The NXR Podcast - August 28, 2024


THE LIVESTREAM - Make Seminaries Great Again

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW - The Fifth Commandment with Eric Conn THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Mormonism with Cultish

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 15 minutes

Words per minute

190.74

Word count

14,359

Sentence count

429

Harmful content

Misogyny

29

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

49

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Wesley and Wesley are joined by Eric khan to discuss the lack of theological education in the United States, and how we can fix it. They discuss the role of the seminary, the need for theological education, and what we can do about it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Christianity has been greatly served by the scholars, theologians, and pastors that were
00:00:08 equipped for defending the faith through study at institutions such as Cambridge, Yale, and
00:00:15 Princeton. Pastors and scholars like Jonathan Edwards, B.B. Warfield, and R.L. Dabney were
00:00:21 products of rigorous academic instruction in the Western tradition, and their influence
00:00:27 continues to this day. But as of late, notable output of even reformed seminaries seems to be
00:00:36 nothing more than race hustlers, social justice warriors, functional Anabaptists, and pietists 0.92
00:00:43 that would make themselves unrecognizable to their forefathers. So where did things go wrong, 0.93
00:00:49 and what can we do today to fix our seminaries?
00:00:57 welcome back and good afternoon gentlemen that's right the gang's all here the gang's all here
00:01:07 finally yeah we had four weeks where it was me and michael twice it was me and wesley twice
00:01:11 and now we're guest appearance by eric khan yeah yeah last michael ground level europe are they
00:01:16 gonna make it how are things looking over there so michael was just in europe i was in europe for
00:01:19 how long two weeks not quite two weeks yeah 10 days yep so visited friends in england and in
00:01:24 norway and i would say where we were in norway they are more committed to actually fighting the
00:01:29 fight good and in england the issues that we believe very passionately but i said what's what's
00:01:33 the view of abortion here he said oh we just he was a christian he didn't but he said we as a
00:01:37 country we just laugh at the backwards americans who are still arguing over things like abortion
00:01:41 and kind of a given and given up on the issue there in the church even so as in it's not even 0.69
00:01:46 a fight yeah someone said that recently they were traveling and uh i think it was terrible to agree
00:01:51 with him but roger and he said a christian in a european country they're like you are so lucky
00:01:56 that this is a fight that's even on the table right it's not even on the table for us and
00:01:59 hasn't been for decades you guys are lucky that it's a real conversation like will this be allowed
00:02:03 or not so well great we got a great topic today he's saying he's saying we're lucky and it's not
00:02:10 on the table for us like isn't like we're lucky to have that option this is a battlefield for real
00:02:15 politicians i know he's in hungary but like isn't he an american well he left i just we don't go
00:02:23 there so sad it's sad when that guy you really don't like you're green with him conservatives
00:02:29 right lord help us lord help us all right well i was about to say and speaking of conservatives
00:02:33 uh we've had this episode actually planned for a while finally getting around to it
00:02:37 but um so the seminary uh the root word actually is seminarium it comes from latin um there's
00:02:43 another prefix root word in there that I won't say on air, but it means seedbed. So, a seminary
00:02:48 in classical terms has meant a seedbed, and it's intended to be a place where wisdom and knowledge
00:02:53 they're deposited in men aspiring to the clergy, and then later on in life, those crops that have
00:02:58 been planted, those seeds that have been planted, they grow up and they bear fruit. They bear fruit
00:03:02 in the lives of the clergy, of course, but also the individuals that they minister to, that it's
00:03:06 intended to be this place that cultivates men, that imbues them with knowledge, and then later
00:03:11 on in life that goes on to bear much fruit for the kingdom. I was reading, doing some preparation
00:03:16 for this episode, and one guy said this. He said, the Reformation, it was birthed in an academic
00:03:20 setting. The base of the Reformation was the university. Martin Luther, Philip Melanchthon,
00:03:25 Ulrich Zwingli, and John Calvin formed and clarified their doctrine in the give and take
00:03:30 of academic debate. So, as Protestants, as evangelicals, the seminary and academia have
00:03:37 always been very important. We've needed these men that have dedicated their lives, brilliant men,
00:03:42 to studying the languages, studying theology, working out systematic, coherent systems.
00:03:47 And so from the outset, we have a lot to thank them for. But the purpose of a system is what it
00:03:53 does. Aaron McIntyre uses that term a lot, and I think it's a good one. So we can say in today,
00:03:58 in our current time, well, our seminaries are intended to continue that great tradition,
00:04:01 to educate men, to prepare them for the ministry, to take those that are aspiring to the clergy
00:04:06 and get them ready to go out and do good work.
00:04:09 We can say that, but what is actually happening?
00:04:12 When we look at the notable output, is that what's going on?
00:04:16 That soldiers are going to the front line for King Jesus?
00:04:18 I was just going to say the purpose of the system is not the title that you give it.
00:04:23 Exactly.
00:04:23 You can write sugar on a label and put it on the flour jar, but it's still flour.
00:04:31 Right.
00:04:32 So what you call something, what you say about something is not nearly as integral to what it is as much as what it does.
00:04:41 What does it actually do?
00:04:43 So the public school system, we would say, well, it's not for education.
00:04:46 It's for producing Democrat voters and turning children against their parents.
00:04:51 But it says school on the door. 0.76
00:04:52 It's for the purpose of the public school district is to trans kids, put out Democrat voters, and make sure that children go up to hate their parents. 0.75
00:04:59 That's what it does. 0.79
00:05:01 That is the system.
00:05:02 it's not about education exactly same with seminaries we i think it's time if we can say
00:05:06 those things about the public school system right i think not maybe in the same way in some ways
00:05:12 it's maybe not so severe in other ways i think it might even be more pernicious and sinister
00:05:16 but we need to start talking about what is if we're honest in terms of what it does what is
00:05:22 the purpose of seminaries that's actually uh nate if you have that first clip i'm going to play the
00:05:26 clip, and then I'll give you the background for it. VP Kamala Harris has been a leader on so many
00:05:32 issues that matter to our communities. From advancing the child tax credit, which reduced
00:05:37 child poverty by 50% in 2021, something we want to continue to work on together to ensure that
00:05:44 families have access to affordable health care, like low prescription drug prices, contraception,
00:05:51 and IVF, issues that evangelicals overwhelmingly support. She has also advanced a biblical view
00:06:00 of creation care and works to find solutions to the climate crisis, and has been an advocate
00:06:05 for racial justice, which we all know is rooted in a vision of justice scriptures, which is laid
00:06:11 out from Genesis to Revelation. All people are created in the image of God, and Vice President
00:06:18 And Harris has worked hard to ensure that we achieve policy solutions that reflect these goals.
00:06:24 All right.
00:06:25 Just before you do this, Wes, I want to just make sure that we don't unintentionally malign our tech guy, Nate.
00:06:32 The little pop-up box on the window, that was part of the video.
00:06:35 That was not Nate.
00:06:36 Nathan would never, ever be such a normie as to let that happen.
00:06:41 To have a pop-up.
00:06:42 All right.
00:06:43 So what you just heard was a woman named Ekomeni Yuan.
00:06:46 was leading a zoom call evangelicals for harris a roundtable gathering years and years ago when i
00:06:54 saw this video west i know you're joking but seriously when you sent this in our thread as
00:06:59 we were preparing for today i thought like i don't know if it's super relevant to show like a video
00:07:03 that's probably from like 2012 or no i was i was i got on god's honest truth i thought this has to
00:07:10 be from 2012 to 2015. And then you're like, no, my dear brother in Christ, that was from two weeks
00:07:16 ago. That was two weeks ago. So, this is Ekomeni. She's a leader. She wrote a book. I think it's
00:07:21 called Truth Talks. She also hosts a podcast, which I went through. I scrolled some of the
00:07:26 podcast titles. One of them was The Sacred Act of Self-Help or Sacred Act of Self-Care. So,
00:07:32 now, why does that matter? Well, this woman graduated less than a decade ago from Westminster
00:07:37 theological seminary not west east the seminary philadelphia the seminary founded by the the lion
00:07:46 in the faith j gresham machen who took a stand against liberalism where cornelius van till
00:07:52 lectured less than she graduated hold up hold up she graduated in homemaking what like what
00:08:00 i don't understand my brother in christ i regret to inform you what was homemaking what was her
00:08:04 degree i don't understand see this is i'll just be honest i'll just part of the part of the problem
00:08:10 is not like hey here's somebody who graduated from a supposedly very conservative seminary and
00:08:14 look at you know look at how far off the rails now they're supporting evangelicals for harris
00:08:18 um and ivf they just kills and slaughters you know hundreds and thousands of children
00:08:23 freezes them on ice and most of them get discarded um it's not just that it's also um like let's 0.76
00:08:29 let's just i'll say it um what what is what is a woman doing yeah in seminary yep i what is a
00:08:37 woman doing in seminary i don't understand like i said it tongue-in-cheek the home thing but
00:08:43 like but but seriously and even that would frustrate me because why would you go into
00:08:48 debt for your future husband to study home ec in a college when you could study that with your
00:08:53 mother by being her daughter in a home so anyways there's something i just i'm gonna just 1.00
