagreeing with um the immediate preceding generation to ours because um they dishonored
01:23:13 all of their fathers it's i i didn't you know i didn't do this i didn't i don't want it to be 0.72
01:23:18 this way i'm not trying to pick on anybody i'm not trying to be disrespectful but um the hippie
01:23:24 free love movement of the 60s i mean that's literally what it was founded on it was it was
01:23:29 literally founded on rebelling against dad that's literally what it was it was i'm gonna if i'm a
01:23:36 dude i'm gonna grow my hair out you know just to stick it to the man i'm gonna have long hair just 0.91
01:23:40 as a sign of rebellion if i'm a chick i'm going to cut it short we're going to do drugs um you
01:23:45 know drugs rock and roll all this kind of you know whatever and but the whole thing is um we're
01:23:50 raging against the machine we're going against our fathers and their fathers and their fathers
01:23:54 and their fathers and their fathers so yeah so if if the if the train is gonna you know it's been
01:23:59 derailed if it's going to get put back on the tracks um you can do it respectfully you don't 0.96
01:24:04 have to be a jerk about it you shouldn't be a jerk about it uh but what it's going to look like 0.97
01:24:08 is telling an entire generation no that's what it's going to look like and you do that respectfully 1.00
01:24:14 but it's going to look like saying i'm sorry uh but your your gay race communism is not going to 0.95
01:24:21 be uh distilled down to my children like it stops the buck stops here stopping with my generation 0.97
01:24:27 um that was gay that was wrong i'm not rebellious you're rebellious you literally had t-shirts made 0.85
01:24:34 about rebellion you your your generation you were proud of it the rebellious generation so for me to 0.99
01:24:42 not be rebellious i have to rebel against the rebellious generation i'm sorry i don't make
01:24:47 the rules but under christian nationalism the boomer mindset will be defeated so i think that's
01:24:54 what jeff halfley's talking about nothing to do with our conversation today but he gave a super
01:24:59 chat trying to honor it jeremy kearns he gave a super chat he said great conference right response
01:25:03 glad that god uh has put y'all in our lives i uh believe your conference will be talked about
01:25:09 uh in the history books probably not but i appreciate that uh the tide is turning and i
01:25:14 think that's true uh it will be taught probably not in the history books but it will be talked
01:25:18 about in the twitter streets i guarantee you it already has been i saw the form uh going around
01:25:23 did you guys see this somebody was saying uh it was a church disciplinary form and it was saying
01:25:29 If you have anyone that you personally know who is at the Christ is King Right Response Conference, here's a form, and you need to write down their name, and there's two boxes that you could check.
01:25:45 Is that real?
01:25:46 That sounds like fake news to me.
01:25:47 No, it was real.
01:25:47 No, he made it for real.
01:25:49 Absolutely real.
01:25:50 Yep, you can check the box if the person's repentant, but if they're unrepentant, then you need to check that box.
01:25:56 they're an impenitent ongoing sin because they attended uh the white nationalist conference that
01:26:02 had uh calvin robinson we're not doing very good you know if that's the goal um you know calvin was
01:26:07 you know he was there and it was funny in the green room he was like now i know i know it's
01:26:12 tough uh you know with me being an anglo-catholic and i said no man it's it's tough because you're
01:26:16 half black and he laughed you know so but but this was a real form and he's saying fill it out
01:26:23 and find what church people go to
01:26:25 and send it to their elders,
01:26:27 send it to their pastors.
01:26:28 So we're already getting,
01:26:30 my point is, yeah,
01:26:31 it's not going to be talked about
01:26:32 in the history books
01:26:32 because there are better men than us.
01:26:34 And hopefully they'll make the history books
01:26:35 and maybe we'll be a footnote,
01:26:37 you know, or in the appendix
01:26:38 or something like that.
01:26:39 An honorable mention,
01:26:40 you know, maybe that,
01:26:41 probably not even that.
01:26:42 But it will be talked about
01:26:44 in the Twitter streets
01:26:46 and what we're doing,
01:26:47 just so you guys know,
01:26:48 so this is where I'll make the plug.
01:26:50 We're going to put out
01:26:50 one piece of content.
