The NXR Podcast - January 10, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Is Scripture Sufficient For Politics? With C.Jay Engel and Andrew Isker

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - How England’s Elites Abandoned Their Country’s Children THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - “Judeo-Christian” Was Always A Psyop - S04E01 w Andrew Isker @contramundumpodcast

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 45 minutes

Words per minute

183.01

Word count

19,397

Sentence count

615

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

42

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Well-known and beloved moderate centrist C.J. Engel ruffled feathers yesterday when he posted the post, " Scripture is sufficient to understand the gospel and be saved, and to inform righteous living. It is not sufficient to resolve political problems, create a sustainable culture, give a united social vision, or provide practical guidance for living in the material world."

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it.
00:00:04 It's annoying.
00:00:05 Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm so that
00:00:12 our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:15 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries
00:00:20 aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 Well-known and beloved moderate centrist C.J. Engel ruffled feathers yesterday when he posted
00:00:36 the following, Scripture is sufficient to understand the gospel and be saved and to
00:00:42 inform righteous living. It is not sufficient to resolve political problems, create a sustainable
00:00:49 culture, give a people a united social vision, or provide practical guidance for living in the
00:00:57 material world." This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and
00:01:05 Reese Fund, as well as our Patreon members and donors. You can join our Patreon at patreon.com
00:01:13 forward slash RightResponseMinistries, or you can donate at RightResponseMinistries.com
00:01:20 forward slash donate. So today, join us with my co-host, Wesley Todd and Michael Belch,
00:01:28 and in addition, special guest, Andrew Isker, and the troublemaker himself, CJ Engel, who will be
00:01:35 coming on the show to discuss his recent post, The Sufficiency of Scripture, and All of Christ
00:01:41 for all of life all right we all got the green memo today that's right texted it out 9 a.m we
00:01:57 all coordinated and aligned west would text something like that out but uh he would be
00:02:02 immediately ridiculed by both michael and i and so uh so he doesn't sorry i restrained myself
00:02:08 We'll bring you talking about that post.
00:02:10 Talk with the man himself who posted it.
00:02:12 Let's go ahead and just start off with what the New Testament says about itself.
00:02:17 It can almost feel like a bit of a fresh rune because in the 80s and the 90s and 2000s,
00:02:22 it was the battle for the inerrancy, the infallibility, and the sufficiency in many ways of Scripture.
00:02:28 There was a lot of higher criticism of theological liberalism that was really coming in and saying,
00:02:33 like, is the Bible really infallible?
00:02:35 Is the Bible really inerrant?
00:02:37 Does it really apply to all of these things?
00:02:39 I mean, for decades, you listened to Sproul talk about this.
00:02:42 I was listening to some of his lectures today, to Rush Dooney.
00:02:45 That was the battle they're fighting.
00:02:46 Scripture is reliable.
00:02:48 It is inerrant.
00:02:49 It is infallible.
00:02:51 Direct, plenary, verbal inspiration inspired in every word by God.
00:02:55 So that was the battle.
00:02:56 But then, so to hear kind of some of those that, you know, still remember that and you're
00:03:00 still living with that emphasis that the teachers of kind of a generation past put on it, to
00:03:04 hear someone from our camp kind of come and say, and hey, here's some practical areas where you
00:03:09 said scripture isn't sufficient. But hang on, didn't we just have this battle? Then we just
00:03:13 fight for it being perfect and the word of God and applicable and all of these things. So let's
00:03:18 just start off. Let's read what the New Testament says about itself and then talk about that
00:03:22 intersection of life and living and how God's word applies to it. So this is a classic and
00:03:29 I love it. I love how Paul's exhorting Timothy here. 2 Timothy 3.17, all scripture is breathed
00:03:35 out by God and profitable for, notice kind of the categories he lays out, teaching for reproof
00:03:42 or correction and for training in righteousness that the man of God may be complete, equipped
00:03:47 for every good work. So Paul's writing to Timothy. He's exhorting him to study and labor in the
00:03:52 scriptures. And he says it's for teaching and for reproof and for correction and training in
00:03:56 righteousness to the end result that the man of God is equipped for every good work. 2 Peter 1.3,
00:04:03 sometimes this is kind of merged together and blurred together with scripture. In the broader
00:04:08 context, it seems that Peter's more saying the Christian is equipped by God for everything he
00:04:12 needs in life. He says this, 2 Peter 1.3, his divine power, that is God's, has given us everything
00:04:18 required for life and godliness through the knowledge of him who called us by his own glory
00:04:23 and goodness. And so just to be kind of technical there, Peter's speaking more broadly that through
00:04:28 the knowledge of God, the man of God is equipped for every good work. He's equipped for life. He's
00:04:34 equipped for godliness. But specifically, Peter there is not speaking of Paul's writings or the
00:04:39 Old Testament scripture as he does in other places. First Peter, he starts off with that.
00:04:43 Later in 2 Peter, he talks about Paul's writings, which are difficult to understand.
00:04:47 In 2 Peter 1, though, that's not what's directly in scope. And then lastly, Hebrews 4.12, for the
00:04:52 word of God, there's dual application here, certainly of the scripture, but also of Christ
00:04:56 as a word of God, is living and active, sharper than any two-edged sword, piercing to the division
00:05:01 of soul and spirit, of joints and of marrow, and discerning the thoughts and intentions of the
00:05:06 heart. That's Hebrews 4.12. And that's where scripture in the New Testament specifically
00:05:10 speaks most directly and self-reflectively about itself. Good. Yeah, a lot of it with this topic
00:05:19 and other topics as well but particularly this topic a lot of it comes down to the framing of
00:05:24 the debate right so um you can lose the argument before the argument even begins depending on you
00:05:31 know who gets to frame the debate who gets to set the terms the rules for the match so if you have
00:05:38 somebody who's moderating this kind of debate and they say in one corner standing you know six feet
00:05:44 tall, you know, weighing 185 pounds, ripped and shredded to the max, we have the sufficiency
00:05:52 of the infallible Word of God. On the other side, we have somebody who hates the Word of God
00:05:58 and trusts the reason of man more. Like, all right, you're done, you know? And I want to be
00:06:05 clear here. I think this is one of the reasons why people absolutely hate me and our podcast
00:06:11 and my ministry, public ministry. And at the same time, for those who are perhaps a little bit more
00:06:18 good faith and have been following along for a few years now and haven't just tuned in, you know,
00:06:22 15 minutes ago, this is why I think they like me. Because I'll be the first to admit that I am a
00:06:31 work in progress, that I am learning in real time. And whenever I change a position, which is not all
00:06:38 the time i don't change a position every week but i have changed a position within a year which is
00:06:43 still relatively a short period of time not a major position like justification i've been you
00:06:49 know a calvinist and holding to the you know the five solos and the tulip and those kinds of things
00:06:54 in terms of soteriology since 2007 now at this point so for a minute um but there are other
00:07:01 things where i'm still in development but what i like to do that i think the good faith actors
00:07:05 appreciate rather than despising and using as an opportunity for a cheap shot below the belt is
00:07:11 when i change a position um i'll actually say out loud that i changed a position i'll actually admit
00:07:19 it um there are other guys who change positions too um but they often will change positions and
00:07:25 pretend as though it's the position they held all along right i think that's one of the key
00:07:29 differences i'm a little biased but i think that's one of the key differences so that said about two
00:07:34 years ago, a year and a half to two years ago, I would have framed the debate the way that I just
00:07:41 said facetiously a moment ago. I would have said, in one corner we have the sufficiency of the Word
00:07:46 of God, in the other corner we have the reason of man and this arrogant person who thinks that
00:07:52 it's superior to God's Word. Today, I would frame it differently. One of the ways that I would frame
00:07:59 I mean, it is, I would kind of gravitate a little bit over towards the regular principle of worship.
00:08:05 I'm a regular principle of worship kind of guy.
00:08:08 We have a fairly, you know, it's, somebody could walk in and they wouldn't be lost on our Sunday morning, Lord's Day, worship gathering.
00:08:18 But in, as far as Baptists go, in the Baptist world, it's relatively high church for Baptists, which isn't saying a whole lot.
00:08:27 I acknowledge.
00:08:28 The bar is low.
00:08:28 But, like, we have a covenant renewal liturgy we call, you know, the sacraments, sacraments, instead of just ordinances and things like that.
00:08:38 And so it's relatively, yeah, the Apostles' Creed every single week.
00:08:42 That's, you know, in our confession of faith, which comes after, you know, the assurance of pardon, which comes after a corporate confession of sin.
00:08:49 And, you know, there's a call to worship, a prayer of ascendancy.
00:08:52 And then towards the end, you know, we take the Lord's Supper every week, not just once a quarter.
00:08:58 I appreciate Welch's in my personal life with my children who are very young from time to time,
00:09:04 but we are Welch's disrespecters on the Lord's Day.
00:09:08 We use wine, you know, so we're taking the Lord's Supper.
00:09:11 It's all culminating into communing with the Triune God.
00:09:15 John Owen, he talked about how the justification is the heart of the gospel,
00:09:20 but not the end of the gospel,
00:09:22 that the end of the gospel is actually eternal and perfect communion with the Triune God.
00:09:27 So it's not just rehashing over and over the means of salvation, but actually enjoying
00:09:32 what that salvation produced for us, which is reconciliation with God, communing with
00:09:36 Him in eternal bliss and joy and peace forever.
00:09:40 And so our service reflects that, that the gospel is preached in the liturgy always.
00:09:46 It is often preached in the sermon, depending on the text.
00:09:50 And I do believe the gospel is in every text in a large sense, not necessarily every verse,
00:09:54 but as Spurgeon would have said, maybe not every verse, but every chapter. And then that culminates
00:09:59 in the Lord's Supper, which is a part of our liturgy. And that's the bellying up and you have
00:10:03 the gospel there, but more than just the gospel in terms of the heart of the gospel justification,
00:10:07 but you also have the end of the gospel communion. We're actually sharing a meal
00:10:11 with one another and with the Lord. And so all these things, my point is that the regular
00:10:15 principle of worship matters. The regular principle of worship, just to flesh that out
00:10:18 for our listeners. It doesn't mean regular. Think regulated. The regulative principle of worship
00:10:27 means that you're only going to do in corporate worship on the Lord's day that which the Bible,
00:10:33 God's Word, clearly prescribes. The opposite position or the alternate position is the
00:10:39 normative principle of worship, which would assert that it's free game to do whatever the
00:10:44 bible does not explicitly forbid so as long as it's not forbidden right there's no verse that
00:10:49 says thou shall not use smoke machines so smoke machines are back on the menu you know um and so
00:10:54 we can do anything and everything and we will from you know uh cables that you know bring in
00:11:00 you know santa claus for you know sunday right before christmas you know from hanging from the 0.96
00:11:05 the chandelier here you know whatever we're going to do all those things as long as the bible doesn't
00:11:09 strictly forbid it whereas that's normative whereas the regular principle is the bible
00:11:14 regulates strictly what is permissible in Lord's Day worship. And it's not just that we avoid that
00:11:19 which is forbidden, but we only do that which is prescribed. So here's my point. The regular
00:11:26 principle of worship, which we adhere to, I do not believe that the regular principle of worship
00:11:32 applies 24 hours a day, seven days a week. I think it applies to our Lord's Day worship,
00:11:39 certainly when we gather as the church the ecclesia the gathering of the excellent ones
00:11:46 and all the earth the saints to preach the word publicly pray the word publicly sing the word
00:11:52 publicly in hymns and psalms and spiritual songs and see the word publicly in the only two images
00:11:58 that the lord jesus himself has actually prescribed as lawful for us in our worship that being
00:12:03 baptism in the Lord's Supper. So in that context, church, then I'm a regular principle guy through
00:12:10 and through. The Bible regulates. It's not just avoiding what is forbidden, but it's only doing
00:12:15 that which is prescribed. The regular principle of worship does not apply, not in any meaningful
00:12:21 way within the Reformed tradition to a Monday afternoon. The Bible doesn't talk about car
00:12:26 mechanics because there weren't cars at the writing of the Bible. And yet it is permissible,
00:12:32 even though I don't have an explicit command in Scripture to change the oil in my car,
00:12:38 it is absolutely permissible, and we would argue even necessary and prudent,
00:12:43 to go and get the oil changed from your car, or do it yourself.