00:08:59 pull back a tiny bit there because there's a lot of women who are not getting that right that's 0.97
00:09:03 true there might need to be a generation of real intentional training yeah but not at a four-year 1.00
00:09:09 school i agree not at a four-year school with 150 000 of debt you know or 80 000 of debt that
00:09:14 eventually you know you're you're basically crossing your fingers and hoping that some
00:09:17 democrat president will make all the conservatives pay for it with their tax dollars that's not how
00:09:21 you do it and for the record i like i'm not against um women going to school for anything
00:09:28 higher education for anything. I do think that there may be some cases where a young woman
00:09:33 goes to school and studies, you know, X, Y, Z, because for a time as she's waiting to get married,
00:09:39 because here's the reality, we are in such disrepair that the average 18-year-old woman
00:09:45 who is conservative, loves the Lord, was raised right by her parents and does want to be a wife
00:09:49 and a mom. A lot of times there's not that, you know, that 20-year-old man who is standing right
00:09:56 there who loves the Lord Jesus Christ and is working hard and is ready to sweep her off her
00:10:00 feet. Like, so she's like, what do I, what do I do? And I think there's a lot of options. And just
00:10:04 for the record, going to school, I'm not totally against it, but I will certainly say that it is
00:10:10 lower on my list. Like if you're thinking, what can I do? Because what you're thinking is
00:10:14 eventually the end goal, if God would be so kind, all right, we can't, we can't make it happen. God
00:10:19 is sovereign and not every woman's going to get married. Sadly, that's just the reality. But 0.92
00:10:23 ordinarily they will ordinarily they will and if that's the goal is being a wife and a mother
00:10:28 then racking up debt for your future husband is probably not the best strategy so there may be
00:10:35 some things to go to school for and in those cases you're going to a school that's affordable
00:10:39 and not racking up debt but in most cases there are certain things that you can be doing as you're
00:10:45 waiting on on marriage and family that where you're making money and where your parents are
00:10:51 helping you towards this and helping you towards that but here all that being said that's that's
00:10:54 those are my disclaimers but all that out of the way one school you definitely don't need to be
00:11:00 going to is seminary which is supposed to train pastors yep which you can't be yep the bible 0.99
00:11:06 literally tells you you can't be one so so we're gonna coax in young women to rack up debt to pay 1.00
00:11:13 for our professors to teach them to do something that they're not supposed to do i want to come 0.54
00:11:18 back to the the some of the output of the seminary because it's like oh you got one clip that was bad 0.78
00:11:22 sure but is that systemic we'll get back to that but on that point do you know why they admit women
00:11:26 the way a lot of these seminaries and to be fair that doesn't really help much they technically
00:11:31 are not typically allowed in mdiv programs which are intended for pastoral ministry they would do
00:11:35 something similar to an ma or a master's in theological arts but you know the reason that
00:11:39 most of these seminaries have accepted women to pay their salaries title nine which is a federal
00:11:45 title, which requires under the Civil Rights Act that schools that can receive federal funding
00:11:49 and loans, they cannot discriminate on the basis of sex. So, if a school like, say, Greenville
00:11:55 Presbyterian Seminary wanted to access for their students, for their faculty, for themselves,
00:12:00 federal dollars, what they would have to do is have to have the program open and not discriminate
00:12:05 on the basis of any of those things. And well, does Jesus say, the love of money is the root
00:12:10 of all kinds of evil. So, these men know, yeah, a woman can't be a pastor. Yeah, a woman getting 0.95
00:12:14 her Master's of Arts in Biblical Counseling. 1.00
00:12:16 Eh, it's not ideal.
00:12:17 They would know that if they've read Calvin and any of those guys.
00:12:21 But here's the allure.
00:12:22 Nice $200,000 salary to write academic papers and lecture a couple times a year.
00:12:27 And so, a big driving force of this, I would argue, is money.
00:12:32 Yes, there's some of the theology. 0.99
00:12:33 Well, an unordained woman can do anything a man can do, and some of these men won't 0.60
00:12:36 be ordained.
00:12:37 But really, underneath it, I think a lot of it is Title IX, eligibility for federal funding,
00:12:42 and these seminaries, daddy government came by with a big check in hand, ready to write it out,
00:12:47 and they said, yes, please. We'll be happy to open up our own little program and integrate
00:12:51 these classes and bring women onto campus for those sweet federal dollars. Well, it's interesting
00:12:56 because since we're going down this path right now, some of the stuff that I looked at was the
00:13:01 fact that especially evangelical seminaries are having a really difficult time getting enrollment,
00:13:07 getting numbers, maintaining their numbers.
00:13:10 For instance, in Gordon Theological Seminary...
00:13:13 Gordon Conwell?
00:13:14 Gordon Conwell.
00:13:14 Yep, Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary
00:13:16 recently announced that they're going to have to sell
00:13:20 most of their 102-acre campus
00:13:23 in order to stay financially viable.
00:13:28 And you think 15, 20, 30 years ago,
00:13:30 that never would have been.
00:13:31 Tell me Meredith Klein's legacy,
00:13:32 because he lectured at Gordon Conwell,
00:13:34 didn't save the institution.
00:13:35 I'm shocked.
00:13:36 So Fuller, 2018, it closed three of its satellite campuses, and it's selling property in Pasadena, California.
00:13:44 And its financial future is totally in jeopardy.
00:13:49 So one of the things that seminaries have been doing, because Title IX is there, they have been offering more, shall we say, creative degree tracks.
00:14:01 Okay, so here's a list of some of the degree tracks that are available at seminaries now, evangelical seminaries.
00:14:05 We have aging and spirituality, a four-year degree.
00:14:09 Well, no, not a four-year, two-year, an MA at Asbury Theological Seminary.
00:14:12 And what is it?
00:14:13 Aging and spirituality.
00:14:15 A master's in aging, like getting older.
00:14:18 Yeah, so how to do pastoral care towards those who are aging.
00:14:24 Okay, you've got apologetics and cosmogony.
00:14:28 That's Regent University, School of Divinity.
00:14:31 Biblical exegesis and linguistics at Dallas.
00:14:34 that's not that that bad black church studies at ashland theological seminary cultural engagement
00:14:40 whole master's degree in cultural engagement from denver seminary okay it just goes on and on
00:14:46 islamic studies near eastern archaeology um i that's that's more academic and and one of the
00:14:51 things that we could talk about is whether some of the academic like an archaeology degree does
00:14:56 the seminary need to be offering yeah you know archaeology non-profit leadership for social
00:15:01 justice at grand rapids theological seminary i have friends who went to that seminary that's a
00:15:06 big dutch reformed area grand rapids yep some of the guys like voss and bob inc and others what
00:15:10 was it non-profit leadership for social justice an ma profit leadership okay and so um you should
00:15:18 go to that joel urban ministry urban ministry again grand kenyan theological seminary the point
00:15:23 is, as the seminaries have achieved this sort of financial bubble over maybe the 90s, 2000s,
00:15:35 Title IX money came in, in order for them to sustain the numbers, now that I would argue,
00:15:41 some people are seeing the fruit of their ministry, which we're going to get to, and
00:15:44 are like, I'm not going to seminary. I'm not sending my sons to that seminary. So they've
00:15:47 had to introduce this sort of degree track a lot of them in order to enter to entice um new students
00:15:55 and a lot of those new students this is just kind of speculation here i don't have numbers on this
00:16:00 but a lot of those new students are going to be women right and it's not an mdv track clip yep
00:16:05 let's do that second clip then hold up real quick before we do it i just want to address this one 1.00
00:16:09 comment because i think it it it's an opportunity to provide some clarity eyes of laura mars she
00:16:16 She said, Mary sat at Jesus' feet learning, and Priscilla helped.
00:16:20 I guess she's talking about...
00:16:22 Helped the church.
00:16:23 Yeah, she was a helper. 1.00
00:16:25 Doesn't mean that either of these women are going to be a pastor.
00:16:29 So Mary's sitting at the feet of Jesus learning.
00:16:31 So the way that I would respond to that is simply by saying that we are not against women learning.
00:16:36 So one of the things that Paul explicitly says in 1 Timothy 2, I believe starting in verse 9, it might be verse 11,
00:16:44 but he says a woman must learn must learn and then he begins to say in what manner what what 0.91
00:16:51 what kind of disposition she should possess as she's learning she must learn in quietness and
00:16:57 full submission he's not saying she should learn how to be quiet he's saying she should learn and
00:17:03 the implication is all the things that the men are learning but where this is the key he's talking
00:17:09 about the context of the local church so so mary sitting at the feet of jesus learning um yeah my
00:17:16 daughters uh six and five and three years old are sitting at the feet of jesus in a proverbial and
00:17:25 spiritual but biblically true sense every single week on the lord's day uh during during the the
00:17:32 gathering of the saints and the ministering of the ordinary means of grace preaching the word
00:17:37 praying the word singing the word when these things are happening and seeing the word and
00:17:42 the sacrament of the lord's supper and baptism um everyone is sitting at the feet and not just
00:17:46 men and women um but but we're one of those churches that uh that is not discriminating
00:17:51 against children um the person usually the the feminist savvy person uh about 99.99999 percent
00:18:00 of the time if they go to a church it's a liberal church and you know what that church does number
00:18:04 one, it probably doesn't have kids, right? Because it's hard to procreate when, you know,
00:18:08 when you're gay. And then two, if they do have kids, what do they do for church? They send them 0.95
