The NXR Podcast - January 17, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Men, Don’t Hate Your Sons

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Andrew Tate Clueless Christians THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Why Talmudic Judaism Is A Perversion Of The Old Testament - w Andrew Isker @contramundumpodcast

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 36 minutes

Words per minute

182.21

Word count

17,569

Sentence count

722

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

64

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Are you a young white man who just can t seem to get a stable job that will afford a home, a family, and a modest lifestyle? Well, have no fear. Panda Express is hiring assistant managers for $70,000 a year, or you could work at Chipotle stuffing burritos for $100,000 in a few years. Now, it seems silly, but this is real advice being offered by conservative, and I'm putting conservative in quotation marks, journalists and pundits. If after all, they managed to make their own big break a decade or two ago, then there's no reason that you can t walk into a suit and tie and be offered a great job by simply having a solid handshake and a smile.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 Are you a young white man who just can't seem to get a stable job that will afford a home,
00:00:34 a family, and modest lifestyle? Well, have no fear. Panda Express is hiring assistant managers 0.51
00:00:40 for $70,000 a year. Or you could work at Chipotle stuffing burritos and making $100,000 in just a
00:00:48 few years. Now, it seems silly, but this is real advice being offered by conservative,
00:00:54 and I'm putting conservative in quotation marks, think tank journalists and pundits.
00:00:59 If after all, they managed to make their own big break a decade or two ago,
00:01:05 then there's no reason that you can't put on a suit and a tie and walk into a job interview
00:01:12 and be offered a great job by simply having a solid handshake and a smile.
00:01:21 Now, I'm being a little bit tongue-in-cheek, but in biblical terms, it's important to recognize
00:01:26 that this process is called exasperating your sons.
00:01:30 Real wages are the lowest that they've ever been today.
00:01:34 Housing is flat-out unaffordable. 0.91
00:01:36 And all this while 94% of new jobs added to the S&P 100 companies are going to people
00:01:42 of color who are a significant minority in the U.S.
00:01:47 Advice that really did work for the prior generation just doesn't get you as far anymore.
00:01:53 It's harder than ever to provide, save, and build up an inheritance.
00:01:58 And for us to actually give helpful, loving advice,
00:02:01 we have to be honest about the challenges that young men are facing today.
00:02:06 This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund,
00:02:12 as well as our Patreon members and faithful donors.
00:02:14 You can join our Patreon by going to patreon.com forward slash Right Response Ministries,
00:02:21 or you can donate at rightresponseministries.com forward slash donate.
00:02:26 In this episode, we'll also be joined by the one and only Oren McIntyre to address and discuss this very important topic.
00:02:36 Tune in now.
00:02:44 You've listened to all these people, and so what have you learned?
00:02:47 The bad news is that people feel like they've done absolutely everything right,
00:02:53 and their lives are trapped.
00:02:56 They, you know, young people say, look, okay, I went through, I got an education,
00:03:02 I work nonstop, and I have made the calculation that there is no mathematical path for me to own a house.
00:03:10 It's just not possible.
00:03:12 In Toronto here, for example, if you take the average income and the average house price, it would take use 29 years to save up for a down payment for a down payment, not to pay it off, forget paying it off. 0.99
00:03:26 And so if you're a young woman who's got a biological clock, obviously, we'll do the math. 0.94
00:03:30 You're going to be in your 50s before you can afford the average house. 1.00
00:03:34 All right, guys, thanks for joining us today.
00:03:36 uh if you're wondering what was going on during that cold open uh we had written it out and so
00:03:42 i was doing my best to read but over uh the screen where it was written there was another screen
00:03:48 covering up a good 30 of the words so i couldn't read it and then some of you might be wondering i
00:03:54 saw in the live chat somebody said hey somebody's walking in front of the camera well that was
00:03:58 michael god bless him he did the right thing i was just sitting here like well you're in for the
00:04:02 long haul hope it goes well michael was trying to run over to nathan to say hey um basically the
00:04:08 entire teleprompter is covered by another screen and joel is literally just from memory guessing
00:04:13 right now which is what i was doing so to read a three-minute script um this is the last one i've
00:04:18 written in a while too today i was like we got a longer one it was a three-minute script and wes
00:04:22 even talked to me before he wrote it and he said do you think you can uh read a three-minute script
00:04:26 without messing up and i should have said i didn't i said yes what i should have said is
00:04:31 yes, if I can see it, if it's actually on the screen, which it was not, unfortunately.
00:04:36 But we got through it. I think you get the main point. So Oren McIntyre, he's going to be joining
00:04:41 us at 3.30 Central Time, 3.30 PM Central Time. So we've got about 25 minutes or so to outline
00:04:49 this episode for you. And basically, the big idea of what I was saying is that right now,
00:04:55 it is not a great time to be a young man especially to be a young white man well i'm not a i'm not
00:05:02 white are you discluding me yes um not everybody's included in everything um if you are a young black
00:05:09 man uh the last eight years were easier for you that's just the truth and on average not every
00:05:16 single person comparatively we're speaking of dynamics right so if you were it's like well i
00:05:21 was a young black man, but I'm a quadriplegic. Okay, well, that's different. Okay, there, of
00:05:25 course, there are exceptions. But in generalities in group dynamics, from about 2015, and you could
00:05:33 argue earlier, but definitely 2015, all the way up until 2024. Yes, if you were a young white man,
00:05:41 you had added, added disadvantages that a person of color did not have. And so we are talking to
00:05:49 everybody, but we are especially talking to young, white, heterosexual Christian men who have, 0.52
00:05:56 our culture has essentially said, our economy, our culture, our society, and sadly, even many
00:06:01 of their churches has essentially said that we don't care about you, and there is nothing for
00:06:08 you. And a lot of the advice and counsel that you'll get from older men, should you seek out
00:06:13 godly, mature older men, especially older Christian men, in order to give counsel and
00:06:19 advice, of course. But you have to recognize that a lot of the advice they're giving is not
00:06:24 malicious necessarily. We're not saying that it's on purpose or intentional, but it is still just
00:06:30 a reality that the advice that a boomer is giving, if he's giving the kind of advice of practical
00:06:37 things for earning an income and getting married, these kinds of things that worked for him,
00:06:41 well the reality is those things don't work anymore when a boomer says well all you need to
00:06:45 you know dress not for the job you have but for the job that you want you know buy you know clean
00:06:51 yourself up you know why don't you shave your beard get a haircut you know put on a nice suit
00:06:56 and a tie go in with a firm handshake and smile and that look him in the eye look him in the eye
00:07:01 young man and stop being so lazy you know and stop whining um yeah that's great if you're a young 0.84
00:07:08 black man let's just be honest and if you're a young black man who can wear glasses that's even 0.98
00:07:14 better i mean they did an entire episode on curb your enthusiasm right one of the black characters 0.81
00:07:21 throughout the entire episode he didn't need glasses but he got a fake pair non-prescription
00:07:26 glasses and he put them on and they were mocking but there's some truth in it they were mocking 0.53
00:07:29 the fact that you know he all of a sudden he was well received by the the upper echelon of white
00:07:35 society, a bunch of boomers that had money and affluence and influence and jobs. And they were
00:07:41 laughing at it, but they were laughing at it for a reason. It was comedy. It's fiction, a fictional
00:07:46 story, curb your enthusiasm. But they made a joke about it for a reason, for a reason. It wasn't
00:07:53 completely random. And so, yeah, the game has changed. The world has changed. And there are
00:08:00 certain things that used to work that don't work anymore. Right. When a boomer says, well, you think
00:08:05 interest rates are bad today. I remember in the seventies, you know, we had, uh, our home had an
00:08:09 18, 17, 18% interest rate. Yeah. Your, your home, uh, that, that the principal was $48,000.
00:08:19 I'll take that. Something like, uh, like four times your median average wage. So in real terms,
00:08:24 cause you would say like, well, it was less the cost of the home, but then the wages were less
00:08:29 too. But think in terms, not just of raw, like 50,000, a hundred thousand, but think in terms
00:08:33 of how many times my yearly income does it take? And we'll show the graph in a minute, but like
00:08:38 a tiny amount compared to what you would need now. Because they might say, well, but we only
00:08:42 made 30 grand a year. Okay. But your house was 48,000. So you're talking about in that kind of
00:08:48 scenario, your house is barely over 50% one year's income. Whereas now people are looking at $400,000
00:08:56 houses, and their income is $70,000 or $80,000. So wages have maybe a little over doubled,
00:09:04 but the housing prices have multiplied by 10x, right? This is just basic math. And crying about
00:09:13 it, of course, crying about it doesn't solve the problem. Nobody's saying that it does.
00:09:18 But there's something to be said. I mean, even pastorally or as a father, when you're counseling
00:09:23 one of your sons or daughters, as a pastor who's counseling one of his parishioners,
00:09:29 one of the things that you want to do if they say, hey, I've been devastated by this situation
00:09:37 or this person wronged me, you want to determine whether or not, first and foremost, it's actually
00:09:44 true. But if it's true, then you can actually sympathize with someone and say, oh my goodness,
00:09:51 I am so sorry that that happened.
00:09:54 So you are now, because of this, because we live in a world that's tarnished by sin,
00:09:59 you are objectively at an extreme disadvantage.
00:10:02 I'm so sorry, brother.
00:10:03 I'm so sorry, sister.
00:10:05 And so let's talk about, because you're behind the eight ball, and that's actually not your
00:10:10 fault.
00:10:11 We can acknowledge that and say, I'm so sorry that that's the case.
00:10:15 And so now what can we do?
00:10:16 um but but a lot of guys today a lot of in the saturday it'd be one thing if it was a bunch of
00:10:22 progressive leftists right it'd be one thing if it was aoc you know and she was the only you know
00:10:26 nancy pelosi and joe biden they're the only ones you know who are saying this but you're talking
00:10:31 about conservatives guys who over the last decade not just conservatives but guys who over the last
00:10:37 decade were supposedly leading the charge against dei and these kinds of things and and these are
00:10:43 the guys who are giving the advice and saying, Hey, you know what, things aren't so bad, you can
00:10:48 go and stuff burritos at Chipotle, right? Things aren't so bad. Just go work in fast food, you
00:10:54 know, whereas it's like, but can't you acknowledge that 15 minutes ago, literally 15 minutes ago,
00:11:01 the advice was, well, how, who do you think you are thinking that you're going to be able to make
00:11:07 a livable wage doing fast food, you get you need to apply yourself and get a real job fast food is
00:11:13 supposed to be a job that's temporary just for teenagers and then literally it's like like by
00:11:18 the week by the week so the same guys who are saying well um that's ridiculous that you would
00:11:24 expect you know to to make um a a real wage and fast food and then they turn around a week later
00:11:30 and they're like um all all the uh software engineering jobs and and all the manufacturing
00:11:36 jobs are going to a bunch of Vivek Ramaswamy's friends in India with the H-1B visas. Well,
00:11:45 whoever told you that you would be able to have a middle management job in an industry that you
00:11:52 actually were attracted to. Everybody knows for the last 15 minutes, everybody knows that
00:11:58 if you want to feed a family, you do it at Chipotle. So it's just, you can't win.