01:26:51 So there were seven main sessions
01:26:53 and three panels two of those were panels where we're just having a conversation and then one of
01:26:58 those was a discussion slash debate there was some formality with open statements closing statements
01:27:03 but then in the cross-examination we made it more conversational but that was between uh pastor
01:27:08 david reese and dr stephen wolf um predominantly focusing on theonomy versus natural law and i
01:27:14 think that they actually did a fantastic job getting to the crux of the argument because
01:27:19 everybody's like what are we where do we disagree where do we disagree with it like what is the
01:27:23 crux of the argument and they nailed it with this 90 minute debate um four minutes before the end
01:27:29 they got to the crux it was four minutes before the end where they finally they got to this point
01:27:34 and this is where i think the crux of the debate was and it was literally four minutes until i had
01:27:38 to go up and stop it and so it was it was kind of a bummer but um they finally got to the point
01:27:42 where it was stephen his position was uh that he believes that civil government is an institution
01:27:49 that would have existed in a pre-lapsarian world and that the obligation the duties that god has
01:27:55 given to the civil magistrate um is not just to punish bad guys but to promote the good earthly
01:28:02 good for the heavenly good and that's basically his so his premise when he thinks of the civil
01:28:07 magistrate he's not just thinking about tamping down on crime and and punishing bad behavior but
01:28:13 he's thinking about incentivizing and structuring and even rewarding positive behavior uh temporal
01:28:19 earthly goods and and promoting that in such a way that it serves the heavenly good whereas uh for
01:28:24 david reese he feels like that's that's a noteworthy calling but he believes that that belongs to
01:28:30 churches in the family and if you want that role uh to be to be done poorly promoting the earthly
01:28:36 good that leads towards heavenly good then give it to the the stair um and that's in a nutshell
01:28:40 that's his position is you know if you want a job done done poorly um then go ahead and make sure
01:28:45 the government does it and so for him he believes uh that it's the Noahic covenant genesis chapter
01:28:50 nine that that's where the civil magistrate really comes into the picture that there wouldn't really
01:28:54 be a government a civil role in a pre-lapsarian you know if there had been no fall pre-lapsarian
01:28:59 no fall no sin entering the world um and so this is actually a post-lapsarian it's because of sin
01:29:04 And it's instituted in the Noahic Covenant, and it's strictly to punish evil.
01:29:10 And yes, Romans 13 says praise the good, but not so much incentivizing or rewarding or promoting the good.
01:29:19 And so for Stephen, government would exist whether there was sin in the world or not,
01:29:23 because it's not just to punish sin, sin particularly that becomes in the realm of crime.
01:29:28 It would have been in a pre-lapse area.
01:29:30 If sin had never entered the world, it still would have existed.
01:29:32 And it's a larger, broader banner.
01:29:34 it's not just uh get the bad guys but it's promote the public earthly good and even the heavenly
01:29:40 good in such a way that it orient uh the temporal orients towards the eternal and uh for david
01:29:45 reese he's saying yeah that's an important job and and to be fair to to you know to pastor reese
01:29:50 he's saying it's got to be done but i trust households and the and families and churches to
01:29:55 do that and and the state is going to to make a mess of that he just needs to get the bad guys
01:30:00 and it's a post lapsarian uh type of government and we and and i think like that was the clearest
01:30:06 i ever heard it was like oh here's the difference and they they nailed it they got right down
01:30:11 to brass tacks um after 86 minutes and so uh with you know with four minutes to go so that's
01:30:17 that was the debate all these what i was going to say all these are going to be posted
01:30:21 um and they're going to be you know p p o a s they're going to be posted and uh and they're
01:30:27 going to be weekly so we're going to put it out but we got to we got to take a couple weeks because
01:30:31 nathan literally just set the studio back up like an hour before we started live streaming and uh
01:30:36 and has been unloading and all this kind of stuff for the conference there's a lot of logistics on
01:30:39 the back side so it's going to be a couple weeks before we start doing it but it's going to be
01:30:43 seven main sessions three panels one of them being the debate that i just summarized um and it's
01:30:48 going to be weekly so probably expect i would say two to three weeks from now expect one once a week
01:30:53 we'll drop a piece of content from the conference but if you want to see it all ahead of time
01:30:58 you can go to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries patreon.com forward slash
01:31:05 right response ministries we are reserving us for our gold tier members and so you will have to sign
01:31:11 up to be a gold member but for 10 bucks and believe it or not i know it sounds like it like
01:31:17 is that even possible i've been reliably informed that it is possible it's not probable but it is
01:31:22 possible to subscribe to something and to make use of it and then cancel the subscription