00:12:48 And so that's how I would frame the debate now.
00:12:51 I want to say in one corner we have an actual Christian who is determined not to go to hell,
00:12:58 who believes in the sufficiency of Scripture, 0.82
00:13:00 And in the other corner, we have a rank heretic who hates Christ, who thinks the reason of man
00:13:05 is superior. Just a couple of years ago, I wouldn't have, I obviously wouldn't have said it 0.50
00:13:09 that, you know, that, you know, that, that hyperbolically, but I, but that's, that's how
00:13:14 I would have framed it. And, and that would have been dishonest framing. In my case, I can say it
00:13:20 was, it would have been ignorant framing, but I think others who do know better do it dishonestly.
00:13:25 whereas now i would say no no no the bible i don't think the bible ever claims to be
00:13:31 um the bible is sufficient but but the bible doesn't claim to be exhaustive
00:13:37 um in every single detail of human society and life the bible doesn't tell me um you know about
00:13:47 you know car car maintenance um and or plumbing and that's okay that's okay and so when it comes
00:13:55 a political life, my position is that I think the Bible does offer to us major principles.
00:14:02 This also gets into not just the sufficiency of Scripture, but also the perspicuity. Perspicuity
00:14:06 is just a really unclear word that means clarity, ironically. All Scripture, we believe in the
00:14:12 perspicuity of Scripture. That's a well-held Protestant belief. But we don't believe that
00:14:18 all Scripture is equally clear. We believe that the Bible is particularly clear on matters of
00:14:25 salvation, but perhaps less clear in other areas, which is why Christians can debate for centuries
00:14:33 over more secondary and tertiary issues, whereas there should be, apart from, in this case, rank
00:14:42 heresy, there should be uniformity and agreement on major primary issues, especially things like
00:14:49 doctrine of god and soteriology um so we think that all scripture is clear but there's a sliding
00:14:56 scale there are degrees of clarity and so i think both in the realm of sufficiency and certainly
00:15:01 in the realm of perspicuity um clarity the bible's level of exhaustive sufficiency and its degree of
00:15:11 particular clarity on a topic like like politics i i think is less than a topic like soteriology
00:15:22 salvation right and so i think the bible gives us the macro it gives us the big principles
00:15:27 like the bible does provide for us equal weights and measures in terms of what is just what is
00:15:33 justice but then how exactly to execute that justice um depends on people place time right
00:15:45 so i i think uh justice there's just in the macro there's the virtue of justice but then in the
00:15:51 micro um laws that that reflect justice god's standard of justice not man's that's set for us
00:16:00 But laws that accurately and helpfully reflect God's system of justice for driving on the highway, that had to be determined with prudence by people, and not in all times and all places, but particularly at the time that cars actually were invented in the places that had cars.
00:16:24 I don't think that's a crazy thought.
00:16:25 So do you guys have anything to say before we get ready to go to our first commercial?
00:16:29 Yeah, one thing is, it kind of dovetails together with what you were saying about cars.
00:16:36 1 Corinthians 10.31 says, whether you drink, dwell to the glory of God.
00:16:40 And I've heard from different people, I've heard one person say, there is no Christian
00:16:47 perspective on food.
00:16:49 You boil water, you make your mac and cheese, whatever.
00:16:52 And then I've heard other people say, there is a Christian perspective on food because
00:16:55 we don't eat our neighbors anymore, right?
00:16:57 And so there has to be, in my mind, at least an overarching way that Christians do all things for God's glory.
00:17:08 Now, to go with what you were saying about the car, Joel, it's a practical truth that if I take care of my car, that I change the oil, that I do the maintenance, according to the maintenance schedule of the manufacturer, the car is going to last longer, and that's going to cost me less money over time.
00:17:25 and maybe i can sell it for more and that's better stewardship that but that's my point
00:17:30 and stewardship is talked about that's my point i i as a christian want to add to that financial
00:17:36 benefit the tangent not the tangible the spiritual benefit of caring for my car in a way that pleases
00:17:43 god the the the natural man can take care of his car steward his car reap a financial benefit
00:17:49 sell it at a higher cost down the road, but he doesn't get the additional benefit
00:17:55 of having that done as an obedience to the Lord. I want to take care of the things that you give
00:18:00 Romans 14. It wasn't done in faith. Correct. Only a Christian can do something in faith. And I've
00:18:06 always defined that like not faith in general definition, but to do something, an action in
00:18:11 faith, I've always defined as simply as I can to do something in faith is to do it for the glory of
00:18:16 God with a reliance on his grace. To do it for God's glory, relying on God's grace. Go ahead.
00:18:23 So the question then, and we've been talking about categories, or we'll be talking about categories,
00:18:29 comes down to this. And this is a question I'm still thinking through, but
00:18:33 what is right then for a Christian nation, if we're aspiring to be, again, a Christian nation?
00:18:39 Well, to me, part of it is that the leaders and the people who actually are charged by God to
00:18:44 think through these issues, help the people think about how the things that they do that are maybe
00:18:50 derived by natural revelation, common sense, logic, but how do those reflect the fact that
00:18:58 we're a Christian nation, and how do they reap not just temporal good, but spiritual good as well,
00:19:03 by becoming ways of actually obeying and appreciating the design, the structure, the
00:19:08 character of the world that God has built, so that when we take care of our car, it's not just,
00:19:13 oh, I get more money. It's also, isn't it amazing how God set up the world? He wants me to be
00:19:17 faithful with this. This is a chance to be responsible, to be a good steward, and to
00:19:22 carry out my mandate in a small way of taking dominion and stewarding the earth.
00:19:26 Amen. Wes, any thoughts?
00:19:29 Gahardus Voss, he had a good series of lectures on natural theology, and he pinpoints that through
00:19:33 the church age, so it's easy to say, like, well, I'd go with the Word of God, right? Man's reason,
00:19:37 man's logic, man's principles, history, tradition, I'll take the Word of God. But the Reformed 0.98
00:19:43 tradition certainly, and even the Catholic, lowercase c Catholic tradition prior, from
00:19:47 Augustine through to Turretin, they definitely conceived of reality and nature and scripture
00:19:52 as two books. So God wrote the Bible, but then in the beginning God said, spoke, let
00:19:59 there be light. The world, the universe is upheld by the word of God's power. So God's
00:20:04 word, it is right here in the Bible. His written word that is infallible and this tree, this
00:20:10 set, me and you, were sustained by the spoken word of God. And that word speaks and reveals
00:20:16 things to us. It's not as though we have the Bible and God's word, and then everything else
00:20:20 is simply discerned and appropriated. And I'm aware of the argument of the reliability of
00:20:25 sense data. But if we assume the reliability of it, that we can perceive things as they are,
00:20:29 when we're actually saying, how do I solve this political issue? And I could look to scripture
00:20:34 and examples and analogs, try to bring them across and apply. Or I could look to history
00:20:39 and read Aristotle, we're not competing, do we take what God says for it or man? We're actually
00:20:45 saying in what way and manner has God spoken about this? A couple years ago, Michael, you remember,
00:20:51 my son actually got to the point where like discipline and parenting mattered. First couple
00:20:55 months, it's you survive, they eat, they sleep. There's not a lot of technique. But I was getting
00:21:00 to the point where, you know, like it was time for discipline. And I'd come up on all the classic
00:21:04 Christian parenting books, Shepherding a Child's Heart. And I felt it should be pretty simple,
00:21:09 right there's you got your verses discipline but then i realized the bible is shockingly lacking
00:21:14 in particulars or of spankings what age do you start what material do you always do the hand
00:21:21 if they reach out or they disobey you do you do all of those particulars the bible says a rod okay
00:21:26 that's fine right uh what what kind of rod wouldn't switch yeah what's it made up how big is it you
00:21:32 know like and then how many spankings exactly you know is it two three forty like and and it's
00:21:40 you're absolutely right like bible loving believers who love the word and know it well
00:21:45 that's one of the most common questions i've gotten as as a pastor is because they'll recognize like
00:21:50 um you know rebellion is bound up in the heart of the child and the rod removes it far from them
00:21:54 and these are people who love their children and love the lord and love his word these are not
00:21:58 abusive people i want to make that clear right and yet they've come to me and said like and like we
00:22:03 just had this all out you know battle like battle royale you know like it was like a war you know
00:22:11 like you know my wife was you know she was ducking behind the island you know wearing like a pot on
00:22:17 her head for protection like like our toddler you know was just was raging and you know and the bible
00:22:23 says that if we discipline them then that's going to fix it you know but um but it didn't fix
00:22:29 anything we we actually tried to discipline them uh we've got voices on here nate if you can take
00:22:35 care of that uh but we tried to discipline them and it didn't work right um and and they were still
00:22:41 rebelling and because they were still rebelling well we knew like we have to win this battle we
00:22:46 can't just you know what would that communicate to our child that if you you know if you just
00:22:49 keep rebelling, then eventually you get what you want. And so some of the practical wisdom
00:22:54 that I was able to offer them as someone who had more children and older children and had been
00:23:00 parenting longer was I told them, you know, we do it like a boxing match in rounds. So by God's
00:23:05 grace, our children have learned, and this would be a very rare occurrence now because our children
00:23:09 are very well-behaved children. But when they were younger, they were, you know, with a couple
00:23:15 of our kids there were occasions where um there's discipline there's not any uh repentance there's
00:23:22 defiance and actually the child is now further stirred up and even in more rebellion towards us
00:23:27 um and if you keep applying discipline in that moment and the only ultimatum the only the only
00:23:35 um way that you'll be willing to to relent is if the child submits and that child in that moment
00:23:41 is one a particularly young child that doesn't have a lot of wisdom and maybe a child who's
00:23:48 particularly strong-willed and they just then uh then if if your mindset if what you think
00:23:55 pleases the lord is i i won't stop disciplining until the child stops sinning then you're going
00:24:02 to discipline that child to death they're not going to stop there are times so so i that little
00:24:10 thing practical advice has been one of the most common pieces of advice that i've given to parents
00:24:14 is i say treat it like rounds you box and then you go to your corner so we would do two swats
00:24:20 oh you're not responding well you're you're yelling you're you're still angry you're arching
00:24:26 your back you're still in defiance you're not coming into fellowship you're not submitting 0.53
00:24:31 okay i'm going to leave you in your room instead of immediately going to that that next spanking
00:24:37 right we would no i'm going to leave you in your room and i'm going to give you a chance to calm 0.98
00:24:41 down and we would pray dear jesus please help so and so to calm down and to repent of their sin
00:24:48 i'm going to leave you in your room and i will come back and check on you and you better have
00:24:53 calmed down and be ready to apologize when i come back i come back it gives them a minute a minute
00:24:58 not just not just dealing with their fallenness the sin nature but their finitude the fact that
00:25:04 it's a two-year-old. It's a two-year-old. They're extremely finite, extremely fallen,
00:25:09 don't get me wrong, but also extremely finite. And so it's giving them a moment to collect
00:25:13 themselves and you're rooting for them. You're not against them. You're for them. You want them
00:25:17 to calm down. You want to aid them, want to help them. And so you give it two minutes. They still
00:25:23 haven't calmed down. Maybe you stand behind the door and listen a little longer, hoping and
00:25:27 praying, God, please help my little child to calm down. And then you come back in. Are you ready to
00:25:32 apologize you're ready to be back in fellowship you're ready to have a good attitude and and let's
00:25:37 say you know a lot of times it's yes but sometimes now they see you come in the door they say all
00:25:42 right now so we went to our stools like a boxing metaphor now it's round two pop pop you know and
00:25:49 then okay and and right after the pops they're not now they're the least calmed down right so
00:25:55 so but we're going back to our stools we're going back to our corners give you another chance
00:26:00 that little piece of counsel has been a lifesaver i've had more more than almost any counsel i've
00:26:06 ever given i've had parents say this is so helpful i've like no parenting book ever said this and the
00:26:12 bible doesn't explicitly say this i had no idea i thought that i was going to that ultimately i was
00:26:18 being disobedient to god and his word if i ever let up right and so like and and that like but
00:26:26 here's the deal um yeah the bible is sufficient for for for parenting i believe that in the macro
00:26:34 principles um but that little piece of big picture big picture but that little micro particular the
00:26:41 bible is sufficient in principles and certainly uh principles of eternal matters like salvation
00:26:47 the bible is not necessarily exhaustively sufficient in in um not principles but
00:26:53 particularities, especially particularities in categories outside of the eternal, things outside
00:27:00 of merely salvation. And if you don't get that, you are in danger of being a biblicist, which 0.95
00:27:06 sounds like a good thing, but it is not. And a biblicist parent, if they were being consistent, 0.57
00:27:12 would have to sit there and spank their child until they got quiet. And that might be 40 1.00
00:27:17 spankings in a row. And you better hope that your neighbors don't hear because you will lose your 1.00
00:27:23 child. What I was about to say is you didn't say, well, I tried the Bible's way, and I couldn't get
00:27:30 this child to calm down, and so I'm taking off the Bible's discipline, the Bible's principles,
00:27:35 and I'm stepping into, well, I'm going to leverage my reason and my logic to go ahead and figure out
00:27:39 how to solve the solution. Now, what you did is you discerned that human psychology, as God made
00:27:44 it, is such that we need space to calm down. When people are backed into a corner, what do we call
00:27:49 them like a caged animal a trapped animal people get defensive and so you recognize that god has
00:27:54 made the world such that people typically don't in a 30 second span back down from their position
00:27:59 and so discerning that that's how god made the world with the macro overarching biblical principle
00:28:04 of discipline and obedience and play you said i'm going to step back from this i'm going to give it
00:28:08 time and the point is none of that is you saying the bible's not enough we try the bible's parenting
00:28:14 way right got to toss it to the side you're same thing you're looking at god's word he made the
00:28:19 world this way, this is how people are, this is how sin works, and this is how I'm going to do
00:28:23 about it and actually navigate it. Amen. Because in the final analysis, in the ultimate macro
00:28:28 again sense, God's Word, what did it prove in the final analysis? Well, it proved to be true.