00:12:06 You can't win.
00:12:07 And one of the things that we're trying to do as a ministry is give real counsel from
00:12:13 the Word of God, spiritual counsel, but also real, practical, tangible counsel for young
00:12:18 men how to live in the world today.
00:12:20 But we try to preface it because a lot of guys aren't doing this.
00:12:25 A lot of conservatives aren't doing it.
00:12:26 A lot of Christian pastors aren't doing this.
00:12:28 We try to preface it by first acknowledging, yeah, the deck is absolutely rigged against
00:12:35 you.
00:12:35 it is rigged against you um this this is not fair your parents lived in a golden age a golden age
00:12:43 this is one of the first generations one of the first generations in american history um where
00:12:49 in terms of economically and real purchasing power of wages um the children the following generation
00:12:58 will make far less than the preceding generation that's so we're living in real terms in real
00:13:03 terms in terms of purchasing power, what it can buy, but what it can buy. So the purchasing power
00:13:08 of your wages today, if you're a young man in your twenties and thirties, and even early forties,
00:13:13 the purchasing power has, has radically decreased from what your parents at that same stage of life
00:13:20 were able to purchase with their wages. And this is really one of the first times,
00:13:25 at least in American history, I can't speak to every place at every time since the beginning
00:13:29 of human history. But for American history, what we've seen is basically generation after
00:13:35 generation after generation from our founding, things improved and improved and improved. And
00:13:40 that just became assumed. It just became assumed that things will always get better. But we are
00:13:45 living in a historic moment, at least for American history. This is a historic moment where things
00:13:50 are actually going down. Life expectancy going down. IQ going down. Real purchasing power of
00:13:57 wages, going down. The only things that are going up is criminals, crime, immigration. 1.00
00:14:05 Women use of antidepressants. 1.00
00:14:06 Yeah, female use of antidepressants, food dye, you know, in the grocery store. Those are the, 0.99
00:14:11 you know, cancer. So, you know, I don't want to be completely negative. There are some things that
00:14:15 are going up, some numbers, you know, cancer numbers, they're up, you know. But all the good
00:14:21 things that you would like to see go up are going down. And that's the world you're living in. That's
00:14:26 what you're up against, and those are the things that we want to address today. Real quick, we've
00:14:30 got a super chat. I appreciate this. It's from Michael. He says, I'm very thankful that you're
00:14:35 speaking up for me, a young white man like me, and sharing that we actually are discriminated
00:14:42 against in America today, especially over the last decade, rather than just bashing me. Michael,
00:14:48 you're welcome. I don't normally do this, and I don't want to be cliche,
00:14:53 um but but i i mean this genuinely from the bottom of my heart uh let's just pray for michael
00:15:00 and everybody else that he represents you're talking about millions of young men uh father
00:15:04 god we just uh we ask for your mercy um our country and our our fathers and mothers um sold
00:15:11 out their children and grandchildren's future for the gdp to go up and to uh and to be able to pat 0.71
00:15:18 themselves on the back and uh and console themselves by telling them that that they're
00:15:22 not racist. And so in the name of not being racist and in the name of their 401k going up
00:15:30 because of companies, not the American people, but corporations doing better because the bottom line
00:15:36 went lower because jobs were outsourced for cheap labor. For those things, the prior generation of
00:15:44 boomers was willing to sell the future of their own children and grandchildren. Incredibly,
00:15:49 incredibly wicked thing. Much like Esau, who sold his own birthright for a bowl of soup.
00:15:54 The boomers have sold the birthrights, not even of themselves. In many ways, it's even more wicked 0.90
00:15:59 than Esau. They didn't sell their own birthright. They sold the birthright of their own children
00:16:03 and grandchildren. And they did it for something comparable to soup. They did it for GDP must go up
00:16:09 and foreigners must come in so that I can tell myself I'm not a racist. What a wicked, wicked 0.98
00:16:15 thing. Father, we pray for repentance for those boomers who are still alive, that they would 1.00
00:16:20 acknowledge that sin, a real sin, repent of it and find mercy and forgiveness and grace 0.99
00:16:25 in Jesus Christ. And we pray for their children and children's children, for these upcoming
00:16:33 generations, for millennials, for Zoomers. Lord, we pray just for your mercy and we pray for 1.00
00:16:39 incredible wisdom, God. We pray that you would make us as innocent as doves, that we wouldn't
00:16:46 compromise or take cheap shots in order to get ahead, but that we would be innocent as doves, 1.00
00:16:53 but that we would be as shrewd as vipers, that you would give to us a Christian spirit of shrewdness
00:16:59 and strategy, that we would be wise and cunning and find new ways to succeed in a world that has
00:17:07 been stacked against us we pray this on behalf of every young man who listens to this podcast and
00:17:12 we pray it in the name of jesus amen all right west this is uh your episode go ahead and yeah
00:17:18 lead us off let's actually start at the the end what michael was saying so when we say well a lot
00:17:24 of new jobs they've been going to people of color let me show you this analysis so this is from
00:17:28 bloomberg news bloomberg went ahead and they dived into the data just following the year after george
00:17:33 floyd so you think june 2020 george floyd and all of the uh all the black lives matter the
00:17:39 protests the rallies the commitments right the uh the kind of i promise i'm not racist uh statements
00:17:44 from ceos and they promised we're going to hire more people people of color we're going to hire
00:17:49 more people of color for ceos we're going to put them in middle of management we're going to put
00:17:52 them in leadership we're going to do it and so they went ahead and they actually did it this
00:17:57 was kind of bloomberg was was shocked to really show it so of in the s&p 100 so top 100 companies
00:18:02 I think by market cap, the U.S. Stock Exchange, it's an ETF.
00:18:06 So out of these 100 companies in that year, they added 320,000 jobs, 320,000 jobs, which
00:18:13 is a decent amount of jobs.
00:18:15 And these are four companies that have great pension plans, great benefits, great health
00:18:18 insurance, top tier companies.
00:18:20 When you think of, you know, your dad worked at Dell back in the day, think of these type
00:18:24 of companies.
00:18:24 So they added 320,000 jobs.
00:18:27 94 of these jobs went to people of color six percent of them went to white men to whites
00:18:37 so out of these top companies out of 320 000 jobs that have been added only six percent went to
00:18:44 basically the stock the founders of this nation you think about the founding fathers when they
00:18:48 said for our uh for us and our posterity for for our people the founders would be just rolling over
00:18:56 in their graves they would be enraged yes you did what to our children and all of these dots right
00:19:02 here like just think about the u.s so it's about 55 to 60 percent white or so and then a groupings
00:19:07 of different people say say it landed on along those lines right 15 to 20 percent black if you're
00:19:13 50 60 percent white those those fallings out you wouldn't see you wouldn't look at that and say
00:19:18 unequal weights and measures were definitely utilized here but you look at the dots there
00:19:23 And every one of those dots represents, to a high degree, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 generations of Americans, young men that were looking for a good job.
00:19:35 And once you get a job, what typically happens when a man is stable, affords a home, he lives somewhere for a while, so he's able to date and then marry, is children.
00:19:43 You can think of many of those dots as representing young men who entered the workforce, 2021, 2022, 2023,
00:19:49 and they had to settle for something much less
00:19:52 to make much less money, to move around more.
00:19:55 So because they were in a job
00:19:56 that was just sales and unstable
00:19:57 and then they had to move here,
00:19:58 it's not affording them to be able
00:20:00 to move out of their parents' home.
00:20:01 That's what we're looking at here.
00:20:03 I'm gonna go to home prices.
00:20:05 You mentioned it, Joel.
00:20:06 This is a chart here of home prices
00:20:08 in terms of the ratio of median income,
00:20:12 median household income ratio
00:20:13 to the actual cost of the home.
00:20:15 So think about if you made $50,000 a year,
00:20:17 the average home was $200,000. That would be a ratio of four. Through the 70s, through the 80s,
00:20:24 through the 90s, you're coming out of kind of the Great Depression and World War II there on the
00:20:28 left side. Through them, you had a ratio that at times was below, but roughly around four. So again,
00:20:33 that means you make $50,000 a year annually. Your home, $200,000. You have the bubble,
00:20:40 that's the housing bubble. And now we've surpassed that to where the ratio is closer to seven. So now
00:20:46 you probably the average median rate income, it's not 50,000 anymore, it's 100,000. But did that
00:20:52 house stay 200,000? Or did maybe the average even just go up to 400,000? It's now seven times. So
00:21:00 say you make 100,000, your dad made 50,000, bought a $200,000 home. That was the average. That's what
00:21:06 he was looking at. That was the type of salary he was getting. That was the cost of the home.
00:21:10 Say now you make 100,000 and your dad's proud of you. Good job, son. You went out and you got a
00:21:14 six-figure salary well that hundred thousand dollar salary the ratio to the median home cost
00:21:19 is now a seven hundred thousand dollar home interest taxes all those things they're exponentially
00:21:27 higher and in terms of purchasing power the home that portion of your budget is going to be twice
00:21:33 yes so if it was a third of your parents uh budget and well now your cash poor because it's
00:21:37 going to be two-thirds it's going to be the vast majority of your entire paycheck is going towards
00:21:43 housing yep exactly and um and this is not the first time that uh like the economy is like well
00:21:50 you may not care about the economy but the economy cares about you uh the great depression all of
00:21:55 these things clearly the economy matters but but there's a lot of guys who just they dug in and
00:21:59 they did it but i would say the one thing about it when i listened to stories it was more my great
00:22:03 grandparents about the great depression and stuff at the end of the day they had kids and a wife
00:22:09 and family. They lived around. They're kind of extended family. There's a bit of a sense of all
00:22:13 in it together. But as we know from the statistics, millennials and marriage not going very well. The
00:22:18 average age of marriage is increasing. And if you're a young man, we don't talk about this a 0.82
00:22:23 lot, probably because we're all married, but your options out there for dating, and let's just even 0.96
00:22:29 say just a non-Christian. Say you're non-Christian, but you're a general right-wing man. Well, what
00:22:33 are your options? Well, according to the statistics, about 15 to 20% of women out there would be on
00:22:39 hormonal birth control. Hormonal birth control changes the profile of the type of man she's
00:22:44 attracted to. Women on hormonal birth control are more tuned towards men that are more feminine in
00:22:51 their nature and the disposition. Someday we'll maybe do a whole episode on this. Women are also 0.94
00:22:56 in increasing rates, and I have some charts here on the screen, they're going on antidepressants,
00:23:01 SSRIs, between hormonal birth control, SSRIs, increased promiscuity. This one that you'll see
00:23:07 on your screen, they're more liberal than ever. Young men, they're actually turning right wing,
00:23:12 generally speaking, that's where the trend is going. But young women are more liberal than 0.97
00:23:15 ever. So in terms of home, in terms of a job, and just in terms of dating and finding a woman to 1.00
00:23:22 start a family with. Young men across the board, certainly Christian men, and certainly a vast
00:23:27 majority of that white men, they have it so much harder. Like this right here is antidepressant
00:23:33 use, just accelerating, almost doubling in women from 20 to 24 years old from since 1995 to 2010.