01:31:27 afterwards so it is possible um but not probable but you actually can spend ten dollars and only
01:31:34 ten dollars and get all the comp uh all the conference content and have 30 days to watch it
01:31:39 so go to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries you'll get it all um and you get early
01:31:44 access and you'll be able to watch it now and uh but when we start posting it uh i think i think
01:31:49 ron dodson would uh be able to confirm that this is true and not hyperbole uh once it starts coming
01:31:55 out publicly uh there will be screeching and wailing and gnashing of teeth people will just
01:32:02 be like i can't believe it i can't believe that these these heretics did this conference and i
01:32:06 just i just don't know what to do there will be pearl clutching uh people will you know hide your
01:32:10 wife hide your kids uh they did they did a conference where they believed that christ
01:32:14 should actually be king it's crazy so all right that's my that's my pitch joel we have lots of
01:32:18 of questions but some at the bottom that are specifically financial related do you want to
01:32:22 yeah sure let's let's give it to ron you ask it michael and give it to ron uh from colin erb ron
01:32:28 uh colin says does the upcoming recession that you guys foresee impact thoughts on starting a business
01:32:36 what's the business i'm not opening my consulting uh shop today but i mean i mean that's dependent
01:32:45 upon that's dependent upon uh what's your financing source uh do you you know is it a typical operating
01:32:53 operator and capital partner type of relationship are you just doing bank financing or is it you
01:33:00 know savings uh that kind of thing what what's your uh what what need are you you know before
01:33:08 you open any business you're you're you're trying to meet a need that isn't currently being met
01:33:12 or meeting it in a more efficient or better way.
01:33:17 And then you have to decide how elastic, see full circle,
01:33:24 how elastic the demand is for that need.
01:33:27 So is it a want?
01:33:29 Is it a luxury good?
01:33:30 Is it meeting an actual need?
01:33:33 And all those things play into a business plan
01:33:36 that you either determine is resilient or not
01:33:41 to uh recessionary concerns so um that's that's about the best i can do on that i did want to say
01:33:49 i did want to say that regarding uh one thing i forgot about matthew 17 when we're talking about
01:33:55 tribute you know solomon when he solomon split ended up because of his actions split the kingdom
01:34:01 and what was it over he taxed the people uh uh uh over and above the tithe to the temple
01:34:10 to go and do certain things. And that's why the northern tribes left. And so you see,
01:34:17 and God never judges the northern tribe. God judges the northern tribes because of their 0.73
01:34:22 unfaithfulness, not because they left due to that. And so I think that's a, we can get some 1.00
01:34:29 principles from that about the right relationship of the righteous king. And then regarding what
01:34:35 you were saying, Joe, by the way, very good distillation of that. I caught up with Isker
01:34:41 about this stuff. With the theonomy debate? Is that what you're talking about? Yeah, it's really good
01:34:46 because, you know, but, you know, you have to ask yourself, was Jesus not going to, in a prelapsed
01:34:52 area, if Adam had not fallen, would Jesus have ever been king? And so is there an eternal purpose
01:34:59 king. And who reformed the priesthood? Was it a prophet? Was it the high priest or was it the
01:35:05 king? It was David. David reformed the priesthood and David was no sinless man. He was just the king
01:35:12 and he had the authority to do so. And even if you look at the geography of Jerusalem, it is
01:35:17 not Mount Moriah that is tallest. It is Mount Zion, the traditional home of the Davidic king.
01:35:23 And so you have to look at some of these eternal purposes and not just think sometimes in our reformed zeal to be forensic about everything.
01:35:34 We lose some of the some of the more exciting topological insights that come from a literary reading of Scripture.
01:35:48 Yep. Well said.
01:35:49 Sorry, I'm a finance guy doing biblical theology.
01:35:51 so no no no we do tariffs we do we know we spent some time with you ron ron knows his bible you
01:35:58 can speak to the bible ron this is a question that is beyond at least my pay grade probably all of
01:36:03 our pay grade this is cory he says do you think china will dump bonds in response to the tariffs
01:36:09 if so how would affect how would that affect the us well they don't know nearly as many bonds as
01:36:16 has been advertised but sure they could dump bonds the question is is uh is how else are
01:36:22 they gonna i mean uh there are some they don't have complete and utter freedom because their
01:36:30 their buying of bonds has to do with the fact that they take in dollars if they take in fewer dollars
01:36:35 then they're gonna buy fewer bonds the the the issue is though is that is we had a we had a
01:36:42 uh, uh, everybody was very, very concerned about the treasury auction today, and it was so
01:36:49 oversubscribed. So there's no, there's no lessening demand for, uh, treasury notes and
01:36:58 bonds. The issue that the reason rates have risen over the last three or four days, it has to do
01:37:04 with, uh, the breakdown of the basis trade, uh, because the, that gets real arcane. It's kind of
01:37:11 Beyond this discussion, you can look it up.