00:28:34 Rebellion really is bound up in the heart of a child, and the rod really does remove it.
00:28:40 Right. So none of what I just offered is in contradiction to the truthfulness and helpfulness
00:28:46 of god's word it's just particularities in the practical realm coming alongside the principles
00:28:53 in the spiritual realm and if you but if you don't have those categories right that's that's going to
00:28:59 be one of our episodes a couple weeks from now is on categories thinking in categories but a lot of
00:29:04 christians cannot chew gum and walk at the same time but by golly by the grace of god we're going
00:29:10 to need to learn too all right do me a favor uh like this video help us with the algorithm let's
00:29:15 get it out to as many people as possible. When you do that, it's not just trying to grow our
00:29:19 ministry. Yeah, I won't lie to you. I would like to see the ministry grow. You know why? Because
00:29:25 that means more numbers. Well, why do you care about numbers? Because they represent people,
00:29:30 and we want people to hear the Word of God. We want to help people. I don't know what to tell
00:29:34 you. So help us out with the algorithm. This is just part of the way that the world works,
00:29:38 especially the social media world. Like the video. It gets it out to more people. Comment
00:29:42 in the chat, if you're willing to. We'll try to engage the chat a little bit later on.
00:29:46 Go ahead and subscribe. If you're watching us live on YouTube, subscribe to the channel,
00:29:51 click the bell so that you're actually notified. Tons of people email me and say, I'm subscribed,
00:29:55 and I forgot about Right Response Ministries that you guys even existed. I didn't see anything from
00:30:00 you for three months. So click that bell so you're actually notified, and then go on over to X. If
00:30:06 you don't follow us on X, you'll get the videos, but you'll also get some freebies like
00:30:12 uh, this afternoon, me, um, taking off, um, all the, all the EO bros, all the permanently online
00:30:19 denomination. I become a catechumen. I'm on a Twitter account. Yeah. I'm online a lot. I'm
00:30:25 online a lot, but, uh, but I can't hold a candle and it wouldn't need to be a candle to the EO
00:30:31 guys, uh, a candle with a particular kind of incense. And, um, I always, I'm fond of saying
00:30:37 it's not appreciated though. I don't get why, but I'm always fond of saying that, uh, Eastern
00:30:41 orthodoxy is uh essential oils for men so um that's that's my i you know i what i posted today
00:30:48 was i was like i i uh reject eastern orthodoxy on two accounts one biblical faithfulness um
00:30:54 and this is an order of priority of course uh biblical faithfulness number two um i'm an
00:30:59 american the american tradition is um it is specifically protestant it is a protestant
00:31:07 and then protest western and then protest um i don't like roman catholicism either at all i hate
00:31:13 trent trent literally anathematized the gospel so i i don't like that um but i will be the first to
00:31:19 admit although i think there are massive problems with rome uh roman catholicism which is not
00:31:24 uniquely american it still would be more compatible in america than eastern orthodoxy
00:31:29 simply by virtue of it being western so anyways uh go ahead over to x the handle is at right
00:31:36 response m at right response m so that you can follow all of our videos go live on x and you can
00:31:43 get the free bonus of joel you know making people mad um in between videos um you're welcome so uh
00:31:50 this is what we're going to do we're going to have andrew isker and cj angle they're going to hop on
00:31:54 the show right after uh this first commercial break all right the clock is running out you need
00:32:00 to go and register now for our Christ is King, How to Defeat Trash World Conference. It's happening
00:32:06 the year of our Lord, 2025, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th. That's a Thursday, Friday, and Saturday,
00:32:13 and by God's grace, we're able to provide for you an all-star lineup. We've got Steve Dace,
00:32:18 Calvin Robinson, Orrin McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolfe, Eric Kahn, David Reese, Andrew Isker,
00:32:25 John Harris, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, C.J. Engel, and yours truly,
00:32:33 Pastor Joel Webin. Come on out. Join us April 3rd, 4th and 5th, 2025, Thursday through Saturday. Go
00:32:41 to rightresponseconference.com to register today. Again, that's rightresponseconference.com.
00:32:49 Okay, here we are. We're going to have Pastor Andrew and C.J. Engel joining us to talk about
00:32:56 our friend and well-known, beloved, moderate centrist, C.J. Engel, with a milquetoast,
00:33:07 boring take that should have offended no one, and yet it offended everyone. So you probably
00:33:13 can hear them right now i'm just uh talking unfazed but uh they obviously cannot hear me
00:33:18 so we're gonna keep working on it for a second as they get their audio figured out they're working
00:33:23 on it there we go can you hear us all right we've got the tennessee boys the tennessee titans is
00:33:31 that still a thing it's a football team yeah i know they're really really bad though oh they're
00:33:37 okay i didn't even know if it was still a team i'm not a small guy football team yeah andrew
00:33:42 Andrew's a sports ball guy. Are you, CJ?
00:33:44 No. What is sports ball?
00:33:46 Yeah, I don't really...
00:33:47 I forced him to watch a Vikings game with me
00:33:50 last week. It was fun. I got to see him
00:33:52 prostrate on the ground on his back.
00:33:54 I was about to say, that game did not go well.
00:33:57 That was the wrong game to show.
00:33:59 That's funny.
00:34:00 That's amazing. I got some live footage for premium
00:34:02 subscribers.
00:34:04 Nice.
00:34:05 This is a great idea.
00:34:07 This is a fantastic idea, Wes.
00:34:10 CJ, this is how I introduced you.
00:34:12 At the beginning of our episode, I said that we wanted to use a tweet from a well-known and beloved moderate centrist.
00:34:23 It's a milquetoast, middle-of-the-road tweet that should have offended no one.
00:34:27 And then we read it.
00:34:27 So do you want to read the tweet out loud and then tell us what were you thinking?
00:34:34 What was going through your mind?
00:34:36 So, like, yeah, I mean, first of all, I don't tweet after thinking.
00:34:40 I think about it after I tweet it.
00:34:42 the best way to tweet by the way find it what's that yeah go
00:34:46 west just said it's the best way to tweet it is go ahead and find it if you can't nathan can pull
00:34:54 it up no i i got it here so it says scripture is sufficient to understand the gospel and to be
00:35:00 saved and to inform righteous living and then the the kicker is that it is not sufficient to resolve
00:35:08 political problems create a sustainable culture give a people a united social vision or provide
00:35:14 practical guidance for living in the material world that's it that's the tweet all right what
00:35:20 do you think about it cj give us your thoughts yeah so what do you what do you think about the
00:35:25 responses to it whatever so there's a variety of different responses um you know like the people
00:35:32 i look up to um supported it the people i look down on hated it so that was good um i think
00:35:40 overall what i was trying to get at was um there's this tendency it's funny because like
00:35:46 the thing that came up was um the very theonomic um approach to politics obviously was one um
00:35:54 group of people that opposed it the other group of people was actually the ones that i was trying
00:35:58 to challenge, which is the people that, that try to, um, ask us to proof text every time we're
00:36:04 using a secular source. Right. So like if we use Aristotle, um, if we use other people that we're
00:36:10 not supposed to mention, like Carl Schmidt, um, other people that I've actually learned from James
00:36:15 Buchanan, James Buchanan, James Burnham, Pat Buchanan, others, um, that are not like derived
00:36:21 from scripture. Is that an appropriate use of, um, information of knowledge of, of contributions to
00:36:27 political and sociological theory? Is that an appropriate appeal? Can I make that appeal to
00:36:31 them? But also more generally, when we're crafting our approach to politics, can we use things like
00:36:38 common law, the Magna Carta, the US Constitution, Lockean political dynamics? Are these things
00:36:44 appropriate for use for the Christian in building a case for political action? And when I use the
00:36:52 word sufficient, what I had in mind is this definition of it's the only thing that we should
00:36:58 use. That's what I mean by sufficient. So the Westminster Confession refers to the fact that
00:37:04 the Bible is sufficient for being saved. In the context of the Reformation, they were making a
00:37:12 claim against Rome. The Bible itself is actually the only thing that a would-be believer needs in 0.83
00:37:18 order to inform um to be informed about you know what is required for salvation i don't think they
00:37:23 ever you know intended to expand that that understanding of sufficiency to things like
00:37:29 economics um you know political dynamics um historical analysis things like that i think
00:37:36 that it was a bounded uh rationale and that's what they were trying to do with that word
00:37:40 sufficiency though i use the word sufficiency very um specifically i i could have used necessary
00:37:46 i could have used authoritatively but i didn't because i think the scripture is necessary i
00:37:51 think it is i noticed that yeah i think it's and i think it's authoritative and all of these things
00:37:56 in all areas of life i just don't think it's the only thing therefore i i denied that it was
00:38:00 sufficient amen and i thought the exact same the moment that i read it i thought yeah i agree i
00:38:06 know what he's saying um and part of that is uh because carl schmidt remains undefeated um
00:38:11 cj is my friend and so and i don't mean because he's my friend he gets a pass no matter what he
00:38:17 says uh but what i do mean is that uh because he's my friend i um i'm going to read with the
00:38:23 deck not already being uh stacked against you from the get-go i'm going to read it you know
00:38:27 more charitably and more in good faith and those kind of things and but that was my first initial
00:38:31 thought was i was like uh if cj had said necessary um and i might have sent you a text and said hey
00:38:39 what are you saying uh but you didn't you didn't say because if it was uh the bible is not necessary
00:38:45 for political life like at all i'd be like wait a second but that's not what you said
00:38:50 when and so i took you to mean sufficiency in the sense of exhaustive right all-encompassing
00:38:56 the only uh the exclusive uh exclusivity the only source required whereas i'm thinking like
00:39:04 yeah you you can't you can't do politics with less than the bible but you need more you need
00:39:10 more than the bible yeah i mean the other thing too and it's not it's not even about just like
00:39:15 political theory or whatever it's like you know what does it mean to have a tranquil
00:39:19 social order what does it mean what does it mean to have a culture like there's other elements of
00:39:24 a culture there's language there's corporate myths there's shared memories there's um you know
00:39:31 like like patterns there's there's like the overcoming of struggles together there's um the
00:39:36 clothes that we wear the aesthetics that we're all pleased by these are all things that make up a
00:39:40 culture the architecture that we agree is beautiful beauty itself is part of a culture and you can't
00:39:45 just derive these things from logically deducing um in propositional form from the bible like
00:39:52 there's more to it there's more to um this is this is actually gets into like c.s lewis's men
00:39:57 without chests you know you're going to undermine the very nature the robust and and completed
00:40:04 nature of man if you deny him all of these other elements of good living um so like there's an
00:40:10 element of wisdom there's an element of learning from history and all of these things are actually
00:40:15 required including the bible as the very foundation and an infallible um source of authority that we
00:40:23 have, all these things are important to us. And I think that a lot of times these deracinated
00:40:29 American Western evangelical Christians can fall into this trap of refusing to look outside the
00:40:35 Bible. And they only do this, you know, they only do this selectively. Like they'll only like a good
00:40:42 example of this is actually like in Stephen Wolf's book, when so many people were frustrated with him
00:40:48 because he didn't list a proof text and every, you know, every step down the path, he didn't
00:40:52 was the proof text. And they criticized him for appealing to authorities outside the
00:40:57 preservation. Right. Same as the Antioch declaration. No proof text. Let's do this.