00:23:41 Birth control, hormonal birth control, antidepressants, liberal in their political
00:23:47 views. And you just, you have to be honest with it. This stuff is real. These are young men
00:23:53 meeting real women, trying to purchase real homes, trying to find real jobs, and they're just
00:23:58 not able to. Michael, you had some stuff on purchasing power as well that I think is helpful 0.91
00:24:02 to flesh out. So some of the numbers can get a little bit, you know, they're numbers, right?
00:24:08 But one of the things I did some research on was comparing adjusted average salary. And I excluded
00:24:17 things like just working at a car wash or something like this. This would be like your first job at
00:24:22 an actual company, like your first career job, but just starting off, okay? The kind of job that
00:24:28 maybe a 22-year-old guy is going to be looking for. So adjusting that number between 1920 to now
00:24:35 to match real-time dollars. So adjusting for inflation to now, and then comparing that
00:24:43 purchasing power or how much it would take for one of your years of salary to pay for some of
00:24:50 the expenses so in 1920 it would take that young man with that entry-level but career job entry-level
00:24:58 job it would take him four of his annual salaries to pay off the home that he and his wife just
00:25:06 purchased now it would take 10 years 10 annual salaries to pay off the average starter home
00:25:14 that's his whole salary that's yeah that's assuming he were to put all of his salary
00:25:17 But so if he's making $40,000, $160,000 in adjusted modern dollars, so more than double, two and a half times increase.
00:25:29 Things like an average car, it would have taken a third of his annual salary to pay off a car.
00:25:38 Now it takes 0.75 years to pay off a car.
00:25:42 So it's more than doubled.
00:25:44 Just the amount of dollars that he's earning, two and a half times higher to pay off a home or longer, two times longer to pay a car.
00:25:53 College affordability is crazy.
00:25:55 It used to take 0.1 years of that 19-20 salary.
00:25:59 Now it takes 0.375 of his yearly salary to pay off that college.
00:26:05 And what's really interesting is some of these numbers, they fluctuated some, but they kind of went pretty steadily.
00:26:11 I looked at every 20-year increment, 20s, 40s, 60s, 80s, 2000s, and 2020s. And it was really
00:26:17 only in the 2000s and now the 2020s especially that that purchasing power of the wage that he
00:26:25 was making compared to how long it would take him, same amount of stuff to buy, has just increased
00:26:30 astronomically. It's crazy. So I'm sure, as we mentioned in the cold open, conservatives have
00:26:37 some great thoughts on this, some good solutions, and they're recognizing the dynamics. This is the
00:26:42 post that set off a firestorm. And for the record, when we get into social media and stuff, for one,
00:26:47 we're highlighting people that have significant influence and voices, right? I don't think you're
00:26:51 ever going to see anyone up here with just 15 followers. We're talking about people that command
00:26:55 a lot of influence in the type of circles that you, the listener, would be in. And so this is
00:27:00 Chris Ruffo, who, for the record, as you were alluding to earlier, he's done great work on DEI,
00:27:04 on exposing practices, especially at public universities,
00:27:08 so universities funded by your tax dollars.
00:27:10 But someone said this.
00:27:11 They essentially said, I'm looking around.
00:27:15 They're like, I've made it, I've done well,
00:27:17 but I'm looking around and I'm seeing layoffs
00:27:19 and everything, everything everywhere.
00:27:22 So this is a pedantic killjoy said,
00:27:24 people keep telling me the economy is strong,
00:27:27 but every time I look at the news,
00:27:28 I see layoffs and businesses closing.
00:27:30 Personally, I'm doing just fine,
00:27:32 but I can see with my own eyes that something is wrong.
00:27:34 not sure what to believe here did you say i'm doing just fine i'm mewing just fine i'm doing
00:27:41 just fine i'm i'm doing just fine chris ruffo he's here to help he said this is basically he's
00:27:48 referring to the unemployment numbers full employment so the unemployment rate is about
00:27:52 4.1 percent which for the record a lot of men they've actually there's a new category which
00:27:57 would be they've left the workforce so when we say unemployment there's 4.1 percent people
00:28:01 of working force that's unemployed that's actually there are millions and millions of men that they
00:28:07 just they've stopped looking for jobs they've either moved back in with their family they're
00:28:10 on some type of disability and so it's not capturing those it's simply saying of those
00:28:14 that are looking for work and we know we're still looking for work only four percent of them are
00:28:18 unemployed so chris ruffo said this is basically full employment the panda express near my house
00:28:22 is offering 70k a year plus benefits for the assistant manager you can make 100k a year working
00:28:27 at chipotle for a few years and working up to the store manager i have a couple other examples but
00:28:34 this is the one that really got people because in all of what we just said home prices cost of
00:28:41 living food inflation cars the advice is well go uh go serve orange chicken for 70k a year and that
00:28:51 should be so young man you're concerned about a family you're concerned about a stable uh like a
00:28:56 stable home life you're concerned about an inheritance right so you're saving not just
00:28:59 to be able to retire hopefully at some point but an inheritance and uh and the advice is is there's
00:29:04 tons of places where you can work for a job that's that's not going to take you very far
00:29:08 and you should be happy about it there's an abundance out there what's the big fuss essentially
00:29:14 so that gives you guys the lay of the land that sets the framework for this episode we're going
00:29:20 to go to our first commercial break and then we'll come back with orrin mcintyre our sponsor
00:29:24 private family banking wants to help you with one money move that'll implicate itself in
00:29:29 multi-generational wealth building starting the first day. They help you to avoid taxation and
00:29:35 to draw compound interest to your money. Now, if you're a high net worth individual, someone who
00:29:41 has maybe even $10 million in net worth, then they can help you even more. W-2 workers, contract
00:29:48 networkers, business owners, it's all about cash flow and making tax-deferred gains on all your
00:29:55 money for the rest of your life. Don't avoid this. It's a big move, but it's a great time to make it.
00:30:01 Click the link below and you can get on Chuck DeLaterrante's calendar and he'll go over your
00:30:06 background and what you want to accomplish. And he's going to help model a program that exactly
00:30:12 fits your needs. So go ahead and send an email to chuck at privatefamilybanking.com. Again,
00:30:19 that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com, or you can click the link below. Make a free discovery
00:30:25 call now. America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their
00:30:30 duty before God and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:30:35 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied, not just as a
00:30:39 plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business as though they're commandments from
00:30:44 God that we're supposed to obey. Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them
00:30:50 up. We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our
00:30:54 capacity to do things here. Reese Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:31:03 All right, we are back and we should have Oren McIntyre ready to join the show.
00:31:07 there he is orin thanks for coming on hey guys how's it going it's going it is going so we've
00:31:13 been watching you a little bit on x you're coming to our conference by the way i got to plug that
00:31:17 real quick so april 3rd 4th and 5th the year of our lord 2025 it's a thursday friday saturday we've
00:31:23 got steve days we've got orin mcintyre he'll be there we've got calvin robinson we've got
00:31:27 all the ogden boys from new christened press we've got andrew isker and cj angle and dr
00:31:33 Stephen Wolf, and a whole host of others. So we're really excited. John Harris, Aidy Robles,
00:31:38 really excited about this conference. The Christian prince himself, Dusty Devers,
00:31:42 the senator, Dusty Devers, forgive me. So we're excited about that conference. But I've been
00:31:47 following you for a while, Oren, and we connected and you were gracious enough to come to the
00:31:51 conference. You had me on your show. I've had you a couple of times, but I've been watching you over
00:31:55 the last, well, really since Christmas, since the whole H-1B and Vivek, who came out of hibernation
00:32:02 today on X. God bless him. He's ready now that Trump's going to be inaugurated to show his face
00:32:09 again and hope that we all forgot that he's for India first instead of America first. But you've
00:32:17 been doing a great job. And so can you just kind of, I don't know, way into the discussion? We
00:32:21 already showed the tweet from Chris Ruffo. And what do you think's going on here and how do we
00:32:26 fix it i think that there's kind of this default mode uh that most conservatives fall into which
00:32:34 is everybody needs some tough love right you gotta you gotta tell the kids to get out there
00:32:38 get off the video games you know touch some grass uh go go work hard and that'll just fix everything
00:32:45 right and obviously one-on-one like clean up your room work hard like that's good advice if if i
00:32:53 have a friend and he's down on his luck he can't pay his bills the kids aren't getting food on
00:32:58 their plate and there's a job at a panda express and the question is hey or would you tell that
00:33:04 guy to go work at panda express answers yeah of course like yes like you shouldn't be drawing 0.97
00:33:09 welfare you shouldn't be sitting on your butt playing a video game while your kids are starving 0.85
00:33:14 or you can't you know pay your bills like this is not beneath you you should do this work however 0.97
00:33:19 However, when your job is literally to shape public policy, when you are a leader of men, you can't just tell everybody, oh, well, I mean, the system's kind of screwed, but just work hard.
00:33:31 Like, that doesn't work.
00:33:32 When you spend literally years saying, hey, Bidenomics is failing, inflation is out of control, illegal immigration is destroying opportunity and social fabric, the ability to form families, get married is under assault.