00:18:14 to a separate room. They put them in childcare. Not at Covenant Bible Church. We have both old
00:18:20 and young, both male and female. And it's not just this, you know, well, there's, you know,
00:18:25 deep theology for the men. And then there's, you know, watered-down theology for the women or deep 0.72
00:18:29 theology for the adults. But, you know, the kids are dumb and, you know, we're not going to give 0.99
00:18:33 much. No, no, no. Everybody is drinking from the same fount. Everyone is receiving the same 1.00
00:18:40 spiritual meal that's being laid before them, seven-course meal, and I'm not talking, not
00:18:44 boasting about myself, not talking about just the sermon. I'm talking about the liturgy from start
00:18:48 to finish, the pastoral prayers, the scripture readings, the Lord's Supper, the singing,
00:18:53 the hymns and the psalms, the whole nine yards. Everyone is eating from the same table. We're
00:19:00 We're not like those parents who set up their children for failure, who make two meals for
00:19:06 the family because they know the kids might complain.
00:19:08 And so the kids get chicken nuggets, mac and cheese, or pizza every single night of the
00:19:13 week while the adults eat something else.
00:19:15 No, we don't make two meals, two spiritual meals for the adults and the children or for
00:19:19 the men and the women on the Lord's Day.
00:19:21 We all come together as the family of God, young and old, man and woman, and we sit at
00:19:27 the same table, we eat the same meal.
00:19:29 and that here's the deal that is what i would liken to the example of mary sitting at the feet
00:19:35 of jesus and learning that's where you learn that's what first timothy chapter two is all about
00:19:40 paul is talking about the context of the local church he's not talking about seminaries
00:19:44 so so we are all for women learning and here's the thing if you actually have qualified men
00:19:50 going to seminaries and you have qualified seminaries to train those men then guess who
00:19:55 benefits from it everybody including the women because then those men come back to local churches
00:20:00 and fill the pulpits and teach the word of god rightly dividing the word of god and the word of
00:20:05 truth and and everybody benefits from that the women in our church are learning theology proper 0.86
00:20:10 doctrine of god they're learning about um the impassibility of god they're learning about a
00:20:15 god without parts and divine simplicity they're learning all these things um because i i don't 0.99
00:20:22 treat people like idiots when we preach the Word of God. I preach the Word of God at a high level 0.98
00:20:28 knowing that if people have questions, guess what? Women can ask their husbands, which is exactly
00:20:34 what Paul says in 1 Corinthians. Oh, that's so chauvinistic. That's just Bible. If any woman
00:20:40 has a question, let her ask her husband at home. I don't like the way you interpreted that. I didn't.
00:20:44 I quoted it. That's Scripture. And then secondly, if her husband can't answer the question, then
00:20:49 guess what then it becomes their question and then they go and seek out pastors and the pastor
00:20:54 can't answer the question then i'm going to be seeking out other guys and you know other ministers
00:20:58 who are qualified and we're going to so our our church the whole church the children the men the
00:21:04 women we are learning sound deep profound doctrine and the idea that uh that somehow you are barring
00:21:12 women from learning barring them from sitting at the feet of jesus by not uh church is not providing
00:21:18 scholarships for women to go to a four-year degree in seminary, I reject. I reject, ma'am. 0.99
00:21:25 Let's play this clip. Yeah, we'll play it, then we'll have some comments.
00:21:29 We're here at NSO, and we're going to get to know some of our new students and just hear what
00:21:35 they're about, what they're studying, and where they come from. So let's see if we can talk to
00:21:39 some friends. How are you guys doing? What are your guys' names? I'm Clara. I'm Sydney. What
00:21:46 has been your favorite thing about today so far? Probably breakfast. Meeting new
00:21:53 people. Alright my name is Zach Johnson I was actually born when my parents were
00:21:58 students here so I am visiting my birthplace into the same apartment that
00:22:01 I slept in as a newborn so that's wow. Full circle. What are you studying? I'm studying the MDiv in Christian
00:22:09 Ministry. Awesome. I'm here with Holly Ann. What are you studying? I am studying the MA
00:22:15 Christian Marital Family and Individual Counseling. Wow, she got it all right, too. 0.96
00:22:20 Can you just speak a little bit to why you chose Southeastern? I always kind of knew about their
00:22:23 commitment to the Bible and to the Lord, and when I visited, everyone was very genuine.
00:22:28 I just thought it would be a great place to study as a Christian, because I want to be a
00:22:31 Christian counselor, specifically. Oh, hey. Who are you?
00:22:36 I'm Trevor. Hey, Trevor. What are you studying this
00:22:39 fall? I am studying for my MDiv and Church Revitalization.
00:22:43 One word for NSO. What would you use?
00:22:46 I mean, it's been amazing. I don't really have one word for it, but just being able to get to meet people that are walking through similar stages of life as you, it's pretty cool.
00:23:01 Where is that from, Wes?
00:23:02 This is from a new student orientation that just happened. SBC Underground posted it on x slash Twitter.
00:23:08 Just kind of showing what's going on in campus.
00:23:10 But which seminary?
00:23:11 Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary, which is an SBC.
00:23:14 You're going to have a flagship seminary for SBC.
00:23:17 You're going to have to monologue for a little bit, Wes, because I will get myself in so much trouble if I respond to that.
00:23:26 I'll say this.
00:23:27 What are your thoughts?
00:23:28 I don't have any thoughts.
00:23:28 If you can't recognize what's going on in that clip, my brother in Christ, you are in the water, you are swimming in it, and you can't get out of it.
00:23:36 Think of the caliber of men.
00:23:38 And not just intellectual.
00:23:39 like there is intellectual caliber but also of of stature of discipline of gravitas of people
00:23:47 like stonewall like just be speaking more broadly than seminaries stonewall jackson and then you
00:23:52 look at this robert lee christian preachers like you know charles spurgeon who would literally
00:23:57 send men away based off of their physique yeah there's one man and i understand just real quick
00:24:04 to play the devil's advocate people say yeah but they didn't have microphones and blah blah blah
00:24:07 And so he was talking about barrel-chested men so that they could, you know, they could enunciate and they could project so that their voice would be heard to large crowds, you know, in an organic sense.
00:24:17 Uh-huh, yeah.
00:24:18 And also Charles Spurgeon has a quote about beards.
00:24:21 And he literally, in typical Spurgeon fashion, right, he doesn't say, well, I have an opinion or I think or this is open for, he just, everything is dogma with Spurgeon.
00:24:29 And Spurgeon straight up said, to not have a beard is unbiblical.
00:24:33 Yep.
00:24:33 It's unmanly and unbiblical. 0.95
00:24:35 Well, that one is not about your voice.
00:24:36 you know that one doesn't have a functional like no charles spurgeon just straight up would judge
00:24:41 guys uh i'm going to decide whether or not i'm going to train you to be a preacher based off of
00:24:46 your character your godliness your theology your theological aptitude intellectual capacity and
00:24:51 also if you look like a dude there was a guy who preached go home in in his lectures to students
00:24:57 and he said i had to send him away because for all the gold and tarshish i could not have kept
00:25:01 a straight face as he spoke wow literally his voice like you do not have the voice yeah to be
00:25:05 a minister and so i don't want to pick on these kids but i mean they're young like these these
00:25:11 are what we're supposed to send to the front lines the culture war is as thick as it's ever been
00:25:14 uh the church is in more need than ever before of good godly ministers good godly men to fill
00:25:21 pulpits and it's for one it's 50 women so that's 50 that won't be going to the pulpit spoiler
00:25:26 probably about 25 of them will in due time yes so half of that can't even go into the pulpits
00:25:30 Then the other half, it's this?
00:25:36 Like, this is what we have to...
00:25:39 Part of it, maybe we pick this apart a little more later on, but part of it is that I think that we don't know what seminaries are for anymore.
00:25:51 Right?
00:25:51 And so if seminary is just to provide the brand new Christian a place to explore his journey in Christ...
00:26:00 That's just not seminary. 0.62
00:26:01 That's not seminary.
00:26:03 That's actually a local church.
00:26:04 Right, that's a local church.
00:26:06 But that, you know, some of the people in that clip, like this was the myth of the university,
00:26:13 have the college experience, find yourself, discover who you are, just apply it in a Christian context.
00:26:18 Not, we're training warriors to go out and advance Christ's kingdom from the pulpit
00:26:24 and in writing and in scholarship of what Christ has said through the Word
00:26:29 and what the Church Fathers have said throughout history.
00:26:32 Like, this is not military training here.
00:26:35 This is not the army of the living God here.
00:26:40 This is find yourself and come do it at our seminary.
00:26:44 It's role-playing in many ways.
00:26:45 One other thing that I noticed, right?
00:26:48 So you guys bought me some time, so I've been able to calm down.
00:26:52 i think i can say it very very calmly um but uh is it just me maybe you know i could be biased but
00:26:59 i saw a lot of chicks yeah like i i think 50 might be low i think 50 like if i said half were
00:27:07 were female um i i think that that would not be accurate i think it was well over half wow now
00:27:14 that doesn't mean that like i don't i don't have the roster in front of me but i'm just saying
00:27:17 that this is still a video that they put out i'm assuming it's something that they feel good about
00:27:22 they think it's this is putting our best foot forward this is like this is what we want to
00:27:25 represent so that doesn't mean that over half of their enrollment is uh female but it does mean
00:27:31 that in terms of like what we want to present we want to present that you know in in our video
00:27:36 we want to display as though over half of the people here on campus are women well this just