01:37:13 If you look up hedge fund basis, treasury basis trading and probably get a, you know,
01:37:18 have Chad GPT or Garak explain it to you.
01:37:22 Great.
01:37:24 Deacon St. John asks, as of an hour ago, there's reporting that today the S&P rose 2,900 points,
01:37:30 over 10% best day ever recorded, allegedly.
01:37:34 Is MAGA winning?
01:37:35 The market was great here towards the end.
01:37:39 What do you make of that, Ron?
01:37:41 Well, it wouldn't be the S&P rising 2,900 points. That would be the Dow, I believe it was 2,900
01:37:49 points. Well, I mean, then the Dow is cap-weighted and the S&P is, I mean, the Dow is price-weighted
01:37:56 and the S&P is cap-weighted. They're just different instruments. One's 30 stocks, one's 500.
01:38:02 What do I make of the reaction today? I think the reaction, what we're seeing is you better
01:38:06 have your big boy pants on if you're trying to trade this market because it's not acting
01:38:11 stochastically so guys like me who are quant oriented we trade based upon that which we can
01:38:18 model and you can't model it's very similar to the uh latter half of 2008 where it's really based
01:38:28 upon the market is trading upon policy decisions and there's no way to model that unless you can
01:38:33 read minds or you know have inside information into policy decisions so personally i believe
01:38:41 that uh sorry we got some kind of noise going on here in the uh in the worldwide offices of
01:38:46 dodson incorporated here um anyway the uh uh i what i take away from the response today is is that
01:38:56 is that the people who make decisions at the margin of whether to buy or sell stocks
01:39:03 are doing so on on short to middle term risk and that short term short to middle term risk
01:39:11 was set aside for the collateral damage that is absolutely part and parcel of a tariff regime
01:39:19 mostly with europe and other uh other stuff uh other nations not china so it this was a response
01:39:27 simply to that. And I don't think this, it goes beyond much of that. And then you have momentum
01:39:36 that comes with just people suddenly feeling, oh, okay, it's okay to buy again. Maybe the mess is
01:39:42 over. I think this whole year is going to be choppy. The quantitative look at the markets
01:39:49 going into January 1st, before all this stuff happened, tend to suggest that the market was
01:39:58 going to close the year somewhere between six up and six down, six percentage points up,
01:40:03 six percentage points down. That's kind of what if you have a year like last year and you have
01:40:09 the first year of a presidential cycle and so on and so forth, that doesn't mean that's what's
01:40:15 going to happen, but that's kind of where the big fat part of the bell curve is for a year,
01:40:19 you know, going into the year. Now, I would tend to stick with that, except maybe widen that out
01:40:25 a little bit because of some of the boldness of our president. And I think that boldness is good,
01:40:32 but it's going to cause some volatility. And, you know, I'm not dodging the question. I'm just
01:40:38 being honest. I've been out of the equity markets other than what I'm mandated in my family office
01:40:44 to be. I'm at my lowest percentage in my family office. I'm only 25% invested in stocks there.
01:40:53 And I have zero vol-arb positions on right now in my hedge fund. So that tells you my view
01:41:02 of the volatility in the market. I think it's going to continue. If I'd been short any calls
01:41:08 today i would have had my head ripped off so um but i'm in and out of the market
01:41:15 i i i analyze the market uh for something called stochasticity which is is it performing in a
01:41:22 pseudo random way and that's what you know i'll put all your watchers to sleep on that but but
01:41:28 that's what i'm looking at and we're outside of a stochastic a pseudo stochastic market
01:41:33 with a bounce like today ron i'm curious do you um because it like you said i think there's
01:41:38 going to be a lot of volatility and um i don't i don't see a v-shaped recovery happening at least
01:41:46 at least for a while um so with a bounce like we had today do you think uh do you think we go up
01:41:51 from here or do you think we touch back down well i i am not a day trader uh and i don't you know
01:42:01 my stock portfolio will rebalance uh at the first of next month um and my vol arb so what what vol
01:42:10 arb does in a very concise way i'll try to be very quick about this is i try to take i try to
01:42:18 arb out the difference between uh implied and realized volatility that's called the volatility
01:42:24 risk premium. But I saw, you know, due to some quantitative things that there is not going to
01:42:32 be an ARB. And thank goodness, because realized has been way beyond implied over the last three
01:42:38 weeks. So that's very good. Thank you, Lord Jesus, for good models. But as far as what it does in
01:42:49 the next few days. Generally, these things sort themselves out in three-day cycles. Traditionally,
01:42:57 I would look at, I mean, if you want to get real technical, you can look at, you know, put three
01:43:02 percentage point bands around a 21-day moving average around the S&P 500. And if the market
01:43:08 trades outside of that, good luck trading it. If the market is inside of that, then you can kind of
01:43:14 have some level of normalcy. The problem is we moved back into those bands at the close today,
01:43:21 but off of a almost 10 percentage point move up, well, that in and of itself is that's
01:43:28 five sigma probably move up on the S&P. So I'm probably not even jumping in the vol-arb space
01:43:38 until the first of next week. And that's if things calm way down. So that's where my mind is
01:43:43 As far as what it does in the next few days, that's not really my knitting.