00:33:46 you know we are uncovering these DEI programs that specifically target men and specifically 0.53
00:33:51 target white men and they're not allowed to go to college and get ahead and get hired when you
00:33:56 literally make a career pointing all of this stuff out you can't just be like oh well Trump got
00:34:02 elected uh just go work hard I guess like no you you need a plan you have to show people that you
00:34:07 care and you notice the problems and yes they need to work hard they can't just wallow in self-pity
00:34:12 but you are taking action to change the system that you know and have talked about is failing
00:34:19 agreed yeah so um i mean i what do you think it is i mean i feel like immigration is
00:34:29 a major factor i feel like we're finally at the place where you know illegal immigration of course
00:34:34 that's off the table but it seems like as conservatives um and even some christians
00:34:39 Christians, sadly, per usual, are not really leading the charge, but instead kind of,
00:34:46 you know, would it Ben Shapiro say, okay, all right, well, you know, it's safe to say it now, 0.98
00:34:50 you know. But it does seem like the conversation of legal, not illegal, but legal immigration is
00:34:56 finally on the table where we're like, yeah, maybe not a ton of that either. That seems a
00:35:03 little bit hopeful. What do you think? Yeah, no, it's definitely a good sign. I want people to
00:35:08 understand that, yes, it was annoying to have Elon and Vivek come out on Christmas Day and say,
00:35:14 well, we kind of need infinite foreigners to take the jobs that you really want to do. Yeah, 0.76
00:35:19 before we were saying, you know, immigrants do jobs that Americans don't want to do. But now 1.00
00:35:23 we're specifically bringing them in to do jobs you absolutely want to do and are going to college
00:35:28 to do. Like, that's very frustrating. However, the very fact that the conversation has shifted
00:35:33 away from open borders and infinite illegal immigration instead to how much legal immigration
00:35:40 should we have is itself a great sign that is momentum in our direction that is a victory
00:35:45 yes we still have to fight these fights yes we still have to hash out the coalition as it was
00:35:51 created to get trump elected these are all just parts of the political process you you get a
00:35:57 coalition together for politics and then once the victory comes you got to have the internal you
00:36:02 kind of struggle session. Unfortunately, it would be great if that wasn't the way that politics
00:36:06 worked, but it just is. And so no one should be defeated. No one should be down on themselves
00:36:12 because this conversation is taking place. You're only having this conversation because of a
00:36:17 victory. You just can't stop after the victory. That's what conservatives always do. You win the
00:36:21 election and then they just stop paying attention to what's going on. And what I'm hoping and what
00:36:26 many people are hoping is that we can keep the attention focus and we can actually continue that
00:36:30 victory, not just get Trump across the finish line, but actually get the things that were
00:36:34 promised that people who support Trump really want. Right. Yeah, I agree. There's a comment
00:36:41 real quick I want to read because I think it's insightful. It's from Glorious and Free Ministries
00:36:44 says it'll be nice when evangelical boomers prioritize telling third worlders in Africa
00:36:51 and elsewhere who can't properly feed their own 10 children to pull themselves up by their bootstraps
00:36:57 instead of uh telling that to their own struggling children here in america um and now i i personally
00:37:05 you know this is my position i would advocate for neither but point taken i think it's a good point
00:37:10 uh do you think orin that it's a bit ironic perchance even we could use a word as strong
00:37:17 as hypocritical that um that you never see that type of rhetoric levied against the third world
00:37:23 You never see, right, like we would never look at Uganda and say, well, you know, they're just lazy, you know, maybe if they just worked a little bit harder, you know, and why aren't they wearing a suit and a tie when they go to the job interview, you know, and firm handshake and look the employer in the eyes, you know, with a warm smile, you know, worked for me, why doesn't it work for them? 0.54
00:37:43 um and like what i'm saying is we would immediately recognize well wait a second there's actually such 0.76
00:37:49 a thing in nations as um corrupt elites who actually make things impossible so it's it's not
00:37:56 fair uh entirely like yeah you still have to you know work with with the the hand that you've been
00:38:02 dealt and so we can talk about that all day long but but before you talk about how to um how to
00:38:07 dig yourself out of a hole when you're starting at a disadvantage it's first very helpful um to
00:38:13 recognize that the disadvantage actually exists, that you actually have a disadvantage, and then
00:38:17 begin talking about solutions. But my point is, it seems as though Americans, and especially
00:38:23 evangelicals, and especially boomers, but that the older generation of Christians here in America
00:38:30 are, it's like nobody has to sit them down and show them a chart or graphs or statistics or even
00:38:37 or even history books or or um or the the politics of uganda or the politics of the sudan they
00:38:43 instinctively understand um that it's the elite's fault in these other nations and that the people
00:38:50 there that the actual citizens are being oppressed and that the poverty is induced right now like i
00:38:56 don't know any christian boomer any christian over the age of you know 65 who's saying man
00:39:01 the north koreans gosh they're lazy you know like um they would say no they're poor but the the
00:39:08 poverty can be tracked back to sin poverty is always linked to sin but it's not always linked 0.99
00:39:13 to your sin right it's not always um i'm poor and it's my sin it can sometimes be and often
00:39:20 throughout world history um it can be i'm poor and it's your sin it's somebody else who's actually
00:39:25 made me impoverished and and it seems like americans and christian americans and older
00:39:31 Americans instinctively understand this with every nation except for our own. So in this house,
00:39:37 I got this from you, Warren, in this house, we believe in elite theory. Can you talk a little
00:39:41 bit about that for our listeners? Sure, absolutely. And one of the things that I focus on a lot in my
00:39:46 work, my writing, and my show is a school of political theory called Italian elite theory.
00:39:51 And really, it comes from Machiavelli and moves through guys like Vilfredo Pareto and Gaetano
00:39:58 Mosca and Robert Michels. And ultimately what these guys were trying to highlight is that
00:40:04 every civilization is ultimately influenced and run by its elite. And that's not to say that the
00:40:12 elite aren't influenced by the common people and religion and culture and everything else,
00:40:18 but that the tastemakers and the movers of the levers of power ultimately do a lot more to kind
00:40:24 of inform the citizenry and create their situations then vice versa and so if you want to understand
00:40:30 the mechanics of a civil civilization its culture the way things are moving the best thing to do is
00:40:37 to focus on its elites now what a lot of people worry about what a lot of the kind of the mainstream
00:40:43 conservative commentators that were kind of digging into this whereas that ultimately this
00:40:47 creates a kind of helplessness right that this creates a victim mentality and of course we see
00:40:53 this on the left. We see this with Marxist-based class analysis, right? Well, the elites control
00:40:58 everything. There's nothing we can do. They're all corrupt. We got to get rid of them. And in
00:41:02 the meantime, well, just, you know, be lazy. You can blame everything on them. We absolutely want
00:41:07 to avoid that. They are right to say that that is not the mentality that you should have. We have
00:41:12 to cultivate virtue in the population. Young men need the virtue that comes with hard work and
00:41:18 ambition. But what is the real disconnect here, I think, is understanding the well-being of the
00:41:25 people. Ultimately, right, we want men to work hard, but we want them to work hard because it's
00:41:30 meaningful, because it's connecting to something that matters. Telling someone to put 80 hours
00:41:35 into Panda Express or Chipotle every week just makes them a cog in the machine. They have no
00:41:41 agency. They are simply under a bunch of managers and bureaucrats. Now, telling a man to work 80
00:41:47 hours opening his own restaurant giving him the ability to build something that he can pass on to
00:41:53 his children that is a radically different thing but there was just this huge disconnect i think
00:41:59 from a lot of people who are worried that all these young zuber men are just going to sit around and
00:42:04 you know they're going to blame society and of course that does exist i'm not pretending that
00:42:08 there aren't you know lazy or entitled people that you know young people don't need to learn
00:42:12 the value of work but ultimately you build the right to tell a man to give him that advice to
00:42:19 give him that tough love speech because you've shown that you care about him as elite you have
00:42:24 a responsibility to first show that you care about and you are working towards the betterment of
00:42:30 someone and then you can look in the eye and say and by the way now that i've made this easier for
00:42:35 you you need to get out there and get this done but you have to take the action first right well
00:42:40 said uh west michael any thoughts uh all right i was interested in so when we talk about the 0.81
00:42:46 difficulties young men face it's kind of like well you know these gangs of asian men in britain are
00:42:51 doing terrible things like well no it's a very specific subgroup within this and so we talk
00:42:56 about young men it is specifically white men and you could blame it on dei so dei hiring practices
00:43:03 the preference for people of color in in hiring and promoting and hiring them above uh white men 0.63
00:43:09 But I feel like, to me at least, that seems almost like a symptom of some type of underlying root cause. 0.87
00:43:14 I don't know if I could go as far back as the Civil Rights Act, kind of removing the freedom of association. 0.95
00:43:19 Where would you say the train came off the tracks as far as these big companies really got it in their veins, got it in their mindset to really set to the side, push aside and bring in, I mean, certainly immigrants for sure. 0.54
00:43:34 but just generally a preference for people of color at the expense of white European Christian
00:43:41 men. Like you said, this goes back pretty far, and the Civil Rights Act is pretty central to this.
00:43:47 A lot of people think of the Civil Rights Act in its first iteration, right, where it specifically
00:43:52 says that this can't be used to discriminate against anyone or elevate anyone based on their
00:43:58 race, including white people. However, what we've seen over time is as civil rights law has
00:44:04 developed, as the different layers of law have been added, court decisions and these kind of
00:44:09 things, this is altered radically. Specifically, the most pernicious one is the ruling in Griggs
00:44:14 versus Duke Power, which created the idea of disparate impact. And this is a policy that says
00:44:21 anything that affects any racial group disproportionately is automatically prima
00:44:27 facie evidence of discrimination you don't need to intentionally discriminate if there are any
00:44:33 differences then you are discriminating no matter what and this leads to modern decisions for
00:44:38 instance uh the biden administration uh sued their department of justice sued a gas station company
00:44:45 and actually won the judgment because they were using criminal background checks and
00:44:49 disproportionately minorities are more represented in criminal background checks so fewer minorities
00:44:55 were getting hired. That meant that checking criminal backgrounds was evidence of racism and
00:45:00 a violation of the Civil Rights Act. Now, this court ruling is so bad that it was basically
00:45:06 repealed through court law, but then it was reintroduced and codified into the 1991 Civil
00:45:13 Rights Act. So a lot of people hear the Civil Rights Act and they think, oh, well, this just
00:45:17 makes everybody equal. But no, it literally makes it illegal for you to hire more white people if 0.77
00:45:23 they happen to not have a criminal record. And this radiates out into basically every interaction
00:45:29 in our society. Yeah, I think one of the things that I realized a few years back was, you know,
00:45:36 because at first it was like, well, let's just, you know, let's just not be woke, right? Let's
00:45:40 be anti-woke. And, you know, even before that, you know, like 2017, 18, 19, preceding 2020 and,
00:45:49 you know, the summer of love, mostly peaceful, you know, riots and things like that. In the
00:45:55 church world, the conversation was all about social justice. And I was a part of a network
00:46:00 at that time called Acts 29 Network that very much was beating the social justice drum. And
00:46:07 I remember, you know, being bothered by it and starting to speak out against it. But at the time,
00:46:12 Like most of the rhetoric, most of the defense against social justice in the church, a social justice gospel was, you know, we would say, well, that's a blurring of the gospel, right?
00:46:27 Because the gospel is, it's grace and it's not works.
00:46:30 And you're making, this is a works gospel because you're adding to the gospel.
00:46:34 You're saying that, you know, you're blurring the lines and you're not just saying that we should do good things, you know, as a result, as an evidence of being saved by grace.
00:46:44 But you're actually saying that we should do the gospel and the gospel is not something we do.
00:46:48 It's just something we believe.
00:46:49 So this is a works gospel where it's faith in Jesus plus being, you know, a social justice advocate and working towards, you know, protecting the poor from being oppressed or whatever.
00:46:59 And so that was like the line of attack from conservative Christians, you know, and I was one of them. And I picked up that rhetoric probably 2017, 18, 19. It wasn't until about 2020 that I started to realize, well, you know, and then it became woke, you know, social justice, what wasn't, you know, woke became the thing.