00:41:04 That's all that's really well said, CJ. I want to hear more from you, but also give Isker a second.
00:41:09 But real quick for the chat here, those of you who are watching us live, go ahead, please,
00:41:13 and start right now writing in questions for both CJ and Isker, because I'd love to be able
00:41:20 to engage, especially since it's Friday. I feel like Feedback Friday, it's got a good ring to it.
00:41:25 You might say, well, isn't that a Steve Dace thing? And I would say, it was. It's my thing now.
00:41:34 Anything I like is now mine. So I'm appropriating Steve Dace's thing. But Feedback Friday,
00:41:39 let's make it a thing. So in the chat, write your thoughts or help us put it in question form. If
00:41:45 you put it in question form, Nathan will go ahead and take those comments and separate that into a
00:41:49 category and I'll be able to read off questions for CJ and Isker. So Isker, what do you, what do
00:41:54 you think? Yeah, I think some of what, what CJ is saying too, um, it, like it applies to so many of
00:42:02 the, you know, hot button cultural things that are afflicting the church today. So like even,
00:42:09 even topics like, like patriarchy and, you know, male and female relations or,
00:42:15 or are men and women different right how do you address the trans issue right i mean there there's
00:42:22 there's plenty of bible this is what god created man you know male and female he created them
00:42:26 but uh there's there's a lot about the differences between men and women that is is simply assumed
00:42:34 by the bible right that uh that we all intuitively understand when you're a child
00:42:39 right that that men are bigger than women they're stronger than women um and and they they feel
00:42:47 different emotions of the exact same thing than you know men and women do differently uh and and
00:42:52 so like we we know all those things they're not spelled out for us in scripture uh but so you look
00:42:57 at like the complementarian debate from 20 or 30 years ago and what they wanted to do was like be
00:43:05 as reductionistic as possible. What is the bare amount that the Bible says about, you know,
00:43:11 a husband's authority over the wife and so forth. And, and to be as minimalistic as possible and
00:43:19 say, all right, well, yeah, I guess technically husbands have authority over their wives. So we
00:43:24 got to do that. And technically for reasons that are a total mystery to us, God says that men have
00:43:31 to be pastors and women can't um and and then that's it right and they even do things like i
00:43:37 don't know if you guys talked about um one of cj's interlocutors uh uh owen strayan but i'll
00:43:44 bring him up uh and uh right he uh he's you know uh losing it at cj on twitter and that doesn't
00:43:52 sound like owen that surprises me he's he's never done that he's never done that to me
00:43:57 i'm just kidding it's funny though exactly uh or me either uh but it's so funny because
00:44:05 right he he was involved in in that debate and instead of looking to uh what what so many i
00:44:14 mean just protestant rights reformed writers have said about the the distinctions between men and
00:44:19 women and their roles in society and so forth i mean all of this this heritage we have because
00:44:25 it relies on not just the bible it relies on common experience it relies on uh you know
00:44:33 naturally deduced uh things right so that's all thrown out so what are we going to do instead
00:44:38 we're going to fiddle with the trinity to try to come up with some explanation for why
00:44:43 why uh wives should submit to their husbands what we'll just say that jesus is functionally
00:44:48 subordinate to like they'll do that instead i mean something insane right to mess with the trinity
00:44:54 because you got to have a proof text and you need even stronger proof text than the proof text,
00:45:00 right? That's the concept. And so it's not a coincidence that like Owen Stray and, you know,
00:45:05 freaked out on CJ over this, because this is how people like that operate, right? You have to have
00:45:11 a proof text to justify whatever it is you already believed. So they wanted to be, you know, the
00:45:19 the bare minimum faithful to the bible yes we're gonna be complementarian and we we can't say the
00:45:26 reasons why everyone did patriarchy for all of human history um so we're gonna mess with the
00:45:33 trinity and so the same thing with anything political right they'll do that as well they'll
00:45:37 be like oh uh can a nation have borders and have an immigration policy well i mean there's there's
00:45:43 a couple of verses here and there about that but uh but then the they'll say like galatians 3 28
00:45:50 right there's no um there's no june or greek so we should have a multicultural society where 0.99
00:45:56 where you know i mean if we want to have millions of muslims running around raping girls in england 0.99
00:46:02 that's that's just part of it because there's no male there's no rather there's no um uh june or 1.00
00:46:07 greek so all how dare you andrew millions of millions of asian men yes it's asian men
00:46:14 yes japan did you know that a bunch of japanese people are currently in england
00:46:21 it's it's the japanese anybody really it could be anybody billions of possibilities but yeah
00:46:27 and and so yeah it's it's so like all of these things it's it all it's always a post hoc
00:46:35 justification using the bible to arrive at acceptable contemporary politics right that's
00:46:43 what these people always do that is what they always do you're right and i love how you use
00:46:47 the complementarian example and saying like well we have to find some kind of example in the trinity
00:46:51 and if you're unfamiliar with that uh to the listener the short version is this um is jesus
00:46:57 you know it goes like this is uh is the son equally divine to the father you know and equal
00:47:01 in terms of meriting worship and honor and praise and all this? And the answer, of course, is yes.
00:47:06 And then what they would argue is, yeah, but the son still plays while being equal to the father
00:47:11 in terms of divinity. He still plays a role of submission. But then, of course, the counter is
00:47:15 going to be, yeah, but that's because he took upon himself a second nature, namely the human nature,
00:47:19 and he was submissive to the father because he was fulfilling all righteousness and fulfillment
00:47:24 of everything that was said about him before the foundations of the world were laid. And so he did
00:47:28 that in his earthly life. And that's a pretty good counter. So then the counter to the counter
00:47:32 that you have to do with the ESF group, you know, or EFS, the Eternal Functional Subordination of
00:47:40 the Son, is going to say, well, actually, he's eternally even now, even in heaven, while seated
00:47:45 at the right hand of the Father, he's still in a role of submission while, you know, ontologically
00:47:50 he's equal to the Father in terms of divinity and majesty, but he's still, in terms of role,
00:47:55 you know the the economic trinity he is playing a um and you know long story short um one that's
00:48:02 bad trinitarian doctrine and two um i do think in large parts if you're trying to find a source of
00:48:08 what will you know what would possess a man you know what madness would drive him there you know
00:48:12 uh to the minds of moria you know like well uh the madness of feminism and uh and a weak man's
00:48:20 desperate attempt to prove that he's not a misogynist so well said uh can i read some
00:48:24 questions for both you and CJ, Michael and Wes also, if you guys got a thought here. But let's
00:48:29 start, scroll up just a little bit, Nathan. There's some really good ones here. Okay, this is a quick
00:48:34 one. This is from Michael. He says, what do you think are the best five non-Christian sources to
00:48:41 use to promote a Christian governing order? Non-Christian sources. That's a good question. 0.95
00:48:49 Well, so the framing is interesting because I wouldn't approach it in that way.
00:48:58 When I'm dealing with politics, I'm dealing with very practical problems, and I think one of the things that I continue to emphasize is that politics is not about blueprinting the ideal.
00:49:09 And if you approach politics in terms of it's about coming to the table, drawing out the way that a society should be structured, and then going out into the world and scolding people or whatever, coming up with means of attributing or obtaining this ideal, you're missing the point of politics.
00:49:29 the politics politics is very much about um dealing with the fact that we live in a world
00:49:35 of conflict and there's scarce resources and there's groups with a variety of different
00:49:40 interests and we have to work on protecting our own and confronting those that have um you know
00:49:47 a completely different vision of the world and you have to use power to do that like politics is
00:49:51 the theater of of power dynamics and so i i would i would disagree with the framing i i wouldn't use
00:49:58 a non-christian source to come up with a christian um you know blueprint of how government should be
00:50:04 that's not what i would that's not the that's not the function of the non-christian contributor to
00:50:09 yeah let me rephrase the question because it yeah like the question is it's still trying to arrive
00:50:15 at a universal principle when when you're saying that politics is particularist right it's it's
00:50:20 dealing with a particular situation so if i were going to rephrase the the listener's question
00:50:25 to be all right what five books would you say would be the best for from non-christians
00:50:32 to deal with the problems confronting christians in our in the united states of america today
00:50:39 right that that would be a better question i think right yeah i mean so then but then there's
00:50:45 the you know then there's the question of like are you are you talking about like how to like
00:50:49 what non-christian authors could i use in in training myself about how to think about political
00:50:54 problems right that's one thing um i would i would refer to people like edmund burke i would
00:51:00 refer to people like russell kirk or i mean both those men were christians but yeah but they're
00:51:05 not christian authors okay well that's fair yeah they are but in that sense carl schmidt is a
00:51:09 christian yeah i mean technically so like so they don't have they don't like i have like a theological
00:51:14 methodology about them yeah yeah it's not it's not uh like they're not theological books yeah
00:51:20 they're not theological books in fact the funny thing is that i'm thinking as more of a classical
00:51:24 thinker like all of these people are yeah i mean i would tell people to read like alinsky's rules
00:51:29 for radical not as a guide as like a framework of what ought but understanding the present
00:51:35 situation but understanding the is yeah yeah um and so concept of the political is a short book
00:51:41 too yeah say it again wes the concept of the political it's on youtube for free it's a short
00:51:46 book great read who's it by carl schmidt okay yeah i mean i'm sort of like a paul gottfried
00:51:53 stand so like i i think that like if you really want to understand like the present situation
00:51:59 like i would read things like his multiculturalism and the politics of guilt um you know i can't
00:52:05 believe you're recommending a jew while sitting next to andrew isker you know what i mean i've
00:52:11 been told i've been told by every major reformed leader that uh that isker and i we we wouldn't
00:52:20 even tolerate such a thing so i know right uh but it turns out they're wrong that's never happened
00:52:27 before one of paul's greatest contributions is like his dogmatic insistence that america is a
00:52:33 protestant country yeah like it's actually funny because like in in traditionalist conservative
00:52:38 circles you know everyone's kind of like returning to rome like that's like the thing to do i don't
00:52:43 know if you saw the twitter spat that broke out maybe you guys didn't see it when it's on the air
00:52:46 but like jay dyer wants to fight all of us uh yeah well that's good that's because of my tweet
00:52:52 did you see my tweet today yeah yeah that was a good one huh i'm like i'm like i'm like i need
00:52:58 to get joel a better picture of me so like jay dyer don't call me fat uh or or don't because 0.91
00:53:06 there's no better motivation to shit than to shed a few pounds than the entire public world 0.98
00:53:12 on the internet calling you fat you know i mean that's just about a powerfully motivated 0.99
00:53:15 dude you have no idea how much how hungry i am right now
00:53:19 you said something about how it was feed me friday and it like got me going
00:53:25 okay let's here let's do this there's a couple more questions i want to get to nathan go back
00:53:33 up for a moment um that's all the questions oh okay um so so one of them that i wanted to address
00:53:40 was uh so this is uh matt barouche i don't know does that sound right that sounds good all right
00:53:46 good enough matt brouche he says uh when it comes to psychology or counseling would you go outside
00:53:53 the bible for principles or techniques i'm going to take that one real quick uh what i would say
00:53:58 is i'm i you know land on biblical counseling as my position pastorally for people in our church
00:54:04 who are looking for counsel marriage counseling is usually 90 of what pastoral counseling is about
00:54:10 or counseling for parenting those kinds of things family related the reason why i reject i would not
00:54:17 look to modern psychologists for help is because all truth is god's truth the problem with the
00:54:25 modern psychologists is they don't have any of god's truth they actually modern psychologists
00:54:30 actually for the most part hate god and so psychology literally even within you know god's
00:54:35 written two books, special revelation, 66 books of the Bible, the canon, but also natural
00:54:40 revelation. The problem is that the psychologist hates both of those books. He hates natural
00:54:45 revelation just as much as he hates special revelation. The psychologist, at least pop
00:54:49 modern-day psychologist, you know, for us as Christians, we're saying, well, Jesus is the
00:54:55 ideal man. He's the perfect man, the God-man. So that's what we're trying to shape people into.