00:27:44 happened at Reformed Theological Seminary in Jackson. They posted a video of new student
00:27:48 orientation for the lunch. You got blasted for that one. I didn't get destroyed because I was
00:27:52 right, and I got way more likes than comments. But people were mad because I pointed out it was
00:27:56 about 50% women. It was a lunch setting. Some of them were maybe wives, so maybe even. It was 30%, 0.90
00:28:01 40%. But this is at Reformed Theological Seminary. I couldn't find the quote. Calvin himself
00:28:06 commentating on 1 Timothy, he says, if a woman should spend all her days in the church in prayer
00:28:11 and piety and teaching and service that would not be as acceptable to god as to rear up the home and
00:28:16 to love her children in the reformed tradition that is what we've believed that the place of
00:28:21 the woman is the home to serve and to love her husband if she is married uh to love her children
00:28:26 to teach them and then you but we pan out then and we look at the incoming class of rts jackson 0.54
00:28:32 and uh it's 40 women to go do what to go girl boss to go be like imagine imagine walking into
00:28:39 marriage counseling and it's it's kaylee who's 25 with an ma in biblical counseling i'm sorry i'd
00:28:45 say oh i must be in the wrong room i'll i'll see myself out the hall yeah right let me do we want
00:28:53 to hit a break or uh yeah let's go ahead to our first commercial break and then we're going to
00:28:56 come back we're going to engage with the chat you guys go ahead and uh we've already done a little
00:29:00 bit but uh we want to be in the habit each week of trying to answer some of your questions so if
00:29:04 you say hey this you know make it clear it's a question question and then go ahead and state it
00:29:09 And we're going to come back.
00:29:10 We're going to deal with a few more, a little bit more of the subject matter, but then we're
00:29:14 going to start engaging with you guys and answering questions.
00:29:17 So first commercial break.
00:29:21 Right Response Ministries 2025 conference is a go.
00:29:26 This is three days, full jam-packed conference with eight main sessions, three to four hour
00:29:32 and a half long panels, and an all-star super-based lineup of speakers, 15 speakers in all who
00:29:39 are they? Steve Dace, Jeff Durbin, Orne McIntyre, Stephen Wolfe, Brian Sauve, Andrew Isker, John
00:29:46 Harris, Eric Kahn, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, the Christian Prince himself, Dusty Devers, Ben
00:29:53 Garrett, David Reese, and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webin. Again, this is April 3rd, 4th, and 5th,
00:30:00 2025, and the early registration is open right now. This is the longest conference with the most
00:30:08 speakers we've ever offered, and yet it is our all-time lowest price. The early registration
00:30:14 available today is only $140 for an adult. So go to rightresponseconference.com. Again,
00:30:22 that is rightresponseconference.com to register right now because the early registration will
00:30:28 not last long. Are you a Christian struggling to find companies that align with your values
00:30:34 and beliefs? Well, then Squirrely Joe's has you covered for all your coffee needs. All of their
00:30:40 coffee is hand-selected and roasted fresh every day by a family of fellow believers. Try them out
00:30:46 and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your investment supports a company committed
00:30:52 to following God's teachings and upholding truth and righteousness, ensuring that your hard-earned
00:30:58 money contributes to the growth of God's kingdom. Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans
00:31:04 who support evil. Right Response listeners have access to an exclusive deal. Your first bag of
00:31:10 coffee is free. All you have to do is cover the shipping. So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com
00:31:17 forward slash right response. Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response
00:31:23 to claim your first free bag of coffee today. Visit the word soap.com today. Again, that's 0.81
00:31:31 thewordsoap.com. Everyone needs soap, so wash yourself in the Word. 1.00
00:31:41 Welcome back. Thanks for adding those questions. Those of you who had questions, we'll go ahead
00:31:45 and get to them a little bit later in the segment. I did promise I would go back and give a little
00:31:49 bit of a list of some of these individuals that have been influential. Yeah, what do we do, Wes?
00:31:52 What do we do? Well, what we do comes after who. My bad. Why is the problem? Because we played a
00:31:56 clip of someone, Evangelicals for Harris, and someone could say, well, okay, come on, you found
00:32:00 one bad person that graduated from the seminary that's not the whole story but i'm going to go
00:32:03 through i'm going to name i'm not going to take a ton of time with this name some of the most
00:32:07 influential and subversive individuals and where they came up where they taught and how they got
00:32:12 their influence so one of the big ones is russell moore russell moore went to sbts and not only went
00:32:18 there then went on to professor there and do you think he would have been appointed to the er
00:32:22 erlc where he did all that damage if he did not first spend 10 to 15 years in the southern baptist
00:32:28 Theological Seminary Circuit? Absolutely not. That's where he made a name for himself. Went
00:32:32 there, taught there. Ed Stetzer, S-B-T-S. Stephen Furtick went to a Southern Baptist Theological
00:32:38 Seminary. Lots of great stuff coming out of him. Jamar Tisby, one of the greatest race hustlers
00:32:44 out there today. I mean, he's got the grift on point. He was on a podcast, it was a decent time
00:32:49 ago, like two years, and there's a woman there talking about queer theology and the inclusion
00:32:53 of everyone didn't breathe the word of protest when he came out of rts in 2016 ligan duncan
00:32:58 another terrible example chancellor of rts was singing his praises jamar tisby is a bright right
00:33:05 right that was eric mason my bad but he was singing his praises jamar tisby is the future
00:33:11 of reformed theology he is a bright brilliant mind who's going to go on and defend theology
00:33:16 of god and the reformed tradition it's just embarrassing yeah uh some of these other issues
00:33:22 the crucial point of attack and people have done a terrible job with them timothy keller that's
00:33:27 gordon conwell and then taught till the end of his life at rts he's bad on abortion he's bad on a
00:33:32 number of things sadly abortion was a big spot paul david tripp westminster theological seminary
00:33:38 lectured there race relations uh wait wait wait wait he lectured on race relations not at
00:33:43 westminster but in 2020 he did a struggle session on the stairs of his apartment i remember it was
00:33:48 a struggle session for all struggle sessions but he but how did these people have their names yeah
00:33:53 they went to conservative evangelical seminaries attended taught wrote books wrote academic stuff
00:34:00 and then got their name their conference circuit this that or the other dude what what year was
00:34:05 it for you guys when you realized that uh the phrase gospel centered just meant voting for
00:34:09 democrats for me it was 2018 yeah which i'm ashamed to say i was it took me eric mason
00:34:16 writing woke church right and uh that's when i left acts 29 and i realized oh gospel center just
00:34:21 means pastors ignoring everything in scripture but the law or but the gospel and avoiding the
00:34:28 law of god uh so that their parishioners who already vote for democrats won't leave their
00:34:33 church and will continue to tithe like that took you know i feel embarrassed to say it but it took
00:34:38 me until 2018 to realize that gospel-centered means pastors who assuage the conscience of
00:34:44 democrat voters so that their churches can be larger yeah yep but what year for you guys it
00:34:49 was when i heard you say it yep there you go yeah about 2018 2019 i remember listening to you and i
00:34:55 was like oh yeah that's pretty much and then we saw it in 2020 on display who else crumbled
00:35:00 jonathan lehman i think it was actually westminster that he also taught some visiting
00:35:05 classes at or maybe rts christian political engagement owen strand r scott clark kevin de
00:35:12 young seminary bread seminary teachers and their political engagement has been terrible just
00:35:19 listened to today i did it in the car which i don't recommend like you if you were in your car
00:35:23 that's dangerous do not put on mortification of spin with carl truman and todd pritt because you'll
00:35:27 want to crash your car you will look for the easiest way out to stop the pain and the suffering
00:35:31 yes so todd pritt and carl truman for anyone who's not familiar they're the ones who put amy bird on
00:35:36 the map amy bird is a feminist who they hosted on their podcast many times and unleashed her on 1.00
00:35:42 years ago yeah in the opc and then eventually she started getting a blog and then she started what
00:35:47 was that book in 2018 responding to biblical manhood or womanhood yeah yeah she came up
00:35:53 no but i don't think it was just responding to i think it was like beyond gender yeah beyond
00:35:57 or like leaving
00:35:59 or deconstructing
00:36:00 from you know
00:36:01 recovering
00:36:02 recovering
00:36:02 that's what it was
00:36:04 recovering
00:36:04 recovering from the Bible
00:36:06 and now she preaches
00:36:07 on Sunday morning
00:36:07 she does
00:36:08 Carl Truman
00:36:09 and Todd Pritt
00:36:09 who put her on the map
00:36:10 where she is now
00:36:12 deconstructed
00:36:13 preaching on a Sunday morning
00:36:14 where does she preach
00:36:14 Sunday morning
00:36:15 not in the OPC
00:36:16 not in the OPC
00:36:18 maybe in Carl Truman's
00:36:19 living room
00:36:20 like a personal sermon
00:36:21 for him
00:36:21 he would allow that
00:36:22 Presbyterian church
00:36:23 I think it's somewhere
00:36:24 in the east
00:36:25 I believe it was Tennessee
00:36:27 I remember
00:36:27 they were all very excited that amy bird such a bummer because i remember reading um the uh what
00:36:32 was it the triumph of the triumph of the modern self exactly i remember reading that and saying
00:36:36 yeah it's a pretty good book i i didn't think it was as amazing as everybody else but i was like
00:36:41 yeah this guy like i'm you know i'm just being you know petting and and envious if i can't
00:36:48 acknowledge like this guy is a good thinker he's got a good mind this is helpful and i remember he
00:36:53 came to our town to georgetown there was a church that hosted him and he gave a presentation that