01:43:48 I trade on a longer timescale than that.
01:43:52 Yeah.
01:43:52 Okay.
01:43:53 Joel, I don't know if legally I hear all the cool podcasts do it,
01:43:57 if we have to say something about how this is a guest and we're talking opinions
01:44:01 and none of this is legal advice or trading advice or, you know.
01:44:05 No, this is financial advice.
01:44:07 No, it's not.
01:44:08 None of this is financial advice.
01:44:09 Ron is not your financial advisor.
01:44:10 Neither are we.
01:44:13 But no, I want to make some. I am not a I am not a day trader. I trade in and out of stocks for my family office account once a month and I rebalance. I am a I'm a I'm a you. You want advice on volarb? Then you're my competitor and I'm not giving it. So.
01:44:33 fair enough uh any other questions that look worth addressing jesse s he says what's the
01:44:43 theme for next year's conference honestly i couldn't tell you i you know not that you won't
01:44:50 you couldn't i couldn't tell you i would tell you um no like i'll say this um i just think
01:44:58 everything is shifting and changing so quickly there's been so many fractures um in the world
01:45:05 in our in our country politically and ecclesiologically um ecclesiastically like
01:45:11 within the church um that it's it's hard to predict honestly it's it's hard to predict um
01:45:18 what the lord may be doing what would be most useful what would be most helpful and it's perhaps
01:45:23 even exponentially more difficult to predict who to invite i think that that's in in some sense
01:45:32 that's one of the mistakes that i've made in previous years is trying to solidify our conference
01:45:39 you know too soon well ahead of time it's nice for people to plan but then but then something
01:45:46 happens and all of a sudden you know the person that you know one of the people that you invited
01:45:53 it's like uh you know like maybe he doesn't doesn't really like you anymore you know and so
01:45:59 it feels like every six months there's like some earth shattering you know transition and uh change
01:46:05 that's uh happening and so i i don't really know if i had to guess today one one of the things i'll
01:46:12 say this um i don't know what you know a year from now what what what will happen we'll start
01:46:17 you know making plans and and as we make plans we'll make announcements and uh and make that
01:46:22 you know public information but for now um the biggest my biggest takeaway from the conference
01:46:29 and and it's not really because of anything that somebody specifically said at the conference but
01:46:33 i've just been feeling this leading up to the conference and i feel like it's all the more
01:46:36 confirmed um after the conference uh just in conversations that i've had with people um i i
01:46:43 think dan burkholder and i had a conversation on wednesday night and i thought it was really
01:46:49 insightful um it was it was the two of us and um and you know the other ogden boys were there eric
01:46:56 and ben and so you know so the four of us were talking but dan and i were primarily you know
01:47:01 going back and forth and we're talking about like the next four years now that we've had a trump
01:47:04 victory and these kinds of things and the first thing that dan said was um that because we've had
01:47:10 this victory you know which is far from perfect and there's a ton more work to do and honestly
01:47:15 in my opinion you know not not speaking about finances or tariffs or the i i'm i those things
01:47:21 i'm i'm i'm pretty pleased but there's some other issues where i'm like i think the verdict's still
01:47:26 out whether or not uh how much of a victory this is actually going to be right like if if
01:47:31 if all of a sudden you know income tax is done away with and you know america enters you know
01:47:38 financially a golden age but um but i i have to think about how to plan my prison ministry
01:47:44 um because trump's greatest contribute contribution is um anti-anti-semitism laws
01:47:53 and palantir's facial recognition puts me in jail then you know i don't know for me personally i
01:48:01 don't know if it uh you know if i'd be looking back and say yeah that was a victory all right
01:48:05 yeah we're winning you know i'm like at that point i'd be like yeah i think i am sick of
01:48:10 winning because winning threw me in jail but um uh so here's my point dan was kind of saying like
01:48:16 i think it's gonna be harder for for ministries and and different you know media companies and
01:48:22 stuff like that to distinguish themselves in the next four years on the backdrop of victory whereas
01:48:27 the last four years there were so many headwinds and now we may have some tailwinds but there were
01:48:32 so many headwinds that it was really easy to distinguish yourself and i know what he's saying
01:48:37 And I generally agree. He was talking about COVID. He was talking about, you know, mostly peaceful riots, you know, in the summer of love and George Floyd and BLM, you know, and all these different things. And saying that, like, you know, if you just, if you had some courage, then you could, you know, you could distinguish yourself from all of Big Eva and all, you know, this group. And all of a sudden you start to, you start to stand out. And I think that's a generally right instinct. I think he's correct.