00:47:17 So we need to be not woke. But it wasn't until, you know, probably like 2020 that I started to
00:47:24 realize, wait a second, like the problem here, it's not technically, it's not justice. Justice
00:47:30 isn't a problem. Justice is a good thing. And the problem isn't even just wokeness, you know,
00:47:37 that became a stand-in for social justice in regards to minority people. The problem is that
00:47:44 it's all lies. Like what we need is truth. There is actually a theological problem in my view of
00:47:55 blending salvation by grace alone and doing certain works in order to merit the favor and
00:48:01 love of God. So there is a theological problem there. But the best of the social justice guys
00:48:07 were careful enough theologically not to blur those lines. And so they would say, no, no, no,
00:48:11 you know, we're not saying you do it to be saved, but we're saying that if you're saved,
00:48:15 that salvation will be evidenced by doing good works. And there's no better work than to let
00:48:20 justice roll down like mighty rivers. And what that means, you know, is basically everything
00:48:26 that, you know, Martin Luther King preached and you need to be doing that. And so it wasn't,
00:48:30 you know, for about three years from 2017 leading up to 2020, I, you know, I was hitting it from
00:48:36 this angle of, well, don't blend social justice with the gospel, or don't be a racist towards
00:48:44 black people. Just don't be a racist at all. Be colorblind. Don't see color at all. Race is 0.78
00:48:50 insignificant. It's not even a thing. It's just different shades of melanin, and there's just 1.00
00:48:55 one race, the human race, and all those kinds of things I picked up. And then it just finally hit
00:49:00 me and I realized that the problem with the left is that it's not true. So the problem of saying
00:49:07 that, you know, all these people of color are discriminated, one of the biggest problems with
00:49:11 that is not because it focuses us on social justice or it takes us away from the gospel
00:49:16 or this, that, and the other. The problem is it's fundamentally a lie. At the time that we were
00:49:23 being told that people of color were being discriminated against, white people on the
00:49:30 books were being discriminated against. And so now I'm of the frame of mind that, no,
00:49:39 we do need to talk about justice. We just need to talk about it truthfully. We need to talk about
00:49:44 justice as it pertains to those who really are experiencing injustice. And we need to talk about
00:49:51 fixing those things, especially when a country is hating its own native citizens.
00:49:57 But that kind of rhetoric, which is basically, you correct me if I'm wrong, Orrin, but
00:50:02 from doing some of the reading, that kind of rhetoric seems to be the obvious no-duh from
00:50:09 any writer who existed before 1945. But basically, what I've been told is that if you think the same
00:50:19 way that every single person ever thought in the history of the world until about 70, 80 years ago,
00:50:26 then you're woke. You're woke right. And there's a wonderful, brilliant, staunch conservative
00:50:33 thinker, James Lindsay, who talks about this. What do you think about his conception of the
00:50:40 woke right? And what do you think about what I'm talking about in terms of, no, we really do need
00:50:45 to fight injustice but it needs to be actual injustice you know in the 1930s if you had come
00:50:53 to me and said hey uh there is a actual racism like there are racist laws on the books i would
00:50:59 have agreed with you and if you had said hey we need to change these laws so they don't discriminate
00:51:04 against you know uh black people in america i'd be like well yes of course that's wrong um if you
00:51:10 come to me in 2020 and tell me that that's the case then that's just obviously not true like
00:51:14 It's just factually inaccurate that there are laws put in place that, you know, are on the books that actively discriminate against black Americans.
00:51:24 However, if you told me in the 1930s that we needed to change something because white people were to be discriminated against, I would say, well, that doesn't seem right.
00:51:32 It doesn't seem like those laws are on the books. 0.59
00:51:34 However, if in 2020 you told me that, well, I can literally point to affirmative action.
00:51:40 I can literally point to Greggs versus Duke Power.
00:51:43 These things exist. They are in the law. I don't understand why we needed to get rid of laws that specifically were biased against black Americans, but we don't need to get rid of laws that are specifically biased today against white Americans, mostly, and also Asian Americans, sometimes other groups as well.
00:52:02 It just doesn't make any sense to me. And the problem was not that you needed to have justice. As you point out, the problem was the definition of justice, the fact that you were bending over backwards to create problems in the law that simply did not exist.
00:52:17 I'm not asking for any special treatment for white people. I don't think we need white identity politics, but I think it's very stupid to pretend that noticing a literal law on the books that is actively limiting the ability of white people and most often white men to advance in society. 0.93
00:52:36 I don't think there's a problem with that. That doesn't turn you into a victim. I don't think you should build an entire BLM style movement around this. We don't need BLM or DEI for white people, which has now become the catchphrase. But when you're calling just having an immigration system or getting rid of active racist laws against white people, DEI for white people, now you're just being dishonest. Like now you are very obviously playing for your own advantage, not actually playing by the rules. 0.96
00:53:06 Yeah, well said. And for anybody who's listening, it's funny because I see you, you know, on social media, you know, particularly X and a lot of times guys like James Lindsay, who I was, you know, using facetiously just a moment ago, you know, make you out to be like some kind of far right extremist.
00:53:25 And I'm listening to everything you said, and I think it's well said, and I agree with it 90%.
00:53:29 And I'm thinking, Orrin McIntyre, one of my favorite, you know, centrist, just a moderate, you know, moderate conservative.
00:53:37 Because I'm thinking, theoretically, in terms of arguments for permissibility.
00:53:41 So I'm not saying what's ideal and what we should do tomorrow, you know, or any of that.
00:53:44 But if we're just talking about, you know, permissibility, and we're talking about, you know, theoretically and political philosophy and me as a pastor, you know, blending some of that with my theological questions.
00:53:55 convictions, then there's nothing wrong. There's nothing inherently immoral about a nation
00:53:59 actually preferring, in our case, because America is unique, it wouldn't necessarily be white people
00:54:05 in an exclusive sense. But if a nation prioritizes one faith, for instance, like I would advocate as
00:54:13 a Christian nationalist, I would say, I'm happy to wear the moniker. I totally understand why some
00:54:16 people don't. And I would be a part of the larger conversation on the team of, you know, new
00:54:20 dissonant right, or the new Christian right, or whatever you want to call it, very much for that
00:54:26 team and on that team. But I also like the moniker Christian nationalism. And so for me, as a proud
00:54:32 Christian nationalist, I would say, yeah, in terms of permissibility, there would be nothing wrong 0.79
00:54:38 with America, which is a Christian nation. I would argue we're currently in apostasy, but in terms of 0.88
00:54:44 its founding, its origin, all those kinds of things, there's nothing wrong with a Christian
00:54:48 nation, prioritizing in terms of faith, religion, saying, yeah, we're going to be, because America
00:54:55 is also unique in the sense of its tolerance of those who have different views. And so I would
00:55:00 like for America to still be America. It's not Sharia law, and that's not even compatible with 0.98
00:55:05 Christian theological convictions, but also not America and its culture and its founding and the
00:55:11 people that we are. So, okay, so America will probably, if I was king for a day, America would
00:55:17 always have, I think, some added measure of patience and tolerance and compassion in a way
00:55:24 that many other parts of the world don't have when it comes to different religions. But blasphemy 0.94
00:55:30 would not be tolerated in the public square. You wouldn't have the police rounding up people who
00:55:34 are Muslims or a different faith in their private homes. But in the public square, there wouldn't
00:55:39 be blasphemy. There'd be things like that. I'm okay with blue laws, again, in terms of
00:55:44 permissibility and conviction, those kinds of things. But there would be an exalting,
00:55:48 so it's not necessarily putting everyone else out, but the esteeming of the Christian faith,
00:55:54 right? Your holidays, national parades or ceremonies, they would be distinctly Christian,
00:56:00 right? When you swear into office, it's a Christian Bible, the Quran, sorry, you can 1.00
00:56:05 privately read it in your home, but that doesn't work in a court of law. It needs to be the Bible,
00:56:09 the word of God, the triune God. So there's nothing wrong in terms of permissibility on 0.89
00:56:13 the theological side of actually preferring the Christian faith, the faith of that particular
00:56:19 nation. On the social side, there seems to me, in terms of arguments of permissibility,
00:56:25 not saying we have to do it tomorrow, or that we'll even ever do it, but it doesn't seem as
00:56:29 though there's anything inherently immoral about preferring also a particular people, 0.62
00:56:34 in our case with America being unique, it wasn't all white, it was predominantly white, but it
00:56:38 wasn't all white, but I would just say heritage Americans, to say, yeah, we're going, and so what
00:56:43 does that mean it means um that america would prefer those who can track their ancestry um
00:56:50 to this this piece of land this country their fathers fought in our wars um and and they can
00:56:56 do so more than just 15 minutes ago they didn't just arrive on an h-1b visa to take your job
00:57:03 at at the you know the software company um you know yesterday but instead there's actually
00:57:10 there is actually an esteeming and a preference given to Christian faith over other faiths and
00:57:17 American heritage people over other people. And that doesn't mean that we have to be rude or
00:57:23 anything like that. But it does mean that there's actually something to, there's something to be
00:57:29 said for, this is my place. These are my people. This is, these are my traditions. This is my
00:57:35 religion. Um, this is my country. And, and I think about that, you know, and the more I think about
00:57:41 it, um, you know, cause people will say, well, um, if you want those good jobs and you just,
00:57:46 you gotta, you gotta, um, you gotta compete, you know, you gotta be better. And, and I just,
00:57:51 I think I would disagree on two levels. One, I would say, um, I don't think that Americans are
00:57:55 fundamentally lazy, you know, because they watch too much, you know, boy meets world. I think I,
00:57:59 I take great offense at that. Actually. Um, I think that the rest of the world, wherever we
00:58:04 innovation. It's usually copying the innovation that happened in America. Americans are the most
00:58:10 innovative, you know, the most ingenuity, like Americans have done incredible things. So one,
00:58:16 I just, I disagree with that sentiment that we've got to, you know, all the geniuses, the next Tesla
00:58:21 is going to be found in India, you know, and not America. I just statistically, I don't think
00:58:27 that's true. And then secondly, I also think, but wait a second, it's your country. And if America
00:58:35 first means America as a sports team beats in the global Olympics of widget factories, if that's
00:58:43 what it means to be America first, then I would just say, then I'm perfectly content with America
00:58:48 coming in second place or third place or 50th place if it means, if the price to be paid for 0.61
00:58:54 America first, is that America as a jersey, as a sports jersey, wins the Super Bowl of widget
00:59:01 making, but American people are unemployed and devastated. I feel like the leaders of a country,
00:59:09 their first priority has to be to their people above their country, you know, making trades with
00:59:17 other teams, you know, with India or whatever, just to make sure that they win the Super Bowl of
00:59:21 of who can colonize mars the fastest any thoughts on that yeah there's this guy samuel huntington
00:59:29 and he's famous for his class of civilizations thesis but he was a professor at harvard he's a
00:59:34 center-left guy actually but he wrote this great book called who are we and really huntington was
00:59:40 looking after the cold war and said hey we had this weird moment where the entire world was
00:59:45 basically set in this bifurcated scenario you were either communist or you were a capitalist you
00:59:50 either United States or Soviet Union. And that kind of superseded the normal national identity.