00:36:58 was similar to the book just like um in a general sense this is bad and it deals with questions of
00:37:05 identity and it answers them precisely in the opposite way that the bible wouldn't so yeah
00:37:09 that's really good um but then there was a follow-up for pastors only the next morning that
00:37:14 was hosted and um and i got to go and it was you know maybe 25 other pastors in the room
00:37:19 and in that scenario it was a q a where we got to actually engage with them and um i remember
00:37:25 asking you know some practical questions like you know well okay with transgenderism and these
00:37:30 kinds of things um what do you do if there's a gay pride parade you know in your hometown and
00:37:36 you know they're marching through the street and and in some of these cases as we've seen you know
00:37:40 like um guys who are straight up naked and you know gyrating in front of little little children
00:37:45 um so like what do you what do you do with that um and uh and and then i was even you know and he
00:37:52 gave an answer that was just kind of weak and so then i even pressed further and just saying like
00:37:56 well can you um can you oppose it can you can you can you stand and and preach and tell them that
00:38:04 this is perversion and uh can you oppose it is there any muscular option and uh and the answer
00:38:12 It was pretty clear no.
00:38:14 Well, he just said today in that episode that I listened to, they were talking about Christian nationalism.
00:38:19 Of course.
00:38:19 I mentioned the Amy Bird thing to say. 0.52
00:38:21 Their discernment, their record's already rocky.
00:38:23 He said this, but they, that is Christian nationalists, are an existential threat to congregations and denominations. 0.59
00:38:30 And that's why we need to be very aware of what's going on online relative to individuals coming forward from ministry now. 0.52
00:38:35 And he actually said, when we get seminarians and we're testing for their ordination, we need to be asking them if they're Christian nationalists.
00:38:42 That's what they said in that episode today.
00:38:44 Not because they want that.
00:38:45 Because they would weed it out.
00:38:46 Exactly.
00:38:47 So Spurgeon will ban the unmanly men, and they will ban the ones who want their nation to honor God.
00:38:52 Right.
00:38:53 Which also is the masculine.
00:38:55 That's right.
00:38:56 And that's what it really comes down to.
00:38:58 Again, a system, it's not what it's called.
00:39:00 It's what it does.
00:39:01 The purpose of a system is what it does.
00:39:03 um and so the purpose of you know the seminary uh system i think we have to acknowledge at some
00:39:08 level um it is to crush masculinity i really believe that so whether it's um whether it's
00:39:15 carl truman and opc seminaries you know trying to weed out uh christian nationalism right wanting
00:39:21 a christian to be distinct a nation to be distinctly christian to honor god and to legislate
00:39:27 here's the thing
00:39:29 and to legislate
00:39:30 both tables of the law
00:39:31 in other words
00:39:32 having the same views
00:39:34 as John Calvin
00:39:35 and John Gill
00:39:36 on the Baptist side
00:39:37 the confessional view
00:39:38 and I know about
00:39:39 the American revision
00:39:40 it's still perfectly
00:39:42 it's perfectly
00:39:42 yeah
00:39:43 whether it be Philadelphia
00:39:44 whether it be London
00:39:45 it is perfectly
00:39:47 compliant with both
00:39:48 so
00:39:50 but the point is
00:39:51 it's not just that
00:39:52 it's not just like
00:39:52 oh we want to weed out politics
00:39:53 we want to
00:39:54 if you
00:39:54 If you subtract it down to the lowest common denominator of, you know, trying to ban a
00:40:01 muscular political approach, you know, or trying to, not too much cultural engagement
00:40:05 or this or that, what it all has in common is the purpose of seminaries is to feminize
00:40:12 the church.
00:40:13 That's right.
00:40:13 I believe that.
00:40:14 I really do.
00:40:14 So, it's like, what have we seen?
00:40:16 The current iteration of seminaries.
00:40:17 Exactly.
00:40:18 Exactly.
00:40:18 It's not what it was supposed to, originally, but that's what it is today.
00:40:21 and um and if you think well but i'm in the opc and they're super conservative the guys the opc
00:40:28 gave you amy bird that's right you just have to own that all right that's like i'm not saying you
00:40:32 suck with everything i'm grateful for the opc in many in many different ways but that's a giant l
00:40:36 and you have to wear it you know just like the scarlet letter a you know like you have to walk 0.97
00:40:40 around and you have to say you know by the grace of god you know there's hope but also unclean
00:40:46 unclean we we unleashed amy bird on the world that is that that is carl truman and uh that's
00:40:53 you you got to own that well think about but my point is like with that and the video we showed
00:40:57 all the women coming to so whether it's uh their enrollments with all the women or whether it's
00:41:03 banning christian nationalism in with opc you know like conservative seminaries or whether it's this 0.66
00:41:08 that and the other um i really do think that like the point of seminary is um is is to feminize
00:41:16 the church i really do what the westminster seminary they finally got all the faculty
00:41:20 together to write a book in the 90s and what was it against abortion transgenderism the sexual
00:41:25 revolution against theonomy right westminster which provides it's not affiliated with the
00:41:30 denomination so it is not technically a pc okay so say that again this is in the 90s i remember
00:41:35 so in the 90s from greg bonson is pretty based on that he's like he's like you have to lock your
00:41:39 windows at night is that like right like people are there murder is at an all-time high there's
00:41:45 this going on and that going on and uh and you want to uh you want to got everyone together
00:41:50 because it's hard to get everyone together against theonomy that's your big concern so they got all
00:41:55 the faculty this is the project can we get everyone together can you write this can you
00:41:59 write that has a fantastic comment i don't know if we should read it but hey zach i know you're
00:42:04 listening and i you just like the scripture says give honor where honor is due uh well done brother
00:42:10 that is yep you did well all right how do i fix it though i can't say it no no i won't say i don't
00:42:16 i don't i can say it on our show the problem is i get picked up by somebody else and then that
00:42:19 will it'll be seven seconds yeah and that'll be the only thing they'll be like yeah joel webbin
00:42:24 uh doesn't he believe in mermaids and he also said that one time yeah anyways that's it that's
00:42:29 what you're known for right all right we've pointed out the problems it is not just a one-off
00:42:34 here and one-off there it is a systemic problem can i can i just say one other thing before we
00:42:38 can go there go for it there are seminaries like the master's seminary where they do not allow
00:42:43 women yep um they do not allow their students to go into debt to pay for seminary they're not
00:42:51 taking government money and yet a lot of the people that are coming out of them are not the
00:42:56 manly warrior types right like it is not just an issue um joel i think you're onto something it's
00:43:02 not just an issue of well the seminaries that took government money or not right there has been a
00:43:07 prevailing trend to make christianity feminine and when that is the goal the training for those who
00:43:16 will train other christians is to feminize them as well right and that's why when zachary garris
00:43:22 writes a book masking christianity that until not long ago was just common thought and belief it's
00:43:30 it's this firestorm and and so i like i just west before you go into fixing it i want some people
00:43:36 Joel you've said this when they when we talk about public schools they'll say yeah those are all
00:43:40 terrible but mine is great right and some of them are going to say yeah seminaries are terrible but
00:43:45 the one you know the one that we send our guys to is fantastic and it's like you need to ask
00:43:51 yourself how many of the products of the seminary that your church sends men to are battling for
00:43:58 truth not compromising truth so we're not seeing social justice on relevant cultural issues right
00:44:03 there's lots who are battling for cultural issues. They're the woke social justice Christians. So how
00:44:10 many of them are based theologically and are fighting the current battles? Right? Not very
00:44:15 many of them. To credit where credit is due, the forward to Zachary Garris' Honor Thy Fathers,
00:44:20 an anti-feminist work, was written by Joseph Pipa, who is chancellor or president at Greenville
00:44:27 Presbyterian Theological Seminary. They do admit women. I actually had a really good friend who
00:44:31 went there but it does seem like overall a rigorous program especially if you're going there
00:44:35 for more the academic part of it the formal instruction versus the actually being made
00:44:40 behavior into a masculine man so great point michael i'm going to say these three things
00:44:45 um they are not going to be the only things they're going to fix it but i think they are the
00:44:48 base level to getting back to where our seminaries are just even putting out people that are not
00:44:53 going to counter signal other christians that are not going to go to war with not the world the
00:44:58 flesh and the devil, but turn their fire on the Christians out there doing good work. So three
00:45:03 things, I'll read them all, and then we can discuss maybe each one in turn, maybe more,
00:45:07 maybe less. Get women out of seminary. There's, in a seminary context, again, not all education 1.00
00:45:13 we've talked about, but in a seminary context, get women out. We've talked about why for the
00:45:17 women's, but also the dynamic of a woman in a classroom, women are, they're less aggressive, 1.00
00:45:22 which is good and right. That's how God made them. They're less aggressive, they're less 1.00
00:45:26 confrontational and they're more passive, that changes the dynamic of a classroom. It neuters
00:45:32 the type of male initiative, edge, and discipline that should be present in the men that we would
00:45:39 hope that would come to our pulpits. So men that are going to preach, men that are going to engage
00:45:43 the culture, men that are going to live godly lives, we want them at some level to have an
00:45:47 edge. But if every single classroom they have to share and debate and do group projects with is