00:55:00 That's the process of sanctification being formed more and more to the image of the Son. And so
00:55:05 here's the end, the end game. And then also, there has to be good, not just theology, but
00:55:09 anthropology. Who are we currently? What is man? You know, and what are my problems? And so,
00:55:16 if this is Jesus, Jesus is over here, he looks like this, and this is man, you know, apart from
00:55:22 Jesus, and he looks like this, and now I know that my A and Z and which direction to go. Well,
00:55:28 psychology misses both of those. It misses who Jesus is, and it also has bad anthropology,
00:55:33 misses who man is. Psychology is literally the opposite of what the Bible says. For us as
00:55:39 biblical Christians, we would say on the outside, the exterior, man can do incredible things,
00:55:44 suspension bridges and trigonometry and rockets and all these different things because he's made
00:55:48 in the image of God. So on the outside, man is not a parasite or a mere consumer, but a lowercase
00:55:53 C creator in the image of God himself. But on the inside, he's totally depraved. Well, pop psychology 0.99
00:56:00 is basically there's really no difference in worldview from disney um it's the exact opposite
00:56:05 so they would say on the outside man is just consumers and that's why we need to abort babies
00:56:09 and have less people because we'll be overpopulated because people produce less than they consume man
00:56:14 is parasitical externally but internally um there's a there's a precious dream in his heart
00:56:19 and he's actually beautiful and wonderful and so um that's why i wouldn't go to psychology um but
00:56:24 But the bigger principle that I garner from this question, when it comes to psychology or counseling, would you go outside the Bible?
00:56:32 There's one more question on this, too, for the pastors.
00:56:35 Okay, scroll down, Nathan.
00:56:37 Oh, some guy.
00:56:38 Here it is.
00:56:39 And so he follows it up and says, question to Andrew and Joel as pastors, when it comes to counseling, would you go outside the Bible to external psychology?
00:56:45 So that's basically what I'm answering right now.
00:56:47 No, I wouldn't. But it's not because the psychologist relies too heavily on natural revelation and doesn't give enough proof text, chapter and verse. It's because the psychologist hates natural revelation as much as he hates special revelation. That's why.
00:57:05 I have an answer to that. I mean, I, I mostly agree with you, Joel. Uh, there is, I mean,
00:57:10 there is like one field of psychology that, that I find, um, you know, really interesting and has
00:57:17 a lot of insights and that's, uh, like family systems therapy. Um, so there's, there's a really
00:57:25 good book on this is, this is, I mean, this is a theme here today, uh, by, uh, by a man named,
00:57:31 Edwin Friedman, who is, I believe he was a rabbi, but he was drawing on the psychology
00:57:38 of another Jewish psychologist. 0.85
00:57:41 Shut it down. 0.93
00:57:42 Shut it down.
00:57:44 He's going to be interviewing Clayton next for family.
00:57:46 Yeah, that's right.
00:57:47 Yeah, that's right.
00:57:48 But no, no, like the, like, so one of his books that I think is, is, is really good
00:57:55 because it's, it's way outside the mainstream of psychology.
00:57:58 That's part of it. 0.99
00:57:59 So like when I say I agree in principle, like, yeah, the majority of psychology is just garbage. You're right. And so what his book, like Generation to Generation, like it looks at all sorts of different problems as they occur in families, typically, from one generation to the next, why certain things tend to happen within families and are passed on from father to son and mother to daughter and so forth. 0.99
00:58:27 um and it looks at at individuals not merely as individuals but part of an organic whole
00:58:35 um so it's uh you know the theonomists are going to love when i said but it looks at the world
00:58:39 covenantally right like that that you aren't merely an individual you are an individual but
00:58:44 you aren't merely one right you're connected to um to other people and other people have an effect
00:58:50 on, on how you feel inside, uh, on your behavior, uh, and so forth. And, you know, I think that book
00:58:57 does a really good job. Uh, I mean, there are, because it's not Christian, there are things that 0.99
00:59:02 they, that, um, that I think he gets wrong and you have to, you have to read it with wisdom, 0.95
00:59:07 right? You can't just take it and, and copy and paste it into your brain and think that this is
00:59:12 just perfect, but, but there there's wisdom there to, that can be applied. Uh, and so I think they,
00:59:19 that this author and um the the people that he was influenced by right they noticed something
00:59:25 about god's world and and the structure of god's world um uh and and i think it's really useful um
00:59:33 so i wouldn't i wouldn't reject it categorically but i mean uh i i mostly would and would say
00:59:40 there's a you know a few exceptions um but yeah yeah so it's there there are things to be gleaned
00:59:47 but not there's not very many of there's not very many of them uh not very many well yeah so
00:59:54 you know my perspective on this first of all is i think like like modern psychology is bunk
01:00:00 yeah you know but i think i think the more important lesson here like tom cruise knows
01:00:04 more about modern psychology like that's a good example is like okay there's a non-christian that
01:00:10 we can drop on like tom cruise uh being interviewed by matt uh lauer right uh two non-christians uh
01:00:16 having an argument about psychology i'll go i'll go tom cruise uh like crazy right but anyway sorry
01:00:23 i interrupted you no i mean like that's that's a typical thing that happens but so but i i i agree
01:00:30 with that for sure i think that the broader question is like the bible came from a certain
01:00:34 metaphysical background and it assumed a certain um nature of of man and his relation to the world
01:00:42 in history i think that's much healthier so um in general it's because of the the soil in which
01:00:49 the bible was written and god set up this metaphysic and history that produced something
01:00:55 like the bible and so therefore the bible i mean not therefore the bible is good but the bible is
01:01:01 is good in in the same way that other texts can be helpful yeah the bible of course is the
01:01:06 foundation of of all of these counseling problems and you have to get into the realm of sin and you
01:01:12 have to get into the brokenness that comes from spiritual decay and the bible of course is the
01:01:17 foundation of all of those things but at the same time i think we are living in a way that's at odds
01:01:23 with um the the created order and i think that a lot of classical authors understood the created
01:01:28 order just naturally and organically much better than we do today and all of our expertise and
01:01:34 credentialism yeah they they lived in a world that was real right they lived in the world that
01:01:39 god had created they didn't they didn't live in trash world and and so it it everything in in our
01:01:46 world is totally inverted and so if you're drawing on on sources today right they believe men can
01:01:52 become women and so forth like they believe in insane things so how could you trust like this
01:01:58 stuff you know you you could glean some very like some very important wisdom from um the lessons
01:02:06 of of the greek tragedies there's a lot there that speak to the despair that modern man feels today
01:02:14 and so that's what i mean by the fact that the bible was was born into this soil of rich
01:02:20 classical thought and i think that all these things are important um so i don't like as like
01:02:26 On principle, I don't say I never look out to the Bible, but the Bible itself is the preeminent solution.
01:02:33 It's the preeminent expression of God's mind in a way that pop psychology just doesn't have the presuppositions to hold a candle to.
01:02:41 You can't even approach it at all, yeah.
01:02:43 Let's go to the top real quick, Nathan.
01:02:45 Scroll up.
01:02:45 That's good, guys.
01:02:46 I appreciate that.
01:02:47 There's one more question I want to get to, and then we need to do our last commercial break, and we'll come back for maybe a couple more questions and some concluding thoughts.
01:02:54 So this is from Truddle.
01:02:55 he says how do we stop nathan already had the cursor right there because we've been working
01:03:00 together nathan is my cousin we're literally related so we've been working together technically
01:03:05 in the technical sense for 36 years it's like 36 years what were you working on well originally
01:03:09 we were working on things like donkey kong you know or building a tent you know in a fort in
01:03:14 the backyard but in some capacity one way or another we've been working together for a long
01:03:18 time so he he knew what question i was going to truttle he writes this how do we stop mask up
01:03:24 stay safe if anything is on the table, right? That's what I hear you saying, CJ. I hear a
01:03:30 Jordan Peterson-esque view of the Bible from you. If anything's on the table, CJ, wasn't COVID wrong
01:03:36 because it violated... No, let me finish the question. I'm being facetious, but wasn't COVID
01:03:42 wrong because it violated the regular principle of politics? It's a good question. I appreciate
01:03:48 Trudl, thank you. I appreciate you putting it in, but I would actually have a strong no to that,
01:03:53 but uh but i want to hear yeah go ahead cj you go first but let me repeat it one more time how do
01:03:57 we stop things like mask up and stay safe in 2020 if anything is on the table wasn't covid wrong
01:04:03 precisely because it violated the regular principle of politics and shuttle agrees with
01:04:07 us he's on our side he might be kind of like pointing out just like how do we kind of answer
01:04:11 the objection right if it's all up in the air right exactly he's with us but he's yeah asking
01:04:16 a good question what do you think cj yeah like i've never held a position that anything goes
01:04:21 like the state can do whatever it wants i mean this there's a there's a strong sense of like
01:04:26 you know um the state the state against history and like so this is what this is the one of the
01:04:31 things that i think you know maybe i'm i stress more than a lot of other people is what i call
01:04:36 the sanctification of history and the fact that um we have these historical norms that i think
01:04:42 um are authoritative that history actually is authoritative in terms of delineating what is
01:04:50 right and what is wrong for a state to do and if you know like we can appeal to the scripture and
01:04:54 there's there's warnings against tyranny and the sufferings of man that come from that but i also
01:04:59 think at the same time that heritage heritage can can be an argument in and of itself and i think
01:05:05 that our heritage is one of of these types of medical freedoms and i think that that in itself
01:05:10 is a justification for things but my argument is never that yeah the state can do whatever it wants
01:05:16 But rather, there's a clash of group interests at play. And these things are harmful to the expression of Western man in fulfilling the way of living that we've inherited. And so that, I think, is a justification for itself. I think that history provides its own justification. Our freedoms are particular to us, and we have a duty to uphold them as recipients of what our ancestors carved out for us.
01:05:43 Yeah, I think that's a good point. Yeah, I would just add to it that history, tradition, everything else, these are authorities, right? They aren't the final authority, and you're not making the argument that they're the final. The Bible is the final authority.
01:06:01 But when you reject that lesser authority and you say all we have is the Bible, right?
01:06:08 Then you're left with the legions of evangelicals who just said, well, Romans 13, right?