00:59:56 And now that that is gone, now that we have seen the end of the Cold War, we're going to start
01:00:01 moving back towards traditional forms of identity. And that's going to become more and more
01:00:06 important. Every nation is going to be defined by its more classic features and no longer by
01:00:10 kind of this rough ideology of capitalism versus communism. And he said, we in the United States
01:00:17 need to grapple with this question. Who are we? If we are going to return to a more traditional
01:00:22 understanding of peoplehood, of nationhood, then we can't keep this idea of just being an abstract
01:00:27 principle. We have to be grounded in what nations have been grounded in for pretty much all of
01:00:32 history. And again, this guy is a center-left guy. He's not some right-wing bomb thrower. But in the
01:00:37 book, he basically comes to the conclusion that America is an Anglo-Protestant nation, that
01:00:42 everything about it all these principles that we love to talk about aren't just some abstract
01:00:47 gnostic thing floating around it's grounded in a particular people a particular religion a
01:00:53 particular tradition and heritage and understanding and of course being a man of the left he was not
01:00:57 looking for any kind of hardline identity of you know anglo-protestantism he said people can join
01:01:03 people must join they must assimilate but that is key they must assimilate they have to become
01:01:08 part of that process we can't just leave identity off the table identity will continue to exist
01:01:15 if you just leave it to the left then guess what happens they define it the same thing that
01:01:19 happened when we tried to push religion out oh we're going to be a neutral country when it comes
01:01:23 to religion well guess what we ended up with wokeness as the new religion because the left
01:01:27 dominated all of those quote-unquote neutral spaces the same thing is going to be true of
01:01:32 identity if you just abandon it as the right then guess who's going to control what the american
01:01:37 identity is it's going to be the left and i think having an anglo-protestant core identity is
01:01:43 critical again we are a nation that has always allowed people to join in that but we must make
01:01:48 it the priority it has to be something that binds us together and by the way preferring a particular
01:01:53 people is actually great for you it doesn't it's not just morally permissible spiritually
01:01:58 permissible it's actually achieves a lot of the goals that conservatives and libertarians want
01:02:03 to achieve because when you have a multicultural society you have conflicting worldviews of 0.70
01:02:08 conflicting moral visions and guess who can be the only person who can arbitrate that conflict 0.95
01:02:14 in every level from the personal to the political to the business interaction it's the government
01:02:19 yes the state has to get involved so when you prefer a specific way of doing things everyone
01:02:25 shares the same culture the same religion at least superficially at least as part of the culture
01:02:32 then the state doesn't have to involve itself in every interaction because there is a baseline
01:02:36 shared moral vision tradition understanding heritage that everyone can be a part of but
01:02:42 when you create a multicultural society you necessarily grow the government because it's
01:02:47 the only one that can dictate what's going to happen when all these other moral visions are
01:02:52 clashing well said we're going to go to our final commercial break of the day and then we'll come
01:02:58 back with Orin for our last segment. All right, the clock is running out. You need to go and
01:03:04 register now for our Christ is King, How to Defeat Trash World Conference. It's happening
01:03:10 the year of our Lord, 2025, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th. That's a Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.
01:03:17 And by God's grace, we're able to provide for you an all-star lineup. We've got Steve Dace,
01:03:22 Calvin Robinson, Orrin McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolfe, Eric Kahn, David Reese, Andrew Isker,
01:03:29 John Harris, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, C.J. Engel, and yours truly,
01:03:36 Pastor Joel Webin. Come on out. Join us April 3rd, 4th and 5th, 2025, Thursday through a Saturday.
01:03:44 go to rightresponseconference.com to register today. Again, that's rightresponseconference.com.
01:03:52 Listen, guys, you probably listen to Right Response Ministries because
01:03:56 you take the Dominion mandate offered to us in Scripture seriously. Well, unsurprisingly,
01:04:03 so does Dominion Wealth Strategist. As the only distinctly reformed financial consulting firm,
01:04:10 they help Calvinistic, covenantal, and confessional Christians to steward their
01:04:15 resources faithfully in a way that actually aligns with God's Word. Dominion Wealth leverages
01:04:21 all corners of the financial service industry as independent brokerage agents, matching you
01:04:27 with suitable products and services from dozens of top industry providers. Their mission is to
01:04:34 equip believers to secure their family's future and build a legacy that glorifies God by building
01:04:42 holistic financial strategies that include budgeting, insurance, debt management, retirement
01:04:48 planning, estate planning, and more. In order to make wealth Christian again with a portfolio that
01:04:55 might even put King Solomon to shame, go and take dominion over your finances today by visiting
01:05:02 www.reformed.money and book an introductory overview right now. All of Christ for all of life
01:05:11 and all of finance for Christendom. All right, we are back. I'm going to give it to Michael Belch.
01:05:18 He's going to ask some questions for Oren. Just one question. Oren, thanks for joining the show
01:05:22 today. As you said earlier, the fact that we are having the discussion about immigration and even
01:05:30 whether we ought to have some limits on our immigration policy is, in a sense, a victory.
01:05:35 The conversation is happening.
01:05:37 I'm curious about your assessment of the coalition that is under Trump.
01:05:43 I mean, I hate to call it the conservative party anymore because it really isn't.
01:05:47 It really is the party of the dissidents who have all aligned under Trump's umbrella.
01:05:51 And the quote, or not the quote, the tweet that we had from Christopher Ruffo at the
01:05:57 beginning of the episode, which I'm sure you saw where he said there's the $70,000 job at Panda
01:06:03 Express. Go take that. I'm curious if that indicates something about the new dissident
01:06:12 conservatist movement where the goal, conservatism has always been kind of equated with fiscal
01:06:19 responsibility or at least fiscal conservatism. And is the fact that Rufo would think, oh,
01:06:25 there's a $70,000 job. It's just cash. As opposed to kind of what you were talking about with the
01:06:31 nobility of your purpose, building something, having kind of a more sincere ownership and
01:06:39 attachment to providing a service that's really worthwhile that you can pass on to your children.
01:06:45 Is there anything that is being talked about, do you think, in the new Trump conservative
01:06:51 coalition about really the spirit of what it means to be a worker as opposed to a cog.
01:06:57 Is that is that head conversation happening at all?
01:07:00 Is it something that we should push for as dissident right members?
01:07:05 How do you think that that is going in the I guess the new dissident right?
01:07:12 I should say at the outset that I like Chris.
01:07:15 I've had him on the show.
01:07:17 I've talked to him.
01:07:17 He does great work.
01:07:18 So I want to make it clear that just because we were having a disagreement on this doesn't mean that he doesn't have a large body of work to stand on and people shouldn't respect what he's done that's good.
01:07:28 That said, there are a lot of kind of mechanical assumptions going into this.
01:07:33 I'm somebody who grew up on conservative talk radio, listening to Rush Limbaugh and Dennis Prager and all these guys.
01:07:38 And I learned a lot there and I had a lot of those kind of, you know, that mentality locked in for most of my life until just a few years ago.
01:07:47 So it takes a while to turn this ship. There's a lot of reflex. And I think that's what we saw in the last few days here online was kind of this conservative rhetoric reflex rather than thinking through the implications of kind of the ideas that have been onboarded.
01:08:02 The really odd thing is if you listen to J.D. Vance, he gave an interview in which he specifically addressed this topic and pointed out that kind of the workforce participation numbers were fake.
01:08:13 And ultimately, it was important to give to prefer Americans over any foreigner and make sure that we're giving meaningful work to these guys. 0.96
01:08:22 It's kind of weird that all these people who have been rah, rah, rah for J.D. Vance over the last few years, and rightly so. 1.00
01:08:27 I think Vance is awesome. But the fact that they kind of just blew past this point that he himself has been making is very strange. Vance has also said explicitly, America is a nation. It is a people. It's not just an office park or an economic zone.
01:08:42 again this is the rhetoric at the core of the trump uh you know a movement at this point jd
01:08:48 vance is riding shotgun next to a president who's over 80 years old he's right next to power and
01:08:55 you know the fact that he holds this belief i think ultimately underlines that this current
01:09:00 is running very strong through kind of i guess what would people call the new right i really
01:09:04 think it's the old right it's just the actual right coming back um but but that's what we need
01:09:09 And hopefully that continues. I went to the National Conservatism Conference. J.D. Vance spoke there before he was declared as the vice presidential nominee. And his ideas were very much alive in that room. There were others. Veck was also there. He started selling this idea of libertarian nationalism. And I knew right then that things were not going to go well.
01:09:33 that eventually we were going to get that knife in the back.
01:09:36 But to be clear, guys like Vance don't just have a seat at the table.
01:09:40 They are the guys at the head of the table.
01:09:42 And that's great news.
01:09:44 That is great news.
01:09:45 He's not riding shotgun, though.
01:09:46 He's riding shotgun to a guy from South Africa who's riding shotgun.
01:09:51 To be fair. 0.91
01:09:52 But no, you're right.
01:09:54 It's super hopeful.
01:09:55 And who knows?
01:09:56 I mean, do you think, I know it's way early to make a prediction here,
01:10:00 But what do you, I feel like the next four years are going to be largely positive at
01:10:05 minimum, I've heard you say, and others have said, and I agree, you know, four years to
01:10:09 build, you know, some breathing room, a pause.
01:10:12 So for conservatives to build, but I think that it's entirely possible that it could
01:10:16 be more than just a time to build, but there actually could be some serious achievements
01:10:20 that, you know, that the right is able to accomplish during this time.
01:10:24 And so assuming that things might be positive, then we might have more than four years.
01:10:29 Do you think that someone like J.D. Vance could be president?
01:10:33 Could we get 12 years?
01:10:34 Is that possible?
01:10:35 I think it's absolutely possible.
01:10:37 And again, it really all depends on what they do here.
01:10:41 The fact that we need things like voter security and ID and if we close the borders, like so many of these things will permanently shape the way that elections operate inside the United States.
01:10:52 They have a lot of opportunities to make significant changes that will not only better the lives of Americans, but will also ensure a more conservative or right wing kind of bent to elections and outcomes and all these other things.
01:11:05 The left is certainly think about this when they leave the border open for infinite new voters.
01:11:10 The right needs to start thinking the same way.
01:11:12 I do.
01:11:13 And I am hopeful ultimately that we will see some big gains.
01:11:17 But like you said, I always preach to people.
01:11:19 You've got to be active.
01:11:21 It's not enough to sit around and wait for Trump or Vance or whoever to make the big changes, even though I'm an elite theory guy.
01:11:26 I do think ultimately they will make the largest the largest contributions.
01:11:31 But I think what we really need on the right now is a farm team.
01:11:34 We need to be building talent. We need to be building an aristocracy.
01:11:39 We need to become worthy to be in those positions of power and make sure we have a deep bench.
01:11:44 So there's a guy behind Trump and behind J.D. Vance and behind the next guy who is very good and very conservative. We need to rise to raise up leaders across the country, locally, state level and at the national level.
01:11:59 And that has to be our priority, which is, again, why I think it's so important for conservative influencers and politicians and others to change their language on this kind of stuff.
01:12:09 You need to be encouraging young men.
01:12:11 You need to be giving them a future that is not just about, you know, securing a managerial job at some kind of, you know, fast food chain.
01:12:21 You need to give them a vision where they are meaningful contributors to their community and they have a path forward, not just to make money, but to make a difference.
01:12:30 The left sells young people on their ability to make a difference, not on their ability to make X amount of dollars.