00:45:52 50% women, 30% women, 20% women, that classroom is going to be suited to the feminine sensibilities 0.96
00:45:58 that God has made women to have. God made women to be more passive, to be less aggressive, 1.00
00:46:03 and those are wonderful in their context. And the context is not a classroom where we're training
00:46:08 men to go into pastoral ministry. So get women out of seminary. As professors as well. As professors 1.00
00:46:14 as well. Yeah. Not just enrolling. Yep. Students and professors. Attach pastoral training to local
00:46:20 churches. We had a question on this, so I'll dive more into detail on that a little bit after, but
00:46:24 at least for the time, I think it's wisest that seminaries be attached to churches, attached to
00:46:29 the oversight, attached to the elders, attached to the structure, the teaching, the lecturing of
00:46:33 pastors in a local church. And then finally, make seminary manly again, like you said. And there is
00:46:40 a faux masculinity, so I'm not talking about a bench press requirement, although I truly believe
00:46:46 this guys you could put me in a lie detector test for a while now so this is not just clickbait you
00:46:51 make the entry requirement to seminary bench 225 for three and you would fix seminaries in 10 years
00:46:57 i'm not even kidding if you made that and and not to have to do it every year for the rest of your
00:47:03 life but you're a man you're preparing for entry into seminary you need to actually be a man you
00:47:08 need to actually have a little bit of a chest a man in his 20s should be able to get there in like
00:47:12 three to four months. And if you don't have the discipline to do that, we don't really want you.
00:47:17 I'm sorry. There's lots of good men out there. So making seminaries manly, that starts with faculty,
00:47:21 well-disciplined men who look sharp, who present well, who have, like I talked about, an edge to
00:47:27 them, who teach, are godly, they're strong, they're willing to say offensive things. Make seminaries
00:47:32 manly again, get women out, and attach them to local churches. Those, I think, would be a great
00:47:37 starting point um in this yeah to making seminaries great again make seminary great again yeah they
00:47:45 were great and they are not anymore i think that's well thought out that's good michael any thoughts
00:47:50 yeah um i just the only one i'll add and i already said this is just and i don't know where
00:47:56 i don't know where this change can happen but the perception of what seminaries are for
00:48:02 needs to change. And part of that's going to be godly men coming into leadership at seminaries
00:48:08 and them just putting an end to the nonsense, saying, no, we are not providing, you know,
00:48:13 church revitalization, inner city church revitalization programs, right? And so I don't
00:48:20 think that there's really any other way than for godly men going to seminaries and saying,
00:48:24 we're not offering these fluff degrees. This is not a place to find yourself. This is not a place
00:48:29 for you to, as a baby Christian, you know, study, like, it's not that. So at some point, 0.94
00:48:39 seminaries are going to have to properly position themselves and define themselves.
00:48:43 And part of that is, this is not a new idea to us, we've mentioned it before,
00:48:49 but part of that is not elevating the pastoral ministry as the only viable option for ambitious,
00:48:56 well-qualified men who love jesus who love jesus yeah and so if there are if the church and pastors
00:49:04 esteem other things other programs then seminary doesn't have to be this end all like christian
00:49:12 experience it can just be a tool that trains pastors right trains pastors in in theology and
00:49:19 to think about relevant issues but is simply just that brian survey i think it was in a king's hall
00:49:25 episode and they talked about, it might have been seminaries and education, but they said the ideal
00:49:29 situation is you have a church that's been established and there's a young man who shows
00:49:33 potential and desires it. So, he's been vetted, families know him, and then seminary is merely
00:49:38 the addendum on what might be an already qualified man to go on and do that vocationally. So, he's
00:49:44 already a leader, already godly, already qualified, already leading his family. There's just a piece
00:49:50 on some of the systematic theology that he hasn't been able to learn because maybe he works a full
00:49:54 time job. That's where the seminary comes in. And then probably he comes back to the local church
00:49:59 to benefit. And again, he's installed as a pastor, not as somebody, somebody mentioned just sending
00:50:04 out your resume across the nation. He's not so-and-so from the Denver seminary that we
00:50:08 don't know from Adam. It's a young man who came up in this church, who we've known him and his
00:50:12 family for 10 to 15 years. We've witnessed him grow as a man, and now he has a formal theological
00:50:18 education. He's sharp as a tack. He can rebuff any assault in the scripture, and you bring that man
00:50:23 back in that man back in that is the recipe for someone who will do decades by god's grace of good
00:50:29 faithful godly ministry the situation we have now the attrition rates from ministry yes they're bad
00:50:34 a lot of men don't stick with it yeah they spend all the money and they don't even continue in
00:50:38 ministry but that one it's not going to be perfect that's going to get you a lot better success fruit
00:50:44 and godliness on the long term than this is the the current model we have right now right but what
00:50:50 it would mean is probably just a lot less people go to seminary well and so it's just yep it's
00:50:56 well you know it's funny because you know everybody everybody is uh very very very
00:51:02 concerned you know troubled and concerned the concern bros right there's there's such a thing
00:51:06 as a theo bro but there's certainly such a thing as a concern bro we've got a couple in the chat
00:51:10 right here i'm looking at them um the concern bros are real and one of their deep deep deep
00:51:16 concerns is grifting and they think that somehow um that anybody with a podcast has a monopoly
00:51:22 on grifting but if we want to talk about professional level you know like like gold
00:51:28 tier level grifting like right because i i mean i'm over here you know just doing a podcast and
00:51:33 i i may be a grifter but i must not be very good at it you know because because if we want to talk
00:51:39 about champions of grifting um we're talking about entire you know like like 200 300 400 acre
00:51:46 campuses you know and and stone buildings and you know millions and hundreds of millions of
00:51:53 dollars of assets and you know employing you know hundreds of people and all you know tenured
00:51:58 professions where you can never lose your job and good retirement or like now that that is a grift
00:52:05 and um but it ain't the podcasters um it's the it's the it's a seminary yeah um seminaries have
00:52:13 become like it's it's like anything else just like a mega church or anything you know the the purpose
00:52:17 of the system is what it does and sadly at this point uh seminaries are an end in themselves it's
00:52:23 it's not a means to the end of actually um benefiting the church it's just how can our
00:52:28 seminary grow not how the church of jesus but how can the seminary continue to grow well one way you
00:52:33 can get anything to grow, is if you double the market, you know, and say like, hey, you
00:52:39 know what, upon further research, you know, we went back to the Scripture and we realized 0.98
00:52:44 that, I mean, yeah, okay, you know, maybe a woman still can't be a pastor, we'll keep
00:52:49 our, you know, our complementarian, soft complementarian card, you know, in our back pocket, but there's 0.99
00:52:54 no reason that a woman can't go to seminary, because, I mean, that's great, if she racks 0.92
00:52:57 up $80,000 in debt, you know, training to do something that the Scripture won't allow
00:53:01 her to do in the first place that's great you know because she's going to teach her kids you 0.96
00:53:05 know and and don't we want you know a seminary trained woman to teach her kids you know and it's 0.99
00:53:11 like no um we want uh intelligent well-learned women training their kids yes um but i don't 1.00
00:53:18 think that you have to do that for 80 grand i don't think that you have to do that at seminary
00:53:22 we are not against women learning what we're against is we're against uh grifters uh charging
00:53:29 women $80,000 to learn with no way of getting a return and keeping women in many cases from doing
00:53:37 the very thing that God has called them to do because they're racking up debt and it's actually 1.00
00:53:43 going to become a hindrance, not a help, but a hindrance towards marriage and family. The very
00:53:48 thing that a lot of these young women actually in their heart of hearts would like to be, a wife and
00:53:53 a mother and you're you're actually putting them behind not ahead in that endeavor well and along
00:54:00 those lines it it troubles me that whenever this conversation comes up with with due respect to the
00:54:09 commentators because you know i don't i don't know you or or how many times you may have raised this
00:54:14 objection in your life but it's troubling that in general when this conversation comes up someone
00:54:18 comes along and says well you think that a woman can't learn theology and our perspective on where
00:54:27 on where we are to learn theology is like like maybe this is a product of seminaries maybe they've
00:54:33 marketed themselves as the place to learn the bible that is a profoundly unchristian idea it's
00:54:40 profoundly un-american christian idea right that you would have to go to seminary to learn the bible
00:54:45 Well, if that's the case, then yes, we are withholding theological knowledge from great swaths of people.
00:54:53 And we need more and more and more seminaries.
00:54:55 No, the church and fathers, and even go read a book, are to be the ways that the Christians in a society learn theology.
00:55:05 And God help us if the perception is the church is not for learning.
00:55:09 The church is not for learning theology.
00:55:11 And this is maybe a product of the seeker-sensitive movements who were a mile wide, an inch deep, where you don't learn theology when you go to a church.
00:55:19 So maybe that has contributed some to the idea that, well, if you really want to learn, you must go to seminary. 0.67
00:55:24 But that is a fatal idea to the life of Christians and to the church.
00:55:29 Let's hit our second commercial break, and then we'll take the questions.