01:49:04 but i actually i told him and and he ended up agreeing with me i i think it won't be harder
01:49:10 to distinguish ourselves in the next four years i think it'll actually be far easier and the reason
01:49:15 why is is not because you know after careful consideration i've decided to become worse
01:49:20 it's not that scenario although i have after careful consideration i have decided to become
01:49:24 worse but without becoming worse this is my point you will not have to step forward this is my
01:49:30 prediction for the next four years. You will not have to step forward. All you have to do is stay
01:49:35 put in terms of courage and what you're talking about and what you're willing to address. You
01:49:39 don't have to take it up a notch. You don't have to step forward. You just stay put and you will
01:49:44 distinguish yourself because all of your friends are going to be taking 10 steps back. And I'm
01:49:49 watching that happen in real time. I'm watching that happen in real time. I'm watching, you know
01:49:55 what, now that we've had this win, I'm doing the calculus. And for me personally, you know, my
01:49:59 goals are really more suited towards this and i don't know if i really want to go after this issue
01:50:04 you know that gets you in trouble and i don't really know like this is enough like a lot of 0.64
01:50:09 people right now are and i'm not talking about you know a bunch of heathens i'm talking about
01:50:13 i'm talking about reformed ministers i'm talking about christians um and i think a lot of them are
01:50:21 doing the calculus and they actually are saying um it's enough winning for me uh this is enough
01:50:27 winning for me i've i've won enough and um and for me i'm i'm looking at that and um and it's not
01:50:35 enough winning for me um i think that there are formidable enemies of christ that are still at
01:50:42 large in the world there's been um zero threat posed to them they're walking around uh free as 0.87
01:50:49 bird uh terrorizing a whole swaths of the church and uh and i plan to go for their throats and um
01:50:59 and i plan to talk about those kinds of issues and um and it's not really so much a change for
01:51:07 me but it's just i'm going to continue doing what i'm doing and i have lots of friends that i
01:51:12 respect and i'm not even saying they're wrong so i'm not even saying hear me i'm not saying this
01:51:16 it's objectively compromised and this person is in sin or this person is selling out or i'm not
01:51:21 saying any of those things everybody has to decide individually but the reason why ogden and i
01:51:25 georgetown and ogden are so aligned part of it to just to be frank it's it's not just conviction
01:51:31 it's not just theological um but but there is there's a practical calculus ogden in addition
01:51:37 to you know like they're insulated like who's going to fire brian so they
01:51:41 their elder rule they're not a part of a presbytery right like like all the the guys
01:51:50 who became presbyterian you know in the last five years it's like well are you presbyterian 0.83
01:51:54 because kind of the key word there is presbytery you like you're just paedo baptist you're john
01:51:58 owen you're a congregationalist you know who baptized babies and that's great i'm here for
01:52:01 it that's you know i support you but my point is in just in terms of their church polity they're
01:52:05 not a part of presbytery it's it's um it's it's inside it's autonomous it's elder rule
01:52:13 um brian is bulletproof and i'm glad he is i'm not saying any of that is a bad thing i
01:52:20 thank god that that brian survey and eric khan um that they actually can't be canceled they can't
01:52:27 they are bulletproof they are uncanceable and and outside of their church life pastorally what
01:52:33 they're doing there and that's and that's first and foremost and that has to be the priority but
01:52:37 beyond that um what are they doing as they're making the calculus for the next four years what
01:52:42 are they trying to do um they're they're starting a media company and so in starting a media company
01:52:48 they have every incentive to distinguish themselves and not just be big con ink you know and like
01:52:56 you know daily wire 2.0 yeah daily wire you know you know the israeli wire 2.0 like they're no
01:53:02 they're going to want to distinguish themselves and exercise, for them, courage is currency.