01:12:39 And that is a huge motivator.
01:12:40 There is zero reason that the left should own that, especially when we're the side that can actually give people hope.
01:12:47 We can actually give them meaning.
01:12:48 we know what is good and true and beautiful. The left does not. We should be giving that to the
01:12:54 young. Well said. Two questions. One's a super fast one. Are you Southern Baptist? What is your?
01:13:02 Yep. Southern Baptist. Okay. And then two, that's what I thought. Number two,
01:13:06 if you said you were Catholic, I was going to be in huge trouble. At this point, you got one, 1.00
01:13:11 if you got one, you might as well invite them all. Anyways, I don't know if you've seen on
01:13:16 twitter but i've gotten uh some pushback from uh calvin robinson which i'm i'm happy that he's
01:13:21 going to be joining us uh much to the chagrin of uh many others uh second question is uh for these
01:13:27 next four years and and it seems like conservatives are going to have tailwinds for the first time
01:13:31 and in my lifetime maybe you know so uh not just like losing some of the headwinds but
01:13:36 maybe even some tailwinds you know wind in our sails um and i was thinking about that just in
01:13:41 regards to, you know, in multiple different arenas, but, but particularly just as it pertains
01:13:48 to social media. I, I mean, if you've got Zuckerberg coming out, you know, and, and saying,
01:13:56 yeah, I, you know, like, I'm going to, you know, basically just start copying what Elon has done
01:14:01 with X. And, you know, what, what I told you, everybody was like, I don't really think he's
01:14:06 repentant. I don't think he had a change of heart. And for me, I've, you know, I've said
01:14:09 multiple times publicly. Good. I actually prefer that. Not at an individual level. I do, as a
01:14:16 Christian, I do prefer that he actually would feel, you know, not just worldly sorrow, but like
01:14:21 2 Corinthians talks, you know, godly sorrow for the fact that he rigged an election. I mean,
01:14:27 he had a major hand in suppressing true stories that affected how people would vote and is
01:14:32 responsible for, to that end, he bears some responsibility, and I would argue a decent share
01:14:38 of 13, you know, US service members that died. Like all the bad decisions that were made under
01:14:42 the Biden administration and real human beings who lost their lives. Zuckerberg bears some
01:14:49 responsibility for that. He, I mean, he absolutely helped Biden get elected. And so because of that,
01:14:54 I do pray as a Christian that there would be godly sorrow for what I would consider actually
01:15:00 sin. I think it's actually sin. And that ultimately he would put his faith in Jesus
01:15:05 christ and be saved and not go to hell so i'm you know i'm hoping for that when i say good what i
01:15:10 mean is at a political level and more of a practical temporal level um i actually think
01:15:15 it's an even stronger win for the right uh when um when some of the most powerful not just your
01:15:23 you know you know 85 percent of the population your npcs you know who are doing you know she's
01:15:27 so brat you know and then all of a sudden you know and and the you know the robots power down
01:15:33 and the chip is removed and then replaced.
01:15:36 And now, you know, literally on a turn on a dime,
01:15:38 now they're doing this, you know,
01:15:39 like whether it's a NFL star or, you know, a musician
01:15:43 or just all the TikTok videos, you know,
01:15:45 from the sorority girls, like, I mean,
01:15:47 literally on the turn of a dime, 180 degree, 1.00
01:15:50 you know, that's your NPCs.
01:15:52 But when you have Zuckerberg,
01:15:53 when you have billionaires, you know,
01:15:54 at that level who arguably are not,
01:15:59 they don't have godly sorrow.
01:16:00 They don't feel actual remorse
01:16:02 and and don't see it as they did something evil but they're still going to say the line and change
01:16:07 the rhetoric and and change uh change course to me that's that's when you know you're winning
01:16:14 right you you know you're winning when um because for the longest time i would have said you know
01:16:19 like well it's just you know uh one one heart and one mind at a time you know it's it's um you know
01:16:24 facts don't care about your feelings and so i gotta you know uh bust out you know the the
01:16:28 spreadsheets and the charts, and I need to just simply persuade and convince people one heart at
01:16:33 a time, one mind at a time. And if we can get 50% of the population plus one, you know, then in our
01:16:38 sacred democracy, we can win elections and we can start to make change and blah, blah, blah, blah,
01:16:42 and now I look at it and I'm like, you actually don't have to persuade that many people. I would
01:16:47 actually, you don't even actually have to persuade most people or the majority of people.
01:16:52 You just have to win. Because if you win, they persuade themselves overnight, all of a sudden,
01:16:57 trump dance instead of she's so brat just like that just like you don't have to persuade 22
01:17:03 year old college girls you don't you just have to win and then they realize oh gosh i don't want
01:17:09 to be a loser you know and they switch teams it's and and zuckerberg i think has more in common even
01:17:15 though he's a billionaire with a 22 year old sorority girl um then you know an actual man 0.93
01:17:22 of history who shapes the world you know somebody who's actually a leader and so um all that being
01:17:27 said as it pertains to social media if zuckerberg if i'm right about that and it's not a genuine
01:17:33 change of heart it's just falling in line because there's a there's a new winner in town um if
01:17:40 that's true then then youtube might fall in line and and everything you know every everything might
01:17:48 fall in line and i and i i perceive at least the possibility of um of not just that the headwinds
01:17:56 finally lighten up for conservatives across the board but especially in the realm of social media
01:18:01 but that we actually experience some tailwinds like i'm i'm wondering and i'm curious if you
01:18:07 you know as a as a media you know voice yourself um i think the next four years like like we could
01:18:15 we could actually we could we could put some numbers on the board like we could like some
01:18:21 big things could happen without just having to take a tenth the size of your audience over on
01:18:26 rumble but that you could actually be on major platforms saying the things that we're saying
01:18:31 um and and maybe not be suppressed and maybe even a tailwind of an algorithm that favors you because
01:18:39 people want to hear it and are actually interested do you think that those kinds of things like am i
01:18:45 Do I need a couple of black pills maybe?
01:18:47 Like I've swallowed too many white pills.
01:18:48 Like what do you think?
01:18:49 Am I crazy? 0.98
01:18:50 I have a white pill and a black pill for you. 0.97
01:18:53 So a couple of black pills.
01:18:55 Okay.
01:18:55 I got one in each hand.
01:18:57 So the good news, the part that I agree with you is of course, as we said, we believe in
01:19:03 elite theory in this house.
01:19:04 And so we know that actually opinion does not determine power.
01:19:09 Power determines opinions.
01:19:11 And so when you win, then they like you.
01:19:14 uh that it really is that simple most people want status most people want to be cool and that's way
01:19:21 better than any argument in the marketplace of ideas you will ever ever make and so the most
01:19:26 important thing if you would like to change culture is to have the power the levers of which
01:19:31 it is manufactured most conservatives don't see that because they kind of think of popular
01:19:36 sovereignty it's democracy that's what makes these things happen but it's not it makes some
01:19:41 people angry, but that's just the truth. And so if you have that, then the changes you're talking
01:19:47 about are much easier, right? And that's how you know a real political win. A political win is not
01:19:52 something that changes one issue that you want, though that is good. It's a thing that makes the
01:19:57 next win easier. And once you win all the things, you can change whatever you want, because then
01:20:02 you don't have to worry about any of those encumbrances. So that is the good news. I do
01:20:08 think we have big wins i do think that we are seeing that shift that you're talking about the
01:20:12 vibe shift is coming a lot of elites who uh were you know kind of on that didn't care they weren't
01:20:17 committed one way or another they're on board they're going to change things they see the way
01:20:21 that things are blowing and they want to be on the winning team and that's going to cascade down
01:20:25 that preference cascade is going to move all the way down the socioeconomic ladder to the average
01:20:30 person a lot of people get angry about this oh you're just saying people are led and no i don't
01:20:35 hate people that's just how they work that's fine you don't need to judge people on that you don't
01:20:40 need to feel bad about it that's just yeah we're not speaking to people's innate dignity or value
01:20:45 so by making that statement we're not saying and therefore these people have no value and we don't
01:20:49 love them like no all all equal footing in the sight of god as as image bearers of the living god
01:20:55 they have an eternal soul uh jesus loves them we as fellow human beings love them as a neighbor
01:21:01 we also love them as christians and and and love their soul and want to see them born again if
01:21:05 they're not, or if they are, then they're our Christian brother or Christian sister. So we're
01:21:08 not speaking of innate dignity or value or anything like that. But what we're recognizing is that God,
01:21:13 it's God's world, right? God made the world and he made the rules by which his world functions and
01:21:19 operates. And one of the ways that God made the world, it's just a fact, is that the world is not
01:21:25 the egalitarian utopia, which I would argue would be a dystopia, that the left imagines. That's not
01:21:31 the way the world works the world god has has orchestrated into the world which he has made
01:21:35 inescapable hierarchy inescapable hierarchy um and and that's why um a nation should never have
01:21:44 women in combat um like like men and women are different um also at an individual level there
01:21:50 are people like the idea of uh well not equal outcomes you know but equal opportunity we don't
01:21:55 have equal i've never had the equal opportunity as michael jordan to play in the nba and i never
01:22:00 had it, never will have it. We don't have equal opportunities because God made a beautiful world
01:22:06 and a beautiful world is not a homogenous world. It's a world that actually has real
01:22:14 diversity, different people, different gifts, different skills, different intellect,
01:22:18 different abilities, all these different things. And so what we're talking about is,
01:22:24 the concept is this simple. If everyone's a leader, then there's no such thing as a leader.
01:22:29 all throughout human history there are leaders and and and a leader um what that signifies what
01:22:37 it assumes is that um there's you know for every leader there's um a a handful at least of followers
01:22:45 whether that's a one to ten ratio you know or a one to a hundred or but there's there's there's
01:22:50 leaders which assumes followers and i think it's not that much further to say probably more followers
01:22:56 than leaders, not just 50% are leaders and they're each leading one person, but it's probably less
01:23:02 than half of the population are leaders. So it's not some crazy statement for me to say the majority
01:23:09 of people are followers. That doesn't mean the majority of people are worthless or those followers
01:23:15 have less innate dignity than the leaders do in the sight of God, or that they should be treated
01:23:19 differently under the law or none of that. But it's just recognizing God made the world. He made
01:23:25 according to his rules, God, for whatever reason, has seen fit in his infinite wisdom to orchestrate
01:23:30 hierarchy and not a homogenous, you know, steamrolled population where everybody's
01:23:35 exactly the same. So some people are leaders, some people are followers, there's probably
01:23:39 less leaders and there are followers. And that's how change happens.
01:23:44 I still have my black pill for you, though. Oh, no. Oh, no. Go for it.
01:23:49 The black pill is that I think scale is a real factor. I talk about this in my book, The Total State. I think that some of the problems that we are facing are fundamentally ones that emerge once you hit a certain level of scale that requires managerial bureaucracies.
01:24:07 And the tendencies of those bureaucracies lead us to what we identify as very leftist outcomes. When we kind of pull away from that subsidiary, that locality, those natural hierarchies and them influencing people that they really know and care about directly, we start to take on leftist features.