01:06:14 Romans 13, you got to obey them.
01:06:16 You got to do what they say, right?
01:06:18 But it's like, no, you have this history and tradition of American freedoms that our ancestors left us and preserved for us over generations.
01:06:31 that we're we're drawing upon that no you can't do this yeah right you're not allowed to do this
01:06:35 because we are americans yeah like that that's a valid argument it is a valid argument that's
01:06:42 a valid argument right we don't do that i didn't know it's a great argument i remember andy you
01:06:46 talking to me about uh a hotel uh in your small town when you were in um minnesota michigan or
01:06:53 where were you i was in minnesota yeah minnesota i've been in one time yeah and the and the you
01:06:58 you know, the bottom floor, like the, uh, the foyer, you know,
01:07:01 it kind of was turned into like a flea market and you're like,
01:07:04 it's a perfectly, perfectly valid argument to make to say simply to go to the
01:07:08 owner and do so, you know, respectfully and politely say, um,
01:07:11 we don't do that here. This is America. Yeah. You know? Yeah. And so, uh,
01:07:15 let, let me, let me, uh, take a crack at it.
01:07:17 And then I'm going to give it to Michael and Wes and make sure that they get a
01:07:20 chance to speak. And then we'll go to our commercial and we'll come right back.
01:07:22 Um, but that same question. So how do we stop, uh, the mask up,
01:07:26 stay safe kind of rhetoric, things like that, overreach, tyranny from the government,
01:07:30 if anything is on the table. Wasn't COVID wrong? Wasn't our mechanism as Christians
01:07:34 to say, well, it's the Bible. It's wrong because the Bible says that the state's job is to bear
01:07:42 the sword against the evildoer, and the state in this particular instance is overstepping its
01:07:46 jurisdiction, and so that's why it's wrong, and so we're going to worship anyways. My answer would
01:07:51 be um that that would be a lot of my rhetoric back in 2020 uh four would that be yeah four years ago
01:07:57 now uh that would have been a lot of my rhetoric is it four years or five years it'd be five or
01:08:02 five oh my goodness gracious almost five years so that would have yeah that would have been a lot of
01:08:07 my rhetoric is i would have said stay in your lane state you know um you know hashtag libertarianism
01:08:14 ron swanson you know whatever um but now i like here's it so here's the thing so let's just let's
01:08:20 just played out for a second um is so is it is it always a sin to miss church like is it ever
01:08:27 permissible in the sight of god for a christian who's a member of a visible church local church
01:08:33 to miss church when they're sick right and and like can can you miss church when you're sick
01:08:39 if you're burning up you have 103 fever you know you've got the flu this that the other
01:08:42 um are you is it permissible for you to stay home and and i would say yes it is um but but then what
01:08:49 the next thing that this is what we're all we we just assume this it's it's it's inescapable what
01:08:56 you're what you're having to interpret is two books not one you're looking at special revelation
01:09:01 and all that you know so the hebrews passages you know do not forsake the gathering you know
01:09:04 and especially all the more as you know that you see the day drawing you yes and amen a million
01:09:09 times uh but but the second book natural revelation is i need to be able to say uh well am i sick am
01:09:15 I contagious? Am I going to subject everybody else to being sick? In other words, the pushback on
01:09:21 COVID, we weren't, the church wasn't prepared for it. So half of the church just, you know,
01:09:25 just they're like, give me another jab, govern me harder. I love it. You know, and then, you know,
01:09:30 and then, and then the other half, you know, we have, it was way more than way more. You're right.
01:09:34 Way more. So 80%, 90%. And then the good guys still, like we were, you know, we were top tards
01:09:40 in the lord's army you know like we meaning we took the right position but but we got there 0.81
01:09:44 we weren't very brilliant is is the point uh myself you know the chief chief of tards and so
01:09:50 i you know i i i landed on the right position but um but it wasn't well fleshed out because now what
01:09:56 i would say is uh no we resisted covid uh one because we're not going to miss you know a year
01:10:02 and a half of church because of what the scripture says but also because it's not a real thing
01:10:07 covid's not real like yes it is it is a cold it is like it's a sniffly nose if i miss church
01:10:14 right now as a father of five from ages zero to seven young children if i miss church every time
01:10:21 a member of my family had a sniffly nose i would never be in church i would have to miss the next
01:10:27 20 years of church and you will i can vouch for it right and so well here's the deal that's covid
01:10:33 That's COVID.
01:10:34 If you're 400 pounds, you've already had triple bypass surgery, and you're 90 years old, then
01:10:39 yes, you're in trouble, and you can shelter yourself.
01:10:42 For everybody else, you were fine.
01:10:45 You really were fine.
01:10:47 And so my point is, but here's the thing.
01:10:49 How did we conclude that?
01:10:51 Not exclusively from Scripture.
01:10:54 We concluded that by observation in the natural world.
01:10:58 we concluded that by eventually we were able to get our own hands on uh the the medical data and
01:11:05 the studies and eventually we each of us probably contracted covet ourselves and we were able to
01:11:10 experience the symptoms and this and that and so over time we were able it's not just like over
01:11:15 time we did more and more bible studies and then as our bible studies became more potent then no
01:11:20 it was also it was it's not just god's first book of special revelation the scripture but also the
01:11:25 second book. The reason why we should have told the government to pound sand and take a hike
01:11:30 on that particular issue is on both grounds, not merely one. It's not just because Hebrews 0.99
01:11:35 tells me in chapter 10 not to forsake the gathering of the saints, but it's also because 0.88
01:11:40 the government is telling me to forsake the gathering of the saints for a dumb reason, 0.77
01:11:45 for a dumb natural reason. Because here's the deal, if you just make it ideological 0.93
01:11:51 in a biblicist mode, well, if you apply that consistently, then you can't ever miss church
01:11:57 for anything. So if you have 103 fever, like a lot of the guys, if they were beat, and I'm talking
01:12:02 about the 10% that did good on COVID, the good church guys who still gathered, those guys,
01:12:07 myself again included, I'm putting myself in there, but if we were perfectly consistent with
01:12:13 the rhetoric and the type of arguments we were using to defy the civil magistrate, to continue
01:12:19 gathering um as a church if we were perfectly consistent with those arguments then we would
01:12:24 have to never miss church if we're perfectly consistent if i'm sick i better go to church
01:12:29 if i'm going to be consistent with what i was saying in 2020 you know so uh michael thoughts
01:12:34 from you west thoughts and then we've got to do commercial i'm going to reserve mine because one
01:12:38 of the questions mirrors something i wanted to bring up so i'm going to i'm going to as i say
01:12:42 in congress i'm going to reserve my time yeah and i'll pass it to west and i'll make mine after the
01:12:46 All I would say is this is why politics is tough is because there's no retreat of a certain ideology that fixes everything.
01:12:54 Like this is why smart people that could dedicate just about all of their time that were like had land and children.
01:13:01 Like that's why they typically did politics in the ancient world, because there is no one size fits all universal system that will protect against excesses like covid and restrain freedom and all of that.
01:13:10 And so it's a great question, and it gets to why politics actually has to be done in a careful, labored, precise way by men, men, that are intelligent enough to do it.
01:13:21 Because there is nothing, no law in the books and no system, even theonomy, that would perfectly insulate you from something like that without running into a ditch somewhere else on the other side.
01:13:31 Amen.
01:13:32 All right, here is our last commercial break for the day.
01:13:34 our sponsor private family banking wants to help you with one money move that'll implicate itself
01:13:41 in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day they help you to avoid taxation
01:13:47 and to draw compound interest to your money now if you're a high net worth individual someone who
01:13:54 has maybe even 10 million dollars in net worth then they can help you even more w-2 workers
01:14:00 contract workers, business owners. It's all about cash flow and making tax deferred gains
01:14:07 on all your money for the rest of your life. Don't avoid this. It's a big move, but it's a
01:14:12 great time to make it. Click the link below and you can get on Chuck DeLaterrante's calendar
01:14:17 and he'll go over your background and what you want to accomplish. And he's going to help model
01:14:23 a program that exactly fits your needs. So go ahead and send an email to chuck
01:14:28 at privatefamilybanking.com.
01:14:31 Again, that's Chuck at privatefamilybanking.com.
01:14:35 Or you can click the link below.
01:14:37 Make a free discovery call now.
01:14:39 America is a country that was founded 1.00
01:14:41 for the purpose of allowing Christians
01:14:42 to do their duty before God
01:14:43 and not to have their consciences ruled
01:14:45 by the doctrines and commandments of men.
01:14:47 Reese Fund exists in order to see
01:14:49 the 10 commandments properly applied,
01:14:51 not just as a plaque on the wall,
01:14:52 but to actually be used in business
01:14:54 as though they're commandments from God
01:14:57 that we're supposed to obey.
01:14:58 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
01:15:03 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
01:15:09 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
01:15:14 Bye.
01:15:16 All right, we are back. We're back.
01:15:18 This is a question that's specifically for CJ.
01:15:21 Let's just make sure that we still got him.
01:15:22 Do we still have Iskra and CJ?
01:15:24 You.
01:15:24 Yep.
01:15:25 We've got him.
01:15:26 Hello.
01:15:26 They're here.
01:15:26 Andrew changed.
01:15:27 all right can you guys hear us can you hear us cj okay they can hear us all right so here we go
01:15:34 this is a question uh specifically for cj it is from matthew owens and then there's one more
01:15:39 michael that you wanted to address right um so owen says uh cj what are your thoughts on james
01:15:46 buchanan uh and others like gordon tulick in the public choice school that's a tough one i haven't
01:15:54 done my economics in a long time um i don't i don't have i don't have a fully prepared answer
01:16:00 for that like in the context of what i was studying public choice theory i was i was very
01:16:04 much like a mosesian like a methodological individualist so i actually haven't gone back
01:16:10 and redone my my thinking on economics so i can't give an informed opinion on that right now
01:16:14 okay all right and then here's the other question and michael do you want to ask it and then you
01:16:20 have thoughts on it also because um i'll ask the question but to preface it um cj you said
01:16:25 something interesting earlier about the the fact that the the art of politics is not about pursuing
01:16:33 the ideal necessarily or about laying down a blueprint the perfect blueprint it's about
01:16:38 dealing with reality um and achieving goals so i think one of the things that comes up is people
01:16:45 look at the writing around the constitution the declaration of independence and i know even then
01:16:51 there were political compromises even the bill of rights was a political compromise nevertheless
01:16:55 it seems like that was a time where um the founders were perhaps uniquely in history
01:17:01 being able to say what kind of system do we want and so i think a lot of modern christian thinkers
01:17:10 look at the founding of America, and they say that's normative politics, where they were shooting for
01:17:16 a particular ideal, who are we as a people, who are we as a society. And so my question,
01:17:21 and then I'm going to read the question that's related to this, is that a disconnect? Is that
01:17:25 a wrong way? Should we not look at the founding of America and conclude political things? Were
01:17:30 they doing something different? And then Easy Mac asks, in conjunction to that, what's an example
01:17:35 of something the Bible does not address specifically? But then he says, the principles
01:17:38 that the founders followed could, to my mind, always trace back to patterns in the Bible.
01:17:45 I think one of the cool things about history is you see this unfolding of different ways
01:17:53 that particular people have resolved their particular struggles in ways that relate to
01:18:00 each other. And so one of the things about the Constitution that's interesting is the great
01:18:04 debate was, is monarchy preferable? Should we give power to, you know, should we have something like
01:18:10 popular sovereignty? And so there are all these, you know, there are all these particular interests
01:18:14 coming to the table, you know, you had these agrarians, you had these, you know, people that
01:18:18 were much more interested in appealing to, like the demos, the people that, you know, the people
01:18:24 at large, those are the popular sovereignists, then you had much more of the elitists who were
01:18:28 worried about the fact that if you give too much power to the people, they would, in a corrupt
01:18:33 fashion undermined the traditional institutions of stability. And so I think the Constitution is
01:18:39 brilliant in the sense that it really was an attempt to check and balance all of these
01:18:46 different influences and all of these different power impulses. And they recognized actually
01:18:52 uniquely in history, maybe, that people like Alexander Hamilton realized that politics actually
01:19:00 was this balance of powers at all times. And you always have to be aware of which power block
01:19:09 was threatening to undermine other blocks of power. And so it really wasn't this ideal at all.