01:53:11 For them, it is in their practical best interest. Aside from theological convictions and their
01:53:16 fidelity to the Lord Jesus Christ, they have every practical incentive to exercise courage.
01:53:22 There are plenty of other guys that we love, guys who are on the broader team. So what I hope
01:53:26 doesn't happen, I'll add this disclaimer, is we don't need any more fracturing. We don't need any
01:53:30 more divisions we don't need to go we don't need any more brother wars i really hope that we could
01:53:35 be done with that so what i foresee is actually more divisions but more charitable divisions
01:53:39 where we can have a broader team where we genuinely love each other but it may get to the
01:53:44 point where where there's still enough separation distinction between us where it's simply not
01:53:50 advantageous for instance for someone like william wolf who i admire and respect uh but it just may
01:53:58 not make if if he's trying to unseat the erlc and brent leatherwood with cbl um and win normies
01:54:06 in the sbc that is a noble and honorable cause and it just may not suit his practical purposes
01:54:12 to speak at our next conference right and get blacklisted you know like and so that's just a
01:54:19 practical calculus that doesn't say anything about william compromising anything that's that's my
01:54:24 point so i don't want anybody to read it like think like this is cryptic what's he actually
01:54:28 saying is there another brother war you know brewing behind the scenes not that i'm aware of
01:54:33 i'm sure there is but not that i'm aware of um i'm not saying any of that what i am saying is
01:54:37 um there have been the brother wars where it's like it's the reformed you know they call it the
01:54:41 reformed longhouse i i think in some ways there is that but there's also the reformed deep state
01:54:46 where it's like this is a hit job we're trying to take somebody out like we're literally trying
01:54:50 to destroy you um and i i think that we'll probably get a little bit less of that because
01:54:55 i think a lot of those dividing lines have already fallen and people just kind of you know let bygones
01:55:01 be bygone and go in their separate ways right i think a lot of that dust is settling hopefully
01:55:05 by god's grace we don't have that like just full-on shootouts but i do think we'll still
01:55:10 have fractures they don't have to be they can be i think they'll be amicable fractures i don't think
01:55:16 they have to be mean spirited i don't think they have to be bloody um but but i do think we're
01:55:21 gonna have fractures where it's like this group that two years ago we might have partnered on
01:55:26 something or this group that you know six months ago we might have been doing this or he might have
01:55:31 come on the podcast and and now he's not going to and it's not because he's not an ally it's not
01:55:38 because he's not a part of this broader um banner of like a co-belligerent and it's not even because
01:55:43 he's not a friend i can still pick up the phone and call him privately i could get counsel uh he
01:55:48 loves me i love him even behind the scenes there might still be some partnering there might even
01:55:52 be a donation from someone you know from time to time but in terms of public facing everybody's
01:55:59 doing the personal calculus now that we have some some tailwinds um all we've had is headwinds
01:56:05 forever forever like we as conservatives we didn't think tailwinds were a thing we forgot that like
01:56:11 that that could actually happen so now that like we we actually have some tailwinds people are
01:56:16 going to be making the calculus of what to do with those tailwinds which chart to course or which
01:56:21 course to to chart and and they're going to be you know and some of the guys are going to say
01:56:25 these tailwinds are enough to to to get me what i'm trying to do i'm trying to start a business
01:56:31 i'm trying to win the sbc i'm trying to just pastor a church and and and it's a bunch of
01:56:39 normies or a bunch of boomers or a bunch of you know whatever and they're not they're not ready
01:56:42 for a conversation about x y and z and and so there's going to be a lot of people making that
01:56:48 calculus based off of what their ministry is what is their vocation what are they doing what are
01:56:53 their goals um ogden and georgetown are unique in the sense that um we're both highly insulated
01:57:00 um just like ogden uh you know our church covenant bible church is independent um
01:57:08 and and in terms of internally with the church um people can drop whatever hit piece they want
01:57:15 and because i've been honest and forthright um the church is not caught off guard they're not
01:57:21 surprised and they're for me they're in my corner and so uh brian silvey and eric khan are bullet
01:57:27 proof. Joel Webin is bulletproof. And in addition to our local church ministries, we both also have
01:57:33 the same practical goals of we're both starting media companies. And in that world, when that's