00:55:32 Are you desiring to change your financial trajectory and build multi-generational wealth for your children and grandchildren?
00:55:38 Our sponsor, Private Family Banking Partners, invites you to join a growing number of like-minded individuals, families, and entrepreneurs who are working together to form a unique part of the parallel economy.
00:55:53 With Private Family Banking, you will learn how to establish a privatized banking system that will increase the value of the money and savings that you already have flowing through your life.
00:56:04 Join this growing community today as a part of putting post-mill talk into post-mill action
00:56:10 by contacting a private family banking partner today by emailing them at banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:56:18 Also, see the show notes below to schedule a discovery call and get a free copy of the e-book,
00:56:24 Protect Your Money Now, How to Build Multigenerational Wealth Outside of Wall Street and Avoid the Coming Banking Meltdown.
00:56:34 Our beef supply is under attack.
00:56:37 More than ever, the industry for fake industrial-produced meat is underway. 0.99
00:56:42 As reformed post-mill Christians, the founders of Dominion Ranch 0.93
00:56:46 seek to honor Christ's rule and continue building His kingdom on earth
00:56:51 by supplying Christians with high-quality beef for the journey.
00:56:55 We believe in excellence, and that is why Dominion Ranch works as a collective
00:57:01 with multi-generational ranchers across Texas
00:57:04 to bring you the best in great tasting and nutritious beef.
00:57:09 Our motto is that kingdoms were never built on salads alone.
00:57:13 Eat beef and subdue the earth.
00:57:15 And one more thing,
00:57:16 don't forget to enter the Dominion Ranch Super Summer Giveaway
00:57:20 for some delicious Wagyu beef,
00:57:22 a mouth-watering addition to your freezer.
00:57:25 Click the link in the description and enter to win.
00:57:27 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty
00:57:32 before God and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:57:37 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied, not just as a
00:57:41 plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business as though they're commandments from God
00:57:46 that we're supposed to obey. Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:57:52 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our
00:57:57 capacity to do things here.
00:57:59 Reefs Fund, Christian Capital,
00:58:01 boldly deployed.
00:58:05 Well, welcome back.
00:58:07 In this final segment, we've been taking questions,
00:58:09 so if you have a question, go ahead and phrase
00:58:11 it as a question, a question mark,
00:58:13 give it a preface or something like that
00:58:15 so we can see it. It was a good question.
00:58:17 Peter asked a set of questions that we'll
00:58:19 get to, but Paul asked a good question.
00:58:20 I'm going to read it out, and I'd like to hear
00:58:22 your guys' thoughts. Paul said this,
00:58:24 I have a daughter. What would be a biblical 0.99
00:58:26 educational education i could give her i kind of want to try i just want to try to say his last
00:58:33 name paul i don't know if it's his last name art yomenko art yomenko art yomenko i like that i saw
00:58:41 that and i said there's there's no way i'm even trying paul great to have you in the chat i saw
00:58:45 that last name and i felt embarrassed because the first thought that i had was like hyo miyasaki
00:58:51 and most people will not even know what i'm talking about i'm not going to explain it because
00:58:55 i don't want to embarrass myself further so anyways paul good question uh the question is
00:59:00 what you know how do i teach my daughter yeah if i'm not going to send her to seminary you know pay
00:59:04 80 grand 120 grand uh what do we teach her what do you think i i do think that there's a certain
00:59:11 sense where um we're preparing our daughters generally and specifically so of course you're
00:59:18 going to know your daughter you're going to know the giftings that god has given to her
00:59:21 you're going to know the abilities that that you know so you might you might have a daughter who's
00:59:27 who's just quick with math and and you might say look let's you could maybe learn accounting or
00:59:33 something like that that you can do from home and certainly your family budget you can manage your
00:59:36 husband's business um that would be a direction but you might have a daughter who it's like you
00:59:40 need to marry a guy who's good with math because you've got other skills but he's going to be doing
00:59:44 you know more of the math side in your family so there's a sense where there's not a cookie cutter
00:59:49 answer, but if we're talking higher education, my priorities are things that enhance and align
00:59:58 with feminine virtues, things that can be done from and for the home, and things that are not 1.00
01:00:06 going to put her on a career path where maybe she is single for a couple years, so she does take a 0.99
01:00:11 secular job, and she's supporting herself that way, and then she gets married, and now to pull 1.00
01:00:15 the plug on this career is an unthinkable idea for her so feminine qualities qualities that will 1.00
01:00:22 benefit the home that can be done from the home and certainly not things like like if you send 1.00
01:00:27 your daughter to law school and she has 120 000 in debt she's going to have to work for x amount
01:00:33 of time to pay that off regardless of whether she gets married or not right yep that's good i agree
01:00:38 um something i would say is just uh you know i i've always been a fan of books you know i just
01:00:46 think that uh there's you know there's this one uh scene with goodwill hunting the movie where
01:00:51 he kind of is putting the the highly educated ivy league you know student in his place you know
01:00:59 will the main character is poor and he can't afford to go to the school and pay tuition
01:01:02 but he's smart and he said you know the real shame is that um you know that uh you're spending
01:01:09 hundreds of thousands of dollars to get an education that you could have got uh with a
01:01:13 library card and a few overdue fines you know something like that and so um now i i'm not
01:01:19 saying that there there is something to be said for organized and disciplined study yeah um the
01:01:25 reality is that uh by not going to seminary there are certain things that you will almost certainly
01:01:30 neglect you will because um you just won't like them you won't like them exactly yeah you just
01:01:36 won't like them like i you know uh in different seasons of my life i've beefed up my understanding
01:01:41 of different subjects as i've developed interest for those subjects or or the need or the need or
01:01:47 i've been around i've you know in relationships and community with other people who are interested
01:01:52 about those subjects and so then would drive me you know having a season where i'm particularly
01:01:57 interested in church history, you know, and right now I'm particularly interested in one,
01:02:02 you know, subset of church history, namely the Crusades, because me and every other, you know,
01:02:07 man around 40, you know, and under read, you know, Defenders of the West and, you know,
01:02:13 and God's Battalions and, you know, and so, but my point is like, there's a lot. There's a lot
01:02:20 that can be gained simply by studying and by reading. And, you know, if you want disciplined
01:02:24 studies um you know i mean all all these seminaries for the most part have their curriculum
01:02:31 um and their you know all their courses and all their classes and the books for those courses and
01:02:37 classes listed for free online videos too that you can watch a lot of them have yeah so so just
01:02:43 for the record um because somebody in the chat continues to just absolutely insist uh that we
01:02:50 don't want women to learn um no that's not what we're saying we don't want women in debt
01:02:57 that's what i'm trying to say what i'm saying is that i don't think that we should send our 0.98
01:03:02 daughters to seminaries which their whole design or at least it was supposed to be originally
01:03:08 was to train men for the ministry right and the bible prohibits women from preaching and from
01:03:17 pastoral ministry vocational so we're saying women who primarily first and foremost that 0.98
01:03:24 doesn't mean that out of the overflow of her domestic feminine virtue and ministry at home
01:03:29 that there's not an overflow like the proverbs 31 woman that it begins to overflow into other
01:03:34 things and this and that and blah blah blah that's fine that's not what we're talking about
01:03:38 but we're saying first and foremost um it is domestic it is feminine it is wife it is mother
01:03:44 that's first and foremost and what it certainly can't be which it seems like most people in the
01:03:49 chat are agreeing with most of them are it's cute you know when you're complimentarian think you're
01:03:54 conservative but you know everybody you know is pretending to be conservative in the chat today
01:03:58 and so then you would all agree that um that the woman can't preach and that she can't be a pastor
01:04:03 so what does that mean it means she doesn't if she's first and foremost called to be a mom 0.65
01:04:08 wife and a mom and she can't preach or be a pastor then um can we just agree that maybe the
01:04:15 first step of direction that we take is not racking up 120 grand of student loans at seminary
01:04:23 that's that's what i'm saying i'm not saying that there's one subject matter that that seminary is
01:04:28 going to cover that she can't learn but she doesn't need to learn it there right she doesn't
01:04:33 need to be there right she can learn it with her dad she can learn it with her husband she can learn
01:04:38 it by herself and just studying with all the ancient fathers and reading Aquinas and reading
01:04:43 Athanasius and reading Calvin. I'm not prohibiting any of that.
01:04:48 If anything, praise God that a woman would feel, if it's born out of a good desire,
01:04:52 to love God more, to know Him.
01:04:53 Right. If she's in this stage of being an adolescent and she's not yet married and she
01:04:59 has time on her hands and she wants to be productive and she has a desire for knowing
01:05:03 God, the study of God, that's what theology is, all that's great. I'm just saying that
01:05:07 she doesn't need to go to the place that was invented originally for training pastors if the
01:05:14 book, namely the Bible, says that she can't be one. That doesn't make sense. And more than the