01:19:16 I think it came about because they were recognizing the fact that if any one faction was getting too
01:19:21 much power, it really was this compromise, very particularistic government. I'm also not one that
01:19:27 says um that we need to go back to my monarchy but at the same time we can't um idolize you know
01:19:33 the constitutional republic like these things are always particular they're always situational
01:19:38 situationalist i think at the time you know the constitutional structure was a good way of dealing
01:19:43 with um the the particular threats and and um you know like uh claims to power that that different
01:19:50 um you know constituencies had and so i think that all of politics was this way and i think that that
01:19:56 Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, even Thomas Jefferson, although he's much more ideological,
01:20:02 I think a lot of them saw this great tradition in classical European politics that very much was
01:20:09 a compromise. It really was this tentative settling of different political dynamics.
01:20:16 Roger Scruton talks about this all the time, that one of the essences of politics is tentative
01:20:21 compromise, where everything is always, you don't set in stone for all time a single system. I think
01:20:28 the Constitution was good for what it was, but as John Adams said, it was only meant for a moral
01:20:32 people. And so therefore, when you lose the morality of the people, what are the ramifications
01:20:37 of that? So we always need to be rethinking, what are the exceptions? The Constitution was never
01:20:42 meant to cover all people for all times. It came in the soil of a certain circumstance, a certain
01:20:48 historical situation and it was good for that situation but i don't think it's an ideal that
01:20:53 has to be applied to every single people group in every single context of the world for instance
01:20:58 the constitution doesn't actually speak to um our you know like it doesn't actually speak to
01:21:04 the fact that ngos are basically sponsoring the replacement of western peoples like it doesn't
01:21:10 it doesn't have any dynamics to deal with that and so you have to come up with states of exception 0.55
01:21:14 and deal with that. That's politics. Politics is dealing with the state of the exception
01:21:19 at all times. You always have to be determining when does the law apply? When does the constitution
01:21:23 apply? These are very dangerous things we're talking about, for sure. But the consequences
01:21:27 of ignoring them may actually be greater. That's well said. Let me take a crack at this
01:21:34 one real quick, and then I got something I want to tell Andrew. So this was EasyMac 308. You
01:21:38 already read the question, right, Michael? I'll read it one more time, just for guys who are
01:21:41 hopping in right now live. What is an example of something the Bible does not address sufficiently
01:21:48 when it comes to political life? I would say immigration. This was one of the big ones that
01:21:57 the Lord, I think, providentially used for me to open my eyes, to move me from a capital T
01:22:03 theonomist to a general equity, lowercase t theonomist, emphasis on general equity,
01:22:08 uh aka just you know the 1689 or westminster confession you know just being a confessionally
01:22:14 reformed um and and here's how i thought about it because because i talked to uh many notable
01:22:19 theonomists about it and i asked them so i i gave it a fair shake um and i said you know so
01:22:25 what what is the theonomic position what is the you know the chapter and verse presuppositional
01:22:31 you know, um, uh, bulwark that's going to, uh, protect, um, Americans from losing every single 0.99
01:22:40 one of their jobs to a bunch of Hindus. I would like to know, I think that that seems like, 1.00
01:22:45 you know, like if we're saying the Bible is all sufficient. And when we say sufficient, we mean,
01:22:49 um, exhaustive and exclusive, um, for every single thing under the sun, then I would like to know,
01:22:57 like, I just, I haven't found that chapter and verse. And so could you, could you point it out
01:23:00 to me. And basically, this was the answer that I got. Uniformly, from every theonomist I talked to,
01:23:05 they said, well, there's four mechanisms, things that are explicit in Scripture. One,
01:23:12 you can't be an illegal immigrant. The sojourner, the stranger, the alien, these aren't people who 1.00
01:23:17 climbed over a wall. They still came legally. So one, only legal immigrants. So you have to go
01:23:23 through the legal avenues. Number two, well, we would want America to be a Christian nation, 0.88
01:23:29 and so we would only take Christians. 1.00
01:23:30 There needs to be a public profession
01:23:31 of distinctly Christian faith.
01:23:33 So Christian, you come legally. 0.91
01:23:36 Number three, getting rid of the welfare state.
01:23:38 And so you're not coming for free money.
01:23:42 You're gonna come and you have to adopt
01:23:44 the Protestant work ethic. 0.99
01:23:45 You're gonna have to work. 0.97
01:23:46 You're gonna have to pay your own way.
01:23:47 It's not gonna come at the expense
01:23:49 of the citizens, taxpayers.
01:23:51 And then number four,
01:23:52 you also have to be a law-abiding citizen.
01:23:55 So come in legally, but then also obey the law
01:23:57 and uh otherwise you're you're gone um so you're gonna so uh you need to be a christian you need
01:24:02 to come legally you need to obey the law while you're here and you need to work and and i thought
01:24:06 about that and it took me about and i'm not the sharpest tool in the shed so this is saying
01:24:10 something it took me about um 15 seconds to think okay well wait a second um this isn't even like
01:24:18 some some far-fetched hypothetical i'm what i'm about to uh use as as an example um is something
01:24:24 that has literally already happened uh what if america is a christian nation and two-thirds of
01:24:29 the world is not so like what if we achieve it what if christian nationalism or whatever you
01:24:34 want to call the new the new christian right whatever what if it works what if we win by
01:24:37 the grace of god and we win in our lifetimes and america is a christian nation um but most of europe 0.85
01:24:43 still sucks and and even that looks like like heaven by comparison to the third world um and 0.95
01:24:52 all these third worlders they know that if they come to america they're not going to get free 0.98
01:24:57 money they know they're going to have to obey the rules and not break any laws they know they're 0.99
01:25:02 going to have to uh speak english learn the language um they know that they have to make
01:25:06 a public profession of faith right when they're trying to immigrate they're going to be tested
01:25:11 you know they're going to have to memorize an icene creed or whatever i don't know whatever it
01:25:14 is and they're going to have to profess faith in the lord jesus christ and um and they're going to
01:25:18 have to come through legal avenues um what that assumes that theonomic position it assumes that
01:25:24 the only motivation for people to come to our country is free money what it neglects to account
01:25:29 for is that there are a ton of other incentives for people to want to come to the united states
01:25:34 especially if it's a christian nation already there's there's enough but if you're saying
01:25:38 america as it is now but even better it's even more god glorifying christ exalting um so so then
01:25:44 what are some of the things that would come with that well you don't get free money anymore but
01:25:48 you know what you do get um you don't you don't get uh your country that's torn by war you don't
01:25:53 get drug cartels you don't get crime you don't like so so i don't get free cash but you're telling
01:25:58 me i get economic opportunity uh i'm not stricken by poverty and uh and my kids won't get raped
01:26:04 right um you know how many people that'll appeal to approximately i don't know maybe four to six
01:26:11 billion so what do you do if four to six billion people who aren't even necessarily regenerate
01:26:17 but we don't have election goggles. We can't discern that. They make an external, outward,
01:26:23 public profession of faith in the Lord Jesus Christ, and they say, we'll come through the
01:26:27 legal avenues. And I asked the theonomists this verbatim, like explicitly, I asked them,
01:26:33 is there any theonomic mechanism for telling those who say they're Christians, so they do make that
01:26:40 public profession of faith, they say they'll work hard, they're not asking for free money,
01:26:44 they they want to come through a legal avenue and they want to be law-abiding
01:26:47 citizens is there any mechanism to still say no and the theonomist answer was uniformly no you
01:26:55 have to take them because there's not a bible verse that um that allows a nation to um to
01:27:01 what they would consider arbitrarily put a cap on the number of immigrants and so theoretically
01:27:08 and it's not that far-fetched theoretically it is entirely possible especially if you're
01:27:13 post-millennial you think that the post-millennial doesn't believe all the nations become christian
01:27:17 at the same time so it's it's entirely possible that america becomes christian a thousand years 0.68
01:27:22 before two-thirds of the world and all of a sudden you've got a billion indians um saying that they
01:27:29 believe in jesus simply because their their country is you know they're using cow dung instead of cow 0.99
01:27:36 and they want to come here and uh and you can't tell them no and i thought ah well i think i think
01:27:44 you can i think you can just say that's too many and well how did how do you decide that what
01:27:48 chapter and verse well i decided it in the light of nature i decided it um because america is
01:27:53 currently um a country of a population of 330 you know to 350 million people and and a a nation
01:28:00 that size cannot take in one calendar year three times its total population in immigrants
01:28:09 all at the same time because it will collapse so the strict theonomist would have to give himself 0.84
01:28:16 over to the destruction of his own country so to answer the question my answer to the question
01:28:20 would be you ask for is there any example of something that you know that you don't track back
01:28:25 explicitly or directly to scripture that's political. And I say, yeah, immigration is a
01:28:30 great example. Thoughts? And that's why I referred to the NGOs. The question is, do the English
01:28:37 people have a right, as the English people, to preserve the English integrity of the land that
01:28:42 they inherited from their fathers? Is that a legitimate thing that a people, which is basically
01:28:47 a derivative of a family, can say about themselves that we want to maintain the Englishness of our
01:28:54 family is that a legitimate claim do they have the right to say that and i say yes they do and so
01:28:59 therefore but but the theonomist there's no there's no mechanism within scriptural deduction
01:29:04 that allows them this claim for their country and i would say at the same time that the american
01:29:10 people are a people that we have a history and that we have the right as a people to maintain
01:29:15 the integrity of the thing that has been handed to us by our forefathers that is a legitimate claim
01:29:22 And I don't think I need to have a chapter and verse to deny the NGOs the right to do this, but just the fact that this is an extension of my duty and obligation to honor my ancestors and act as a catalyst between those ancestors and my descendants to maintain the integrity of the nation that I have been handed.
01:29:44 that is a good thing and i think that is a natural um ordered love situation and it doesn't need to
01:29:50 be you know um deduced from from scriptural exegesis andrew any thoughts yeah i mean like
01:29:59 it's it's a similar it's a similar circumstance like like we were talking about with with covid
01:30:05 right where they like if you have um just bare minimum right the only thing that we we can use
01:30:16 to address what the state is doing to us during that situation is is the bible well then then
01:30:24 you're just left with romans 13 and that's all you got right it's it's the it's the same dynamic
01:30:29 right where no we we have other authorities where the bible is not is silent on the particulars
01:30:35 that we can draw upon right uh the bible is authoritative over those those lesser authorities
01:30:42 but they still are authoritative and i mean and like instinctively people like this is what your
01:30:49 question is jewel is is one out of instinct right that you like you know something smells funny like
01:30:54 this is not right that we could just import the you know a third of the population of india into
01:31:01 america and say cool that's great uh we don't have any laws against they all right even within
01:31:07 that that scenario like they all profess christ and they're not getting welfare so i guess it's
01:31:11 it's okay right no no it's it's it's not and and everyone knows that it's not they might not be
01:31:18 able to articulate exactly why but they know there's something wrong with that and to say
01:31:24 that well the bible is is totally sufficient for all of these questions is to say that you you
01:31:29 can't object to something that's totally wrong. Like if the, if the state said, okay, well now
01:31:34 they need to like be part of your family. Right. Like if that, if that's the scenario, right. You
01:31:38 they're, they're mandating foreign adoptions into your family. Like you're going to take two kids 1.00
01:31:43 from Senegal into your family and they're going to be, you have to raise them as your children. 0.98
01:31:47 Right. That would be monstrous, but there's, there's not a Bible verse that says they can't 1.00
01:31:52 do that. Right. Romans 13. Right. You have to submit to the authorities. Right. Well, we would,
01:31:59 We would have all sorts of arguments why that's wrong, why you can't do that.