01:57:41 your objective, we have every practical, like everybody else who's going to be taking five
01:57:48 steps back or 10 steps back or 20 steps back saying that it's please, Mr. President, it's
01:57:54 enough winning this is all i need for me my family my vocation my goals um and they're going to play
01:57:59 ball a little bit and just say hey it's good you know this is this meets my goals and what i'm
01:58:04 trying to achieve for for guys like ogden and guys like us um that actually is counterintuitive to
01:58:12 our goals we do that if we do that uh we lose our entire listening base and for all those who are
01:58:19 listening right now i would say kudos well done you should leave if uh if if i back down you
01:58:26 should leave you should stop watching you should stop supporting um if i back down you have you
01:58:32 have my unadulterated blessing to absolutely abandon me and uh and it's the same ogden is
01:58:40 the same calculus with him like eric and i you know we talked just yesterday morning and we're
01:58:44 like yeah um everybody's still our friend we love them wish them the best privately if there's
01:58:51 anything we can do to help them serve them um absolutely 100 no public counter signaling
01:58:57 right no no you know uh subtweeting and uh you know like no we're not doing that
01:59:03 but uh for ourselves individually and what what we're overseeing after careful consideration
01:59:11 we've decided to become worse so anyways all that back to the conference question you know what's
01:59:17 what's the theme of next year's conference um tbd it's to be determined uh but it'll probably
01:59:25 if i had to guess if anything it'll probably be something along those lines it'll be um it'll be
01:59:31 identifying what are the dragons right because lots of people like to lark they like to go to
01:59:37 the dead carcass of the dragon that was killed 50 years ago you know like racism you know and
01:59:42 they just they kick it you know and hit it with their pretend wooden toy swords you know and
01:59:47 pretend to be you know you know knights in shining armor fighting a dead dragon that somebody else
01:59:51 slayed 50 years before they were born um that's that's not what i'm gonna do that's not what
01:59:57 ogden's gonna do so for us i think you know in in looking at future themes and things that we're
02:00:03 going to address it's going to be um it's going to be whatever the reigning terror whatever the
02:00:08 leviathan is um presently not the leviathan of 50 years ago not the leviathan of four years ago
02:00:15 it's not just going to be rehashing crt and wokeness um like you know like we're not we're
02:00:21 not going to larp anymore wokeness um no there's plenty of people who are not putting the woke
02:00:25 away but a lot of people are like a lot of people are putting the woke away even if they didn't want
02:00:31 to because because just capitalism is is saying no to wokeness and um and so a lot of people are
02:00:37 putting so we're not we're not going to just go and and uh address wokeness while fully embodying
02:00:44 woke light you know like no we're we're gonna we're gonna keep pushing the ball forward you
02:00:50 know what's what's the next thing and um and i have some ideas and we'll probably have to save
02:00:55 that for another episode but i think there are at least three three pillars um formidable enemies
02:01:03 of the church in our american context that must be must be addressed and um and i'm going to
02:01:11 address them and i'm talking about you know doing series on these topics and there's a lot of things
02:01:17 that we'll be announcing in the near future that i'm excited about so uh that's it for a conference
02:01:22 question that's it for all the questions that's all the time we have ron do you have any final
02:01:26 thoughts or final words that you'd like to leave the audience with where can we find you too oh
02:01:30 yeah how can we follow uh i'm uh ronald dodson on uh twitter at ron dodson uh and then i have a
02:01:39 sub stack the eyes of apilles uh which is uh ron dodson sub dot sub stack however that works
02:01:46 uh then i write for american reformer uh i was just published uh as i mentioned in uh the american
02:01:54 mind yesterday uh i think i'll have another piece coming out with them in the next week or so uh
02:02:02 and uh you know i uh oh i'm on with con the guys contramundum often and uh and with several other
02:02:12 I've been on, I got an appearance with Pete Canona's coming out in the next day or two.
02:02:18 Nice.
02:02:19 And so you can find me if you just put Ron Dodson or Ronald Dodson in, I'm out there.
02:02:28 All right.
02:02:29 Great.
02:02:29 Well, thanks for coming on the show.
02:02:30 We appreciate your expertise and your willingness to address this topic that was a little bit
02:02:36 above our pay grade, but we did our best and it helped to have you on the show.
02:02:40 Thank you.
02:02:41 well thank you guys appreciate it all right thanks to the listeners thanks for
02:02:46 tuning in and we will see you Lord willing on Friday God bless