01:05:20 debt thing, too, and you're alluding to that right there at the end, if a woman goes to seminary,
01:05:25 part of her self-conception, her purpose, right? Because when we educate ourselves, 0.78
01:05:30 it's usually for a purpose. If I go study to be an attorney, my idea is I got to do something with
01:05:35 law to justify the four, six, or whatever, seven years that I spent studying law. And if we send
01:05:41 women to seminaries, part of their perceived purpose in life is going to be some sort of 0.99
01:05:47 theological training of others or ministry, vocational ministry. And so even from right 1.00
01:05:54 there, we set women who go to seminaries up to assume, I have to do some sort of ministry, 0.73
01:06:00 right more even along with the debt that they rack up their their perception on their calling
01:06:08 in life is some sort of ministry or some sort of theological training yeah you saw that in the
01:06:13 video let's say just add one more thing we can hit the next questions to uh paul's point but
01:06:17 if you're if you're all of your children your sons and your daughters if they're well catechized
01:06:23 and taught uh coming up through the ranks they will know so much bible just by virtue of learning
01:06:28 the Westminster Shorter Catechism, learning memory verses, sitting under teaching. We talked about
01:06:32 family integrated, sitting under the teaching of a pastor thousands of times. So if you get to that
01:06:37 point in their 18, I would say, if it's a good family, most children, and even some men that
01:06:43 maybe will go out and do some type of blue-collar work, have enough of a biblical foundation
01:06:48 that should last them through their life. The disciplines of prayer, the disciplines of
01:06:53 the sabbath and of worship um personal devotion those should all be instilled by 18 so we're
01:07:01 thinking about like a biblical education well it's going to happen at home gradually to the
01:07:05 point where at 18 i would say most boys and girls if they've been brought up right they have
01:07:10 enough that they need for the most part and that can be supplemented as needed
01:07:14 pastoral counsel wisdom things like that um but yeah i would say yeah mostly you should know
01:07:21 know your bible and uh if you're well taught you will all right uh peter sawyer let's not read all
01:07:27 three of these questions so what are the thoughts about the system in place where young men age 22
01:07:31 to 25 or so go to seminary and then send out resumes to churches for employment does this
01:07:37 system so the system he just talked about sending out resumes does it not produce hirelings last
01:07:42 question should we not instead recognize qualified men from within the body yeah i think we'd agree
01:07:47 on on all three points you said earlier you're going to touch on this topic i think it was in
01:07:51 response to this question right about the um seminaries and local churches and yep yeah we
01:07:57 touched on it a little bit but um it's it is strange that we live in a time i think of people
01:08:03 that i visit that are older than me and i ask them like oh where are your kids what are they
01:08:06 doing and they always report a variety of states california texas colorado when so and so is here
01:08:12 with our grandkids it is very novel that we would travel as much as we do so we talk about sending
01:08:17 out resumes. So say you even go to a seminary local to home, but you didn't come up in the
01:08:21 church, that kind of process we talked about. You're going to be sending your resume all over
01:08:25 the place. They're going to be congregations that you don't know from Adam. They're going to be
01:08:30 people that aren't familiar with you. You're not familiar with them. You're going to go to a state
01:08:33 where you're maybe not familiar with the culture, the type of things that people do there in their
01:08:37 free time. So it is not an ideal system. And exactly to his point, those young men, they send
01:08:42 off the resume because they've graduated. They're not connected to a local church that was actually
01:08:46 supporting them as they went through seminary so they send it out and then they leave family
01:08:50 that's ideally if anything they've probably already left family to go to seminary but then
01:08:55 they leave family they go somewhere else and then they're alone two time zones away making
01:08:59 forty thousand dollars a year and struggling and that system absolutely does produce men that go
01:09:03 and go uh no i can't do this we want to go back uh i'm not actually cut out for this so it does 0.63
01:09:09 i would say produce hirelings and it is much more preferable i think we'd all agree a young man in
01:09:14 a local church his gifting is recognized he himself has the desire the first qualification
01:09:19 first timothy's first timothy three desire he desires to be an elder the church supports him
01:09:24 then in his ministry maybe he goes away for a little while to seminary but then he comes back
01:09:28 for service in that church that is much less likely to produce a hireling produce someone
01:09:33 who doesn't stick with the ministry than what i just described yep agreed that's good all right
01:09:39 I would say it's acceptable.
01:09:43 You know, you think of, like, in the U.S., early in the U.S.,
01:09:49 they would call ministers over from England to the U.S.
01:09:52 And so there is a history of, especially in the Presbyterian Church, right,
01:09:57 you're calling ministers in.
01:09:59 Yeah, there's nothing wrong with that.
01:10:00 It's not inherently wrong.
01:10:02 But I think, Wes, what you're saying is the training of a man going into ministry
01:10:09 is more than the two or three years he spends at ministry.
01:10:13 And if those two or three years are spent at a seminary,
01:10:17 good, solid seminary, that's one thing.
01:10:20 If the overall context of his training is the evaluation of his character,
01:10:26 of how he's leading his family, if he's married already,
01:10:29 all of those things coming up through the church,
01:10:33 the pastors, the local pastors recognize a gifting.
01:10:35 um that's but but but what so many young men and women now are doing is they're treating seminary
01:10:44 like a college and it's like what do i want to do well i think maybe i'll just go to seminary
01:10:48 right rather than a church putting their stamp of approval on someone not that he's perfect but
01:10:52 saying look we believe this is the calling it's a desire you have and rather than send you to go
01:10:58 be a lawyer we believe that god has is is setting you apart to go to ministry do ministry and we're
01:11:03 going to support you in that so when you come back there'll be a place for you or we'll help
01:11:06 you find a place at a church in the area um that's a totally different model than the well let's go
01:11:14 to the seminary that gives me the best uh scholarship and then i'll go to the church that
01:11:19 will take me yep all right um let's go ahead and what i was gonna say you got a ufo question
01:11:27 i see it i see it i'll say it for another time all right all right i appreciate it uh jonathan
01:11:33 johnson i see you i hear you i feel you you're speaking my language but i just i don't have it
01:11:39 in me today so um let's go ahead and uh land the plane nate do we have any more commercials for
01:11:46 today conference all right so one thing that's really important is our early bird pricing it is
01:11:53 ending um at the end of this month so you just have that's for the conference in april yep for
01:11:57 the conference. So, rightresponseconference.com, Christ is King, How to Defeat Trash World.
01:12:03 That is ending August 31st at 1159 p.m. Central Time. So, go and register for that today. Again,
01:12:10 that's rightresponseconference.com. We have a super-packed lineup, and it's going to be great.
01:12:17 And not everybody, just for the record, intentionally by design, not everybody
01:12:21 agrees with everybody theologically. We're going to have multiple panels. We're going to have some
01:12:26 discussion we're going to have disagreements we're going to have some debate and discussion and um
01:12:31 it's it's going to be really good yeah it's going to be manly we have eight main sessions we have
01:12:36 i think four panels um it's thursday friday and saturday uh april 3rd 4th and 5th april 3rd 4th
01:12:43 and 5th next year so uh the price is going up it's going up um a decent amount we have the lowest
01:12:48 price that we're offering um right now with the early bird special and then the last thing i was
01:12:53 going to say is uh check out patreon every single week for the live stream on wednesday michael and
01:12:58 they alternate writing an article um for that's that kind of guides our discussion so that we
01:13:04 have some preparation coming in for that week's live stream and so uh wes you wrote the article
01:13:09 this week and um and so if you want to be able to as someone who writes the article and then
01:13:14 sometimes navigates a discussion that doesn't touch on the article just because where it goes
01:13:18 the article generally has things that we don't talk about right here in the in the discussion
01:13:22 absolutely yeah so if you want to be able to uh to get the article um go and join us on patreon
01:13:27 also what you'll get is with our friday special you get ad free you get ad free pretty much all
01:13:33 the content you get ad free but you get early access and ad free for the friday special as
01:13:38 soon as the first episode of a friday special season drops there's usually you know eight
01:13:44 nine ten eleven twelve episodes in a season and as soon as the very first one drops they're all
01:13:49 available for our patreon members and we've got a new season uh coming out with the friday special
01:13:54 very soon the very beginning of october uh just a little over a month away uh we've got a new
01:13:59 season with me and andrew isker um on everybody's favorite topic uh israel so we'll see i will see
01:14:07 how people respond to that so but anyways uh join us to get early access to the friday special join
01:14:12 us on patreon to get the articles that wes and michael are writing every week for the wednesday
01:14:16 day live stream, all you have to do is go to patreon.com forward slash right response
01:14:21 ministries, patreon.com forward slash right response ministries.
01:14:26 And also, again, you've got like three or four days for Christ is King, How to Defeat
01:14:31 Trash World for that conference, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, and that's right response conference.
01:14:38 Instead of ministries, it's right response conference.com to get the early bird rate.
01:14:46 We'll be right back.