01:32:03 And so all of these questions are such that everyone knows the answer to them.
01:32:11 But when we adopt this ideology where it's a regulative principle of political action, where we have to have a Bible verse giving us permission to do X, Y, or Z, then it actually restricts evangelicals, evangelical Christians from acting on their correct political instincts.
01:32:32 I mean you saw this all the time with Trump too, with Christians supporting Trump. Instinctively, they knew this is right. He's not a good guy or whatever, but his policies are good for our country, are good for our people, and we want to pursue that over and against any objections contrary from evangelical leaders. 0.62
01:32:54 Right. That that's the instinct that I think we have to tap into, that Christians have to the few leaders that we do have that are going to tell the truth about these things. 0.58
01:33:06 We're not going to play this little shell game of of proof texts anymore. 0.88
01:33:12 Right. It has to stop. Right. We have to be able to say, yes, we 100 percent believe that the Bible is totally authoritative over everything.
01:33:21 but it doesn't speak to every particular situation and we must use wisdom we must use
01:33:28 tradition we must use the things that have been handed to us in order to act politically well said
01:33:35 uh nathan scroll up real quick because there's one more question that i i have a short answer
01:33:39 to and it's gonna hurt but it needs to be said keep going up up up up up up maybe not on the
01:33:45 questions list yeah on the just on the comments yep um go up slow down slow down here we go there
01:33:51 we go uh this is from knocked loose he said um are these people talking about uh isker and uh cj
01:33:58 me uh michael and west um are these people seriously arguing that theonomy leads to
01:34:04 propositional nationhood uh this this is going to hurt but uh yes yes that's exactly what i'm saying
01:34:09 what i'm saying is that i don't think that it inherently has to but for whatever reason in
01:34:17 the providence of god it has i won't say that for every theonomist because i don't even personally
01:34:23 know every theonomist but i think it's a fair statement for me to say that many if not most
01:34:30 and i would lean towards most modern theonomists today their conception of theonomy is perfectly
01:34:39 compatible and pretty much um a synonym with propositional nationhood and then uh real quick
01:34:47 one more truttle go up to truttle it's the uh grover um there it is uh truttle said i regret
01:34:54 to inform you that theonomists today are libertarians and not like rush duny well said
01:35:00 first duny was definitely against immigration he thought very highly of the american stocks and
01:35:05 said we cannot allow and that that was the you know i'm saying this to you guys because i love
01:35:10 you knock loose i love you i know it's hard to hear it hurt my heart as well it hit me deep in
01:35:15 the chest it when i when i was you know sitting you know and reading and and came to that
01:35:22 realization that um the average modern theonomist today is a libertarian propositional nationhood
01:35:32 defending globalist uh it broke my heart it really did um but it's the cold hard truth
01:35:40 and i'm going to give you the cold hard truth um and trottle is absolutely right i still love
01:35:45 rush journey um but the apples have fallen very far from the tree and we have to just come to
01:35:51 terms with that um when when we talk about theonomist today when you listen or read i'll
01:35:58 just say it. Um, if you're watching Andrew Sandlin and then you pick up, you know, uh, biblical,
01:36:06 you know, biblical law institutes, uh, by rush duty, and you can't discern a difference between
01:36:11 the two, then, um, you're, you're in trouble. Uh, those two things are not, not the same.
01:36:18 Um, this is the announcement that I wanted to give real quick. Um, so it's good. Um, I decided,
01:36:23 you know, we're live right now. Everybody's watching. So, but I'll put you on the spot.
01:36:26 so i i have decided unless you have a strong objection um it is you know it's already geared
01:36:32 up and ready to go um to take our series our nine-part series that we did on israel and just
01:36:38 go ahead and make that bad boy live because i feel like all let's go all the pushback like at
01:36:44 this point it's like i was trying to spare you and i a little bit of the controversy thinking
01:36:49 you know if i put it behind the paywall then maybe we'll get a little less grief
01:36:52 i don't feel like i got any less grief do you i think we've probably gotten more grief uh yeah
01:36:59 i feel like not everybody can yeah i feel at this point at this point i feel like what it'll do this
01:37:06 is my prediction um some people clip it up and and you know and the usual suspects will give us
01:37:12 a hard time however um i think that like a lot of people have already levied their accusations
01:37:18 and i think a full robust nine-part series on your book that's going to be coming out
01:37:24 um i i think if anything it'll actually um it'll actually serve as a defense i don't i don't think
01:37:30 it'll get us in more trouble i think it'll actually provide the the further clarifications
01:37:34 for the things that people have you know slandered us with that it'll actually they'll be like you
01:37:40 know it'll be harder for them to defend their slander what do you think yeah i think so i mean
01:37:46 looking back on it it's like we just you know we just talked about um the bible and the new
01:37:53 testament and what the new testament says about the difference between the church and israel
01:37:58 right like it wasn't right it wasn't anything too crazy you know i mean most of the i mean
01:38:05 maybe you got more hate than i did uh but a lot i definitely got more hate than you did for sure
01:38:11 you always do uh but so i mean i got way more hate for people like why did they say anything
01:38:17 about this or that like people from like you know further to the right right and things like that
01:38:22 you know uh online like why didn't you talk about this you know why don't you talk about the uss
01:38:28 liberty or whatever or yeah name name the thing and it's like because we wanted to talk about the
01:38:34 bible and like that's the need of the hour is to understand what the new testament says
01:38:38 on the relationship between christianity and judaism and jews and so forth so it's like
01:38:46 yeah i i don't know man like uh people can watch it i and i hope they do because i hope they did
01:38:53 good stuff there yeah i think it was super tame very hinged like very i mean maybe if for you
01:39:03 know from time to time a few synagogue of satan kind of you know things might have just you know
01:39:07 slipped off the tongue you know but other than that i think it was a let me be clear 0.97
01:39:11 you know like i mean yeah we like we think judaism is a demonic false religion but most of it really 0.93
01:39:18 was i think exegetical and just all right here's here's galatians here's ephesians here's acts 0.94
01:39:24 here's hebrews here you know here's romans 11 you know that was the big one and so i i think it'll
01:39:29 be really helpful for people so all right there you have it we've gotten andrew's uh official
01:39:33 permission. So we're good to go. So that starts tonight, ladies and gentlemen. So tonight at 8pm
01:39:38 Central, that's our Friday special for the next nine weeks. It'll be live on X. It'll be live on
01:39:44 YouTube. It'll be on rightresponseministries.com, our website. It'll be on our app. It'll be on
01:39:48 your favorite listening platform, Apple, Spotify, XYZ. So on all the things, Fridays at 8pm Central
01:39:55 time for the next nine weeks, because it's a nine part series, you'll have the series on all things
01:40:03 Israel and Judaism and the Jews and all that kind of stuff and how Christians should be thinking
01:40:08 about this biblically and properly and politically today. That'll be for the next nine weeks. So
01:40:14 that's Q1 Friday special. That's going to get us through January, February, and a little bit into
01:40:19 March. And then Q2, starting the first Friday of April, you're going to have a 10-part series on
01:40:25 Fridays, one per week on Fridays for 10 weeks at 8 p.m. Central Time of a 10 part series on
01:40:33 Christian nationalism with myself and Dr. Stephen Wolf. But here's the deal. If you don't want to
01:40:38 wait for the slow drip, you want to get the whole series with me and Iska right now and be able to
01:40:42 binge watch all nine episodes completely ad free. And you certainly don't want to wait a whole
01:40:48 quarter all the way till April for a one per week episode to drop with me and Stephen Wolf
01:40:53 on all things Christian Nationalism, I have very good news for you. You can get the entire
01:40:58 nine-part series with Isker and the entire 10-part series with me and Dr. Wolf on Christian
01:41:05 Nationalism. Both of those series, a total of 19 episodes, all ad-free, is actually available
01:41:10 in total today, but exclusively for our Patreon members. At the lowest tier,
01:41:17 five bucks a month, costs you a cup of coffee. You can binge it in a month and cancel your
01:41:21 subscription if you have to. Out of the goodness of your heart, I ask you not to, but you could
01:41:25 theoretically cancel your subscription. All you have to do is go on over to patreon.com
01:41:32 forward slash right response ministries. Again, one more time, that's patreon.com
01:41:38 forward slash right response ministries. All right, let me turn it back to Andrew and CJ.
01:41:43 Any final thoughts for today? Guys, thank you so much for coming on. Anything you want to leave us
01:41:47 with how can people follow you at least give us that for sure hey you can follow me on twitter
01:41:52 um at contra mordor and um you know you can you can subscribe to our podcast contra mundum
01:41:59 um and it's on youtube and you know all the major podcatchers and we got some we got some cool stuff
01:42:04 lined up from 2025 we don't have a we don't have a nine-part series on the relationship between
01:42:09 israel and christianity but we do have some cool stuff coming up too so check us out on youtube
01:42:14 and twitter and i think andrew are you are you on twitter i am i am at boniface option and uh you
01:42:21 can find me there oh snap docs we got him it's me the whole time we got him yeah yeah so uh yeah
01:42:32 find me there and and on the podcast with cj and yeah we've got we've got cool we might do some
01:42:37 series in 2025 we've got a series just not that one well yeah yeah just not that one not that and
01:42:44 speaking of series i i've already told cj this and andrew i thought i got to i had the distinct
01:42:48 pleasure of speaking to both of you on the phone in the last couple days but um we want to have
01:42:53 uh you guys come out both of you so i've done something now twice with andrew but i'd love to
01:42:58 do it with you as well cj and so um if we can uh we would like to get you guys to fly out and have
01:43:04 you in person the studio and do some kind of multiple part series uh we've got you know q1
01:43:09 and q2 already ramped up and ready to go um and you know but we've got two more quarters in the
01:43:15 year and i already know what it should be yeah so something you know something that any anywhere
01:43:21 between i would say anywhere between eight and 12 episodes um but i would love to do something like
01:43:26 that and then i'll plug this for andrew but um definitely check out his books he's got two books
01:43:32 already published and a third that's on the way but um you've got christian nationalism with you
01:43:36 and Torba and then you also have your most recent book that uh was I mean didn't you sell like 20,000
01:43:43 copies I mean it was it did well right yeah it's done really well I think it's it's just it's just
01:43:49 around there uh total praise god I don't yeah I don't know the exact number uh what's it called
01:43:54 and where can people get it the Boniface option and Amazon is the best place to get that uh so
01:44:01 So yeah, you'll want to check that out too.
01:44:03 Awesome.
01:44:04 And then of course, CJ, last thing is that CJ and Andrew will be joining Michael and
01:44:10 Wes and I at our conference, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
01:44:14 That's a Thursday, Friday, Saturday coming up in less than three months at this point.
01:44:18 So April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, the title of the conference is Christ is King, subtitle
01:44:22 How to Defeat Trash World.
01:44:24 And we used Trash World, which is kind of a term that Andrew coined, similar to Clown
01:44:30 world and other things that were already kind of in the mix. But I loved Boniface Options so much
01:44:36 that I used a little bit of its jargon that Andrew provided for us. And so Andrew's going to be doing
01:44:42 one of the main sessions. Both Andrew and CJ are going to be on a panel with us, and that's going
01:44:46 to be a great time. We hope that you guys can come out and make that. Go to RightResponse
01:44:50 Conference, not ministries, but RightResponseConference.com if you want to register for
01:44:55 the conference. I think that's about it. Michael and Wes, you guys have anything you want to say?
01:44:59 it. Yep. Okay. Uh, one last time, subscribe to, uh, our, our channel on YouTube and click the
01:45:05 bell. If you want to be notified with all of our content that we put out on, uh, not just a weekly,
01:45:10 but almost daily basis. And then also go ahead and follow us on X at right response, M at right
01:45:17 response, M, uh, Andrew and CJ. Thanks again so much for coming on the show. Appreciate it.
01:45:23 Yeah. Thank you so much for having us. All right. See you soon.
01:45:29 Thank you.