01:24:26 And the more we scale up, the more we move towards those things.
01:24:30 And so while I think our elite are moving in the direction of conservatism and right-wing
01:24:35 leadership under Trump and Vance and others, and that's good, and I think they can accomplish
01:24:39 a lot, and we should be optimistic, I think there are systemic limitations to the ways
01:24:44 in which tech companies and larger corporations and just many social features can actively
01:24:50 work.
01:24:51 We see this in everything from churches to corporations to government.
01:24:55 The bigger it gets, often the more leftist gets. And that's not some kind of weird thing. That's not that it's an actual feature of the way that scale works. And so we're going to have to think about big questions of how we can address that if we still want our society to operate kind of the way it does.
01:25:12 We might have to fundamentally address some of those issues if we want to avoid a constant leftist slide, even if the elites are currently looking to the right for kind of their tastemaking.
01:25:21 yeah that's insightful um anything else you guys want to follow up with michael west don't think
01:25:30 so okay uh we have one final super chat i don't quite understand i think it's it's making a
01:25:37 statement and then asking for your thoughts i assume oran uh but this is jeff halfley um super
01:25:42 chat from jeff halfley we appreciate it he says in the past white workers and bosses had their
01:25:47 own political parties representing them. Now they are forced, uh, they have forced them into a
01:25:54 single party resulting in, um, Elon versus X type of things. What do you think? Does that make sense
01:26:02 to you, Warren? Do you have a thought? Uh, I mean, I can, I can take my best stab at I think
01:26:06 maybe what he's getting to there. Uh, yeah, you obviously, we don't have specific parties based
01:26:13 on race at this point, not explicitly, at least. Obviously, you're going to have a sorting feature
01:26:19 that moves majorities of one racial population or another into the parties. And that's often
01:26:24 how we see them characterized. But obviously, there's no official move of that. And I don't
01:26:29 think there should be. Again, I'm not looking for specific white identity politics. I don't
01:26:34 think that's a solution to America's problems overall. And I don't think morally it's advisable
01:26:39 either. That said, we should be comfortable inside the coalition on the right of recognizing
01:26:47 things that affect everyone in that coalition, including white workers. And if there is
01:26:52 something that is specifically targeting them, working against them, then that should be brought
01:26:58 up. And so when someone like Elon says, no, I'm going to bring in infinite migrants from India
01:27:03 or whatever to do these jobs because they do them cheaper, I'm not going to invest in any of the 0.95
01:27:08 people in the united states the majority of which barely still are white uh you know i'm going to
01:27:12 bring in people of another faith and another heritage and another race and i'm going to bring
01:27:17 them in and i'm going to favor them over you we should be able to address that it's okay to notice
01:27:21 that it's okay to say explicitly that's not good but i don't think that needs to result in some
01:27:26 kind of you know separate white solidarity uh party or movement i i really hope that people
01:27:33 can understand that we need to take care of this problem in the right way so we don't get a worse
01:27:38 problem later on if we are active and loud and and real about this problem today then we won't get
01:27:47 many of the you know more bombastic identity politics that people are more worried about and
01:27:52 this is where i think kind of the james lindsays of the world often fail they say any step in the
01:27:58 direction of recognizing a problem will automatically lead you to you know mid-century
01:28:03 german goose stepping i think that's exactly the wrong understanding if you take forceful action
01:28:09 now to solve a injustice now you can prevent the very thing you're worried about because you will
01:28:15 have good people in positions of leadership if you leave it on the table and you don't address it
01:28:20 people get more radical and they start listening to anyone who will talk about it including the
01:28:24 worst people in the room. This is the Andrew Tate effect, right? No one would talk about masculinity,
01:28:29 so you get Andrew Tate. And if no one will talk about the problems facing white working class
01:28:35 people, then you will get much worse than Andrew Tate for white people if you don't address them
01:28:41 legitimately in a moral way today. Right. I think you're absolutely right. Yeah, 0.94
01:28:45 we just did an episode on Andrew Tate, but we've been talking for a few years in regards to both
01:28:50 nationalism and also biblical patriarchy and you know i constantly tell the detractors um my my
01:28:56 detractors um you you think i'm extreme um you will be if if you silence every you know me and
01:29:05 everybody like me um in five years time maybe sooner two three years but definitely five to
01:29:11 ten years time you will be begging for the centrist moderate reasonable you know joel
01:29:18 weapons of the world um that if you if you hate men long enough um the way i see it is it's just
01:29:25 right now like in the theological world the big argument is about natural law it's just it's it's
01:29:32 a return to nature uh nature is healing as the kids say you know and so um it seems as though
01:29:37 you know like life finds a way you know a great prophet from jurassic park once said um and the
01:29:44 industrial age and all this technology and things like that, you know, you know, made it to where
01:29:48 instead of manual labor outside, you know, for 12 hours a day, you can work eight hours, you know,
01:29:52 in an office, pushing pencils and counting beings, you know, with HVAC. And, and so in that world,
01:29:58 like, you know, what women could work and, and maybe even, you know, provide for a family and
01:30:04 these kinds of things, but all of it was superficial. God designed the world in a, in a
01:30:08 particular way. And, and, and it seems as though the world, it's not even just an American thing,
01:30:14 because you see this happening in other countries as well, Argentina, and, you know, so it seems
01:30:18 like the world is reverting back to a natural order. And I think that means nationalism over
01:30:24 globalism. I think that means patriarchy over feminism. I think that means hierarchy over
01:30:30 egalitarianism. I think, you know, all these different things, the whole world seems to be
01:30:34 rubber band was stretched so far for so long, it's now snapping back. And if I was to boil it
01:30:40 down to a word, the common denominator across the board, whether it's nationalism, globalism,
01:30:45 patriarchy, feminism, you know, really to sum it up in a word, the word would be nature. The world
01:30:51 seems to be reverting back to nature. And so in that nature category, we just need to recognize
01:30:58 as Christians, Christians don't have a monopoly on natural things. I think Christians do it the
01:31:06 best. I'm a Christian. But if we study the world, there were plenty of places for centuries, if not
01:31:14 millennia, before the Christian gospel was ever introduced to them, before they converted to
01:31:19 Christianity, that had sustainable, with certain levels of atrocities, but sustainable, viable,
01:31:28 um ways of doing life um for centuries if not millennia so i think like the aztecs um 0.86
01:31:37 would have hated christ and also hated feminism is what i'm saying globalism like they were they
01:31:44 were they operated in god's natural world according to his natural his his rules um natural law and 0.99
01:31:52 and so what i'm saying is that all the guys who think you're crazy or in your extreme you're crazy 0.85
01:31:57 joel you're extreme um the way i see it is not whether but which the the rubber band is snapping 0.61
01:32:03 back to naturalism and and and that's that's nationalism that's patriarch all the things i've
01:32:09 already listed so then the question is not whether but which kinds of these things will we get i we're
01:32:14 going globalism is not viable so that that's that's going away you don't have an option there
01:32:19 that's going away that's not that's not a viable option it's proven not to be a viable option so
01:32:25 instead you're going to get nationalism the choice that we have right now before us if we can stop
01:32:31 you know running like chicken little the sky is falling the christian nationalist no you're going
01:32:35 to get nationalism you are going to wish and hope and beg 10 years from now that it had been christian 0.87
01:32:43 nationalism because the other choices are not gay homoglobalism that's not a choice it's not viable 0.87
01:32:49 So your alternatives, it's Christian nationalism or Islamic nationalism or just pagan kind of Darwinian naturalism. 0.83
01:32:58 There are forms of nationalism, whether it's the Vikings' form of nationalism, the Aztecs' form of nationalism, or the Muslims' form of nationalism.
01:33:06 But you're going to get nationalism.
01:33:08 I implore you to consider now, before the waiter just orders for you, while you're still holding the menu, before the dishes come,
01:33:17 um can i can i interest you in the special of the day it is called christian nationalism can i
01:33:22 interest you in biblical patriarchy instead of sharia patriarchy can i interest you in like
01:33:28 and i'm telling if if the james lindseys of the world win this argument and scare 0.70
01:33:35 successfully scare all the listeners to simply just double down on gay globalism 0.55
01:33:42 and egalitarianism for another 10 years um and andrew tate will be mild um with with what we'll
01:33:51 get so i that that's my final thought for the day any do you agree with that assessment or do you
01:33:56 think it's you think it's i'm sure you word it differently but no i i think that's exactly right
01:34:02 you know you you had in the you know the soviet union had you know this insane revolution it was
01:34:07 supposed to be universal it was supposed to be uh global and guess uh what it worked terribly
01:34:13 until uh finally a guy named stalin came in and he made it national and he basically converted
01:34:18 to fascism because that's what actually worked that's the way you could actually make that
01:34:22 system work you don't want to just sit around and wait until a guy like that shows up like
01:34:26 someone will eventually make the trains run on time but if you wait until the guy who makes the
01:34:31 trains run on time, shows up, history tells you bad things happen. Yes, identity is scary. Yes,
01:34:38 a lot of these questions are difficult, but the strong gods are coming back no matter what. We
01:34:42 will answer the question, who are we? So the best answer would be brothers in Christ.
01:34:49 Amen. Let me just read Jeff Halfley. He followed up and it's a really good distinction. So he left
01:34:53 two super chats. I just want to read them both. Jeff Halfley, there you go. That's how we get
01:34:57 super chats is if every time somebody says something, we intentionally misunderstand.
01:35:01 What? I can't read this. You're going to have to send, you know, seven more super chats to clarify.
01:35:07 So Jeff first asked, he just said, this is the first super chat. In the past, white workers and bosses had their own political parties. They weren't the same, but different. Representing them. Now they are forced into a single party resulting in these kind of Elon versus X, like an H1B type of things. What do you think?
01:35:23 And then he followed up and said, Democrats used to represent the workers, think unions, and Republicans used to represent bosses.
01:35:30 Demography has forced them into single parties resulting in friction.
01:35:35 And then finally followed it up, monocultural societies tend to divide along income and class.
01:35:40 Multicultural societies tend to divide along race and religion. 1.00
01:35:44 And I think that's 100% true. 1.00
01:35:46 Well said.
01:35:47 All right.
01:35:47 Well, that's it for us today.
01:35:49 I hope you've been blessed.
01:35:50 Where can people follow?
01:35:51 Yeah, where can people follow you on?
01:35:51 oh of course yeah i've got uh obviously the orrin mcintyre show it's on youtube it's on rumble
01:35:58 it's on odyssey it's on all your favorite podcast platforms and of course i'm over at blaze tv
01:36:02 and i'm on twitter and pretty much everything else at orrin mcintyre at orrin mcintyre great
01:36:08 and he will also be at our conference go to right response conference.com not right response
01:36:13 ministries right response conference.com register for the conference coming up christ is king
01:36:18 conference, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
01:36:20 Oren, thanks for coming on the show.
01:36:21 We appreciate it.
01:36:23 Thanks for having me.
01:36:24 All right.
01:36:24 Thanks.